HELEŕò0k%Ŗ¬fÀė2ô¨ē«ªĉĤ

2016X5~19yLindee WongŘŎŒĿĪŔœĬįŒĵ

k%*fÀĖoŘò0k%ŕHELE)¬-¦îe> EÚJ1µ³¯21C¸³EÎŕCOP21ŖĒö<EsYėHĖWIzĨ¡ï@+ēÕĈ
đ2ô
ôġģ3&ĕăďö1.5ôôĕgþĤ/-ĨØ8ĉĤĆēĨ³Ĉč> R0ĲĹk%*ĖÆ°ēĈđöò0k%ŕHELE)¬-¦îāoćĥđüĤ

¤¬4ŕWCAŖŖ “ò0k%ŕHELE)¬-¦îeĖÈ¹ėöà2
´C9œÏ¥œ)¢fÀŕCCUS)ĀĢk%ĻŐĕĝĄč
ĥĕÿüđö}}'ĖáÃĔĹľĽňēĔĤ÷HELE¦îfÀėxĕB)¢ćĥđÿģöUåāÛĞĘö!î-ßäĀĢĖR0ĲĹk%Ĩ³20%*ĉĤĆēā;»ē
ĔĤ÷%#: http://www.worldcoal.org/reducing-co2-emissions/high-efficiency-low-emission-coal
2© ECOFYS | 20/05/2016 | Lindee WongňŐĸĭĴŀĖ¨§> HELE¬¬-¦îėözĨ2ôôĕgþĤ¨ē«ªĈĔüĀŚ> ¬-¦îēk%ĕÿüđöJ1ĕçĉĤsYæńŃŏŕIPCCŖÿġęEìĮŃŏĳŔçŕIEAŖĖ2ôķłŎİĖQwÊĨ¿ý> GöÈSâ1,400ĳĲőĽŀŕGWŖĖ¬-¦îeāÇ£ćĥđüĤĖĒöĆĖÇ£ā2ôķłŎİĕ«ªĈĔüĀÊĉĤ3© ECOFYS | 20/05/2016 | Lindee Wong

HELE¬-¦îė
½¤F¦îfÀĕĚđò0k%> HELE¬-¦îė ½¤F¬-¦îĕĚđò0k%
Jp0

CO2 k%75ó(gCO2/kWh)¬Ðâó(g/kWh)}Ló38%≥880≥380

Ñ½¤FŕSCŖŖ}Ló42%

800–880

340–380

Ñø½¤FŕUSCŖŖ}Ló45%

740–800

320–340ÛÑø½¤F-¦îfÀŕAUSCŖŖ/ ¬ĲĹ2Â=¦îŕIGCCŖŖ

45–50%

670–740

290–320fÀ½¤F%#:EìĮŃŏĳŔçŕIEA), 2012X, ò0k%Ė¬-¦îfÀŐŔŁŉĽň> ĆĖ Ė0§Ĕ¦îfÀõġģòü0ĖŘMĲĹ-¦îĖ¦î0ė}L60%õġģüCO2 k%75ĖŘMĲĹ-¦îĖCO2 k%tė350–õõõõ
490 gCO2/kWhöñ-ÿġęNé¦îĖk%tė0 gCO2/kWh4© ECOFYS | 20/05/2016 | Lindee Wong´C9œÏ¥ŕCCSŖ Ă-¦îėk%75ĖĜĔĢĊJp0ğąĤ> ´C9œÏ¥ŕCCSŖĖňŐĺĹŘ
VĠĮŃŏĳŔçÚÈĀĢk%ćĥĤCO2Ĩ&íöC9ÖÙãÏ¥> k%75ėö50-150 gCO2/kWhēnPĉĤ
> ōīņĶīĴŏCO2k%â (mlö.VöÖÙ) ė95-150 gCO2/kWhēĈđØ.
> CO2 &ífÀėĮŃŏĳŔĨÐĈöJp0ĨćċĤ> CCS ĂóĖ¬-¦îeėöóIPCCÿġęIEAĖ2ôķłŎİĕÿüđėöáÃĔ¹Ĩ6
ĞđüĤ

5© ECOFYS | 20/05/2016 | Lindee Wong

2ô¨ÞdĖčĞĕ
î-ßäė2050X
XěĒĕ¼´2ĈđüĤ`ÃāûĤ> IPCCĖ2°CķłŎİėöî-ßäā2050XěĒĕ¼´2ĨÛĞĤ`ÃāûĤē­ĈđüĤ

> 2050XX èėöî-ßäĖk%âĨŉīłĹĕĉĤ`ÃāûĤŕŃŃĲľĪŇœĮŊĽķŌŒŖóIPCCĖ2ôķłŎİĕġĤ¦îĀĢĖCO2 k%â (MtCO2/year)
15,00010,0005,000
0-5,000-10,000-15,000

2010 2020 2030 2040 2050 2060 2070 2080 2090 2100
1090ńŔĺŒļīŏ10th-90th
percentile

OMedian

出典：IPCC、2014年、Climate Change 2014: Mitigation of Climate Change. Contribution of Working Group III to the Fifth Assessment Report of theIntergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (Annex III)（気候変動 2014：気候変動の緩和―IPCC 第 5 次評価報告書の第 3 作業部会報告書）
6© ECOFYS | 20/05/2016 | Lindee Wong

CCSā üđüĔü¬-¦îeė2050X
XěĒĕê§ĕZ
10,000

IPCC1.5ôķłŎİĕÿĄĤ¬-ŕCCSĔĈŖĖ¦îâ (TWh/year)

IPCC2ôķłŎİĕÿĄĤ¬-ŕCCSĔĈŖĖ¦îâ (TWh/year)
10th-90th
percentile
1090ńŔĺŒļīŏ

MedianO

10,000

8,000

8,000

6,000

6,000

4,000

4,000

2,0002,00000

10th-90th
percentile
1090ńŔĺŒļīŏ

MedianOCCSĔĈĖ¬-¦îeĖê§Z
X2°C ķłŎİ1.5°C ķłŎİ2010 – 2020-4%/X-5%/X

2020 – 2030

-6%/X

-6%/X

2030 – 2040

-5%/X

-8%/X

出典: IPCC, 2014年,; 気候変動2014：気候変動の緩和-IPCC第5時評価報告書の第3作業歩合報告書 Rogelj, J., G. Luderer, R. C. Pietzcker, E. Kriegler, M. Schaeffer, V. Krey and K. Riahi (2015). "Energysystem transformations for limiting end-of-century warming to below 1.5°C." Nature Clim. Change 5(6): 519-527.

7© ECOFYS | 20/05/2016 | Lindee WongIEA 450ķłŎİė
2040Xĕė¬-¦îeĖ75%ā
āCCS ĂĕĔĤē> IEA 450ķłŎİ (450S) ėöHĖWIzĨ2ôĕgþĤčĞĕ`ÃĔs°ĨPĈđüĤ÷
ČĥĢĕėöĖCCSĕçĉĤğĖóğ?ěĥĤŘ–EĖî-ßäĒė2020XðĀĢöīŒŁĒė2025XðĀĢCCSāUåćĥĤ––yĖ¬-¦îeĕğCCSāTćĥĤĩŋŎıēEUĒėCCSĖ)¢rqāhLĉĤ

> 2040Xĕė¬-¦îeĖ75% āCCS ĂĕĔĤCoalgeneration (incl.
CCS)¬-Ė¦îâŕCCS
ĂĨ?ĝŖ
ó¬-Ė¦îâŕCCSĔĈŖõõ
Coal
generation (excl. CCS)óCO2k%â
CO2emissions¦îâŕTWśŖ
Generation(TWh)10,00012,00010,000

8,000

8,000

6,000

6,000

4,000

4,000

2,000

2,000

02010

2020

2030

2040

CO2 emissions(MtCO2)Co2 k%âŕMtCo
2Ŗ

12,00002050%#: IEA, 2015,X ùWorld Energy Outlookŕ¤ĮŃŏĳŔUŖú8© ECOFYS | 20/05/2016 | Lindee Wong

450ķłŎİĒėî-ĕ,ģjĢĥč2ôôķłŎİĕÿĄĤ´±ĖĉĚđĨ¬-āÐřvs°ŗ¿s°ķłŎİĕÿĄĤk%âÝK¬-¦îĖ¦îâ (TWh/year)¦îßäĀĢĖCO2 k%â (MtCO2/year)

20,00015,00015,000

Excl. CCS

10,000

Excl. CCS

5,000

010,000

5,0000Excl. CCS
2010

2020

2030

2040

IPCC2ôķłŎİĖ²DŕCCSĔĈŖIPCC
2°C range excl. CCS
IPCC2ôķłŎİĖOŕCCSĔĈŖIPCC
2°C Median excl. CCS
NewPolicies incl.
CCSIEAĖNPS(CCSĂĨ?ĝŖ
Current
Policies ĂĨ?ĝŖ
incl. CCSIEAĖCPSŕCCS450Sincl. CCS ĂĨ?ĝŖIEAĖ450SŕCCS

-5,0002050

2010

2020

2030

2040

2050

IPCC
2°C range (power generation)
IPCC2ôķłŎİĖ²Dŕ¦îßä!ŖIPCC
2°C median (power generation)
IPCC2ôķłŎİĖOŕ¦îßä!ŖIEAĖNPS(¬¦îŖ
New
Policies (coal generation)IEAĖCPSŕ¬¦îŖ
Current
Policies (coal generation)
IEAĖ450Sŕ¬¦îŖ
450S(coal generation)> IEA
¿s°ķłŎİŕCPS) –Qw$¹ā"\ĕm¢ćĥđüĤs°ĖĜĨºcĈöĆĥĢĖs°ā]2ćĥĊĕi·ĉĤēPĈčķłŎİ

> IEA vs°ķłŎİŕNPS) –E(¨ŕINDC;³¾Ŗĕ|ĀĥčĮŃŏĳŔçÚĖs°Ĩ?ĞöĆĥěĒĕ¦Áćĥčs°Ġw°ĨºcĈčķłŎİ9© ECOFYS | 20/05/2016 | Lindee WongÇ£Ė¬-¦îeĖXæk%âėö
2030XĖ¦îĕÿĄĤ2ôôķłŎİĒÉćĥĤk%âĉĚđĕË^> 1,400 GWĖ¬-ĖvÈSâāÇ£> 2ôķłŎİĒėöÇ£ćĥđüĤÈSâĖÈ)¢ė20%
ŕ!;©^ÜÔ{æó1,600{æŖŅĸŃĹm±ā=ħĔüēĔģöÇ£SâĖŅ> WIk%tā830 gCO2/kWhĒûĤĆēėöÇÇ£Ė¦îe!đāHELE¬¬-¦îĒėĔüĆēĨ­AĈđüĤÇ£Ė¬-¦îeĀĢĖCO2 k%âēôķłŎİēĖÕ (MtCO2/year)
IPCC 2ôÇ£ĖÈSâ (GW)
16,000Ç£"ÁÌ;+
12,000434(30%)488(34%)4,000

156(11%)352(25%)

Ì;:_[È
出典: 世界石炭火力発電所トラッカー,2016年, 提案されている石炭火力発電所（国別102°CķłŎİē
Ė«ª8,000© ECOFYS | 20/05/2016 | Lindee Wong

0-4,000MW)2016年1月

IPCC2°C range (power generation)
IPCC2ôķłŎİĖ²Dŕ¦îßä!ŖIPCC
2°C Median (power generation)
IPCC2ôķłŎİĖOŕ¦îßä!ŖÇ£Ė¬-õk%â
Plannedcoal power emissions

2010

2020

2030

2040

2050

Ç£SâāĉĚđHELE¬-ěčėCCS ĂĒûĐđğã§ĕė2ô¨āÞdĒĂĤÄ×ĜāĔüÇ£ŗ Í§Ĕ¬¦îeĀĢĖCO2 k%âēIPCC 2ôôķłŎİēĖÕ (MtCO2/year)> ĕĉĚđĖÇ£Ė¬-¦îSâā¬-¦îeĎēĈđğöCO2 k%â 16,000HELE¬
ė2040XĖ!î-ßäĀĢĖ´±Ė2 ēĔĤ
12,000> Ç£SâĖĉĚđāCCS ĂĎēĉĥĘ:–2030Xē2040XĕÿüđėözĨ2ôĕgþĤ¶Òĕý

–X5,400 MtCO2ĖC9œÏ¥ā`ÃĒûĤĆēĀĢŕG®ĖCCS¦îeė1ĀeĖĜĒöC9âė1 MtCO2/XŖóXĕQĒĂĤ;»aėü2030X–ĆĖĒûĐđğ¦îeĀĢĖCO2k%ė2°C ķłŎİĖ¶ÒĕÿĄĤXĖ´±ĨÑÝĈđüĤ;»2050X
aāòü8,0002°CķłŎİē
Ė«ª

4,000

0-4,000ã§ĕğ2ķłŎİĕ«ª

2010

2020

2030

2040

2050

IPCC
2°C range (power generation)
IPCC2ôķłŎİĖ²Dŕ¦îßä!ŖIPCC2ôķłŎİĖOŕ¦îßä!ŖIPCC
2°C Median (power generation)Ç£Ė¬-õk%â
Plannedcoal power emissions¬-õbk%â(A-USC¦îeŖ
Theoreticalcoal power emissions (A-USC plants)¬-õbk%âŕCCS
ĂŖ
Theoreticalcoal power emissions(CCS equipped)
11© ECOFYS | 20/05/2016 | Lindee Wong

HELE¬-¦îė2ôĖ¶Òē«ªĉĤ> 2ôķłŎİĨÞdĉĤĕėöî-ßäė2050XěĒĕ¼´2ĈöCCSā üđüĔü¬-¦îeė2050XěĒĕê§ĕZćĥĔĄĥĘĔĢĔü

> IEA450ķłŎİėö75%Ė¬-¦îeāCCS ĂĒûĤēüýĨÓěþđğö
2040XĕėzĨ2ôĕgþĤčĞĕî-ßäĕÉćĥĤ´±Ĩ!đÐĈđĈěý

> IEAĖ¿s°ķłŎİÿġęvs°ķłŎİėöüĊĥğ2ô¨ĕ>Ąč¶Òĕu=Ĉ
Ĕü> Ç£Ė¬-¦îÈŕ1,400 GWŖĖ!đāHELE¬-¦îĎēĈđğö2ô¨ĕu=ĈĔü
õó2050Xö¬-¦îeāCCSĂĒûĐčēĈđğöĠėģ2ô¨ĕu=ĈĔü> 2ô¨Ė¶ÒēĖëčģėöġģQ§ĔbPĖĒėćĢĕLĂăĔĤĎĦý:– ĆĖ& ėöÅ§ĔJp0ēCCS/HELE¦îĖUåĨ+oĕĈđüĤ
– ĆĖ& ĕōīņĶīĴŏk%âė?ěĥđüĔü

12© ECOFYS | 20/05/2016 | Lindee Wong