July, 2015

Date of Issue: July 15, 2015

Superconductivity Web21
Published by International Superconductivity Technology Center
KSP, Kawasaki, Kanagawa 213-0012 Japan Tel:+81-44-850-1612, Fax:+81-44-850-1613

Contents:

Topics: What’s New in the World of Superconductivity
Feature Article: Refrigeration and Cryogenic Technologies- Full Automated Brayton Refrigerator with Single-switch Operation- Development of High Performance Refrigerator- Single-stage GM Refrigerator for High-temperature Superconducting Equipment
Feature Article : ISS2014/ISS-IEA Joint session (Special Edition)- ISS2014 / ISS-IEA Joint session(Young Generation Award - Best Presentation Award Paper)- ISS2014 / ISS-IEA Joint session(Young Generation Award - Runner-up Presentation Award Paper)

Top of Superconductivity Web21

Superconductivity Web21
Published by International Superconductivity Technology Center
KSP, Kawasaki, Kanagawa 213-0012 Japan
Tel:+81-44-850-1612, Fax:+81-44-850-1613
Top of Superconductivity Web21: http://www.istec.or.jp/web21/web21-E.html
This work was subsidized by JKA using promotion funds fromKEIRIN RACE
http://ringring-keirin.jp

July 2015© ISTEC 2015 All rights reserved.

July 2015

Date of Issue: July 15, 2015

Superconductivity Web21
Published by International Superconductivity Technology Center
KSP, Kawasaki, Kanagawa 213-0012 Japan Tel:+81-44-850-1612, Fax:+81-44-850-1613

What’s New in the World of Superconductivity초전도 뉴스 –세계의 동향超电导新闻 -世界的动向chāo diàn dǎo xīnwén

- shìjiè de dòngxiàng-

Yutaka Yamada, Principal Research Fellow
Superconductivity Research Laboratory, ISTEC★News sources and related areas in this issue►Power Application

전력응용电力应用 [diànlì yìngyòng]New LN2 Refrigeration System for the “AmpaCity” HTS Cable ProjectMesser Group (14 April, 2015)
Industrial gases specialist Messer, has developed a new liquid-nitrogen cryogenic refrigeration technology
to cool superconducting cables for the “AmpaCity” project of the energy supplier RWE. This technology
offers numerous benefits over the originally envisaged cooling system using Stirling engines. It involves
vaporizing nitrogen at below atmospheric pressure, thereby allowing a temperature of -209 °C to beattained and thus meet cable specifications. At this temperature, the refrigerated nitrogen offsets the heat

July, 2015

© ISTEC 2015 All rights reserved.

-1-

July 2015

Date of Issue: July 15, 2015

Superconductivity Web21
Published by International Superconductivity Technology Center
KSP, Kawasaki, Kanagawa 213-0012 Japan Tel:+81-44-850-1612, Fax:+81-44-850-1613

absorbed by the AmpaCity superconductor cable from its surroundings making it possible to transport
electricity with almost zero losses. Further cooling is not possible since nitrogen freezes at -210 °C.
“AmpaCity” now qualifies as one of the projects for KlimaExpo.NRW, an initiative from local government inNorth-Rhine Westphalia and Germany’s Federal Ministry for Economic Affairs and Energy. A part of the pilot
project involves commissioning the longest superconducting cable, which was trialed in Essen in April 2014.
Superconducting cables are able to transport 5-times the amount of electricity through cables having thesame cross-section with relatively low voltages. Additional to reducing energy losses, there are anticipatedsavings on both cost and space for both operators and communities.
Dr. Friedhelm Herzog, Messer’s specialist for gases applications in the industry, was quoted as saying thatthe apparatus used had to undergo rigorous procedures, the principal of which was the safety of theconstruction and its reliability in operation. For plant safety, the liquid nitrogen supply tank is also used forventing purposes so that liquid nitrogen can be flushed from the cable in the event of the cable sufferingdamage, rather than it escaping uncontrolled into the environment. The routing system responsible for plantsafety is being patented. For system reliability, all pumps and critical fittings have redundancy built in, which
also allows maintenance to be undertaken whilst the system is in operation.
The project is drawing immense interest from the media, from politicians and from experts in the field.
Source: ”Minus 209 degrees Celsius: New cryogenic technology enables transmission of electricity almost
lossless” (14 Apr, 2015) Press Release
http://www.messergroup.com/de/Presse/wpresse/150414_minus-209-grad-celsius_neue-kuehltechnologie-ermoeglicht-nahezu-verlustfreien-stromtransport/index.html
Contact: Diana Buss, Diana.buss@messergroup.com

HTS Power Transformer
Fabrum Solutions (22 May, 2015)
Christchurch hi-tech manufacturer Fabrum Solutions, have developed a HTS power transformer that isenvironmentally friendly, safe and reduces energy losses compared to conventional transformers.
The industry-led collaboration that includes Victoria University and others, shows that energy losses areindeed half that of a conventional transformer especially when it was at very low temperatures. There has
already been interest from Unites States businesses that are safety driven. Mike Staines, Robinson InstituteHTS transformers science leader is quoted as saying, “New Zealand has developed a competitive edge in
HTS and other new technologies.”
Fabrum’s specialty is the manufacture of cryostats. They are working on commercializing a project to makeCallaghan Innovation designed cryocoolers, which will be launched for commercial sale at a cryogenic
engineering conference in Tucson Arizona on July 1.
Source: ”FABRUM IN TRANSFORMERS DEAL” (22 May, 2015) Press Release
July, 2015

© ISTEC 2015 All rights reserved.

-2-

July 2015

Date of Issue: July 15, 2015

Superconductivity Web21
Published by International Superconductivity Technology Center
KSP, Kawasaki, Kanagawa 213-0012 Japan Tel:+81-44-850-1612, Fax:+81-44-850-1613

http://www.fabrumsolutions.com/news-posts/fabrum-in-transformers-deal/
Contact: info@company.com►Industrial Application

산업응용

工业应用 [gōngyè yìngyòng]$8.5 million Contract with US Navy HTS Degaussing System
AMSC (19 May, 2015)
The U.S. Navy has awarded AMSC a contract worth up to $8.5 million to provide HTS-based shipprotection system equipment that will employ AMSC's advanced HTS degaussing system, referred by
AMSC as "Ship Protection Systems." The components of the degaussing system are applicable to otherapplications that are being targeted for ship implementation.
AMSC is continuing to expand HTS technology via a number of applications for power, propulsion, andprotection equipment. "We've worked with the U.S. Navy for a number of years on the deployment of thesesystems, and we are pleased to allow the U.S. Navy to purchase ship protection system equipment," said
Daniel P. McGahn, President and CEO, AMSC.
Source: ”AMSC Announces Contract From U.S. Navy for High Temperature Superconductor (HTS)
Equipment” (19 May, 2015) Press Release
http://ir.amsc.com/releases.cfm
Contact: Kerry Farrell, Kerry.farrell@amsc.com

►Wire

선 재료

缐材料 [xiàn cáiliào]

Plans for Superconductor Manufacturing Institute in University of Houston
University of Houston (8 May, 2015)
The University of Houston (UH) will head plans for an Advanced Superconductor Manufacturing Institute(ASMI), aimed at speeding up the commercialization of high-temperature superconductors. Energetics Inc.
will join in these efforts.
The United States has five Advanced Manufacturing Institutes but none are involved in superconductor
technology. The current plans are to house the industry-driven university research and related projects near
the main campus, but consortium members will make the ultimate decision.
Venkat Selvamanickam, M.D. Anderson Chair Professor of Mechanical Engineering at UH, will be theprincipal investigator, receiving a $500,000 planning grant from the National Institute of Standards andTechnology (NIST). The grant was part of the second round funding provided by NIST’s Advanced
Manufacturing Technology Consortia, which launched in 2013 to address advanced manufacturing ofJuly, 2015

© ISTEC 2015 All rights reserved.

-3-

July 2015

Date of Issue: July 15, 2015

Superconductivity Web21
Published by International Superconductivity Technology Center
KSP, Kawasaki, Kanagawa 213-0012 Japan Tel:+81-44-850-1612, Fax:+81-44-850-1613

superconductors in the United States.
The grant addresses technical barriers that have hindered superconductor manufacturing from today’s
small-volume manufacturing to full commercialization, as well as to develop a business plan in conjunction
with the industry-led consortium. The consortium will be formed over the next 18 months and will be madeup of industry, academia and others, as well as developing plans to address the obstructions to low-cost,high-volume production, quality assurance and reliability testing.
Ramanan Krishnamoorti, chief energy officer at UH and acting vice president/vice chancellor for researchand technology transfer, stated “I anticipate a revolution in the scalable manufacturing of low cost, highperformance superconductors.”
Source: ”UH Launches Plans for Superconductor Manufacturing Institute”(8 May, 2015) News Releases
http://www.uh.edu/news-events/stories/2015/May/0508SuperconductorManufacturing
Contact: Jeannie Kever, jekever@uh.edu►Management and Finance 경영정보经营信息[jīngyíng xìnxī]2015 First Quarter Results
Superconductor Technologies Inc (12 May, 2015)
Superconductor Technologies Inc. (STI) reported results for the quarter ended March 28, 2015.
During the first quarter, STI shipped Conductus wire to ten of its customers: seven existing and three new,bringing their total customer counts to 34. Six of their customers are in Stage 1 evaluation, which comprises
wire characterization and performance testing, and four are in Stage 2, which comprises more stringent
trials necessary for commercial deployment. One Stage 2 shipments was to a customer that is completing a
superconducting cable demonstration project.
STI's first quarter 2015 net revenues were $55,000 compared to $82,000 in the fourth quarter of 2014 and$389,000 in the first quarter of 2014. Revenue for all periods was primarily from legacy wireless products.
As of March 28, 2015, STI had $5.3 million in cash and cash equivalents. Capex is expected to be less than$400,000 for the entirety of 2015 now that the Conductus wire production suite is completed.
Jeff Quiram, STI's president and chief executive officer noted that, "STI strives to be responsive to customer
requests aimed at fulfilling customer qualification processes. Customer feedback provides us with our future
strategies and STI are the best-positioned to aggressively deploy superconducting devices in the market”.
The Conductus wire production system is progressing with wire being produced over the entire depositionarea necessary to produce long lengths of wire and shipped to customers for qualification testing. The plans
for the second quarter include increasing capacities to fulfill existing Stage 2 qualification orders.

July, 2015

© ISTEC 2015 All rights reserved.

-4-

July 2015

Date of Issue: July 15, 2015

Superconductivity Web21
Published by International Superconductivity Technology Center
KSP, Kawasaki, Kanagawa 213-0012 Japan Tel:+81-44-850-1612, Fax:+81-44-850-1613

Source: ”Superconductor Technologies Reports 2015 First Quarter Results” (12 May, 2015)
Press Release
http://phx.corporate-ir.net/phoenix.zhtml?c=70847&p=irol-newsArticle_Print&ID=2046866
Contact: Cathy Mattison, invest@suptech.com

Top of Superconductivity Web21
July, 2015

© ISTEC 2015 All rights reserved.

-5-

July 2015

Date of Issue: July 15, 2015

Superconductivity Web21
Published by International Superconductivity Technology Center
KSP, Kawasaki, Kanagawa 213-0012 Japan Tel:+81-44-850-1612, Fax:+81-44-850-1613

Feature Article: Refrigeration and Cryogenic Technologies-Full Automated Brayton Refrigerator with Single-switch Operation
Ken-etsu Uwamori
Cryogenic Development Group, Project Administration Sec.
Development & Engineering Division
Taiyo Nippon Sanso Corporation
R&D into High Temperature Superconducting (HTS) power equipment is predicted to be vital for energy
saving power technology and is being actively pursued towards practical applications. Recent years haveseen superconducting cables and superconducting fault current limiters for practical applications entering
the final stages of R&D with some already planned for grid connection trials. The need for a suitablerefrigerator to cryocool high temperature superconducting power equipment has therefore heightened. The
necessary specifications of a refrigerator applicable to high temperature superconducting power equipment
include, 1) to have control of cooling temperatures and cooling capacities required to sustain stablesuperconductivity; 2) continuous long-term operational reliability; 3) greater cooling efficiencies (low runningcosts); 4) system compactness (compact footprint); and 5) low maintenance costs.
Typical operating temperatures of refrigeration systems currently employed for cooling HTS power
equipment ranges between 20 to 80 K and with cooling capacities varying between 2 to 10 kW, meeting theneeds of superconducting cables operating at 70 K. Current compact cryocoolers available in the market
provide lower cooling capacities of around 1 kW at 80 K and with frictional bearings require regular
maintenance once per year. On the other hand, large-scale cryogenic systems utilized for cryogenic air
separation units and helium liquefiers employ expansion turbines equipped with non-contact bearings thathave proved durable. However, the cooling capacities of such systems are far beyond the necessities
required by HTS power equipment and are therefore being addressed by a NEDO project entitled,“Technological Development of Yttrium-based superconducting power equipment,” which developed aportable 2 kW neon turbo-Brayton cycle refrigerator operating at 65 K using neon as the working fluid.
Further work by Taiyo Nippon Sanso Corporation has led to the renovation of a 2 kW refrigerator. As shownin Figure 1, further compactness has been realized allowing installation of the equipment and cold box (heatexchanger) onto a common base. With the main focus now on enhancing system operations by repeatedly
modifying and improving the operational program, has led to the establishment of an automated technology
offering a single-switch operation for start-up and controlling the liquid nitrogen temperature set-point. The
system is programmed so that the refrigerator stops and operates at the touch of a button, and is alreadyintegrated into the product.
Recent trials involve reducing the refrigerator’s power consumption. At a cooling temperature of 70 K and acooling capacity of 2 kW the compressor consumes around 50 kW. To address this issue a newcompressor is currently under development, which if realized will reduce power consumption by several kW
and will also simplify components.

July, 2015

© ISTEC 2015 All rights reserved.

-6-

July 2015

Date of Issue: July 15, 2015

Superconductivity Web21
Published by International Superconductivity Technology Center
KSP, Kawasaki, Kanagawa 213-0012 Japan Tel:+81-44-850-1612, Fax:+81-44-850-1613

Buffer tank
Expansion turbine

2600 mm

Turbo compressor
Heat exchanger

3320 mm

2400 mmFig. 1 2 kW turbo Brayton neon refrigerator

Here, while demonstration studies into high temperature superconducting power equipment have reachedactual grid-scales, the requirements of large-scale refrigerators with even larger 5-20 kW-class cooling
capacities have intensified. The company has commenced a project to develop a 10 kW-class refrigerator,and last year a prototype was fabricated. Figure 2 shows a prototype 10 kW-class turbo Brayton neon
refrigerator that has been fabricated. The prototype comprises of a heat exchanger housed horizontally in acold box and a turbine-compressor installed in upper part of the cold box. Performance evaluations of the
10 kW refrigerators are currently ongoing. Further modifications and enhancements are envisaged andaimed towards a future product line-up.
Operation control panel
Buffer tank

Turbine-compressor

Control panel
Inter cooler /Cold box

After cooler

Fig. 2 10 kW turbo Brayton neon refrigerator (prototype)Top of Superconductivity Web21
July, 2015

© ISTEC 2015 All rights reserved.

-7-

July 2015

Date of Issue: July 15, 2015

Superconductivity Web21
Published by International Superconductivity Technology Center
KSP, Kawasaki, Kanagawa 213-0012 Japan Tel:+81-44-850-1612, Fax:+81-44-850-1613

Feature Article: Refrigeration and Cryogenic Technologies-Development of High Performance Refrigerator
Naoko Nakamura
Vice Senior Research Fellow
Mayekawa MFG. Co., Ltd.
Under a NEDO project entitled, “Demonstration studies of stability/reliability of the next-generationtransmission systems,” the author and her research team aims to demonstrate the long term performance,
reliability and feasibility of a refrigerator in an actual grid by performing a 1-year continuous operation of aBrayton refrigerator, which has been developed under the “Demonstration project of high-temperature
superconducting cable”. The author herewith introduces the Brayton refrigerator that has been developed
along with a future plan of the project.
The targets for a single-unit Brayton refrigerator are set to have a cooling capacity of 5 kW and COP: 0.1,
with maintenance interval of 30,000 hrs. A reverse Brayton cycle has been selected taking into
consideration refrigerator targets such as higher capacities and greater efficiencies. A turbo-compressor
and a turbo-expander have been employed in order to take advantage of the maximum operational
characteristics of the reverse Brayton cycle. Integrating the first, second and third-stage turbo compressors
with a turbo-expander and by recycling the power generated by the expander have produced efficiency
gains in the refrigerator. Neon gas was utilized by considering the speed of sound, which would greatly
influence the architecture and efficiency of the rotor.
A turbo-compressor/expander for air refrigeration system and a super-compact turbo-expander designed
for helium liquefaction applicable to the Brayton cycle system, already commercialized by Mayekawa, hasbeen investigated. Elaborate technological studies comprising of design and fluid/structural analysis has led
to the development of rotors that have almost realized the targeted adiabatic efficiency of 0.8. Furthermore,
performance trials of Brayton refrigerators have met their developmental targets, realizing cooling capacitiesof 5.8 kW and COP 0.1 at liquid nitrogen temperatures of 77 K, measured at the exit end of the refrigerator.
The utilization of the pressure control method proposed by this development has led to greater operational
efficiencies at a stable COP. This is made possible by modifying the circulating gas pressure by controlled
rated revolutions, which controls the changing mass flow capacity at a constant volume flow. It is
understood that the refrigerator operates with greater efficiency at stable COP with cooling capacities of
0.65 ~ 1.0.
The Brayton refrigerator was transferred to the Asahi Substation owned by Tokyo Electric Power Company
and have undergone factory trials. Trial operations are currently ongoing. After the reliability of the coolingsystem has been verified, future plans involve its connection to high temperature superconducting cables inan actual grid and continuous operational trials to demonstrate refrigerator performance from different
perspectives. It is also understood that the efficiency of both the turbo-compressor and expander can beenhanced by further elaborate structural studies and additional investigations are planned. To realize hightemperature superconducting cable systems for practical use, the author will pursue further studies aiming
July, 2015

© ISTEC 2015 All rights reserved.

-8-

July 2015

Date of Issue: July 15, 2015

Superconductivity Web21
Published by International Superconductivity Technology Center
KSP, Kawasaki, Kanagawa 213-0012 Japan Tel:+81-44-850-1612, Fax:+81-44-850-1613

for compactness and reducing costs of the entire cooling system including the refrigerator.

Brayton refrigerator transferred to the Asahi Substation

Top of Superconductivity Web21
July, 2015

© ISTEC 2015 All rights reserved.

-9-

July 2015

Date of Issue: July 15, 2015

Superconductivity Web21
Published by International Superconductivity Technology Center
KSP, Kawasaki, Kanagawa 213-0012 Japan Tel:+81-44-850-1612, Fax:+81-44-850-1613

Feature Article: Refrigeration and Cryogenic Technologies-Single-stage GM Refrigerator for High-temperature Superconducting
Equipment
Rui LiTechnology Group, Precision Equipment Division
Sumitomo Heavy Industries, Ltd.
1. Introduction
Typically, cryocooling superconducting equipment can be largely divided into two systems - one utilizing
coolants such as LHe and LN2 and others utilizing cryocoolers. HTS equipment employing cryo-coolingsystems are highly anticipated because of greater system reliability and the ease of operation andmanagement. The author introduces herewith a new single-GM refrigerator developed specifically for hightemperature superconducting equipment applications.
2. Main specifications of the RDK-500B single-stage GM refrigerator
In order to be applicable to an array of systems, the developed refrigerator has high cooling capacities
between 20~30 K and at 80 K. The development with cooling efficiency as the main focus, resulted in not
only suppressing the primary factors affecting cooling capacities due to the angle of installation, it also
negated the need for a large-scale compressor to operate the refrigerator. The resulting refrigerator is easy
to install at the user site since a compressor exempt from the high-pressure gas safety act can be selected.
(1) Refrigerator Unit type：RDK-500B (Fig.1)(2) Compressor Unit type：F-70LP(3) Input Power Supply：AC200 V three-phase (50/60 Hz)
Power Consumption：(Steady Operation) 7.5/9.0 kW (50/60 Hz)(Start-up) 8.5/9.8 kW (50/60 Hz)(4) Size, Weight：(Refrigerator Unit) 25 kg, about H570×W180×L325 mm(Compressor Unit) 100 kg, about H575×W443×L493 mm(5) Cooling capacity：(50 Hz) >40 W at 20 K, >80 W at 30 K (Fig.2)(60 Hz) >45 W at 20 K, >94 W at 30 K (Reference value, Fig.2)(6) Compliant：comply with UL, CE-marking、RoHS Directive
Exemption from the high-pressure gas safety act

July, 2015

© ISTEC 2015 All rights reserved.

- 10 -

July 2015

Date of Issue: July 15, 2015

Superconductivity Web21
Published by International Superconductivity Technology Center
KSP, Kawasaki, Kanagawa 213-0012 Japan Tel:+81-44-850-1612, Fax:+81-44-850-1613

Fig.1 Refrigerator unit

Fig.2 RDK-500B cooling capacity diagram

3. Mounting angle dependency of cooling efficiency and cooling capacity
The cooling efficiency (COP) of a single-stage GM refrigerator can be simply evaluated by the size ofcooling capacity versus the input power. The cooling capacity of the system developed exhibited 46 W at 20
K (6.8 kW) and 85 W at 30 K (6.9 kW), both at 50 Hz, resulting in a relatively high value of COP of 0.0068 at
20 K and 0.0123 at 30 K.
On the other hand, regarding the mounting angle dependency of the cooling capacity, this was not entirely
eliminated as shown in Figure 3, but in fact was suppressed to less than 24 % at max.

Fig.3 RDK-500B Mounting angle dependency of cooling capacity

Top of Superconductivity Web21
July, 2015

© ISTEC 2015 All rights reserved.

- 11 -

Special edition

Date of Issue: July 2, 2015

Superconductivity Web21
Published by International Superconductivity Technology Center
KSP, Kawasaki, Kanagawa 213-0012 Japan Tel:+81-44-850-1612, Fax:+81-44-850-1613

Feature Article：ISS2014/ISS-IEA Joint session（Young Generation Award – Best Presentation Award Paper）-Removal of iron scale with superconducting magnet high gradient magnetic
separation from feed-water in thermal power plant, including future energy
society and my research work
Saori Shibatani, Osaka University
In November 26, 2014, IEA-HTS-IA and ISS joint session was held, and I made a presentation entitled“Removal of iron scale with superconducting magnet high gradient magnetic separation from feed-water inthermal power plant, including future energy society and my research work”. The content of mypresentation is as follows.

Fig.1 World electricity generation outlook

Fig.1 shows world electricity generation outlook1). World’s electricity generation will have been increasing
and approximately 66 % of electric source is fossil fuels in 2035. This data shows that CO2 emission will
have been increasing in future.
There are some methods to reduce CO2 emission. One is to increase the renewable energy. Renewableenergy is CO2 free in electric generation, but it has demerits of low energy density, high-cost of power
generation and unstable energy. Thus, it takes long term to introduce renewable energy. Another is toincrease the nuclear power generation. The nuclear power is CO2 free in electric generation, high-energy
density and low-cost of power generation. However, it involves high risk for a use of nuclear fuel. So, it isdifficult to gain public acceptance to increase nuclear power generation.

Special edition, 2015

© ISTEC 2015 All rights reserved.

- 12 -

Special edition

Date of Issue: July 2, 2015

Superconductivity Web21
Published by International Superconductivity Technology Center
KSP, Kawasaki, Kanagawa 213-0012 Japan Tel:+81-44-850-1612, Fax:+81-44-850-1613

Fig.2 LC-CO2 emission

Therefore, as a new method for CO2 reduction, I’d like to introduce my study “improvement of thermal
power plant efficiency using superconducting magnet”. Fig.2 shows CO2 emission by electric source2).
Thermal power generation releases more carbon dioxide than other electric power generation processes.
Therefore, we considered improvement of thermal power generation efficiency. The main factor of decline inthermal power generation efficiency is the scale which adheres to piping wall surface. The scale is ironoxide particles which consist of magnetite, hematite and oxyhydroxide. The thermal conductivity of scale isabout tenth part of pipework. So the scale adhesion causes decrease in heat-exchange efficiency andincrease in pressure loss. It is known that removal of 20 μm of scale reduces 1% of CO2 emission3). We
examined for the improvement of thermal power generation efficiency by removing the scale.
The scale generates in feed-water of thermal power plant by oxidation of the iron ion which was eluted bycorrosion of the pipework as oxide and hydroxide. In low-temperature part (condenser – low pressure
heater), the main component of the scale is oxyhydroxide which is paramagnetic and small particle size. On
the other hand, in high-temperature part (deaerator – boiler inlet), the main component of the scale ismagnetite which is ferromagnetic and large particle size. Moreover, the scale amount in high-temperaturepart is much larger than in low-temperature part. For these reasons, it is effective to remove the scale inhigh-temperature part. So we considered a new High Gradient Magnetic Separation (HGMS) system thatcan be installed in high-temperature part. This technique can be installed to existing thermal power plants,
so it takes relatively low cost and short term for the introduction.
Fig.3 shows schematic illustration of the HGMS experimental device. We conducted the experiment underhigh-temperature and high-pressure condition (200 °C, 20 atmospheres) assuming thermal power plant.
We used the simulated scale that was mixture of magnetite 80 wt% and hematite 20 wt%. The simulated
scale suspension was flown into the magnetic separation filter, and the scale was separated by a solenoidal
superconducting magnet. The separation rate was estimated from the concentration of passed iron.

Special edition, 2015

© ISTEC 2015 All rights reserved.

- 13 -

Special edition

Date of Issue: July 2, 2015

Superconductivity Web21
Published by International Superconductivity Technology Center
KSP, Kawasaki, Kanagawa 213-0012 Japan Tel:+81-44-850-1612, Fax:+81-44-850-1613

Fig.3 HGMS experimental device

The separation rate of simulated scale is 98 % with 2 T of magnetic field. We succeeded in removing
simulated scale under high-temperature and high-pressure condition. As a result, the scale removal by
HGMS can be realized by using superconducting magnet. The possibility was shown that the efficiency ofthermal power generation can be improved by HGMS with superconducting magnet.
When this technology is realized, CO2 emission from thermal power plant will be reduced and fuel forthermal power generation is also saved. As mentioned above, most of CO2 exhausted by generation comefrom thermal power generation, so CO2 reduction of thermal power plant has large effect for future. By
using scale removal technology, the environmental load by thermal power generation will be reduced in the
future.

Fig.4 Energy combination
Special edition, 2015

© ISTEC 2015 All rights reserved.

- 14 -

Special edition

Date of Issue: July 2, 2015

Superconductivity Web21
Published by International Superconductivity Technology Center
KSP, Kawasaki, Kanagawa 213-0012 Japan Tel:+81-44-850-1612, Fax:+81-44-850-1613

In the discussions so far, I focused on problems of CO2 emission. But it is necessary to consider the futureenergy society from several points of view. So I think it is important to combine improved thermal power
generation with other power generation methods (Fig.4). For example, by combining thermal power
generation with the renewable energy, it can be used as dispersed power system. On the other hand, by
combining with nuclear power generation, energy security is developed.
In this manner, future energy society should aim to the best mix of these power sources. The efficiency
improvement of thermal power generation raises feasibility of the energy best mix. So our study about scale
removal by magnetic separation looks ahead to the future energy society.
At a later date, I visited National Institute for Materials Science(NIMS) which is the facility collaborating with us for this study. I
observed various specifications of superconducting magnets,
water-cooled copper magnets, hybrid magnets and NMR. The
hybrid magnet (Fig.5) which consist of superconducting magnet andwater-cooled copper magnet could produce up to 37 T. It wasthought when I used it for magnetic separation, the high speed
processing not only for ferromagnetic substances or paramagnetic
substances but also for diamagnetic substance will be possible. For
example, biomedical materials or DNA can be separated, so we canuse it for medical field. Currently, the maximum of the static magnetic
field that can be produced is 45 T in America. However, I heard that
NIMS tries to produce more than 45 T developing theFig.5 Hybrid magnet
superconducting material. I have studied only application of theat NIMS
superconducting magnet, so there were many contents to hear for
the first time about materials study. In addition, I saw a solenoidal superconducting magnet whose boa
diameter is 40 cm at NIMS. In my study, I use a solenoidal superconducting magnet whose boa diameter is
10 cm at the experiment, but it is thought that boa diameter around 40 cm is necessary to be used inpipework of feed-water in the actual thermal power plant. I could watch the actual size of superconducting
magnet and was able to sense the size of the scale removal device this time.
References
1) IEA, World Energy Outlook 2012
2) Central Research Institute of Electric Power Industry, Evaluation of Life Cycle CO2 Emissions of Power
Generation Technologies, 20103) H.Okada (private communication)
Acknowledgment
I’m grateful to Hidehiko Okada and Noriyuki Hirota for giving me a tour when I visited to National Institutefor Materials Science.

Top of Superconductivity Web21
Special edition, 2015

© ISTEC 2015 All rights reserved.

- 15 -

Special edition

Date of Issue: July 2, 2015

Superconductivity Web21
Published by International Superconductivity Technology Center
KSP, Kawasaki, Kanagawa 213-0012 Japan Tel:+81-44-850-1612, Fax:+81-44-850-1613

Feature Article：ISS2014/ISS-IEA Joint session（Young Generation Award – Runner-up Presentation Award Paper）-IEA-HTS-IA and ISS joint session inspired me to dream more
Department of Electrical Engineering, Graduate School of Information Science and Electrical Engineering,
Kyushu University, Japan
Kohei Higashikawa (Associate Professor)
In the spring of 2014, I first heard that “IEA-HTS-IA and ISS joint session” was supposed to be held at
ISS2014. According to the website, the session was for young researchers under 35 years old, andrequired them to present their prospects and opinions for future energy society in relation to their own
research works. When I was a student, I was relatively high-spirited to know the brilliance ofsuperconducting technology. In recent years, however, I felt slight stress to consider some realistic
obstacles to overcome to expand practical uses of superconducting applications. Therefore I applied for thissession to energize myself again.
The title of my presentation was “Advanced Diagnostics of Superconducting Wires and Tapes forHigh-performance and Highly-functional Power Applications Supporting Large-scale Introduction of
Renewable Energy.” I have a lecture on “Electrical Energy Environment Engineering” in the graduate
school, and deal with large-scale introduction of renewable energies in the future as well as the energy
society currently depending on the fossil fuels. Especially for Japan, it has been considered difficult to cover
power consumption mostly by renewable energies, e.g., photovoltaic and wind power generations, in termsof climatic and geographical conditions, e.g., narrow land and unstable wind condition. Furthermore,
acceptable amount of the renewable energies with largely fluctuating outputs has been limited by the issuesof power system stability. After knowing these situations, many of the students come round to thinking that it
is inevasible to utilize nuclear power generation again in Japan, while a large part of the lay public is
negative about that as a result of the earthquake. However, if all electric power consumption can becovered by renewable energies, all the people will agree to the concept itself at least. This was the main
reason why I set the above-mentioned title for this session.
For example, Fig. 1 shows a famous figure, which suggests that electric power consumption in the world
can be fully covered by a very small part of the Sahara with photovoltaic power generation1). It is true thatthe area itself is enormous but it is dream-inspiring for me that such a small portion of the earth can fully
supply electric power consumed all over the world. However, power-consuming area is often located very
far away from such a region; then long-distance power transmission is indispensable. Furthermore, power
generation and consumption does not necessarily match with each other within a short time scale; thenelectric power storage is essentially important. These two keywords, i.e., “long-distance power transmission”
and “power storage,” bring an idea with superconducting technologies.

Special edition, 2015

© ISTEC 2015 All rights reserved.

- 16 -

Special edition

Date of Issue: July 2, 2015

Superconductivity Web21
Published by International Superconductivity Technology Center
KSP, Kawasaki, Kanagawa 213-0012 Japan Tel:+81-44-850-1612, Fax:+81-44-850-1613

All Energies Supplied from Renewable Energies (PV, WT, etc.)
will be possible in principle

Fig. 1. Area needed for covering electric power consumption by photovoltaic power generation.

Fig. 2 illustrates the concept. The key point is DC power transmission with a global-scale loop structure.
DC power transmission will be rather natural considering that the power sources are solar and wind powers.
This will also be preferable for superconducting cables from the viewpoint of AC losses. On the other hand,
the true aim is to store energy in power grid itself. For example, tera-joule-class energy can be stored by anaround-the-globe loop with a DC current of 100 kA. Furthermore, even peta-joule-class energy could be
stored supposing a cable with strands tightly twisted around a magnetic core. Namely, both “long-distancepower transmission” and “power storage,” which are key items for large-scale introduction of renewableenergies, are realized at the same time. Then, this can be called as “ubiquitous superconducting power
network” where we can generate and consume electricity anytime and anywhere.
Technical Obstacles:
1. power transmission invery long distance
2. temporal change inpower generation…

Solution:
Superconducting Power Network- superconducting cable- energy storage in the grid
+ SFCL, SMES, DC reactor for
power quality & control

energystoredFig. 2. Ubiquitous superconducting power network with long-distance power transmission and power storage
enabled by global-scale DC loop configuration.

Special edition, 2015

© ISTEC 2015 All rights reserved.

- 17 -

Special edition

Date of Issue: July 2, 2015

Superconductivity Web21
Published by International Superconductivity Technology Center
KSP, Kawasaki, Kanagawa 213-0012 Japan Tel:+81-44-850-1612, Fax:+81-44-850-1613

In relation to this, I attended a Mongolia-Japan joint seminar on electric power technologies. Mongolia
has the Gobi Desert with the world’s second-largest amount of sunlight just behind the Sahara. A Japaneseorganization reports its high potential for huge renewable energy generation, and seeks out an opportunity
for business 2). For Japan, also from the viewpoint of distance, importing renewable energies from there ismuch more realistic than the case from the Sahara. This was a reason why I decided to attend the seminar.
The attendees were from Mongolian University of Science and Technology (MUST) and powertransmission/distribution companies in Mongolia, and from seven universities in Japan. In particular, theattendees from Japan included very famous professors who are in charge with international standardization
on smart grids and power transmission/distribution systems. This was also a good chance for me to discusswith such people who were not the specialists for applied superconductivity.

Fig. 3. A scenery in Mongolia a few hours away from Ulan Bator by bus:
endlessly broad land with clear sky which seems to be appropriate for photovoltaic power generation.

After visiting MUST in Ulan Bator first, then we moved to the seminar site at Delgerkhaan by bus together
with the Mongolian people. Fig. 3 shows a landscape on the way there. Such a broad land with a clear sky
continued the whole way; this reminded me of the great potential for large-scale solar power generation inthis country. Furthermore, I received the impression that the wind condition was suitable for wind power
generation as can be seen from the flying flags shown in Fig. 4. Eight Japanese people and around 30
Mongolian people attended the seminar, and Fig. 5 shows the atmosphere in my presentation. The personnext to me kindly translated my talk to Mongolian because many of the Mongolian attendees do not speak
English. I introduced my research and its future prospect; then I felt very good responses from them. In
particular, they were excited about a vision for the power transmission from Mongolia to Japan bysuperconducting cables.
Special edition, 2015

© ISTEC 2015 All rights reserved.

- 18 -

Special edition

Date of Issue: July 2, 2015

Superconductivity Web21
Published by International Superconductivity Technology Center
KSP, Kawasaki, Kanagawa 213-0012 Japan Tel:+81-44-850-1612, Fax:+81-44-850-1613

Fig. 4. Another scenery in Mongolia a few hours away from Ulan Bator by bus (2): good wind condition

Fig. 5. Atmosphere for my presentation at the Mongolia-Japan joint seminar.

Special edition, 2015

© ISTEC 2015 All rights reserved.

- 19 -

Special edition

Date of Issue: July 2, 2015

Superconductivity Web21
Published by International Superconductivity Technology Center
KSP, Kawasaki, Kanagawa 213-0012 Japan Tel:+81-44-850-1612, Fax:+81-44-850-1613

On the other hand, the current situation in Mongolia needs a fully-established technology such as
ultrahigh voltage transmission rather than a highly-advanced technology such as superconducting power
applications. Therefore, they would only show favorable responses to my presentation because they mightrecognize it as dream or entertainment. Contrastingly, Japanese attendees seriously asked me sometechnical questions because they would know the progresses of superconducting technologies as practicaluses in electric power applications: how to take power from a closed loop, how to break a fault current, how
to cool such a long object, how to clear political issues, and so on. These experiences reminded me that toenrich the understanding and then to build up achievements first in Japan would be appealing to a foreigncountry to employ superconducting technologies there. I believe that this kind of intercommunion withleading persons in Japan as well as with those in a foreign country will bear fruit in the form of export ofsuperconducting electric power infrastructure in the future.
Lastly, my main research topics are characterization of superconducting wires including long-length ones
, design of applications based on their properties4) and investigation of their behaviors in electric powersystem5). The IEA-HTS-IA and ISS joint session was very precious opportunity for me to recall that I wasworking towards such a dream. Actually, I could not believe that I could receive the award because otherpresenters were really excellent in terms of well-described story and very fluent English. However, I could
confidently say that I was right about applying for this session even if I could not win any award. I hope that
this session will continue and develop for many more years.
3)

References:
1) Figure by http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Desertec. Data by the German Center of Aerospace (DLR) (2005).
2) Japanese Business Alliance for Smart Energy World Wide (2012).
3) K. Higashikawa, K. Katahira, M. Inoue, T. Kiss, Y. Shingai, M. Konishi, K. Ohmatsu, T. Machi, M.
Yoshizumi, T. Izumi, Y. Shiohara: “Nondestructive Diagnostics of Narrow Coated Conductors for ElectricPower Applications,” IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity, vol. 24, no. 3 (2014) pp.
6600704.
4) K. Higashikawa, T. Nakamura, K. Shikimachi, N. Hirano, S. Nagaya, T. Kiss, M. Inoue: “Conceptual
Design of HTS Coil for SMES Using YBCO Coated Conductor,” IEEE Transactions on Applied
Superconductivity, vol. 17, no. 2 (2007) pp. 1990-1993.
5) K. Higashikawa, S. Urasaki, M. Inoue, M. Tomita, T. Kiss: ``Hardware-in-the-loop Simulation ofSuperconducting Devices for DC Electric Railway Systems Based on Real-time Digital Simulator,’’ to bepresented at MT-24.

Top of Superconductivity Web21

Special edition, 2015

© ISTEC 2015 All rights reserved.

- 20 -