11.16.2020

Global Health Diplomacy Workshop (2020)
概要 Course Overview<趣旨>
令和 2 年度厚⽣労働科学研究費「国際会議で効果的な介⼊を⾏うための戦略的・効果<Purpose>In the 2020 Ministry of Health, Labour andWelfare's Health and Labour Sciences Research的な介⼊⼿法の確⽴に資する研究（20ＢＡ
1002）」において、グローバルヘルスの今⽇的課題に関する経緯や⽇本及び各国政府の動向を分析し、我が国が国際的な議論に戦略的に介⼊し、⽇本の⽴場を主張するための介⼊⼿法、グローバルヘルス外交教材、効果的な教育プログラムを開発すること、並びに厚⽣労働省、外務省、JICA、海外のグローバルヘルス政策実務機関、研究機関等と連携することで、より現実的で効果的な介⼊並びに有⽤な教材・研修プロクラムの開発につなげることを⽬的としている。とりわけ、新型コロナ感染症の世界的流⾏により、ウイズコロナ、ポストコロナに伴う地政学的変化のなかで、国際益と国益とを調和をもって国際舞台で主張できる

Grant "Study for the Establishment of Strategicand Effective Intervention Methodologies forInternational Conferences (20BA1002)," theresearch team aims to analyze the history
behind current issues in global health, examine
global health diplomacy trends of Japan andother nations, establish strategic intervention
methodologies for Japan, and develop aneffective global health diplomacy educationalprogram. In addition, the research team aims
to work with the Ministry of Health, Labour andWelfare (MHLW), Ministry of Foreign Affairs(MOFA), Japan International Cooperation
Agency (JICA), and other global health policy
organizations and research institutions
overseas to develop more realistic and⼈材の養成が急務であり、その実現の⼀助として本ワークショップを企画、実施する。

effective interventions, as well as educational
materials and training programs. Amidst thegeopolitical changes caused by the global
pandemic of a novel coronavirus disease(COVID-19), there is an urgent need to cultivate
human resources who can advocate for global
health at the global level in harmony withinternational and national interests. This
workshop was designed and will be
implemented to help achieve such goals.

<対象>
国際的機関の意思決定会合（governing bodymeeting） に参加予定の者で、国際会議経験に乏しい官⺠の若⼿〜中堅実務者を対象にする。
所属先：厚労省、外務省、JICA、NCGM、⼤学、シンクタンク・NGO など
⼈数：参加者 30 名とオブザーバー20 名（推薦ベース）<Target audience>
The workshop is open to young and mid-level
public and private sector practitioners who areplanning to participate in a governing bodymeeting of international organizations and11.16.2020<⽬的・⽬標>世界保健総会をはじめとする国際会議にて、国際保健課題の議論に戦略的に介⼊して⽇本の⽴場を有効的に主張できる⼈材を育成するため、以下の教育⽬標を設定する。
１ 国際的機関（国連・国連の専⾨機関・パートナーシップ）におけるガバナンスの意味を理解する。
２ 会議前の国内調整と会議準備プロセスを理解する。
３ 国際会議の標準的なルールを理解する。
４ 国際会議で有効な発⾔をすることができる。
５ 国際会議の意思決定に⾃らの主張を反映させる技法を習得する。
６ 国際益と国益を調和させる姿勢を滋養する。
７ 国際会議の暗黙知を共有する

have little experience in such international
meetings.
Possible affiliations include MHLW, MOFA,JICA, NCGM, universities, think tanks, NGOs,etc.
Expect number of participants: 30 participantsand 20 observers (both on a recommendationbasis)<Objectives and Goals>
In order to develop human resources who canstrategically intervene in the discussion of
global health issues and effectively advocate
Japan's position at the World Health Assemblyand other international conferences, thefollowing educational objectives have been
established
1. Understand governance in internationalorganizations (UN, UN specialized agencies,partnerships).
2. Understand the pre-conference national
coordination and conference preparation
process.
3. Understand the standard rules forinternational meetings.
4. To be able to speak effectively atinternational meetings.
5. Acquire techniques for reflecting one's own
arguments in international conference
decision-making
6. Nourish an attitude for harmonizing
international and national interests
7. Understand the unspoken rules/tactics
international conferences

11.16.2020＜⽇時＞
2020 年 12 ⽉ 12 ⽇（⼟）・13 ⽇（⽇）＜会場＞
オンライン(Zoom)参加
事務局と⽇本⼈講師は旅⼯房スタジオから参加＜様式＞
オンライン形式によるワークショップ（国内リソースパーソンは会場に参集またはオンライン参加。外国⼈リソースパーソンは原則オンラインによりオンデマンド＋リアルタイム参加＊
注：＊リアルタイム参加が原則だが、可能な限り録画ビデオを送っていただきオンディマンド教材として⽤いる。当⽇、接続が悪い場合は録画ビデオ放映。ベストなのは、冒頭講師挨拶、ビデオ供覧、供覧中チャットで寄せられる質問に回答、ビデオ終了後ライブで Q&A）
＜⾔語＞
⽇本⼈講師のみのコマは⽇本語で、外国⼈講師が関与する部分は英語で実施。（同時通訳なし）<Date and time>
Saturday, December 12 and Sunday, December
13, 2020＜Venue>Online (Zoom), with the secretariat and someJapanese resource persons participating from ameeting room the Tabikobo office.
<Style>Online workshop
Domestic resource persons will join either fromthe venue or online. Overseas resource persons
will participate online in principle, with ondemand and in real time*
Note: *In principle, real-time participation isrequired, but if possible, a video recording for
the use as an on-demand teaching aid should
be presented to the secretariat ahead of time.
If there is a poor connection on the day, we will
broadcast the video on demand. (The bestthing to do is to give a speech at the beginningof the session, watch the video, answer
questions from the chat room, and do a live
Q&A after the video.)<Language>
Sessions with only Japanese instructors will be
conducted in Japanese, and sessions involving
overseas instructors will be conducted inEnglish. (Simultaneous interpretation will notbe provided.)11.16.2020<講義内容>
1. 国際保健概要
l国際保健外交：⽇本・タイの事例

2. 決議作成プロセスと有効な介⼊（intervention, 発⾔⽅法）
ll

決議⽂書の読み⽅
有効な介⼊発⾔の準備の仕⽅
Ø ⽇本・タイの事例
l 介⼊発⾔（intervention）の練習（資料はワークショップ開催前にメールで配布し、参加者には事前に介⼊⽂（intervention）を準備・作成してきてもらい、ワークショップ初⽇に発⾔を⾏う。）<Workshop Contents>
1. Overview on global health diplomacy•

2. Resolution-making process and effectiveinterventions (interventions, speakingmethods)•How to read the resolution documents•

How to prepare for an effective
intervention
Ø Examples from Japan and Thailand•

3. 交渉におけるイニシアチブの取り⽅
l

The Case of Japan and Thailand

Practicing Intervention(Materials will be distributed via email

過去の交渉事例紹介・経験談の共有

prior to the workshop and participants
will be asked to prepare an intervention
statement beforehand and to deliver it on＜研究班としての活動＞
1. 事前・事後評価（アンケート）によるスキルの習得状況

2. 効果的な会議参加者に求められるスキルの同定

3. 研修カリキュラムの形成と評価
4. 今回⽤いた資料を基にした教材開発

the first day of the workshop).
3. How to take the initiative in negotiations•Learning from past negotiation cases andpersonal experiences of resource persons

11.16.2020

Global Health Diplomacy Workshop (2020) Course Schedule Overview (Draft)
Day 1
Time
8:509:00

Session Title
Sign-inSession Content
Registration and house keeping matters to be
explained

Facilitator
Ms. Ishizuka

9:009:30

Self-introduction

Self Introduction
All resource persons and participants saya word after being called upon (20 min)Ms. Ishizuka

Course objectives

Overview of the workshop
Prof Iso (10 min)Overview of global healthdiplomacy (lecture)Thailand’s history on and investments inglobal health• Dr. Suwit Wibulpolprasert & Dr. Attaya
Limwattanayingyong 15 min

9:3010:20

Using global health platforms and diplomacy
to drive national interests• Prof. Yasushi Katsuma (15 min)
Q&A: Dr. Suwit, Dr. Attaya,& Prof. Katsuma(20 min)Break20 min

10:4012:00

World HealthOrganization and its rolein global healthgovernance (lecture)

Structure, functions, and governing bodies
Navigating the Document systems• Prof. Hiroki Nakatani (60 min)<Session in Japanese>

Q&A: Prof. Katsuma and Prof. Nakatani (20min)

LUNCH

60 min

13:0014:15

Preparing for WHA anddrafting of interventions(lecture)

Forming national positions (Thai andJapanese cases)••

Dr. Warisa Panichkriangkrai (20 min)Dr. Yui Sekitani, (20 min)

Making interventions: dos and don’ts• Dr. Haruka Sakamoto (20 min)Break
14:4516:45

30 minMocked up intervention(role play exercise)

Q&A: Dr. Warisa, Dr. Sekitani, Dr. Sakamoto(15 min)Prepare for mock up session
Delivering interventions at WHA (participantsdeliver an intervention as if they are a
representative from Japan or non-state actor)

Prof. Iso (Introducethe speakers andfacilitate Q&A)
(with an Assistant tomonitor thecomments
submitted throughthe Zoom’s chatfunction: ChatmonitoringAssistant)
Dr. Akashi(Introduce thespeaker andfacilitate Q&A)
(Chat monitoringAssistant)

Dr. Umeda(Introduce thespeakers andfacilitate Q&A)
(Chat monitoringAssistant)

Prof. Nakatani(Chair the mockmeeting, facilitate
feedback byresource persons)11.16.2020•••••

Intervention to be delivered for 3 minutes
per participant (3 min x all or selectedparticipants)
Feedback by resource persons (30 min)
One theme (agenda item) to be selected
and shared with participants ahead oftime.
Participants will prepare statements
representing their own country or nonstate actors.
Mock Japanese national stance will beshared with participants

All resource persons
16:4517:00

Recap of the day<Session in Japanese>

Day 2
Time
8:50-9:00

Session Title
Recap of Day 1

9:0010:00

Introduction tonegotiations (lecture)(Chat monitoringAssistant)(with an Assistant tosort the order ofspeakers. Thespeakers will raise
hands using thefunction on Zoom)(with an Assistant tomonitor the time ofeach intervention)

Q&A: Prof. Iso and Prof. Nakatani (10 min)Dr. Sakamoto & Ms.
Ishizuka(facilitate Q&A)
(Chat monitoringAssistant)Selection of a participant to provide a recap
on Day 2. (5 min)Prof. IsoSession Content
One lucky participant to provide a summary ofwhat they learned in Day 1
Negotiation in global health: the principles• Mr. Charlie Garnjana-Goonchorn (50 min)Facilitator
Ms. Ishizuka

Q&A: Mr. Charlie (10 min)Ms. Ishizuka(Introduce thespeakers andfacilitate Q&A)
(Chat monitoring
Assistant)Break
10:3012:00

LUNCH
13:00-14:00

14:0015:00

30 minReal life negotiations:
Case studies of difficult
negotiations 1 (lecture)

Negotiations behind a resolution: Universal
Health Coverage• Dr. Satoshi Ezoe (80 min)<Session in Japanese>

Q&A: Dr. Ezoe (10 min)60 minReal life negotiations:
Case studies of difficult
negotiations 2 (videolecture)

Negotiations behind drafting of a resolution:
Access to medicines• Mr. Nilo Dytz Filho (60 min)

WHO Partnerships,
Networks and Alliances:

Dr. Umeda(Introduce thespeakers andfacilitate Q&A)
(Chat monitoringAssistant)

Prof. Natakani(Introduce thespeakers(Chat monitoringAssistant)

Navigating the politics and governance of amultilateral agency• Mr. Issa Matta (60 min)Prof. Natakani(Introduce thespeakers)

11.16.2020
Challenges andOpportunities(video lecture)Break
15:3016:30

30 minInteractive Q&A(Chat monitoringAssistant)
Q&A: Mr. Filho and Mr. Matta (60 min)Prof. Natakani(Introduce thespeakers andfacilitate Q&A)
(Chat monitoringAssistant)

16:3017:00

Wrap up<Session in Japanese>

Course summary and comments by Prof Isoand Prof NakataniFeedback on the course from participantsProf. Iso11.16.2020

Resource persons list
Dr. Suwit Wibulpolprasert（タイ）Vice Chair, International Health Policy Program Foundation (IHPF), Health Intervention and Technology
Assessment Foundation (HITAF), International Health Policy Program (IHPP Thailand), Ministry of Public
Health, Thailand
Dr. Attaya Limwattanayingyong
Ministry of Public Health, Thailand
Dr. Warisa Panichkriangkrai（タイ）International Health Policy Program (IHPP Thailand), Thailand
Mr. Charlie Garnjana-Goonchorn（タイ）Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Thailand
Mr. Nilo Dytz Filho (スイス）
Minister Counsellor, Permanent Mission of Brazil, GenevaMr. Issa Matta （スイス）
Attorney, WHO Office of the Legal Counsel
Dr. Satoshi Ezoe（⽇本）
Director, Global Health Policy Division
Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Japan
Dr. Yui Sekitani, （⽇本）
Deputy Director
International Affairs Division
Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare, Japan
Prof. Hiroyasu Iso 磯博康(⽇本)
Director, Institute for Global Health Policy Research (iGHP), National Center for Global Health andMedicine (NCGM)
国⽴国際医療研究センター(NCGM) 国際医療協⼒局グローバルヘルス政策研究センター(iGHP) センター⻑
Prof. Hiroki Nakatani 中⾕⽐呂樹（⽇本）
Director, Human Resource Strategy Center for Global Health (HRC-GH), NCGM
NCGM グロバルヘルス⼈材戦略センター(HRC-GH) センター⻑
Prof. Yaushi Katsuma 勝間靖（⽇本）Director, Department of Global Health Affairs & Governance, iGHP, NCGM
NCGM 国際医療協⼒局グローバルヘルス政策研究センター(iGHP) グローバルヘルス外交・ガバ
ナンス研究科研究科⻑
Dr. Tamami Umeda 梅⽥ 珠実（⽇本）
Director, Bureau of International Health Cooperation, NCGM
NCGM 国際医療協⼒局 局⻑
Dr. Hidechika Akashi 明⽯秀親（⽇本）Director, Department of Health Planning and Management, NCGM
NCGM 国際医療協⼒局 連携協⼒部 部⻑
Dr. Haruka Sakamoto 坂元晴⾹（⽇本）
Project Assistant Professor, Department of Health Policy and Management, School of Medicine, KeioUniversity
慶應義塾⼤学医学部医療政策・管理学教室 特任助教
Ms. Aya Ishizuka ⽯塚彩（⽇本）Specially Appointed Researcher, IGHP, NCGM
NCGM 国際医療協⼒局グローバルヘルス政策研究センター(iGHP) 特任研究員
Others:NCGM Secretariat: 2-3 persons a day to assist with the operation during the workshop.