ASIAN ALPINE E-NEWS
Issue No 75. September 2020C
CONTENTS
All-Afghan Team with two Women Climb
Nation's Highest Peak Noshakh 7492m of Afghanistan

Page 2 ~ 6

Himalayan Club E-Letter vol. 40

Page 7 ~ 431

All-Afghan Team, with 2 Women
Climb Nation's Highest – Peak Noshakh 7492m
The team members said they did their exercises for the trip in Panjshir, Salang and other places for one
month ahead of their journey.

Related News•

Female 30K Cycling Race Starts in Afghanistan•

Afghan Female Cyclist in France Prepares for Olympics

Fatima Sultani, an 18-year-old Afghan woman, spoke to TOLOnews and said she andcompanions reached the summit of Noshakh in the Hindu Kush mountains, which is the highest
peak in Afghanistan at 7,492 meters.

1

The group claims to be the first all-Afghan team to reach the summit.
Fatima was joined by eight other mountaineers, including two girls and six men, on the 17-day
journey.

They began the challenging trip almost a month ago from Kabul. Noshakh is located in the
Wakhan corridor in the northeastern province of Badakhshan.
“Mountaineering is a strong sport, but we can conquer the summit if we are provided the gear,”
Sultani said.The team members said they did their exercises for the trip in Panjshir, Salang
and other places for one month ahead of their journey.
“We made a plan with our friends to conquer Noshakh summit without foreign support as thefirst Afghan team,” said Ali Akbar Sakhi, head of the team.
The mountaineers said their trip posed challenge but they overcame them.
2

“The snow changed into ice after it melted. The way was slippery,” said Tahira Sultani, amountaineer, referring to the hardships they experienced during their journey. They are
members of Hike Ventures, a mountaineering team that has at least 200 members. Fatima is
the youngest member of the team and was a boxer before this.

3Noshakh

Noshakh (also called Nowshak or Nōshākh; (Persian ‫ )نوشاخ‬is the second highest peak in the
Hindu Kush Range (after Tirich Mir) at 7,492 m (24,580 ft). It lies in the Wakhan corridor,
Afghanistan's Badakhshan Province. It is the highest point in Afghanistan and is the world's
westernmost 7,000 meters massif.
Noshaq main was first climbed by a Japanese expedition in 1960 led by Professor Sakato.
Other members of the expedition were Goro Iwatsubo and Toshiaki Sakai. The climb followed
the normal Pakistan approach, the southeast ridge from the Qadzi Deh Glacier. The normal
Afghanistan approach route is by the west ridge.
4Noshaq East, Noshaq Central and Noshaq West were first climbed in 1963 by Austrians Dr.
Gerald Gruber and Rudolf Pischenger.
The first winter ascent was 13 February 1973 by Tadeusz Piotrowski and Andrzej Zawada,
members of a Polish expedition, via the north face. It was the world's first winter climb of any
7000 m peak. Until now it is the only winter ascent to this summit.
Between the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan in 1979 and the fall of the Taliban in 2001, themountain was very difficult to access because of political turmoil in the region. In 2011,
National Geographic noted that the trail to the summit was again accessible to climbers, withhopes of opening the area up for tourism.
The first Afghan ascent of the mountain was in July 2009. Two members, Malang Daria andAmruddin Sanjar, of a team of four Afghans, also including Afiat Khan and Gurg Ali - whoturned around on the final stretch of their climb for health reasons - from the Wakhan Corridor
summited on July 19.
In August 2018, Hanifa Yousoufi became the first female Afghan climber to summit themountain.

5

THE HIMALAYAN CLUB

Climbing and Beyond...

THE HIMALAYAN CLUBTHE HIMALAYAN CLUB E-LETTERVOLUME 40  AUGUST 2020

Contents - Volume 40
COMMEMORATING PIONEERING CLIMBS
50th Year of first ascent of Annapurna South Face............ 02

CLIMBS, TREKS AND EXPLORATIONS
Bhagirathi IV............ 05

Mountaineering Expedition to unnamed and............ 16

unscaled peak –Harsil Horn (4880 m)
ARTICLES
Friendship Peak Speed Ascent............ 21

NEWS AND PERSONALITIESCatherine Destivelle Earns Piolets d’Or
Lifetime Achievement Award............ 26

Mount Everest: Chinese team summit during pandemic ............ 28
20 Years of Mountain Heritage Trust............ 29

Himalayan Mountaineering Institute............ 312020 Piolets d’Or Honoured Ascent............ 33

REMEMBRANCEWorld Renowned Mountaineer Martin Moran............ 35

Front Cover: Shivling from Bhagirathi IV (Arianna Colliard)THE HIMALAYAN CLUB E-LETTER VOLUME 40

Commemorating Pioneering Climbs
50th Year of first ascent of Annapurna South Face

Dougal Haston between Camp 4 and 5

The South Face of Annapurna is one of the most formidable mountainwalls in the world, with 12,000 ft of steep rock and ice leading to its
26,545 ft summit. Its ascent in the Spring of 1970 by Chris Bonington’s
expedition was a land mark in the history of mountaineering as importantas that of the original ascent of Everest, for this was the first time that
one of these huge barriers, the Himalayan equivalent – on a vaster scale– of the North Wall of the Eiger, had been conquered.
Excerpt from - Annapurna South Face by Chris Bonington.
Ed. Note : Sir Chris Bonington, C. B. E. is an Honorary Member of
The Himalayan Club2

THE HIMALAYAN CLUB E-LETTER VOLUME 40

Don Whillans (left) and Mick Burkeat base camp with the south face ofAnnapurna in the background

Martin Boysen on one of thesteepest sections of the ice ridge on
Annapurna

3

THE HIMALAYAN CLUB E-LETTER VOLUME 40

Ian Clough traversing fixed ropes on
the steepest part of the ice ridge on thesouth face of Annapurna

Don Whillans on the summit ofAnnapurna (16mm movie frame)

Annapurna expedition members at the end of the climb in 1970
Images @ Chris Bonington Picture Library4THE HIMALAYAN CLUB E-LETTER VOLUME 40

Climbs,Treks and Explorations
Bhagirathi IV

Matteo Della Bordella

The Massif

According to the legend, the Ganga came down from the matted locksof Shiva, followed the king Bhagirath and dug its course in a narrow anddeep valley, which since then took the name of Bhagirathi (river).
Besides being considered a holy place for Hinduism, Bhagirathis (groupof peak) offer to alpinists a unique challenge: steep and difficult big walls
at above 6000 meters of altitude.
Here have been written some of the most fantastic pages of the historyof alpinism, such as the route “Estrella impossible” on the West pillarof Bhagirathi III (6454 m) or the route opened by Silvo Karo and Janec
Jeglic right in the center of that same face, legendary ascents!
As a lover of the history of mountaineering, looking for information on
the routes opened up in this gigantic amphitheater that starts from the5

THE HIMALAYAN CLUB E-LETTER VOLUME 40

The objective

South face of Bhagirathi II (6512 m) and ends with the “Scottish” routeon Bhagirathi III, there was a detail that immediately caught my attention:
one of these mythical walls was still unclimbed!
It was precisely the West of the Bhagirathi IV, that with its 6193 metersof altitude, is the lowest among the peaks of the massif, but certainly not
the least attractive from a mountaineering point of view.
Few sources were available on the web, mostly reporting informationthat was concise and essential for various attempts, many of which were
stopped before beginning, for bad weather or for bureaucratic reasons,while others stopped after a few hundred meters of climbing.
In the spring of 2015 it was this lack of information that fueled mycuriosity and suggested an attempt with Luca Schiera, who was alreadymy companion in various climbs scattered between Patagonia andPakistan and with Matteo De Zaiacomo “Giga”, twenty-one years old,
who entered our Ragni di Lecco group a few months before.
Luca and I had already been together to Trango just two years before andwe thought this was a good business card to the Bhagirathis; however
6THE HIMALAYAN CLUB E-LETTER VOLUME 40

Time to take some pictures

Climbing up

the Indian Himalayas immediately gave us a resounding slap in the face,
as if to tell us “Look guys this place is no joke!”
Our first attempt on the wall was a debacle: we understood what “westface at 5500 meters” meant, that is a temperature of -10 degrees until
noon and then, when you finally started feeling the blood flowing in yourhands and feet, the whistles of the stones that fall from above to the rightand to the left begin. We climbed two pitches and a half before beating aretreat due to an inability to climb at that altitude on that kind of difficulty
and an approximate acclimatization.
At least we had understood who or what we had in front of us and we7THE HIMALAYAN CLUB E-LETTER VOLUME 40

Climbing up

were prepared for a new attempt, following a line possibly more logicaland even more climbing-friendly looking, which started fifty meters
further to the right on the same West face of the Bhagirathi IV.
That time the mountain allowed us three days of climbing, bivouacking
in three in the portaledge for two people, before meeting the fearsome
band of black rock that makes up the last two hundred meters of wall.
Again, we had underestimated an aspect of the climb: the danger andconsistency of this type of rock, a schist completely different from thegranite we had encountered on the first part of the route, made up ofhorizontal layers, like roof tiles, piled randomly one on the other andready to fall down.
Exhausted from fatigue and altitude, after two almost sleepless nights
spent looking for the best position in the narrow hanging tent, we decided
to give up and bail.
During that descent we perhaps discovered a possible solution to our
problem, the line that maybe would have allowed us to climb this wall.
8THE HIMALAYAN CLUB E-LETTER VOLUME 40

Starting the climb

We identified an exposed 60-meter horizontal beam that led to anothersystem of diagonal cracks: we would have had to cut the entire wall tobe able to reach a section where the schist strip was 50 meters high orslightly more.
But alas, our chance was over that year: the weather had changed andthe snow started and settled on the walls, and a muscle injury forced me
to rest for ten days.
In the head there was the idea to try again, maybe ... one day ... who
knows when ...
Many times the most difficult step is precisely the first, the start, todecide to dedicate another summer season to a project that has alreadyrejected you and where you are not so convinced that you can achieve
the result.
It’s true that we had seen the line that we should have followed, butthere were two unknown factors that held me back: the first was to find9

THE HIMALAYAN CLUB E-LETTER VOLUME 40

the weather conditions suitable for free climbing, the second was theovercoming of the final schist band, which although it was about 50-60
meters, it left many doubts, since a few meters were enough to stop us
in our 2015 attempt.
Between one expedition and another, between a referral and another,four years had already passed since that attempt and I soon realizedthat we were losing the train, so when a few months ago Luca said tome: “How about returning to the Bhagirathi this year?” I thought the timefor excuses, postponements and other projects was over.

The traverse

I immediately accepted that proposal because I understood that both
Luca and Giga would have been determined and motivated at least as
much as I, perhaps occur more, to climb that wall and that maybe a similaroccasion would never occur again; and because in 4 years I wanted tosee if we had made progress (alpinistically speaking) or if our abilities
had remained unchanged. Seeing improvements in oneself in an activity
in which one has worked hard for years - in our case mountaineering - is10

THE HIMALAYAN CLUB E-LETTER VOLUME 40

one of the most satisfying sensations that a person can experience andI was firmly convinced that we would have experienced it.
This year, at least, we had clear ideas on how to organize the expedition.
Maybe too clear since we had studied everything to the smallest detail,without even considering a “plan b”.
Things would have started exactly the same way as four years before:
the flight to Delhi, the transfer to Gangotri and then the two days of
trekking to get to Nandanvan, that is the place of our base camp, green
balcony with perfect view on the Shivling ( 6543m) located at 4400
meters altitude. The tents were in the same place four years before, we
had the same cook, at times it seemed to me that I was living a deja vù.
So our program included an acclimatization phase divided into two steps:
first we would bring the portaledge and part of the climbing material up
to the base of the wall at an altitude of 5400 meters; then we would
have climbed the Bhagirathi II from the East side, reaching the altitudeof 6500 meters.
Acclimatization is perhaps the most boring part of an expedition, especially

Climbing up

11

THE HIMALAYAN CLUB E-LETTER VOLUME 40

when you already know the place and have clear ideas about what todo. But it is as boring as it is necessary, and in spite of the certainly not
optimal time, everything went exactly according to the schedule set athome.
On September 3, 2019 things are going well. All three of us feel in fullform and even the monsoon has been over for a few days, the copious
rains that had accompanied us in the first two weeks of shipping are now
nothing but harmless fogs, which envelop us in the evening hours. It ishot, too hot and we cannot explain how only 4 years before we could get
cold in this same place and at the same time of the year.
We are at the advanced camp at 5000 meters of altitude, the longawaited day of putting our hands on the Bhagirathi IV is about to arrive.
While I am absorbed in my thoughts it is Giga at some point to call myattention:“Look! ... Teo Look!” His voice is alarmed and I leave the tent in a hurry.
Just in time to see the show that leaves me speechless: big blocks likecars are bouncing exactly along the line that we should have climbed
the next day. They split into a thousand pieces and then still roll down,
covering the entire wall with debris until they reach the plinth and thenthe stony ground.
Ten minutes later, I’m still amazed and the show repeats itself and thistime I also look at it in the front row. Other rocks come off the final shaleband of the Bhagirathi IV, bounce and channel themselves right on ourway: I see the debris travel along the two dihedrals, then the slabs andthen on the easier approach.
No one dares to breathe. There are no half words to describe what
happened: if we had found ourselves on our ascent line at that moment,
we would probably be dead, crushed by the mass of newly fallen stones.
What did we do after witnessing a such a show? Well, what any humanwould have done: we have not attacked the route and we have returnedto the base camp with morale at its lowest.
It’s September 14th 2019 and eleven days have passed since themoment which changed our expedition. “That rockfall…” I kept telling
12THE HIMALAYAN CLUB E-LETTER VOLUME 40

myself and my companions “it changed all our plans ... if only ...”.
Fortunately with the “if” you do not go anywhere and in the meantime wealso made a failed attempt on a line more direct and repaired, but maybe
too hard: it rejected us once we reached the base of a completely blinddihedral after 3 climbing days.
Yet we are still there at the same point. Luca, Giga and I at the advanced
camp to stare the West of the Bhagirathi IV.
Crazy when I think, that only two days before we had brought down all
the material and declared our expedition closed. But then that night anidea perhaps insane started to creep into my mind, it took root in thedepths of my thoughts and didn’t let me sleep, making me think of every
single detail, of every scenario that we could face. When I showed it to
my companions, I didn’t know what to expect ... would they immediately
reject it or would they find a brilliant idea?
“Guys, one last speed attempt. In a day and with the minimum necessary.
It seems impossible, but we might as well try it “.
We start at midnight from the 5,000 meters of our advanced base camp.
At 3 o’clock, with about ten degrees below zero (in the meantime thetemperatures have finally fallen) is Luca starting to climb. After 6 longpitches my turn comes: the climb sucks, nothing to do with what it wasin 2015. Or rather, it would be beautiful vertical and overhanging crack
pitches on 6c / 7a, except that everything is covered or clogged with dust
and debris from the rockfall.
The only positive thing is that I don’t feel the 5,900 meters of altitude,
it seems to me to be on the Grand Capucin and I don’t make too much
effort, on the other hand we have been in this place for almost 30 days
now!
After 10 pitches, a 60 meter traverse awaits us, there I say goodbye
my ultralight camalot two, sacrificed for a pendulum that makes us earnprecious minutes.
We are outside the rockfall area, now the rock is clean. However, therocks start getting worse with several unstable blocks. Giga follows
fast with a heavy bag, he has the hard task of sacrificing himself for
13

THE HIMALAYAN CLUB E-LETTER VOLUME 40

everyone’s success, this is the real work and team spirit. A few more
pitches and I pass the lead to Luca for the icing on the cake: one lastsection on granite before chasing two pitches on the layers of friable

The route14THE HIMALAYAN CLUB E-LETTER VOLUME 40

shale that made these mountains famous.
He manages to climb the first pitch with the light, while he climbs upwards,
the movement of the rope is enough to drop on us a rain of thin, flatstones like the tiles of a roof, then luckily he crosses to the left and afterendless minutes builds an anchor. He climbs the second and last pitchof the schist in the dark.
Now the snow: to be as light as possible we have a pair of crampons in
3, but it’s not too bad. I take the lead, patiently try and find a way to makedecent anchors for my friends who go up jumaring.
At 11.00 pm we all touch the 6.193 meters of the summit. We are so
euphoric that we no longer even feel tired.
We then rest a few hours in our sleeping bags, before starting the descentfrom the East side.
Ed. Note : 2019 Significant ascent mentioned in Piolets d’Or.

Team members at Base Camp

15

THE HIMALAYAN CLUB E-LETTER VOLUME 40

Mountaineering Expedition to unnamed andunscaled peak –Harsil Horn (4880 m / 16010 ft)
Col. Amit Bisht

The aim of the expedition was to do the first ascent of an unscaled peakof height 4880 m in Harsil Chamoli area of Garhwal Himalayas and carryout calibration and marking of most feasible route to the summit.
This expedition is indeed a very special one; as team successfully scaled
the virgin peak in a very short duration of 9 days with a small team of 5

Team at summit

climbers during the COVID -19 pandemic effect and National lock downin the uncharted Harsil Valley of Garhwal Himalayas.
The ten member team reached Harsil road head and immediately
commenced induction to Ratha Camp on 22nd June 2020 for first stageof acclimatization, stayed in the camp for two nights, carrying out load
ferries to the Base Camp. On 24th June the team reached Base Camp
16

THE HIMALAYAN CLUB E-LETTER VOLUME 40

Summit Camp(3620 M). On 25th June, a small team under Lt Col Yogesh Dhumal,
Dy team leader carried out a recce of the route to the Summit Camp(4387 M). The route was a mix of initial grasslands and bushes, andthe final part being a mix of snow covered steep slopes with occasional
rocky outcrops in between. After load ferry to the Summit Camp on 26th
June, the complete team shifted to the Summit Camp on 27th June withminimum required ration, tents and fixed ropes in the initial part of theroute. The final push to Summit was commenced on 28th June at 4:00
hrs. The negotiation of the route involved near vertical climb in hard snow,
traverse route on a highly exposed slope with a mix of snow and rocks
and the last patch with pure rock at almost 60 to 75 degrees gradient,17THE HIMALAYAN CLUB E-LETTER VOLUME 40

where sharp boulders and rocky ridges made the climb even moredifficult. The climbing technique used for ascent included fixed rope infew patches and roping up with anchoring at few places. After deliberatesafe climbing along the arduous terrain, the team finally achieved thefirst ascent of the peak at 4880m on 28th June at 9:30 hrs. Team stayedat the top for 30 minutes & clicked photographs & recorded GPS shots.
I nailed a prayer flag and a snow stake with NIM painted on it, on thesummit as proof of ascent. By this time the weather turned bad and afternegotiating extreme weather conditions the team reached back safely toSummit Camp at 11:45 hrs and on the same day descended to the BaseCamp. The team further took two days to carry load ferry to the roadhead at Harsil and completed the de-induction on 30th June.

Enroute Summit Camp
18

THE HIMALAYAN CLUB E-LETTER VOLUME 40

Ascent towards summit

Climb towards summit
19THE HIMALAYAN CLUB E-LETTER VOLUME 40

View of summit point

Enroute Summit Camp
20

THE HIMALAYAN CLUB E-LETTER VOLUME 40

Peak view from the way to summit

ArticleFriendship Peak Speed Ascent
Kieren Dsouza

Friendship Peak Speed Ascent
I did a reconnaissance on the 14th of June till just below the col, on theroute I was going to climb. I was carrying my gear bag which contained
my boots, crampons, waterproof jacket, pants and a pair of gloves. I
stashed it carefully at Lady Leg ridge knowing that I would need it on
the day of the attempt. The 4Play team was divided into two, one would
document and support me on the road and the other on the mountain.
After the recce, the mountain team camped on the mountain while I
headed back to Manali. On 16th June, at 1:02 AM, I started from theMall road (Rambagh chowk) in Manali. I ran via Old Manali, Goshal,through the village trail to Shanag, continuing via Bhurva to Solang. I
reached Solang in about 1 hour 11 minutes. From here I again ran till
Dhundi – the road head for Friendship peak, where I arrived in 1 hour
55 minutes (from the start time). I continued following the regular trail
till the main river crossing for Bakarthach campsite. However, insteadof crossing over to the right bank, I continued on the left bank. This trail
21

THE HIMALAYAN CLUB E-LETTER VOLUME 40

Kieren training in his backyard, Nasogi (Manali, HP). (Nitish Walia)

opens up just before the climb to Lady Leg. I began the climb up to Lady
Leg ridge right away, with no rest. I reached the top of the ridge in a totalof 3 hours 45 minutes from the mall road; this is where the snow began.
Here I stopped and had a sip of water, and collected my pack that I had
left on the 14th.
My next stop was at the col at about 5 hours 4 minutes. I changed into
my boots and crampons, waterproof jacket/pants and continued to move
up. I probably could not have asked for better snow conditions. It helped
me move up fairly smoothly and at about 7 hours 16 minutes (from thestart time) I was at the summit. I stayed at the summit for a 15 minutes
break, did an Instagram live, took a couple of videos and then started
climbing down with Aditya Bikram Pande (part of the high altitude filmingcrew) who had climbed with me from the col to the summit. I was back at
the col after a slow descent, at about 8 hours 36 minutes (from the starttime). I had left my original pack here, which I had carried since the startat 01:02 AM, on the way up. So I stopped, changed back into my running22

THE HIMALAYAN CLUB E-LETTER VOLUME 40

Kieren running near the summit of Kanamo (5974m), Spiti (HP). (Abhijeet Singh)shoes and started to run down.
I left my climbing boots and crampons for the filming team to carry back.
I was back at the lady leg ridge at about 8 hours 56 minutes (from thestart time). I stopped, had 2 glasses of soup provided by the 4Play team,changed into my running shorts, left my waterproof jacket and pants
here with the team, said bye and ran down the lady leg ridge. I was backin Dhundi in about 9 hours 58 minutes. I continued on to Manali. I was
at Solang in about 10 hours 35 minutes, and took the same way back to
Manali. After crossing the Old Manali bridge, I ran through Nature Parkand not the road, as I had done when I started, for the sake of capturing
better footage for the film. I finished at the same place I had started at,on the Mall road, in 11 hours 45 minutes 50 seconds.
The Idea Of Self-Sufficiency
There are various ways in which the styles can be combined, which makes
the definition of ‘self-sufficiency’ even more confusing. My definition ofself-sufficiency primarily relies on one’s own ability to move over the23

THE HIMALAYAN CLUB E-LETTER VOLUME 40

climbing medium (be it rock, snow or ice). The clothing and equipment
should be the bare minimum that anyone would need in order to makeprogress and to survive in the conditions he/she finds himself in. I wantto cite my own run as an example so others who love the outdoors or
who relate to a minimalistic ethic can improve on the idea. I covered a
distance of 53.38 kilometres on foot in a total time span of 11 hours 45
minutes and 50 seconds. Alongside, I gained a total 3,657 metres of
elevation during the project, and lost 3,623 meters mostly during thedescent. My final run on the 16th produced 7 plastic wrappers (5 gels and2 bars) that I carried all the way back home. The team on the mountain
was provided packed food by the chef at the 4Play office, Ram Singh.
All garbage generated by the team, including packets of instant noodles
were brought back to the roadhead; along with the pieces of plastic thatwere found while hiking.

Kieren on the upper slopes of Friendship. (Mohit Sharma)24THE HIMALAYAN CLUB E-LETTER VOLUME 40

Kieren reaching the Col on Friendship. (Mohit Sharma)

Kieren running back to Manali after climbing Friendship. (Sankash Sood)
25

THE HIMALAYAN CLUB E-LETTER VOLUME 40

News and Personalities
Catherine Destivelle Earns Piolets d’Or
Lifetime Achievement Award
Destivelle becomes the first woman to receive the award since it began in 2009
Bennett Slavsky

The Piolets d’Or jury has chosen Catherine Destivelle to be the recipientof their 2020 Lifetime Achievement Award. Since its inception in 2009, theLifetime Achievement Award is meant to honor climbers who’s careers
serve as inspiration to following generations, and has been awarded tolegendary climbers such as Walter Bonatti, Reinhold Messner, and John
Roskelley. Catherine Destivelle is the first female recipient of the award..
Destivelle was born in 1960 in French Algeria. Her family moved toFrance when she was a child. She began bouldering in Fontainebleau
when she was 12 years old. As a teenager, Destivelle got a taste formountaineering in the Alps, but in the 1980s turned her attention to sport
climbing—a rapidly growing discipline in Europe at that time. She was
the first woman to redpoint 8a (5.13b).

Catherine on Sishapangma (8015m) (Erik Decamp)
26

THE HIMALAYAN CLUB E-LETTER VOLUME 40

Destivelle was one of the pioneers of climbing competitions as well.
She won the Italy’s Sportroccia in 1985, the first international climbing
competitions. Throughout the late-1980s, Destivelle and Lynn Hill often
rivaled one another for first place at international competitions.
Though Destivelle was a top-tier sport climber, her true passion was
alpinism, which she made a triumphant return to in 1990 with a solo
ascent of the Bonatti Pillar on the Petit Dru. In 1992, she became thefirst woman to solo the North Face of the Eiger, which she completed
in winter. The following year, she did a winter solo of the Walker Spuron the Grandes Jorasses, and a winter solo of the Bonatti Route on the
North Face of the Matterhorn the year after that. Destivelle then took
the skills she learned in the Alps to the Greater Ranges, climbing highaltitude routes in the Himalaya and Karakorum.
Catherine Destivelle crushed the stereotypes that top level sport climbing
and daring alpinism were reserved for men. She is one of the most wellrounded climbers of all time—from the boulders of Fontainebleau to
the Himalaya—and her storied career serves as inspiration to climbers
everywhere.
Read the full Piolets d’Or announcement below :We are happy to announce that the Piolets d’Or 2020 event will go ahead
as planned during the 25th edition of the Ladek Mountain Film Festival
in Poland. Access to a large area and the adoption of precautionary
measures will allow us to safely welcome over 1000 members of the
public.
We also have the immense pleasure of announcing that on the 19th
September, during this festival, the 12th Walter Bonatti - Piolets d’Or
Lifetime Achievement Award will be presented to Catherine Destivelle.
Catherine Destivelle started making a name for herself in the climbing
world during the 1980s, a time when sport climbing was exploding
in popularity and grades were rising rapidly. The media focused its
attention on this new discipline, ignoring the fact that Catherine had
been an alpinist from a young age. Shortly after discovering climbing at
Fontainebleau at the age of 12, she was tackling big routes in the Mont27

THE HIMALAYAN CLUB E-LETTER VOLUME 40

Blanc massif. However, by the mid-1980s she had started participatingin sport-climbing competitions and her success in these, and the fact she
became the first woman to redpoint 8a, turned her into a rock climbing
star. But few people knew that as a teenager she had climbed some of
the biggest routes in the Alps.
In 1990, the rock star made her mountain comeback with an impressive
solo ascent of the Bonatti Pillar on the Petit Dru. This finally gained herrecognition as an alpinist. She went on to open a new route on the west
face of the Petit Dru over 11 days, before completing a solo winter trilogy;
the north face of the Eiger in 1992, the Walker Spur on the north faceof the Grandes Jorasses in 1993, and the Bonatti route on the northface of the Matterhorn in 1994. This latter route is still rarely climbed
today. It was her second big Bonatti route and the first time a woman had
climbed at such a high standard in the Alps. However, Catherine didn’t
just want to be known as an accomplished female climber, she wanted
her performances to be measured against those of any alpinist, no matter
their gender. How many people could claim to operate at this standard?
Catherine had proved that women could climb just as hard as men.
Courtesy - Climbing

Mount Everest: Chinese team summit during pandemic
Navin Singh Khadka

A team of Chinese climbers and surveyors scaled Mount Everest on
26th and 27th May, becoming the only climbers to summit the world’s
highest peak during the corona virus pandemic.
Chinese media report the team is there to re-measure the height ofEverest, which is on the border with Nepal.
Until now China has put the height at 4m lower than Nepal does. The
huge 2015 earthquake may also have had an impact.
This year both countries banned foreign teams from climbing themountain due to corona virus travel restrictions.
China permitted only its citizens for the climb this spring season, while28

THE HIMALAYAN CLUB E-LETTER VOLUME 40

Nepal cancelled all expeditions.
The Chinese team began their ascent in April and summit bids werethwarted by bad weather.
“After summiting, team members began erecting a survey marker on
the snow-covered peak, which measures less than 20 square metres,”
Xinhua news agency reported.
Climbing guides were able to fix ropes to the summit, allowing the restof the team to ascend, Xinhua said.
“Two professional surveyors had been withdrawn from the peak-climbing
squad due to uncertainties about the weather and insufficient supplies
such as oxygen,” it added.
Mountaineering record-keepers say it is a very rare case of Chinese
climbers being the only ones on the peak.
“In spring 1960, only the Chinese reached the summit. The Indians
tried, but failed,” said Richard Salisbury of the Himalayan Database, anorganisation that keeps records of all expeditions in the Himalayas.
“There were various Chinese recons, research and training climbs from1958 through 1967 when nobody else was on the mountain, but noascents by any of them.”
The all-Chinese summiting of Everest comes just when China iscelebrating the 60th anniversary of its first successful ascent of the peak.
Courtesy : BBC World Service

20 Years of Mountain Heritage Trust
Kelda RoeIt’s 20 years since the foundation of the Mountain Heritage Trust andthey are sharing their work through a new short film.
Made possible through a grant from The National Archives and producedby Land & Sky Media, the film features interviews with Sir Chris
Bonington, Doug Scott and BMC President Lynn Robinson. It offers an
insight into the value of the Mountain Heritage Trust’s work and includes
29

THE HIMALAYAN CLUB E-LETTER VOLUME 40

behind the scenes footage of their efforts to preserve and share Britain’s
extraordinary mountaineering and climbing heritage.
Based in Cumbria, UK, the Mountain Heritage Trust is a registeredcharity who care for some of Britain’s most significant mountaineeringand climbing collections. They are currently fundraising to secure theArchive Store

Chris Bonington film still30

THE HIMALAYAN CLUB E-LETTER VOLUME 40

future of the Trust – donations can be made at https://www.justgiving.
com/mountainheritagetrust.
Images Courtesy @ Mountain Heritage Trust

Himalayan Mountaineering Institute
Manik Banerjee

Premier mountaineering training establishment in Asia - Himalayan
Mountaineering Institute (HMI) in Darjeeling West Bengal, took novel
measures to tackle the condition emerged out of countrywide lock down
caused by the Corona virus outbreak.

Trainees at H M I Darjeeling undergoing sessions of Yoga

HMI Principal Gp Capt Jai Kishen informed that a total 75 trainees
including 53 in Basic Mountaineering Training Course and 22 including
two women in Search & Rescue Course were undergoing field training
at an altitude of 14,500 feet in Chourikhang at West Sikkim from March
10 and 14 respectively. They completed their training on March 24 andthe countrywide lock down was declared from same midnight.
The principal said that “with great efforts the trainees were safely brought backfrom the Base Camp at Chowrikhang to the Institute campus in Darjeelingunder special arrangements with Governments of Sikkim and West Bengal.”31THE HIMALAYAN CLUB E-LETTER VOLUME 40

As per schedule, the course would have been over by 29th March andthe trainees would have left the Institute after the graduation ceremony
the same day itself. However, in view of the countrywide lock down
the Institute made special arrangements to keep them at the Instituteconsidering their safety and vulnerability of getting infected with Corona
virus and further spreading it if they were asked to leave the Institute oncompletion of the course, he said.
Gp Capt Jai Kishen said the Institute made adequate arrangement for
food, medical and other essential items. Their medical fitness is being
closely monitored by the Institute doctor and nursing staff. HMI has madeall necessary and possible arrangements for their boarding, lodging andPhysical Training and Prayer during Covid 19 lock down

safety at the Institute at no extra cost.
Principal Jai Kishen intimated that in order to keep morale of thestudents high , make them occupied and at the same time utilize theirtalents and interests in productive ways , the Institute during this periodof lock down designed a special programme and a competition titled“HMI 21 DAYS’ BIG BOSS CHALLENGE” . The programme include
various events like prayer, yoga, meditation, cleanliness, gardening,group discussion on various topics, poem/essay/articles writing, story
32

THE HIMALAYAN CLUB E-LETTER VOLUME 40

telling . He said that adequate safety measures were being followed
during the conduct of this programme.
All the students after the restrictions on movement and lock down eased
left for their respective homes in different parts of the country.
Images Courtesy : Himalayan Mountaineering Institute2020 Piolets d’Or Honoured Ascent
MARK RICHEY - STEVE SWENSON - CHRIS WRIGHT - GRAHAMZIMMERMAN (USA)FIRST ASCENT VIA THE SOUTHEAST FACE, 2,300M, AI4 M6+ 90°,
JULY 31-AUGUST 8 ROUND TRIP FROM AN ADVANCED BASE AT
4,700M.
Another much-coveted problem, thistime in the eastern Pakistan Karakoram,
Link Sar had received at least eightattempts before 2019. But the difficulties
are not just about climbing the peak: theIndo-Pakistan conflict has made thisregion an on-off affair (largely off) whenit comes to obtaining a mountaineering
permit.
Steve Swenson first attempted Link
Sar in 2001 with a strong American
team, and then again, after a numberof failed permit attempts, in 2017 with
Chris Wright and Graham Zimmerman.
Having now discovered a feasible line ofMark Richey
ascent, these three decided to reinforce
the team in 2019 with the addition of Mark Richey.
Six days after setting out from Advanced Base, they reached thetop. During that time they had waited out a 36+ hours storm, and on
the summit day recovered from a 35m leader fall due to avalancheand overcome an upgradable final pitch of deep, steep and unstable
33

THE HIMALAYAN CLUB E-LETTER VOLUME 40“Peruvian” snow. A little overtwo days were then needed
to reverse the route. These
climbers succeeded because
they were persistent, usedtheir 126 years of combined
climbing experience, andunderstood what partnershipmeant.
Courtesy : pioletsdor.net

Steve Swenson

Climbing above Camp 3 (Steve Swenson)
Ed. Note: Mark Richey and Steve Swenson are both Honorary Member of The
Himalayan Club and we the members are proud of their achievement. This is
Steve’s second Piolets d’Or.

34THE HIMALAYAN CLUB E-LETTER VOLUME 40

REMEMBRANCEWorld Renowned Mountaineer Martin MoranC S Pandey

It is with a sense of deep shock that
we received the news that Martin
Moran died whilst climbing in
Kumaon region of Indian Himalaya
along with 7 other climbers. Born
on 19th February, 1955, Martin
grew up in North Tyneside. He
met his future wife Joy when they
were both 18. He took a degreein Geography at Cambridge
University and later qualified asa Chartered Accountant in Sheffield. During the winter of 1984/85 hecompleted all of the Munros in a single round. In 1985 Martin qualified
as a British Mountain Guide and he and Joy started a mountaineering
instruction and guiding business based in Lochcarron in the NW
Highlands of Scotland. Martin ran summer Alpine mountaineeringcourses based in Argentière, France and then in Evolène, Switzerlandfor 20 years.
I first came in contact with Martin during Year 1990 for organizing
his expedition to Indian Himalaya. Our friendship continued foralmost 30 years until this news of him with other seven mountaineers
gone missing came to me during last week of May 2019 which was
unbelievable because he was always thinking of safety first while on
outdoor activities. In Year 1991, Martin started planning to take hiscommercial mountaineering expeditions to the Indian Himalaya and I
was associated with him in this mission as his ground handling agent
in India. After more than 40 successful commercial (often pioneering)
expeditions the company Moran Mountain is known as one of Britain’s
most experienced mountain adventure companies. Martin, a British and
IFMGA Mountain Guide, had been leading an expedition to climb Nanda
35

THE HIMALAYAN CLUB E-LETTER VOLUME 40

Devi East along with seven other climbers and were acclimatizing on an
adjacent un-named peak (6477m) where they were reported missing
during last week of May.
As a friend, guide, mountaineer, writer, Martin was a long-standing
trustworthy friend and ambassador for me and my organisation.
He was also an inspiration to many and his talent as a climber wasunquestionable, having pioneered numerous routes in the Himalaya.
But it was the sheer breadth of his achievements in the mountains
that stood Martin apart and made him one of the most influential
mountaineers of the world. Martin’s team were engaged in the type ofadventurous, exploratory mountaineering that he had built a reputationfor over three decades as a mountain guide and safe climber and teamleader. He was a man whose reputation for getting the most out ofboth clients and conditions was the stuff of legend. He was not after aleisurely breakfast but instead dawn-till-dusk adventures making themost of the big mountaineering challenges.
He was an acknowledged authority on the mountains of Northern
India, leading exploratory climbing trips to the area for both work andpleasure, and making notable first ascents along the way. He delivered
lectures about his mountaineering trips in India at Indian Mountaineering
Foundation, Delhi and The Himalayan Club, Mumbai and had highreputation amongst HC & IMF members and officials.
According to British Mountain Association, Martin went through thevery rigorous process of becoming an IFMGA Mountain Guide, aninternational qualification recognized across the world and known by all
to represent the highest standards of competence and professionalism.
He was the very embodiment of a British and International Mountain
Guide, highly respected and a consummate professional.
In 2009 he attempted Nanda Devi East with clients and returned to try
a new route on the same mountain in 2015 (reaching 6,865m on theunclimbed North East Ridge). Highlights in India included the first ascentsof the South Face of Nanda Kot, 6,861m in 1995 and the West Ridge ofNilkanth, 6,596m in 2000, along with a dozen other pioneering ascents.
He also led trips to Kamet and Trisul etc., also in the Uttarakhand region.
36

THE HIMALAYAN CLUB E-LETTER VOLUME 40

None of us would have thought in our dreams that such mishappening
will took place especially with THE MOUNTAINEER MARTIN MORAN.
Martin, you will always remain in my heart as a sole friend whom with
I used to share the same frequency of thinking and that made possible
to work with you and to continue 30 years of friendship and promoting
adventure sports in Indian Himalaya.

Shivling from Base Camp of Bhagirathi IV (Arianna Colliard)

Edited by : Nilay Chakraborty

Email: nilay24@gmail.com
Published for The Himalayan Club
Himalayan Club Centre, 314, Turf Estate, Shakti Mills Lane,
Off Dr. E. Moses Road, Mahalaxmi [West], Mumbai 400011, India.
Phone: [91-22] 24912829
www.himalayanclub.org
If you do not wish to receive the e-letter, please let us know at info@himalayanclub.org(For private circulation only)

37