Application of Tungsten- and Molybdenum-based
Materials to Resistance Welding Electrodes
タングステン・モリブデン系材料の抵抗溶接用電極への応用
Tomoki TANAKA田中智基

Shingo MUKAE

向江信悟

Hirofumi YAMAGUCHI山口博文

Key words; Resistance welding electrodes, weld conditions, tungsten, molybdenum, NDB electrode
キーワード；抵抗溶接電極、溶接条件、タングステン、モリブデン、NDB 電極
Abstract
In recent years, objects to be welded by resistance welding have been diversified and the load ofwelding conditions is sometimes too much for a generally-used copper alloy electrode. There are somecases that such load decreases the life of a welding electrode and makes the joining quality unstable.
Under specific severe welding conditions, W- and Mo-based materials have been used as electrodematerials with increasing frequency making the life of an electrode longer and improving the joining
quality.
近年、抵抗溶接における被溶接物が多様化されており、一般的に使用される銅合金電極では、溶接条件の負荷が大きすぎる場合がある。この場合、抵抗溶接電極が短寿命になる場合や接合品質が安定しないといった事例がある。特定の過酷な溶接条件下では、W・Mo 系材料が電極材料として用いられるケースが増えており、電極の寿命化や接合品質の向上などの実績を上げている。

1.Introduction
Resistance welding method is to overlap metals to be welded, pinch the welding point with electrodes
with adequate welding pressure and apply high current to generate heat sufficient to melt and join
metals. This is one of welding techniques and widely used for joining various products such as auto partsand home electronics.
The roles of a resistance welding electrode are to:① Apply high current to the weld,② Apply a high voltage to the weld, and③ Cool down the surface of the weld.

Nippon Tungsten Review Vol.40 (2016)– 22 –

To fulfill above roles, the following characteristics are required for a resistance welding electrode:① Hardly deformed by high pressure or high temperature② Excellent thermal/electric conductivity③ Hardly alloyed with the weld or plating metals④ Hardly oxidized in the atmosphere⑤ Low cost
A precipitation hardened alloy, chromium copper (CrCu), is most commonly used as a resistancewelding electrode which fulfills above conditions. During the resistance welding, however, precipitates
are dissolved in Cu matrix by heating repeatedly and the hardness and electric conductivity of theelectrode decrease and reach the end of service life.
In addition, there is another electrode called alumina-dispersed copper which increases its hardness
and electric conductivity by dispersing hard particles into copper. The performances of this electrode areless deteriorated by heating repeatedly unlike precipitation hardened copper, but its lifetime is shortened
under the following welding conditions:① Copper is alloyed with the weld or its plating film,② Cu wire having a high thermal conductivity is welded,③ High-current or long-time welding, and④ Welding shot cycle is fast.

2.ResultsandDiscussion

2.1 Characteristics of Tungsten and Molybdenum(1) Tungsten (W)・The melting point is the highest among metals (3,387℃ ).
・The hardness is high at both normal and high temperatures.
・Tungsten (W) starts oxidizing from about 400 ℃ forming W3O, WO2 and W20O58 and rapidly oxidizes
from about 700 ℃ forming WO3.
・The electric resistivity is high (5.5×10-8 Ω m).
(2) Molybdenum (Mo)・High melting point
・At high temperature, the mechanical strength is high.
・Molybdenum oxidizes rapidly at above 500 ℃ .

At above 650 ℃ , it changes to gray-white-coloredMoO3.
・The electric resistivity is high (5.7×10-8 Ω m).
As above, tungsten and molybdenum have high mechanical strength at high temperature and are
frequently used under the welding condition where heat load on the electrode is high such as highcurrent and fast shot cycle. However, the amount of heat generated by the electrode becomes relatively
larger due to its low thermal conductivity. In the case of workpiece materials alloyed easily with tungsten
or molybdenum or plating materials, weld deposit and sputtering may awfully grow.
In addition, tungsten and molybdenum tend to oxidize so it is necessary to cool down the electrode as
much as possible so that oxidative consumption can be suppressed.

– 23 –

Nippon Tungsten Review Vol.40 (2016)

2.2 The field of application and proper use of tungsten- and molybdenum-based electrode materials(1) Tungsten and molybdenum
Tungsten and molybdenum have an excellent high-temperature strength and are available forworkpieces or plating products that are easily alloyed with copper and often used for heating workpieces
using exotherm of an electrode and performing thermal caulking under high pressure. Tungsten andmolybdenum are used separately depending on the following advantages:
・Tungsten tends to be cracked by thermal shock. Molybdenum is often used when cracks or breaks
occur frequently.
・Oxidative consumption of molybdenum is higher than that of tungsten. Tungsten is often used whenplacing emphasis on lifetime.
・The high-temperature strength of tungsten is higher than that of molybdenum.
(2) S-TUN
S-TUN is a tungsten material having non-directional structure. This isotropic structure sometimes
works as a countermeasure against cracks and has been used for a heater tip for fusing welding.
However, the mechanical strength is weaker than conventional tungsten depending on the size or theshape.
(3) Cu-W/Ag-W alloy
Both Cu-W and Ag-W alloys have a high temperature strength and a high electric conductivity. Our
company has various compositions of them and is able to provide the best one according to the welding
conditions.
Recently, Ag-W alloy electrodes have been often used from the viewpoint of preventing short-circuitaccidents caused by copper contamination in a manufacture line. Since Ag is hard to be alloyed with Feor Ni, it is often used for welding of SUS and Ni foil.
(4) Ag-WC alloy
When tungsten reacts with carbon and becomes WC, the oxygen resistance increases and is effective
for oxidation consumption measures, but the electrical resistivity decreases. By alloying WC with Ag andCu, the resistivity and the heat conduction are improved and such alloys have been commercialized.
(5) Heavy alloy
Heavy alloy mainly consists of W with sintering aids such as Ni, Cu and Fe. A W-Ni-Cu alloy with 94 %or higher W content (HAC2) is used as a chuck electrode for welding solder plating wire with a diameterof about 1 millimeter such as resistors and capacitors. Heavy alloy has advantages such as higher
oxidation resistance than W, free-cutting and low cost.
Cost is also the most important factor for choosing an electrode. Rare metals such as W and Mo,
precious metals such as Ag and intractable metals are costly.
Figs. 1-6 show structures of metal materials manufactured by our company. Table 1 shows thecharacteristics of them.

Nippon Tungsten Review Vol.40 (2016)– 24 –

Fig.1. Internal structure of tungsten

Fig.2. Internal structure of “S-TUN”

Fig.3. Internal structure of 30%Cu-W alloy

Fig.4. Internal structure of 35%Ag-W alloy

Fig.5. Internal structure of 40%Ag-WC alloy

Fig.6. Internal structure of heavy alloy(94%-Ni-2%Cu)– 25 –

Nippon Tungsten Review Vol.40 (2016)Table1. Characteristics of metal materials manufactured by our company

Fig. 7 shows workpiece materials used for metallic electrodes and electrode conditions.
Tungsten- and molybdenum-based electrode materials are less used for steel sheet welding which ishigh demand but used for welding non-ferrous materials such as copper and nickel making use of thehigh strength at high temperature.

Fig. 7. Workpiece materials used for metallic electrodes and electrode conditions
2.3 NDB (Non-Defective Bonding) method
W, Mo and their alloys are used for a tip of an electrode for resistance welding and Cu and Cr-Cu alloy
are used for its shanks (holders or part of cooling holes). Though “silver brazing” and “pressure welding”
are generally used to join an electrode with a shank, the joining quality is apt to vary and/or the life of anelectrode might be shortened due to drop out of the electrode material, decrease in heat conductance orheat generation at the junction.
Our company provides customers electrodes manufactured using NDB method which was developedby improving conventional joining methods. NDB (Non-Defective Bonding) method is a joining method to
directly join copper with W, Mo or Cu-W alloy developed and patented by our company. The process of

Nippon Tungsten Review Vol.40 (2016)– 26 –NDB is shown in Fig. 8. Since NDB product has good thermal conductivity to the shank (Fig. 9), theelectrode can be cooled down quickly while the energization is suspended. It not only avoids electrodeburnout but also hastens the shot cycle to contribute to productivity improvement and enables thewelding cycle which cannot be achieved by brazing or pressure welding.

Fig. 8. The process of NDB.

Fig. 9. Comparison of joining qualities (left: brazed electrode, right: NDB electrode)
2.4 Cooling performance of NDB electrode
In order to compare performances of NDB-W, W-brazed and W-solid electrodes, we measured thechange in electrode temperature when cooling down from 1000 ℃ to 300 ℃ as shown in Fig. 10. The
results are shown in Fig. 11. From these results, i.e. the NDB electrode is cooled down 304 msec. fasterthan the W-brazed one and 1688 msec. faster than the W-solid one. Therefore, the cooling performanceof the NDB electrode is the best.

– 27 –

Nippon Tungsten Review Vol.40 (2016)

Fig. 10. Schematic diagram of the competitive experimentFig. 11. Results of the competitive experiment3.Conclusions
Welding conditions are varied depending on the quality of materials to be welded and the welding
machine. Tungsten, molybdenum and their alloys have excellent high-temperature strength but theelectric and thermal conductivities are poorer than those of Cr-Cu alloy and Al2O3 dispersion
strengthened Cu alloy. Therefore, even under the same welding conditions as Cr-Cu alloy, the welding
temperature excessively increases and may cause a deposition. It is important to find out electrodematerials, electrode joining methods and welding conditions so that the heat balance between an
electrode and a workpiece is appropriate.

Nippon Tungsten Review Vol.40 (2016)– 28 –