MIRAI Archive   

No.2015-010

International Research Unit of Advanced Future Studies(IRU-AFS)   ˲ʍǱˉ˳¯˃ĮĹĤȞǼȂĹȜȬŽ ȜȬ¸ɲ˗dfp.Iìʳȑȝĩȁʒ1ĀȂ.ʬIƢ ƪ  2015 ŗ 8 Ƴ 7 Ƣ ˮ ƶ ˯ 13˱ 00−13˱ 40
Ħ Ž  `   R  ¯ ˃  202śˊ ʨ ƛ¦ˮƣȨȆĮĹ ìʳȂŏĹǎǅŏĹȣ ƚƋ˯ʍǱ ɥƶ Ëˁˮju`}kbRUfȜȬŽ ȾȜȬē˯The narrowness of AI and human adaptation
 f  R s 4 5 6 7

ɥƶThe overflow model of the evolution of consciousness+Ǽ1Ȃʌ+

A1

+*A+A+&)Ę'1íMɇJ3Ǽ1ȂʌļŻI+-ɓƠ-1*J2Ȣ1ȯĦG+'2Ǽ1Ȃʌ*2-

Ę'1í#+ɇJ#+)A"J2Ǽ1ȂʌMǊŻ+F

1*-!+ǼȂȑ-ĺĽ1ɽʭMļŻ#+)Aŵʎ1ĕˡǗIG-1*ŵʎ1ĕˡ+

12\WPˮQualia˯+ɞŒ+~SQˮFree will˯*1MIRAI Archive  No.2015-010

 J.')=Wy~+ƢGǞ˪ŪN+Ė&)ɶǵGȂʌMŋˌ))1ʃ2±ę2C@F

YouTube *overflowconsciousness++I1*ƨ

+.-H=#Zs *Ǉɀ)#$+±ŗdZ*ˌÍJ#Ĺ¸*ȢȐɯ#ipdà)=1*ɟĐIƠ2>)$Wy~+12LJLJąǒ@GJIųĥ2ŵʎ1ysRgˮbandwidth˯ˈM2I.ʝ))"J.ńIPlpdŵʎ1ʜǯ$+)2ʌƝMƱ

Ʊ

#HF

+)

+-1*J.'

#HƸM

=

fRs 9 ƨƢGǞN+Ė&)șə˯1ʃMF

+

)B

AIˮ°ŏ

+*ȮǷ*°ŏșə1ǿ+°ˍ1ʼūˮThe narrowness of AI
and human adaptation˯+$

kRr*ʃ

)ƹǴNȯ%#1ȿƭG˞ģƷƺìŻ+6L

+*1p%3N

1-+Ů&)ŵʎ1ĕˡ+Ȣ1ʟĐ1¢ȉ*2-=#

8NɟĐMA#J)# f  R s 10
 °ŏșə*2YXfz~ˮGarry Kimovich
Kasparov˯+mTf1m}WqQˮmTfņȅ1fz`}k˯.ʓ
)=

=#

 f  R s 11
 IBM 1rjˮWATSON˯eTzqQ˭ˮJeopardy!˯+=J)˗Ĺ\Rg.ó&)#H)=rj2÷ȏųĥ1âƽ-,.A¾L=2

I°ŏșə1ʃMF+Ů=MIRAI Archive  No.2015-010

 f  R s 12 RXoRˮRay Kurzweil˯d[pQˮSingularity˯+

+M

&)

=d

[pQ+2LJLJ1șŰ.°ŏșəʮ')ʝ)==°ŏșə.ˎI))ǽȌǵMʝ#

'

)Ʊ

)

+

+-1*Ȣ2

ȡ1Čé

+

ňʉMƱ

+1¢ȉ,-I1.

="J2+A"1F-ªǭ=ŻHȯ&)= f  R s 13 Ȣ1ŉŗƪ´1{2PrPRdkRˮAlbert Einstein˯-1*;2R[f. 2 ŗˍ

#1*R[f*2|neRq

QWnrˮVillage Idiot˯+ƹ.

I˧˫ɔ

F`qQ.à)I1*fRs1ÜȖ2
pQzRjGĄ&#1*LJLJ2
ƹ
.

$1 IQ

I˧˫ɔ+PRdkR+1

1ő2Į-A1$+Ů&)= f  R s 14 15 16%->. IQ +2mgUssf}PˮCharles Edward Spearman˯+° 1906 ŗ1

ʌƝ* g ĚķˮSpearman’s g factor˯MƎǄ=#
ġ˟1F-,1

K

K-kf\

"1kf\.×ʱ1 g Ěķ+
˟1F

I1*A1

LDI IQ .Ȕš)&)JI"J.Ȕ

šIɝǤò-,AƲʫ1ȜȬ*L&))ȂMIé˟ɦ1ęʠ g Ěķ+1ȔˎI+3=Ⱥý.

+ɝ1jfȶ

+L&)H=

MIRAI Archive  No.2015-010

 f  R s 17Ňƺ.°ŏșəd[pQMʪ)#+3șəƇƜ 4,000 ++.-I+°ˍ1

F-$1șə1ő-N)ˎ

Ã--I;21ɶǵĮ¬$+Ů&)I1*'=H°ˍ1Ų+$1˟1F+12"Gd[pQM

ʪ#°ŏșəG>I+=&#ŵĐ 1r\1-*2

'

M=ǞN+AȜȬ#
2Wjf+ȜȬM#GF

-+Ů&)

1*2-

+

ƎǄ

IA¯˃ĮĹ1Ơ*A…J=z\HA!N!NWn^* f  R s 18

 IQ 2ƫʱYSdP1âœˮGaussian distribution˯MéƎ.ľɏJ)
"J+=&#ʺ&#ǏÒ.
ľˈȑ.ɼǭI1+&#+1RpeTfˮintelligence˯M,Ƹʚȑ-ĕˡIJ2=$ľɏFJ)'=H#+3ċĕˡM 1,000 Å+ 10,000 Åʲ*IFŰ1e+)2,

ʀÁJ3F1șŰ1e-N,
2#

#+-

I1*

*AF

1F

-

.-&#șə2șI.°ˍ1$1âœ1-*IQ  60 + 180 1ő+

B-



1



 ʚȑ.e)=&#șŰ.'ˮExtrapolation˯*I1+

+.ń)

+d[pQ1ʀÁ**1 IQ 1e*2-),"JMU\fr=GeMȅŵ)-1*-1*g Ěķ1FșŰ1eM

mPeTlˮResearch Agenda˯1 *
4

d

-ÊőÇȑ-ŵĐ=GˌȐIũɳIJb

MIRAI Archive  No.2015-010

 f  R s 19
 Pm]ˮAlan Turing˯2Child
Machine+*2ǉŬMà=#kb

1*Ʋä.ķ,A1ǾŸMȅŵ))"GĹɑIĹɑI+*

K-+MĹ71*K

#%1°ŏșəà)I+LJLJ2șŰ1`fpQm
dˮconstitution˯Mn\n\f+)
ƀ

-

1*

K

K+Ĝ&#ĕˡà)I1* f  R s 20=ǥɪH1qQu]ˮDeep Learning˯+dfpȀŦI+

+*ĤƸȑ.°ˍ2"1ʹȦM`r*-

+.-I1* f  R s 21 12ǉŬɞ»M°ŏșə

+MɘƬ.#+3ffU

n\fˮSpaceX˯pfkgˮ Tesla
Motors˯RzˮPayPal˯Mȯ%#R
f\2°ŏșə24E&+#GǁØėFHAÿ˓AJ-

+ɻ&)JĮ-r}n\.-&)

=

)

5

+

MIRAI Archive  No.2015-010

 f  R s 22 23

 -!°ŏșəǁØėFHAÿ˓-1AJ-++#+3~ORtd^nr*2 50%G]Īʕ*ƼŊʑN+°ŏșə1ȜȬM)

#G

I°.ɕ

ƻ¯ĮĹ*

= 1nsˮtwȤ˯*ĄŞ*IG

1*


 +

+2°ˍ1qRrlrs)A=&#įáſ%*-)

1+.F&)~ORtd^nr]Īʕ*īòIF&)=
2-

1*1F

+źŬJ)-.-ĻľŰ°ŏșə1ūȅ.F&)A#GJI1*

I f  R s 24 25

 1900 ŗG 1991 ŗ1ǮŌż«1+.DARTˮDynamic Analysis and Replanning Tool˯
+

A1

GN-.

H=#'2;2
K

K-+Mʋ9)Ÿ*=$àǺȠ2ǟ=&)-=ɤʆ*°ŏșə1ƸMƱ

I1*

= 7 ëG

1*…1 DART +

)

)$

ĀȩɂL&)

IǾ

12AI MA+.

efpQ\fˮLogistics˯MƲʼôIo-1*

+K-1*

ǮŌż«1+. DART 2°ŏșə1ūȅ.F&)PX1ʤ¬Ƃɫ.~OqQ]MàɃɌ1ʹā 30 ŗˍ1 AI ȜȬ1Ʉʖˮbudget˯MʝIȸȽñƾ
6

MIRAI Archive  No.2015-010&#+

1*J2

1990 ŗ1ʃ*G0
 f  R s 26 27
 ƢƸ*2=$ǻǑȑ-Ǿǡ
.

I1*PX*

2°ŏșə1ʤ¬Ƃɫ81ū
ȅȖê.ʏʌJ)=fRs1A DART *"
1+.źŬJI1*.sP~YufkCR\-,*¾LJ))J$1frR\
ˮStrike˯J)H¼°Aǘ

I1*

=2=$

PX1ʤ¬Ĥġ*e
RfpQn\1F-A1.

FIʻ˔ƒ½*Ʋɂȑ-fr
R\1åƞM)I1*

J2 24 ƪˍW
dM)k_nrMƔƑI+-&#+.ʷ
JƣJ°ŏșəMūȅ)
°1ʅʎF5ƔƑ1ǟƞM
IF.-I12ȓ.>)˯1°$&#GɈń."

I1*;PXğˏɊȕƸřɠˮka

=F f  R s 28 "-&#+.High Frequency

Trading 1¿*ƈ#F

-

ĻľŰ

ʤ¬Ƃɫ.AA%=JI1*2+=źŬJ)



I1*"1F-+MɘƬ.un\frˮNick
Bostrom˯2ĸĠ1f\ˮExistential
Risks˯+

+M

&)

I
7

MIRAI Archive  No.2015-010

 °ŏșə1A#Gÿ˓.'

)R[f1^neĮĹ+W\f~VsĮĹ"JGPX1 MIRIˮMachine Intelligence Research Institute˯+'1ȜȬɃɌȯ%&)

I1*Ȣ2ƢƸ*AɈń."=°ŏșəɞ»MȜȬI+
A#GĻÕÄ˕1źŬfr+

K

A12'I9$+Ů&)FHA°ŏșə1Ƞ¸ȑRz\rC"J
K-+MȜȬIɃɌƢƸ*Aũɳ*1°2W\f~VsĮĹ*"JMȜȬ)I°*

 f  R s 29
 $GbmPeTl 2 +)2AI
M

.`rI1+ĕˡ

H=fRs1ȈÐ2U\fZtˮEx
Machina˯+±ŗR[f*ÖˌJ#ƦȈ*Ȣ2ˣɪǎ1-*>#1*­'1ĕˡM1ƦȈ2ƀ&)='m]pfr*1ıŰ2 AI -1*1°MRk|)1°°ˍ+öæ*-1*A,MåƞI˚ŗƺI1*"J'1ƦȈ1p

'2J2vky-1*AI 1ıŰ˚ŗ.űM)"1űŶŷųMçȅ)ȜȬơɾGƄàI1*ƲŤ2˚ŗˋʩ@GJ)
à)J+-&)=&)AI 1ıŰƵMȗ)ɬMǓ*frd=*ɻ&)=&#+

4,)

I+K*ɂLI1ʃ*0

 °ŏșə1Ņʩ@ĕˡ+12frG1ȜȬ`upQ*ʏʌJ)

I1*'=H°ŏșəM

.Ņʩ@I+*I1+J2Į-ȜȬp1'$+Ů&)= f  R s 30
 PRcn\Pd~ˮIsaac Asimov˯nrŏĹĀèMà=#J2ǙʧȑșGJ)-1Āè2
1F)Aİƙ)=2Ʊ

)

+¬Ŀ-1*.ô)¿*Pd~

I1*Pd~1Țɋ1-

*1Āè*nr2ò1*
ȁĿ.à¸+¿Ĭ-,Ȅ)18ĕˡ*MIRAI Archive  No.2015-010

Āè*2
)

=

-

¬¿ȄI1+Mȟ#@.Pd~1Āè2à

I1*

 f  R s 31 32 33 34
 AI 1`r2#8N˘

)=$ƢƸʆ.2ɿJ)2fr1*Superintelligence+Ƹ.à)Iâˢ+)2W\ˮOracle˯euˮGenie˯j
ˮSovereign˯+
\+

A1

IW

12°ˍ-.ĕMȐ

I+"J.ńIȴMà)JI
eu2°ˍ-.kf\Mƃ
I+"JMĿɪ)JIj+
12ļÕ.°ŏșə.ÕǍMĴ¶I+

+*

#%*

W\Geu")j8+°ŏșəʵô#+."JM,`rI1+ĕˡ

H=fr2ĔĹɔ-1*ţ1Superintelligence

+

Ƹ1-

*"1`rĕˡ.'.p\uX-ʏʌɪ-LJ))ʄɁ=AɟĐ=9IƠ2ɷ

#$J3+ŮMIRAI Archive  No.2015-010

 f  R s 35
 "JµĬ. AI 1ÈȂĹˮethics˯+ˇȜȬâIJ=*1ʃ2AI 1`rĕ+Googleˡ*ÈȂ+2,

++ɞòʸʥʣMȜȬ))J2ˍʺ

-

ƢƸ.AÔ&)I"1+.ÈȂĕˡŢ.
H=LHC¿+)2¬Ɩʜ&#+.ʊ1ʔ¶-1+

+

H=

ɞòʣX-1j~rSTP1¸Ƞ-1"J+A".§&)

I°

-1

 f  R s 36

 "J$*2-)'2rˮTrolley˯ĕˡ+A1

I1*J

2R^bqˮMichael J. Sandel˯Justice1ʍɏ1Ȳ 1 ę@*AŞȅ)
I1*

,I¬ƖMˀI#@.æ1¬ƖMʜF-Ǿǡʜ&#+.

Ĥǰ*-.MÑÓ9#+3ɞòʸʥʣ ʛ&)Aˣ5à)#ķ,AMƘ#@.ůZM#GŤKGƺ#­ʨʣ

1yR\ɮȮ)­ʨʣ.§&)ʨʣŤKGƺ)MI9,I+ML&)+I+.ķ,#°1:ĮM)Ǖ/+I­-Gķ,A1đMƘ#@.ůZ

ÈȂĕˡɞòʸʥʣ.2ǳĠȑ.

H=JMȜ

ȬI+ˆɳ$+ɓGJ=

10

MIRAI Archive  No.2015-010

 f  R s 37 1âˇ1ˆɳ-ǉŬ2Coherent
Extrapolated Volition++*Ucs`~fZˮEliezer Yudkowsky˯+°ƎǄ)

2MIRI .

=s`~fZ

I~f1ȜȬɔ-

1*AK°*#+3

ǞNţı.

I#@.lR

s1ƇʨMǐ"J*­'1ȷI"J*ǞNŐMĄJ+ AI .ǣƝ#+=+KAI 2ĉ.lRs1ƇʨÔ&)I+Mș&)

ˮinstruction˯2ŐÌMĄJ+I+="I+ǞN1Ƈȟ

+-1*:N+1ǞN1ŵĞ2

+*$G AI 2:N+

lRs1ƇʨÔ&)IȷMĄJ+2ĉMĄI:

3ǞNlRs1ƇʨMţı.i

F

G.

rI+*ŁŝōĩIAJ=°2ţı.

NI+ AI 2"=*ɓ)1

I#@.lRs1ƇʨMĄH#

2ĄG

-

:

ĉ1:

.Ƈʨ

F

1$+

&)A

+ɻ&)

I,:N++K=*åƞIAJ=)ŐÌMĄI++A

N"1+.

I1*

°ˢ1`\pQ-frPsRpfrˮthe Best and the Brightest˯ "1ĆƮM˖@#ŵĞˮVolition˯ Coherent Extrapolated Volition +ǉŬ*#+

3ĻÅN˖ěȑɞɭǍMĿȁIȧ1q1AF+)+*ƢƸ1˖ěȑĻÕÄ˕1#@.ũɳ$+:N+I,"J2
en\*)

+-ǉŬMĿɱI+*~s- AI MĿȁF* f  R s 38 ɝȣĹ1ɶǵG+J2 TEDxTokyo *ÓƢʃ#1*ÚǧN1ʍǱ1+.Ȣ
2ɞˋȎf\r.

I1*2-

&)

ʃM=#ɰŎN2'2ɞˋȎ.ʫ
ɞŒʅʎ

*

."JfrPsRpfr19)1qkM˖@#+1WpQˮoptimum˯-mRf-1,
1F

IB-

I+Ʃ1+.ɕ

+#1*

upQ}XˮNeurotypical˯-°2,
11+2æĕˡ*"+A11ǉŬMIRAI Archive  No.2015-010%G++ʌȂɣž*ŷųŦŵ-1*P|Pfˮambiguous˯-+Ŧŵ-1*bOȎÆɎ1°2ʌȂȑ-+Ĳ* f  R s 39 f  R s 40 '2°ŏșə2ɝ1ÏG+fzbO1F

-+K

I1

*°ŏșə1ǿ2°ˍ1upQ}X-Ud1zf+2ʺ
ǈ@)1ƠčfzbOȑ-Ud1-*d[p
QMʪF

+)

IJ°ŏșə1ǟľȑ-ǿ* MIT qQP1Ƞˊ1·ɩȫN2 I+.}cM 10 °âǣƝ)"JMÝß) 3 ƢˍżȊ_MRɉ)72 ƪˍŃ.R)ó&#G
1*"1$. 10 °â1}cM+,ïǹ)#9)

N2'1+. 72 ƪˍ˖¤I+ƪˍ+12`}k1ƪˍ*#G

bOȑ-əí+L@)Ț

*·ɩȫ

I72

`}k+12

'1ĕˡ. 1,000 ƪˍ+ 10,000 ƪˍMʴɉ)˖¤*I1*"J*˦ƝćAɻL-³1+ACG- f  R s 41 ++2AI +12°ˍȑ-ɴƠMI+fzbO+. AI 1ǿAúʞŰAJ)+*"H=J2ɒɿ=eTRgynr+°1°ŏșə °ˢƲŲ.)ƲŤ1ȐƤˮOur Final
Invention˯ +Ƹ1-*AI 1zjtpQ.ǣȓ)|emRsdtW
ˮThe busy child scenario˯+%E=+-.M)

Iň

=#

'A

I

ķ,A1F
12

$+

+*AI Mzj

MIRAI Archive  No.2015-010

tpQ+)>I+#8NǿzjtpQA&)-

 f  R s 42 43

 #+3

=j~ry\ĪHà)I1nzˮPepper˯-,A"

1*'1+.˖¤)bOȑ-əíMà12F
pQ+

ɶǵGĕˡ-

1*zjtI f  R s 44

zjtpQ2ŨȂĹ*ǣȓJ))fRs1A1|n]~OR*Űǃ1 5 ɳȿ+)ˌƕŰˮOpenness˯ʇĿŰˮConscientiousness˯ĬčŰˮExtraversion˯ûʋŰˮAgreeableness˯ȡɄȎÎčˮNeuroticism˯

H=J2ïǫ">=ŨȂĹɔ#%2ˊŗ1žˍM)1 5 ɳȿ¥ɳ-ɳȿ$+13.
MIRAI Archive  No.2015-010

+Mȹ

)

Ŀȁ)

=1F
I.--ɶǵG AI 2L@)ǿ

+zjtpQ1eM

I1*

 f  R s 45
 B

°ǃ2,

-A12

*I1++ƴí

Group socialization theory*J2eqQfnmxfˮJudith Rich Harris˯° 1995 ŗ.Ʊ

+)=1°2~f1ȜȬɔ-1*J*PXŨȂĹ¸ʘMAG&)IŢ˜2 0%+=ɸŰǃ.¡ɮƑȑ-Ʌʌ*ʃˡ.-&#fpQ}XˮSteven Arthur Pinker˯A1ȜȬMUsWfˮendorse˯
)

I1*

 f  R s 46 47ķ,AȠ¸ȑ.

KK-°.ĝ=J)"1-*K

K-Ţ˜Mą)Ɲɛ1-*ɞâ1zjtpQMȹI+

q*$Gʾ¹ķ.FIy  P |  p Q ˮ variability˯ 2  $1+șGJ)#"1-*ŁŝȃĨ1Ţ˜2i.ʫ
+xf1ȜȬ*L&)

50% G
F

=


14

I1*

-yP|pQʉƤ*-+MIRAI Archive  No.2015-010

 f  R s 48
 1F

-#%*ʑ-Ƞ¸Ű1-*ɗ=J)

#zjtpQ1ʑ.ń)AI 2'1ǿĕˡ˞ģ.˖¤I+*úʞI
 f  R s 49 bmPeTl 4 *RpeT
f2ưH-H.A IQ pfr>#-#%*ǭIˮquantify˯+*I+

+

.-&)

=zjtpQ1e

2A1ƯƧ-1*Ó:,1|n]~ORA¥ɹʀÁ-,*C&)-)°ŏȑ-UeTr.2--ĬƊ*-1*
-="GȜȬ-)212zjtpQ1e2,1F+$+Ů.ľˈȑ.ľɏ*I1+



1*

 #+3|emRs+-&)A"J2þʒʀÁ.-),G1°2zjtpQǿqf.Ĥ()%N+

IF

1ˌȐ.ʗI+Ů=

f\r..)"

-

+

ɳȿ
+MU|

I+

UeTr ÓƢTEDxTokyo 1+.j~ry\1UeuP])ţG2Udˮemotion˯M AI .Rr)

I1*ǶȂ-I+\)

N$F"1\2$&)Ud1q-N)+,qkMɻN)A12qkAf.'

1*FŏĹɔɻUdMĿɱ#-+K*F0
&>#)2ÛŕˎƜ1Ŀɪ+-ŷ*FRpeT

+*m]dȑ-uybpQˮuniversality˯Mľɏ*I1*Ud&)FH=

q"A"ANG $G"AI *2=$Ud1Ŀɱ*)mTfCŇǆM
ʱHG
I+

N$GŏĹɔ2=Ƈ AI I+-\2F1žMʀÁˎƜ*ƲʼôJ3F+

+.A-I1*

1*FJ2 100 ŷųMĿȁ)

I AI Cnr\2=&#thf*"A"AʅșȣĹCɝȣĹ*ŷųCz
15

MIRAI Archive  No.2015-010

jtpQFľɏJ)
mMIũɳ-

1*"Mľɏ-)2

-

1*b

I

 f  R s 50
 IQ p f r - , 2  > -  N 1 Ʋ Į 1 ə í M ǭ & )I+

+-1*'=H

IQ pfrMI+.ǞN-N2IQ
pfrM) 200 Mʝ)ǭľ
G

*J2

Ĉə+LJ#=ʼš.'&#ʃ*ˮȱ˯IQ pfrM)I 10 âˍ29)1

+MƕHƃ)"J.˖¤)n\f.
+MéƎ+)Ĺǀ1ÓȄ-,2 IQ

I+

pfrMI1*$GZdˮmaximam˯
-z~Vf-1* zjtpQ+

12pQ}Xˮtypical˯-z~Vf*ǞN

& IQ ˪)AY~sĭ#+˅M˥>ʹ#+*ȜȬɔ+)1z~VfZd*2-)pQ}X*

IĈəŰ

I1*

'=HǞN+)2ÙĢȑ-z~Vf*. IQ pfr+zjt
pQ1ǂƸȑ-ʺ&)n\f.'1+.˖¤) IQ pfrMǭI+ɓƠ+pQ}X-z~VfM@zjtpQ+
%

+

+*

 f  R s 51
 "+KG TIEˮTypical Intellectual

Engagement˯+F-+Aà))A+A+ǳĠȑ.əí˪)A&

."1°qRRdfˮdaily basis˯*U_erˮengagement˯I+F-+MʀÁI








16

ɓƠ!N!NMIRAI Archive  No.2015-010

 f  R s 52 53

 Zdz~Vf2`}k.2č
.I+*A

G&+˖¤)

&<

*°ˍ+

I1*1$M,)=`}k2:I1*˦A-ƝćAɻL-

12ƢŖȄǤ1-*pQ}X-z~VfM'-ˆɳ-Rr.-I++* f  R s 54
 G.ˊ=ȓ*>)>=íMA&#°=HŵĐ-

sc-,

I1*GíMA&)

I+

+2

=&#ŵĐ-*F0"J+ċF

.ɼȵʲ

+

1A`}k.

JGŵĐ-*F0"1F-

3F#%*$N$N+LJLJ1șŰ1˂â,
N,N+ AI 1:.rf~OJ)ɽŹ-,A"*F0

 "1+.°ˍ2"Gʙ+…#+3¯ĮȄ2ʙhndˮobsession˯*Ȅ)#°#%BÔ&)É*Ⱥý.

+ǠĊħ1ǌʁ*¼º$+ÊőÇ*







17

+

'$++MW
+0¯Į.

MIRAI Archive  No.2015-010

 f  R s 55 56

 "1ʙ+Whnd2$N$N+ŵĐ--I$KƻĎ+ƻĮ1Ôʁĕˡ.č+ªŴJI1*°ŏșəMƟ®ȼķN'&)$G"JµĬ1ɳȿM°ˍà1Į¬*AI °ˍMĝ?F.°ˍ,1F-zjtpQMȐŋ

J3F

=

.-&#+

1"GJG

bmPeTl+)Į¬*JbmPeTl 5 *J2A1
ǩ

Rr*

 #+3 Google 1ɞòʸʥX
I+

WdAI+.!N7 Google 1ɞòʸʥʣ.D$0

I1$J,A"G°ˍ22ɞâ*A%E&+ƣɪ+Mĉ.ưJ+Fun to Drive $&#G%E&+ʸʥ
K>#

-+

I+Ů

Mâ

1+

ȜȬĮ¬* #+3

1*°ŏșə1əí+°ˍ1əí*,1F.²¬=mTf*2qQXfz~Mƙ&)=&#1*Ɵ

mTfľɏJ)°ˍ`}kM¾-GmTfMI+Aɪ-LJ)=`}kPdfpnsmTfˮComputer assisted chess˯>#ǉŬ2°ˍ9)MI1*2-)
.əíMȐƐ*I+F-ƟIȦŚ AI 1PdfrMą),1F-+*1ȜȬâˇ2JGǹ-I+

ªŴJI1*








18

MIRAI Archive  No.2015-010

 f  R s 57 58

 xsYstˮHoward Gardner˯mRpeTfˮMultiple
intelligences˯+
H
>N-F

&)

)1ž1ʃ2ɡ}Ĳ-1*șŰ2ĭˆ*I+2Ŧŵ*Aæ1+2ɣž-++FI$G°ˍ2>N-ʺ&)-ʃĲ-1*0J2Ĺĕȑ--HlSr~ˮdoubtful˯-A1*f}P 1 g Ěķ2"1F
1×ʱĚķMƌK
f>#++-1*ɇɼĹȑ.

-ɓƠ2ƁåI1*F" f  R s 59
 "*PpQ~QdeTvRp
eTfˮArtificial General Intelligence˯+à)I1*J
ǝȅ°ŏșə>#1ȜȬPeTl*

-A1*I+°ŏșə2

J2Ŧŵ$J,AJ2ɣž>#$N+--&)

A1

-+$N+ɓI"1+.2#

)UqQrˮembodiment˯ũɳ-1,ȜȬJI9+* f  R s 60
 fpQSVguPn\ˮStephen Gary
Wozniak˯+Apple 1`~OSlˮCo-founder˯

1 1 °`{RZ]kf\ˮCoffee
making task˯+J2-.+

+MƎǄ)

I1*

+;ǞN1ł.ɪ&)ǞN1#@.`{M'I1*
19

-

K

K-Ȍ-Iəí+mRpeT
A1*2-

+

MIRAI Archive  No.2015-010

 J2ĮĹˑȄ.+,ɕ)AK,

K-ÔJƠ

ÔJ=+ɕ+)AÝɨŜ.ÔJ)

K

I+

K

1*
Ď1Ł*2`{M

I1*F`{ʐ1Äĸ.'K-^f

IƉƠAž*Ɖ°+1-*˙ò*Ɖ+"A"A`{M˥=ʫ.
°A°A

Ifkyn\fI1*ɞâ*2`{M'G-)fky*ʕ&)I+

F

-

I1*

 "

9)1^f.

I1,

+

)`{M'I+

kf\M°ŏșə*

+2UqQr1ʃ+ˎʴ)ˮissue˯$+

IJˆɳ-Rd

12PpQ~QdeTvRpeTf.

)ʢ»Űũ˝-1,+ȜȬǜ@GJ)

I+

+*

 f  R s 61 E

2;1ʟĐ*


)

IȜȬ*

Iŵʎ1Ȝ

ȬM

&

)°ŏșə1ȜȬ.')'¿ȟȑ.°ŏșəȜȬ1PeTlM

ʃ=#ĤƸȑ.Ȣ2AI 2°ˍ1ɝ+Ǚ9I+ǿ

+*Żî)HAI +
&<I+ʅʎ)='=

12fzbO*I* ° ˍ 1  y f r v f ˮ robustness˯ 2 

ŷųMď?zjtpQ1:.

I#+3

fpQegˮSteve Jobs˯1zjtpQ+
+

I

\j>#

&<

*°fpQ.-.ŵɴMɻ

12ȿƭG+
1\jCK"N--ŵɴMA&)C&)+"1Ħ*2^m^m.-ɐƢPnˮApple˯."1°àȠI+fpQeg>N-1é*>N-ȿƭG

PRqPMŮ

ŵɴMɞâ1ɓ*
 "
>#

'

I1F

#N$,+ƨƢ"1°fpQ.ɻ&#
.ɻ

6G)

I"N-4,

fpQeg1zjtpQ+-Pm*2=&#ʉƤ*-ˮanecdotal˯-ʃ*2-,1F
e$+Ů

="°$&#1*0

12-N-1AI 1ʙ

1*"MþʒʀÁCPv\sk.ľˈôǊʳôIˆɳ-bm1mɶǵG

'1bmPeTlMƎǄ=# ƢƸ*A°ŏșə1ȜȬ"1A1$*-°ŏșə+°ˍ+1ˎLH"JGȠ¸ȑRz\r+1ˎLH.'
E

2ůʿ1F)K

K-+MIũɳ-i.=#µ*20I+Ů&)MIRAI Archive  No.2015-010

ʨ

H+



=#"J*2ʚĕ-,2˴ǚ°ŏșə1Ûŕȑ-+K.
2

#H=+

3

H=

&)°ˍ1șŰGʶɜ1Ơč.

I+

1#H=*ĕˡ-+2zjtpQM°ŏșə*ɓI+ʈɺMðˊIĈəŰ

I+Ů

=#

 ƨƢARl\dˮinduction˯+ql\dˮdeduction˯+

A1

&)

Pteˮanalogy˯+Pl\dˮabduction˯1ʦMƱ=#ƝȻ+ɢɫŁ1°2"

A1.Ɨŷ*Rl\d+ql\d+Ûŕȑ-Ǌʳ+m]d$+"MɍƏ#H´Ô#H++K**IF

A12
I.ɖ

Ǌʳ-1*ȂȣȻ1°2"&%1+2FLI$J,APteCPl\d-,2ʦ2Ʊ-F-A1*!

N7Ȍʚ-A1*Ȍʚ-A1ʴɉ))'-HLG-.ALGɅƾȑ.'-&)$-1*IF.>I+ ɻʆĹ-,Aøé¤Aĕˡ.-&#zqQ]ˮparadigma˯+dk]ˮsyntagma˯

H=dk]2ɍƏC´Ô*ȂȣȻ1°ˍȂɺ*IȺý-ʃ*zqQ]+A12!N!NȌʚ-A1£N*

1.£ɍI+ʽƅI"d1]]+ę&)
&)

#F

IF

A1.-&)

1&1

I1*0

-ŵĐ*2d[pQǔ*2C"°ŏșəȑ-˟1F-N)>N-Ǖ03+Ů
[pQMŨ˄I+¡)F

IRl\dql\-A1GʶɜI+K+.°ˍȑ-A1+ˎÃ) Ȣ2"1F)=&#ˎÃ-1+1*"J2

)

)d

12üõż«1K.ü˂1°#%ˬ°.ɞȇM++ċF $Gùâ2æ.,ƪ´ƺ)

*A-Ũ˄.Ů)=+Ů&))ɥƶN1ɻ&)

I+2LI

1*
°ŏșə.IzjtpQ1ȜȬ-N)ʃ2ȂȣȻ1°ˍȂȣȻ1hf*)AF
I+

1Ó:,1Pl\d-N)˂âGÕ»M*&%

A1ŠŞ-ʃMďN*Ʌƾȑ.2L&)=
-.F

1Ų

+ċƪ.Ů&)=I

ʴɉ*Ȍʚ*+˛Mà)>N-J2F

1LG"1F

1$J,AȘFŲ-+*ȂȣȻ1hf*2˘ °ŏșə1-.zjtpQ1F

ĭǋŰ$+Ȍʚ-A11ʴɉŰȌʚ*

H-Gʴɉ*I+ʴɉȑ-A1*"

I+

+Mɻ&)
21

+K

I

1…

-A12!N!N-&#A1M*&%

+

˛à#G>N-xn

"J*zjtpQ-,M=#°ŏșə1-*I+

Ȼ+ɢɫŁ2ƥG"

I.ALGzjtpQ$+
IA1M>F

Ơč.-&)=+Ɲô#.ALGȂȣȻ1°ˍ2MIRAI Archive  No.2015-010!N!NȂɺ)

-

G"

ʃ.-&)

I"J.')2,ŮLJ=)2ƕ&)++*ɥƶʯ.ɕ#1*
zjtpQ.'ľˈȑ-e2ǶȂ$+˴ǚ"N-+2-

+*E



*FȢI+J3°ˍȑ-AK

l\dql\d1Ûŕȑ-Ǌʳ+ªľʋĒȑ-ʶɜ+
¸&)

I+M,

I1+

CɯȁA*I+Ů
ɥƶ+
ɻ&#F

+K2RF-A1à

+.ˎIk~Vn\ˮ metaphoric ˯-q=

+2RpeTf1e1Ǌʳ+=&#ʺ-Mď@#e$+I+J3e+˴ǚe+ɻɻ+*0A"ƠǛ.L-ƠǛ.L-+Ì1dk]1Ǌʳ.Ɇ>+GJ)=



+

A1

+*

e+ɻ&#Șˍ.&%ɥƶfXˎƜ-1ĭǏÒʌ1\r-1LG)>J3"=˴N

,#.

LJ$0˵ǚe1ýº2-N*J=*Ae++3N.à)I1*"1e1ýº2ǼȂ$&#G%BN+ýºȻ+

I1*F

ɥƶ»Ȼ2#7Nx}vf-,2happinessGoogle Scholar *Ǉɀ…˵ǚJ=*-#AN.e+"JM%BN+ǭH=E++M&B&#+Ů

1*

+MȔžMŀ»ɶI#@1Ĥǰˈô1+1ýº2…
ɥƶ;

&)I+*2-)bm`upQ1-*2ĤƸ2¥ɹʀÁ*0#+37

Rrf^*'*+ɕȑ-ȔˎM>I-,1Pm*"J2;)
pQ*2"1F

.)

I+

I+

+*ýº2-.+)"1ɇɼ

FHA`u
LJ#Gýº2-*˵ǚ"J2uyb-A1.-I1*ɥƶLH=N˵ǚ'=Hƪ´+"
ɥƶ,

-1*E

A1.ˠIF#$'

3&1ŧˤ* 1 G 5 1-ʀÁ.-I1++*

I+2¥ɹʀÁMJ=F0#+%*,JG*#5 ȋ+)

˵ǚRtf…
ɥƶRtfÓȄʀÁJ#ƜÇ+Ȕˎ)

I1*"

IɝǤòŵĐ.FI+¥ɹȑ-ʀÁ+
22

I+

12…

+2L&

MIRAI Archive  No.2015-010

˵ǚ1ʀÁ+ɥƶ"
1F

121

+AJ=.)#+-#+1¸ʃ.

)ŵĐ-Nɡȑ.ʅșȣĹ1`upQ2J=*"+*;AA+A+2ǼȂM).Iýº+-.Mǭ&)˵ǚˈôI+

1*F

I1+

ƲʼôI+

++2ʺ

&)AF

#1*ǼȂ=

1*-.MƲʼôI+

1…
ɥƶ

)

-G3°ˍ1ɝ1-*e.ȔšIǤò

+*2
°ˍ1ɝ1ɏ.ƍɉCAJ=+&BI1*˵ǚI˂â1ǤòM>)ɻ

Ơ2

+AJ=-#2ˎÃŰFHAŀɹȑ.°.Ǭ+*IFI+

+M¥şJ)ɥƶ-NG1Ǚʧ*IF
˵ǚȢ

Ůʏ.Ů

+ǞĎ

1*

-A1

12"

I:

 A

Âç$K

+

*E

IT +

+

12Žʂ"

ƪˍ+

H=#+3°ˍ*

A1

IF

-+2-.1ɧȪ*

A1##>=J)Ô&)d[pQ

I"1ɧȪ+I1*F0TI 1-.".Ǚʧ*Ińʒ.-I1,



ɥƶ,

%E&+ɓ˵ǚIT MĕˡôI+Ǩ)=)$+.…ȢɞʢAǪ¨)

-

I+

1*F

I1*%E&+ʚĕ=#ɥƶĕˡƎʜ2ąǒ@#1*%E&+ɓ
=1˵ǚ1ʃ.ˎÃ

)$

˘

I+-N1e*AF,ȁĿ¢ȉ.UqQrI+

F

121bit ,1ˆ*,1G

1Uv[


23-ǛIN$ǼȂȑ-dfp*'GJI1UqQrA"J$1ųĥˈMA#
1Į*,1Gĕˡ-1*

I1*Ʋʫ1Ȅđ1ʜǯ+ AI 1ĕˡ21bit +12j~rSTP*C&)

-

A1

.Ȅ)$G"J&):N+
-1*E

+.

&#+#G°ˍ1ɝ1-.2ƪˍ

#G"J2°ˍ1˂âȭˍ.'GJ#ƪˍ1+´Ǽ-1$

+.d[pQ1ʃà#+.d

&)

G-

ʀÁ$+



[pQ+

˶ǚ

+*

12ƪˍ…J2Șˍɢ*I1$G='ȍĕ-1*IT +

+

=1 TI

I1*F0Gd[pQ*)A"J2.˒ā*)=
AJ-

K

N

-A1M

=.ȯ%I1$G5 ŗA)3F

J3"J2"J*F+%3NǼȂ¥NɝǤòɞ»ƝɛÀĸ$+ˎÃŰÀĸ*J3"J2"1+H*+.ń)I9*

F

I+

I1$K

I#@.,1G

I12:N+.ǭMIRAI Archive  No.2015-010

 "J2-N*AF+#GȄđ1ʜǯ2¤ȭGǦ5&#A1.-&)

=

+

"

*2-

d*-+KȄđ1ʜǯ*#$1ôĹăūȄđ.re+1ĀĚ1'.-&)

IUqQr*ɓI+Į¬*-'PruWleWˮAnthonio Damasio˯1+ĲĶ*)=

ɥ ƶ  N 1 ɻFF.ʢ»ŰI. PpQ~QdeTv RpeTf*0"1+.AUqQrM¡#G AI ĲĶ
MA'1*"#Șˍ.…A&+ŭ

A1*0

 &1eýºǼȂȑ-A1*ýº¡GJ)»¡GJ)le
Wȑ-ŵĐ*ĲĶ*I"

I+.2@)Ȅđȑ-A1.-I1*

"1+. 2 ȋȓ1d[pQɚĵ.Ʋä.ɻ&#d[pQ2˵
ǚ

F.Ⱥý.ĄH˒J)=r#+.2

-A1AJ-

%3Nɚĵ.-I1*2-

 $Gɓ-)22~.ʍ)

F

+Ů



12-. 1bit MƓ)

-IJ,A'2"*2-

,UqQ

I+ɻ

+MLJLJ*-J3-I:,1bit MƓIǼȂȑ-Ǌʳũɳ.-&))"JMɓI+ȄǼ1ʜǯ1ĕˡ+ȳÁ-1*$G-N*AųĥMƆILB-)
1Uv[ǾŸƆ"J2¤ȭ1ʃ*2-IǽľIǽľ1ğ.àȁ#+ɓGJI1*

JG"JMɓ-)2

 $G IT + AI +
F

GȄđ

Iǽľ1âķ1-ƪ´$+Ȣ2Ů=

&)Aƿȭ1 SF 1ʃ*2-)ȁĿ."1ǾǡMĿȁ+Ů&)Ŀ˩Mĳ@)ɓII+ʰȰ.Uv[ǾŸ+,JG

1˙ķ

I1+"+yyyyyn+Ô&))"Gĳ=I+ɥƶ$G-N*++mgvnrˮCharles Bennett˯ɻ&# The

thermodynamics of computation-,1ʃ,*ĂǸJ-J3Ů=˶ǚ$G"J2Ɉń.=#ɓIMɥƶ"







*0

˷ǚȢ2ȜȬɔ+
G

-

#

+

-I+AJ=ÜȖŁ-1*!N!NʺȯĦ-1*"1ȯĦ

H=ƨƢ.ƹǴÓȄʃJ#ƷƺìŻĹ1Õ».'N*~VXfJ)-HPeTlM'&),.č+)IƠčŰ
I1*E

ȜȬžǢ

°ˍ1ǽǖ-əíMɺƤI+.č+)I1"JMrf)Ȅ>à"+)

I1'=HƷƺMìK

+)I1ʹāMbmF

I1

,&%-1.F&)=&#ʺ ʹā1A1*

J3ťƺȣĹ+A1.-&)IF

A1Ŧŵ-âˇ*24+)-ǛI1*
K

K-ƠǢ

&

MIRAI Archive  No.2015-010)ƨƢ1ĮˇÓȄ1ôț1ʃ-,KK+

KG,

ŵĐ*-12LH=

ʡ>à1,"MÔJI1ÔJ-I+Ů

1*"1ʹā+N1 Ǔ$*AƷƺ+1+F+",&%-N$K&E.)F

F

1"1

#HM,

ɥƶ"1ȍĕ.'2=#"M

1;1ɶǵGI
1â#:

ɓ-1-+ǲǷ+#ɓ-1*+$+Ů=rf{ug+

+*Ǉɀ#$+#Nà)=rf*G°ˍ°ˍMʝ#
fr{ug+ɻƠA

I1*ʝ°ˍô"JG

°ˍµː1+Mɓĳ@#1AJ-+

 $G#N.ʹā1°ˍMȂɺ)"JMÛȁF
bmPeTl$+ɴ-J)F&E

)1Zs2J*rf{ugˮTranshumanism˯+
)

+Ů

+K.

+.!N7#.¸ʃ*I1"MãHâ)¸ʃ#:++-1,
ƠJ)

˷ǚ

I+Ů

ʏʌ

fr{

I+

+"

I

+*
+Mʝ#="J°ˍ.+&)Ř

-1

2=&#æ1ĕˡ*AI 1`upQ*21F

I+

-ɻ

+*

=1ʃ2ĤƸȑ.2".1&#…

ɥƶ;*;2A+A+ɝ1ȜȬM2@#12egˮSir
Roger Penrose˯1 ȒŔ1Ɵ+Ũ `}˰kŨǼȂǢèˮThe Emperor's New Mind˯°ŏșə1é1ŏșə*2Ûȁ*-+&#1*"1+.gŵʎ-,2°ɓƠM@)"J.;2ɟĐMA&)ɝ1ȜȬ.ÔH=#J2;1ʟĐ1¢ȉ-1*ɇɼȑ-Ĺɑɵè-,1Pm*2ŵʎ2ɺƤ*-+

1;1ǂƸȑ-fkf-1*eW

rwuˮGiulio Tononi˯)I IITˮIntegrated information theory˯+

~Oˮrefer˯)

I1*J*2ŵʎ1Ƹʚ.2ʬJ-

IȜȬ

>N-
+

1Ȣ1ɓƠ*

=1°ŏșə2ɇɼȑ-ĹɑɵèMC&)ʎ2'J-

ŵʎ2A)-

I"J*ʝbO1F
)IF

I1*;1ȯĦ2°ŏșə*2ŵ

1$J,A°ŏșə2'1+3H-ŷ*șŰ+e.

.>I$*ĤƸȑ.°ŏșə.2ŵʎ-)2°ˍMrf+1;1ȯĦ

* Ó:,à#XoR+
&)

F

-°2
°ˍ1ŵʎM`}k.ȥ

I1*;2"J2\\z$+Ů&)2\\z$+Ů&)I1*;ɻ&)I1*XoOR

I12ɴE

eTfMe.#+.°ŏșəȢ#%MʝI+2
25

I+

1Rp

I*E



MIRAI Archive  No.2015-010$Gÿ˓-1*E °ŏșə1ǿ+2"

+*°ŏșə2ŵʎA#-*.ALGȢ#%M2I.Þ˨IəíMA&)=I1*"J.ń),

#GF!N°ŏșəǔB

H=

ɥƶ

=#

H+



1+

G

ǿ

1

ƪ´Mʪ)

1;1ĤƸȑ-ɓƠ*!N

N

ˮ©˯

26