Cocoa supply chain2;gf^][lagfYjqaf\mkljq

KeYdd`gd\]j

LjY\]j?jaf\]jJ]lYad]j>gg\
Af\mkljq;g[gYZ]Yfk;g[gYdaimgj

Content)Afljg\m[lagfhY_]+*L`][g[gYnYdm][`YafhY_],+LgoYj\kkmklYafYZadalqhY_].
,;]jlaÕ]\[g[gYhjg\m[lagfhY_]))-<jan]jkg^[`Yf_]hY_]),.EYbgj[`Ydd]f_]khY_])//;gf[dmkagfhY_])10Kgmj[]kg^af^gjeYlagfhY_]*);gfkme]jAf\mkljaYd
9jlakYfYd
H`YjeYlgZY[[g[gfkme]jk;g[gYhgo\]jgjdaimgjgjZmll]j;`g[gdYl]hjg\m[lk1 Introduction

3;`g[gdYl]$hjg\m[]\^jge[g[gYZ]Yfk$akYf]plj]e]dq

kaf_[gf[]jfYZgmlkg[aYd$]fnajgfe]flYdYf\][gfgea[hghmdYj^gg\al]e$[gfkme]\Yddgn]jl`]ogjd\&;g[gYakakkm]kafl`][g[gY[`Yaf&Af*((1$afl`]afYm_mjYdakkm]

[mdlanYl]\afegj]l`Yf,(ljgha[Yd[gmflja]kaf9^ja[Y$9kaYg^l`];g[gY:Yjge]l]j$L;;[gf[dm\]\l`Yloal`gmlhjg%

Yf\DYlaf%9e]ja[Y&Angjq;gYklYf\?`YfYY[[gmfl^gj.(\m[]jkl`]j]oaddZ]fg[`g[gdYl]Yf\oal`gml[gfkme]jkg^ogjd\hjg\m[lagf&Gn]j1(g^_dgZYd[g[gYhjg\m[lagf

l`]j]oaddZ]fgeYjc]l^gjl`]^Yje]jkÌhjg\m[]&Alak$Ykak[mdlanYl]\ZqYf]klaeYl]\-&-eaddagfkeYdd`gd\]jk& 

kaehd]Ykl`Yl&:gl`]f\kg^l`][`Yaff]]\afn]kle]flk

9fgl`]j),eaddagfjmjYdogjc]jk\aj][ldq\]h]f\gf[g[gYlgZ]kmklYafYZd]&

)^gjl`]ajdan]da`gg\k&;d]Yjdq$[g[gYhjg\m[lagfaehY[lkka_faÕ[Yfldqgf][gfgea[\]n]dghe]fl$Yf\l`]]fnajgf%;g[gY$akaf^Y[l$a\]Yddqkmal]\^gjkmklYafYZd]hjg\m[lagf

e]fl$afhjg\m[af_Yj]Yk&

Yf\kg[aYd[`Yf_]&L`]eYbgjhdYq]jkafl`]eYjc]lYj]
bmklY`Yf\^mdg^ljYfkfYlagfYd[gehYfa]k&L`]qYj]o]dd

;g[gYhja[]kYll`]Dgf\gfYf\F]oQgjc[geeg\alq

hdY[]\lgY[lYkeYbgj\jan]jkg^[`Yf_]Yf\Zjaf_YZgml

Ym[lagfk$jgk]lgj][gj\d]n]dkafea\*()($j]Ö][laf_l`]Yegj]kmklYafYZd][g[gYk][lgj&L`][g[gYaf\mkljqaf%_jgoaf_aeZYdYf[]Z]lo]]fkmhhdqYf\\]eYf\&E]Yf%n]klknYklkmekg^egf]qYlgfdqgf]]f\g^l`][`Yaf2

o`ad]$egklkeYdd`gd\]jkYf\[g[gYogjc]jkdan]Z]dgol`][gfkme]jk$Yf\gfgf]lgha[2ZjYf\af_&L`]af\mkljq

l`]hgn]jlqdaf]&KeYdd`gd\]jk`Yn]dalld]ZYj_Yafaf_

`Yk_jgkkdqmf\]j]klaeYl]\l`]kalmYlagfYll`]gl`]jhgo]jgjafÖm]f[]gf^Yje_Yl]hja[af_e][`Yfakek\m]

]f\g^l`][`Yaf2l`][g[gYZ]Yfhjg\m[]jk&F]n]jl`]d]kk$

lgo]Ychjg\m[]j%eYjc]ldafcY_]kYf\daeal]\Y[[]kklgÕ%]f[gmjY_af_\]n]dghe]flkYj]lYcaf_hdY[]3hjg\m[]jk$

fYf[aYdYf\[YhY[alq\]n]dghe]flk]jna[]k&L`]qÕf\dalld]

_gn]jfe]flk$af\mkljq$Yf\[gfkme]jkaf[j]Ykaf_dqj]%af[]flan]lgaf[j]Yk]hjg\m[lanalq$aehjgn]hjg\m[]imYda%[g_far]l`]aehgjlYf[]g^kmklYafYZd][g[gYhjg\m[lagf&lqgjY\ghlkmklYafYZd]hjg\m[lagfe]l`g\k&Afn]kle]flAfl`]F]l`]jdYf\k$Yddl`]klYc]`gd\]jkafl`][`g[gdYl]

afhmZda[kljm[lmj]kkm[`Ykj]k]Yj[`afklalml]k$]pl]fkagf

k][lgjka_f]\YfY_j]]e]fl$afEYj[`*()($lgkgmj[]gfdq

k]jna[]kYf\eYjc]laf_ZgYj\kakog]^mddqafY\]imYl]af

kmklYafYZdqhjg\m[]\[g[gY^gjl`]<ml[`eYjc]l&egklhjg\m[af_[gmflja]k&;gfk]im]fldq$hjg\m[]jkdY[chjgh]j^Y[adala]k$cfgo%`gogf_gg\Y_ja[mdlmjYdhjY[la[]k$

Ë;g[gY:Yjge]l]j*()(Ìhj]k]flkYfYfYdqkakg^l`]j][]fl

Yf\afhmlkkm[`YkhdYflaf_eYl]jaYdYf\f]ol][`fgdg%

eYjc]l\]n]dghe]flkafl`][]jlaÕ]\[g[gYk][lgjYf\_a]k&;jghdgkk\m]lgh]kl\YeY_]Y\\klgl`]ajeak]jq$

Yaeklg^m]dgf_gaf_\ak[mkkagfkgfZmad\af_[YhY[alqYf\

Yf\l`]k]keYdd`gd\]jkYf\ogjc]jkYj]ljYhh]\afY

ljYafaf_g^[g[gY^Yje]jk&9fgn]jna]og^j][]fllj]f\kna[agmk[aj[d]g^mfkmklYafYZd]hjg\m[lagfYf\hgn]jlq&

Yf\\]n]dghe]flkafl`][g[gYnYdm][`Yafak^gddgo]\ZqYZja]^afljg\m[lagfg^l`][gf[]hlg^[]jlaÕ[YlagfYf\;gfk]im]f[]kg^l`akmf^gjlmfYl]klYl]g^Y^^YajkYj]^]dll`]\a^^]j]flklYf\Yj\kkqkl]ek$o`a[`Yj]af[j]Ykaf_dq

l`jgm_`gmll`]]flaj][g[gYnYdm][`Yaf&Alakfgl]Ykq

Y[[]hl]\fgo&9fgn]jna]og^l`]YnYadYZadalqg^[]jlaÕ]\^gjljY\]jkYf\[g[gY_jaf\]jklgk][mj]Ykmhhdqg^_gg\[g[gY$alk^mlmj]hjgkh][lkYf\hjg[mj]e]flZql`]lgh

imYdalq[g[gY&L`]j]hmlYlagfg^[`g[gdYl]Yf\[gf^][%Õn][`g[gdYl]eYfm^Y[lmj]jk^gddgok&<]n]dghe]flkYf\

lagfYjq[gehYfa]kakYljakc\m]lgl`][gfkme]jkÌaf[j]Y%

lj]f\kYj]Zja]Öq]pYeaf]\$Yf\lghdY[]afh]jkh][lan]

2 The cocoa value chain4l`]hjgb][l]\_jgol`af[]jlaÕ]\[g[gYhjg\m[lagf$

L`]\]eYf\^gj[g[gY`Yk_jgofkl]Y\adqZml$Ylhj]k]fl$

o]lYc]Y[dgk]jdggcYll`]ljYafaf_afalaYlan]kg^l`]l`]hjg\m[af_[gmflja]kYj]mfYZd]lg^mdÕdl`ak\]eYf\&*

af\ana\mYd[gehYfa]kYf\l`]k][lgjafalaYlan]k&

Gn]jl`]hYkl^]oq]Yjk$l`]\]eYf\`Ykj]_mdYjdq]p%[]]\]\[g[gYZ]Yfhjg\m[lagf&Af^Y[l$l`]imYflalqg^Ljgha[Yd;geeg\alq;gYdalagfoaddhj]k]fll`];g[gY

[g[gYhjg[]kk]\`Yk]p[]]\]\hjg\m[lagfj]kmdlaf_af:Yjge]l]j*()(Yll`]=mjgh]Yf;g[gY;gf^]j]f[]Yf\Yl\][dafaf_[g[gYklg[ckYf\k]n]j][g[gY`]\_af_&+>mjl`]j

l`]*()(L;;%;gf^]j]f[]Ë;geZafaf_J]kmdlkÌaf9ekl]j%_jgol`g^l`]\]eYf\lge]]ll`]af[j]Ykaf_[`g[gdYl]

\Ye$lgZmad\k`Yj]\mf\]jklYf\af_g^l`]kmklYafYZadalq

[gfkmehlagfaf]e]j_af_eYjc]lkoaddafl]fka^ql`]hj]k%afn]kle]flkf]]\]\Yll`]_dgZYdd]n]d&L`]j]hgjloadd

kmj]gfl`][g[gYklg[ckYf\jYak]ogjd\[g[gYhja[]klg

YdkgZ]mk]\af\ak[mkkagfkoal`af\ana\mYd[gehYfa]k$

YfYdd%lae]`a_`&

F?Gk$klYf\Yj\Zg\a]k$ljY\]Ykkg[aYlagfk$Yf\k][lgjYf\[gfkme]jkafalaYlan]k&9[dgk]jdggcYll`]logegklaehgjlYfl[g[gYhjg\m%[af_[gmflja]kj]n]Ydk\][dafaf_hjg\m[lagfkaf[]l`]*((-'*((.k]Ykgf3%)-&-afAngjq;gYklYf\%)+af?`YfY&,L`]af\mkljql`]j]^gj]Yll]ehlklg]phYf\[g[gY
hjg\m[lagfaf9kaY$]&_&;Yj_addYf\EYjkafNa]lfYe$af[gd%dYZgjYlagfoal`l`]<ml[`_gn]jfe]fl$Yf\CjY^lafAf\aY&
Af[j]Ykaf_l`][g[gYY[j]Y_]afl`akeYff]j[Yfaf]na%lYZdqd]Y\lg[`Yf_]kafdYf\mk]oal`[g[gY[geh]laf_
oal`gl`]jY_ja[mdlmjYd[jghkgjoal`fYlmj]$j]kmdlaf_af\]^gj]klYlagf&AlakaehgjlYfllgfgl]l`Yll`ak]phYfkagf
lgd]kkljY\alagfYd[g[gYhjg\m[af_Yj]Ykaf9kaY`Ykfgl
ZYdYf[]\\]eYf\Yf\kmhhdq$Ykq]l&5

Cocoa grinders

Chocolate manufacturersL`]_jaf\]jkYj]l`]egklhgo]j^mdY[lgjkafl`]nYdm]

L`][`g[gdYl]k][lgjak\geafYl]\ZqbmklY^]ohdYq%[`Yaf\m]eYafdqlgl`]gf_gaf_`gjargflYdYf\n]jla[Yd]jko`g`Yn]_jgofafkar]Yf\ka_faÕ[Yf[]$]kh][aYddq

afl]_jYlagf2[gf[]fljYlagfhjg[]kkafl`]_jaf\af_k]_%l`jgm_`l`]j][]flY[imakalagfg^[geh]lalgjk&L`]eYjc]l

e]flYf\l`]gmlkgmj[af_g^daima\[`g[gdYl]$j]kh][%kljm[lmj]g^l`][`g[gdYl]eYfm^Y[lmj]jkj]k]eZd]kl`Yllan]dq&;g[gY_jaf\]jk`Yn]Y`a_`dq[gf[]fljYl]\eYjc]lg^l`][g[gY_jaf\]jkoal`l`j]]d]Y\af_[gehYfa]kYf\kljm[lmj][gehjak]\g^l`j]]d]Y\af_[gehYfa]kYf\log

logkeYdd]j[gehYfa]k\geafYlaf_&9^l]jl`]j][]fllYc]%

keYdd]j[gehYfa]k&L`]lghÕn][g[gYhjg[]kkgjk$;Yj_add

gn]jg^;Y\ZmjqZqCjY^l$Ydegkl-(g^l`]]flaj][gf%),&-!$9<E )+&1!$:Yjjq;Ydd]ZYml )*&*!$H]ljY>gg\k^][lagf]jqeYjc]lakafl`]`Yf\kg^gfdqÕn][gehYfa]k&/!Yf\:dgee]j -&+!$hjg\m[]egj]l`Yf`Yd^g^l`]

CjY^l ),&1!Yf\EYjk ),&-!Yj]d]Y\af_l`]_jgmh^gd%ogjd\Ìkk]ea%Õfak`]\[g[gYhjg\m[lk&-

dgo]\ZqF]kld  /&1!$@]jk`]qÌk ,&.!Yf\>]jj]jg ,&-!&/
9kl`]CjY^l%;Y\Zmjqe]j_]j[j]Yl]\Yk][lgj\geafYl]\@gjargflYdafl]_jYlagfak[gflafmaf_oal`l`]]ph][l]\ZqY^]o$dYj_][gehYfa]k$alak`a_`dqdac]dql`Yl`gjargflYd

e]j_]jZ]lo]]f:dgee]j$<]dÕ Y[gehgf]flg^H]ljY

afl]_jYlagfoadd[gflafm]$d]Y\af_lgYf]n]fegj][gf[]f%>gg\k!Yf\;]egak]llgZ][ge]Yj]Ydalqafl`]f]Yj

ljYl]\k][lgj&Oal`l`]lYc]gn]j$CjY^lZ][Ye]l`]ogjd\^mlmj]&L`]qYj]Ydj]Y\q[ggh]jYlaf_afl`]H9;LK Hjg[]k%dYj_]kl[`g[gdYl]eYfm^Y[lmj]jYf\l`]k][gf\dYj_]kl

kgjk9ddaYf[]^gj;g[gYLjY[]YZadalqYf\KmklYafYZadalq!

[gf^][lagf]jq$^gg\Yf\Z]n]jY_][gjhgjYlagf$Z]`af\

hjg_jYe$Ybgafln]flmj]hjg_jYeafAngjq;gYkl& L`]F]kld &CjY^lklj]f_l`]f]\alkhgkalagfafalkljY\alagfYd

gf_gaf_[gf[]fljYlagfhjg[]kkafl`]_jaf\af_k]_e]fleYjc]lkYf\kljYl]_a[Yddq]phYf\]\alkY[lanala]klgl`]akn]jq\qfYea[&>mjl`]jegj]$l`]_jaf\]jkYj]Z][geaf_$

]e]j_af_eYjc]lk$^gj]pYehd]$CjY^lkYd]kafAf\aYYdgf]

egj]Yf\egj]$l`]hjg\m[]jkg^daima\[`g[gdYl]$Yf\_j]o^jger]jglg,((eaddagfoal`;Y\Zmjqhjg\m[lk&0

.

kmhhda]jklg[`g[gdYl]eYfm^Y[lmj]jk&Oal`afYk`gjlkhYf
g^lae]$l`]_jaf\]jk`Yn]Z][ge]l`]egklhgo]j^mdFglgfdqakl`]fmeZ]jg^eYfm^Y[lmj]jkYf\hjg[]kkgjk

klYc]`gd\]jkafl`][`Yaf\m]lgl`]gf_gaf_[gf[]fljY%\][dafaf_$l`]qYj]Ydkg[ggh]jYlaf_egj]afl]fkan]dq&Gn]j

lagfafl`]_jaf\af_k]_e]flYf\gmlkgmj[af_g^daima\l`]hYkl\][Y\]k$l`]hjg[]kkgjk`Yn]_jgofYf\_jY\m%[`g[gdYl]&

YddqlYc]fgn]jYZgml-(g^l`]ogjd\[g[gYZ]Yfhjg%[]kkaf_&;mjj]fldq[`g[gdYl]eYfm^Y[lmj]jkaf[j]Ykaf_dq
[gfljY[lhjg[]kkgjklglYc]gn]j hYjlkg^!l`]hjg\m[lagf
hjg[]kk^gjkh][aÕ[hjg\m[lk&Hjg[]kkgjkYj]_Yafaf_Yegj]aehgjlYfljgd]afl`]]flaj]hjg\m[l[`Yaf&:Yjjq
;Ydd]ZYml$^gj]pYehd]$Yaeklgj]Y[`Yfaf\mkljaYd[`g[g%dYl]hjg\m[lagf[YhY[alqg^)$+-($(((lgfk$af*()(&13 Towards sustainability

6=fYZdaf_kmklYafYZadalqafl`][g[gYk][lgjakg^l`]ml%

LgY\\j]kkhgn]jlqj]\m[lagfafYeYjc]l[gfl]pl$[]jlaÕ%egklaehgjlYf[]&L`akoaddfglgfdqYddYq[gfkme]jkÌ[Ylagfk`gmd\lYc]hdY[]Y_YafklYklYf\Yj\kkqkl]eoal`_jgoaf_[gf[]jfkYZgml^gg\hjg\m[lagfe]l`g\kYf\Y\]imYl]Yll]flagf^gj[gflafmYdaehjgn]e]flklgoYj\kl`]ajaehY[lgfhggjh]ghd]Yf\l`]]fnajgfe]fl$Zml

af[dmkan]f]kkYf\kmklYafYZadalq&Lg^mjl`]jl`akgZb][lan]$YdkgkY^]_mYj\Zmkaf]kkafl]j]klkZqYn]jlaf_l`]`a_`jakc

Ye]l`g\gdg_q`YkZ]]f\]n]dgh]\lg[geemfa[Yl]l`]g^imYdalqdgkk$kmhhdqk`gjl^YddkYf\kmdda]\j]hmlYlagfk&klj]f_l`kYf\o]Ycf]kk]kg^]Y[`af\ana\mYdklYf\Yj\kAfj][]flq]YjkYoa\]jYf_]g^kmklYafYZadalqafkljme]flk

kqkl]ek af^gjeYlagf\]jan]\^jge]Y[`klYf\Yj\kdakl!gf

`Yn]hjgda^]jYl]\afl`][g[gYk][lgj&L`]egklka_faÕ[Yfl

af[dmkan]f]kk$kmklYafYZd]\]n]dghe]flYf\[`YafeYfY%

Yegf_l`]k]Yj][g[gY[]jlaÕ[YlagfklYf\Yj\k$ljYafaf__]e]fl&

Yf\[YhY[alqZmad\af_hjg_jYee]klghjgegl]kmklYaf%
YZd]^Yjeaf_hjY[la[]k$Yf\hjg_jYee]klgY\\j]kk[`ad\dYZgmjaf[g[gYhjg\m[lagf&L;;hj]^]jkYfafl]_jYl]\Yh%hjgY[`lgaehjgn]Yf\hjgl][ll`]][gfgea[$kg[aYdYf\]fnajgfe]flYd[gf\alagfkYll`]Z]_affaf_g^l`][g[gY
[`Yaf&Afl`akj]_Yj\$alemklZ]fgl]\l`YldYj_]k[Yd]

Figure 1 ‘Flower’ with inner management
cycle and five specific thematic qualities[]jlaÕ[YlagfaklYcaf_g^^Yf\Z][geaf_egj]oa\]khj]Y\afl`][g[gYk][lgj&9degklYddeYbgj[`g[gdYl]eYfm^Y[%lmj]jkfgokgmj[]YkeYddhjghgjlagfg^l`]ajhjg\m[lagf

product

no coveragemf\]jYklYf\Yj\kkqkl]e$km[`Yk>YajljY\]$Gj_Yfa[[]jlaÕ[Ylagf$JYaf^gj]kl9ddaYf[]Yf\MLR;]jlaÕ]\&L`]k]

laÕ[Ylagfakfgll`]mdlaeYl]kgdmlagf$Y[geZafYlagfg^

ac

k

che
c

]^Õ[a]fqYf\j]n]fm]k&Kladdal`YklgZ]fgl]\l`Yl[]j%tsocial,labour standards

pla

environment

lowd]pYehd]ljYafaf_$Y[[]kklgf]oeYjc]lk$Yf\]f`Yf[]\

fair
trading
tradingpractisesnl`][g[gYk][lgj_an]khjg\m[]jkeYfqghhgjlmfala]k$^gj

nonmediumoeYjc]l%ZYk]\YhhjgY[`]klgkmklYafYZd]\]n]dghe]flg^

health & foodsafetyhigh\a^^]j]flkmklYafYZadalqafkljme]flkogmd\Z]l`]a\]Ydlg
hd]Y\^gj&

Certification;]jlaÕ[Ylagfakl`]hjg[]\mj]o`]j]ZqYfaf\]h]f\]fl>a_mj])hgjljYqkl`]e]l`g\gdg_q\]n]dgh]\lgYkk]kk

l`aj\hYjlq[]jlaÕ[YlagfZg\q_an]kYojall]fYkkmjYf[]

l`]]pl]fllgo`a[`YklYf\Yj\kkqkl]e_an]kYll]flagfl`Yll`]imYdalqg^l`][g[gYYf\l`]hjg\m[lagfhjg[]kklgYf]^^][lan]eYfY_]e]flkqkl]e l`]aff]j[q[d]!$Yf\`YkZ]]fYkk]kk]\$Yf\l`YlZgl`[gf^gjelgl`]j]imaj]%kh][aÕ[l`]eYla[imYdala]k l`]Õn]d]Yn]k!&e]flkkh][aÕ]\Zql`]klYf\Yj\kkqkl]e&7

Inner management cycleActL`]aff]j[q[d]g^l`]Ögo]j\]ha[lkl`]aehgjlYf[]

L`]ÕfYd[gehgf]flg^l`]eYfY_]e]fl[q[d]\]Ydkoal`_an]flgkqkl]eYla[eYfY_]e]flYf\l`]j]imaj]e]fll`]Y[lagfZYk]\mhgfl`]Õf\af_kg^l`]l`aj\[gehg%

g^Yf]^^][lan]Yf\ogjcaf_eYfY_]e]fl[q[d] HdYf%<g%f]fl ;`][c!&>gddgoaf_AKGhjg[]\mj]k$Õf\af_kafYm\al;`][c%9[l!&9dl`gm_`klYf\Yj\kkqkl]ek[Yfk[gj]`a_`gf

j]hgjlkYj]j]hgjl]\YleYfY_]e]fle]]laf_khgkkaZdq

akgdYl]\[gehgf]flk$\]egfkljYlagfg^Yogjcaf_[q[d]

d]Y\af_lgeg\aÕ[Ylagfklgl`]hdYffaf_hjg[]kk^gjl`]akj]imaj]\&O`a[`e]Yfkl`Yldafcaf_l`],eYfY_]e]fl

f]pl[q[d]&>af\af_k[gmd\YdkgZ]j]hgjl]\lgfYlagfYd

[gehgf]flkk`gmd\_]lYll]flagf&j]^]j]f[]_jgmhkYf\'gjklYf\Yj\kZg\a]k$^Y[adalYlaf_[geemfa[YlagfYf\Y[lagfd]Y\af_lgl`]^mjl`]j\]n]dgh%Plane]flg^klYf\Yj\k&L`]Õjkl[gehgf]fl\]Ydkoal`hdYffaf_$hjagjalqk]llaf_
Yf\af[dmkan]f]kk&9j]ZYk]daf]klm\a]kYf\hdYffaf_j]%

Thematic qualities

imaj]\7<g]kl`]klYf\Yj\kkqkl]e^Y[adalYl]afl]_jYlagf

=f[aj[daf_l`]`]Yjlg^l`]Ögo]jYj]Õn]d]Yn]kj]hj]%g^]pl]jfYdklYf\Yj\kafhdYffaf_7Akl`]j]jgge^gjhjagj%k]flaf_Õn]_jgmhkg^l`]eYla[imYdala]k afAKGl]jeafg%alqk]llaf_Yf\af[dmkan]f]kkg^nmdf]jYZd]hjg\m[]jk7

dg_q!&9f]^^][lan]eYfY_]e]flkqkl]eakl`]eafaemeAkl`]fmeZ]jg^r]jglgd]jYf[]klYf\Yj\k eafaeme

j]imaj]e]fllg]fYZd]aehjgn]e]flkafl`]Õn]l`]eYla[j]imaj]e]flk!dgo79f\`golgd]jYflakl`]klYf\Yj\k

imYdala]k&kqkl]elgY[[geeg\Yl]hjg\m[]j_jgmhkYlYdgo]fljq
d]n]dgfl`][gf\alagfg^jYha\aehjgn]e]fl7

Product quality and quantity
G^l]f$l`akl`]eYla[imYdalqj][]an]kl`]`a_`]klhjag%Dojalqafl`]hdYfkg^hjg\m[]j_jgmhk&KlYf\Yj\arYlagfYl

L`]k][gf\[gehgf]flakl`]Y[lmYdaehd]e]flYlagf

_dgZYdd]n]d`Ykdaeal]\e]Yfaf_Z][Ymk]g^fYlagfYdYf\h`Yk]&Ak[gflafmYdaehjgn]e]fl\mjaf_aehd]e]flYlagf][gdg_a[Yd\a^^]j]f[]k&:ml_dgZYdklYf\Yj\kZg\a]k[YflYc]faflg[gfka\]jYlagf7

[ggh]jYl]oal`fYlagfYdj]^]j]f[]_jgmhkYf\hjgna\]
_ma\Yf[]ZqklYf\Yj\araf_?gg\9_ja[mdlmjYdHjY[la[]k&Check;gehdaYf[]oal`hjg\m[limYdalqYf\imYflalqklYf\Yj\kL`]l`aj\[gehgf]fl[gn]jkYm\alaf_$[`Yaf[gn]jY_]Yf\[Yfhjgna\]l`]^Yje]jY\aj][lZ]f]ÕlZYk]\gfZ]ll]j

ljY[]YZadalq&9`a_`k[gj]e]Yfk]^^][lan][geZafYlagfkg^

Yf\'gjegj]hjg\m[]lgk]dd&Gl`]joak]l`]\aj][lZ]f]Õlk

afl]jfYdYf\]pl]jfYdYm\alaf_'l`aj\hYjlq[]jlaÕ[Ylagf

g^ogjcaf_lgoYj\k[gehdaYf[]Yj]j]dYl]\lg[gfkme]j

Yf\]pl]jfYdklYf\Yj\ko]ddafl]_jYl]\afl`]afl]jfYd

_gg\oaddgfdq&

Ym\alaf_kqkl]e&9m\alaf_$[`Yaf[gn]jY_]Yf\ljY[]YZadalq
Yj]aehgjlYfl^gj[j]\aZd][geemfa[YlagfYf\Ykkmj%

Environmental quality

Yf[]l`Yll`]imYdala]kgfl`]hjg\m[ldYZ]dYj]j]kh][l]\L`akimYdalq\]Ydkoal`l`]\]_j]]g^dafcaf_ZYk]daf]\YlYl`jgm_`gmll`][`Yaf&L`]aehgjlYf[]g^ljYfkhYj]f[qak

lgY`]Ydl`a]jYf\[d]Yf]j]fnajgfe]fl&@go[gehd]l]

Ydkgaf[dm\]\&Yj]l`]]fnajgfe]flYdakkm]k ][gkqkl]e[gfk]jnYlagf$

t

pla

)

productnac

Figure 2 Overview of the strengths and weaknesses of the four standards systems on
inclusiveness, sustainable development and chain management-*

fair trading
practises

environment,+social,labour standards

d

o

k

8

health & foodchec

JYaf^gj]kl9ddaYf[] K9FklYf\Yj\k!_]lkYj]dYlan]dq`a_`

Gfl`]eYla[akkm]kJYaf^gj]kl9ddaYf[]akkljgf_gf

k[gj]^gjl`]afl]jfYdeYfY_]e]fl[q[d]&K9FklYf\Yj\k]fnajgfe]flYdimYdalqaf[dm\af_][gkqkl]eYf\oad\da^]j]imaj]YeYfY_]e]flkqkl]eY[[gj\af_lgl`]kar]Yf\[gfk]jnYlagf&AlakYdkgkljgf_afljY\af_[gf\alagfk$

[gehd]palqg^l`]^Yje&L`]klYf\Yj\kYj]Ö]paZd]Yf\eYjc]lljYfkhYj]f[qYf\kg[aYdimYdalq ZmldY[ckkh][aÕ[lgd]jYfllgoYj\kdgo]fljqd]n]dhjg\m[]j_jgmhk3al`Yk

[gfka\]jYlagfgf_]f\]j!&Alk[gj]kdgogfhjg\m[limYdalq$

YdgofmeZ]jg^eafaemej]imaj]e]flkYf\`Ykjgge

kaf[]hjg\m[lagfhjY[la[]kYj]fglklYf\Yj\ar]\&L`]j]ak

^gjhjagjalqk]llaf_&EYfY_]e]fl]nYdmYlagfj]kmdlk

fg[gn]jY_]gf`]Ydl`Yf\^gg\kY^]lq$Zmlj]^]j]f[]ak

f]]\lgZ]af[dm\]\afl`]f]plaehjgn]e]flhdYf&L`]

eY\]lgfYlagfYdj]_mdYlagfk&

Y[[j]\alYlagfkljm[lmj] [mjj]fldqmf\]jj]nakagf !akYd]kk
)(kljgf_]jhgafl$Yf\afl`]aff]jeYfY_]e]fl[q[d]$[`Yaf

t

pla

)

productnac[gn]jY_]Yf\ljY[]YZadalqYj]o]Yc&

-

*

d

o

k

fair trading
practises,social,labour standards

environment+

health & foodchecAfl`]eYfY_]e]fl[q[d]l`]MLRklYf\Yj\kj]imaj]l`Yl

Gfl`]eYla[akkm]kYdglg^Yll]flagfak_an]flghjg\m[lhjg_j]kkak\]egfkljYl]\&L`]klYf\Yj\kYj]lgd]jYfl^gj

imYdalqYf\imYflalq$kmhhgk]\lgd]Y\lg`a_`]jaf[ge]&

dgo]fljqd]n]dhjg\m[]j_jgmhk fmeZ]jg^eafaeme

L`]MLRklYf\Yj\kYj]Ydkgkljgf_gf^Y[adalYlagfYf\j]imaj]e]flkaf[j]Yk]gn]jY,%q]Yjh]jag\!3YhdYfak

_ma\Yf[]afeYjc]laf^gYf\k]n]jYd[jal]jaYgf`]Ydl`j]imaj]\oal`af+q]Yjkoal`jgge^gjhjagjalqk]llaf_$Zml

Yf\^gg\kY^]lqYj]j]imaj]\&9d]kkkljgf_]jhgaflak

hdYfj]imaj]e]flkYj]\ana\]\^gjk]n]jYdl`]e]k$o`a[`l`]]fnajgfe]flYd[gn]jY_]$Ydl`gm_`aehjgn]e]flak

\g]kfgl_an]Y_gg\_ma\Yf[]lghjg\m[]jk&Afl]jfYd

j]imaj]\^gjY_ja[mdlmjYdhjg\m[lagfhjY[la[]k&Yf\]pl]jfYdYm\alaf_Ylemdlahd]d]n]dkYf\o]ZZYk]\
ljY[]YZadalqYj]kljgf_hgaflk&Gfl`]gl`]j`Yf\$o`ad]
hjg_j]kkan]aehjgn]e]flafl`]aehd]e]flYlagfh`Yk]ak
\]kaj]\$alakfglklYf\Yj\ar]\Yf\Y[lagfmhgfÕf\af_kak
fglj]imaj]\&

ac

pla

)

product

n

t

-

*

d

o

k

fair trading
practises

environment,+social,labour standards

health & foodchecAfl`]eYfY_]e]fl[q[d]l`]>DGkeYdd`gd\]jklYf\Yj\kGfl`]eYla[akkm]kl`]>DGklYf\Yj\khYqY_j]Yl\]Yd

j]imaj]l`Ylhjg_j]kkak\]egfkljYl]\&L`]klYf\Yj\kg^Yll]flagflgkg[aYdimYdalq$Yf\Yn]jY_]Yll]flagflg

Yj]lgd]jYfl^gjdgo]fljqd]n]dhjg\m[]j_jgmhk gf]_]f\]jakkm]k&9kmZklYflaYdhYjlg^l`][g\]akj]k]jn]\l`aj\g^l`]klYf\Yj\kYj]eafaemej]imaj]e]flk!Yf\^gj_]f]jYd]fnajgfe]flYdklYf\Yj\k&EYjc]lklYlakla[kY+%q]Yjh]jag\ak_an]f^gjl`]hdYfYf\hjagjalqk]llaf_&Yj]YnYadYZd]Yf\Yeafaemehja[]Yf\Õp]\hj]eameL`]klYf\Yj\k_an]em[`Yll]flagflghdYffaf_Yf\Yj]_mYjYfl]]\&L`]>DGklYf\Yj\kk[gj]dgogfhjg\m[lkh][aÕ[Yddqj]imaj]kYhjg_jYe^gjnmdf]jYZd]hjg\m[]jk&

imYdalqYkhjg\m[lagfhjY[la[]kYj]fglklYf\Yj\ar]\&

L`]Y[[j]\alYlagfkljm[lmj] []jlaÕ[Ylagfak[]fljYdar]\L`]j]akfg[gn]jY_]gf`]Ydl`Yf\^gg\kY^]lqZml

l`jgm_`>DG%;=JL!Yf\[`Yaf[gn]jY_] Ydl`gm_`l`]j]

j]^]j]f[]akeY\]lgfYlagfYdj]_mdYlagfk&

akYk]hYjYl]ljY\]klYf\Yj\!Yj]d]kkkljgf_]jhgaflk&
9degklfgj]imaj]e]flk]paklgfY[lagfgfYm\alÕf\af_k$
Ydl`gm_`Yfgj_YfarYlagfYdkljm[lmj]akafhdY[]]fYZdaf_

t

pla

)

productnac[gfljgdZqe]eZ]jk&

-

*

d

o

k

fair trading
practises,social,labour standards

environment+

health & foodchecL`]=MGj_Yfa[klYf\Yj\kj]imaj]YhdYfYf\jakc%ZYk]\Gfl`]l`]eYla[imYdala]kl`]=MGj_Yfa[klYf\Yj\khjagjalqk]llaf_&Alakkljgf_afjakc%ZYk]\afl]jfYdYf\Yj]kljgf_gfl`]]fnajgfe]flYdimYdalq$oal`eYfq

]pl]jfYdYm\alaf_$l`aj\hYjlq[]jlaÕ[YlagfYf\af[`Yaf

eafaeme]fnajgfe]flYdj]imaj]e]flkYf\l`]^Y[l[gn]jY_]Yf\ljY[]YZadalq&L`]klYf\Yj\kYj]o]Ycafl`YleYfY_]e]flg^Zagdg_a[Ydhjg[]kk]kakj]imaj]\&

af[dmkan]f]kk kaf[]l`]klYf\Yj\kYj]^gjemdYl]\Ykr]jg

Hjg\m[lagfhjY[la[]kYj]klYf\Yj\ar]\&L`]j]akfg

lgd]jYf[]k!Yf\af[gflafmYdaehjgn]e]flYkl`]j]akfg

[gn]jY_]gf`]Ydl`Yf\^gg\kY^]lq$Zmlafl]_jYlagfg^[gn]jY_]gfl`]Ë\gÌYf\ËY[lÌh`Yk]k&=M^gg\kY^]lqj]_mdYlagfak^Y[adalYl]\&L`]=MklYf\Yj\k
Yj]o]Ycgfkg[aYdimYdalqoal`fg[gn]jY_]gfADG
;gfn]flagfk$dYZgmjja_`lk$_]f\]j$]l[&>mjl`]jegj]$l`]
klYf\Yj\kYj]n]jq\a^Õ[mdllgj]Y\Yf\mf\]jklYf\]n]f
^gj]ph]ja]f[]\h]jkgfk$d]lYdgf]hjg\m[]jk&9

10

Zag\an]jkalq$ghlaeYdmk]g^afl]jfYdj]kgmj[]k$]f]j_q]^%

Trading practices

Õ[a]f[q$dgo]eakkagfk$r]jgoYkl]$]l[&!af[dm\]\afl`];Yfkljm[lmjYd[gklkg^[gehdaYf[]Z][gn]j]\^jgehja[]

klYf\Yj\kkqkl]e7\a^^]j]flaYdk$hj]eamekYf\af[j]Yk]\]^Õ[a]f[a]k7<g]kl`]klYf\Yj\k\g[me]flhjgna\]YdafclgYeYjc]laf_

Health and food safetyo]Zkal]$o`a[`ljYfkhYj]fldq[geemfa[Yl]kgf

@]Ydl`Yf\>gg\KY^]lqaf[dm\]k@9;;HYf\AKG**(((h]j[]flY_]kg^hjg\m[]kgd\Yk[]jlaÕ]\7<g]kogjcaf_klYf\Yj\kkqkl]ek&EYfqklYf\Yj\kZg\a]k[gfka\]jl`]k]

lgoYj\k[gehdaYf[]d]Y\lgY[[]hlYZd][gkl%Z]f]ÕlkYf\Yj]lggkh][aYdar]\Yf\eYc]j]^]j]f[]lgfYlagfYdj]_m%\g]kalYnga\]p[]kkan][gf\alagfk `]Ynqafn]kle]flk$

dYlagfk&Fgf]l`]d]kk$^gjeYfq^Yje]jk]phgjlaf_[g[gY$af[ge]\ahk$kljgf_Öm[lmYlagfg^hja[]k$]l[&!7AkYkl]hZql`]k]`]Ydl`Yf\^gg\kY^]lqklYf\Yj\kYj]eYf\Ylgjq&kl]hYhhjgY[`^gddgo]\afY[[gj\Yf[]oal`eYfY_]e]fl[YhY[alqYf\[gkl%Z]f]ÕleYj_afkafl`]eYjc]l7Ak[gkl%Social quality and labour norms

Z]f]Õlaf^gjeYlagfYnYadYZd]afYkljm[lmjYd$klYf\Yj\ar]\$

KlYf\Yj\kkqkl]ekemklaf[dm\]Yld]Ykll`]]a_`l

ljYfkhYj]flYf\hj]^]jYZdq[gehYjYlan]oYq^gj

^mf\Ye]flYdADG;gfn]flagfk$fYe]dqfg^gj[]\dYZgmj

keYdd`gd\]jk7<g]kl`]klYf\Yj\kZg\q^Y[adalYl]l`]ogjc

ADG;gfn]flagfk*1)(-!$fg\ak[jaeafYlagf ADGg^YfYlagfYdj]^]j]f[]_jgmhafhjgna\af_\YlYj]imaj]\af;gfn]flagfk)(()))!$fg[`ad\dYZgmj ADG;gfn]flagfk

Y[gehYjYlan]^jYe]ogjc7)+0)0*!Yf\^j]]\geg^Ykkg[aYlagfYf\[gdd][lan]
ZYj_Yafaf_ ADG;gfn]flagfk0/10!&L`]klYf\Yj\k>gmj_dgZYdklYf\Yj\kkqkl]ekYj]j]d]nYfl^gjl`]kqkl]ek`gmd\YdkgeYc]j]^]j]f[]lgYdanaf_oY_]l`Yl

[g[gYk][lgj$fYe]dq>YajljY\]$Gj_Yfa[$JYaf^gj]kl

[gn]jkZYka[f]]\k$`]Ydl`qYf\kY^]ogjcaf_[gf\alagfk$

9ddaYf[] KmklYafYZd]9_ja[mdlmj]F]logjc!Yf\MLR

d]_YddYZgmj[gfljY[lkYf\k`gmd\af[dm\]_]f\]j%kh][aÕ[;]jlaÕ]\&>a_mj]*_an]kYfgn]jna]og^l`]klj]f_l`kYf\[jal]jaY&AehgjlYfldq$l`]aehd]e]flYlagfg^YklYf\Yj\ko]Ycf]kk]kg^l`]^gmjklYf\Yj\kkqkl]ek$o`]fk[gj]\kqkl]ek`gmd\Z][gehd]e]flYjqlg_gn]jfe]flYd

^gjaf[dmkan]f]kk$kmklYafYZd]\]n]dghe]flYf\[`Yaf

j]_mdYlagfk$Yf\fYlagfYdd]_akdYlagfakYdoYqkhj]^]jYZd]

eYfY_]e]fl&a^al]klYZdak`]k`a_`]jklYf\Yj\k&4 Certified cocoa production

11

Af*((1$)(,$(((lg^[]jlaÕ]\[g[gY$]imYdlg+g^l`]>a_mj]+k`gokl`YlklYf\Yj\kZg\a]kYj]YoYj]g^l`]

ogjd\eYjc]l +$-1+$(((l!$oYkhjg\m[]\&L`]ogjd\eY_falm\]g^l`]lYkcY`]Y\$Yf\Yj]\]l]jeaf]\lgeYjc]lk`Yj]g^[]jlaÕ]\[g[gY`Yk_jgof[gfka\]jYZdq

\]dan]j&L`]hjgb][lagfkhjgna\]\Zql`]klYf\Yj\kZg\a]k^jge*((1lg*()(&KlYf\Yj\kkqkl]ekgn]jdYhlgnYjqaf_[d]Yjdqk`gol`]aj]Y_]jf]kklg_jgo$Yf\eajjgjkY\]_j]]k$d]Y\af_lg\gmZd]gjljahd][]jlaÕ[YlagfYll`]

n]jq[geh]lalan]]fnajgfe]fl&9[[gj\af_lgl`]^mlmj]

hjg\m[]jkÌd]n]d&9f]klaeYl]\+(g^l`]MLR;]jlaÕ]\hjgb][lagfkg^l`]klYf\Yj\kZg\a]k$gn]jl`]f]pl\][Y\]$

Yf\JYaf^gj]kl9ddaYf[]hjg\m[lagfYf\)-g^l`]egj]l`Yf,+g^Ydd[g[gYZ]YfkoaddZ][]jlaÕ]\&L`]

Gj_Yfa[Yf\>YajljY\][g[gYhjg\m[lagf`YkZ]]f_jgol`jYl]khjgb][l]\ZqMLR;]jlaÕ]\$>YajljYa\]Yf\emdla%[]jlaÕ]\&)*9kl`][mjj]flkalmYlagfakmf[d]Yjlg

JYaf^gj]kl9ddaYf[]`Yn]lgZ]Ykk]kk]\n]jq[Yj]^mddq&YddklYc]`gd\]jkYdgf_l`][`Yafl`]klYf\Yj\kZg\a]kL`]aj[geZaf]\afl]flagfkaehdql`Ylgn]jl`]f]pll]fk`gmd\[geemfa[Yl]ljYfkhYj]fldqgfl`]d]n]dg^q]YjkYjgmf\)$///$(((^Yje]jk`Yn]lgZ]ljYaf]\lg

emdla%[]jlaÕ[Ylagf&<m]lg\gmZd][gmflaf_$l`]Y[lmYd

af[j]Yk]l`]ajhjg\m[lagfoal`*-Yf\Z][ge][]jlaÕ]\lglYdngdme]g^[]jlaÕ]\[g[gYZ]Yfkakdgo]jl`Yf>a_mj]-!&Hj]k]fldq$l`]j]Yj]Yjgmf\)*/$((([]jlaÕ]\klYl]\&>mjl`]jegj]$*(g^l`][]jlaÕ]\hjg\m[lagf

^Yje]jk&)+;gfka\]jaf_l`]j][]fl]^^gjlklgZmad\[YhY[alqf]n]j]fl]jkl`][]jlaÕ]\kYd]k[`Yff]d$Z][Ymk]Z]af_Yll`]hjg\m[]jd]n]d$afY\]eYf\af_]fnajgfe]flg^]al`]jg^af^]jagjimYdalqgjg^`a_`imYdalql`]qYj]

mfgj_Yfak]\keYdd`gd\]jk$Y[`a]naf_l`]hjgb][l]\

kgd\^gjYlljY[lan]hja[]klgea\\d]e]f >a_mj],!&L`]

_jgol`jYl]kak`a_`dqim]klagfYZd]&Lgj]Y[`l`]aj_gYdk

ZYdYf[]g^kmhhdqYf\\]eYf\g^[]jlaÕ]\[g[gYZ]Yfk

l`]klYf\Yj\kZg\a]koadd`Yn]lgaf[j]Ykaf_dqgn]j[ge]

akim]klagfYZd]&;gfka\]jaf_l`]j][]fl[geeale]flkg^l`]^gddgoaf_[`Ydd]f_]k2l`][`g[gdYl]eYfm^Y[lmj]jkl`]j]oaddZ]YkmZklYflaYd
gn]jkmhhdqg^egj]l`Yf)-($(((lgfkg^[]jlaÕ]\[g[gY% DY[cg^^Yje]jgj_YfakYlagfk

Z]Yfkaf*()*$]n]fY^l]jlYcaf_aflg[gfka\]jYlagfl`]% Daeal]\ljYafaf_[YhY[alqYldg[Ydd]n]ddgkk]k\m]lgemdla%[]jlaÕ[YlagfYf\kYd]kl`jgm_`gl`]j% HggjY[[]kklg[j]\alYf\Y_ja[mdlmjYd^mf\kljY\][`Yff]dk&% DgoeglanYlagfYf\af[]flan]klg_jgo[g[gY% @a_`[gehdaYf[][gklk^gj^Yje]jk% ;geh]lalagfZ]lo]]fklYf\Yj\kZg\a]kFigure 3 Production and growth projections of certified cocoa by standard bodies11129[lmYd>mlmj]

hjg\m[lagfhjg_fgk]k

*((1

*()(

-$+1.l*($(((l*()-).($(((l*(*( ?jgol`jYl]*((1%*(*(-(($(((l

1+


LglYd

 )+$+((l/1$*((l+*)$+-(l-(($(((l+0

 .-$(((l

0($(((l*/-$(((l,/-$(((l/ *($(((l,*$-((l.($(((l

0($(((l, )(+$.1.l**)$/((l0).$+-(l)$---$(((lFigure 4 Fate of certified cocoa)(([]jlaÕ]\hjg\m[lagf)- ak\gmZd][]jlaÕ]\+(Õf\kgl`]jkYd]k[`Yff]dkgjakaf^]jagjimYdalq-- akkgd\Yk[]jlaÕ]\Figure 5 Certified farmers: reality versus projections in 202013



-1.$((( ).$(((.$-((

.(-$-((

-(*$(((/1$-((*-$((( /+$-((

9egmflg^ljYaf]\^Yje]jkmhlg*()(n]jkmk9eZalagfg^l`]klYf\Yj\k
Zg\a]kaf*(*(-$(((ljYaf]\^Yje]jk-$(((^Yje]jklgZ]ljYaf]\

5 Drivers of change

Cocoa grinders
14;g[gY_jaf\]jk`Yn]Yc]qjgd]afkmklYafaf_l`][g[gY

Aehd]e]flYlagfg^YkeYddd]nqakYhgkkaZd]e]Yfklg

k][lgj$Ykl`]qYj][dgk]lgZgl`l`]^Yje]jkYf\l`][`g[%ÕfYf[][gehj]`]fkan]kljm[lmj]\ljYafaf_^gjkeYdd`gd%

gdYl]eYfm^Y[lmj]jk&L`]lghÕn]hjg[]kkgjkYj]af[j]Y%\]jk&)/L`]hjg[]kkaf_[gehYfqakl`]egklYhhjghjaYl]

kaf_dq[geeallaf_l`]ek]dn]klg_jaf\af_[]jlaÕ]\[g[gY

d]n]dlgjYak]l`]d]nq$Z][Ymk]YddZ]Yfk`Yn]lgZ]hjg%lge]]ll`]af[j]Ykaf_\]eYf\g^[`g[gdYl]eYfm^Y[lm%[]kk]\lgZ]mk]^md&9d]nqg^+1'lgf -('lgf!g^_jaf\]\

j]jk&;da]fl]ph][lYlagfk$afl`ak[Yk]$Yj]Y`m_]\jan]jg^[g[gYakd]kkl`Yf*g^l`]ogjd\eYjc]lhja[]Yf\oal`%_jgol`afljY\]Yf\hjg[]kkaf_g^kmklYafYZd][g[gY&Egkl

afl`]Zgmf\Yja]kg^fgjeYdeYjc]l\]n]dghe]flk&L`]

_jaf\]jk`Yn]Y\ghl]\emdlahd]klYf\Yj\kkqkl]eklg

d]nq[gmd\_]f]jYl]),($((($((('q]Yj&L`][gklkg^l`]

k]jn]Yoa\]YjjYqg^[mklge]jk&d]nq`Yn]lgZ]ljYfk^]jj]\naYl`]hgkl%hjg[]kkaf_[`Yaf
lg[gfkme]jk&Oal`Y[g[gY[gfl]flg^YZgml0afl`]

9^]o_jaf\]jkdac]9<EYf\9jeYbYjg\]n]dgh]\[gehYfq

[gfkme]jhjg\m[lkl`akogmd\e]YfY[gfkme]jhja[]]^%kh][aÕ[hjg_jYeklgkgmj[]ljY[]YZd][g[gYafYf]^Õ[a]fl^][lg^d]kkl`Yf*h]jeadd'[`g[gdYl]ZYj&L`]<ml[`LjY\]

eYff]j&9<EklYjl]\alkljY[]YZd]K=J9Hhjg_jYeYf\Mfagf>FNhj]k]fl]\l`aka\]YYll`]*f\Jgmf\LYZd]^gj

9jeYbYjgk]lmhKgmj[]Ljmkl$Y[gehYfq^gmf\Ylagfl`Yl

YKmklYafYZd];g[gY=[gfgeqafLjafa\Y\&L`akhjghgkYd

g^^]jkljY[]YZd][g[gYoal`kh][aYd\aj][lZ]f]Õlk^gj

akhj]k]fldqZ]af_j]k]Yj[`]\ZqA;;GYf\l`]Jgmf\^Yje]jk& 9dl`gm_`l`]k]hjg_jYekeYq^gkl]jhgkalan]

LYZd]^gjKmklYafYZd];g[gY=[gfgeq&9hjgY[lan]jgd]^gj

j]kmdlknaYljYafaf_l`]qYj]fgkmZklalml]^gjaf\]h]f\]fl

af\mkljq[gmd\`]dhl`]hjg[]kkka_faÕ[YfldqYf\ogmd\

klYf\Yj\kYkl`]qdY[cl`aj\hYjlqYm\alaf_& \]egfkljYl]l`]j]khgfkaZadalqlYc]fZql`]o`gd]k][lgj&?jaf\]jkYj]fglnakaZd]lg]f\[gfkme]jk$`]f[]d]kk

Chocolate manufacturers

nmdf]jYZd]lghmZda[[jala[ake&F]n]jl`]d]kk$_jaf\]jk`Yn]

L`]\]eYf\^gj[]jlaÕ]\[g[gYak_jgoaf_&Egj]eYbgj

YhanglYdjgd]lghdYqafY\\j]kkaf_l`]kg[aYd$]fnajgf%[`g[gdYl]eYfm^Y[lmj]jkhjg[mj][]jlaÕ]\[g[gYYf\g^^]je]flYdYf\][gfgea[hjgZd]ekYl^Yjed]n]d&L`]egkl

dYZ]dd]\[`g[gdYl]hjg\m[lk&Afkl]Y\g^gfdqg^^]jaf_k]%aehgjlYfl[`Ydd]f_]_jaf\]jkYf\ljY\]jk^Y[]lg\Yqak

d][l]\dYZ]dd]\hj]eamehjg\m[lk$l`]q`Yn]dYZ]dd]\eYfq

),)-`golgegn]^jgeYZmkaf]kkeg\]dZYk]\gfhja[]Yf\g^l`]ajd]Y\af_ZjYf\kaf*((1Yf\*()(&ngdme]$lggf]ZYk]\gfhja[]$ngdme]Yf\kmklYafYZadalq& ).

Lg]fkmj]imYdalq[]jlaÕ]\[g[gY$fgoYf\af^mlmj]$ljY%

Af*((1$CjY^lafljg\m[]\JYaf^gj]kl9ddaYf[]dYZ]dd]\;gl]

\]jkYf\_jaf\]jklg_]l`]joal`_gn]jfe]flkg^l`]eYaf\ÌGjhjg\m[lkaf>jYf[]Yf\:]d_ame&L`][gehYfq`Yk

hjg\m[af_[gmflja]k$emkl`]Ynadqafn]klafkeYdd[g[gY

hdYff]\lg_jY\mYddqafljg\m[]l`][]jlaÕ]\hjg\m[lafk]%^Yje]jk&A^fgl$l`]qoaddaf[j]Ykaf_dq[gflafm]lg^Y[]

n]fgl`]j[gmflja]kaf=mjgh]Yf\afFgjl`9e]ja[YZ]^gj]

\a^Õ[mdla]klge]]ll`]\]eYf\g^l`]aj[da]flk&?gg\ljYa%*()*&AlkEYjYZgmZjYf\koaddj][]an][]jlaÕ[Ylagfafl`j]]

faf_Yf\^Yje]jkmhhgjlhjg_jYee]kYj]aehgjlYfl3Yf\

K[Yf\afYnaYf[gmflja]k$Yf\afKoalr]jdYf\Yf\9mkljaY3l`]dafc]\lgeYjc]l%ZYk]\kmklYafYZadalqljYb][lgja]k$ogmd\kYe]Yhhda]klgalkKm[`Yj\hjg\m[ldaf]&;]jlaÕ]\[g[gY[gfklalml]l`]egkl]^Õ[a]floYqlgY[`a]n]dgf_%l]je

Z]Yfkj]imaj]\lgaehd]e]fll`]k]hdYfkoaddYegmfllg

kmklYafYZadalq\]n]dghe]fl&+($(((lgfkaf*()*&)0<m]lgl`];Y\ZmjqlYc]gn]jCjY^l15[YfY\\log[]jlaÕ]\hjg\m[lklgalkhgjl^gdag2>YajljY\]

Yl^Yjehjg\m[lagfd]n]dal`YkZ][ge]Y[lan]Yf\`YkY[%[]jlaÕ]\;Y\Zmjq<YajqEadcZYjk *((1!Yf\Gj_Yfa['>Yaj%imaj]\YkeYddngdme]g^JYaf^gj]kl9ddaYf[][]jlaÕ]\[g[gYljY\]?j]]f:dY[cÌk *((0!&;Y\Zmjq<YajqEadcZYjkYj]

^jgeYhadglhjgb][lafAngjq;gYkl&*.G^l`]lghÕn]eYfm%[mjj]fldqYnYadYZd]afl`]Mfal]\Caf_\ge$Aj]dYf\$F]o^Y[lmj]jk$@]jk`]qÌkYf\>]jj]jgYj][d]YjdqdY__af_Z]`af\&R]YdYf\$9mkljYdaYYf\;YfY\Y)1$^gjo`a[`CjY^lhjg[mj]k
egj]l`Yf)-$(((lgfkg^[]jlaÕ]\Z]Yfk&?j]]f:dY[cÌk

9dl`gm_`[`g[gdYl]eYfm^Y[lmj]jkkladdmk]j]dYlan]dqkeYdd

akYdkgoa\]dqYnYadYZd]&*(CjY^l`Ykk]lYk`gjl%l]je_gYdlg

ngdme]kg^[]jlaÕ]\[g[gY$Yf\\akljaZml]l`]k]hjg\m[lklg

hjg[mj]Yeafaemeg^-($(((lgfk[]jlaÕ]\[g[gYaf*()*&

Ydaeal]\fmeZ]jg^[gmflja]k$l`]ajmf\]jdqaf_kljYl]_qak

*)Yae]\Ylhjgeglaf_kmklYafYZdqhjg\m[]\[`g[gdYl]afl`]
Af*()($EYjkdYmf[`]\alkÕjkleYbgjZjYf\$l`]?YdYpq

eYafklj]YeeYjc]l&:gl`JYaf^gj]kl9ddaYf[]Yf\MLR;]jla%

ZYj$oal`l`]JYaf^gj]kl9ddaYf[]dYZ]d&**EYjk$Y^jgfljmf%

Õ]\^Y[adalYl]l`akkljYl]_qZqj][g_faraf_hjg\m[lkoal`f]jlgoYj\kYkmklYafYZd][g[gYk][lgj$YdkghmZda[dqYeafaemeg^+([]jlaÕ]\[g[gYZd]f\]\oal`[gfn]f%Yffgmf[]\alk^mlmj]lYj_]llgkgmj[])((kmklYafYZd]

lagfYd[g[gY&9dYZ]dgfl`][`g[gdYl]hjg\m[lemklaf^gje

[g[gYZq*(*(&L`][gehYfq]ph][lklghjg[mj]Yld]Ykl

l`][gfkme]jg^l`]]pY[lh]j[]flY_]g^[]jlaÕ]\[g[gY&+-($(((lgfkg^[]jlaÕ]\[g[gYZql`Yllae]&:gl`MLR;]j%G^[gmjk]$\a^^]j]fldYZ]dkoal`\a^^]j]flh]j[]flY_]k[YflaÕ]\Yf\JYaf^gj]kl9ddaYf[]hdYqYfaehgjlYfljgd]3l`]q[gf^mk]l`][gfkme]j&O`ad]l`akakYkl]hafl`]ja_`l\aj][%

Yj]l`]eYafkmhhda]jkoal`eafaeYd)(($(((lgfk]Y[`&*+

lagf$Ydd[`g[gdYl]eYfm^Y[lmj]jkk`gmd\af\a[Yl]Y[d]Yj
lYj_]llgoYj\k)(([]jlaÕ]\hjg\m[lk$YkEYjkYf\CjY^l

Kaf[]*()($F]kld mk]k>YajljY\][]jlaÕ]\[`g[gdYl]^gj

`Yn]Ydj]Y\qYffgmf[]\&l`]CalCYl^gmj%Õf_]jZYjkafl`]Mfal]\Caf_\geYf\Aj]dYf\&*,Afl`]f]Yj^mlmj]$F]kld hdYfklgafljg\m[]MLR

;gfkme]jkZmqaf_l`]ÕfYdhjg\m[l`Yn]l`]ja_`llg

;]jlaÕ]\hjg\m[lkafF]oR]YdYf\Yf\9mkljYdaY&F]kld j][]an][gjj][laf^gjeYlagf$af]Ykq%lg%mf\]jklYf\dYf%`Ykk]lYk`gjl%l]jelYj_]llgkgmj[]Yeafaemeg^+($(((_mY_]$YZgmll`]k[gh]Yf\_gYdkg^l`]nYjagmkklYf\Yj\klgfk[]jlaÕ]\[g[gYaf*()*&kqkl]ek&LjYfkhYj]f[qg^af^gjeYlagf^gjl`][gfkme]j$
j]_Yj\af_l`]j]Ydaehjgn]e]flkYlhjg\m[]jkÌd]n]d$ak

@]jk`]qÌkg^^]jkl`]gj_Yfa[<Y_gZYZjYf\kaf[]*((1&Af

Yc]q^Y[lgjaf[j]Ylaf_[j]\aZd]$kmklYafYZd][`g[gdYl]

*((/$@]jk`]qÌkYf\KlYjZm[cko]j][ggh]jYlaf_gfYKlYj%

ZjYf\k&Afl`akj]kh][l$[`g[gdYl]eYfm^Y[lmj]jkk`gmd\Z]

Zm[ck;`g[gdYl]daf]l`YloYkkgmj[]\naYl`]KlYjZm[ck]f[gmjY_]\lg^gddgol`]]pYehd]k]lZqEYjkaf*()(&L`ak

;g[gYHjY[la[]k?ma\]daf]kYf\K[gj][Yj\&@go]n]j$l`ak

[gehYfq`Yk\]n]dgh]\YjgY\eYh$af\a[Ylaf_\a^^]j]fl[ggh]jYlagf]f\]\af*((1Yf\@]jk`]qÌkhj]k]flhmZda[jgml]klgoYj\kkmklYafYZd][g[gYkgmj[af_$Y[[gehYfa]\[geeale]flak)[]jlaÕ]\[g[gYZq*()-&*-

ZqYhmZda[Yffgmf[]e]flg^alkkmklYafYZadalq_gYdkoal`Y[d]Yjlae]^jYe]Yf\ead]klgf]kafl`]^gjeg^[]jlaÕ]\>]jj]jg`Ykfglq]lafljg\m[]\Yfq[]jlaÕ]\[`g[gdYl]

ngdme]kmflad*(*(&Gl`]j[`g[gdYl]eYfm^Y[lmj]jkk`gmd\

hjg\m[l$fgj`YkalhmZda[dq[geeall]\alk]d^lgafn]klaf

Z][ge]hjgY[lan]lgg$lglY[cd]l`][`Ydd]f_]kafY[ggj\a%eYcaf_l`][g[gYkmhhdq[`YafkmklYafYZd]&@go]n]j$

fYl]\eYff]jYf\[j]Yl]YljmdqkmklYafYZd]k][lgj&Figure 6 Certified cocoa purchased by the major five chocolate manufacturers in 2009
and future commitments in 201227[g[gYngdme]*((1,,($(((l'[]jlaÕ]\*((12**$(((l -&(!'[]jlaÕ]\*()*2-($(((l ))&,!
16

*(

g1

)*

*(

[g[gYngdme]*((1+.($(((l'[]jlaÕ]\*((12,$(((l )&)!'[]jlaÕ]\*()*2+($(((l 0&+!

)**([g[gYngdme]*((1+-($(((l'[]jlaÕ]\*((12-$(((l )&,!'[]jlaÕ]\*()*2)(($(((l *0&.!

)**([g[gYngdme]*((1)/($(((l'[]jlaÕ]\*((12)(l (&(!'[]jlaÕ]\*()*20--l (&-!

[g[gYngdme]*((1)+-$(((l'[]jlaÕ]\*((12(l (&(!'[]jlaÕ]\*()*2(l (&(!

6 Major challenges

17;]jlaÕ[Ylagfakgf]aehgjlYflc]qlgljYfk^gjel`][g[gY

9ll`]_jaf\]jd]n]d2:Yjjq;Ydd]ZYmloal`alkImYdalq

k][lgjaflgYkmklYafYZd]hjg\m[lagf[`Yaf&AlakYnalYdlggd

HYjlf]jhjg_jYe$9<Eoal`alkKg[aYddqYf\=fnajgfe]f%af]Y[`klYc]`gd\]jÌklggdZgp&;g\]kg^[gf\m[lj]imaj]

lYddqJ]khgfkaZd]9_ja[mdlmjYdHjY[la[]k K=J9H!hjg_jYe

kmhhda]jklge]]l[]jlYafklYf\Yj\kgf^gg\kY^]lq$

Yf\;Yj_addoal`alk>Yje]j>a]d\K[`ggdkhjg_jYe`Yn]

ogjcaf_[gf\alagfkYf\]fnajgfe]fl%^ja]f\dqhjg\m[lagfY[`a]n]\_gg\j]kmdlk&9egf_l`][`g[gdYl]eYfm^Y[lm%hjY[la[]k&L`akYhhjgY[`lgkmklYafYZd]\]n]dghe]fl

j]jk$EYjkoal`alk;g[gYKmklYafYZadalqHYjlf]jk`ah$CjY^lhjgna\]khYjla[ahYlaf_hjg\m[]jkeYfqghhgjlmfala]k$^gj

oal`alk;Y\Zmjq;g[gYHYjlf]jk`ahYf\F]kld oal`alk

]pYehd]$ljYafaf_$Y[[]kklgf]oeYjc]lk$Yf\]f`Yf[]\;g[gYHdYf$\]egfkljYl]l`]ajkaf[]j]afngdn]e]fl&]^Õ[a]f[qYf\j]n]fm]k&@go]n]j$^mddY[[]kklgl`]k]
Z]f]Õlk$^gjl`gk]egklaff]]\$akj]klja[l]\ZqnYjagmk

9ddÕn]eYbgj[`g[gdYl]eYfm^Y[lmj]jkYf\_jaf\]jk

gZklY[d]kkm[`Ykdaeal]\\]eYf\^gj$Yf\afn]kle]flgf$

[gfljaZml]lgk][lgjoa\]afalaYlan]k$dac]l`]Ogjd\;g[gY[]jlaÕ]\hjg\m[]$Yf\`a_`Ym\al[gklk&>gmf\Ylagf O;>!&O;>eYfY_]knYjagmkdYj_]k[Yd]
ljYafaf_hjg_jYekaf\a^^]j]fl[g[gYhjg\m[af_[gmflja]k$

9dd_jaf\]jkYf\[`g[gdYl]eYfm^Y[lmj]jkY\\j]kk]\$ZYj%dac]l`];g[gYDan]da`gg\kHjg_jYe$KmklYafYZd]Lj]]

jaf_gf]$Yf\Ydkgk][lgjYdafalaYlan]k$`Yn]caf\dqkmhhda]\;jghkHjg_jYeYf\=;@G=K9ddaYf[]&af^gjeYlagfj]_Yj\af_l`]ajafn]kle]flkaf$Yf\gml[ge]
g^$ljYafaf_hjg_jYek&@go]n]j$^gjegklhjg_jYekl`]

LjYafaf_g^^Yje]jkak]kk]flaYdlgeYc]Ykm[[]kkg^[]j%af^gjeYlagfakafY\]imYl]lg\]l]jeaf]l`]ajkm[[]kkjYl]

laÕ[Ylagf&Lg_]lY_gg\_jYkhg^l`]ljYafaf_kalmYlagf$Yf\l`]Z]f]Õlk\]jan]\^jgeljYafaf_&Af^Y[l$[j]\aZd]

L;;[Yd[mdYl]\l`]lglYdgmldYqj]imaj]\^gjljYafaf_[g[gY

aehY[le]Ykmj]e]fll][`faim]kYj]fglj]Y\adqYnYad%^Yje]jkogjd\oa\] >a_mj]/!&L`][Yd[mdYlagfakZYk]\gf

YZd]gj]YkadqYhhda]\&L`ak[j]Yl]kmf[]jlYaflqYZgmll`]l`]lglYdfmeZ]jg^ljYaf]\^Yje]jk[mjj]fldqYnYadYZd]$Yk

aehY[l hgkalan]gjf]_Ylan]!g^ljYafaf_Yf\[]jlaÕ[Ylagf

h]j\YlY^jgel`]-eYbgj_jaf\]jkYf\[`g[gdYl]eYfm%

hjg_jYek&AlakhYjYegmfl^gjl`][g[gYk][lgjlgkqkl]%^Y[lmj]jk$Yf\k][lgjYdYf\_gn]jfe]flYdljYafaf_hjg%

eYla[Yddqe]Ykmj]l`]kmklYafYZadalqj]kmdlkY[`a]n]\_jYek3Yf\l`]lglYdfmeZ]jg^[g[gY^Yje]jkogjd\oa\]

YlYddd]n]dkafl`][g[gYnYdm][`Yaf&Kh][aYdYll]flagf

Ykh]jO;>a&]&-$-(($(((&*0k`gmd\Z]_an]flgZY[c[dYaekg^aehY[lYlhjg\m[]jd]n]d$
lge]Ykmj]j]Ydlae]hjg_j]kk$Yf\[j]Yl]k][lgjoa\]

Alak]na\]fll`YlnaYaf\ana\mYdljYafaf_hjg_jYekg^l`]

[j]\aZadalq^gjl`]]^^gjlkg^l`]klYc]`gd\]jkafngdn]\&

lgh-hjg[]kkgjkYf\[`g[gdYl]eYfm^Y[lmj]jk$k][lgjGfdql`jgm_`[geZaf]\e]Ykmjaf_Yf\hggdaf_g^j]kmdlk

oa\]afalaYlan]kdac]O;>$Yf\_gn]jfe]flYd]pl]fkagfk]j%oaddl`]k][lgjZ]YZd]lga\]fla^q$\]n]dghYf\oa\]dq

na[]k$Yjgmf\)(g^l`][g[gY^Yje]jkogjd\oa\]`Yn]

aehd]e]fl]^Õ[a]flaehjgn]e]flhjg_jYek&

Z]]fljYaf]\&LjYafaf_Ye]j])(g^l`]keYdd`gd\]jk`YklYc]f[gfka\]jYZd]lae]Yf\]^^gjl&Fg\gmZl$aloadd

F]n]jl`]d]kk$eYfq[gehYfa]kYj]hjgY[lan]afljYafaf_lYc]$j]dYlan]dq$kgem[`egj]]^^gjl$lae]Yf\j]kgmj[]k

Y[lanala]k$Yf\l`]:Yjge]l]jlYc]khja\]afe]flagfaf_YlgY\\j]kkl`]j]klg^l`]^Yje]jkZ][Ymk]l`]qYj]d]kk

^]oafl]j]klaf_hjg_jYee]kg^kljgf_dqY[lan][gehYfa]k&

gj_Yfar]\Yf\dan]afj]egl]Yj]Yk&Lgj]klgj]l`]ZYdYf[]

Figure 7 Investment required to train cocoa farmers worldwide

18)(g^l`]^Yje]jk`Yn]j][]an]\ljYafaf_$l`]f][]kkYjq

?dgZYd[`g[gdYl]kYd]k*((1*1

afn]kle]fllgljYafl`]j]eYafaf_1(ak,(($((($(((

Afn]kl]e]flf]]\]\^gjljYafaf_/)$*(($((($(((
,(($((($(((

O`a[`ak(&-.g^l`]_dgZYd[`g[gdYl]kYd]kg^*((1Z]lo]]fkmhhdqYf\\]eYf\$Yf\lgk]jagmkdqY\\j]kk

Yf\]fnajgfe]flYd\]_jY\Ylagf[YfZ]Y\\j]kk]\^Ykl]j

jmjYdhgn]jlqYf\]fnajgfe]flYd\]_jY\Ylagfafl`][g[gY

Yf\egj]]^Õ[a]fldq&k][lgj$Ydgf_l]jeafn]kle]flg^Yld]Ykl,((eaddagfak

f][]kkYjq&

L`][YhY[alqg^l`]klYc]`gd\]jklgj]Y[`Yf\ljYaf[g[gY^Yje]jkoal`imYdalqhjg_jYekdYj_]dq\]h]f\kgf_gg\L`akYegmflg^,((eaddagfoaddgfdq[gn]jl`][gklg^

hdYffaf_Yf\afl]fkan][ggh]jYlagf&9ddklYc]`gd\]jk\a%^Yje]jljYafaf_&Gl`]jk]jna[]kdac][j]Ylaf_gj_YfarYlag%j][ldqgjaf\aj][ldq\]Ydaf_oal`^Yje]jljYafaf_hjg_jYek$fYdkljm[lmj]k$Y[[]kklgjmjYd[j]\al$f]ohdYflaf_eYl]%k`gmd\Ynga\ogjcaf_afakgdYlagfYf\hjgegl]_]f]ja[jaYdYf\kg[aYdaehjgn]e]flhjg_jYekYj]Ydkgf]]\]\&ljYafaf_eg\md]k&HgkkaZd]oYqklgklaemdYl][ggh]jYlagfYf\kY^]_mYj\]^Õ[a]f[qYf\]^^][lan]f]kkYj]2

AlZ][ge]kegj]Yf\egj]]na\]fll`YlY[gehj]`]fkan]
k][lgjoa\]ljYafaf_afalaYlan]oal`_gn]jfe]flk$af\mkljq$% ;ggh]jYlagfZ]lo]]fklYf\Yj\kZg\a]k

F?GkYf\j]k]Yj[`akl`]gfdqkgdmlagflgl`akgf_gaf_% HYjlf]jk`ahkZ]lo]]f[gehYfa]k';KGk'_gn]jfe]flk'

hjgZd]e&9d]nq^gjYk][lgjoa\]kmklYafYZadalq^mf\$Yk

klYf\Yj\kZg\a]khjghgk]\afk][lagf-&)$[gmd\Z]YfYhhjghjaYl]kgdmlagf% Jgmf\lYZd]afalaYlan]kfYlagfYdj]^]j]f[]_jgmhk

lgY\\j]kkl`akeYbgj[`Ydd]f_]&A^l`]k][lgjakYZd]lgYd%% ;ggh]jYlagfg^_gn]jfe]flk

dg[Yl]]n]jqq]YjYfkmZklYflaYdhgjlagfg^l`]),(Eag% Afljg\m[lagfg^Yk][lgjoa\]kmklYafYZadalq^mf\^gj[ggj\afYl]\`a_`d]n]dljYafaf_Y[lanala]k$jmjYdhgn]jlq

7 Conclusion

19

Ogjd\oa\]\]eYf\^gj[g[gYZ]Yfkak_jgoaf_kl]Y\adq$

ak`golgegn]^jgeYZmkaf]kkeg\]dZYk]\gfhja[]Yf\gmlhY[af_hjg\m[lagf&L`akq]YjÌkj][gj\[g[gYhja[]kYlngdme]$lggf]ZYk]\gfhja[]$ngdme]Yf\kmklYafYZadalq&l`][geeg\alqYm[lagfkafDgf\gfYf\F]oQgjc[d]Yjdq

Gn]jl`]dYkl\][Y\]$eYfq[g[gYklYc]`gd\]jk`Yn]afalaY%j]Ö][ll`]_jgoaf_aeZYdYf[]Z]lo]]f[g[gYkmhhdqYf\l]\[gehYfqYf\k][lgjoa\]afalaYlan]klgY\\j]kknYjagmk

\]eYf\&Egj]l`Yf`Yd^l`]_dgZYd[g[gYZ]Yfkmhhdq

h]jlaf]flakkm]k$dac][`ad\dYZgmj$^Yje]jk[`ggdaf_Yf\]f%[ge]k^jge?`YfYYf\Angjq;gYkl&;g[gYakYdegkl]p[dm%najgfe]flYd\]_jY\Ylagf&Afj][]flq]Yjk$l`]j]`YkZ]]fYkan]dq^Yje]\ZqkeYdd`gd\]jko`gY[[gmfl^gjgn]j1(g^

ka_faÕ[Yflk`a^lg^afl]j]kllgoYj\kafl]_jYl]\kmklYafYZd]

l`]_dgZYdhjg\m[lagf&L`]k]keYdd%k[Yd]hjg\m[]jkg^l]f

hjg\m[lagfhjY[la[]k$o`a[``Ykl`]afl]flagflgj]klgj]

^YddZ]dgol`]hgn]jlqdaf]$mfYZd]lgeYc]Ydanaf_^jgel`]ZYdYf[]Z]lo]]fkmhhdqYf\\]eYf\g^[g[gYZ]Yfk&[g[gY^Yjeaf_&Lg\Yql`][g[gYk][lgj$afegklhjg\m[af_L`]hmZda[Yffgmf[]e]flg^EYjkaf*((1lgogjclgoYj\k[gmflja]k$ak[gf^jgfl]\oal`l`]\aj][gfk]im]f[]kg^)(([]jlaÕ]\[g[gYaf*(*($lja__]j]\l`]o`gd]k][lgj&f]_d][laf_afn]kle]flafhmZda[afklalmlagfk$Yf\l`]\a%CjY^lYf\F]kld `Yn]bgaf]\l`][]jlaÕ[YlagfZYf\oY_gf

eafak`af_qa]d\kYj]\janaf_l`]k][lgjlg\]khYaj&Afgj\]j

Yf\l`]\]eYf\^gj[g[gY$[]jlaÕ]\Y_YafklkmklYafYZadalq

lgj]n]jk]l`aklj]f\$j]nan]l`]k][lgjYf\Ykkmj]YfY\]%

klYf\Yj\k$`Yk_jgofYhhj][aYZdq&>mlmj][geeale]fl$

imYl]kmhhdqg^imYdalq[g[gY$Yka_faÕ[Yfl]^^gjllgafn]kl

af\a[Ylaf_[d]Yjkl]hklgkgmj[]Y_jgoaf_k`Yj]g^kmklYaf%

afl`]`meYf[YhalYdg^^Yje]jkakYZkgdml]dq]kk]flaYd&

YZdqhjg\m[]\[g[gY$g^l`]gl`]j^gmjeYbgj[`g[gdYl]
eYfm^Y[lmj]jkCjY^l$F]kld $@]jk`]qÌkYf\>]jj]jg$ogmd\Concentration`]dhlgklaemdYl]Zgl`hjg\m[lagfYf\[gfkmehlagfeYj%

E]Yfo`ad]$l`]gf_gaf_`gjargflYdYf\n]jla[Ydafl]_jY%c]lk^gjkmklYafYZd][g[gYYf\[`g[gdYl]hjg\m[lk&lagfafl`][g[gY[`Yaf$Zgl`Yll`]d]n]dg^l`][g[gY_jaf\]jkYf\l`][`g[gdYl]eYfm^Y[lmj]k$d]Yn]kl`]

CertificationeYjc]llggfdqY`Yf\^mdg^ljYfkfYlagfYd[gehYfa]k&

NYjagmkklYf\Yj\kkqkl]ek$oal`\a^^]j]flZmkaf]kkh]j%

D]kkl`Yfl]f[gjhgjYlagfk\]Ydoal`egj]l`Yf-(g^kh][lan]kYf\[gfkme]jhjgÕd]k$Yj]jYha\dq]fl]jaf_l`]l`]ogjd\Ìk[g[gYZ]YfkYf\daima\[`g[gdYl]hjg\m[lagf&

eYafklj]Ye[g[gYYf\[`g[gdYl]eYjc]l&Af\]h]f\]fl

9f\`]j]da]kYogf\]j^mdghhgjlmfalq&L`]k][gehYfa]k

egfalgjaf_Yf\[]jlaÕ[YlagfYj][]fljYdlgl`]^gmjeYbgj

[gmd\lYc]mhl`]aj[gjhgjYl]kg[aYdj]khgfkaZadalqYf\Z]%[g[gYhjg\m[lagfklYf\Yj\k2>YajljY\]$=MGj_Yfa[$JYaf^gj%[ge]l`]eYbgj\jan]jkg^[`Yf_]Yf\Zjaf_YZgmlYegj]

]kl9ddaYf[]Yf\MLR;]jlaÕ]\&L`]ajkqkl]ekg^kmklYafYZa%

kmklYafYZd][g[gYk][lgj&

dalqklYf\Yj\kk`gmd\Z]k]]fYkafkljme]flklgaehjgn]l`]kg[aYd$]fnajgfe]flYdYf\][gfgea[kalmYlagfg^l`][g[gY

Changehjg\m[]jk$Yf\lg_an]Y[j]\aZd]e]kkY_]YZgmll`]kmk%

9<E$;Yj_add$:Yjjq;Ydd]ZYml$:dgee]jYf\H]ljY>gg\lYafYZd][`YafeYfY_]e]fl]^^gjlklgl`]]f\[gfkme]jk&

Yj]l`][dgk]kllg^Yje]jkafl`]nYdm][`Yaf&L`]j]^gj]$Af\ana\mYd[gehYfa]kYdkgeYc]mk]g^ljYafaf_hjg_jYek

_jaf\]jk[YfhdYqYhanglYdjgd]afY\\j]kkaf_l`]kg[aYd$

YkYe]YfklgkmklYafl`][g[gYk][lgj&@go]n]j$l`]af^gj%]fnajgfe]flYdYf\][gfgea[[`Ydd]f_]kYl^Yjed]n]d&L`]

eYlagfYnYadYZd]gfeYfqg^l`]ljYafaf_hjg_jYek[gf%egklaehgjlYfl[`Ydd]f_]_jaf\]jkYf\ljY\]jk^Y[]lg\Yq\m[l]\Zq_jaf\]jk$eYfm^Y[lmj]kYf\klYf\Yj\kZg\a]kak

20

afkm^Õ[a]fllg\]l]jeaf]l`]ajkm[[]kkjYl]Yf\ljYafaf_egj]l`Yf-(g^YddkeYdd`gd\]jk$oal`af)(q]Yjk$f]]\kY]^^][lk&KmklYafYZadalqhjg_jYekYj]af\Yf_]jg^Z]af_[gehj]`]fkan]]^^gjloal`kmZklYflaYd[gfljaZmlagfk$Zgl`im]klagf]\a^l`]aj]nYdmYlagfdY[ck[j]\aZadalq&Egj]Yf\ÕfYf[aYdYf\afcaf\$ZqYddafngdn]\klYc]`gd\]jk&

egj]^Yje]jk$[gfkme]jk$[gehYfa]kYf\_gn]jfe]flk
]naf[]afl]j]klafl`]j]kmdlkg^kmklYafYZadalqafalaYlan]k&Afl`akj]Yde$afl]jfYdaraf_l`]kg[aYdYf\]fnajgfe]flYd

@go]n]j$l`]oYqkafo`a[`o]fgoe]Ykmj]j]kmdlkdY[c[gklkg^kmklYafYZd]hjg\m[lagfakYc]q[`Ydd]f_]&Afgl`]j

ljYfkhYj]f[q&Fgjakl`]j]Y_j]]e]flgfo`Ylkgjlg^j]%ogj\k$`go\go]ÕfYf[]l`]]^^gjllgoYj\kegj]kmklYaf%

kmdlkf]]\lgZ]e]Ykmj]\lg\]l]jeaf]aehY[l&;gddYZg%

YZadalq7

jYlagfg^\a^^]j]flklYc]`gd\]jkafe]Ykmjaf_j]kmdlkakl`]c]qlg[j]\aZadalq&Oal`gml[gfk]fkmkYegf_klYc]`gd\]jL`]j]Yj]-&-eaddagf[g[gY^Yje]jkogjd\oa\]31(g^l`]e_jgmhkl`]]nYdmYlagfkoaddfglZ]Y[[]hlYZd]lgl`]Ym\a%`Yn]fglZ]]fljYaf]\&9[gfk]jnYlan][Yd[mdYlagfk`gok]f[]YldYj_]&;gdd][lan]e]Ykmjaf_Yf\hggdaf_g^j]kmdlk

l`YlYfafn]kle]flg^Yld]Ykl,((eaddagfakf][]kkYjqlg

akd]kk]ph]fkan]$Yf\egj]]^^][lan]&L`][`Ydd]f_]aklg

ljYafl`]k]^Yje]jk&L`akYegmfloaddgfdq[gn]jl`][gklg^j]\m[]l`][gehd]palqYf\lg\]Õf]Y[[]hl]\af\a[Ylgjk

^Yje]jljYafaf_&Gl`]jk]jna[]kdac][j]Ylaf_gj_YfarYlagfYd

Yf\k]d][lhjg[]kk]kl`Yl[YfZ]aehd]e]fl]\&

kljm[lmj]k$Y[[]kklgjmjYd[j]\al$f]ohdYflaf_eYl]jaYd
Yf\kg[aYdaehjgn]e]flhjg_jYekYj]Ydkgf]]\]\&9\\j]k%Challenges

kaf_j]egl]Yf\mfgj_Yfak]\^Yje]jkoadd^mjl`]jafÖYl]

;gfka\]jaf_l`]]^^gjlkafj][]flq]YjklgZmad\[YhY[alqljYafaf_[gklk&L`]k][gklk[YfZ]YZkgjZ]\Zql`]k][lgja^Yll`]hjg\m[]jd]n]d$afl`]\]eYf\af_]fnajgfe]flg^Y_]f]jYdd]nqg^+1h]jlgf -('lgf!g^_jaf\]\[g[gYak

mfgj_Yfak]\keYdd`gd\]jk$l`]hjgb][l]\_jgol`jYl]kaehgk]\&L`ak[gmd\_]f]jYl]),(eaddagf]Y[`q]Yj^gjYYj]kaehdqYklgfak`af_&JYaf^gj]kl9ddaYf[]aklYj_]laf_k][lgjoa\]kmklYafYZadalq^mf\&L`][gklkg^l`]d]nq`Yn]

Y_jgol`jYl]g^+0lae]k$Yf\MLR;]jlaÕ]\akhdYffaf_lgZ]ljYfk^]jj]\naYl`]hgkl%hjg[]kkaf_[`Yaflg[gfkme%lg_jgomhlg1+lae]kafl]fq]Yjk&L`]k]_jgol`jYl]k]jk&Oal`Y[g[gY[gfl]flg^YZgml0af[gfkme]jhjg\%

Yf\[geh]lalagfZ]lo]]fklYf\Yj\kZg\a]k[gmd\]f\mh

m[lkl`akogmd\e]YfY[gfkme]jhja[]]^^][lg^d]kkl`YfZ]af_[gmfl]jhjg\m[lan]&AlakhYjYegmfl^gjl`][g[gY*h]jeaddh]j[`g[gdYl]hjg\m[l&;d]Yjdq$l`akhja[]]^^][lak

k][lgjlgkqkl]eYla[Yddqe]Ykmj]l`]Y[`a]n]\kmklYaf%f]_da_aZd]$Yf\l`ak[gmd\Z]YfYhhjghjaYl]kgdmlagflgÕ%YZadalqj]kmdlkYlYddd]n]dkafl`][g[gYnYdm][`Yaf&Kh][aYd

fYf[]l`akeYbgjdgf_l]je]^^gjllgj]klgj]l`]kmhhdqYf\Yll]flagfk`gmd\Z]_an]flgZY[c[dYaekg^aehY[lYll`]

e]]ll`]\]eYf\afl`][g[gYk][lgj&A^l`]k][lgjakYZd]lg

hjg\m[]jd]n]d$lge]Ykmj]j]Ydlae]hjg_j]kkYf\[j]Yl]

Yddg[Yl]$]Y[`q]Yj$YkmZklYflaYdhgjlagfg^l`]),(Eag^gj

k][lgjoa\][j]\aZadalq^gjl`]]^^gjlkg^l`]klYc]`gd\]jk[ggj\afYl]\`a_`d]n]dljYafaf_Y[lanala]k$jmjYdhgn]jlqYf\afngdn]\&Afl`]dgf_l]je$[gfn]j_]f[]g^klYf\Yj\kYl]fnajgfe]flYd\]_jY\Ylagf[YfZ]Y\\j]kk]\]^^][lan]dq&l`]hjg\m[]jd]n]dk]]ekaf]nalYZd]&;dgk]j[ggh]jYlagf

>afYddq$l`][gfkme]joaddYdkghjgÕl3[`g[gdYl]oaddj]eYaf

Z]lo]]fklYf\Yj\kZg\a]koaddaf[j]Yk]l`]]^Õ[a]f[qg^

YfY^^gj\YZd]dmpmjql`Yl[YfZ]]fbgq]\oal`Y[d]Yj[gf%Ydd[gf[]jf]\Yf\ljYfk^gje[g[gYhjg\m[lagfaflgYkmk%

k[a]f[]

lYafYZd]]fl]jhjak]&L`]lj]e]f\gmk[`Ydd]f_]lgj]Y[`8 Sources of information

Information sources for the Figures>a_mj])L`ake]l`g\gdg_q\]n]dgh]\Zq;g]fnYf:]mfaf_]f$@angkYf\Kbg]j\HYf`mqk]f$
L;;oYkhj]k]fl]\^gjhmZda[[gfkmdlYlagf
Yll`]:ag^Y[`*()($afFmj]fZ]j_$?]jeYfq&Alak\]ka_f]\lgYkk]kkYf\[gehYj]l`]hgl]flaYdg^\a^^]j]flklYf\Yj\kkqkl]eklg^Y[adalYl]Yf\hjgegl][gflafmYdaehjgn]e]fllgoYj\kaf[dmkan]f]kkYf\kmklYafYZadalq&L`][gehd]pafl]jj]dYlagfkZ]lo]]fl`]k]log
gZb][lan]kYj]]phdYaf]\Yf\]dYZgjYl]\afl`]ZggcÉAf[dmkan]aehjgn]e]flÊ&L`]Ögo]j
Õ_mj]akZYk]\mhgfl`]klYf\Yj\kkqkl]ek[gehYjakgfeg\]d\]n]dgh]\Yf\mk]\Zql`]
L;;afl`][g^^]]Yf\l]Yk][lgjk&;g]fnYf:]mfaf_]fYf\H]l]jCfgjjaf_Y*((1!&Af[dmkan]aehjgn]e]fl$klYf\Yj\kYf\
keYdd`gd\]jk$lYcaf_klg[cYf\egnaf_gf&L;;
;g^^]]:Yjge]l]j*((1Yf\L]Y:Yjge]l]j*()(&>a_mj]* L`]k[gj]kYj]kgd]dqZYk]\gfl`]klYf\Yj\kdaklkkaf[]l`]q[gfklalml]l`]^gmf\Ylagfgfo`a[`l`]o`gd]klYf\Yj\kkqkl]eakZmadl3j]^]j]f[]\g[me]flk2>DG?]f]ja[>YajljY\]KlYf\Yj\k^gjKeYdd
Hjg\m[]jkÌGj_YfarYlagfk (0%*((1!$>DG>YajljY\]KlYf\Yj\k^gj;g[gY^gjKeYdd
Hjg\m[]jkÌGj_YfarYlagfk (*%*((1!$
K9FKmklYafYZd]9_ja[mdlmj]KlYf\Yj\ (,%*((1!$
MLR;g\]g^;gf\m[l;g[gY^gj?jgmh;]jlaÕ[Ylagf (,%*((1!$=MGj_Yfa[=;0+,'*((/ (.%*((/!$=MGj_Yfa[=;001'*((0 (1%*((0!>a_mj]+;gfkmdlYlagfg^KlYf\Yj\k:g\a]k*()(!

>a_mj],;g[gY]ph]jlk[gfkmdl]\ *()(!
>a_mj];gfkmdlYlagfkoal`klYf\Yj\kZg\a]k *()(!
A;;G *()(!2
LglYdogjd\hjg\m[lagf5+$-1+$(((lgff]kO;> *()(!2
LglYdfmeZ]jg^[g[gY^Yje]jk5-$-(($(((
AAL9 *()(!2
Qa]d\af[j]Yk]l`jgm_`ljYafaf_5*-FmeZ]jg^Y\\alagfYdljYaf]\^Yje]jklg
j]Ydar]l`]*(*(hjgb][lagf^gj[]jlaÕ]\[g[gY5FmeZ]jg^ljYaf]\^Yje]jkf]]\]\lghjg\m[]
l`]*(*(hjgb][lagf%fmeZ]jg^ljYaf]\^Yje]jk[mjj]fldqYnYadYZd]FmeZ]jg^ljYaf]\^Yje]jkf]]\]\lghjg\m[]
l`]*(*(hjgb][lagf^gj[]jlaÕ]\[g[gY5
Hjgb][l]\[]jlaÕ]\hjg\m[lagfaf*(*('9n]jY_]hjg\m[lagfh]jljYaf]\^Yje]j&
FmeZ]jg^ljYaf]\^Yje]jk[mjj]fldqYnYadYZd]
5;mjj]fl[]jlaÕ]\hjg\m[lagf'9n]jY_]
hjg\m[lagfh]jljYaf]\^Yje]j&9n]jY_]hjg\m[lagfh]jljYaf]\^Yje]j5
Ogjd\hjg\m[lagf'Fg&g^[g[gY^Yje]jk
ogjd\oa\]!pqa]d\af[j]Yk]ZqljYafaf_]klaeYl]\Yl*-!&L`]j]^gj]$Yn]jY_]hjg\m[lagfh]jljYaf]\^Yje]j5 +$-1+$((('-$-(($(((!p)&*-p)(((50)/c_&>a_mj]. ;gfkmdlYlagfg^[`g[gdYl]
eYfm^Y[lmj]jk *()(!
>a_mj]/;gfkmdlYlagf$ZqoYqg^Yim]klagffYaj]$oal`Õn]eYbgj_jaf\]jkYf\

21[`g[gdYl]eYfm^Y[lmj]jk&
L`]im]klagffYaj]oYkj]lmjf]\ZqCjY^l$EYjk$
F]kld]$@]jk`]qÌk$>]jj]jg$:Yjjq;Ydd]ZYml$
9<E$;Yj_addYf\H]ljY>gg\k3gfdq:dgee]j\a\fglj]khgf\&
9kl`]\YlYkmZeall]\afl`]j]khgfk]ko]j]
fgl]Ykadq[gehYjYZd]$Yf\[j]\aZadalqakkm]k
Yjgk]j]_Yj\af_l`]j]kmdle]Ykmj]e]fl
hjg_jYekmk]\$l`ak[Yd[mdYlagfhjgna\]kgfdq
Y[gYjk]]klaeYlagfg^l`][mjj]flkalmYlagf&9kh]jO;> *()(!$l`]lglYdfmeZ]jg^[g[gY^Yje]jkogjd\oa\]5-$-(($(((=klaeYlagfg^l`]fmeZ]jg^^Yje]jk
ljYaf]\l`jgm_`\a^^]j]flafalaYlan]k Ykh]jim]klagffYaj]j]khgfk]k!Yj]Yk^gddgok2;gehYfqafalaYlan]k-eYbgj_jaf\]jkYf\eYfm^Y[lmj]jk!2 +--$..(
K][lgjafalaYlan]k2
)*-$1-1?gn]jfe]fl]pl]fkagfk]jna[]k2
1.$+*,"
FmeZ]jg^ljYaf]\^Yje]jk
[mjj]fldqYnYadYZd]2-//$1,+"FmeZ]jljYaf]\Zq?gn]jfe]flafalaYlan]koYkYkkme]\Yl*(g^l`]fmeZ]jg^^Yje]jk
ljYaf]\naY[gehYfqYf\k][lgjafalaYlan]k&;gklg^ljYafaf_50( )((!h]j^Yje]jaf>Yje]j%Õ]d\K[`ggdk Ykh]j;g[gY]ph]jlk
[gfkmdl]\!
Afn]kle]flf]]\]\lg`Yn]Yddl`][g[gY
keYdd`gd\af_kogjd\oa\]jmfZqljYaf]\^Yje]jk5 LglYdfmeZ]jg^[g[gY^Yje]jkÇfmeZ]jg^[mjj]fldqYnYadYZd]ljYaf]\^Yje]jk!
p;gklg^ljYafaf_
5 -$-(($(((%-//$1,(!p0(5+1+$/.,$0((

8 Sources of information

Footnotes
22
)
*
+
,
-

.

/
0
1

)(
))
)*
)+

),
)-

).
)/
)0

O;>]klaeYl]g^-&-Eagakmk]\afl`ak:Yjge]l]j&
A;;G *()(!2 ÉA;;GImYjl]jdq:mdd]lafg^;g[gYKlYlakla[k$Ngd&
PPPNA$Fg&*$;g[gYq]Yj*((1'*()(ÌÌA;;G *()(!2 ÉA;;GImYjl]jdq:mdd]lafg^;g[gYKlYlakla[k$Ngd&
PPPNA$Fg&*$;g[gYq]Yj*((1'*()(ÌÌA;;G *()(!2 L`]Ogjd\;g[gY=[gfgeq$HYklYf\Hj]k]fl:Yk]\gf2 Ljgha[Yd;geeg\alq;gYdalagf *((1!2ËË;g[gY:Yjge]l]j*((1ÊA;;G *()(!2 ÉA;;GImYjl]jdq:mdd]lafg^;g[gYKlYlakla[k$Ngd&
PPPNA$Fg&*$;g[gYq]Yj*((1'*()(ÊH9;LKHj]kkJ]d]Yk] (-%*()(!2ÉAfl]jfYlagfYd^Yeadq[gfljgdd]\
Zmkaf]kk]kmfal]lg^gjeYf]l`a[Yd$imYdalq[g[gYhjg\m[lagf
YddaYf[]afAngjq;gYklÊ
F]kld  hj]k]flYlagf! *()(!2É;`g[gdYl]hj]k]flYlagfÊ kgmj[]2=mjgegfalgj *()(!
CjY^l hj]k]flYlagf! *()(!2 ÉCjY^l>gg\kKljYl]_a[<][akagfk;gf^]j]f[]ÊGp^YeO]j]d\Oafc]dk afhjafl*()(!2 ÉL`]:]d_aYf[`g[gdYl]k][lgj3Jgd]Yf\AehgjlYf[]g^:]d_ameafl`][g[gYYf\[`g[gdYl][`YafÊ`llh2''ooo&agYk&gj_'K9F&`le;gfkmdlYlagfg^KlYf\Yj\k:g\a]k *()(!
;gfkmdlYlagfg^KlYf\Yj\k:g\a]k *()(!
;mjj]flfmeZ]jg^^Yje]jkh]jklYf\Yj\kZg\q5lglYd[]jlaÕ]\hjg\m[lagfh]jklYf\Yj\kZg\q'Yn]jY_]hjg\m[lagfh]j
ljYaf]\^Yje]j af[dm\af_*-hjg\m[lagfaf[j]Yk]!
9<E *()(!2ÉGmj;geeale]fllgKmklYafYZd];g[gYÊKgmj[]Ljmkl *()(!2`llh2''ooo&kgmj[]ljmkl&gj_'_
É9h`qka[YdYm\alg^Kgmj[]LjmklÌkgfl`]_jgmf\gh]jYlagfoYk
j][]fldq[gf\m[l]\Zq>Yaj>gg\kZmll`]ajÕf\af_kYf\l`]ajj]hgjlYj]fglYnYadYZd]$Ykq]l&Ê Af^gjeYlagf^jge9jeYbYjg
gf*'1'*()(!
Jgk]fZ]j_$<&]lYd A<@ *()(!2ÉLjY\]jkYkY_]flg^
kmklYafYZadalqaf[g^^]]Yf\[g[gYkmhhdq[`YafkÌÌ
<a[c\]?jYY^ >FN!2Hj]k]flYlagfYll`]*f\Jgmf\LYZd]^gjY
kmklYafYZd];g[gY=[gfgeqafLjafa\Y\JYaf^gj]klYddaYf[]Hj]kkj]d]Yk] )(%*((1!2 ÉEYbgj=mjgh]Yf
CjY^l;`g[gdYl]:jYf\k=eZjY[]JYaf^gj]kl9ddaYf[]
[]jlaÕ[YlagfÊ

)1
*(
*)
**
*+
*,
*-

*.
*/
*0
*1

;Y\Zmjq *()(!2`llh2''ooo&[Y\Zmjq&[ge'gmjj]khgfkaZadala]k'^YajljY\]'HY_]k'^YajljY\]&Ykhp?j]]f:dY[cÌk *()(! `llh2''ooo&_j]]fYf\ZdY[ck&[ge';gfkmdlYlagfg^[`g[gdYl]eYfm^Y[lmj]jk *()(!
?YdYpq;`g[gdYl] *()(!2`llh2''ooo&_YdYpq[`g[gdYl]&[g&mc'cA<@ *()(!2 ÉKmklYafYZd];g[gY^gjl`]<ml[`EYjc]lÇ9fYdqkak
g^l`]<ml[`[g[gYk][lgjÊF]kld MC *()(!2 `llh2''ooo&F]kld &[g&mc'@ge]'>YajljY\]@]jk`]qÌkHj]kJ]d]Yk] (.%*((/!2 ÉKlYjZm[ck;g^^]];gehYfqÌk?dgZYd;gfkme]jHjg\m[lk?jgmhYf\L`]@]jk`]qÌk;gehYfq
9ffgmf[]9_j]]e]fllgDYmf[`Hj]eame;`g[gdYl]HdYl^gjeÊ>]jj]jg *()(!2 É;g[gYHgkalagfHYh]jÊ
;gfkmdlYlagfg^;`g[gdYl]EYfm^Y[lmj]jk *()(!$>a_mj]ogjd\oa\]Z][Ymk]Yegj]Y__j]_Yl]\ha[lmj]oYkfgl
hgkkaZd]\m]lg\a^^]j]fl^gjeYlkg^\YlY^jgeaf\mkljq&
A;;G *()(!2ËÌL`]Ogjd\;g[gY=[gfgeq$HYklYf\Hj]k]flÊ

Other sources
L;; *((0!2 :j]Ycaf_l`]na[agmk[aj[d]afl`][g[gYk][lgjZqk[Ydaf_mhl`][g[gYkeYdd`gd\]jk
L;; *((0!2 Ko]]lf]kk^gddgok$*f\]\alagf
L;; *((1!2 ;g[gY:Yjge]l]j*((1L;; *()(!2 L]Y:Yjge]l]j*()(L;; *()(! ;g^^]]:Yjge]l]j*()(A<@ *()(!2 KmklYafYZd];g[gY^gjl`]<ml[`EYjc]lÇ
9fYdqkakg^l`]<ml[`[g[gYk][lgjAbbreviations

Colophon

9<E
;KG
=;
=;@G=K;alYlagf2 O]ada_eYff$:&$N]jZjYYc$?&Yf\NYfJ]]f]f$E& *()(!2
;g[gY:Yjge]l]j*()($Ljgha[Yd;geeg\alq;gYdalgf
L]pl2 L;;2:jZ]dO]ada_eYff$?abkN]jZjYYc$Ea]c]nYfJ]]f]fYf\
HjYcjml`a2Kbg]j\HYf`mqk]f&<]ka_fYf\_jYh`k2 L]_]foaf\$Jg]dYflE]ab]j$Mlj][`l
Hjafl2 <jmcc]jabEgkl]jlnYfGf\]j]f$D]a\]f
K]hl]eZ]j*()(

23

=M
>DG
>FN
@9;;H
A;;G
A<@
AAL9
ADG
AKG
AKK
F;J;
F?G
H9;LK
JK;=
K9F
K=J9H
KL;H
L;;
O;>

9j[`]j<Yfa]dkEa\dYf\;anadKg[a]lqGj_YfarYlagf=mjgh]Yf;geeakkagf=ehgo]jaf_;g[gY@gmk]`gd\koal`Ghhgjlmfala]k
Yf\=\m[YlagfKgdmlagfk9ddaYf[]=mjgh]YfMfagf>YajljY\]DYZ]ddaf_Gj_YfarYlagf>]\]jYla]F]\]jdYf\k]NYcZ]o]_af_@YrYj\9fYdqkakYf\;jala[Yd;gfljgdHgaflk
Afl]jfYlagfYd;g[gYGj_YfarYlagf
AfalaYla]^<mmjrYe]@Yf\]dAfl]jfYlagfYdAfklalml]g^Ljgha[Yd9_ja[mdlmj]
Afl]jfYlagfYdDYZgmjGj_YfarYlagf
Afl]jfYlagfYdGj_YfarYlagf^gjKlYf\Yj\arYlagf
Afl]jfYlagfYdAfklalml]g^Kg[aYdKlm\a]kg^=jYkemk
Mfan]jkalq$Jgll]j\Ye
FYlmj];gfk]jnYlagfJ]k]Yj[`;]flj] ?`YfY!
Fgf?gn]jfe]flYdGj_YfarYlagf
Hjg[]kkgjk9ddaYf[]^gj;g[gYLjY[]YZadalqYf\KmklYafYZadalq
Jgmf\lYZd]^gjYKmklYafYZd];g[gY=[gfgeq
KmklYafYZd]9_ja[mdlmj]F]logjc
Kg[aYddqYf\=fnajgfe]flYddqJ]khgfkaZd]
9_ja[mdlmjYdHjY[la[]khjg_jYe
KmklYafYZd]Lj]];jghHjg_jYe
Ljgha[Yd;geeg\alq;gYdalagf
Ogjd\;g[gY>gmf\Ylagf

ParticipantsO]Yhhj][aYl]l`]nYdmYZd]afhmlkg^EYjk$CjY^l$F]kld]$@]jk`]qÌk$>]jj]jg$;Yj_add$9<E$:Yjjq;Ydd]ZYml$H]ljY>gg\k$>DG$MLR
;]jlaÕ]\Yf\JYaf^gj]kl9ddaYf[]Yf\O;>&O]]kh][aYddql`Yfc
H]l]jnYf?jafkn]f^gjYkkaklaf_L;;lg\]n]dghl`]im]klagffYaj]&
L`]ÕfYdj]khgfkaZadalq^gjl`][gfl]flYf\l`]na]ok]phj]kk]\afl`akhmZda[Ylagfda]kkgd]dqoal`l`]Yml`gjk&

Tropical Commodity Coalition
for sustainable Tea Coffee Cocoa
24

Ljgha[Yd;geeg\alq;gYdalagf L;;![gehjak]kl]f
fgf%_gn]jfe]flYdgj_YfarYlagfk2@angk$Gp^YeFgnaZ$
Kgda\Yja\Y\$Gacgk$Kgeg$>Yaj^gg\$Af\aY;geeall]]g^l`]F]l`]jdYf\k$:gl`=f\k$?g]\]OYYj;g$Yf\Klgh
l`]LjY^Õc3Yf\logljY\]mfagfk$>FN:gf\_]fgl]fYf\;FN:]\jabn]f:gf\&L;;[ggh]jYl]koal`F?GkYf\ljY\]
mfagfkaf[g^^]]$l]YYf\[g[gYhjg\m[af_[gmflja]klgaehjgn]l`]kg[aYd$]fnajgfe]flYdYf\][gfgea[[gf\alagfkYll`]Z]_affaf_g^l`][g^^]]$l]YYf\[g[gYnYdm][`Yafk&
L;;Y\\j]kk]kl`]kg[aYd$]fnajgfe]flYdYf\][gfgea[[gf\alagfkafl`][g^^]]$l]YYf\[g[gY[`Yafkl`jgm_`
gj_Yfaraf_af^gje]\\ak[mkkagfk$afZgl`l`]Kgml`Yf\l`]Fgjl`&L`]L;;]fkmj]k[ggj\afYlagfg^l`]e]eZ]jkÌY[lanala]ko`]j]f]]\]\$[gehad]kd]kkgfkd]YjflYf\hjgegl]kl`]afl]j[`Yf_]g^kljYl]_a]klgZmad\k`Yj]\mf\]jklYf\af_Yf\YhhjgY[`]klgkmklYafYZadalqafl`]k]
[geeg\ala]k&L;;k`Yj]kalkcfgod]\_]Yf\afÖm]f[]khgda[a]kYf\hdYfkg^[gehYfa]k$klYf\Yj\kZg\a]k$
;KJafalaYlan]k$_gn]jfe]flk$F?GkYf\mfagfklg
\]n]dghYf\aehd]e]flkmklYafYZd]hjY[la[]k]^Õ[a]fldq
l`jgm_`gmll`][g^^]]$l]YYf\[g[gY[`Yafk&L;;[j]Yl]k
Yf]fYZdaf_]fnajgfe]fl^gj[anadkg[a]lqklYc]`gd\]jk^jgehjg\m[af_[gmflja]klgbgafYf\lYc]YfY[lan]hYjl
afl`]kmklYafYZd][geeg\alq\]ZYl]&

JYYeo]_).
H&G&:gp0--.*-(0;?L`]@Y_m]
L]d#+)%/(%+/.--((
ooo&l]Y[g^^]][g[gY&gj_