19 

20181012-13 %―%"








$―

#&

!


+ [+• ;4J9@I• +3DAB6
• +@I

%[+

• "5/ENSVRDAB%@I• "5/E-J@I• %+D"5/E-J&=B(• #%WMT HXJPKQL?<78@I•
E!E 'F2:J=I+E1J=I

+@I

0Z6E>C+EY)$ORUO*,Y2017;24:279-284.
GH.


1.

,.%"5 >,/';1-<

2. (
,9&1,0%<85($ "5525#4 -<5'>-<
3. 5)
5#(:'43/.:$4+=. >-<@ 5? (4+=0%3%46$!4 +=.
>70$3 ><*1A





1. 
15306427Journal for
Japanese Society for Clinical Pathway8' (1530642&#. ,*"/-&#.'  $ %+'$%!/)%-%
2.
…

'%-*&( '&.

Y1Z

.[SWURXVTH65BP&(E: G# =NK
/QA:'%H;P;P<J)2QLMI

Y2Z&([SWURXVTH65BP&(E:'%H;P;P<J)2QLMI
Y3Z3[SWURXVTH65BP! E:I?BPH GI;PMI

Q@:

Y4Z,

1[SWURXVTH65BP8HC<DI,;P<J
%G01QFBPMI

Y5Z"

7[SWURXVTH65BP$G=NK! HC<D
4BPMIE: FAD-7>OI9FBP

Y6Z5

4[SWURXVTH65BP$G=NK! Q*+%H4BPMIE: FAD-7>OI9FBP
4S'!
Q5R#HF1
ONM.C@K%(= ILK EG6# M
@K <JF-MB:K>CME,/
@K>C7D;6+P%(
G8"9E,/@K>
C7
Q,/FR
8%(G655$4 #  F-MB?A79
 8M.C@K*%(E3@K#29)M
0?B:K>CM&-Conflict of Interest: COILFZ^=-2[ 3I;\`VXJ259YBZT
cb,PWE,[ #Q [dcbJ _ [dcb^Y_[NPZ:>PaQA%TcP][NM
f 0

759\ORb34^</\IUbGJ306(26$F!,g4h8+
f6g

34^H634^).e*"\CDUbSZK

5h 34
8&\@>Q?1\`b
'eUbSZK

34fCOIg


1. #X
lvc`>CF/vu

!nita2. 'k>CV)2ZA,n& Kc`}>C5w~qrpF/vu<3svc|xwnita

3. ;9D
x>CHx ` .N.*4``>CF/`T({py9RP>CHxN{py[vL?vh69nita

4. \"B\M

8"Bx%WxYGg-w`mB_Qx^Qw"Bnit\"Bansw 8jp|x` x 8@xOUow|dm sT(tlr:Lnit\M 8a5. [v
JHV17pjvcHJHweit`|lhyJHV1gbH
JHtlvcita
E]I+0SHg$nT("B0Sxf

4=zhvc  8`pp.63-75`2017.



 1. " !#2.  3. "#
4. 
5. 

6. 
7. 
8. 
9.  

"GLJFMKI 0?4;B<7@2D?:=1
*#7&7.( 7"7" O/ !,%?89A/$ GLJFMKI@+)'>!6?5CA-3HE@N"GLJFMKI 0N2014;16(3)UTµ-.?QCeB§¯­¦°®© (®©)  PNI¢25}
;?x&v¡¨¤!0Dl}®©¨¤"!9:¢<~8Jµ eY`Z±Y`Z¢FEgQw50²¢L K3
1601QweBSRV* P®© (-.?®©) r6®© (r6®©)
 PNIvfm)tqnA¢h~®© PNI3c}Qw±
QCM.vr¢D ~-.?®©u;?x&v¡¨¤zUki¢ 1}Dl~
a@µ-.?®©44Qw (26.0²)}r6®©107Qw (63.3²)  P ~$oQw+ -.?®©19Qw40\{~r6®©±-.?®©c}®©c>/Qw Q&] O| w:7W~¨¤!9:[H ª¥«§¯©¬-.?®©4¢~¨¤"y'2:U^(y'3³33.3²´~d#µr6®©Gp-.?®©% s£NIX ~r6®
©-.?®©8¢ PQw}w:7¢Wb] O¢
_h¡ d ~;?x&4s}T¨¤zU!9:¢<m®©=,j~
1. #%.5@/<?<CC$;+92. ';
3.

-=18A)!;78A) FKIEL
JH<:4 ;2BA
"0GD< 6*,OAPA;>"0(/&<LMLN

36p.1762013.




•
•


•

&





 "% !*#( !$#

,

-


&
'.+*,)%*-#"*
•&I3*E=C,:>AM0
H+':;B9<D):(EFN
H"D5N4•

12$GEBC.HAKH+'I#O+=3@HHADL JQOLG;F/O7N4
X•

Y&HVSTVG86C3 %!RWUG
LBC$H-HQPO?N(:5N4


•

<:;<1 0!)-2" 9$, 1'87-(-$6#)&)"+
742$*7341<:;< "<:;< = <:;<9.)$-%5"+71/ 128
7-$/$#• 26$54')9
4"-9>=540&1
: ,?1@$• +84# 4"-9<;5 40&
1!-9/7$ 
>=5<;3.5:8(4-9*3?
2@:3,/%







1. 
• 
• 

2. # %&

3. "$!
4. "$!
5. 




1. *

F"'/• +E2
%# L.:>5JOPSQNR (WAM-NET) CGI2)$(&T$(&L:>5J0 V!W 314820@-0D80E>+@:2;KL193068
C75>;D50U?4J 1534L:<3

ADG6B?2ADG6B+L2
AD9H5D2,M=D8


1.  <#K.L• 1:5HEFHCJAGI$6-)3213
@%.( 91601$:$: "49@!0(@'02• #;( 24 810 M1022 5)32

7:>+8 5(7:/?*:#(DJB@&=2:,



2. 5:'•

5IH8KEAL>?X@%9H!/•* =1"-;=3&, (2 %=%)$=9)=. ONU
RPQ = VSTV% H#=. VST
VW< 4(6H#MGC>+F07BL5:'IBJD07


3. 



•

6.(&? 3 2%-:'3 "#;,/)2(C@A 3$3&?
 33; -:/7(Kruskal Wallis
+85χB 2895%1 ;0/)• 24;*/)<>=SPSS 11.5 J for Windows

,/( <>=;!


1. &.0_4IUDMECV*U,:ME6;K\^QH]J_5>
2. 3V<Ecd`bae<EE.0XV1UMQSV[
IUBMOVJ
9'/U&.0V=#E\^OW&.0V
YU+N]LREW  MAU)^TH[
I2*N]LR_8$N]!%_(ME9'/V?
@_ZPQ.0 XVRMOF&.0WEGG-C*'V'E_Q"MOF

71.


%-%•  1*•)*2

2. /0.-1,+-$2• #&"1("2• "1

*

'!2





1. $>2+0&:'
2. 3+4!'• # .00 58;0&:'• %(<'97,)*;0&:'• %3 =+-4 =/0*;0&:'3. 36= 5:
?"4

1@







1. 
2.  3.  
4.
 







1. ) / &
+$.

'-

2.  %'"!&(#$*
'&
3. '.('-',(0 /1

#9=rG%msVK~3e|4S^107(63.3) nmXjhrqdV"~dlY|4Ss44 (26.0) n3 q/hp]jhWr30,qRe|3@Qr+Iq\YlVKq ["w3dlY|4SsV~3dpY4Sq+t
S!^8_V4Sr4;1^U]jhW*#zsV
~jhi`msS!s.gfV44Kqy{ P4SV6T4SponrK~)>e?$runv|bnxV~<(7qM3dV 6rH~XaV 5~.zebn^OCmX|nJtlY|W#9=q\Yl"~dlY|4SmsVbryZp ^jl
Y|bn^:c}|WuhV26-V'6-VEFBD^Nc}l
Y|4&r ^VKn"r3^UY
nYZ?$]zwVqk_ 6rL^:c}lY|nA[|W%<@vK'qwZO6i7Wb107
(63.3) rq\nlvuhZ$ hp]
7Ww44 (26.0) r3 u1ltanl[v62.uVi3CUv-Mu`]pZOu _$z6hp]7WwZ6ht]7Wu-x
W#b;cZ7Wv7>4bYanl[,%}wZnlmdqwW#w0kjZ77Ou|~T7WZ9X7WtsrvO +Ai
fr{Z?*:uQ6hZ 9vL\eZ80}ifrbSGq\rNxp][%<@u`]p$ hp]7WqwZfv|^t b np
]frb=g[F<@!3ylZ59/Z)9/ZIJEHbRgp]7(v"bZOr$v6 bY]r]^B&a}zZuoc 9vPb=g
p]rD_[#9=tH%ouXL 3g}4U`107(63.3) poZljtsfX" fn[}4Uu44 (26.0) p3 s/jr_ljY t30,sTg}3@St+Js^[nXL s ]"x3fn[}4UuX 3fr[4Us+v
U!`8aX4Ut4;1`W_ljY*#{uXljkbouU!u.ihX44Lsz|R4UX6V4UrqptL)>g}dpyX <(7sN3fX 6tIZcX 5.{gdp`QCoZ}pKvn[}Y#9=s^[n" fn[}4UouXdtz\r `ln[}dp`:e~}Y
wjX26-X'6-XFGBD`Oe~n
?$tEP
[}4&t
`XL p" t3
`W[
p[\?$_{xX sma 6tM`:e~n[}pA]}Y• =G8BA 2N I&8OJ%6OQG8BA 2HC5D3@I R'=3I#$HCG;D5:
#$EJWUR.=D) (KITSI
RO8H>P<FF=A93VXSYUI!1HC5DJ-=D7O?3WUF 0ITS9?=M*>PFJ/OG54LA#$I 
J19.2%F:3&I+HJR,>P4
Z" [
1. 27•+)ICGL5@J>$%4)@>R
"J4LIIPK;27<K8OR•

27K T/D
E@*>

2. 

:L1T

:

FG?>

WUV

•

0K BSG>RMDOG; 
WUV<KAR•$%K=EQ (KCEHP:K.
BSG>J> M6CJ>
!:,-[APAKN#3'0&LXYXZ9:pp.25-26:2013.

•  )2$
#-)

(*',

} &0'} !%+." '} &0 '

•

(

• 

1/."
UTµ-.?QCeB§¯­¦°®© (®©)  PNI¢25}
;?x&v¡¨¤!0Dl}®©¨¤"!9:¢<~8Jµ eY`Z±Y`Z¢FEgQw50²¢L K3
1601QweBSRV* P®© (-.?®©) r6®© (r6®
©)  PNIvfm)tqnA¢h~®© PNI3c}Qw±QCM.vr¢D ~-.?®©u;?x&v¡¨¤zUki¢ 1}Dl~
a@µ-.?®©44Qw (26.0²)}r6®©107Qw (63.3²)  P 
~$oQw+ -.?®©19Qw40\{~r6®©±-.?®
©c}®©c>/Qw Q&] O| w:7W~¨¤!9:[H ª¥«§¯©¬-.?®©4¢~¨¤"y'2:U^(y'3
³33.3²´~d#µr6®©Gp-.?®©% s£NIX ~r6®©-.?®©8¢ PQw}w:7¢Wb] O¢_h¡ d ~;?x&4s}T¨¤zU!9:¢<m®©=,j~







 %,.(#-$
 +$ + $! + $,.(#)#$" + $,
*&.(#-$/'(#)#$0


 
>%#1;--"• -18<•! 

GB@DACFH• 2(<0+/*,?65?29:$E3'-1#<&
 '.)4#& 6=7%&-*4#&

 1• &• 

$

• 2 

$• #%• 
•

#%$!"'  2• #')
•



*

!!

• #')$,•  #"(%"&+•  $



1. 9E<'#A$@NKJ:<%62.  A

3. " 7

CE=4D6!73D6

4. %>:=F?:=4D6
5. (A&R$7;D%P$AILR5FEB8?4QOMGH211*/-)/.2-+,0*
1. 
2. 
3. 



=.28E$H/9<<06>+%#(H
F%#)H
F

85+61A;
8>@ :G
85+61A;
8>@

&H,7?9--

G

F 8>@- G

'HFG
B8! 7"-*@C 804-+D 39
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.

6f&Mc+lrutS)f .d$Ku+maTqr:nS(Cv}{ifeH_]qQbl\/DZpS(C>ifFf* ^uGjpSTro[W9,d )@u`XpS(C>fv}{eg%3e;=.e7ZpS(C>Tq!"uXaRdRJg )ZdR
bVdRv}{enQ Oe5.ev}{ZpS

9. (C>c<eE#urYaRW|yxueZpS
10. 6eQLIRo10QB?UdRT3AZpS
2htfkT (Cv}{if$K108'6z~wuPms]me -4EN2017;27(2):106-109.





1. 0+J0P=C8AB8A:&
2. 0IU\]ZP@ILL"
3. 0+IHFIN9H= =A;P7@I!#M?C.3
4. 

1DFI(H/>O;P%

5.  1I (P2^)D-%>OGF%
6.

E=C7(>KCP6 b1I<,_$*`c0 I<7<5I'I<c. 4XVRSYQ[TW]a2009; 9:54-59.


























  -**",+*' 4"#/ %(0
2'/ ""#"5786)$*24" / "*&*.(13 "/!

85 inqkZY,$)Y#"V&*Y#"E(MTA[Od?
%MTGRKA?
JcAQRF[MT>WB]@`EVBJLA[N?
JY-`>)V&*Y#"E(MTA[OdUM
QYU>)Y#"cY^BXAQM[MQ?
;8300:5079486<#"r !XCHa' golfpmj 1mj20
Y cM>K_X/ X.baheY XSAT+NaQ\>mjYhe VPY c_DX
NaIVVMQ?=
.(X]`Z%

1. +J$#H',J$#9*?F
5KAS4&?F:D>54=J/O3+H',J$#9*?F5KASG?CJG3+J$#R
JM6I5C?K?C4
p2, l. 18-20“$#b "I7;P) V^[
U_\Y (\Y) J! R?3>NI1 I0QPWTJ 
IE5F-@PCL3\YJWTHBJ RN8I@P<HH?
C42

2. aaaaaa

aaaaaa3. aaaaaa

aaaaaa


1. >94 A381:?+10"
9B20-&.+1'0(?
2. 4 &=804GIDC;"
4A*?$%0 2
3. A .?<3.?
4HJHA@6"FJEH5!)2#
4. '3
7K,@/="4>9