MuddyWater
Operations in Lebanon
and OmanUsing an Israeli compromised
domain for a two-stage campaign

ClearSky Cyber Security
11/2018
1

Table of Contents
Abstract ................................................................................................................................................................3
Attribution ........................................................................................................................................................3
TTPs: .................................................................................................................................................................3
Technical Details ...................................................................................................................................................5First Stage Analysis ...........................................................................................................................................5
Second Stage Analysis ....................................................................................................................................10
VBE Deobfuscation ....................................................................................................................................10
JavaScript Deobfuscation ...........................................................................................................................11
Persistency .................................................................................................................................................12
POWERSTATS Deobfuscation .....................................................................................................................12
Conclusions .........................................................................................................................................................13
Pivot ....................................................................................................................................................................14
Appendix - Indicators of Compromise: ...............................................................................................................15
Macro-embedded Documents: ..................................................................................................................15
Network Indicators: ...................................................................................................................................162

Abstract
MuddyWater is an Iranian high-profile threat actor that's been seen active since 2017. The group is known
for espionage campaigns in the Middle East. Over the past year, we've seen the group extensively targeting awide gamut of entities in various sectors, including Governments, Academy, Crypto-Currency,
Telecommunications and the Oil sectors.
MuddyWater has recently been targeting victims likely from Lebanon and Oman, while leveraging
compromised domains, one of which is owned by an Israeli web developer. The investigation aimed touncover additional details regarding the compromise vector. Further, we wished to determine the infection
vector, which is currently unknown. With that in mind, past experience implies that this might be a two-stage
spear-phishing campaign.
In the first stage of the operation the attackers deliver a macro-embedded document. Depending on eachsample, the content of document is either a fake resume application, or a letter from the Ministry of Justicein Lebanon or Saudi Arabia. Note that these documents' content is falsely blurred in order to increase thechances of infection. As stated, the obfuscated code used in the campaign was hosted on three compromised
domains, including an Israeli domain (pazazta[.]com).
An interesting aspect of this campaign is that the attackers, uncharacteristically to the group, implemented amanual override to the attack process; which in turn provided them with more control over the payload.
Moreover, previously the group only executed single-stage attacks; however, this time around they split thecourse of attack into two stages. Thus, spreading MuddyWater's main PowerShell Backdoor dubbed
POWERSTATS in a stealthier method.
Special thanks for the researchers Jacob Soo and Mo Bustami that assisted us.

Attribution
As MuddyWater has consistently been using POWERSTATS as its main tool, they are relatively easy to
distinguish from other actors. Nevertheless, this time we observed a slightly similar but different pattern,
depicting conservation of TTPs alongside developing new capabilities.
Our findings corroborate several TTPs changes that were foreseen by other researchers. These assessments
were based on leaked test documents attributed to the group, that were observed during the past year. It
appears MuddyWater recent efforts to evolve are beginning to bear fruit, as they also added evasion
capabilities to their arsenal.

TTPs:
One of the most noteworthy aspects of MuddyWater's recent transformation is the progression from a singlestage to a two-stage attack process.
1) Malicious macro-embedded document used to launch an Excel process and a PowerShellcommand as first stage. The group leverages commands execution via 3rd party processes (e.g.
Excel) used not only for POWERSTATS functionality as seen before, but also for first-stage needs pertaining to downloading the second stage from a certain open-directory.
2) Obfuscated source code hosted on compromised domains is retrieved and executed as second
stage for POWERSTATS Backdoor propagation. Main source code consists of PowerShellcommands and variables. These variables are then divided into multiple layers of obfuscatedintertwined encoded VBScript (VBE), JavaScript and PowerShell code.
This point is of particular importance, as it is the basis for a new three-steps backdoor execution
mechanism (this will be further detailed later in the blog).

3

Moreover, it appears MuddyWater operators do not cover their tracks and do not remove theircode from these open-directories that are currently accessible and available to everyone.

4Technical Details
First Stage Analysis
As previously mentioned, the campaign in Lebanon was recently extended to Oman, as additional documents
are continually detected. The campaign revolves around several malicious Word documents that pose as either
a fake resume application, or a letter from the Ministry of Justice in Lebanon or Saudi Arabia. In each document
you may find a deceptive text and message boxes such as “the document has been made in an old version of
Microsoft”. This lure method is common and has been in use systematically by MuddyWater, with the purposeof deceiving unsuspecting victims or getting them to click on either “Enable Editing” or “Enable Content”
buttons to execute malicious macro.

Figure 1: Blurred resume document showing a deceptive error message.

5

Figure 2: Blurred document disguised as a letter from the Ministry of Justice in Lebanon

6Figure 3: Blurred document disguised as a letter from the Ministry of Justice in Saudi Arabia (target from Oman)

Upon document opening, an authentic but general error message pops up, trying to deceit the victim into
thinking that there is an apparent compatibility issue responsible for the blurred text. Simultaneously, theobfuscated macro code that is executed automatically in the background leads to an Excel process execution
via an embedded COM object.
Using ViperMonkey1, a VBA emulation engine, we managed to de-obfuscate the parts of the malicious macro.

17

https://github.com/decalage2/ViperMonkey

Figure 4: ViperMonkey summary of recorded actions

According to the highlighted output of the tool, we deduce that the macro code is intended to run when the
document is opened, which in turn leads to the creation of an Excel process. This Excel process is immediately
used as a parent process for running a PowerShell command.

Figure 5: Logged process tree of first-stage attack (Israeli compromised-server highlighted)

As can be seen in the process tree that is provided by Any.Run sandbox, the PowerShell command leads todownloading and executing additional PowerShell code derived from certain compromised domains. Using
this method, the attackers have implemented a two-phase attack process, while relying on the need ofdownloading the main POWERSTATS code from their preferred compromised domains. In this scenario, we
encountered several samples downloading the same payload, while few samples downloaded a base64
encoded of the same payload. These files were inserted to an open-directory that is located in eachcompromised domain several days before the attack occurred. Interestingly, it appears that MuddyWater
operators do not cover their tracks and do not remove their code from these open-directories.

8Figure 6: 3cbc[.]net open-directory hosting second-stage PowerShell code masquerading as an icon.icon fileFigure 7: Israeli domain pazazta[.]com open-directory: second-stage PowerShell code masquerading as an icon.png photo

Figure 8: ohe[.]ie open-directory hosting second-stage base64 encoded blob masquerading as an icon.png photo

9

Second Stage Analysis
Looking at the additional PowerShell code that is downloaded from the compromised domains, we identified
few variables and commands that perform the following actions:•

Saving JavaScript, encoded VBScript (VBE) and PowerShell code respectively to three files.

•

Initialization of three-steps backdoor execution mechanism:
1) WScript.exe executes VBE code.
2) CScript.exe executes obfuscated JavaScript code.
3) PowerShell command de-obfuscates and executes POWERSTATS backdoor.

•

Using taskkill command to kill Excel’s process.

Figure 9: Second-stage PowerShell code downloaded from the compromised domains

VBE Deobfuscation
The base64 encoded VBScript code is saved to a PowerShell variable called $vbs, then it is decoded and stored
in another variable named $Content. Its value is saved to the following path:
C:\Windows\temp\Windows.vbe$vbs ="I0B+XlhBQUFBQT09L00rQ0QrfTRMf21EY0pxL15EYndPIFV0K15zSipSSSFVfkoxLzFEcndPfkoybExrXkRid09+Oyk
tdwlieFtXU2QnLVB/OmEtLUQrczJSTndMSkJQVFMsc2xeZCsvQjhBQUE9PV4jfkAA"
Source code 1: base64 encoded VBE code found in the compromised domains--> CreateObjzct("Wscript.Shell").Run "cscript /E:jscript C:\\Windows\\Tzmp\\temp.jpg", 0, False
Source code 2: base64 decoded VBE code

The decoded VBScript code is responsible for running the obfuscated JavaScript code stored in another filemasquerading an image file “temp.jpg”. The VBE code is executed using WScript.exe, leading to the JavaScript
code execution via CScript.exe. Both Windows Script Host processes are used as a method of executing
commands from external files and support various scripting languages.

10Figure 10: Second-stage process tree depicting Windows Script Host usage

JavaScript Deobfuscation
From the second-stage PowerShell code that was downloaded from the compromised domains, anobfuscated JavaScript code is stored in a variable named $js. Its content decoded and saved in the following
path:
C:\Windows\Temp\temp.jpg
Within the above-mentioned three-steps POWERSTATS execution mechanism, the second step consists ofrunning the obfuscated base64 encoded JavaScript. This code snippet leverages the Winmgmt WMI service
classes Win32_Process and Win32_ProcessStartup.
$js ="dmFyIGE9Wyd3Nm5Dc01LQk44TzUnLCdCOE8rd3I5M3dwMDhTakhDbUV3cndybkRvY0tidz[…]"Source code 3: base64 decoded JavaScript code

var a=['w6nCsMKBN8O5','B8O+wr93wp08SjHCmEwrwrnDocKbw4[…]
Source code 4: Obfuscated decoded JavaScript code

Figure 11: De-obfuscated JavaScript CodeThus, a relevant PowerShell process is created for decoding the main obfuscated POWERSTATS backdoor,
completing the third step towards running the backdoor. This de-obfuscated JavaScript snippet holds aPowerShell command that is intended to de-obfuscate and execute the PowerShell backdoor that is
encapsulated in a C# code. Previously, the obfuscated main backdoor code was stored into a “Microsoft.db”
file via the seconds-stage PowerShell file, which was hosted on one of the compromised domains. The fullpath of the main obfuscated backdoor code file:
C:\ProgramData\Microsoft.db
In addition, the group uses various techniques in order to bypass UAC. As seen in the past, MuddyWater
makes use of a tool found in the .NET framework called csc.exe, which can be used to compile an executablefrom C# code. This means that an attacker doesn’t necessarily need to download a compiled executable tothe target’s computer, but can instead download the source code and compile it on the target computer.
11

Figure 12: PowerShell process de-obfuscates and runs POWERSTATS

Persistency
Notice that POWERSTATS backdoor maintain the same persistency mechanism with almost every new
campaign. It makes use of a scheduled task named “MicrosoftEdge” (Scheduled task name may differ fromone sample to another) running daily at 12:00 o’clock, which starts the three-steps backdoor’s execution
mechanism using the following command:"C:\Windows\system32\schtasks.exe" /Create /F /SC DAILY /ST 12:00 /TN MicrosoftEdge/TR "c:\windows\system32\wscript.exe C:\Windows\temp\Windows.vbe"

POWERSTATS Deobfuscation
The POWERSTATS backdoor’s code is a multi-layered obfuscated, encoded and compressed blob. As
mentioned in the upper section, the latter PowerShell command de-obfuscates the main POWERSTATS
backdoor’s code, first to a deflated-compressed base64 code. Then, a decoded and decompressed using an
inflate method, but obfuscated PowerShell code snippet is revealed. Finally, this code is de-obfuscated tothe main backdoor code.
$code = "-FJ+QM2?@2CQ1AX1G-,<*+VI.XQ/UW-BQ0RZ2?C1B91=C.ER2[Z1GD0IH[...]"
Source code 5: Main POWERSTATS backdoor code hosted on the compromised domains as part of the second-stage$(New-Object IO.StreamReader ($(New-Object IO.Compression.DeflateStream ($(NewObject IO.MemoryStream(,$([Convert]::FromBase64String('jX1pdxq7sujnZK38B92sc2PYG[…]')))),[IO.Compression.CompressionMode]::Decompress)), [Text.Encoding]::ASCII)).ReadToEnd();
Source code 6: Main POWERSTATS backdoor code de-obfuscated by the PowerShell command found inside the JavaScript codesnippet&("{2}{0}{3}{1}" -f 'R','abLE','set-Va','i') ("UW"+("{0}{1}" -f'1r9','P')) ()'x'+]31[dIlleHS$+]1[dILleHs$ (& | )421]rAhc[,'Fe5' ecaLperC-[…]"

Source code 7: Main POWERSTATS backdoor code is decoded and decompressed, but still obfuscatedAlthough we cannot present the full code of the backdoor, we would like to examine part of the backdoor’s
persistency mechanism. This mechanism involves creating a registry key called “MicrosoftEdge”, with a value
corresponds to the command that is responsible to initialize the above-mentioned three-steps backdoor’s
execution mechanism:
start-sleep (Get-Random -Minimum 10 -Maximum 20)ertChfu -p"HKCU:SOFTWARE\Microsoft\Windows\CurrentVersion\Run" -k 'MicrosoftEdge' -v'c:\windows\system32\wscript.exe C:\Windows\temp\Windows.vbe'
Source code 8: POWERSTATS backdoor persistency mechanism found inside the backdoor’s

12Conclusions
The Iranian MuddyWater group keeps evolving, improving its capabilities with every new campaign. We
encourage the security community to harness these IOCs and knowledge to detect and defend from the threat.

13

Pivot14

Appendix - Indicators of Compromise:
Macro-embedded Documents:
SHA256 Hash

File Name

Impersonation

65bd49d9f6d9b92478e3653362c0031919607302db6cfb3a7c1994d20be18bcc

MyCV.doc

Fake resume

294a907c27d622380727496cd7c53bf908af7a88657302ebd0a9ecdd30d2ec9d

Cv.docFake resume

ac360ec9dbf84ab7e26effcb1d28ca4d0ac4381c9376ac1eddee7a8f7f26ccb0

shakva-lb (1).zip

b6c483536379840e89444523d27ac7828b3eb50342b992d2c8f608450cd7bb53

shakva-lb.doc

a6ba3480f3c7055dce2a7a43c3f70d3d6b266290f917be150a0e17b6ac4a3724

shakva-om.zip

e5c56c5b9620fb542eab82bdf75237d179bc996584b5c5f7a1c34ef5ae521c7d

shakva-om.doc

15

Ministry of Justice in
LebanonMinistry of Justice in
Saudi Arabia

Network Indicators:
Second-stage delivery URLs:•

hxxp://3cbc[.]net/dropbox/icon[.]icon•

hxxp://pazazta[.]com/app/icon[.]png•

hxxp://ohe[.]ie/cli/icon[.]png•

hxxp://ohe[.]ie/cp/icon[.]png

Proxy-List of POWERSTATS backdoor

16•

hxxp://andreabelfi[.]com/main.php•

hxxp://andreasiegl[.]com/main.php•

hxxp://andresocana[.]com/main.php•

hxxp://amorenvena[.]com/main.php•

hxxp://amphira[.]com/main.php•

hxxp://amphibiblechurch[.]com/main.php