植物科学最前線 7:20 (2016)

Flaveria '14=0< C4 &C"ðĮ HKǦƨÌ ăƂêƒ¯ŰŨîěƘèîǓèî tSWaSVeŤŮŨ
630-0192 śǡÿǢûŞ 8916ǧ5
Evolutionary model of C4 photosynthesis in genus Flaveria
Key words: C4 photosynthesis, evolution, genus Flaveria,
Yuri N. Munekage & Yukimi Y. Taniguchi
Graduate School of Biological Sciences,
Nara Institute of Science and Technology Takayama, Ikoma, Nara 630-0192, Japan
HG





C4 àķŐ=ǦC3 àķŐ8ş:KƔƇŷƊ8ŽŲĳǜŷƊ<ūǞ<ŷƊO¦46ƧźƯOÂ#+ǦŽŲĳǜŷƊ@ CO2 Oŋſ-L C4 à°ÏęOƗ46LC4 à°Ïę7=ǦŁ
ì#J±46%1 CO2 =ǦƔƇŷƊ7ī C4 ǈ<ċ7Ûñ*M1čǦŽŲĳǜŷƊ@ƽ>MǦ
ƍŌǈǇŶ;IKŽŲĳǜŷƊ7 CO2 $ĥ¸*ML))7śę+1 C3 ǈ=¶?ƔƇŷƊ;ƽ>M¶Ć CO2 ÛñÈĔ;¦NMLâƪ8:L)< C4 ×Ư8Õ>MLƧźƯ;IKǦŽ
ŲĳǜŷƊ< CO2 ¹ÝOǢEL)8$7%LĪǦC3 à°Ïę;"6ƔƇŷƊ7 CO2ÛñOƗ46Lye 1,5-veǈX}Zcg/WZc^pgǤRuBisCOǥ
=ǦC4 àķŐ7=ǦŠŗǝá$ŽŲĳǜŷƊ@ǒñÃ*MLĎ46ǦC3 à°Ïę7=°Õ
Ò;I46°ÏęÁŖ$ 20ǣǧ50ǣ£-L$ǦC4 à°Ïę7=°ÕÒ;IL°ÏęÁŖ<£OǑ')8$7%L)<1EǦC4 à°Ïę=ǦǢňGł¹ļŚä;IKƔ´< CO2ŋĆ$£-LĴ7ǦC3 à°ÏęIKİ¼;­&(Long 1999)
ßŘ;= 19 <ú;N1Lŵ 7500 ū< C4 àķŐ$íÞ-LŴżîơĵ;IKǦ0MJ= 66 Ŵż<œů< C3 àŧ¯ū#JŠś+18ƅ!JM6L(Sage 2012)B1ǦC3-C4 Ǐà;¹Ǟ*MLķŐ$ 21 ŴżíÞ+Ǧ)<

3 12 Ŵż;"6 C3-C4 Ǐū8 C4 ū$³Ƹ<ŧ¯Oĝ5)8$ãÓ*M6L(Christin et al. 2011, Sage et al. 2011))<)8#JǦC4à°Ïę=ǦC3-C4 ǏàOź6Šś+18ƅ!JM6LC3-C4 Ǐà°Ïę7=Ǧ°ÕÒ7ś,1]cOŽŲĳǜŷƊ@ƽP7 CO2 Oĥ¸-L]ccn;I46CO2 <ŋſOƗ)<]ccn7= C4 ×Ư8ÐĹ;ƔƇŷƊ8ŽŲĳǜŷƊ

<ūǞ<ŷƊO¦46 CO2 Oŋſ-L)8#JǦC3-C4 Ǐà7=ǦC4 à°Ïę<Ŋ¬Ŀ
ǔ<ċĘGƧźƯ$ĸų*M6L8ƅ!JMLĲŬ7Ÿ-LZ\Ũ Flaveria úķŐ;=ǦC3 ūǦC4 ū2(7:&ǦC3-C4 Ǐū8 C4 Ĺū$çĦíÞ-L)MJƻÃš;Ƶ&Ð,^sƉĮOF5ū<ŀƳơĵ#JǦƵĂǂë{7Ĺ:ŗƩ$N#K55L

Y. N. Munekage & Y. Y. Taniguchi-1
BSJ-Review 7:20 (2016)

植物科学最前線 7:21 (2016)ĲŬ7=ǦFlaveria úķŐOm8+ǦĿǔš;ƻP2 C4 à°ÏęęůB7<ƻÃƾŪ;56ƅõ-L

IG9 Flaveria '14?3!F

C4 àķŐ$ßŘ;¸ŗ+1<=ŵ 3300 Ă7L8Ġŉ*M6LǤSage et al. 2012ǥ)M;ö+ Flaveria ú< C4 Ŵż=ƻÃš;ĩ+&Ǧŵ 300 Ă¾;¸ŗ+18Ġŉ*M6
LǤChristin et al. 2011ǥFlaveria ú<ç&=RXÏƖÜ<ÅǄǦZc_"I?ƝSoƦý;¹Ā+6"KǦŗÞ C3 #J C4 ūOÑE6 23 ūíÞ-L)8$ťƣ*M6LǤPowell 1978, McKown et al. 2005ǥŴżîšơĵ;IKǦ)MJ= C3 ū7ĸę*MLâąƃǦClade AǦClade B ;¹Ǟ*MLǤ))7=Ě$ơĵ;¦ŝ+1 8 ū<COŦ-ǦÚ1ǥB1Ǧ)<ơĵ#J Flaveria ú7=ǦC3
ū#J C3-C4 Ǐū$Šś+1čǦ2 5<Clade ;¹#M6 C4 Ã$ƻP2)8$N#L(McKown et al. 2005ǥClade A ;= C3-C4 Ǐà, C4 ĹàǦC4 àū$ÑBML<;ö+ǦCladeB 7įF C4 Ã+1ū=ǦC4 Ĺū< F. brownii <C7L
C3 #J C4 àB7<°ÏęiSz=Ǧ0MJ<ķŐ$F5 CO2 ƛ®ō8ǦWZc^pgÈĔ;IL°Ïę£ŖǤO2 inhibition, %ǥ;I46¹(J6"KǦC3 à=ŵ 50 µl/l, C3-C4
Ǐà= 30-10 µl/l, C4 Ĺà= 10-5 µl/lǦC4 à= 5 µl/l < CO2 ƛ®ōOŦ-ǤKu et al. 1991ǥ12+ C3-C4 ǏūG C4 Ĺū;"6Ǧ0MJ< C4 ÃĆÏǤ9M2( C4 à;ƵĕƪOF5#9#ǥ=ū;I46Ĺ7LJG;),Kranz 2B8DFlaveria úķŐ;"6ǦC3 ū8 C4 ū7=ā<ĄƔ$ċę*ML<;ö+ǦC3-C4 Ǐū<ǄG C4 Ĺū=ŷǍƔ$ċę*MLǤÚ 2ǥ)8#JǦƔ<ċ= C4 à8ǐ¨+:8
ƅ!JMLĪǦÎ Flaveria ū<ƔƌuiOƠõ-L8ǦC3 à7=ǦƔƌǏƭǙ$Ą<;ö+ǦC3-C4 Ǐū7=GGŔ&ǦC4 Ĺū"I? C4 ū7=įFŔ&:46LǤÚ 3, Mckwon & Dengler 2007ǥ)<I:ŽŲĳôĆ<Ĭ=ǦƔƇŷƊ8ŽŲĳǜŷƊOǨǫǨ7ǅƁ*/L1E;ǉƞ7L)8$ãÓ*M6LǤDengler and Nelson1999ǥFlaveria úķŐ7=ǦC3 à#J C3-C4
ǏàǦC4 Ĺà@<ƻÃ<ƾŪ7ǦĿǔš;ŽŲĳôĆ$Ĭ+6L)8$N#L

Y. N. Munekage & Y. Y. Taniguchi-2BSJ-Review 7:21 (2016)

植物科学最前線 7:22 (2016)

C4 àķŐ7=ǦƑ;ƓŚOėÔ-L Kranz
ĸƹ8I>MLƔ<´Ǆ<ŹƀċĘ$Ơõ*M
LKranz ĸƹ<ñƄ=B7L$ǦǨǥƔƇŷƊ;ö+6ŽŲĳǜŷƊ$è%&ƈèÃ-LƢ<ŽŲĳôĆ<Ĭ;IKǩǥƔƇ
ŷƊ(M)$ŽŲĳǜŷƊ(BS);ǖğ+6ÐĒµŒ;ǨǫǨ7ǅƁ*MǦvein-BS-M-M-BS-veinuiOċę-LǪǥŽŲĳǜŷƊ;"
6Ɣž¤<ĦGè%*$åè+Ǧ0MJ$ŽŲ
ĳ;ö+ŃĒšB1=ǀĒš;ǅƁ*ML8

ċĘæÃ$ÑBMLǤDengler and Nelson

1999ǥÇëƔķŐ7=ŽŲĳ=Ɯǘ;ƫL1EǦï²: vein-BS-M-M-BS-vein uiOċę+:$ǦǞ¡+1ċĘ$ƟJMLFlavera úķŐÎū<ƔĺĨºŏOƠõ-L8ǦC3
àū7=ŽŲĳǜŷƊ=ƔƇŷƊ;ö+6÷*$ǦC3-C4 Ǐū7=ǦŽŲĳǜŷƊ8ƔƇ
ŷƊ=Ð,è%*7KǦC4 ĹūG C4 ū7=ŽŲĳǜŷƊ<Ī$ƔƇŷƊIKFè%&ǦƔŹƀ
ĸƹ$Ŀǔš;æÃ+6LĹë$ƟJMLǤÚ
4ǥB1ǦC3-C4 Ǐū7=ǦC3 ū8ŀƳ+6ŽŲĳǜŷƊ<Ɣž¤Gn_oR<Ħ$å¿+Ǧ0MJ<ç&=ŃĒš¢Ɓ;ǅƁ*ML
C4 ĹūG C4 ū7=ǦŽŲĳǜŷƊ;"(LƔž¤<Ħ$*J;å!ǦƔž¤<è%*Fåè-LǤÚ 4ǦNakamura et al. 2013ǥ)<I:ǦC3-C4

Ǐū#JƟJMLŽŲĳǜŷƊ;"(LWYr<Šƿ=ǦƔƇŷƊ8ŽŲĳǜŷƊ<5<ŷƊO¦41ƧźƯ<Šƿ8ôğ;ǐ¨+6L8ƅ!JMLKG8D

C4 %@6*C3-C4 Ǐū<ƔƇŷƊ7=ǦC3 ū8ÐĹ; RuBisCO $íÞ+ǦC3 ×Ư$×46LC3-C4Ǐū7=Ǧ]ccn;IL CO2 ŋſĻƋ$­&1EǦC3 ūIKF£ CO2 ƛ®ōOĝ5)8$ãÓ*M6LǤBauwe 2011, Keerberg et al. 2014ǥƔƇŷƊ7 RuBisCO <WZc^pgÈĔ;IKś,1]c=ǦŽŲĳǜŷƊ@ƽ>MǦ0)7<ƍŌǈÈĔ;IK CO2 $ĥ¸*MLǤÚ 5ǥŽŲĳǜŷƊ<Ɣž¤=n_oR<Ƶ«;¢Ɓ+Ǧn_oR7ĥ¸*M1 CO2 OƔž¤$ÁŖI&nkz7%LƍŌǈ<Ǖ;ś,1f
=ǦƷ;ƔƇŷƊ@ƽ>MLC3 à°Ïę#J C3-C4 Ǐà<]ccn$ŕď*MLƾŪ=ǦŀƳšcz:æÃ7Ƥĭ*M6Lǉƞ:~Sn=Ǧn_oR7ƍŌǈÈĔOƗ]cmX}ZcgǤGDCǥ<Šŗǝá$ǦŽŲĳǜŷƊ;Y. N. Munekage & Y. Y. Taniguchi-3BSJ-Review 7:22 (2016)

植物科学最前線 7:23 (2016)

ǒñ*ML)8KǦƧŜŐ<ũÂ=ŋĆ§íš;Ƭ)L8ƅ!JM6LǤEngelmann et al. 2008, Sage et al. 2013ǥ]ccn<ŕď;IKǦķŐ=ƔƇŷƊ8ŽŲĳǜŷƊ<5<ŷƊO¦41ƧźƯOǠÂ-L)88:LC3-C4Ǐū7=)<źƯ<ŕď8³;ŽŲĳǜ
ŷƊ7<WYr<ƕŭ$©*M18ƅ
!JML]ccnOF5 C3-C4 Ǐà#J9<I; C4 ×Ư$Šƿ-L<#=Ǧ

B2ơĭ*M6:$ǦFlavera úķŐOŝ1ŀƳơĵ#JƐÔņƩ$ĭJ#;:46L]ccnOĝ5 C3-C4 Ǐū<ç&=ǦĻƋš: C4 ×ƯOĝ1:)8$
ãÓ*M6LǤBauwe 2011ǥ$ǦFlavera C3-C4 Ǐū7=Ǧ14CO2 < C4 ǈ@<ÊKƴC$£{7Ơõ*M6LǤMonson et al. 1986ǥB1ǦFlavera C3-C4 Ǐū7=ǦC4 ×Ư
7­&ǇŶƃǦ|e|VswvǈX}ZcgǤPEPCǥǦwvǈǈdZpgǤPPDKǥǦNADP-k\VbSǤNADP-MEǥGRqRsnexUg<Šŗ$ǦC3 ū8ŀƳ+6Ǣ)8$ãÓ*M6LǤMallmann et al. 2014ǥ)M
J<Ʃ=Ǐū;"6FǦC4 ƧǇŶO¦41ƧźƯ$Ǆ¹š;ĻƋ-L)8OƺĖ
*/LMallmann J=Ǧ]ccn7ǈÃŌŶ8³;ĥ¸*MLRqROƧ-L1E;ǦC4 ƧǇŶƃ$¦NM1ÍƋĕOĞģ+6LòǕ;ǦRuBisCO <Šŗ$ƔƇŷƊ;ľL C4 Ĺū F. brownii 7=Ǧ]ccn;¿!ĻƋš: C4 ×Ư$­&)8$
ãÓ*M6"KǤCheng et al. 1988, Monson et al. 1988, Shulze et al. 2013, Sage 2014ǥ]ccn;§í+1 CO2 ŋſ#J C4 ×Ư;IL CO2 ŋſ@Ŀǔš;ũƗ+1ÍƋĕ
$ƅ!JML

LGC4 & $--:$-#+/E"
 C4 °Ïę<ęů;=ǦƧǇŶƃ<ŠŗĬ2(7:&Ǧ0MJ<Šŗǝá$ƔƇŷƊB
1=ŽŲĳǜŷƊ@ǒñÃ*ML)8$ǉƞ:elkz8:L)<ùÞÃ<elkzFB
1ǦC3-C4 Ǐà#J C4 ĹàǦC4 à@<ƻÃƾŪ7Ŀǔš;ƻDǤTaniguchi et al. in preparationǥFlaveria úķŐ;= PEPC O_o-Lǂë$Ǧ6 ūíÞ-L$Ǧ0MJ<3 PPCA <Š

ŗ<C$ C3 ū#J C3-C4 ǏūǦC4 ĹūǦC4 ū;"6Ŀǔš;Ĭ-LĪǦŠŗǝá
OƥAL8ǦPPCA =ǦC3-C4 Ǐū F. floridana 7=ǦƔƇŷƊ8ŽŲĳǜŷƊ<ÇĪ7Šŗ
+6L<;ö+ǦC4 Ĺū F. brownii 7=ǦPPCA <Šŗ=ƔƇŷƊ7Ċ&ŽŲĳǜŷƊ7ĉǤTaniguchi et al. in preparationǥB1ǦC4 ū Flaveria 7=ǦPPCA Šŗǝá=ï²;ƔƇ
ŷƊ;ǒñÃ*MLPPCA <ƔƇŷƊőşš:Šŗ=ǦPPCA <z―i;íÞL MEM1 8Õ>MLceǅ»$ǐ-L)8$ãÓ*M1ǤAkyildiz et al. 2007ǥ+#+:$JǦClade B ;ú-L F. floridana 8 F. brownii Ǐ7=ǦMEM1 ǅ»;þş$:&ǦB1)
MJ<ǘ F2 ǗÙOŝ1Ǧƙŗà8ǂëà<ƺǌơĵ#JǦPPCA <ùÞÃ;z―iǅ»$ǐ+:)8$ĭJ#8:41ǤMunekage et al. in preparationǥĎ46ǦPPCA

Y. N. Munekage & Y. Y. Taniguchi-4
BSJ-Review 7:23 (2016)

植物科学最前線 7:24 (2016)<ùÞÃ=ǦneØë;I46Ĉ%Ƭ)*M1ÍƋĕFƅ!JMLPEPC 2(7:&Ǧ
PPDK, NADP-ME <ŠŗǝáF mRNA {7½Đ*MǦǏà#J C4 Ĺà@<ƻÃ<ƾŪ7ŷƊőşĕ$ŕď*MLǤTaniguchi et al. in preparationǥC4 ƧǇŶƃ<Šŗǝá$ǒñÃ*MLū8ǦĻƋš: C4 ×Ư$­&)8$ãÓ*M6Lū$Ə-L)8#JǦŠŗǝá<ǒñÃ$ǦC4 ×ƯOǠÂ-L5<ƞØ7L8ƅ!JMLǤÚ 6ǥĪǦ RuBisCO<ŠŗǝáFB1ǦĿǔš;ǦŽŲĳǜŷƊ@ǒñÃ*M)8$ǦFlaveria úķŐ<ơĵ#JĭJ#;:46LǤMoore et al. 1988, Moore et al. 1989ǥC3-C4 Ǐū7=ǦRuBisCO =ƔƇŷƊ8ŽŲĳǜŷƊ<ÇĪ7Šŗ-L<;ö+ǦC4 Ĺū7=ǦƔƇŷƊ7<Šŗ$è%&Ĝ½*MǦC4 ū7=ï²;ŽŲĳǜŷƊ@ǒñÃ*MLRuBisCO <Šŗǝá$ï²;Ž
ŲĳǜŷƊ@ǒñÃ*ML)87ǦƔƇŷƊ7<WZc^pgÈĔ$Ĝ½*MǦ£ CO2ƛ®ōOF5 C4 à°Ïę$ęů-LǤÚ 6ǥRuBisCO <Šŗ;=Ǧĸęay

qkn7

LĶ;_o*ML RBCS 8Ɣž¤;_o*ML RBCL <Ī<Ʋ·"I?Ʋ·č½ĐĻĸ$ǐNL)8$ţJM6LǤPatel and Berry 2008ǥC4 ū Flaveria bidentis 7= RBCS < 5’
UTR "I? 3’UTR ǅ»$ŽŲĳǜŷƊ@<Šŗǝá<ǒñÃ;è%&##NL)8$ãÓ
*M6LǤPatel et al.
2006ǥFlaveria úķŐOÑEǦĹ:ķŐ;"6ǦRBCS =ƜĦ<ǂë;_o*M6L)8$ãÓ*M6"
KǦ0<ŠŗǊFǂë;§í+:)<I;ƜĦ<ǂëć;_o*MLxQǂëŠŗOĜ½-L1E;=ǦUTRs O¦41 mRNA {7<½Đ$İÁ7L8ƅ!JML C4 à°Ïę=ǦCO2 ŋſĻĸOŕď+1)8;IKǦC3 °ÏęIKFIKç&<Vr[O0<ƧÈĔOǠÂ-L1E;ēƞ8-L1 ¹ë< CO2 Ûñ;ǦC3 à°Ïę7= 3 ¹
ë< ATP 8 2 ¹ë< NADPH $ēƞ7L<;
ö+ǦC4 à°Ïę7= 5 ¹ë< ATPǦ2 ¹ë<NADPH $ēƞ7L)< ATP ÏęOƛE;ǦƔž¤đŚàǚë1ƿ$ĻƋ-L)8$

ŦÖ*M1ǤKanai and Edwards 1999ǥFlaveria
úķŐ7=ǦđŚàǚë

ƿńĕ=ǦC4 ×Ư$ĻƋ+6L C4 Ĺū8 C4 ū7ǟưš;Ǣ&:KǦB1 C4 Ĺ F. palmeri "I? C4 ū7=ŽŲ
ĳǜŷƊ<Ɣž¤<j_SoƎĸƹ$è%&
æÃ+Ǧ°ÃîŴ II $ùÞ-L]pĸƹ$Ň
ø-LǤÚ 7ǦNakamura et al. 2013ǥŽŲĳǜ
ŷƊ7=ǦATP 8 NADPH <ÇĪOśŜ-LŢǌàǚë

ƿńĕ$Ĝ½*MǦƷ; ATP <C<

Y. N. Munekage & Y. Y. Taniguchi-5
BSJ-Review 7:24 (2016)

植物科学最前線 7:25 (2016)

śŜ;ó-LđŚàǚëƿńĕ$©ƻ*ML)87ǦC4 à°Ïę;ēƞ:Vr[ǛŻte$ª1ML8ƅ!JML12+ǦC4 ū Flaveria 7=ǦPEPC ;Ûñ*M1WZaǆǈ<Ǆ$Reu[ǈ@æġ*MǦ`ǈ8Reu[ǈ<ÇĪ$ŽŲĳǜŷƊ@ƽ>ML)8$ãÓ*M6LǤMoore and Edwards 1986, Meister et al. 1996ǥŽŲĳǜŷƊ7Reu[ǈ#J`ǈ@<ƶǃ; NADPH $ēƞ7L1EǦnT_cGhY8ŀƳ+6 C4 ū Flaveria 7=ǦŽŲĳǜŷƊƔž¤<]pĸƹ=ï²;=Ņé
+6"J.°ÃîŴ II ńĕ$ľ*M6"KǦŢǌǚë
ǤMeister et al. 1996ǥ)<I;Ǧǚë

ƿ$­&)8$ŦÖ*M6LƿÈĔ=ƧÈĔ8ƺÂ+6½ĐOË(Ǧ°ÏęÈĔ<įǁÃ$ƗNM6L

MG



à°Ïę=ƚëķŐ<çü;N1Lú7ŕď*M6L)8#JƚëķŐ$ǢňGÄŎĴ;ǁĔ+6&ƾŪ7Ĉ%Ƭ)*M1ÉħƻÃċ<57L8ƅ!JMLĎ46à@<ƻÃ=¥#àķŐ$³Ƹ+6F5celO¼ŝ+6Ĉ%Ƭ)*M1ÍƋĕ$ƅ!JML$)<ƻÃ;ǐNLZ8:LØë=ĭJ#;:46: ú=ŀƳšç&<Ǐàū$ŗí+6"KƾÆ<śřîšśÃîšơĵŹƀîšơĵ0+6ƵĂǟưš;ƻP2ǂë{7<ơĵ;IKàƻÃ;"(LĹ:ƾŪ$ĭJ#;:K55Lč^s{7<ơĵ$ƻD)87ƻÃ<ƱƮ$ĭJ8:L)8OıČ-LNG>AĲŬ7Ÿ+1űƆJ<ŤŮ=¯ŰŤŮÀęâǋÀęǋį¯ŰĽŤŮǎŠĤĢz]Ǥ ǥ"I?^sĤĢ    <ĤĢOď6ƼƗ+1

OG(7.5Akyildiz M, Gowik U, Engelmann S, Koczor M, Streubel M, Westhoff P. 2007. Evolution andfunction of a cis-regulatory module for mesophyll-specific gene expression in the C4 dicot Flaveria
trinervia. Plant Cell. 19: 3391-402.
Bauwe H. 2011. Photorespiration: the bridge to C4 photosynthesis. In: Raghavendra AS, Sage RF, eds.
C4 photosynthesis and related CO2 concentrating mechanisms. Dordrecht, The Netherlands:Springer, 81–108.
Christin P-A, Osborne CP, Sage RF, Arakaki M, Edwards EJ. 2011. C4 eudicots are not younger thanC4 monocots. J Exp Bot 62: 3171–81.
Cheng SH, Moore BD, Edwards GE, Ku MS. 1988. Photosynthesis in Flaveria brownii, a C4-likeSpecies. Leaf anatomy, characteristics of CO2 exchange, compartmentation of photosynthetic
enzymes, and metabolism of 14CO2. Plant Physiology 87: 867-873.
Dengler NG and Nelson T 1999. Leaf structure and development in C4 plants. In: Sage RF, Monson
RK, eds. C4 Plant Biology. San Diego, USA: Academic Press, 133-172.
Engelmann S, Wiludda C, Burscheidt J, Gowik U, Schlue U, Koczor M, Streubel M, Cossu R, Bauwe
Y. N. Munekage & Y. Y. Taniguchi-6
BSJ-Review 7:25 (2016)

植物科学最前線 7:26 (2016)

H, Westhoff P. 2008. The gene for the P-subunit of glycine decarboxylase from the C4 species
Flaveria trinervia: analysis of transcriptional control in transgenic Flaveria bidentis (C4) andArabidopsis (C3). Plant Physiol, 146: 1773-85.
Kanai R, Edwards GE. 1999. The biochemistry of C4 photosynthesis. In: Sage RF, Monson RK, eds.
C4 Plant Biology. San Diego, USA: Academic Press, 215-249.
Keerberg O, Pärnik T, Ivanova H, Bassüner B, Bauwe H. 2014. C2 photosynthesis generates about
3-fold elevated leaf CO2 levels in the C3-C4 intermediate species Flaveria pubescens. J Exp Bot 65:3649-56
Ku MSB, Wu J, Dai Z, Scott RA, Chu C, Edward GE. 1991. Photosynthetic and photorespiratory
characteristics of Flaveria species. Plant Physiology 96: 518-528.
Long SP. 1999. Environmental Responses. In: Sage RF, Monson RK, eds. C4 Plant Biology. San
Diego, USA: Academic Press, 215-249.
Mallmann J, Heckmann D, Bräutigam A, Lercher MJ, Weber AP, Westhoff P, Gowik U. 2014. The
role of photorespiration during the evolution of C4 photosynthesis in the genus Flaveria. eLife 3,e02478.
Mckown, A. D., Moncalvo, J. M. and Dengler N. G. 2005. Phylogeny of Flaveria (Asteraceae) andinference of C4 photosynthesis evolution. American Journal of Botany 92: 1911–1928.
McKown AD, Dengler NG. 2007. Key innovations in the evolution of Kranz anatomy and C4 vein
pattern in Flaveria (Asteraceae). American Journal of Botany 94: 382–399.
Meister M, Agostino A, Hatch MD 1996. The roles of malate and aspartate in C4 photosynthetic
metabolism of Flaveria bidentis (L.) Planta 199: 262-269
Monson RK, Teeri JA, Ku MS, Gurevitch J, Mets LJ, Dudley S. 1988. Carbon-isotope discriminationby leaves of Flaveria species exhibiting different amounts of C3-and C4-cycle co-function. Planta174: 145-51.
Monson RK, Moore Bd, Ku MSB, Edward GE. 1986. Co-function of C3- and C4-photosynthetic
pathways in C3, C4 and C3-C4 intermediate Flaveria species. Planta 168: 493-502.
Moore BD and Edwards GE 1986. Photosynthetic induction in a C4 dicot, Flaveria trinervia Plant
Physiol. 81: 663-668
Moore Bd, Ku MSB, Edwards GE. 1989. Expression of C4-like photosynthesis in several species ofFlaveria. Plant, Cell & Environment 12: 541-549.
Moore Bd, Monson RK, Ku MSB, Edwards GE. 1988. Activities of principal photosynthetic andphotorespiratory enzymes in leaf mesophyll and bundle sheath protoplasts from the C3-C4
intermediate Flaveriaramosissima. Plant Cell Physiology 29: 999-1006.
Nakamura, N., Iwano, M., Havaux, M., Yokota, A., Munekage, Y.N. 2013. Promotion of cyclic
electron transport around photosystem I during the evolution of NADP-malic enzyme-type C4
photosynthesis in the genus Flaveria. New Phytologist. 199: 832-842
Patel M and Berry JO. 2008. Rubisco gene expression in C4 plants. J Exp Bot. 59: 1625-34.
Patel M, Siegel AJ, Berry JO. 2006. Untranslated regions of FbRbcS1 mRNA mediate bundle sheathcell-specific gene expression in leaves of a C4 plant. J Biol Chem. 281: 25485-91.
Y. N. Munekage & Y. Y. Taniguchi-7
BSJ-Review 7:26 (2016)

植物科学最前線 7:27 (2016)

Powell, A. M. 1978. Systematics of Flaveria (Flaveriinae–Asteraceae). Annals of the Missouri
Botanical Garden 65: 590–636.
Sage, T.L., Busch, F.A., Johnson, D.C., Friesen, P.C., Stinson, C.R., Stata, M., Sultmanis, S., Rahman,B.A., Rawsthorne, S., & Sage, R.F. 2013. Initial events during the evolution of C4 photosynthesis inC3 species of Flaveria. Plant Physiol, 163: 1266-1276.
Sage RF, Christin PA, Edward EJ. 2011. The C4 plant lineages of planet Earth. Journal ofExperimental Botany 62: 3155-3169.
Sage RF, Khoshravesh R and Sage TL 2014. From proto-Kranz to C4 Kranz: building the bridge to C4
photosynthesis J Exp Bot. 65: 3341-56.
Sage RF, Sage TL, Kocacinar K. 2012. Photorespiration and the evolution of C4 photosynthesis.
Annual Review of Plant Biology 63: 19-47.
Schulze S, Mallmann J, Burscheidt J, Koczor M, Streubel M, Bauwe H, Gowik U, Westhoff P. 2013.
Evolution of C4 photosynthesis in the genus Flaveria: establishment of a photorespiratory CO2 pump.
Plant Cell. 25: 2522-35.

Y. N. Munekage & Y. Y. Taniguchi-8
BSJ-Review 7:27 (2016)