 '*,$& ÞŅ ǾĜyŦŜ ¢ðǱ
XqzteïöōŲŻŲöƌƙĥ

The genetic basis for the evolution of self-compatibility in Arabidopsis
Key words: Arabidopsis; genetic basis of adaptation; reproductive systems;
self-compatibility; selfing.
Takashi Tsuchimatsu & Kentaro K. Shimizu
Institute of Plant Biology, University of Zurich
Zollikerstrasse 107, CH-8008 Zurich, Switzerland.-
©ǈôōŲ, !Ƥ 7 µ*Æ1ƗȔ/'#,ǂ,*ȁȒǂơȓ
yȃȒƼŷȓ, 2 #,ğD
Ī#ğǂD#@'Ɗ>A% @ (Yampolsky & Yampolsky 1922)ğǂD#@ōŲ,*-ƿĈ,ǂơ'Ƽŷ,ǳ*="%ƗôD#@'Ëƽ)Ɨî ?Ȕ,=)ƴŘőďDƿŘȒƿüÉƢȓ'Ǒ A*þȔÏë,ǂơ'Ƽŷ,ǳ-ŘȒüÉƢȓ'Ô.A@ōŲƿŘDǆ ǮĝƄ)ġƸȔƿŘDǪ @ -Ùǰ@nL_TmȔƿŘōŲȂÛ*:>Ǫ¾Ƅ)ĕȈ)(-ȔWzIGxŃȔŻĢöyǪ¾ö* @ĚƄ)ǗȌ& @ƒ!-Ȕ®ôǯö,o[uŻŲ& @Fgs^ƓRwH`^T^Dż %Ȕ®ôviu,Ɗǌ>,= )ŻĢöƄyǪ¾öƄ)× *ǦB '% @łƯǖ&-ȔƿŘƌƙ,ŖÌDƠÂ*Ĭ?ǥ?Ȕƒ!,ƌƙ',ė,ĂĿDƧ /-'!+$%
ƿŘ,ľ±)ŭy±)ŭDĽ°*ƓöƄ*ƌƙ,-ȔƗ,ǞŪDǃǪ¾ŻŲö,ƐWzIGx (C. Darwin)& @WzIGx-ƾï)ķ,ōŲƗ*# %ǳúȏDǆ ȔƿŘDƘŏƄ*ǆ Ɨõà@{Ĺ&Ȕî,ōŲƗ-ŽŃ,ǂơ&ƗôDƫú@'DĻ>*A*· %WzIGx-ȔƿŘŽŃ,-ŘŽŃ,*Ś3%{ǀ*ģǸyƴŘƽ¶ 'Dƃǌ (Darwin 1876)ōŲ;e\DÑ8ő)ŻŲ*%Ȕ

ƿŘ,= )ǤǍǳŽŃ,ô÷,ģǸŶ"?ǯƁ,ƃƂtSMȐ6"?@ŸǛƊ>A% ?ȔADǤđ½'Ô1Ǥđ½-ȔȂÛ* ȋĎ&õà@¸ğľûƚůìƀjoĮÎ&İ'*=?ĐǞA@ (Ưǖ'% Charlesworth & Willis2009)
)>Ȕ{Ĺ&ƿŘDǆ ōŲ:îõà@ƿŘ*-Ǥđ½Dǉ"%? @±ŭ @- 'ƹ ȔWzIGxĽƨƄ*ǆƉ ǖƴŘǓǖ& "WzIGx-ȔǿȅAȂÛ)(,ǳƈĦā) ŴŠ;Ȕǧơƺ,ǒǂȋĎøù)źé
T. Tuchimatsu & K.K. Shimizu - 1&-Ȕ{ &ƗôDŗ@ƿŘğ-ƍú)ƴŘDǓ@'

ŭ&ľ±*)@,&-) 'ƹ ,ėȔǳƈĦŧā%6 Ëƽğ,Ȑ ǸǠȅ®ĶDƪƗ-ƿŘğ,:,î '{ǀƄ)¤ÐȔiHLzȒH.G. Bakerȓ*="%æÒA (Baker 1955)

iHLz,š²'Ô.A@,¤Ð-ȔƴŘǓǖDĴĪ@ǓĨ,/'#& @ƿŘ,ǮĝƄġƸ*Ǻ@: /'#,Ǵǋ)ƹý-ȔfGYRpzȒR.A. Fisherȓ*=@ǯô,ǬºŶ& @ (Fisher 1941)WzIGx-Ǥđ½'

ƿŘ,±*ƉƆ%ȔfGYRpz-8BåłƄ*-ƿŘ,Ĺľ±)- 'ƹ Ř*="%>AƗô&-ȔŰǍȒǂơǍȓ'řǍȒƼŷǍȓ-ǭ & @{ĹȔƿŘ*="%>AƗô&-ŰǍ:řǍ:ÏȔƿ®ƿǡ& @#6?ȔƿŘŽŃ,Ɨô-Ǎ,ǯô>,7ŐģA% @'*)@ȔŘŽŃ,Ɨô&-ȔÁ®-ƿ®ŽŃ& @:,,: Á®-6",ŽŃ& @,'-ȔŘ=?ƿŘ,4 Ŕ2,ǯô,ǬºŶ 2

ǁ Ȕ#6?Ǫ¾Ƅ*ľ±& @'DġÓ@,'>fGYRpz-ȔǤđ½'ǯô,ǬºŶ,csxS&AA,Ɨ,ƿŘŶş6@'ƹ «Ƅ*-ȔǤđ½,ĒȒŘŽŃ,,ǮĝĎ*þ@ƿŘŽŃ,,ǮĝĎ,µÎȓ 1/2 ,'-ŘDǪ@ğǝǪ¾Ȕ1/2 ~,'-ƿŘDƘŏƄ*ǆ ğǝǪ¾@,&-) ', ũ& @1/2'¡-ƿŘ* @2

,ǯô,ǬºŶ*ŽŃ@#6?ȔǬºŶ,ľ±Ǥđ½,±*ħ!¼#'ƿŘľ±*)@'

C& @

ƿŘ,ǮĝƄġƸ*Ǻ@ǚĸ-,ė:Ʈ'­űA&: Lande & Schemske (1985)-ȔfGYRpz,o[uD>*ŢƱȔúȀ,ōŲDż %ŹǚDŎǓ@ňƩ7DıŌŭ&ų*Ǵǋ& @&-,ǔƦ*-ǐA) ȔLande & Schemske (1985)',ė,ƌƙÌD6'9Ưǖ'% Goodwillie et al. (2005)Dǅ9 0-'!'*,$&2  ƿŘ,ǮĝƄġƸ*Ǻ@ƌƙ-Ȕ,= *6&ƅE*ǆCA%,{Ĺ&ȔŘƄ)Ɨ'ƿŘƄ)Ɨ,Ǫ¾Ƅ)ƕǆ,hwUS*Ǻ@Ɗǌ-ů'%ķā) ƿŘyŘ'ğǝ-ǤƲƗǹ&:ȍǃ*ƀ)@çÎ @'{ǀ*Ɗ>A% ?A>,Ɨ&-ǫÅ*ƴÝ 1 RwH`^T^* @ƿüÕÎğ,ţğ¾'ƿŘ,Ǫ¾

Řőď,Ǫ¾Ƅ)ì¾ "-& @«Ƅ*(,ǯô,(,ìƀ*="%

#(,= )źé&ƴŘRSZm,ƕǆǞ,"×Ȍ*È?Ʃ89*-ŻĢöƄ)ǘŊ &-)ƿŘğyŘğ*ǺC@ǯôviu,Ɗǌœ) &ƒ!-ȔFgs^ƓRwH`^T^ă*ă®ôǯöƌƙ,o[uŻŲ'%Ɗ>A@RwH`^T^*ƉƆ
T. Tuchimatsu & K.K. Shimizu - 2

RwH`^T^-ƿŘğ,Ɨ& ?Ȕǵí&#@Ɨô,Ƥ 99%-ƿŘŽŃ& @'įùA% @,{ĹȔbMPxbVQK)(,ǤƲƗ-Řğ& @ (Ýȕ)RwH`^T^,ǤƲƗŘğ),-ȔA>,ƗƿüÕÎğ'Ô.A@nL_TmDĪ"% @9&@ƿüÕÎğ'-ȔƿĈ,ǂơ'Ƽŷ,ǳDǰ@ǯƄ)7& @ .ȔŘğ,bMPxbVQK&-ȔƿĈ,ǂơŉȊ*# %:ǂơƞDǸ@'&ȔƗôĔģA) ="%ȔRwH`^T^&-ȔǫÅ*,RSZmţğ¾@'*="%ƿüÕÎğ>ƿüÕÎğ*)?ȔƿŘDǆ = *)"'ƹ >A@ (Ýȕ)
RwH`^T^ă&-Ȕ,ƿüÕÎğ,Ƿ')@ǯôȔSCR (SP11 ':Ô.A@)' SRK
&*ÂȅA% @ (Kusaba et al. 2001)SCR -ǂơ£&ƃŸȔSRK -ŉȊ£&ƃŸ@ƿüÕÎğDĪ#ŘƗ*%-ȔÏŽŃ,ǂơŉȊ*# '* SCRySRK ǹ,ųƀƄ)ƈżǞ?ȔǂơƞǸǼûA@
RwH`^T^&-ȔA> SCR' SRK , A*ŒƽØòã,ƚůìƀDǞ@'*="%ƿüÕÎğţğ¾ȔȐ ƿŘŶǪ¾Ëƽğ @ADƍ9@
9*Ȕƒ!-rzwYd*®ĉ@RwH`^T^,ő)Ɨ¬ƣƬ*#% SCR ' SRK ,èåǳ¯DşùȔ
6A>DǤƲƗ,bMPxbVQ
Ý 2 RwH`^T^,ǂơ£Úô SCR =0ŉȊ£Úô
SRK ~*ŻƚůìƀrzwYd,ő)âŭ>ĭ
ȂARwH`^T^,SCR =0 SRK , !ǇƄ)ǳ¯DǤƲƗ&ƿüÕÎğD:#bMPxbVQK,ǳ¯'ŚǢSCR ~, 213 èå,ǨƗ¬&čªľA% @{ĹSRK ~*ŒƽØòãƚůìƀ,ǌ>A) ƣƬ: #ƃǌAK,ǳ¯'ŚǢ,ƫŇȔÝ 2,= * #:,ŒƽØòãƚůì
ƀ  SCR y SRK ~ * ǌ #  " (Shimizu et al. 2008)6ȔŉȊ£ǯô SRK ~*-ȔfvzmRf\)(,ŒƽØòãƚůìƀîǌ#",{Ĺ&Ȕā)': 12 ƣƬ,RwH`^T^*%Ȕǳ¯~-(:êA% ) ŕċ)

SRK ǌ#" (Tsuchimatsu et al. 2010), 12 ƣƬ-ȔRwH`^T^,Ɨ©, 4%4(,ƣƬ*ƈē@A*þŒƽã,ǂơ£ǯô SCR -(,ƣƬ>:ǌ#>ȔOz]ȉä,Ľė* 213 èå,Ǩǌ>A@'C" (Tsuchimatsu et al. 2010),Ǩìƀ-RwH`^T^*% 95%~'Ȑ µÎ&ªľA% ,*þȔAí, #,ƚůìƀ- A:ȋĎ">*ȔǨD¦*Ĥǂơ£ǯô SCR , DNA ǳ¯D PCR *="%ćƄ*ģȔŕċ)ŉȊ£ǯô SRK D:#RwH`^T^,ƣƬ,/'#*ǯôÿ¨'BȔǯôÿ¨*%ƿüÕÎÇĝǎýA@'C" (Tsuchimatsu et al. 2010, ªÏƌƙƺ& @ń¿ïö,ǙǒǲáðÃë [Ÿy}Ǵïö]yÀĆƑśyŨǣŕñÃë*=@úȏ)
A>,ƫŇ-Ȕǂơ£ǯô SCR ~*ŻǨìƀRwH`^T^* @ǫÅ,ƿ
T. Tuchimatsu & K.K. Shimizu - 3üÕÎğ,Ǫ¾*ǺC"ƚůìƀ,/'#& @'DƎSCRySRK ~*ǌ#",,ő)ìƀ-Ȕ,ǨìƀŻėȔŔƄ*ǄƘìƀ& ?ȔƿüÕÎğ,Ǫ¾,ƇĮ,ÄÚ')"ìƀ&-) 'ƹ >A@ƒ!,ƌƙ-ȔǵíȂÛ*%ƿüÕÎğ,Ǫ¾*ǺC"ƚůìƀD®ôviu&ÏùȔ,ƚůìƀ45Ɨ©*č"'Dƍ9ſ°,æÒ& @,ƫŇ-DƎÖ@ B ƿüÕÎğ- SCR ' SRK DÑ8î,ǯô*="%ģ?ƛ#ǊȄ)RSZm& @/'0ƿüÕÎğǪ¾>ȔRSZm©ƛ¾Ȕ
AA,ǯô*ƚůìƀǄƘ% 'ƹ >A@úȀ*-Ȕǂơ£ǯô SCR,ƚůìƀDćƄ*ę@ &ƿüÕÎğęţ)C!Ȕ
ā)':Ɨ¬,ķȑ,ƣƬ*# %-ȔSCR ,Ǩí-ŕċ)66& "''& @A-ȔRwH`^T^* @ƿüÕÎğ,ţğ¾ŚǢƄĽǤ*Ǟ'DƎÖ@:Ǹ ļǹ
ƪ"% >ȔSCR ,Ǩí*:î,ƚůìƀǄƘ% -& @,ƌƙNuz
h*=@ÏƸƶĲŶyȇÏƸƶĲŶ,Ś*å$ Ǐņ*=@'ȔRwH`^T^* @ƿüÕÎğ,Ǫ¾-Ȕ:"':Ê% 413,000 Č³ƖĎ'įùA% @ (Ý 1ȔBechsgaard et al. 2006)
,¡-ȔǤƲƗ',®ąČȒƤ 500-600 |Č³ȓ=?:{ŋā) KzWz& @
RwH`^T^ƿüÕÎğDò"'ƹ >A@ķ|ČķÀ|Č³ȔRwH`^T^®ĉ@rzwYd&-Ȕ!< (ŝŀyǹŝŀ,PHMu,&»ōŲ,®ĉïĩïyƳĀ% 'ƹ >A% @®ĉïì¾@ŴŠ&-ȔǳƈĦǟȔÀ®)üǂơĘ>A)":A) ,= )źé,&-Ȕ{ &ô÷Dŗ'&@ƿŘğ-ȔƴŘǓ,ǎŭ>ľ±*)? @6Ȕ®ĉ,ĞŬ)ĩï*"%Ż@Ē ǯƄk\uaYM-Ȕ®ĉĩï,Ľ³ư,ȂÛ*%Ǥđ½,¡D@ºŇ @'ǤČīĳA% @ (Pujol et al. 2009)Ǥđ½®ĉĩïD"*@' A.Ȕǯô,ǬºŶ,Ȑ&ƿŘ-Ř=?:ľ±*)?ȔŘDƿüÕÎğ-ţğ¾@ĹÐ2ťŞß¥  B ,= *Ȕƒ!,ƃǌ-ȔWzIGxȔ
fGYRpz>,ǖD®ôviu>ĴĪ@:,& @ƿüÕÎğyƿŘğ,Ǫ¾ĽǤ,®ĉĩï'':*Ǟ'-ÏFgs^Ɠ,uis^T^&:æÒA% ? (Guo etal. 2009)ȔRwH`^T^*ǽ>) {ǀƄ)¤Ð:A) >)@ƌƙ,ǄƘĖA@

1- RwH`^T^*%ǌ>AŘ>ƿŘ2'

Ǫ¾,ĹÐğ-Ȕ,®ȎƷ*%:{ǀƄ& @)C!Ȕ*ƿüÕÎğ,Ǫ¾D"*%ŘƗ>ƿŘƗĎ:Ƶ?ǥǞŪ@:,,Ȕ,Ǩ,Ǫ¾- 6?Ǟ>) 'ƹ >A% @ (Stebbins 1974)
,= )Ǫ¾,ËǨğ-)Ż@,DȔė,ĂĿ'%Ľė*ƹ %7 Ÿà,'Bï 2 #,ǋƥǴǋ& @'ƹ >A% @ (Stebbins 1974, Takebayashi &Morrell 2001){#Ɔ-ȔƿüÕÎğţğ¾@,-ƠÂ Ȕ/'0ţğ¾@',ęĊ-ÜȆ& @'ŭ& @ "Eţğ¾ƿüÕÎğęĊ@9*-ȔÏǯô,ÏƝĥ*: {Ď¦ǩ?*@ƚůìƀŻ@ěǋ @,ƍŶ-ȔƿüT. Tuchimatsu & K.K. Shimizu - 4ÕÎğ*ǺC@ǯôƷ,(/'#*ìƀǞ@ƍŶ*Ś3@'"' -& @ǊȄ)RSZm,ŵĘ'Øò*ǌ>A@,= )ȇþƔğ-Ȕ{ǀ*]wz,š²'Ô.A@: {ŭ-ȔƿŘȂÛ* @ǯƄîőğ,ŧā*':) ƭūŶ,~ĺ& @ƿüÕÎƚůìƀȂÛ*č6?(,:ƿŘDǆ = *)@'ȔƩ7Ĳ ,ŧā;ǯƄŤ»,ºŇ*=?ȔȂÛ,ǯƄîőğŧā@'ƹ >A@ǮĝǪ¾,Ä»¶& @ǯƄîőğòCA@'Ȕċ*ì¾@ŻŲƄyŮŻŲƄźé*þĝ&ȔƿŘȂÛ-ŘȂÛ=?ƭū
; ' ĠA@
ƿŘğ-ȔǯôǬºŶyƴŘǓ)(,ƋŀƄ)ľ±>ȂÛ*č6@:,,ȔȂÛ
viu,Ǫ¾,lZxRpuDƭūŶDȐ9@ŭ&ȔǸŀƄ*-±)ğǝ:A)
{ĎǪ¾>ĤA) Ȕ '-ƭūDĖ#.?'ġÓ&ȔƿüÕÎğ'A*':) ƿŘ,Ǫ¾-Ǫ¾,[Y]Jx]':ǑCA@ Ȕ, ũ-À®*ŎǓA'- ų*ȔƿŘúȀ*ȂÛ,ǯƄîőğD@'&ǮĝǪ¾,lZxRpuDŧā%@DúǓƄ*Ļ>*-4'E()(Takebayashi & Morrell2001)®ôviu,ƊǌDÈ?¨A)>Ȕėő)®ȎƷ&ǵí&,Ǫ¾öƄyŻĢöƄƌ
ƙDƘ7Ǵ+% 'Ǵǋ& B ()ǙǒǲáðÃëȒ}Ǵïȓ
ȔŨǣŕñÃëȔÀĆƑśȒń¿ïȓȔǶŁ´ÃëȒïǻĵƻïȓ
ȔȐĄǕÍÃëȒóǁ§Ɯïȓ*-ȔªÏƌƙDǩ%ķ,¹ǑDǜ"Ɵ Əž~@

#"Baker, H.G. 1955. Self-compatibility and establishment after ‘long-distance’ dispersal. Evolution 9:347-349.
Bechsgaard, J.S., Castric, V., Charlesworth, D., Vekemans, X. & Schierup, M.H. 2006. The transition toself-compatibility in Arabidopsis thaliana and evolution within S-haplotypes over 10 Myr. Mol. Biol.
Evol. 23: 1741-1750.
Charlesworth, D. & Willis, J.H. 2009. The genetics of inbreeding depression. Nat. Rev. Genet. 10: 783-796.
Darwin, C. 1876. The Effects of Cross and Self Fertilisation in the Vegetable Kingdom. J. Murray, London.
Fisher, R. A. 1941. Average excess and average effect of a gene substitution. Ann. Eugen. 11: 53-63.
Goodwillie, C., Kalisz, S. & Eckert, C.G. 2005. The evolutionary enigma of mixed mating systems inplants: occurrence, theoretical explanations, and empirical evidence. Annu. Rev. Ecol. Evol. Syst. 36:47-79.
Guo, Y.L., Bechsgaard, J.S., Slotte, T., Neuffer, B., Lascoux, M., Weigel, D. & Schierup, M.H. 2009. Recent
speciation of Capsella rubella from Capsella grandiflora, associated with loss of self-incompatibility andan extreme bottleneck. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 106: 5246-5251.
Kusaba, M., Dwyer, K., Hendershot, J., Vrebalov, J., Nasrallah, J.B. & Nasrallah, M.E. 2001.
Self-incompatibility in the genus Arabidopsis: characterization of the S locus in the outcrossing A. lyrata
and its autogamous relative A. thaliana. Pl. Cell 13: 627-643.
T. Tuchimatsu & K.K. Shimizu - 5

Lande, R. & Schemske, D.W. 1985. The evolution of self-fertilization and inbreeding depression in plants. I.
Genetic models. Evolution 39: 24-40.
Pujol, B., Zhou, S.R., Sanchez Vilas, J. & Pannell, J.R. 2009. Reduced inbreeding depression after species
range expansion. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 106: 15379-15383.
Shimizu, K.K., Shimizu-Inatsugi, R., Tsuchimatsu, T. & Purugganan, M.D. 2008. Independent origins ofself-compatibility in Arabidopsis thaliana. Mol. Ecol. 17: 704-714.
Stebbins, G.L. 1974. Flowering Plants: Evolution Above the Species Level. Harvard University Press,Cambridge, Massachusetts.
Takebayashi, N. & Morrell, P.L. 2001. Is self-fertilization an evolutionary dead end? Revisiting an oldhypothesis with genetic theories and a macroevolutionary approach. Amer. J. Bot. 88: 1143-1150.
Tsuchimatsu, T., Suwabe, K., Shimizu-Inatsugi, R., Isokawa, S., Pavlidis, P., Städler, T., Suzuki, G.,Takayama, S., Watanabe, M. & Shimizu, K.K. 2010. Evolution of self-compatibility in Arabidopsis by amutation in the male specificity gene. Nature 464: 1342-1346.
Yampolsky, C. & Yampolsky, H. 1922. Distribution of sex forms in the phanerogamic flora. Bibliotheca
Genetica 3: 1-62.

T. Tuchimatsu & K.K. Shimizu - 6