᪥ᮏᩍ⫱ᕤᏛ఍ࠉ 㻞㻜㻞㻜 ᖺ᫓Ꮨ඲ᅜ኱఍ A Proposal of Guidelines for Supporting Subject Matter Experts
in Providing Individual Feedback on Report AssignmentsÁƍ æ*1, Î{ ţ*1, Ɗńšĕ*1 , ÓÏü¾*1
Kei AMANO, Ai YAMASHITA, Shigeki TSUZUKU, Naoshi HIRAOKAĤĈÀÃøðUW\kÃĹŁXvYx*1
Research Center for Instructional Systems, Kumamoto University*1ƪB<%ƫĘū3³Ɯ4È&D¬ŹŜ5Ã9Hôó&D)>46Ơy-81-Į3Dħş5ÃŚçċĥHZN[Q%ƠfKx_d[QSlv^Hò%/Ơ¬ŹŜHķÅ3Ã9:Ë/ßŨDơŅŜB
6Ơ"5A3ÃŚŷƜ0øĽÇ5ÉƐÆ25A3ŪĢ4Ĭå%/fKx_d[QSlv^Hç&E7AƠ(%/(EHůŜƒ02Ć%/HòĎ%)ơ"E<05ŅŜBÅžĹŁHő/Ţŀ%/)fKx_d[Q5ÿĜHïCƂCƠƢƟđá4».ūƋƠƣƟ¬ŹŜ5×HÊƌƠƤƟ¬ŹŜ5ŬƃHÖīƠƥƟƢľ5ŪĢƠƦƟÉƐÆ1%/JL]JHĻƠƧƟä¼ ¹fKx_d[QƠƨƟıÍĲ
3ÃŚ:5ų5ƨ-5ŪĢHòĎ%)ơ#B4Ơ"%)ŪĢHůŜƒ0Ć&D)>5ÿĜ1%/ƠƢƟ
janJr5òƠƣƟŗŚ5ĖƞuxQUo[hƟ5òƠƤƟADÂ÷4È&DŲź®G'ƠƥƟSlv^5òHî!)ơƪPxux_ƫ fKx_d[QƠĘū3³ƜƠZxk\KxZvR //?B"1H>$%/)ơůÿĜ5đŨHť ŅŜB6Ơ¬ŹŜò%)six^4È&D

Ƣ4Ļ&ơÃŚĴē6Ơ¬ŹŜşſĵƙ%/Dŷ

fKx_d[Q4ķĴ%/ƠÀÃƑŹÕ5õ´Áƍ

Ɯ4È&DūěŇHśĎ&D"15A4Ơūy-B  4«CŐI0)"5ĹŁ06ƠfKx_d4Ä<B3³4È&D¬ŹŜ5«CŐ=HÈŻ4[Q5ĖHŧùµŭD"1@¬ŹŜ4ħş5ś%/)ơ<)ƠůŜ5ŽčH  0¾­Hì-Ŝ

HĚ>DŷƜ0fKx_d[QHò&D"1ŹÕ1%ƠøĽÇ4ŋƅ%)ÉƐÆ1%)"1ƠĈÅ

:5¢Ė.

HƝ>D"1Ơ(%/¬ŹŜ4ADž5ĦÞ0Dơ"E<04ŅŜBÅž%/)ÿ

şÑñĢHË&D"1fKx_d[QĐ5¡ĩĜHqfsQUovƞ°±wď¨%Ɵ%/Ơf¤4-3D"1HĂB4%)ơ(5yÿ0Ơ"5Kx_d[Q5bMcMHúĪ&D"14%)ơĐ6ůŜ4żëD)>4Ơ2Zxk0fm r9W]Zn

Kx_d[QĐHƇī&DHĒŊ&DŷƜl13,/)ơ("0ƠĈĹŁ06ƠůŜZxklEjc[Ʃ ĪŸHàī%/øŞ5õ´ĎHòĻ0Dr9n5Ʃ¬ŹŜşſ5øŞ4È&Dõ´JL]
JņH<1>)six^0®č»ġHĠ)&"1 0six^4fKx_d[QSlv^Hç%/Űō6ƠÁƍB Hªģ)>5ÿĜHòĎ&D"14%)ơl dgW]

 H}F.(0#:<'0 ĹŁ5ÈŻ6ƠĤĈÀÃƑŹÕLvW^pQU$&!TSo`r]TLvƞ{ƠƟƐŖ0DơŹÕ5 ÉƐÆ4ADsix^:5fKx_d[QHô¬ŹŜ6ƠÀÃøŝ²@¥İŌŝĿÜŜƠĐ5ó&DíƎHťƣ4<1>)ơĘūDÃŚŷƜ5ĉŞçëØŜƠÉƐÃČø²ņƠB5øŞ1

½®6ƠÉƐÆĸ,/Dū42@,/)2C-

Đ£4Ü&Dļ0Dơ"5ŹÕ06Ơ¬Ź

7AHūŵ&E7Aơ1"FƠūy-4

Ŝ4  5»ĺĸźHŚÝ#'ƠøŞ5õ´4ÚŃ

Ä<B3³Ɯ5½®46ƠÉƐÆy-81-5ç

㻙㻌㻝㻤㻟㻌㻙r9lxYƩ 5¾­Hì-ÉƐÆQ|㻞㻜㻞㻜 ᖺ 㻞 ᭶ 㻞㻥 ᪥㸦ᅵ㸧 㻝㻟㻦㻠㻜㻌㹼㻌㻝㻡㻦㻞㻜 ࠉ఍ሙ㸸 㻺㻝㻜㻠㻟㻙㻺㻝㻜㻠㻙㻝 ċĥHZN[Q%/ƠÉƐƛº5Ũ3đáƞ"5Ĺ0*;XŁfKxr_5½®6  m]rƟ4»./ş5ū Zxk0ìŔĲ4Ƈī%/)>46Ơ"5íƎƋHƃ;DßŨDơÒ4đá4Ń+èD"14A

HůŜƒ0Ć%/ßŨDơ(5ÿŇ1%,/Ơů5ÓâHë&D"14?-3D*F/Ơė5ƥ-HśĎ%)ƞťƤƟ
ơjanJr@ŗŚ5ơ<)ƠūŧùDÃŚŷƜ0DB"(ƠƉĖ5ò0ŏGC063ƠƇī5œŔĲ3õ´43/63B356ƠÉƐÆş5śHê%-3DA4ƠƤƟADÂ÷4È&DŲź®G



D"10Dơ(EHƔ)>4ƠƣƟ¬ŹŜ5×HÊƌƠƤƟ¬ŹŜ5Ŭƃ5ÖīƠƥƟyľ5'@ƠƥƟSlv^5òHĳCƁI*ơŪĢƠƦƟÉƐÆ1%/5JL]J5ĻHî!)ơ
ąÛ4ƠfKx_d[QH¦4çŘÄ5½063Ơm r9l~ W|;X Ph )%,-R8
ťƣ5ŪĢH?14Ơ¬ŹŜò&Dsix^5¬ŹŜ5#B3DÃ9:-3!/?51&D)>

2"4ķĶ%/Ơ2fKx_d[QHç&;

4ƠƧƟä¼4-/5éƚHW\[hwdLwW\[h0ò¹fKx_d[QƠƨƟıÍĲ3ÃĻ&DơŚ:5ųHî!)ơƞƣƟij\6R8þ)3ůŜfKx_d[QSlv^HŗŚ0m H}F.(0#DĖHÅĀ&Dơťƣ5ŪĢHŕř%)ZN[
:<'0$&!TS Q|QqW^Hç%/ůHŤ,)CƠĔŉ15ę

ZNB pzƀHŤ,)CƠį³HūĞ%)C&D"14A,/ƠÉƐƛº5Ũ3đá4»./Ơş5ūƋHƃ;DơůŜƒ0ÿƎ5Ųź®G'HŤơůŜƒ0Ć%Ųź®G'HŤơÅĀÛ4ƠS

ň5ƕHłA3ŮýŒċHƃ;D5063Ơlv^ç0ãI*"1324-/ïCƂCHĢĜơ

+/#7R8?vlqyK`

Slv^Đ~5VogOL_1%/Ơƈ©5Sl¬ŹŜĄ/D"1BƗE/ƠůŜ§Żv^Hò&DơůŜSlv^5ÿƎ4ãI@åũHĄ/%<G3A4Ơ¬ŹŜ5ŬƃH

*14ªģ&D"10Dơ2fo^Ęū3ÃŚŷƜ5½®ƠÉƐÆ5ś?y-5×4ƈ3ơ(5"1Håź%ƠůŜ6ş5śHê%

D5063Ơ%/621Ŷ=«E)5A4Ơ<0y5ś1%/Slv^HĄơŤƠÛ62&DH1%/ăþ%/ơ 

Öī%/Slv^H}&Dơ

fKx_d[Q5Ɩ6B5»ġHÌÔ1%/ƌĎ&DơğĢĜ063

sw@

Slv^¶Ƙ3@ůGEDH>¬ŹŜ@C)"1H2ıÍ#'DHòDUG?vl1LI{H}F 3Mu ĈĹŁ06ƠÉƐÆ4ADsix^:5fKx_d[QHôó&DíƎHúĪ%Ơ(EHůŜƒ0Ć&DÿĜHòĎ%)ơÛ6ƠÉƐÆ4ADÙç"7eŷƜūěÃŚ4 DÉƐÆ5Ú6ƠACĆ¡3JL]JHĻ&D"10DMerrill 2012ơ¬Ź
Ŝ5JL]JH#B4Š&D462&E7A

Ĳů@Å¸ů1õ´HŤƠ"5éĜHĝŗ#'/)1ś/DơƠÉƐÆ1%/¬ŹŜ5ŷƜH2śDH
Ļ&Dơ

>kV_

OC4=A'0$&!
<,/3Ģ4-/6ƠĊ|Ċ*03Ơ2"H2ĵ'7AƠĲ3ä¼H
òĻ&DƞƏćƟơaJbEjtÛ5#B3DÃŚ4-3DAƠ¬ŹŜŬƃ%/DÇ4ƓƆ5DªśûĨņHŎ&DơÁƍæƠƊńšĕƠƏćĂƠÓÏü¾ƞ Ɵļ¯øŞhtRpk4 D4È&D¢Ė. H¯z#'D)>5fKx_d[Q5]TLvơāĈøŞ
ÐÃŸûű    Merrill, M. D. (2012) First Principles of Instruction. Pfeiffer, SanFranciscoƏćĂ(1989)\seöƄĭŐ4AD¿·ŴøŞHŦ_qr¹ CAI 5ĒŊ4-/ơöƄøŞĹŁƠ17Ʃ21-37㻙㻌㻝㻤㻠㻌㻙