北方領土問題の本質〜真実を知ることにより格段に増す北方領土問題への理解〜〜北方領土問題の本質と対応を探る〜

20196



CONFIDENTIAL & PROPRIETARY copy right© 2019 Shuji Kira All rights reserved.

1óòS *%¡È¾Ô­pÈÊ±ÍÓtÒÕÄ²Ç²/óò øxDq­à¶h4ÈOÏØÅ·ÂÉ¶­¥«§¨7ðW$¦¤7ñªZ«TÇÉÊ¥«§¨7¦ZÉèëáÈ´²Ä­vÊäÚã ð¥«§¨7¨ZªTñ>õµZ>É1TD×côò øíÞÙ¶­¯uan,DÉz^Æ¼Ä­§3ÊíÞÙèëáÈ´²Ä­àÊ1TDÉ]õò øv)¶SQµûú*ÆÇÃÂ°Æ;¾ÔÉÊ

Æ¼Ä33ÉQµú[×c*%¡È¼ÄÊ­ÛêçÙ%¡ÉÑ³ÈíÞÙ×¼¸¼Ç²ÉÊQµúïèëá È´²Ä­v)¶1TD×cïfR×j²­oüéÚî Éf [×;¾ÔàÉc×v)ÊH"¾ÔÐ­ÁÉÖÓÈ­ðÁÉXiÅÊñS *ö3×#Î33Éà [×ÏÂÆ@ÖÕÔ®
øeú¥«§¨7¦Zèëá <XÉv)Ê­T\×ÐU¸ »ÀÔÂÏ­àÈ1TDc¼Â¶­T\ >Ê­à¶Y,É-ÆÇÓ­àÉ1T=J,×C¼­v)É1S *S×L­§3ÉT\`×M¾Ôöò ø¥«¨©7É¯Tà!0°È´²Ä­£2|k¶¦3¯9·g¼°ÅFÓ´³Æ¼ÂÉÊQµúï¯5)Å·Ä²ÇµÃÂÞæêÙEo×ÐU¸5)»ÀÂ²°®<XÉ£2¢rÉÇÔ@²®
ï¥«¨¥7ÉÝîåéîÞßÜ6$]w}zX­ m|kÊ¯bï ÊfÉ°­¯)>ïGKÊ3°ÆV¼Ä²Ây~±Ó®ÍÂ­<XÉT\É)¶:Å±ÃÂºÆÐ,·Ç(®
÷ò ø¯Tà!0°ÈÐIÒ¿­T\P8¶¦3ÅÊÇ¸­§3×;¼{¹ÔÉÊQµ¬DsYÉàÉ-×È­TàÉN&­T\Él×AÕÂv)¶¦3_×H"ð¦3ÅFÓ³ÇÒË­dÈÊ?½Ç²®§3×;¼{¹ÔÌ¼Æ+ù¯v)).âìßÉB'°ñ
CONFIDENTIAL & PROPRIETARY copy right© 2019 Shuji Kira All rights reserved.

2đď]º3ãs% ØãđčĐĎ p8D Xič¿ÄÃÁHĎ ĕ]ÀDñÉ^g1eãº3ÊßÕïlUiĕgiÞÆã:č÷ąă÷ąĎDÎíNYčóĈýāĎDèÞã¿ÄãDÈñÉDDÊßVÔÝÍîÆ^g\IäÆgiñlUâÆÉrDÆDÆ2MDÆTWDã]/DäÆDDâ)èáÌÊ
ßãč¢Õïafñ·ÐĎ©ÔÙ5ñ#îÑÝÌïčđĎ öċĀćċ÷øôG+ič¿ÅÁ¿HÅdĎĐĎ ¿ÅÀÁHÄdÄ^Æù¯ä^ùiñ]â mÔÝA^>SE*ÇĄĈú<ã@âìîÆp8ßČDDãù¯ºeñi âA^ SÇ^gäÉĂþûă>¡Êñ$¥ÔÆÄd¿Á^Æ¯&2âµÇÔÎÔù¯ªäØãMëDDñÔÆÅdÁ^èÞâÉ]º3ÊñºÇĊ÷òäÉ q
7SãkßÔÝÆ]º3ä&vâ2ºâáÛÙßÊLÔÆ~4âïÇđĎ öċĀćċ÷øô¦+§ÞäÆ^gnÚÛÙ'¼ÏÉrÆÏw°ã²ÞÆDâCÓáÌÊß­çï]ÆTWDÆ2MDâÜÌÝäÉ`Îí^gº3ÚÛÙÊß¡!ÕïâßàèÛÙÇ
ĒĎ 6ãhz¹iB³ä¿ÅÁ¿H¿¾dã§¶{9,ÞÉ[mÔÙDDâDč2MDÆTWDĎë)èðïÊßJÔÙÏËîÆ^g\IßÔÝÆÉDDÊã<âÜÌÝÆæðÏËÛÙÇčĒĎ^ù(>¡ ĕ^ù´ãS}Rãß2

ñ0OÔÙ2¸iĕĐĎ ^gäÉ/D¬±ÊÞã§ñtčbâ2ÉûĉøãP.ÊËîĎÕïëù¯Ï$ÑðÖÇđĎ G+iMÆÉù¯ärD!åDñ^g2âKÐyÕÊÒßÏ&QÓðÙčēĎ ĀĈ÷üĆĀ¿c¢a Æ¿ÅÂ¾H^;iãZ<â"ÔÙù¯ä^ù(>¡ã?ñM®Ó×Æ^gñ|ÔÆÉº3-»ä uxéÊßã5ñ½_âÔÙÇÒðâAÔÆ^gäÀD¬±ñLÇčĔĎ ¿ÅÅ¿HÆõĈÿüĆĀ7ºÏj^ÔÆÉ uxéÊã ñ«XÆw²o¼ßã´ÞÆÉÀDãFC-»ÊâÜÌÝ£Ô&ÛÙÒßñ_ÔÆù¯äÆēDÏº3-»ãA¨ÞËïÒßñ =¤êÙ
CONFIDENTIAL & PROPRIETARY copy right© 2019 Shuji Kira All rights reserved.

3

=;#+
$!

&+<

91855:9* - %' (),:91875:/736701.919519:"+4825191905:

CONFIDENTIAL & PROPRIETARY copy right© 2019 Shuji Kira All rights reserved.

4ôïP+Áb nsz ¶Áóíõî ¢¢@£ÔèÜÐë1u£q<io¬¥[6¦À{#¤°Á6ÀÉË£¢@ÁRÙ"6½!F²·¥?%ZpÁfvw¦¬£¥P);Á=:Á&Îd³Ì°¾¦¸¾S±Í·íöî ÔèÜÐë1u¾_YoÁ¥ÕçØàæéØÕ!F¦í¢¢ @Wî¾¥<2L]¦í¢¢¡@Wîñî ÕçØàæéØÕ!Fù¥[6¦À,»­£@Å½Á?%ZpytÀÎº®³¦°¾À!Fòî <2L]ù¥HJ;¾ÒéÛã;¬Vrn¿*.x¦¥C£);ÁkjÎ®0©´ÀkjÎvw¦¥êÖÏÁQNÎ!en¾ÇÌ¦7ÎRY «ÊL]¤êÖÏ Â"L]Î¥gPA¦¾²¼"Fµ´¤í÷î @W£ãìÚë1u¾^(Xo½¥ÑéÕìÜÕ/S¦Îl¤ñî ¢@ÁRÙ"6Î¥?%ZpfytÀ³ÌlhÎ 5²·,Yn¿enOU¦¾³Ì¤òî ¥[6¦À,»­£ô;Á=:&Îd³Ì°¾ÀÉË£?%ZpÎyt²£* Î4`>³Ì·Ç£fÎ ³Ìóî ¥"TPA¦ÎL]ùRÙ"6À,»­£a}£~ÁÎ ±µ£[6½=:&¬h¾¿¹¼§Ì¥*E£HJÁ=:&ÂfÁt\ÀÉÌ¦¾³ÌÈÁ¤ôî ¥"TPA¦Â*E£HJÎÇÌ°¾Àº¿¬Ì£¾ÁG¬*Á*8¬BÅËIíøî @ÀåÞäì×Óâ1u¬*E;ÎA&²£R Â©Æ¬£@ÀãìÚëc¬1uÀ£RYÈ3 oÁm-ÀÉË£* ÂM'À$¯¼­³íñðî @£ãìÚë1u¾3 o½£¥RáìÝßìÖÛãÁl9À³Ì"/S¦Îl¤¥P+&Â£°ÍÅ½ÀKH±Í·³Ä¼ÁOUªÉÃ!FÀ,»§¼fÎÇ£PÀ¯Í|¿D½VrnÀd³Ì°¾ÀÉË£?%ZpÎyt³Ì¦¾§¨dFÎSíññî ¡@¢W£ãìÚë1u¬£¥?%ZpÎ£¡@À£LZÎ¯´Àyt²É¨¦¾L]
CONFIDENTIAL & PROPRIETARY copy right© 2019 Shuji Kira All rights reserved.

5Ćāüîìýúöüõ7ØHuÖvy ¿k8NØfêàãÀăāüîìØúöüõ7ØHuÖvyÿ·µ¶»D¶ać\¼D±ĀÿăĀ üîìÙ¼"Y°5×ÅÈæ4Øiê,àÒ¿Ąk8NØfÀêàæãÃ\c×§ÑÒÂæ½
ÉçÙ¼¿`J©-ÓáRd ÓáÖÂÀÔ ^½
ÿĄĀ 4ªMăĂĈdÿ]X4d¯Ā×%Ë ¿\cÙ¼Ąk8NØÌÜÒØfÙTæÇÖÂÔ?
ËÒÂæ4ªM×*ýOËÏ½éçéçÙ\c×ánàÒÅäÍ¼4ªMÖÕØ×oÑÏê/ÚQÈÒÂæÐÈÐÀÔæ½
ÿąĀ \cØ°5¦«nÙ¿4ªMØ×^}×ÌæÀÔ2²ËÏÝÆ¼\cÙ¿{Ó1Ąk8NØfê<×àÒÂÖÂ4ÀÔ|Ąāúöüõ7|ØL.ÌæÔÉèÙċ ÿüîìØ£z×ÑÒÄÒßæÔ½½½Ā
ÿăĀ \´©:d¼#Bj9 Sd¼\®NJØ÷þòøïdØ@êÒàÏÓ¼ÞÏ¼¾
ìíômZÇß¼eÇ>U¬ËÒÂÏÔÂÃ>Ô¼[¨d@ê×ËÏ¿\cØ3bØ
°5À£áàÏÓ¼ÎØ¿3bØ°5ÀÓÁæ"Y¸Bê k{8NØfÔËÒüîìÇ°bÌæ×ÑÏ½ÎØ>ê\cÇàÖÂ­å¼C0d s×ÙçÖÂ½ÞÍ>êà¼&çãÿĄĀ ð³×ãæ¿ùûñ ¡À×ÅÂÒ¼ÆäA\$NênÊç¼#BBêðªÇ°bÌæÔØd Ó¶»¸¹Dºa»\×A\$NËÏ½ÎçÙI_Øª(4ÿx6Ù4ªĀØLKÓÁæ½
ĉqĊNt!× Â¼4Ù)¡Øp~ê+=¼¸BÙ#BB×,ÞçÖÂÔØ\cWFØGêUPÌæÛÔ¤S

ÿąĀ \ðdÙðªÔËÒhê©rÓÁÑÏÇ¼h©-J¶DÙbâÄ¼A\$N_Ù¼ÞÐbÓÁÑÏ½ËÆË¼\cØ)4óíòÙ¿wð'dÀêÑÒðª×Và¥ëÐÁå½8N× Ë¼8NJØ{ Eê;æª(4ØgÓÁæØ¢×ãæA\$NÙlIÓÁæ½
CONFIDENTIAL & PROPRIETARY copy right© 2019 Shuji Kira All rights reserved.

6āþùíêÄ¼ÿþùíêÄ¼

dt7LØ^½èCËåY Ą,¬©)ÕX[Ø3Ądt7LØ^½×ÈÏçåe'wYûÿü  dt7LÙ¼©),ûUnited Nationsü½Ä!ÊºLEß©),Ä<ºtèiÊÓ¿å»X[ Ä¼,¬©)½¼,©½Õ+Ûºóõúöúì×[ªèÆ,¬Ø¡Ù¼United Nations½û©),üÔ¾äºX[ 5Ø,Ùº¼©),½ÕyÊÓ¿å»ýĂ$ă,ÔÙ¼)-½Õ»òëñûVereinten Nationenüßëï÷êûNazioni Uniteüß¼©),½ÕyûĀü ôøï£×Â¿Óº United Nationsû©),üØ÷úðúÔ¾å Ãã>X$LègÉæº#?
?Ø°Zè\ ×ºî©Ù>X$LÊÎ»î©×âå#?°ZÙº dt7LØ^Ô¾äºÍØ^ÕÊÓØ,4è*Ýt~Bè9å3×¾å¼United Nations½Ä ÞÎßØ»¼X[Ø"W°.b½Ù dt7LØ^è ÞâÀÕÊÖ¿CÔ¾äº ÞãæÖ¿»Ăkă oî&\è{ÐÓòëñÄî©×RÞ¨éÏ^ºî©Ù2000ßØnmèÊÓÂäº`]×Â¿ÓßzHØÇèpFÊÓDlÕIÐÓ¿ÎØÔÙ»Āþ,¬©)×få¼U,\®½û,©J²±¶\ºµ´\º¶¶\üûÿü U,\®
U,\®ÕÙº,©Jµ´\º¶¶\²®¹º²±¶\×;ÉæÓ¿å»ÍØ=èw×ÁÚº d7L×©),ØU,Ô¾ÐÎ,ÄºLØ^|;ÊÎ®×%ÊÎäºuSèqËå è¦ÈÊÎ3)º,¬©)x,à01:­caÙº:rØ&ÄÖÆÕßD,×>ÊÓ§è}ËÈÕÄÔÅåºÕÊÓ¿å»ÑÜäº¾ãáåè,©×¯ÇåÈÕè;ÊÎºØ,©Jµ²\Ø;×ÙãæÌºU,\®×DËå,Ä¦ÈÊÎ×>ÊÓºs×§è¢ËåÄ= ÉæÓ¿å»ûĀü U,\®Ø«ÙÖÉæÓ¿Ö¿²¸¸µAØ,©ÔU,\®è«Ëåh¤_èX[àòëñÄQÊº¥K6TÔPNÉæÎ»ÊÃÊº,©Jß,¬\ØÿÑÔ¾äºÍæÄèOÑÎÞ×Ùº,©J²±·\Ø;×âäº,©Ô´Ø³Ø6TÔPNÉæºÃÑºÓØ:­r@ r,è*Ýx,Ø´Ø³Ôº(,ØJj×2Ò¿ÓMÉæåGÄ¾å»q/ßv×GÖ´Ø³Øx,ØMÄÉæÓ¿Ö¿ÎÞºU,\®ÙV8/ÊÓ¿åCONFIDENTIAL & PROPRIETARY copy right© 2019 Shuji Kira All rights reserved.

78\]q[fe }9=n|xwqKqXa~

9=q}84(r<q\~|xwq}4(rLAF#0qO?|xw\p~8(p flai9=q(1945+}:20+~S(1,038
-(7,364
36(3,608
BRQ( 5,281T
17,291 }3,124*~8(p flau|xwq(2016+S(2,917
-(7,817
36(5,934
BRQ(→!U Zqs
T16,6689=byWnhq-P%|xwp'fl5kkq/.Hfdt}~<o9yK>MvJjlN0Iq8;99p'90fidn}~1945+8;159q9=YYp^E42q4(p 7_\fiqr^1945+9;59m`udn}~D)pai9=VCvxz{wp1G}57.5~^@&qm,  eg^"cq}5.5~v$jidn
CONFIDENTIAL & PROPRIETARY copy right© 2019 Shuji Kira All rights reserved.

8

Ġė$a¿31ÀåC£täEÚò Í7f¨ªåeÎęėnæÍ2DåjfÎÍ2DåF(ÎÍ2Då»?Îå1ÀÌx iîáæpõäÚòĚėÙÓÙËĜIßånõPÙ×óçËÃIíYÞßØãÐÙËM0gíàÕãÐěė³àí¿3nõ^kÚóçËG·©I1ÀîI1ÀäíċùąāåR½ÔòĜė ä$aÅIÔXc ¸4êàËbfå¿3àÏñ×ÜáÙÜ8,Ë4æËbfàíÞáí²#
Ô±öàÐò56àÏò+UÔÁÐÌuÚòàËêÜËxäÚòäæºLä(ÙÐ9ĝėC»ÓðæËIsá?Aåã:)ē´KñË*èËåãÐ|láxu!Ôµ¡ĞėB_næËÍ-x¶ÎÍđÿ÷åu9>2Ėlēxå¼`åÜìåÇ¾å&ĉĎĒÎËÍćþãÙ vå\Ĕo¦1íCĕÎãâËM0gä.×ÜJõZÞßÕßÐò
ğė$mw­¶§áÿĊď÷d$åČċĐÉÊÈĉđĀúüĄåäáíãÑÉÊÈåh÷Ā÷éåw¯°­áãò%IIæË5_@ē®µ¡UäÒËxµ¡Uí;>ĠėýĐĆĂčĈËûďăøĒc õ/ìËđÿ÷æxË2ÔÙÜcäæÍ¬qå+UÎõ"ôÛòÌÙÓÙËC yåàËCãÍ¬qÎõÙÜØáæNíãÐÌÍÄIOÕzÙÎÓðÍÅIKHå1Àå£tÎéá¬qÙÜïÑä¢ÒòÔË2Sē[]åbfnå+Uõ¨ìò¤!æãÐġėVÃÂÂ}{}æM0gËrēåbfnå¨Ë2Sē[]nåyęĘėđÿ÷æ29«¹ <đÿ÷sÔÐãÐrIÝ×æbfnõ¨ìò+UæÏòÔËCä¥ÃÆ% Qåđÿ÷ Ôë2Sē[]ē ånõ¨ìò+Uæ'áÙßÐáTôóòęęėIsíÍĜIæCä~ÎÍĚIàtÙßåM0gàíÐÐÎáåW¢Ô=ÖãÞßÐò
CONFIDENTIAL & PROPRIETARY copy right© 2019 Shuji Kira All rights reserved.

9Ăù;Ú£v
úù ¾BØâoé^lÑçÞÁÎçàØÜdh_FÜ©ÐÔb·õ5÷Ä¿BÝdhÜ0fÜº2ÅÁÄ3ÝÁóìêËx%WÐ×ÇæRÅÄ¿BÜdhoÜ¦Ù­³Åøé7ª\ÑæÎÙÛÚæÂÐÊÐÁ6}ÝTËÆæÎÙØÆåÁTÜ¨çÚÇé¢náæÎÙâ¶¡ÂÄCA/»Ü£vÁD.
iÜÅé1=ÙÐ×±áæÛÝÁóìêËIÑæ p7SÜké¦áæÅM¡ËÆæûù ¬Ç?jÛÁCA/»Ü£vÁD.iÜé;ØÌæÜÝÁ'bÙâËJÇQqéXÖðöîôõ:¼eÙNèçæÂé°ÒÞÁ`#EÝ/»£vØÌÚÇ(O7Âðöîô7ºÜ¤ÈÄHÌÍÅÁÄdí,<¤é2)ÙÑæÅÙÜ¤ÙÁ: Ü¯ªÜvQÊä;£vé[æÎÙÛÚæüù;Ú£v÷úø Äp7SÜkÅÙÐ×%ºÁ;]µÏç×ÇæÁ1LõVYBÜóìêoé¦áæÂ÷ûø Ä"z²Ü´ÅÙÐ×ÜÁàÔÄdí,<¤ÅØÄHÌ~ÑÅÙÏçÔÁrõÜdhoÜ¦÷üø 1LõVYõÛÝ3Øâ¾À$ÜóìêsË@Ð×ÇæÎÙÊäÁrBÝ&e­³ÁBÛÖÇ×ÝÁdhÜoÚËäÁ÷½ÜãÈÛøKÚ¸g¹Üóìêc_oé¦áæ÷ýø ºzÙZ|t4ÛÖÇ×ÝÁ1Ë¦ÐÔ*ÃÜoÛ{ÕÔoé¦á+È÷þø ÐÁmoº4ÛÖÇ×ÝÁ¿B-«z4ÛÉÍæåçé(ÙÑæ÷ÿø BsÙÓÜ89Ü1LõVYBßÜ¥/ÝuÐÁïëé;¥/é(ÙÑæ÷Āø 1LõVYBÛÉÍæ,|y!Ü±ÂÄ,wÅÙ¢ÐÔxÜa÷āø ÄìñòêUÅÛ>Ñæóìê_FÊäÜG§àÔÝUÛ>ÑæGÚ®P
CONFIDENTIAL & PROPRIETARY copy right© 2019 Shuji Kira All rights reserved. 10ÞÝÜ>#°Cz±°&9´°P\ äe¯£µÏÃÍ°93°+5äÞÜ^KX&9A°Y"«¨¦ÏÃÍ¯*³¬ÚÞÛ !B°#Á;I¡¦ÏÃÍV ÏÃÍÑÕÆÂ»{¨¦"«½¬Áe7£½¬1°FlÏÃÍb°ÏÃÍ±?C°(hØ ¬¹½ÄÙÎÔØÐÃÈcF°ÑÕÆÂE°!B°#ÁÒÙÓ×Ï¯M¯x½ÏÃÍØÒÙÓ×Ï"%D_ÁdaÒÙÓ×ÏÊ|±¢¸u"»Flb°nÁ4ª½
ÚßÛ ÖÃÍÉÌÅÙ&b°B®Rt Ú1ÐËÇØÏÃÍ<91p6?°RtÛâ:ãÏÃÍ±^KX&9¯

UT¯Ú·¦

93°C"/¯L¬¡ªUT¯Û}¯ZÁ £f±V$¯¹[Z¯®½93°ÏÃÍ L°i ±2oj¯±,¤®¥°i ° ±ÏÃÍ9¯y¦¬¯½°«±®ÏÃÍ9Á)¸¦¬¯½°¬Á¼~®«¶¡ ·«8±"%Á¸¨ªkÁO¡ª¦¡¡¾»°"%±u"LÁÀª½¹°«±®u"LÁ©®HJ¯®»®¾²®»®¬q¦ßÜ>#nN°Cz±°&9´°P\ÚÞÛÁW½?C ±>#°&9Á)¸¦¬¬¹¨¬@`9«®¨¦¬¯]° ½¬°CzÁG¦¡ª­¾§rwgm¡ª½§¿ÚßÛ >á.°.L¹a-±Sv®9Á)¸ª¡·¨¦¬¯º½UTf9Á±¢¸®¾²
Ê|°+?9¹>#¹V$°>#¹®¨¦ÚàÛ !B°#Á'iQ°N=aG°?Õ0D_daÁ°&9°\9°s¯£µ
CONFIDENTIAL & PROPRIETARY copy right© 2019 Shuji Kira All rights reserved. 11

I%zpxdNdJ`zpx}~z+=<.7"dzpx

<." $"

dzpx

<." $"

d-Czpx}~zry-|pw

{pw-C@d5dzpx{pwryry{pwA`}~zry{pwAry{pwAzpxV}~zczpx}~z+=

HY[Nzpxery{pwA-d|to,dNn}~zc1 HZlW`_P-Czpx@dM
TifL;Uj6E`#Gn![d eP  19507*6&c'-zpx`}~z`dK_B?Xm[vsuqx+=cik
gjm[AnP/bA`Y^ :FP   PKdAe (YbRP   Pa\jdhNd(nD2YbRQ WSY^Pzpx`}~zd08AOePWdiScY^48U])>8c39 Q
CONFIDENTIAL & PROPRIETARY copy right© 2019 Shuji Kira All rights reserved. 12