6KDUHWR&RPSDUH WKH0DQGDULQ EǷ &RPSDUDWLYHPLWFKR 0LFKDHO 芳貴 (UOHZLQH  0DVVDFKXVHWWV,QVWLWXWHRI7HFKQRORJ\:HVW&RDVW&RQIHUHQFHRQ)RUPDO/LQJXLVWLFV :&&)/  $SULO 7KH0DQGDULQ EL &RPSDUDWLYH

3DUDOOHOLVPEHWZHHQWKHWDUJHWDQGVWDQGDUG

7KHWDUJHWDQGVWDQGDUGLQWKH EǷ FRPSDUDWLYHVHHPWRH[KLELWD SDUDOOHOLVP UH
TXLUHPHQW ERWKPXVWEHRIWKHVDPHV\QWDFWLF´W\SHµ )X  +RQJ  /L
DQG7KRPSVRQ  7VDR *RDOV
7KH EǷ ⌴ FRPSDUDWLYHLVDYHU\FRPPRQFRPSDUDWLYHFRQVWUXFWLRQLQ0DQGDULQ&KLQHVHDQGWKHPRVWFRPPRQO\VWXGLHGLQWKHOLWHUDWXUH 7KH EǷ FRPSDUDWLYHIROORZVWKHVFKHPDLQ  

WDUJHW EǷ VWDQGDUG



⬊⧌



,QGHSHQGHQW'HSHQGHQF\$ FRPSDUDWLYH>; EǷ < SUHGLFDWH@LQFOXGHVERWK>; SUHGLFDWH@DQG><SUHGLFDWH@ZLWKLQLWVV\QWDFWLFGHULYDWLRQ• PRWLYDWHWKLVFODLPWKURXJK V\QWDFWLFGHSHQGHQFLHV PRYHPHQWFKDLQV EHWZHHQERWKWKHWDUJHWDQGWKHSUHGLFDWHDQGWKHVWDQGDUGDQGWKHSUHGLFDWH
LQLQWHUQDODUJXPHQWFRPSDUDWLYHV VXEMHFWUHFRQVWUXFWLRQ EqL ORQJSDVVLYHV
DQGYHUEFRS\FRQVWUXFWLRQV⃂夬ᮣ´&ODXVDOµWDUJHWDQGVWDQGDUG
⬊⧌

勿

刿

⌴ ⃂夬 勿692692㇧☧ ⶼᮣ´-RKQULGHVKRUVHVIDVWHUWKDQ0DU\ULGHVFRZVµ

0LVPDWFKHVDUHGLVDOORZHG RQO\RQHSRVVLEOHUHDGLQJ⬊⧌⌴ ⃂夬 勿㇧

勿☧ ⶼᮣ<XHKDQ EL 0DOL TL QLX TL GH NXDL
-RKQ%, 0DU\ ULGH FRZ ULGH '( IDVW
D

>⬊⧌@

⌴ >⃂夬 勿

㇧@

勿

☧ ⶼᮣ

'3692><XHKDQ@ EL >0DOL TL QLX@ >TL GH NXDL@-RKQ%, 0DU\ ULGH FRZ ULGH '( IDVW´-RKQULGHV WKLQJV IDVWHUWKDQ0DU\ULGHVFRZVµ
E

!

>⬊⧌@

⌴ >⃂夬@ >勿 ㇧

勿

☧ ⶼ@ᮣ

><XHKDQ@ EL >0DOL@ >TL QLX TL GH NXDL@-RKQ%, 0DU\ ULGH FRZ ULGH '( IDVW´-RKQULGHVFRZVIDVWHUWKDQ0DU\ULGHVFRZVµ
0DQ\WKDQNVWR1RUYLQ5LFKDUGV 'DYLG3HVHWVN\ ,UHQH+HLP &KULV.HQQHG\ -LP+XDQJ $GDP$OEULJKW+DGDV.RWHN <DVXWDGD6XGR DQGWKHDXGLHQFHDWWKH0,7 :RUNVKRSRQ&RPSDUDWLYHVIRULQYDOXDEOHGLVFXVVLRQ
DQGFRPPHQWV 7KDQNVDUHDOVRGXHWRP\PDQ\LQIRUPDQWV LQFOXGLQJ PRVWUHFHQWO\ &0/RXLV/LX 3DPHOD
3DQ &<(GZLQ7VDL DQG<LPHL;LDQJ $OOHUURUVDUHP\RZQ
,Q %KDWWDQG7DNDKDVKL·V  WHUPLQRORJ\ WKHSURSRVDOSUHVHQWHGKHUHLVD5HGXFWLRQ$QDO\VLV勿><XHKDQ TL PD@ EL >0DOL TL QLX@ TL GH NXDL-RKQULGH KRUVH %, 0DU\ ULGH FRZ ULGH '( IDVW• QRWHWKDWUHFHQWDQDO\VHV (UOHZLQH  /LQ  ;LDQJ  FDQQRWDFFXUDWHO\DFFRXQWIRUWKHVHIDFWV DQG
• LOOXVWUDWHRQHRIWZR SRWHQWLDOWHFKQLFDOLPSOHPHQWDWLRQV ZKLFKREH\,QGH
SHQGHQW'HSHQGHQF\ XVLQJPXOWLGRPLQDQFH ´VKDULQJµ  DQGVKRZKRZWKLVSURSRVDO\LHOGVDPRUHUHÀQHGFKDUDFWHUL]DWLRQRIUHVWULFWLRQVRQWKH
FRQVWUXFWLRQ㥢ᚖ´-RKQOLNHV0DU\PRUHWKDQ7RPGRHVµ• DUJXHWKDWWKHJUDGDEOHSUHGLFDWHLQD EǷ FRPSDUDWLYHPXVWEHWKHSUHGLFDWH
LQWZRFODXVHV³RQHIRUWKHWDUJHWDQGRQHIRUWKHVWDQGDUG


⌴ ᡕㄽ

'3'3

><XHKDQ@ %, >7DQJPX@ [LKXDQ 0DOL
-RKQ
EL 7RP
OLNH
0DU\

SUHGLFDWHRIFRPSDULVRQ

7RGD\, ZLOO

3KUDVDOWDUJHWDQGVWDQGDUG



'3'3





3UHYLRXVDQDO\VHV☞ &RQWUDWKH'LUHFW$QDO\VLV WKHUHFDQQRWEHRQO\RQHLQVWDQFHRIWKHSUHGLFDWH
RIFRPSDULVRQLQV\QWD[;LDQJ    (UOHZLQH  ☞ 7KHSDUDOOHOLVPUHTXLUHPHQWVREVHUYHGPD\EHH[SODLQHGE\HPSOR\LQJ +HLP·V ´GLUHFWDQDO\VLVµLQDOO EǷ FRPSDUDWLYHV

+HLP·V  'LUHFW$QDO\VLV *LYHQJUDGDEOHSUHGLFDWH f DIXQFWLRQ
IURPLQGLYLGXDOVWRGHJUHHV !HU!a, b"f " = 1 ⇐⇒ f (a) > f (b),QGHSHQGHQW'HSHQGHQF\$ FRPSDUDWLYH>; EǷ < SUHGLFDWH@LQFOXGHVERWK>; SUHGLFDWH@DQG><SUHGLFDWH@ZLWKLQLWVV\QWDFWLFGHULYDWLRQ• ,QRWKHUZRUGV ERWKWKHWDUJHW; DQGWKHVWDQGDUG< DUHLQGHSHQGHQWO\GHSHQGHQW
XSRQWKHSUHGLFDWH , ZLOOSUHVHQWHYLGHQFHIURPPRYHPHQWFKDLQVEHWZHHQ
WKHSUHGLFDWHDQGWKHWDUJHWDQGEHWZHHQWKHSUHGLFDWHDQGWKHVWDQGDUGZLWKDVKDUHGJDSZLWKLQWKHSUHGLFDWHRIFRPSDULVRQ,QD'LUHFW$QDO\VLVFRPSDUDWLYH WKHUHLVRQO\ RQHLQVWDQFHRIWKHSUHGLFDWH LQ
WKHV\QWD[ %KDWWDQG7DNDKDVKL   7KHJUDGDEOHSUHGLFDWHLVDVVRFLDWHGZLWK
WKHWDUJHWDQGVWDQGDUGRQO\YLDWKHVHPDQWLFV/LQ  • 7HFKQLFDOO\ WKLVFRXOGLQYROYHREOLJDWRU\ HOOLSVLV RU PXOWLGRPLQDQFH ,ZLOOQRWDWWHPSWWRGLVWLQJXLVKEHWZHHQWKHVHWZRDSSURDFKHVKHUH DQGZLOO
SUHVHQWRQO\DPXOWLGRPLQDQFHDQDO\VLV FI *UDFDQLQ<XNVHN   /LQ  H[WHQGVWKH'LUHFW$QDO\VLVWRDOVRDSSO\WRPXOWLSOHWRSLFFRPSDUDWLYHV


3URSRVDO ,QGHSHQGHQW'HSHQGHQF\´0XOWLSOHWRSLFFRPSDULVRQµ 7VDR  
㚳 㾒㝢

㵀 ఢ㨑

⌴㣄

ⱅ㝢

㵀 ⭨㪒

䱜㨲



>WD ]XRWLDQ ]DL [XH[LDR@ EL >ZR MLQWLDQ ]DL MLDOL@ NDL[LQ+H \HVWHUGD\ DW VFKRRO %, ,WRGD\ DW KRPH KDSS\☞ ,QWKLVVHFWLRQ, ZLOOSUHVHQWHYLGHQFHIURPYDULRXVFRQVWUXFWLRQVZKLFKLQ
YROYHPRYHPHQWVLPXOWDQHRXVO\EHWZHHQWKHSUHGLFDWHDQGWKHWDUJHWDQG
EHWZHHQWKHSUHGLFDWHDQGWKHVWDQGDUG $QDO\VHVZLWKMXVWRQHFRS\RIWKH
SUHGLFDWHLQV\QWD[FDQQRWDFFRXQWIRUVXFKGDWD´+HZDVKDSSLHU\HVWHUGD\DWVFKRROWKDQ, DPWRGD\DWKRPHµ☞ $ 'LUHFW$QDO\VLVIRUPXOWLSOHDUJXPHQWV /LQ·V EǷ ÀUVWPHUJHVZLWKWKHn DUJXPHQWV y Q , ..., y  ZKLFKIRUPWKHVWDQGDUG WKHQPHUJLQJZLWKDQ n
SODFHJUDGDEOHSUHGLFDWH WKHQPHUJLQJZLWKWKH n DUJXPHQWVRIWKHWDUJHW
xQ , ..., x 
– 6WULFWSDUDOOHOLVP ,IDOOWKH n·VDUHQ·WWKHVDPH n WKHGHULYDWLRQFUDVKHV6XPPDU\'HSHQGHQFLHVEHWZHHQWDUJHWSUHGLFDWHDQGVWDQGDUGSUHGLFDWH 6XEMHFWUHFRQVWUXFWLRQ ,QWHUQDODUJXPHQWFRPSDUDWLYHV
WDUJHW


VWDQGDUG
 EqL SDVVLYHVSUHGLFDWH
 9HUEFRS\☞ 7KHWDUJHWDQGVWDQGDUGLQD0DQGDULQ EǷ FRPSDUDWLYHH[KLELW DSDUDOOHOLVPUHTXLUHPHQW
☞ 7KHSUHYLRXVDQDO\VHVUHYLHZHGKDYHRQO\ RQHLQVWDQFHRIWKHSUHGLFDWHLQ
V\QWD[ 7KH\SXWWKHEXUGHQRIFRPSRVLQJWKHSUHGLFDWHRIFRPSDULVRQZLWK
LWVDUJXPHQWVRQ EǷ,QWKLVYLHZ WKHVXUIDFHFODXVDOVWDQGDUGV  ZRXOGDOVRKDYHWREHDUJXPHQWV VHQWHQWLDOVXEMHFWV RIWKHSUHG
LFDWHRIFRPSDULVRQ







☞ 7VDR  REVHUYHGWKDWWKHVDPHGLVWULEXWLRQDOUHVWULFWLRQVRQ,$ FRPSDUDWLYHVDOVRDSSO\WRWKH REMHFWSUHSRVLQJ FRQVWUXFWLRQ (UQVWDQG:DQJ 
3DXO  DVZHOO6XEMHFWUHFRQVWUXFWLRQZLWKGHGLFWRUHDGLQJV jOD *URV] 

5HFRQVWUXFWLRQ  RI  ERWK  WKH  WDUJHW  DQG  VWDQGDUG  LQWR  D  ORZHU  VXEMHFW  SRVLWLRQ³ZLWKLQWKHSUHGLFDWHRIFRPSDULVRQ³PXVWEHSRVVLEOH


GHUHGHGLFWRUHDGLQJV EDVHOLQH
㺲ऌ㑉

㱸⶙ㅢ

䄜

=KRQJJXRUHQ \RXNHQHQJ&KLQHVHSHUVRQ SRVVLEOH

⌴ ≲㻀㑉

㱸⶙ㅢ

䄜

䓑

E

∃ ! OLNHO\OLNHO\ ! ∃

Ӟ ⌴䂬

F

☞ 5HFRQVWUXFWLRQRI ERWKVXEMHFWV ZLWKLQWKH93XQGHUWKHVFRSHRI \RXNHQHQJPXVWEHSRVVLEOH DVVXPLQJV\QWDFWLFUHFRQVWUXFWLRQIRUWKHGHULYDWLRQRIGHGLFWRUHDGLQJV





☧ ⧝

㣄 㿦

⌴⤓

㥢ᚖ

ZR PDR EL JRX [LKXDQ, FDW EL GRJ OLNH,QW ¶, OLNHFDWVPRUHWKDQGRJV·
F·

㥢ᚖ

㣄 ■ቯ

⌴ ฝ⧨

㥢ᚖ

ZR GDLVKX EL MLKH
[LKXDQ, DOJHEUD EL JHRPHWU\ OLNH¶, OLNHDOJHEUDPRUHWKDQJHRPHWU\·

2EMHFWSUHSRVLQJFDQQRWOHDYHEHKLQGDPRQRV\OODELFYHUEZLWKJDSDOVRUHVWULFWHGLQ,$ FRPSDUDWLYHV FI FF·DERYH&RPSDUDWLYH
2EMHFWSUHSRVLQJ
㣄 ■ቯ

D·

ྜྷ

㣄 ■ቯ

⌴ ฝ⧨

ྜྷ

ZR GDLVKX EL MLKHDL
, DOJHEUD EL JHRPHWU\ ORYH
,QW ¶, ORYHDOJ PRUHWKDQJHR·,QWHUQDODUJXPHQWVLQ,$ FRPSDUDWLYHVFDQQRWEHLQGHÀQLWH
&RQWH[W ORRNLQJDWDFRXUVHOLVWLQJ㣄WD \LQJZHQ EL ZR IDZHQ VKXR GH KDR+H (QJOLVK %, , )UHQFK VSHDN '( JRRG

㑻

Ӟ ⶖㅅ

⌴ㅩ

‫ץ‬

Ӟ ⶖㅅ

㥢ᚖ

☧ ✂

>ZR VDQ JH NHPX@ EL >QL OLDQJ JH NHPX@ [LKXDQ GH GXR,WKUHH &/ FODVVHV %, \RX WZR &/ FRXUVHV OLNH'( PRUH´+HVSHDNV(QJOLVKEHWWHUWKDQ, VSHDN)UHQFKµ



㣄 ■ቯ

?

,QDGGLWLRQ SUHSRVHGREMHFWVFDQQRWEHLQGHÀQLWH 7VDR  DR  7KHVDPH
HIIHFWLVREVHUYHGZLWK,$ FRPSDUDWLYHV

,QWHUQDO$UJXPHQW ,$ FRPSDUDWLYHV 7VDR  

1RWDOOREMHFWVFDQSDUWLFLSDWHLQWKLVIUDPH >6XEM; 2EM; EǷ 6XEM< 2EM< 3UHG

E·

㥢ᚖ

ZR GDLVKX DL, DOJHEUD ORYH
,QW ¶,DOJHEUD ORYH·,QWHUQDODUJXPHQWFRPSDUDWLYHVDUHLQVWDQFHVRIREMHFWSUHSRVLQJ ZKHUHWKH
REMHFWVEDVHJHQHUDWHGDVFRPSOHPHQWVRIWKHYHUEZLWKLQWKHSUHGLFDWHRIFRPSDULVRQ WKHQPRYHWRWKHLUVXUIDFHSRVLWLRQV㶋㣄 㿦⌴ ⹼㙼 㥢ᚖ

0RUHRYHU ,$ FRPSDUDWLYHVLQDQLPDWHLQDQLPDWHRULQDQLPDWHDQLPDWHREMHFWRUGHUDUHXQLIRUPO\MXGJHGDVKHVLWDQWWRXQJUDPPDWLFDO LH WKHDQLPDF\UHVWULF
WLRQDSSOLHVHTXDOO\WRREMHFWVLQWKHWDUJHWDQGREMHFWVLQWKHVWDQGDUG,QWHUQDODUJXPHQWFRPSDUDWLYHV⌴ 㣄 ➈㢶?

ZR GDLVKX [LKXDQ, DOJHEUD OLNH¶,DOJHEUD OLNH·

D

㚳 㱊㢶

㣄 ຌ㑻

ZR =KDQJVDQ EL /LVL [LKXDQ, =6
EL /6 OLNH,QW ¶, OLNH=6 PRUHWKDQ, OLNH/6·

ZR PDR [LKXDQ, FDW OLNH,QW ¶,FDW OLNH·\LQJ ]KH JH ELVDLZLQ WKLV &/ FRPS'HUHGHUH ¶$ VSHFLÀF &KLQHVHSHUVRQLVPRUHOLNHO\WRZLQWKHUDFH
WKDQD VSHFLÀF $XVWUDOLDQ·∃ ! OLNHO\'HGLFWRGHGLFWR ¶,WLVPRUHOLNHO\WKDWD&KLQHVHSHUVRQZLOOZLQWKH
UDFHWKDQWKDWDQ$XVWUDOLDQZLOO·OLNHO\ ! ∃



D·

㥢ᚖ

ZR =KDQJVDQ [LKXDQ
, =6
OLNH
,QW ¶,=KDQJVDQ OLNH·\LQJ ]KH JH ELVDLZLQ WKLV &/ FRPSHWLWLRQ=KRQJJXRUHQ EL $R]KRXUHQ \RXNHQHQJ&KLQHVHSHUVRQ %, $XVWUDOLDQ SRVVLEOH



㣄 ຌ㑻

Ӟ ⌴䂬

&RPSDUDWLYHVJHWGHUHGHGLFWRUHDGLQJV㺲ऌ㑉$QLPDF\UHVWULFWLRQVRQREMHFWSUHSRVLQJDQG,$ FRPSDUDWLYHV&RPSDUDWLYH
2EMHFWSUHSRVLQJD䓑'HUH ¶$ VSHFLÀF &KLQHVHSHUVRQLVOLNHO\WRZLQWKHUDFH·'HGLFWR ¶,WLVOLNHO\WKDWD&KLQHVHSHUVRQZLOOZLQWKHUDFH·,QW ¶ RIWKHVHFRXUVHV ,WKUHHFRXUVHV OLNHPRUHWKDQ\RX WZRFRXUVHV·@

7KH'LUHFW$QDO\VLVRI %KDWWDQG7DNDKDVKL  ZRXOGSUHGLFWDQDV\PPHWULFHIIHFW ZKHUHRQO\WKHREMHFWLQ
WKHWDUJHWLVDQLQVWDQFHRIREMHFWSUHSRVLQJ

7KH EǷ FRPSDUDWLYHQHHGQRWKDYHDVSHFLDOPHFKDQLVPIRU,$ FRPSDUDWLYHV ,$FRPSDUDWLYHVDUHFDVHVRISDUDOOHOREMHFWSUHSRVLQJ H[SODLQLQJZK\WKHVDPH
UHVWULFWLRQVDSSO\RQERWK 7ZRLQVWDQFHVRIREMHFWSUHSRVLQJDUHLQYROYHG

7KHÁDJVKLSDQDO\VLVRIWKH EqL ORQJSDVVLYH +XDQJ  DUJXHVWKDWWKH\LQ
YROYH $PRYHPHQWRIDQRSHUDWRUWRDSRVLWLRQEHWZHHQ EqL DQGWKHDJHQW
,3

2EMHFWSUHSRVLQJLVD0DQGDULQ73LQWHUQDOWRSLF RIWHQFRQWUDVWLYH FRQVWUXFWLRQ :KHUHREMHFWSUHSRVLQJOHDYHVDJDSDIWHUDWUDQVLWLYHYHUE WKHREMHFWKDV
PRYHGIURPLWVEDVHSRVLWLRQWRWKHWRSLFSRVLWLRQ 3DXO  

'3=KDQJVDQ'HULYDWLRQRI F· 

EǷ

7

73

7RS3

SUR



7

7RS3

SUHGLFDWHDOJHEUD 1% /LQ  FOHDUO\RYHUJHQHUDWHV,$ FRPSDUDWLYHV DVKHFDQJHQHUDWHWKHP
ZLWKRXWPDNLQJXVHRIREMHFWSUHSRVLQJDQGWKXVZLWKRXWWKHSXUVXDQWUHVWULFWLRQV



⌧ ⊄⊄

⺟

☧ ⧶

ᚶ



IDWKHUVFROG ti ⌧ ⊄⊄⌴ ⌧ ஘஘

⺟

☧ 䔐

㮔

⢚

ᚶ

9HUEFRS\FRQVWUXFWLRQV´&ODXVDOµFRPSDUDWLYHVLQYROYHWZRLQVWDQFHVRIYHUEFRS\ EXWWKHUHLVRQO\
RQH´ORZHUFRS\µYLVLEOH´9HUEFRS\µFRQVWUXFWLRQV
勿 刿

勿 ☧ ⧶

ⶼᮣ

<XHKDQ TL PD TL GH KHQ NXDL-RKQULGH KRUVH ULGH '( +(1 IDVWEqL ORQJSDVVLYHVLQFRPSDUDWLYHV<XHKDQ EHL EDED PD GH KHQ FDQ-RKQ%(, IDWKHU VFROG GH YHU\ VHULRXV¶-RKQZDVVFROGHGYHU\VHULRXVO\E\KLVIDWKHU·93¶-RKQZDVVFROGHGE\KLVIDWKHUWRDGHJUHHPRUHVHULRXVWKDQE\KLV
PRWKHU·⬊⧌

7KH EqL SDVVLYHLQYROYHV $PRYHPHQWRIDQXOORSHUDWRUDERYHWKHHPEHGGHG
DJHQWSRVLWLRQIURPZLWKLQWKHSUHGLFDWH ,QFRPSDUDWLYHVDFURVVWZRGLIIHU
HQW>EqL DJHQW@V WKHRSHUDWRUPXVWPRYHWRERWKWKHWDUJHWDQGVWDQGDUGIURPZLWKLQWKHSUHGLFDWHRIFRPSDULVRQ'3<XHKDQ EHL EDED EL EHL PDPD PD GH KDL \DR JHQJ FDQ-RKQ%(, IDWKHU %, %(, PRWKHU VFROG GH HYHQ ZDQW PRUH VHULRXVJHRPHWU\

OLNH

⬊⧌

,3

´VKDULQJµWKHSUHGLFDWHRIWZR EqL ORQJSDVVLYHV⬊⧌SUHGLFDWH




9



,3

23
i





9
EqL 123

73
,

93

´-RKQULGHVKRUVHVTXLFNO\µ´&ODXVDOµFRPSDUDWLYHVDUHGHULYHGIURPWKHVHFRQVWUXFWLRQV
⬊⧌

勿 刿

⌴ ⃂夬

勿 ㇧



勿 ☧ ⶼᮣ><XHKDQ TL PD@ EL >0DOL TL QLX@ >TL GH NXDL@-RKQULGH KRUVH EL 0DU\ ULGH FRZ ULGH '( IDVW´-RKQULGHVKRUVHVIDVWHUWKDQ0DU\ULGHVFRZVµ$OOWKUHHLQVWDQFHVRIWKHYHUELQH[DPSOHVVXFKDV  PXVWPDWFKSUHFLVHO\☞ &KHQJ   +XDQJ   DUJXHWKDWWKHVHYHUEFRS\FRQVWUXFWLRQVDUH
LQGHHGGHULYHGYLDPRYHPHQWZLWKRXWGHOHWLRQ +DYLQJRQO\RQHFRS\RI
WKHSUHGLFDWHLQWKHGHULYDWLRQRI  ZRXOGEHSUREOHPDWLFD·

8QJUDPPDWLFDOGHULYDWLRQRIXQSDUDOOHOSDUVH D 
732☞ ,QWKHVHH[DPSOHV ZHVHHSDUWVRIWKHVWDQGDUGDQGWDUJHWVLPXOWDQHRXVO\PRYLQJRXWRIWKHSUHGLFDWHRIFRPSDULVRQ 7ZRKDYHPRYHGRXW EXWZH
RQO\VHHRQHEDVHSRVLWLRQ 6XFKH[DPSOHVDUHDQLPPHGLDWHGLIÀFXOW\IRU'LUHFW$QDO\VLVDSSURDFKHV EXWDUHVLPSOHLIWKHUHDUHWZRLQVWDQFHVRIWKH
SUHGLFDWHRIFRPSDULVRQLQV\QWD['HULYLQJSDUDOOHOLVP

3DUDOOHOLVPE\&26+-RKQ⌴ ⃂夬 勿

SUHGLFDWH
'(


FRZ

9

IDVW

731
EǷ

㇧

-RKQ

勿

7

SUHG ①← QRW&26+FRPSOLDQW

732
0DU\
②

7

⇒

☧ ⶼᮣ



<XHKDQ EL 0DOL TL QLX TL GH NXDL
-RKQ%, 0DU\ ULGH FRZ ULGH '( IDVW
D

>⬊⧌@

⌴ >⃂夬 勿

㇧@

勿

FRZ
☧ ⶼᮣ

><XHKDQ@ EL >0DOL TL QLX@ >TL GH NXDL@-RKQ%, 0DU\ ULGH FRZ ULGH '( IDVW´-RKQULGHV WKLQJV IDVWHUWKDQ0DU\ULGHVFRZVµ
E

!

>⬊⧌@

SUHGLFDWH
'( IDVWULGH

3DUDOOHOLVPLQDFWLRQ
⬊⧌

7

7

ULGH

5HFDOOWKDWWKHUHVHHPWREHVRPHSDUDOOHOLVPUHTXLUHPHQWVEHWZHHQWKHWDUJHW
DQGWKHVWDQGDUG


0DU\

731

&RQFOXVLRQ⌴ >⃂夬@ >勿 ㇧

勿

☧ ⶼ@ᮣ

><XHKDQ@ EL >0DOL@ >TL QLX TL GH NXDL@%, 0DU\ ULGH FRZ ULGH '( IDVW
-RKQ´-RKQULGHVFRZVIDVWHUWKDQ0DU\ULGHVFRZVµ☞ ,QGHSHQGHQW'HSHQGHQF\LWVHOIZLOOQRW\LHOGWKHVHUHVWULFWLRQV &RQVLGHU
WKHIROORZLQJ,QGHSHQGHQW'HSHQGHQF\REH\LQJVWUXFWXUHIRU D  D· 
%RWK>; SUHGLFDWH@DQG>< SUHGLFDWH@VHQWHQFHVDUHYDOLGVWUXFWXUHV PRGXORSRVLWLYHIRUPPDUNHU KėQ  1RWHWKDW732 LVDYHUEFRS\VWUXFWXUH
9

SUHG ③



'(

IDVW

ULGH



☞ 7KLVVWUXFWXUH KRZHYHU LVUXOHGRXWE\WKH&RQVWUDLQWRQ6KDULQJ &26+
*UDFDQLQ<XNVHN    DQLQGHSHQGHQWO\PRWLYDWHGFRQVWUDLQWRQPXOWLGRPLQDWHGVWUXFWXUHVDQGWKHLUOLQHDUL]DWLRQEDVHGRQWKHVWXG\RI4 4·V

4 4:KDWDQGZKHUHGRHV3HWHUVLQJ"&RQVWUDLQWRQ6KDULQJ &26+  LQIRUPDOYHU
0XOWLSOHORFDOO\KLJKHVWPRWKHUVRIHYHU\VKDUHGQRGHLQDPXOWLGRPLQDWHGVWUXFWXUHFRPSOHWHO\GRPLQDWH LGHQWLFDOVHWVRIWHUPLQDOQRGHV☞ ´ULGHµLQ D KDVWZRORFDOO\KLJKHVWPRWKHUV ① ② EXWWKH\FRPSOHWHO\GRPLQDWHGLIIHUHQWVHWVRIQRGHV ② GRPLQDWHV´FRZµZKLFK ① GRHVQRWE  RQWKHRWKHUKDQG KDVD&26+FRPSOLDQWSDUVH





D·

*UDPPDWLFDOGHULYDWLRQRISDUDOOHOSDUVH E 
732
731
0DU\
7 SUHGLFDWH-RKQ
7 SUHGLFDWH







/LQ·V  V\QWD[VHPDQWLFVUHTXLUHVWKDWWKHWDUJHWDQGWKHVWDQGDUGLQWKH EǷ
FRPSDUDWLYHEHWKHVDPHQXPEHURIDUJXPHQWVDQGDGMXQFWV&RQWH[W =KDQJVDQLVDYHU\LPSRUWDQWEXVLQHVVPDQ %RWK8636 DQG)HG([KDYH
VSHFLDOSULRULW\VHUYLFHVSHFLÀFDOO\IRU=KDQJVDQ


FRZ



FRZ

9

'(
'(



IDVW


9

ULGH

6WULFWSDUDOOHOLVPLVDQLOOXVLRQ)HG([ 8636
=KDQJVDQGD\V GD\V
HYHU\RQHHOVH GD\V GD\V

IDVW



ULGH



$QRSWLRQDOO\GLWUDQVLWLYHSUHGLFDWH EDVHOLQH
D
8636☨ 㮥⊑
⟞‫گ‬
㚅
㨳
㚅
☧ ⧶
ⶼ
8636 GH \LEDQ IXZX VRQJ [LQ VRQJ GH KHQ NXDL
8636*(1 UHJXODU VHUYLFH GHOLYHU OHWWHU GHOLYHU '( YHU\ IDVW
¶8636·VUHJXODUVHUYLFHGHOLYHUVOHWWHUVTXLFNO\·E
)HG([ ⯄ ຌ㑻
㚅
㨳
㚅
☧ ⧶
ⶼ
)HG([ JHL =KDQJVDQ VRQJ [LQ VRQJ GH KHQ NXDL
)HG([ *(, =6GHOLYHU OHWWHU GHOLYHU '( YHU\ IDVW¶)HG([GHOLYHUVOHWWHUVWR=KDQJVDQYHU\TXLFNO\·



7KHWHVW FRPSDULQJWKHWUDQVLWLYH JHQHULF ZLWKWKHGLWUDQVLWLYH
D ! )HG([ ⯄ ຌ㑻
⌴ 8636☨ 㮥⊑⟞‫گ‬㚅㨳)HG([ JHL =KDQJVDQ EL 8636 GH \LEDQ IXZX VRQJ [LQ)HG([ *(, =KDQJVDQ %, 8636*(1 UHJXODU VHUYLFH GHOLYHU OHWWHU← &26+FRPSOLDQW

731
EǷ

732

-RKQ
7

SUHGLFDWH


⇒

0DU\
7

SUHGLFDWH












'3



9

FRZ



'(

㚅

IDVW

ULGH

☞ ,QGHSHQGHQW'HSHQGHQF\DQG&26+ FDQGHULYHSDUDOOHOLVPHIIHFWV,QWXLWLYHO\ WKHSUHGLFDWHLQWKHWDUJHWFODXVHDQGLQWKHVWDQGDUGFODXVHPD\
GLIIHU VRORQJDVDQ\GLIIHULQJFRQWHQWKDYHDQLQGHSHQGHQWPHFKDQLVPE\ZKLFKWKH\FDQHVFDSHWKHREOLJDWRULO\VKDUHGSURMHFWLRQ LQSDUDOOHO LQWRWKHWDUJHWDQG
VWDQGDUG UHVSHFWLYHO\ 7KLVUHVXOWVLQWKHWLJKWSDUDOOHOLVPUHTXLUHPHQWVRE
VHUYHGDQGLVSUHFLVHO\ZKDWZHVDZLQDFWLRQLQ

E

&RPSOHWHGRPLQDQFH )R[DQG3HVHWVN\   DQRGH α FRPSOHWHO\GRPLQDWHVDQRGH β LIIHYHU\SDWKIURP β
WRWKHURRWLQFOXGHV α




☧ ⶼ

VRQJ GH NXDLGHOLYHU '( IDVW¶)HG([GHOLYHUVOHWWHUVWR=KDQJVDQIDVWHUWKDQ8636·VUHJXODUVHU
YLFHGHOLYHUVOHWWHUV LQJHQHUDO ·
7UXH LQFRQWH[W GD\VGD\V
)HG([ ⌴ 8636 ⯄ ຌ㑻
㚅
㨳
㚅
☧ ⶼ
)HG([ EL 8636 JHL =KDQJVDQ VRQJ [LQ VRQJ GH NXDL
)HG([ %, 8636 *(, =KDQJVDQ GHOLYHU OHWWHU GHOLYHU '( IDVW¶)HG([GHOLYHUVOHWWHUVWR=KDQJVDQIDVWHUWKDQ8636 GRHV>GHOLYHU
OHWWHUVWR=KDQJVDQ@·)DOVH LQFRQWH[W GD\V '< GD\V

PRGXORGHOHWLRQRI´VKDUHGµ LQFRPPRQ DUJXPHQWVDQGSUHVHQWWLPHSODFHDGMXQFWVD LVDSSURSULDWHIRUWKLVFRQWH[W EXW E LVQRW 7KLVLVEHFDXVHWKH)HG([
VHUYLFHIRU=KDQJVDQLVIDVWHUWKDQ8636·VVHUYLFHLQJHQHUDO EXWLVQRWIDVWHU
WKDQ8636·V=KDQJVDQH[SUHVVVHUYLFH 7KXV D PXVWEHLQWHUSUHWHGZLWKWKH
LQGLUHFWREMHFWRQO\LQWKHVWDQGDUG EXWQRWLQWKHWDUJHW'HULYDWLRQRI D 



&RQFOXVLRQ☞ 3UHYLRXVDQDO\VHVRIWKH0DQGDULQ EǷ FRPSDUDWLYHZKLFKV\QWDFWLFDOO\RQO\
KDYHRQHLQVWDQFHRIWKHSUHGLFDWH (UOHZLQH  /LQ  ;LDQJ  DUH
XQDEOHWRGHULYHFRPSDUDWLYHVZKLFKLQYROYHREMHFWSUHSRVLQJ VXEMHFWUHFRQVWUXFWLRQ YHUEFRS\ RUWKH EqL ORQJSDVVLYH 7KHVHH[DPSOHVSRVHD
FKDOOHQJHIRUDQ\'LUHFW$QDO\VLVDSSURDFK


73
EǷ
)HG([

7

$SSO3

=KDQJVDQ



$SSO
JHL



73
8636·V 7
UHJXODUVHUYLFH
SUHGLFDWH
GHOLYHUOHWWHUVTXLFNO\☞ /LQ  H[SOLFLWO\UXOHVRXWVXFKVWUXFWXUHVZLWKWDUJHWVDQGVWDQGDUGVRI
GLIIHULQJQXPEHUVRIDUJXPHQWV&RQFOXVLRQ• ,QGHSHQGHQW'HSHQGHQF\DQGWKHXQLYHUVDO&RQVWUDLQWRQ6KDULQJ &26+
FDQGHULYHDPRUHQXDQFHGFKDUDFWHUL]DWLRQRIWKH´SDUDOOHOLVPµHIIHFWVRE
VHUYHGEHWZHHQWDUJHWDQGVWDQGDUG
• 6WULFWSDUDOOHOLVPLVDQLOOXVLRQDQG /LQ  ZRXOGH[SOLFLWO\UXOHRXWVHQ
WHQFHVVXFKDV D ,QGHSHQGHQW'HSHQGHQF\$ FRPSDUDWLYH>; EǷ < SUHGLFDWH@LQFOXGHVERWK>; SUHGLFDWH@DQG><SUHGLFDWH@ZLWKLQLWVV\QWDFWLFGHULYDWLRQ• $ PXOWLGRPLQDQFHV\QWD[ ZDVSUHVHQWHGDVRQHRIWZRSRWHQWLDODQDO\
VHV³DQHOOLSVLVDFFRXQWDQGDPXOWLGRPLQDQFHDFFRXQW³ZKLFKREH\,Q
GHSHQGHQW'HSHQGHQF\ 7KHSURSRVDOPDGHKHUHGHULYHV DPRUHSUHFLVHFKDUDFWHUL]DWLRQRIWKH´SDUDOOHOLVPµHIIHFWVREVHUYHGEHWZHHQWKHWDUJHW
DQGVWDQGDUG

ͦ $UHWKHUHWHVWVDSSOLFDEOHWR0DQGDULQ&KLQHVHZKLFKFDQKHOSGLVWLQJXLVK
EHWZHHQWKHPXOWLGRPLQDQFHDQDO\VLVSUHVHQWHGDQGDQHOOLSVLVDFFRXQW"+RZLVWKHREOLJDWRU\VKDULQJRUHOOLSVLVHQIRUFHG"☞ 7KHDYDLODELOLW\RIPXOWLGRPLQDQFHDVDYLDEOHDOWHUQDWLYHWRHOOLSVLVIRUD
5HGXFWLRQ$QDO\VLVRIWKH0DQGDULQ EǷ FRPSDUDWLYHSURYRNHVUHHYDOXDWLRQRIWKHSUHYLRXVOLWHUDWXUHRQHOOLSVLVYHUVXVGLUHFWDQDO\VHVRIFRPSDUDWLYHV
LQRWKHUODQJXDJHV

5HIHUHQFHV%KDWW 5DMHVK DQG6KRLFKL7DNDKDVKL 5HGXFHGDQGXQUHGXFHGSKUDVDOFRPSDUDWLYHV 1DWXUDO/DQJXDJH /LQJXLVWLF7KHRU\ &KHQJ /LVD/DL6KHQ 9HUEFRS\LQJLQPDQGDULQFKLQHVH ,Q 7KHFRS\WKHRU\
RIPRYHPHQW HG1RUEHUW&RUYHUDQG-DLUR1XQHV-RKQ%HQMDPLQV3XEOLVKLQJ&RPSDQ\(UOHZLQH 0LFKDHO <RVKLWDND $ QHZV\QWD[VHPDQWLFVIRUWKH0DQGDULQEL FRPSDUDWLYH 0DVWHU·VWKHVLV 8QLYHUVLW\RI&KLFDJR 85/ IUUQNJUDIP
DPNBDBEFNJDFSMFXJOFUIFTJTQEG
(UQVW 7KRPDV DQG&KHQJFKL:DQJ 2EMHFWSUHSRVLQJLQ0DQGDULQ&KL
QHVH -RXUQDORI(DVW$VLDQ/LQJXLVWLFV ²)R[ 'DQQ\ DQG'DYLG3HVHWVN\ &\FOLFOLQHDUL]DWLRQRIV\QWDFWLFVWUXFWXUH
7KHRUHWLFDO/LQJXLVWLFV )X <L&KLQ &RPSDUDWLYHVWUXFWXUHVLQ(QJOLVKDQG0DQGDULQ&KLQHVH'RFWRUDO'LVVHUWDWLRQ 8QLYHUVLW\RI0LFKLJDQ0LFKDHO<RVKLWDND(UOHZLQH
0DVVDFKXVHWWV,QVWLWXWHRI7HFKQRORJ\
0DVVDFKXVHWWV$YHQXH'&DPEULGJH 0$ 86$
NJUDIP!NJUDIPDPN*UDFDQLQ<XNVHN 0DUWLQD $ERXWVKDULQJ 'RFWRUDO'LVVHUWDWLRQ 0DVVDFKXVHWWV,QVWLWXWHRI7HFKQRORJ\*UDFDQLQ<XNVHN 0DUWLQD :KDWDQGZK\FDQ·WEHVKDUHG $SULO
*URV] 3DWULFN 0RYHPHQWDQGDJUHHPHQWLQULJKWQRGHUDLVLQJFRQVWUXFWLRQV 0DVVDFKXVHWWV,QVWLWXWHRI7HFKQRORJ\+HLP ,UHQH  
1RWHV  RQ  FRPSDUDWLYHV  DQG  UHODWHG  PDWWHUV85/
IUUQTFNBOUJDTBSDIJWFOFU"SDIJWF[D;K:.$PNQBSBUJWFTQEGPDQXVFULSW+RQJ :HLPHL ⨃ԃよ  &RPSDUDWLYHVWUXFWXUHLQ0DQGDULQ&KLQHVH 0DVWHU·VWKHVLV 1DWLRQDO7VLQJ+XD8QLYHUVLW\+XDQJ &KHQJ7HK -DPHV :RSDRGHNXDL DQG&KLQHVHSKUDVHVWUXFWXUH/DQJXDJH ²+XDQJ &KHQJ7HK -DPHV &KLQHVHSDVVLYHVLQFRPSDUDWLYHSHUVSHFWLYH
7VLQJ+XD-RXUQDORI&KLQHVH6WXGLHV ² 85/ IUUQXXXQFPQMFGBTIBSWBSEFEV_DUKIVBOHNZ@QBQFSTQBTTJWFTQEG
/L &KDUOHV 1 DQG6DQGUD $7KRPSVRQ 0DQGDULQ&KLQHVH $ IXQFWLRQDOUHIHUHQFHJUDPPDU 8QLYHUVLW\RI&DOLIRUQLD3UHVV/LQ -RZDQJ &KLQHVHFRPSDUDWLYHVDQGWKHLULPSOLFDWLRQDOSDUDPHWHUV1DWXUDO/DQJXDJH6HPDQWLFV ²
3DXO :DOWUDXG 6HQWHQFHLQWHUQDOWRSLFVLQ0DQGDULQ&KLQHVH WKHFDVHRI
REMHFWSUHSRVLQJ /DQJXDJHDQG/LQJXLVWLFV ²
7VDR )HQJIX &RPSDULVRQLQ&KLQHVH DWRSLFFRPPHQWDSSURDFK 7VLQJ+XD-RXUQDORI&KLQHVH6WXGLHV ²;LDQJ 0LQJ $ SKUDVDODQDO\VLVRI&KLQHVHFRPSDUDWLYHV ,Q &/6  85/
IUUQXXXMJOHVNEFEV_NYJBOH9JBOH$-4QEG
;LDQJ 0LQJ 6RPHWRSLFVLQFRPSDUDWLYHFRQVWUXFWLRQV 'RFWRUDO'LVVHUWDWLRQ 0LFKLJDQ6WDWH8QLYHUVLW\