一ノ瀬俊明/KVKICVKPIWTDCPJGCVKUNCPFRJGPQOGPCKPRNCPPKPI%JKPGUGOGICEKVKGU6QUJKCMK+EJKPQUG
5GPKQT4GUGCTEJ5EKGPVKUV0CVKQPCN+PUVKVWVGHQT'PXKTQPOGPVCN5VWFKGU6UWMWDC+DCTCMK,CRCP#UUQEKCVG2TQHGUUQT%JKDC7PKXGTUKV[/CVUWFQ%JKDC,CRCP#FXKUQT[2TQHGUUQT'CUV%JKPC0QTOCN7PKXGTUKV[5JCPIJCK%JKPC6JGOCKPGPXKTQPOGPVCNRTQDNGOUQH%JKPGUGOGICEKVKGUCTKUGHTQOVJGHCEVVJCVRTKQTKV[KUIKXGPVQGEQPQOKEFGXGNQROGPVOQTGVJCPVQGPXKTQPOGPVCNRTQVGEVKQP+VKUPGEGUUCT[VQEQPVTQNVGEJPQNQIKGUWUGFKPETGCVKPIVJGWTDCPGPXKTQPOGPVVQIGVJGTYKVJOGVJQFUQHWTDCPRNCPPKPI+P)GTOCP[GURGEKCNN[KPVJGHKGNFQHWTDCPRNCPPKPIOCP[RNCPPGTUCTGVCMKPICFXCPVCIGQHENKOCVQNQIKUVUῚTGUWNVU $TWGPFN*QTDGTVGVCN 0QYCFC[UJGCVKUNCPFRJGPQOGPC GI.CPFUDGTI GZGORNKHKGFD[VJG
YCTOKPIQHWTDCPCTGCUCTGQHITGCVEQPEGTP9CTOKPIQHWTDCPCTGCUKUIGPGTCNN[TGICTFGFCUOCMKPIWTDCPNKHGWPEQOHQTVCDNG2TGXKQWUTGUGCTEJQPWTDCPENKOCVQNQI[JCUUJQYPVJGECWUGUQHJGCVKUNCPFRJGPQOGPCVQDGCPVJTQRQIGPKEJGCVGOKUUKQP
TGFWEVKQPQHITGGPURCEGCPFYCVGTUWTHCEGKPWTDCPCTGCUEJCPIGQHJGCVECRCEKV[QHVJGOCVGTKCNQPWTDCPUWTHCEGUEJCPIGQHGPXKTQPOGPVYKVJTGICTFVQTCFKCVKQPCPF
VJGEQODKPCVKQPQHVJGUGHCEVQTU GI1MG 4GUGCTEJRTQITGUUQPVJGKORTQXGOGPVQHWTDCPVJGTOCNGPXKTQPOGPVUJCUDGGPKPCFGSWCVGYJKNGCITGCVCOQWPVQHMPQYNGFIGQP WTDCP ENKOCVG JCU DGGP CEEWOWNCVGF KP VJG NQPI JKUVQT[ QH WTDCP ENKOCVQNQI[;QUJKPQ 
0QYCFC[UWTDCPRNCPPKPIYKVJEQPUKFGTCVKQPQHWTDCPENKOCVGTGRTGUGPVGFD[VJG
EQPEGRVQHCPWTDCPXGPVKNCVKQPNCPGKUYKFGN[RTCEVKEGFKP)GTOCP[/GVJQFUHQT
ENKOCVQNQIKECNQDUGTXCVKQPUCPFPWOGTKECNUKOWNCVKQPUQHVJGVJGTOCNGPXKTQPOGPVCTG
YGNNGUVCDNKUJGFKPWTDCPRNCPPKPI+PVJGGCTN[UVJG/KPKUVT[QH'PXKTQPOGPV5VCVG
QH$CFGP9WGTVVGODGTIUVCTVGFCPCKTSWCNKV[EQPVTQNRNCP /KPKUVGTKWOHWGT7OYGNV$CFGP9WGTVVGODGTI HQTKVUECRKVCNEKV[5VWVVICTV6JKURNCPCNUQMPQYPCUVJG
ENGCPCKTRNCPHQTVJGCTGCQH5VWVVICTV .WHVTGKPJCNVGRNCP)TQUUTCWO5VWVVICTV KPENWFGUVJGEQPEGRVQHVJGWTDCPXGPVKNCVKQPNCPGCUQPGQHKVURQNKE[QRVKQPU6JGRNCPCKOUVQTGFWEGWTDCPCKTRQNNWVKQPD[PCVWTCNEQNFFTCKPCIGCKTHNQYUVJCVCTGVQDGKPVGPUKHKGF
D[UWKVCDNGCNKIPOGPVQHDWKNFKPIUCUYGNNCUNCPFWUG\QPKPIDCUGFQPUEKGPVKHKEFCVC
9KTVUEJCHVUOKPKUVGTKWO$CFGP9WGTVVGODGTI 6JGRNCPCNUQCKOUVQKORTQXG
VJGTOCNEQOHQTVYKVJKPVJKUWTDCPCTGC2CTMUHQTGUVUCPFDWKNFKPIUYGTGRNCPPGFKP
QTFGTVQCNNQYVJGHNQYQHHTGUJRWTGCKTKPVQVJGEGPVTCNEKV[CTGC῝(GPI5JWK῞KUCFKUEKRNKPGQTCU[UVGOQHMPQYNGFIGGUVCDNKUJGFKPCPEKGPV%JKPC+P῝(GPI5JWK῞VJGTGCTGOCP[UVCVGOGPVUQPVJGEQPVTQNQHVJGCODKGPVGPXKTQPOGPVVJTQWIJOGVJQFUQHWTDCPQTDWKNFKPIRNCPPKPI+VCNUQKPENWFGFKVGOUQPVJGWTDCPVJGTOCNGPXKTQPOGPV6JGCWVJQTDGNKGXGUVJCVWTDCPRNCPPKPIYKVJEQPUKFGTCVKQPQH
WTDCPENKOCVGCURTCEVKEGUKP)GTOCPEKVKGUKUC)GTOCPHQTOQH῝(GPI5JWK῞QTOQFGTP YGUVGTP ῝(GPI 5JWK῞ 6JG CWVJQT HGGNU VJCV KVU CRRNKECVKQP VQ %JKPGUG
OGICEKVKGUHQTVJGOKVKICVKQPQHUGTKQWUWTDCPVJGTOCNRQNNWVKQPYKNNDGUWEEGUUHWNDGECWUG%JKPCJCUCNQPIJKUVQT[QHVTCFKVKQPCN῝(GPI5JWK῞6JGPGYKFGCKUVJGKORQTV
QHOQFGTP)GTOCP῝(GPI5JWK῞VQ%JKPC1HEQWTUGYGPGGFPQVQPN[VQUVWF[VJG
ENKOCVQNQIKECN HGCVWTGU QH %JKPGUG EKVKGU DWV CNUQ VQ EQORCTG VJG NGICN U[UVGOU%QTTGURQPFKPICWVJQTCFFTGUU6QUJKCMK+EJKPQUG%GPVGTHQT)NQDCN'PXKTQPOGPVCN4GUGCTEJ0CVKQPCN+PUVKVWVGHQT'PXKTQPOGPVCN5VWFKGU1PQICYC6UWMWDC+DCTCMK,CRCPGOCKNVQUJKCMK"PKGUIQLR

331

第２セッション〈環境〉

UWRRQTVKPIWTDCPRNCPPKPIKP)GTOCP[CPF%JKPC+P ,CRCP /KPKUVT[ QH 'PXKTQPOGPV /Q'  JCU UVCTVGF OCMKPI U[UVGOCVKEEQWPVGTCEVKQPU CICKPUV WTDCP JGCV KUNCPF 7*+  KP ,CRCPGUG TGIKQPCN CWVQPQOKGUTGICTFKPI 7*+ CU QPG QH CKT RQNNWVKQP D[ JGCV 0QYCFC[U C XKGYRQKPV QH VJGTOCNGPXKTQPOGPVCNRTQVGEVKQPKPWTDCPRNCPPKPIRTQEGUUKUUVKNNCPWPHCOKNKCTEQPEGRVHQT
,CRCPGUGWTDCPRNCPPGTU$WVVJGTOCNUVTGUUKPUWOOGTKUQPGQHVJGUVTQPIKPVGTGUVU
QHOCP[,CRCPGUGEKVK\GPU/Q'JCUQTICPK\GFUGXGTCNEQWPEKNUQP7*+RTQDNGOUCPF
RWDNKUJGF TGRQTVU QP EQWPVGTCEVKQPU HQT VJGO 6JGUG CEVKXKVKGU JCXG DTQWIJV VJGEQPEGRVQHOKVKICVKQPQHWTDCPVJGTOCNRQNNWVKQPCUCPGYXKGYRQKPVVQWTDCPRNCPPKPIRTQEGUUKPTGIKQPCNCWVQPQOKGUKP,CRCP6JGCWVJQTCUCOGODGTQHVJGUGEQWPEKNUFKUEWUUGF QP FGUKTCDNG EQWPVGTCEVKQPU HQT 7*+ KP ,CRCPGUG CPF %JKPGUG TGIKQPCNCWVQPQOKGUCPFGXCNWCVKQPUQPVJGKPFKXKFWCNEQWPVGTCEVKQPUDCUGFQPFKUEWUUKQPUCPFTGUWNVUQHVJGUGEQWPEKNU'CEJEQWPEKNYCUEQORQUGFQHVQGZRGTVU DWKNFKPIUEKGPVKUVU RJ[UKECN IGQITCRJGTU OGVGQTQNQIKUVU GPXKTQPOGPVCN UEKGPVKUVU WTDCPRNCPPGTUCFOKPKUVTCVKXGUVCHHUKPTGIKQPCNCWVQPQOKGU &WTKPITGEGPVUGXGTCN[GCTUOCP[OCUUOGFKCU GZ0*-6JG,CRCP6KOGU6JG
9CUJKPIVQP2QUV JCXGRKEMGFWRVJGUGCEVKQPUQHVJG,CRCPGUGIQXGTPOGPV(QTVJGUGCEVKQPUUVTQPIKPVGTGUVUCTGIKXGPHTQO#UKCPEQWPVTKGU#UHQTGKIPGZCORNGUQHUWEJCEVKQPU5VCGFVGDCWNKEJG-NKOCHKDGN 9KTVUEJCHVUOKPKUVGTKWO$CFGP9WGTVVGODGTI CPF8&+IWKFGNKPG 8&+ KP)GTOCP['2#4GRQTV '2# KP75#CTGYGNNMPQYPDWVCRRNKECDNGEQPVGPVUHQT,CRCPGUGECUGUVWFKGUJCXGVQDGFGXGNQRGFD[QWTQYPEQWPVT[+PUQOGTGIKQPCNCWVQPQOKGUKP,CRCPVJG[YKNNRTQOQVGEQWPVGTCEVKQPUHQT
7*+YKVJHQTINQDCNYCTOKPICUQPGIGPGTCNCEVKQP0QY5%, 5EKGPEG%QWPEKNQH,CRCP KUCNUQRTGRCTKPIJKUPGYCEVKQPRNCPCPFTGEQOOGPFCVKQPHQTRQNKE[OCMKPIQP7*+
6JGUG,CRCPGUGOQXGOGPVUYKNNIKXGPQNKVVNGKORCEVHQT%JKPCQPRQNKE[HQTWTDCPRNCPPKPIEQPUKFGTKPIWTDCPVJGTOCNGPXKTQPOGPVCNRTQVGEVKQP
4GHGTGPEGU$TWGPFN9%NKOCVGHWPEVKQPOCRUCPFWTDCPRNCPPKPI'PGTI[CPF$WKNFKPIU
'2#%QQNKPIQWTEQOOWPKVKGU#IWKFGDQQMQPVTGGRNCPVKPICPFNKIJVEQNQTGFUWTHCEKPI*QTDGTV/GVCN1PVJGOGVJQFHQTEJCTVKPIVJGENKOCVGQHCPGPVKTGNCTIGWTDCPCTGC'PGTI[CPF$WKNFKPIU
.CPFUDGTI*'6JGWTDCPENKOCVG#ECFGOKE2TGUURR /KPKUVGTKWOHWGT7OYGNV$CFGP9WGTVVGODGTI.WHVTGKPJCNVGRNCP)TQUUTCWO5VWVVICTV6GKN῔'OKUUKQPGP+OOKUKQPGP9KTMWPIGPRR  KP)GTOCP 
1MG64$QWPFCT[NC[GTENKOCVGU4QWVNGFIGRR 8&+  7OYGNVOGVGQTQNQIKG -NKOC WPF .WHVJ[IKGPGMCTVGP HWGT 5VCGFVG WPF 4GIKQPGP
8&+4KEJVNKPKGP8&+$NCVVRR  KP)GTOCPCPFKP'PINKUJ 
9KTVUEJCHVUOKPKUVGTKWO $CFGP9WGTVVGODGTI  5VCGFVGDCWNKEJG -NKOCHKDGN *KPYGKUG HWGT FKG$CWNGKVRNCPWPIRR  KP)GTOCP ;QUJKPQ/&GXGNQROGPVQHWTDCPENKOCVQNQI[CPFRTQDNGOUVQFC['PGTI[CPF$WKNFKPIU
332

一ノ瀬俊明333

第２セッション〈環境〉

ᐕ᦬਄ᶏߢߩᢙ୯⸘▚㧔$CKGVCN㧕 ᓳరലᨐ㧔ᥤᾲ⃻⽎ᡷༀ㧕ߩᢙ୯⸘▚㧔㊄࡮㊄㧘㧕䇭䇭䇭Ꮢⴝൻ䈘䉏䈢࿾ၞ䈮䇭䇭䇭㜞᷷ㇱ䈏⷗䉌䉏䉎䇯䇭ᐕᄐㇺᏒౝᄢⷙᮨᴡᎹ㧔࠰࠙࡞ᏒᷡᷧᎹ㧕ߩᓳర‫ޓ‬ㇺᏒਅ᳓〝ψᥧᷯൻ࡮㜞᨞㆏〝㧔ᐕઍ㧕‫ߩ࡜ࡈࡦࠗޓ‬⠴ਭ㒢⇇‫⥄ޓ‬ὼߣ౒↢ߔࠆ߹ߜߠߊࠅᄤὼ䈱಄ළⵝ⟎䈫䈚䈩䈱ㇺᏒౝᄢⷙᮨ✛࿾ᷡᷧᎹᓳర඙㑆᧲੩䊶ᣂኋᓮ⧞䋨ᚑ↰䉌䋬㪉㪇㪇㪋䋩ͤͦͩͣͧͦͥͣͦͤͦͨ͑ͫͤͦͪ͑ͫͤͦ͑ͫͤͦͤ͑ͫ͢͢͢͢͢͢͡͡͡͡͡͡͡͡͡͞͞͡͡͡͡͞͞͡͡͡͡͞͞͡͡͡͡͞͞͡͡͡⊖⪲▫

ͤͦͦ͑ͫ͢͡͞͞͡͡͡

'DWH

ͤͦͨ͑ͫͤͦͪ͑ͫ͢͢͡͞͞͡͡͡͡͞͞͡͡͡

5HODWLYH+XPLGLW\ 

7 HPSHUDWXUH GHJUHHͣͦͤͦͦ͑ͫ͡͡͞͞͡͡͡㗼ᾲࡈ࡜࠶ࠢࠬߩ⸘᷹ᄛ㑆䈮䈍䈔䉎✛࿾䈎䉌䈱಄᳇䈱䈮䈛䉂಴䈚ͣ͢͡΅ΖΞΡΖΣΒΥΣΦΖ
΃ΖΝΒΥΚΧΖ͑͹ΦΞΚΕΚΥΪͤ͡P͡
ͤͦͣ͑ͫ͢͡͞͞͡͡͡

FDOPDQGFORXGOHVVQLJKW⒖േ᷹ⷰᴡᎹߥߤㇺᏒౝߩ᳓૕㧩ࡅ࡯࠻ࠕࠗ࡜ࡦ࠼ࠍシᷫㇺᔃߦ߅ߌࠆᷡᵹߩᄢⷙᮨߥᓳᵴ‫ޓ‬㧩‫࡞࠙࠰ޓ‬Ꮢ᡽ᐭߩ࠴ࡖ࡟ࡦࠫ‫ޓ‬㧩‫ޓ‬ᥤᾲ✭๺ലᨐᬌ⸽ߩ࠴ࡖࡦࠬㇺᏒ㐿⊒ߩࡄ࡜࠳ࠗࡓォ឵߳㧍%XLOWXS
$UHD

ଥ⇐࠱ࡦ࠺

*UHHQ3DUN
PRUHWKDQP%XLOWXS
$UHD

੤ㅢ㊂ߩᷫዋߦࠃࠆᄢ᳇ᵺൻ࡮࿾ၞ⚻ᷣߩ⊒ዷ߽䊄䉟䉿䈮䈍䈔䉎䇸㘑䈱㆏䇹䋺⃻ઍ䈱㘑᳓䋿

54
4
44
3 .60 45'%

& '%

&%

&

:67;

 ;

&;

(& '&
'

%

$
$

()

*
+

('

(('( )

<)

*+)
*

*

=
=
=

<<) *(
*56< 61 '< <<<;

) 2. '

'<Â䉲䊠䉿䉾䊃䉧䊦䊃䋨㪪㫋㫌㫋㫋㪾㪸㫉㫋䋩ᏒÂ䊣䊷䊨䉾䊌䈱ౝ㒽⋆࿾䈱ᐩ䈮┙࿾Â㘑ㅦ䈲৻⥸䈮㕖Ᏹ䈮ᒙ䈇Â౻ቄ䈱ᄢ᳇ᳪᨴ䋨ធ࿾ㅒォጀ䈱⊒㆐䋩Âᄐቄ䈱ᥤᾲ䉅໧㗴Â䇸㘑䈱㆏䇹䋺ㇺᏒ᳇୥଻ో䈱䈢䉄䈱ㇺᏒ⸘↹Âᄛ㑆䇮Ꮢⴝ࿾๟ㄝ䈱ਐ㒺਄䈪᡼኿಄ළ䈮䉋䉍಄ᶭ䈭ⓨ᳇䈱ጀ䈏࿾⴫㕙ઃㄭ䈮ᒻᚑÂ಄᳇ᵹ䈏⋆࿾ᐩ䈱Ꮢⴝ࿾䈻Âᄤὼ䈱ᄢ᳇ᳪᨴ䊶ᥤᾲ✭๺ᯏ⢻䉕៊䈭䉒䈭䈇䉋䈉䈭࿯࿾೑↪䈫ᑪ▽‛䈱㈩⟎⸘↹ 5

4

&

%
%

$

PV5

4

3
3
3
3

䌾 P᳇᷷䋨㷄䋩䌙䌙䌑䌑䌑䌙

P7HPS ,QVLGHᓮ⧞ౝ*UHHQ3DUN䌙䌙䌙䌙䌙䌄䌙䌄䌄䌄䌄䌄䌄䌑䌑䌑 䌑P䌓

$0 $0〒㔌䋨䌭䋩

䌎

334

一ノ瀬俊明ᄛ㑆䊐䊤䉟䊑䊦䉪䈱Ꮢⴝ࿾䉕಄ළ䈜䉎಄᳇ᵹᢙ୯⸘▚䋨㪪㪺㪿㫎㪸㪹䉌䈮䉋䉎䋩䊐䊤䉟䊑䊦䉪䋨㪝㫉㪼㫀㪹㫌㫉㪾䋩Ꮢ䈱੐଀⑔ጟ䈱㘑䈱㆏ᚢ⇛㩷䋨࿖࿯੤ㅢ⋭⸥⠪⊒⴫䋩㘑䈱㆏䉕ណ䉍౉䉏䈢㐿⊒଀䊐䊤䉟䊑䊦䉪㇠ᄖ 5LHVHOIHOG䉁䈫䉄䃨䉁䈤䈨䈒䉍䈮䈍䈔䉎ᄢ᳇䊶ᾲⅣႺ䈱଻ో䇭䉝䉳䉝䈱ㇺᏒ䈮䈲䉁䈣᥉෸䈚䈩䈇䈭䈇䇯䃨䉧䉟䊄䊤䉟䊮䊶ᢎ⑼ᦠ䋨䊄䉟䉿䈱੐଀䋩䇭ౝኈ䉕ᢎ᧦⊛䈮ㆡ↪䈜䉎䈫ෂ㒾䋨䈘䉌䈭䉎ၮ␆⎇ⓥ䈲ᔅⷐ䋩䇯䃨ਃᄢἫἹ䋨㊀ᘮ䇮ᱞṽ䇮ධ੩䋩䇮ർ੩䇮਄ᶏ䇮⪇ධ࿾ᣇ䈱ㇺᏒ䈭䈬䇮ᄐቄ䈱ᥤᾲኻ╷䈏㐳ᦼ㑆ᔅⷐ䇯䃨ᣣᧄ䈱႐ว䇮࿾ᮭ䈭䈬ౣ㐿⊒䉕䉄䈓䉎วᗧᒻᚑㆊ⒟䈏ᄢᄌ䇯䇭䋨ਛ࿖䈏᦭೑䋩䃨䋨⑼ቇ⊛⍮⷗䈮ⵣᛂ䈤䈘䉏䈢䋩⃻ઍ䈱㘑᳓䇭ᚑ㐳⪺䈚䈇䉝䉳䉝䈱ㇺᏒ䈮䈍䈇䈩Ⴧ䈜㊀ⷐᕈ

335