植物科学最前線 7:110 (2016)

VX[N%!"+7?D31@;7F=^U&TJ\ĚŸ ƅǅɍƷĕ ŗàƞÕĉƯƼĿ ƟûȎƍƸĉƯƼZ]
230-0045 ƶĄĖƭŷƈĚɊǺÖŧġƤ 1-7-22
Yasunori Ichihashi, Atsushi Fukushima
Frontiers of Transcriptomics in Plant Science
Key words: Gene co-expression, Library preparation, Network analysis, RNA-seq,
Transcriptome
RIKEN Center for Sustainable Resource Science, Yokohama, Kanagawa, 230-0045 Japan
'#)%
 RiyȦÅ,ǽȅA#+ɍĂȬ,b]A¢ǉƩ+Ł
ą4#

ŀƃ'

=KxOXǽūɋFukushima and Kusano 2014Ɍ,'8c~XOqcyǽū-ɍRiy;ŢǏƩ*ǴƝô0(ĹøAŸƋ=ȓÀơƖº¢AŞ;+=(+:<ɍƠçƝȋ,ƞǽ+ăȍƛ=ɋIchihashi et al. 2015; Ichihashi and Sinha 2014ɌźVQT,łǳȞż+:<ȂƠRNA-seq -ɍc~XOqcyǽū,ǈĢAăĞ+Ĥ=((8+ɍÛƞƩ+)B*ƠƖƹ+

&8c~XOqcyǽūAȢƢßǦ(ɋWang et al. 2009ɌĮŪ,jFp^F[V}+:=wFODF9TMƃ+÷%VQXłǳ(ž1&ɍRNA-seq -ȤćƨƝ,ŲÃǅðġ7c~XOqcy,ǸȹķAŻư+ŲÃ'=ɋMader et al. 2011Ɍ;+Śǻ,ȓÀơƖɍsmall RNAsɍ
alternative splicing variants AŲÃ'ɍȓÀơƖ,ú÷ȦÅAƫŎȅ6(+:< SNPsɍfusiontranscriptɍȓÀȲąƐ8ãČ=(ßǦ(*=ɋOzsolak and Milos 2011Ɍ,:RNA-seq +:=c~XOqcyǽū-ɍƠƖĉÄȫºǪ++&ƮȊƨǺAÏț&= źVQT,q~`cty-ĝ+ŕǫ>ɍVQXb],Ȭ
ăĞ+ä&+Ⱥ*=,7ɍĭ;+ă*XQ'čɇßǦ(*=(-ĺ´*;ɍ RNA-seq ~Fp~£Ľ-<ăǻŶ*qWHOc0,ĔȲ,Éȵǹî(*#&Aŀ+>=('^d*śƃ4!*]õƂ=ĸ>

ȏ(8+4!ÑÍɍšȳɍSXc

=Ï

&ɍ

(

ăǻŶ,b](&8ɍĂȬ'$Ǹȹ*b],ǽūŀƃ+$&8X]

7ɍĂ,QX'ƠƖĉƩĻæAĤÃ('+b='ŨǖȄ'->;,ëɄA¸Ť'=ŢŚ,~Fp~£Ľłǳ:/ăǻŶb]ǽūŀƃAǎɍűƖƸĉ+=ŚƯƼĔȲ+$&

ǠĐ=

Y. Ichihashi & A. Fukushima-1
BSJ-Review 7:110 (2016)

植物科学最前線 7:111 (2016)  ?/:?@FIQR]
 '-źVQT,':¥@>&Fp~£Ľ+$= Illumina Ƶ,q~`ctyƢ,~&Ȉ=H($&?/:?@FIQR]
 Ɲò4',śƃ(& Illumina Ƶ 2012 ĠĨš+ƨÿ

jFXq`cƢ, TruSeq

RNA sample preparation kit A8(+ RNA-seq ~Fp~£Ľ,÷ŨƩ*Xa`q+$ȄŞ=ɋñ 1AɌ4ƠƖǐǛ; total RNA AņÃɍmRNA AǈǷ=į;>+$ǲ&©ȷFKAƢ&řƔÕ=řƔÕ

&

mRNA

mRNA A8(+ 2 Ũȯ cDNA âĽA,ĭɍIdsD+:< 5’ŧƿȨÕ>ğƏŧƿ, cDNA řƔAį=A aP+:< 3’ŧƿ+ A AÏɍTA OfPAÈƢ&D^q]A cDNAřƔ,ƿ+Ŏǔ=ǿ,ȧǋÝĵ(+ɍsolid-phase reversible immobilization ɋSRRIɌƱſķmYA¥į;>ǈǷɍ¤& cDNA řƔ,TFYA=Č,ă+ȣŅ&D^q] cDNA řƔA PCR üĞ&ɍRNA-seq ~Fp~ċĽ=,śƃ-ɍƠƖǐǛ;: 3 ŝȳ' 24 ~Fp~£ĽßǦ'=,:RNA-seq ~Fp~£Ľ-ɍĨš,łǳ'jFXq`cAĶɃ+Ȳƨ>#&8ɍÑÍ

šȳ

SXc#&

+

śƃ'



    c d?/:?@FIQR]
 'ǯǡ;-:<jFXq`c* RNA-seq AčƝ=
=śƃAȲƨ,Ɛ+$

7ɍǇª

ȗț

Ċ©+'

ɋHTRɍKumar et al. 2012Ɍ, HTR '-ɍIllumina Ƶ,śƃA8(+&ăŕǫ

Ɏ1ɌǐǛ;ƫŎ mRNA AņÃ=ɍ2ɌmRNA '*

cDNA AřƔÕ=ɍ3ɌcDNA řƔ,ŧƿ¬ɆÝĵ,º&A SRRI mY'ǲ ɋFisher et
al. 2011Ɍɍ4Ɍ96 kSdAD^q]+ǐ5Ȗ6ɋñ 1BɌ>;,ŕǫ+:<ɍƠƖǐǛ; 2 ŝȳ' 96 ~Fp~£ĽßǦ(*<ɍĮŪ,śƃ+ž1& 6 ®,jFXq`cÕčƝÏ;+SXc8Ĩš,Ěù©ů+

& 3-11 ®ÊƊ=(+ĽÎ&ɍ~Fp~,ȏ8 Illumina Ƶ,śƃ(23ãǁ'<ɍ6?u\y RNA ,S]xhV}Ē*

ǫȏ,8,'&ãTqZ`c+$&ȤćƨƝ,ĘƧAǽū=(ɍăÙ,Ȥćǝ+$qcS+:#&ŲÃ>
Ǻ$#
ȳ,ȡ

,

 ,śƃ-ĞġHTR ( Illumina Ƶ,qcSA¥#&-ɍqcSȳ'Ƨ*=ŋÓAƳȤćǝ8Ă

7ɍƧ*=qcS'į+×ÄƄĻ1'

ıȳ',ȃĘĒ*

#



=4

TqAǗ+ǽū=ȸ-qcSí,ǽūǒŬ;-ɍHTR ,27ɍǓǾƩŲÃÍɉb]AÃ(8@#űƖƹ+ĵƢ'ɍƝò4'+Ă,ǭŨűƖ+Ï

6ǱɅɋCaulerpa taxifoliaɌ9Pfǰƻ

łǳƩÝ



&ɍƀÄAĂåŦŨ,űƖɋGevuina avellanaɌ'8ɉ

ǈ

Y. Ichihashi & A. Fukushima-2
BSJ-Review 7:111 (2016)

植物科学最前線 7:112 (2016)

Ģ,b]AÞį&ƃAƢ=ɋRanjan et al. 2015; Ostria-Gallardo et al., unpublishedɌ4=('ăǻŶ* RNA-seq Aǲ

Șǚƹȳ, Introgression line 76 ǉǓ+
300 TqɌAǲ

(ßǦ(*#

¦,ś.ɍǯǡ;-cwc(& RNA-seq ǽūɋƠƖĉƩÝıAÏ

&ɍ:ɍ introgression ,ûƦAú÷r'ƗČ ɋChitwood et al. 2013aɌ

ãš+,b]A¥#&ɍȤćƨƝAȬƩĩȏ(Łɍ>+ĪȽ=RiyɂöAƗČ= expression quantitative trait locusɋeQTLɌǽūAǲ('ɍȤćƨƝÉİARiy

r'Ş;+=('ɋRanjan et al., unpublishedɌ    c  ǯǡ;-ȘĠɍ;+ǇªɍɉțɍȐ¡©ůAčƝet al. 2015Ɍ, BrADseq '-ɍǿ, HTR +]ÏA 2 Ũȯ cDNA âĽ((8+ǲd?/:?@FIQR]

śƃAȲƨ ɋBrADseqɍTownsley=Xa`qAŕì!'*ɍD^qśƃAƚǧ+ȲƨɍqcS+Þ<¹>ɋñ 1CɌ½¢Ʃ+- 2 ŨȯŮȨ,ŧƿÕĉƩƗķ+:#&Ȳȱ=ƝȋAÈƢ&ɋvonHippel et al. 2013Ɍɍ5’ŧƿƗƧƩ+D^q]Aǐ5Ȗ6(+ĽÎǐǛ;#

6 šȳ' 96 ~Fp~£ĽßǦ(*<ɍSXc8 HTR :<8;+ 7®ɍĮŪ,śƃ:<8 21-77 ®ÊƊ'=

, BrADseq -ɍ7ɍĹøȬ:<·čÏ& strand-specificity ,b]AÞį=('=HTR ( BrADseq ,qcS

'ȤćƨƝ,ĘƧAžȕ=(ɍȻĝ+ɉ
BrADseq 8ǓǾƩŲÃÍɉ=~Fp~'Ƭȴį;>

7ɍHTR (ãŴ+b]AÃ('= ś'ǿ,śƃā+8ŘĂ, RNA-seq ~Fp~£ĽśƃȲƨ>&&¦.ɍdUTP A¥#~Fp~£ĽAǲÕčƝ>&=strand-specific ~Fp~9Ă,TqAq& 1 Ýĵ'śƃ<ɍ>;84

ƚǧ+SXc^G9jFXq`c=ɋShishkin et al. 2015; Wang et al. 2011Ɍ,ȤćƨƝǽū-ɍ­,ȤćAđȋ(ČȬƩ PCR ,::<ȒȘ*łǳ+*=(ǯǡ;-ƌ&=

7 RNA-seq +:=ǕǜƩ*ƨƝǽū+Þ#&@<ɍ

Y. Ichihashi & A. Fukushima-3
BSJ-Review 7:112 (2016)

植物科学最前線 7:113 (2016)ñ 1. RNA-seq ~Fp~£Ľśƃ(ǹ=ŝŘ,žȕ
ɋAɌIllumina Ƶ, TruSeq RNA sample preparation kitɍ
ɋBɌHTRɍɋCɌBrADseq ~Fp~£Ľ,OoȘĠ,łǳȲƨ+:<ɍȚĝ 3 ŝ' 24 Tq,(?ɍ6 šȳ' 96 Tq(
jFXq`cÕčƝ>

6F4^U '- RNA-seq ,b]ǽū,"ɍƇ,ȦÅǽū+$]Z`c+:<ǓǾƩ*ëɄƠ9+$&'-*ɍăǻŶ*bɍƨƝȬAǃÃŻǻÕĭ,b]ǽūŀƃ&Ȉ=ɋñ 2AɌKLaEMLa^U Ëș

~Fp~£Ľłǳ,ȼŚ+:<ɍĮŪ:<8-=+ăǻŶ*čɇßǦ(*=ś'ɍb],¿ĎǸȹÕ&=(Ďş+ĺ´'=¾ôƩKxOXb
],ǽūDq_(&-ɍ2 ǝȳ',žȕȚĝ:ǲ@>&=ºƨƝȤć+$& 2 ǝȳ,ƨƝȬ,ğó,ĘAŲÃɍt ŲČɋŻǻÄě;b]į;>&ËŐɌ*),ȄŲČA=(=ţĻƀƎ'ǲ(+:<ɍđȋ(= 2 ǝȳ'ƨƝŴģƧ*=ï,Ȥćǝ ɋdifferentially expressed genes, DEGsɌ AãČ'= ɋñ 2BɌDEGs
ǽū+-dŘȌ,ɀÄě+Į(AČ

ŀƃ'= edgeRɋRobinson et al.

2010Ɍ9 DEseqɋAnders et al. 2013Ɍ*),Ǿǃ\oc R 'ÈƢ'=l`QWƝò:

Y. Ichihashi & A. Fukushima-4
BSJ-Review 7:113 (2016)

植物科学最前線 7:114 (2016)ÈƢ>&=;+Ƈǽū(&ɍ>; DEGs +$& Gene ontologyɋGOɌǽū9

Gene set enrichmentɋGSEɌǽūAǲ('ɍƗČ,ŹǦ9ȉǑȑ+ȴ=Ȥćǝ

DEGs ¿+ǓǾƩţĻ+ĂĈò&=ŲČ=('ɋHung et al. 2012Ɍɍ2 ǝȳ',ȤćƨƝ,ȡAƗĲ%=('= šǉÅb]*),Ǹȹ*b]+$ɋñ 2CɌ¦(#&-ĂĀȬǽūAǲ

('ǺȚ:*=.ɍƨƝl]AņÃ=ƪƩ'ɍk-means clustering 9 hierarchical clustering

O~X]Pǽū:¥@>&=ɋAndreopoulos et al. 2009Ɍ4ƨƝl]

,º¢Ʃ*ƗĲAŃő=ƪƩ'ɍĽÄÄū9Ăź¶ēĢųĽƃ:¥@>=>;-ĂĀȬb],ĀŘ+Ȫ5A$&ĒŘ,âĽĀŘA£=(+:<ɍĂź¶b]A:<¡ź¶+=('b],ǽȩAÐ=;+ă*XQ,b]'-ɍǸŘ,ǹî¹>ćƘ+*#ĂĀȬb]+*=QXǠ¶b]Aǽū=ŀƃ(&ĭș= ΔPC AƢ'=(Ƴ>mapsɌ(;>=ŢȘɍ#Ăź

superSOM O~X]PǽūţÒɋChitwood et al. 2013bɌSOM -ɍǧęǐǛÕw`qɋSelf-organizingėƶǑíȑh`cO,ƹ'ɍŖĜ*ĉǟ+:#&¹Íb]AĻ,ź¶0À´=('=ɋWehrens and Buydens 2007ɌƗ+ superSOM -ɍĀŘ(+
Ȫ5'=

7ɍĂź¶b],O~X]Pǽū+Ƣ=('='Ăź¶b]ɋ¦.ɍƧ*=Âƞũ+=šǉÅ,ȤćƨƝAžȕ=Ɍ;ǹîȳ,Ƭ£Ƣɋ¦.ɍÂƞ × šȳ,Ƭ£ƢɌAņÃ=

7ɍ4ĽÄÄū+:<ºb]A¡ź¶ƽȳɋPC spaceɌ+w`q&ɍƧ*=ǹî,ȳ'ĀÕ=ȤćA PC space
',ĀÕȬɋΔPCɌ(& PC Ȕ(+Ǿǃ=º ΔPC +$'=O~X]Pśƃ'£Ƣɋ¦= superSOM 'ǽū=(+:<ɍƧ*=ǹîȳ',Ƭ

.ɍƧ*=Âƞũ'šǉÅ,ȤćƨƝl]ĀÕ=ƗĲɌAVX

ayr'ǿșƞǽ=('=,:DEGs ǽū9O~X]Pǽū'-ŲÃ'*=¦&ɍĀŘ(+Ȫ5*ǽū+:#&ɍĮŪ,sDFYȤćƨƝ,^FexOXŞ;+*. Chitwood et al.ɋ2013bɌ'-ɍcwc(Șǚƹ,Ƨ*=ǐǛ+= RNA-seq b

]A¥#&ɍΔPC AƢ

superSOM O~X]PǽūAĵƢ=(+:<ɍƹȳ',ǐǛÇ,ȤćƨƝl],ĀÕ,ƗĲAŞ;+,'ɍcwc,Ȥć-Șǚƹ,ƬãȤć+ž1&ɍzXayAå6ǐǛ'ɉƨƝɍÄÕ

ƝAƳ³ä+<ɍ>-ƹȳ,zXay,ă,ȡ

AÝŠ&

ǐǛ'-¡

ƨ



857CF1^U ƠƖƹƳŴ*Ɲȋ,Ă-ɍŘØ;Ř,Ƨ*=Ȥćǝ,Ǹȹ*Éİh`c
O,Ō=ǩ+¨Ĉ=,:*Ǹȹ*VXayAƞǽ=7+ɍȤćÉİh`cO,ŏČ(,{W|ɋTph`cOɌ,ÒƜƩ*ãČ-ɍƝ,VXay
ƠƖĉ+=ĳƩȆɄ,$'=TqŘüÏ

c~XOqcyb

Y. Ichihashi & A. Fukushima-5
BSJ-Review 7:114 (2016)

植物科学最前線 7:115 (2016)]-ɍȤć X―Ȥć Y ƨƝl]ȳ,Ʌķɋ¼ƨƝɌAǕǜƩ+ȇ1=Ȥć¼ƨ
Ɲh`cOǽūɋȤćAƐȤćȳȴȝķAǘ'Ǵh`cOɌA;+ħÍ+=ɋñ 2DɌ,ƨƝl]ȳ,ȴȝķAȇ1=ɅķēĢ+$&-ɍnD\Ƭȴ«Ř ɋr -ɍĀŘ X, Y (,ȴ«ķ,ŉŵɍ-1 < r < 1 ,°A(=Ɍ Ţ8:¥@>&=ɋde Siqueira Santos et al. 2014ɌɍnD\Ƭȴ«Ř-ɍƨƝl]ȳ,ƫǘȴ«,5ŏČßǦ',<ɍā>° ɋ,°+ž1&ȸƾ#&Ƨ*=°Ɍ +@7&ĥ7ɍƫǘ,5*;ÚȇüƊ+ȴ&ŏČßǦ'ā>°+ħȴ«Ř,ȢƢ8ţÒ'ć Z A

=4

XnDw,Ɂ

ƬȤć X ( Y (,ȳ,Ƭȴȴ«Ĉò&8ɍǀ 3 ,ȤǺ,Ƭȴȴ«AǺ&

=QX8

=,:

*ĪȽAȶ

7+ɍ±Ƭȴ«ŘÈƢ'=ɋde la Fuente et al. 2004Ɍ Ȥć X―Ȥć Y ƨƝl]ȳ,ȴ«ķ-ƫǘɋǘĩɌȴ«,5*;Ŵ*Ȼǘĩȴ«å4>=ßǦķ=ƬĹøȬA¥#=,7ĹøƞȈ+÷%ɍX ( Y (¼ţ=ĹøȬAƌ

2 ĀŘȳ,ȴ«ķ,ŏČB+ƯƼ>&=ɋVinga 2014ɏWang

and Huang 2014; Liu 2015ɌȘĠ'-ɍŢăĹø«ŘɍMaximal Information CoefficientɋMICɍ
Reshef et al. 2011Ɍ9 Hilbert-Schmidt Independence CriteriaɋHSICɍGretton et al. 2005ɌĀŘȳ,Ȼǘĩȴ«AČȬ=21 Ǌ,Ƭȴ*)(ƪ>&%=4ɍǘĩŘŀƃ+÷&ĀŘȳ,ƫŎƩ¨ĈķAŏČ= network deconvolution 8ŐŰ>&

2013Ɍ !Ȥć¼ƨƝȴ«,ŏČ+ȵ#Ĵ8µ>& ǿ,:

ùâɍƬĹøȬ+÷%ŀƃƬȴ+ž1&=@'-*ɍùâ+:#&-ā>°+ħ

midcorrelation  MIC AÁ(Ƴ>&=ɋFeizi et al.

Ƭ ȴ « Ř biweight=ɋSong et al. 2012Ɍ*h`cOǽū;ɍȤćƨƝ,5,b]'=+8@;ɍȤćÉİh`cO,ȥAŏČ=('=čȸǯǡ;8cwc(Șǚƹ+=Ǯ,Ƨ*=ƨƠXaW, RNA-seq b];ɍǮ,ĩļȞÕ+Ȫǹ*ȤćÉİh`c
O,{W|AŏČɍčɇb]+:#&,ǒŬAŔň ɋIchihashi et al. 2014ɌÏ&ɍh`cOǽū;ȤćŹǦAŏČ=(8ßǦ'ƨƝl]&=Ȥćãþ-ŹǦ&=(ťĬ>==ɋHansen et al. 2014Ɍ
7ɍŹǦŜƮ,Ȥć

AMFd(&ȤćŹǦƌ'=ɋAoki et al. 2007; Usadel et al. 2009Ɍ,śƃ-ɍűƖ,Ǎǥý9źȉƖ+ȴȝȤć,ŹǦǽū',ĆÍAƨŒ& ɋSaito et al.

2008Ɍ 10 Ġ,ȳ+»¼ÈƢßǦ*b]AÈƢXůŽ+ü&¼ƨƝb]AŐ§=b]r=Æť,ȿ-{bűƖVFgeYeĳ'-ƹȳ'¼ƨƝȴ«,žȕ8ßǦ+*#&&,Ȫǹ*ƠƖĉƩ*ĻæņÃ'=!?

=

#

ɍŢȘ'

7ɋǴ 1Ɍɍh`cOǽū;Ă6.9-BD2>A857CF1 ;+Ǹȹ*ƠƖƝȋAƞǽ='ɍƧ*=h`cOAžȕ=ŀƃĴǹ(*=Y. Ichihashi & A. Fukushima-6
BSJ-Review 7:115 (2016)

植物科学最前線 7:116 (2016)'ƨƝĘƧɋDEGsɌ(Ȥć¼ƨƝ(Aǐ5â@Ǡ

ǧƒ*ŇĦ(&ɍ¼ƨƝĘƧA

=('=ɋñ 2EɌ>-ɍđƓǝ:/čɇǝ, 2 ǝȳ'Ƨ*=¼ƨƝȴ«A

ãČ=ɍ*@"Ƨ*=h`cOȳ'ĀÕ'=ɋFukushima 2013; Kayano et al. 2014Ɍ¦wFODFb]AƢ

Ƭ£ƢAVXayr'Ş;+.ǯǡ;-ɍcwc,Ǯ(Ŭč;į;>ăǻŶ*¼ƨƝĘƧh`cO+:<ɍȉǑȑ+=NXa`qAŞ;+&ɋFukushima et al. 2012Ɍ ;+ȘĠ'-ɍ¼ƨƝĘƧ(ȓÀîćĹø(Aǐ5â@

differential regulation analysis

ɋDRAɌŐŰ> ɋHudson et al. 2012; Yang et al. 2013; Yu et al. 2014Ɍ>-ȓÀîćA
Sd=Ȥć+$
â@=('ɍǲ&ɍ2 ǝȳ',ƨƝĘƧ(¼ƨƝĘƧ(A>>Ȫ5%ǐ5=ȓÀîć,h`cO0,ĪȽAÝŠǯǡ;Ʈ=ȵ<űƖƸĉ',¦-4!*;>

ǓǾȬ+:<ɁɍǂǢȏ*nI{aƕ(èƕ;į

ǸŘ,ƨȠXaW+=wFODFb]:<ǃÃ

FactorɋRIFɌǓǾȬ-ɍǂǢȏǂǢǣă,ÛîȤć'ɈůǂÄÕńÉȤćɌAŻŏČ&ŚRegulatory Impact=xKX]_ɋMyostatin; MSTNɍɋHudson et al. 2009ɌǨæƉ¥@>=ȤćƨƝȬɍƨƝĘƧɍ¼ƨƝ+÷%b]ǽū,Ƴê'*#(+ɍȚĝ:

>8 MSTN ,ȪǹķA

7ɍDRA -c~XOqcyb]A¥#

Dq_AŐ§=RIF Aå7ANȤćōǌ+ǸŘ, DRA ŀƃ-ɍ¼ƨƝĘƧAǾǃ'=

R ,l`QW DCGLɋYang et al. 2013Ɍ'ÈƢßǦ'=,(;b]ǽū+&­,Ȥć,h`cO¿',īÌ9Ǎǥ¿SaNXcAh`cOº¢;Ȁ
©=(Ȫǹ'=(@<ɍĂȬ'Ǹȹ*b];ţƢ*ĹøAį=ŢŚ,ǓǾǽūƃAčǵ&Ŋ6Ĵǹ=(@#&8;

=!?

7+-ɍ



0<136F4^U%!"+WPGb ǿ,b]ǽūǒŬ+÷%ȤćŹǦčɇ,ǾƥA=ȸɍƄĻ1ƐAŋ=Ɏ
1.


ǹ'

2.


=¦

 ȤćƨƝl]ȳ,ȴ«ķųȜAŃő=Ļæ'@7&Ȫ.ɍā>°

#ùâ,nD\Ƭȴ«Ř+

!!!  :Ôȡ&

>=QX'&8ɍĴ8ãŹǦ(-ȵ;ɍ²ƒ

3.

*ƄĻĴǹ'=

),:

*ƙ



'ɍ),:







=ɍ,Ǥĭ+ǾƥAƾ&=(Ȫǹ'

=

ùâ8

<

=

,'ɍb],ǽȩ+-×Ä ÈƢ=b]rX9ǽūŀƃ*b];ɍ),:ȳ,ɅķAČȬ&=ɍƨƝl]

l]AƳ4&9ɍƫŎƩ*îŬȴ«AĴ8Ƴ@'-Ƒ=Ĺø-**Dq_'ɍȤćƨƝl]=ųĺ9ƄĻƐA×Ä+ƞǽ&čɇ

Y. Ichihashi & A. Fukushima-7
BSJ-Review 7:116 (2016)

植物科学最前線 7:117 (2016)ñ 2. RNA-seq ,ȤćƨƝȬb];,ǽūśƃ
ɋAɌVQVP;Ƈǽū,ȦÅǽūoCX+w`q>dALGc=(+:<ȤćƨƝȬAǃÃ=ɋȚĝɍȤćŘ p >>TqŘ nɌ
ɋB-EɌƨƝȬAǃÃb],ǽūŀƃɍɋBɌDEGs ǽū=Ȥć A ,ƨƝȬ+Ęĭ,= t ŲČ*)'ȇ1=ɋCɌĂĀȬǽū,O~X]Pǽū(ĽÄÄūȤćƨƝ,l]AņÃ=ɋDɌh`cOǽūǸŘ,ƨƝb];ȤćAƐȤćȳȴȝķAǘ'Ǵh`cOAųǆ'=ȤćȤć,ȴ«ķ-ɍƫǘȴ«ɋǘĩȴ«ɌAƳùâ(ɍȻǘĩȴ«AƳùâ<ɍƬ

ȴ(ĹøƞȈ(+÷%ɅķēĢ>>ÈƢ'=
ɋEɌ¼ƨƝĘƧǽū2 $,ũȳ'áƌČ>Ȥćǝȳ,¼ƨƝl]-ɍ2 ũȳ'Ƨ*=ùâ-ɍȮȧǋȤć9ȓÀȇǄîć*)å4>=ßǦķɉ=>;¼ƨƝĘƧȤć+











Y. Ichihashi & A. Fukushima-8
BSJ-Review 7:117 (2016)maize, rice







microarraymicroarraymicroarrayRNA-seq

microarray#(

the Eukaryotic
Gene Orthologues
database-

PCC* PCC, Pearson's correlation coefficient; CLR, Context Likelihood of Relatedness

binary asymmetricdistance
PCC

OrthoMCL

OrthoMCL
Reciprocal Best BLAST
Hit

NCBI HomoloGene

CLR

PCC

PCC

PCC

cosine correlation
correspondense analysis
and Pearson's correlation
coefficient
OrthoMCL

Miozzi et al. Plant Mol Biol,2010
Tzfadia et al. Plant Cell, 2012

Jupiter et al. BMC
Bioinformatics, 2009
Movahedi et al. Plant Physiol,
2011
Ficklin and Feltus, Plant
Physiol, 2011
Netotea et al. BMC Genomics,
2014
Yim et al. BMC Plant Biol,
2013

Ohyanagi et al. PCP, 2015

Aoki et al. PCP, 2015
Ogata et al. Bioinformatics,
2010

Mutwil et al. Plant Cell, 2011 !

Reciprocal Best BLAST
Hit

PCC and reciprocal rank PFAM

*

weighted PCC andmicroarray and RNA-seq mutual rank

microarrayArabidopsis, poplar, rice
microarray
Arabidopsis, soybean, barley, rice,
tomato, wheat, grape, maize
PLANEX
microarray
EST presence/absence
profileconservation
ORTom
tomato, potato, tobacco, pepper
MORPH Algorithm Arabidopsis, tomato
microarray

ComPlExPODC

CoP

ATTED-II

PLANET

Maize-riceArabidopsis, rice



ECC

(

STARNET2"

$
Arabidopsis, barley, medicago,
poplar, rice, soybean, wheat,brachypodium
Arabidopsis, field mustard,
soybean, medick, poplar, tomato,grape, rice, maize
Arabidopsis, barley, poplar, rice,soybean, wheat, grape, maize
Arabidopsis, rice, Sorghum,
tomato, grape, medicago, potato,
soybeanhuman, rat, mouse, chicken,
zebrafish, Drosophila, C. elegans,S. cerevisiae, Arabidopsis, rice&1 $)'%

http://ortom.ivv.cnr.it/
http://bioinformatics.psb.ugent.be/webtools/morph/

http://planex.plantbioinformatics.org/

http://complex.plantgenie.org/

http://www.clemson.edu/genenetwork/network.php

http://bioinformatics.psb.ugent.be/supplementary_data/samov/apr2011/

http://vanburenlab.medicine.tamhsc.edu/starnet2.html

http://bioinf.mind.meiji.ac.jp/podc/

http://webs2.kazusa.or.jp/kagiana/cop0911/

http://atted.jp/

http://aranet.mpimp-golm.mpg.de/

URL

植物科学最前線 7:118 (2016)



Y. Ichihashi & A. Fukushima-9

BSJ-Review 7:118 (2016)

植物科学最前線 7:119 (2016)

!,*%
 ĭ,űƖƸĉ+

&c~XOqcyǽū-),:ɐŨǖȄ'Ƴ+ɍRNA-seq ɉĢ+jFXq`cÕ=('ɍ:<ăǻŶ:*qWHOcßǦ(*=>+:<ǓǾƩ+ɉ+ÈƢ>&

!?

ǈĢ,b]Þį-8"?BɍoEdAđȋ(=Ơļĉ0,ĔȲ9ɍ,ƯƼǡ'$,űƖƹ,c~XOqc
yw`qA£Ľ'=*)ɍŚǻȤć,ƨǺÏț=!?
Ç,ƨƝǽūAǲ

Ï&ɍ:<ȁǍ+ǐǛ

7+ǐǛÇq{]9UwFO^FZOV}AƢƨƝǽū9ɍȘĠ,Ƈ¢Íĉ,ȞĔ+:<ßǦ(*#8ȒȘ*łǳ(*=!? ɋPicelli et al. 2014Ɍ4
QT-:<ȰȦÅAȅ6('=

1 Ǎǥ,c~XOqcyǽūǀVQT'= 1 ÄćV7ɍȓÀơƖºȰAĢ+VQX'=

ɋTilgner et al. 2014Ɍ,łǳc~XOqcyǽū+ÈƢ>=(+*>.ɍ:<ŻƨƝȬ9 alternative splicing variants AČȬ=('= ŨǖȄ'-ȁș*#ɍVQVPĭ,ȦÅb]ǽū'-:<ɉț'Żư*

oCX0,w`nP9ȤćƨƝȬŏČŀƃ,ƆǙƁ7;>&=Ï~XOqcyb],5*;Ğġz_yz]uyoHiy(#

Ŵ*KxOXb]AǓâɍqaKy+Śǻ,ƠƖĉƩĻǞAĤÃǾǃƠƖĉ kFKFoJwaEOXÄȫ,ĳȆɄ(*#&Ɨ+>;b]AƢ

&ɍc=ɋCavill et al. 2015Ɍ

ǓâƩ*h`cOǽū-ɍȪǹĩȏ+ȴ=ȮîćȤć,ƌ9oEd',ǴƝôƌAǲǴƝôȴȝķ,ǽŞ+ď=,:ÒƜƩ*{bA8;ßǦķA8"Ȥô*łǳȞż+:<c~XOqcyAå7KxOXǽū,đȋwO+8xO+8ŇăɍľǺ=('=Ʀġ=ĭɍ,Ś

ƦAǺ=(+:#&ɍ

+ƦǼ*@"ŚAƞǽ'=ź,ƯƼǡ+Ɓ7;>=ȆɄ'?

ƠƖĉƩƮǺ

_`
 Ũƺ'ǎĉƯƼǶÐȭ

ǯǡ;,ƯƼ,ȥ-ɍƞÕĉƯƼĿ

ǬŀƯƼ Bɋ15K18589ɌɋĚŸ ƅǅɌɍÜ/ƸĉƯƼǶÐȭ

ɋ26850024ɌɋƷĕ ŗàɌ,ŔœAį&ȟǲvcAȾ

÷ƲƸĉƗÇƯƼéÉĢ:/Ƹ4ŨƯƼAȞ7=+

ǬŀƯƼ B<ɍŘ,T

ɍLoJfDăĉbmXŭ Prof. Neelima SinhaɍDr. Ravi KumarɍDr. Brad

TownsleyɍDr. Jie Pengɍded^oJXƯƼĿ Dr. Daniel Chitwood +ɍ,ùA¯<&ƴƣ4OZSY
Anders, S., McCarthy, D.J., Chen, Y., Okoniewski, M., Smyth, G.K., Huber, W. & Robinson, M.D.
2013. Count-based differential expression analysis of RNA sequencing data using R and

Y. Ichihashi & A. Fukushima-10
BSJ-Review 7:119 (2016)

植物科学最前線 7:120 (2016)

Bioconductor. Nat Protoc 8:1765-1786.
Andreopoulos, B., An, A., Wang, X. & Schroeder, M. 2009. A roadmap of clustering algorithms:
finding a match for a biomedical application. Brief Bioinform 10:297-314.
Aoki, K., Ogata, Y. & Shibata, D. 2007. Approaches for extracting practical information from gene
co-expression networks in plant biology. Plant & cell physiology 48:381-390.
Aoki, Y., Okamura, Y., Tadaka, S., Kinoshita, K. & Obayashi, T. 2015. ATTED-II in 2016: A plant
coexpression database towards lineage-specific coexpression. Plant & cell physiology doi:
10.1093/pcp/pcv165.
Cavill, R., Jennen, D., Kleinjans, J. & Briedé, J.J. 2015. Transcriptomic and metabolomic data
integration. Brief Bioinform doi: 10.1093/bib/bbv090.
Chitwood, D.H., Kumar, R., Headland, L.R., Ranjan, A., Covington, M.F., Ichihashi, Y., Fulop, D.,
Jimenez-Gomez, J.M., Peng, J., Maloof, J.N. & Sinha, N.R. 2013a. A quantitative genetic basis forleaf morphology in a set of precisely defined tomato introgression lines. The Plant cell
25:2465-2481.
Chitwood, D.H., Maloof, J.N. & Sinha, N.R. 2013b. Dynamic transcriptomic profiles between tomato
and a wild relative reflect distinct developmental architectures. Plant physiology 162:537-552.
de la Fuente, A., Bing, N., Hoeschele, I. & Mendes, P. 2004. Discovery of meaningful associations ingenomic data using partial correlation coefficients. Bioinformatics 20:3565-3574.
de Siqueira Santos, S., Takahashi, D.Y., Nakata, A. & Fujita, A. 2014. A comparative study ofstatistical methods used to identify dependencies between gene expression signals. Brief Bioinform
15:906-918.
Feizi, S., Marbach, D., Medard, M. & Kellis, M. 2013. Network deconvolution as a general method todistinguish direct dependencies in networks. Nat Biotechnol 31:726-733.
Ficklin, S.P. & Feltus, F.A. 2011. Gene coexpression network alignment and conservation of gene
modules between two grass species: maize and rice. Plant physiology 156:1244-1256.
Fisher, S., Barry, A., Abreu, J., Minie, B., Nolan, J., Delorey, T.M., Young, G., Fennell, T.J., Allen, A.,
Ambrogio, L., Berlin. A.M., Blumenstiel, B., Cibulskis, K., Friedrich, D., Johnson, R., Juhn, F.,
Reilly, B., Shammas, R., Stalker, J., Sykes, S.M., Thompson, J., Walsh, J., Zimmer, A., Zwirko, Z.,
Gabriel, S., Nicol, R. & Nusbaum, C. 2011. A scalable, fully automated process for construction ofsequence-ready human exome targeted capture libraries. Genome biology 12:R1.
Fukushima, A. 2013. DiffCorr: an R package to analyze and visualize differential correlations inbiological networks. Gene 518:209-214.
Fukushima, A. & Kusano, M. 2014. A network perspective on nitrogen metabolism from model tocrop plants using integrated 'omics' approaches. Journal of experimental botany 65:5619-5630.
Fukushima, A., Nishizawa, T., Hayakumo, M., Hikosaka, S., Saito, K., Goto, E. & Kusano, M. 2012.

Y. Ichihashi & A. Fukushima-11
BSJ-Review 7:120 (2016)

植物科学最前線 7:121 (2016)

Exploring tomato gene functions based on coexpression modules using graph clustering anddifferential coexpression approaches. Plant physiology 158:1487-1502.
Gretton, A., Bousquet, O., Smola, A. & Schölkopf, B. 2005. Measuring statistical dependence withhilbert-schmidt norms. Springer, Berlin Heidelberg
Hansen, B.O., Vaid, N., Musialak-Lange, M., Janowski, M. & Mutwil, M. 2014. Elucidating genefunction and function evolution through comparison of co-expression networks of plants. Frontiersin plant science 5:394.
Hudson, N.J., Dalrymple, B.P. & Reverter, A. 2012. Beyond differential expression: the quest forcausal mutations and effector molecules. BMC Genomics 13:356.
Hudson, N.J., Reverter, A. & Dalrymple, B.P. 2009. A differential wiring analysis of expression data
correctly identifies the gene containing the causal mutation. PLoS Comput Biol 5:e1000382.
Hung, J.H., Yang, T.H., Hu, Z., Weng, Z. & DeLisi, C. 2012. Gene set enrichment analysis:
performance evaluation and usage guidelines. Brief Bioinform 13:281-291.
Ichihashi, Y., Aguilar-Martinez, J.A., Farhi, M., Chitwood, D.H., Kumar, R., Millon, L.V., Peng, J.,
Maloof, J.N. & Sinha, N.R. 2014. Evolutionary developmental transcriptomics reveals a gene
network module regulating interspecific diversity in plant leaf shape. Proceedings of the National
Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 111:E2616-2621.
Ichihashi, Y., Mutuku, J.M., Yoshida, S. & Shirasu, K. 2015. Transcriptomics exposes the uniquenessof parasitic plants. Brief Funct Genomics 14:275-282.
Ichihashi, Y. & Sinha, N.R. 2014. From genome to phenome and back in tomato. Current opinion inplant biology 18:9-15.
Jupiter, D., Chen, H. & VanBuren, V. 2009. STARNET 2: a web-based tool for accelerating discovery
of gene regulatory networks using microarray co-expression data. BMC Bioinformatics 10:332.
Kayano, M., Shiga, M. & Mamitsuka, H. 2014. Detecting differentially coexpressed genes fromlabeled expression data: a brief review. IEEE/ACM Trans Comput Biol Bioinform 11:154-167.
Kumar, R., Ichihashi, Y., Kimura, S., Chitwood, D.H., Headland, L.R., Peng, J., Maloof, J.N. & Sinha,
N.R. 2012. A high-throughput method for Illumina RNA-Seq library preparation. Frontiers inplant science 3:202.
Liu, Z.P. 2015. Reverse engineering of genome-wide gene regulatory networks from gene expression
data. Curr Genomics 16:3-22.
Mader, U., Nicolas, P., Richard, H., Bessieres, P. & Aymerich, S. 2011. Comprehensive identificationand quantification of microbial transcriptomes by genome-wide unbiased methods. Curr Opin
Biotechnol 22:32-41.
Miozzi, L., Provero, P. & Accotto, G.P. 2010. ORTom: a multi-species approach based on conserved
co-expression to identify putative functional relationships among genes in tomato. Plant molecular

Y. Ichihashi & A. Fukushima-12
BSJ-Review 7:121 (2016)

植物科学最前線 7:122 (2016)

biology 73:519-532.
Movahedi, S., Van de Peer, Y. & Vandepoele, K. 2011. Comparative network analysis reveals thattissue specificity and gene function are important factors influencing the mode of expression
evolution in Arabidopsis and rice. Plant physiology 156:1316-1330.
Mutwil, M., Klie, S., Tohge, T., Giorgi, F.M., Wilkins, O., Campbell, M.M., Fernie, A.R., Usadel, B.,
Nikoloski, Z. & Persson, S. 2011. PlaNet: combined sequence and expression comparisons acrossplant networks derived from seven species. The Plant cell 23:895-910.
Netotea, S., Sundell, D., Street, N.R. & Hvidsten, T.R. 2014. ComPlEx: conservation and divergenceof co-expression networks in A. thaliana, Populus and O. sativa. BMC Genomics 15:106.
Ohyanagi, H., Takano, T., Terashima, S., Kobayashi, M., Kanno, M., Morimoto, K., Kanegae, H.,
Sasaki, Y., Saito, M., Asano, S., Ozaki, S., Kudo, T., Yokoyama, K., Aya, K., Suwabe, K., Suzuki,G., Aoki, K., Kubo, Y., Watanabe, M., Matsuoka, M. & Yano, K. 2015. Plant Omics Data Center:
an integrated web repository for interspecies gene expression networks with NLP-based curation.
Plant & cell physiology 56:e9.
Ogata, Y., Suzuki, H., Sakurai, N. & Shibata, D. 2010. CoP: a database for characterizing
co-expressed gene modules with biological information in plants. Bioinformatics 26: 1267-1268.
Ozsolak, F. & Milos, P.M. 2011. RNA sequencing: advances, challenges and opportunities. Nature
reviews Genetics 12:87-98.
Picelli, S., Faridani, O.R., Bjorklund, A.K., Winberg, G., Sagasser, S. & Sandberg, R. 2014.
Full-length RNA-seq from single cells using Smart-seq2. Nat Protoc 9:171-181.
Ranjan, A., Townsley, B.T., Ichihashi, Y., Sinha, N.R. & Chitwood, D.H. 2015. An intracellulartranscriptomic atlas of the giant coenocyte Caulerpa taxifolia. PLoS genetics 11:e1004900.
Reshef, D.N., Reshef, Y.A., Finucane, H.K., Grossman, S.R., McVean, G., Turnbaugh, P.J., Lander,
E.S., Mitzenmacher, M. & Sabeti, P.C. 2011. Detecting novel associations in large data sets.
Science 334:1518-1524.
Robinson, M.D., McCarthy, D.J. & Smyth, G.K. 2010. edgeR: a Bioconductor package for differential
expression analysis of digital gene expression data. Bioinformatics 26:139-140.
Saito, K., Hirai, M.Y. & Yonekura-Sakakibara, K. 2008. Decoding genes with coexpression networks
and metabolomics - 'majority report by precogs'. Trends in plant science 13:36-43.
Shishkin, A.A., Giannoukos, G., Kucukural, A., Ciulla, D., Busby, M., Surka, C., Chen, J.,
Bhattacharyya, R.P., Rudy, R.F., Patel, M.M., Novod, N., Hung, D.T., Gnirke, A., Garber, M,.
Guttman, M. & Livny, J. 2015. Simultaneous generation of many RNA-seq libraries in a single
reaction. Nature methods 12:323-325.
Song, L., Langfelder, P. & Horvath, S. 2012. Comparison of co-expression measures: mutual
information, correlation, and model based indices. BMC Bioinformatics 13:328.

Y. Ichihashi & A. Fukushima-13
BSJ-Review 7:122 (2016)

植物科学最前線 7:123 (2016)

Tilgner, H., Grubert, F., Sharon, D. & Snyder, M.P. 2014. Defining a personal, allele-specific, andsingle-molecule long-read transcriptome. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of theUnited States of America 111:9869-9874.
Townsley, B.T., Covington, M.F., Ichihashi, Y., Zumstein, K. & Sinha, N.R. 2015. BrAD-seq: Breath
Adapter Directional sequencing: a streamlined, ultra-simple and fast library preparation protocol
for strand specific mRNA library construction. Frontiers in plant science 6:366.
Tzfadia, O., Amar, D., Bradbury, L.M., Wurtzel, E.T. & Shamir, R. 2012. The MORPH algorithm:
ranking candidate genes for membership in Arabidopsis and tomato pathways. The Plant cell
24:4389-4406.
Usadel, B., Obayashi, T., Mutwil, M., Giorgi, F.M., Bassel, G.W., Tanimoto, M., Chow, A.,
Steinhauser, D., Persson, S. & Provart, N.J. 2009. Co-expression tools for plant biology:
opportunities for hypothesis generation and caveats. Plant Cell Environ 32:1633-1651.
Vinga, S. 2014. Editorial: Alignment-free methods in computational biology. Brief Bioinform
15:341-342.
von Hippel, P.H., Johnson, N.P. & Marcus, A.H. 2013. Fifty years of DNA "Breathing": Reflections
on old and new approaches. Biopolymers 99:923-954.
Wang, L., Si, Y., Dedow, L.K., Shao, Y., Liu, P. & Brutnell, T.P. 2011. A low-cost library
construction protocol and data analysis pipeline for Illumina-based strand-specific multiplex
RNA-seq. PLoS One 6:e26426.
Wang, Y.X. & Huang, H. 2014. Review on statistical methods for gene network reconstruction using
expression data. J Theor Biol 362:53-61.
Wang, Z., Gerstein, M. & Snyder, M. 2009. RNA-Seq: a revolutionary tool for transcriptomics.
Nature reviews Genetics 10:57-63.
Wehrens, R. & Buydens, L.M.C. 2007. Self- and super-organizing maps in R: The kohonen package. J
Stat Softw 21:1-19.
Yang, J., Yu, H., Liu, B.H., Zhao, Z., Liu, L., Ma, L.X., Li, Y.X. & Li, Y.Y. 2013. DCGL v2.0: an R
package for unveiling differential regulation from differential co-expression. PLoS One 8:e79729.
Yim, W.C., Yu, Y., Song, K., Jang, C.S. & Lee, B.M. 2013. PLANEX: the plant co-expression
database. BMC Plant Biol 13:83.
Yu, H., Mitra, R., Yang, J., Li, Y. & Zhao, Z. 2014. Algorithms for network-based identification ofdifferential regulators from transcriptome data: a systematic evaluation. Sci China Life Sci
57:1090-1102.

Y. Ichihashi & A. Fukushima-14
BSJ-Review 7:123 (2016)