RUSSIA NUCLEAR DATA CENTER - RNDC
Alias: CENTR JADERNYKH DANNYKH - CJD
Institute of Physics and Power Engineering - IPPE
Bondarenko Sq., 1,Obninsk 249033
Kaluga Region, RUSSIA
Telephone:+7 (48439)98779 (M.Mikhaylyukova)
Fax:+7 (48439)68225
Internet:
www.ippe.ru/podr/cjd

MEMO 4C-4/189
DATE:
TO:
From:
Subject:

17 May 2011
Distribution
M.Mikhaylyukova
Comments of CHEX, for NRDC2011

Comments of CHEX
A. These my comments were already considered and proper corrections were done in CHEX:
1) I,M in REL-REF.
2) Limits of uncertainties.
3) "3" in MONIT-REF for evaluated libraries.
____________________________________________

B. Recent comments proposed for consideration:
1)Entry 41375.002:** Illegal code infield 4
REACTION 1(50-SN-116(N,G)50-SN-117,,MLT,,RES) Average** Illegal code infield 4
REACTION 1(50-SN-116(N,G)50-SN-117-M,,MLT,,RES) Average

41375002

41375002

Comment:
When I added SN-117 in SF4 according to Naohiko's comment, CHEX gives these messages.
Probably, for CHEX this is resonance parameter and SF4 has to be empty for res. par.?
Naohiko insisted that SF4 is not empty.

2) Entry 23103** Nonmonatonic data field
1.675
0.00.25

E-LVL-INI
0.0323103010

Comment:
Really, I decided this problem: split this Subent into two Subents.
But this message of CHEX :Nonmonatonic data field
E-LVL-INI
looks very strange, because they are monotonic...
Also Nonmonatonic -> Nonmonotonic (a -> o)?

3)

ENTRY 41191** Illegal floating point number** Illegal data field
41191002
ERR-ANALYS (DATA-ERR,3.,10.) Not specified, probably total.
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ENTRY 41290** Illegal floating point number** Illegal data field
41290002
ERR-ANALYS (DATA-ERR,1.,30.) Total error, mainly due to^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

Comment:
These two messages of CHEX are not understandable for me.

4)

ENTRY 41427** Check use of heading

TEMP

41427002** Check use of heading

TEMP41427003

Comment:
These messages are not understandable, because in Subents:
REACTION(92-U-235(N,G)92-U-236,,SIF/TMP,,AV)
Self-indication 41427
function in capture cross-section of U-235,
41427TEMP- sample temperature.
41427

222345EN-MIN
EV

41427
41427
41427

222121314(92-U-235(N,F),,SIF/TMP,,AV)
Self-indication
function in fission cross-section of U-235,
TEMP- sample temperature.

41427
41427
41427

333345EN-MIN
EV

41427
41427
41427

33312131441427
41427

441213...
EN-MAX
EV
4.65
REACTION.....
EN-MAX
EV

TEMP
K
2.15

4.65

DATA
NO-DIM
100.

TEMP
K
2.15

DATA
NO-DIM
100.

DATA-ERR
NO-DIM
0.38
0.01

DATA-ERR
NO-DIM
0.50
0.015)ENTRY 41427** Incorrect units, should be dimension

THK in field 341427004

In Subent:
EN-MINEV

EN-MAXEV

THICKNESSMMDATA
NO-DIM

DATA-ERR
NO-DIM

Comment:
Sometimes thickness of sample is given in units like millimetresand corresponding values in atoms/barn units are not given in an article.
Probably, “MM” unit could be added in dictionaries as the unit for thickness.

6)
ENTRY 41507

** Incorrect units, should be dimension

YLD in field 341507003

Comment:
In Subent:
E-MIN
MEV

E-MAX
MEV

DATA-MAX
PRT/FIS

41507
41507

This message of CHEX is not understandable, because PRT/FIS is the unit for yield.

331415

Distribution list:
blokhin@ippe.ru,
chiba@earth.sgu.ac.jp,
claes.nordborg@oecd.org,
emmeric.dupont@oecd.org,
exfor@nea.fr,
ganesan@barc.gov.in,
gezg@ciae.ac.cn,
hongwei@ciae.ac.cn,
jhchang@kaeri.re.kr,
j.roberts@iaea.org,
kaltchenko@kinr.kiev.ua,
katakura.junichi@jaea.go.jp,
kato@nucl.sci.hokudai.ac.jp,
kiralyb@atomki.hu,
l.vrapcenjak@iaea.org,
manuel.bossant@oecd.org,
manokhin@ippe.ru,
mmarina@ippe.ru,
mwherman@bnl.gov,
nklimova@kinr.kiev.ua,
nicolas.soppera@oecd.org,
n.otsuka@iaea.org,
ogritzay@kinr.kiev.ua,
otto.schwerer@aon.at,oblozinsky@bnl.gov,
pronyaev@ippe.ru,
r.forrest@iaea.org,
samaev@obninsk.ru,
sbabykina@yandex.ru,
scyang@kaeri.re.kr,
V.Semkova@iaea.org

stakacs@atomki.hu,
stanislav.hlavac@savba.sk,
taova@expd.vniief.ru,
tarkanyi@atomki.hu,
varlamov@depni.sinp.msu.ru,
vlasov@kinr.kiev.ua,
vmclane@optonline.net,
v.zerkin@iaea.org,
yolee@kaeri.re.kr