土木学会論文集F4（建設マネジメント）, Vol. 68, No. 3, 193-210, 2012.

!"#$%&'#()*+,-+./+01$23'45!"! #$1
1%&'! ()*+,-! ./-012223-8522 3456789:3-14-1;

E-mail: yoneda@sd.keio.ac.jp<=>?@ABCDEFGHI?JKLMNEBO?PQI=ERISTILUVWXYZ=[X\]^_DE@AB?PQI?RISTIUVL`aXbcdefghijklEUVhmnWXop?qr
shtuWXvdhwxdWX\yzO{DERILUVloPQ&|?_}yzS~•€•‚yzET
ILUVhpƒWPQ&|?„~…•†yzS~•€•‚yzC[X\‡?ˆ‰ERISTIUVL`jŠDEPQI?‹Œ•Ž••h‘’Wefg=“”•X–??EHIg?—˜E‹Œ•™š›š?œ•E
žŸ?y EIœ¡1I¢£?œ¡;?¤¥EUVL¦§X¨©Lª«¬bc=[Xvd=§’NE‡?
qrshtulo\

Key Words: under populated areas, reduction of public works, local construction industry,! ! ! ! ! ! new business, agriculture, forestry

1.! 678$@A?næBçCDEFGHI?JKLMNEBO?
PQ&|=6?78LnkWXYZ=[X\nk9DR<=>?PQ-žDE1990 ®¯°’”E±²³´LµTIE:;HIE<=¬1ô>L§oX=E]?@CD¶FGHI?·J•|&¸¹?º»´LMN¼½?¾¿

RI`MATILBwWX\RT/CÄÅ2005 ®RTI

LVÀo\>ÁÂÃÄÅ2007 ®PQ-ž“ÃlÆLMX

D•EFÆLMXdERIÜIÝGD 2000 ®? 389 ÚÝ

dEPQ-žDÇ•ÈÉ? 1992 ®©?Ê 84 ËÌ’”E’” 2005 ®? 335 ÚÝÛ 14HJKl60 IJK= 69Hh

2007 ®©LDÇ•ÈÉ?Ê 6 Í?Ê 52 ËÌLÎCJK

LpŠjX\1990 ®’” 2005 ®ÎCLERICDMN

lo\PQ-ž?ÏE²Ð-žDÇ•ÈÉ? 1995 ®©

OPB= 21.7 Ú ha ’” 38.6 Ú ha LñQlERSTUV?Ê 35 ËÌ’” 2007 ®©LDÊ 5 Í?Ê 17 ËÌLJK

1WUXY;= 48H’” 40HLJKWXdj¶Zj[lo\ÑOE>ÁÂÃÄÅ2007 ®ÒeIÓÔyÕÆdÖ

\]LMX^c=‘_ŠjX\Ö×ÄÅ`º 17 ®>a×ÄÅ2007 ®ØÙ•yzÆLMXdEPQI?ÒeIÓ

yzÆLMXdETIÜIÓD 2000 ®? 6.7 ÚÝ’”ÔDÇ•ÈÉ? 1999 ®©? 60 Ú’” 2006 ®©? 52 Ú2005 ®? 4.6 ÚÝÛ 31HJKl 65 IJK= 26HhLp

ÛEÜIÓDÇ•ÈÉ? 1997 ®©? 685 ÚÝ= 2007 ®

ŠjX\TICDbT?-.=nÎcE+dTUVD©? 552 ÚÝdÊ 2 Í?JKLWÞ¬j\PQ-ž?,1990 ®’” 2005 ®ÎCL 26H’” 20HLJKWXdj

ß¬JKLàÕ•áEÜIÓDâã?äå=[X\¶Zj[\]LMX^c=‘_ŠjX\PQI?RIS! @A?næBçDFGHILèéWXÍê=ëìEBTIUVLBwWX?DEPQIDZj[=âã?äå

O?PQ&|?íîDïlðhñlŠjX\l’lEò

C[X?LqlŠERISTIDZj[\]?äåL[ó=ôj<=>CDEõÁLöljPQ&|=÷BçL

X’”C[X\øNE9ùxL|&¸¹húûü.WXýþ=[X\FPQIL¦§Xef?_}DJgLhW_}L¯ið

GHIL¯§Xÿ!"kdBç?õÁh#XP
Q&|?

•XM¶LÔôj\jkD 1963 ®Ll9]?PQIm1)

é$=bcL¬ÀŠjX\¬`E]^_L`jŠÅFG

hknlEPQI?5oE/Hpq?rsEíîtuv

HIÆDE%&²Ð•BOFG'(=)*WXÁ+SP LwjŠE‡?x(yhz”’LlEI{|}•I¡œ,/HhðW–?dlEv•LDERB?-.•RI/

L`aXbcLwjŠ~ÕŠjX\•€D 1993 ®Lk

0?úû¬1?RIÁ+E23HI•T4-.¬1?T

nlolPQIh•loÝ«m2)• 2005 ®L)ilo

IÁ+–5Î•X–?dWX\l§=>PQI?º‚d)ƒL¦WX?@„z2…MN193

土木学会論文集F4（建設マネジメント）, Vol. 68, No. 3, 193-210, 2012.

†‡ˆ‰…m3)L`jŠEÁ+P,pqI?Š¯?‹Œ

WBOPQIdbTtê?Þß&1 '(dTIS+dC

h?@lEz2 20 ®¯?Á+P,pqI’”Eˆ‰?

I? 5 |L„~…•†yzhÕjEbcdefghÜkPQI?º‚ÎCEPQ&|?)ƒL•Žh`Z¬=”E WX\v?„~…•†ˆ‰höàLáâWXopLEÞ
P,•Ý|&?•‘EÁ+ØÙÓ?’ºÎC?@“hßß&LãWXPQ&|40 |LqlŠ~•€•‚yzh”ì^_ŠjX\Ÿ]”D 1999 ®Lknlol9]?

Õ¶\yzÉ×D 2008 ® 12 ÝC[X\v•”?RIU

PQCIm4)L`jŠEFG/H?)*•F–—EPQ

VyzdTIUVyz?ˆ‰h–dLEbch-.lŠ

ØÙ?|}d˜™EPQE•šF?›F‚dœ•¬1
E

UVhmnWXop?qrshtuWX\

PQI?žrh7ŸlEI{?

xghëpXopLE

2.! )*+,-+01,9:¡¢£h?¤þg¬1h^_ŠjX\PQIL¦WX?
@=ôj¬’CEPQI?¥78nkL¦WX?@DE
2002 ®©?FGHI¦? 1 Í·Jh§ŽL¨ÎÀodv

(1) -+01 40 ;<,=>9:©C[NE_}?ÔDK¬j\! PQI?RIUVL`aXefghijklEÑäx

! PQI?¥78nkL¦§X_}dlŠD
E2002 ®L¬bchtuWXopL_}yzhÕÀo\E¥åæç¬1?÷¢?
PQIª•¸Ÿ=)ilol%½PQI?¥78S¥5 ! BOT2(=NºloH¼½5)=[o£«?op?¬I-®L¦WX¯°±²°•m

FižS’”#N•o120 ?RIUVH¼hE2003 ®’X\o³lEv•DPQI?´µHIÛ?nkhmW–” 2006 ®?èL!"”=x>hyzl
ElPQI?¥?CE¶I¢Û?nkÎCD^_Šj¬j\PQI?¶

11)!
l¥78LêˆW
78nkm6) lPQéR?WWpm

I¢?nkL¦lŠDE!"= 2003 ®LknlolP

XPQI„YZ³lo 450 |m12)lPQI’”D_ÎX

QI?¥78nkm6)=[X\2003 ®J·E7¸4E¹BçšëìFm13)lí 4 îPQ‚ïð²•ñ•òó•²º»¬1?BOT2(LMNH¼½=Nºð•E!"”—m14;Lôõlo\120 ?¶öCERIUVL`aX’

LMN¾¿•yz¢À¾=Nºð•o\÷EefgEbcLwjŠøõhloH¼D401¤ù! Š®?YZdlŠDEÁÂ=E2007 ®L^_l¬I?

húì;C[X\v? 40 H¼h-.lŠE7ŸhÕÀ

7)

RIUV?ž¯xÃ*dbcm hE2007 ®LRIíîo\-&ClBç%½PQI?RIUVL[oÀŠ?¬IÃ ! ?-1 LE40 H¼?ûtüýþEþÿBEUV’÷EÄdbcm8)h)ilEPQI?RIUVL`aXÅÆ

efgEUt_}?!"dôõ#hhW\40 H¼DEg•ÿ!L¦§XíîK?bch^_ŠjX\Á+-&•L@ABLéÿWXBO%½PQ&|C[N
E$I'CDEÇÈSÉ= 2006 ®LlÊ{LèéWXRË‘C

Ô%’”&'%Ež]Ÿ 100 Ú’”Ô(ÚÌE)Kë=9)

dPQI?ôÌ´ˆÍm dlŠE•LRSTUVdR

Ô(Ú’”Ô*+Ì?,-C[NE•LBOFG'()IÛ?ôÌ´LwjŠ^_E9]íîÎÏ-&CDE,*?Á+/Hh.*WX¬IC[X\Ð= 2010 ®Ll%½PQI?ôÌ´ˆÍL`aXôÌa) -+01,@A10)´©díîrs?¦Ñm CEôÌ´lo¬IhqÒL

! ¬I=RILUVWXoê
ERB{LMNERB?û

ÓÆ•ÅÔL¦§Xíî7ŸhÕÀŠjX
\v?M¶L•L¦§X¨/=[X\v•Dˆ‰?RB01CERBRIUVhqÒdlo?@^_D[X=ETIUVhq?þ2DTNR3L/4ð•oopLQa”•o\2000Òdlo?@^_D“”•¬j\®?RI‘C{Ý?þ56‡•
E2005 ®?˜4{Ý78HI¬1LMNE/48ZC¬I=RBh9!CZXM]?@DE@A?næBçL`aXPQI?RISTIUVLÖ×h[ŠEbcdefghijklEUVh¶L¬Ào=EžrC–¨Ê=ôj\

mnWXop?qrshtuWXvdhwxLWX\v! 40 H¼?RIUV?’÷hyÕE?-2 LhW 3 w?U•ÎC?RIUV??@^_CDE•LíîL`aXb

V’÷L-.lo\÷H¼?UV’÷D?-1 ? 4 :w;

c=^Ø”•ŠZo=E]^_CDEv•”?bcLQ’÷<Lhlo\ÙE¨©•I¢?¤¥L`aXbc–qÒdlŠEH¼! =L 3 w?UV’÷?˜>LwjŠ~ÕX
\! ! !

h–dLÚÛxLtuhnpX\! (1)?ÅR?¬IdlŠUVÆD
ERNI.@dAQB?@?O{DE_}yzE„~…•†yzE~•€•

CC[X\RNI.@DENI?üÕ¶opERBhþ

‚yzLMX\PQI?RIUVCDERIUVloP

2WXýþ=¬j\RB{?,4LDEFcLER?¬

Q&| 40 H¼h_}yzWXdGL
E31 |L~•€•

IC–Õ¶vd=CZX\AQBCDE–•l•GHE‚yzhÕjEbcdefghÜkWX\yzÉ×DIÞ•‚J‚?/MBC
EKLEKM¬1ENRBCO

2007 ® 2 ÝC[X\PQI?TIUVCDEPQ&|?

}IxLAQCBCCZX–?C[X\

TIUV=¨ÎÀodv©C[XopETIUVhpƒ

(2)?ÅP&|CRI‘C{ÝhQ‚ÆDRBhQÀo
! ! ! ! !

194

土木学会論文集F4（建設マネジメント）, Vol. 68, No. 3, 193-210, 2012.
?-2! PQ&|?RIUV 3 w?’÷?-1! PQ&|?RIUV 40 H¼;<!

-+01,BCDEF!

GH!

01
@A!

IJK!

0L=>!

RS!

01,@A!

;+TU!

;<V!

(1)

-Wô+g§X01!

-`+ab! !

Mm ;<!

Y*z{!

M! NO-+PQRST8U3!

VWX!

(1)

E.G.H.

7) P72-73

Y! Z[\]^_,-`+Tab!

VWX!

(1)

E.

7) P70-71

c! RQdTefg3'-+hidjklQ!

VWX!

(1)

E.G.

7) P74-75

m! -`+nopqrs,ab+t!

VWX!

(1)

E.G.H.

13) P50-51

u! vwxy,z{\|}!

~•€!

(1)

B.H.

13) P58-59!

•! ‚ƒ,Z„z{!

~•€!

(1)

B.H.

14) P14-16

RIíîC[X\RI‘C{ÝDÅR3h•(dWX{…! 7†‡ˆ‰,z{g|}!

VWX!

(1)

B.H.

7) P84-85

ÝÆC[NER'?SÔJK=RNI$HÓ
ER?Ó’Š! P‹ŒQk•,Ž•g•Sdji‘’!

VWX!

(1)

H.

7) P86-87”?kžêT= 4 7? 1 JgE)NKU?S7JK=R“! ”•–,—˜$™'š›œ•,žŸ|}!

¡€!

(1)

A.

14) P185-187

I`MARI¦-HI?ÅVdj¶þ5=[X
\¬I?

¬@€!

(1)

F.H.

13) P56-57

íîÓ=VÝdlŠRBhû•lRI‘C{ÝhQ‚W

M£¤¥¦TŽ•§\¨©.ª«|}!

(2)

Z[\D-+èé]ñT* -#T"˜§À-+!

YY ;<!

^§X01!

(3)

B_]ñ$™'-+01!

`ab#Tc§À-#± m ;<!
QS$™'-+!

M¢! -Q®\®¯Q°±Q\²³,´µz{!
¶¬€! (1)
B.F.
7) P78-79
Xoê=[X\RI‘C{ÝDERB?WVSXY=e
M!
M )*·¸,¹º»¼$™'±P½k¯!
¾²€! (1)
A.C.
13) P80-81
fC[NERIÓåa?¨©Zž•[\Ÿ?qÒd¬X\Y!
M ¿ª±P½k¯§À¹Á»¼ÂÃ,ÄÅ|}! ÆB€! (1)A.C.
13) 74-75! (3)?Å˜4{ÝLMXRIUVÆD
E5]^=ÅMN
c!
M £¤¥¦TŽ•.|}\ÇÈoÉ,Ê’! ËÌ€! (1)F.H.
7) P88-89
OP?ôjBçE_‰ôì¬N‡¶¬BçÆhqÒBdm!
M ‚ÍÎÏ²³,Ð-Ñz{!
VWX! (2)
A.F.
12) P105-109
lŠ4poKCER3’”RBh½pŠE¬IdÞ4hu!
M š›-+$™'ÒÓ¤Ôz{!
VWX! (2)
A.C.D.E.F.H. 7) P68-69
ˆ`C7lkWOaC[X\˜4{Ý?oêE4 |% 3•!
M ÕÖ×z{gØ½iÙŸ!
VWX! (2)|DEMNOPB=7lkð•Xdd–L
ET2(?Ô
H.
7) P82-83…!
M Ú-Ñ-Q®z{gžÛžŸ.|}!
VWX! (2)bh.aŠjo\B.
13) P46-47
Š!
M ‚ÍÎÜ-Ý,Þß!
b) -+01$%&'IJK
VWX! (2)E.
13) P48-49“!
Y! RIUV 40 H¼?_}’”ERIUVL`aXef¡àÔáâãk,Ž•!
¡€! (2)
14) P117-119¢!
Y ‚ÍÎÜ-+gš›œ•\äåæç,èé!
gd˜>hÜklodv©E94 ?cw=[U”•o\¡€! (2)
A.C.E.H.
13) P64-65
M!
Y š›œ•$™'-ê,‹ji¤Ô½ë!
˜>DefgLw¬=Xop
EefgdlŠÎdpŠø
ìí€! (2)A.C.H.
13) P52-53
Y!
~WXvdLlo\v•”?cwLDGÃWX–?=ô
Y vîz{gš›-+$™'[`!
ïÌ€! (2)A.
14) P23-25c!
ìEGÃWX–?hÎdpŠE?-3 ?ÅA.ÁdL¤×ÆY ðñ,ò`ó,ô+õÄ!
ïÌ€! (2)
A.I.
14) P26-29m!
ÅB.eRfBCÆÅC.g:h?ÁdiìNÆÅD.øjk
Y ‚ö›÷T—˜§ø`#Tùú-`+ab!
¬@€! (2)
E.G.I.
13) P54-55
u!
lLMXm‹ÆÅE.RI?Ž•´ÆÅF.PQŽ•LMXY ûüýþÿ!T"˜§Àji#,z{!
¬@€! (2)C.
15) P126-P128•!
¸¹-.ÆÅG./“ü.?nVÆÅH.¬IhRI?ƒ
Y š›œ•$™'²³z{!
$%€! (2)
A.B.
14) P147-150…!
£ÆÅI.RIdPQI?-®Æ? 9 ?cwL-.lo\Y Ú-Ñd&dz{\'(ö-+8U3!
¾²€! (2)
A.D.I.
7) P76-77
÷H¼L`aXefgD
E?-1ÅPQ&|?RIUV 40Š!
Y Ï§,èé\|}n)'ˆg-*s!
%+€! (2)F.
14) P17-19
H¼Æ?5:w;efg<Lhlo\“!
c Ú-Ñ®¯Q°±Q,‚ÍÎz{!
%+€! (2)
A.B.D.F.H.
7) P80-81! PQ&|?RIUVCDEÁB0o•p/v?‹Œh¢!
c ,-.,••g|}!
%+€! (2)C.F.H.
14) P11-13
9!lŠÁdNNL¤×h`ìH¼=16 [X\eRfE
M!
c /égŸ*,'(é+!
%+€! (2)A.C.I.
13) P60-61
qRfE2ŽrSLMNstsx¬RIhpƒWH¼=
Y!
c #0,'(ö-+!
12€! (2)A.C.F.G.H.
13) P62-63
8 [X\RœøðEuEv?wx¬1h9!log:hc!
c %3,š›z{g/+!
45€! (2)
A.B.
14) P139-141?ÁdiìNhÕ¶H¼=9 [X\ÎoEÁ+/H?ø
m!
c Z„678,-¦Sz{TõÄ!
‚9€! (2)H.
14) P20-22
jkl?œ¡hRILûöyü
EBCm‹?zÚhD’u!
c :âiz{g;<&=>|}!
‚9€! (2)H.
14) P113-115
XH¼= 3 [X\•!
c ?²ÖÕ@ABCDE×F‡pGAó!
ìí€! (3)12) P136-140! PQI?Ž•‹Œhj’lERI?Ž•´hnpXH…!
c HI(BC! ¬JDd&dGAó!
$%€! (3)A.E.F.
12) P147-152¼= 9ET|?PQŽ•hQÀŠRo-.•MNOPBŠ!
c ¬K,„`Lü#DÚ-Ñ[`gMN!
~•€! (3)F.H.
12) P153-158?{‘¬1?RI?¸¹-.hnpXH¼=12 [X\“!
m „`Lü#DPO&½áz{!
PQ%€! (3)F.
12) P190-194
PQI?/“ü.?[{hE7|loùÔ?RB?MN¢!
*;UV’÷?
(1)E(2)E(3)D?-2ÅPQ&|?RIUV 3 w?’÷ÆLqr
\LnVlEžŽddÝ'h}VoìîlŠ‘Cg?åK

efg? A ’” I D?-3Å40 H¼?RIUVL`aXefgÆLqr
\hpƒWH¼= 3 [X\
Ut_}LDH¼ôõ?Ut_}?!"dôõ#hhW\! RC~?‘C³aC¬ì
EQ/••)E€•R‚¬1

195

土木学会論文集F4（建設マネジメント）, Vol. 68, No. 3, 193-210, 2012.
?-4! 40 H¼L`aXRIUVÉ?Ñäxbc

?-3! 40 H¼?RIUVL`aXefg!"""#"$%&$%&'()*+,

defgh;<9:ixjxFÀdefgh,TU

;<RS

A

-./0

-2'3456789:-;<=>/0

16 *+

1

15?<

@ABC

EABF@ABFGHIJF@KLI’¾’t'"¿À""

ÁÂM’t5ÃÄe89FÅ•ÆÇFÈ•É~5ÊËÌ[¿ÀÍ"
ÎÏÐ~FÑÒÑÓMN'¾¨ÔÕ5Ök’×'ØÙÍ"ÚÛFÚÜ""ÝFÚÞ"D

JMN/OPAQ5RS

TUV'

WXYZ5678[\I;<=F]^

©ªß'"
àá"

-.;<=

_*`a[b5c'dJe8f'g

AQ'È•É~'âãF?Oäåæçèxé'êëÍ"
Ast'½8u©ªßÃÄ'ØÙÍ"ìíîïðñxv'òó&'ôõÍ"ö÷"ÚÚFö÷"
ø÷"

AQ34'"
qù"‹ú-'ûü’t'•ýF‹ú-'34þÿ5!"Í"•#/$%&Mu•ýF'('34)*+*',ù&-.Í"/ƒCD'•ýF0x1x/OPþÿ5ôõÍ"2Lî34H5'34Ð›56§P7e5ôõÍ"•8'‹ú-FAºFA9'9:5ÌP;:&-.Í"öÞFÚÜ"
ÝFÚÞ"
"
Û"
ÝFøÛ"
øøFøÛ"<œ=>'"
àá"‚ƒ?Œ/FAQ/…a¢P@A'=>&BPi5ôõÍ"CRîD7>EF'GH>IH5/JKÍ"‚ƒ?Œ€A'£Q'[†FLMI='NO'Í"

Úö"
öP"
øQ"

RS=>'"
êT"

RS=>'êTñxv'ØÙÍ"*QUV5ÅW8F>IH5eXYÍ"

Úö"
öP"

A•,ù'"
Z8["‹Œî\]ç&áG89uP-•'Gò675ôõÍ"A•ž'[†FA•,ù'L^&_<FA•'`a'âãÖZ8uÍ"Èbc5d89A•5eœ¢P7e5ôõÍ"fg•F‘’“”•'675ôõÍ"ø÷Føø"
Ú÷FPø""
ÚÜFPÞF"
ÛFøÛ"

hi:'"
àá"

A’Qj*ç5‹Œ'áG¢Phi:`kÌPi5ôõÍ"jQl'm/nQAº•\®ç&uPi5êëÍ"
AQ\®ç'o75ôõÍ"‚ƒjQl'@ANpe89'AQ5qÙÍ"

Ú"
rFøø"
ö"
ÚFPFøÛ"•8sAºtuv
Fwe'ê‰"•8'AQ9xyýe'*z9{&-."•8'Aº'x|5ùP'/*z9{&-.Í"‚ƒQ'6}~•e€MPAQ—sî\]'Qqr/eËNuÍ"øFöFöQF
Úø"öÞFöÛFö÷"QFøQFÚÛ"

AQ—s"
ž¹ôõ"

•l'‚ƒ,„•&AQ5µj*ç
FA'ç'a=ý ööFöÝ"U&…Ÿ'r„†Fª•‡'ƒŸ„•&Ast5µeu
Sˆ.Ç&Z8uÍ"<œ•‰Š"A•,ùFAQž¹'Å‹•‡F'•‰&Œ•Í"Ž•ž¹'ƒÅ.Ç/N89L•&_¢‘PÍ"ö÷FÚQ"
Ú÷"

<œ’“"
'¿À"

A•67'GEFAQ—sž¹'.Ç5”•$%iM
NÁÂM.–5—˜8<œ’“5¿À¢P-.&BPÍA•ž'L•&_‚‘PÍ"øFÚ÷FPø""™šLM"A’Q6›`€FAQH•'›œœ/LMI=&•ÌMuÍ"A'£Qe89<œ¢Pœ/•žþÿp&MuÍ"
AQ<œœ/FA'£Q€LMI=&•ÌMuÍ"ÚFP""ÚFøQFöÞ"
ÛFPø"

B
C

8 *+

9 *+

hij\I5k<PMNFTUV'.;<=5RS
D

E
F

!lmn

-2_*'!lmn'qr5FAs/OPot'CD!l/7uP*/O=vwxpyz{|}'~•5€iP

AQ'H‚ƒQ'H•345„i8FAQ'•K

H•K5…†P‚ƒH•‹Œ'‚ƒH•5•Ž9A•‰Š•/OP‡‘’“”•'–—5RS

3 *+

9 *+
12 *+

ˆ‰Š
G
H

_˜™š

_˜™š'•ž5Ÿ A•'‘’/'›œ›œ8F—s&'~•5†¡¢£QVA

A’t'—s¦§`M<F¨_•©

Q'¤¥ªF«¬A^•AQ-®'¯°{z±

5 *+
18 *+

²³¤¥5´PI

AQe‚·;<=¸¹'Aºeµ¶8»¼M·

ƒQ'µ

5—s¢PMNF‚ƒQeAQ'½[¶

Mµ¶5RS4 *+šëìFƒ£hƒXH¼=18E!iìN%Ý?R3d®l„o¬!h‘CWX¬1
EPQIdRI?¥o¬®hÕ¶H¼=4 [X\! v•”?efg?¶öCEÅE.RI?Ž•´ÆÅF.PQŽ•LMX¸¹-.ÆÅG./“ü.?nVÆDE?-1?H¼!" 1E3E4E16E19E21E25E33 L`jŠER
I?‘CghåKðFXäå=“”•X\c) -+01$%&'defÏgh
! RIUV 40 H¼?_}’”EPQI?RIUVL`aXÑäx¬bchÜklodv©
E61 ?bc=[U”•o\v•”?bc?¶öEGÃWXcwhÎdpŠ
ÅN8N~?…†ÆÅ•)9?—˜ÆÅRI‹Œ?œ
•ÆÅUVžŸ?—˜ÆÅ‡ˆžŸ?yÆÅRBû•?‰lðÆÅØÙ•?—˜ÆÅBŠ1R3
EJA v;d?y-ÆÅRI‘C{Ýæ‹ÆÅUV[$ZÆÅUV’ *;ÅUVÉÆdDUV?æ‹dUV[$Z?••hðW÷?…†ÆÅ\º¨©Æ?12 cwL-.lo\‡?Ï
Œh?-4 LhW\

?0o-žÆÅžŸy

ÆÅPQ5o?¼½ÆÅ¨©K! RIUV 40 H¼?_}’”ERIUV‰L`aXÑ?^cÆ? 10 cwL-.lo\‡?ÏŒh?-5 LhW\äx¬bchÜklodv©
E47 ?bc=[U”•o\vvCÅUVÉÆdDUV?æ‹dUV[$Z?••v•”?bc?¶öEGÃWXcwhÎdpŠÅÅÔ0hðlEÅUV‰ÆdDRI‘Ch£¨lo‰?••h•ÆÅ•0?Ž,ÆÅRI‹Œ?œ•ÆÅ‘C?s4

ðW\ÅUVÉÆdÅUV‰Æ?‘id–LEôªC¤´ÆÅRI?,-Ž,ÆÅ~†…šëìFƒ£ÆÅRB þ¬bc=•”•od’§•X\196

?-5! 40 H¼L`aXRIUV‰?Ñäxbc
defgh;<9:ixjxFÀdefgh,TUqk»laBmn,4‰|}¯QdTow\ßpqTrs3'tuv

;<RS
24\34

=>.|}.ÇÈÝ,Iwå$™'qk»lÝ,tu
v
8\18

|},~‚

#x,y>[\ÇÈz[,zu{|F
v

20\31

-z,•€¯Qd6íV•{4‰
v

37\22

!"#,À8\|}‚TDƒ&',{„§‰
v

15\34

…†;+,a‡$ˆFX‰ÀÀ8\|}Ä‰T„§AŠ7'v

11\15!"#$%&'()*"!

®ji‹Tr^§\|},ŒåT8U3•g{|Fv

5\10\24+,-.)*"!

½ilQ7ãd$™'|},ÎŽv

7\8|}Ä‰$23'…fk•{|F

10\15\37-+•‘#0,-+“g,ñfÏƒÏ{óT”•3'|F
v

40

,’j

~Í,`–,ÉO\#0W,—˜êix•‘T’j3'|Fv17-éý{`É,Ín$O™š$\`Éßp{„§‰•g{›'
v

11\37

•‘,œ•gñÃ•ž{ŸF
v

24\33

èé,
_å

_å,À8$\`ý,z{(]\z{¡K,¢£§{|Fv

6_¤¥¦§,r^{gh
v

10\22

á-1! PQI?RIUV~•€•‚yz! 31 |C`šD 13 + 4 (ÚÌ?¬IC[X\ž]ŸE$I'ÔE¨©ª,«©\¬`-©
\®¯°±D _¤¥{„§‰v

23\27

-+,

-`+ab²&DÏA\+t³´,~‚Tµ¶
v

2

ÍÎ~‚

›÷T‚ö$§X\‚ÍÎ-+TõÄ§\hSdT·¸'v

3‘’ _,À8$\-+,‚ÍÎåTÎŽv

19\21\32

8 |E¦›S›34 |E7• 3 |E7¸4 2 |E3ž 2 |E¹º±R»€¼,½;rs,À8\œ•žŸ\»¼¹Ý,Iwå{|Fv

4\12

Ÿ> 2 |E ¡ 1 |E›¸ 1 |dx>L7¢lŠjX\

7SõÄÇÈoÉ\•Sdji\=>+Ý,õÄ{|Fv

8\10\13! î™¬I?RI78?,-DE?-6 LhWM¶LE1

Ø½ižŸ\Zé=>#\#0R»7SÝIwåÝ,tu
v

17\26

|[oN?)KD0 Ì’” 67,000 ÚÌC`šD 5287 ÚÌE-#,»¼

x„`Lü#D›¿ÀÀ8\-#,»¼$IÀ,¾Â{|F39

1 |[oN?íî¿£D 7.95a ’” 12,339a C`šD 1,142a¾Â-+èéý,œ•,À8$\-#,»¼{|F27

1RNI.@d¤ChÕ¶¬Ihúì;C[X
\RI7

ÂÁ9Â

-+,§ÃÄÂTa&'•g{„§‰v

15

8?ù¥$HÓ?ÔD
E1 Ý’” 18 ÝC`šD 3.5 ÝC

ÅÆ.Ç˜ÁÈ#,ÉKÁÄ›2,"˜TÎŽv

4\24[X\RI78?)KEíî¿£E$I'Ôd–Eî™

)*`É¹Ë>;,ÌÍÎD{‚ÏA\ÂÁ9Â{„§AÏ¿3\4\22¬IèLá”wZ=[X\,Ê6Àv-+‘’~‚Ý,ÐÑ{Ï‰v§Ã•,-#],À8\-#Bj$§Ó{IA\ÍÎ~‚{„§‰

Òh-+01Ô$)*+,‘’;ÕÖ:,×m{·{¿À 8\10\28Ø`ÙÚ]g-Û],¹#"˜Í§{IA\ÜÝv

)Kd–Eî™¬IèLá”wZ=[X\! ¬I?þÿBDEá-1 LhWM¶LE›7 8 |E3œ! RI?‘COaDE"S¦S‰§= 19 |EAQBC=
1\39
8\18

*;ÅUV‰ÆdDRI‘Ch£¨lo‰?••hðW

8 |ERNI.@=5 |E¤C 3 |EZ?vBC=4 |C[X1ùÔ?OahÕ¶¬I2N;\! BCNwDEî™¬I= 31 |LqlŠENwÔD 51
dôªC[X\/¨ 7 |E©ª•«…•5 |?6DEì¬E›•©E›‚-¬1 49 NwD‡•®•P«?1 |=BC

(2) -+01,¹iÞQd9:$™'gh,ßà

lŠjX\2ŽBCSJRfBChÕ¶¬I=
12 |E! 40 H¼yzCDEPQI?RIUVL`aXefgd¯Rœ•f!N~¬1E8Q°±?ëjBC{•NwhÑäx¬bchÜklo\RIUVL`aXbchöl…²¬I=10 |[X\ìáâWXopLEÑäx¬bcC[=Àocwh–d ! UV’÷DER?¬IdlŠUV11 |EP&|?RI‘C{ÝCUV 12 |E˜4{ÝdlŠUV 3 |C[X
L…†“hNºlŠ~•€•‚yzhÕÀo
\! ~•€•‚yzD 2007 ®LÕjEBOT2(LMX 12}î™26;\
H¼½E”•—••ëE¥åæç¬1?÷¢?FižS ! RI78?ÅÔD24 |=³´¸yE4 |=ÅÔšµE1’”ERILûNt`CjXdð•XPQ&|h50 ||=¶´¸yC[X12}î™
29;\…AE~•€•‚–h—˜lo\˜8lo 50 Ã?¶öE ! RIUV?YŽDEÅFGHI?JKÆ= 30 |EÅPîÅD 31 ÃCEîÅVD 62HC[Ào\á-1 LhWM

QI?‹ŒS™š›š=·!CZXdtÙoÆ=14 |E¶LEv?¶ö 40 H¼d¤¬X&|D12 |C[X\ÅRISPQId–L¸¹lo”Bç=úûCZ¬ì¬a) âãô+,äKg-+01,EåXÆ= 8 |EÅº»ERI=BçhÔÙXCIL¬Xd! î™¬I 31 |DEBO?%½PQIC[NEž]ŸD

’ÀoÆ= 7 |EÅíîž¼1ØÙSÁBv;?2}·100 ÚÌ’” 9,800 ÚÌC`šD3,654 ÚÌE$I'ÔD4!?opÆ=4 |C[X1ùÔî™e;Ý’” 200 ÝC`šD45.7 ÝE)KD800 ÚÌ’” 60 +Ì土木学会論文集F4（建設マネジメント）, Vol. 68, No. 3, 193-210, 2012.
?-6! RI78?)K1½¾¿ÚÌ;Eíî¿£1½¾¿a;2006®©
Ÿ

ª•

\]
¡¢

Ÿ

ª•

\]
¡¢

Ÿ

ª•

?-7! RIUVÉL`aXbc

\]
¡¢

!!

1

67,000

850

11

2,400

1,000

21

500

16

2

13,488

※

600£

12

1,943

1,895

22

450

45

3

11,70095,000

!

13

1,500

150¤※

23

200

4

10,000

65

14

1,392

450

24

5

8,695

100

15

1,200

1,960

6

7,800

4,200

16

1,030

7

7,000

12,339

17

8

3,900

7.95

9

3,581

10

3,100

æVâã! !
nšçâãVcMs!

èdé! !
nšçâãVY¢s!

!!

OÙ!

}•!
•é!

}•!
·é!

OÙ!

}•!
•é!

}•!
·é!

350

|}‚,rs!

Y¢!

Š!

MY!

…!

Y!

u!

200

16

-+•‘,’j(]
!

M…!

M¢!

…!

c!

M!

Y!

25

50

290

-+01$|FÏÂÁ,
rs!

M¢!

u!

u!

Y!

M!

M!

905

26

1

10

`ê`–,oë!

u!

Y!

c!

¢!

¢!

¢!

800

※

2,500¤

27

0700

ÊøÂÁ,9Â(]!

u!

c!

Y!

c!

c!

¢!

18

667

1,313

!

28

0

350

3,611

19

500

450

29

0

330

#xg,9ìn-ê.í
î.-+ïð[ÏÖs
!

c!

Y!

M!

M!

M!

¢!

200

20

500

105

30

0

129.4

c!

M!

Y!

M!

¢!

M!

31

0

95

-+èé]ñ*^FñT
òÀ3•g{„§‰!
óôu,rs!

c!

c!

¢!

M!

M!

¢!

-#Bj,„§ˆ!

Y!

M!

M!

¢!

¢!

¢!

ŠjXoêE2006 ® 12 ÝÎC?)K\íî¿£DRNI.@¿£

01íõÏ{ÜÝ!

Y!

¢!

Y!

M!

¢!

M!

h5æ\íî¿£?ÂCÃ?[XÔ´D¤CL`aXÄÅÆÔh
E

ö,÷!

m!

Y!

Y!

M!

M!

¢!

OÙ!

…m!

c…!

c…!

Y¢!

M¢!

M¢!

*¿]iD)K?ôjÀLÁÕo
\)KL¦lŠE2006 ®©’”‘ClÇDRNI.@hilŠjX\b) ¹iÞQd9:DjxFÀ01$%&'gh! ÅRIUVÉL`jŠbcd¬Ào–?DÈ’Æ?Q*;)KK¾S)Kg¾DRI0Î?)KK¾
16 |Eg¾ 15 |hhW\^hERIUV 40 H¼?_}yzL`aXÅRIUV ! ÅRIUV‰L`jŠbcd¬Ào–?DÈ’Æ?Q^hERIUV 40 H¼?_}yzL`aXÅRIUV
É?Ñäx¬bc1?-4;Æ? 12 cw?¶öEÅUV
’÷?…†ÆÅ\º¨©Æhúì10 cwhî™?…†‰?Ñäx¬bc1?-5;Æ? 10 cw?¶öEÅ¨©

“dlŠNºlo\ùÔî™eCEÉ–ÊŠDÎXbc

K?^cÆhúì9 cwhî™?…†“dlŠNºlo\!

1íÑ¾;hÑw…²vdhèËlo
\¬`ÅUV’÷ùÔî™eCEÉ–ÊŠDÎXbc1íÑ¾;hÑw…

?…†ÆÅ\º¨©Æ?2 cwDE=Ì?Åc)!î™¬I²vdhèËlo\¬`Å¨©K?^cÆ?cwDE=?¨©Û?þÍÆ?qÒdlo\! ?-7 DEPQI?RIUVÉL`aXbc?î™ˆ‰Ì?Åc)!î™¬I?¨©Û?þÍÆ
?qÒdlo\! ?-8 DEPQI?RIUV‰L`aXbc?î™ˆ‰C[X\UVÉ?bcdlŠî™Ô=É–ô’Ào–?

C[X\UV‰?bcDEî™?ô’ÀoÀLEÅ•0DÅ•)9?—˜ÆC[X\˜LERI0Î?)Kg¾?Ž,ÆÅÅÔ0•ÆÅPQI?ÐöyüÆÅRI‹Œ?†ª•ðCDE¤þ¬bcdlŠ[UX¬I=12 |?œ•ÑAåKÆÅ~†…šëìFƒ£=‰ljÆÅs

[Ào\

4lo‘C=CZ¬jÆÅRI?,-Ž,ÆÅžŸy

2 !wJ·DÅRI‹Œ?œ•O{ÆÅRIUVLý

ÆÅRB?0o-žÆC[X\þ¬žŸ?—˜ÆÅN8Nw?…†ÆÅ‡ˆžŸ?y! î™Ó=í1 ¾L…`³–?DEôjÀLEÅ•0?Ž
O{ÆÅBŠd?y-ÆÅRI‘C{ÝQ‚þ5?‰l ,ÆÅÅÔ0•ÆÅRI‹Œ?œ•`MAåKÆC[NEðÆÅØÙ•?—˜Æd$jŠjX\

HIg?—˜d‹Œ?œ•?¤þg=ëjvd=§’X\

î™Ó=í1 ¾L…`³–?DEôjÀLEÅ•)9?—˜ÆÅRI‹Œ?œ•O{ÆÅ‡ˆžŸ?yO

1 |`š?bc?…†ÔDEUVÉD 2.4 VEUV‰
D 2.8 VC[X\RI0Î?)KhK¾Sg¾L7aŠ{ÆC[X\!

ˆ‰h“ŠüXdEUVÉ??-7EUV‰??-8 d–LE

! UVÉ?bcdlŠÅ‡ˆžŸ?yO{Æh…`³ bc?…†L`jŠ,Z¬¥jD¬’Ào\¬I 5 |?¶öEí 1 ¾?bcdlo¬I=3 |[N,! ! UVÉEUV‰d–LE•0?—˜E‹Œ?œ•Ež
žŸ?—˜=‰lj¬ICDE‡•=¤,¬bcd¬ÀŠjXvd=§’XÏ!

198

Ÿ?y =,Z¬bcL¬ÀŠjX\土木学会論文集F4（建設マネジメント）, Vol. 68, No. 3, 193-210, 2012.
?-8! RIUV‰L`aXbc?-9! RIUV?¨©LqWXÃ“SþÍ1ùÔî™;¨©
sGò¦§, 24w

!!

æVâã!
!ùšçâãVY…ú!

ýU

ª•"
•

ª•"
†

!!

OÙ!

}•! }••é! ·é!

OÙ!

}•! }••é! ·é!

10

8

4

4

M•!

Š!

Š!

u!

c!

Y!

8

4

5

3

2

11

5

6

1

0

1

Mu!

u!

M¢!

…!

c!

m!

AQ34'qù´ä~•

9

3

6

3

2

1

Mm!

…!

…!

c!

Y!

M!

¯°{z±²³'¤¥&
Z8u

8

5

3

0

0

0

-+01û$%&'§ÃÄÂ!
,~ü!
|}Ä‰$23'k•T!
§XE§‰!
)*+,‘’;ÕÖ:Ý,!
ýþT§XE§‰!
-˜#Bj$23'§Ã!
n-#]s,¢£§!

M¢!

m!

•!

¢!

¢!

¢!

Ñ•8[—s&`ŠMu

6

4

2

2

1

1

…!

c!

m!

Y!

Y!

¢!

AQ'µq«2

5

2

3

1

0

1

•!

m!

Y!

M!

¢!

M!

=>êT

3

2

1

2

1

1

A•'-¼¶=

3

0

3

0

0

0

u!

Y!

c!

Y!

M!

M!

f'·

4

3

1

2

2

0

-+èé]ñ,*^Fñÿ!
!
-`+ab,ô+$"-+!
$#3'ÄÂT§XE§‰!
Ø`ÙÚ]g-Û],¹#!
"˜Í§,¢£§!
B_]ñ,Fñÿ!!

m!

Y!

Y!

¢!

¢!

¢!

ö,÷!

Y!

Y!

¢!

M!

M!

¢!

OÙ!

…“!

c…!

mY!

YM!

MY!

“!

"

¥,¦§
sGò¦§, 29w"

ýUª•" ª•"
•
†

©ª'«2

19

9

¬þ-®

12

‚ƒQ'¯‹°±&²³„•/2Šu

ýU

80

41

39

24

13

11

*;)KK¾S)Kg¾DRI0Î?)KK¾
15 |Eg¾ 14 |hhW\!

èdé!
!ùšçâãVYMs!

‡?6?Ã“SþÍ1TÒø~;!

!
c) âãô+,§ÃÝ,Fø! Å1?M¶¬¨©=[•á
EUV=mnð•Xd’¶-+•‘{Ï‰\±Sk{‚Ï‰À8$èéÄ$û6‘’{° _$Ï'•g{|%D›'vö,À8\01ÔV¼K$™À¿X\&žT§XE§‰v!

’Æ?Q^hEÅRIUVÉ?Ñäx¬bc1?-4;Æ

01,NOfÏ'({E§‰v!

dÅRIUV‰?Ñäx¬bc1?-5;Æ’”Üklo)&Á,'(TJA D6ÏA\Æ*{Æ×+ÏD›'v!

9 ?¨©Û?þÍhEî™?…†“dlŠNºlo\ù-Ñ.å,••.-p.,I¾Ý,§/T3'+Ïv!

Ôî™eCEÉ–ÊŠDÎXbc1íÑ¾;hÑw…²vdhèËlo\ÎoE‡?6?Ã“SþÍdlŠ
ET

01-#T"—˜DÏ'À8,§ÃT*^§XE§‰v!
f 2-éý$#3'&žT"¿g§XE§‰v!

ÒøV?ÂhQao\(3s2ö-+$#3'&žT"¿gÆ×+ÏD›'v!

! RIUVÉ??-4 ’”ÜkloþÍDÅRIUVÉL`aX¨©Zž?ŽzÆÅRNI.@?¬IL–RIL*;)KK¾S)Kg¾DRI0Î?)KK¾
14 |Eg¾ 13 |hhW\qWXZžhlŠÓljÆÅR!Bû•L¦WX¨©
EÖêx¬UV
1RB{;?“ÔlÆÅ˜4{Ý?þ56‡ÆÅRI‘ ! ‡?6?Ã“SþÍÛ?TÒø~CD
ÛGE:;˜xhRIÛ?\º¬1?7 ?þÍ=[Ào\C{Ý?Q‚þ56‡ÆC[X\! RIUV‰??-5 ’”ÜkloþÍDEÅ•0£«Ld)!ghÝ,âãô+,#4!
¦WXÔbhlŠÓljÆÅPQI?íîHcÕzÛ? ! ~•€•‚Chð•oUVÉEUV‰?bcLqWX\÷¬Ö×hlŠÓljÆÅØ5TÙ{dRª{?ÁB9!, ¬I?qrLwjŠETÒø~?î™hÅ½lo
I?qrDôªC[NEUVÉ?qrdlŠ 57EUV¨?“ÔlÆC[X\! ?-9 DQ^LqWXî™C[X\¨©Û?þÍdlŠE ‰?qrdlŠ 41 ?î™=•”•o\÷î™DEUVÅUVÉL`aX¨©Zž?ŽzÆÅ•0£«Û?Ô

É•UV‰?÷bcLýcl–1 q 1 CqrlŠ`”cE\vvCEUVÉdUbÆÅPQI?íîHcÕzÛ?Ö×ÆÅR!Bû•L ùÔ?bcLqrWX–?–[X¦WX¨©Æ?ÀLî™=ô’Ào\V‰?bch,Z¬7ÜCììN
Ev•”?î™h-.

! î™Ó=íÑ¾L…`³–?DEÅ•0£«Û?Ô

WXvdLlo\EbÆÅUVÉL`aX¨©Zž?ŽzÆÅPQI?íî ! ¬I=¶I¢LUVWXoê?bc?7ÜdlŠD
HcÕzÛ?Ö×Æ?ÀLô’Ào\ÑäxLE(°)HIg?—˜E(Ý)‹ŒS™š›š?œ•E! RI0Î?)Kg¾?†ª•ðCD
E13 |% 10 |=!

(›)žŸ?y E(Þ)Iœ¡1I¢£?œ¡;?¤¥EÅ•0£«Û?ÔbÆh…`C`N
E˜LÚjþÍd¬(”)¨©K?bc?5 w=ß4ð•X\

ÀŠjX\v?6?cwDE)KK¾Eg¾L`aX¥! RIUVÉL`aXbc1?-7;ERIUV‰L`ajD[ÎNü”•¬’Ào\

Xbc1?-8;hEv? 5 w?7ÜLÊŠDpodv©
E

199

土木学会論文集F4（建設マネジメント）, Vol. 68, No. 3, 193-210, 2012.

=?M¶L7aXvd=CZo\?-10! RIUVÉEUV‰?bcÛ?î™¬I?qr!

(°)HIg?—˜¿UVÉ?bcÅ•)9?—˜ÆÅN

"

8Nw?…†ÆÅØÙ•?—˜Æ
\UV‰?bcÅ•0º»¼" *Q½¾F]Q¢P7e`©ªàásÛw"©ª'«2'[†F‹:`]QsQw"?Ž,ÆÅÅÔ0•ÆÅ~†…šëìF?ƒ£=‰l&'àá""

È•¿aÀ¢P7e`©ªàbîÑ_?îAºe'µ¶`©ªÒ…söw"

"""

ásPw"

ÑXsÓÔÕ*wÖ×'[†'ØÙ5RS""

Á'Âd`©ªàásöw"Ast'XÚ~•/ke†9©ª«2"(Ý)‹ŒS™š›š?œ•¿UVÉ?bcÅRI‹Œ?

"""

GH£QÃÄ'ÅÆ?/<¨"È•êë5{yxÔ?Œ/!""œ•O{Æ\UV‰?bcÅRI‹Œ?œ•ÑAåKÆ
\"""ÇxÈ|}É°H5567"

ìí5µ£Qî>IH5'þÿ56§P"(›)žŸ?y ¿UVÉ?bcÅRIUVLýþ¬žŸ""";:8[&©ª`ŠÊsöw"•Û•ÜÝ-'þÿ56§P"‚ƒQ'ËÌÍe0MjMu©ªÞßà½8"’×5¿À"½µ'—st'¥á"L,ZjÆÅžŸy ÆÅRB?0o-žÆ‚ƒ(Î„'ijÏxvÐl

CD34'~•5´P"(Þ)Iœ¡?¤¥¿UVÉ?bcÅBŠd?y-1Ro7sÚw"—sµq«25´PsPw"

3SJASRIá'&¬1;Æ\"’¾œÍê‰`A’Q6›¡¢5«2"

jÆÅs4lo‘C=CZ¬jÆÅRI?,-Ž,Æ\?—˜Æ\UV‰?bcÅPQI?Ðöyü=àßJK

<œœ'N¸"<œ¹'N¸"Ast'¨_•5,ù"(”)¨©K?bc¿UVÉ?bcÅRI‘C{ÝQ‚þ·â'AQçeµ¶5´P"

5hâoWvd=‰ljÆÅRBû•?‰lðÆÅUV

AQ(Î«2î¯°{z±²³¤¥¢P"[$Z=ãäÆ

¹Çæãäsöw"! v? 5 7ÜCEbcÛ?î™¬I?qrh-.lE‡

A’Q6›/5¢PJ>'-•"‚ƒQijAQ¿hi:5åÉ[æP"?ˆ‰h?-10 LhW\

Œl'ºç5Él¢P"! ?-10ÅRIUVÉEUV‰?bcÛ?î™¬I?qºè¼""34î"

éêî3ëîìq?/<¨s÷w"

AQ34'3ë?/<¨söw"

rÆL`jŠDEUVÉdUV‰hê§FŠEÅ1°;)*+*Aºîí´lFij½¾Ð›5

AQ345‹:`qù"

HIg?—˜ÆÛ?qr=É–ô’Ào\UVÉLDE'qù"

6§PsÝw"Ñ•—s†¡8CD34~•/;:sÚw"‹jîRïðsöw"•Û‹ú-î"uv'AQÐ›56§P"

Áij’×¿À'Ð›56§

AQ5µ£Q'34Ð›56§P"?9!LMX•0?—˜hD_p
EPQI?èé…d¤PsÚw"¨_/5¢P×ñ5qù"¬”¬jNw?…†¬1 20 ?qr=[X\UV‰LDE

AQ5µ£Q/Ð›56§P"÷þÛîIE5okåE»?æ<EJ•€–ç•†Ž¦•0Ž,E‘C,-Ž,E~†…šëìFƒ£EÝ5¦·J¬1L¦lŠ28 ?qr=[X\º+¼""=>‚ƒ(Î'=>567sÝw"

LMI='67söw"'êT"

LMI=î™š>567söw"‚ƒ(Î'=>O=e=œô"™š>e‹ò=>'óÛ567"! =LÅ1Ý;‹ŒS™š›š?œ•ÆÛ?qr=ôj\•ÛCR¿9:.~"UVÉLDEêuS?ëSìœ&LUQ
ERIÓ?ín

ºè¼""Qq

A•,ù/B[=F•8Aºeh.aX¬1 22 ?qr=[X\UV‰LDE?ë&L

r'Jõ"'ý|’š/öhÍ÷øAºeùý5ú/MjMuCD’×

UQEBC‹Œ?åKL×pXE‹Œính.aX¬1
9 ?qr=[X\! 3 !wLôj?DÅ1›;žŸ?yÆÛ?qrC[ûª™šFF•#'Üx’Q/9:"5¿•"ºü¼""LM‹Œ`A•êë5RuFA•5

•'ýþ"

àá"

X\UVÉLDPQ0Î?žŸh9!E¨©Zž?9!E

AQ—sž¹ƒÅ`FAQžBOîÕÛÞ•þp¬1?11 ?qr=[NEUV‰L¹?{/Ð›5ÿ‘FM!ei‹"!#M8"ƒÅ`Š[Í"D¨©Zž?YVEPQ0Î?žŸ’”YV¬1?3 ?

! ! ! ! !TÒø~LMXî™’”Nº\1!;DùÔî™Ô!

qr=[X\! Å1&;Iœ¡?¤¥ÆCDEUVÉLERBû••BCN~?…4CEBŠ?RIÓd?êÃ’ºÛ?ï•=¬ð•Š`NEUV‰LDBç?GðNILÞ•WX
vdCBŠ?RIÓd?Z‡hƒÀŠjX\˜ÆC[X\UVÉ?qrdlŠDET•CîIlo¬I= 6 |dôj=E5okå14 |;•»?æ<h9!
lo¬I12 |;–[X\•)CZ¬’Ào¬I–2 |[X\UV‰DET•CîI=5 |E]Sõ/&ßþS! Å1”;¨©K?bcÆCDEUVÉLÅT|CRB
yzhÕjRBh—˜ÆÅRI‘C{Ý?Q‚CRIá'&LínhñòÆ=qrdlŠ[U”•ŠjX
\R3d?-®C•0Ž,lo¬I=
2 |E…E•ö&|
h9!lo¬I=1 |[X\
! UV‰DE•)9?—˜dd–LÅÅÔ0•Æ=bce) ¹iÞQd9:DßàˆFÀghg5ô+,#4! ~•€•‚yzCáâð•obcd÷
¬I?qrLw
jŠEd)C~Õo5 7Üh!jŠE‡•®•~ÕX\!
ó°ôHIg?—˜! !
! UVÉSUV‰GLEÉ–,Z¬bcDÅ•)9?—!

200

L¬X\RI78?ÅÔD24 |=³´¸yE4 |=ÅÔšµE1 |=¶´¸yC[X\! ! !
! ÅÅÔ0•ÆÛ?qrdlŠD
E‘C,-Ž,EÝ5¦·JEBC‹ŒåKE¥,?‘C~?£)E•)ˆÍ“ÔlEQ/S•)Û?šëìFƒ
£dj¶î™=[Ào\R土木学会論文集F4（建設マネジメント）, Vol. 68, No. 3, 193-210, 2012.

NI.@?SŸ?0÷há@9LþÍlo¬I–[X\ó”ô¨©K?bc!

! PQI?RIUVCDEHIgh—˜WX?Dø‰¬! RIUV?¨©LqWXÃ“SþÍL`jŠô’Ào

opE•0£«L¦WXFx¬ÔbhùpXÃ“=15?DE1 !=ÅUVÉL`aX¨©Zž?ŽzÆ
E2 !

|dôj\

=Å•0£«L¦WXÔbÆC[X\3 !DEÅPQI

óÝô‹ŒS™š›š?œ•!

?íîHcÕzÛ?Ö×ÆC[NERILUVlovd! ÅRI‹Œ?œ•O{ÆDEUVÉEUV‰d–L¤

Cq*=ñlŠíîHcÕz?+°=g=N
EFGHI

þ¬bcd¬ÀŠjX\úû•ÁdLüýð•EJÞþ?V,C\9L¬”¬jM¶ùpŠjX
\~ª1`NLj’¬jBC‹Œ?œ•hbcdWX¬I ! 4 !J·DEÅR!Bû•L¦WX¨©1RB{;?
=ôj\BC‹ŒDERC~?•)½°dÅYL¦§N
E “ÔlÆEÅRI‘C{ÝQ‚þ5?6‡ÆEÅRNIÅÔ0•?opL¤þC[X\.@?¬IL–RIZžhÆ
EÅØ5TÙ{dRª{?

! UVÉ?RI‹Œ?œ•LDE?ëvLUQlo¬IÁB9!,¨?“ÔlÆÅ˜4{Ý?þ56‡Æ=$j= 9 |ER3SÿÑín'?ính.aX¬I=
7 |CŠjX\¬I?RIUV=-p”•odDjÙ
E¨Ê.

[NET•C!Õ"#lŠœ•WX¬ID
2 |C[Ào\ 5=ïlWÞX?CEMNTÒLRILUVðFŠ/lBC‹Œ?œ•LDERI?$Î3LMXính.aX

jdj¶þÍ=Újvd=§’X\¬I=ôj\Õ²LMX‹Œín?‰oWRÍ–,Zj\ ! v?6LÕ²LqWXþÍdlŠ
EÅUV‰?0$x
ÎoEBçCBCÚ%?K¬jNwL¦lŠD
EBç?

¬\ºÆÅUV?Öêx¬ÛG=ÓljÆÅ[\Ÿ?Û?RIÓ?‹Œính.aX&|=[X\Gh JA1RIÞðtê;CD¬ìÕ²=Õ¶ÕZC[ó›ôžŸ?y !

XÆÅ12B?9·!?op?¨©Q‚Æ?Ã“=[X\!

! ÅUVÉ?bcyzÆC 3 !wLôì[U”•o?D(3) -+01$23'9:,66

ÅžŸ?y Æ?^cC[X\ÅRIUV?¨©LqWXÃ“SþÍÆCÉ–ô’Ào?DEFx¬¨©Zž?

RILUVloPQ&|hqÒLE40 H¼?_}yŽzC[NE16 |=þÍlŠjX\

zE31 |’”î™h•o~•€•‚yzhÚAWXv! UVÉ?¬I?qrdlŠDÅ]IC[XPQ0Î?

dLMNEHIg?—˜E‹Œ•™š›š?œ•EžŸ

žŸ?9!Æ=7 |dô’Ào\v•DEPQ&|DR?y =¤þ¬bcd¬ÀŠ`NEIœ¡?¤¥E¨©

I?¨©Zž?qÒL¬”¬jop
ET&?žŸhkl

L–bc=éÿWXvd=§’Ào\ÑOCEPQI?

o¬I=ô’Ào?=.Òd’§•X\PQ&|C–E

Ž•••¸¹-.•LMNRI=0•WXefg=Ñ0

PLRI‘C{ÝhQ‚W•á¨©Zž?qÒd¬N
E

L“”•X\¨©?“Ôl•FxÔbÛ?þÍ–ôj\~•€•‚yzC– 2 |=UVÉL¨©Zžh9!loqÒ¬IÔ=/”•ŠjXop
EPQI?RIUV?xdî™lŠjX\(háâlodDjÙ¬j=EÑäx¬bchÜkWX

! žŸ?y =bcL¬ÀŠjX?DEFGHI?¼½

vd=CZod’§•X\

dGLEBO?PQ&|Díî=³´WXäåL[NET&ž]=JKlE'èŸZŽ¦’”?YV=‰lì¬ 3.! )*+,/+01,9:
Nww[Xopd’§•X\UV‰?bcdlŠEÅP
QI?Ðöyü=àßJKL,ZjÆd™ÙX¬I=
11 |[XvdL–hð•ŠjX\‡?opERI?¨(1) /+01$23'7¹±iº9:
PQI?TIUVL`aXefgdbcháâWXo

\©ZžhRILUVWX¬ILŽzWXvdhùpXÃ pLE2008 ® 9 Ý’” 12 ÝL„~…•†yzhÕÀo“=ôj\PQI?TIUVDE‡?YZ=¨ÎÀo••L[NEóÞôIœ¡?¤¥!

]3x¬UVH¼DÓd`1¬j\‡vCE„~…•†! RIUVÉL1?M¶¬bc=[Ào’?î™Lql
E yz?qÒdlŠEPQ&|=TILUVlww[X>E>4»
ÅeéR3SJA1RIÞðtê;¬1?BŠd?y-Æ 4»?5³TISPQIbiìNÞß&1J‰=bcd™Ùo¬I=3 |[Ào\Þß&dj¶;ETI`MA+dCIC9Õx¬ûtü! UVÉL`aX¬I?qrdlŠDEÅeéR3d(hÕÀŠjX¬IS'(5 |h…`³1?-11;\ê¦ÑL¬”¬jBCNwh…4ÆÅRB?û•L`j>4»Þß&DEx>6?BçPQIÞ&dBçbT

ŠBŠ?eéR3d?êÃ’ºL)ØÆ=[X\UV‰tê?-®C[X\TI`MA+dCI?5 |DE78?qrdlŠDEÅ/0ü.vEBç?GðNILÞ

»E>4»E9ØÐL[NEI¢DETIHI(ETI•Æ=[X\BŠ?R3•RI'(d?Þ•¦Ñh,ì íîÓEbTtêEOd/oEê:;•<•C[X\! /”•oî™ÔdBçCD[X=
ETIS+dCILvdLï•WXPQ&|=[Xvd=§’X\201

土木学会論文集F4（建設マネジメント）, Vol. 68, No. 3, 193-210, 2012.

DTIS+dCI?î™CC[X\?-11! TIUV„~…•†yz?qÒ

! 11 cw?¶öEPQIdETIS+dCI?‘Ó=

7¹±iº#8! 9:!

-;€z<[$%&')*+n-)s!

-;€z<[$%&'/+

n-/s!

-;€z<[$%&'/*—˜ên-—s!

åZ¬Ó=ô’Àoopd’§•X\Ñä?TIÓh

=]€\/+;+¦! K /+

n/;s!

qÒdWXÉD¶¬Xˆ‰–ß4ð•X\-;€\/+‘’“! N /+n/‘s!

! PQI³a=î™lŠTIS+dCI=î™l¬’>Ø?\¡/CO! ! H ¡/COnCOs!

ÀocwD(10)Å>Á˜xÛ?K}ÆC[NEPQI?

=]€\žÃ>É! ! T\

nžÃs!

î™=TIS+dCIMNô’ÀocwD(2)ÅPQŽ

>Ø?\O@:QÒQH é+

nO@s!

•?·!ÆC[X\TIS+dCI?ü=î™loc

î™lo–?D 8 cwC[NE‘ÓLGÃL-Äð•ŠjXcw=ôj\v?.ÒDE]yz?qÒd¬À
oTIS+dCI?î™ÓDEPQI?TIUVLR

wD(7)ÅBŠ?+dQ/?ª•Æ(8)Åè?d?9!Æ
¦§X¶¬XI¢hqÒLloop
E‡•®•?‚o’”?î™h•Xvd=CZo\! TILDEbThþ2lTIhíîWXÅTIíî

C[X\TIS+dCI?î™=ôjcwD(4)Å½Ê
´AI?nƒÆ(5)ÅPQIdTI?Þ•LMX¤G}‰ÆC[X\! v?M¶LEPQI?TIUVL`aXefgdl(ÆETI?AIhÕ¶ÅTIHI(ÆEbTþ2ÓŠEFGHICâãd¬ÀoPQI?Ý'•Ž•h·?bThûNÎdpEþ2ÓL¯§ÀŠbT?-.•!WXvdEPQI?UVC0F-.•TB?½Ê´

ü.hÕ¶ÅbTtêÆ=[X\=nüTI?‘Cg=åKWXvdEè?d?Skd! v?¬’CEPQI=UVl•Wj’÷DÅTIH

+d9!=nævdEbT{‘=>Á˜xEBMNO

I(Æd’§•X\¥oLbThû•lŠTIíîÓ

´PQLTUWXvd=…Vð•ŠjX\! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

L¬XO{–[X=Eô=?žŸ=ýþL¬NŒ>Cb) /+01$%&'ghD¬j\>4»Þß&C–TIHI(Û?UVhæ‹! „~…•†yz’”EPQI?TIUVL`aXb

lŠjXopE]?@CDÅTIHI(ÆÛ?UVhchÜklodv©48 ?bc=[U”•o\v•”?

qÒdWXvdLWX\TI?HIDE}TE˜ÅE

bc?¶öEGÃWXcwhÎdpŠEÅNI½°Æ

?@EABLæaoBBÙ¬1?bTAIdNI4-

ÅWH?—˜LwjŠÆÅTIAI?ÅÔÆÅ[\H.hðWvddWX\23HI•T4-.DETI?

IdFG/HÆÅ|Ï?êÃÆÅTI‹Œ?œ•Æ

HILD5Î•cEFGHIL5Î•X–?dWX\

Åsxg?—˜ÆÅ6…-žÆÅ4iìN?¤¥Æ¬`ENI4DbTþ2Ó=wìXC>¬4CET4Å¶I¢-®?\sÆÅ½Ê´AI?‰lðÆÅbT

DDEx¬FGAQC[X\

X?NF£S;{?\z—ðÆÅ[\Ÿ¨©Lwj! ¬I?TIHI(Û?UVDE¨©KCDERB{

ŠÆÅž3¨©dFx¨©Æ?14 cwL-.lo\?ÅRBhþ2CZX?DMNÓ³aÆLü”•XM! v•”? 14 cwhERIUVL`aXbc?7ÜC¶¬¨/D¬j\TILýþ¬‹ŒEŽdh.Ùo¬

hlo1°;HIg?—˜E1Ý;‹ŒS™š›š?

IC[•áETIHILUVWXvd=CZX\

œ•E1›;žŸ?y E1Þ;Iœ¡?¤¥E(”)¨a) /+01$%&'IJK©K?bc? 5 7ÜL[ŠDpŠüodv©E@\]! „~…•†yz’”EPQI?TIUVL`aXe¬ì7ÜCZo\$ÀŠETIUV?bc–v? 5 w

fghÜklodv©E42 ?efg=[U”•o\v

L7ÜlŠtuWXvdLWX\‡?ˆ‰dÏŒh?-•”?efg?¶öEGÃWXcwhÎdpŠEÅF

13 LhW\÷î™?kþLwjŠD
E?-11 ?Í´h!

GHI¼½LMXâãÝ'?·!ÆÅPQŽ•?·jŠhW\i?F’a?¬jÂDPQIEF’a?Â

!ÆÅPQILMX0F-.?nƒÆÅ½Ê´AI?

DTIS+dCI?î™CC[X\nƒÆÅPQIdTI?Þ•LMX¤G}‰ÆÅbT! TIUV? 14 cw?bc?¶öEPQIdTIS+?ü.?ë©´ÆÅBŠ?+dQ/?ª•ÆÅè?d

dCI?‘Ó’”î™h•o–?D11 cwC[NE‘?9!?HnÆÅbTI°JJF?9!?mnÆÅb

ÓLGÃL-Äð•ŠjXbc=ôj\PQI?ü=T{‘LMX>Á˜xÛ?K}ÆÅ
CO2 LÅLMXBM

î™locwD1°;?Å|Ï?êÃÆ E1”;?

NO´PQÆ? 11 cwL-.lo\?-12 LE11 cw

Å[\Ÿ¨©ÆÅž3¨©dFx¨©Æ?3 cwC[?ÏŒhhW\î™?kþDE?-11 ?Í´h!jŠh

NEPQI?î™=ô’ÀocwD1›;?Å6…-

lŠjX\i?F’a?¬jÂDPQIEF’a?Â

žÆC[X\TIS+dCI?ü=î™locwD¬

202

土木学会論文集F4（建設マネジメント）, Vol. 68, No. 3, 193-210, 2012.
$-13! „~…•†yzC•”•oTIUV?bc’Ào\TIS+dCI’”î™=ô’ÀocwD

n½s;+K,rs!

1&;?Å4iìN?¤¥ÆÅ¶I¢-®?\sÆ`+Am!

1”;?ÅbTX?NF£S;{?\z—ðÆC[X\$-12! „~…•†yzC•”•oTIUV?efg@AeMŽ[‚ƒQ(Qç'„7'‚) ÍNpe89*Q5Í+'*H,-.'.2`/u•&-.

'0î*\
34

*Q(Qç1•'2å5Í+*Q*Q-'5š&-.

'‚*QH•€‚ƒH•'6x³Ç7É/*Q7'¯89Ô0Év5¾‰F
RS):@A/MŽ[‚ƒH•'S7$%'‚’Q;&<u[†F&VH€S7$%**î*\H•/rô[‚ƒQç€G:M/u•‚ƒQ';’=5„i8[ª=‰Šª=‰ŠeH•K'û…/OP*Q->'0î*\’Q;‰Š'…¤5Í+

34’Q;¥ƒ'/u•1•'2åý?

ª=‰Š`H,4'@a5Í+Ý•K'ý|’š'[†'0Î.l&-.

'0A•K/Q€*Q5úç¦§`€Z8u'024Ñ•DE/€Ý•K&-.

/+,ü9Ï½;q{rsDÏ'i°!

-)!

N#å{O„ÏÀ8\`+XHPÓåY+,QHå{„§‰!

-/!

¡/ìR,SF6I‰",,\N#å,TFD;+q,rs{„§‰!

/;!

½;rs$6¡/COg,U§O‰{|F!

-)!

çV,¼‰`+àSWX,”•{gh!

-)!

`+XìR.KYY+#,ZG‘[,Ó…\{)&Á²{\]^{° !

-/!

_Ë|}$™'q16`ßhSd$ab§XcÀv¡/Gš“,Y+$#3'B‰2f!

O@!

Cdef$™' ‰WÃ,g1DËÃmn{Bhv_Ëmn,B·!

!

)&;+g…†>;!
-)!

)&;+$™'¡/Y+g…†>;
ù)*+ú6@A{i×v…†>;6jkD›ólmixÁÀ{no'v/+6\Y+,pqÔ$Ö:ˆFkr‰À{no'vpqµ:,æG"™ió$A‰!

-/!

/+g)*+6a‡@A{JÏ'v•,i‰$ˆF'|F›ó!

!

\T,Os!
-)!

\T,OsTj',{„§‰!

!
!

nâs•‘.t¦-¦,’j!
/+•‘,’j!
-)!

`+X`*\ËÃÊ`6\)*>;$uA’j§H3‰{\`+X,v@ÙÚ\oË\Yw\iióËþÿ
\ŸÃ\#xy_6„§‰!

-)!

/+2e$ƒ‰XzŒ,|F›ó!

-/!

Ÿ›,{`6ÒhÏ‰{\Yw(œ\|}ó\#xy_6B$‘~{|F!

žÃ!

/+,°Wji$™'•#€•{|F
!

!

2K,rs
!

‚ƒQ'<œ`Ý•K…B$%&C*‰Š/€Ý•K&-.F‚ƒQ'<œ/Í+

'*

-)!

/+Y+,qk!

s4w" A•K/Q'…¤'‚'0`+X6BhSd$LM'+Ï!

!

s3w" ‚ƒQ/OPª=‰Š'…¤'‚'‚`+X,Am6\CDEX,ÓF9,dvX},”ŸæGHXI6JÏ'{mnK6‚!

-—!

½;,rs$ƒ‰X!

s2w" ‚ƒH•'„7'‚/+,`+Am6\)*+™ó"B‰!

-)!
!

s1w" •Ü*Q%&/OP@A¹l'„7
'‚

-)!

!

-)!

/+`+6¹Ë>;™ó‚ƒK{4A\#„{|F!

-)!

…†D,¤‡QiˆQ‰‰HwË6‚ƒ!

-)!

;Š9:{ü9DÏA
\`+XT`'û,Ì‹#$‚ƒTŠ7'!

žÃ!

)*+6/+,‚ƒKT™AÿŒ3+Ï
!

!

n-sÂÁ,9Â!
m¡¾Â!

s5w" ‚ƒQe*Q'9:/OPJFòG

-)!

/+›÷#,m¡¾ÂÀ{¢•"ó
O„!

-)!

)*+6‘’{Ž§A¾Â$/•!

-)!

¡/COœ&,/+›÷,)&Á§ÃT\)*+“$"~ü§XE§‰!

*Qe‚ƒQ'9i`C*‰Š¡¢'«2"-)!

01û,…fÄÂ,~üTFø!

'0*Qe•Ü*Q'óÛ$%M*Q-5Í+-)!

/+›÷,±QS.•il¯$#3')&Á,Fø!

34€Qâ'<œ`*Q*Q-'ùH:~•žÃ!

/+›÷±QSÝ,k•{|F
!

'‚
'0

*Qe‚ƒQ')*+*5„i899:8FH•Ke@a5û…
‚ƒQe*Q`@aH,5û…

'*

!
!

n•s+’ˆ,‘i!

s6w" C*'™š'IMK'‚'0‚ƒ'Ç²±0Év:5C*UV/JKL•N¸&_iŽ[C*/Q/F‚ƒ?Œ'ƒUF¢MF_˜UVF')*+*5›œ**áNžMC*yý/eŽ9€€Qâ'<œ€¼uOP

XGAó,‘i!
¹ËD6’“fÏX}T`¿XÏÀ{\/+6”fÏXGAóD›'
v¹ËD6\;Š•qg*Ùá–$-)!
ö¿XY>3'v/+D6\¬,—ÉD`+X,v@Tn8'
v`+X6˜“K$#3'ýþ{cÏ‰!

s7w" •8'24¨_'QR'0@a4'.¨F̀24sQ•ST'••sQ'„&K5Í+ý?

‚ƒQ'24¿'5Ò&IËP7e`FSTî‚Uî-2`2467'.¨5Í+*•Y4eMŽ9u[H,4'@a.¨
H,4'„75Í+Í-.'¥VÖ0.

ý?

H,45678[ý?'.s5Í+!

¹Ë,X`ó$•žŸš
\/+,X`óT,Õ+Ï!

-)!

¡/CO,zu{Ï&F¢/+016„§‰!

-/!

¡/CO$™¿X\£å.^É{JÏ'•gTÿŒ§XE§‰!

-—!

¡/CO{)*+,/+01$J<T¤M'ÉO{›ó×'!

CO!

)*+6/+T,‡²•D013+Ï
!

!

n¥s§Ã•,gh!
PÓåY+,„§ˆ!

*•Y45@a8FC*W»XÇ³e8967
C*W»XÇ³'èxé&IËŽ9?=Fª=‰Š`@a&.ÌPeÍ
+-)!

/#,3•{°¦D\°H.°¦Gš“{§M
X%ó\N#å,OsTj',{O„!

-/!

Éš/$%‰X\Gš“$N#åT™wi&XPÓåY+T¨©3'—˜,ñÃ{|F!

/;!

)*[\,#x,ñªT«ó$N#åTÞ8'(]"›'
vN#å¬Þ,§Ã{|F!

O@!

/#,PÓå,O„{”Ÿfgh!

!

¡/-,®…Ä.3•,°¦rˆ!

s10w" C*–—/OPY-áÓ¿'Z['‚'‚)*+$6š›Ï*Ùá–{›'{\/+$6Ï‰v/+œ$»l,Ð#{›'v!

CO!

J+ ¬¡,° !

s9w" C*W»XÇ³'67'Ò…
'‚'0)*+6\/+,À8,`+X,ÿŒ°™!

-—!
!

s8w" H,4'67'Ò…
'0
'0

-/!

C*‰Š€Y-áÓ/kM&P@aH,'./̈OPì2\]'ä^-)!

¡/$2™'¡/-#{¡/CO¯W,“61íDÏÏ‰À8$\/#,Gš“g/#,3•Tr°3'•g{„§‰v¡/-T…Ä§X±§‰
v3•r°TÞ8X±§‰
v!

/;!

)*+6¡/-T1íDÏÏ‰,D\/#,Gš“T5'À8$\‘²Ï³óT´µ!

CO!

/#3•,°¦g¡/-,°¶rˆ{/+,l‚,ghv§Ã,¢£§{|F!

CO!

)*[\{¡/-#T`ab·ÉD¸¹DÏX"\ö,TU{••gJÏ'ÉO{I‰!

!

)&Á§Ã$ƒ‰X!

s11w" CO2_¬/OP•`abKcd'‚*\

C*‰Š€•`abKcd/ef
CO2ãä/~§C*¿'Í+IËP

'0

gh{•i'CO2ãä'j/H,&-.

-)!

Y+$2™')&Á,íõÏ{æÝD”ºåTFø!

-)!

¡/COT€ˆÏ‰g»j{„§‰!

-)!

)&Á,¼qÖ:,æGg;Ô½^,½CD{™ió$A‰v§Ã,¢£§TFøv!

!

Ân§Ãg…f§Ã
!
-)!
!

*;i?F’a?¬jÂDPQI
EF’a?ÂDTIS+dCI?î™

/+,ÂnH\¡/C9Hs /§ÃÏÖ,…fÏ§Ã{™ió$A‰!

!

*;i?F’a?¬jÂDPQI
EF’a?ÂDTIS+dCI?î™

203Ž•9Ô ÕÖ5Öv Uš›U¢bU×¡N av5 bDE-9I6 ØDÙ2d B ØE(- BIuc bDE2F
ÚÛÌDWXD|2£D9B ØE(-ef Iuc UWXÜ$WÝÑÁd-Ë@2F!

土木学会論文集F4（建設マネジメント）,
Vol. 68, No. 3, 193-210, 2012.
!

(2) /+01,¹iÞQd9:$™'IJKggh! „~…•†yzLMÀŠE>4»Þß&?PQIÓS
TIÓST²$Î3ETIHI(ETIíîÓEbTt
êEOd/oEê:;•<•E‡•®•?¶¬X‚o’”ETIUVL`aXefg•àßð•XbcLwjŠE
FYx¬î™h•o\=Lv•”?efgdbc?¤þ
gháâWXopLE>4»Þß&LãWXPQ&|
40 |L 2008 ® 11 ÝL~•€•‚yzhÕÀo
\40 |DETIUVhæ‹%?ZUV¬IC[X\! !

! „~…•†yzh–dLNºloefg?…†“111cw;Ebc?…†“114 cw;LqlE…†“?%

ÞœJKUß;àá'(âãäUSåæš›S9çèéäUSåæbS!
á-2! PQI?TIUVL`aXefg
Z[lH! B```a b95```I b9c```c b9I```5 b9a```B bD ¡!

’”[ÊWXcwh5 w…†lE„9©?ëj–?’”E
5 ×’” 1 ×ÎC?•×hî™ÓLèËlŠ
E‡?êT*;1;Ï?Ô´Dî™ÔÔ ÕÖ5Öv! :,ÆêëUìí;ÏÐD|2Ád!

h\klo\v•”?ˆ‰há-2Eá-3 LhW\!

a) /+01$%&'IJK,¹iÞQd¾¿b) /+01$%&'gh,¹iÞQd¾¿
204

TIUVL`aXefgh]IXQ^CDE?-12

TIUVL`aXbch]IXQ^CDE?-13Å„Å„~…•†yzC•”•oTIUV?efgÆ? 11~…•†yzC•”•oTIUV?bcÆ? 14 cwhEcwhEî™?…†“dlo\UV?efgLqWX~

î™?…†“dlo\TIUVL`aXbc?~•€••€•‚ˆ‰há-2 LhW\É–ë•×DÅTIdP

‚ˆ‰há-3 LhW\É–ëj×Ô³Ào?DÅ@\=QI?ÞÙC¥ljTI•F–—hwíFXÆ
(100 ×)E û•X’7’”¬jÆ(130 ×)EÅTI?vdh[ÎN=jCÅâãÝ'h·!CZXÆ
(98 ×)EÅ0F-.L#”¬jÆ(77 ×)EÅ6…-žL1•³a’’X’7’
PQI?‹Œh·’FXÆ(85 ×)EÅTILPQŽ•h”¬jÆ(60 ×)EÅWHY=—˜CZX’7’”¬jÆ·’FXÆ(58 ×)C[X\(48 ×)EÅPQIdTI?NI½°L_=[XÆ
(46 ×)%èx¬•×DEÅ+dh9!loBoCI=·g

C[X\´WXÆ(51 ×)EÅ½Ê´AILPQI?•=·’F%èx¬×ÔL¬Ào?D
EÅ'2T?½Ê´AI=

XÆ147 ×;EÅPQI?Jìë;•‚•=·’F‰ljÆ142 ×;EÅbTtêS'èHIÓd?-®

XÆ140 ×;EÅbT{‘LMN>Á˜xLK}CZ

L\s=[XÆ140 ×;EÅ[\HI(TI)dFGHI

XÆ138 ×;C[X\(PQI)D’÷=¥¶Æ140 ×;EÅTINI?sxg! ÑOE•×=ej?DEÅbTI°JJFh·!CZ

L\s=[XÆ136 ×;EÅÁ+?4iìNdTI?

XÆ19 ×;EÅè?dh3’”klŠ·!CZXÆ

0FiìND¥¶Æ1
32 ×;C[X\

21 ×;
120 ×;EÅCO2 LÅ=º»šëìFL¬XÆ1! ÑOE×Ô=ej?DEÅ|Ï?êÃh•X?LØ•C[X\hþWXÆ10 ×;EÅ[\Ÿv?[$Z=7’”¬v?ˆ‰’”E0F-.•Ž•´hnpŠETId

jÆ18 ×;EÅž3¨©=7’”¬jÆ18 ×;E?ÞÙC¥ljTIhpƒWopLÅPQI?•h·’ ÅTB¡¢(;{`)=7’NLìjÆ110 ×;C[X\lojÆdj¶Új^Í=§’X\‡vC‘Î•X}‰v?ˆ‰’”ETIT(?ÅÆg=ej¬’C E

dlŠESkd?ñQEBoCI?·g´E½Ê´AI

ÅTI78Cíî=ºN‚w’1¶’ÆLwjŠÚja

?nƒE>Á˜xL–…V=[X\o³lEbTI°J

bhcjŠjXvd=§’X\=LÅTI?vdh[Î
\ N#”¬jÆdj¶î™=ôj=JF?·!• CO2 LÅdj¶}‰Û?…VDëì¬j
Ed(xLTILUVTIUV?„~…•†yzCETIS+dCI³a=lM¶dWXÉLEÚe?WH•WtüL
wjŠ#Ä=
î™loefgÅBŠ?+dQ/?ª•ÆÅè?d?9 \]lŠjXvdLfijoÓ=ôjd’§•X\ð”!Æ?•×DE‡•®• 51 ×E20 ×C[X\TIS+LETILUVloÉLWòLÔ¿l‡¶¬
E½Ê´?
dCI’”î™=ô’ÀoÅPQIdTI?Þ•LMX ‰lðEbTtêd?-®?‰lð
EFGHId¥¶W¤G}‰ÆD 100 ×EÅ½Ê´AI?nƒÆD47 ×d

tüEgh¬TINIETId?4NN?¥jL–E\

C[X\Åè?d?9!Æ?•×=••ej–??
EPshûÀŠjX\o³lEUV‰lá”ìí@lŠž•

QIdTIS+dCI?èLE_‰?efgL¦WXÃŠìX[\Ÿ¨©?ùäðEž3¨©ETB?;{\zÄL,Z¬¥j=¬jvd=§’X\—ðDEÎ³¤,¬bcdlŠ-Äð•Šj¬jd’§
•X\

204

土木学会論文集F4（建設マネジメント）, Vol. 68, No. 3, 193-210, 2012.
!

LUQCZX\óÝô‹ŒS™š›š?œ•!
! TI?‹Œ?%C–E?X+h…²…+Eös••t•LMX?uE’’N+v.E}d¬1DEghhµjE
œ•WX?LÉè=’’X\TIS+dCI’”DET
I?«–²•LMXÚBín=ýþ
ETI?ghghMì.wWÕZdj¶Ã“=[X\! PQIDEœ•WÕZ#ÄdlŠE‹Œ³aC¬ìE
TI?¨©•[\Ÿxph5æTIxäh[UŠjX\
TICDEVÝÜIÓÛ?ìœ•Ú‹ínDÕ§•ŠZ!

o=E¬Iåa?ìœDÓd`1¬ìEœ•O{=bc

á-3! PQI?TIUVL`aXbc!"#$%&'()*+,-.%/0123/4567.%/018/!

L¬ÀŠjX\

9:;<! =>>>? 84@>>>A
84B>>>B
84A>>>@ 84?>>>= 8CDE!
*;1;Ï?Ô´Dî™Ôó›ôžŸ?y !

! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! F GH@HI! JKLMN%OP%QR!

TICDEÎ³TIUV?H¼=K¬jvd–[NE!

¬`ETIUV?„~…•†yzCETIS+dC

6…-žL1•³a’’X’§’”¬jdj¶bc=[X\I-®?\sÆÅ;{?\z—ðÆ?•×DE‡•®
JK'OPWXYZ[*+\]4^%_`aOPUVbcdefWXgbhi*+Yjk4

TIŽ•DÿÑyÔ=K¬ìEÑy[oN?½°=ë=L

S?TOPUV!

• lmngo+%pqrsOPtupvwKxytBBzx4{|Cq}~%K•€•ytB‚zx4
32 ×E40 ×E10 ×C[NEep?×ÔL¬ÀŠjX\ ¬Xäå=[X\PQ&|?íîD³´äåL[NETIqƒ„…
†‡yt@Izx4qˆ%‰ytBzxCŠX‹qJKN%Œ•ypEbcLqWXÃÄ?c‚ŽCŠX‹SF GH@H•T!
Ž•?WVžŸ?y =‰ljdj¶íz=[X\
PQIdTIS+dCI?èL
PQI’”ETIÓåa?¨©Zž•Ž•WVÉ?[•=[Xvd=§’X\~•€•‚yzDEZUV?PQIÓhqÒdlŠj \ŸhETILUVWXPQ&|L–ŽzlŠÓljE
XopE„~…•†yzCTIÓ=¤êlobc•UV ÎoETIŽ•?…•F•{•|ªÛ?[\ŸhŽzl
‰Lž•Xbc?M¶LETILÚeL$HWXRLDÚilLìjbcD+°=eì¬Ào–?d’§•X\ŠÓljdj¶þÍ=[X\TIŽ•DEPQŽ•?«•FJ••LTI!?~|ïö;•‚h}$lo–?=ôj
\eé?PQŽ•?…

(3) /+01,9:DßàˆFÀgh•FS{•|ª&|=TIŽ•?…•FS{•|ªhÕ! PQI?TIUV?„~…•†yzd~•€•‚yz¶vd=CZ•áETIUVWXPQ&|?6…-ž?

Cáâð•obcLwjŠE„~…•†yz?bcC!
SGT•‘’“K%cdef!

~JLw¬=Xefg=[X\‡?opETIŽ•L¦!

F GH@H•! JKLMN%OPUV!

!

joJK'OPWXYZ[*+\]'•”‘•YcdefWX“K'–|—hi*+Yjk4l
5 7ÜL§aŠE‡•®•~ÕX\

WX[\ŸhEWVL³aC¬ìE…•FS{•|ª–npq˜J‘]Y™š*+OPyt?‚zx4{|Cq›œ•w%’yt@Bzx4q›œ•wž˜J“Kyó°ôHIg?—˜!

qÒLWXþÍ=kŠjXd’§•X\

t=Izx4qŸ ¡Kyt?zx4qˆ%‰ytBzxCŠX‹SF GH@H=‚T!
óÞôIœ¡?¤¥!
! PQIDETIHI?@\•WHY?—˜LqWX\!
s=Új\HIgh—˜WXLDENI4-.dŽ•´ ! PQILDÅNI4?½°DET4•TY•4?Ê'hnpE}V?ojNI•F–—?|,=ýþdj¶Ã 7?ÑÆdj¶î™L¯ið•X4?°3_Û?dÎ1
206
j=[X\DEx¬FGAQdlŠ?ÅT4Æd
EÑÉ
“=[X\
! PQIETIS+dCId–LEbT-.?jÿkþ

x¬AQdlŠbTþ2Ó=-.WXÅNI4ÆCD,

Dôj–??EWHY=—˜CZX’1¶’hablŠ 3=¶¬X\! PQIDv•ÎC>…Q!hR€LT4•40hÉè
jX\TB?;{? 6 Í=Z—4CEbTþ2Ó?4 7? 1 =\ÿþ2ÓC[NETB?½Ê´=n`Cj¬j\ d¦!h’aŠwìÀŠZo\ÑOENI4DE3TL‡?opLENI4?-.•bTAI=lÿ´lLìj\ jZE‡?oC`’hmpEC>¬/{CA/WX\s+dCI’”ETB?½Ê´hmnWX¨©
E½Ê´?

°C[X=E•N‚lQÙX‘C¸¹LD¬NLìj\$Î3?Åº=ýþd?Ã“=[X\! TI’”EPQIÓLqlŠETI?4NNh-²Õ

\‡?ÑO! PQIDE[\HILMXbTAIdFGHI?pq ZEe›F‚LƒÙXÕZdj¶Ã“=[X
CEbTAI?Ž•´d+dSk?opL
ENI4?„?.*’÷=¶¬XvdhablŠjX\[\HI?W\„Eg?[XNI4tü=§’NLììEV,ÉLŸ==mÎXpqd¶¬ EghëpXýþ=k¨pŠjX
he›F‚CwìXvd=bcL¬ÀŠjX\
NETIDnoæz?‰Lp\ð•X\o³lEvvC[U”•o[\HIDEq2T?bTAI?oêhíl

! TIUVÉLEBŠ?bTtêd?-®?‰lð=b

ŠjX\>2T•F2TCDE'èá@LMXrd‘C

cL¬ÀŠjX\>4»Þß&CDEBŠ?PQIÞ&pqHI–Õ§•Š`NEÑ4?þ5hâoFáEV,dbTtê=Þß&hQ‚lŠ
ETIUVhnpŠjX\

205

土木学会論文集F4（建設マネジメント）, Vol. 68, No. 3, 193-210, 2012.

ó”ô¨©K?bc(”)¨©K?bc? 5 7ÜL7aXvd=CZo\]Ì! TB?B¿yz?…•E\ÿS\zbTþ2Ó?ñQ

CDEÅ2.PQI?RIUV?yzÆÅ3.PQI?TI¬1CETB?½Ê´=‰ljdj¶bc=[X\T

UV?yzÆ?ˆ‰h–dLEv•”?7ÜŒdLEb

IS+dCIDETB?B¿yzhHnWXWtü
E½

cd‡?qshtuWX\Ê´hHnWX¨©iìN=¤þC[Xdî™lŠjX\ ó°ôHIg?—˜!
! TB?½Ê´hHnWXLD
EbT?§¢E†£YE! RIUVSTIUV?yz?ˆ‰ERIETId–LE;{Eþ2ÓhôõlobTXv=ýþL¬X=
EbT@\hdXvd?‰lðhbcdWX¬I=ô’Ào\têDbTXv?klh˜2WXvd=CZX=EÑäRIUVlo¬I?ôìD³´íîC[X\TI?oê

LD07x¬‡ˆl’Òð•¬jvd=ôj
\bTtê

DEsj?d?•VC+d?°3=eŽlŠ`N
EbTJ??Ó=E½Ê´hHnWX?D‰lj\VÝ¡¢?

þ2ÓDbTAIÛ?¦t=•j\TB?½Ê´=n`‰jL*ÃWXýþD[X=EPQI’”E½Ê´WX

Cj¬jdv©=ôìEWHYh—˜CZX’1¶’\ÓLqlŠbTXhF£lŠÓljdj¶þÍ=[X\

shi_ŠjX&|=ôj
\! TI?\º¨©LwjŠEPQI’”E¨©?qÒh! PQI?RIUVL`jŠDE/“ü.hQÀo7|

TIUVhpƒW¬ILŽzlŠÓlj
E¨©hCr´

RB?MNEPQI?Ž•••Ro?-.•h·’WHlŠÓljdj¶þÍ=[X\¼=[Ào\PQI?TIUVL`jŠDEPQI?•
hj’lŠ0F-.dŽ•´hnpXHh…VWXÃ“(4) /+01$23'9:,66=ô’Ào\

PQI?TIUVCDETIUVhpƒWBOPQI! @AB?•þCIC[XRISTISPQI=‡©À?'(dTIS+dCI?¦ÑÓL„~…•†yzhÕ ŠeŽWXvdDE@AB?eŽLw¬=X\bcDôjefgdÑäxbchÜklE‡?ˆ‰h–dLPQ

j–??EBOPQ&|?RISTIUVLDEŽ•´E

IÓL~•€•‚yzhÕÀo\,-Ž,•‘CgåK=…Vð•ŠjX\‡?opEPPQI?TIUVL`jŠEPQI?Ž••d¸¹-

QI?RIUVhnpXopLDEUVÊ6L`aX¨.•h·’lŠETI?‘CghåKðFXefg=…

©Zž•Fx¬‹ŒÔbS•0£«Ôb=Ñw?qsL

Vð•X\ÑOEHIg?—˜E‹Œ?œ•EžŸ?y¬Xd’§•X\TIUVhnpXopLDEUVÊ6EIœ¡?¤¥=¤þ¬bcC[X\„~…•†CDE L`aX¨©Zž•FxÔbdd–L
ETB?½Ê´hTIL¦§X¨©?“Ôl?þÍ–î™ð•o\npX¨©=ýþd’§•X\„~…•†DEPQIETIS+dCI?‘ÓhqÒ! o³lEUVÊ6?FxÔb=ERISTI?T‚LLÕjE~•€•‚DPQIhqÒLÕÀo\‡?ˆ‰E w¬=Xvd=¤þC[X\RI?oêE÷¬I=E‘
efgL`jŠDEPQIdTIS+dCI?‘Ó?GC,-?Ž,EBC‹Œ?åKE•)ª•‚?£«ER

ÃgDë’Ào\v?.ÒDE]yzLÞ•loTIS

C~?Q/S•)Û?šëìFƒ£LåaŠï•h$a+dCI?ODEPQI?TIUVLRåZ¬O=ô’

Xvd=¤þdjÙX\ð”LEPQID.*‘C=ôÀoopd’§•X\ÑOEbcL`jŠDETI•+ì•0£«L\¡•¬opERœS•ÃS½)Id?-

dCI=¤êlŠjXL–’’§”c
EPQI=Š‹L®–¤þL¬Xd’§•X\.aQpŠj¬jbc=[Ào
\v?.ÒDEZUV?

! TI?oêE÷¬I=ETB?½Ê´hmnl
ENI4PQIÓLdÀŠDETILÚeL$HWXRLDÚi

h-.lEŽ•´hnpŠE+d?SkYhñ•l
ETIlLìjbcD+°=eì¬Ào–?d’§•X\?‘CghåKWXvdLûtævd=¤þdjÙX
\yz?ˆ‰LDEqÒdloPQIETIS+dCIóÝô‹ŒS™š›š?œ•!

?˜>LMX/{D[X–??
E„~…•†yzDôª! ôì?¬I=ERISTIL`aX#ÄE™š›šE¬I¢’”•oî™C[NEx(x¬efgdbc?ä

‹Œ?œ•=bcd~ÕŠjX\RICDEBC‹Œ?

åháâCZod’§•X\œ•{«ª=ERC~?œ•E½°E‘CY?s4¬1ERIíîLÔ}xL¦§ÀŠjX\TIUVCDENI

4.! -+./+01$%&'ghg#„$23'
LÀ

4?`’TÙE?X+h…²…+E?uE’’N+v.E}dv?»‘‹ŒEsxqshœ•WXvd=bcdð•ŠjX\! PQI?RISTIUVL`aXbcLDEðÎƒÎ

! RISTId–LEVÝÜIÓLqWXFx¬ìœ•¬–?=[X=E‘Ód–(°)HIg?—˜E(Ý)‹ŒSÚ‹ínDzÚlŠjX–??
E¬Iåa?ìœDÓd

™š›š?œ•E(›)žŸ?y E(Þ)Iœ¡?¤¥E`1¬ìE‡?zÚ=qrs?Ñwd’§•X\!

206

土木学会論文集F4（建設マネジメント）, Vol. 68, No. 3, 193-210, 2012.

! RI‹Œ?œ•DEBCœwEfûSÁd.5LMÀó”ô¨©K?bc!

Š¶¬NEJÞþ~ª1`NLj’¬jopEÚ×ín! ¬I=RILUVWXoê
ERB{LMN¬I=RB

h.aXvd=ýþd’§•X\

hþ2WXvd=CZ¬j¬1
E¨©LMXUV›œ=! TI?oêDEös••t•LMX?uE’’N+v[X\5]^h<lŠRBhYNX˜4{Ý?"QC
E.vDghhµjœ•WXLÉè=’’X\‡?Bç?

,¨D6‡ð•ww[X=›œDøÀŠjX
\bTLölj«–²•?TIÓLMXÚBín=ýþC ! ÑOETI?oêETIHI(L¬Xop?UV›œ[Xd’§•X\‘Ód–EBç?RIÓETIÓd?

DE¨©KD¬j\l’lETI?¨©=•LbTtêÞ•(¨h,ìvd=¤þC[Xd’§•X\hqÒLlŠjXvddETI?¨©=?0’”§’Nó›ôžŸ?y !

Lìjvd=EUVL`aXbcdízð•ŠjX\ð! FGHI?¼½dGLEBO?PQ&|Díî=³´”LTIL`jŠDETB?½Ê´h•ólŠjXbT

WXäåL[NET&ž]=JKlE'èŸZŽ¦’”X?NF£S;{?\z—ð?^c=[X\?YV=‰lì¬Nww[X\‡?opERISTI?

! PQI?RIUVhmnWXoêLDERI‘C{ÝUVL[oNE¨©Zžh9!loj¬IDôj=EP•˜4{Ý?þ56‡¬1?UV›œ?eJ=ýþdt

Q&|DERTIåa?¨©Zž?qÒ?C[Xdj¶Ù”•X\PQI?TIUVhmnWXoêLDETI

bc=ízð•ŠjX\?¨©hCr´WXdGLETI?\º¨©hbTtê

! RICDERBû•L’’X¦!•Ž•SAQ?nV J??ÓL–ŽzWXvd
ETB?½Ê´hpƒW¬I
žŸ=ýþL¬X\TICDEÎ³TIUV?H¼=K

LqlŠbTXh£hWXvd
ETB?B¿yz?Hn¬jvd–[NETIŽ•?WV¬1?6…-žL1•=ýþL¬Xd’§•X\³a’’X’7’”¬jdj¶\s?’=[X\

5.! ¾Á!

! ¬I?RIUVhnpXoêLDERI?¨©Zž•[\Ÿ?qÒhEÅRIÓÆ³aC¬ìERILíÑ“h”ükW¬IERNI.@•AQBC¬1hîæR?

]?@DE@A?næBOL`aXPQI?RIS¬IL–”UXvd=ýþL¬Xd’§•X\TIL`

TIUVL`aXbcdefgL¦lŠE_}yzE„

jŠ–ðªLE¨©Zž?qÒhETILÑ“h”ük

~…•†yzE~•€•‚yzhÕjEHIg?—˜E

W¬IL”UXvd=ýþL¬Xd’§•X\ÎoTI‹Œ•™š›š?œ•EžŸ?y EIœ¡?¤¥E¨Ž•LqWX[\ŸhEWV³aC¬ìE…•FS{•©K?bc?5 cwL7ÜlŠEbcdefghz”’|ª–qÒLWXvd=qrsL¬Xd’§•X\

LlEUVhmnWXop?qrshtulo\RICóÞôIœ¡?¤¥!

DUV=n`CjXopLEUVlo¬IhqÒLlE

! PQI?RISTIUVCDEBŠR3•bTtêd

TICDUV=¨ÎÀodv©C[Xop
E•LTIU?Þ•¦Ñ?|,=bcd¬ÀŠjX\VhpƒWBOPQ&|dTIS+dCIhqÒLlo
\\! RIUVÉLDEBCNw?…4LwjŠBŠR3d ! ]?@?žŸÏC•oˆ^hJgLhW?(ê¦Ñhy-WXvd•RB?û•L`jŠBŠR (1) RIUVETIUVd–LEHIg?—˜E‹Œ?
3?HRêÃh•XvdEUV‰D/0ü.¬1?Bçœ•EžŸ?—˜=¤þ¬bcdð•ŠjX\PQ?GðNILÞ•WXvdC
EBŠ?R3d?Þ•¦Ñ

I?Ž•••¸¹-.•LMNERICD‘Cg=h,ìvd=ýþd’§•X\åKWXefg=Ñ0L“”•ETICD0F-.

! TIUVÉLDEBŠ?bTtê?WHh•¶–?CDdŽ•´=nævd=…Vð•ŠjX\¬ìE…•ŠjXbT-.hbTtêdGLnpŠjì–(2) PQI?RIUVLDE{¨©K?UV›œ=[NE?C[Xdj¶–z=ýþd’§•X\

TIUVLDUV›œD¨©KD¬j=ETI?¨! ë—RI•Zj[\]h[˜WXRNI¯Õ•
EMNO©=•LbTtêhqÒdlŠ`NE?0’”§’

PB?{‘ENI4NQLMXTI?‘C¸¹?-.¬1NLìjvd=bcC[X\ÎoETB?;{?Z

LMNEBŠR3EbTtêLdÀŠ–oj¿=[Xvd—4E½Ê´?…•LMNEbTAI?WHYh—hEUVWXPQ&|=hWvd=¤þd’§•X\˜lLìjvd=bcC[X\! PQIdTIL`aX4iìN?¥j?M¶LE`™

(3) PQI?RIUVhnpXoêLDE‹Œœ•S•

j?Iœ¡h.wl[¶?=‰ljoêLDEPQI?

0£«SUV[$L¦WXUVÉ?FxÔb
EUV„EgdTI?e°3?oðhê§Fo¸šx¬NI4¬IÛ?¨©Zž?qÒŽ,=¤þC[NERI‘

h"QWX¬1?E¶I¢?Â•’”MNoj–?h‘C{Ý•˜4{Ý?þ56‡LMXUV›œ?eJükWï•=¤þC[Xd’§•X\–ýþC[X\!

207

土木学会論文集F4（建設マネジメント）, Vol. 68, No. 3, 193-210, 2012.

UVÊ6?FxÔb=RI?T‚Lw¬=XM¶L
E wvd=.5L¬ÀŠ`N
ER?¬I?ÎÎCRIh$
RIUVlo¬I=Eeé?R3dÞ•¦Ñh,ZaXÓDqÒLlŠj¬j\¬=”E‘C,-?Ž,EBC‹Œ?åKE•)ª! 2008 ® 10 ÝLERT¤IŸZF¥D%½¬IŸZF•‚?£«ERC~?Q/S•)vLåaŠï•W¥vd¦êð•E9]²sŸZF¥d¬Ào\RT¤

Xvd=¤þC[X\ð”LEPQID.*‘C=IŸZF¥=‰ÀŠZo¨©Zž?ôìDE9]²sôì•0£«L\¡•¬opERœS•ÃS½)IŸZF¥?RT/CHIL§Z0=•ŠjX\o³lEd?-®=¤þL¬Xd’§•X\

RTI¨¨©ZždE%½¬IåaFxZžDE$»(4) PQI?TIUVhnpXoêLDEUV¬IÛ?

ÃN?RT/CÄ¨dí©CIÄ¨?ªÍNC‡!ð¨©Zž?qÒŽ,dd–LETIhpƒW¬IL•ŠjX\qlŠbTXh£hWXvdETB;{?—4•B! 2009 ® 6 ÝLRB{=0%ð•ŠÅRI‘C{ÝJ?

¿yz?Hn=ýþC[X\UVÊ6?FxÔb=?{ÝvÆLMXRB?XYC?«9û•=ERB?¬

TI?T‚Lw¬=XM¶LETIUVWX¬I=E %9!SBçRIÓd?-®S
1 %JK?I×-ÕR'bTtêdÞ•¦Ñh,Z¬=”ENI4h-.lE ?RI$H?.5?–dCefL¬Ào\RB{?¸]Ž•´hnpŠE+d?SkYhñ•lETI?‘®¯C[XÅMNÓ•*Æh“ÔlE.58ZCD[XCghåKWXvdLûtævd=¤þd’§•X\ =ERIÓJ??{Ý=RBh9!WXvd=CZXM¶L¬Ào\

6.! ÂÔ,gh(2)" <œ'É~! ]?@DERISTILUVWXPQI? ’”?y

! yzÉ×J·EPQ&|?RIUVLwjŠDEFx

z`MAtuhnpo–?C[NEð”Lô¿x¬yz

yz=¬ð•Šj¬jopE‡?UVÔháâCZ¬j\`MAtu=ýþdjÙX\˜L.aV•?RIST

o³lEPQ&|?RIUV?3w?’÷?¶öEÅ˜I¦ÑÓ?yzhÕ¶ýþ=[X\ÎoEPQIJ??

4{Ý78HIÆLwjŠD
E2005®’”2009®9ÝÎC

I¢LMXRTIUVLwjŠ–yÕEPQIdj¶I?¦T=[NEI¢PUVÓÔ=yÕ”•ŠjX?Cv¢L¡¢WXbcLwjŠtuWXýþ=[X\ÎoEvL§!WX\TICDPQI?UV=¨ÎÀo••L[Xop
E_‰E ! ˜4{Ý78HI1RB…•FOa;LMX
UV{Ý
UV=nævdLMNE1?M¶¬bc=‘_X’LwÔDE2009®9ÝCEx>C414{Ýd¬Ào\ 2006®9Ý

jŠyzWXýþ=[X\?É×CD173{ÝC[NE3®èC241{Ý?ñQC[! ]?@DEPQI?RISTIUV^c?Ñ0LûN

X\˜LE2008®9Ý’”2009®9ÝÎC?1®èCD94{t`³LWÞ¬j\@A?næBçCDERTIdPQÝ?ñQd¬NE1®èC?ñQÔDE˜4{Ý78H

I=•þ¬CIC[X\_‰–PQIdRTI?-®LI£¨J»EÉ–ô’Ào\I¢P?{ÝÔ?ÍêDE

wjŠ?æ‹•?@=nüEBç?·g´=ƒ”•Xv

2009®9ÝÉ×?°TCEPQI148|136H;ERœ&dhÍæ\|79|119H;C[X\2008®’”2009®?1®èCUVlo{ÝdlŠDEPQI=44{ÝCx(?47HERœ

êÃ A! 9:ûÄ¯Å,)*+,-+01,DÏ

&|D14{ÝC15HC[NEè±dlŠEPQI=ÉôUVI¢d¬ÀŠjX\v?vd’”EPQI?RIU! PQI?RIUV?yzÉ×12007®2Ý;J·?Y

V=BÚLn`CjXvd=§’X\¬`Ev?˜4{

ZdlŠERIUVL¦§X¨©?0%`MAEUV?

Ý78HIDERB{?0%C2009®CnoWXvdLYåLwjŠ~ÕX\¬Ào\! RB{0%LMNE7YC?²a&|v?Ñä{ÝL(1)" AQ<œ/5kPLM'-l

MXRIUV=efL¬ÀŠJ·ERBh9!lŠRI! RIUVLDERB{?M¶¬{¨©K?UV›œ=íîhÕ¶{ÝDBÚLñQlŠjX\0%RB{=A[X\yzÉ×J·ERI?ôª¬Zj[Åº•RI?

Õð•o2009®12ÝJ·’”2012®2ÝÎCCRILUV(£•åK?ýþg=ß^ð•
ERIL¦§XUV›œ

lo{ÝD763CE1®ÊN`šUVÔD381C[X\0%=07xL6‡ð•o\R?`šUVÔ67LàÕŠÊ6³LñÙŠjX\0%‰?

! 2007 ® 4 ÝJ·LERI?¨©Zž?Ñ0=ERIL

UV{Ý763?I¢P?ÔDERœ¦-CI=1711x(¥,UVWXR?¬IL–-p”•XM¶L¬Ào\o?22H;ERIS¤CI=127117H;EPQI=113³lER?¬I=5 ®JÏL-4RIÓd¬XTÙh– 115H;EO}I=4216H;C[X\¶I¢’”?UV

208

土木学会論文集F4（建設マネジメント）, Vol. 68, No. 3, 193-210, 2012.

CDEPQIDRœ¦-CI?=LôjI¢C[NEPoûNtühHnWX–?C[X\v?HI?¬’CEQI?RIUV=$jŠjXvd=§’X\

Å4. (&)Iœ¡?¤¥ÆCÀÑloÅPQI?„Egd
TI?e°3?oðhê§Fo¸šx¬NI4Æ?,êÃB! 9:ûÄ¯Å,)*+,/+01,DÏ

3=æ‹ð•ŠÚžlo
\! PQI?TIUVLDERB{?M¶¬{¨©L`a(2)" <œ'É~

XUV›œD¬j–??ETI?e@\g•Iœ¡K?

! PQI?TIUVrsLwjŠDEÅPQIdBç?

¥j¬1?^c=[X\yzÉ×12008 ® 12 Ý;J·E Šfî¹HIÆh>ÁÂÃÄ=FÁlod
v©Ex>’
T8´d>ÂÄ?Ôb?–dC
EBç?TIdPQI=” 240 5?rÁ=[NE2009 ® 6 ÝLí 1 =7dlŠ-®hdN¬=”EPQI?TIUVhnpXÅTPÞ

104 5=…4ð•o\…á•oHIh–•JPL“XdE

ÙÆ?YZ==?M¶L]3´lŠ`NEx>L”=N

É–ô’Ào?DÅ€•ÆdÅTIÆC
Ejc•– 25

¨pŠjX\v?YåLwjŠ~ÕX\

5C[Ào\! ÅPQIdBç?Šfî¹HIÆC…4ð•oTI(1)" *Q<œ/5kPLM

dPQI?-®hƒX 25 ?Þß&?¶öCEPQI?

! Bç?TIdPQI?-®ÅTPÞÙÆLwjŠDETIUVL¦§XÞß&D 18 C[NE‡?%Âh=L

2009 ® 1 ÝE>ÁÂÃÄÖê²s¾dT8´bT-.0

hW\j§ŠPQITIÃaÄÞß&Eü•ÞTPGDE‘Ä?-%CÅBç?TIdPQI?-®LwjÙHnÞß&EÅ"»Ò9]Æ5BçbT{‘Þß&E

ŠÆ?Ã#hE÷Ø4Ð»PQIZÊ0¾d÷Ø4Ð» 3’»ÉKBçTISPQI·g´Þß&EÇ¹»&
T×ZÊ0¾L)klo\ÈjÎÀd+E°Èª"}Þß&EÉÊ»ËÌôÍT! ‡?ÏŒDE‘Ä=Þ•lŠEBO{‘hÖêx’

ISPQIÞß&E(Î»›>:B8Ï3-.Þß&E

w}‰xLHnWX€×’”ETIdPQI=-®l3Ð»,Ý5Šfî¹SbÑ3Þß&EÒk»Ó3©

oûtühHnWX–?C[X\‡?ÏŒh=Lµ¶ìbiìNÞß&E>4»ÔKBçbiìNÞß&E

WX\

Õ€»úÖBçPQISTPGÙº»ªæ‹Þß&E! lPQIDEBç?¸šCIC[NE‡?˜2WX×¤»›Ø¡Bç·g´Þß&EÙÚ»¶övBçŠ

ÝdEŽd•™š›švh·’lŠERTIE€•v

fî¹HIHnÞß&EÙÚ»EÚë®3Iª•Þß?¶I¢d-®loHILMNEPQI?·•h{‘&Eë#»ÛÜ5PQISTI·g´Þß&Eë#»

WXdGLEBO?CI•·”lhÔÙXvd=ùp

ÝWD”b?3R HnÞß&E>Ü»¹®S¹TISP”•X\QIGÙÞß&EÞ]»ß]àXðdbTiìNÞß

! ÎoETI78CDEbTLÅ¼qshHnWX€&\v?M¶LE9]÷BCPQI?TIUV=¨Î

×’”Eè??¤×x¬ÚALïpŠ`NEè?ÚA

ÀŠjX\Lýþ¬0F-.vLÊoÀŠDEBç?Ú¡h”Î

! >4»Þß&L`jŠD
EBç?PQ&|dbTtê

ÙbTtêvdPQ&|=-®lwwEPQ&|?Ý

LMNEo’•ÎTIPQIÞðtêE5³bT-.Þ

d•Ždvh·!WXvd=2}C[X\ÎoEv•ðtêEgáTPGðHI(=Q‚ð•ŠEPQI?T”hÃ_Šè??ÚAYhŽ,WXvdDEBç?í

IUV=]3´lE>4»ÏCDEâãEäåEÔK?

©•ÿ!L¸Ñ}‰h–o”WdjÙX
\3 BçC–TPÞÙ=nƒ%C[X\! 2008 ®©í 2 =[%à\L`jŠDE>ÁÂÃÄCD
TPÞÙh5æPQI=¶I¢d-®loHI?Ôb? 0L=>
op?PQIdBç?Šfî¹HIhET8´CD0F1) jk! ë¿9]?PQIEæ¸¥¾E1963.

-.Bç-®º»ªHI¬1h¼½lŠjX\÷Ø4Ð2) •€çè¿PQIh•loÝ«Eé>|E1993.

„z2…
»L`jŠDEPQZÊ0¾dT×ZÊ0¾?-®h* 3) •€çè¿§=>PQI?º‚d)ƒL¦WX?@

7LƒNEínOM©lì`¾jloj\m

MN†‡ˆ‰…E2005.

! >ÁÂÃÄDðHI?opL2008 ®©[%à\C354) Ÿ]oêë¿9]?PQCIE9]í©¥å|E1999.

+ÌhTKlŠ`NE1 5ÊoNÉë 2500 ÚÌh\º5) PQIª•¸Ÿ¿%½PQI?¥78S¥5o£«?op?

lo\ÑOET8´D 2008 ®©í 2 =[%à\LÅ0¬I-®L¦WX¯°±²°•
E2002.

F-.Bç-®º»ªHIÆdlŠ58 +ÌE2009 ®©

6) !"#$¿PQI?¥78nk
E›ìí©¥¢|E2003.

[%à\LÅbT-.Q¿´STI{‘HIÆdlŠ

7) ÁÂfí¿¬I?RIUV?ž¯xÃ*dbc„BO%½P

1238 +ÌhTKlo\jc•–TIdPQI=-®l

209QIhqÒdloÚÛ7Ÿ
E2007.

土木学会論文集F4（建設マネジメント）, Vol. 68, No. 3, 193-210, 2012.
8) ÁÂfí¿Bç%½PQI?RIUVL[oÀŠ?¬IÃÄ 11) !"#$¿PQéR?WWpE%&F^¥|E2004 .
12) !"#$¿¥78LêˆWXPQI
E›ìí©¥¢|
E2004.

dbcERIíî-&! RIíî?@EVol.45E2007.

9) ÇÈîïEÉ! ‡9¿Ê{LèéWXRË‘CdPQI?ô 13) !"#$¿PQI’”D_ÎXBçšëìF
EÞó¶FjE2006.
14) PQ‚ïð²•ñ•çô0S!"#$¿í 4 îPQ‚ïðÌ´ˆÍEÁ+-&! BM:;••ðëš—ìñ^_½
E
Vol.14E2006.

²•ñ•òó•²—¢À¾
E2009.

10) ,Ðò¯¿%½PQI?ôÌ´ˆÍL`aXôÌ´©dí(2012. 1. 27 aê)îrs?¦ÑE9]íîÎÏ-&^½EVol.9E2010.

ENTERING AGRICULTURE AND FORESTRY OF CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRYIN UNDER POPULATED AREAS
Masako YONEDAThe Japanese construction market has decreased since the late 1990s. In under-populated areas, diversification of construction companies into agriculture and forestry has begun to maintain local economy.
1. The local construction companies that entered agriculture are investigated, and current situations, issues and possibilities are verified.
2. The local construction companies aiming at the forestry entry are investigated, and current situations,issues and possibilities are verified.
3. Problems of both forestry and agricultural entries are arranged, and the measures are examined.

210