School Durban 2011

スクール「ダーバン2011」2013年以降の気候変動新枠組み交渉合意に向けたシリーズ勉強会

第 2 回：2011 年の国際交渉がスタート！
バンコク会議報告【2】ギガトンギャップペーパー
WWFジャパン

制作：ＷＷＦジャパン

山岸尚之 （2011 年 4 月 開催）

気候変動プログラム

2011 年 2 月〜 2011 年 12 月
http://www.wwf.or.jp/climate/climatechange@wwf.or.jp®WWF Registered Trademark Owner©1986 PANDA symbol WWF -World Wide Fund For Nature（formerly World Wildlife Fund）

42@OP4H=E/

{',!

ó

ô1O5Ou/sô
2011 Ű 4 ǡ 19 ǎ͆Ȭ͇ Ver. 1
WWF cw Ţţ ŝÐÃ
COP16COP/MOP6 3. NGO ǠBȖɔ .(˜˘5͊, ZXoZl| 0˘ȯ/+( ZXoZl| 06Ƚȸ/đĩƶ.Hȣő÷ǰX
dưâ̔5ìȡȍȨ0ȌÇĽøƠȅ5(A3Ƅˀ2ìȡȍȨ5̜5ŀ2̫Lƭ"ĩ̂ɀĸˈɆ͆UNEP͇±Ǥɕí3Ɏʻ (ĵęǞ3EH05̫͆Zl|͇6 2020 ŰǗ
ȯ/ 5090 Òo3H
5Zl|LİAH0˄ȯF6W[Ēƒ61IFˡȺ(͐

Zl|LİAH(A5ǋȓ36ŀã. 3 ,Hɴ 1 6Ăʅ3đĩ5ìȡɔǿCìȡʹø5ȍȨ͆ǅň͇LŶH0ǋȓɴ 2 6ìȡɔǿCìȡʹø¬ľ5(07ĘČȧ3̝"HCWre3̝"H21LŹüĆǵü"H0ǋȓɴ 3 6̙Ǥɑ2čʉ?LÃ"éųLǆH0ǋȓ/H
IF 3 ,5ǋȓ5˄ȯFW[ĒƒƬ,÷ǰLǨɫ/6ǹˉ (&5ʋǰW[Ēƒ3ė>IH̵ɔ5Ŀ6cmP{2ƒĚ͆Zl|ʖś͇/BsXmP{2ƒĚ͆Zl|ƫŀ͇/BŎ̔ɑ3 xx o5Zl|ʖś͉ƫŀ3ŕ"H 0ȽȈ̥/6
ˇ2B5ĿŎƍɑ36Ŝ20BZl|ʖś3ˡȺ"HďʣƍLȇ (0H0ã+(& .&5ďʣƍLȘ .(A36͇͊Zl|3Ŗ"H˒˛LEGÚŵ3¤Ƞ
53µʚ-H0͇͋ ɽĦ LƬ+.ìȡɔǿCìȡʹøLˋŎ .Hĩ &5ɽĦ5ɳ͆EG̓ƃɑ2ǋ5ǅň͇LƲƣ/Hǫ®LǑɟü3 ǆ.0
͇͌ ìȡɔǿCìȡ̵ʹø¬ľ5 3.Zl|I¬ƫŀ"H0L̟
/05 3 ,ẕ́6̒ˀ/H0ʝFIH
2 Ɋɔ5 ɽĦ5ɳLɟÄ "Hčʉ?3,.6Õ̃ĩ5ìȡɔǿ5íƸǫ®Lʂǳ"H)/62˾ĩ5ìȡʹø5Ŀ˦̕ƞʺYwbmPxnP\ƾƻLíƸ0 .H0Bˮ>.&5ǫ®5ǑɟüǆÎLħ+.;/H>(3 Ɋɔ5  5ŹüĆǵü3̝"HÜ·ɑ2¼0 .6 ¹î AAU 5ʙG˫ Ģ̺ 5E3§ƀ5˜˘ȃɴ/6 10 ÒoL˪HZl|ƫŀ5ż̴LƬ*HB
5Lķ/ʹ0Õ̃ĩ5ǷǯC˾ĩ5 REDD+Wre21ȽǗȯ/6&5÷ǰ
LɟŎ 3B55ďʣƍ0 .6C6GǅÿÒo5ż̴LƬ*Hã̓/55ĆǵüLħH0LƮH0/Hȷ3Wre3.W[ĒƒFľ
I( j{WRo5̟ȅ 6ʄ 13 Òoɧų5Zl|ƫŀ5d[LƬ,05ˎɺB
H>(W[ĒƒF̵ɔ0 .0ľI. >+(ĩ̧ʩɯʬʫ3̝"Hìȡ
5čʉ?3,.Ǒɟ3˂Ŏ .0B̒ˀ/Hȃ3ǎǨZl|ʖś315E3ˡȺ/HLǹˉ (ǎǨ5ìȡɔǿ/H
25̈́ìȡɔǿ6ȿƑɑ/62Ȋ˴ɑ̓ƃɑ0Hɔǿ/HILǝ3ŶH
06Ŝ20BȽǗȯ/6̬ (+.ǎǨˡȺ H¢̵0 .6͇͊ĩÞɀĸ5ǆÎ3E+. 25̈́ìȡLEG
ɟŐ2B50 .0͇͋ ìȡɔǿCìȡ̵ʹø¬ľ5 3Hɬǻɑ2Ƹ
ˇ3E+.Zl|I¬ƫŀ"H0L̟/05 2 ,̒ˀ/Hìȡɔǿìȡʹø5ȍȨLŶHöñ̒ˀ/H06˘Lž(2Zl|LŜ /BİA.2I72F20ȽȸL̘?I7& (ã̓3.ǎǨɬǻɑ2ɱĶLş̛ .06ĩ̧ɢ±5/íĕ2ŽïLǰ( .0ƒĚ
3.ǻA.ˣ̒/H
IF5ã̓5̎6ˁ"I7ǻA.ƞʺɑŗ̚ɑ2ã̓0ˁËI*/H&36ǅÒoǅÿÒo5Zl|Lʖś"H(A5ºG5ďʣƍHĿŀ2Hż̴LHȌÇĽøĢ̺L§ƀ̾ȅA.(A36& (ã̓/5öñBʐ2I72F2

"'Yb_W[/̛ÏI( COP16COP/MOP6͆ĩ̂ȌÇĽøǱʉǫʄɴ 16 Ĥʔʄĩ±˜¥̏˜ŎǞɴ 6 Ĥʔʄĩ±˜͎¬ W[±˜ ͇6Ŀ5±˜ĈóʞĄƐ
(EGB6H3ʭŻ/ W[Ēƒ LƲƣ"H03Ɩò (ǎǨ/6 do¥̏Õ˻G ɷ5ˁâ /Ȋ˴ɑsXmP{3±˜5ʋǰ6̎ĵ̆I(2009 Ű5_~u^/5 COP15COP/MOP5͆¬ _~u^±˜ ͇¬̡5¤Ƞɔɱ+(̃şLˁ$.2+(0OW5̜̋ƮʋǰLĎ.ĩ̧ɑ2û
F3łKI,,+(01Lˮ>I7W[ĒƒƖɱ (0ʦ·6B+0́ˍ¿I. H;/JW[Ēƒ3ōÙ3Ȧˬ .H NGO 62
WWF BėAĿ5 NGO 6W[±˜5Ɩǰ3ʡŎɑ2ˍ¿L.H& (ĒƒƖɱ&5B5B55ƒʜ06ç3W[±˜3,.Ŀ5 NGO ȷ
3Ȗɔ .(˘ȯH&I6 ZXoZl|L1IFİAH0/HH6İAH(A5ǹˉ̅ɧL̛ń/H 0ȯ/H͆CAN 2010͇
ZXoZl| 06Ƚȸ/đĩƶ.HìȡȍȨ0ȌÇĽøƠȅ5(A3Ƅˀ2ìȡȍȨ5̜5ŀ2̫Lƭ"Ƚȸ/đĩƶ.HȍȨ 06Ü·ɑ36đĩ͆Õ̃ĩ˾ĩǋ͇_~u^±˜5íƀFʦɑ3Ɏʻ .Hưâ̔ìȡɔǿE8ìȡʹø2̇ƖI(ĶĒ5ɇ5ưâ̔Lƭ"

1

OW5̜̋Ʈ/ȋ×ǃýÛĝ×˜ūL³7

2(03EGOW˜±ȌÇTsZÛ˿)Ũɋ5Hˢ¯ ąë3ĳ-_~u^ĒƒCW[Ēƒ/6Õ̃ĩŐǌ"Hʜùɑ2ìȡɔǿ0˾ĩʹ źːĩ30+.̉ä2ʕĝʹø ͆Nationally Appropriate Mitigation Actions; NAMAs͇
0LɄ˓0 .»ã.HǨɫ/BI3ÈÕ̃ĩ3,.6 ìȡɔǿ ˾ĩ3,.6 ìȡʹø 0Ʉ˓L»Ʉ"H

2ȌÇĽøƠȅ5(A3Ƅˀ2ìȡȍȨ 06ɇÙ·0 . 2ǦȦ C 1.5ǦȦ 0+(ɔǿ 3L̇Ɩ"H(A3Ƅˀ2ưâ̔ìȡ̇ƖI(ĶĒ5ưâ̔5ȍȨLƭ"IF 2 ,5̜32020 ŰǗȯ/ǅÿÒoĂµ/5̫ɂ!H0¡ȤIH(A5̫50L ZXoZl| 0ě9͆ʱ˓/ 10 Òo6ZXo͆giga ton͇0ě7I
H͇ɳɑ3ˇ7ȽǗȯ/đĩɔƭ .Hưâìȡ̔/6ȌÇĽøLĄ̤/2ȍȨ3
Ơé"H06/200/H
W[±˜/ NGO Ȗɔ.(56

! &5Zl|ŉĬ"H0˒˛3Ēƒ/H

! &5

Zl|

LİAH(A5LŹü/H

! &5

Zl|

LİAH(A5ǹˉ|fdLÚŵü/H

0ȯ/+(͆CAN 2010͇IF5˄ȯF W[Ēƒ LˁH0&5Ɩǰ61
5E3ˍ¿/H5)J¬Ǩɫ/6 (˄ȯFW[ĒƒLƯG˸+.
?(í ì 4 2 @ O P 4 H = E !  z ñ UNEP } x 2009 Ű 12 ǡ5_~u^±˜:ĕ.Ŀ5ĩ
ĩ5ưâ̔ìȡɔǿCìȡʹøLɎʻ (6ʦɑ3 2020 Ű:ĕ.5ʦ_~u^±˜6Ēƒ5Ʋƣ3łǃ _~u^ĒƒL̰Úŵ3 Ɉƒ()301>+(đĩ6_~u^Ēƒ/5˂Ŏ3&+.ʦɑ3Ɏʻ (ɔǿCʹøLǫʄ¢ùŞ3Ŗ .Ƹâ .ɏ̖L ( (Õ̃ĩ5ìȡɔǿC˾ĩ5ìȡʹøLÙ.ɬ?(ĶĒ5ɇÙ·/5÷ǰ3,  .    ,  5 ɜ ɮ Ȃ ̝  ã Ǯ L ʹ + .  ( ͆ Climate Action Tracker 2010; Climate
Interactive 2010; Project Catalyst 2010͇
 &IF5ãǮ36͊,ŀ2˗̺+(đĩ5ɔǿʹø6&I'I3,
.íƸ0I.Hǫ®ɋ2Gđĩâ .(ǅňLĂʅ3ˬ ĒK$H00/2(07ǎǨ 2009 Ű3Ɏʻ ( ȣő÷ǰXdưâ̔L 2020 Ű>/3 1990 Ű
Ȋ/ 25̈́ìȡ"H 0ìȡɔǿ6Ȋ˴ɑb|2ɔǿ)I/"F1IFȚľ[clo˨ØL˿!(˾ĩ/5ìȡL3ė@5ǷǯĘČȧ5»ɄL1IFˁ˶M/H50+(ȯǑF3I.25/©5ĩ5ɔǿ0ɕƳȊ˴"H5̬ ˬ ĒK$H53BíƸLʚƄˀH
EU CVdoO5E3ǫ®3E+. 20̈́͑30̈́͆EU͇5̈́͑15̈́͑25̈́͆V
doO͇0Ż/ɔǿ3 ŭ LƬ($.HĩBI7rcp5E3Ƿǯ5»Ʉɷ3Ŏ5ǫ®L.HĩBH

3

Ÿ

CAN 6 ɇ5ůĮȌȣ5ǐLɃǺ̲Ĝí0Ȋ˴ . 1.5ǦȦ3ƠH Lɇɑ2ɔǿ0"H;)0.HƁǬ6 2ǦȦ /+(Ŗɸ5̄IC̻Ĭü"HȌÇĽø5ż̴Lˮ>ȿƑɑ36
1.5ǦȦ L̇Ɩ"H;05ɱĶ3ɦʹ .H3

>(˾ĩ5ìȡʹø3,.BĩCQp216GDP ź(G5ìȡɔǿ͆KD
HąĂµɔǿ͇Lƶ.H&5ĶĒ6GDP 5Ɩ̙Ȼ5ƑŎɋ2I7Ő̧5ưâ̔Bɋ
2+. >
F3ĩ3E+. ŰF Ẍ́ìȡ 0Ǘ5ĳȨŰ̈1990 ŰLɄ.H
ĩBI72000 ŰC 2005 ŰLɄ.HĩBH
ˊ5ɜɮȂ̝5ãǮ6 (íƸǫ®5ʨCǑ2ȯ3Ŏ5ƑŎL(/ʹKI.H(AɜɮȂ̝ēĻ5ŨHɧųɂ!. >+.(&IÙ.5ȿɅ/6
2B55UNEP 6̎ãɑ36 (ŨLİAH0Lɔɑ0 .The Emissions Gap
Report L0G>0A(͆UNEP 2010͎¬ UNEP ĵęǞ ͇&5ƒĚ/5ĵęǞ6
I>/5Zl|3̝"HĵęǞ5̪ŀƖ0BˇHUNEP ĵęǞ6Ǡʈɑ36¬5E3ʋ˘L>0A.H2 ɔǿLIPCC 5Ŏʜ/0J5 ďʣƍ́ ͆likely͎66̈́¬͇ɽĦ/̇Ɩ"H(A36ɇ5ȣő÷ǰXdưâ̔L 2020 Ű/ 440 Òo͆CO2 ƹɺ͇ɧ
ų͆390 Ò͑440 Òo5ɽĦ͇3ƠHƄˀH>(5ưâ̔ȍȨ6
1.5 ɔǿL ɧų ͆50͑66̈́5͇B 6&I¬5ɟȻ/̇Ɩ"HȍȨ/BH Ƚȸ¬5ŖɸL0F2+(bqV͆Business As Usual͇5/6ɇ5ưâ̔62020 Ű3 560 Òo͆540 Ò͑600 Òo͇32H 2 ɔǿ0 120 Òo5Zl| đĩƶ.HìȡɔǿCʹøǠ¶̢5ȍȨ/ŐǌI(ĶĒ5ɇ5ưâ̔62020 Ű3 530 Òo͆520͑570 Òo͇32H90 Òo5Zl| đĩƶ.HìȡɔǿCʹø*M0ŐǌI͆ŭLƬ+.Hɔǿ5ĶĒ6́ǋ5ìȡɔǿ/ŐǌI͇ǷǯĘČȧ3̝"HC¹î AAU 3̝"H͆ɴ 3 ɲĈȳ͇Ć ˋŎI(ĶĒ5ɇ5ưâ̔6 2020 Ű3 490 Òo͆470
͑510 Òo͇32H50 Òo5Zl|ʒ!.ˇ750͑90 Òo5
ʻ 1/HÏ 1ñ
ñ UNEP } x Zl|ŉĬ"H032H¬L>0A(5,4H=EÕÂ!§Ð
2020 ŰǗȯ5ɇ5ưâ̔
͆CO2 ƹɺ͇

bqV

Zl|
͆CO2 ƹɺ͇Ƚȸ¬5ŖɸL0F2+(ĶĒ͆BAU͇

560 Òo120 ÒođĩƶHìȡɔǿʹøLǠ¶̢̇Ɩ (ĶĒ5ưâ̔

530 Òo

90 Òo

đĩƶHìȡɔǿʹøL
Ćǵ3̇Ɩ (ĶĒ5ưâ̔

490 Òo

50 Òo

2ǦȦL̇Ɩ"H(A3Ƅˀ2ưâ̔ȍȨ440 Òo4͆âƙ͇UNEP ͆2010͇

5 50͑90 Òo0ǅň15ɧų5B5Lɡ"¼0 .UNEP ĵęǞ650 Òo
2005 Ű5ɇÙ·5˰vd&5©5˵˻Ȃ̝F5ưâ̔3ɖź"H0LƮ.
HB͊,̈+(¼LóH0"I7OWÙ·5 2008 ŰǗȯ5ȣő÷ǰXdưâ̔6ʄ 70 Òo/H͆US EPA 2010͇
,>G5 Zl| LİAH(A36Ǡ¶/B 2005 ŰǗȯ/5˵˻Ȃ̝ĭȾF
Ù.Ȱ2HB 6 2008 ŰǗȯ5OW 1 ĩ0Ȱ2H<15ìȡƄˀ0032H (¢¼65 Zl| 3ȝê2B5/HLȶ˓+.
H B2010 ŰL̅2011 Ű3ɰØ . >+(§&5 Zl| LİAH(A3ȇI.HǗ̜6 10 Ű̜ 2

îì4H=E/{','"[Ð

/6Zl|LİAH(A36·¸Ƅˀ25ˑ ãǮ63 ɲ/W[Ēƒ5ÞŔLƯG˸+(ƀ3Bųʹ0 ./6Zl|LİAH36ĳǨɑ3 3 ,5ƚȈH0Lɟ˒ .1 ,ɔ6đĩ5ìȡɔǿE8ʹø5ȍȨLŶH0/H2 ,ɔ6đĩ5ìȡɔǿCʹø¬ľ5̎ã3̝"Hĩ̧LĆǵ3ºH0/ìȡ̔L ɪ 0/H
& . 3 ,ɔ6đĩ̙Ǥɑ2čGʉ?Lʹéųɑ2ĳɓLǆÎ"H0/H&I'I3,.ɿĂ3˕ǑLʹ3 ɲ/6&IF3ŖƇ$HŻ/W[ĒƒLƯG˸+.?(î íìty!h®¹¨Ph®Íl!R
EGŀ2ưâ̔ìȡL̇Ɩ"H(A3đĩ5ìȡɔǿCìȡʹø5ȍȨLŶH0Ƅˀ)00ʦ·6̬ cl[/62  I36F3 2 ,5Í̱H
1 ,ɔ6ìȡ5ǅÉ&5B5Lŀ"H0Ǉň˿G5ƒĚ2 ,ɔ6&5ìȡɟŐ3̇ƖIH0,>Gɔǿʹø5 ɟŐƍ C Å̹
ƍ ĹAH00/H3́ɔǿ/J0B&ILƶ(ĩ̇Ɩ"HƒƅLǨź6Ƭ+.2I7ƒĚ2 ̇Ɩ (,BG/BŐ6ưâ̔5ɺŎ3˔G
I7&5÷ǰȡ+. >B I2>((0ìȡ5ƒƅ+(0 .BˈɆ5ÎC¸F5ľɑˀĥ//22+. >0BGH5 2 Ɋɔ5Í̱3,
.̒ˀ32+.H5ɴ 3 ɲ/˹;H MRV͆Measurable Reportable and Verifiable͎ȤŎĵęǹˌďʣƍ͇C̊ŋ0ě7IH¨ʉ?/Hî îìty!câh®¹¨PÍlW~!LQL/m,đĩ5ưâ̔ìȡɔǿCìȡʹø&5B5/620BìȡǅÉ5Ő˧ɑ2ƒĚLŧĐ"H0B5HÜ·ɑ36Ǎŉ5¥̏WreCǊ Wre5& .ǷǯĘČȧ3̝"H21«ʻɑ/HĘČȧ3,.6Õ̃ĩ5ĶĒ6 LULUCF͆Land Use, LandUse Change and Forestry͇5̒ˀ02G˾ĩ5ĶĒ6 REDD+͆Reducing Emissions

5

from Deforestation and Degradation in Developing countries Plus͇5̒ˀ32HIF5ưâ̔ìȡLÖIH(A5Ƣɭ02H0L̟Ő˧ɑ2ìȡ3,2HB50.0̒ˀ/Hó.ȽǗȯ/5đĩ5ưâ̔ìȡɔǿCʹø/6Ƅ# BWvI.2B 
6I.(0 .Bÿã3 I.2ã̓05BHÝį¼0 .6¥̏˜ŎǞ/6˂é5Ŗ˞02+.2ĩ̧ʬʫʩɯF5ưâ̔/HIF5̎̚F
5ưâ̔62008 Ű5Ǘȯ/ʄ 10 ÒoH͆IEA 2010a͇˹ ( REDD+ /˜˘I.
H˾ĩ3HǷǯȡŜôüF5ưâB>(ȽĬ5Ǳʉ?5/6WvI.
2˾ĩʦɑ3ƶ.Hìȡʹø536̎ė>I.HB5BHɇ5
2 ïŷ5ưâ̔LăAH0ˇKIH5ưâȧL1Ɲ6Ù·ɑ25/B̒ˀã̓/Hî ïìä

·r+Å&/Íf·|¸/^,&B&BȌÇĽøLŶ˩"56ŀȌ5ȣő÷ǰXd5ȫų/G&ILȏŎ"H56̙Ű3K(+.ưâ̔1I)ŀȌ3ǀâIH/H5 ̙Ű3K(+. 053 Ɋɔ5ƚȈ3̝̂"H̒ˀ2Qo/HZXoZl| 5˜˘6ȽĬ¤Ƞ5ƃ02+.H 2020 Ű0ĂŰ3ȱ
ȯL.. &5Ǘȯ/5 Zl|L0G.HǨǬ62020 Ű0Ă5Ű)̒ˀ25/622020 ŰBėA(ŘǬ5ŎǤ̜3Ȣ+.ȣő÷ǰXd1I)
ưâIʐH500̒ˀ25/H (+.2020 Ű0ȷŎŰ5dql|blo 3Ȗɔ"H0BĢ̺LǑɟü"H/6źȲ̒ˀ/6H&I)
/62̙Ǥ3Ȣ+.15E3đĩ/ŖɸL̃A.5&5(A5éųL15E3ǆÎL"H50ȯB̒ˀ25/H
ȷ3 2020 Ű¬̡5čʉ?LÃ"¨ʉ?̒ˀ32+.H2%2F2020 Ű0Ű>/60 10 Ű 22020 ŰLɔǿ3"I7&5 10 Ű̜5ˈɆBźȲė>I.H0ʝ
FIHǋ2020 Ű¬̡5čʉ?3,.6ȽǗȯ/6ɯɐ32HďʣƍHF/Hïì1O5Ou,4H=EåÝàd

W[Ēƒ6 Zl|?â2+(55˄ȯF615E2ƖǰLɂ?â

(5H6ɂ

W[Ēƒ3ė>IH<0M15˘ȯ6(0̜Ƴɑ/6+.Bìȡ3¸F5̝ÂH5/W[ĒƒÙ·̒ˀ/H0ˇHíɲ/ɟ˒ ( 3 ,5ǋȓ&I'I3
̝̂"H̎ã/ȷ3̒ˀ0ʝFIHɹƙ5?L̶3ˁ.
ʻ 26&5Ǽˀ/H̯ʮ5̎ã6Zl|ʖś30+.|d5÷ǰLƬ,ďʣƍ
1*F07́̎ãLɡ"̓ʮ61*F3BÑďʣƍHɹƙLɡ"y[ʮ6Zl|ʖś30+.6Qqd3Ñďʣƍ1*F07́̎ãLɡ"ʻLˁ .ãHE3W[Ēƒ6Zl|3̝ .Ŏ̔ɑ2÷ǰ͆¼͍o5Zl|LİAH͇LƬ,ɹƙ056<0M12  Zl|LİA.
(A5˜˘L"H(A5ǴƪLɂ?â .Hɹƙ,H

6

Ï 2ñ
ñ1O5Ou,4H=EåÝàd!èdá
đĩ5ìȡɔ
ǿʹø5ŶÖÁÛǢxc3H
1.5 :5ˇĉE8x5˂Ŏ

4H=E$!è

2

0
 Zl|LİAH(A5˘ƪ3ȆʌƍLH ŘǬ̙ǤɔǿLˁɕ"Ȃ±LH

COP ȏŎ͍Iw\z 4͑6Vw\z 138͑140 4Zl|ŉĬ"H05ŷ˒˛ ʪ˘0 .Õ̃ĩ5ɔǿLŶ2
I72F205Ǵƪ02H

COP ȏŎ͍Iw\z 37͎
COP/MOP ȏŎíǇw\z4đĩ5ìȡɔǿìȡʹø5Ɉƒ
COP ȏŎIII-A w\z 36IIIB w\z 49

 Ǎŉ5ɔǿLŜ20B˜˘5âɎȯ0.6»Hɔǿ5íƸǫ®LǑɟü"H|fd
5ɟɱ

 Zl|LİAH(A5˜˘5ǴƪLƂH

COP ȏŎIII-A w\z 38IIIB w\z 51
MRV 5¨ʉ?-G0
ęǞŹü

.5ĩçĵ
 ĩçĵęǞ5̸ųCĵęÞŔx5·é5Źü3EHìȡɔǿìȡʹø5ɟŐƍ͉Å̹ƍ5Źü

COP ȏŎIII-A w\z 40͑
44II-B w\z 6064ìȡɔǿʹ
ø¬ľ5
5Źü

 Õ̃ĩ3̝ .6̓ƃ5ȍȨLŶ
H(A5Ü·ɑ2̋ƣʠLǹˉ/Hĩ̧ʩɯʬʫF5ưâ̔3̝"HĒƒ5Ĭ BAU /5ưâĹL̓ǀ
ʣƍ

3

.

>ď

ːź̎ã2
ǷǯĘČȧ͆LULUCF͇3̝"H̎ãĒƒ

LULUCF 3̝"H COP/MOP ȏŎ͎
AWG KP ¤ȠǇǞ pp.22-615
REDD+3̝"HŀǱ/5ĒƒĈȳ} 5˜˘3.Zl|ƫŀ"HĄ̤ƍG() ȽȈ̥/
61*F0B2

 REDD͈3̝"Hčʉ?Ù·0

.5ɔǿ

4

¬Ǩɲ/6W[±˜3H AWG LCA͆ǫʄ AWG͇5¤Ƞʋǰ0 .5 COP ȏŎ
͆FCCC/CP/2010/7/Add.1͇E8 AWG KP͆˜ŎǞ AWG͇5¤Ƞʋǰ0 .5 COP/MOP ȏŎ
͆FCCC/KP/CMP/2010/12/Add.1͇55ːźɹƙL
Þ3ɡ"ȃ~cF5śɼiQo3,.BēǾ
5

FCCC/KP/AWG/2010/CRP.4/Rev.45ǇǞ6W[Ēƒ0Ƞ5}d02HB50 .µʚ-FI.H

7.ƲƣI(B5/62Ŷʐ5¤Ȱ(AÙ·0

COP ȏŎIII-C w\z 68
79.5ż̴6Ǧəǅ

 >(ʇ̎3̝"HBIF/H(AZl|5ƫŀ͉ʖś3,2H
6æǉ/2 ȽǗȯ/6 4 ,5̋ƣʠG÷ǰǑ

¹î AAU 5ʙG˫ƣʠ

é̢3̝"H̋ () ̉ä2̋ƣʠ̋ƣII71
Ű(Gʄ 1422 Òo5Zl|ƫŀ÷ǰLƬ,¹î AAU Lʄ 7͑12 Òoɧ
ų3ƠH0/H

AWG KP ¤ȠǇǞ pp.15-16Ǎŉ5Wre3̝"HïŶȻɷ5˂Ŏ
AWGKP ¤ȠǇǞ pp. 62-67

Ǌ Wre3̝"Hąë5ȏŎ
0ǹˉ|fd5ɟɱ
COP ȏŎIII-D w\z 80

 CDM L slo/5 ìȡ3,2.
ďʣƍ5HïŶȻ3̝"HV|bȇ+.H  Ƚȸ/6̰˺ó
ɑ2|cS[oBĿ0KI.H(
A&5÷ǰ6ɱɑ32HďʣƍB́

slo /5ìȡLÄˌ"HąëØ+(06Zl|ʖś30+.6|d j{WRo3̝"Hąëǜǔ/H06Zl|ʖś30+.6
Qqd87˦̕ƞʺYwbmPxnP
\3̝"HĳǨɑ2ǋĕƍ5ȏŎ
COP ȏŎIV-A͑B̙Ǥɑ2čʉ
?LÃ"éų

¶ȮʆɎşƗɉB 3ʉʘ̱éų̱/5˜˘3̃ş+(Ü·ɑ2˦̕ȧɷ5˜˘/5̃şŜ2Zl|ʖś3Ü·ɑ3ˡȺ"H>/36>)Ǘ̜H

6ˈɆ5ɸŎ

COP ȏŎIII-A w\z 45IIIB w\z 65

 2020 Ű¬̡5ưâ̔3,.Bčʉ?
LÃ"¨ʉ?02+.ďʣƍɂ!(͆âƙ͇ɵʞºƖï íìty!h®¹¨PÍl!Rđĩ5ìȡɔǿʹø5Ŷ3KHȏŎ¢̵6ŀ+.¬5 6 ,+(`C8JO,2 )#1.5$!ÒpMCIQ!ÑCOP ¬ñIPBK6KD 4ô6VPBK6KD 138ô140
1 ,ɔ6ǫʄ AWG͆AWG LCA͇5 ÛǢxc
E8 1.5 ǦȦ:5ˇĉØ+(0/H

0ě7IHã̓3.

2

¬íFǫʄɴ 2 ǫ5 ɮǻɔɑ LÜ·ü"HB50 .Ȍȣǐŭ͊,5̋ƣʠ
0 .˜˘I.(ĩ̂/5 Ʋƣ 3ʧF2+(_~u^Ēƒ/B ɇ5
Ȍȣǐ6 2ǦȦ/H; 05ǇˇØ+.(() 5Ǘ6 ,0Ȋ˴

8

. 0ˇʵ6Ø+.2+((A͆˿Ŭ6 ɃǺ̲Ĝ͆ŦǺü͇í0Ȋ˴ . 0
E2ǇˇØH͇CCǜǔ2µʚ-/+(50&B&B_~u^Ēƒ6Ȇŵ
2Ēƒ362+.20Ģ̺+(W[Ēƒ/6 ˒˛"H 0ŷǇˇ5ƀ/6H6ɃǺ̲Ĝí0Ȋ˴ .Ȍ
ȣǐL 2ǦȦ 3ƠH(A36 ŀŭ2ìȡ ͆deep cuts͇Ƅˀ/H0ǇˇØ+(F3C6G ˒˛"H 0ŷǇˇ5ƀ/6H 1.5ǦȦ 05̝
ÂLėA. èɄďʣ2ǠǊ5ɥŊ3ĳ-.̙Ǥ5ɇɔǿLŹü"H0LǠå5
x5/ǹˉ"HƄˀH0 0ˇʵØ+( (Ǉˇ Zl| 5˄ȯF̒ˀ/HȿɅ6IF Zl| Lǹˉ"H03ȆʌƍLHF/H&B&BɇÙ·0 .ȌÇĽøL 2ǦȦ C
1.5ǦȦ 3Ơé"H0Ƅˀ)05 ˒˛ ȰI7Zl|LİAH0Ƅˀ/H0ˇäH0ʦ·3Ǵƪ2&5ƒĚ/W[Ēƒ/6Ŝ20B&5˒˛Ǡ¶̢ɟÄI(06H>( 1.5 05̝̂/̒ˀ256 Ǡå5x  2013 3̛ńI2015 Ű
3ʋ˘âIH; 0ǞI.H0/Hŀ¢256Ü·ɑ2ǗǤBȏ>+.
Hȯ/H5Ü·ɑ3ȏAFI(Ǥ̜Þ5x3E+.̙Ǥ5ɔǿ 1.5ǦȦ
3ŶFIHďʣƍBâ.(00/HI05̝̂/ēǗ3̒ˀ256
COP ȏŎ5/62050 Ű>/5\v2ưâìȡɔǿ0,>/3ɇ5ưâ̔Ly
[$H50ɔǿL COP17 3ǹˉ"H032+.HB
2050 Űɔǿ 0y[ɔǿ 3,.ĒƒI(ĶĒ/ˇKI.Hx6&IFLĽǝ"H+3B2GH() źȲ2Fx5ʋǰ15E2ȏŎIH6ʔʄĩȃɴ/H&.5x6>/ 2ǦȦ 0̙Ǥ5ɔǿ3,.5x/G&IL
Ď.ìȡɔǿLĽǝƄˀ/H0ȏŎH16çĢ̺/H
B 1 ,̒ˀ2Ȗƒȯ6Ǩɫ/Ģ̺0 .H Ƚȸ/Ǎ3 2ǦȦ0ɔǿ0Ȋ;.B Zl|H0ȯ3,.65ŘǬ5̙ǤɔǿLŖ˞0 ( x3̝"HǇˇ)/6ɕƳɑ2˅ȏɸ062G2ȯ/H
4H=E z,  ! ×ØCOP ¬ñIPBK6KD 37òCOP/MOP ¬PiPBK6KD 4
2 ,ɔ6COP ȏŎE8 COP/MOP ȏŎ&I'I5Ķ/Zl|5ŉĬ0&ILİAH
Ƅˀƍ3,.5ŷ˒˛ɡI(0/H
>#COP ȏŎ/6Õ̃ĩ3Ŗ . IPCC ɴ 4 ȃˍ¿ĵęǞ3.ƴŃI(ȍȨ0ǆĒɑ02HE3 ìȡɔǿ5ȍȨLH0L ŹȎAH ͆urge͇0ˇʵØ+(ìȡɔǿ5ȍȨL2I7200˒˛I.Hȯ6ˍ¿/

6ĩ̂ȏŎ5ǇǞ/6˿Ŭ ʔʄĩ±˜6¬50L"H 0Ż/ȏŎǞI&5  1ʻȽ32H3E+.Ēƒ5ŹĽKH(07 ˒˛"H ͆recognize͇0ʻȽ/I7
Ǉň˿G5ƒĚ/H0BH&I6 ˒˛6"H &ILÜ·ɑ2ʹø3ɦ2I72F213,.6Ēƒ20LƒĚ"HĶĒBHI3Ŗ .Ǉň˿G ͑00LȏŎ"H͆decide͇0ʻȽ»KII7&5 ͑ 0¢̵6CF2I72F200 .ʔʄĩĒƒ (0LƒĚ"H5/ʻȽ0 .6EGŹ2H

9

HÜ·ɑ315ȍȨ>/ǜǔ2ʻȽ02+. >+.HIPCC ɴ 4 ȃˍ¿ĵęǞ3
6ʮ 2ìȡ5ȍȨɡI.G5Ǉˇ5?/6IPCC ɴ 4 ȃˍ¿ĵęǞ3H15bqVLŨ 15ɧų5ìȡȍȨLĈȳ"H;/H0ǉŎ"H56̬ *2?3˾ĩ5ìȡʹø3Ŗ .6ēǾ5ʻȽ6Ø+.2
©ǋCOP/MOP ȏŎ3.6Zl|3̝"HǇˇ6 2 ɹƙ3ãI.ŉĬ

.H>#íǇ5/IPCC 5ɴ 4 ȃˍ¿ĵęǞ3.͆ȣő÷ǰXdȫų͇ǠB¶ȍȨL̇Ɩ"H(A36Õ̃ĩ6\|0 . 2020 Ű>/3 1990 ŰȊ/ 25͑40̈́5ìȡƄˀ/H0 ˒˛ I.H& .ǨǇ3Hç5w\z3. IPCC
ɴ 4 ȃˍ¿ĵęǞ3.ɡI(ɽĦ3ȑ+.\|Ù·0 .5ȣő÷ǰXdưâ̔L
ìȡ"H0Lɔ˾0 . Õ̃ĩ3Ŗ . ̓ƃ5ȍȨLH0LŹȎAH 02+.H,>Gē!ǇǞ5/Ǡå3 25͑40̈́ 0ɽĦˇĉI(ƀ3 IPCC
ɴ 4 ȃˍ¿ĵęǞ3.ɡI(ɽĦ3ȑ+. 0ʻȽâ.H5/ 25͑40̈́
&5 ɽĦ /H00LǛ3ɡ&0 .H0˖A2B2   25͑
40̈́ 0ǅň0 ̓ƃ5ȍȨLŶH 0ˇʵ5̜3ɕƳɑ2,2G62§ƀ5¤Ƞ5/ 2540̈́ 5?LǑɟ2Ǵƪ0"H36CCŷ0KHLƂ2
5E3COP ȏŎE8 COP/MOP ȏŎ&I'I3.Ŝ20BÕ̃ĩ5ìȡɔǿ0Ƅˀ2ìȡȍȨ05̜3Zl|5ŉĬL˒AɔǿLŶH0LÃ"Ǉˇ6Ø+(06H  &ILÜ·ɑ31>/ŶH;253,.6Ǒɟ2ˇĉ/.2,>Gʪ˘0 .Õ̃ĩ5ìȡɔǿLŶH;05Ǵƪ36/.B1>/0Ü·ɑ2ɽĦLƬ+.ˇ36CC̬ 00/HŜ2
0Bɋ˘Lȇ"Ż32+.H06H& .5E3Õ̃ĩ5ɔǿ3,.5Zl|˒˛5E2ŷŻ/ ɡ.
2I7 Û˿)Ũɋ5Hˢ¯ ąë˾ĩ3,.ēǾ5ǇˇLØIH56̬
5(A˾ĩ5 ìȡʹø 5ȍȨ05Ƅˀ2ìȡ̔05̜5Zl|3̝"H˒˛5Ǉˇ6<0M1Ø+.2
ty!h®¹¨Ph®Íl!´COP ¬PIII-A BK6KD 36III-B BK6KD 49
3 ,ɔ6_~u^Ēƒ3Ŗ .đĩƸâ (ìȡɔǿCìȡʹøĩ̂ȌÇĽøǱʉǫʄE8¥̏˜ŎǞ5ʾõȂ̝5 INF ǇǞ0 . Ɉƒ ͆take note͇I§ƀ5¤Ƞ3.Ĉȳďʣ32+(00/Hí˹50G2009 Ű 12 ǡ3_~u^Ēƒ Ɉƒ I(ƀđĩ6&I'IƶHưâ̔ìȡɔǿCìȡʹøL_~u^Ēƒ53ɏ̖ .HŻŵ6_~u^Ēƒ5̠ŠǞ I͆Appendix I͇3Õ̃ĩ5ìȡɔǿɏ̖I̠ŠǞ II͆Appendix
II͇3˾ĩ5ìȡʹøɏ̖I(  _~u^Ēƒ6ĩ̂5/5Ȇŵ2Ē
ƒ/62͆ Ʋƣ I.2͇5/IF5ìȡɔǿCìȡʹøL§ƀ5¤Ƞ5}d0"H06/2ȸȒ)+(5 Əĵ 5ƝL1"H50ȯW[
±˜5 1 ,5˗̺/+(5˗̺6ìȡɔǿCìȡʹøLĩ̂|fd53µʚH0ƒĚ/OW\͆ ɞLJ" 5ƒ͇0ě7I(ʋǰ0 .65Əĵ6ʾõȂ̝5(A5 INF ǇǞ0 .ǆȿICOP ȏŎE8
COP/MOP ȏŎ5Ċǋ3. Ɉƒ"H 0032G§ƀ5¤Ƞ/Ĉȳďʣ02+

10

(() INF ǇǞ6Żŵ0 .6>/ĈʝƏĵ25/µʚ-6ŷ(07ĒƒǇǞ&5B55/̠ŠǞɷ5Ż/µʚ-FIH03Ȋ;I7µʚ-6CCŷ>( Zl| 5˄ȯFˇ7"/3&IF5ìȡɔǿìȡʹø/6ÿã/
H0Ǒɟ25/HF 3ǞI.HìȡɔǿìȡʹøLǠ¶̢5ȍȨ0. 0E2µʚ-3"H0ǣ> +(  & (Ǉˇ6äØF#§ƀ5¤Ƞ5/IF5ɔǿ»H00ɟÄI(5?/+(¹¨!i¢X/»m,EN;9!»¾
COP ¬PIII-A BK6KD 38III-B BK6KD 51
4 ,ɔ6đĩƶ(ìȡɔǿìȡʹø3̝"HíƸǫ®LǑF3"H|fdˋFI(0/H˹ (E3đĩƶ(ìȡɔǿìȡʹø6íƸǫ®ɷŀɋ2+.H(
A&5>>ˬ ĒK$.ĒˈLâ"0B/2I7Ȋ˴"H0B̬ Ǡʈɑ3
đĩ5ɔǿCʹøLŎA.3(+.650̨Œ32H(AíƸǫ®ɷLǑɟ
ü"H|fdˋFIH032+(Ü·ɑ36ǫʄ¢ùŞ3Ŗ .đĩ5ìȡɔǿìȡʹø5íƸLǹˉ"H(A5[bl|L̛Ï"H0ȎAHȏŎI(&5[bl|3E+.ǑF3IH;íƸǫ®0 .Õ̃ĩ3,.͇͊ũĶWreF5[clo5èɄ͇͋ǷǯĘČȧ5èɄ& .͇͌̓ƃ5ȍȨLŶ
H(A5̋ƣʠƮFI.H˾ĩ3,.6[bl|6͇͊ìȡʹø5ĿǾƍ͇͋íƸǫ®͇͌ìȡʹøLŐǌ"H(A3Ƅˀ2ƾƻ5 3 ,Lȿ˅"H(A0˂ŎI.H[bl|3.íƸǫ®LǑɟü (0 .BɕƳɑ36Zl|5ŀ36ż̴ 2  &I'I5ĩ Ƭ,íƸLǑF3 .0/ìȡɔǿCìȡʹø5EGȆɟ2ŐƓLƟƺ"H0ďʣ32Hȷ3Õ̃ĩ5[bl|3,.
6 ̓ƃ5ȍȨLŶH(A5̋ƣʠ BǹˉŖ˞02+.H­3 ɘ5 ìȡɔǿCìȡʹø5ņʻ̱5ǅňEGB#9M0ś0KI7&IF5ȍȨLŶH;)0Ǵƪ3 .0/HďʣƍH,>G5[bl|36Zl|LİAH(A5˜˘LŹü"H(A5Ǵƪ5ðâE8Ü·ɑ2Ŷ5ǋȓ5ǹˉ͆Õ̃ĩ5?͇Ŝ20BǇˇ6Ǥž/H
MRV !VÅ&+!ye}xm
COP ¬PIII-A BK6KD 40ô44II-B BK6KD 6064
5 ,ɔ6ưâ̔ìȡ5ɟŐƍCÅ̹ƍĹAH¨ʉ?05ȏŎI(0/H

.5 MRV 5¨ʉ?ǽɾ:ĕ.

Õ̃ĩ˾ĩ0B3MRV 5¨ʉ?ǽɾ6ĩçĵęǞ͆national communication͇5ŹüLƃ3ʹKIH032+(Õ̃ĩ3,.6 ĵęÞŔĵę͆LºH3ź(+.͇5XQpQ͆ĵę
5͇x5XQpQ 0 3 ,5ã̓3,. Źü ʹKI.H͆ʻ 3͇Õ̃ĩ6ưâ̔ƏĵCìȡŖɸ3,.6HɧųǍŉ5ĩçĵęǞ5/BĵęL
.H5/ĵęÞŔ3,.6 Źü 5ÞŔÜ·ɑ32+.2Ƚȸ/6&I<
1ŀ2ż̴62  W[Ēƒ3HIF5Źü5ÞŔ5/Ȗ˃";611ĵę5XQpQ 5Źü3. ˾ĩ:5˦̕ƞʺYwbmPxnP\ƾƻ 3,.5Û˿üI(ĵęǾŵǋȓ5ºƖˇĉI.Hȯ/HI>/5ĩçĵęǞ3.B˾ĩƾƻ3,.6ĵę"H0ˀ®0I.(B55Û˿üI(zUlo62+( (+.đĩúƚ3ʦĩ5˾ĩƾƻLǞ.
H)/+(  Û˿5ĵęǾŵɷǊ(3ºFIH006Əĵ5Ɇƍ
́>GĶĒ3E+.6Ȋ˴C̪ʄďʣ32HďʣƍBH&"I7Əĵ0 .5
ǢɄƍ6ŀ́>G˾ĩ5ìȡ30+.5íƸǫ®02Hƾƻ3̝"HƏĵ5ǆÎ3,
2H(A5ȯ5ƒʜ6ŀ>(IF5Əĵ6̦Ű/ƸâȎAFIH032+(Ƚȸ5ĩçĵęǞ6Ǽ4 3
͑5 Ű5̜̦/ƸâI.H(AÞŔ)/2̸ų5̱/BŹüħFIH032H
 (Źü6§ƀˑʇ˜˘I.032+.H>(ĩçĵęǞ3̝"HXQpQ5Źü06ç3ìȡɔǿ3̝Â"Hưâ̔CĘČ
̔3,.SBI 5/ĩ̧ɑ3ˍ¿ .|fd5ˋɱBȏŎI(Ǉˇ5/6ìȡɔǿ5 ĩ̧ˍ¿/62 ìȡɔǿ3̝Â"Hưâ̔CĘČ̔5 ĩ̧ˍ¿02+.H(Aɔǿʦ·5ĩ̧ˍ¿IHK/62˜˘5/ˇĉ/Hɧų5Ǵƪ
6ȇ"Ǉˇ02+(Ï 3ñ
ñ _ Þ y ! h ® ¹ ¨ P Ù ã   ¿ ! MRV
dá

màd

ĩçĵęǞ

ĵę͆ʦ·͇

å,¬TéaZ·b

Q}oE8Q}oĵęǞ͆Ű 1 Ĥ͇̦Ű5ĵęǞ͆¬5ÞŔLė@͇ ưâìȡ3̝"H̃ş ˾ĩ:5˦̕ƞʺYwbmPxnP\ƾƻ
5½ìȡɔǿ̇Ɩ3̝"Hʾˬɑ2Əĵ̸͆ų6ˇĉ2ĵęXQp
Q

͇

ĵęǞ5ƏĵōÙȊ˴ďʣ˽ǑȆɟ/H0LɟÄ"H(A ˦̕3̝"HÛ˿5ĵęǾŵǋȓ˘

x5XQpQ ưâ̔ìȡ5̃ş ˦̕ƞʺYwbmPxnP\ƾƻ5½

ȣő÷ǰXdưâ̔ĘČ̔ɺŎ3Ƅˀ2ĩÞéų5ǆÎ
SBI 5/5ìȡɔǿ3̝̂"Hưâ̔ĘČ̔5ĩ̧ˍ¿|fd5ˋɱ

˾ĩ3,.BĳǨɑ36ĩçĵęǞ5/5ĵę5ŹüȏAFI.H͆ʻ 4͇3
,Ȗɔ";QoH

12ɴ 1 3˾ĩ6ĩçĵęǞL 4 Ű3 1 ųƸâ"H;0˂ŎI(ȽǗȯ/ĩçĵęǞL 2 Ĥ¬Ƹâ .Hĩ6>GĿ2<0M15ĩ 6 1 ų Ƹâ .2
0LʝH04 Ű3 1 ų0Ż/̸ųǑɟüIH0ʦ·2Gˮ?˶M)Ēƒ
/H0H
ɴ 2 3̦Ű/5Ol|noĵęBƸâ"H032+(& .&/6͇͊Q}oĵęǞE8͇͋ìȡʹøreĎ(ƾƻ3,.5ƏĵLƸ½"H03
2+.Hȷ3ƀʞ5ƏĵƸ½IH0̒ˀ)ȃ5ɴ 3 5Qo0ĒK+.
ǝ3̒ˀ02H
ɴ 3 6ĩ̧ɑE8ĩÞɑ2 ȤŎĵęǹˌ ͆MRV͇3̝"H˂Ŏ/H>#ĩ̧ɑ2ƾƻLĎ(ìȡʹø3,.6ĩÞɑ2ȤŎĵęǹˌ̅ɧLʊ(/ĩ̧
ɑ2ȤŎĵęǹˌ3BªIH032+(Ü·ɑ2XQpQ3,.6§ƀȏ>HF3̒ˀ25í˹5̦Ű/5Ol|noĵęBSBI 5/̰ț̾ɑ̰ƕʛɑ,ȁLř̒ (Ż/ĩ̧ɑ2ā˜ãǮ͆international consultations and analysis͇Lʹ|fdŐǌIH032+( ̦Ű/5Ol|noĵę 36ĩ̧ɑ2ƾƻLĎ(ìȡʹø)/2ĩÞ/ȹʦ3ʹìȡʹø3̝"HƏĵBė@032H,>Gĩ̧ɑ2ƾƻLĎ(ìȡʹø3,.6ɕƳ3ĩ̧ɑ2 MRV 5Ŗ˞02H53Ŗ ƾƻLĎ.2ȹʦ5ìȡʹø3,.B̜Ƴɑ3ĩ̧ɑ2ā˜ãǮ0Ż/˜˘Lʹ|fdɟÄI(0HÏ 4ñ
ñÜRy!h®Íl
dá
ĩçĵęǞ

å  , MRV!¬Té

màd
ĵę

aZ·b
ÞŔE8̸ų̠ŠǞ I ĩ0Ȋ.̒ʲ32F2E3

4 Ű3 1 Ĥ
B6 COP 3H̸ų3,.5ǝ2HȏŎ3Ɓ̦Ű5ǝǊĵęǞ ȣő÷ǰXdQ}o͆Q}oĵęǞLė@͇ ìȡʹøreE8Ď(ƾƻĩ̧ɑ2ā˜ãǮ͆SBI /͇̦ŰĵęǞ ̰ÀØɑ̰ƕʛɑ,ȁLř̒(Ż/ ìȡʹø0&5÷ǰ5˽Ǒƍ5ĕLɔƭ"͎ˀʄĵęǞ
LºH

MRV

ĩ̧ɑ2ƾƻL
Ď(ìȡʹø!

źːʔʄĩ05ā˜5/5ŗ̚œ3EHãǮ!

ˁ˅5Ã̃ɑÛǢ ĩÞ3.ȤŎĵęǹˌLĎH ǫʄ5/ºFIHXQpQ3Ɓĩ̧ɑ2ȤŎ

13ĵęǹˌ5Ŗ˞3B2H
ĩÞ/ƾƻLĎ
(ìȡʹø

ǫʄ5/ºFIHʪɑ2XQpQ3ƁĩÞ/ȤŎĵęǹˌIH

Õ̃ĩ˾ĩ5#I5]dBÜ·ɑ2XQpQ5ɸŎ6§ƀ5˜˘3D)4F
I.HI>/5˜˘LʝI7&I2G3ˮ?˶M)ÞŔ/H0H
MRV 3̝"H (˚ 5¨ʉ?-G6ìȡɔǿCìȡʹø5ǅň5́¶36ż̴
2  &IF5ǅňŘǬǨź3̇ƖIH15Å̹ƍCɟŐƍLƦÄ"H
03,2GŜ20BZl|I¬ű2F2E3"H(A5̒ˀ2¡̟ʓ3
2H (ż̴LŎ̔ɑ3ɡ"06̬ ˳˃"H0/2ż̴LƬ,0ʝ
FIH / 1 ,ƭƼL .472F256/6 ̊ŋ 5˜˘I.
200/Hȷ3Õ̃ĩ5ìȡɔǿ3,.Ő̧3&I̇ƖI2+(0ʛëFI(G¸F5Ƶʚ0FI(G"H53,.6W[±˜5 COP
ȏŎ/6ˇĉ2ìȡ5ɟŐƍĹAH˄ȯF65ȯ̊ŋéųLǍ3Ƭ,¥̏˜ŎǞLĳɠ0 (¤Ƞ̃M/H˜ŎǞ AWG͆COP/MOP ȏŎ͇0Ȋ˴ .ŷ̎ã/
H©ǋ˜ŎǞ AWG 5ǋ5˜˘/B̊ŋLŘǬ15E3 .53,.5˜˘
6ŀ0GFI.2E/Hï îìty!h®¹¨PÍlW~!àd!LQL!myçÊ½PÌË *!câÖàdå,u!SzW[Ēƒ5ǇǞ0 .5ǽƖ62007 Ű5vʹøˈɆLĳǨɑ36ŖƇ .H§ĤvʹøˈɆ3+(f[b/0Ȝ.H̎ãH&I5ĩ̧ʩɯʬʫ3̝"Hčʉ?˜˘I.H āñɑf[oO|kE8f[i
3ȷü (ʹø 0ã̓/H¥̏˜ŎǞ/6ìȡʜù5Ŗ˞02+.2ĩ̧ʩɯʬʫF5ưâ̔6ȽĬ6&I'Iʦɑ2čʉ?3¯I.HƁíEGIF5ã̓/5ưâ̔ìȡLĩ̂5Ǳʉ?
5/˂Ŏ"H(A5˜˘ʹKI.(§Ĥ6Ēƒ3ʧH0/#f[b&
5B5ĒƒF6ľI. >+(Ēƒ/2+(ȿɅ6˾ĩŸ"H Û˿)Ũɋ5Hˢ¯ąë L15E35ã̓5/̉Ʉ .53,.Ĉóĩ5
/Ēƒ/2+(0KI.Hĩ̧ʩɯCʬʫ6 ĩ 3EHGK̬ 
ã̓/G&5/F3Õ̃ĩ0˾ĩ5ˢ¯5ŨɋL15E3ċǓ$.56ƞʺɑ3BǁȐɑ3B̬ 3ɕ̱ .H5ã̓F5 CO2 ưâ̔6 2008 ŰǗȯ/Ű̜ʄ 10 Òo/G§ƀBĹó¡ƑI.H 7̉ä2ŖɸI7ưâ̔LȡŜ3Ś0/Hɶ3BKF#W[Ēƒ/6& (ǋĕƍL,H0/2+(7

IEA  2010 Ű3Ɏʻ ( World Energy Outlook 2010 3H¡Ȥ/6ȽĬ5ǁɸ3ĳ-(bqV͆Current
Policies Scenario͇3Hĩ̧ʬʫʩɯF5ưâ̔62008 Ű5 10 Ò 3300 oF 2020 ŰǗ36 11 Ò

14() §ĤĒƒ/2+(0/ŘǬ5˜˘FBĩ̧ʬʫʩɯŖ˞ľ32H
0K/62§ƀBŶʐ¤ȠIH
¥£wq¯êLULUCFë å,àduLULUCF å, COP/MOP ¬òAWG KP U­ pp.22-61Õ̃ĩʦĩÞ5Ƿǯɷ3EHĘČ̔L15E3ɺØ"H3,.5LULUCF
͆ĪĭèɄĪĭèɄĽüE8ǯǺ͇6ȽĬ6˜ŎǞ AWG 5/˜˘I.HW[Ēƒ/6&5˜˘5/â..HÙ.5˘ȯ3,.6Ēƒ"H0/#̎ãɑ2Ēƒ301>+.H() ŀǱ/6Ƚȸ5Lʏʐ"Hǋĕƍƛ*âI.HZl|05̝̂/ȷ3̒ˀ256¬5 2 ,/H
1 ,6Ƿǯɻȿ͆forest management͇3EHĘČ̔5ɺØ3Yl|͆̢͇LˋH1
3,.6§ƀ5ǹˉ0I(0/H
B 1 ,6ē!Ƿǯɻȿ3EHĘČ̔5ɺØǋȓ3,.Ĉȳ}͆reference
level͇ǋŵƲɄIHǋĕƍŹ>+(00/Hȷ3ƀʞ3,.6§ƀ5˜˘5ş̛ȃɴ/6ʋǰ0 .@ JZl|LűHĄ̤
H2%2FĈȳ}5ˋŎ3.Ő˧ɑ2ĘČ̔ĹóL0B2+.H5ɟŐ2ɺŎʹKIHďʣƍHF/HĈȳ}3,.6đĩǍ3Ƹâ .
Hǅň3,.2011 Ű5íĀ3xLʹ¡Ŏ02+.H5xL
3Ćǵ3ʹ0/H1̗02H
Ȋ˴ɑȿ˅ C"Ǌ˂ǸǯCßǸǯ͆ǷǯȰ+(0J3Ǹǯ3E+.ǷǯĹó"I7ĘČ.H06Hɧų˕Ǒ C"͇0̈ǷǯLEGEɻȿ"H0
F5ĘČ̔LɺŎ E0"H Ƿǯɻȿ 361 .BɟŐƍ,>0Ĉȳ}ǋŵ6Ǎ3HǷǯĘČ (/J̔L2MF5ǋȓ/ Ĉȳ} 0 .Ŏʜ&I0Ő̧5Ƿǯɻȿ3EHĘČ̔5ŨãLìȡ3ɖź"HĘČ̔0 .ɺØ E0ǋŵ/HȽǗȯ/6IƄ#Zl|ƫŀ3,2H0ǉŎ6/2&5Ą̤ƍ6ȇ
H

.

>(IF¬ľ3B&B&B ȥĭ 5Ɲ21 Ǌ˂ǸǯßǸǯǷǯȡŜ¬ľ5ȘøL1>/ØI˶@53̝"H°ƲI(ǥǩFºFIHǯɃȶ3ʷ
ɬI.HȮʆ5Ɲ3̝"H °ƲǥǩʿĞ ͆Harvested Wood Products͇0ě7IHŢȬ¢ɍʸŒ215ʦȲȭŒɷ5ďơñ͆force majeure͇3̝"HL15E3"H3,.¤ȠʹKI(ȏŎ36ɒG˶>I2+(#IBZl|3,.ɖźɧų5ż̴LƬ*H

7500 o3ʄ 14̈́Ĺó"H0I.HI3Ŗ ŀȌ5ȣő÷ǰXdȫųL 450ppm 3ƠH0LƑŎ (bqV͆450 Scenario͇/62020 Ű/ 11 Ò 3600 o͆2008 ŰȊʄ 10̈́Ĺó͇3ƠH0/H0¡Ȥ .H͆IEA 2010b͇bqV5ưâ̔Ũ6ʄ 3900 o0032H

15

REDD+  !¤!u
COP ¬PIII-C BK6KD 6879
REDD+ 6¤ȠĒƒLɂ?â$2+(_~u^±˜3+.ǠBĒƒ3˷+(ã̓0I.(2010 Ű3Ø+.F5¤Ƞ/6&I̎ʶ ˸IHE2¤Ƞ
ʐ.(W[Ēƒ/6ECŀǱ3,.ĒƒI(  ˑʇ6>)IF5¤Ƞ
3Ņ4FI.HREDD+ Ù·Ƭ,ɀĸɑ2ż̴Lǹˉ"H/6§ĤĒƒ53ė>I(fzXpąë̒ˀ/HZl|5˄ȯF6REDD+ Ù·0 .5ɔǿLɡ"Ǉˇ6Ø+.20̒ˀ/HǷǯȡŜF5ưâ̔6ɇÙ·5ưâ̔5 2 ïŷLăAH0ˇKI.H8Õ̃ĩ3HĘČ̔ưâ̔6Ŝ20B̎ãɑ36˹5 LULUCF 55/ɺŎIɔǿ5
3ɺØI.H  ˾ĩ5ǷǯF5ưâ̔3,.6͆˿Ŭ5TsZ»ɄɷF5ưâ0ēǾ3͇WvI.2§ĤŀǱ/5ĒƒºFI(03E+.
REDD+ 0ã̓3,.5čʉ?I.06ǋĕ,FI(&IÙ·0.15E2ìȡ3,2+.56ãF2WWF 65ȯ3,.6ɇÙ·/ 2020 Ű>/3ǷǯȡŜôüF5ưâ̔Lslog͆ưâ̔ĹH̎ã+(
0 .B&I6ç5Ķƙ/5ǷǯĹó3E+.ɖȉIH͇3"H0Lɔɑ0"H;)0Ÿ .H  W[Ēƒ5/6&5E2 REDD+ Ù·0 .15E
2ìȡLɔƭ .5L˂Ŏ"HǇˇ6ØF2+(REDD+ 3̝"Hčʉ?5Ǳʉ?ǆFI(06ǣ>20˗̺0 .ȇHŀ2ɔǿˋŎI.

\j AAU !Ç+Ú/fæ,ßÉ
AWG KP U­ pp.15-16¥̏˜ŎǞƖɱ (ǗFbOE8ǭȄ˚ĩ5̎3 loTO 0ě7IH¹
î AAU͆ïź͇̔ɂ!H0Ģ̺˃I.(IF5ĩ 690 Ű«¬̡5ʊȟ5
Ìȩ5(AȷȈ5ìȡöñ20Bưâ̔ȡ+.0¡ƑI.((A¥̏˜ŎǞɔǿL˪̅̇Ɩ ʋǰ0 .¹î AAU Lɂ?â"¢ã+.( (ɴ 1 ʄǪǤ̜5ˇK7˟5̌ɃvY\5¨ʉ?3E+.ȃǤʄǪǤ̜3B
ʙG˫I&IȃǤɔǿ̇Ɩ5/©5ĩ 3͆ļˤL˿!.͇èɄIH002I7
ʋǰ0 .͆Ƚȸ/Ǎ3ÿã2͇ȃǤɔǿF3ŷAFI. >032H
¹î AAU 5ż̴6ŀɴ 1 ʄǪǤ̜Ù·/ɂ!H̔6 110 Òo3H0ˎɺB
H͆Schaeffer 2010͇ɴ 2 ʄǪǤ̜5̙1IF32H͆5 ŰB 6 8 Ű
͇3BEH1 Űź(G3ɕ"0ʄ 1422 Òoɧų5Qw[o02HI6ǎ
Ǩ 1 ĩã5Ű̜ưâ̔EGBŀ̔/H(+.5¹î AAU 5Ɲ6Zl|5˄ȯF6ǻA.̒ˀ2Ģ̺/H

8

IPCC 5ɴ 4 ȃˍ¿ĵęǞ/62004 ŰǗȯ/5ɇ5ȣő÷ǰXdưâ̔5*17.3̈́ǷǯȡŜɷF5
CO2 ưâ̔/H0 .H

16

W[±˜/65Ģ̺3,.ȏŎ6I2+(() ¤Ƞ5mYdo 95
365Ģ̺3̝"H˜˘5˾ʊ̅0 .4 ,5̋ƣʠǆȿI.H͆ʻ 5͇
Ï 5ñ
ñ \ j AAU¦Ô-

,ßÉ

̋ƣʠ 1

Ľǝ2

͆͏Ƚȸ˿Gɴ 2 ʄǪǤ̜3ʙG˫

ďʣ͇

̋ƣʠ 2

̢LˋH͆ẍ́0.1̈́1̈́5̈́10͇̈́̋ƣʠ 3

ʙG˫ 6ąë0 ./H¹î AAU LǢ"Hĩ6͇͊ļˤ6/#͇͋ʦĩ5ưâ̔ȃǤɔǿLĤ+. >+(ĶĒ5?ʦĩ5ɔǿ̇Ɩ3»Ʉ
/H

̋ƣʠ 4

ʙG˫

L˒A2
͆âƙ͇FCCC/KP/AWG/2010/CRP.4/Rev.4 EGɵʞºƖ

¹î AAU Lé̢"H0˄ȯF6źȲ2F̋ƣʠ 4 ǠBǣ>   bOCR[Qq5E2ĩFˁI7̅ć3ȏŎ (3E+.˒AFI(ʦã(*5ȁèLƀ32+.FĖŎIH032H(AŹƤơLɡ .H
/6Ăʅ2ĖŎ/62̋ƣʠ 2 C̋ƣʠ 3 61¤Ƞ3ʹKI( AOSIS F5|
gmb/6̋ƣʠ 2 C̋ƣʠ 3 3EHé̢10Ƭ,ż̴6ưâ̔3ƹɺ .E& 7 Ò12 Òo͉Ű32H0͆AOSIS 2010͇AOSIS 5ˎɺ6 2020 Ű>/5ʄǪ3Ŗ
"Hż̴Lˎɺ .H5/í˹5 14 Òo͉Ű0Ȋ˴"H0ĀãB 6&I¬Lé
̢/H0LƒĚ"HōÙ3¹îLự"H03Ȋ;I7ÿã/6H$A.̋
ƣʠ 2 C 3 ƲɄIH0Ƅˀ/H0ˇH5¹î AAU 3̝"H6ŗ̚ɑ2˜˘0 .ˁËIdloQoź(H06Ŝ25Ƭ, Zl| :5ż̴6ȏ .˳2§ĤȏŎ53
6ė>I2+(§ƀ5¤Ƞ5/6ȖɔL 2I72̒ˀ2Ģ̺/H!G1A:F å,k²¿!ÑAWGKP U­ pp. 62-67¥̏˜ŎǞ5/ˋɱȏAFI( 3 ,5Ǎŉ5Wre͆ưâ̔čŶ[̛Ɏ
Wre͆CDM͇ÛēŐǌ͆JI͇͇5ŘǬ3,.6˜ŎǞ AWG /¤ȠʹKI.(ĳǨɑ3IF5Wreŉʐ"H0ʦ·3ċŖL"Hĩ6Ŝ2˾ĩ5Ŀ6¥̏˜ŎǞ5/5ìȡɔǿ5ˋŎLWre5ŉʐ5íƸ0 .H0JBĿWre5ŉʐʦ·3,.ĖŎɑ2ˁǋL .Hĩ6Ŝ2(+.˜˘5ȱȯ6ŘǬ3K(+.IF5WreL15E3Ľ.ʹ5
ʹ250+(ȯ3ź.FI.H

9

FCCC/KP/AWG/2010/CRP.4/Rev.4

10

AOSIS 5|gmb6ɕƳɑ3̋ƣʠ 2 0 3 3ˎɺLŖƇ$.HK/62<=ē!0ˁË$H(A/6Áŏ&5>>»Ʉ (17W[Ēƒ5/6ǍŉWre3,.5ȏŎ6ė>I.F#Ŷʐ¤ȠʏʐIH032+.H (+.Zl|5˄ȯFǍŉ5Wre3̝ .ŀ2Ľü62&5¤Ƞ˾5mYdo36̒ˀ2˘ȯB,ė>I.Hȷ3̒ˀ256ïŶȻ5ṵ̈̄/HïŶȻ06CDM F5[clo3Ŗ .̉ɄIH0ƑŎI.H¨ʉ?/H(07H|cS[oF5ìȡ[clo͆CER͇5Ɏɂ 20 o/+(0 .ïŶȻ 50̈́/I7Ő̧3ƂFIH[clo6 10 o0032H
IZl|5˄ȯF̒ˀ2565¨ʉ? CDM Ƭ, slog 5ƍ˧L˪.ďʣƍHF/H˿ŬCDM 6ĭȾŀ/6¥̏˜ŎǞʄǪ .H¬5ìȡ6B(F2˾ĩ3. CDM |cS[oŐǌI20 oìȡII720 o5 CER Ɏɂ"HIÕ̃ĩ5ɔǿ̇Ɩ3»KIH5 »KIH
05ƒĚ6&5 20 oã)Õ̃ĩĩÞ/ìȡ"H0LÖIH0ƒĚ/H(+.CDM 0¨ʉ?6ąë0 .¥̏˜ŎǞ5ìȡɔǿƬ,¬5ìȡ6B(F2CDM ŘǬBʏʐII75ƍ˧6ŘǬ5ɔǿ3,.B&5>>Ŷʏ
IH11
I3ïŶȻóKH0¢ƏŜ ĽKHÕ<10ē! 20 oìȡIHĶĒ/Bìȡ[clo6Ő̧36 10 o Ɏɂ 2,>GÕ̃ĩìȡLÖIH56 10o5?/HŨã5 10 o6[clo0 .6»ɄI2˾ĩ3.6Ő̧3ìȡ˩.H5/ĭȾŀ/ˁ(03slo͆net͇/ìȡɎɂ"H,>G
CDM 5èɄ¥̏˜ŎǞB 6ŘǬ5ìȡɔǿ3Ŗ .˺ó/5ìȡ3ˡȺ"H
032H (¨ʉ?ØI7Zl|LİAHõ02HďʣƍH() Ő̧36Ƚȸ5 CDM /6̰˺óɑ2|cS[oŀ̔3Ɏɂ .H0ˇK
I.H͆Haya 2007͇ ̰˺óɑ2 |cS[o06CDM 0¨ʉ?J02
J0ŐǌI(|cS[oL"2007 Ű5Ǘȯ/ʹKI(ɜɮ/6Ùɏ̖|cS[o®ǅ5*5 40̈́Ő̧5[clo̔3 .ʄ 20̈́̰˺óɑ/H0ɌH
0˹;FI.H͆Schneider 2007͇ (|cS[oĿ006Ő̧36
CDM 0¨ʉ?ìȡ3ˡȺ"H1J¥̏˜ŎǞ5ìȡɔǿLŶH÷ǰLƬ+. >+.H0LƒĚ"H,>GȽȸ/6Zl|Lű. >+.H5/H
Fenhann (2011) 6ȽĬ>/3ƸâI.H|cS[oLŖ˞3͆2013 Ű¬̡3̛ń
IH|cS[oḶ͇2013 Ű͑2020 Ű5̜3Ű̜1IF5[clo͆CER͇Ɏɂ HLˎɺ .G&5É6Ű̜ʄ 6 Ò 8200  t /H͆2013͑2020 Ű5Ǥ̜Ù·// 54 Ò 5300  t͇˹5ɜɮƭƼ"HE35[clo5­3 20̈́ ̰˺óɑ /+(0"I7Ű̜ʄ 1 Ò 3640  t 5ưâƫŀLƩ032H˼3ˇ7ïŶȻ slo/5ìȡ 3ˡȺ"H(A36 20̈́L˪HȻ/˗IH0Ƅˀ02H
/»Ʉ ( 20̈́ 6>/ɜɮF5ŶɄ/ǻA.z2ˎɺ/6HȽȸ5

11

CDM 6 ąëɑ36 slog5ƍ˧LƬ,&/620ƭƼBH&5ȿɅ63 2 ,/H͊,6CDM 6[cloǤ̜0ě7IHȷŎ5Ǥ̜ [clo5ɎɂLWRo 2(A&I¬̡5ìȡ6[clo0 .WRoI#ʅʁ2ìȡ32H0B͊,6CDM |cS[oʹKI(ʋǰƞʺɦ˲21Ȕĉɑ3źĭ/˩G&5ʋǰ|cS[o5ĸɇ5ľ/ǝ2Hìȡ̃@ĶĒH00IF5ƭƼ6Ȇ &IF5÷ǰ3¢í3Ǥž"H5B̬ 

18

CDM 36"/3(Zl|ƫŀ5d[H06˒˛

.2I72F2(+. ïŶȻ Ƭ,÷ǰ6CDM Lslo/5ìȡ3ˡȺ/HE2¨ʉ?3
2H¬í3$A.|dQqdg3Ƙ .E2÷ǰ02Hďʣƍ́˺óƍ5Ģ̺6ïŶȻ5̉Ʉ)/Ƭ+.˅ȏ"HƄˀ62&5©5ƿģL˿!./B
ʹHǨɫ/6ʇɱ*ØH06/2&IFL˿!.5ƿģ0ʉ?ĒK$I7
ïŶȻ6 slo /5ìȡLƒĚ"H¨ʉ?3/H
 G1A:F å,ng!¬¦ÔEN;9!»¾
COP ¬PIII-D BK6KD 8087Ǎŉ5Wre3̝"H˜˘3˜ŎǞ AWG /ʹKI.(53Ŗ ưâ̔čŶ͉
CDM͉JI ¬ľ5Ǌ Wre3̝"H˜˘63ǫʄ AWG 3.ʹKI.(  Ǌ Wre ȷ3Ǎŉ5 CDM 0ēǾ3[cloLɎɂ$HiQ|͆ũĶį5Wre͇3,.6xO}seTɷ5 ALBA ˚ĩ12̰Ŭ3Ź
ƧĖ5ņûLɡ .H(A§ĤBŀ2¤Ƞ5̃ş6ǤžI.2+(/Ǌ ũĶį5Wre0 .ƑŎI.H56EU ɷƸǶ .H͆|c
S[oĂµ/62͇f[iLŖ˞0 (Wre͆f[o[nPmP\Wref[oonP\͇C̳ĩƸǶ .H NAMA 3̝"H[clo5Wre/HW[Ēƒ5/6 (Ü·ɑ2ƸǶ36äˆIH02ŀã. 2 ,ȏŎI(͊,6 ũĶįWre E8 ̰ũĶįWre 5ǋLǹˉ.|fd&I'I3,.ɱ*FI(05|fd6 COP17 5Ȉ̥/ʋ˘LƂH0Lɔǿ0 .HB͊,6&IF5ǹˉ3ź(+.5ʝƔIH;ąëĒƒ53ɒG˶>I(0/HũĶį̰ũĶįWre0B3Zl|3Ŗ .15E2ƒĚLƬ*H3,
.6&5ÞŔÜ·ɑ3˜˘I.2ȽȈ̥/61*F0Bˇ2  ¬5
3 ,5ȯ6̒ˀ/H
1 ,ɔ6Ēƒ3ė>I(Ǉˇ530/H

slo/5ȡŜ

3̝"HB5ė>I(0

slo/5ȡŜ 06íɼ5Ǎŉ5Wre3̝"HïŶȻ5̎ã/˕Ǒ ( slo /5ìȡ0ē!ƒĚ/HȏŎ36ũĶį5Wre3,.Ɉƒ";¢̵5
3 ɇ5ȣő÷ǰXdưâ̔5slo/5ȡŜ͆ʅȡ͇E8͉B 6Ĥ̍LÄˌ"
H 0ąëė>I( (+.IFǹˉIHǊ Wre6Ƚʹ5
CDM 06̈Ŝ20BÙ·0 .ŘǬǱʉ?5/ĒƒIHɔǿ¬5ìȡLB(F"¨ʉ?ɔƭIH032H
2 ,ɔ6j{WRo3̝"Hąë̎ãɑ3
12

ė>I2+(0/H

ALBA͆Alternativa Bolivariana para las Américas͎ʀťv«ǟʌĒǽƑ͇6B0B0OWƸġ"
HʀťʦɅ˥ǒāŎ͆FTAA͇3Ŗ"HOkmg0 .}seTxOYv21Lƃ3ʋƖI(ĩ 5\|ǽƑ/H&5ƊƑƍD˷Ű5ȌÇĽøĩ̧¤Ƞ/6ȷ3ũĶWre3Ŗ .ŹċŖ5ɱĶL0+.H19

j{WRo 0Ģ̺36Ő6 2 ɩ̼H͊,6ưâìȡ̔5j{WRo/HI6Õ̃ĩ0˾ĩ/ē!ìȡL 2 ųWRo . >0Ģ̺/HB͊,6͊,5˦̕5șI3 2 ,5̈ƒĚL. >0ƒĚ/5j{WRo/HÜ·ɑ36[clo˨Ø3E+.ɂ!(˦̕5șI,>GÕ̃ĩʦĩ5ɔǿL̇Ɩ"H(A3ƾƜ+(̕LēǗ3˾ĩ3Ŗ"Hƾƻ0 .BWRo . >0Ģ̺/HW[Ēƒ/6 ưâìȡ̔5j{WRo L̟;)0Ǒɟ2Ǉˇ2ɀĸÿÙƍLÄƬ"H 0ǇˇH(AűƒĚ/6 (Ģ̺5ʝƔBė@0262Ǵƪ0 .6ŷ Ǌ Wre 5/Ɏɂ ([cloHĩ5ɔǿ̇Ɩ5(A3»KI©ǋ/ç5ĩ͆˾ĩ͇3.6&IʦĩÞ5ìȡʹø͆NAMAs͇Őǌ5/WRoI. >0¢ƓɎɂ"Hd[6ÿãG
HUNEP ĵęǞ/6 (j{WRo3EHZl|5 ǝ2H ƫŀ5d[
13 Òo3H0ˎɺI.Gȏ .˳˃"H0/2Ģ̺/H͆UNEP 2010͇
B 1 ,5 ˦̕5șI3̝"Hj{WRo 3,.6Ƈ5é̢0 . ˾
ĩ3EHźːĩ30+.̉ä2ʕĝʹø͆NAMAs͇3Ŗ"H©5ƚȈ/5ƾƻLʾō"H
0ǇˇØ+.H ©5ƚȈ/5ƾƻLʾō"H 006 ©5ƚȈ/5ƾƻ 0 ũĶįWreL˿!(̕5șI 05̜/þçH0LƑŎ .H(+.Ŝ20B ©5ƚȈ/5ƾƻ 0Ȟē6I26#/H  ũĶį
Wre3EH̕5șIÕ̃ĩ5ɔǿ̇Ɩ3»KIHB5/+(0 .B ƾƻ
0˅̑I. >ďʣƍ6ȇ+.H5 j{WRo 5Ą̤ƍ6 ([clo˨Ø3EH˦̕5șIƾƻ0 .WRoIʋǰ0 .Õ̃ĩƸ½"H;ƾƻ¢ŐɔȡG"HďʣƍHB I˩I7ʋǰ0 .˾ĩ/5Ŗɸ̄I
H032Gưâ̔ìȡ5̱/B̄Iɂ!H&2I7Zl|:5Ǝż̴6ÖI2
3 ,ɔ6̰ũĶįWre5̋ƣʠȇI.H0/H̰ũĶįWre 0ˁǜǔȀʃ0 (ǼƉŚØI(ʢǙ36 3 ,H0
ʝFIHɴ͊5ʢǙ6xOC}seT5E3ũĶįWre3,.ĖŎ
ɑ2ĩ 3Ŗ"H̐ƔFWre05Ƅ# B[cloLðâ"HWre
06̢F200Lɡ"(A35ǼƉǄ.ŚØI(00ɴ 2 6
CDM 3H HFC-23 C N2O 5ìȡ5E3ìȡ_do[clo5ũĶ¿ǵEGBīÆ
ɑ3ŌũĶįWre@ Jìȡ5̰÷ȻüLƩ.H]dH0Lˮ>
& (]d36ç5ƚȈ/ŖƇ"H0Lǹˉ"HƄˀH0ʢǙ/H& .
ɴ 3 6SD-PAMs͆Ƭʐďʣ2̛Ɏ3ˡȺ"Hǁɸ0Ƶʚ͇5E3ɔɑ6ȌÇĽø̟ȅ/62ǁɸ5 CO2 ìȡC̉Ƈ3̝"H÷ǰL˒A&I3¸F5zNQqdLʹ;
/H05ʢǙ/H͆Bradley et al 2005͇ȽǗȯ/63 Ɋɔ5 SD-PAMs Ḷ5ã
̓3,.Ü·ɑ2ƸǶ62 13SD-PAMs 3 .BȽǗȯ/6_f|o0+(ǋȆɟ/Ǒɟ2éųƸǶ056̬ 5 ̰ũĶįWre 5̋ƣʠȇ+.H05Zl|5˄ȯFˁ(̒ˀƍ6
/Ʈ( 3 ,5ʢǙ5*5 2 ,ɔHFC-23 Lė@ F Xd5ìȡC N2O 5ìȡLEG÷Ȼ13() W[±˜¬̡3ƸâI(đĩ5ƒˁ536 üɛȴǈ3Ŗ"Hʾõ̕5Ŵḛ̏ũĶįWre 5˜˘3ØI˶B0ƒˁBâ..H

20

21L5ɑ÷ǰɑ3̃AHWreLǹˉ"HĶ0 .5ďʣƍȇI.H03Hȷ3
˾ĩ3H F XdC N2O 5ìȡLȽǗȯ/ƑŎI.HEGBǏ~d/ìȡ"H(A5WreʝǶ/I7Zl|5ʖś3ŀ2ˡȺ/HďʣƍHO
W5ɀĸÄ˝Ş͆US EPA͇62010 ŰF 2020 Ű5̜3N2O ưâ̔Ùɇ/ʄ 35 ÒoF 40 Òo͆CO2 ƹɺ͇3Ĺó"H0¡Ȥ .GF Xd3,.6ʄ 6 ÒoF 9 Òo͆CO2 ƹɺ͇3Ĺó"H0¡Ȥ .H͆Û3 2006 ŰǗȯ/5¡Ȥ͇IF5Ĺó~dLƠH¢/I7Zl|ʖś3Ŀŀ2ˡȺ02H͆USEPA 2006͇
ÙãPÎP3HB7>0CL?0O6
COP ¬PIV-AôBå,|¡·v!¬˦̕ƞʺYwbmPxnP\0 3 ,5ã̓6#IBưâ̔&5B536
ɕƳɑ36ż̴ 2  IF 3 ,5ã̓/5ƾƻÕ̃ĩF˾ĩ3̀C3ʹ
KIH13E+.˾ĩ3Hưâ̔ìȡ5ŀCǏ3Ŀŀ2ż̴â.ƂH>#˦̕3,.W[Ēƒ/6 ɚǤ˦̕ ͆Fast-start Finance͇ ̙Ǥ˦̕
͆ Long-term Finance ͇  \    Ȍ Ç ĳ ̕ ͆ Green Climate Fund ͇  Ŭ ¯ Ņ ğ ±͆Standing Committee͇5 4 ã̓3,.ĒƒƖɱ (Ù·0 .6ȷ3̙Ǥ˦̕LƸ½.(A5ʉʘéų̱/5˜˘3̃şˁFI(Ü·ɑ2˦̕ȧ3,.5˜˘6ɔɱ+(̃şȰ+(ƞʺ3,.61 ,5ɔȼ0 . ƞʺWre ͆Technology Mechanism͇5ˋɱ
ȏ>G&ILƾHB50 . 2 ,5Ȃ̝5ɱ*BȏAFI(1 ,6 ƞʺĲʹŅ
ğ± ͆Technology Executive Committee͇/GB 1 ,6 [m[tcf
iͅslo[ ͆Clean Technology Centre and Network͇/Híʞ6ƞʺ3̝"HȸȒ5ãǮ0Ü·ɑ2čʉ?LƸǶ"Hʉʘ0 .µʚ-FI.Hƀʞ6ĩ}
Cĭı}ĩ̧}/5āñLÃ̃"H(A5ʉʘ0 .µʚ-FI.H() ʞ5̝ÂCǑɟ2µʚ-6§ƀˏAH002+.H,>Gƞʺ5ã̓/Bʉʘ
5̱/6ʯŮ5̃şˁFI.H(07Ü·ɑ2ɔǿɷȏAFI.HK/B
2I7&5(A5ƭǿLºH0ĒƒI(K/B2ƞʺ5̛ɎFǘĉɦ˲>/5aQ[Lƴ ̃AH0/H¨ʉ?Ǩź3ĩ̧ɑ3/H16ȽǗȯ/6Ǒ0KHLƂ2
YwbmPxnP\3,.6ˊ 2 ,5ã̓0Ȋ;.ǜǔ2ʋǰ â.2
YwbmPxnP\5̒ˀƍCčGʉ@;ã̓3,.ʯŮ5ĒƒI.H
B55Ü·ɑ2¨ʉ?-G36ˮ?˶A.2
¬5˿G˦̕ƞʺYwbmPxnP\5 3 ã̓3,.6Zl|5ʖś
3,2HǑɟ2ȏŎI(06ˇ(˦̕3,.I>/̃>2+(̎ã͆ʉʘ5ˋɱ͇3Ēƒ2I(0ȯ6ˍ¿3É"H  ˾ĩ5ìȡʹø5Ŀ̉ä2˦̕ƞʺYwbmPxnP\LíƸ0 (ÞŔ/H0LʝH0>)>)§ƀˏA.2I72F2ÞŔĿ­3ƾƻ̄II7˾ĩ/5ìȡʹø5̃ş3Bƾ̨L( Zl|ƫŀ3,2HďʣƍBH

21ï ïìä

·rÅ&/]fY°Ä¶µ("Ó³!ÀCOP ¬PIII-A BK6KD 45III-B BK6KD 65
W[Ēƒ/6Ü·ɑ2ÞŔ6äǞI.2B5 ¶ȮʆɎşƗɉB 6ˈ
5ɸŎÕ̃ĩ˾ĩ&I'I3ȎAFI.HÕ̃ĩ6ʜù0 .˾ĩ6
ƴŃIH B50 .0̈6HB555Ʉ˓6B0B0 EU ƸǶL .
Hˇʵ/G&5ĶĒ62050 Ű>/5̙Ǥ/5ưâ̔ìȡ3̝"HƗɉ5ɸŎL"H;
/H05ŸL .(ɆWWF Lė@ NGO B¬íEGÕ̃ĩ3,.6 ʤȮʆʹøˈɆ͆Zero Carbon ActionPlan͇ ͆ZCAPs͇L˾ĩ3,.6 ¶ȮʆʹøˈɆ͆Low Carbon Action Plan͇͆LCAPs͇LƲƣ"H0LȎA.(& .&I'I3¸ė>I15E2x
5|fdLʊH;BėA.ƸǶL .(͆Meyer et al 2009͇
ȽǗȯ/65 ¶ȮʆɎşƗɉB 6ˈɆ &B&B 2050 Ű>/LŖ˞0 (̙ǤɑˈɆLƭ"B532H515E2ǽ́LƬ+(B532H5ƨǪñ6H5¸ė>IH5xɷ6ʹKIH50+(ȯǑF/2(AZl|3
Ŗ"HɕƳɑ2ż̴Lƴ ̔H06/2  ¤Ƞ5/5ǼƉƲɄI(
06Ǌ Ǳʉ?5/6Ǥɑ2ɔǿ͆2020 Űɔǿ͇)/62EG̙Ǥ/5Ŗɸ5ˈɆBȎAFIH032HǋĕƍK#2FȽKI(00/Hï ðì%'¬5ǹˉL>0A(5~c5ʻ 2/HW[ĒƒZl|3,.Ƭ,ż
̴6ȽǗȯ/6Ǒɟ,Ŏ̔ɑ3ɡIHB56Ŝ20H  ãGǒǑ
ƈ/2F0+.W[ĒƒZl|3,.Ƭ,ż̴200362F
2
ȷ3Ȗƒ 2I72F256ʻ 23H̵ɔ5Āã¬Zl|5ƫŀʖś
1*F3BˡȺ H00/HI5Ȇ5Í̱LˁI7§ƀZl|Lʖś.0/H0BʝFIH˟5Í̱LˁI7ȽǗȯ/Ǎ3ˬG.2ĩ̧öñ5ȍȨFF3+.ďʣƍŀ0LɡĠ .HI¬5Z
l|ƫŀ62M0 .B̍472F#&5ƒĚ/63ɡ (&I'I/5
Źü6§ƀ5Zl|˜˘3.BǻA.̒ˀ0H

ðì4H=E"{'*-,!
§ƀZl|LŜ /BİA.(A3¸Ƅˀ25>#6ĩ̧ɑ2˃ȯFɜɮȂ̝E8 NGO ʹ+(ǹˉLȊ˴ .?H&5ƀ&ILˮ>.ǎǨ3¸/
HLʝ.?(ð íìº¼©å) # NGO),¦ÔÜ·ɑ315E3Zl|LİA.0/H53,.UNEP͆ĩ̂ɀĸˈ
Ɇ͇Climate Action Tracker (CAT) Greenpeace (GP)WWF &I'IǹˉLʹ+.H&IFL>0A(5ʻ 6/H1 ɲ/ƭƼ (E3&I'I3Zl|5ˈɺ5íƸ02+.HB5̈5/Ăʅ2Ȋ˴6/2ƮFI.H̵ɔ6´˿+.H
22

Ï 6ñ
ñ4H=EÆªå,9<?0!«Û

i

UNEP

CAT

GP

WWF

Ƚȸ5ìȡȍȨ3EH2020 Űưâ̔

490 Ò t520͑540 Ò t

480͑540 Ò t

479͑536 Ò t

23Ƅˀ2 2020 Űưâ̔440 Ò t440 Ò t400 Ò t440 Ò tZl|120 Ò t80͑120 Ò t

80͑140 Ò t

79͑136 Ò t

4H=EÆª43 Ò tÕ̃ĩ5ìȡɔǿŶ

25 Ò t͆40͇̈́

20͑50 Ò t˦̕ƾƻLɟŐ3"H03E+.˾ĩ5ìȡLŹü"H23 Ò t36 Ò t17 Ò t10 Ò t¹î AAU Ŗɸ
10͑20 Ò tǷǯĘČȧ5ɺŎ5Ćǵü

͆ɴ 2 ʄǪǤ
̜5¹îB͇
5Òt

CDM ɷ5Wre5ƿģj{WRo5̟ȅ5Òt
24 Ò t5Òtǅň2
͆@ JZl|ƫŀ5d[0 . 13 Ò t͇

10 Ò tĩ̧ʩɯʬʫ5ưâ̔ìȡ

10 Ò t5 Ò t,F Xdìȡ5ó̀

20 Ò t5Òt

13 Ò tǷǯȡŜôüF5ưâ̔ì
ȡ5Źü

21 Ò tȕȮĭưȍ3EH
ȭF5ưâ̟ȅ

10 Ò tȵE8ȬVhšɝĺȶ˧3,.˺óɑ2ìȡLʹ{l[W3Ŗ .BŖɸLʹ

ǅň2

͆âƙ͇Climate Action Tracker (2011)Greenpeace International (2010)UNEP (2010)WWF International(2010)

23

IF5Ȋ˴F1 ,ƭƼ/H56đĩ5ìȡɔǿCìȡʹø5ȍȨLŶH
0ǠBɕƳɑ,ŀ2÷ǰLƬ,Zl|ʖś5ƚȈ/H0źȲ/H0 .B
&I¬ľ55ŹüĆǵü3E+.Bɖźɧų5Zl|ʖśħIH00/H(07 ˦̕ƾƻLɟŐ3ʹ03E+.˾ĩ5ìȡLŹü"H 0̵ɔ
#I5ˎɺ3.B 10 Òo¬5Zl|ʖś÷ǰLB(F .H5Ü·ɑǴƪ
02+.H56̎5˾ĩĩÞĕ36_~u^Ēƒ/Ɏʻ (ɔǿEGB̓ƃɑ2ˈɆLƬ+.HĶĒH0/H(07ĩ6_~u^Ēƒ
3ƸâI(ìȡʹø0 .6 GDP (G5ưâ̔L 40͑45̈́ìȡ"H0Lƶ.HĩÞǁɸ0 .Ǎ3ɎʻI.HTsZ÷ȻƿģɔǿCßɂďʣTsZɔǿLŐǌ(ĶĒ6EGŀ2ìȡˁ˶AH0ˎɺI.H͆Climate Action Tracker 2011͇ɴ 3 ɲ3HW[Ēƒ5ãǮ0¬5đɜɮȂ̝NGO 5ãǮLˮ>H0§ƀZl|Lɇɑ3ʖś .(A36¬5E2čʉ?̒ˀ32+.H0ʝF
IHɴ3 ( Zl| &5B53Ŗ"H˒˛LEGÚŵ3¤Ƞ53µʚ-H0̒ˀ/H͌ ͊/ˁ(E3Zl|5˒˛6W[Ēƒ3ʉ?ØIFI.
HB55CCŷbl|5Ķ21L˿!.&5˒˛LĨA.ʹ0̒ˀ
/Hɴ£3 ɽĦ LƬ+.ìȡɔǿCìȡʹøLˋŎ .Hĩ &5ɽĦ5ɳ͆EG̓ƃɑ2ǋ5ǅň͇LƲƣ/Hǫ®LǑɟü3 ǆ.0̒ˀ/H/?
(E3đĩɔǿǅÉ5ɳL0H5ɳL0H53E+.ǅÿÒo5Ũɂ>IHI36Õ̃ĩ5ìȡɔǿ5íƸǫ®Lʂǳ"H0ºǺBė>IH˾ĩ
5ìȡʹø5Ŀ˦̕ƞʺYwbmPxnP\ƾƻLíƸ0 .H0Bˮ>
H;/H&5ǫ®5ǑɟüǆÎLħ+.;/Hɴ3 ìȡɔǿCìȡ̵ʹø¬ľ5 3.Zl|I¬ƫŀ"H
0L̟/0Bŀ2mbLƬ+.HÜ·ɑ36 ¹î AAU 5ʙG˫ Ģ̺ 5E3§ƀ5˜˘ȃɴ/6 10 ÒoL˪
HZl|ƫŀ5ż̴LƬ*HB5Lķ/ʹ0̒ˀ/HēǾ3Õ̃ĩ5Ƿǯ
C˾ĩ5 REDD+Wre213,.Bʻ 6ɡ .HE3ďʣƍ0 .6C6GǅÿÒo5ż̴LƬ*Hȷ3Wre3.W[ĒƒFľI( j{WRo5̟ȅ 6ʄ 13 Òoɧų5Zl|ƫŀ5d[LƬ,05ˎɺBH
F3W[ĒƒF̵ɔ0 .0ľI. >+(ĩ̧ʩɯʬʫ3̝"Hìȡ5čʉ
?3,.Ǒɟ3˂Ŏ .0C oV˜ŎǞ·é05āñL˿!. F XdŖɸLŹü .0B̒ˀ/Hƀʞ3̝ .6Wre˜˘5*̰ũĶįWre5ã̓˜˘5d~d0 .6»HB I2 ( 1 , 1 ,56ƞʺɑŗ̚ɑ2ã̓/6H   (LˏAH0/Ŝ /B5ʥŀ2Zl|LİAH0/H5/I7&3ĩ̧ɑ
2öñL̪$H)5¿É6ÿã3H

24ð îì¡[Zl|LŜ
8ɴ 3 ɲ/»Ʉ

/BİA.(A3ǎǨ0 .6¸/H5/Jɴ 2 ɲE( 3 ,5þã3ȑ+.¬ǹˉLʹ

h®¹¨

,

)#h®Íl!RǎǨȽĬƶ.H 25̈́ìȡɔǿ6Ȋ˴ɑ̓ƃɑ2̼̎3ØH1.5ǦȦ5E2̙ǤɔǿLíƸ0"I75ɔǿ/"Fÿã02H  ȽĬ5ǁȐʊȟȸȒLˮ>
H05ɔǿLF3ŶHȏŎIHďʣƍ6ǻA.¶@ JŶFIHďʣƍ"FH0H
/6ɕƳɑ2Ŷǣ> B55Ȱȿ)0"I7 Ŷ ¬ľ3ǎǨȽǗȯ/ʦĩ5ìȡɔǿ3̝ ./Hʹø6¸¬5͌ȯʝFIH

25̈́

0ɔǿLĴƬ"H &5ŀ̎ãLĩÞ5ìȡ/ʹ0LǑɟ3"H ɔǿ̇ƖLƦÄ/HE2ȓſǁɸLƖɱ$ɔǿĂ2HdX/20LÞľ3ɡ",>GǎǨ5ìȡɔǿĂ2Hʍ3Ʒ(̿/620LÄˌ"H0/ɔǿ5Å̹ƍLɟÄ"H0̒ˀ/H
& .&5Å̹ƍ5ɟÄLíƸ0 (/©ĩ3Ŗ .ìȡɔǿCìȡʹø5ŶLÃ .0BƄˀ/H&I6 ˣĩ6ɔǿLŶH;) 0E2
ɕʽɑ2lfcLâ .0EG6íƸǫ®LǑF3 .03E+.Ȋ˴ŗ̚œCnPO5̜/Ŕǒ3/HɀĸL̜Ƴɑ2īñLFIHE3 .
;/H14Õ̃ĩ5ìȡɔǿÙ·0 .Ŝ /BŶFIH0ȰI7ȃ5dml|0.˾ĩ3EG̓ƃɑ2ìȡʹøLÃ"06̬ /Jȷ3˾ĩ3Ŗ .ì
ȡʹø5ŶLÃ"̧36˦̕ƞʺYwbmPxnP\3̝"Hƾƻ3,.ǎǨȨÎH0LǑɟ3ɡ .2I72F2() ¬50Lǹˉ"Ḩ3̨Œ02H56OW5ȸȒ/H2010 Ű5̜̋Ʈ5ʋǰFȌÇĽøTsZȓǶŜ20B 2012 Ű5ŀʌ̷̋LʊH>/6Ʋƣ
IHˁ˶?ʎǣɑ32+. >+( (+.OWɔǿŶ5˜˘3ȽǗȯ/Ƈ!Hďʣƍ6ǻA.¶OW5ɔǿȍȨ6ȏ .́25/&5ȸȒ/6
Úůƍ5˄ȯF©5Õ̃ĩɔǿŶ3Ƈ!.ďʣƍB¶ > .C˾ĩìȡʹø5d]Ol|LʝHďʣƍ6B+0¶2+. >
5 OWĢ̺ 6ŘǬǱʉ?5ǽɾÙʪ3ŀ2żLʴ0 .H  OWLȿɅ3 .Zl|5˜˘L˙A. >7>">"Ŗɸɇɑ3̄IH)/H() 1 ,H56OWLŬ3d]|`o5E3ȘɄ"H̽Ȫâ.H0)6̟2I72F25Ģ̺5żŀǂ&5ż36©5Ǿ 2øȂ
14

 ǨɫLĲɵ .HǠ3ǭǎǨŀ̮ȭɎɂ ((AǎǨ Ŗľɑ3ÑƱH 005ďʣƍ¶2+. >+(06ĖA2  ĳǨɑ2ʝǋ0 .ǎǨɔǿLĴƬ Ŗľɑ3ÑƱ
H05̒ˀƍ6ĽKF25/Ǩɫ6&5>>3 .H

25

̩IH0/. >ƚL"I7OWLȿɅ3̓ƃ5ȍȨLE0ø"Fâ.E& (Ðĕ6̍2I72F2h®¹¨PÍlW~!LQL!mɴ 3 ɲ5W[Ēƒ5ãǮ/ˁ(E3ãGC" ìȡɔǿ C ìȡʹø ¬ľ
5̎ã5BŐ6Zl|5ƫŀʖś36ŀ2ż̴HǎǨ65ã̓/5Zl|ʖś3.Bɬǻɑ3Ü·ɑƸǶL .;/H
IF5ã̓/Ü·ɑ2ƸǶL²+(ɬǻɑƸǶLʹ0/I7Ǌ?ǽɾ5ĩ̂¤Ƞ3.̒ˀ2ˡȺL"H0/HŘǬǱʉ

ȷ3¬5 3 ,5ã̓6̒ˀ/H0ʝFIH Ǎŉ5WreE8Ǌ Wre3̝"H˜˘5/slo/5ìȡLȎAH
ƸǶL +Gʹ+.0ēǗ3j{WRoL̟ȅ"HŸL+*G0
Ÿ .0 F Xdɷ5ŦǺXd5ìȡ3ʗHĩ̧ɑ2WreLƸǶ"H ˦̕ƞʺYwbmPxnP\3̝"H·ɑ2ƸǶ0ŐǌL .0&5̧Ƚȸ/ɯɐ02+.Hĩ̧ʩɯʬʫ3Ŗ"HŖɸ0 .5ɨ̕ɷLƀƥ "H
06˦̱̕0Ŗɸ5ˡȺLǋǤž/Hã̓/H
1 Ɋɔ3,.6ǎǨȽĬǹˉL̃A.H 2 ĩ̜[clo 5˜˘3BKH(
A̒ˀ/H2 ĩ̜[clo6Ĕí5˿G&B&Bĩ̂L}d0 (¨ʉ?LƑŎ
.HK/62(AɕƳɑ3 Ǌ Wre 5˜˘36ʋ8,2ǎǨ
Wre5˜˘5/15E2˜˘Lş̛"H3Ő˧ɑ3ż̴ .H0¡ƑIH
Ƚȸ/615E2B532H5Ü·ɑ2ƸǶ2(AãF2&5âʦǍŉ5 CDM 3Ŗ"HȦL 1 ,5ȿɅ0 .H0LʝH0CDM ¬3ʕéųǽɾIHďʣƍH&5ĶĒɇÙ·/5ìȡ3ʗF2E2éų32HďʣƍBGB &IǎǨǁŲ5ƸǶ02I7źȲǎǨǁŲ5 Ǌ Wre 3
̝"H˜˘3Bż̴ .H Ǌ Wre 3Ŗ"HĢ̺ƒ˛H0LEG
cmP{3Ș"0Ƅˀ/H
2 Ɋɔ3,.6ǎǨ6ÓũĶWre 5ďʣƍLʡŎ ,,B&I¬ľ5
ƚȓGH03,.Bǲ˱2ʝǋLƬ,ĩ/BH ̰ũĶį Wre5
¼5GǋLɬǻɑ3ƸǶ .03E+.vd50I(˜˘5Gǋ3ˡȺ/
HB I2
3 Ɋɔ3,.6ǎǨ5Ü·ɑ2ƸǶƄˀ/H˦̕3,.6ɚǤɑ2˦̕0.͂ŢQrbOmP{ʏʐɑ3ŐǌI.H&IFǰ( .1I<1˺óɑ2B5/H6¾Ȳ0 .˽Ǒ2>>/H>(̙Ǥ5˦̕3,.6ǍŉƸǶ3Ŗ"HǑɟ2cbBȹʦ5ƸǶB#IBǑɡ/.2ƞʺ3,.B ǎǨ5ɀĸƞʺLɇɑ3̉Ʉ"I7ŀŭ2ìȡ/H 0ˇʵ 7 7ʟIH  &ILÜ·ɑ315E3ʹ;25>(ǎǨƬ+.Hƞʺ6˾ĩȽĬƄ
ˀ0 .Hƞʺ0lk .H5əɑˠɃȁ5Ģ̺615E3áȿ"H;25& (ɌĢ3ɕƳɑ3ƇHčʉ?6Ǧ)3ˁź(F2ƞʺɦ˲ 1 ,5ŀ2ɔɑ/+( APP͆OcOŁůȗwoqbl|͇BȽȸ/6ûLł+.GÕ͆Ŝ2
0Bľ̎F6͇ˁ2ȸȒ/H

26

Ȱ˘IF¬ľ5̵ɔ̒ˀ/20K/62¬ 3 ,5̵ɔ¬ľ5Ù.5̵ɔ/ǎǨZl|Lʖś"H(A5Ü·ɑ2ƸǶLâ .0Ƅˀ/Hä·r+Å&/]fȽĬ5ǎǨ5ǁŲ5čʉ?5/̙Ǥɑ2čʉ?3̝Â"HB56 3 ,H͊,6ĭȾȣǚüŖɸĳǨȓǶ/HēȓǶ62011 Ű5˿Ŭĩ±/B˜˘IH¡Ŏ
02+.G15 2050 Ű>/3 1990 ŰȊ 80̈́ìȡ"H 0ɔǿLėM/HIƲƣII7Ŝ20B̙Ǥɔǿ6ɟÄIH
2 ,ɔ6ēȓǶ3.Ʋƣ"H032+.H
˜˘L̃A.( ̙Ǥpl| /H

ĳǨˈɆ

5̯àɘ0

.ɀĸɗ

3 Ɋɔ6ʊɃɗƃ02+.ºƖ ǕŰ̞˜ȏŎI(TsZĳǨˈɆ͆ 2030
Ű>/3 30̈́ìȡ 0ɔǿLė@͇/H5ĳǨˈɆ62011 Ű 3 ǡ 11 ǎ5ǭǎǨŀ̮ȭ0ɣŤɴąŇñɎ̭ƙ5¢ǂLĎ.2012 Ű 3 ǡǧ5ßɸŎLɔá3ˁɕIH
032+.H
IF5̜5ǆĒƍL15E30H0˗̺6H̮ȭLʊ̀ (ǎǨ30+.
ĩœɑ2xc5Ƅˀƍ6@ J́>+.H0HǎǨ5Ǥ/5 25̈́ìȡɔǿ6Ȋ˴ɑ̓ƃɑ2ɔǿ/6H&I/BȌÇĽøƠȅ5˄ȯFÔã2ɔǿ/62 (+.̙Ǥɑ2čʉ?5/EGɬǻɑ2ìȡLş̛ .Ƅˀƍ6ǎǨ3BźȲH
& .&5Ő˭L˿!.ɇ3Ŗ .¶Ȯʆɢ±͉ʤȮʆɢ±5 nLɡ &5ŐȽďʣƍL˯LB+.ɡ .0ɇ30+.Bˣ̒2ˡȺ02GHẕ́5Zl|ʖś30+.6í 2 ɼ5 ìȡɔǿʹø5Ŷ C ìȡɔǿʹø¬ľ5 3̝"H¢̵5ǋEGʑƌƍ6́ (̙Ǥɑ2čʉ?3̝"HéųǆÎB§ƀ6EG̒ˀ32H
.+/˹;.(E2Zl|LİAHǋɸL ʍɯ¢ 0ǉ!H56(C" ¢Ő#IBĩ 5̜/ĒƒL"H06̬ ­3Ēƒ/(0 .BŐʹ"H56Ŕǒ/62   &M2061$/2 0ˇ36ŘǬ˩H 3͑4
H6&I¬5ɇɑ2ůĮȌȣǐLɁĎ"H0̒?H0LƆI.62F2
&5̒?06Ŀ5ɂȶɩ5ĭFȜ.0LĎØI ȍ 0ɂĜ5
Ǵȧ3̝KH˦ȧ5ˬ3ʰ @¦ 5ǅ5ǝ2HĹóLƩɋŬȌ˞3E+.Ĺó"H/JʼŒLˁ̅"05̒?/H
&5E2̒?LƬ+( 1$/2 6Êȿɑ3ĎØIH06/2&I/25/I75ʳŀ2HZl|LŜ /BİAH(A5ĩ̧ĒƒLŪȎ"HöñLƋ+.62F2&I6ĩ5Þ̎/BŐǌ/H ĩ̂5¤Ƞ3.B2I
H;öñ/H&5 Zl| 5˜˘6ˇƹI75ĩ̧Ǳʉ?6&B&B¸
5(A5Ǳʉ?25LɰˏAH˜˘/BH&5˜˘3Ŗ .ɤ(*6ɘƽ3čGʉM/2I72F2

15()

̮ȭ3EG&5¡Ŏ6˽Ǒ32+(

27

oÈ±
Alliance of Small Island States (AOSIS) (2010) Options to address surplus AAUs and carry over St Lucia on behalfof AOSIS. Presentation at AWG-KP (December6, 2010)
Bradly, Rob, Jonathan Pershing, Lee Schipper, Kevin A. Baumert, Navroz K. Dubash, Jose Roberto Moreira,
Stanford Mwakasonda, Wei-Shiuen Ng, Luiz Augusto Horta Nogueira, Virginia Parente, Harald Winkler.
(2005) Growing in the Greenhouse: Protecting the Climate by Putting Development First. World Resouces
Institute (WRI). Retrieved from http://www.wri.org/publication/growing-in-the-greenhouse
Climate Action Network (CAN) (2010) Cancun Building Blocks: Essential Steps on the Road to A Fair, Ambitious
and Binding Deal. CAN.
Climate Action Tracker (2010) Are countries on track for 2oC or 1.5oC goals?. Climate Action Tracker. Retrieved
from http://www.climateactiontracker.org/
Climate Action Tracker (2011) Cancun climate talks – Keeping options open to close the gap. Climate Action
Tracker. Retrieved from http://www.climateactiontracker.org/
Climate Interactive (2010) Climate Scoreboard. Retrieve from http://climateinteractive.org/scoreboard
Fenhann, Jørgen (2011) CDM Pipeline Overview. UNEP Risø Centre.Retrieved from http://cdmpipeline.org/
Greenpeace International (2010) Mind the Gap! Greenpeace. Retrieved fromhttp://www.greenpeace.org/international/en/publications/reports/Mind-the-Gap/
Haya, Barbara. (2007) Faild Mechanism: How the CDM is subsidizing hydro developers and harming the Kyoto
Protocol . International Rivers. Retrieved from http://www.internationalrivers.org/node/2326
US EPA (Environmental Protection Agency) (2006) Global Anthropogenic Non-CO2 Greenhouse Gas Emissions:
1990-2020. EPA. Retrieved from http://www.epa.gov/climatechange/economics/international.html
US EPA (2010) Inventory of U.S. Greenhouse Gas Emissions and Sinks: 1990-2008. EPA. Retrieved fromhttp://www.epa.gov/climatechange/emissions/usinventoryreport.html
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) (2007) Technical Summary. In: Climate Change 2007:
Mitigation. Contribution of Working Group III to the Fourth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental
Panel on Climate Change. Cambridge University Press.
IEA (International Energy Agency) (2010a) CO2 Emissions from Fuel Combustion. 2010 Edition. IEA.
IEA (2010b) World Energy Outlook 2010. IEA.
Meyer, Alden et al (2009) A Copenhagen Climate Treaty: A proposal for an amended Kyoto Protocol and a new
Copenhagen Protocol by members of the NGO community (Version 1.0) David Suzuki Foundation /Germanwatch e.V. / Greenpeace International / IndyACT / National Ecological Centre of Ukraine / WWF
International Retrieved from http://wwf.panda.org/who_we_are/wwf_offices/bolivia/publication/?187301/
Project Catalyst (2010) Taking stock – the emission levels implied by the pledges to the Copenhagen Accord. Project
Catalysit. Retrieved from http://www.project-catalyst.info/
Schaeffer, Michiel (2010) Surplus AAUs. Presentation at the UNFCCC Side Event "Analysing Copenhagen: 3.5°C,
2°C, or 1.5°C?” Bonn, Germany Retrieved from http://www.climateanalytics.org/
Schneider, Lambert. (2007) Is the CDM fulfilling its environmental and sustainable development objectives? Anevaluation of the CDM and options for improvement.
WWF International (2010) Plugging the Gap: An easy guide to a safe climate future. Retrieve fromhttp://wwf.panda.org/what_we_do/footprint/climate_carbon_energy/climate_agreement/publications/?1954
03/the-gigatonne-gap

28