ɆɟɠǹșȦ ɽɈŗÉɠʃȂnfƵ?ƐȂȈʥȪǔ¨Ȕ Art Expression Study, "Infantile Representational Drawings": Drawing
Development during the Scribble Period
Aya Takenaga

Abstract
Actual experience of drawing in the scribble period in the developmental history of an
infant’s representational drawing behavior, which starts at age 0, can be said to be themost important period for a child, who develops through interactions with every aspectof the world through drawing, to develop rich expressions spontaneously and proceedwith his or her developmental process at his or her own timing.
Based on the analysis and reflection of drawings in the scribble period, this paper
presents the importance and understanding of such drawings which everyone from an
infant to an adult has experienced as well as one way of supporting rich drawing
experience.

Keywords: infantile representational drawings, scribbles, development of drawing

behavior, actual experience, drawing experience support, expressions in art˙Rhoda Kellogg

ɣȲ
 0 Ǌ!TʲĮ*WVŗÉɠʃȂnfƵ= 'VƐȂ?Ĺ·ˍ@ƐȂZʚ,TRV˃Ę:ʴYU<"TȈʥZʠ(Vı;O=:68ʂ!<ɠǹZɒȈȉ=Ňʲ*0ɒŏ?q^ g9ȈʥʣȢZʟN8%9ƱOʬɣ<ƭƵ:ɭVƸɼ9@nfƵ?ƐȂÖƼ:ɊŁ!TŗÉ!TĥªK9ɺO"ƈ5üY08V)?ƐȂǞã?ʬɣű:Ǻɫʂ!<ƐȂ·ˍƘƔ?U!3ZĂ.Vexˢ ŗÉɠʃȂ˙nf˙ƐȂȈʥ˙Ĺ·ˍ˙ƐȂƘƔ˙Ɇɟɠǹ˙
rhtg

− 37 −

１． はじめにÉȩƐȂ?ŭǺȉșȦɋrhtg˗Rhoda Kellogg 1998˘@ªʳ@ǼKW8Ø
N8?ƐȂnf˗scribbles˜ǂşǍʸ˘=ĮKUr^]g˗diagrams˜é·đ˜ŢŷǍʸ˘j{^˗combines˜Ⱥüđ˜vk^Ǎʸ˘]gi^w˗aggregates˜ʻüđ˜vk^Ǎʸ˘2,8 4~5 ǊˁSUfsnum˗picturestage˜ȻȂƵ˘G:Ȉʥ,8%:ɼ-8Vı;O@ 0 Ǌ!T 3 ǊK9?ʳ=ɐQĶĸ,3ȯȞ?ęȋ=<VȈʥZǸŨ.VŗÉɠʃȂ= 'VnfƵ")W:ʬ<UǭȿZŭ:,3nfZƐ#
nfƐȂ!TǸŨ,3Ţŷ˗ɠ˝˘@ƐȂ?ȵƹ:,8^m"ɜȥ*WSUʂ!<ƐȂɠǹ?ęȋ:<V )?ƭƵı;O@¦ŶZʚ,8TRVƦǚZɳL<"TǞãZĮNɒʍ?ɍ·ʢã!TǼ-3ʎʊ˗nfƐȂ˘@2?ȫǉ:<V
<1ı;O@nfZƐȂ.V?!nfƵ?¹ĈZɦ8V:ƐȂ=
ɠWV?DQ!9ʌãŶ?Vȿɒʍ?ʢã=SUǼ-3ʎʊ=ɠWVŶã@ìĮ?ƭ
°SUªʳ"Þʜ.Vìãß:<68VǞ#Ǟ#:,3ǀ,*ZŶ-*0VȻȂ='Vȿ?ɘɟ:ɭYWVɣȵ.H8Zɺ=ƛYV):O<%ŵǆȉ=ƍȶ,ƐȂɠǹ.Vį@K*=ɘɟĻ9VȂĻ|cp˗Pablo Picasso 1881-1973˘Z@-N
Ĥ%?fa^qʥ"ı;O?Þʜű=ȓȒ,2?¹Ĉ!T^nlZŨ8¹ĈZÞ¹,8#3ı;O?ȻQʜŢ@ɠǹ?Ƹʇɘɟȃ?Ǧ<?9V¼Ɏɋ"ɠǹǞãZƘƔ.V9ı;OZC:U?ªʳ:,8Ńʬ,2?ƐȂɠǹ!TĴJ:.VȑƖ<įå!Tı;O?ƐȂ=ǹWV¾ű:ɠǹ?Ƹʇ"ɦ8%VƸɼ9@rhtg˗1998˘ŗÉȻȂ?Ȉʥ:m`l]y (Jerome S. Bruner 1976)ɵȕɏß?żʰ:˟7?ɠʃ?șȦZę=nfƵ˗ã¹ȉɠʃƵ˘=Vı;O˗ȁÉ K˘?ƐȂɊŁ!TƷȈʥ<ı;O?<&UƐ#:,8ʏɦ*WVÃÿ=63)?ƭƵ?ɠǹǞã"ƐȂ?ȈʥªʳŢż?ęȋ:<Vʬɣ<ƭƵ9V):ZȚɵ.V

２． 描画の考察方法˗˝˘ƐȂ?ÖˈƦǚ ˗rhtg 1998˘ŗÉȻȂ?Ȉʥ˛nf˗scribbles˘ÝƵŧƵ˛r^]g˗diagrams˜é·đ˘˛j{^˗combines˜Ⱥüđ˘˛]gi^w˗aggregates˜ʻüđ˘
˛fsnum˗picturestage˜ȻȂƵ˘±ˤ ?ȈʥʣȢ!T˛nf˗scribbles˘ÝƵŧƵ¹ĈZɊŁłʃ:.V

− 38 −˖˝˗ɟʂ?ÕˇƥǙ m`l]y˖1976˗
ɴȔɎÞ?Żʯ:˞7?ɟʂ˚â¹Ȉɟʂ˖enactive representation˗ɑŎŬĢ:Î?æØ"ș!9@<â¹=SVȌƍȈ<˖ŵɦʡâȈ˗Ɓƒ˚ƩÄȈɟʂ˖iconic representation˗ɟʽȈ<š?^m˖ƩÄ˗=SVŁʂ?Ɓƒ˚ʂūȈɟʂ˖symbolic representation˗Ɵıɮùɬɶ=SVŁʂ?Ɓƒ
ɮ˞ǌʷ?ɟʂȇʤZʟ(3Żª= 8@Ê8?ɟʂZƇ5ûY08ĲĔ,8V˖˞˗Łʂ¹ć?Əȁŕ˕˖ʝ˕˗  ɵǻ!T˜ǉ 2 !Ʊ387 Ʀ˛61 ʝȋ
9ʱĭ*W3ȀÈ K ?ɀƣȈƏȁ¹ćɆ!Tnf˖scribbles˗Üƴ˛Ŧƴ?ǴūZț. 2 ǉ 8 !Ʊ975 Ʀ˛128 ʝȋK
9˖˟˗Łʂ¹ć?ƏȁǺĜ˖»ɍɊ?ʳYU˗ɨŀɊɮʮɊ »ɿɊ˖Ǎɧ˗"ȧ5ûɮʮ˖Əȁ,3Ʀ¯˘Əȁ?ǁİ˘ȀÈ K :ɨŀɊ?³ɳ˘
j zhlÎĻ˗ɮʮŦƏȁƦ¯ˁ=»Ĳ
ɨŀɊ?ƏȁǝâG?ʳYU
İ;O?ƏȁɨŀɊ˖»ɿɊZĀN3Ĥª˗@ƈŃȈ¬ÉZ,<
Əȁ.Vİ;O!T?]sĞƋ'=@Ů-İ;O!TƏȁG?íßǅǔ"63ĚûɨŀɊOƏȁ=íß.VƏȁǺĜƏȁǺĜ˖ǽȳȁƸ˗@ǻǝ.VĚ=ŒƬƝİ;O"ƏȁZǅǔ,3Ěû7
9OƏȁ9#VSǦÁ,83
˖ˠ˗ɉŀŁʂ¹ć?ƃÔ=78
ȀÈ K ?nfƴƏȁ¹ćÊ 110 ǬSUnfƴ?ȇʤ:Əȁ?ǴūZ
ț. 12 ǬƏȁƃÔ˟˚¹ć S˙1ˣS˙12

３． ス クリ ブル 期 に お け る 描画の特徴
 ɟ˜=ț*W3ĘƷȈnf 20 ȣˇ@rhtg˖1998˘p.19˙22˗=SVŖÈȺȁ?ȇʤ˚nf˖scribbles˗?Õˇ9VnfÕˇȄù 1~20 @ȇʤˁř?ɟɮ9@<− 39 −ɠ˝ęƸȉnf:ûnfȿ?ʢãƦÿnf
ȅú

ȿ?ʢãƦÿ
nfŢŷÖˈ
Ɂ

ǃ

ƣN

Ð

Ġƒ

nf 1ǭnf 2éɁȿ ˗éȿ˘nf 3éǃȿ ˗éȿ˘nf 4éƣȿ ˗éȿ˘nf 5éƮȿ ˗éȿ˘nf 6

ɢɁȿ ˗ɢȿ˘

nf 7ɢǃȿ ˗ɢȿ˘

nf 8ɢƣȿ ˗ɢȿ˘

nf 9ɢƮȿ ˗ɢȿ˘

nf 10

>>ʲȿ

nf 11

>>ʱȿ

nf 12mgkgV@Ǜȿnf 13éʑȿnf 14ɢʑȿnf 15ǥŐȿnf 16ʬ<UÐnf 17ɢÐĄnf 18Ƈ"UÐnf 19é©Ðnf 20

ķËÐ



<,



− 40 −










İ;O?Əȁ@ʌ·Ȉȇʤ:ʜâ,8ȇʤ.V２˚˖˝˗=ț*W3 3 7?ɟʂ!Tâ¹ȈɟʂƴǳZƒVǱſ9ƎMƘ.ƈÇ97KM!T?7!KUȧ5ɓĄ?
VƥþGʘ:63ɝâ"ɟWVǻŦ 10 Ʊˀ!TȁƸZƇ3*WV:2?ſZƉUĎ
,ȁʽ=Š363Ƅİ=ǬQȾ:63nf?ĘƷš"ǻLÔ*W×N8?Əȁ
:<V)?S<·ˌ"ǻǝ?9ɃUʔ*WV5Əȁ*WVĘƷȈnf"ʁĽ=<Vnf=78rhtg@±?S=ķɇ,8VĘƷȈnf:@ 2 ǉV@2W±?ŖÈ?¹V 20 ȣˇ?š?):9V)WT?â¹@úȣ?ȫɌȼş?ǁŞZ,N.O?9ɥɦȈd^rn"ŭɢ<Y'99@<˖rhtg 1998 ǟǾɰ˘p.18˗
   K3×ƴ?nf@ªʲ=ÇĥȈ=ÁY68VȮȝȈ¹ǽ:,8ɝYWVnf?ȾǀŻ@T!-NŬ?=ʃTW3O?9<%šŶ?ȍ¥¹ǽ@ȑ:ſ?ȍ¥¹ǽZʙ,8Ã#š@ɑǯ=â¹!TǻKW8%VO?9V:ɸ8V
 â¹Ȉɟʂ:ʫ<Vnfƴİ;O@ʌ?ĎU?TRVO?=ɫWŁʂZȔX
:.VȁǽȳQf|n:63Əȁ?3N=ǦÁ*W3ȁƸ4'9<%ˉ¤=ſ=73hst9uZô#gg:ƈZâ!.Ƅİ=ǋVǬQȾĕʽQȗ=ſʈQƈ"ƍɫ,8Ôƹ3ȾQǬOnf·ˌ:<Vrhtg˖1998˘p.58˗@ĘƷȈnf?ƏȁšŶ"ɬɶQƟåǻǝɈ
ŷ?ȅ<VȂ?İ;O?Əȁ=Ìʙ,8V):Z 100 Ƽ=îFİ;O?Ⱥ?Õƻ
!TɣÔ,3İ;O@ɑÕ"ǻKW3đQƟåǻǝǺĜɑǯǺĜ=ʧŮ,<"Tǻǝ
Q2D?9nfƏȁZ·ˌ,ȇʤZǷŧ.V

４．スクリブル期 描画の考察˖˜˗ɉŀŁʂ9Vnfƴ?Əȁ¹ć
nfƴ?Əȁ¹ć˖˝˗S˙1ˣS˙12 @ȀÈ K ?Əȁʱĭ 1 ǉ 2 !Ʊ61
ʝȋnfÜƴ!T 2 ǉ 4 !Ʊ128 ʝȋnfŦƴǄ?ȇʤǌʷ9
Vr^]g˖è·Đ˗=Ƞɝ.VȌÜK9?¹ć9ɟʂ@â¹Ȉɟʂƴ=3V
nf?ĘƷšŶ@Əȁ.Vİ;O?ȫɌȼş?Y/!<ō9ɡƜ?ĘƷš
Ŷ?ǴūZY0Ƈ7O?OƏȁ*WV2?3N 20 ȣˇ?ĘƷȈnf@ǮƜ?Ⱥ?ʧÖ<Õˇ·ȯZƐº.VĘǦ:,ɉŀ.V

− 41 −

˗˞˘nfƐȂɠ?ɠɯÏļnf¹Ĉ S˚1ˤS˚12 üɮ 12 ǭ   ¹Ĉ@ØN8?ƐȂnfÝƵ!TnfŧƵK9Ƨ¯˂=ɠȜ  ƐȂƭ?Ŗ˖:ʞ˖  ƐȂƭ?ɠʃƵ ƐȂ=Ȩ5³63ǎɨ=SUƐȂÏ=ɯʯ*W3Ïļ ęƸȉnf 20 Ȥˈ˗ɠ˝˘!TƐȂ=ǾTW3nfŢŷ?ƄÕ   ¹ĈZƐȂ.Vʹ?ƐȂ¶ɅZɠɯ˗¶ɅZ¹ĈÒȑɠÏ=9eg˘¹Ĉ S˚1

1 Ǌ 2 !Ʋ˗61 ʞȌ˘            

ã¹ȉɠʃƵ

ǼKW8ØN8?ƐȂęƸȉnf
1. ǭ
2. éɁȿ
3. éǃȿƐȂ¶ɅƐȂʲĮƭ@Ǿȴ?=¡UƐȂ

ØN8?ƐȂÒȑ 1 Ǿȴ=Òȑ 2 ƶǬȈɤÒȑ 3 łʃȚɵ

Òȑ 4 ʢãʲĮÒȑ 1ˤ4 @¹Ĉ S˚1 ?ƐȂ=ɓVK9ØN8ƐȂǻĝZTW3ʹ?ɯʯ
9VƐȂ.VǾȴ@tw?=Ɵ!W2?=ı;O"ŞUʲĮ*W3
˗Òȑ 1˘ı;O"ƐȂȵƹ9VƶǬˊH8OĶË<ȵƹZȈɤ˗Òȑ 2˘ƶ
Ǭ=ɔąZƈ5ô=ʢ[9Țɵ˗Òȑ 3˘ǒ=Ê63:ã¹ɠǹ?ŧƶǬZ
Ɠ63ƀZʢã*0V˗Òȑ 4˘)?Ƨ@ƐȂK9ɓT<!63")? 5 Ƨŧ=¹Ĉ S˚1 ZƐ3ǼKW8ØN8?nf@ƶǬZƓ63ƀZƊUX.
ƊUď.ã¹?ʹƀ=Ɠ63ƶǬ"Ǿȴ=š363ʎʊ!TǭȿZŭ:,3ęƸȉnf"ƐȂ*W3ɒÖ?ʢã?ʊ"ǌV):ZȈɤ,3ı;O@ýʢãZɄUʕ,^mZɯŻ.V))=nfȅú 1˛2˛3˛?ƐȂ"Țɵ
9#V

− 42 −

¹Ĉ S˚2 


1 Ǌ 5 !Ʋ˗79 ʞȌ˘           

ã¹ȉɠʃƵ

ɯʯ<,ęƸȉnf
1. ǭ
2. éɁȿ
5. éƮȿ7. ɢǃȿ10. >>ʲȿƐȂ¶Ʌˢ5 ƦÿȂʾ?ĄĐTRVƦÿ
!TƐȂ,8V?"Ö!VnfØƵ9ã¹ȉɠʃƵȂʾ?ōù:63Ʀÿű?ɵɿ@ĸK68
T/ɒȀ=TRVƦÿ!TƐȂ.V5 Ʀÿ!T?ƐȂZȚɵɑ?ǃťŪʢã!TǼ-3nfȅú 7˛ɢǃȿ"ɠÕ,ɢǃȿ=©Ŏ˗èƠĲ˘,3ɢǃȿ"ɠWV")W@ƐȂ¶ɅZĠ8ý-ɢǃȿZʬ>8ƐȂ,33NǼ-8V¹Ĉ S˚3

1 Ǌ 6 !Ʋ˗80 ʞȌ˘            

ã¹ȉɠʃƵ

ɯʯ<,ęƸȉnf
1. ǭ
2. éɁȿ
3. éǃȿ4. éƣȿƐȂ¶Ʌˢ˝ƦÿnfØƵ9ã¹ȉɠʃƵnf·ˍ?ɜȥ!Tʢã:ƐȂ?ɯŻ"ĸ
ȓ,8%V:ɑ?ã#Zjw,ȿ?{al"ĞVı;O"ƨȚ<ŵŰZƈ68ƐȂ,3fn˗èƠĲ˘@nfØƵ!TŧƵȹˍ"ʂľ=<V:ǅ?r^]g˜é·đ=SU˒ƨ=ɠÕ.V¹Ĉ S˚2 ?ɢɁȿ=SVÁǰ?©Ŏ:ǐʐ.V:)?¹Ĉ9@ȂʾĨ=ȍȿZS;L<%ƐȂ,éɁȿ:éǃȿ"©YV)?·ˍɯŻ"ŧ?˒ƨ<èƠĲɠǹG:7<"V− 43 −

¹ć S˙4

1 ǉ 6 !Ʊ˖82 ʝȋ˗            

â¹Ȉɟʂƴ

ʇ@{\{\ĘƷȈnf
1. Ǭ
2. èɀȾ
4. èƢȾ5. èƭȾ7. ɡǂȾ8. ɡƢȾ9. ɡƭȾ10. >>ʱȾ
11. >>ʰȾ
13. èʐȾ
20. ĶÊÏ
Əȁ¶Ʉˡ˜ƥþnfʱĭ!T 4 cƱâ¹ȈɟʂƴƏȁ?ïũ·ˌ!Tɮź=ķȒ,3šŶ@ÐǸ9#VS=<VƦŒǻǝ= 'VɝâȬď?Ř"U@ɏ=ÚǩZɟ
ǸG?ƌȵŴǅ"ʞLâ¹Ȉɟʂƴ:Ì=ƩÄȈɟʂƴ?Æ¾"ɟWV»ɍɊ˖Ǎ˗=SVʇ@{\{\:?ɮÉ!Tİ;O"ƏȁZʙ,8ăď:j zhlZñU2?ŁʂZ)WK9?Əȁ=<!63Ƕȧ,3Ï9ɟǸ,3˖ȁʽø˗Ï@ĶÊ=ʰ-TW8@< Əȁ:ɟʂ?ȇʤ=µƤ,šŶ?Ƿŧ"ˆɚ=<V»ɍɊ:?ƏȁZ¬,8?j zhl:ÌŵƬʲ?ÌƲ@İ;O?ƏȁG?ĊD:ŴǅZˎNƌȵ?ëâÞ:<V¹ć S˙5

1 ǉ 6 !Ʊ˖82 ʝȋ˗            

â¹Ȉɟʂƴ

ɮʮ<,ĘƷȈnf
2. èɀȾ
3. èǂȾ5. èƭȾ6. ɡɀȾ
7. ɡǂȾ8. ɡƢȾ9. ɡƭȾ10. >>ʱȾ
11. >>ʰȾ
13. èʐȾ
Əȁ¶Ʉˡ˝ƥþ− 44 −

¹Ĉ S˚5 1 Ǌ 6 !Ʋ˗82 ʞȌ˘ã¹ȉɠʃƵnfØƵnf?ęƸŢŷ?ǸŨZʟNV¼Ɏɋ˗ǎ˘"ƐȂÏ=ɯʯ,3Ƨ¯?!Tnf,8VƐȂ.Vı;O:¼Ɏɋ?ɭɚ=SVjzhl=àƐȂZʚ,8Ȏƀ:ý-ɞǮ˗Íý¹ƿ˘Zɞ):92?ċDQǀ,*ZÍŶ,S:,8V¹Ĉ S˚6

1 Ǌ 6 !Ʋ˗83 ʞȌ˘            

ã¹ȉɠʃƵ

ɯʯ<,ęƸȉnf

1. ǭ

2. éɁȿ
3. éǃȿ7. ɢǃȿ15. ǥŐȿ17. ɢÐĄ
20. ķËÐ
ƐȂ¶Ʌˢ˝Ʀÿ¹Ĉ S˚4 =ɠÕ,3Ð?ǸŨ"ʟMɢÐĄ˗ō˘!TǥŐȿ˗ù˘Ĩ=ʱTW2<Ð:ɪŢ"ɠÕūȷ<ʢã?jw=SUɢÐĄ?ƐȂ!TǥŐȿQʱ-TW3éǷ?ÐG:Ňʲ*WƐȂʜŢɠǹ?ęțŢŷ:<VŘ¸ĴŢŷ˗Ð:ɪŢ˘"Țɵ9#VȁÉ K ?ɁƤȉƐȂ¹Ĉ!TŘ¸ĴŢŷ?ÐɪŢĎɪŢ˗ȖŢ˘?ǸŨ@nfƵ=ʲĮ*W]gi^w˜ʻüđ=Ț!<O?:<V
¹Ĉ S˚7

1 Ǌ 6 !Ʋ˗83 ʞȌ˘            

ã¹ȉɠʃƵ

f|đưˌ?CS)6)? ɴ³Gɞ63«Ƨ@ʼęƸȉnf
1. ǭ
2. éɁȿ
3. éǃȿ4. éƣȿ5. éƮȿ6. ɢɁȿ
7. ɢǃȿ10. >>ʲȿ
13. éʑȿ
14. ɢʑȿ
15. ǥŐȿ20. ķËÐ
ƐȂ¶Ʌˢ˝Ʀÿ− 45 −

¹Ĉ S˚7 1 Ǌ 6 !Ʋ˗83 ʞȌ˘ã¹ȉɠʃƵ¹Ĉ S˚6 9ɠÕ,3ɪ?VŢŷ˗ɪŢ?ìė˘:nf?ǡü)WK9
ǸŨ,3ŢŷZĹˍȉ=ɄUʕ,Ɛ#2?ȸLüY0!TÁǰ=Õƺ3ŢQ^mZɯŻ,8ɠǹZř(VƐȂ,3¹Ĉ=ł.VĄĐ?ðůOƪÅ:Í=ɯŻ,8%
¹Ĉ S˚8

1 Ǌ 6 !Ʋ˗84 ʞȌ˘            

ã¹ȉɠʃƵ

ƬęƸȉnf
1. ǭ
2. éɁȿ
3. éǃȿ4. éƣȿ5. éƮȿ6. ɢɁȿ
7. ɢǃȿ8. ɢƣȿ10. >>ʲȿ
11. >>ʱȿƐȂ¶Ʌˢ˝ƦÿnfŧƵ)WK9Ȃʾ?=TRVƦÿ!TnfZʫɅ.VƐȂ
"ŭ963")?¹Ĉ9@ĸ?˃ĘZƈ63ĥ#<Ţŷ?=nf"Ɛ!W8V˃Ę?=ʫɅ*W3nf@ęƸȉnfZŭ:,2W=à8Ř¸ĴŢŷ?ȖŢ˗ĎɪŢ˘?ɣȵZƈ7nfOɠÕ,8V¹Ĉ S˚6 9Ð¹Ĉ S˚7 9ɪŢƸ¹Ĉ9ȖŢ˗ĎɪŢ˘?ìė:<Vnf"ƐȂ*WŘ¸ĴŢŷ?ǸŨ"ʟɞ,8Vǭ!TnfŧƵ=ÊUǅ?ȈʥǍʸr^]g˜é·đ=ÿ!68ǉLZʟN8V¹Ĉ S˚9

1 Ǌ 8 !Ʋ˗91 ʞȌ˘            

ã¹ȉɠʃƵ

_sZ5PF÷?9,3ĥʭęƸȉnf
1. ǭ
2. éɁȿ
3. éǃȿ4. éƣȿƐȂ¶Ʌˢ˝Ʀÿ− 46 −

¹Ĉ S˚9 1 Ǌ 8 !Ʋ˗91 ʞȌ˘ã¹ȉɠʃƵ¹Ĉ S˚8 9nfŧƵ=ÊUɠǹ*WVŢŷ?{al"ʂ!=<V:ƞǺ*W3ƐȂOǼKWVƐȂ*W3nf?ɣȵ@¹Ĉ S˚1 ØN
8?ƐȂ:IJý-ǭéɁȿéǃȿéƣȿ9V"ɑ?ʢã!TÁǰǼK
W3ØN8?ƐȂ?ɵɿ:@Ȇ<VƐȂʢãZjw9#Vɏß:ı;O?ŵŰ"ƨȚ=<U)WK9=ǸŨ,3Ţŷ!TȿZʩDƐ%3NʩÙ*W3nf"ɠǹ*WVƐȂ?Ȉʥ:ýƭ=ɠʃ?Ȉʥ= 8Oã¹ȉɠʃƵ=àƪÅȉɠʃƵ?ɣȵ"ȚĹ<O?:<68%Vȿ"©Ŏ.VŢŷ@ǅ?Ǎ
ʸr^]g˜é·đ=<V:SUƨȚ=ɠÕ.VèƠĲ?ǸŨ@±ŧ?Ɛ
Ȃ9ǞǾ*W)WT?nfŢŷZęț:,8fsnum˗ȻȂƵ˘ʃŬȉɠʃƵ=ÊUƠĲ?ǸŨG:7<"V¹Ĉ S˚10

1 Ǌ 8 !Ʋ˗91 ʞȌ˘           

ã¹ȉɠʃƵ

«ƴ@^jwZȓ8ģʡDĢˊ?ʘ9Čþ9OÆǒęƸȉnf
1. ǭ
2. éɁȿ
3. éǃȿ6. ɢɁȿ
7. ɢǃȿ11. >>ʱȿ
13. éʑȿ
14. ɢʑȿ
16. ʬ<UÐ
17. ɢÐĄ
18. Ƈ"UÐ19. é©Ð20. ķËÐ
ƐȂ¶Ʌˢ˝Ʀÿ)?Ƨģ2DZȹˍ,2?·ˍ:Ŷã"ȵȍ=ɠW8VĿ!63>ˉ
"~~<;¼Ɏɋ:Í=·ˍ?ÛǪZƐȂZʚ-8ÍƳÍŶ.VċD
"Ȃʾ6B=nf9ɠǹ*W3Ȃʾù˗Ⱦɖ˘=ķË=ʱ-TW3Ð
"ǹWʱ-TW3Ð@ƐȂ=ƥ,ŇʲZVȁÉ K ?nf¹Ĉɇ?
9Ř¸ĴŢŷÐ?ɠǹ"ȚĹ<O?:<63):ZȜ.¹Ĉ9VÐ?ǸŨ
@±ŧr^]g˜é·đ?ƐȂɠǹ=ůǾ*WVnfŧƵnfęțŢŷ"ʂľ=<UɄUʕ,ƐȂ*WV:)X!TŢŷ?ǸŨ"ĸȓ,8#8
V?"Y!V− 47 −

¹Ĉ S˚11

2 Ǌ 4 !Ʋ˗128 ʞȌ˘           

ã¹ȉɠʃƵ

ɯʯ<,ęƸȉnf
6. ɢɁȿ
7. ɢǃȿ8. ɢƣȿ9. ɢƮȿ11. >>ʱȿ
14. ɢʑȿ
17. ɢÐĄ
20. ķËÐ
ƐȂ¶Ʌˢ˝ƦÿȂʾĨ=˃ĘZƈ63ķËÐ?=nfC:7?Ţ˃ĘZƈ63ƐȂ@ŧ?ªʳ?ˆ¡UǴ:63ɠǹG:Ňʲ*WVnfØƵ˗ã¹ȉɠʃƵ˘ɒÖ:®ɋ?ʍ·ȉ˃Ęĳĕ?çÙ"ƷÖæ<ı;O@ĄĐ?TRVO?=
ɬW2?ʢã?ʎʊ9VƐȂ·ˍZɄUʕ,<"TɒÖ?ĳĕZȚ!NVƐȂ?Ȉʥ::O=ɒŽOəǼnfŧƵ!Tr^]g˜é·đG?ȡɞ:ƪÅȉɠʃƵZƈ5üY0Vˁ˃ĘZƈ5ǷȨ,3ŢŷZƐȂ.V
¹Ĉ S˚12

2 Ǌ 4 !Ʋ˗128 ʞȌ˘           

ã¹ȉɠʃƵ

 E>?0[XęƸȉnf
1. ǭ
6. ɢɁȿ
7. ɢǃȿ9. ɢƮȿ11. >>ʱȿ
14. ɢʑȿ
16. ʬ<UÐ
17. ɢÐĄ
18. Ƈ"UÐ19. é©Ð20. ķËÐ
ƐȂ¶Ʌˢ˝ƦÿȂʾƻ=ƐȂ*W3nf@ E>?0[X:˅*WÎ·ȉ<^mZ´S:,8V¹Ĉ S˚11 ?ɠǹ!TƯ=ŵǆȉ=Ɛ!W8V2 Ǌ 4cƲǼǞ?9ɞãȭĐQ·ˍ"ř"Uʍ·ȉȈʥ!TɒÖ99#V):Qɠǹ"®ɋ=ɵNTWjzhl"ʟM:ƥ3<ƐȂɠǹǸŨ?3NĹˍ:ƍȶZʟNnfZƈ5üY0<"Tr^]g˜é·đG?ȡɞ"ĮK68V):"nfŢŷ:Ȃʾ?ǁđ!TȚɵ9#V

− 48 −

５．まとめ ～スクリブル描画への関わり～˟˚¹ć S˙1ˣS˙12 ?nfƏȁ?ɉŀ!Tİ;O"ƦɃUʔ*WVƏȁ?ĸ
·ˌZʙ,8Ƥ,nfšŶZǷŧ,2?šŶZĸˌȈ=ȷLûY0<"TƏȁZņʱ*0»ɿɊ:?jzhlQĢ2D<;ƦŒǝâ?Ř"U:Ì=ĬĨŬZƇ68ŴǅȈ=ƌȵ,8Vǁİ"șɴ9#V
0 ǉ˖ǻŦ 10 !Ʊˀ˗!Tʱĭ*WVnfƴʌʓ=ĲĔ.V»ɍɊ"İ;O?ƏȁɟǸ=łìZƇ68ƍ,ȇʤ=ļUǡ63ƗƓ:ǺĜɯķʳYUZƇ7):"ʁ
!<ŵŰ:ɏQʌ·?¿Ê<ȇʤG:Ń%rhtg˖1998˗"ĈV 0 ǉˣ3 ǉK9=Əȁ*WVnfZ<&UƏ#:ȟ,3 V_``x˖Viktor
Lowenfe1d 1967˗@<&UƏ#Ƭƴ?ʫɢŰZŖÈɅɞȘȥɑŎɟǸ= 'Vư×
?ǌʷ ˙<&UƏ#?ǌʷ˙˖2 ƀSU 4 ƀK9˗?9Ǆ?S=ʕH8V<&UƏ#?×ƴǌʷ= 8@ǝâZʞɝ*0V3N=ƚŐ"VàK,±Ģ?Úǩ@ŭɢ<˖ȃ˗<&UƏ#@œǣ*WVH#9@<)?Ǚ
Û@@-N?ǌʷ=OŦ?ǌʷ=Oü-S=ŭɢ9V<1<T)?S<œǣ@ʫɢ<ǻąȈȸˌZİº!TĪñVA!U9<%2?Ŧ?­¤9!
WZÙŨ,ã54!T9V«ʕH3S<œǣ@İº=ĸǳÐǸZ*0S
:.V:)X=ǻ/V?4"Ĥª=@2W"Y!T/=İº?ʡâŵɦǃɎ?
ŻʯZÙŨ.V):=<V˖V_``x 1967 ȩÎęÎǇ§ɰ˘p.138˗
İ;O?ƏȁǝâG?ƗƓ:@ ·@İ;O=V):Zɴɾ,ǎƦ?2D?9
ƏȁɟǸ9#VǺĜ¹U:2?ɟǸZò'ǆNƏȁZÌ=ƿ,L2?ƬʲZÌƲ.V):9VƦ?Əȁǝâ=ļUǡɨŀɮʮ,2?ğåQȇʤ?Æ,=Ǒ¯%):"9#VȧĚ?»ɍɊ"ªC:U?½ŰQƏȁȇʤ?ưĤ?ǹɪɊ:<V
nfƴ?İ;O?Əȁǝâ@ǕWQĵÊ<Ƹơ<;ʪŸ"ŭɢ:<V"â¹ȈɟʂƴÊʌ?ŵɦZȘ$ǨK,2?·ˌ!TȇʤZǷŧ.Vİ;O=:682D?ĸ·ˌ"ʫɢ<Ƭƴ9U2?·ˌ!TǄ?ȇʤʢȡG:ǈLZʞNV
ªʲ?Əȁȇʤ?Ǌ÷= 8]yg˖ĸ·ˌ˗Ŭ?Ƭ°ƦŒǻǝQɑǯ·ˌ
2D?9ɑǯ:Ń!Wnf·ˌ9#VǺĜ"63Ǹ°?İ;O35?ǻǝ@!78<I;vmqȂ"ʌʓ=ĲĔ,Ŗˀ!TnwbQ|pjǃČ=SV{s˖²ųǸĸ˗Ȃ92FƬʲ"ĝ¦ŵZʙ,82?Ɂȶ<ʥZ·
ˌ.V]yg<nf·ˌ!Tʦ+!63ǺĜ=V2?ţʾ=ŹŸ,<"TO)W!TƮ=ʞǈ.VvmqȂZİ;Oʤ?ǻǝ!TƊʶ.V):@ǸĸȈ9@<İ;O35?2DQǻǝ?9vmqȂ:?¿Ê<ÌĲƥǙ@)W!T?ɺ˄9
V− 49 −

あ とが き ǻŦ 11 Ʊ?ǈ#ĭN3Ǽ:ʻ"U=ƛǈZ,3ƬËĒ?ĕʽ=9#3ǒ3KUZ
ȇɣ,3Ǽ"ɑÕ<U?ʚʈ9ǈLļUʖY/ǒʽZô#ǒ,F#ZǞD<"Tǒʽ=Ř"VǚȲ=)[<¤=<V?!:ˍ#:ŵâ96B?ɟŲZɣ03Ʈ=
ǒ3KU?=ſZȦ6ʒLĕʽZƖ9VS=gg:ſZâ!.:ǒ"ēɕ=<
68ǤZŏ8ğå,3Ǽ@ǒ3KU?=ʊLʒ[92?ǁİZ-6:ɣ7Nɓī,8]]:õDɠʈ9ĕʽZʊL˓T,32?Ƅİ=QYT!ǜ?=ʈʉ?Ó
Ò"ǋV):Zȇɣ.V:¸ŜOĕʽZʊL7'2?ʉZșɴ.V)?İ=:68)?ĕʽG?ʌ·]fl"×N8?Əȁ·ˌ463?9V)?ɝǭ?Ŧǒ3KU?
=9[&Uʔ,Z.VS=˃?ʿǬZǒ3KU=7'82?ŵɫZˏ?ǐ:˃ȉ9Ą
YưŦ=ǒZˊO:,3ɝǭ@Ǎɧ=S68Ùǆ*0TW3"â¹Ȉɟʂƴİ;O@ɑÕ=9#ŧVʵU?ƥǙ9Ƥ3<ǺĜ=ɫWɑÕ?ɝâ:ʡâ!Tǻ-3ʍʉ˖nf˗Zǋ,3?9VÊʌ/FǪW=<UǍɧ=Ƃ!W8őVʸſZǒ3
KU=Ř(<"TʈZA37!0O6:QT08%W:ĤǛ#,3Ģ2D9ǕWV):ZűWǒ3KU!Tİ;OZʦ+'83T?ƬÊʌ9ʌʼ
.VS<ŵâ:ȇɣZ·ˌ9#<!634XǒQē?ŵɫZİ;O"ĄY2?
Úǩ!T×N8?nf·ˌG:Ń!W3?O2?ɝâZĿĻ=ɣĴV»ɍɊ?Ĳ
Ĕ"63!T9VvmqŬ?Ǹ°= 8Oİ;O?ȇʤ@]yg<ĸ·ˌ=S68Ń!WVĤª=:68@ǒ3KU:ƦŒȈ<ĲĔ"ǎƦ?2D!TȇʤZʟ(Vİ;O=:68ĬĨŬZɍ8ȇʤZŃ%ÚǩȈ9ːÞȈĲĔ9V):Zʻ"U?ƛǈ"ƚ8%W3
ƷȘȥ@İ;O?ɵǻ!TǎƦ?ǻǝ9ưOʌʓ=ļUǡưĤ?ǹɪɊ9V»ɍɊ˖Ǎɧ˗=SUðʺɮʮ*W3ʅơZĘ=ɉŀ,8VƷɻ9ñU(3nfƴƏȁ¹ć?¹Ɋ K ÿ@ǸĔ 12 ǉ=<UȺȁ?ȇʤ"Ķ
Ż*WV 18 ǉ=þ!68ȇʤ?ǈLZʞN8VǻKW8×N8?Əȁ!TƏȁǺĜZ
Ɲ8ǸĚ=ȧ5³İ;O?Əȁ=łìZƇ68ƍ,Ù¹Ʀ2?ǵǘİ;O?ɶU
Ƌ'Zɮʮ,Ȼ'3 K ÿ:Ǎɧ?ĲĔ<,=Ʒɻ@Żȧ,8<ʄʫ<ʅơZƐº,8343 K ÿɧİ=Ŭ!Tŵɽ,8QK<)W!TƮ=ŖÈʛšȘȥZǟNV)::.V

− 50 −

参考文献
V_``x˙ȪÏǣĚÏƚǈ§äʺÍɱ˗1967˘
Ɇɟ=SVªʳŢż˙˕ƨưž˛ơɝ¨Ȕ˗2014˘}w@<1ȻZƐ%?! ɘɟɵȕȟĴG?ƆŦ
˙ŊǛưś˛J˛S˛yɛ˙ ŉƸġƶ®ɱ˗1976˘ɵɿɏß?żʰ˗˘˙ ƨǘđưÕǳ˛Ȫǔ¨ȔĜćʤɛ˙˗2017˘ɆɟɠǹșȦ ɽɈŗÉɠʃȂ?ɁƤȉɯʯ?ƾɲʔȇĥĴ¢ŌȗƵĥĴșȦȱɣ˙ȫ 47 ú pp.6484Ȫǔ¨ȔĜćʤɛ˙˗2018˘ɆɟɠǹșȦ ɽɈŗÉɠʃȂ?ƐȂ?Ȉʥ:ǵŬʔȇĥĴ¢ŌȗƵĥĴșȦȱɣ˙ȫ 48 ú pp.3853˓ņƫɆɛ˙˗1995˘ı;O?ȻZr=,8K0[!ˣ
˙İªǼǞȝ˛ÏʵŜɀɛƠʪȟĴȏɀɛëǼâÄȏɀɛ˙
˗2017˘ŕż 29 ŖăȜ ŗȣēƛɎɣ˃¼Ɏſ¼ɎƉʮ ŗ¼ʝƕėɵĸ);OēƛɎ¼Ɏɣ˃ ìƸ ˙s^xƸȝ.
ŋɃǗɛ˙(2005)ȮĔʡD?ŭǺĴ}w"7%Vs|m")>V˙ˉʳưžĜćʤȪǔ¨Ȕɛ˙
˗2016˘ŗÉɠʃȂ=ĴFɽɈªǴȂǴȂǨɉ?ńÊǚ:ƐǚʔȇĥĴ¢ŌȗƵĥĴșȦȱɣ˙ȫ 46 ú pp.4751
H dxyɛ˙Ʃćıɱ˗1998˘ı;O?ƐȂ ˚<&UƐ#!TɘɟK9˚
˙ɸ½ưž˛ĺǈʒħɛ˙˗1985˘ŗÉ?Ȼ@ǼǞ,8V˙êƠȝ˛ňƸɌɗǿä£ǱʁĊıɛ˙
˗2009˘ŗÉƵ!TÉȩƵ=ęƸȉ<ǼǞɉŸQɥȭŵɿZʍ=¯'V):?ʬɣű=78ɐ?Ȉʥ:ŭ?co?ɤĖ!TĪɕȐȨƛɎșȦſ șȦȱɣ șȦʻʯ˙ȫ 17 ú pp.4-5
rhtgɛ˙ǠǿŅţɱ˗1998˘ÉȩȂ?ȈʥʣȢ ―<&UƐ#!Tfns
G―
˙˕ƨưž˛− 51 −