RivMIP update
Cédric H. David1, Dai Yamazaki2, Sylvain
Biancamaria3, Aaron Boone4, R. Edward
Beighley5, Rodrigo Paiva6, Ayan Santos
Fleischmann6, Konstantinos M. Adreadis1,Colby Fisher7
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.

Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, CA, United States
University of Tokyo, Tokyo, Japan
Laboratoire d’Etudes en Géophysique et Océanographie Spatiales, Toulouse, FranceCentre National de Recherches Meteorologiques, Toulouse, France
Northeastern University, Boston, MA, United States
Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul, Porto Alegre, RS, BrazilPrinceton University, Princeton, NJ, United States

Study domain

Zooming in on main confluences

Model outputs used
• Over the past year we went from 3 to 7 models!
• The files used for the analysis herein are below:

File formats
14 locations
throughout theMississippi RiverBasinAs specified in experimental design table:
http://rapid-hub.org/docs/SWOT_ST_WG_Mississippi_Experimental_Design.pdf
With a slight change on River ID / vs USGS code and date format

Processing toolbox

https://github.com/c-h-david/rrr
Has been updated by Kostas!
(Need to change hydrographlegend based on csv header, also
add NSE and Correl in graph)Analysis metrics (10 years)

CaMa-Floodrivid

Mississippi@Grafton
Missouri@Herman

Ohio@Metropolis
Mississippi@Thebes

QobsbarQmodbar
RMSE
Bias
STDE
Nash
Correl231083466.872168.192847.6
1701.32
2283.49-641.26266984401.49627.94527.94226.46476.9-0.47328965755.543248.363653.292492.83
2670.64-208.66
339344
989.58265.441022.5724.14721.9-0.48
3412372188.62341.47
1183.07152.871173.160.393632603418.113203.96
1855.13214.151842.730.353671212083.225760.095317.363676.873841.22-13.2
3681995547.149002.835910.453455.694794.96-1.863732953623.28
1216.213775.262407.072908.36-0.41
3891898129.673297.737045.394831.945127.37-0.38
3894916080.379290.675964.73210.35027.09-1.44407204303.33737.56796.49434.23667.71-3.784206531294.14
1877.28
1510.05
583.141392.91-0.14440065588.61793.52679.05204.91647.390.12

Mississippi@Grafton
Missouri@Herman
Mississippi@Thebes

Ohio@Metropolis

0.11
0.77
0.64
0.53
0.79
0.67
0.64
0.69
0.43
0.55
0.65
0.61
0.59
0.59

CTRIP
rivid

Mississippi@Grafton
Missouri@Herman

Ohio@Metropolis
Mississippi@Thebes

QobsbarQmodbar
RMSE
Bias
STDE
Nash
Correl231083466.881119.71066.06
652.82842.8-88.99266984401.54407.08329.36
5.54
329.310.43
328965755.592196.32
1924.85
1440.73
1276.45-57.2
339344
989.471036.41478.0546.93
475.740.683412372188.443360.821603.89
1172.38
1094.53-0.123632603417.34889.69
1911.091472.39
1218.330.313671212083.125229.463889.53146.35
2286.64-6.63681995546.1210352.23
5677.784806.13022.99-1.643732953622.734334.57
2250.3711.842134.75
0.53891898127.93
10401.05
4157.482273.123481.03
0.52
3894916078.4610798.08
5607.944719.613028.91-1.16407204303.381138.57
993.02835.19537.17-6.424206531294.143315.79
2379.922021.66
1255.76-1.83440065588.4
1221.37755.12
632.97411.77-0.09

Mississippi@Grafton
Missouri@Herman
Mississippi@Thebes

Ohio@Metropolis

0.17
0.69
0.66
0.83
0.87
0.9
0.79
0.88
0.74
0.82
0.87
0.79
0.81
0.89

HRRrivid

Mississippi@Grafton
Missouri@Herman

Ohio@Metropolis
Mississippi@Thebes

QobsbarQmodbar
RMSE
Bias
STDE
Nash
Correl231083466.871522.26
1727.361055.39
1367.45-235.33
266984401.49730.43915.27328.94854.12-3.41
328965755.542447.66
2610.71692.121988.09-106.07339344
989.58967.78706.5821.81
706.240.29341237
2188.63598.963013.841410.35
2663.48-2.973632603418.114964.92
3502.51546.813142.44-1.33
3671212083.225347.594941.563264.363709.85-11.273681995547.1410388.26
7624.95
4841.135890.95-3.76
3732953623.283852.212147.3228.932135.070.54
3891898129.678837.52
3493.17707.853420.70.66
3894916080.37
10917.47
7779.74837.096093.13-3.15407204303.33804.44886.07501.11730.75-4.914206531294.142417.362050.361123.21
1715.33-1.1440065588.611065.38
1027.06
476.77909.7-1.01

Mississippi@Grafton
Missouri@Herman
Mississippi@Thebes

Ohio@Metropolis

0.05
0.39
0.54
0.55
0.59
0.65
0.68
0.72
0.74
0.84
0.7
0.6
0.66
0.64

LISFLOOD
rivid

Mississippi@Grafton
Missouri@Herman

Ohio@Metropolis
Mississippi@Thebes

QobsbarQmodbar
RMSE
Bias
STDE
Nash
Correl231083466.87324.54407.97142.33382.34-12.18-0.17266984401.492164.862309.31763.37
1491.11-27.050.23
328965755.541903.68
1491.06
1148.15
951.33-33.93
0.39
339344
989.58395.23990.06594.35791.82-0.39
0.343412372188.61160.99
1995.821027.62
1710.94-0.74
0.163632603418.113226.87
2469.11191.24
2461.69-0.16
0.243671212083.222605.441705.11522.22
1623.18-0.46
0.31
3681995547.143927.293495.26
1619.853097.2400.47
3732953623.28616.724257.983006.563015.13-0.79
0.453891898129.672203.25
8169.075926.425622.38-0.86
0.44
3894916080.37
5160.993479.59919.383355.940.17
0.49407204303.336925.797233.126622.462908.79-392.990.344206531294.14450.23
1628.41843.921392.66-0.33
0.19
440065588.617418.137529.746829.51
3170.92-107.20.22

Mississippi@Grafton
Missouri@Herman
Mississippi@Thebes

Ohio@Metropolis

MGBrivid

Mississippi@Grafton
Missouri@Herman

Ohio@Metropolis
Mississippi@Thebes

QobsbarQmodbar
RMSE
Bias
STDE
Nash
Correl231083466.871489.81412.671022.93974.31-157.07266984401.49731.83583.33330.34480.77-0.79
328965755.542432.862231.811677.33
1472.25-77.25339344
989.581004.9829.6615.31
829.520.03
3412372188.6
3566.04
2475.781377.432057.23-1.683632603418.114943.932810.091525.822359.76-0.53671212083.225383.14462.05
3299.883003.45-93681995547.1410393.25
6664.094846.124574.42-2.633732953623.283885.362924.36
262.082912.590.16
3891898129.678912.994893.85783.324830.75
0.33
3894916080.3710924.6
6734.234844.234677.96-2.11407204303.33804.96701.95501.63491.02-2.714206531294.142415.55
1619.811121.41
1168.85-0.31440065588.611044.98666.13456.37485.240.15

Mississippi@Grafton
Missouri@Herman
Mississippi@Thebes

Ohio@Metropolis

0.04
0.57
0.62
0.3
0.51
0.63
0.69
0.71
0.45
0.63
0.7
0.74
0.73
0.84

RAPID
rivid

Mississippi@Grafton
Missouri@Herman

Ohio@Metropolis
Mississippi@Thebes

QobsbarQmodbar
RMSE
Bias
STDE
Nash
Correl231083466.88908.49885.84441.61
767.91-61.14266984401.54477.12520.3475.59514.82-0.42328965755.591921.84
2000.641166.25
1625.55-61.87339344
989.471003.27457.1413.8
456.930.73412372188.442977.871539.36
789.431321.52-0.04
3632603417.34445.62
1962.561028.311671.590.273671212083.124976.84276.92893.68
3149.37-8.19
3681995546.129520.455617.893974.33
3970.56-1.58
3732953622.734369.312170.34746.582037.890.54
3891898127.9310413
3577.192285.072752.230.64
3894916078.4610257.41
5787.95
4178.95
4004.6-1.3407204303.381020.281030.72716.9
740.56-74206531294.142990
2442.89
1695.87
1758.34-1.98
440065588.4
1420.04
1310.45831.641012.74-2.28

Mississippi@Grafton
Missouri@Herman
Mississippi@Thebes

Ohio@Metropolis

0.13
0.56
0.63
0.84
0.83
0.85
0.8
0.88
0.77
0.9
0.87
0.74
0.75
0.73

RVIC
rivid

Mississippi@Grafton
Missouri@Herman

Ohio@Metropolis
Mississippi@Thebes

QobsbarQmodbar
RMSE
Bias
STDE
Nash
Correl231083466.87995.38972.34528.5
816.17-73.89266984401.49282.49355.71118.99335.210.33
328965755.54695.49760.5360.05
758.16-8.09
339344
989.581180.07632.99190.49603.650.433412372188.62990.95
1365.31802.351104.680.193632603418.113639.091534.8220.981518.80.553671212083.2215.92
2497.32067.3
1400.98-2.133681995547.148839.274985.04
3292.133743.32-1.03
3732953623.284317.26
2641.63
693.982548.850.313891898129.677239.074111
890.6
4013.38
0.53389491
6080.3710255.47
7224.98
4175.15896.51-2.58
407204303.33287.95354.7515.38
354.410.05
4206531294.14
39.05
1868.821255.091384.65-0.75440065588.61592.38473.773.77
473.750.57

Mississippi@Grafton
Missouri@Herman
Mississippi@Thebes

Ohio@Metropolis

0.17
0.65
0.54
0.72
0.87
0.81
0.5
0.79
0.62
0.75
0.31
0.6
0.5
0.77

Hydrographs (2 years)

Mississippi@Grafton

CaMa-Flood

Missouri@Herman
Mississippi@Thebes

Ohio@Metropolis

Mississippi@Grafton

CTRIP

Missouri@Herman
Mississippi@Thebes

Ohio@Metropolis

Mississippi@Grafton

HRR

Missouri@Herman
Mississippi@Thebes

Ohio@Metropolis

Mississippi@Grafton

LISFLOOD

Missouri@Herman
Mississippi@Thebes

Ohio@Metropolis

Mississippi@Grafton

MGB

Missouri@Herman
Mississippi@Thebes

Ohio@Metropolis

Mississippi@Grafton

RAPID

Missouri@Herman
Mississippi@Thebes

Ohio@Metropolis

Mississippi@Grafton

RVIC

Missouri@Herman
Mississippi@Thebes

Ohio@Metropolis

Thanks!
Questions?