2019Ó11Ļ28Ĭ̌ŀ̗̍ŉŃÎçĀ[ BÓÙƸ2 ŉŃÎǕ{Ĥǥ$Ȟ]Ĥǥ¨$XÙʼƋô̊ɅƍʷŉŃÎĤǥǴģʺ½ʪˌģƻĚȆ

4Ë£¬ ĤǣġĞˣ̈˥̋ǯǭűɌearai@shinshu-u.ac.jp
1

http://kyoushoku.shinshu-u.ac.jp/arai/Ì¬ɍƋ¬ɍŉŃÎ¬ŏ…ĥ¬̏ƋƯɽƹ¬ŏ…ĥ¬̏ƋƯɘɔÎ¬ŏ ƋƯ̏ĥ¬ɽƹ¬ŏ ƋƯ̏ĥ¬̏ø̏Ìŗ¬ǫȩŒtíˇvǦ¬ǫȩŒtíˇvǦħ¬ɍŉŃÎ¬ŏ…ƪ$̏ǭȑ̏ȑɽƹ¬ŏ…JŬ̏Ƌŧw̏ǭȑ̏ȑ¬ǫȩŒtíˇvǦȷ¬ɍǚǒ¬ɍƎÎ¬ŏ ƋƯɽƹ¬ŏ ƋƯ̏Ìŗ

lƼȶŅ

¬ŏ…ƋƯ
ɽƹ¬ŏ…ƋƯ̏ȷŗ2ʋŃĬʼO¸ʋʽʩˆʺ1̐Ĥǥ¨$XÙʼƋô
2̐Ĥǥ¨$XÙʼɅƍ
3̐ĤǥģƻːǠʛˌȂƁ
4̐ŉŃÎĤǥǴģʺ½ʪˌģƻĚȆʜˏˋʺ31.Ĥǥ¨$XÙʼƋôʌʒǴģ¨$ʓʷʨʵʼĤǥ¨$ʖǴģ¨$ʗ̖ǴģʼƆ²Tɔʺʳʙʵʍ{ȞXʶʍʭʼǣcːǴʪˌˇʼʎɿģűƚ Ƶ÷̊JŦ÷ʞůˆˊˍˌTɔ̌J®¨$ʍɋđ¨$ʹʸ̍ʀ¿əƚąǵƚʹƤȜ̊ąǦʞůˆˊˍˌTɔ̌¨$ʹʸ̍ʁ½ƵʪˌW¶ȕĦːǴʚʯˆWƛǸʼq^ʞůˆˊˍˌTɔ
̌_?¨$ʹʸ̍̊ĤǥǴģʼģűƚ Ƶ÷ʼƨ3̊ĤǥǴģʼ®²÷̊ǐǑ÷ʼƨ3̊ĤǥǴģʼ¿ə÷ʷŬ÷ʼƨ35ʌXÙʼpƋʖÿZʼĤǥXÙʼpƋʗɿ ¥ɧşʷ±@ġɐʀaǞʁĐĝƜƣǴģʂǨǴģˁʼìÈʖÿêʼĤǥXÙʼpƋʗɿĤǥʼĪǧűʀŴéǞʼpYʁĤǥʼǧ÷̊¿ə÷ʼÀɓʂĤǥʼ Ƶ÷ʼƨ36ʌĤǥǴģʼǨpYɿĤǥǴģʼŴéǞʀĤǥǴģʼƵ÷̌ģűƚ̊°ĤƚƵ̍ʁĤǥǴģʼĪTşgʷŬgʂĤǥǴģʼǧ÷̊¿ə÷ʃĤǥǴģʼǦƉgʄĤǥǴģʼȒıȧ"7ʌĤǥ¨$ʼǣcşɡnĤǥ¨$ʼǣcşɡ̌ĪǧűŴƸ180ņʼ8̍ʒĤǥ¨$ʽʍVʺŴéʼ²ˆˌʷʤˎʺˉˋʍ¬ŏʭʼʼĤǥšɜːƾƋʨʍ¬ŏʼǋǛǗXʍĤǥȔƱʍĤƯĹʭʼʼĤńʼtĂrʿĤǥǣʼȱTtĂʺɜʪˌcːǴʙʍ ʿʺƪ$ĤǥʭʼĤǥʍ¬ǵrʿħgʺɜʪˌcːƾƋʨrʿʤˍːǴʪˌʓ8ʌĤǥɘʺ¨"ʶʟʹʙcɿĤǥʺɜʪˌcʼƾƋ̊ǴʼŃƚĪɕʺɜʪˌʤʷʀĤǥ¨$ȁY̊ȁƱʼX²ʍĢÜʺɜʪˌʤʷʁĤǥ¨$Āƾʼ¬ŏ̊ĤǥšɜʼȈǜʍÜťʺɜʪˌʤʷʂĤǥ¨$ˈʭʼĀƾʼ¬ŏƹʼǣʼ"Eʭʼʺɜʪˌʤʷ
ʃĤǥʺɜʪˌcʼƾƋ̊ǴʼƇųʼƁŖ̊Ȋ1ʺɜʪˌʤʷʄĤǥcʼƽʭʼȞ$ʼȞŰːǌˌ˂ʟɯʼȞœʺʳʙʵɘʺLƐʪˌùȀʺɜʪˌʤʷ→{ȞXʼĤǥ¨$ʞǧˊƾƋ̊Ǵʪˌñǿʞʘˌc 9ʌXÙʼƋô
ɿĤǥʼģűƚ Ƶ÷ʼƨ3 ̌←ɺɘʝˊʼƈƵ÷̍→ʒŒʼ¯þʓːƞĐʨʵǴˏˍˌĤǥʼO¸ʽʍ ƵJŦʶʘˌʤʷʞɓǿʎìʲʵʍǴģǴʼɥˇʍ6ƚʹ18UĨˈƆ²ʼGŸƚæɭ]ʝˊ
Ƶ÷ːƨ3ʪˌʤʷʞñǿʶʘˋʍ ɋđʶäǰʞÍxʦˍˌƈ"Xɺɘˁʼşɡʼɧ ːɟťʪˌʯˆʺʍƈƵšɜʯˌǴģ¨$ːǜʟʍ Ƶƚ̊¿əƚʹǴģɅːĊ3ʪˌʎʀĤǥʼǐǑ÷̊®²÷ʼƨ3̌→ʒ{ȞXʓʷʙʚùõŰ²ĪŴ̍→ĤǥʽȦʨʯĪɕʼʍ®²ƚʺǴˏˍˌʤʷʞñǿʎìʲʵʍ¡ŜʹÈ÷ʝˊɋ"ʦˍˌǼĥ¨ʼ{ȞXʺˉˋʍ¡ŜʹùȀ̊ƵːɧǅʨʯƵ̊JŦ̊üɓʹùõŰ²ːǴʙʍģƻŰ²ˈǴģɅː¡BgʪˌʤʷʶʍɘĿƚĤǥǴģʼȇƒʷʍ®²ƚʹĤǥǴģɅːvǦʺʪˌʎʁq^ŬǞ̊)Ŭǧűʼ³Ɗ̌←)ŬʼùõŰ²̆̕˕˻̈̊˝̈ˬ̇̋̅̍→Ĥǥʽʍ)ŬʺʷʲʵȱȺʶɜðʼɽʙǴģTɔʶʘˌʯˆʍ)Ŭʼù~ːȰ˄ˌʤʷʞñǿʎ ìʲʵʍ¿əƚǴģ±ʶśþʦˍˌcÆː)ŬʞĐĝƜƣʪˌʒ̆˕˻̈̊˝̈ˬ̇̋̅ʓ̌ǇǏX̍ʼǋ˅ʺˉˋʍ¿ə·ʼUĨʼ˅ʺˉˊʹʙʍÖʠ)Ŭʼù~ːsĲʨʯĤǥǴģː³Ɗʪˌʎ10ʌXÙʺ½ʪˌăUɿ̄̋˦̋˟˨˶ʼʷɧşƚ̊ƒƚʹ½ó→ɺɘʝˊƠ½ƚʺƈƵʨʵʙˌsɫʍƈƵʨʯşɡ̊¿ə÷ʞáʠʍɺɘɍÆʷʼɜ2̌Ǖ{ƚŠĨƚ½ó̍ˉˋˇʍɎɈØƢĤ¨ˈħƯơʷʼɜ2
̌6VƚƟƚ½ó̍ːɓȂʨʞʱʎʤˍʺˉˋʍˈɎɈØƢʼƩʪĪ~÷ʺìʚʤʷʺɧ ʨʍʼ³øʺóʩʯģƻːƵœʪˌò~ʞáʙʎʀȧ"ʼĀʞķĳʹùõŰ²ĪŴ̌{ȞX̍→Űǹʽ{ȞXʼ¨$$ȞʶʼĄȐːñǿʷʪˌʯˆʍȹɁʹcRƋˈǴģǴʞʶʟʫʍʝʳʍȧ"ʼĀʞıƨʎʁĤǥ¨$$ȞʼåɼgʷĤǥ¨ʼ}ȏǣg
→$ȞʽɪÑe̊Nǣʶ}ȏǣgʨʯĤǥ¨ʞĻ1̊2$ȞʶkȞʪˌƱÙʶʍ)Ŭʼù~ːsĲʨʼĤǥģƻːƵœʪˌç[ːŋʯʨʵʙʹʙʎĤǥɘ̌Ĥǥ¨$cÆ̍ʼmʹˌȽȐšɜʷʹʲʵʙˌʎ11ʌXÙʺ½ʪˌăU
ʂʒ"XʓʼĤǥ¨ʼɡƓ→ɛĖƚ)ŬǸ÷ːļʪˌʰʢʶɋđƹʺˉˌ4"ʼš$ʞʹʙ"XʼĤǥ¨ʼȀȅʽʍ)Ŭʼù~ːsĲʨʯˇʼʷʹʲʵʙʹʙʎ
ʃ¼ȞʼJɚ÷̊ȿı÷ʼƨ3→)ŬʺʷʲʵĤǥ¨$ʞʸʼˉʚʹç[ːŋʯʨʍʙʝʹˌŷbːǴʲʵʙˌʼʝʞȐƤʦˍʵʙʹʙ̌Ȟɖʼ,þ̊Jɚ̍ʎʄɪÑe¨ʺ½ʪˌɑʼ§ä÷→Ļɵ197jP̌¯IĻɵX→$ȞSÐĬĥʺóʩʯĬɵXˁ̍

12ʌXÙĢɬȘȞʼȘƁɿŷ÷gȘ̊Ĥǥ¨$ʼǋǛʼã]ǧ¨ĥ̊ɋ"ĪŴ̊$ȞɅ̍̊ɺɘʷĤǥ¨$ʼşɡTĊʼã]ǧħg̊ˡ˺̋˩̊ƌź¬ǟġĞ̍̊Ĥǥ¨$ʷĤǥɘʼɜ2ĢʀÜťȘ̊ĤǥǴģːÎŬʺˉˋȱȺʹģØʶʘˌǧű*ʼɺɘʺǜʟʍɺɘʼƟĖĀƾʶǴʪˌʎ̊Ĥǥ¨$ʼș¨$g̊Ĥǥ¼Ȟ$ʼȈǜ̌Ĥǥ¨ːˆˌ̍
ʁ"ùȈǜȘ

13ʌXÙĢɬȘȞʼȘƁɿŮÒƚǏ{a̍ǧű*{-ʺ%ʚĤǥ¨$ȁŞʼč£b̍6Vǧű*OʶʼĤǥ¨$ŗcʼɺɘɍÆˁʼưƾʀƟƚTşa̍ʝˊĪˁʼşɡʼưȟʍɜʼǙž̊Üť̌MƚʹĪTş̍b̍Ĥǥ¨$ʼşɡʼ6V¬ŏˁʼ¨ȟ
14ʌXÙĢɬȘȞʼȘƁɿɺɘʷĤǥ¨$ʷʼɜ2→ʒŬ÷ʓːļʪˌJɋXʼɺɘʷʍʒ¿ə÷ʓːļʪˌ"XʼĤǥ¨$ʼ˳̃̈ˡʀĤǥɘʷĤǥ¨ʷʼɜ2→ ʒ¿əƚĐÁ÷ʓ ːļʪˌĤǥɘʷʍʒ)ŬǏXʓʼç[ːĿèʦˍˌĤǥ¨ʼ˳̃̈ˡʁĤǥ¨$cÆʼĢɬ→ʒZ.ȰǽʓʍʒĐÁ0«*Ȫʓʺ½ʪˌ

ȘʼăU15

ʌ2014ÓʼĤǴŴĢŦʼȭĮɿĤǥʼģűƚƵ÷ʼƨ3ʀĤǥʼǐǑ÷̊®²÷ʼƨ3ʁĪĤǥǴģʺʜʢˌȧ"ʼıƨgʂȹɁʹnšƾƋ*XʼśǀʃɺɘʷʼɃğʼâgʄĪʺ½ʪˌʼɜʼȀƟʨ16ʌȔɴùȜʷŴĢŦʼȭĮɿĤǥ¨ɘʷĤǥɘʼʸʱˊʞȧ"ǡʝˏʝˋʺʠʙ→ĤǥǴģʺʜʢˌȧ"*XʼıƨgʀĤǥ¨$ʼ¼Ȟʼåɼg→Ĥǥ¨$ʼ¼Ȟʼŷ÷gʁʙʩˆƹʼɴʺ½ʨʵñʫʨˇȹɁʺ½óʶʟʵʙʹʙ
→ȹɁʹnšƾƋ*Xʼśǀʂ)ŬʼŬùʞiTʺsĲʦˍʵʙʹʙ
→ʼŬùːǸʪˌɺɘʷʼɃğʼâgʃĪĤǥǴģʺɴʞʘˌ{ʺʍʞĺǊƚʺȧ"ːŋʯʬˌˉʚʺʪˌñǿʞʘˌ→ʙʩˆʺˉˌǧũƹʞȫʟʯêʺʜʙʵˇʍQƘɟťʼʯˆʺʞĤǥ¨$ʺĐƩʶʟˌʤʷːıƨg17ʌȔɴùȜʷ½óĪŴʖŶùƁʗʌģűƚƵ÷ʼƨ3̊Ĥǥ¨$ʽʍßʟǑʟʍǴšɜ̊Ǖ{Ĥǥ$ȞʶʍɺɘʷkȞ̊ȕĦʽǴʚʞʍĺǊƚʹǴşɡʽĤǥ¨$ʺƔ3ʦˍʵʙˌʎ

18ʌXÙĢɬʼ˺˕̈ˬ
ɿĤǥɘ→ĩʒĤǥɘʓ̌Ĥǥ¨ɘʷĤǥɘːŃg̍ʼȈǜʀĤǥ¨$→Ĥǥɘˁʼ˧˖˨˛šǦʼâg+$ȞʼȿıgʁĤǥ£Ǔ→ɺɘʞĤǥʺɜʪˌʒ£Ǔʓːƻ²ʂǕ{Ĥǥ$Ȟ→IʵʼĪJK*ʺʒǕ{Ĥǥ$ȞʓːȈǜ19ɿĩʒĤǥɘʓʼȈǜ20ʀĤǥ¨$ʼšǦʼȀƟʨ→Ĥǥɘˁʼ˧˖˨˛šǦʼâgʷ$ȞʼȿıgʌĩʒĤǥɘʓʼUĨʺˉˌĤǥ¨ˁʼȹɁʹøĚ/ˈ$Ȟʼċɧʼ³ƊʌĤǥ¨ʺˉˌ˧˖˨˛šǦʼâgʼʯˆʍ̊Ĥǥ¨ʼ²ĥ̒̑̓ ʝˊʼ$Ȟʼċɧʼȗů̊Ĥǥ¨$ȁYʶ²ˆˌʷʤˎʺˉˋʍĤǥɘʞ¨"ʦˍʯcʼƾƋ̊ǴƇųːʪˌǞcʺʳʙʵȁ²ʎ
ʌ$ȞʼȿıgʼʯˆʍpYʷʨʵʍ$ȞʼȞɖː,þ̊JǸʪˌʤʷ

Ĥǥ¨$ʼ¼Ȟʼŷ÷g

21ʁĤǥʺɜʪˌʒ£Ǔʓʼƻ²→ɺɘʞʍĤǥʺɜʪˌʒ£Ǔʓːƻ²ʌ£ǓʷʽʍĤǥʼƞŝˈīƻʼőŃƚʹĪɕʎĤǥŃŴƸ17ņʺȁ²ʪˌŃƚʹĪɕːqɏʨʵ²ˆˌʎʌǕ{Ĥǥ$ȞʺʜʙʵʍɺɘʷĤǥ¨$ʞkȞ̊ȕĦːÅʠʨʍɺɘʞƻ²ʎʌɺɘrʿĤǥ¨$ʽʍƻ²ʨʯ£ǓʼʺʍʭˍʮˍʼĀƾʪˌcːǴʎĪJK*ʷʨʵʼĤǥģƻʺɜʪˌĪ~÷ʼıƨg22ʂʒǕ{Ĥǥ$ȞʓʼȈǜ

23

2.Ĥǥ¨$XÙʼɅƍ24ʌXÙĢɬʼ˺˕̈ˬ

ɿǧű*ĤǥǴģʼǕĎȧ"ǡʶʘˌɺɘʼĤǥǴģʼ'ːˉˋıƨʺʨşɡːâˆʯʤʷ̊ɺɘʞĤǥɘːȞ$|ùʶƟĖ"̊ǝEʶʟˌˉʚʺʨʯʎ
̊Ĥǥɘ"Ŀː3ÓʺƥǙʨʵɺɘʼ"Ŀ ʺĺ(ʽĤǥɘː"ʶʟˌˉʚʺʨʯʎ

25ÂÊŦʒŖȉ̕ĩĤǥ¨$XÙʓʔĤǣƧ5ʕ2019ÓĻy-11ĻyʌXÙĢɬʼ˺˕̈ˬʀɺɘʼĤǥǴģʺ½ʪˌƘȆşːâˆʍǧTʼù~ːĤǥǴģʺˉˋƟĖƚʺsĲʶʟˌˉʚʺʨʯʤʷ̊ɺɘʽʍǧTʼǠʛːĤǥ£Ǔʷʨʵƻ²ʪˌʤʷʞvǦʺʹˋʍǕ{Ĥǥ$ȞʶʽʍĤǥ£Ǔʼƻ²ʼ˃ʝʺʍĤǥņ!ʼĦ<ƹɓƁƚʺțʫ˂ʟīƻʍǔöʼ{ʺțʫ˂ʟĘǜʺʳʙʵkȞ̊ȕĦːǴʚʤʷʞʶʟˌˉʚʺʹʲʯʎ26ÂÊŦʒŖȉ̕ĩĤǥ¨$XÙʓʔĤǣƧ5ʕ2019ÓĻy-11ĻyʌXÙĢɬʼ˺˕̈ˬʁĤǥǴģʼˬ˨˶ʶʘˌĤǥɘʼ'̊şɡːĦƋʨƟʨʵĤǥǴģʼȧ"ʼıƨgːʲʯʤʷ
̊ĭĤǥ¨ɘʷĤǥɘːŃgʨʯĩʯʹȧ"ǡ̌ĩĤǥɘ̍ʷʨʍĤǥ¨$ʼ$cːǕƋʨĤǥ¨$ːǸʪˌˇʼʷʨʯʎ̊Ĥǥɘʼ'̊şɡʼâgʺ½ʨʵʍĤǥ¨ʼĤǥɘʺ½ʪˌ˧˖˨˛šǦːâgʪˌƵʝˊʍĤǥ¨ʽʍĤǥɘʺ½
ʨĤǥ¨$$Ȟʼċɧːůˆˌʤʷʞʶʟˌˉʚʺʨʍ˄ʯʍĤǥɘʽʍ¨"ʦˍʯcʼǴƇųːĤǥ¨$ʺʪˌʤ
ʷʞǞcʢˊˍʯʎ
27
ÂÊŦʒŖȉ̕ĩĤǥ¨$XÙʓʔĤǣƧ5ʕ2019ÓĻy-11ĻyʌĤǥ¨$XÙĢɬʺ˅ˌ˳̃̈ˡʼg
ʷĪʼ˳̃̈ˡ

¿ə÷ʷKɀ÷̊Ȧ÷ʼ˳̃̈ˡĤǥ¨$X ʼŮƀǒď̊Kɀ÷ːÙːǒďɓȂĤǥʼ¿ə÷ːɓȂĤǥɘːɺɘ Īʼƈǧ÷ːɓȂʞƟĖ"ʼTɔʷʼKɀ÷̊Ȧ÷ːɓȂ

Ǖ{Ĥǥ$Ȟ Īʼƈǧ÷ːɓȂʼȈǜʼTɔʷʼKɀ÷̊Ȧ÷ːɓȂʼĪˁʼ ʼŮƀǒď̊Kɀ÷ːɜʼȀƟʨ ɓȂĤǥʼ¿ə÷ːɓȂ

I*ʷʨʵʽ̊̊̊
ʋʤˍ˄ʶˉˋˇʍĪʼƈǧ÷ːɓȂʋ¿ə÷ˉˋˇʍʼTɔʷʼKɀ÷̊Ȧ÷ːɓȂŅƬǗ̌2014̍ʔĤǥ¨$Ģɬ5ʳʼ˺˕̈ˬʕ¬Sƅ̏45ɮˉˋĈǂ

2828

ʌXÙĢɬʺ½ʪˌȊ1ɿăUƚƵ̊ɺɘʺˉˌĤǥ£Ǔʼƻ²ʷɺɘµʼǕ{ĤǥĢɬːɀʨʵ³ȪƚʺɺɘʼĤǥǴģġɐʞâ˄ˋʍĤ¨ʼģƻŰ²ˈ³cǴʼşɡʞǙÂʦˍˌʎʀǤ²ƚʹƵ̊ɺɘʼĤǥǴģʺ½ʪˌƘȆşʞâgʦˍʯʞʍǴšɜʼĤ¨ʞǒďʦˍʍʒĩʓĤǥɘʼ\ȈˇƊƇȽȐʶĤǥɘʼç[ʺ£ʟʹĸʽƌʩʵʙʹʙʍĤǥ£ǓˈǕ{Ĥǥ$ȞʼkȞ̊ȕĦˇɺɘʷĤǥ¨$ʼzşɡʼƿO
ʶǴˏˍˌˇʼʶʘˋʍƊǴXÙːȰǽʨʯˇʼʶʘˌʎìʲʵʍɺɘʷĤ¨ʞʙʲʭʚʼùõƖɀːˋǧű*I*ʼÖʙȂɔʝˊǕ{ƚ̊*ǃƚʹĤǥǴģːėɄʪˌ*XʴʠˋʺȩʪˌʎʁĢŦːƗȂʪˌƵ̊ɺɘʼĤǥǴģˁʼɜâgʷĤǥ¨$XÙʼǒďʷʙʚàǘƚʹXÙĢɬʷʹʲʯʯˆʍȧ"*XʞˉˋıƨʺʹˋʍĪĤǥǴģʼɅƍʺʜʢˌȧ"ĀʞˉˋǼɨgʨŻːƌʩʦʬʯʎ29ÂÊŦʒŖȉ̕ĩĤǥ¨$XÙʓʔĤǣƧ5ʕ2019ÓĻy-11ĻyʌXÙĢɬʺ½ʪˌŖȉʼȄƁɿĤǥ£ǓʼŖȉ̊ɺɘʞƻ²ʪˌĤǥ£ǓʞĤǥ¨$ʼşɡʺÈʪˌīƻO¸ʺʸʤ˄ʶɜʪˌʝ̌ʶʟˌʝ̍ʝ̌←ĤǥǴģʼƈƵ÷̊ Ƶ÷ʼƨ3̍ʎ̊£ǓʼȭĮ̌ĤǥǴģˁʼʙʲʭʚʼŬùsĲʷīƻʼǕ{ƚėɄ̍ʺɗ˅ʵʍĤǥ£Ǔʞʸʼˉʚʹ`ŋːďʲʯʝʎʀǕ{Ĥǥ$ȞʼŖȉ̊£ǓʼkȞːɀʨʵʍĤǥīƻʼǕ{g̊*ǃgʷʙʲʭʚʼŬùsĲʷʙʚƁʶʍ
Ǖ{Ĥǥ$Ȟʞʸʼˉʚʹç[ːŋʯʨʯʝʎ̊kȞ̊ȕĦʼœʷʨʵ+ʞĂˏˍʍɺɘʷĤ¨ʼɛʶɴʞƌʩˌ.ʽʘʲʯʝʎʁĤǥ¨$ɅʷĤǥ¨ʼŷbʼŖȉ̊Ĥǥ¨$$ȞˈĤǥǴģɅˁʼŬùsĲʼâgʽʹʨʛʯʝʎ
̊¼ȞɇƱʼJɚ÷̊ȿı÷ːɽˆʍ̊Ȟ$ƹʺ½ʪˌøƘ4ʽʹʨʛʯʝʎ̊Ĥǥ¨$ʼç[ʞʘʯʝˇĤǥɘʼcǴʼ˧˖˨˛ʰʢʺƦÂgʦˍʵʙʹʙʝʎ30ÂÊŦʒŖȉ̕ĩĤǥ¨$XÙʓʔĤǣƧ5ʕ2019ÓĻy-11Ļyʌ˫̋˥ʼǉʌĤǥɘʺ"ʦˍʯǡʼÈ÷̌ɎɈØƢ̊ģÎ̑ÎƑŅ̍ʌĤǥɘʼ"āǑʟʶʼÌ¤ˈ˧˖˨˛šǦ̌ɎɈØƢ̊ģÎ̑ÎƑŅ̍ʌǕ{Ĥǥ$ȞːɀʩʯɺɘʷĤ¨ʼɃğ̌ɎɈØƢ̊ģÎ̑ÎƑŅ̍ʌǕ{Ĥǥ$ȞʶĤ¨ʷɺɘʞùȀěʪˌš$ʌ¨$$Ȟɚ=ĥʷɲÙV[{ʌÓɛ$Ȟĥ18-29ʼȁŞVÎƑŅ[{ʼėưʌÓɛ$Ȟĥ30 ɚ=ʨʵʙˌÎƑŅ[{ʼėưʌĤǥ¨$$ȞʼÓɛǕɚ=ĴɛʼÒ̌Ĵɛ̑Ó̍ʌȎǈʹ̑ǁmʹȞɖʼ,þ̌ɎɈØƢ̊ģÎʷÎƑŅ̍ʌÎƑŅȁŞVʶȀʯȎǈʹȞɖ,þʼƇųʌȎǈʹ̑ǁmʹȞɖʼJǸ̌ɎɈØƢ̊ģÎʷÎƑŅ̍ʌŁJǸÎƑŅĥʼėưʌXÙĢɬʺ½ʪˌȊ1̋ɺɘʷĤǥɘʼūȴʌXÙʼɅƍʺ½ʪˌɺɘʷĤǥɘʼȐȜʼūȴʌXÙʼ`ŋʺɜʪˌȪˁʼĤǥɘʼƺ
31ÂÊŦʒŖȉ̕ĩĤǥ¨$XÙʓʔĤǣƧ5ʕ2019ÓĻy-11ĻyʌĤǥɘʺ"ʦˍʯǡʼÈ÷̌ɎɈØƢ̊ģÎ̍ÓÙ

ǧű*ĥĤǥǴģǌɻǡ ǨǴģǌɻǡĤǥǣǌɻǡʭʼ201530

21(70.00%̍

19̌63.33%̍

6̌20.00%̍

2̌6.66%̍

201655

37̌67.27%̍

37̌67.27%̍

10̌18.18%̍

2̌3.63%̍

201764

43̌67.18%̍

41̌64.06%̍

12̌18.75%̍

2̌3.12%̍

201867

45̌67.16%̍

45̌67.16%̍

14̌20.89%̍

3̌4.47%̍

ʌĤǥɘʺ"ʦˍʯǡʼÈ÷̌ÎƑŅ̍
ÓÙ

ǧű*ĥ

ĤǥǴģǌɻǡ ǨǴģǌɻǡ Ĥǥǣǌɻǡ

ʭʼ

2015

552

394̌71.37%̍

133̌24.09%̍

364̌65.94%̍

13̌2.35%̍

2016

847

590̌69.65%̍

177̌20.89%̍

513̌60.56%̍

17̌2.00%̍

2017

1374

949̌69.06%̍

320̌23.28%̍

892̌64.91%̍

33̌2.40%̍

2018

1718

1133̌65.94%̍

362̌21.07%̍1089̌63.38%̍

33̌1.92%̍

→ìŇʝˊʼ>~̌ɎɈØƢ̊ģÎʼĤǥɘʽʍǨǴģǣSȱǡʶĤǥ¨$cÆƹʶʼĤǥǴģǌɻǡʞ¡ʙʍÎƑŅʼĤǥɘʽĤSȱʶĤǥ¨$cÆƹʶʼĤǥǴģǌɻǡʞ¡ʙ̍ʽʍgʹʨ→"ʦˍʯĤǥɘʼÈ÷ʺgʽƌʩʵʙʹʙʎħɍƯ¬ơʒĩĤǥ¨$XÙˁʼưǴʺɜʪˌȕōʓ̌2015ÓÙ-2018ÓÙ̍32ÂÊŦʒŖȉ̕ĩĤǥ¨$XÙʓʔĤǣƧ5ʕ2019ÓĻy-11ĻyʌĤǥɘʼ"āǑʟʶʼÌ¤ˈ˧˖˨˛šǦ̌ɎɈØƢ̊ģÎ̍ÓÙ

2015ÓÙ

2016ÓÙ

2017ÓÙ

2018ÓÙ

̌ȍäʼǧű*ĥ̍

30

55

6467

Ȟ$ʺʜʢˌĤǥɘ7ǻǡʺˉˌĀ4ǸıʍȪƗːǴʲʯ

1̌3.3%̍

1̌1.8%̍

1̌1.6%̍

2̌3.0%̍

Ȟ$ʺʜʢˌĤǥɘ7ǻǡʺˉˌĀ4Ǹıʼ˅ːǴʲʯ

10̌33.3%̍

14̌25.5%̍

17̌25.2%̍

17̌23.9%̍

Ȟ$ʺʜʙʵɺɘʺ
½ʪˌȪƗːǴʲʯ

3̌10.0%̍

6̌10.9%̍

8̌12.5%̍

8̌11.9%̍

Ȟ$ʺʜʙʵĀ4ǸıˈȪƗʽʹʠʍĔŰʼ˅

12̌40.0%̍

20̌36.4%̍

23̌35.9%̍

27̌40.3%̍

ʭʼ

4̌13.3%̍

14̌25.5%̍

15̌23.4%̍

14̌20.9%̍

→Ȟ$ʺĿèʦˍʯ˧˖˨˛šǦʼâgʽʘ˄ˋƨȐʶʟʹʙʎħɍƯ¬ơʒĩĤǥ¨$XÙˁʼưǴʺɜʪˌȕōʓ̌2015ÓÙ-2018ÓÙ̍ÂÊŦʒŖȉ̕ĩĤǥ¨$XÙʓʔĤǣƧ5ʕ2019ÓĻy-11Ļy 33ʌĤǥɘʼ"āǑʟʶʼÌ¤ˈ˧˖˨˛šǦ
̌ÎƑŅ̍
ÓÙ

2015ÓÙ

2016ÓÙ

2017ÓÙ

2018ÓÙ

̌ȍäʼǧű*ĥ̍

552

847

1374

1649

Ȟ$ʺʜʢˌĤǥɘ
7ǻǡʺˉˌĀ4ǸıʍȪƗːǴʲʯ

37̌6.7%̍

44̌5.2%̍

79̌5.7%̍

96̌5.8%̍

Ȟ$ʺʜʢˌĤǥɘ
7ǻǡʺˉˌĀ4Ǹıʼ˅ːǴʲʯ

94̌17.0%̍

154̌18.2%̍

252̌18.3%̍

281̌17.0%̍

Ȟ$ʺʜʙʵɺɘʺ
½ʪˌȪƗːǴʲʯ

161̌29.2%̍

241̌28.5%̍

382̌27.8%̍

494̌30.0%̍

Ȟ$ʺʜʙʵĀ4ǸıˈȪƗʽʹʠʍĔŰʼ˅

220̌39.9%̍

342̌40.4%̍

538̌39.2%̍

631̌38.3%̍

ʭʼ

40̌7.2%̍

66̌7.8%̍

123̌9.0%̍

147̌8.9%̍

→Ȟ$ʺĿèʦˍʯ˧˖˨˛šǦʼâgʽʘ˄ˋƨȐʶʟʹʙʎ
ħɍƯ¬ơʒĩĤǥ¨$XÙˁʼưǴʺɜʪˌȕōʓ̌2015ÓÙ-2018ÓÙ̍ÂÊŦʒŖȉ̕ĩĤǥ¨$XÙʓʔĤǣƧ5ʕ2019ÓĻy-11Ļy 34ʌǕ{Ĥǥ$ȞːɀʩʯɺɘʷĤ¨ʼɃğ̌ɎɈØƢ̊ģÎ̍
2016Ó

2017Ó

2018Ó

ɃğːɄˆˌʤʷʞʶʟʯ

32̌47.8%̍

35̌52.2%̍

33̌49.3%̍

ìŇʝˊʼɃğːǐǑʦʬˌʤʷʺȩʨʵʙˌ

34̌50.7%̍

32̌47.8%̍

34̌50.7%̍

þŋʽ˄ʰˏʝˊʹʙ

1̌1.5%̍ʌǕ{Ĥǥ$ȞːɀʩʯɺɘʷĤ¨ʼɃğ̌ÎƑŅ̍
2016Ó

2017Ó

2018Ó

ɃğːɄˆˌʤʷʞʶʟʯ

719̌42.4%̍

780̌45.5%̍

809̌47.1%̍

ìŇʝˊʼɃğːǐǑʦʬˌʤʷʺȩʨʵʙˌ

693̌40.9%̍

735̌42.9%̍

739̌43.1%̍

þŋʽ˄ʰˏʝˊʹʙ

284̌16.7%̍

200̌11.7%̍

169̌9.8%̍

→Ǖ{Ĥǥ$ȞʞʵʙˌʎǡʼɃğʺȩʪˌʷǠʛʵʙˌǧű*ʞ²ƱÙ«ʨħɍƯ¬ơʒĩĤǥ¨$XÙˁʼưǴʺɜʪˌȕōʓ̌2015ÓÙ-2018ÓÙ̍ÂÊŦʒŖȉ̕ĩĤǥ¨$XÙʓʔĤǣƧ5ʕ2019ÓĻy-11Ļy 35ʌǕ{Ĥǥ$ȞʶĤ¨ʷɺɘʞùȀěʪˌš$ɎɈØƢ̊ģÎ

2016Ó

2017Ó

2018Ó

Łɚ=

51̌76.1%̍

55̌82.1%̍

55̌82.1%̍

Ó1

12̌17.9%̍

10̌14.9%̍

10̌14.9%̍

Ó2

1̌1.5%̍

1̌1.5%̍Ó3

1̌1.5%̍

1̌1.5%̍Ó2-3

3̌4.5%̍Ó4

1̌1.5%̍



ÎƑŅ

2016Ó

2017Ó

2018Ó

Łɚ=

1331̌77.5%̍

1374̌80.0%̍

1403̌81.7%̍

Ó1

259̌15.1%̍

220̌12.8%̍

209̌12.2%̍

Ó2

70̌4.1%̍

57̌3.3%̍

Ó3

27̌1.6%̍

21̌1.2%̍

27̌1.6%̍

287̌1.6%̍

Ó2-3

102̌1.2%̍

Ó4

26̌1.5%̍→ɺɘʷĤ¨ʞùȀěʪˌʼ̊š$ʽžÃʍǕ{Ĥǥ$ȞːȲʺȕĦʦˍʵʙˌħɍƯ¬ơʒĩĤǥ¨$XÙˁʼưǴʺɜʪˌȕōʓ̌2015ÓÙ-2018ÓÙ̍vǦ÷ʘˋʎ36ÂÊŦʒŖȉ̕ĩĤǥ¨$XÙʓʔĤǣƧ5ʕ2019ÓĻy-11Ļyʌ¨$$Ȟɚ=ĥʷɲÙV[{ɎɈØƢ̊ģÎ

2014ÓÙɛ2015ÓÙɛ

2016ÓÙɛ2017ÓÙɛ

1-11

0.00%

0.00%

0.00%

1.50%

12-17

14.90%

11.90%

14.90%

9.00%

18-29

43.30%

44.80%

38.80%

46.30%

30

41.80%

43.30%

46.30%

43.30%

ÎƑŅ2014ÓÙɛ2015ÓÙɛ

2016ÓÙɛ2017ÓÙɛ

1-11

11.20%

12.00%

12.90%

12.30%

12-17

65.90%

68.20%

68.90%

69.30%

18-29

19.40%

16.90%

16.10%

16.10%

30

3.40%

2.90%

2.20%

2.30%



→Ǖ{Ĥǥ$Ȟʼɚ=ˁʼ½óʷʨʵʍƀ<ʼʯˆʺ$Ȟːˈʨʯǧű*ʷʍȤĊȳžʼʯˆʺžˊʨʯǧű*ʺTʎħɍƯ¬ơʒĤǥ¨$ʼƊƇʺɜʪˌȕōʓ̌2014ÓÙɛ-2018ÓÙɛ̍ÂÊŦʒŖȉ̕ĩĤǥ¨$XÙʓʔĤǣƧ5ʕ2019ÓĻy-11Ļy 37ʌÓɛ$Ȟĥ18-29ʼȁŞVÎƑŅ[{ʼėưÎƑŅȁŞ

2014ÓÙɛ2015ÓÙɛ

2016ÓÙɛ2017ÓÙɛ5,000Łſ

9.50%

4.80%

5.50%

6.40%

5,000-8,000

6.70%

6.00%

5.50%

5.60%

8,000-1.5

8.10%

9.90%

7.30%

5.90%

1.5-3

15.00%

10.30%

11.10%

11.30%

3-5

20.30%

16.30%

16.10%

15.90%

5-10

30.90%

29.00%

26.20%

25.80%

10-30

38.60%

34.30%

33.30%

33.50%

30-50

47.90%

47.90%

43.80%

51.00%

50

43.80%

50.00%

58.80%

47.10%

ʌÓɛ$Ȟĥ30 ɚ=ʨʵʙˌÎƑŅ[{ʼėưÎƑŅȁŞ2014ÓÙɛ2015ÓÙɛ

2016ÓÙɛ2017ÓÙɛ

5-10

5.00%

3.40%

2.00%

1.60%

10-30

14.20%

12.40%

10.60%

11.00%

30-50

18.80%

16.70%

8.30%

10.20%

50

25.00%

25.00%

17.60%

38
17.60%

ʌĤǥ¨$$ȞʼÓɛǕɚ=ĴɛʼÒ̌Ĵɛ̑Ó̍ǕĴɛĥ

2014ÓÙɛ2015ÓÙɛ

2016ÓÙɛ2017ÓÙɛɎɈØƢ̊ģÎ

46.9Ĵɛ

45.7Ĵɛ

42.3Ĵɛ

42.5Ĵɛ

ÎƑŅ

24.4Ĵɛ

23.5Ĵɛ

21.6Ĵɛ

21.2Ĵɛ

→ʤʤĥÓɛʍǕɚ=ĴɛʽžÃ>~ʎħɍƯ¬ơʒĤǥ¨$ʼƊƇʺɜʪˌȕōʓ̌2014ÓÙɛ-2018ÓÙɛ̍
39ÂÊŦʒŖȉ̕ĩĤǥ¨$XÙʓʔĤǣƧ5ʕ2019ÓĻy-11ĻyʌȎǈʹȞɖʼ,þ̌ɎɈØƢ̊ģÎʷÎƑŅ̍
2014ÓÙɛ2015ÓÙɛ

2016ÓÙɛ2017ÓÙɛɎɈØƢ̊ģÎ

91.00%

98.50%

97.00%

97.00%

ÎƑŅ62.20%

65.30%

66.10%

66.10%

ʌǁmʹȞɖʼ,þ̌ɎɈØƢ̊ģÎʷÎƑŅ̍
2014ÓÙɛ2015ÓÙɛ

2016ÓÙɛ2017ÓÙɛɎɈØƢ̊ģÎ

9.00%

1.50%

3.00%

3.00%

ÎƑŅ37.60%

34.60%

33.80%

33.80%→Ȟɖʼʒ,þʓʺɜʨʵʽʍŠʾʙ>~ʎħɍƯ¬ơʒĤǥ¨$ʼƊƇʺɜʪˌȕōʓ̌2014ÓÙɛ-2018ÓÙɛ̍40ÂÊŦʒŖȉ̕ĩĤǥ¨$XÙʓʔĤǣƧ5ʕ2019ÓĻy-11ĻyʌÎƑŅȁŞVʶȀʯȎǈʹȞɖ,þʼƇų
2014ÓÙɛ2015ÓÙɛ

2016ÓÙɛ2017ÓÙɛ5jŁſ

45.40%

46.70%

51.10%

50.90%

5j-8j

59.40%

56.60%

58.30%

56.50%

8j-1.5

58.10%

56.90%

57.90%

55.10%

1.5-3

53.30%

59.10%

56.80%

58.70%

3-5

66.50%

71.50%

70.70%

74.50%

5-10

70.20%

75.60%

77.00%75.80%

10-30

80.20%

85.10%

86.40%

87.00%

30-50

91.70%

95.80%

97.90%

95.90%

50

93.80%

93.80%

94.10%

94.10%

ħɍƯ¬ơʒĤǥ¨$ʼƊƇʺɜʪˌȕōʓ̌2014ÓÙɛ-2018ÓÙɛ̍
41ÂÊŦʒŖȉ̕ĩĤǥ¨$XÙʓʔĤǣƧ5ʕ2019ÓĻy-11ĻyʌȎǈʹȞɖʼJǸ̌ɎɈØƢ̊ģÎʷÎƑŅ̍
2014ÓÙɛ2015ÓÙɛ

2016ÓÙɛ2017ÓÙɛɎɈØƢ̊ģÎ

89.60%

98.50%

97.00%

94.00%

ÎƑŅ31.70%

39.50%

41.70%

42.80%

ʌǁmʹȞŚǿʼ˅JǸ̌ɎɈØƢ̊ģÎʷÎƑŅ̍
2014ÓÙɛ2015ÓÙɛ

2016ÓÙɛ2017ÓÙɛɎɈØƢ̊ģÎ

10.40%

1.50%

3.00%

6.00%

ÎƑŅ24.40%

24.40%

25.10%

26.50%→ȎǈʹȞɖʼʒJǸʓʺɜʨʵʽʍɎɈØƢ̊ģÎʽžÃ>~ʍÎƑŅʽ^>~ʎħɍƯ¬ơʒĤǥ¨$ʼƊƇʺɜʪˌȕōʓ̌2014ÓÙɛ-2018ÓÙɛ̍42ÂÊŦʒŖȉ̕ĩĤǥ¨$XÙʓʔĤǣƧ5ʕ2019ÓĻy-11ĻyʌŁJǸÎƑŅĥʼėư
2014ÓÙɛ2015ÓÙɛ

2016ÓÙɛ2017ÓÙɛ43.90%

36.10%

33.20%

30.70%

5jŁſ

60.40%

58.80%

57.30%

51.20%

5j-8j

60.60%

61.40%

55.80%

54.70%

8j-1.5

63.70%

54.30%

50.20%

45.80%

1.5-3

52.60%

41.30%

38.30%

35.30%

3-5

39.00%

25.10%

21.90%

22.20%

5-10

27.50%

16.40%

11.70%

10.30%

10-30

11.20%

6.40%

5.60%

4.00%

30-50

6.30%

1.00%

0.00%

0.00%

IÎƑŅÎƑŅȁŞV

→ŁJǸÎƑŅĥʽʍʤʤĥÓɛʽʍžÃ>~ʎħɍƯ¬ơʒĤǥ¨$ʼƊƇʺɜʪˌȕōʓ̌2014ÓÙɛ-2018ÓÙɛ̍43ÂÊŦʒŖȉ̕ĩĤǥ¨$XÙʓʔĤǣƧ5ʕ2019ÓĻy-11ĻyʌXÙĢɬʺ½ʪˌȊ1̋ɺɘʷĤǥɘʼūȴʭʚõʚʸʱˊʝʷʙʛ
ʾʭʚõʚʸʱˊʷˇʙʛʹʙʸʱˊʝʷʙʛʾʭʚõˏʹʙʭʚõˏʹʙɺɘĤǥɘɺɘĤǥ
ɘ

ɺɘĤǥɘ

ɺɘ

Ĥǥ
ɘ

ɺɘ

Ĥǥ
ɘ

ɿ§äʹXÙĢɬʶʘʲʯʷ
õʚ

18.0%

12.6%

47.6%

44.9%

24.1%

28.5%

3.5%

6.3%

1.8%

4.4%

ʀƈ"XʼĤǥɘʼşɡːˉˋâgʪ˂ʟʰʲʯʷõʚ

2.2%

2.3%

10.7%

13.9%

53.1%

50.3%

14.6%

15.7%

13.4%

14.5%

ʁ{ȞXʼĤǥ¨$ʼşɡːˉˋâgʪ˂ʟʰʲʯʷ
õʚ

1.0%

1.6%

7.1%

15.6%

58.1%

55.2%

15.9%

14.0%

12.2%

10.2%

ʂɺɘʼĤǥǴģʺɜʪˌşɡːˉˋâgʪ˂ʟʶʘʲʯʷõʚ3.0%

0.3%

15.7%

3.4%

51.1%

41.7%

12.5%

28.2%

13.0%

23.8%

ʃĤǥ¨$XÙːÜťʪ˂ʟʶʘʲʯʷõʚ0.6
%

0.9%

0.8%

1.5%

16.5%

12.7%

11.6%

10.1%

64.0%

72.3
%

→Ĥǥɘʼ˃ʚʞɺɘʼĤǥǴģʺɜʪˌşɡːʤˍʽüɓʶʘˌ˂ʟʰʷǠʛʵʙˌʎâˆˌʤʷʺ½ʨʵŅƬ˃ʝʒĩĤǥ¨$XÙʷʭʼɅƍ³ûʺɜʪˌɺɘ̊ĤǥɘʼùȜʷȊ1ʓʔň44£¬£¬ɢĤǥ¬ƧƴƯǄǿʕƸ58y̏2018Ó3ĻʌXÙʼɅƍʺ½ʪˌɺɘʷĤǥɘʼȐȜʼūȴʭʚõʚʸʱˊʝʷʙʛ
ʾʭʚõʚʸʱˊʷˇʙʛʹʙʸʱˊʝʷʙʛʾʭʚõˏʹʙ

ʭʚõˏʹʙɺɘĤǥɘɺɘĤǥɘɺɘ

ĤǥɘɺɘĤǥɘɺɘĤǥɘɿɺɘʼĤǥģƻˁʼæɭ]ʽXÙĢɬZʺū˂ʵɽ
˄ʲʯ

11.5%

6.2%

38.6%

32.9%

34.9%

33.0%

4.2%

6.9%

7.4%

16.0%

ʀɺɘĀƾʼǴģ̊ģƻɱʷĤǥǴģʼɃğʞˋ
ˈʪʙ

14.6%

6.8%

44.2%

44.7%

32.0%

35.1%

3.0%

3.6%

3.4%

5.9%

ʁĤǥɘːɺɘ"Ŀ ʺÙʽ"ʶʟˌʤʷʽʙʙʤ
ʷʰ

34.3%

22.9%

36.3%

39.3%

22.6%

24.4%

1.7%

3.8%

2.5%

4.7%

ʂɺɘʼĤǥģƻʺɜʪˌȧ"ʽĢɬZʺū˂ʵɓʙ

20.7%

7.5%

45.0%

44.0%

24.5%

34.1%

2.0%

4.0%

4.8%

6.8%ʃĩȈʼǕ{Ĥǥ$ȞʺʽùǞʞʘˌʷõʚ

32.7%

25.3%

44.8%

52.7%

16.2%

14.7%

2.0%

2.3%

2.0%

2.8%

ŅƬ˃ʝʒĩĤǥ¨$XÙʷʭʼɅƍ³ûʺɜʪˌɺɘ̊ĤǥɘʼùȜʷȊ1ʓʔň
45£¬£¬ɢĤǥ¬ƧƴƯǄǿʕƸ58y̏2018Ó3ĻʌXÙʼɅƍʺ½ʪˌɺɘʷĤǥɘʼȐȜʼūȴʭʚõʚʸʱˊʝʷʙʛ
ʾʭʚõʚʸʱˊʷˇʙʛʹʙʸʱˊʝʷʙʛʾʭʚõˏʹʙ

ʭʚõˏʹʙ

ɺɘ

Ĥǥɘ

ɺɘ

Ĥǥ
ɘ

ɺɘ

Ĥǥ
ɘ

ɺɘ

Ĥǥ
ɘ

ɺɘ

Ĥǥ
ɘ

ʄɺɘʽĤǥɘˁʼ¨"ːɀʩʵĤǥģƻʼ³Ɗːˌ
ʼʞǪʙ

17.3
%

12.2%

43.4
%

49.9%

30.6%

29.5%

3.9%

2.7%

2.2%

3.1%

ʅɺɘʽĢɬêʶʘʲʵˇĤǥģƻʺɜʪˌñǿʽʹʙ

0.9%

1.6%

4.7%

4.2%

20.4%

27.9%

24.0%

27.9%

47.4%

36.3%

ʆɺɘʽǧˊĤǥģƻʺɜʨǧű*ʼĤǥĢɬʺÅ]ʪ
ˌñǿʞʘˌ

29.1%

10.0%

40.7%

38.0%

21.4%

34.9%

4.6%

9.0%

2.1%

5.6%

ʇƊʼÎhƑŅĤǥ¨$XÙʽXÙʼȭĮʺŲʲʵšǦʨʵʙˌ

8.4%

7.5%

48.5%

52.0%

32.0%

30.7%

4.2%

3.9%

1.6%

1.6%

ʈȨǧű*ʼĤ¨XÙʽXÙʼȭĮʺŲʲʵˉʠšǦʨ
ʵʙˌ

23.2
%

16.0%

55.3%

57.7%

16.2%

20.7%

2.1%

2.2%

0.6%

0.7%

→ɺɘʼĪʞǕʩʵXÙʼɅƍʼgːǤ²ƚʺȊ1ʨʵʜˋʍǧű*ʼĤǥģƻʺ½ʪˌȧ"ːˉˋǧȃʨʍĐÁ÷ːƘĝʪˌùŤˇɽˆʵʙˌʎ→ĤǥɘʽʍɅƍʼgːǤ²ʨʳʳˇʍüɓʹ©dʷʹʲʵʙˌʎŅƬ˃ʝʒĩĤǥ¨$XÙʷʭʼɅƍ³ûʺɜʪˌɺɘ̊ĤǥɘʼùȜʷȊ1ʓʔň46£¬£¬ɢĤǥ¬ƧƴƯǄǿʕƸ58y̏2018Ó3ĻʌXÙʼ`ŋʺɜʪˌȪˁʼʒĤǥɘʓʼƺʭʚõʚʸʱˊʝʷʙʛʾʭʚõʚʸʱˊʷˇʙʛʹʙʸʱˊʝʷʙʛʾʭʚõˏʹʙʭʚõˏʹʙ

ɿĤǥʺɜʪˌƽćǷʞǴʙˈʪʠʹʲʯ

4.4

24.4

50.9

5.6

11.1

ʀǧű*OʶʼĤǥģƻʼADɰ'ʞɽ
˄ʲʯ

2.3

16.3

58.9

6.9

11.9

ʁȞ$ʶʼĤǥģƻʼȪƗʺʜʙʵɺɘʞ
ƺÞʪˌš$ʞʛʯ

0.9

7.7

39.0

15.8

33.5

ʂĤǥɘ̊Ĥǥ¨ʼœ¼Ȟʼ|ù˄ʶʼāǑʟʞ»ʺʹʲʯ

1.9

16.1

46.9

8.3

19.9

ŅƬ˃ʝʒĩĤǥ¨$XÙʷʭʼɅƍ³ûʺɜʪˌɺɘ̊ĤǥɘʼùȜʷȊ1ʓʔň47£¬£¬ɢĤǥ¬ƧƴƯǄǿʕƸ58y̏2018Ó3Ļ

3.ĤǥģƻːǠʛˌȂƁ

49ǯǭűɌʒĤǥ̊ƭƫĢɬʷXÙȈȇʼĐɕʓłŉǺǗʔĤǥǌȘʕ¬ħƪ̏2017Ó9ĻʎʌĤǥXÙʷ3ʳʼƪ$ƚƞŝʼɜ2

ʖɧ{ƚ;ɫʗ

A̍ŬƚÒƹ̌ļǦʹÎŬʼǥþ̍ʐģűƚ;ɫʑʖ6Ǟƚ;ɫʗ
B̍ƪ$ƚ`Ɖ̌ļǦʹ_?ǡʼǥþ̍

C̍ƪ$ưb̌ƪ$ƚ'ʼ~̍ʐÎƚ;ɫʑ

50
ÖƎƃÔʒȺÓʼĤǥĢɬ̌Ș̍ːʸʚ˅ˌʝʓʔĤǥĢɬʼˈˆĪʕÉŵĹ×̏2019ÓʌJĤǥʼƞƚʷĤǥĢɬːˆʡˌƁĤǥˁʼǿȗ

ģűƚ;ɫ̌Ŭƚģűʝˊʼǿů̍Îƚ;ɫ̌ȩŃÎʝˊʼǿů̍

6Ǟƚ;ɫ

ɧ{ƚ;ɫ

A̍ŬƚÒƹ̌ļǦʹÎŬʼǥþ̍
A1̍Ɉïƚ3­Ǟ̌6Ɉï̍

A2̍̄˷̃̅¡BǞ̌ÎŬɈï̍

B̍ƪ$ƚ`Ɖ̌ļǦʹ_?ǡʼǥþ̍
B1̍ǣŗƚùǞʼıƨg

B2̍¡Ŝʹƞŝ

B3̍ȋˆȸ˅ǞB̔̍*ƚ¬ǟ

B5̍˰˘̄˷̃̅ʹĢɬ̌ÎpƋ̍ B6̍ĵɆƚʺāoʙĤǥC̍ƪ$ưb̌ƪ$ƚ'ʼ~̍C1̍ȋˆȸ˅ǞC2̍*ƚ¬ǟC3̍Òƹʹš$C4̍6ʺóʩʯįĿTg51
ÖƎƃÔʒȺÓʼĤǥĢɬ̌Ș̍ːʸʚ˅ˌʝʓʔĤǥĢɬʼˈˆĪʕÉŵĹ×̏2019Ó

4.ŉŃÎĤǥǴģʺ½ʪˌģƻĚȆʌƊʼĤǥȔɴʋO ʼ¬]ȕōʼǍŋʺˉˍʾʍȺÓʍĢ>~̌TIMSSʍPISA̍ʋªʸˇʼ9[ ʞ¬ŏƌŷːřʨʙʷúʩʍ3Ƞǡʼ8[ʽǕ{ƚʺȀʵ¬ŏʺſȮ̌OɝØȕō̍ʊUĨőČˈƋƏːıƨʺƩʨʹʞˊǧTʼǠʛːȼ˂ˌʍ³ɻǍŋːTŊʨʵȅɒ̊ǠºʨʍǡʺȒıʨʯˋʪˌʊ¬ˀʤʷ̌ǧTʼUĨˈǴb̍→řʨʦ̊ùǞʍǧTʼƌʍƪ$ʴʠˋʊICTWƍĴɛʼ^→ȂȃøʷȆǱʷʼǍʿʳʟʼÏǲǧƤȃøʼùʼʍħƶʼśɂ̊O¸ːƚƨʺĒʛȓ˅ȅʠ̍ʍˡ˻˹0«ʼ̄ˡ˛ʊuʢȱʼȓĹ→ǦbƚȓĹ̌øʼƋȅʝˊʍǧTʼǠʛʼåþ̍ʊǧƂ*ɻŷb̊ħgǫǵ*ɻŷbˁʼq^ʍɅbʪˌª̑ʨʹʙªʼŘgʊŎɸĠtʼ9ˋˈľɶŢɶʷʙʲʯɶǟýʼˍʊƙŏFƷƌëʍǞcĤǥŁ5ʼ¬ɾȬɇǡƹʼÄ¬3ɦʊ ƏŇʼªʸˇˁʼ½ó̌ĢŦHƾŴʼæɭ̍ʊƆVġĞĤǥʼ½ȣč£̌ɀÑ¬ǆʺʜʢˌƘɉɦ¶6.5%ɴ̍ʊªʸˇʼȥʼƪ$ɴǧ·ÚʼǌŽø→Ʉ¬Ɖʍ¬]ʍ*ɻʼȢʝʦ̍
→6VʼĤǥƚ˯̋ˢʼĆĜ̌6ʺóʩʯĐÁʍ¬ʿƟʨʼC³ʼñǿ÷̍ Ĥ¼ƺƐʔÕƲʍÂ¬ŏʍ ¬ŏʍɽƹ¬ŏrʿƆVġĞ¬ŏʼ¬ǟĐÁǿɱƹʼĢrʿñǿʹĪƻƹ53ʺʳʙʵʕ̌Òþ28Ó12Ļ21Ĭ̍ʌ¬ɎŉŃʼƊʷêʉ¬ɎŉŃ̌¬ʿǑʢˌ˄ʱʍKʺ¬ˀ˄ʱʍţʺßʟǐʡ˄ʱ̍ʼǐǑʉʒfĎ˜˓˟ˡ˪˽ʓʼśǀ̌Òþ37Ó̍̊Òþ26Ó4Ļ̕ÎOI35h488Ƒ$ʺʒʴʠˋˣ̈˥̋ʓƘȮʉʒŉŃƅ̊4Ë˝˼́˯˪˔ˡ˛̋̅ʓʼƘÇ̊ŉŃʼƝːĊʚhJŬɹʼ¬ŏ˞˺̋ˬ̌¬ŏóĞ̍ŗːƘÇʦʬʵʍhJŬɹɘʞ˝̋˫˔˰̋˥̋ːcˆʹʞˊ³Ɗ̊ŉŃÎƪ$Ĥǥ¨$$ȞʒĚȆĹ ŉŃƅ˝˼́˯˪˔ˡ˛̋̅ˁʼĚȆʪ˂ʵʺ½ʨʵˈʦʨʠʜˇʙˈˋʺƌʟˌ£ˁʓ̌ B9Ļ30Ĭ̍ʉʒKY˫˾˛̃˟̋ʓʼ¯þ̊˄ʳˇʷªʸˇŁŇ¨$̌Â̊ ̊ɽƌ½ȣ̍̊ɩÃÓ˹̋˽ʺˉˌʒŉŃǬǡ$Ȟʓ̌£¬ƌ½ȣ̍ʉʒ˕˱˷̋˟̂̈ʓ̌\ɂ÷̍ʷʒˣ̋˵˪˔˰˨ˬʓ̌ƪ$ƚJŦ̍ʼ̊ŉŃÎªʸˇʼşWʺɜʪˌņǅ̌Òþ25Ó4Ļ̍Ƶ54

ʌêʼȘƁɿ[Ä¬ZĤǥŨɤ]ɿÕ3ɃğʷÕ3Â Ƀğ̊ˡ˥̋ˬ˓˨˶˙̄˚́̃˽ʍ10ʼ©
ʀ4ËǧƂ3ǥXÙʼŷƍ̕Ŕʼˉʚʱʛˑ
̊ɪȐƤƚǦ]ʼǥþ[ǞcĤǥŨɤ]ɿ ŐÎ ɠʺ%ʚĤƧ5şʼưȟ̊ŉŃÎĤǥħgˣ̈˥̋ʼŷƍʍɘɔƢǕ{Ĥǥˣ̈˥̋ʷʼŕ˅Tʢ̊˚˿̄˓ʺóʩʯĤƧ5*ǃʷǥþĐŝʍĐÁʼɐǜ̊ʒĤƯƹƧƴėɄĤʓʼ'ǜʢ[.]̕ɘɔÎĤǥˣ̈˥̋ʀŉŃƅ̊4Ë˝˼́˯˪˔ˡ˛̋̅ʼƘÇ̊ʒfĎ˜˓˟ˡ˪˽ʓʷʼɃb̊ʴʠˋˣ̈˥̋ˡ˥˨˵ʍJŬɹ̌Ǭā̍ʼƳŘŷƍ[.]̕¾Â¬ŏ̌ʺʤʺʤ̅̋˽̍ʍİƑÂ¬ŏ̎®phJŬɹ̎4Ë£¬[.]̕ɃğėɄ˫˔̆˛˥̋̌Ⱦǣŏɘ̊Ĥ̍55ʌêʼȘƁʀ[ǞcĤǥŨɤ]ʁƙŏ½ƻ̊ ɛĤ´̊ɊóĐÁĤ´ʷªʸˇʼġĞ̊ƠȖˡ˸̋ˡʒʽʡ̅˨˺ʓʼɃğ̊˵̄̋ˡ˛̋̅ʼȐȉȊ1ʍ˕̈˥̋ˮ˟̂ˮ̅ˡ˛̋̅[.]̕ƄȡÎƵ¹Ȁ ¬ŏʍŠŹÎƵ£Ŧ ¬ŏʍŠŹÎƵ ÊǾ ¬ŏʂªʸˇʼȥ½ƻ̊ǳè½ƻ
̊SCʍSSWʼŷƍ̌˜̋ˡ$Ȟ˻˯́˓̅̍̊ȝº̊FƷƠȖĀʷʼɃğ[.]̕ǮɔÎʼʒĤǥʓ̌Ĥǥ¨$̍ʷʒƭƫʓ̌ɺɘɍÆ̍ʼɃğ̌šśĢɬ̍ʃ ƏŇʼªʸˇʼġĞ̊ĬŃȑːŪȑʷʨʵʹʙFƷƌëġĞŗ̗̌ŉŃÎªʸˇĬŃȑĤǥˣ̈˥̋̍
̊ʒ¢ɛ ¬ʓʼÁH
ʄʙʩˆ½ƻ
̊ˡ˛̋̅̊̇˕̀̋ʼÁHʷɐǜ[.]̕ɘɔÎʼʒʦʲʷ¬Ğɣʓ

56ʌêʼȘƁʁ[ɽƹ¬ŏŨɤ]ɿʒĕƴƚʹ¬ʿʓʼġĞ[.]̕ɷƎÎʼJŬɹʺˉˌġĞ[.]̕żŮ ¬ŏʍƢ̉ ɽƹ¬ŏʍ4Ë£¬ʼɃğ̌²̍ʀƮƵ¬ŏʝˊʼġĞʼǿĽ[ǬǡġĞ]
ɿʒKY˫˾˛̃˟̋ʓʼ¯þʍǬǡʺAʨʙǶ̊¼Ȟ$ˁʼʒǬǡŌʓʼņ.g[.]̕4Ë£¬¬ƌ*CHANGEʼÖęȵʍʒJŬɹƧƴɧ$ʓˁʼq^ʍʒ:Û¾Ý&ɎÎ̊ŉŃʼ\ɂkȞ$ʓˁʼq^̊Ǭǡ˵˖ˡʼɚ=̌Ĥǥšɜ14ŏʍ¬ƌ20850̍
̊Ǭǡʺˉˌƪ$q^[.]̕ 4Ë£¬ʷŉŃÎçĀʺˉˌk?˶̇ˠ˖˛ˬʒ˄ʳˇʲʷʓʺˉˌʒ¬[ʶʳʹʞʲʵíʨʵʝʛˌ˴ˡ˺̋ˬ̌¬˴ˡ̍ʓʼÁH57ʌĤǥ¨ʺ½ʪˌĿèɿ3Ƞǡ̊)ŬʍĤǥɜ2ǡ̊*ƹʷʼȌʨ{ʙƹːɀʩʵʍļʼĤǥɴˈ˯̋ˢːēˋȫʤʨɧǅʨʍƈǧʼ£Ǔː˄ʷˆʵʙʠʤʷʀŃ£ǓːȰ˄ʛʵʍL*ƚʹģƻʼĪɕ̊#ƒƵœʷǴģǴʺɜʨʵʽʍĤǥɘ̌Ĥǥ¨$cÆ̍ʺ¨ʻʯʶʍĤǥɘ̌Ĥǥ¨$cÆ̍ʼːÎŬ̊)ŬǸʷʨʵ£ĀɽĀʝˊ˧˖˨˛ʨʍȊ1ʪˌʤʷʍģƻ̊ǴģɅˁʼƕȞƐʨƵʵƹːȹɁʺǴʚʤʷʁɺɘ̊Ȟ$̊ƪ$ʺȊ1ƹʼøƘ4ʨʍʶʼĤǥȘȞ̌Ĥǥ˵˗̋̃˽̍ːȫʨ̄̋˭ʪˌʤʷ58ʌĤǥ¨ʺ½ʪˌĿèʋʒǩtˋçʓ ̌˵˒˟̄˪̋˥̋̍ʷʨʵʼĤǥ¨ɿ˲̋˭ʹĤǥȔɴ̌¬ŏʼȈ̊īȈȈ<ʹʸ̍ʀˤ˵ˬʹĤǥȔɴ̌ŏOĶ]ʍƙŏʍFƷƌëʼ³ûʹʸ̍ʋƆļʼȔɴʼʒĆĜʓʷʒKļʓ̌äǡ÷ʷģƻ³Ǵ]̍

ʶʟˌʰʢĤǥƊʺȮːɅˀʿùȀěʼːȈʢˌʤʷʶʍƸǖʶ¦ɞʪˌĤʞĉʛˌȔɴːKļʨʍĤǥǴģʼƳŘƚġĞˁʷʳʹʣˌʎʒ¬ʿǑʢˌĤǥ¨ʓʼ³ȯ
ʒ4ɳʦˍˌĤǥǴģʓʼ³Ɗ

59ʌĤǣġĞˣ̈˥̋ʶʽʍĤǣȔƱːļʪˌ5¬ɍ(ħ¬ɍʍƋ¬ɍʍÌ¬ɍʍȷ¬ɍʍǚǒ¬ɍ)ʼĤǣĤǥːǴʲʵʙ˄ʪʎʌ¬OȚšɜˈʼĤǥɜ2ȚšɜʷɃğʨʹʞˊʍĤǣĤǥʺɜˏˌŜʏʹŗʺtˋǋˑʶʙ˄ʪʼʶʍ+ʝʘˍʾʜŭȳʺʥɃǎʠʰʦʙʎn îżǢʘˋʞʷʚʥʧʙ˄ʨʯʎn Ȫƹʺʳʙʵʽ̊̊̊

earai@shinshu-u.ac.jpʍʘˌʙʽʍ
http://kyoushoku.shinshu-u.ac.jp/arai/
ʼʒʙ{ˏʬ˵˗̋˽ʓʝˊʥɃǎʠʰʦʙʎn 24ĴɛOʺʜȻʙʯʨ˄ʪʎ

60