#'*1. >,.)>ÉŐ àbmrNsqNJbōŁÑŠŧû 1)
Photosynthetic Rhizarians
Keywords: Chlorarachniophytes; endosymbiosis; Paulinella; Rhizaria.
Shuhei Ota
Station Biologique de Roscoff
Place Georges Place Georges Tessier, 29682 Roscoff, France;:
nLn=& Cavalier-Smith (2002)¨ōōŁ%uƁ

ā¹

6ǝďÏƍǔǝĄąƍǔǝHoJQ=ǔ;²0ŜĚōŁ%uŮŸƁ;èú7 (½ 1)nLn=%¥ŮŸõ&ǝƳá%ƒĆǀÎ$47ÎŮŸƘē$42ăþ87(!'ǝBurki et al. 2007ǝ2008, 2009, Hackett
et al. 2007Ǜǝ%ųƄèø&Ǒß$ÈĢ7nLn=%È

&ƫǚĂƫǛě

%4$Ė7=jt^Ń;³72%Èǝ%łð

nLn=!°%ơļǚEnM=ơ: rhizoǡěǛ!#½Ǟ nLn=ōŁ%ŮŸǉBass et al. (2005) ;ªƃ$½ūŔ¢%1ǝProteomyxidea, Metopion
Ū%ŮŸƁ&śŔ7ĎƳ Cavalier-Smith (2009) &ÎŮŸVtR$ǝųƄǝƼ
Ū%VtR;ƃùǝŜĚōŁ%ŮŸƺ¢;ƥđƦĽĢäǝōĴĢäǝƾóÝ

&ǝCavalier-Smith (2009) $Á

ǝnLn=%ŮŸŘƀ;ū¥$ŴCavalier-Smith %ŮŸƢ$Á2)

ĚōŁ&lYJrW!^?JrW%~ÉGotd$587  lYJrW&
ǔǝ=jtfQ=%­Ɓ!ǝŜ
ŁǝƊ5#6ǝ^?JrW&ŅƂ%ĝŁǚuĦĝŁǡŻƉĝŁǜŰƉĝ

ŁǜľƉĝŁǛǝFqi=oeBmtRǚǡFqhNRǜ=oeBmtRǛǝnLn=ǝAF
NCetWǝ=dPQ=%­Ɓ

5ġú87Cavalier-Smith (2003) &ǝŅƂ%ĝŁ

4)Fqi=oeBmtR;JoU>CtR!.!16ǝCavalier-Smith (2009)&ǝnLn=;JoU>CtR%ÍÌƁ!ý73) ĎƳÂ´8ÈǀÎ$47É
ƕģÎŮŸƘē$2ǝJoU>CtRǜnLn=%¥ŮŸõ&ŸƛŘ$æ

87 (Burki et al. 2007, 2008)ǝBurki et al. (2007, 2008)

S. Ota - 1ăþ&ǝFqi=oeBm

tR&¥ŮŸ!#5ǝNWmj\_?oǜ=oeBmtRǜnLn=Ɓ!FndWĝŁǜ
]dWĝŁƁ$Ǐ74)
wǝū¥$nLn=%ŮŸŘƀ$ƙ8ǝ

ǃƓ#!&ǝnLn=&^?JrR%Đ$Ûœpeo$£ć7ŮŸƁ!ƚ

7Ŀ

7

<:%6#'*1.
<;:$1"9uĦĝŁǚŅƂ%ĝŁǛ%ƋŻm7!&â

M=\^FUn=%ųƄō;ƪļ!7BoD[ş587ǚuĦō!·*ǛuĊǝŜĚōŁ;Ɣ7!ǝ~Ħǚ

7&vĦǛōőĒ%ƋŻ;þGotd2ÈĆş587.88%ƋŻ&ǝÕ|!ō%Ÿ®%ťãǚǀŘ#Ÿ®ǝųƄµĐ%Ÿ®ǝƧŘ#Ÿ®Ǜ2Ģ
7ō!ƋŻ%ǈ%żå

w

7Keeling & Archibald (2008) &ǝĚ+ŤƏǝō+Rr_FƩƲƵ87Ńø;BoD[m%ƷƔƘ!77đƦĽ5ƋŻ$Ƈ7"%ƺ¢ĩǌ&ǐƨƥ;ǢBoD[mǣ!·,'%ō%ǀÎǝ#:ō

ǝé5&.%żå

&Ò$&ċš$#5#9!2ƴ,&ū¥$ǝÕ|%ųƄµĐ!¯ƤŘ$Ƒ7ĩǌw;ƋŻǚBoD[mǛ!ƃ7%4#ƋŻ;þnLn=ōŁ$&ǝPaulinella chromatophora !Fq
mmFYBrĝŁÐ¾7ďÏƍsĄąƍ&ǝÿǖ$4ōǚĻǒĬƌŪǛ;þ7Gotd&ƨƥ

Ð¾7

ǝ85%ō&¥ń

2ōÐ¬ƅ

71ǝ

5ǊÇ7

<<:Paulinella chromatophoraPaulinella chromatophora &HoJQ=%@qJCinř$ǔ87¨ōōŁ5įĭ¿$Ĝö7ųƄ&§èǁÐ¾ǝ

n=Řłð;È
7!

;ƏP. chromatophora &ǝųƄxǝďƉǛ!·'87ō;þďƉ&èøŘ$M=\^FUĨ

6ǝŮŸŘ$2 Synechococcus/Prochlorococcus FptX$ƀş587 (Marin et al. 2005)P. chromatophora &ǝ100 áƱ8ōŁŠŧ

ǅê 30-40 µmǝňǂƩ%ÇĪ;þÇĪ$&Ǉ«

5ŭŃƫ;ǅ=jt^Ƽ$ chromatophoreǚ

7ǝķĭ¿

ǝƳá%ōŁ%ÀǗę

wǚ1895 áǛ$ƝšŨ8!$46ǝP. chromatophora %ǕƮŘ$ƺħĎƳ Nakayama & Ishida (2009) &®úǉƹǀÎ%(! psaE

P. chromatophora %Õ|Ě$JtX87!;Â´psaE ǀÎ&ďƉ$&JtX85ǝ%!& psaE ǀÎō5Õ|Ě+ƯŤ!;ţ7%Šŧ&uĦĝŁ!_mpo#BoD[m%ņîƽťǝM=\^FUn=ōǚďƉǛ!Õ|%ǀÎpeo%Ÿ®;ţĎ%Â´

7%!&.6 P.

chromatophoraǝuĦō&ƽ©$u»ƪ

!7ÓƢ%Ç!#7¬ƅõ;ţ7ǝƉŲƄ!Õ|%ō%ťã&.Đĩǌ

7!ƃ58

6ǝ%

1ǝP. chromatophora %ďƉ&ǝBoD[m%Đƺ¢%kVo!Ǒß$ƈ¶ĸǚĎ
Ƴ%źƢ! Keeling 2010Ǜ

S. Ota - 2

<=:,.
FqmmFYBrĝŁ2HoJQ=$Ù7

ǝP. chromatophora !&ŕ#7ŮŸŘƀ$

7 (Bass et al. 2005).ǝ88%ƋŻǚƉŲǛ%ƪļ2ŕ#7¦ P.

chromatophoraǝFqmmFYB&ǝƋŻ&M=\^FUn=ǚ¨ĚōŁǛƪļrĝŁ%Ã®&ǝHoJQ=ōŁ7 (Ơ7Żƌ;ųƄ$ōŷĕBoD[m¢2%& Takahashi et al. 2007)

F q m m F Y B r ĝ Ł %  ǔ % Æ ƿ ; ū ¥ $ Ŵ      Ď  $ŗ Ɣ  8 

Chlorarachnion reptans &ǝ1930 á Geitler $4ǙŻƌŹ%ƌ!ƝƱ8%ů
50 áëǝHibberd & Norris & C. reptans %ÀǗę%šŨ$úé5&šŨ8ÀǗę;ŏĞƜ;ƏǝíĒ%ƌǔGotd!&ŕ#7łð;ƔǚHibberd & Norris
1984Ǜ%łð!&ǝ1) ƋŻ&Fqqb>o a+b ;þ!ǝ2) ƋŻ& 4 ǃƆ¼.

87!ǝ3) ƋŻµž¤Œ$ZFpBkobǚō%ŖƬĚǛ;þ!ǝ4) ŝĿ;þ#!ǝ5) Vrdr;ĥ
Ɓ&çČş58#!

7%4#èƩ%ŵ/®:;þōŁ1ǝHibberd & Norris &ĉ#ĝŁǆ!FqmmFYBr

ĝŁǆ;ƞŨ (Hibberd & Norris 1984)2009 áŉ¾ǝđĝŁ$& 7 Ù 12 Ŧ
6ǝ,ĵŎŦ%/ş58

7FqmmFYBrĝŁ%Ù&ǝ1) ap\?XïųġƸǝ2) ZFpBkob%ƀǝ3) ĘǗųƄ%R?dǚ=jt^ŃǝŊŃǝ7&ƻĲõǛ Į15
87%èƩ

ÓƂ87Ù&ǝÎŮŸ!ŞŚ#ǚOta et al. 2009;  Lotharella

Ù%/ÈŮŸǛ
đĝŁ%ĘǗųƄ&ŭŃƫ;þ=jt^Ń;³72%

ÈǝųƄÅ;þŊŃ%Ŧǝ7&ǞđǒĬ;þƻĲõ%Ŧ2ş587=jt^Ń;³7Ŧ&ǝĹ®ĘǗǚ®úǜÿǖǛ;Əǝ46ĝŁŘ#y%ŊŃųƄ+%ƺ¢%Ċ±õ;ţŮŸƁ3ǝÇĳ%ƐÚĭŌÄ+%ƾó;ţ!ô:87dmrFWrõ%ŮŸƁ#"7%4$ǝFqmmFYBrĝŁ&Ģ#ĘǗĢä;þǝİÜ¿]`RTW2ÈÛ$ĺ71ǝōĴŌǑß$ÈĢ¢7%

łðş585Çĳ¿.
7FqmmFYBrĝŁ&ƋŻµž¤ŒǚƋŻ¡Ɔ% 2 Ĕř! 3 Ĕř%ǈ%¤ŒǛ$Z
FpBkob!·'87Ě$ġƸ;þ%&ǝMcFadden et al. (1994)
iK?O

Ôǎ$ōƌ%ŖƬĚ

Ġũ$ſ×7'ǝZFpBkobI\i

ZFpBkob%ǀÎ&Éǁ

Õ|%Ě$Ť8ǝ%I\i&Ò$&ĶĨ87!ô:87 (Ơ=:3 =;:#'*1.
nLn=ōŁƁ&-!<"

ǝI\Ƙƣ8 Bigelowiellaſ×7 (Gilson et al. 2006).6ǝ
ǝ7&ĶË!ƃ585ėƉĝŁ%ƋŻ&Ò$BoD[m¢7uü%ĩǌƩ

7!Ɵċ

7ZFpBkob&èøŘ$Ě$7natans %Ã®ǝ%I\iK?O& 373 kbp .
7

ǝ8

Ĩ87%1ǝđ

6ǝƋŻ$&.ŜĚŘ#õ

& Archibald 2007)

,.&07

íÙĘǗōŁġú8

S. Ota - 3

6ǝ®úōŁ!&ǝ:

$ P. chromatophora !FqmmFYBrĝŁ%ǟGotd

ş587%/

7

wƴ%4$ǝzōŁƁ&ƋŻņîƽť%ƶ{ĩǌ$71ǝƋŻ%ņîĤġǝƺ¢;ŋƘ7w

ıř87ëǝP. chromatophora

tS$46ǝƋŻņîĤġ3%ƺ¢ÑŘŠŧ&ǝI\iǝųƄōŁÑŘ=dq

ØǇ8

!ô:87ł$ P.

chromatophora &uĦĝŁ!&_mpo#ƺ¢Ŷƭ$4M=\^FUn=;BoD[m!ņî6ǝ¢;ŋƘ7w

Ď2ƈ¶ĸUtg%u$ZFpBkobƋŻRr_FƩƲƵĤġ%Šŧ&ǝBoD[m%ĐƺǍ7Ŀ587ĎƳǝzĝŁƁ$8

7uĊFqmmFYBrĝŁ&ǝƋŻƈ¶ĸ¯Ģ#ōŁƁ!&ǝFndWĝŁ

ZFpBkob%I\iK?O;īư7Šŧ

6ǝǔƁ!$I\iK?O

ÈĢ

7!

ċ5

ş
#

$8 (Tanifuji et al. 2006ǝ

Silva et al. 2007)85%Šŧ&ǝōƌĚ%I\i%ſ×Ĥġ;Ā7ÁŢŠŧ!ǃƓ
6ǝë5$ZFpBkob%I\i"%4$Žú8!ƈ¶ĸ

Šŧ$ŗØ79.FqmmFYBrĝŁ%uŦ Lotharella amoebiformis$ǀÎÖŮšŨ8

ƵĤġ2ì$ċ5
ŘƗĿ6 (Hirakawa et al. 2008)ǝđĝŁ$5)$877ƋŻRr_FƩƲuĊǝZFpBkob%ƑĢä#"ųƄōŁÑ

5FqmmFYBrĝŁ3FndWĝŁ;Šŧ7!2òƓ8&ZFpBkob;²0ƋŻ&ǝ

7!ƃ7"%ťãŜĚōŁŘõƩ;Ĩ7%!

ƈ¶ĸŠŧUtg%ŗĿ!#6ǝō%BoD[m¢%Ĥġ;ŋƘ7!$#7!ƃ7

=<:!8
Fqi=oeBmtRƢ (Cavalier-Smith 1999) !&ǝŰƌőĒǚFqqb>o a+c R?
dǛ%ƉŲ;þ~ĦĝŁǚĻǒĬĝŁǝyŪĬĝŁǝFndWĝŁǝ]dWĝŁǛ;²0FqhNR!=oeBmtR%¥ŮŸõºǓ&ŉ¾¥ŮŸƁ2ÈĆ%ƨƥ

7!7Ƣ

:8

7Fqi=oeBmtR

6ǝƋŻ%ƺ¢ÑŘŠŧ$ǃƓ#ğƢ!#7 (ĎƳ%źƢ!& Archibald 2009, Keeling 2009, 2010)nLn=$&ŰƌőĒ%ƉŲ;þGotd&ŗƔ8
eBmtRƨƥ%ƎÞ%Ç$

5ǝǅ5nLn=&Fqi=oǝƳá%Éƕģ#ÎŮŸƘēŠŧ&ǝFqi=oeBmtRǚNWmj\_?oǜ=oeBmtRǛ!nLn=¥ŮŸ (Burki et al. 2007, 2008, 2009, Hackett et al. 2007)%!&ǝ8
BmtR%ŠŧǚŰƌƪļ%ƉŲ%ƺ¢ŠŧǛ$ƥòƓ

7!;ţ

5%Fqi=oeǝnLn=ōŁ2ƖǄ$8ƨ7!;ţ¸7(2+/Archibald, J.M. 2007. Nucleomorph genomes: structure, function, origin and evolution. BioEssays 29:392-402.
Archibald, J.M. 2009. The puzzle of plastid evolution. Curr. Biol. 19: R81-R88.
Bass, D., Moreira D., López-García P., Polet S., Chao, E.E., von der Heyden, S., Pawlowski, J. &S. Ota - 4Cavalier-Smith, T. 2005. Polyubiquitin Insertions and the Phylogeny of Cercozoa and Rhizaria.
Protist 156: 149-161.
Burki, F., Shalchian-Tabrizi, K., Minge, M., Skjaeveland, A., Nikolaev, S.I., Jakobsen, K.S. &Pawlowski, J. 2007. Phylogenomics reshuffles the eukaryotic supergroups. PLoS ONE 2:e790.
Burki, F., Shalchian-Tabrizi, K. & Pawlowski, J. 2008. Phylogenomics reveals a new ‘megagroup’including most photosynthetic eukaryotes. Biol. Lett. 4: 366-369.
Burki, F. et al. 2009. Large-scale phylogenomic analyses reveal that two enigmatic protist lineages,telonemia and centroheliozoa, are related to photosynthetic chromalveolates, Genome. Biol. Evol.
2009: 231-238.
Cavalier-Smith, T. 1999. Principles of protein and lipid targeting in secondary symbiogenesis:
euglenoid, dinoflagellate, and sporozoan plastid origins and the eukaryote family tree. J. Eukaryot.
Microbiol. 46: 347-366.
Cavalier-Smith, T. 2002. The phagotrophic origin of eukaryotes and phylogenetic classification ofProtozoa. Int. J. Syst. Evol. Microbiol. 52: 297-354.
Cavalier-Smith, T. 2003. Protist phylogeny and the high-level classification of Protozoa. Eur. J.
Protistol. 39: 338-348.
Cavalier-Smith, T. 2009. Megaphylogeny, cell body plans, adaptive zones: causes and timing ofeukaryote basal radiations. J. Eukaryot. Microbiol. 56: 26-33.
Cavalier-Smith, T. 2010. Kingdoms Protozoa and Chromista and the eozoan root of the eukaryotictree. Biol. Lett. 6: 342-345.
Geitler, L. 1930. Ein grünes Filarplasmodium und andere neue Protisten. Arc. Protistenkd. 69:615-636.
Gilson, P.R., Su, V., Slamovits, C.H., Reith, M.E., Keeling, P.J. & McFadden, G.I. 2006. Complete
nucleotide sequence of the chlorarachniophyte nucleomorph: nature’s smallest nucleus. Proc. Natl.
Acad. Sci. USA 103: 9566-9571.
Hackett, J.D., Yoon, H.S., Li, S., Reyes-Prieto, A., Rummele, S.E. & Bhattacharya, D. 2007.
Phylogenomic analysis supports the monophyly of cryptophytes and haptophytes and theassociation of rhizaria with chromalveolates. Mol. Biol. Evol. 24: 1702–1713.
Hibberd, D.J. & Norris, R.E. 1984. Cytology and ultrastructure of Chlorarachnion reptans(Chlorarachniophyta divisio nova, Chlorarachniophyceae classis nova). J. Phycol. 20: 310-330.
Hirakawa, Y., Kofuji, R. & Ishida, K. 2008. Transient transformation of a chlorarachniophyte alga,Lotharella amoebiformis (chlorarachniophyceae), with uidA and egfp reporter. J. Phycol. 44:
814-820.
Keeling, P.J. 2009. Chromalveolates and the Evolution of Plastids by Secondary Endosymbiosis. J.
Eukaryot. Microbiol. 56: 1-8.
Keeling, P.J. 2010. The endosymbiotic origin, diversification and fate of plastids. Phil. Trans. R. Soc.
B. 365: 729-748.
Keeling, P.J. & Archibald, J.M. 2008. Organelle Evolution: what's in a name? Curr. Biol. 18:

S. Ota - 5

R345-347.
Marin, B., Nowack, E.C. & Melkonian, M. 2005. A plastid in the making: evidence for a second
primary endosymbiosis. Protist 156: 425-432.
McFadden, G.I., Gilson, P.R., Hofmann, C.J., Adcock, G.J. & Maier, U.G. 1994. Evidence that an
amoeba acquired a chloroplast by retaining part of an engulfed eukaryotic alga. Proc. Natl. Acad.
Sci. USA 91: 3690-3694.
Nakayama, T. & Ishida, K. 2009. Another acquisition of a primary photosynthetic organelle isunderway in Paulinella chromatophora. Curr. Biol. 19: R284-R285.
Ota, S., Daniel, V., Le Gall, F., Yabuki, A. & Ishida, K. 2009. Partenskyella glossopodia gen. et sp.
nov., the first report of a chlorarachniophyte that lacks a pyrenoid. Protist 160: 137-150.
Silver, T.D., Koike, S., Yabuki, A., Kofuj, R., Archibald, J.M. & Ishida, K. 2007. Phylogeny andnucleomorph karyotype diversity of chlorarachniophyte algae. J. Eukaryot. Microbiol. 54:403-410.
Takahashi, F., Okabe, Y., Nakada, T., Sekimoto, H., Ito, M., Kataoka, H. & Nozaki, H. 2007. Originsof the secondary plastids of Euglenophyta and Chlorarachniophyta as revealed by an analysis of
the plastid-targeting, nuclear-encoded gene psbO. J. Phycol. 43: 1302-1309.
Tanifuji, G., Erata, M., Ishida, K., Onodera, N. & Hara, Y. 2006. Diversity of secondary
endosymbiont-derived actin-coding genes in cryptomonads and their evolutionary implications. J.
Pl. Res. 119: 205-215.
541)

ŉûÙǠDepartment of Biology, University of Oslo, P.O. Box 1066 Blindern, NO-0316, Oslo, Norway
Cavalier-Smith ŏ7lYJrWǝ^?JrW&ǌű;þGotd°ǚǔƁǛ &#ǚl
YJrW ¥ŮŸ 7!7!ǝCavalier-Smith (2010) %dqWQt=œ&ċ5 $ŮŸƁ!
#7!$ı÷ǛƠ &ǝCavalier-Smith (2010) ªŀ3)ĎƳǝCavalier-Smith (2010) &8. %ǔŮ;uǁčĉCavalier-Smith (2010) %Ů$Á !ǝNWmj\_?oǜ=oeBmtRǜnLn= 5#7Gotd; Harosa œ!
.!1ǝ8;FqhNRœ$²17.6%Ů &ǝnLn=&FqhNRœ%uF
otd!ý:874)ĎƳÂ´8 Burki et al. (2009) %ÎŮŸƘē &ǝFndWĝŁǝ]dWĝŁǝď{ñŬÊǋƍǔ 4)Uq[gǔ 5ú7Gotd%¥ŮŸõ {ťã$ăþ87! ţ8ǚctWNWmTdǡ70%ǝ}ëšŇǡ0.88Ǜé5&8;CCTH FptX!·< 75$ǝ
Burki et al. (2009) %ŮŸƘē &ǝCCTH FptX!ǝNWmj\_?oǜ=oeBmtRǜnLn=ƁǚSAR FptXǡHarosaǛ ǘŸƛŘăþ ¥ŮŸ!#7! ţ8Ơ &ǝBurkiet al. (2009) ªŀ5)ĎƳǝFqmmFYBrĝŁ$ǉ7ƋŻRr_FƩƲƵĤġ%ŠŧƥĈ Â´8
Hirakawa, Y., Nagamune, K. & Ishida, K. 2009. Protein targeting into secondary plastids ofchlorarachniophytes. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 106: 12820-12825.
Hirakawa, Y., Gile, G.H., Ota, S, Keeling, P.J. & Ishida, K. 2010. Characterization of periplastidal
compartment targeting signals in chlorarachniophytes. Mol. Biol. Evol. 27: 1538-1545.
Hirakawa Y. & Ishida K. 2010. Internal plastid-targeting signal found in a RubisCO small subunit protein ofa chlorarachniophyte alga. Plant J. (in press).

2)

S. Ota - 6