Anomalies
symmetry ofA

whenit

E.
.
g

when

isAnomaly of global symmetry

Nothingtheis

Rather thanif theWarditharmless,theory itself.

theorydoes

Absence oft HooftA

you doisanomalyit.

Nothingsymmetry.
le g anomalous.

.

more.

unacceptable !

is

sense

is

importantanjust thatisuseful information

make

not

may
is

becomewrong

really gauge it.
andusefulunderinvariantanomaly of=>

It

as

a

quantumtheory.

criterionof consistency.

anomalyimportantIt

notglobal symmetrygauge

usgives

Anomaly of gauge symmetryThe

harmless.

below forSee.

anomalous.
procedurechange of measure is understoodidentity)be.

the classicalquantum system loses

topath-integral measure

theiswith thewrong

said

isby regularization

brokenisactionsymmetry of

a

not

it

classical

theanomalyofwithanomalous
theRather,information of
the RG

when

you

theory itself
the,long asanomaly is anthetheory.

flow :

high energy (or elementary) theory
lowas

try to·energy (or effective) theory

Suppose we have
Euclidean

aactionsymmetries

classical system ofS(b)S(p]:This may be

madeby coupling

it=

gives

togaugeisafield A.

it:

S1A9 PST SCA P),=,,(Classical "ganging" .

.

withsystem

abackground (or external(or correlation function)

The partition(Gabe-S(a=invariantz(AS)=If DasP"
Thenposition dependent g(u)'sfunctional of A :Zlat
IsEgeC,field A

g()globalgroup G ofaundergauge

atheusS(P]invariantOG-valued function
Thiswith,& andvariablewe=

DAP

cangauge theory,makewithd)-AHAS ?

under(Obe,S(as P)=thenA/Pape-,yesz(AT,dynamicalvariableand(A D) :,S[A P9],"S(A b),=z(A].

consider theZ

S=Syn[A]-emeasure

2[A]

A/g
This

theis

However

this,

DPS
This

ganging=GeEP
SometimesInsucha,

may not be

Dap eThis

AgCA

Ag[A P],gis,

P)

is.

field independent-,=case,

theDAP.

,:=deZCA]
is=:so

Dat idela PJ=ZlAs)-:

possible if OASPis

The infinitesimal form
anomaly.

theisIt.

e=ag(A)Z[A]igelA]Z(A].

usual form of t'Hooft anomaly.

Ag(A).

Remarks·&ELA P]

IfAcCa Pl,

then=canweCounterterm,,,

themodified(,.

,,--,)

theto:p -)dix-,,

Lagrangian,,SAb)),

noanomaly

=0.

:

=

S[A P],-S'(AS paBas ps e,ide(A P]

=has

Je(DabeS[A3 ps]

p 00 --)dix--i) of(Asystem-Finite versionda,,

S(A P] +de SCA P]

that,

iOLIA of ... 0 20=,andde)

L (Amodify the system by adding the local

S'(A q)soof some local expression

variationis,,=+i@g(A P],. Sa pl-iaP)

Dape-=and,DaPe,

SA P],↑,

After this modification
thatThis shows
variationthe,symmetryanomalyof localis·The,-G(DAPeforan(S(A,Ge)02(aJcurrentsymmetrydefinedP))

-=

Gabe

The Ward

JApa ej

identity

relationshipforbetween,p --)dix.

S(A P],Ja GA J.

.
A-A + SA*=--,

defined byisarbitrary variationJA

only up toexpressionac (A P) ~ac(A q] +,safely gangedcan bethethe=j Ga

symmetryshowsCaanomaly and the current

Ward idJade

Say bl,0(a)↓=psSlas0(P9](Op:,-DabS(A b]ig(a,,b):.

The

infinitesimal version

Sca

Jad,

PS

Sate

Thatis.

PsGe0(b))+,=(JaxDrD JYO-ide(A PJ 07A.

,showside(A b),=where=meansof

otherThis

is

theJM

0(9)

deA J,(50)aThis.

JadeS(a (ide(t P)0(p7,=>

PuE

istheJaixDpE JY.

=-thatholds

betweentheidentity

JdxE DpJY.

intheabsence

operator .

relationshipcurrent.

anomayand(June 24 2024)

In Lecture 10,-Ge (DadeS(A p)and therefore

but that

1,,

S(Aisthe variationThe

anomaly oftheanomalyi9e(p):=·anomaly,=,includes

P))(d*DrE JM.

=Gabe

S(A P],of pbut,.

only.

simplyisthe Trivial garge field
,

Jax

=0,

d in

Ja GA J

original global symmetryide (A#variation

-of A

theat

=-ide(A d),·De-Sla P] JaxDrE JM=Je(DAPS(A P))
G(DAPesaid

WRONG !

was-I,b]

OpE Jncurrent.

-=-JaxxEb

non-conservation

J,.

*Two basic examples

axial

anomaly (global (chiralanomaly (gauge:'torHooft)

Axial anomaly

Theorygauge theory:fermion ↑S(A 4]

in:

W(l)

5=agange group J

axial(r (ThenUs,=>

Indeed=Us==E

Jax(-iπDA4)=- jeiers,ivov)

1 a BV"+phase rotations of fermion

4- gitsp

recallDiracmassless,

representation V of G:

Sin(A]=,Symmetrywith=rv=-vir pri-virs

et4p

SpEDYE Mr+ 1on-on SEC") -4,

FAY -FeierDa4=**

4F Dat-Da=- E(X) :iF A4

The Noether current is:Fr"OliEU)4J-Pr r4*===-

GEFrU4

FrV"4anomaly:a(A]:=a&Hereused4],

Jax(Fr Fyx)

ENex +(()-162

differential forms

Apdx*=,,jweA

A

0=JE tr(FanFa)=== (AzFarFa,

Fa

=dA+:

&(A A],=&Fmndx ndx*Far Fex daedsedan da=-(n - xd4x
RemarkOriginalWe:mayungauge

external

elementary,

A-unganged:external,4)

1234
=1G.

--(As=:~elementaryGisfield-dependent

S field-independent

Chiral anomaly

Theoryfree massless fermion:

SymmetryJaxx)=↑ R + 94R

:

4.

+,

current,

:

=.

Fra

=

inof G

TnQ4m :4)
-Fr

942,

SCA Ym 4n]

anomaly-inand

UR and UL

representations

S↑m--Fig
Eg

Jdix(-iFRatr-iFcDate)iFUetR+iFVety:ae(A)=Ja [tra(ed(AdA [A)]+T( - d(AdA [A3))),+-DnJRE(trun(ed(AAAAA-Itistr (e On (And An

field independent.

*+&ArteAx)]]

Remark

Axial(Gunganged)

anomalyas

aspecial

case of

Got=Willy

G

Vot=

*V(l)

..

chiral

Was-a=VH)---Was

anomaly

beregarded:G
representation ofWills charge

VotL

can+1G
representation ofaWills charge Thenthe axial,

regarded

as

NB

is

chird anomaly

forthethe variation
theanomaly (where AErt

background AtoWe needfor

the=+=(e,((0 A),modification.
match0external)

by local counter termcanbeComputation of anomalies
toexamine

formulae forabove

theaxial andchinal anomalies.
Axialanomaly (Gungauged) and chiral anomaly.
field independentdeZ(A]If

we=write

Gz(A)

=

Thus

are,ide[A) z(A].

Z(A)(00e=Jade-SCA

S(A P),IlJai,P]--W(a--,JA J-z(A]( GW(AJ)-:-GW(A](Jax=JA.

JA

In particularide(A)==GeZ(A)/ZIA)-CrederivingwhedeWCA)

=

(Jax

Ward identity forO=DrE1).

-JY)

AthenGGz(A)=(00e

S(t,P)(at JJaxA j--Ilin(z(A] (-:-G,W(A1) z(A]) &d W(A]=-GW(A) d W(AS)+,GdW(A]=,[Ja d. A J JadA 5)
.

.

,

A

Ja GA-J][JaGA-j]a-.

JJain=>·-

di-dWCA]id---indeCA]=>/Jan--dA

J (dis JA 5 A.

.

Saridit JJA

==,,

coun

.

,

com

di - dndEW(A]-/didit JA

DE JN.

.

.

com[Jar (GiAn ) JJ AJA.

,,

coAxial

anomaly(A)=-GW(as A) lago(Jaej)a=,iglo)=<Jakejs )*ida(a] lao

by "Lorentz inv= o.

>JaindEjs Jaiy JA J (3)=.

Conn&fj5[=Jai*.
i didJA J.

iF@4

=

iT Ve4

JAva-M

P( ↑(3) irrea 4(3)()](VU"() Tos

Da laylaoJaf()(a(-)=/diy GAvalE(x)=Jared d A J(x))

Do this for A=&EYWsV 4*=:9,:::com

=

dieiA

=deciJaitr (ii)
-M

=(x2)

(ax(((x)e-=i(P+ q)k-E(X)i(p 9) , e

Ji Tos (VV"threei(p 9(x)+++ins~(9 9 01 (p b e)
,,,,

p+ 9F

frithmically divergent

Los/zPauli-Villars
IntroduceThis

regularization
aregulatornu

replaces

,

mass

1,

opposite statistics (bose)

by

= 0

ifaie(x)e-=spinoraabovethe(A)(ai dida:

:C +((regulator

wheref(h m),: =twos(r) Tverehm)+(9 9 015+ (P.

.

,b,9)

Computef(k m),vs()=f(k m),=29=-* U5-us )( m)+++2m2truece") +rs)- Virt-+vshasthUm Oftrolece)[-NVs-mrmVtn)

zmVTh+=4) m)Vs((-+(VU"Comsre(l ms)+(R+ M2) (Cl-pl2 m2)+trs (rs( + m) +" (+my r))(h 1) mil (h2 my++ 2m

Trs (Vs(()++myr ( m)()((( 4) m))++(h+ /+ m (h mi ((h-p1 m2)+++(9 0)4 (1 9).

.

&exchange

Use

Vy-Uppips=*try (V> + -(4)=tr (VVVVert)·ofnumerator

4(=-afterthe*=3hx(k-Pym -=pu,

Similarlyofthe3rdtrs (Vy(()+m)V" ((v [rV=4)

no*+uxPr

No contribution

0.

to theintegral+(Ur() +mirs(rU +yars)

4m exter 9 Po

kx & Px:P m)m)((((=+1)

term

mers

+

=

contribution=,=try (V58 +(P)4 * &Pohaswernthe 2ndnumerator

=

(()"

+k-integration of the regularized system>·-

1st term-·905

0933+25 v3)-+yu-ve +x)

:S(f(m 0) f(u 1)
,-,

Nulee

=

(21)41 e*Exp+((k q)++12) (h[12) ((k p) 14-+(9 0) - (P 9),,endoubles

h 14=,-16th cereOmit

1+ 0=

Mi
==th(ee) exee Pr=-,=

Join Exe=me-·:

did a (a) (a=ofor dA
These

are&In---tobe

comparedi(P+q)x,= inlee) Pr

GA=des etip

withEntr
JaElkFminX

X(az& X (a0=0=
=

a [0]

=

da=0.

(A)(a=0-GGX /azo
=dif

(aas>
-((x -above :Try J Frip.

16T)2,

SaxEie-GeFispe* 2--(i Mantiquad)-=MMMM4i(p+9)x-ee

19

Gippi+Din Plastine
Meet &nMa.

[MUM &n Pps.

=:

diacalla

GlA]=Produs) e Eit-=u

Jak Elk et F
modulo

O(A3)

terms

=-

*"9P,