ISSN 1346-7328
国総研資料 第963号
平 成 2 9 年 3 月

国土技術政策総合研究所資料
TECHNICAL NOTE of
National Institute for Land and Infrastructure Management

No. 963

March 2017

機材サイズ・運航便数に関するエアライン戦略のモデル化―国内線を対象とした同時方程式モデルによるアプローチ―

井上岳・川西和幸

A simultaneous Equations Model for Strategic Determinationof Aircraft Size and Frequency by Airlines in Japan

Gaku INOUE, Kazuyuki KAWANISHI

国土交通省

国土技術政策総合研究所

National Institute for Land and Infrastructure Management
Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism, Japan

国土技術政策総合研究所資料
No. 9632017 年 3 月(YSK-N-368)

機材サイズ・運航便数に関するエアライン戦略のモデル化－国内線を対象とした同時方程式モデルによるアプローチ－

井上岳＊ ・川西和幸 ＊＊要旨

長期的に必要となる空港基本施設（空港法第六条に掲げる「滑走路等」をいう．）の規模を適切に見積もるためには，旅客数や貨物量の見積のみならず，路線別の機材サイズ・運航便数の適正な見積が不可欠である．本稿ではエアライン間の競合関係を考慮し，かつ，路線別航空需要を所与とした場
合における機材サイズ・運航便数を，同時方程式モデル（３段階最小二乗法(3SLS)）により，内生的に同時に推定するためのモデル化を行った．
キーワード：空港計画，航空需要推計，同時方程式*空港研究部空港計画研究室長**空港研究部空港計画研究室研究員〒239-0826 横須賀市長瀬3-1-1 国土交通省国土技術政策総合研究所
電話：046-844-5032
e-mail ： ysk.nil-kikaku@ml.mlit.go.jpiTechnical Note of NILIM
No. 963

March 2017

(YSK-N-368)

A simultaneous Equations Model for Strategic Determinationof Aircraft Size and Frequency by Airlines in Japan

Gaku INOUE＊
Kazuyuki KAWANISHI＊＊

Synopsis

Forecasting aircraft size and frequency for traffic on domestic routes is necessary to determine a longterm/short-term facility provision of runways, taxiways, aprons, and so on. In this regard, this research
paper provides a model for determination of aircraft size and frequency for domestic trunk routes. This model isformulated based on the Two-Stage/Three-Stage Least Squares (2SLS/3SLS), given estimated future traffic oneach domestic route.
Key Words : Airport Planning, Air Traffic Forecasts, Simultaneous Equations＊

Head of Airport planning Division, Airport Department
Research Engineer of Airport planning Division, Airport Department
National Institute for Land and Infrastructure Management
Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism
3-1-1 Nagase, Yokosuka, 239-0826 Japan
Phone：+81-46-844-5032
e-mail：ysk.nil-kikaku@ml.mlit.go.jp
＊＊

ii

目

次

1．はじめに ‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥1
1.1

背景と目的 ‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥1

1.2

既往研究 ‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥1

2．方法 ‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥1
2.1

モデル ‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥1

2.2

使用データおよびプログラム ‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥ 22.3

符号条件 ‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥2

3．結果 ‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥3
3.1

1年モデル

‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥3

3.2

5年モデル

‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥44．まとめ ‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥5
参考文献‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥5

付録A．入力データ ‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥6
付録B．Stataの実行コードおよび出力結果‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥‥26

iii

iv

国総研資料 No.963

１. はじめになどを考慮し，Pitfield et al.(2010)の研究をベースにしてモデル構築を試みることとする．

1.1 背景と目的

２．方法

国総研航空需要推計モデル（国土交通省国土技術政策
総合研究所(2007)）では，旅客数が変化した場合，エアラインが提供座席数を調整するにあたって機材サイズを2.1 モデル

変更することで対応するのか，運航便数を調整すること

本研究は，Pitfield et al.(2010)と同様の考え方でで対応するのかについての考察が十分になされていない．

モデルを式(1)および式(2)のとおり構築する．式(1)で結果として，予測値にはある程度の整合性を保つことがは右辺第 5 項、式(2)では右辺第 4 項を加えた．前者はできるものの，個別の路線単位で見た場合にそれらの影

路線距離が運航便数に与える影響を考慮するため，後者

響が強く現れる路線（特に需要変動が大きいと考えられは機材の入れ替えが頻繁に生じない本邦航空市場の状況

る路線）について，運航便数や旅客数の推計値が実績とを鑑みると，機材構成は過去の構成に大きく影響するこ

乖離する可能性があると考えられる．

とが考えられためである．国総研航空需要推計モデルのそこで本研究では，旅客数変動が生じた際の機材サイサブモジュールとして利用するため，旅客数は外生的にズ及び運航便数の変化を表現するモデルを構築すること与える．

によりこの課題に対処することを検討した．

この結果，航空需要，使用機材及び運航便数のモデルは以下のとおり定式化した：

1.2 既往研究

ln

航空会社の使用機材と運航便数のモデル化に関連する

=

+

ln

+ 1 ln研究はこれまでにも複数の研究者によってなされている．
ln

Pitfield et al.(2010)は，空港のエアサイドの施設=++ 1 ln整備のために，旅客需要，機材サイズ，運航便数を変数としたモデル式を 3 段階最小二乗法（3SLS）により構築

+
+

ln

2 ln

+
+

ln

2 ln

+
+

ln

1 ln

3 ln

+
+

3 ln

, −1

+
ln

(1)
1

, −1

+

2．

(2)

ただし，
：t 年における経路 i の運航便数

し，旅客増加は機材サイズよりも運航便数に対して大きな 影 響 を 与 え る と の 結 論 を 得 て い る ． Givonai and：t-1 年における経路 i の運航便数−1

Piet(2009)は便あたりの旅客数を機材サイズの代替指：t 年における経路 i の旅客数標とみなし，路線の提供座席数，大圏距離，滑走路数，：t 年における経路 i の機材サイズ

1

ハーフィンダール・ハーシュマン指数 などを説明変数と：t-1 年における経路 i の機材サイズ−1：t 年における経路 i のエアライン間の競合

して最小二乗法および提供座席数に内生性が認められる可能性を考慮して 2 段階最小二乗法（2SLS）によりモデ状態

ル式を作成している．作成したモデルから機材サイズは：経路の路線距離

ノードである空港の特性（ハブ空港か否か，スロット調：トレンド

整がなされているか）ではなく，飛行距離や需要等の経1,路の特性に大きく依存するとしている．Pai(2010)によ, ,る研究では，航空機のサイズと運航便数について空港周

である．

2

：誤差項
：モデルパラメータ

辺地域の統計データや空港，経路，エアラインの特性値

なお，国総研航空需要推計モデル（例えば,国土交通などを使用する事により特定することを試みている．管

省国土技術政策総合研究所（2007））による推計は 5 年

理職の増加や 25 歳以下人口の増加が小型機による高頻毎に行っている．このため，式(1)及び式(2)のとおり 1度運航に結びつく傾向や路線距離と大型機による運航と年毎のラグ変数によるモデル（「1 年モデル」：5 年後の関連が示されている．欠航が相次ぐ空港においてはリを推計するために 1 年毎の推計を逐次 5 回実施する）に

スクヘッジのため，機材の大型化，高頻度化が認められおけるラグ変数 −1 , −1 をそれぞれ：t-5 年における経路 i の運航便数−5るとしている．
本研究は既往の航空需要予測モデルとの連接の容易さ−5：t-5 年における経路 i の機材サイズに置換するモデル（「5 年モデル」）を検討する．また，
1

ラグ変数を用いないモデル（「ラグなしモデル」）も検市場の集中度を測る指標-1-

機材サイズ・運航便数に関するエアライン戦略のモデル化/井上岳・川西和幸

表-1
変数
路線別運航便数（回／日）
路線別年間旅客数（人／年）
路線別機材サイズ（席／便）
路線別競合状況（会社数）
路線距離（ｋｍ）

使用データ

データ元
国土交通省「航空輸送統計調査」
国土交通省「航空輸送統計調査」
国土交通省「航空輸送統計調査」
JTB パブリッシング「JTB 時刻表」
国土交通省「航空輸送統計調査」

表-2

1 年モデルH23-27 年度
H23-27 年度
H23-27 年度
H23-27 年度
H23-27 年度

5 年毎モデルH19-22, 24-27 年度
H19-22, 24-27 年度
H19-22, 24-27 年度
H19-22, 24-27 年度
H19-22, 24-27 年度

符号条件
説明変数

被説明変数
運航便数
機材サイズ

運航便数

機材サイズ

旅客数

－

＋
＋

－

航空会社数

路線距離

運航便数
（ラグ項）

機材サイズ
（ラグ項）

トレンド

＋
＋

＋

表-3 パラメタを推計したケース
番号
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)

被説明
変数
運航便数
機材ｻｲｽﾞ
運航便数
機材ｻｲｽﾞ
運航便数
機材ｻｲｽﾞ
運航便数
機材ｻｲｽﾞ
運航便数
機材ｻｲｽﾞ
運航便数
機材ｻｲｽﾞ
運航便数
機材ｻｲｽﾞ

運航便数

機材ｻｲｽﾞ

旅客数

○

○
○
○
○
○

○
○
○
○
○
○

○

○

○
○
○
○
○
○

○
○
○
○
○
○

航空会社
数
○
○
○
○
○
○
○
○
○
○
○
○
○

路線距離
○
○

運航便数
（ラグ）
○

機材ｻｲｽﾞ
（ラグ）
○

トレンド
○
○

○
○
○
○
○
○
○
○
○

○
○

○
○

○
○
○

○
○

討する．

に運航がなされてきた路線に限定して推計する（127 路

また，Pitfield et.al (2010)においては、エアライ

線，サンプル数 508）．いずれのモデルも航空会社の別ン間の競合状態をハーフィンダール・ハーシュマン指数を区別せず推計する．

と参入航空会社数の２通り検討しているが，本研究は参推計は，Stata12 を使用した．

入航空会社数のみ検討した．

使用データならびに Stata12 の実行コマンドおよび出式(1)及び式(2)は，一方の式の説明変数が別の式の被力結果は付録に示す．

説明変数として使用されている．説明変数の内生性を考慮する必要があると考えられることから，Pitfield et

2.3 符号条件

al.(2010) と 同 様 の 理 由 に よ り ， 三 段 階 最 小 二 乗 法

モデルの符号条件は表-2のとおり設定した．旅客数を（3SLS）により推計した．詳細はWooldridge(2002)を参所与（固定）とした場合，運航便数と機材サイズは，ほ照されたい．

ぼ反比例の関係にあるものと思料される．このため，運航便数を説明するモデルにあっては機材サイズ，機材サ

2.2 使用データおよびプログラム

イズを説明するモデルにあっては運航便数の符号条件をモデルの作成に使用したデータは表-1 のとおり．1 年「－」と設定した．

モデルは H23-27 年度に渡って継続して運航がなされてモデルの推計は，表-3の説明変数の組み合わせを試行

きた路線に限定して推計する（151 路線，サンプル数

し，背反するモデルは採用の候補から落とす．

604）.5 年モデルは H18-27 年度に渡って 10 年間継続的-2-

国総研資料 No.963

３．結果
3.1

(2)現況再現性

1 年モデル

H23 年度実績値→H24 年度推計値→H25 年度推計値→

説明変数の複数の組み合わせによるモデルの推計を行

H26 年度推計値→H27 年度推計値と順に推計し，推計値とったところ，符号条件を満たすモデルは以下となった．

実績値との比較を行った．実績値の入力を H23 年度に限

(1)推計結果

り繰り返し適用することで，予測としての活用可能性を

説明変数の複数の組み合わせによるモデルの推計を行検証した（図-1～図-3）．

ったところ，符号条件を満たしたのは表-4，表-5である．

細かいところにフォーカスすると多少のズレが見られ

2

なお，Hausman検定 の帰無仮説は棄却された．
1年モデル推計結果（運航便数）

切片-3.830448

0.0885999 -43.23

機材サイズ-0.8163909

0.0177537 -45.98

年間旅客数
参入航空会社数
路線距離0.8867887

0.0082026 108.11

0.1148641

0.0159522-0.1696625

0.013284 -12.77

表-5

120
100

z値

7.20

1年モデル推計結果（機材サイズ）
推計値
パラメタ

標準誤差

z値

-0.8073095

0.2520099

-3.20

運航便数

-0.1926745

0.0508726

-3.79

年間旅客数

0.1840159

0.0475837

3.87

東京国際-那覇成田国際-新千歳
成田国際-関西国際
関西国際-福岡

0切片

東京国際-大阪国際

20

説明変数

80

標準誤差

60

説明変数

運航便数

40

推計値
パラメタ

推計値（回/日（双方向））

表-4

る部分も存在するが，概ね良い結果が得られていると考

機材サイズ（1 年前）

0.7815384

0.0483453

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

実績値（回/日（双方向））

16.17

図-1

1 年モデル再現性（運航便数）

機材サイズ

50

400

運航便数（50 回/日以下を拡大）

成田国際-新千歳

300

福岡-新千歳

東京国際-広島
東京国際-北九州

20

成田国際-関西国際
東京国際-函館
関西国際-福岡
旭川-東京国際

大阪国際-鹿児島
東京国際-小松

東京国際-小松
東京国際-富山

中部国際-宮崎

旭川-東京国際
東京国際-石垣中部国際-熊本
小松-福岡

大阪国際-新千歳

100

成田国際-広島

東京国際-函館

関西国際-新千歳

200

成田国際-福岡

推計値(席/便）

30

大阪国際-新千歳

10

推計値（回/日（双方向））40

東京国際-⾧崎

富山-新千歳新潟-新千歳仙台-成田国際
成田国際-広島
福島-大阪国際

仙台-中部国際00

東京国際-大島

0

10

20

30

40

0

50

図-2
2

100

200

300

実績値（席/便）

実績値（回/日（双方向））

図-3

1 年モデル再現性（運航便数:50 回/日以下）「最小二乗推定と同時方程式による推定に差がない」を帰無仮説とする検定．

-3-

1年モデル再現性（機材サイズ）

400

機材サイズ・運航便数に関するエアライン戦略のモデル化/井上岳・川西和幸

えられる．座席数で比較的乖離の大きい，東京国際―大(2)現況再現性

島，成田国際―広島などはH23年度からH27年度にかけて

H12 年度実績値→H17 年度推計値→H22 年度推計値→

機材サイズの変動が大きかった路線（前者は，56席→120

H27 年度推計値と順に推計し，推計値と実績値との比較

席，後者は59席→146席）である．1年のラグ項に大きくを行った．実績値の入力を H12 年度に限ることで，長期依存する本モデルでは初期値依存性が非常に高く，予測予測としての活用可能性を検証した（図-4～図-7）．

への適用に留意が必要である．

LCCが参入した路線（関西～福岡）や北海道新幹線開通などの影響を受ける路線（羽田～函館）については，再3.2

5 年モデル

現が不十分であり，長期予測を実施する上では，別途の(1)推計結果考慮が必要であると判断される．

説明変数の複数の組み合わせによるモデルの推計を行ったところ，符号条件を満たしたのは表-6，表-7である．
なお，Hausman検定の帰無仮説は棄却された．

表-65年モデル推計結果（運航便数）

表-7

推計値

説明変数

パラメタ

標準誤差

5年モデル推計結果（機材サイズ）
推計値

説明変数

z値

パラメタ

標準誤差

z値

切片

-3.759713

0.1245686-30.18

切片-3.387019

0.1835625-18.45

機材サイズ-0.8097245

0.0350581-23.10運航便数-0.7367297

0.0349949-21.05

年間旅客数0.873807

0.0137695

63.46

年間旅客数

0.7213166

0.0299508

24.08

参入航空会社数0.1304208

0.0202801

6.43

機材サイズ
（5 年前）

0.1756232

0.0267375

6.57

路線距離

-0.1606353

0.0198306

-8.10

運航便数

50

120

運航便数

40

40

成田国際-新千歳
東京国際-関西国際30

成田国際-福岡
東京国際-函館

東京国際-宮崎

秋田-東京国際

東京国際-北九州

関西国際-福岡
大阪国際-鹿児島

大阪国際-那覇成田国際-大阪国際
大阪国際-熊本

福岡-対馬

10

20

東京国際-函館
関西国際-福岡

東京国際-関西国際

2060

東京国際-那覇

推計値（回/日（双方向））80

東京国際-福岡
東京国際-大阪国際

東京国際-北九州

秋田-大阪国際

大阪国際-鹿児島0

青森-大阪国際0

推計値（回/日（双方向））

100

成田国際-新千歳

0

20

40

60

80

100

0

120

20

30

40

50

実績値（回/日（双方向））

実績値（回/日（双方向））

図-4

10

5年モデル再現性（運航便数）

図-5

-4-

5年モデル再現性（運航便数50回/日以下）

国総研資料 No.963

機材サイズ

150
旭川-東京国際
東京国際-岡山
東京国際-函館
東京国際-関西国際
稚内-東京国際花巻-大阪国際

東京国際-中標津
成田国際-大阪国際
関西国際-函館
紋別-東京国際

仙台-広島

富山-新千歳福島-新千歳関西国際-福岡

東京国際-八丈島

秋田-東京国際青森-大阪国際
仙台-広島

釧路-新千歳50

100

花巻-大阪国際青森-大阪国際100

大阪国際-那覇
東京国際-佐賀

推計値（席/便）

東京国際-大阪国際

200

推計値(席/便）

300

200

400

機材サイズ

釧路-新千歳
東京国際-大島00

東京国際-大島

0

100

200

300

400

0

実績値（席/便）

図-6

50

100

150

200

実績値（席/便）

5年モデル再現性（座席数）図-75年モデル再現性（座席数200席以下）
frequency with changing demand and competition:

４．おわりにa simultaneous equations approach for traffic on
the North Atlantic, Journal of Air Transport

寡占下のエアライン間の競合関係を考慮し，かつ，路Management, Volume 16.3, pp.151-158.

線別航空需要を所与とした場合における機材サイズ・運Wooldridge, Jeffrey M.(2002): Econometric Analysis

航便数を，内生的に同時推定するためのモデル化を行っ

of Cross Section and Panel Data, The MIT Press .

た．その結果，1 年モデル，5 年モデルとも概ね現況を再現可能なモデルを構築した．ただし，5 年モデルでは，
LCC 参入や新幹線開通などの影響を受ける路線について
は，再現が不十分であり，長期予測を実施する上では，別途の考慮が必要であると判断される．
（2017 年 2 月 14 日受付）
謝辞
参考文献
国土交通省国土技術政策総合研究所(2007)：航空需要予測について
http://www.ysk.nilim.go.jp/kakubu/kukou/keika
ku/juyou1.html (2017.2.13 アクセス)
Pai, Vivek.
（2010）: On the factors that affect airline
flight frequency and aircraft size, Journal of

Air Transport Management, Volume 16.4,
pp.169-177.
Givoni, Moshe. and Piet, Rietveld.(2009): Airline’s
choice of aircraft size– Explanations andimplications, Transportation Research Part A:

Policy and Practice, Volume 43.5, pp.500-510.
Pitfield, D.E., Caves, R.E. and Quddus,M.A.(2010):
Airline strategies for aircraft size and airline-5-

機材サイズ・運航便数に関するエアライン戦略のモデル化/井上岳・川西和幸

付録Ａ．入力データ
A.1

1 年モデルの入力データ

データはすべて対数表示である．
CurrentNum
OfAL

CurrentNum
OfOps

CurrentNum
OfPsg

CurrentFleet
Size

PreviousNum
OfAL

PreviousFleet
Size

7.08590.00000.9256

11.51815.23490.00000.9513Trend

11.48815.10175.87770.00001.2771

10.53734.30590.00000.00001.310210.4598

4.3074

6.95840.69312.630013.4692

5.29870.00001.09862.639613.40195.1544

7.10820.00000.684911.01900.00005.12800.00000.687710.9032

5.09855.47230.00000.61180.00009.49483.58350.0000-0.08888.46083.5835

7.11720.00000.00000.3786

10.6363

5.12760.00000.393510.50714.9641

7.05270.00000.69312.2982

12.9409

5.1426

0.69312.308012.8752

5.02240.00007.22110.00000.686310.93174.96600.00000.6877

10.7941

4.82140.00005.86930.69312.467411.91634.2676

0.69312.356511.8186

4.13770.00006.53670.00002.475713.09275.25140.00002.482413.1801

5.11750.00006.66570.00001.2748

11.12814.41420.00000.426310.2474

4.38230.00006.85220.00001.869911.5955

4.22010.00001.515911.5130

4.29240.00005.72680.00001.855911.3425

3.92290.00001.813911.37413.93750.00006.52940.00001.7766

12.2734

5.09310.00001.790412.41815.08790.00006.55680.00001.373911.2793

4.42620.00000.507010.34314.38380.00006.76850.00001.861011.7326

4.32720.00001.910011.8926

4.28850.00006.14630.00001.869511.3728

3.91400.00001.6772

11.31023.99130.00006.07530.69311.365511.31544.50570.69311.001810.6225

4.13690.00006.39860.00000.664010.1869

3.91200.00000.28229.71283.91200.00006.48770.69312.467912.4080

4.6782

0.69312.041012.03024.67190.00006.6884

1.09863.370513.8032

4.86081.0986

3.096913.52124.87740.00006.90980.00000.672410.6187

4.24850.00000.300610.1546

4.24850.00007.1357

1.09862.4001

12.4140

4.5201

0.69311.756411.73694.29980.00006.4983

1.0986

3.209713.3704

4.60711.3863

2.949613.05654.61450.00006.31900.69312.8794

13.54135.4126

0.69312.7518

13.5780

5.34420.00006.58060.00001.369711.0740

4.30470.00001.3725

11.12174.35680.00006.67580.69312.2857

11.8388

4.20520.00001.965311.44814.04350.00006.09360.00001.7286

11.2097

3.99890.00001.7383

11.2508

3.94550.00006.08900.00000.679410.1527

3.99780.00000.987711.05714.53780.00006.59300.00001.783011.3380

4.17670.00001.8421

11.36704.01820.00006.19240.00002.063912.71975.28330.00002.131812.7320

5.13270.00006.49530.69312.203011.6826

3.99600.00002.2213

11.62593.91200.00006.57930.00001.376711.50884.83630.00001.250011.3592

4.83630.00006.62010.00001.3794

11.8767

5.17610.00000.7465

11.3463

5.17610.00006.69330.00001.375311.9073

5.17610.00001.290011.88945.17610.00006.46930.00001.3641

10.7272

3.91200.00001.373910.57443.91730.00006.2146

0.69312.2941

12.8485

5.1996

0.69312.476012.7092

5.03930.00006.37840.69312.073913.05295.3572

0.69312.081512.9866

5.37800.00006.62270.00001.2326

11.8950

5.16320.00000.507010.6047

4.98330.00006.80020.00001.366910.8066

4.08980.00001.2026

10.57484.07480.00007.00941.60943.1612

13.5806

5.10070.69312.442512.52135.03850.00007.54271.60942.655713.21595.18100.6931

1.6617

12.20515.29810.00006.79351.6094

3.156413.6956

5.14890.69312.409012.67145.06120.00005.08760.00000.58019.17344.02530.00000.59549.08584.03280.00005.86650.00001.687912.1234

5.11260.00001.692012.0779

5.03590.00006.34560.00002.4676

13.5427

5.60710.00002.467413.4801

5.54350.00006.2691

0.6931

3.0991

14.26765.76830.6931

3.109414.18995.65690.00006.27290.00001.380111.9075

5.12630.00001.3842

11.81195.10040.00006.2422

0.69314.086615.4220

5.8831

0.6931

4.092915.38535.86230.00006.5191

1.09863.035613.86445.32401.0986

3.180113.8560

5.30970.00006.54390.69312.716413.58565.24040.69312.761413.6134

5.24490.0000Distance-6-

PreviousNum
OfOps

PreviousNum
OfPsg

国総研資料 No.963

6.45200.00001.7747

11.51414.41830.00001.7663

11.3332

4.29130.00006.50280.00002.061812.5693

5.12510.00002.053412.4835

5.08800.00006.65420.00002.333612.93565.23030.00002.297912.82135.10580.00006.68590.00002.358813.1174

5.29950.00002.292413.02055.22460.00006.81010.00000.679411.0426

5.13360.00000.684910.9734

4.97560.00006.52940.69312.977313.7218

5.39400.69312.933413.6428

5.34240.00006.67200.69313.490314.4146

5.52590.6931

3.522214.38935.50700.00006.84050.69312.878713.56745.3736

0.69312.890513.4773

5.28260.00006.55540.69312.9862

13.5934

5.25270.69312.9292

13.46035.21090.00006.56670.6931

3.163913.9635

5.43370.6931

3.170713.8783

5.40080.00006.75580.6931

3.166914.17295.5516

0.6931

3.175714.07895.52400.00006.7142

0.69312.8821

13.6240

5.3456

0.69312.886913.54365.34050.00006.86480.69313.5201

13.91914.96881.09863.458513.88135.03080.00006.94791.38634.597215.83905.75391.38634.585015.8096

5.75800.00007.03000.00002.152412.5918

5.06720.00002.158412.5308

5.02680.00007.0414

1.38633.327414.16315.43661.38633.328914.0769

5.39710.00006.9903

1.38633.6771

14.4615

5.35961.38633.6356

14.3938

5.35400.00006.83301.0986

3.253413.93195.3804

1.09863.256513.8625

5.21360.00006.9305

1.09863.569514.0966

5.1391

1.09863.568714.02145.11690.00007.01301.38633.736814.6089

5.4293

1.38633.7373

14.54845.37460.00007.26960.00000.672411.28445.04280.00000.6835

11.1798

5.05600.00007.43071.38634.008715.4292

5.8984

1.38634.014015.40465.89040.00007.61090.00000.7121

11.1850

4.99320.00000.7268

11.17114.98800.00007.68290.00001.098611.7500

4.99760.00001.0894

11.6709

4.99590.00006.93930.69312.294113.0165

5.27340.69312.301512.93425.10410.00006.90680.69312.628413.13135.0816

0.69312.635913.10885.03500.00007.01930.00000.6821

11.33035.28710.00000.695911.2732

5.17530.00006.79571.38634.692815.97675.77411.38634.671815.95905.75420.00006.66701.09862.726713.84965.64281.09862.717913.78195.55520.00004.64440.00001.7291

9.8913

2.94440.00001.63439.84702.94430.00004.99040.00001.9607

10.2330

2.94440.00001.736910.09022.94440.00005.14750.00001.6591

9.89332.94500.00001.5062

9.76302.94440.00006.37160.00001.365510.8653

4.30520.00001.359211.00444.30400.00006.4151

0.69312.874412.7653

4.44670.69312.838812.75544.49250.00007.05270.69311.758311.70174.74440.00001.0432

11.0640

4.78850.00006.6267

1.09862.234911.9288

4.53240.6931

1.835511.8097

4.69910.00006.77420.00000.679410.9061

4.83630.00000.6877

10.8615

4.83630.00006.68710.00001.385611.75375.03920.00001.3877

11.64934.87430.00006.86590.00000.6835

11.1346

4.83630.00000.6931

11.1237

4.83630.00006.80900.00000.6752

10.5277

4.33590.00000.6821

10.4455

4.34540.00006.79010.00000.6807

10.5604

4.33600.00000.676610.51314.34460.00006.77540.00001.5617

11.3740

4.34750.00001.6306

11.37294.37440.00007.03610.00000.9702

11.1537

4.76240.00001.2398

11.2605

4.63850.00006.29890.00001.7844

11.49134.30460.00001.783011.42734.30350.00006.61200.69312.935213.29434.95600.00003.064313.29714.96970.00006.72140.00001.380111.72545.00340.00001.382911.66624.99460.00006.62010.00001.7715

11.9133

4.95670.00001.785311.8551

5.07180.00006.41670.00001.370411.0455

4.24850.00001.403311.0933

4.30680.00006.53960.00001.780312.07024.95690.00001.778012.0649

5.12980.00006.69210.00002.075312.5509

5.13710.00002.077412.5334

5.05940.00007.29301.09863.018913.7630

5.19001.09862.9716

13.6604

5.20010.00006.9884

1.0986

3.339713.8849

5.1471

1.0986

3.295413.85035.14180.00006.86690.00001.048011.4325

4.88140.00001.0296

11.4664

5.12520.00006.62010.00002.3681

12.31164.41090.00002.314012.1635

4.38440.00006.67830.00001.4331

11.2058

4.35430.00001.378011.03364.37820.00005.16480.00001.255510.1630

3.52600.00001.227810.17643.54240.00005.90260.00000.676610.5152

4.40210.00000.6766

10.46544.42140.00005.89160.00002.4634

11.6229

3.85560.00002.463911.5516

3.74790.0000-7-

機材サイズ・運航便数に関するエアライン戦略のモデル化/井上岳・川西和幸

5.93490.00003.085213.08434.55400.00003.085813.0649

4.50030.00005.70380.00002.876412.55044.40140.00002.888412.5192

4.33330.00006.3596

1.0986

3.263113.32024.63470.69313.1571

13.3955

4.73960.00006.51170.69312.4767

12.54484.70390.69312.503012.64314.77530.00006.4313

1.09862.911212.9675

4.56191.09862.882312.9835

4.70390.00006.1356

0.69312.481012.10104.2591

0.69312.349412.0486

4.17100.00006.3421

0.6931

2.959213.1478

4.61190.69312.8961

13.17544.76010.00006.4846

0.6931

3.173513.4095

4.85270.6931

3.188313.4909

4.88360.00006.56100.00000.666810.4509

4.30330.00000.656910.3050

4.28410.00006.89670.00000.782211.3097

5.12510.00000.793411.25145.15870.00007.1732

0.6931

1.537913.3000

6.12300.6931

1.548413.3133

6.14100.00007.05700.6931

1.893713.0166

5.54950.69311.900713.17395.70240.00006.3154

1.09862.337613.0779

5.12520.00001.526111.7375

4.93450.00007.13971.38633.265813.94315.1801

1.09862.948013.76095.33530.00007.40850.00001.2461

11.7757

4.92670.00000.6931

11.3432

4.99920.00007.17701.60943.5352

14.2633

5.26270.6931

3.021713.8430

5.40540.00007.08760.00001.095911.4256

5.07510.00001.034511.3503

4.86730.00006.44890.00001.349311.7984

5.17610.00001.373212.0740

5.17610.00007.17630.69312.420813.0218

5.26640.69312.292913.12275.31450.00007.13170.69312.291812.9571

5.3411

0.69312.261213.04645.22670.00006.02830.00001.376010.4176

3.58640.00001.377410.38653.58930.00007.14360.00000.013610.8118

5.63290.0000-0.0055

10.65115.13970.00007.21600.00000.9492

11.4645

5.11610.00000.6863

11.2501

5.07960.00006.24220.00001.378010.2995

3.58350.00001.373910.2908

3.58350.00005.76520.00002.4147

11.5870

3.73690.00002.4792

11.58443.67960.00006.03790.69311.773810.8740

3.81570.00001.780310.9153

3.91600.00005.56070.69312.0852

11.4447

4.0676

0.69312.0446

11.4305

4.28410.00005.24700.00002.055512.10174.85600.00002.054512.14174.86000.00005.39820.00001.715410.55903.66360.00001.694510.5147

3.66360.00005.72681.0986

3.319212.9625

4.39130.00002.890112.6580

4.27700.00005.61310.00001.6023

10.46433.78730.00001.790810.77073.88910.00006.01130.00000.6411

9.55403.58360.00000.66549.39103.57250.00006.51030.00000.671010.33244.30330.00000.6821

10.20424.30410.00006.9157

1.09863.509514.1890

5.2113

1.09863.5681

14.1744

5.19830.00007.38650.6931

1.841612.95465.66440.69311.7931

12.86295.69920.00005.64190.00001.6056

10.39103.58350.00001.751710.5111

3.58350.00005.62040.00001.7507

11.45674.59800.00001.8063

11.4706

4.54580.00005.92430.00001.7644

11.4660

4.57210.00001.783511.3838

4.31260.00005.54910.00002.2982

11.1916

3.58350.00002.092011.0408

3.58350.00005.37990.00001.350010.6985

4.30580.00001.720810.9373

4.30970.00005.17050.00000.59089.1356

3.58350.00000.57249.05493.58350.00005.17050.00000.59089.1356

3.58350.00000.57249.05493.58350.00007.08590.00000.943911.6806

5.31410.00000.9256

11.51815.23490.6931

5.87770.00001.325610.7985

4.47350.00001.2771

10.53734.30590.6931

6.95840.69312.730813.6075

5.33950.69312.630013.4692

5.29870.6931

7.10820.00000.679410.8601

4.85470.00000.684911.0190

5.12800.69315.47230.00000.64409.76503.58350.00000.61189.49483.58350.6931

7.11720.00000.361610.7032

5.11990.00000.3786

10.6363

5.1276

0.6931

7.05270.69312.293212.9670

5.1406

0.69312.2982

12.9409

5.1426

0.69317.22110.00000.686310.82074.86160.00000.686310.93174.96600.69315.86930.69312.477612.0582

4.22750.69312.467411.91634.2676

0.6931

6.53670.00002.469013.1203

5.21100.00002.475713.09275.25140.6931

6.66570.00001.465911.39394.41210.00001.2748

11.12814.4142

0.69316.85220.00001.800911.5134

4.21430.00001.869911.5955

4.2201

0.69315.72680.00001.7826

11.40024.21080.00001.855911.3425

3.92290.6931

6.52940.00001.768712.2243

5.10380.00001.7766

12.2734

5.0931

0.6931

6.55680.00001.596811.6040

4.41830.00001.373911.2793

4.4262

0.6931

6.76850.00002.0722

11.7853

4.31930.00001.861011.7326

4.3272

0.6931-8-

国総研資料 No.963

6.14630.00001.9514

11.4293

4.10020.00001.869511.3728

3.91400.69316.07530.00001.3718

11.3920

4.8291

0.69311.365511.31544.50570.6931

6.39860.00001.369710.7489

3.94490.00000.664010.1869

3.91200.6931

6.48770.69312.6201

12.3836

4.39440.69312.467912.4080

4.6782

0.6931

6.6884

1.0986

3.541313.7795

4.8873

1.09863.370513.8032

4.86080.69316.90980.00001.357811.0276

4.21740.00000.672410.6187

4.24850.69317.13571.38632.744612.76514.67501.09862.4001

12.4140

4.5201

0.6931

6.4983

1.38633.521913.5024

4.7367

1.0986

3.209713.3704

4.6071

0.6931

6.31900.69312.875013.5595

5.3922

0.69312.8794

13.54135.4126

0.69316.58060.00001.393111.09224.31760.00001.369711.0740

4.30470.6931

6.67580.69312.378811.9800

4.19550.69312.2857

11.8388

4.2052

0.6931

6.0936

0.69312.2672

11.4982

4.11710.00001.7286

11.2097

3.99890.69316.08900.00000.6807

10.2586

4.33070.00000.679410.1527

3.99780.6931

6.59300.00001.783011.3237

4.07740.00001.783011.3380

4.17670.6931

6.19240.00002.069512.7373

5.30900.00002.063912.71975.28330.6931

6.49530.69312.278211.8026

4.00740.69312.203011.6826

3.99600.6931

6.57930.00001.3725

11.4940

4.86900.00001.376711.50884.83630.69316.62010.00000.7281

11.1635

5.17610.00001.3794

11.8767

5.1761

0.6931

6.69330.00001.204211.6404

5.17610.00001.375311.9073

5.1761

0.6931

6.46930.00001.369710.9001

4.24610.00001.3641

10.7272

3.91200.6931

6.2146

1.09862.363712.9069

5.11430.69312.2941

12.8485

5.1996

0.6931

6.37840.69312.075013.07745.31650.69312.073913.05295.3572

0.69316.62270.00002.096812.9397

5.19300.00001.2326

11.8950

5.1632

0.69316.8002

0.69311.369010.9652

4.76130.00001.366910.8066

4.08980.69317.00941.6094

3.239613.7254

5.11751.60943.1612

13.5806

5.10070.6931

7.54271.60942.825913.5052

5.19661.60942.655713.21595.18100.6931

6.79351.60943.346613.98105.14371.6094

3.156413.6956

5.14890.69315.08760.00000.56789.33764.03240.00000.58019.17344.02530.69315.86650.00001.725212.1026

5.11900.00001.687912.1234

5.1126

0.6931

6.34560.00002.470913.5777

5.65800.00002.4676

13.5427

5.6071

0.6931

6.2691

0.6931

3.167414.3066

5.69290.6931

3.0991

14.26765.76830.6931

6.27290.00001.375311.8976

5.14310.00001.380111.9075

5.12630.6931

6.2422

0.69314.100915.4784

5.87770.69314.086615.4220

5.8831

0.6931

6.5191

1.0986

3.123313.92455.3042

1.09863.035613.86445.32400.6931

6.54390.69312.061512.89455.43650.69312.716413.58565.24040.69316.45200.00001.7701

11.5255

4.40220.00001.7747

11.51414.41830.69316.50280.00002.070512.6608

5.13380.00002.061812.5693

5.1251

0.69316.65420.00002.387413.14875.23120.00002.333612.93565.23030.69316.68590.00002.377013.31105.35170.00002.358813.1174

5.29950.69316.81010.00000.686311.1695

5.12550.00000.679411.0426

5.1336

0.6931

6.52940.69312.986113.76935.4561

0.69312.977313.7218

5.39400.6931

6.67200.69313.4801

14.39935.53950.69313.490314.4146

5.52590.69316.84050.69312.8993

13.5849

5.4211

0.69312.878713.56745.3736

0.6931

6.55540.6931

3.028613.6732

5.2881

0.69312.9862

13.5934

5.25270.6931

6.56670.6931

3.165514.00485.4746

0.6931

3.163913.9635

5.43370.69316.75580.6931

3.167714.16595.6036

0.6931

3.166914.17295.5516

0.6931

6.7142

0.69312.987913.68785.35030.69312.8821

13.6240

5.3456

0.6931

6.86480.69313.504913.97295.01500.69313.5201

13.91914.96880.6931

6.94791.38634.709215.88645.6922

1.38634.597215.83905.75390.69317.03000.00002.161012.6271

5.04110.00002.152412.5918

5.0672

0.6931

7.0414

1.38633.5756

14.58295.4352

1.38633.327414.16315.4366

0.69316.9903

1.38633.7282

14.5200

5.3704

1.38633.6771

14.4615

5.3596

0.6931

6.83301.09863.3222

13.9491

5.2602

1.0986

3.253413.93195.38040.69316.9305

1.0986

3.574614.14175.2132

1.09863.569514.0966

5.1391

0.6931

7.01301.38633.830514.64145.45051.38633.736814.6089

5.42930.6931

7.26960.00000.684911.3273

5.10450.00000.672411.28445.04280.69317.4307

1.09864.031415.44395.91451.38634.008715.4292

5.89840.69317.61090.00000.6752

11.1927

5.00210.00000.7121

11.1850

4.9932

0.6931-9-

機材サイズ・運航便数に関するエアライン戦略のモデル化/井上岳・川西和幸

7.68290.69311.7455

12.5887

5.24520.00001.098611.7500

4.9976

0.6931

6.9393

1.09862.561613.0705

5.0762

0.69312.294113.0165

5.27340.69316.90680.69312.624913.17235.03180.69312.628413.13135.0816

0.69317.01930.00000.6682

11.33445.30880.00000.6821

11.33035.2871

0.6931

6.79571.38634.682816.0072

5.78451.38634.692815.97675.7741

0.6931

6.66701.09862.710113.90705.6791

1.09862.726713.84965.64280.69314.64440.00001.72239.95302.94600.00001.7291

9.8913

2.94440.69314.99040.00001.968010.29342.95040.00001.9607

10.2330

2.94440.69315.14750.00001.63279.92092.91500.00001.6591

9.89332.94500.6931

6.37160.00001.377410.9632

4.30490.00001.365510.8653

4.3052

0.6931

6.4151

0.69312.985312.8606

4.4536

0.69312.874412.7653

4.44670.6931

7.05270.69311.771011.77634.70870.69311.758311.70174.74440.69316.6267

1.09862.351511.9393

4.4772

1.09862.234911.9288

4.53240.69316.77420.00000.6821

10.9227

4.85840.00000.679410.9061

4.83630.6931

6.68710.00002.0597

11.83614.46050.00001.385611.75375.0392

0.6931

6.86590.00000.6752

11.09824.83890.00000.6835

11.1346

4.83630.69316.80900.00000.662510.6445

4.34970.00000.6752

10.5277

4.33590.69316.79010.00000.666810.61624.34670.00000.6807

10.5604

4.33600.69316.77540.00001.7738

11.6238

4.36180.00001.5617

11.3740

4.34750.69317.0361

0.6931

0.9691

11.24635.01640.00000.9702

11.1537

4.76240.6931

6.29890.00001.7872

11.5386

4.30370.00001.7844

11.49134.3046

0.6931

6.61201.38633.2071

13.6340

4.95740.69312.935213.29434.95600.6931

6.72140.00001.393111.80515.03660.00001.380111.72545.00340.69316.62010.00001.7881

11.88374.86410.00001.7715

11.9133

4.95670.6931

6.41670.00001.366911.1060

4.24850.00001.370411.0455

4.24850.6931

6.53960.00001.799912.0977

4.99980.00001.780312.07024.95690.6931

6.6921

0.69312.366012.8442

5.16200.00002.075312.5509

5.1371

0.69317.29301.09862.969113.75755.23201.09863.018913.7630

5.19000.6931

6.98841.60943.421514.05445.20281.0986

3.339713.8849

5.1471

0.69316.86690.00000.9702

11.4309

5.11270.00001.048011.4325

4.88140.69316.62010.00002.294612.30814.41300.00002.3681

12.31164.41090.6931

6.67830.00001.7085

11.58814.42800.00001.4331

11.2058

4.35430.6931

5.16480.00001.294510.2558

3.54600.00001.255510.1630

3.52600.69315.90260.00000.661110.4753

4.40580.00000.676610.5152

4.4021

0.6931

5.89160.00002.467611.80883.88840.00002.4634

11.6229

3.8556

0.69315.93490.6931

3.168113.1477

4.65600.00003.085213.08434.55400.69315.70380.00002.483812.53684.80220.00002.876412.55044.40140.6931

6.3596

1.09863.444613.4416

4.7075

1.0986

3.263113.32024.63470.6931

6.51170.69312.5102

12.6606

4.68750.69312.4767

12.54484.70390.69316.4313

1.09862.997612.99104.5882

1.09862.911212.9675

4.56190.69316.1356

0.69312.650312.17174.19040.69312.481012.10104.2591

0.6931

6.34211.3863

3.197813.20674.6422

0.6931

2.959213.1478

4.61190.6931

6.4846

0.6931

3.257413.43024.86290.6931

3.173513.4095

4.85270.6931

6.56100.00000.676610.4570

4.30410.00000.666810.4509

4.30330.6931

6.89670.00000.7996

11.3153

5.10590.00000.782211.3097

5.1251

0.69317.1732

0.69312.001913.48395.85740.6931

1.537913.3000

6.12300.6931

7.05700.6931

2.113113.22545.44480.6931

1.893713.0166

5.54950.69316.3154

1.09862.729013.3962

5.1136

1.09862.337613.0779

5.1252

0.6931

7.13971.38633.219313.9434

5.08471.38633.265813.94315.1801

0.6931

7.4085

1.09861.708512.2951

5.10270.00001.2461

11.7757

4.92670.6931

7.17701.38633.344814.17485.17861.60943.5352

14.2633

5.26270.69317.08760.00001.0913

11.3340

4.91750.00001.095911.4256

5.0751

0.6931

6.44890.00001.1597

11.5568

5.17610.00001.349311.7984

5.1761

0.6931

7.17630.69312.360112.9378

5.2746

0.69312.420813.0218

5.26640.6931

7.1317

1.0986

2.1942

12.8433

5.08940.69312.291812.9571

5.3411

0.6931

6.02830.00001.376010.47583.58640.00001.376010.4176

3.58640.6931

7.14360.00000.679411.1357

4.91780.00000.013610.8118

5.63290.6931

7.21600.69311.380811.8484

5.11270.00000.9492

11.4645

5.1161

0.6931- 10 -

国総研資料 No.963

6.24220.00001.377410.35223.58350.00001.378010.2995

3.58350.6931

5.76520.00002.638911.66493.66880.00002.4147

11.5870

3.73690.6931

6.03790.6931

1.784010.9426

3.81240.69311.773810.8740

3.81570.69315.56070.69312.0812

11.5185

4.0542

0.69312.0852

11.4447

4.0676

0.6931

5.24700.00002.0552

12.1447

4.84220.00002.055512.10174.85600.6931

5.39820.00001.701510.7308

3.66360.00001.715410.55903.6636

0.69315.72681.38633.392413.06594.3945

1.0986

3.319212.9625

4.39130.6931

5.61310.00001.379410.1687

3.58500.00001.6023

10.46433.78730.69316.01130.00000.65409.59783.57880.00000.6411

9.55403.5836

0.69316.51030.00000.690410.43484.30410.00000.671010.33244.30330.6931

6.9157

1.09863.504514.2285

5.19501.09863.509514.1890

5.21130.69317.3865

1.09862.075713.08935.55370.6931

1.841612.95465.66440.69315.64190.00001.9011

10.7802

3.58350.00001.6056

10.39103.58350.69315.62040.00001.764911.4956

4.66250.00001.7507

11.45674.59800.6931

5.92430.00001.764911.4998

4.31160.00001.7644

11.4660

4.5721

0.6931

5.54910.00002.1797

11.2775

3.58350.00002.2982

11.1916

3.58350.69315.37990.00001.368311.0030

4.30740.00001.350010.6985

4.30580.69315.17050.00000.62959.23603.58350.00000.59089.1356

3.58350.69315.17050.00000.62959.23603.58350.00000.59089.1356

3.58350.69317.08590.00000.946011.69105.29570.00000.943911.6806

5.3141

1.09865.87770.00001.287010.76854.47060.00001.325610.7985

4.4735

1.09866.95840.69312.634513.60815.3706

0.69312.730813.6075

5.3395

1.0986

7.10820.00000.6821

10.86814.93590.00000.679410.8601

4.8547

1.09865.47230.00000.67389.7452

3.58350.00000.64409.76503.5835

1.0986

7.11720.00000.662511.0848

5.11700.00000.361610.7032

5.11991.0986

7.05270.69312.286012.9630

5.1391

0.69312.293212.9670

5.1406

1.0986

7.22110.00000.672410.8052

4.83810.00000.686310.82074.8616

1.09865.86930.69312.594612.0780

4.13430.69312.477612.0582

4.2275

1.09866.53670.00002.471613.0836

5.11750.00002.469013.1203

5.21101.09866.66570.00001.509811.4088

4.39530.00001.465911.39394.4121

1.09866.8522

0.69312.3192

11.9924

4.29210.00001.800911.5134

4.2143

1.09865.72680.69312.1483

11.61314.22120.00001.7826

11.40024.21081.09866.52940.00001.727212.0836

4.90880.00001.768712.2243

5.10381.09866.55680.00001.7733

11.69224.37400.00001.596811.6040

4.4183

1.09866.76850.00002.0552

11.7783

4.17840.00002.0722

11.7853

4.3193

1.0986

6.14630.00001.938811.4026

4.06790.00001.9514

11.4293

4.1002

1.09866.07530.00001.3767

11.3146

4.82840.00001.3718

11.3920

4.8291

1.09866.39860.00001.362010.9040

4.20760.00001.369710.7489

3.94491.09866.48770.69312.612512.3078

4.36100.69312.6201

12.3836

4.3944

1.09866.6884

1.09863.353913.70454.8522

1.0986

3.541313.7795

4.8873

1.09866.90980.00001.3662

11.1474

4.21710.00001.357811.0276

4.2174

1.09867.13571.38632.621512.75164.77401.38632.744612.76514.67501.09866.4983

1.60943.5172

13.5247

4.7132

1.38633.521913.5024

4.7367

1.0986

6.31900.69312.879513.5624

5.33430.69312.875013.5595

5.3922

1.09866.58060.00001.374611.03664.30400.00001.393111.09224.3176

1.09866.67580.69312.480112.0340

4.15500.69312.378811.9800

4.1955

1.09866.0936

0.69312.2287

11.4752

4.09630.69312.2672

11.4982

4.1171

1.09866.08900.00001.3767

11.22114.33070.00000.6807

10.2586

4.3307

1.09866.59300.00001.7867

11.35414.19170.00001.783011.3237

4.0774

1.0986

6.19240.00002.067412.7705

5.24940.00002.069512.7373

5.30901.09866.49530.69312.062511.89534.3846

0.69312.278211.8026

4.0074

1.0986

6.57930.00001.3571

11.4235

4.89590.00001.3725

11.4940

4.86901.09866.62010.0000-1.16378.98135.17610.00000.7281

11.1635

5.1761

1.09866.69330.00001.291511.8332

5.17610.00001.204211.6404

5.1761

1.0986

6.46930.00000.6752

10.2367

4.18600.00001.369710.9001

4.2461

1.0986

6.2146

0.69312.162212.73625.04681.09862.363712.9069

5.1143

1.09866.37840.69312.076413.07215.3512

0.69312.075013.07745.3165

1.09866.62270.69312.7636

13.6157

5.19260.00002.096812.9397

5.19301.0986- 11 -

機材サイズ・運航便数に関するエアライン戦略のモデル化/井上岳・川西和幸

6.8002

0.6931

1.5261

11.8680

4.91300.69311.369010.9652

4.7613

1.09867.0094

1.09863.0151

13.6249

5.11281.6094

3.239613.7254

5.1175

1.0986

7.54271.60942.8026

13.57855.2553

1.60942.825913.5052

5.1966

1.09866.79351.60943.323714.0591

5.16541.60943.346613.98105.1437

1.09865.08760.00000.58019.3086

4.78720.00000.56789.33764.0324

1.09865.86650.00001.728612.0260

5.11130.00001.725212.1026

5.11901.09866.34560.00002.463713.5680

5.67310.00002.470913.5777

5.65801.0986

6.2691

0.6931

3.169714.30915.67980.6931

3.167414.3066

5.69291.09866.27290.00001.3822

11.86225.13000.00001.375311.8976

5.1431

1.09866.2422

0.69314.118815.47845.83750.69314.100915.4784

5.8777

1.09866.5191

1.0986

3.144413.9170

5.3056

1.0986

3.123313.92455.3042

1.09866.54390.69312.339713.0626

5.31930.69312.061512.89455.4365

1.09866.45200.00001.772911.4827

4.34350.00001.7701

11.5255

4.4022

1.09866.50280.00002.292412.69625.09980.00002.070512.6608

5.13381.09866.6542

0.69312.585013.22105.19030.00002.387413.14875.2312

1.09866.68590.00002.3732

13.2284

5.37530.00002.377013.31105.3517

1.09866.81010.00001.3815

11.5636

4.97990.00000.686311.1695

5.1255

1.09866.52940.6931

3.1222

13.78445.40630.69312.986113.76935.4561

1.09866.67200.69313.519314.40075.4892

0.69313.4801

14.39935.5395

1.09866.84050.69312.9337

13.61625.33230.69312.8993

13.5849

5.4211

1.09866.55540.6931

3.166913.71815.34470.6931

3.028613.6732

5.2881

1.09866.56670.6931

3.247513.98295.39480.6931

3.165514.00485.4746

1.09866.75580.6931

3.172914.16505.54670.6931

3.167714.16595.6036

1.09866.7142

0.69312.989013.69885.32200.69312.987913.68785.3503

1.09866.86480.6931

3.565313.97675.04090.69313.504913.97295.01501.09866.94791.38634.678215.92255.7132

1.38634.709215.88645.6922

1.09867.03000.00002.377012.8250

5.00480.00002.161012.6271

5.0411

1.0986

7.0414

1.3863

3.5793

14.6105

5.42261.38633.5756

14.58295.4352

1.09866.9903

1.09863.600614.47445.4183

1.38633.7282

14.5200

5.3704

1.09866.83301.0986

3.325013.95535.2087

1.09863.3222

13.9491

5.2602

1.09866.9305

1.09863.569014.1340

5.2136

1.0986

3.574614.14175.2132

1.09867.01301.38633.818014.6250

5.4204

1.38633.830514.64145.4505

1.0986

7.26960.00000.666811.0770

5.10590.00000.684911.3273

5.1045

1.09867.4307

1.0986

3.989215.4057

5.8941

1.09864.031415.44395.9145

1.09867.61090.00000.6835

11.2485

4.97680.00000.6752

11.1927

5.0021

1.09867.68291.09862.602813.6497

5.22370.69311.7455

12.5887

5.2452

1.09866.9393

1.09862.463713.05175.10281.09862.561613.0705

5.0762

1.09866.90680.69312.626913.18645.09280.69312.624913.17235.03181.09867.01930.00000.656911.35835.32690.00000.6682

11.33445.30881.09866.79571.38634.6651

16.00255.7682

1.38634.682816.0072

5.7845

1.09866.66701.09862.767113.90425.6367

1.09862.710113.90705.6791

1.09864.64440.00001.72039.95342.94440.00001.72239.95302.94601.09864.99040.00001.983210.32912.94440.00001.968010.29342.9504

1.0986

5.14750.00001.65509.93762.94440.00001.63279.92092.91501.09866.37160.00001.3641

10.8498

4.30410.00001.377410.9632

4.30491.09866.4151

1.09862.978712.9018

4.44950.69312.985312.8606

4.4536

1.0986

7.05270.69311.771511.79694.73830.69311.771011.77634.7087

1.09866.6267

1.09862.3392

11.93714.5484

1.09862.351511.9393

4.4772

1.09866.77420.00000.666810.94594.89510.00000.6821

10.9227

4.8584

1.09866.6871

0.69312.069511.8840

4.44320.00002.0597

11.83614.4605

1.09866.86590.00000.7108

11.17214.96700.00000.6752

11.09824.83891.09866.80900.00000.684910.6636

4.42780.00000.662510.6445

4.3497

1.09866.79010.00000.6526

10.6624

4.42810.00000.666810.61624.3467

1.09866.77540.00001.7807

11.66694.41030.00001.7738

11.6238

4.36181.09867.0361

0.69310.966011.2732

5.0191

0.6931

0.9691

11.24635.0164

1.09866.29890.00001.7794

11.56644.30470.00001.7872

11.5386

4.3037

1.09866.61201.38633.1381

13.57434.95611.38633.2071

13.6340

4.9574

1.09866.72140.00001.386311.84965.04090.00001.393111.80515.0366

1.0986- 12 -

国総研資料 No.963

6.62010.00002.024912.06174.98060.00001.7881

11.88374.8641

1.09866.41670.00001.361311.0774

4.20650.00001.366911.1060

4.2485

1.09866.53960.00001.778012.0223

4.92800.00001.799912.0977

4.99981.09866.6921

0.69312.424912.8925

5.11230.69312.366012.8442

5.16201.09867.29301.09862.950213.7758

5.22591.09862.969113.75755.23201.09866.9884

1.38633.352214.0155

5.16881.60943.421514.05445.20281.09866.86690.00000.965011.4146

5.11650.00000.9702

11.4309

5.1127

1.09866.62010.00002.297412.3018

4.41880.00002.294612.30814.41301.09866.67830.00001.7654

11.54114.38330.00001.7085

11.58814.42801.0986

5.16480.00001.2847

10.26373.54490.00001.294510.2558

3.54601.09865.90260.00000.676610.4548

4.39880.00000.661110.4753

4.40581.09865.89160.00002.2734

11.6947

4.12720.00002.467611.80883.8884

1.09865.93490.6931

3.170013.1580

4.6402

0.6931

3.168113.1477

4.65601.09865.70380.00002.4767

12.5284

4.58210.00002.483812.53684.8022

1.09866.3596

1.0986

3.228313.41624.6392

1.09863.444613.4416

4.7075

1.09866.51170.69312.638512.7697

4.68000.69312.5102

12.6606

4.6875

1.09866.4313

1.09862.994412.95434.51781.09862.997612.99104.5882

1.09866.1356

1.09862.633812.1893

4.2131

0.69312.650312.17174.1904

1.09866.3421

0.69313.088413.19714.61651.3863

3.197813.20674.6422

1.09866.4846

0.6931

3.2531

13.4606

4.89030.6931

3.257413.43024.86291.09866.56100.00000.6512

10.4187

4.30410.00000.676610.4570

4.3041

1.09866.89670.00000.7797

11.26215.10590.00000.7996

11.3153

5.10591.09867.1732

0.69312.253513.73625.9322

0.69312.001913.48395.8574

1.0986

7.05701.09862.826913.6138

5.12390.6931

2.113113.22545.44481.09866.3154

1.09862.456013.2138

5.1343

1.09862.729013.3962

5.1136

1.0986

7.13971.38633.238013.9615

5.1102

1.38633.219313.9434

5.0847

1.0986

7.4085

1.0986

1.786312.4164

5.1231

1.09861.708512.2951

5.1027

1.0986

7.17701.38633.300014.0878

5.14351.38633.344814.17485.1786

1.09867.08760.00001.0876

11.3149

4.93350.00001.0913

11.3340

4.9175

1.09866.44890.00000.682111.0992

5.17610.00001.1597

11.5568

5.1761

1.0986

7.17630.69312.0253

12.6942

5.16250.69312.360112.9378

5.2746

1.0986

7.1317

1.09862.250612.8357

5.0485

1.0986

2.1942

12.8433

5.0894

1.09866.02830.00001.625710.5098

3.58350.00001.376010.47583.5864

1.0986

7.14360.00000.672411.1224

4.96980.00000.679411.1357

4.91781.0986

7.21600.69311.373911.8326

5.10840.69311.380811.8484

5.1127

1.09866.24220.00001.366910.3314

3.58350.00001.377410.35223.5835

1.09865.76520.00002.399411.7347

4.03490.00002.638911.66493.66881.09866.03790.00002.068110.9967

3.58350.6931

1.784010.9426

3.8124

1.09865.56070.69312.083911.5207

4.0461

0.69312.0812

11.5185

4.0542

1.0986

5.24700.00002.0677

12.13104.60070.00002.0552

12.1447

4.8422

1.09865.39820.00001.717910.7649

3.66360.00001.701510.7308

3.6636

1.09865.72681.0986

3.347413.0818

4.28111.38633.392413.06594.3945

1.0986

5.61310.00001.3767

10.1075

3.58570.00001.379410.1687

3.58501.09866.01130.00000.64699.94694.30410.00000.65409.59783.57881.09866.51030.00001.1265

10.63894.30410.00000.690410.43484.3041

1.09866.91571.38633.586414.2699

5.15491.09863.504514.2285

5.19501.09867.3865

1.09862.071513.0560

5.4134

1.09862.075713.08935.5537

1.09865.64190.00001.9161

10.8884

3.58350.00001.9011

10.7802

3.5835

1.09865.62040.00001.732511.50624.67520.00001.764911.4956

4.6625

1.09865.92430.00001.7296

11.5026

4.30950.00001.764911.4998

4.3116

1.09865.54910.00002.244811.3705

3.58350.00002.1797

11.2775

3.5835

1.09865.37990.00001.354311.0487

4.30540.00001.368311.0030

4.3074

1.0986

5.17050.00000.64839.3142

3.58350.00000.62959.23603.5835

1.0986

5.17050.00000.64839.3142

3.58350.00000.62959.23603.5835

1.09867.08590.00000.9492

11.6315

5.32520.00000.946011.69105.29571.38635.87770.00001.296010.7420

4.30830.00001.287010.76854.47061.3863

6.95840.69312.640013.63675.4776

0.69312.634513.60815.37061.3863

7.10820.00000.678010.90314.94460.00000.6821

10.86814.93591.3863- 13 -

機材サイズ・運航便数に関するエアライン戦略のモデル化/井上岳・川西和幸

5.47230.00000.64119.81043.58350.00000.67389.7452

3.58351.3863

7.11720.00000.6766

11.1175

5.11010.00000.662511.0848

5.11701.38637.05270.69312.300913.0218

5.1991

0.69312.286012.9630

5.13911.38637.22110.00000.684910.7580

4.81730.00000.672410.8052

4.83811.38635.86930.69312.6032

12.1120

4.10490.69312.594612.0780

4.1343

1.38636.53670.00002.483313.15215.11770.00002.471613.0836

5.11751.3863

6.66570.00001.633311.5092

4.39050.00001.509811.4088

4.3953

1.38636.8522

0.69312.484012.13174.26090.69312.3192

11.9924

4.29211.38635.72680.6931

2.264911.7100

4.09540.69312.1483

11.61314.2212

1.3863

6.52940.00001.777512.1696

4.90360.00001.727212.0836

4.90881.3863

6.55680.00001.7872

11.6893

4.40570.00001.7733

11.69224.37401.38636.76850.00002.062211.85884.29950.00002.0552

11.7783

4.1784

1.3863

6.14630.00001.9305

11.39413.92230.00001.938811.4026

4.06791.38636.07530.00001.3842

11.3667

4.83150.00001.3767

11.3146

4.8284

1.3863

6.39860.00001.357810.5095

4.16780.00001.362010.9040

4.20761.38636.48770.69312.6137

12.2436

4.3572

0.69312.612512.3078

4.36101.38636.6884

1.09863.330813.68234.8001

1.09863.353913.70454.8522

1.38636.90980.00001.356411.1149

4.19000.00001.3662

11.1474

4.21711.38637.1357

1.09862.4312

12.57104.59311.38632.621512.75164.77401.38636.4983

1.09863.282813.4906

4.66971.60943.5172

13.5247

4.7132

1.38636.31900.69312.888813.58285.2932

0.69312.879513.5624

5.3343

1.38636.58060.00001.396511.02234.30380.00001.374611.03664.30401.38636.67580.69312.471812.0638

4.14550.69312.480112.0340

4.15501.3863

6.0936

0.69312.178211.5044

4.1281

0.69312.2287

11.4752

4.0963

1.38636.08900.00001.3808

11.3358

4.33070.00001.3767

11.22114.33071.3863

6.59300.00001.785811.4401

4.23860.00001.7867

11.35414.19171.3863

6.19240.00002.076712.7626

5.21120.00002.067412.7705

5.2494

1.38636.49530.69312.0691

12.00744.6642

0.69312.062511.89534.38461.3863

6.57930.00000.6877

11.14225.07530.00001.3571

11.4235

4.89591.38636.62010.00000.892411.3664

5.17610.0000-1.16378.98135.17611.3863

6.69330.00001.005911.7143

5.17610.00001.291511.8332

5.17611.38636.46930.00000.672410.12544.23810.00000.6752

10.2367

4.18601.3863

6.2146

0.69312.170712.7322

4.99980.69312.162212.73625.04681.38636.37840.69312.080813.01465.27450.69312.076413.07215.3512

1.38636.62270.69312.6902

13.6355

5.1641

0.69312.7636

13.6157

5.19261.38636.8002

0.6931

1.738312.2926

4.9866

0.6931

1.5261

11.8680

4.91301.38637.0094

1.38633.125713.9339

5.16281.09863.0151

13.6249

5.11281.38637.5427

1.09862.5887

13.5243

5.25441.60942.8026

13.57855.2553

1.38636.79351.60943.472714.3360

5.1533

1.60943.323714.0591

5.1654

1.38635.08760.00000.07148.75644.78740.00000.58019.3086

4.7872

1.38635.86650.00001.694012.0050

5.10450.00001.728612.0260

5.1113

1.3863

6.34560.00002.471813.0360

5.14750.00002.463713.5680

5.67311.3863

6.2691

0.6931

3.171913.8475

5.2056

0.6931

3.169714.30915.67981.3863

6.27290.00001.379411.90415.11150.00001.3822

11.86225.13001.3863

6.2422

0.6931

4.094415.46315.80300.69314.118815.47845.83751.38636.5191

1.0986

3.164413.9560

5.3095

1.0986

3.144413.9170

5.30561.3863

6.54390.69312.512413.3120

5.35500.69312.339713.0626

5.3193

1.38636.45200.00001.776111.6491

4.48540.00001.772911.4827

4.34351.38636.50280.00002.294612.7620

5.10200.00002.292412.69625.09981.38636.65420.00002.427613.15385.21400.69312.585013.22105.1903

1.38636.68590.00002.299013.22965.34060.00002.3732

13.2284

5.3753

1.38636.81010.00001.371811.6595

5.03870.00001.3815

11.5636

4.97991.3863

6.52940.6931

3.097113.81095.41170.6931

3.1222

13.78445.4063

1.38636.67200.6931

3.507214.31655.49080.69313.519314.40075.4892

1.38636.8405

1.09862.989113.6484

5.2772

0.69312.9337

13.61625.3323

1.38636.55540.69313.135513.7125

5.3096

0.6931

3.166913.71815.34471.38636.56670.6931

3.248413.9966

5.3591

0.6931

3.247513.98295.39481.38636.75580.6931

3.173714.16225.52380.6931

3.172914.16505.54671.3863- 14 -

国総研資料 No.963

6.7142

0.69312.995213.70845.29890.69312.989013.69885.32201.38636.86480.69313.473813.9657

5.04140.6931

3.565313.97675.04091.3863

6.94791.38634.675715.91465.66661.38634.678215.92255.7132

1.38637.03000.00002.420612.9073

5.01490.00002.377012.8250

5.00481.38637.0414

1.09863.569014.63155.44561.3863

3.5793

14.6105

5.42261.38636.9903

1.09863.609114.45435.44191.09863.600614.47445.4183

1.3863

6.83301.09863.330013.97965.2556

1.0986

3.325013.95535.20871.38636.9305

1.09863.580114.16485.2146

1.09863.569014.1340

5.21361.38637.01301.38633.8171

14.6287

5.41301.38633.818014.6250

5.4204

1.38637.26960.00000.686311.13175.10590.00000.666811.0770

5.10591.38637.4307

1.0986

4.115915.4730

5.8027

1.0986

3.989215.4057

5.89411.38637.61090.00000.695911.3527

4.97890.00000.6835

11.2485

4.97681.38637.68290.6931

1.945912.9285

5.3763

1.09862.602813.6497

5.22371.38636.9393

1.09862.473413.08625.13191.09862.463713.05175.10281.38636.90680.69312.627613.2189

5.16830.69312.626913.18645.09281.38637.01930.00000.6807

11.35195.27450.00000.656911.35835.32691.38636.79571.38634.691716.01455.74671.38634.6651

16.00255.7682

1.3863

6.66701.09862.7702

13.9186

5.6021

1.09862.767113.90425.63671.38634.64440.00001.71349.86882.94440.00001.72039.95342.9444

1.38634.99040.00002.004410.40912.94440.00001.983210.32912.9444

1.3863

5.14750.00001.67169.92942.94440.00001.65509.93762.9444

1.38636.37160.00001.373910.9204

4.31790.00001.3641

10.8498

4.30411.3863

6.4151

1.09862.986412.90644.4317

1.09862.978712.9018

4.44951.38637.05270.6931

1.7853

11.78654.71490.69311.771511.79694.7383

1.38636.62670.69312.0022

11.7725

4.2025

1.09862.3392

11.93714.5484

1.38636.77420.00000.683510.98175.11560.00000.666810.94594.89511.38636.6871

0.69312.0636

11.9846

4.43180.69312.069511.8840

4.4432

1.38636.86590.00000.6738

11.1679

5.12840.00000.7108

11.17214.96701.38636.80900.00001.355011.0987

4.40550.00000.684910.6636

4.42781.38636.79010.00000.678010.59134.41170.00000.6526

10.6624

4.42811.38636.77540.00001.980911.7426

4.40450.00001.7807

11.66694.4103

1.38637.0361

0.6931

0.9733

11.2574

4.97780.69310.966011.2732

5.01911.3863

6.29890.00001.7867

11.5966

4.30570.00001.7794

11.56644.30471.38636.61201.38633.1791

13.5850

4.91101.38633.1381

13.57434.95611.38636.72140.00001.393811.91425.06680.00001.386311.84965.04091.38636.6201

0.6931

1.961811.94194.53380.00002.024912.06174.98061.3863

6.41670.00001.370411.04514.23450.00001.361311.0774

4.20651.38636.53960.00001.825011.9827

4.63900.00001.778012.0223

4.92801.38636.6921

0.69312.453812.86034.87990.69312.424912.8925

5.1123

1.38637.29301.60943.027513.8324

5.1855

1.09862.950213.7758

5.22591.3863

6.9884

1.38633.442714.0520

5.1332

1.38633.352214.0155

5.16881.38636.86690.00000.975311.4455

5.06940.00000.965011.4146

5.11651.38636.62010.00002.299012.2451

4.40280.00002.297412.3018

4.41881.38636.67830.00001.7687

11.54034.41340.00001.7654

11.54114.3833

1.38635.16480.00001.3087

10.27093.54700.00001.2847

10.26373.54491.38635.90260.00000.671010.4845

4.40240.00000.676610.4548

4.39881.38635.89160.00002.2866

11.7845

4.19580.00002.2734

11.6947

4.1272

1.38635.93490.6931

3.163013.1232

4.4696

0.6931

3.170013.1580

4.6402

1.38635.70380.00002.481912.4875

4.50700.00002.4767

12.5284

4.58211.38636.3596

1.09863.020813.28674.67081.0986

3.228313.41624.6392

1.38636.51170.69312.648612.7830

4.5756

0.69312.638512.7697

4.68001.38636.43130.69312.932512.8901

4.5331

1.09862.994412.95434.51781.38636.1356

1.09862.6342

12.23904.2496

1.09862.633812.1893

4.21311.38636.3421

0.6931

3.094513.1745

4.5732

0.69313.088413.19714.61651.38636.4846

0.69313.260613.3775

4.68750.6931

3.2531

13.4606

4.8903

1.38636.56100.00000.6611

10.4633

4.30410.00000.6512

10.4187

4.30411.3863

6.89670.00000.8033

11.33075.10590.00000.7797

11.26215.10591.38637.1732

0.69312.374513.7692

5.88780.69312.253513.73625.9322

1.3863- 15 -

機材サイズ・運航便数に関するエアライン戦略のモデル化/井上岳・川西和幸

7.05700.6931

3.026913.84995.2715

1.09862.826913.6138

5.12391.38636.3154

1.09862.353913.2123

5.12781.09862.456013.2138

5.1343

1.3863

7.13971.38633.321714.04545.1412

1.38633.238013.9615

5.1102

1.38637.4085

1.0986

1.726712.4091

5.10691.0986

1.786312.4164

5.12311.3863

7.17701.38633.225414.0134

5.13781.38633.300014.0878

5.14351.38637.08760.00000.0082

10.31135.11190.00001.0876

11.3149

4.93351.38636.44890.00001.0326

11.6348

5.17610.00000.682111.0992

5.17611.38637.17630.69312.136412.7226

5.1642

0.69312.0253

12.6942

5.16251.38637.1317

1.09862.349212.8850

5.0942

1.09862.250612.8357

5.04851.38636.02830.00001.379410.3661

3.58350.00001.625710.5098

3.58351.3863

7.14360.00000.684911.1586

4.96980.00000.672411.1224

4.96981.3863

7.21600.69311.365511.8476

5.07970.69311.373911.8326

5.1084

1.3863

6.24220.00001.135410.1677

3.84100.00001.366910.3314

3.58351.38635.76520.00002.2882

11.6947

4.07670.00002.399411.7347

4.03491.38636.03790.00001.887910.91693.72790.00002.068110.9967

3.58351.38635.56070.69312.0611

11.4859

4.06540.69312.083911.5207

4.04611.38635.24700.00002.054512.0505

4.61690.00002.0677

12.13104.60071.38635.39820.00001.526110.64123.69430.00001.717910.7649

3.66361.38635.72681.09863.345513.0936

4.2703

1.0986

3.347413.0818

4.28111.3863

5.61310.00001.381510.21613.58420.00001.3767

10.1075

3.58571.38636.01130.00000.646910.00214.28320.00000.64699.94694.30411.38636.51030.00000.8227

10.53124.30410.00001.1265

10.63894.30411.38636.91571.38633.669114.3477

5.1582

1.38633.586414.2699

5.15491.38637.3865

1.09862.282113.14835.3681

1.09862.071513.0560

5.4134

1.38635.64190.00001.892910.9194

3.58350.00001.9161

10.8884

3.58351.38635.62040.00001.7441

11.43284.65590.00001.732511.50624.6752

1.38635.92430.00001.755511.5070

4.31890.00001.7296

11.5026

4.30951.38635.54910.00002.2852

11.4015

3.58430.00002.244811.3705

3.58351.38635.37990.00001.3592

11.03074.31250.00001.354311.0487

4.3054

1.38635.17050.00000.63249.25483.58350.00000.64839.3142

3.58351.38635.17050.00000.63249.25483.58350.00000.64839.3142

3.58351.3863- 16 -

国総研資料 No.963

A.2

5 年モデルの入力データ

データはすべて対数表示である．
Distance

CurrentNum
OfAL

CurrentNum
OfOps

CurrentNum
OfPsg

CurrentFleet
Size

PreviousNum
OfAL

PreviousNum
OfOps

PreviousNum
OfPsg

PreviousFleet
Size

7.08590.00000.9256

11.51815.23490.00000.963911.7938

5.42080.00005.87770.00001.2771

10.53734.30590.00000.631010.08815.01350.00006.95840.69312.630013.4692

5.29870.69312.627613.7200

5.53830.00007.10820.00000.684911.0190

5.12800.00000.6931

11.24394.98360.00007.11720.00000.3786

10.6363

5.12760.00000.695910.7348

4.83630.00007.05270.69312.2982

12.9409

5.1426

0.69312.352313.1257

5.35610.00007.22110.00000.686310.93174.96600.00000.687711.0065

4.85320.00005.86930.69312.467411.91634.26760.00001.7807

11.9424

5.01310.00006.53670.00002.475713.09275.25140.00002.479013.5160

5.66740.00006.85220.00001.869911.5955

4.22010.00001.408011.9371

5.01160.00005.72680.00001.855911.3425

3.92290.00001.3131

11.6093

4.96100.00006.52940.00001.7766

12.2734

5.09310.00001.783012.2428

4.98620.00006.76850.00001.861011.7326

4.32720.00001.397911.5638

4.63800.00006.14630.00001.869511.3728

3.91400.00001.3183

11.4995

5.02290.00006.07530.69311.365511.31544.50570.69311.3801

10.7620

3.91210.00006.39860.00000.664010.1869

3.91200.00000.686310.6599

4.86350.00006.48770.69312.467912.4080

4.6782

0.69312.451012.7483

4.87780.00006.6884

1.09863.370513.8032

4.86081.0986

3.185913.91915.25750.00006.90980.00000.672410.6187

4.24850.00000.678011.13475.11190.00007.1357

1.09862.4001

12.4140

4.5201

0.69312.190812.6391

4.97800.00006.4983

1.0986

3.209713.3704

4.6071

1.09862.9907

13.5258

5.20220.00006.31900.69312.8794

13.54135.4126

0.69312.637113.65455.54890.00006.58060.00001.369711.0740

4.30470.00000.6807

10.7929

4.67340.00006.67580.69312.2857

11.8388

4.2052

0.69311.6864

11.52734.43010.00006.09360.00001.7286

11.2097

3.99890.00001.359911.4858

4.97560.00006.08900.00000.679410.1527

3.99780.00000.687710.95454.93680.00006.59300.00001.783011.3380

4.17670.00002.074311.4336

3.91200.00006.19240.00002.063912.71975.28330.00002.067412.8501

5.38580.00006.49530.69312.203011.6826

3.99601.09862.241911.95674.33340.00006.57930.00001.376711.50884.83630.00001.3641

11.6191

4.94280.00006.46930.00001.3641

10.7272

3.91200.00000.662510.05593.91200.00006.2146

0.69312.2941

12.8485

5.1996

0.69311.7922

12.0592

4.85850.00006.37840.69312.073913.05295.3572

1.09862.014012.81025.12050.00006.80020.00001.366910.8066

4.08980.00000.666810.2020

3.91200.00007.00941.60943.1612

13.5806

5.10070.69311.7922

12.22315.14860.00006.79351.6094

3.156413.6956

5.14891.09861.777012.30395.08620.00005.08760.00000.58019.17344.02530.00001.331410.9475

4.71320.00005.86650.00001.687912.1234

5.11260.00001.763512.18075.01260.00006.34560.00002.4676

13.5427

5.60710.00002.481513.7626

5.77130.00006.2691

0.6931

3.0991

14.26765.76830.69313.090014.4329

5.89500.00006.27290.00001.380111.9075

5.12630.00001.387011.9405

5.11100.00006.2422

0.69314.086615.4220

5.8831

0.69314.0366

15.5787

6.07760.00006.5191

1.09863.035613.86445.32401.0986

3.597014.3456

5.39070.00006.54390.69312.716413.58565.2404

1.0986

3.166114.1825

5.47200.00006.45200.00001.7747

11.51414.41830.00001.6284

11.8328

4.93970.00006.50280.00002.061812.5693

5.12510.00002.0677

12.66345.12030.00006.65420.00002.333612.93565.23030.00002.299612.89975.14010.00006.68590.00002.358813.1174

5.29950.00002.296013.1683

5.46730.00006.81010.00000.679411.0426

5.13360.00000.684910.7120

4.83860.00006.52940.69312.977313.7218

5.39400.69312.888713.81435.33550.00006.67200.69313.490314.4146

5.52590.6931

3.395814.65515.87480.00006.84050.69312.878713.56745.3736

0.69312.770713.64515.42630.00006.55540.69312.9862

13.5934

5.25270.00002.482413.50995.62510.0000- 17 -Trend

機材サイズ・運航便数に関するエアライン戦略のモデル化/井上岳・川西和幸

6.56670.6931

3.163913.9635

5.43370.69312.993414.05645.65240.00006.75580.6931

3.166914.17295.5516

0.69312.995514.18145.70620.00006.7142

0.69312.8821

13.6240

5.3456

0.69312.769813.60635.37410.00006.86480.69313.5201

13.91914.96880.69313.437713.8404

4.93670.00006.94791.38634.597215.83905.75391.09864.508615.91175.94130.00007.03000.00002.152412.5918

5.06720.00002.073312.28144.83070.00007.0414

1.38633.327414.16315.4366

1.09863.244914.21405.51200.00006.9903

1.38633.6771

14.4615

5.3596

1.09863.506414.44595.48390.00006.83301.0986

3.253413.93195.38040.69313.032714.0346

5.53550.00006.9305

1.09863.569514.0966

5.1391

1.09863.440614.1756

5.23290.00007.01301.38633.736814.6089

5.4293

1.09863.386914.62455.81120.00007.26960.00000.672411.28445.04280.00000.676611.3075

5.09260.00007.43071.38634.008715.4292

5.8984

1.38633.906015.4971

6.05320.00007.61090.00000.7121

11.1850

4.99320.00000.683511.3598

5.10710.00007.68290.00001.098611.7500

4.99760.00001.0557

11.8561

5.00720.00006.93930.69312.294113.0165

5.27340.69312.299613.2030

5.45420.00006.90680.69312.628413.13135.08160.00002.073613.17055.62980.00007.01930.00000.6821

11.33035.28710.00000.691811.38675.29410.00006.79571.38634.692815.97675.77411.38634.644716.0899

5.93850.00006.66701.09862.726713.84965.64281.09862.635113.9828

5.83530.00004.64440.00001.7291

9.8913

2.94440.00001.69109.65652.77570.00004.99040.00001.9607

10.2330

2.94440.00001.953310.09592.87470.00005.14750.00001.6591

9.89332.94500.00001.64239.71402.83540.00006.37160.00001.365510.8653

4.30520.00001.637011.3734

4.61440.00006.4151

0.69312.874412.7653

4.44670.69312.880013.0001

4.78750.00007.05270.69311.758311.70174.74440.00001.382911.8027

5.07310.00006.6267

1.09862.234911.9288

4.53240.00001.534412.0299

5.11170.00006.77420.00000.679410.9061

4.83630.00000.6904

11.5480

5.62890.00006.68710.00001.385611.75375.03920.00001.6067

11.93274.90830.00006.86590.00000.6835

11.1346

4.83630.00000.689011.5470

5.63240.00006.29890.00001.7844

11.49134.30460.00001.7881

11.2787

4.24950.00006.61200.69312.935213.29434.95600.6931

3.544713.9572

4.98800.00006.72140.00001.380111.72545.00340.00001.3836

11.6991

4.86340.00006.62010.00001.7715

11.9133

4.95670.69312.071912.3832

4.97430.00006.41670.00001.370411.0455

4.24850.00001.3815

11.6687

4.92180.00006.53960.00001.780312.07024.95690.00001.796812.2592

5.21360.00006.69210.00002.075312.5509

5.1371

0.69312.701313.06844.96040.00007.29301.09863.018913.7630

5.19000.69312.397613.9094

6.02270.00006.9884

1.0986

3.339713.8849

5.1471

0.6931

3.259114.04635.33490.00006.86690.00001.048011.4325

4.88140.00001.037411.68094.98050.00006.67830.00001.4331

11.2058

4.35430.00001.3704

10.5439

3.91200.00005.16480.00001.255510.1630

3.52600.00001.252410.15313.54310.00005.90260.00000.676610.5152

4.40210.00000.666810.4657

4.35440.00005.89160.00002.4634

11.6229

3.85560.00002.655611.8008

3.73240.00005.93490.00003.085213.08434.55400.6931

3.3481

13.3332

4.63080.00005.70380.00002.876412.55044.40140.00003.0147

12.6924

4.30410.00006.3596

1.0986

3.263113.32024.6347

1.09862.939513.6505

5.33790.00006.51170.69312.4767

12.54484.70390.69312.651113.14895.28510.00006.4313

1.09862.911212.9675

4.56190.69312.740013.43115.23640.00006.1356

0.69312.481012.10104.2591

0.69312.501212.7053

4.79640.00006.3421

0.6931

2.959213.1478

4.61190.69312.894913.42025.01380.00006.4846

0.6931

3.173513.4095

4.85271.38633.136013.8255

5.27400.00006.89670.00000.782211.3097

5.12510.00000.852411.4051

5.08270.00007.1732

0.6931

1.537913.3000

6.12300.69311.550813.2613

6.09500.00007.05700.6931

1.893713.0166

5.54950.69311.903513.3679

5.85040.00006.3154

1.09862.337613.0779

5.1252

0.69312.788412.91205.04010.00007.13971.38633.265813.94315.1801

1.09862.945313.86565.57020.00007.40850.00001.2461

11.7757

4.92670.00000.691811.3795

5.00980.0000- 18 -

国総研資料 No.963

7.17701.60943.5352

14.2633

5.26270.69313.079413.9632

5.40940.00007.08760.00001.095911.4256

5.0751

0.69311.490912.2818

5.27730.00007.17630.69312.420813.0218

5.2664

1.38632.3722

13.26465.41700.00007.13170.69312.291812.9571

5.3411

0.69312.446513.3505

5.50430.00007.21600.00000.9492

11.4645

5.1161

0.69311.3801

12.3205

5.64560.00005.76520.00002.4147

11.5870

3.73690.6931

1.7872

11.78814.68830.00006.03790.69311.773810.8740

3.81570.00001.789511.0877

3.91200.00005.56070.69312.0852

11.4447

4.06760.00001.9056

11.6495

4.57800.00005.24700.00002.055512.10174.85600.00002.3067

12.2687

4.67630.00005.39820.00001.715410.55903.66360.00002.0292

10.99543.66360.00005.72681.0986

3.319212.9625

4.39130.00002.628813.02145.04100.00006.9157

1.09863.509514.1890

5.2113

1.09863.332414.1200

5.35260.00007.38650.6931

1.841612.95465.66440.6931

1.922913.1587

5.79160.00005.64190.00001.6056

10.39103.58350.6931

2.2168

11.3927

3.88470.00005.62040.00001.7507

11.45674.59800.00001.913310.9047

3.58350.00005.54910.00002.2982

11.1916

3.58350.69312.341311.81453.96060.00005.17050.00000.59089.1356

3.58350.00000.63689.24673.58350.00007.08590.00000.943911.6806

5.31410.00000.947011.5760

5.19330.6931

5.87770.00001.325610.7985

4.47350.00000.599910.12844.83630.6931

6.95840.69312.730813.6075

5.3395

1.09862.959913.8333

5.4242

0.6931

7.10820.00000.679410.8601

4.85470.00000.691811.0028

4.8832

0.6931

7.11720.00000.361610.7032

5.11990.00000.6877

10.7136

4.8366

0.6931

7.05270.69312.293212.9670

5.1406

0.69312.367813.08485.29030.69317.22110.00000.686310.82074.86160.00000.684910.9757

4.8321

0.69315.86930.69312.477612.0582

4.22750.00001.7644

11.8369

5.04650.6931

6.53670.00002.469013.1203

5.21100.00002.481713.44855.6321

0.69316.85220.00001.800911.5134

4.21430.00001.415311.8705

5.01080.69315.72680.00001.7826

11.40024.21080.00001.3065

11.53635.04250.6931

6.52940.00001.768712.2243

5.10380.00001.778912.2299

5.0782

0.6931

6.76850.00002.0722

11.7853

4.31930.69311.373911.4904

4.66550.6931

6.14630.00001.9514

11.4293

4.10020.00001.304311.5053

5.04780.69316.07530.00001.3718

11.3920

4.8291

0.69311.377410.6677

4.12680.6931

6.39860.00001.369710.7489

3.94490.00000.683510.59214.91100.6931

6.48770.69312.6201

12.3836

4.39440.69312.632612.72484.73440.6931

6.6884

1.0986

3.541313.7795

4.8873

1.09863.235513.8450

5.14980.69316.90980.00001.357811.0276

4.21740.00000.690411.0673

5.11190.69317.13571.38632.744612.76514.67500.00001.381512.08995.03280.6931

6.4983

1.38633.521913.5024

4.73670.69313.019213.4523

5.08270.6931

6.31900.69312.875013.5595

5.3922

0.69312.636913.57365.56290.69316.58060.00001.393111.09224.31760.00001.149410.6765

4.30650.6931

6.67580.69312.378811.9800

4.19550.6931

1.7383

11.48524.44650.6931

6.0936

0.69312.2672

11.4982

4.11710.00001.303511.3571

5.05400.69316.08900.00000.6807

10.2586

4.33070.00000.6877

10.8949

5.05240.6931

6.59300.00001.783011.3237

4.07740.00002.0691

11.3385

3.91200.6931

6.19240.00002.069512.7373

5.30900.00002.071912.81285.45070.6931

6.49530.69312.278211.8026

4.00740.69312.020911.7396

4.29150.6931

6.57930.00001.3725

11.4940

4.86900.00001.369011.5600

4.99770.6931

6.46930.00001.369710.9001

4.24610.00000.66969.9311

3.91200.6931

6.2146

1.09862.363712.9069

5.11430.6931

1.7886

11.8101

4.69680.6931

6.37840.69312.075013.07745.3165

1.09862.050312.7130

5.08350.69316.8002

0.69311.369010.9652

4.76130.00000.6821

10.1868

3.91200.69317.00941.6094

3.239613.7254

5.11750.69311.9201

12.2077

5.02680.6931

6.79351.60943.346613.98105.1437

1.09861.780312.1780

5.09550.69315.08760.00000.56789.33764.03240.00001.0736

10.47534.6706

0.69315.86650.00001.725212.1026

5.11900.00001.726212.10025.0146

0.6931

6.34560.00002.470913.5777

5.65800.00002.477313.67485.68300.6931

6.2691

0.6931

3.167414.3066

5.69290.69313.089914.3782

5.8646

0.6931

6.27290.00001.375311.8976

5.14310.00001.383611.9553

5.11130.6931- 19 -

機材サイズ・運航便数に関するエアライン戦略のモデル化/井上岳・川西和幸

6.2422

0.69314.100915.4784

5.87770.6931

4.058315.5594

6.00600.6931

6.5191

1.0986

3.123313.92455.3042

1.0986

3.599414.2326

5.20830.6931

6.54390.69312.061512.89455.4365

1.09862.987913.92215.37650.69316.45200.00001.7701

11.5255

4.40220.00001.626311.8428

5.0592

0.69316.50280.00002.070512.6608

5.13380.00002.0667

12.5917

5.12440.69316.65420.00002.387413.14875.23120.00002.2982

12.8603

5.1172

0.69316.68590.00002.377013.31105.35170.00002.296013.18895.5266

0.69316.81010.00000.686311.1695

5.12550.00000.6904

10.6972

4.84950.6931

6.52940.69312.986113.76935.4561

0.69312.887313.7640

5.38840.6931

6.67200.69313.4801

14.39935.53950.6931

3.399014.6200

5.83230.69316.84050.69312.8993

13.5849

5.4211

0.69312.770713.60045.4202

0.6931

6.55540.6931

3.028613.6732

5.28810.00002.481913.4560

5.5711

0.6931

6.56670.6931

3.165514.00485.4746

0.69312.993314.0265

5.61370.69316.75580.6931

3.167714.16595.6036

0.69313.035314.16685.68830.6931

6.7142

0.69312.987913.68785.35030.69312.770913.57885.36950.6931

6.86480.69313.504913.97295.01500.69313.384913.86514.96670.6931

6.94791.38634.709215.88645.6922

1.09864.499415.8994

5.90930.69317.03000.00002.161012.6271

5.04110.00002.085912.3499

4.94630.6931

7.0414

1.38633.5756

14.58295.4352

1.0986

3.163814.1797

5.5776

0.69316.9903

1.38633.7282

14.5200

5.3704

1.09863.450814.41845.4881

0.6931

6.83301.09863.3222

13.9491

5.2602

0.69313.090013.9825

5.5082

0.69316.9305

1.0986

3.574614.14175.2132

1.09863.477714.1470

5.22040.6931

7.01301.38633.830514.64145.4505

1.09863.4665

14.6370

5.71530.6931

7.26960.00000.684911.3273

5.10450.00000.689011.2829

5.09380.69317.4307

1.09864.031415.44395.91451.3863

3.897215.50996.06880.69317.61090.00000.6752

11.1927

5.00210.00000.684911.3509

5.10430.69317.68290.69311.7455

12.5887

5.24520.00001.061411.8251

5.00740.6931

6.9393

1.09862.561613.0705

5.0762

0.69312.2902

13.1275

5.45370.69316.90680.69312.624913.17235.03180.00002.065013.12635.6522

0.69317.01930.00000.6682

11.33445.30880.00000.6807

11.37465.32270.6931

6.79571.38634.682816.0072

5.78451.38634.646216.0624

5.91680.6931

6.66701.09862.710113.90705.6791

1.09862.632213.92495.7812

0.69314.64440.00001.72239.95302.94600.00001.67479.70952.81390.69314.99040.00001.968010.29342.95040.00001.9388

10.1141

2.83300.69315.14750.00001.63279.92092.91500.00001.60179.72422.84300.6931

6.37160.00001.377410.9632

4.30490.00001.3808

11.1732

4.78500.6931

6.4151

0.69312.985312.8606

4.4536

1.09862.886412.97594.75250.6931

7.05270.69311.771011.77634.70870.00000.690411.0318

4.8552

0.69316.6267

1.09862.351511.9393

4.47720.00001.528411.99035.1116

0.69316.77420.00000.6821

10.9227

4.85840.00000.6794

11.46655.59270.6931

6.68710.00002.0597

11.83614.46050.00001.384911.8426

4.95270.6931

6.86590.00000.6752

11.09824.83890.00000.6821

11.4930

5.61440.6931

6.29890.00001.7872

11.5386

4.30370.00001.737311.30124.2746

0.6931

6.61201.38633.2071

13.6340

4.95740.69313.455113.79104.85370.6931

6.72140.00001.393111.80515.03660.00001.3836

11.6350

4.8811

0.69316.62010.00001.7881

11.88374.8641

0.69312.074312.35074.93230.6931

6.41670.00001.366911.1060

4.24850.00001.3801

11.52524.85500.6931

6.53960.00001.799912.0977

4.99980.00001.800912.1858

5.18630.6931

6.6921

0.69312.366012.8442

5.16200.69312.639313.02414.9232

0.69317.29301.09862.969113.75755.23200.69312.4942

13.9169

5.9526

0.6931

6.98841.60943.421514.05445.20280.6931

3.1882

13.9860

5.3281

0.69316.86690.00000.9702

11.4309

5.11270.00001.0403

11.61224.94870.6931

6.67830.00001.7085

11.58814.42800.00001.089410.3166

3.91200.6931

5.16480.00001.294510.2558

3.54600.00001.288510.27243.52000.69315.90260.00000.661110.4753

4.40580.00000.6766

10.4143

4.35070.6931

5.89160.00002.467611.80883.88840.00002.681811.7620

3.78180.69315.93490.6931

3.168113.1477

4.65600.69313.371013.2424

4.44580.69315.70380.00002.483812.53684.80220.00002.480812.5330

4.6516

0.6931- 20 -

国総研資料 No.963

6.3596

1.09863.444613.4416

4.7075

1.09863.076113.65444.9751

0.6931

6.51170.69312.5102

12.6606

4.68750.69312.493813.0555

5.16450.69316.4313

1.09862.997612.99104.5882

0.69312.782313.39635.21090.69316.1356

0.69312.650312.17174.19040.69312.632012.6097

4.68780.6931

6.34211.3863

3.197813.20674.6422

1.09863.010113.38785.01140.6931

6.4846

0.6931

3.257413.43024.86291.0986

3.188313.8030

5.23870.6931

6.89670.00000.7996

11.3153

5.10590.00000.8512

11.3677

5.09040.69317.1732

0.69312.001913.48395.85740.6931

1.544913.2765

6.1566

0.6931

7.05700.6931

2.113113.22545.44480.6931

1.888713.1876

5.62340.69316.3154

1.09862.729013.3962

5.1136

0.69312.721112.75634.7271

0.6931

7.13971.38633.219313.9434

5.0847

1.09862.925413.87545.59780.6931

7.4085

1.09861.708512.2951

5.10270.00000.6945

11.2665

5.00590.6931

7.17701.38633.344814.17485.1786

0.69313.004213.88495.3862

0.69317.08760.00001.0913

11.3340

4.91750.69311.274811.8497

4.9301

0.6931

7.17630.69312.360112.9378

5.2746

0.69312.300413.12465.43570.6931

7.1317

1.0986

2.1942

12.8433

5.08940.69312.473013.39225.42300.6931

7.21600.69311.380811.8484

5.11270.69311.3767

12.2026

5.46750.6931

5.76520.00002.638911.66493.66880.00001.784011.7508

4.79730.6931

6.03790.6931

1.784010.9426

3.81240.00001.789510.9858

3.91200.69315.56070.69312.0812

11.5185

4.05420.00001.772911.5980

4.8556

0.6931

5.24700.00002.0552

12.1447

4.84220.00002.057312.23374.8612

0.6931

5.39820.00001.701510.7308

3.66360.00001.772910.6923

3.6636

0.69315.72681.38633.392413.06594.39450.00002.627212.9501

5.05490.6931

6.9157

1.09863.504514.2285

5.19501.09863.345314.10635.31870.69317.3865

1.09862.075713.08935.55370.6931

1.781713.0569

5.78330.69315.64190.00001.9011

10.7802

3.58350.69312.097811.1809

3.85700.69315.62040.00001.764911.4956

4.66250.00002.1647

11.1277

3.58350.6931

5.54910.00002.1797

11.2775

3.58350.69312.5095

11.7872

3.8886

0.69315.17050.00000.62959.23603.58350.00000.60749.26743.58350.69317.08590.00000.946011.69105.29570.00000.943911.43225.1406

1.09865.87770.00001.287010.76854.47060.00000.616310.1061

4.84901.09866.95840.69312.634513.60815.3706

1.09862.871513.74935.4026

1.0986

7.10820.00000.6821

10.86814.93590.00000.690410.9676

4.9541

1.0986

7.11720.00000.662511.0848

5.11700.00000.690410.7009

4.8362

1.0986

7.05270.69312.286012.9630

5.1391

0.69312.351813.0408

5.2364

1.0986

7.22110.00000.672410.8052

4.83810.00000.6877

10.87074.8341

1.09865.86930.69312.594612.0780

4.13430.00001.7752

11.81315.0494

1.09866.53670.00002.471613.0836

5.11750.00002.476213.3479

5.60591.09866.8522

0.69312.3192

11.9924

4.29210.00001.4086

11.82535.0142

1.09865.72680.69312.1483

11.61314.22120.00001.3094

11.44205.0102

1.09866.52940.00001.727212.0836

4.90880.00001.776612.16995.0852

1.09866.76850.00002.0552

11.7783

4.17840.69311.7807

11.8694

4.83101.0986

6.14630.00001.938811.4026

4.06790.00001.5243

11.5272

4.7195

1.09866.07530.00001.3767

11.3146

4.82840.69311.377410.71224.12801.09866.39860.00001.362010.9040

4.20760.00000.683510.3173

4.5403

1.09866.48770.69312.612512.3078

4.36100.69312.629812.5933

4.7437

1.09866.6884

1.09863.353913.70454.8522

1.0986

3.280213.81215.1297

1.09866.90980.00001.3662

11.1474

4.21710.00000.6877

10.7796

4.7046

1.09867.13571.38632.621512.75164.77400.69312.2141

12.3995

4.8822

1.09866.4983

1.60943.5172

13.5247

4.7132

1.09863.082013.3994

4.9654

1.0986

6.31900.69312.879513.5624

5.33430.69312.6322

13.4604

5.5404

1.09866.58060.00001.374611.03664.30400.00000.684910.33514.6487

1.09866.67580.69312.480112.0340

4.15500.6931

1.7876

11.7862

4.7712

1.09866.0936

0.69312.2287

11.4752

4.09630.00001.584511.30814.6704

1.09866.08900.00001.3767

11.22114.33070.00000.690410.9440

5.0734

1.09866.59300.00001.7867

11.35414.19170.00001.9576

11.1945

3.91201.0986

6.19240.00002.067412.7705

5.24940.00002.0677

12.69905.4073

1.09866.49530.69312.062511.89534.38460.00002.2457

11.55173.91291.0986- 21 -

機材サイズ・運航便数に関するエアライン戦略のモデル化/井上岳・川西和幸

6.57930.00001.3571

11.4235

4.89590.00001.382911.5070

4.92691.0986

6.46930.00000.6752

10.2367

4.18600.00000.67809.89073.91201.0986

6.2146

0.69312.162212.73625.04680.00001.7354

11.69424.7007

1.09866.37840.69312.076413.07215.3512

0.69312.077412.95145.3433

1.09866.8002

0.6931

1.5261

11.8680

4.91300.00000.684910.1738

3.91201.09867.0094

1.09863.0151

13.6249

5.11280.69312.1763

12.4667

4.91791.09866.79351.60943.323714.0591

5.1654

1.09862.076012.34294.91891.09865.08760.00000.58019.3086

4.78720.00000.58639.71934.56881.09865.86650.00001.728612.0260

5.11130.00001.718812.0590

5.00701.09866.34560.00002.463713.5680

5.67310.00002.464413.49905.6282

1.0986

6.2691

0.6931

3.169714.30915.67980.69313.087514.22835.8387

1.09866.27290.00001.3822

11.86225.13000.00001.3767

11.8889

5.10891.09866.2422

0.69314.118815.47845.83750.6931

4.056415.4669

5.98281.09866.5191

1.0986

3.144413.9170

5.3056

1.09863.365114.0475

5.1874

1.09866.54390.69312.339713.0626

5.3193

1.09862.928713.81965.31401.09866.45200.00001.772911.4827

4.34350.00001.620911.8085

5.06201.09866.50280.00002.292412.69625.09980.00002.0632

12.5579

5.12381.09866.6542

0.69312.585013.22105.19030.00002.299612.8088

5.11381.09866.68590.00002.3732

13.2284

5.37530.00002.298513.10525.4862

1.09866.81010.00001.3815

11.5636

4.97990.00000.683510.68834.83701.09866.52940.6931

3.1222

13.78445.40630.69312.887313.68445.3337

1.09866.67200.69313.519314.40075.4892

0.6931

3.427414.5208

5.72791.09866.84050.69312.9337

13.61625.33230.69312.770013.4933

5.36081.09866.55540.6931

3.166913.71815.34470.00002.480313.38885.5851

1.09866.56670.6931

3.247513.98295.39480.69312.993113.95365.6063

1.09866.75580.6931

3.172914.16505.54670.69313.0892

14.12675.68201.09866.7142

0.69312.989013.69885.32200.69312.7707

13.54695.3696

1.09866.86480.6931

3.565313.97675.04090.6931

3.3631

13.8316

5.0091

1.09866.94791.38634.678215.92255.7132

1.09864.524015.83095.8642

1.09867.03000.00002.377012.8250

5.00480.00002.197812.4594

4.9932

1.0986

7.0414

1.3863

3.5793

14.6105

5.4226

1.0986

3.166114.1426

5.5773

1.09866.9903

1.09863.600614.47445.4183

1.09863.454814.3594

5.49291.09866.83301.0986

3.325013.95535.20870.69313.088813.88995.49801.09866.9305

1.09863.569014.1340

5.2136

1.09863.449014.0894

5.19381.09867.01301.38633.818014.6250

5.4204

1.09863.4891

14.5858

5.70001.0986

7.26960.00000.666811.0770

5.10590.00000.689011.2787

5.09381.09867.4307

1.0986

3.989215.4057

5.89411.38633.914715.4489

6.0565

1.09867.61090.00000.6835

11.2485

4.97680.00000.689011.3246

5.0956

1.09867.68291.09862.602813.6497

5.22370.00001.068011.80455.00801.09866.9393

1.09862.463713.05175.10280.69312.293213.08815.3973

1.09866.90680.69312.626913.18645.09280.00002.069813.1080

5.65491.09867.01930.00000.656911.35835.32690.00000.684911.30415.22391.09866.79571.38634.6651

16.00255.7682

1.38634.643716.01685.9061

1.09866.66701.09862.767113.90425.6367

1.09862.634713.86625.7053

1.09864.64440.00001.72039.95342.94440.00001.69859.75092.7905

1.09864.99040.00001.983210.32912.94440.00001.9771

10.1266

2.80401.0986

5.14750.00001.65509.93762.94440.00001.56869.70142.83501.09866.37160.00001.3641

10.8498

4.30410.00001.365510.78814.30581.09866.4151

1.09862.978712.9018

4.4495

1.09862.946012.8706

4.6854

1.0986

7.05270.69311.771511.79694.73830.00000.676610.95024.87881.09866.6267

1.09862.3392

11.93714.54840.00001.522511.8661

4.8815

1.09866.77420.00000.666810.94594.89510.00000.6807

11.3455

5.3503

1.09866.6871

0.69312.069511.8840

4.44320.00001.380811.7136

4.8946

1.09866.86590.00000.7108

11.17214.96700.00000.689011.3208

5.28401.09866.29890.00001.7794

11.56644.30470.00001.378710.9574

4.30581.09866.61201.38633.1381

13.57434.95610.00003.168313.38074.77991.09866.72140.00001.386311.84965.04090.00001.3787

11.5184

4.8711

1.09866.62010.00002.024912.06174.9806

0.6931

1.997012.18434.9114

1.0986- 22 -

国総研資料 No.963

6.41670.00001.361311.0774

4.20650.00001.379411.3770

4.8405

1.09866.53960.00001.778012.0223

4.92800.00001.794012.0853

5.2233

1.09866.6921

0.69312.424912.8925

5.11230.69312.636912.88614.97601.09867.29301.09862.950213.7758

5.22591.09862.560913.75455.8336

1.09866.9884

1.38633.352214.0155

5.16880.6931

3.237013.88385.22401.09866.86690.00000.965011.4146

5.11650.00001.0452

11.5552

5.00001.09866.67830.00001.7654

11.54114.38330.00001.048010.2566

3.91201.0986

5.16480.00001.2847

10.26373.54490.00001.275610.22073.5442

1.09865.90260.00000.676610.4548

4.39880.00000.716210.42104.32901.09865.89160.00002.2734

11.6947

4.12720.00002.7233

11.60203.6863

1.09865.93490.6931

3.170013.1580

4.6402

0.69313.352613.16284.4854

1.09865.70380.00002.4767

12.5284

4.58210.00002.659812.4818

4.4641

1.09866.3596

1.0986

3.228313.41624.6392

1.0986

3.1681

13.6208

4.9386

1.09866.51170.69312.638512.7697

4.68000.69312.494012.9349

4.98591.09866.4313

1.09862.994412.95434.51781.09862.773313.2666

5.1066

1.09866.1356

1.09862.633812.1893

4.2131

0.69312.632212.45814.68091.09866.3421

0.69313.088413.19714.6165

1.09863.0101

13.2756

4.9285

1.09866.4846

0.6931

3.2531

13.4606

4.8903

1.0986

3.187013.7668

5.18501.09866.89670.00000.7797

11.26215.10590.00000.857011.3467

5.0934

1.09867.1732

0.69312.253513.73625.9322

0.69311.5397

13.2608

6.1552

1.0986

7.05701.09862.826913.6138

5.12390.6931

1.892913.18235.67181.09866.3154

1.09862.456013.2138

5.13430.69312.511512.20184.23581.0986

7.13971.38633.238013.9615

5.1102

0.69312.852113.71485.4023

1.0986

7.4085

1.0986

1.786312.4164

5.12310.00000.700011.2379

5.0036

1.0986

7.17701.38633.300014.0878

5.14350.69312.787213.7633

5.4164

1.09867.08760.00001.0876

11.3149

4.93350.00000.689011.1861

4.79591.0986

7.17630.69312.0253

12.6942

5.16250.69312.371913.1782

5.3804

1.0986

7.1317

1.09862.250612.8357

5.04850.69312.467213.3318

5.3384

1.0986

7.21600.69311.373911.8326

5.10840.00000.979511.7386

5.1957

1.09865.76520.00002.399411.7347

4.03490.00002.0314

11.5359

4.17581.09866.03790.00002.068110.9967

3.58350.00001.788610.9398

3.91201.09865.56070.69312.083911.5207

4.04610.00001.899911.58594.6616

1.0986

5.24700.00002.0677

12.13104.60070.00002.046012.16834.8493

1.09865.39820.00001.717910.7649

3.66360.00001.737310.6785

3.6655

1.09865.72681.0986

3.347413.0818

4.2811

0.69312.624312.82134.8635

1.09866.91571.38633.586414.2699

5.15491.38633.461114.10415.2754

1.09867.3865

1.09862.071513.0560

5.41340.69311.829012.99915.5995

1.09865.64190.00001.9161

10.8884

3.58350.69312.065611.0374

3.8737

1.09865.62040.00001.732511.50624.67520.00002.167911.0895

3.5835

1.09865.54910.00002.244811.3705

3.58350.69312.5298

11.6901

3.8931

1.0986

5.17050.00000.64839.3142

3.58350.00000.63249.18903.5835

1.09867.08590.00000.9492

11.6315

5.32520.00000.962911.45195.19111.38635.87770.00001.296010.7420

4.30830.00001.201010.3841

4.4094

1.3863

6.95840.69312.640013.63675.4776

1.09862.806313.6855

5.38411.3863

7.10820.00000.678010.90314.94460.00000.687711.0101

4.92701.3863

7.11720.00000.6766

11.1175

5.11010.00000.684910.76514.90291.38637.05270.69312.300913.0218

5.1991

0.69312.298512.94625.08871.38637.22110.00000.684910.7580

4.81730.00000.690410.90124.83761.38635.86930.69312.6032

12.1120

4.10491.09862.279611.85784.27591.38636.53670.00002.483313.15215.11770.00002.479013.2982

5.4373

1.38636.8522

0.69312.484012.13174.26090.00001.422011.82434.9983

1.38635.72680.6931

2.264911.7100

4.09540.00001.541411.3890

4.5744

1.3863

6.52940.00001.777512.1696

4.90360.00001.778912.2849

5.08551.38636.76850.00002.062211.85884.29950.00001.783011.79814.68551.3863

6.14630.00001.9305

11.39413.92230.00001.623011.30134.15011.38636.07530.00001.3842

11.3667

4.83150.69311.321910.8825

4.12861.3863

6.39860.00001.357810.5095

4.16780.00000.614810.0890

4.01281.38636.48770.69312.6137

12.2436

4.35720.00002.328012.4995

4.79551.3863- 23 -

機材サイズ・運航便数に関するエアライン戦略のモデル化/井上岳・川西和幸

6.6884

1.09863.330813.68234.8001

1.0986

3.168013.76235.1034

1.38636.90980.00001.356411.1149

4.19000.00000.632410.5033

4.24851.38637.1357

1.09862.4312

12.57104.5931

0.69312.1237

12.20814.6032

1.38636.4983

1.09863.282813.4906

4.66971.38633.174513.3225

4.6953

1.38636.31900.69312.888813.58285.2932

0.69312.634013.4756

5.37751.38636.58060.00001.396511.02234.30380.00001.155410.6873

4.3243

1.38636.67580.69312.471812.0638

4.14550.00001.5726

11.60234.64051.3863

6.0936

0.69312.178211.5044

4.12810.00001.784411.3008

4.17581.38636.08900.00001.3808

11.3358

4.33070.00000.9917

11.1967

4.83851.3863

6.59300.00001.785811.4401

4.23860.00001.809011.2011

4.0583

1.3863

6.19240.00002.076712.7626

5.21120.00002.076712.7473

5.1903

1.38636.49530.69312.0691

12.00744.66420.00002.2186

11.5986

3.91201.3863

6.57930.00000.6877

11.14225.07530.00001.4147

11.4265

4.8363

1.38636.46930.00000.672410.12544.23810.00001.160610.3099

3.9124

1.3863

6.2146

0.69312.170712.7322

4.99980.69312.315412.4298

4.85301.38636.37840.69312.080813.01465.27450.69312.076713.02895.3514

1.38636.8002

0.6931

1.738312.2926

4.98660.00001.181010.54444.06981.38637.0094

1.38633.125713.9339

5.16280.69312.2993

12.56374.94011.38636.79351.60943.472714.3360

5.15330.69312.2996

12.6070

5.05371.38635.08760.00000.07148.75644.78740.00000.63539.27124.0322

1.38635.86650.00001.694012.0050

5.10450.00001.714912.09435.03251.3863

6.34560.00002.471813.0360

5.14750.00002.473413.52595.57561.3863

6.2691

0.6931

3.171913.8475

5.2056

0.69313.084014.21865.7183

1.3863

6.27290.00001.379411.90415.11150.00001.380811.85135.11211.3863

6.2422

0.6931

4.094415.46315.80300.6931

4.058715.4529

5.97301.38636.5191

1.0986

3.164413.9560

5.3095

1.09863.315513.95485.2063

1.3863

6.54390.69312.512413.3120

5.35500.69312.693913.6129

5.27391.38636.45200.00001.776111.6491

4.48540.00001.7798

11.5453

4.35101.38636.50280.00002.294612.7620

5.10200.00002.0636

12.56125.12351.38636.65420.00002.427613.15385.21400.00002.2882

12.8451

5.12281.38636.68590.00002.299013.22965.34060.00002.296013.09885.37961.38636.81010.00001.371811.6595

5.03870.00000.682110.7771

4.8162

1.3863

6.52940.6931

3.097113.81095.41170.69312.889213.65895.37251.38636.67200.6931

3.507214.31655.49080.6931

3.372214.4706

5.67911.38636.8405

1.09862.989113.6484

5.2772

0.69312.771213.5075

5.3433

1.38636.55540.69313.135513.7125

5.3096

0.69312.671013.44815.35111.38636.56670.6931

3.248413.9966

5.3591

0.69313.070213.95225.48011.38636.75580.6931

3.173714.16225.52380.69313.125414.14415.6453

1.38636.7142

0.69312.995213.70845.29890.69312.822013.6056

5.3653

1.38636.86480.69313.473813.9657

5.0414

1.0986

3.407013.86885.0153

1.3863

6.94791.38634.675715.91465.6666

1.09864.523015.8135

5.82761.38637.03000.00002.420612.9073

5.01490.00002.184012.53415.00451.38637.0414

1.09863.569014.63155.4456

1.09863.200614.13285.48451.38636.9903

1.09863.609114.45435.44191.38633.528714.3770

5.4204

1.3863

6.83301.09863.330013.97965.2556

1.0986

3.159513.88235.33001.38636.9305

1.09863.580114.16485.2146

1.0986

3.417214.02125.1843

1.38637.01301.38633.8171

14.6287

5.41301.38633.596514.5650

5.5934

1.38637.26960.00000.686311.13175.10590.00000.6877

11.2164

5.11201.38637.4307

1.0986

4.115915.4730

5.80271.38633.986215.44945.95261.38637.61090.00000.695911.3527

4.97890.00000.726811.34145.0913

1.38637.68290.6931

1.945912.9285

5.37630.00001.094011.75375.00161.38636.9393

1.09862.473413.08625.13190.69312.297913.0694

5.27881.38636.90680.69312.627613.2189

5.16830.00002.083213.0605

5.5383

1.38637.01930.00000.6807

11.35195.27450.00000.6904

11.2758

5.17681.38636.79571.38634.691716.01455.74671.38634.652215.9932

5.8434

1.3863

6.66701.09862.7702

13.9186

5.6021

1.09862.636713.86215.7014

1.38634.64440.00001.71349.86882.94440.00001.72139.8873

2.8382

1.38634.99040.00002.004410.40912.94440.00001.999310.18582.87071.3863- 24 -

国総研資料 No.963

5.14750.00001.67169.92942.94440.00001.59739.76152.8774

1.38636.37160.00001.373910.9204

4.31790.00001.370410.8945

4.30551.3863

6.4151

1.09862.986412.90644.43170.69312.893012.8489

4.57261.38637.05270.6931

1.7853

11.78654.71490.00000.684910.9174

4.84371.38636.62670.69312.0022

11.7725

4.20250.69311.809011.8793

4.7262

1.38636.77420.00000.683510.98175.11560.00000.6877

10.91594.8363

1.38636.6871

0.69312.0636

11.9846

4.43180.00001.380811.67424.9242

1.38636.86590.00000.6738

11.1679

5.12840.00000.684911.1057

4.8363

1.3863

6.29890.00001.7867

11.5966

4.30570.00001.494011.0200

4.14781.38636.61201.38633.1791

13.5850

4.91100.00003.174613.3352

4.76171.38636.72140.00001.393811.91425.06680.00001.3863

11.67424.94251.38636.6201

0.6931

1.961811.94194.53380.00001.3931

11.7130

4.97291.3863

6.41670.00001.370411.04514.23450.00001.382911.31584.72411.38636.53960.00001.825011.9827

4.63900.00001.788112.0456

5.15751.38636.6921

0.69312.453812.86034.87990.00002.417412.7578

4.99811.38637.29301.60943.027513.8324

5.1855

1.09862.563513.69275.61891.3863

6.9884

1.38633.442714.0520

5.1332

0.69313.254213.8503

5.09211.38636.86690.00000.975311.4455

5.06940.00001.0384

11.52905.01471.38636.67830.00001.7687

11.54034.41340.00001.748410.9747

4.05571.38635.16480.00001.3087

10.27093.54700.00001.2547

10.2283

3.5142

1.38635.90260.00000.671010.4845

4.40240.00000.672410.5000

4.33591.38635.89160.00002.2866

11.7845

4.19580.00002.4906

11.5782

3.6514

1.38635.93490.6931

3.163013.1232

4.46960.00003.217513.1178

4.4323

1.38635.70380.00002.481912.4875

4.50700.00002.860412.5274

4.3663

1.38636.3596

1.09863.020813.28674.67081.0986

3.196313.5352

4.91461.38636.51170.69312.648612.7830

4.5756

0.69312.495412.8150

4.8264

1.38636.43130.69312.932512.8901

4.5331

1.09862.763813.1780

5.0492

1.38636.1356

1.09862.6342

12.23904.2496

1.09862.364012.27464.51451.38636.3421

0.6931

3.094513.1745

4.5732

1.09862.896413.2191

4.94101.38636.4846

0.69313.260613.3775

4.68750.6931

3.1757

13.6998

5.11281.3863

6.89670.00000.8033

11.33075.10590.00000.8335

11.2473

5.12501.38637.1732

0.69312.374513.7692

5.88780.6931

1.542613.3246

6.14901.3863

7.05700.6931

3.026913.84995.27150.6931

1.895313.2224

5.74301.38636.3154

1.09862.353913.2123

5.12780.00001.820611.85284.68591.3863

7.13971.38633.321714.04545.1412

1.09862.938513.76095.31181.38637.4085

1.0986

1.726712.4091

5.10690.00000.695911.3466

5.00471.3863

7.17701.38633.225414.0134

5.13780.69312.874413.81025.45181.38637.08760.00000.0082

10.31135.11190.00000.979511.3780

4.84951.38637.17630.69312.136412.7226

5.1642

0.69312.364013.16615.32011.38637.1317

1.09862.349212.8850

5.0942

0.69312.162213.1087

5.46151.3863

7.21600.69311.365511.8476

5.07970.00000.6931

11.52225.3373

1.38635.76520.00002.2882

11.6947

4.07670.00002.1772

11.5376

4.0264

1.38636.03790.00001.887910.91693.72790.00001.784010.97103.91881.38635.56070.69312.0611

11.4859

4.06540.69312.036011.4515

4.4273

1.38635.24700.00002.054512.0505

4.61690.00002.057312.1505

4.8533

1.38635.39820.00001.526110.64123.69430.00001.6581

10.54113.66361.38635.72681.09863.345513.0936

4.27030.00002.791112.75424.61391.38636.91571.38633.669114.3477

5.1582

1.09863.442614.16735.2354

1.38637.3865

1.09862.282113.14835.3681

0.69311.814312.89695.49861.38635.64190.00001.892910.9194

3.58350.00001.629010.5747

3.72101.38635.62040.00001.7441

11.43284.65590.69312.3431

11.48194.35691.38635.54910.00002.2852

11.4015

3.58430.00002.215011.2925

3.7093

1.38635.17050.00000.63249.25483.58350.00000.64119.1902

3.58351.3863- 25 -

機材サイズ・運航便数に関するエアライン戦略のモデル化/井上岳・川西和幸

付録Ｂ．Stata の実行コードおよび出力結果- 26 -

国総研資料 No.963- 27 -

機材サイズ・運航便数に関するエアライン戦略のモデル化/井上岳・川西和幸- 28 -

国土技術政策総合研究所資料
TECHNICAL NOTE of N I L I M
No. 963
編集・発行

March 2017
©国土技術政策総合研究所

本資料の転載・複写のお問い合わせは〒239-0826 神奈川県横須賀市長瀬 3-1-1
管理調整部企画調整課

電話：046-844-5019

E-mail：ysk.nil-kikaku@ml.mlit.go.jp