20193 9 
14 0016 00 L.

ILUOS
AA

T

L LRLRWPR

AD (AA
DKA,.

Ga.

AJ,MNRFor DiscussionPurposes Only)))
A G-

RQ

0!JGA%

D9:

K
L

12671(2017)# #DT 6
MRN+1 6<.  P&'
:K #=O #@18)C
E7BIHM43N;
MSN+2 6<. -K#P&':K #=
MTN+3 6<. #P&'
:K #="2U U0V14
 / . U65 / &': U15V64

5>9:*((30$)?FG,/2 "(715;  (45.0-;)*

40.0

%
;6>+CGC# ;6>9)* 

35.0S-)* 07R/@14R:
2A;:!14&30.0

26.6!(2015)(T)*

25.0;$)SLQOHI?CKMD:=5+;)* <B3/24615.A,

20.0

15.0

FPEJQN+ +' 98;CGC# >:)* 0%15.
A,

10.0

9.6!(2015)
5.00.0
1950

1955

1960

1965

1970

1975

1980

1985

1990

1995

2000

2005

2010

2015

2020

   

2025

2030

2035



2040

2045

2050

2055

2060

3      65 15#64   "1"12.1(1950)⇒1"2.3(2015)⇒1"1.3(2065)  " !  85 91(2065) 4%"P./&A ?)!

2@C:65./&P2015>#60OA./&5 3F4B ACA>D9=4F(./&;8A)12A/-$1:EA*'M( .0, 0P
HJIG?9=A+!B3F50KLN?9=A 5 67<=4715

('!!

)(2012)*462
*65 !
!7
1(15.0&)%%%
2025 "5 1 #$#6-

2&0(/-%3%.)-261.61&'*$/&,+#/
[]26.21

21.81

-11.21[]31.31
[68.71-60-]69.0168.51⇒!"70 "10 )/%*6;[(2013 )]./8!&

42.0:

3,9-25.2:[ ](3)/.72'7($3,9-"4#.54,5+1
"3,9-,.6-05*&' -7 $1 - ))#('"*24%!
- .-6,/+3"8&
#!

& 2008+2018"&

'%()

 30

10 *$9

&BX?+K:]$W#RTQVX 9&B?+X
75(2011*)@9"ZU10)6Y@9"]HPT[XX(b)10

3J<3J<B 30# 50# 30# 40(L)

43.1

13.2

33.7

9.7



39.2

12.9

30.3

0.0



>;A4E!ED/CN( 243()O&BY^a_`G8X,X'%F9X2I-WMS\D/=.

10),-.
(20126)

URL:http://www.city.otsu.lg.jp/shisei/zaisei/shisetsu/1395727759329.html

(&'"*)1#) (!'$ #%+3dgeS_^"P!^0@(E 13

http://www.pref.osaka.lg.jp/kikikanri/keihatsu/nannkaitorafu.html
Q5H Q5>(L.FH 3dgeS>.Filbjc
chlfW 3dgeS^D#]ZY[m=/ n X($24 8,29+ )UM5(P;4JS5^*G) I6^VM8^U:C2]`a1\<N^&)VA^%B?T^&)UV!9\^O VR'k K7-\^O128ko|F
iMB>v D A^vUqaxjN.(SvC$iKvC$ GH%h(1564=)vC$l`mn{vGH%hv? vC$i2 v Rh(65=)v
Lt~ }~]vd+!JIv v
05yrp,Qj?Yf[vd+7Zv4R<uz|O/:6^v
P]_-j]"vd+g&#bo|V3wv;'cECEwv"*vX\@ewv"*j)9)TsWE21
13

ec,-Y:?3adb"7.

g"7.

db"g+?34TB MCN^]I
5 H'8"AX)*Y6 H!2QY Y
E"8W2(X&P]>[Q^U#X P]>Y*M
Y6 WV
cf. 1YJ"KY
eb7gED$9Y/TCN^]I
5000 H'8"AX700)* HE"8W2(X&P]>Y*MY6 WV(5DY/)fb.g:?3 YT"7 Y+?3.YWL9g139<@%X; =68W(M_^RUOS\H0EUF$YJ.K JG1KZWL```I14BDC)**$%7&!
#:<> %A313.9&13*715(:".0?>+⇒ %A313-=7,45# 9 .'2=?>@/6;8,+15

16





(20)17

x{y1/X#'~`nGCa,
1888(5>21)%~# H81889(5>22)%~{#D$(9#]X#]Z#)
1898(5>31)%~{#D (;1922(<11)%~}#R1JLvYuw?) $(9]:@]"]X]Z]N-)1943(618)%~9X 3R⇒9#nAB]|#R1JLDn$,*_N-#\~,nS!j100trVp
1947(622)%~2Q>?3R(57)E+
`D #an? ⇒100tTkjdlb^
z WMt[e&Kn`D #aonI_X#\~X&mcfs
1947%~2Q>?0<(127)X#nqsn
&Kn =.O
dh1956(631)%~2Q>?0<⇒FjD #mPRis
1/ X#(1#]/ X#) 'nU]gkon#nI
D # 'n(;:@#]"#]X#]Z#]N-#n4|X#nPR(97)18

$#AZ:kG2#Q]MD^H\Z=
Y`b . XWZZ$52(LA Z@0Y6c?_F5(8'VPTjjj((75)(<e+RPRL)9Z"e2#PT$#A\Z4;e2#Q`JYXbF

5())))) (4)238 2.

098

5%AV3ZGZ/,HKaNZLG2#Q]MD^HVXSTINF)
0 16
( ()
()

5()
(55(G7*Z- HVPTZ
VEG>\ZC B
VPTZ
VZghife&!PT L1PRdOU[XIFH
19













()

()()20

kml/NdST=VWBAb* XU!c;\^&Y(2000")1!fd4Fo %KE
G!?. d4FoNchi:PH)gN!J@) (N!fdI3o
50jMZ^=o>L(92)ban
70d)(N!oR!(70)U!(71)U<-!(74)U90!(79)VN!=KE8(2012")
2010" QdWONX2$o,DAceO!j#5[_2015"dO!`d!c=jKE]i+6'C`d `d+721

pJ#:
(⇔he.P+L@=d)p8'|J/~s
1943,~h;Z<A+~+%}^V
1947,Ah~gO|Z7Fm{jf
1952,jf~0G
1975,jf~3I
pq&QO|#:
r{wz~ Vyv(2000,)76(h+~[ ct \D(7)B+{S~ 5Z7~EW
Y+u?x h+]M~EW~gUh} !(bKRh+]MR~4⇒ha7_9/23~U1~i

Ah-X(1991,4>)(2018,10>)1375
T(2018,Y]1)7460

`*25-X(2015,5>)Hlo)
{~ $kN
C(")-X 1n~g39n
(2018,10>)
289
T(2018,Y]1)
1246
22

KJ,A?LD=?B4>%5C?6M
92

99

9

9

1
6?

5

L(48I1)?.

7-

92

99

91

97

6

97-

597
3.4

77
7
58

58

800
9950-08

3.4

76
3.4

LEHFG@/54?4:48<"&? ;3C0[] -128,(*2URLhttp://www.chuukakushi.gr.jp/introduction/index.html#b$ !#+1#+;)C?879(2017623') 2 URL: http://www.stat.go.jp/data/s-sugata/naiyou.htm

0
6
3.4
7

6

7
9
3.4

8

23

('$# &"% ) !(2013)



;!E_,%X&k E69R)sb h+^g⇒ruy~QvEl'Eg 7Lwu¡
69R)sb  AEK?J]Url|O>(ez{$EF/twqm0lb O>(eo5p^ czxdXqmb _,N
TIS<[a9R )
k242014"-:0S<= _,Ml*b b`#H[/\j$f&}U. )(D1ZlY8 l3iPVi@i)nBW uoAy{9RpG CJU25~}8'aL ?MPaul A. Samuelson
1915-2009

KLA`hj4Myuz(“vote with one’s feet” model, or “Tiebout” model)
sot|a *da (Paul A. Samuelson)⇔E]b13_6R.Xja]I%Fl`5:XkcZk[U *bGej(Charles M. Tiebout)JH&g$bIaXj
p|{mqa>D^8ia<;l#W\8/`a0l@P\8ia,)`5W\NTJHfI]Sj[UN;]GN9p|{mqlXjV^]I&g$lSYhO^XjJ7"^W\13_xnvrwR2-WIsot|`
QN\f!B_=(C R+Xj^NOJCharles Mills Tiebout (1924–1968) 26

JMIPONKL'(Theory of “City Limits”)

0(<DF14B8;
Peterson, Paul E. (1981) City Limits(The University of Chicago Press).

Paul E. Peterson
Harvard University ="H.C,;:=0)1"9%C&$;:=0*1"9< 567F9.  +=!4<;G?;F@:.#; = H-3  >*
"<A7A7 <;E.)"<A7A7<;F923/27

  Welfare Magnet Effects

28  Welfare Magnet Effects

29



 Welfare Magnet Effects

30

Edb; (race to the bottom)
NH)<nIAVXU_b>, ⇒C)!o7?
)</@cLaUb0ln'^TkL-XV]+Si98( bnF%WkYmRSp

N*LJ4)<n$Z W_L.gB Sib:cVL
#@f @\ej=:@_V]0 VLGb4aD2WkM
URV]L*)b35` cLJ4IAL98j&]n6a;QRSbhR`1"aK[]VeR(⇒OEdb;P)M

31

NQMRTLSOAPWXVTL]. PWXVTL(gated community)&A)CCF,B57H"C⇒* (Suburbanization)]^'KB*B. ?
B EI<,K(:H23,C ?D -B G6P[UZ\Y8I>5G1,+?D!F%/1
A@C(6;J=>4>1:H
'B9>A$#608I>4H2

32

:<\0^G

f9K.{s kpdw3/_(p 'v([ g-C_(h}~3/_(?)kp)d [o=SPs ydWQAJLNBle &$> lpdX`&$>O @# {s6v~vmD
1Eefvovd]Mqvleb(_ba3/PoZv~lrtdV v~r_( d.VPl3/_(ktp!le @pbcv~lrdHT75lpqr*
~q~duztpUF
RYl4|osteI,i9Kn"qxo:<ns%8Aj(;2d2018+)

33

"0d&?,a bapfaog`0>j#3baod^G
tvsy|r{ua: q.hkWRaoH
I9+Jd6d^<P9 0dhq@*V]NnGmnK^dC(d$)kAb7qS]KoH⇒I9Y[d5Be9Y[ZS^KYKJ

FXplMbG"9+P:!wryq Wo PQRapfaog`G"9+q1=Wosz|rPRYiG '/O\-/a:!xy|~bao8q4i]KoH
FVOVG%bXpedtvsy|r{ua 0P2/O\DEb;#UpoT_banOcaKH

/a0_,/a0d}yq`dmLb_odO
34

0=:6;35DE20104?<.-E20155"'
0A!720 ;9;5% A,*8@
⇒ #201847(0)($+2015422

2010/
02 21BA>)
C &<201846(0)35

36

88 .2*1)(!
( 2017 )'$#&%"  4.-02+56,/973