Edits and errata to the 2019 Refinement to the 2006 IPCC Guidelines for National Greenhouse
Gas Inventories

Disclaimer
This list is intended to cover all the edits and errata made to the report prior to publication. It includes
corrections of errors identified after the adoption of and the Overview Chapter and the acceptance of
the underlying report in accordance with the Annex 3 of Appendix A to the Principles Governing IPCC
Work.

It

also

includes

edits

made

to

ensureconsistency

betweenindividual

Chapters/Annexes/Appendices as well as full consistency of the Overview Chapter and the underlying
report. The list might not be fully comprehensive and copy edits are generally not part of this list.
For additional information please contact the IPCC TFI TSU at nggip-tsu@iges.or.jp

NOTE on the advance version released on 14 June 2019Technical corrections of editorial nature have been made to the document <Doc. 3b - Rev.3 - Accepted
Report 2019 Refinement>. They are explained in this note: In Annex 1 (Mapping Tables) of Volume 1, addition of the figure "Decision Tree to choose a Good
Practice method" in Chapter 4 has been reflected on page A1.9.
 In Chapter 4 of Volume 2, the final text proposed by the authors in the Contact Group andexplained orally to the Panel on Sunday, 12 May, has been added in section 4.1.2.
 In Chapter 2 of Volume 4, “ALOS-2” has been moved to a different line in BOX 2.0D (New)Remote Sensing Technologies on page 2.20. This is not a new change, it had already been
captured in the table of changes.
 In Chapter 5 of Volume 4, Table 5A.3.3 was not properly copied in Annex 5A.3 by editorial
mistake. It is now correctly included.
 In Chapter 7 of Volume 4, Equations 7.10, 7.15, 7.16, 7.17 and 7.18 in Section 7.3.3 have beenreformatted; these equations were revised and agreed upon during the Panel session. Thechanges are formatting of the equations to the correct style.
 In Chapter 7 of Volume 4, References have been updated in text citation and in reference list, toreflect changes made at IPCC-49.
 In Chapter 7 of Volume 4, Figure A4 has been updated to correctly reflect the discussion andagreement at IPCC-49.
 In Annex 2 of Volume 4, Mapping tables have been updated to reflect changes made and agreed
at IPCC-49 in Chapter 2: Section 2.6 on Inter-Annual Variability (IAV) and Chapter 7: Floodedland.
 Chapter 2 and Chapter 3 of Volume 1 were missing by editorial mistake. It is now correctly
included. No changes have been made in these chapters at the 49th Session of IPCC.
 The Glossary was missing by editorial mistake. It is now correctly included. Some small changes
have been made to ensure consistency with the changes in the main chapters made at IPCC-49.
In addition, in accordance with the <Decision - IPCC-XLIX-9 - Adoption and Acceptance of 2019refinement>, two footnotes have been added in Chapter 4 of Volume 2. (footnote 5 on page 4.48 andfootnote 8 on page 4.64 in the final publication version)

Volume

Chapter

SectionStart
line
number

Page

End
line
numberCorrection
Overview

Overview Overview -

-

356

356

"microelectricalmechanical" be replaced with "microelectromechanical".

Overview Overview -

-

361

361

replace "ODS substitutes" with "substitutes for ozone depleting substances (ODS)".

Overview Overview -

-

365

365

"Microelectricalmechanical" be replaced with "Microelectromechanical".

Overview Overview -

-

420

422

"The methane conversion factor (MCF) for animal waste management systems arepresented based on climatic regions, as opposed to annual temperatures and a simple
calculation model for deriving the MCF based on monthly temperature regimes has beenpresented." should be "The default methane conversion factor (MCF) values for animal
waste management systems are presented based on climatic regions, as opposed to annual
temperatures, and a simple calculation model for deriving the MCF based on monthly
temperature regimes has been presented."
Glossary

Glossary

Glossary

-

G.4

-

-

[Canal] delete "accessed 10 Apr 18".

Glossary

Glossary

-

G.5

-

-

[Country-specific data] replace "emissions" with "emission factors".

Glossary

Glossary

-

G.8

-

-

[Flow rate] replace "cfs" with "ft3 s-1".

Glossary

Glossary

-

G.9

-

-

Glossary

Glossary

-

G.9

-

-

[Harvested wood products] replace "IPCC good practice guidance (2003, 2006)" with
"Good Practice Guidance for Land Use, Land-Use Change and Forestry (2003) and the2006 IPCC Guidelines".
[Harvested wood products] replace "refers" and "includes" with "refer" and "include".

Glossary

Glossary

-

G.10

-

-

[Large dams] replace "ICOLD" with "International Commission On Large Dams".

Glossary

Glossary

-

G.12

-

-

[Mode] replace "we usually encounter distributions with only one mode" by "distributions
with only one mode are usually encountered".

Glossary

Glossary

-

G.16

-

-

[Surrogate data] add "so-" before "called".
Volume 1

Volume

Chapter

SectionStart
line
number

Page

End
line
numberCorrection

1

1

1.1

1.5

91

91

Footnote 1 "In the 2013 Supplement to the 2006 IPCC Guidelines for National Greenhouse
Gas Inventories: Wetlands (Wetlands Supplement), additional methods are applied to thecoastal wetlands, too, than the standard application of the Managed Land Proxy" to amend
as follows:"In the 2013 Supplement to the 2006 IPCC Guidelines for National Greenhouse Gas
Inventories: Wetlands (Wetlands Supplement), additional methods are applied to thecoastal wetlands that do not follow the standard application of the Managed Land Proxy".

11Authors

1.2

9

9Comma after "Michael Gillenwater (USA)".

1

1

1.4.1.1

1.11

250

253

To remove underlines in notes [c] and [e] under the Table 1.2.

11

1.4.1.3

1.13

275

275

"QA/QC (see section 1.7.3)" to read as: "QA/QC (see Section 1.6.3)".

11

1.4.1.7

1.15

345

345

"...(as defined in Chapter 1.4 of the 2006 IPCC Guidelines)…" to read as: "...(as defined in
Section 1.4 of the 2006 IPCC Guidelines).

1

1

1.4.2

1.16

362

362

"...highlights important data providers..." to read as: ""...highlights importance of data
providers…"

1

1

1.4.2

1.16

378

378

To add "derivation" after "country-specific emission factors".

1

1

1.4.2.1

1.16

385

385

Footnote 7 "Own construction based on the South Africa’s 2rd Biennial Update Report" toread as: "Own construction based on the South Africa’s 2nd Biennial Update Report"

1

2

Authors

2.2--"Veronika Ginzburg (Russia)" to read as: "Veronika Ginzburg (Russian Federation)"

1

2

2.1

2.7

-

-

1

2

2.1

2.5

-

-

1

2

2.1

2.5

-

-

1

2

2.2.3

2.20

-

-

Sentence "Advice related to selecting emission factors focuses on understanding andgenerating measured data as well as addressing where to find and when to use default
factors." to amend as follows:"Advice related to selecting emission factors focuses on understanding of measured data as
well as where to find and when to use default factors.""In establishing routine, formalised, data collection use should be made of existingstatistical organisations and official data wherever possible" to amend as follows: "Inestablishing routine, formalised, data collection use should be made of existing statisticalorganisations and other official data wherever possible".
"Data reporting and archiving are covered in section 1.4.1..." to read as: "Data reporting
and archiving are covered in section 1.5 of the 2006 IPCC Guidelines..."To delete "then" before "...multi-year averaging…".

Volume

Chapter

SectionStart
line
number

Page

End
line
numberCorrection

1

2

2.2.4

2.26

-

-

"It is also good practice, as part of the measurement programme to include in the scope of amonitoring protocol how and other measurements are to be carried out, if the fuel/raw
materials are not dry or there are contaminants that could adversely affect the measurement
process, moisture." to amend as follows: "It is also good practice, as part of themeasurement programme to include in the scope of a monitoring protocol how
measurements are to be carried out, if the fuel/raw materials are not in dry weight or there
are contaminants that could adversely affect the measurement process, or moisture
content.""...if the fuel/raw materials used are not dry, a moisture analysis will be required." toamend as follows: "...if the fuel/raw materials used are not in dry weight, a moisture
analysis will be required.""...it is possible to calculate the emissions which haven’t been reported (e.g. the residual
value can be demonstrated by the following calculation:" to split into two sentences:"...it is possible to calculate the emissions which haven’t been reported. The residual value
can be demonstrated be the following equation:"

1

2

2.2.4

2.26

-

-

1

2

2.3.3.1

2.37

-

-

1

2

2.2

2.10

-

-

Abbreviation "NSO" should be introduced in brackets after National Statistical Offices.

1

2

2.2

2.10

-

-

"involving them in scientific or statistical workshops on the inventory inputs and outputs;"
to read as: "scientific or statistical workshops on the inventory inputs and outputs;"

1

2

2.2.1

2.15

-

-

"sectoral chapters 2-5" to read as: "chapters of Volumes 2-5".

1

2

2.2.4

2.22

-

-

In Table 2.1a "Industrial Processes" to read as "IPPU".

1

2

2.2.4

2.25

-

-

1

2

2.3.2.1

2.34

-

-

"The EFDB invites experts and researchers all over the world to populate the EFDB with
their data." to read as: "Experts and researchers all over the world are invited to populate
the EFDB with their data."
In Table 2.5 separate country-specific default emission factors by slash to read: "countryspecific/default emission factors"

1

2

2.3.3.1

2.37

-

-

"...which haven’t been reported (e.g. the residual value can be demonstrated by thefollowing:" to split into two sentences to read: "...which haven’t been reported. The
residual value can be demonstrated by the following:"

1

2

2.1

2.5

-

-

"...as well as for generating new data by surveys or measurement campaigns." to read as:"...as well as generating new data by surveys or measurement campaigns."

Volume

Chapter

SectionStart
line
number

Page

End
line
numberCorrection

1

2

2.1

2.7

-

-

"Advice related to selecting emission factors focuses on understanding and generating
measured data as well as addressing where to find and when to use default factors." to readas: "Advice related to selecting emission factors focuses on understanding of measured
data as well as where to find and when to use default factors."
In Column L of Table 3.2 brackets should be used both in numerator and denominator of
equation.

13

3.2.3.1

3.28

-

-

1

3

3.2

3.13

-

-

1

3

3.1.1a3.6--"Uncertainty consideration will need to be an integral part of the data collection effort,
including selection of data sources and choice of methods following the guidance in
Chapter 2 of Volume 1 of the 2006 IPCC Guidelines" to read as: "Uncertainty
consideration will need to be an integral part of the data collection effort, including
selection of data sources and choice of methods following the guidance in Chapter 2 ofVolume 1""Chapter 1.1" to read as: "Section 1.1".

1

4

4.1.2

4.6

116

116

"Section 4.5" to read as: "Section 4.4". "Section 4.6" to read as: "Section 4.5".

1

4

4.2

4.6

129

131

To remove sentence: "This will be facilitated by an approach which isaggregated/disaggregated based on methodology and in particular uncertainties".

1

4

4.2

4.6

121

121

"additional good practice" to read as "good practice".

1

4

4.2

4.7

183

185

"Table 4.1 provides suggested aggregation levels with guidance on subdivisions that could
be considered that relate to methods, data sources and assumptions for which estimation
methods are provided in the sectoral volumes." to read as: "Table 4.1 provides suggested
aggregation levels with subdivisions that relate to methods, data sources and assumptions
based on guidance in the sectoral volumes".

1

4

4.5

4.26

420

420

1
1

4
4

4.2
4.2

4.11
4.7

186
183

186
185

Table 4.10, column H: "Cumulative sum of level assessment" to read as "Cumulative sumof trend assessment".
In Table 4.1 (2E): "HCFs" to read as "HFCs".
"Table 4.1 provides suggested aggregation levels with guidance on subdivisions that could
be considered that relate to methods, data sources and assumptions for which estimation
methods are provided in the sectoral volumes" to amend as follows:"Table 4.1 provides suggested aggregation levels with subdivisions that relate to methods,
data sources and assumptions based on guidance in the sectoral volumes".

1

5

Authors

5.2

34

34

"Francesco Tubiello (Italy)" to read as: "Francesco Tubiello (USA and Italy)".

1

5

5.2.1

5.6

Start
line
number
129

1

5

5.2.2

5.7

189

189

"...emissions and removals from agricultural soils or forest ecosystem in low forest cover
countries" to read as: "emissions from and removals by agricultural soils or forest
ecosystem in low forest cover countries".

1

5

5.2.3

5.8

228

230

To remove sentence "This is particularly relevant to categories in which it is possible toimplement direct sampling and measurement programs but that these new data may not be
indicative of conditions in past years".

1

5

5.2.3

5.8

237

238

"In such cases, EFs should be applied from the year the changes took place (i.e. theycannot be applied prior to the year of change)" to amend as follows:"In such cases, new EFs should be applied from the year the changes took place (i.e. theycannot be applied prior to the year of change)".

1

55.3.3.3

5.1

432

432

1

6

Authors

6.2

23

25

1

6

6.10.2.5

6.18

699

699

In Box 5.2a "R2" to read as: "R2".
"Shamil Maksyutov (Japan)" to read as: "Shamil Maksyutov (Japan and RussianFederation)"; "Francesco Tubiello (USA)" to read as "Francesco Tubiello (USA and
Italy)".
To add the following footnote after "review":"http://www.nies.go.jp/soc/en/documents/guidebook/, last accessed 11/09/2018".

16

6.12.7

6.30

1080

1080

"parameterization" to read as: "parameterisation".

1

6

References

6.34

1270

1271

Reference "IG3IS. (2018) An Integrated Global Greenhouse Gas Information System(IG3IS) Science Implementation Plan. Geneva: WMO" to replace by:"DeCola P, Tarasova O, Brunner D, Maksyutov S, Manning A, Vogel F, Gurney K, et al.
(2018) An Integrated Global Greenhouse Gas Information System (IG 3 IS) Science
Implementation Plan . Geneva: WMO".

VolumeChapter

Section

Page

End
line
number129

Correction"In such cases, it is possible for the inventory compiler to apply the old EFs in one set of
the time series and the latest EFs for other parts of the time series." to read as:"In such cases, it is possible for the inventory compiler to apply the EFs before changes in
one set of the time series and the latest EFs for other parts of the time series."

1

6

References

6.35

Start
line
number1323

1

6

References

6.34

1269

1270

To add reference: "Hu H, Landgraf J, Detmers R, Borsdorff T, de Brugh J, Aben I, Butz A,
et al. (2018) Toward Global Mapping of Methane With TROPOMI: First Results andIntersatellite Comparison to GOSAT. Geophysical Research Letters 45: 3682-3689".

1

6References

6.33

1203

1204

1

6

6.10.2.1

6.13

449

450

To add reference: "Bergamaschi P, Corazza M, Karstens U, Athanassiadou M, Thompson
R, Pison I, Manning A, et al. (2015) Top-down estimates of European CH4 and N2Oemissions based on four different inverse models. Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics 15:
715-736".
To delete "to be consistent with the IG3IS Science Implementation Plan approved by the70th session of WMO Executive Council in June 2018".

16

6.10.2.3

6.15

581

581

"Favorable" to read as: "Favourable".

1

6

6.10.2.4

6.17

660

660

1

7

References

7.10

273

275

1

7

Annex

7.11

298

298

"strong emissions in surrounding oceans" to read as: "substantial emissions fromsurrounding oceans".
To relocate reference "EMEP/EEA 2016" from "References copied from the 2006 IPCC
Guidelines" to "References newly cited in the 2019 Refinement" and amend as follows:"EEA (2016) EMEP/EEA air pollutant emission inventory guidebook 2016 . Luxembourg:
Publications Office of the European Union. (https://www.eea.europa.eu/publications/emepeea-guidebook-2016)".
To insert the following Annex title: "Annex 7A.1 Practical examples for carbon emitted ingases other than CO2".

1

77.2.1.5

7.50

129

129

In Footnote 3 "Box 7.1" to read as: "Box 7.2".

1

8

8.2.1

8.5

121

121

"wetland supplement" to read as: "Wetlands Supplement ".

1

8

8.2.1

8.5

124

124

"on reporting these categories and the sub-categories contained in the supplement" to readas: "on reporting of emissions and removals for these categories and the sub-categories
contained in the Wetlands Supplement ".

VolumeChapter

Section

Page

End
line
number1325

Correction
Reference "Matsunaga, T. & Maksyutov, S. (2018) A Guidebook On The Use Of Satellite
Greenhouse Gases Observation Data For Verification Of Greenhouse Gases Emission
Inventories. Tokyo: Satellite Observation Center, National Institute for Environmental
Studies" to amend as:"Matsunaga T, Maksyutov S (2018) A Guidebook on the Use of Satellite Greenhouse
Gases Observation Data to Evaluate and Improve Greenhouse Gas Emission Inventories .
Japan: Satellite Observation Center, National Institute for Environmental Studies".

1

8

8.2.1

8.5

Start
line
number
117

1

8

8.3

8.8

224

224

"missions" to read as "emissions".

1

8

8.5

8.33

Table 8.2

Table 8.2

"Biomass Burning in Forest Lands" to read as: "Biomass Burning in Forest Land";"Biomass Burning in Croplands" to read as: "Biomass Burning in Cropland"; "Biomass
Burning in Grasslands" to read as: "Biomass Burning in Grassland"; "Biomass Burning in
All Other Land" to read as: Biomass Burning in All other lands".
"Emissions from biomass burning that include N2O and CH4 in forest lands" to read as:"Emissions from biomass burning that include N2O and CH4 in forest land"; "Emissions
from biomass burning that include N2O and CH4 in croplands" to read as: "Emissions frombiomass burning that include N2O and CH4 in cropland"; "Emissions from biomass burningthat include N2O and CH4 in grasslands" to read as: "Emissions from biomass burning that
include N2O and CH4 in grassland".
"Emissions from biomass burning that include N2O and CH4 in settlements, and all otherland" to read as: "Emissions from biomass burning that include N2O and CH4 insettlements, wetlands and all other land". "Harvest Wood Products" to read as: "Harvested
Wood Products".

18Note under
Table 8.2

8.4

254

254

Note "(1) Under the 2006 IPCC Guidelines , emissions from the use of carbonates should
be reported in the subcategories (industries) where they occur." to amend as follows: (1)Under the 2006 IPCC Guidelines and its 2019 Refinement , emissions from the use ofcarbonates should be reported in the subcategories (industries) where they occur".

18Annex 8A.2

T.62

Table 6A

Table 6A

"AGROCULTURE" to read as "AGRICULTURE".

1

8Annex 8A.2

T.68

Table 6C

Table 6C

"AGROCULTURE" to read as "AGRICULTURE".

VolumeChapter

Section

Page

End
line
number120

Correction"When reporting total national emissions and removals (Table A: Summary Table), forthose countries that choose to implement the approach described in Section 7.3.3, Volume
4, it is good practice to report the total MLP emissions and removals, as well as theindicative estimates of the anthropogenic component of total emissions." to read as:"When reporting total national emissions and removals, for those countries that choose to
implement the approach described in Section 7.3.3, Volume 4, it is good practice to report
the total MLP emissions and removals, as well as the indicative estimates of theanthropogenic component of total emissions."

1

8

Annex 8A.2

T.53

Start
line
numberTable 3.8

18Annex 8A.2

T.30

Table 2.2

Table 2.2

"2B9f" and "2B10" to read as "2B9g" and "2B11" respectively.

18Annex 8A.2

T.26

Table 2

Table 2

"specific PFC(s) produced" to read as: "specify PFC(s) produced".

18Annex 8A.2

T.30

Table 2.2

Table 2.2

"specific PFC(s) produced" to read as: "specify PFC(s) produced".

1

Annex 1

Mapping Tables A1.13

218

218

"inclusion of new F-gases under gases included in the 2019 Refinement" to read as: "new Fgases under gases included in the 2019 Refinement".

1

Annex 1

Mapping Tables A1.9

136

136

"e.g. overall and interpolation methods" to read as: "e.g. overlap and interpolation
methods".

1

Annex 1

Mapping Tables A1.12

193

195

"new guidance" to read as "updated guidence"; "guidance on carbon content" to read as"data on carbon content".

1

Annex 1

Mapping Tables A1.3

23

23

To delete "additional and".

1

Annex 1

Mapping Tables A1.10

156

157

Equation 5.1 added (NR: "No refinement").

1

Annex 1

Mapping Tables A1.10

158

159

Figures 5.1-5.3 added (NR: "No refinement").

1

Annex 1

Mapping Tables A1.15

233

233

Box 8.1 added (U: "Updated").

VolumeChapter

Section

Page

End
line
numberTable 3.8

Correction"From atmospheric deposition of N volatilized from managed soils from agricultural inputsof N (synthetic N fertilizers; organic N applied as fertilizer; urine and dung N deposited on
pasture, range and paddock by grazing animals (2); N in crop residues (3); and N
mineralization/immobilization associated with loss/gain of soil organic matter resulting
from change of land use or management of mineral soils" to read as:"From atmospheric deposition of N volatilized from managed soils from agricultural inputsof N (synthetic N fertilizers; organic N applied as fertilizer; urine and dung N deposited on
pasture, range and paddock by grazing animals (2)".

Volume 2
2

4

-

-

Table 4.2.4b(New)

Table 4.2.4b(New)Note d. insert "Norwegian" before "VOC Industrial Cooperation"

2

4

-

-

Table 4.2.4b(New)

Table 4.2.4b(New)Note e. insert "Norwegian" before "VOC Industrial Cooperation"

2

4

-

-

Start
line
number
References

2

Appendix 4A.3-

Section 4.3

2

4

-

-

Table 4.3.6

Table 4.3.6

Delete uncertainty value for N2O

2

Appendix 4a.2-

Page 4.151

Page 4.151"biomass fuel transformation" should be "solid to solid fuel transformation"

2

4

-

-

Table 4.2.4G(NEW)

Table 4.2.4G Correct documentation for CH4(NEW)
Edit footnote c: Emission factors for CH4 and CO2 developed from data reported to theAustralian National Greenhouse and Energy Reporting program (NGER) (AustralianGovernment Clean Energy Regulator 2017), as applied in Australian National Inventory(Australian Government 2018). The value for CH4 is the average of emissions for theyears 2014-2017, and the value for CO2 is the average of emissions for the years 201617.

2

4

-

-

Table 4.2.4H(new)Table 4.2.4H For footnote c, change text to "Emission factors from IPCC 2006, Table 4.2.4."
(new)

2

4

-

-

Table 4.2.4H(new)Table 4.2.4H Change 1st subcategory to "Without LDAR or with limited LDAR, or less than 50% of(new)centrifugal compressors have dry seals"

2

4

-

-

Table 4.2.4H(new)Table 4.2.4H Change 2nd subcategory to "Extensive LDAR, and around 50% or more of centrifugal(new)compressors have dry seals"

2

4

-

-

Table 4.2.4J(NEW)

Table 4.2.4J
(NEW)

2

4

-

-

Table
Table 4.2.4K For Natural Gas vehicles row, include a + in front of the high end of each uncertainty range
4.2.4K(NEW) (NEW)(e.g., -50% to +100%)

2

4

-

-

Table 4A.2.6(new)

Table 4A.2.6 Change 1st subcategory to "Without LDAR or with limited LDAR, or less than 50% of(new)centrifugal compressors have dry seals"

2

4

-

-

Table 4A.2.6(new)

Table 4A.2.6 Change 2nd subcategory to "Extensive LDAR, and around 50% or more of centrifugal(new)compressors have dry seals"

2

4

-

-

Page 4.14

Page 4.14

VolumeChapter

Section

Page

End
line
number
References

Correction
In reference list, "Norwegian" should be inserted before "VOC Industrial Cooperation""Fischer–Tropsch process" should be consistently used in section 4.3

For both rows of short term storage, include a + in front of the high end of each uncertainty
range (e.g., -50% to +100%)

The equation number should be corrected from 4.1.X to 4.1.0

Volume222Chapter

-

Start
line
numberPage A2.6

End
line
numberPage A2.6-

Page A2.6

Page A2.6-

Figure 4.3.2

Figure 4.3.2

SectionAnnex 2 (MappingtAnnexbl ) 2 (Mapping
4
-

Page

Correction
Under "Equation", the bullet point should be included - "Equation 4.1.0: Example equationfor estimating fugitive emissions from coal exploration was newly provided"
In the table for Equation, the following information should be inserted. Equation title:
Example equation for estimating fugitive emissions from coal exploration Type ofIn the figure, the fugitive dust emissions were removed, which are not relevant for thischapter on fugitive emissions of GHGs

Volume 333

3
3

3.3.2.2
3.3.2.2

3.7
3.7

203
204

203
205

"by type of production processes" should be "by type of production process""The five production processes types" should be "The five production process types"

33

3.3.2.2

3.8

211

212

3

3

3.10.2.2

3.23

764

765

3

3

3.10.2.2

3.26

925

925

3

4

4.2.2.4
4.2.2.5

4.33
4.35

855
909

855
909

"include all leves of abatement such" should be "include all levels of abatement such"
Comma was removed after from equipement leaks, colon was corrected to dot after asfollows:"
The reference “Schaffner et. al., 2018” was removed, referencing Annex 3A.1 which was
i t d dshouldd be
hi "ingots"ht ill b kdi fti"lingots"“to cross-checked the proper allocation” should be “to cross-check the proper allocation”

3
3

4
4

4.4.5.2
4.4.2.3

4.75
4.43

2333
1172

2333
1172

"tonn" should be "tonne"“does not occur, or occurs at level so low, it is considered negligible” should be “does notoccur, or occurs at levels so low, it is considered negligible”

3

4

4.4.2.3

4.44

1214

1214

3

4

4.4.5.2

4.7

2159

2162

3

4

References

4.97

3053

3053

3

4

4.4.1

4.41

1072

1072

“default emission factors by aluminum production” should be “default emission factors byaluminium production”“discussion under Section 4.4.6.3 Choice of Emission Factors” should be “discussion under
Section 4.4.5.3 Choice of Emission Factors” (two times)
Reference "Official Journal of European Union (2011a)" was corrected to "Official Journalof European Union (2011)", because the reference "Official Journal of European Union(2011b)" was removed. Consistent corrections were made to citations to lines 784-785, 793794, 799-800, 3053
In section 4.4.1 “A small proportion of alumina (<6% in 2015) is produced from the BayerSinter process or nepheline ore refining process using alternative technology” should be"(<3% in 2015)". It is consisntent with the correct figure in section 4.4.5 "In 2017, onlyaround 3% of alumina was produced globally via the Bayer-sintering process and around

3

4

4.4.1

4.41

Start
line
number1085

3

4

4.4.2.3

4.53

1550

1550

3

6

6.2.1.1

6.8

214

214

3

6

6.2.1.1

6.80

237

238

3

6

6.2.1.1

6.90

277

277

3

6

6.2.1.1

6.1

304

304

3

6

6.2.1.1

6.1

315

315

3

6

6.2.1.1

6.1

318

318

3
3
3

6
6
6

6.2.1.1
6.2.1.1
6.2.1.1

6.13
6.18
6.19

387
518
541

389
518
543

3

6

6.2.1.1

6.19

546

546

VolumeChapter

Section

Page

End
line
number1085

Correction"has risen from <30% in 2006 to >60% in 2017" should be "has risen from <30% of global
production in 2006 to >60% in 2017" .
"Lowest uncertainties will be obtained with the second and third options proposed below”
should be "Lowest uncertainties will be obtained with the second and third options
presented below”
Add footnote after "(CVD)" reading: "This chapter uses the term “thin-film deposition,”
which encompasses chemical vapour deposition as well as other thin film deposition
techniques."
Table 6.2. Correct title of second column to "Gaseous Fluorinated Compounds and N2O""The Tier 2 methods are expected to be more accurate than the Tier 1 method because they
rely on the actual consumption of individual gases and account for abatement" should be"The Tier 2 methods are expected to be more accurate than the Tier 1 method because they
rely on the actual consumption of individual gases and account for the use of emissions
control technology.""flowing to abated tools (see discussion…" should be "exhausted from abated tools which
are connected to emission control systems (see discussion…""(2) in the case of abatement calculations,…" should be "(2) in the case of abatement
emissions control calculations,…""...calculating effective destruction efficiencies (ai and ak) " should be "...calculating theimpacts of emissions control systems (Di and Dk)."
In the title of Table 6.3 "CASEOUS" should be "Gaseous""remote clean" with "remote plasma clean""Thus, when using the Tier 2a method, the consumption of C3F8, NF3, and N2O should beapportioned between their different uses, as applicable to each reporting site" should be"Thus, when using the Tier 2a method, consumption of C3F8 and NF3 should beapportioned between RPC and other processes, and consumption of N2O should beapportioned between TFD and “Other” N2O-using processes, as applicable to eachreporting site.""...the Tier 2a method include the destruction and removal efficiency…" should be "theTier 2a method include the destruction and removal efficiency…"

3

6

6.2.1.1

6.2

Start
line
number618

3

6

6.2.1.1

6.2

620

621

3

6

6.2.1.1

6.21

656

657

3

6

6.2.1.1

6.21

669

670

3
3

6
6

6.2.1.1
6.2.1.1

6.21
6.21

676
681

677
681

3
3
3

6
6
6

6.2.1.1
6.2.1.1
6.2.1.1

6.22
6.25
6.27

711
809
941

712
809
943

3

6

6.2.1.1

6.28

964

965

3

6

6.2.1.1

6.28

979

980

VolumeChapter

Section

Page

End
line
number618

Correction
Here and everywhere "When NF3 is used in remote clean process" should be "When NF3
is used in RPC processes." Similarly "NF3 used in remote clean process" should be "NF3
used in RPC processes." These phrases occur throughout the discussion of Equations 6.7
and 6.15, including in the definitions of the terms of the equations.
"Unless the emissions control equipment original equipment manufacturer (OEM)" shouldbe "Unless the emissions control system manufacturer (referred to below as the “original
equipment manufacturer” or “OEM”)"
Equation 6.8, definition ai: "Estimate of the fraction of gas i emitted from process tools
equipped with suitable emissions control technologies (site-specific fraction, as determinedin Equation 6.10)."should be "Estimate of the fraction of gas i emitted from process tools
equipped with suitable emissions control technologies (site-specific fraction, as
determined in Equation 6.10 or Equation 6.18, as applicable).
In the definition of ak, correct "as determined in Equation 6.10" with "as determined in
Equation 6.11 or Equation 6.19, as applicable.""fraction of gas" should be "fractions of gas""remote plasma clean" should be "RPC" and "CVD" should be "TFD". The same changes
should be in all the following text of the document (but not preceding unless noted
otherwise).
(e.g., c-C4F8 IST) should be (e.g., 711 c-C4F8 ITC)
"interlock process tools…" should be "interlocked process tools…"
Variable nup, "Ratio of emissions control systems connected to tools running process typep and certified not to form CF4 within emissions control systems to the total number ofemissions control systems running process type p in the facility (site-specific fraction)"should be "Ratio of emissions control systems connected to tools running process type p
and certified not to form CF4 within emissions control systems to the total number ofemissions control systems connected to tools running process type p in the facility (sitespecific fraction)."Corrected definition of ai,p: "Estimate of the fraction of by-product k emitted from process
tools running process type p and equipped with suitable emissions control technologies(site-specific fraction calculated using Equation 6.18)."
Corrected definition of ak,p:"Estimate of the fraction of by-product k emitted from process
tools running process type p and equipped with suitable emissions control technologies(site-specific fraction calculated using Equation 6.19)."

3

6

6.2.1.1

6.29

Start
line
number999

3

6

6.2.1.1

6.29

1027

1027

3
3

6
6

6.2.1.1
6.2.1.1

6.3
6.33

1053
1138

1053
1138

3

6

6.2.1.1

6.33

1178

1178

3

6

6.2.1.1

6.34

1202

1202

3
3
3
3
3
3
3

6
6
6
6
6
6
6

6.2.1.1
6.2.1.1
6.2.1.1
6.2.1.1
6.2.1.1
6.2.1.1
6.2.1.1

6.34
6.34
6.35
6.35
6.35
6.35
6.36

1207
1242
1244
1246
1269
1273
1291

1207
1242
1244
1246
1269
1273
1291

3
3

6
6

6.2.1.1
6.2.1.1

6.37
6.37

1331
1338

1331
1338

3

6

6.2.1.1

6.37

1348

1349

3
3

6
6

6.2.1.1
6.2.1.1

6.37
6.37

1350
1354

1351
1354

3

6

6.2.1.1

6.37

1359

1370

3

6

6.2.1.1

6.38

1377

1377

VolumeChapter

Section

Page

End
line
number
999

Correction
Correct Equation 6.18 in variable "na i,p" to be "n i,p,a" (moving "a"to a subscript).
Correct the variable below the equation in definitions
Correct Equation 6.19 (and surrounding text), by (1) replacing the variable name "m" with"n," and (2) changing the variables representing the numbers of abated tools ("na") to "n"with an "a" subscript at the end.
"using interlock process tools…" should be "using interlocked process tools…""...different than the default DRE values for abatement systems installed on a certain subset
of process tools…" should be "...different thanfrom the default DRE values forabatement emissions control systems installed on a certain subset of process tools""emissions control equipment, emission factors that have been measured by the reporting
facility" should be "emission factors or emissions control equipment DREs that have beenmeasured by the reporting facility"
After "in-situ analysis", insert a period. Delete "while" and capitalize "In" to create a new
sentence.
Delete "also".
Delete "consumption of each FC gas and N2O, as well as"
Correct "Measurements of" with "Measure"
Correct "Measurements of" with "Measure"
Replace "fluorinated greenhouse gas" with "FC gas"
Remove "Fluorinated" from the title of Equation 6.21.
In the title of Equation 6.22 and throughout the chapter (particularly the stack-testing
section), replace "fluorinated GHG" with "FC".
Equation 6.23, insert "for input gas".
In the definition of "Activityi,f" and everywhere, correct "stack testing period" with"sampling period".
Insert "FC" before "by-product k", and before "input gases i" in first sentence and before"input gas " in second sentence.
" an input gas i" should be " an FC input gas i"
Equation 6.24, "By-product specific emission factor" should be "FC by-product specificemission factor"
In all definitions of the terms of Equation 6.24, insert "FC" before any occurrence of "byproduct" or "input gas i". (In the definition of ESks, use "FC" to replace "fluorinatedGHG.)"
Insert "Input" before "Gas i" in the title of Equation 6.25.

3
3
3

6
6
6

6.2.1.1
6.2.1.1
6.2.1.1

6.38
6.38
6.38

Start
line
number
1392
1394
1398

3

6

6.2.1.1

6.38

1405

1406

3
3

6
6

6.2.1.1
6.2.1.1

6.38
6.39

1407
1425

1407
1425

3
3
3

6
6
6

6.2.1.1
6.2.1.2
6.2.2.1

6.39
6.39
6.44

1426
1450
1585

1426
1451
1585

3

6

6.2.2.1

6.45

1589

1606

3
3

6
6

6.2.2.1
6.2.2.1

6.5
6.54

1609
1677

1610
1678

3
3

6
6

6.3.1
6.3.1

6.58
6.58

1796
1826

1796
1826

3
3

6
6

6.4.1
6.4.2

6.63
6.64

1927
1949

1928
1950

3

6

6.4.2

6.65

1949

1950

VolumeChapter

Section

Page

End
line
number
1392
1394
1409

Correction
Insert "FC" between "each" and "by-product".
Insert "FC" in the title of Equation 6.26 before "by-product k"
In all definitions of the terms of Equation 6.26, insert "FC" before any occurrence of "byproduct" or "input gas i".
Correct the definition of ak,f for Equation 6.26 to read "Estimate of the fraction of FC byproduct gas k emitted from process tools equipped with suitable emissions control
technologies (site-specific fraction, as determined in Equation 6.110) for facility f."
Revise the definition of dk by inserting "FC by-product" before "gas k"
Correct "if suitable backup emissions control equipment or interlocking with the process
tool is implemented for each emissions control equipment" to "if suitable backup emissions
control equipment or interlocking with the process tool is implemented for each emissions
control system""interlock process tools…" should be "interlocked process tools…"
Insert "and" after "(including PFPMIE)," and delete comma.
Correct "by-product of cleaning processes of TFD chamber" to "by-product of chambercleaning processes"
In the footnotes to tables 6.7, 6.9, 6.10, and 6.11 that define "NA," correct "reporter" to"compiler". Do the same in footnote 1 to Figure 6.2 on page 6.32.
Table 6.14. Remove ellipses (…) in the column titles.
Figure 6.4. In the gray box to the top right, "Use default ABNF3,CF4&ABF2,CF4
equipment OEM Emission Rate, or electronics Manufacturer" should be "Use default
factors ABNF3,CF4&ABF2,CF4 in Eq. 6.7 and 6.15." In diamond [4], "Table 6.12" should be"Table 6.17.""abatement" should be "emissions control systems""probabilities of distribution functions (PDFs)" should be "probability distributionfunctions (PDFs)"
Delete fragment "Reporting and documentation" at the end of the paragraph.
Table 6.23, last row on page 64. Add "s" to "Number" and add "with" to obtain thefollowing: "Numbers of EWC and TFD tools equipped with suitable emissions control
technologies."
Table 6.23, 1st row on page 65. Add "s" to "number" in "Total number of EWC and TFD
tools ."

Volume3

Chapter
6

SectionReferences

Page
6.66

Start
line
number
1975

End
line
number2195

Correction
References added:
Czerniak, Mike, "Mechanisms for PFC Formation in CVD Applications," SESHA 2018
Symposium
Gray, Fraser, and Afroza Banu, "Influence of CH4-F2 mixing on CF4 by-productformation in the combustive abatement of F2," Research Disclosure September 2018, 986989.
Li, Shou-Nan, Jung-Nan Hsu, Hui-Ya Shih, Shu-Jen Lin and Jen-Liang Hong (2002).
"FTIR spectrometers measure scrubber abatement efficiencies." Solid State Technology.
45. 157-165.
Semiconductor Industry Association (2012c). Response to EPA’s Stack Test Question 1.
March 7, 2012, URL https://www.regulations.gov/document?D=EPA-HQ-OAR-2011-00280064
Semiconductor Industry Association (2012e) Questions for SIA on Abatement System
DRE, Uptime, and Related Requirements, March 6, 2012, URL
https://www.regulations.gov/document?D=EPA-HQ-OAR-2011-0028-0073
Semiconductor Industry Association (2012f) Report to EPA on Etch Factor Proposal for
Fab GHG Emissions Reporting, February 28, 2012, URL
https://www.regulations.gov/document?D=EPA-HQ-OAR-2011-0028-0074
Semiconductor Industry Association. Attachment A. Additional 2012 Etch Emissions
Characterization Data, URL https://www.regulations.gov/document?D=EPA-HQ-OAR2011-0028-0095
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, (2010) Draft Emission Factors for Refined
Semiconductor Manufacturing Process Categories, Office of Air and Radiation. [EPA-HQOAR-2011-0028-0067] URL https://www.regulations.gov/document?D=EPA-HQ-OAR2011-0028-0067
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, (2012c) Technical Support for Other TechnicalIssues Addressed in Revisions to Subpart I, Office of Air and Radiation, URL
https://www.regulations.gov/document?D=EPA-HQ-OAR-2011-0028-0084

36

References

6.67

Start
line
number1975

3

6

References

6.69

2149

VolumeChapter

Section

Page

End
line
number2195

2149

Correction
Delete the following references, which are not used in Chapter 6:Intel. (2016) Abating greenhouse gases at Intel Corporation. Technology and Operations
Management, URL https://rctom.hbs.org/submission/abating-greenhouse-gases-at-intelcorporation/
Intel. (2015) Intel Global Climate Change Policy Statement. URL
http://www.intel.com/content/dam/www/public/us/en/documents/corporateinformation/environment-climate-change-policy-harper.pdf
Office of Sustainability, City of Austin. (2014) Industrial Process Advisory Group. URL
https://austintexas.gov/sites/default/files/files/Sustainability/Climate/Industrial_TAG_Sept_
17_update.pdf
Ottinger, D., Averyt, M. & Harris, D. (2015) US consumption and supplies of sulphur
hexafluoride reported under the greenhouse gas reporting program.. Journal of Integrative
Environmental Sciences, 12(5): 16.
Semiconductor Industry Association. (2011) Petition for Reconsideration and Request for
Stay Pending Reconsideration of Subpart I of the Final Rule for Mandatory Reporting ofGreenhouse Gases, DOCKET NO. EPA-HQ-OAR-2009-0927, URL
https://www.regulations.gov/document?D=EPA-HQ-OAR-2011-0028-0070
Semiconductor Industry Association. (2015) Semiconductor industry concerns withinclusion of abatement requirement in product environmental standards. URL
https://www.semiconductors.org/clientuploads/directory/DocumentSIA/Environment/Abate
ment%20in%20product%20standards%20nov%202015.pdf
World Semiconductor Council. (2011) Joint statement of the 15th meeting of the World
Semiconductor Council. URL http://www.semiconductorcouncil.org/wpcontent/uploads/2016/07/WSC_2011_Joint_Statement.pdf
World Semiconductor Council. (2016) Joint statement of the 20th meeting of the World
Semiconductor Council. URL
https://www.semiconductors.org/clientuploads/Trade%20and%20IP/20th%20WSC%20Joi
nt%20Statement%20May%202016%20Seoul%20FINAL.pdf

Delete reference listed as "US Environmental Protection Agency. (2012a) Report to EPA
on Etch Factor Proposal for Fab GHG Emissions Reporting, February 28, 2012, URL
https://www.regulations.gov/document?D=EPA-HQ-OAR-2011-0028-0074"

3

7

7.1.2.1

7.12

Start
line
number
325

3
3
3
3
3

7
7
7
Annex 1
Annex 1

7.5.2.1
7.5.2.1
7.5.2.3
2B9
2B9

7.26
7.29
7.34
A1.3
A1.3

743
854
1074
21
24

743
854
1074
21
25

3

Annex 1

2C3

A1.14

96

97

3

Annex 1

2C3

A1.14

99

100

3

Annex 4

Annex 4

A4.2

11

11

3
3

Annex 5Annex 5

-

A5.19

210

211

VolumeChapter

Section

Page

End
line
number326

Correction
Footnote b) was added to table 7.3A (NEW) to address rounding issues (applies to row
with Commercial, Industrial and Transport Refrigeration): "Due to rounding, sums ofindividual items may not equal the totals".
“Additon” should be “Addition”“where” should be “were”“..will be probably…” should be “..will probably be..”“2B9 FLUORORCHEMICAL" should be “2B9 FLUOROCHEMICAL"“2B9 FLUORORCHEMICAL PRODUCTION (UPDATED)”, 2nd table, column labelled“B”, there is a leftover footnote “3)” that has been deleted, and the callout here should also
be deleted. The callout "3)" removed.
Worksheets – 2C3, 13 of 14, column D: “-0.0972* B + 0.890” should be “-0.0972* B +0.8905”.
Worksheets – 2C3, 14 of 14, column D: “-0.0981 * B2 + 0.381 * B + 0.341” should be “0.0981 * B2 + 0.381 * B + 0.3413”.
"and general glossary in Volume 1 of the 2006 IPCC Guidelines" should be "and generalglossary of the 2006 IPCC Guidelines".
Chapter titles were added
Equation titles of equations 6.21, 6.22, 6.23, 6.24, 6.25, 6.26 were corrected accordingly tocorrections implemented in the Chapter 6
Volume 4

4

1

-

-

85

85

Added capitalised 1.INTRODUCTION in line with the 2006 IPCC Guidelines style guide.

4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4

1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1

-

-

98
115
160
183
459
467
469
470
487

98
115
160
183
459
467
469
470
487

Added 2019 Refinement.
Added Revised in italics in line with style guideAbbreviated of inter-annual variability to read IAV in abbreviation
to read nitrous oxide (N2O) in abbreviation
to read Managed Land Proxy (MLP) in abbreviation
emissions and removals abbreviated to E/Rword have changed to read hasemissions and removals abbreviated to E/R
Methane changed to CH4

4

1

-

-

500

500

methane emision changed to read CH4 emissions

4

1

-

-

511

511

remove comma with conjunction after wood products

4
4

1
1

-

-

Start
line
number
98-99
Figure 1.4

4

1

-

-

Figure 1.4

4

1

-

-

4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4

2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2

-

-

Table 1.2
Updated
189
200
392
394
511
524
529
600
611
625
661
709
768
777
868
959

VolumeChapter

Section

Page

End
line
number
98-99

Correction
Added Revised in italics in line with style guideburning of biomass in forest lands/croplands/grasslands should be read as burning of
biomass of forest land/cropland/grassland
burning of biomass in other land should be read as "burning of biomass of all other lands"
Word Revised in Italics added in header and in table

189
200
392
394
511
528
529
600
611
625
661
711
768
777
868
959

bracket removed
legen completed,including adding unit
"REDD+" spelled out"REDD+" replaced with "Redd-plus"
space added after "DBH"";" and "." replaced with commas
Figure 2.2A to read Figure 2.2adiameter at breast height to read (DBH)
Box 2.2 C to read Box 2.0c.
Box 2.0c.National GHGI inventories to read NGHGIBox 2D (new) insert hyphen to read as ALOS-2
National GHGI inventories to read NGHGI
wording dead organic matter inserted before (DOM )"Figure 2.4" replaced with "Figure 2.3"
add hyphen on noncommercial to read non-commercial
change buildup to build-up

Volume4

Chapter2

Section
-

Page
-

Start
line
number
1428

End
line
number1429

Correction
The posted version should have this sentence above equation 2.25A.
The impact of biochar C amendments on mineral soils can also be estimated with a Tier 2
method for mineral soils using Equation 2.25A and adding this estimate to the result inEquation 2.25[1].
There was also a footnote in the sentence with the biochar definition as it applies to thisequation. See lines 1343 and 1344 in the final version that I sent you with the edits tobiochar in Chapter 2 during the week at the plenary in Kyoto. Hopefully this sentence canbe added since it provides the context for Equation 2.25A. Currently there is no sentence
to introduce the equation in the advance version of Chapter 2 posted on the TSU web site.
Foonote to read:Biochar is a solid carbonised product from thermochemical conversion
through pyrolysis (heating with limited air). The term biochar is used herein only to referto materials that have been produced under process conditions in which relatively easily
mineralisable organic materials are converted to more persistent forms by heating toabove 350°C with limited air through a gasification or pyrolysis process. This guidance
does not deal with pyrolytic organic materials that result from wild fires or open fires, andis only applicable for biochar added to mineral soils.

4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4

2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2

-

-

1578
1622
1669
1758
1807
1976
2035
2064
2251
2387
2518
2573
2615
2729
2753

1578
1623
1669
1758
1813
1976
2035
2064
2251
2387
2518
2900
3010
2867
2754

addeed the acronym (NIR)
Rothamsted Carbon Model (RothC) spelled out as first occurrence
Rothamsted Carbon Model deleted since it is not the first occurrence
National GHGI inventories to read NGHGINational GHGI inventories to read NGHGI
remove comma after carbon stock in "heterogeneity in the carbon stock, and"
Change analyze to analyse
Change analyze to analyse
National Inventory Report to be read NIR
wording "quality assurance/quality control" inserted
National GHGI inventories to read NGHGIinter-annual variability to read IAV
National GHGI inventories to read NGHGI
deleted Manged Land Proxy
National Inventory Report to be read NIRVolume

Chapter

Section

Page

4
4

2
2

-

-

4
4
4

2
2
2

-

-

4
4

2
3

-

4
4
4
4
4

3
3
3
3
4

4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4

Start
line
numberBox 2.0A
Box 2.2 LEnd
line
numberCorrection
Allocation of Box 2.0A at the end of 2.2.2
Net E/R plus non CO2 to read non-CO2 with hyphen-

Box 2.2E
Figure 2.1
Table 2.4 andTable 2.6
Table 2.6A
57

National GHGI inventories to read NGHGI
add unchanged to Figure 2.1
Table 2.4 , page 48-49 and Table 2.6 page 54 post harvest to read post-harvest

57

-

-

411
619
1296
1538
101

411
619
1296
1538
101

4
4
4
4
4
4
5
5
5
5

-

-

186
244
443
1441
Table 4.4
Table 4.12

186
244
443
1441

216
307
356

216
307
356

5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5

-

-

433
466
622
829
844
1203
1457
1700
1847

433
466
623
829
844
1203
1457
1700
1847

Table 2.6A step 5: -Change analyze to analyse
Move Box 3.1a (New) Examples of assigning ipcc land-use and land-use change
categories from tables TOC to a separate heading, Boxes are meant to give information
analyze changed to analyse
deleted second occurrence of "used"
Radarsat capitalised to RADARSAT
analyze changed to analyse
add comma after forest soils
remove comma with conjunction after peer-reviewed
add comma after thus
remove comma with conjunction after bracket of word chapter 2
deleted "copied"second Tropical dry to be read Tropical Mountain.
Page 4.53 Continential to read Continental
replace unitless with dimensionlessremove comma with conjunction after management system
add hyphen to read high-resolution
Table 5.4 first row under crop system Fallow- under description column, remove commawith conjunction after fallows
fertilisation spelled fertilization
to read ligno-cellulose with hyphen
corrected spelling to read dimensionless
Table 5.5 under description column, penultimate sentence to read includes
typo corrected leveling to read levelling
remove comma with conjunction after possible
corrected typo leveling to levelling
to read deep-water with hyphen
typo corrected understanding

4

5

-

-

Start
line
number
3719

4

5

-

-

Table 5.1

4
4

5
5

-

-

Table 5.5a
Table 5.7

4
4
4
4
4
4

6
6
6
7
7
7

-

-

92
175
520

92
175
520

535
680

535
697

Constant"a" to be read as two elements: "contant" and "a"; accrdingly the definition of
constant is provided
added the following footnote to hedgerows "Biomass storage rates and tree density forhedgerows are presented per kilometer of hedgerows, not per hectare of agricultural fieldor per hectare of hedgerow"soil C stock rdrafted as SOC
error during iteration of version control in refinement process, Replace Table 5.7 withoriginal disturbance matrix in 2006GL
Food and Agriculture Organization inserted
leveling corrected to levelling
remove comma with conjunction after 3
removing squared brackets from units in equations legend
page 19 measurement based - include hyphen to read measurement-based
page 23 EFCO2 age≤20 , j Change to CO 2

4
4

7
7

-

-

741
940

741
940

page 24 model based - include hyphen to read model-based
page 29 FCO2Anthrop . Change to CO 2

4

7

-

-

950

950

page 29 FCO2Anthrop . Change to CO 2

4

7

-

-

959

959

page 30 EFCO2 age≤20 , j Change to CO 2

4
4
4

7
8
8

-

-

1833
456
Table 8.1

1833
456

Reference corrected
doi referemce links removed
Table references notation corrected to correspond with number in source column of table

4

8

-

-

Table 8.2

4
4

9
10

-

-

Cover Page
740

742

4

10

-

-

879

886

4

10

-

-

1476

1476

VolumeChapter

Section

Page

End
line
number3720
Table 5.2

Correction

Table references notation corrected to correspond with number in source column of table
removal of capital R to read no refinement
Equation 10.10, equation text format used for the second equation, need to delete the firstone
Equation 10.18a (Updated) equation title for estimation of dry mater intake for Heifers toread as equation title format
the current text "countries are mixing Tier 1 and Tier 2 methods and volatile solids arecalculated through Equation 22A and are", should be "countries are mixing Tier 1 and Tier
2 methods and volatile solids are calculated through Equation 10.22A and are"

4

10

-

-

Start
line
number
1966

4

10

-

-

2071

2079

4

10

-

-

2080

2080

4

10

-

-

2105

2106

4

10

-

-

2126

2127

4
4
4
4
4

10
10
10
10
10

-

-

2199
2207
2204
2325
2334

2199
2207

4
4
4

10
10
10

-

-

2338
2344
2345

2343
2344
2345

4

10

-

-

2344

2348

VolumeChapter

Section

Page

End
line
number
1966

2328
2335

Correction
the current text "P = productivity class, high or low, to be considered if using the Tier 1B
approach" Should be read as "P = productivity class, high or low, to be considered if using
the Tier 1a approach"the currrent text "Nintake(T) = the annual N intake per head of animal of species/category
T , kg N animal-1 day-1" Should be "Nintake(T) = the daily N intake per head of animal of
species/category T , kg N animal-1 day-1"
In the legend to Equation 10.31A (new equation), quantity Nretention (T) is wrongly
defined as the "fraction of daily N intake ...". This should be replaced by "amount of daily
N intake by head of animal of species / category T…., kg N animal-1 day-1".
the current text "CP% = percent crude protein in dry matter for growth stage “i”", The text
should be updated as "CP% = percent crude protein in dry matter for growth stage “i”(Table 10A.1, Table 10A.2 and Table 10A.3 present default CP% values for all
regions)
the current text "Milk PR% = percent of protein in milk, calculated as [1.9 + 0.4 ● %Fat],
where %Fat is an input, assumed to be 4% (applicable to dairy cows only)." The following
revision should be implemented "Milk PR% = percent of protein in milk, calculated as [1.9
+ 0.4 ● %Fat], where %Fat is an input, assumed to be 4% (applicable to dairy cows only),or the values reported in Table 10A.1, Table 10A.2 and Table 10A.3 can be used.
replacing "excretion" with "retention"
replacing "excretion" with "retention"; and adding "and broilers"
DWG reads WG
Add the subfix (T,S)
redrafted as: "FRACTION OF MANAGED MANURE N LOST PRIOR TO
APPLICATION TO MANAGED SOILS FOR THE PRODUCTION OF FEED, FUEL OR
FOR CONSTRUCTION USES"
Add the subfix (T,S)
Add the subfix (S)the current text "FracLossMS = total fraction of managed manure nitrogen for livestockcategory T that is lost in the manure management system S, %", should be as "FracLossMS= total fraction of managed manure nitrogen for livestock category T that is lost in the
manure management system S"; %unit should be removed
redrafted as: "emission factor for direct N2O emissions from manure management system
S; in this case considered dimensionless (see Table 10.21)"

4

10

-

-

Start
line
number
2361

4

10

-

-

2346

2350

4

10

-

-

2366

2371

4

10

-

-

2392

2392

4

10

-

-

VolumeChapter

Section

Page

End
line
number
2361

Table 10.19,
footnote 4

4

10

-

-

4

10

-

-

Table 10.14,
footnote 7
Table 10.18

4

10

-

-

TOC

4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4

11
11
11
12
12
12
12
12
12
12
12

-

-

44
157
426
402
TOC
94
95
357
433
380
572

44
157
426
402
94
96
358
433
380
572

Correction
Equation 10.34B - is referred as Equation 10.34C in the text on page 10.105, should be
10.34B.
the current text FracGASMS _ FracLEACHSMS _ FracN2MS = amount of managed
manure nitrogen for livestock category T....", should be as "FracGASMS _FracLEACHSMS _ FracN2MS = fraction of managed manure nitrogen for livestockcategory T …"
consistently with the rpevious comment, "amount" to be replaced with "fraction".
Reference to table 10.23 moved to RN2(N2O)
Equation 10.34B - is referred as Equation 10.34C in the text on page 10.105, should be
10.34B.
the current text" 4 Values are taken from FAO GLEAM databases (FAO 2017). High andlow estimates are simplified extracts from the model database and may be prone torefinement in the final draft. Means of high and low productivity systems are simple means
and will be refined in the final order draft." . The second sentence should be removed. The
updated text should be as "Values are taken from FAO GLEAM databases (FAO 2017). " (page 10.93)
Should be read as "Uncertainty is ±30% consistent with the 2006 IPCC guidelines", thecurrent text "Uncertainty is ±30% consisten with the 2006 guidelines"
Cell "Pasture/Range/Paddock", should be read as "Pasture/Range/Paddock (PRP)"
further, add the following footnote: "3 Comparative definitions with the EMEP/EEA Air
Pollutant Emission Inventory 2016 Guidebook can be found in Annex Table 10A.10"
List of contents: Chapter 10: should be manure management in singular not plural,managements
retain the wording mineralise
retain the wording mineralisation
retain the wording mineralised
publically corrected to publicly
Remove subheadings pages after Annex 12.A
carbon dioxide written in full
Agriculture Forestry and Other Land Use written in full
FAO written in Full
6 -month and one year to read six-month and one-yearchange unplaned to unplannedFirst Order Decaty written as FOD

Volume

Chapter

Section

Page

Start
End
line
line
numbernumber949
949
Table 10A.11
Table 10A.17
Equation
11.7A

Correction
Estimate Service Life( now in acronym ESL
it is a new guidance so "NG" added
This table is a copy of table 10.17 and it is updated as table 10A.18
to be read "R" i.e. removed

4
4
4
4

12
Annex 1
Annex 1
Annex 2--5
5Annex 1
6

-

-

152
548

152
549

5
5
5
5
5
5
5

6
6
6
6
6
6
6

-

-

758
802
575
575
811
811
811

758
802
576
576
812
812
812

Change "methane correction factor" to MCF
Remove "Methane correction factor" and remove bracket from MCF
Change "Treated wastewater treatment system" to "Wastewater treatment system"
Change "Onsite sludge treatment system" to "Sludge treatment system"
Change "Treated wastewater treatment system" to "Wastewater treatment system"
Change "Onsite sludge treatment system" to "Sludge treatment system"
Change the Comments field for "composting" and "incineration and open burning" to thewording used in Table 6.3.

5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5

6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6

-

-

164
283
145
166
173
591
622
643
717
624
871

164
283
145
145
145
591
622
643
717
624
871

Change "meters" to "metres".
Change "meters" to "metres".
Change "centalized" to "centralised".
Change "centalized" to "centralised".
Change "centalized" to "centralised".
Change "urbanization" to "urbanisation".
Change "urbanization" to "urbanisation".
Change "urbanization" to "urbanisation".
Change "urbanization" to "urbanisation".
Change "utilization" to "utilisation".
Change World Health Organization (WHO) to WHO.

5

6

-

-

Multiple

Make consistent between Krem vs Krem vs KREM

5

6

-

-

Multiple

Make consistent between Smass and Smass

5

6

-

-

1306

1307

Volume 5
Replace "abiogenic" with "non-biogenic"
Remove "Default CH4 and N2O EFs related to discharge in non-aquatic environments areproposed".

Change font and font size to match rest of document.

5
5
5
5
5
5

6
6
6
6
6
6

-

-

Start
line
number
503
586
643
394
1037
1135

5

6

-

-

621

VolumeChapter

Section

Page

End
line
number
503
586
643
394
1037
1136

Change ", See" to ". See" in various equations.
Change ", See" to ". See" in various equations.
Change ", See" to ". See" in footnote 4.
Change "(See" to "(see".
Change "(See" to "(see".
Remove "(EF)"641

Moved to after Table 6.5

Correction