6U*<,1V\YUHSWW

%RRN5HYLHZ,PSOLFLWDQG([SOLFLW.QRZOHGJHLQ6HFRQG
/DQJXDJH/HDUQLQJ7HVWLQJDQG7HDFKLQJ
9VK,SSPZ:OH^U3VL^LU*H[OLYPUL,SKLY
9VZLTHY`,YSHT1LULMLY7OPSWHUK/H`V9LPUKLYZ)YPZ[VS<2!4\S[PSPUN\HS4H[[LYZ WW_P 0:)5!  
9L]PL^LKI`:[L]LU;<YPJR:OPa\VRH<UP]LYZP[`;OLL_PZ[LUJLVMHNHWIL[^LLURUV^SLKNLHUKHIPSP[`PZVULVM[OLTVZ[PTWVY[HU[PZZ\LZPUZLJVUKSHUN\HNL3[LHJOPUNHUKSLHYUPUN0[OHZILLUYLJVNUPaLKMVYTHU``LHYZ[OH[[OLYLPZHKPMMLYLUJLIL[^LLU
^OH[SHUN\HNLSLHYULYZRUV^HIV\[[OLPY3HUK^OH[[OL`JHUÅ\LU[S`\ZL-VYL_HTWSLHU,UNSPZOSHUN\HNLSLHYULYTH`RUV^[OH[[OL[OPYKWLYZVU ZPUN\SHY Z\IQLJ[ YLX\PYLZ HU ¸Z¹ H[ [OL LUK VM H WYLZLU[ [LUZL]LYI [OH[ MVSSV^Z P[ I\[ Z[PSS VM[LU WYVK\JL \[[LYHUJLZ Z\JO HZ ¸:OL
WSH` [OL WPHUV¹;OLYL OH]L ILLU THU` H[[LTW[Z [V HJJV\U[ MVY [OPZ
WOLUVTLUVU^P[OPU[OLVYL[PJHS^VYRPUZLJVUKSHUN\HNLHJX\PZP[PVU
:3( ,SSPZ   WYVWVZLZ H ]HYPHISL JVTWL[LUJL TVKLS ^OPSL
4J3H\NOSPU \ZLZ[OLJVUJLW[VMYLZ[Y\J[\YPUN[VHJJV\U[MVY[OLNHWIL[^LLURUV^SLKNLHUKHIPSP[`PUSHUN\HNLSLHYULYZ/LYZJOLUZVOU MYHTLZ [OL WYVISLT HZ H WLYMVYTHUJLJVTWL[LUJL NHW HUK2YHZOLUTHRLZHKPZ[PUJ[PVUIL[^LLUHJX\PZP[PVUHUKSLHYUPUN;OPZHY[PJSLPZHYL]PL^VMHYLJLU[IVVR[OH[YLSPLZVUHTVKLSVML_WSPJP[HUKPTWSPJP[RUV^SLKNL[VL_WSHPU[OLRUV^SLKNLHIPSP[`NHWVMZLJVUK<YPJR¸0TWSPJP[HUKL_WSPJP[RUV^SLKNL¹SHUN\HNLSLHYULYZ>VYRPUN^P[OÄ]LJVH\[OVYZ9VK,SSPZOHZWYVK\JLKHIVVR^OPJOYLWYLZLU[ZWYVNYLZZPU[OLHYLHVM:3(0TWSPJP[HUK,_WSPJP[2UV^SLKNL
PU:LJVUK3HUN\HNL3LHYUPUN;LZ[PUNHUK;LHJOPUNZ\JJLZZM\SS`KLÄULZHUK Q\Z[PÄLZ [OL JVUZ[Y\J[Z VM PTWSPJP[ HUK L_WSPJP[ RUV^SLKNL VMMLYZKL]LSVWLKTLHZ\YLTLU[[VVSZHUKWYV]PKLZZVTLTLHZ\YLVMPUZPNO[PU[V [OL YLSH[PVUZOPWZ HTVUN PTWSPJP[ HUK L_WSPJP[ RUV^SLKNL 3WYVÄJPLUJ` HUK MVYTMVJ\ZLK PUZ[Y\J[PVU 0U [OPZ YL]PL^ 0 L_WSHPU PU
ZVTLKL[HPS[OLTVKLSVML_WSPJP[PTWSPJP[RUV^SLKNL[OH[[OLIVVRW\[Z
MVY^HYK0HSZVKLZJYPIL[OL[LZ[Z^OPJO^LYLKL]LSVWLKHUK]HSPKH[LKHUKIYPLÅ`KPZJ\ZZ[OLZ[\KPLZPUJS\KLKPU[OLIVVR7KHPRGHO;OLTVKLS[OH[,SSPZW\[ZMVY^HYKKYH^ZVU[OL^VYRVM5PJR,SSPZHUK
9PJOHYK:JOTPK[[VWVZP[[OLL_PZ[LUJLVM[^VKPZ[PUJ[[`WLZVMSHUN\HNL
RUV^SLKNL·L_WSPJP[ HUK PTWSPJP[ ,_WSPJP[ RUV^SLKNL PZ JVUZJPV\ZKLJSHYH[P]LHUK]LYIHSPaHISL(SHUN\HNLSLHYULYPZJVUZJPV\ZVMOPZVYOLYL_WSPJP[RUV^SLKNL^OPJOJVUZPZ[ZVMHJVSSLJ[PVUVM¸MHJ[Z¹HUK[OLSLHYULYJHUKLZJYPIL[OPZRUV^SLKNL[OYV\NO[OL\ZLVMSHUN\HNL
0TWSPJP[RUV^SLKNLVU[OLV[OLYOHUKPZ[HJP[HUKPU[\P[P]LWYVJLK\YHSHUK UV[ ]LYIHSPaHISL ( SHUN\HNL SLHYULY JHU L_WSVP[ PTWSPJP[RUV^SLKNL[VL]HS\H[L[OLNYHTTH[PJHSP[`VMHZLU[LUJLI`¸MLLS¹I\[[OPZRUV^SLKNLKVLZUV[PUJS\KLHU`ZVY[VMNYHTTHYY\SL[OH[JV\SKILL_WYLZZLKPUSHUN\HNL)V[OL_WSPJP[HUKPTWSPJP[RUV^SLKNLHYL
\ZLKPUSHUN\HNLWYVK\J[PVUHS[OV\NOPTWSPJP[RUV^SLKNLPZOLH]PS`YLSPLK\WVUMVYHJ[P]P[PLZZ\JOHZJVU]LYZH[PVU^OLYL[PTLJVUZ[YHPU[ZPTWPUNLVUHSHUN\HNL\ZLY»ZHIPSP[`[VYLÅLJ[VU[OLJVYYLJ[ULZZHUKHWWYVWYPH[LULZZVM[OLSHUN\HNL\ZLK
;OLTVKLSWYVWVZLKPU[OLIVVRKPMMLYZPU[^V^H`ZMYVTHULHYSPLYTVKLS WYV]PKLK I` ,SSPZ   WW ;OL ÄYZ[ KPMMLYLUJL PZ
[OH[[OL[^V[`WLZVMRUV^SLKNLHYLZLLUHZLU[PYLS`KPZ[PUJ[,_WSPJP[6U*<,1V\YUHSWWRUV^SLKNLKVLZUV[ILJVTLPTWSPJP[RUV^SLKNLUVYKVLZ[OLVWWVZP[LOHWWLUHUKHS[OV\NO[OLYLPZHYLSH[PVUZOPWIL[^LLU[OL[^V[`WLZVMRUV^SLKNL[OL`HYLZLLUHZM\SS`KPJOV[VTV\Z;OPZJVU[YHZ[Z^P[O[OLLHYSPLYTVKLSPU^OPJOL_WSPJP[RUV^SLKNL¸JHUJVU]LY[KPYLJ[S`PU[VPTWSPJP[RUV^SLKNL¹,SSPZ W
:LJVUK[OLTVKLSYLK\JLZ[OL[`WLZVMRUV^SLKNLMYVTMV\Y[V[^V
0U[OLLHYSPLYTVKLSHKPZ[PUJ[PVUPZTHKLUV[VUS`IL[^LLUPTWSPJP[HUK L_WSPJP[ RUV^SLKNL I\[ HSZV IL[^LLU JVU[YVSSLK HUK H\[VTH[PJWYVJLZZLZ,SSPZ *VU[YVSSLKWYVJLZZLZYLMLY[VTVYL¸JVNUP[P]LS`KLTHUKPUN¹WYVJLZZLZ[OH[HYLHJ[P]H[LK[OYV\NO¸H[[LU[PVUHSJVU[YVS¹HUK ¸\ZL \W H]HPSHISL WYVJLZZPUN JHWHJP[`¹ ,SSPZ   W (\[VTH[PJWYVJLZZLZVU[OLV[OLYOHUKKVUV[YLX\PYLH[[LU[PVUHUKHYL HJX\PYLK [OYV\NO [OL YLWL[P[PVU VM H WH[[LYU;OL LHYSPLY TVKLS[OLU OHK MV\Y [`WLZ VM RUV^SLKNLJVU[YVSSLK L_WSPJP[ RUV^SLKNL
H\[VTH[PJ L_WSPJP[ RUV^SLKNL JVU[YVSSLK PTWSPJP[ RUV^SLKNL HUK
H\[VTH[PJPTWSPJP[RUV^SLKNL;OLJ\YYLU[[OLVY`KVLZH^H`^P[O[OLMV\YMVSK KPZ[PUJ[PVU I` HYN\PUN [OH[ PTWSPJP[ RUV^SLKNL PZ I` UH[\YL
H\[VTH[PJHUK[OH[L_WSPJP[RUV^SLKNLPZI`UH[\YLJVU[YVSSLK;OLH\[OVYZOH]LZ\JJLLKLKPUW\[[PUNMVY^HYKHZPTWSLYTVKLSI\[P[KPMMLYZYHKPJHSS`MYVT^OH[THU`PU[OLÄLSKVMJVNUP[P]LWZ`JOVSVN`HYN\L MVY -VY VUL [OPUN [OLYL PZ NYLH[ KLIH[L V]LY ^OL[OLY PTWSPJP[HUKL_WSPJP[RUV^SLKNLHYLJVU[PU\V\ZVYKPJOV[VTV\Z(JJVYKPUN[V+LRL`ZLY¸L_WSPJP[S`SLHYULKRUV^SLKNLJHUILJVTLPTWSPJP[PU[OLZLUZL[OH[SLHYULYZJHUSVZLH^HYLULZZVMP[ZZ[Y\J[\YLV]LY[PTLHUKSLHYULYZJHUILJVTLH^HYLVM[OLZ[Y\J[\YLVMPTWSPJP[RUV^SLKNL^OLU H[[LTW[PUN [V HJJLZZ P[¹ W  0[ PZ HSZV HU VWLU X\LZ[PVU
^OL[OLYJVUÅH[PUNH\[VTH[PaLKWYVJLZZLZ^P[OPTWSPJP[RUV^SLKNLHUKJVU[YVSSLKWYVJLZZLZ^P[OL_WSPJP[RUV^SLKNLPZ[OLJVYYLJ[[OLVYL[PJHSTV]L[VTHRL+LRL`ZLYHYN\LZ[OH[¸H\[VTH[PaLKRUV^SLKNLPZUV[L_HJ[S`[OLZHTLHZPTWSPJP[RUV^SLKNL¹W

<YPJR¸0TWSPJP[HUKL_WSPJP[RUV^SLKNL¹7KH7HVWV;OLYLHYLÄ]L[LZ[ZPU[YVK\JLKPU[OLIVVR[OYLLVM^OPJOHYLKLZPNULKHZ TLHZ\YLZ VM PTWSPJP[ RUV^SLKNL ;OL ,SPJP[LK 6YHS 0TP[H[PVU ;LZ[TLHZ\YLZ[LZ[[HRLYZ»NYHTTH[PJHSHJJ\YHJ`PUYLWLH[PUNZ[H[LTLU[Z[OH[OH]LILLUWYLZLU[LKPUHTLHUPUNMVJ\ZLKJVU[L_[;OL6YHS5HYYH[P]L;LZ[TLHZ\YLZ[LZ[[HRLYZ»NYHTTH[PJHSHJJ\YHJ`HZ[OL`YL[LSSHZ[VY`HM[LYYLHKPUNP[HSV\K[^V[PTLZ;OL;PTLK.YHTTH[PJHSP[`1\KNTLU[;LZ[;.1;TLHZ\YLZ[LZ[[HRLYZ»HIPSP[`[VQ\KNL[OLNYHTTH[PJHSP[`VM
ZLU[LUJLZ\UKLYH[PTLJVUZ[YHPU[;OL<U[PTLK.YHTTH[PJHSP[`1\KNTLU[;LZ[\ZLZ[OLZHTLJVU[LU[HZ[OL;.1;I\[OHZUV[PTLSPTP[ZMVYHUZ^LYZ;OPZ^HZKLZPNULKHZHTLHZ\YL VM [LZ[[HRLYZ» L_WSPJP[ RUV^SLKNL HZ ^HZ [OL 4L[HSPUN\PZ[PJ2UV^SLKNL;LZ[^OPJOYLX\PYLZ[LZ[[HRLYZ[VHUHS`aLHU\UNYHTTH[PJHSZLU[LUJL HUK [OLU JOVVZL [OL HUZ^LY [OH[ L_WSHPUZ [OL NYHTTH[PJHS
TPZ[HRLTVZ[HJJ\YH[LS`(ZWVPU[LKV\[I`,SSPZPUVYKLYMVYYLZLHYJOIHZLKVU[OLPTWSPJP[L_WSPJP[ RUV^SLKNL WHYHKPNT [V TV]L MVY^HYK [VVSZ ^OPJO TLHZ\YL
IV[ORPUKZVMRUV^SLKNLHYLPUKPZWLUZHISL;OLIVVRPUJS\KLZZ[\KPLZ^OPJO ]HSPKH[L [OL [LZ[Z HUK Z\WWVY[ [OL JVUZ[Y\J[Z ^OPJO \UKLYSPL[OLT;OL [LZ[Z HYL OV^L]LY Z[PSS H ^VYRPUWYVNYLZZ 6UL WYVISLT^OPJOT\Z[ILHKKYLZZLKPZ[OLWYHJ[PJLLMMLJ[^OPJO^HZKPZJV]LYLKMVY[OL,SPJP[LK6YHS0TP[H[PVU;LZ[(SZVHSSVM[OL[LZ[ZMVJ\ZLKZVSLS`VU NYHTTH[PJHS RUV^SLKNL 0U [OL M\[\YL [LZ[Z ^OPJO TLHZ\YL V[OLY[`WLZVMSHUN\HNLRUV^SLKNLWYHNTH[PJWOVUVSVNPJHSWOVUL[PJL[JHYLULLKLK;VILMHPYPUJVUZPKLYPUN[OL]HS\LVM[OL[LZ[ZP[OHZILLUWVPU[LKV\[[OH[[OLYLHYL¸UVWLYMLJ[[LZ[Z¹PU[OPZHYLHHUKHSS[OH[VULJHUKVPZ[VZL[\WHZP[\H[PVU^OLYLJVUKP[PVUZHYL¸JVUK\JP]L[V [OL YL[YPL]HS VM PTWSPJP[ HUK L_WSPJP[ RUV^SLKNL HUK [OLU PUMLY¹+LRL`ZLYW



6U*<,1V\YUHSWW

7KH6WXGLHV,SSPZHJRUV^SLKNLZ[OLNLULYHSSHJRVMZ\JJLZZVM[OLZ[\KPLZ^OPJOJVTWYPZL[OL[OPYKHUKMV\Y[OZLJ[PVUZVM[OLIVVR(UPUZ[HUJLVM[OPZPZ
VULVM[OL[^VZ[\KPLZPUJS\KLKPU*OHW[LY;OLZ[\K`HWWLHYZ[VZOV^UVYLSH[PVUZOPWVYH^LHRYLSH[PVUZOPWIL[^LLUPTWSPJP[RUV^SLKNLHUK*);;6,-3HUK;,6-3P);ZJVYLZ;OPZPZW\aaSPUNPUSPNO[VM[OLMHJ[[OH[LHYSPLYPU[OLZ[\K`HWHULSVML_WLY[ZOHKYH[LKWHY[ZVM[OL;6,-3
[LZ[ZHZOPNOS`YLSPHU[VUPTWSPJP[RUV^SLKNL>OPSL THU` VM [OL Z[\KPLZ HYL SLZZ [OHU Z\JJLZZM\S ZVTL KV
WYV]PKL MVVK MVY [OV\NO[ 6UL Z[\K` KLTVUZ[YH[LZ [OH[ [OL KPMÄJ\S[`VM NYHTTH[PJHS Z[Y\J[\YLZ ]HYPLZ HJJVYKPUN [V [OL [`WL VM RUV^SLKNLL_HTPULK -VY L_HTWSL [OL PUKLÄUP[L HY[PJSL PZ MV\UK [V IL TVYLKPMÄJ\S[ HZ PTWSPJP[ RUV^SLKNL [OHU HZ L_WSPJP[ RUV^SLKNL 6U [OLV[OLYOHUKKH[P]LHS[LYUH[PVUPZMV\UK[VILTVYLKPMÄJ\S[HZL_WSPJP[RUV^SLKNL[OHUHZPTWSPJP[RUV^SLKNL&RQFOXVLRQ0UZWP[LVM[OLSHJRVMZ\JJLZZ^OPJOZVTLVM[OLZ[\KPLZTL[^P[O[OPZ]VS\TLPZHUPTWVY[HU[JVU[YPI\[PVU0[ZJSLHYS`KLSPULH[LKTVKLSVMPTWSPJP[L_WSPJP[RUV^SLKNLHUK[OLKL]LSVWTLU[VM[LZ[ZVML_WSPJP[PTWSPJP[RUV^SLKNLHYLHZ[LWMVY^HYK([[OLTVTLU[[OLYLHYLTHU`JVTWL[PUN[OLVYPLZVM:3(HUKVMPTWSPJP[L_WSPJP[RUV^SLKNLMVY[OH[TH[[LY0[PZ\UJSLHY^OPJO[OLVYPLZ^PSSÄUKMH]VYPU[OLSVUNY\UI\[P[ PZ JLY[HPU [OH[ HU` [OLVY` VM :3( T\Z[ HJJV\U[ MVY [OL RUV^SLKNLHIPSP[`NHWKLTVUZ[YH[LKI`3SLHYULYZ;OPZIVVRYLWYLZLU[ZWYVNYLZZ
PUW\YZ\P[VM[OH[NVHS

5HIHUHQFHV+L2L`ZLY90TWSPJP[HUKL_WSPJP[SLHYUPUN0U*+V\NO[` 43VUN,KZ/HUKIVVRVM:LJVUK3HUN\HNL
(JX\PZP[PVUWW 4HSKLU4(!)SHJR^LSS<YPJR¸0TWSPJP[HUKL_WSPJP[RUV^SLKNL¹+L2L`ZLY90U[YVK\J[PVU!:P[\H[PUN[OLJVUJLW[VM
WYHJ[PJL0U9+LRL`ZLY,K7YHJ[PJLPUHZLJVUKSHUN\HNL!
7LYZWLJ[P]LZMYVTHWWSPLKSPUN\PZ[PJZHUKJVNUP[P]LWZ`JOVSVN`WW5L^@VYR!*HTIYPKNL<UP]LYZP[`7YLZZ,SSPZ9 (]HYPHISLJVTWL[LUJLTVKLSVMZLJVUKSHUN\HNLHJX\PZP[PVU0U[LYUH[PVUHS9L]PL^VM(WWSPLK3PUN\PZ[PJZ ,SSPZ9 :3(YLZLHYJOHUKSHUN\HNL[LHJOPUN6_MVYK!
6_MVYK<UP]LYZP[`7YLZZ/LYZJOLUZVOU1;OLZLJVUK[PTLHYV\UK!4PUPTHSPZTHUK3HJX\PZP[PVU(TZ[LYKHT!1VOU)LUQHTPUZ
2YHZOLU:,_WSVYH[PVUZPUSHUN\HNLHJX\PZP[PVUHUK\ZL!
;OL;HPWLPSLJ[\YLZ7VY[ZTV\[O5/!/LPULTHUU
4J3H\NOSPU) 9LZ[Y\J[\YPUN(WWSPLK3PUN\PZ[PJZ