植物科学最前線3（2012）$&*%#('uǂ ǐǓ 1oǕ­ z×Ǔ 2oèŗ Üv 3
1. ¤ŉǏÖÚ ¤ĝţśÄ\=pkVŹÚNnPp
053-0035 ¤ŉǏƠèŚìǧt ¤ŉǏÖÚ ƠèŚŴžı
2. ŞƀƧėŅ{ Ķıƒ±Ŵžć¼ÃĖć
780-8077 ǧŲŰǧŲìĩƬŦ 2-915
3. ŞƀƧėŅ{ ÃƀŢÏŴžć ŢÏƳŎŴžNnPp)ìèǕê 16-2

305-8506 ơÊŰ

Potential of non-destructive spectral imaging for study on rhizosphere dynamics
Keywords: hyperspectral reflectance; image analysis; near-infrared; root growth
Tatsuro Nakaji 1, Kyotaro Noguchi 2, Hiroyuki Oguma 3
1. Field Science Center for Northern Biosphere, Hokkaido University
Tomakomai Experimental Forest, Takaoka, Tomakomai, Hokkaido 053-0035, Japan
2. Shikoku Research Center, Forestry and Forest Products Research Institute2-915, Asakuranishimachi, Kochi 780-8077, Japan
3. Center for Environmental Measurement and Analysis, National Institute for Environmental
Studies
16-2, Onogawa, Tsukuba, Ibaraki 305-8506, Japan,+
ķś'ĴǬŜ%qƝ%Ůö 2mm Ĭŏ!ÝƖ76ƊĴ(Ǭǥ2Ń'µ«"'Ľƚ1ķśţšÚŬ%ǔƭ!6ÿċē7Ǭ7!$ǬÅÒ*'ħĽśƏŐ"6ǪDe Kroon & Visser 2003ǫ°Ç'Ķı'ŴžţŤ' 2 Ǳ6 

ƊĴ'ţŤ%6"Í¶71ǔƭ!(ǬƆ'Ƈqľ

5Ǭ'ð(ǝï%ÖǪKeyes &Grier 1981, Vogt et al. 1982, Jackson et al.1997, Kajimoto et al. 1999, Janssens et al. 2002, Xiao et al.
2003ǫ'0Ǭ'ţŤð'¦¾:ƊĴ'ĆǗ"ĳĿoƱ"¢Ą'šƱ%ÌƱğ6"(ǬĶı'œƈûŢ'Šŝ"æį:ƶoxŎ60%1ǔƭ!6$4Ǭäƺś

Çs%6"1ǬƊĴ'¢Ą:ǕÔ!ƳŎ6'(áĠ!

($ƊĴ'~ƨŬ$ưŎĈŅ%(ǬĴƜ:Ůďč5ƿƳŎ6ĈŅǪI<Jn^jnGŅǬ>nGmpMI<Jn^jnGŅ$#ǫ"ǬBeiƁ:ťĔõǬ'ŊǗ:ǝŵÑŬ%ƳŎ6ĈŅ

Çu'ŧ:

6ǪkpU?=nV?Ǭi>OUmnŅ$#ǫǪSmit et al. 2000, Satomura et al. 2007, Neumann et al. 2009ǫƘ(č5ƿĴ:İ60ǬZ>AbM'ŎÝ2Ćİ$#:Ƨ6ªǞǬķś"·À'ÅÒ:ŵÑT. Nakaji et al.ǭ1
BSJ- Revi ew 3

植物科学最前線3（2012）

-'!ǬǕÔ!'ǊƐưŎ%Ǜ
ưŎſ:Çu%Éƴ6qĝǬøƘ'ŧƳŎŅ!(ǆğ$ļƛƪ'èÈBei!·À:ÝĪŬ%ĔõǬ1%ƊĴ'Ǘǈó2ƨǞ

ŽĆǗ:ŎÝ6'ĈŅ(ǬZ>AbM:Ýǖ6%(³õǟ4ǬÉƴĢ'ĕwǃŌ6-!'qÝ'Ģǘ:ƭ61''Ǭ'ø(äƺ:ŵÑ$0ǊƐ¢ĄưŎ:Ƨ6ejRU6œƈûŢ$#:ĉŴž!(ǬÝĪŬ%ưŎĴ'

Z>AbM"'ĆǗǈó:1"%ǬƊĴ'ţŤ2ĳĿ'PpnApZpĘ:ƳƂǬÇu'œƈƼŨǈó:ƶ6Ɔ!Ĝ%ūţĴ'ţŤǖ"Ĵ'ŠÙǖ"'Zin
M(ţŤPpnApZpǬĳĿĴ"ŠÙǖ'ZinM(ĳĿPpnApZp"¹)7ǬŧƳŎ%Ì

Ʊİ!(Ǭ77ưŎ?=nV?'Ĵ'ǗǈóǬŊǗǈó:ĴǗâƳƂ76ǪGill & Jackson 2000, Gill et al. 2002ǫǝŵÑƳó'ñǘĦÖ!"Ŏ!ÝĪŬ%ú47674'(ķś'ţšţĄĽƚ2œƈûŢ^mNM'šƱ%"
ǝï%ǔƭ!5ǬèÈ' CCD Bei"Çu%Éƴǆğƃ:cXi>OUmnŅ
'ģ©""1% 1980 ñ~4òŴž7

6ǪHendrick & Pregitzer 1992, Heeraman et al.

1993, Smit et al. 2000, Majdi & Öhrvik 2004, Noguchi et al. 2004, Satomura et al. 2007ǫ)Ǭ

ōĥÇË'ǧ¹µňÿ:ļīĴ'¢Ą%ŇŭŴž!(ǬƑĊ¹µ$#'IMUÐ%36ĳĿĴ'Ð"PpnApZp'rĞ¢Ą'ƱİŇŭ7

6ǪHendrick & Pregitzer 1993ǫŧưŎ'ĽĮ%Ǚ(ǬBartz Technology Ÿ2 C.I.D.ŸǪ"1%ƄÃǫ%36ìƻ'cXi>OUmnKMSdưŎĝŅ

6ƍŋÿ2ÛÝÿĴÄ¢Ą'Ŵž%ưã7Ǭōĥ£$#'ŢÏÓ¢"±9

Ǭǅñ( OA Ľ»'\iRU_RVMDgWp:ť41ħť$ĈŅ"đĵ76ŧƳŎ(qƝŬ$ŴžĈŅ"$4ǬcXi>OUmnŅ:´/ŧƳŎŅ%1

5ǪDannoura et al. 2008ǫǬ
6ǪÁǮǫƹǡ$5ǬĴ"ưãſ'ƈĮ'ůÿǬŃ2ř$#'ÇuŢÏ'ĕw"ŠÎ!'ƹǡǬ351Ĕõ7Ĵ'ŻǢ
2ţĿǬš£Úÿ'ě'¿Ǜùį

4ċē7ƐĴ'Ǣ2š£Úÿ'ĐÝ%ŇŭǬ'q¬57ĜĈŅ'¯ƚÿ%

-+("6ĭż!('ǬŜ%ĦǅħĨƯ7

6ŧƳŎ:Ƌ}6ŧ'Ĕõ%36ţĄưŎ(Ǥº2¥ŪǕǬjfpUNnKnGŴž$#!ðò
ť7

6ǕÔưŎ:úĂ"6jfpUNnKnG!(Ǭķś'ƥ2ƕƤ:äƺ%¯ƯǱųņǗƾÔǠËǪ

3 400Ǳ2500nmǫ'ǊƐªåş'ŧƳŎ%35Ǭ

ķś"ÅÒ'ǚǪDaughtry 2001, Jones & Vaughan 2010ǫǬķśƌƔ'ƞƈ2ĹǉǬǥƈ
Œó2ŃǬjGXn6(NkmpM$#'£ÚƌĆ$#'ƶ(Ǭ+Ƨ9767'śƽ(Âħ'ŜÿǪņǗ"'µ«oªåoǆǎǫ:1Ǭ")ţƌƔ"ÅÒǬƟƌƔ"®ƌƔ$#:ŁǄ6"ũ$6Ŝÿ:Ċ"¦š%Ì6ǪÚjfpUNnKnG'¦š%Ǚ(ǬAsrar 1989, Jones & Vaughan 2010:¨Ŗ7ǫ

T. Nakaji et al.ǭ2
BSJ- Revi ew 3

植物科学最前線3（2012）

Á 1 cXi>OUmn'ĽĮ"ĴÄ'ŧƳŎǪAǫìƻ7

6cXi>OUmn'NnJp

ĭ"ǆğ<FjkQhp]Qhp]:Çu%ÉƴǬNnJp:u%ČÝĪŬ%·À'ŧ:Ĕõ6
ǪBǫ\iRU_RVÈMDgWp%36ưŎǣĤDannoura 4(2008)(Çu%MDgW:ŮďÉƴưãű!(ǆğ$<FjkHpMǀ%Ĕõ6Ǫ¤ŉǏÖÚƠèŚŴžıǫǪCǫǊƐĔõŧ%36ġIdE'Ĵ'ƍĢÓ£ǪPritchard & Rogers 2000ǫ(a)Ǳ(i)'3%ĢƆŧ: 2Ǳ4 ǋ"%ĔõĆǗ2Ĵł'Š"ŊØ:Ʊİ6ĀÍ'ťĝŅ%(ǬŜÝ'ƫĘ'ªåş:1"%ƳƂ76ċĻǪSerrano et al.
2002, Soukupova et al. 2002, Nagler et al. 2003, Delbart et al. 2005ǫǬÕZnV'ǊƐªåş

T. Nakaji et al.ǭ3
BSJ- Revi ew 3

植物科学最前線3（2012）

ǪY>[pM`FUkǫ:ťÕÓǖƱİ2HfeUjFMǪAsner & Martin 2008ǫ$#ĺ$ĈŅ
ŧÙÆ64(ěÍ:1"%Ǭ74%Ǉ6ƳŎ'ejRU"

¿Ǜ$äƺśƽ:ƶ!
ţĄĀÍ:ęšoƱİ!

6ÚĀÍǖ:Õ
6"(Ǭùį'Bip´/"ǬßưŬ$ĘĀ476Ŝ%ǬĴ'ţĿÝ2ŻǢ

'²Ý(ǝï%¿Ǜ!5ưŎƘ%36ě'Ƹë1āÝ760ǬÚĀÍ%36ßư
ÿ'Ŷ(ħť"Ɨ476-ǬƳŎ2jfpUNnKnG'ŴžǕ!ǌ;!
6Ɯ¢Ǣ2ÕÓǖƱİ$#(ǬĴÄ'ĦĜ'ŧƱİŅǪNakaji et al. 2008, Zeng et al. 2008,
Gasch et al. 2011, Nakano et al. 2012ǫ*'ýť1Ī÷76.+)"ĶıţĄƆŴž2ĴÄ'İŴž!(Ǭ3$ǅƾÔŅ1%Ď¬ƷĚ'İĈŅ'q"'ňť76")ǬĶı'jPpu'jGXn2Nkmp

M'İǪOno et al. 2003ǫǬƢĭ'Ĵ'ŻĐÝǪRoumet et al. 2006ǫ2ţĿÝǪPicon-Cochard
et al. 2009ǫ$#àİ%36ĀÍ'Ʊİ:"



Ʒ.47

Ĝ$İŅ"Í¶76Á 2 (Ƣĭ'Ĵ%Jn^jnGƷĚ'ǅƾÔİTpP

4ţĿ:Ʒ.

!6ǪPicon-Cochard et al. 2009ǫPicon-Cochard

4Ǫ2009ǫ(Ǭ5 Ż'Ƣĭ:äƺ%Ǭţ

6Ĵ"{ŕŬ%ĳĿĴ:Ď¬Ǭ¯ƯǭųņǗƾÔǠËǪ400-2500nmǫ%ÔË'µ«ş

6µ«ş:ƳŎ5ǬǕÔƷĚ'ǬĳĿĴ',

ǅƾ

³%6":ŷǬ

HfeUjFM'qĈŅ!6 PLS ½îfTk:Ć!

Ǭ 3 18ǩźó'Ƹë!ţĿ:

6":ŷqƝ%ǬĴ'ţĿ(Ǩƞ£$#'ƞ¸2ƲăƲ!ě6yÕǪWells & Eissenstat 2001, Ruess et al.

2003ǫǬ")ǚé
ŃĽƚŀ

ôĆ7



1u'Ǉ

6"1Í¶75ǪLarcher 1995ǫǬĽƚ"Ĺǉ:ƒ±ţĿ'ńÝ(ǝï%ǛŎÝ(ŮďŬ%ǇŃĽƚ:ƳŎ61'!($ǬĹǉ'Ó£2Ń´ǖ"ǘďŬ$ĀÍ:ĸ!
0ǬěÌő6(ƩǁĀÍ"6'ť(Ī÷76"8!6
ƊĴ'ưŎ%

6ŧ'ňť(7-!%ĘÍ¶7

6§â%(ªå:!($ǬţƌƔ'Ʀªý: 2 :-1+=;+=R

,[WO5ǬWang 4Ǫ1995ǫ

QHJ8!R$R.'R4

(, ƉÔŖås!ĔõƢĭķś'Ĵ'ƦcPicon-Cochard et al. 2009d@ťĴ'ňÿ2ţĿÝ%ť6Ʒ.(

7-!%1Ňŭ7T. Nakaji et al.ǭ4
BSJ- Revi ew 3

植物科学最前線3（2012）ţšŬ$ţĿ'%ħ¡!6":Í¶ý

ũ$6"1ċē7"

(ģǍÿ$#%ƹǡ

ǬķśŻ%3

'Ʀª5ǪSmit & Zuin 1996ǫǬ-ķśŴžqƝ%ť!
ŀ76ĈŅ

6

qĝǬĴ'@>LnG2ţĿ%Ǚ6¯ƯǅƾÔŧ'ť(ǬNakaji 4Ǫ2008ǫ%3Í¶7ƷĚ:Ć6CiMHpM!ƙĆa^i:äƺ%ǬÞǦŬ%ĳĿǬ'¯ƯǭǅƾÔǠËǪ480ǭ972nmǫ'ĴÄ'ǊƐªåşŧ:CiMǀ%Ĕõ"8Ǭţ 3. _^`$R6Ĵ'ªåş(@>LnG""1%Ǭ¯ƯņǗ!

,/c(dDYTLF?R5"c(dcNakaji et al.

2008d@DAP S&%R[3He170DAP NS*-QYKM$[#'GIMAZ@70P\`b/Q)UMe<;/[CJVBE#'$Xa]bc LdE

2QPZ@6

?[9KJ>We#'$Xa]beR?4EHJ@

T. Nakaji et al.ǭ5
BSJ- Revi ew 3

植物科学最前線3（2012）(sǬǅƾÔņǗ!(Ð6"ūǐ"Ǚ!

ğ4%$'3$Ǒ(ǬƌƔĹǉ'6"þ976-Ǭ"¯ƯņǗ!²3$ªåşǪƞ¸²ǫ1ǬǅƾÔņǗ!(ǬÅÒǰjPpoĳĿĴǰĆŘĴ"ªåş!6"ŷ7'Ŝü:1"%Ǭ¯ƯĀÍ%ǅƾÔŧĀÍ: 3 ZnVǪƓǬƾǬǅƾÔǫ'ŧ:ťÅÒ2ĴǬĳĿĴǬjPp'Ɯ¢Ǣ:Ƨ"8ǬǇï'¯ƯǯZnV

ŧǪƾǬǜǬƓǫ%Ł+Ǣƅó30ǩźó³r6"1ğ42008ǫǪÁ 3ǫ-ÞǦŢÏ!ú47ƎĲ!(6

Ǭùį'ŧĔõ*'ŎÝ'ç!6ǪPierret 2008ǫŔ:ūĒ6":ŷĦ'Ŵž/+%$ǪNakaji et al.

ŧĀÍ(Ǭť6ņǗí:ǒ%ƴÝ6"!

7)ǬùįƮ¢Ą2£ÚĆ'ĸ"Ĝ$¯ƚÿ:ĴÄ'Ŵž%14
!Ƌ}
Í¶'Ŵžy,";#!6Ǭ")ǬÇu%!

17$

6Ĵ'Ż2ƱǎźǬĽƚǞ1Ɨą$ƹǡǬQglnL!

6|øǬÞǦƆ""1%\=pkV%

6"



!63%Ǭ-ÞǦŢÏ!'ĸƵ2ƍǦŬ$yţĿÝ2ǬƣĴƣ'ưã$#Ǭýť!
ŀ$7)ǬĴÄŴž%6ƹǡ(--6ĸƵ:ǔ&Ǭ'ģǍÿ:ŬŶ%ƶ

6]lpFMkp

ú476"Ī÷76"!
Asner, G.P., and Martin, R.E. 2008. Canopy phylogenic, chemical and spectral assembly in a lowland
Amazonian forest. New Phytol. 189: 999-1012.
Asrar, G. 1989. Theory and applications of optical remote sensing, John Wiley and Sons, New York.
Dannoura, M., Kominami, Y., Oguma, H., and Kanazawa, Y. 2008. The development of an opticalscanner method for observation of plant root dynamics. Plant Root 2: 14-18.
Daughtry, C.S.T. 2001. Discriminating crop residues from soil by shortwave infrared reflectance.
Agronomy Journal 93: 125-131.
De Kroon H., and Visser, E.J.W. 2003. Root Ecology, Springer-Verlag, New York.
Delbart, N., Kergoat, L., Le Toan, T., Lhermitte, J., and Picard, G. 2005. Determination ofphenological dates in boreal regions using normalized difference water index. Remote Sens.
Environ.

97: 26-38.

Gasch C.K., Collier, T.R., Enloe, S.F., and Prager, S.D. 2011. A GIS-based method for the analysis ofdigital rhizotron images. Plant Root 5: 69-78.
Gill, R.A., and Jackson, R.B. 2000. Global patterns of root turnover for terrestrial ecosystems. NewPhytol. 147: 13-31.
Gill, R.A., Burke, I.C., Lauenroth, W.K., and Milchunas, D.G. 2002. Longevity and turnover of rootsin the short grass steppe: influence of diameter and depth. Plant Ecol. 159: 241–251.
Heeraman, D.A., Crown, P.H., and Juma, N.G. 1993. A color composite technique for detecting root
dynamics of barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) from minirhizotron images. Plant Soil 157: 275-287.

T. Nakaji et al.ǭ6BSJ- Revi ew 3

植物科学最前線3（2012）

Hendrick, R.L, and Pregitzer, K.S. 1992. The demography of fine roots in a northern hardwood forest.
Ecology 73: 1094-1104.
Hendrick, R.L., and Pregitzer, K.S. 1993. Patterns of fine root mortality in two sugar maple forests.
Nature 361: 59-61.
Jackson, RB, Mooney, H.A., and Schulze. E-.D. 1997. A global budget for fine root biomass, surface
area, and nutrient contents. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 94: 7362-7366.
Janssens, I.A., Sampson, D.A., Curiel-Yuste, J., Carrara, A., and Ceulemans, R. 2002. The carbon
cost of fine root turnover in a Scots pine forest, For. Ecol. Manage. 168: 231-240.
Jones, H.G.,, and Vaughan, R.A. 2010. Remote Sensing of Vegetation, Oxford University Press, NewYork.
Kajimoto, T., Matsuura, Y., Sofronov, M.A., Volokitina,A.V., Mori, S., Osawa, A., and Abaimov,A.P. 1999. Above- and belowground biomass and net primary productivity of a Larix gmelinii
stand near Tura, central Siberia. Tree Physiol. 19: 815-822.
Keyes, M.R., and Grier, C.C. 1981. Above- and below-ground net production in 40-year-old Douglas
fir stands on low and high productivity sites. Can. J. For. Res. 11: 599-605.
Larcher, W. 1995. Physiological Plant Ecology. Springer-Verlag, New York, pp. 450.
Majdi, H., and Öhrvik. J. 2004. Interactive effects of soil warming and fertilization on root production,mortality, and longevity in a Norway spruce stand in northern Sweden. Global Change Biol. 10:182-188.
Nagler, P.L, Inoue, Y., Glenn, E.P, Russ, A.L, and Daughtry. C.S.T. 2003. Cellulose absorption index(CAI) to quantify mixed soil-plant litter scenes. Remote Sens. Environ. . 87: 310-325.
Nakaji, T., Noguchi, K., and Oguma, H. 2008. Classification of rhizosphere components using
visible–near infrared spectral images, Plant Soil 310: 245-261.
Nakano, A., Ikeno, H., Kimura, T., Sakamoto, H., Dannoura, M., Hirano, Y., Makita, N., Finer, L.,and Ohashi, M. 2012. Automated analysis of fine-root dynamics using a series of digital images,J. Plant Nutr. Soil Sci. 10.1002/jpln.201100316.
Neumann, G., George, T. S., and Plassard, C. 2009. Strategies and methods for studying therhizosphereǭthe plant science toolbox. Plant Soil 321: 431-456.
Noguchi, K., Sakata, T., Mizoguchi, T., and Takahashi, M. 2004. Estimation of the fine root biomass
in a Japanese cedar (Cryptomeria japonica) plantation using minirhizotrons. J. For. Res. 9:261-264.
Ono, K., Hiraide, M., and Amari, M. 2003. Determination of lignin, holocellulose, and organic
solvent extractives in fresh leaf, litterfall, and organic material on forest floor using near-infrared
reflectance spectroscopy. J. For. Res. 8: 191-198.
Picon-Cochard, C., Pilon, R., Revaillot, S., Jestin, M., and Dawson, L. 2009. Use of near-infrared
reflectance spectroscopy to predict the percentage of dead versus living grass roots. Plant Soil
317: 309-320.
Pierret, A. 2008. Multi-spectral imaging of rhizobox systems: New perspectives for the observation

T. Nakaji et al.ǭ7BSJ- Revi ew 3

植物科学最前線3（2012）and discrimination of rhizosphere components. Plant Soil 310: 263-268.
Pritchard, S.G., and Rogers, H.H. 2000. Spatial and temporal deployment of crop roots in
CO2-enriched environments. New Phytol. 147: 55–71.
Roumet, C., Picon-Cochard C., Dawson, L.A., Joffre, R., Mayes, R., Blanchard, A., and Brewer, M.J.
2006. Quantifying species composition in root mixtures using two methods: near-infrared
reflectance spectroscopy and plant wax markers. New Phytol 170: 631-638.
Ruess, R.W., Hendrick, R.L., Burton, A.J, Pregitzer, K.S, Sveinbjornsson, B., Allen, M. F., andMaurer, G.E. 2003. Coupling fine root dynamics with ecosystem carbon cycling in black spruce
forests of interior Alaska. Ecol. Monogr. 73: 643-662.
Satomura, T., Fukuzawa, C., and Horikoshi, T. 2007. Considerations in the study of tree fine-root
turnover with minirhizotrons. Plant Root 1: 34-45.
Serrano, L., Penuelas, J., and Ustin, S. 2002. Remote sensing of nitrogen and lignin in Mediterraneanvegetation from AVIRIS data: Decomposing biochemical from structural signals. Remote Sens.
Environ.

81: 355-364.

Smit, A.L., and Zuin, A. 1996. Root growth dynamics of Brussels sprouts (Brassica oleracea var.
gemmifera) and leeks (Allium porrum L.) as reflected by root length, root colour and UV
fluorescence. Plan Soil 185: 271-280.
Smit, A.L., Bengough, A.G.., Engels, C., Van Noordwijk, M., Pellerin, S., Van De Geijn, S.C. 2000.
Root Methods A Handbook, Springer-Verlag, New York.
Soukupova, J. Rock, B.N., and Albrechtova, J. 2002. Spectral characteristics of lignin and soluble
phenolics in the near infrared- a comparative study. Int. J. Remote Sens. 23: 3039-3055.
Wang, Z., Burch, W.H., Mou, P., Jones, R.H, and Mitchell, R.J. 1995. Accuracy of visible andultraviolet light for estimating live root proportions with minirhizotrons. Ecology 76: 2330-2334.
Wells, C.E., and Eissenstat, D.M. 2001. Marked differences in survivorship among apple roots ofdifferent diameters. Ecology 82: 882-892.
Vogt, K.A., Grier, C.C., Meier, C.A.,, and Edomonds, R.L. 1982. Mycorrhizal role in net primary
production and nutrient cycling in Abies amabilis ecosystems in western Washington. Ecology
63: 370-380.
Xiao, C.-W., Yuste, J.C., Janssens, I.A., Roskams, P., Nachtergale, L., Carrara, A., Sanchez, B.Y.,
and Ceulemans, R. 2003. Above- and belowground biomass and net primary production in a
73-year-old Scots pine forest. Tree Physiol. 23: 505-516.
Zeng, G. Birchfield, S.T., Wells, C.E. 2008. Automatic discrimination of fine roots in minirhizotron
images. New Phytol. 177: 549–557.

T. Nakaji et al.ǭ8BSJ- Revi ew 3