2022年の第三者機関テストで高い評価を獲得

3位以内に入賞した割合

カスペルスキー製品は、2022年に第三者機関が実施したセキュリティ製品テストと製品レビューに86回参加しました。
そのうち1位を69回、上位3位以内を73回（入賞率85％）獲得しています。

1位受賞 69回
テスト/レビュー参加 86回
3位以内入賞率 85%

より多くのテストに参加し*より多くのトップ評価を得た*
カスペルスキーの保護*kaspersky.co.jp/top3

1

Copyright © 2023 Kaspersky Lab. All rights reserved.

第 1 位となった回数

テスト/レビューへの参加回数
注）• 2022年に実施された法人、個人、モバイル向け製品の第三者機関テスト結果をKasperskyが独自に集計したものです。
• 第三者機関にはAV-Comparatives, AV-TEST, ICSA Labs, MRG Effitas, SE Labs, Testing Ground Labs, Virus Bulletinが含まれます。
• 各テストは既知および未知の脅威ならびに高度な攻撃に対する防御性能を対象にしています。
• 円の大きさは1位受賞の回数を表しています。

2022年 第三者機関テスト ‐TOP3メトリック 集計詳細
TOP3メトリックは、1年間に実施された第三者機関によるテスト結果をKasperskyが独自に集計したものです

参加
テスト数

上位3位
入賞回数

上位3位
入賞率
（%）

1位受賞
回数

Kaspersky

86

73

85%

69

TOP3スコアは、参加ベンダーごとに計算します。

AVG

46

38

83%

36

1. 最終的なテスト結果はテストによって異なり、参加ベンダーに賞が授与される場合や、検知率や誤検知数のリストのみが提示される場合があります。
ベンダーのTOP3カウンターは、賞の受賞またはテストで3位以内に入った場合のどちらかに対して加算されます。賞の受賞とテストでの3位以内獲得の両方が加算されることはありません。
複数のベンダーが検知率や集計結果で同じ結果を出した場合や同じグレードの賞を受賞した場合、これらのベンダーは当該テストで同率順位の扱いになります。
検知率または集計結果の場合、結果が同率順位のベンダーより低いベンダーの順位は「上位ベンダーの数＋1」として計算されます。たとえば、順位が「1,1,2,3」という並びになることはなく、「1,1,3,4」「1,2,2,4」、
または「1,1,1,1,1,6」となります。TOP3カウンターに加算されるのは、太字の順位のベンダーのみです。
賞に関しては、後述しているテストの説明に挙げたルールを参照してください。

Avast

78

63

81%

55

Avira

48

35

73%

32

NortonLifeLock

46

33

72%

32

G DATA

47

32

68%

32

Microsoft

57

38

67%

31

Bitdefender

86

55

64%

54

2. ベンダーの参加回数は、そのベンダーの製品のいずれかがテスト/レビュー/オーバービューに参加するごとに加算されます。
テストによっては、ひとつのベンダーから複数製品が同じテストに参加できる場合があります。その場合、製品ごとに参加回数を加算するため、参加回数がテストの合計数より多くなることがあります。

Trend Micro

54

32

59%

31

AhnLab

41

23

56%

23

ESET

42

23

55%

21

グラフには、テスト合計数の35%以上に参加したベンダーの結果のみを表示しています。

Trellix（McAfee）

63

31

49%

30

Malwarebytes

46

15

33%

15

Broadcom（Symantec）

24

13

54%

13

主な指標であるTOP3スコア（上位3位への入賞率）は、集計期間中にベンダーが参加した第三者機関によるテス
トにおいて、そのベンダーの製品が1位、2位、または3位を何回受賞したかを示します。TOP3スコアは、ベン
ダーの1位、2位、3位獲得回数を、そのベンダーのTOP3カウンター（参加回数）で割って算出します。

2022年のスコアは2023年2月1日時点のデータを集計しました。この日以降のテスト/レビュー結果は含んでいません。
TOP3スコアには、次のセキュリティベンダーの結果が含まれています。Avast、AVG、Avira、Bitdefender、Blackberry (Cylance) 、Broadcom（Symantec）、BullGuard、Crowdstrike、ESET、F-Secure、G DATA、
Kaspersky、Microsoft、NortonLifeLock、Palo Alto、Panda、Sentinel One、Sophos、Trellix（McAfee）、Trend Micro、Quick Heal、VMWare（Carbon Black）ほか。テストに参加した全ベンダーリストは本文書の最後に記載しています。
2

Copyright © 2023 Kaspersky Lab. All rights reserved.

* Broadcom（Symantec）は、テストの合計数の21%にしか参加していませんが、同社の結果はグラフに表示する価値があると当社は判断しました。

2022年 TOP3メトリック詳細（1）
ここでは、高度な脅威や誤検知など、さまざまな種類のマルウェアに対して実施されたテストを紹介します
特定の脅威

APT
• AV-Comparatives. Advanced Threat Protection Test:
Consumer and Business• AV-Comparatives. Endpoint Prevention and Response (EPR)
test• AV-Comparatives. LSASS Credential-Dumping Security Test
• AV-TEST. Advanced Threat Protection Test: Consumer andBusiness• ICSA, Advanced Threat Detection Certification• SE Labs. Enterprise Advanced Security (EDR) Test – Detection
ランサムウェア
• AV-Comparatives. Advanced Threat Protection Test:
Consumer and Business• AV-Comparatives. Business Security Test
• AV-Comparatives. Malware Protection Test
• AV-Comparatives. Real-World Protection Test
• AV-TEST. Advanced Threat Protection Test: Consumer andBusiness• AV-TEST. Bi-Monthly Certification: Consumer and Business• MRG-Effitas. 360 Assessment & Certification• SE Labs. Enterprise Advanced Security (EDR) Test – Detection• SE Labs. Enterprise Endpoint Protection Test
• SE Labs. Home Anti-Malware Protection Test
• SE Labs. Small Business Endpoint Protection Test

ファイルレス

3• AV-Comparatives. Endpoint Prevention and Response (EPR) test
• AV-Comparatives. Advanced Threat Protection Test:
Consumer and Business• MRG-Effitas. 360 Assessment & Certification• SE Labs. Enterprise Endpoint Protection Test
• SE Labs. Home Anti-Malware Protection Test
• SE Labs. Small Business Endpoint Protection Test
エクスプロイト• AV-Comparatives. Advanced Threat Protection Test:
Consumer and Business• MRG-Effitas. 360 Assessment & Certification• SE Labs. Enterprise Advanced Security (EDR) Test – Detection• SE Labs. Enterprise Endpoint Protection Test
• SE Labs. Home Anti-Malware Protection Test
• SE Labs. Small Business Endpoint Protection Test
フィッシング• AV-Comparatives. Anti-Phishing Test

実環境テスト• AV-Comparatives. Advanced Threat Protection Test:
Consumer and Business• AV-Comparatives. Business Security Test
• AV-Comparatives. Real-World Protection Test
• AV-TEST. Advanced Threat Protection Test: Consumer andBusiness• AV-TEST. Bi-Monthly Certification Consumer and Business

Copyright © 2023 Kaspersky Lab. All rights reserved.

• CyberRatings. Endpoint Protection Comparative Test
• MRG-Effitas. 360 Assessment & Certification• SE Labs. Enterprise Endpoint Protection Test
• SE Labs. Home Anti-Malware Protection Test
• SE Labs. Small Business Endpoint Protection Test

Androidテスト• AV-Comparatives. Mobile Security Review• AV-TEST. Android Mobile Security Products Test:
Consumer and Business• MRG Effitas. Android 360 Assessment Programme• Testing Ground Labs. Android Malware Detection Test:
Consumer and Business

Macテスト• AV-Comparatives. Mac Security Test & Review• AV-TEST. Mac Detection & Performance Test:
Consumer and Business

専門テスト• AV-Comparatives. Parental Control Certification• AV-TEST. Parental Control Certification• AV-TEST. VPN Test

誤検知（FP）• 前述の全てのテストのうち、FPの測定が含まれるもの2022年 TOP3メトリック詳細（2）このページ以降のテストは、2022年に実施されTOP3メトリックの算出に利用したものです。テスト実施機関とテストはアルファベット順です。
AV-Comparatives• Product of the YearAt the end of the year, this annual award is given to theConsumer related product which attained the highest
awards in an entire year’s testing cycle, involving thefollowing tests: two Malware Protection Tests (MPT) +two Real-World Protection Tests (RWPT) + two
Performance Tests + Advanced Threat Protection Test
(ATP, formerly known as Enhanced Real-World Test).
According to AV-Comparatives’ rules, in cases where
two or more products receive the same maximum
score, the award goes to the product which gained thehighest individual scores and did not receive it theprevious year. The seal is counted as a first place in the
TOP3 metric.

•

4

Despite all products from consumer Main-Test-Series
are expected to be tested by default, the vendors were
given the opportunity to opt out of this test before thetest started, which is why not all vendors are includedin this test. This test is conducted and counted in themetrics once a year. Consumer and Business related
products are assessed separately.

Products receive the following awards: “Advanced+”,“Advanced”, “Standard” or “Tested”. Only products with“Advanced+” gain an increment of TOP3 counters fortheir vendor.
•

Products which were nominated, but did not receive the‘Product of the Year’ award, are given the ‘Outstanding
Product’ rank for their vendors, which counts as asecond place in the TOP3 metrics. Products which
achieved at least 90 points across the entire test cycle
are awarded the ‘Top Rated’ rank for their vendors,
which counts as a third place in the TOP3 metric.
Products that fail to score any points in, at least, one of
the tests are excluded.
At the end of the year, medals ('Gold’, ‘Silver’, ‘Bronze’)
are also given for the best results in specific tests:
MPT, RWPT, Performance, ATP . As these test results
have already contributed to overall TOP3 metrics, themedals themselves do not count towards it since 2015.
Only awards can contribute towards TOP3 counters in
AV-Comparatives tests.

Malware Protection Test
This test is a successor of the File Detection Test andincludes execution of the tested files. It is conducted
twice a year and, correspondingly, is counted two times
in the metrics. The test consists of two parts: Detection
Rate and False Positives.

Real-World Protection Test
The test lasts for four months and is finalized in a halfyear report using mainly current, visible, and relevant
malicious websites/malware. The test is conducted
twice a year and, correspondingly, counted two times in
the metrics. Because all product components
contribute a significant role in overall protection,
results achieved in this category are a good indicator ofanti-malware product efficiency in real-world scenarios.
Products receive the following awards: “Advanced+”,“Advanced”, “Standard” or “Tested”. Only products with“Advanced+” gain an increment of TOP3 counters fortheir vendor.

•

Advanced Threat Protection Test: Consumer andBusiness
This test uses hacking and penetration techniques thatallow attackers to target specific external computer
systems, and evaluates how well security products
protect against such attacks. This test checks
protection against targeted advanced threats, such as
exploits and fileless attacks.

Copyright © 2023 Kaspersky Lab. All rights reserved.

Consumer products receive the following awards:“Advanced+”, “Advanced”, “Standard” or “Tested”. Only
products with “Advanced+” gain an increment of TOP3
counters for their vendor.
Business products which block at least 8 of the 15
attacks used in the test, without blocking nonmalicious operations, are certified by the test lab andgain an increment of TOP3 counters for their vendor.
•

Endpoint Prevention & Response (EPR) Test
This test is performed and counted once a year andevaluates security solutions response capabilities(active response, passive response) to targeted
attacks, ability to take remedial action, investigate thenature of an attack, collect and show information on
indicators of compromise in an easily accessible form.
The effectiveness of each product at preventing
breaches, the calculated savings resulting from this,the purchase costs of the product, and the product’s
accuracy costs are factored by Enterprise EPR
CyberRisk Quadrant.
Products receive one of the following three certificationlevels: “Strategic Leaders”, “CyberRisk Visionaries”,
and “Strong Challengers”, or they are not certified. Only
products with “Strategic Leader” gain an increment of
TOP3 counters for their vendor.

2022年 TOP3メトリック詳細（3）このページ以降のテストは、2022年に実施されTOP3メトリックの算出に利用したものです。テスト実施機関とテストはアルファベット順です。
•

LSASS Credential-Dumping Security Test
This test is performed and counted in the metrics one
time a year. It evaluates how well business security
products determine their hardening measures protectedagainst attacks on Windows’ Local Security Authority
Subsystem Service (LSASS).
Products placing in the highest three positions basedon the Protection Rate gain an increment of TOP3
counters for their vendor.

•

Business Security Report
This report is published twice a year. Correspondingly,
it is counted two times in the metrics. The report
includes a review of various business security products
and evaluates the protection efficiency in categories
such as Protection Rate on different malware sets,
websites, and exploits, and a False Positive level.
Products achieving, at least, 90 percent Protection Ratewith no False Positives on common business softwarein the Malware Protection Test and, at least, 90 percent
Protection Rate with less than 100 False Positives on
any clean software/websites in the overall Real-World
Protection Test, with no major performance issues, arecertified by the test lab, and gain an increment of TOP3
counters for their vendor.

•

Anti-Phishing Test
This test is performed and counted in the metrics once5•

a year and simulates a common situation: users rely on
the anti-phishing protection provided by their security
products while browsing the web. The test consists of
two parts: Detection Rate and False Positives.

against a product feature list and measures protectionlevels in categories such as Detection Rate on separate
Mac- & Windows-related malware sets and a False
Positive level.

If all products achieve zero False Positives, theproducts achieving the highest three places based on
Protection Rate, gain an increment of TOP3 counters
for their vendor.
If any of participating products achieve any False
Positives, only certified products gain an increment of
TOP3 counters for their vendor.

If all products achieve zero False Positives, theproducts achieving the highest three places based on
Protection Rate, gain an increment of TOP3 counters
for their vendor.

Mobile Security Review
This review is done and counted in the metrics once a
year and includes a malware protection test along withan overview of additional features (theft protection,battery consumption, etc.).
If all products achieve zero False Positives, theproducts achieving the highest three places based on
Protection Rate, gain an increment of TOP3 counters
for their vendor.
If any of participating products achieve any False
Positives, only certified products gain an increment of
TOP3 counters for their vendor.

•

Mac Security Test & Review
This review is done and counted in the metrics once a
year and evaluates various Mac protection products

Copyright © 2023 Kaspersky Lab. All rights reserved.

If any of participating products achieve any False
Positives, only certified products gain an increment of
TOP3 counters for their vendor.
•

Parental Control Certification

This test is performed and counted in the metrics oncea year and evaluates efficiency of security products toprevent children from visiting unwanted web sites.
Only products blocking at least 98% of pornographic
websites with zero False Positives on child-friendly
websites, and having no severe unresolved bugs (ordesign flaws) discovered during the review, are certified
and gain an increment of TOP3 counters for theirvendor.

2022年 TOP3メトリック詳細（4）このページ以降のテストは、2022年に実施されTOP3メトリックの算出に利用したものです。テスト実施機関とテストはアルファベット順です。
AV-TEST• Best Protection Award: Consumer and BusinessThis annual award is given once a year for perfectresults in the Protection category over the course of an
entire year, during which bi-monthly certification takes
place. Consumer and Business related products areassessed separately.
Only products that receive this award gain a TOP3
counter increment for their vendor.
•

Best Android Security: Consumer
This annual award is given once a year for perfectresults in the Android security testing over the courseof a whole year. Consumer and Business related
products are assessed separately.
Only products that receive this award gain a TOP3
counter increment for their vendor.

6

Best Mac Security: Consumer and BusinessThis annual award is given once a year for perfectresults in the Mac security testing over the course of awhole year. Consumer and Business related products
are assessed separately.

•

Advanced Threat Protection Test: Consumer andBusiness
This test is counted six times in the metrics (November,
December, February, April, June, August). Consumer
and Business related products are assessed separately.
It assesses detection and threat prevention capabilities
of end-point solutions against APT attacks deploying
ransomware without generating False Positives on
normal operations. The executed attack chains are split
into separate stages attributed to different TTPs fromMITRE ATT&CK. The sum of the points gained in eachstage makes up the overall score; products in the top
three have their TOP3 counters incremented.

•

Android Mobile Security Products Test: Consumer andBusiness
This year-long certification series evaluates various
security protection products for Android and consists ofConsumer and Business segments, each divided into
six separate tests. Their results are published every odd
months, i.e. this test is counted 6 times in the metrics.
Consumer and Business related products are assessed
separately. All participating products are evaluated andreceive points in Protection, Performance and Usability
categories. The sum of the points gained in eachcategory makes up the overall score; products in the
top three have their TOP3 counters incremented.

Only products that receive this award gain a TOP3
counter increment for their vendor.
•

Best Usability Award: Consumer and BusinessThis annual award is given once a year for perfectresults in the Usability category over the course of an
entire year, during which bi-monthly certification takes
place. Consumer and Business related products areassessed separately.
Only products that receive this award gain a TOP3
counter increment for their vendor.

••

Best Advanced Threat Protection: Consumer andBusiness
This annual award is given once a year for perfectresults in the Advanced Threat Protection testing overthe course of a whole year. Consumer and Business
related products are assessed separately.
Only products that receive this award gain a TOP3
counter increment for their vendor.

•

Bi-Monthly Certification: Consumer and BusinessThis year-long certification series consists of Consumer
and Business segments, each divided into six separate,
two-month-long tests, which results are publishedevery even months, i.e. this test is counted 6 times in
the metrics. Consumer and Business related products
are assessed separately. All participating products areevaluated and receive points in Protection,
Performance and Usability categories. The sum of thepoints gained in each category makes up the overall
score; products in the top three have their TOP3
counters incremented.

Copyright © 2023 Kaspersky Lab. All rights reserved.

2022年 TOP3メトリック詳細（5）このページ以降のテストは、2022年に実施されTOP3メトリックの算出に利用したものです。テスト実施機関とテストはアルファベット順です。
••

Mac Detection & Performance Test: Consumer andBusiness
This test evaluates various security protection products
for Mac OS X and consists of Consumer and Businesssegments, which results are published and counted in
the metrics four times a year. Consumer and Business
related products are assessed separately. All
participating products receive points in Protection,
Performance and Usability categories. The sum of thepoints gained in each category makes up the overall
score; products in the top three have their TOP3
counters incremented.
VPN Test
The test is performed and counted in the metrics oncea year. It assesses and compares VPN solutions byseparate topics of usability, security, privacy, speed,
and transparency.

CyberRatings• Endpoint Protection Comparative Test
This test is performed once a year and evaluates eachparticipated product’s ability to block malware as quickas possible. Products placing in the highest threepositions based on the Average Block Rate (Over Time)gain an increment of TOP3 counters for their vendor.
ICSA Labs• Advanced Threat Defense Certification1
This assessment is performed every quarter, i.e. fourtimes a year, and aims to evaluate the efficiency of
security solutions to detect new and little-known
threats while minimizing false positives. Each productthat passes the certification gains an increment of
TOP3 counter for their vendor.

Each product that passes the certification gains anincrement of TOP3 counter for their vendor.
•

Parental Control Certification
This vendor-commissioned test is performed andcounted in the metrics once a year and evaluates
protection efficiency of security products on Windows,
Android and iOS platforms to protect children fromvisiting unwanted web sites.
Only certified products gain an increment of TOP3
counters for their vendor.

7

Copyright © 2023 Kaspersky Lab. All rights reserved.

MRG Effitas• 360 Assessment & Certification
This test is conducted and published four times a year
and evaluates both the ability to block initial infection
and time taken to detect and remediate malware on acompromised system. This test replaces the older“Time to Detect & Remediate Assessment” test andincludes Online Banking part since second quarter of2020 that assesses the efficiency of products against
financial malware. Only certified products gain an
increment of TOP3 counters for their vendor.
•

Android 360 Degree Assessment ProgrammeThis test is conducted and published four times a year
and evaluates both the ability to block initial infection
while copying it to the device, so called the Early Stage
Detection, and while running it, the Installation Stage.
The test also includes a false positive subtest.
Products placing in the highest three positions basedon the combined of two stages Detection Rate gain an
increment of TOP3 counters for their vendor.

2022年 TOP3メトリック詳細（6）このページ以降のテストは、2022年に実施されTOP3メトリックの算出に利用したものです。テスト実施機関とテストはアルファベット順です。
Three products with the highest Total Accuracy Ratingsscores (calculated as a combination of points of thetwo subtests) gain an increment of TOP3 counters fortheir vendor.

SE Labs (formerly known as Dennis Technology Labs)• Enterprise Endpoint Protection Test
• Small Business Endpoint Protection Test•

Home Anti-Malware Protection Test
These quarterly-long tests are published and counted
in the metrics four times a year. These tests aim tocompare the effectiveness of anti-malware products
provided by well-known security companies. Enterprise,Home, and Small Business products are evaluatedseparately. The products are exposed to live Internet
threats during the test period. This exposure is carriedout in a very realistic way, closely reflecting thecustomer experience. The results reflect how products
perform under real-life, customer-use-case scenarios,
i.e. what happens when a user visits an infectedwebsite. The tests include a detection subtest and afalse positive one.
Three products with the highest Total Accuracy Ratingscores (calculated as a combination of points of thetwo subtests) gain an increment of TOP3 counters fortheir vendor.

•

Enterprise Advanced Security (EDR) Test - Detection
This test is published and counted in the metrics one
time this year. It is also known as Breach ResonseTest and evaluates effectiveness of a tested productagainst a range of hacking attacks designed tocompromise systems and penetrate target networks inthe same way as criminals and other attackers breachsystems and networks. The tests include a detection
subtest and a false positive one.
8•

Email Security Services Protection Test
This test is performed and counted in the metrics one
time a year and assesses how effectively the email
hosted protection services for the Office365 platform
are at detecting and/or protecting against threats inreal time, including phishing, BEC (business e-mailcompromise), social engineering and real world spam.
The test includes a detection subtest and a false
positive one.
Three products with the highest Total Accuracy Ratingscores (calculated as a combination of points of thetwo subtests) gain an increment of TOP3 counters fortheir vendor.

Testing Ground Labs
• Android Malware Detection Test: Consumer andBusiness
This test evaluates how effectively mobile products canprotect users’ Android-based devices from threats. It
includes a detection subtest and a false positives one.
Consumer and Business related products are assessed
separately and are published four and two times thisyear, correspondingly. Starting from June 2022, eachtest of the testing lab is complient with the AMTSO
Testing Protocol Standard and confirmed by AMTSO.
Three products with the highest Total Scores

Copyright © 2023 Kaspersky Lab. All rights reserved.

(calculated as a combination of the two subtests
results) gain an increment of TOP3 counters for theirvendor.
VirusBulletin• VB100 Certification
These tests are held every month to evaluate different
types of products (before that, these tests were held
every even months); the reports are published twelve
times this year.
Each product that passes the certification gains anincrement of TOP3 counter for their vendor.

2022年 TOP3メトリック対象全ベンダー
•

1E

•

CrowdStrike•

Intego•

RevBits•

Vendor A（AVC-EPR）•

Acronis•Cybereason•

IronNet•Rising•Vendor B（AVC-EPR）•

AhnLab

•

Cynet

•

Juniper•

Sangfor•

Vendor C（AVC-EPR）•

Anonimous•

CyRadar•K7•

Scanguard•

Vendor D（AVC-EPR）•

Antiy Labs•

Data443•

Kaspersky•

Securion•

Vendor E（AVC-EPR）•

ArcaBit•Deep Instinct•

Lavasoft•

SentinelOne•

Vendor A（AVC-PC）

•

Avast

•

Defenx•LINE•

Seqrite•Vendor B（AVC-PC）

•

AVG

•

Dr.Web

•Malwarebytes•

Sequretec•

Vendor C（AVC-PC）

•

Avira

•

Elastic•

Microsoft•

Shield Antivirus•

Vendor D（AVC-PC）•

Bitdefender•

EmsiSoft•

Microworld•

SonicWall•

Viettel Security•

BlackBerry（Cylance）

•

ESET

•

NortonLifeLock•

Sophos

•

VIPRE

•

Broadcom（Symantec）•

ESTsecurity

•

NSHC

•

Surfshark•

VMware（Carbon Black）•

BullGuard•

Exosphere•

Palo Alto•

Tabidus•Webroot•

Check Point•

Faronics

•

Panda

•

Tencent•

WithSecure•

CHOMAR•

Fortinet•

PC Pitstop•

TGSoft•Zemana

•

Cisco

•

F-Secure•

PCProtect•

ThreatBook

•

Zoner

•

ClamXav•

G DATA•

Perception-Point•

Total Defense•

Clario•Google••TotalAV•

CMC Cyber Security•

GoSecure

Private Internet AccessInc.

Trellix（McAfee）

Combo

•

Hammock

Qi-ANXIN•••

Comodo•IkarusQuick Heal

Trend Micro

•

•

•
•

Tweaking Technologies

9

Copyright © 2023 Kaspersky Lab. All rights reserved.

(合計 99社)