人工知能学会
経営課題にAIを！ビジネスインフォマティクス研究会 (第7回)
JSAI Special Interest Group on Business Informatics (SIG-BI #7)

w¡r©~§xmŲƃEMoqoĺƓ|qY}q§Design of idea posting site using crowdsourcing
ǫřĤß 1 Îţƙ± 1
A.Komura1, S.Kurahashi111ƘůċčċčǝƐčƋƔƐ

Graduate School of Business Sciences, University of Tsukuba

Abstract: The rise of open innovation has changed the company’s management practice concerning productdevelopment and problem solving. As a result, companies have started seeking ways to incorporate external ideas intointernal innovations using crowdsourcing. However, idea generation itself yet depends largely on personal abilities.
Therefore, ideas are rarely substantially changed through collaboration or combination in common web-basedarchitectures. Idea generation support via information system is expected to provide a new approach toward idea
evolution. In this study, we propose an information system that dynamically recommends personalized information tofacilitate each user’s idea generation. And, we implement our methods on our idea posting site to evaluate its
effectiveness on the quality of posted ideas by using crowdsourcing.
<v©¦©Ǹw¡r©~§x0oqoãÛ0ıąńƭ> t©§q©~ §mńǐGiæ=YªQU
ES0¿ş<oqoĺƓ|qmǚƼE0ƎĉXoqomŪbiBUT0ÒjMoqomħSƱùèX`TƟ]Q@MÇ<7?Q;Ɗgjif8X
WPS=S7i1E;E0oqoãÛZÈŹUE
SÏ¶YǆǇXÈČGiǣ<ċ=?0oqoĺƓ|qƫÅ<oqoãÛm|©Gif8WĥâmŚMGBUZ_UnVW71oqoĺƓ|qƫÅXoqoãÛm|©Giıą~mĐưGiBU<T=j[0ÒjMoqomåſƇXħiBU<T=0\7SZq©~ §XQWAiBUcòƪXWiUīlji1 ǋě0¿şN@TW?Ï¶<w¡r©~§x
mƃ7iBUTĊŢW¶Ř;goqomħiBU
<òƪXWPS=S7i1w¡r©~§xZq§©«T­ŻďĊŋY¶2XĔES¹³m
ƆŰE0ē®mçiBU<T=i¹ƞamŀG1t
+*')(     &       $!#"%$"! $!#%$©§q©~ §mńǐGiæ=<ŲƆXWiW;T0w¡r©~§xYŲƃXcŰƈ<Ǡ`PS7i1KBTŗƋƔTZ0ƿÆEMoqoĺƓ|q
X0oqoãÛm|©GiUīljiŤƪm
ĐưGiBUUGi1DgXKYŤƪYoqoãÛXĔGiåŚm0w¡r©~§xmŲƃES
ŞƹE0oqoãÛXǆGiŕƃWŤƪXQ7S
ƍúmħiBUmƈƇUGi1 +'( */$ !<  ěXw¡r©~§xYŠĪm
ƆƯES;g0t©§q©~ §dØãYƵ
Ŷ;g0w¡r©~§xYßƃXQ7SŢ2W
ƋƔ<WDjS=M1w¡r©~§xmŲƃE
MoqoãÛZ0q§§pm®9gjM¦©u©Ï¶YǆǇXǧiǣ<ċ=;PM<0ǋěZĊŋY¦©u©YƊƳmƞaôlI0oqoãÛmËGıą~<Ūbgjif8XWPS=S
7i !1¼«Yf8WƩŔ;g0Bj`TX¦©
u©;gf7oqomħiMbY¹ł@XQ7

人工知能学会
経営課題にAIを！ビジネスインフォマティクス研究会 (第7回)
JSAI Special Interest Group on Business Informatics (SIG-BI #7)

S0ĐƽƇXƋƔEMÇ<7?Q;ƊgjS7i1 Ç9[ . g !Zw¡r©~§xmßƃESœƸY}q§YoqomçǠES7i1. gZǔÁo£{¢Yƥ9ŏmĩƃGiBUT0¦©u©XÒjMœƸY}q§YƞaôlImË
E0œƸY}q§YŽƫĭm÷«DIiBUXĶ
äES7i1`M0")% g !Z×ØµǎŤǜYßƃmËGMbYoqoYçǠmƮPS7i1")%gZǑìYÒjMoqomÇUESƍDjM¦©
u©Z0Ċ?YoqomÛDW?Wi<0oqoYŽƫĭZćGÑ÷<6i0UES7i1DgX
*/ g !Z0ûùY¤©mçǠE0ŊƨčYÜǙTßƃ<ǐnT7i£©¢wmƃ7Mp©wmƮ8BUT0¦©u©Yûù¤©
YǇm«AiBUXĶäES7i1
 ¼«Yf8X0w¡r©~§xmŲƃESf
7oqomħiMbYŏŮZ7?Q;ƊgjS7icYY0oqoĺƓ|qXBjgYŏŮ<ĐưDjS7iÇZėW71`M0ºXcoqoãÛmËGŏŮZĊ?ƊgjS:h0BjgXQ7S
coqoĺƓ|qXĐưGiBUTt©§q©~ §dØãmËGBU<T=iòƪĭ<6i1 !'(QYoqoĺƓ|qmƃ7iBUT0¬ƻY QY½ǂmŞƽGiBU<T=i1½ǂ  *(#&)"-&*) TĺƓDjioqoYƾÉZ0*)-+*' TĺƓDjioqoYƾÉfhcǭ
71oqoYƞaôlImËGBUT0ãÛDjioqoYƾÉ<ǭ`i½ǂ  .$,-&*) TĺƓDjioqoYƾÉZ0*)-+*' TĺƓDjioqoYƾÉfhcǭ71ƆĲYęmĜAiǇümGiBUT0ãÛDjioqoYƾÉ<ǭ`i$2
 ĐǟXw¡r©~§xmƃ7iBUToq
omǠbiBU<òƪT6iBUYƌǀU0Ǡ`PMoqoYÜǪUoqoYƾÉŏŮmŞƹGi
ƈƇT0²ÐĐǬm¼¬Yf8XƮPM1 oqoĺƓmƮ8¦©u©Z0w¡r©~§x|q3w¡r¦©w4TçǠEM1oqoĺƓYçǠZ¬ƻYf8WŌǣTƮPM1.

 oqoZ3ŐƊYƲƝYŎMWƞaôlI4 !
UƷljS7i1ŐČYoqoY8O0ƾÉYǭ
7cYm¦©u©X7?Q;ŅƍGiBUT0oq
oYǇ<ǭ`iBU<²ĲDji1 `M0oqoãÛmËGŏŮUESZ0d  Ɨ06iƒYsw¢mƃ7S
ü7mƕSiBUToqomƥ9iƴŶmĜAi
ŏŮ<ƊgjS7i1ü7mƕSiBUZĸÝƇī
ƥYśŗƇƲƝUDj !0ü7m®9iBUT¦©
u©Yīƥ<ų`h0fhf7oqo<Ƃ`ji
BU<ǭ`iBU<²ĲDji1
 ¼«Yf8X0¦©u©XoqoYƞaôlImËEMh0ŎMWƴŶ;gYƆĲmËGǇüm®
9iBUT0oqoYǇ<ǭ`iBU<²ĲDjiMb0ŗƋƔTZƯ  XƍG QYoqoĺƓ|qmƕO«AiBUUEM1Ư ƃĳEMoqoĺƓ|q  oqoYçǠX6MPSZ0ĄŗƇXƯ  î]Ā  XƍGoqoĺƓ|q *)-+*' mßƃEM1çǠYƟŚ0 ¾ 5  ÙT  öY¦©u©Yĩç<ħgjM1õª¶ź< ĝĩçEMÇmǞ7S0Ƹ  ¾YüǨŶUoqoY<ħgjM1Ā oqoĺƓ|q*)-+*' ÖSYĺƓXƈmǎGU0oqoYǇZǭ7c

人工知能学会
経営課題にAIを！ビジネスインフォマティクス研究会 (第7回)
JSAI Special Interest Group on Business Informatics (SIG-BI #7)

Y0Ä7cYUŢ2T6if8XīljM1Ç9[Ā YoqoZªďYŽƫĭUŕåĭ<ĴFgjicYY0Ā YoqoZêWiǩŖXG>W7Uīlji1`M0ƧĆYüǨŶcŢ2T6iBU;g0¶XfPSoqomÛGMbXĨƲWıąZ0KY¶Yƣ;jMżŭüǨŶXfPSĈlP
S?iBU<ƍúDjM1
 W:0ÔƮƋƔTZoqoYƾÉXQ7S¦©
u©  ö¼«YƾÉYĚĂmðiBUT0fhÍǧ
ĭ6iƾÉ<ħgjiUES7i !1E;EĐǟX
ÔƮƋƔYƾÉŮmƿEMUBk0ªǖY¦©u©
YƾÉYǇ<Ä?0įĳƇUīljiƾÉ<Ʈljiy©<Ċ?agjMMb0ŗƋƔTZŃƃEW
;PM10%Ā oqoĺƓYÇf7Ç



1$

üǨŶ¨oqoYÜǪZ0oqoĺƓmGi¦©u©Yª¶ª¶YƧĆYüǨŶU0ƥ9S7ioqoYu{¢©moqoĺƓáXǓĻDI
iƈƇTÆĶEM1KYf8XGiƁƄZ0oq
oYƞaôlImËGǟX0ǜǏYW7ƅÜǙYoqoYƞaôlImËGfhc0ÂMüǨŶmļ
9i¦©u©YoqomŅƍEMŏ<0oqoYƞaôlI<ĒőXWDjiBU<ƥ9gjiM
bT6i1`M0ǇümGiX6MPSc0¦©u©Yļ9iüǨŶd0ƥ9S7ioqoYŏ÷ĭm6g;FbƊPS:;W7U0ƇĉjWǇümESE`8Įj<6i1ÜǪYÆĶZ0²ÐĐǬTħgjM 203 ¾XQ7
SÔǌY3¥w¡r¦©u©4XÈǧEM1`H0ƧĆYüǨŶXQ7SħgjMÜǪZƯ 4
YǎhT6i1ÜǪYÆĶZ0oqoĺƓmGi¦©u©YƧĆYüǨŶYu{¢©m³áXĹņ
GiMbXÆĶES7iMb0ƛơDXť@iòƪĭ<6h0¸Ħŉý<ĨƲUWi;cEjW71
Ư 4. ƧĆYüǨŶYÜǪĀ oqoĺƓYÇİ7Ç - $
 ÔƮƋƔYƾÉŏŮ  !míƥX0ƯqoƾÉĄŴƯmÆĶEM1Ư oqoƾÉĄŴƯXƍGo
 ¼¬0oqoYƾÉZw¡r¦©w;g3¥w¡r¦©u©4Yǀďmñ@S:h0éÜWĐƢY6i¦©u© öXÈǧGiBUUEM1ƾ
ÉXĢMPSZ0³áXoqoƾÉĄŴƯXŬP
MƾÉXQ7SéÜWƺƠmƮPM1 DgX0oqoYÜǪUESƯ 5 YÜǪ<ħgjM1¶ǛǜÊYǃǨmĿQ¦©u©Z0ÇĉZ
6icYY03£©£ÆhdƤĵè403zy©~ §YËǐ403¶ŘYŊƨ¨ƺƠ403¶
ŘYǗƣ4Y7Hj;XǜGioqomĿO0à

人工知能学会
経営課題にAIを！ビジネスインフォマティクス研究会 (第7回)
JSAI Special Interest Group on Business Informatics (SIG-BI #7)

ĝ¨ŌèƜYǃǨmĿQ¦©u©cÇĉZ6i<03àĝYĕÕ403àĝYĞŧ403©£YĕÕ¨åſè403¶ŘYƨĶ¨Ųƃ4Y7Hj;XǜGioqomĿQBU<²ÐĐǬTƌǀT=M1
Ư 5. oqoYÜǪ .

#,2$)" oqoYçǠZ²ÐĐǬUõŢXw¡r¦©w«TƮ70oqoYçǠmƮ8ǟYŌǣc
õŢYcYUEM1ąǘZ¦©u©1 ¶6Mh 20
ÙUEM1 oqoĺƓ|q Control, Combination,Question YKjLjX0ĩçES=M 150 öY¦©
u©mŸÆŷX 50 öHQâhĢS0oqoYĺƓmÈǧEM1KjLjY|qX:@i¦©u©
YÆşķǦZĀ 4 YǎhT6i1

Ā 4. óoqoĺƓ|qX:@iÆşķǦ Combination TZ0¦©u©ZƯ 4 YĖÜǪXƍG 9 ǥƈYW;;gªQmǓĻGif8ŀƍmñ@i1ǓĻmGiBUT0²ÐĐǬTǠbgjMƧĆYüǨŶUoqoYYW;;g0ǓĻmEMÜǪXĘE0;QÒjS7iUÝōDjM«Ã 3Q<03ĨƲXĩFSCƫǈYoqoXðhÕjS?ND74U78ŌUUcXƯƍDji¹ƞaX
WPS7i1
 Question TZ0¦©u©ZƯ 4 YĖÜǪXƍGƧ
ĆYüǨŶY 9 ǥƈYW;;gªQmǓĻE0Dg
XƯ 5 YoqoYĖÜǪYW;;gªQmǓĻG
if8XŪbgji1ĖÜǪXZKjLjªQHQ³áXƼďEMǇü<\cR@gjS:h02 þYǓĻmGiBUT0¦©u©XZĔĩGi 2 QYǇ
ü<ŅƍDj0ǇüXĔĩEMƻǊmGif8XŪbgji¹ƞaXWPS7i1ŅƍDjiǇüZĄ
ŗƇW 5W1H Y¤©¦©wXĄR=0¼¬Yf8XƼďEM1
 `H0ƧĆYüǨŶX\cR?ǇüUESZÖS
why ăYǇümƼďEM1Ç9[0ƧĆYüǨŶUES0­ĚƗĴ¨­ÍĴmǓnN¦©u©XZ3WJ­ĚƗĴ¨­ÍĴ<üǨXWif8WƧĆXWPSE`PS7iYTEe8;ǹ4U78ǇümƯƍ
DIM1ºYüǨŶmǓĻEM¦©u©XĔGiǇ
üc°ǁYǒ7<6iƑĝTõŢYǇümŅƍE0ƧĆYüǨŶmų?ƥ9Scg8f8X¹÷@M1 oqoX\cR?ǇüUESZ0ÖS how ăYǇümƼďEM1Ç9[0oqoYÜǪUE
S0£©£ÆhdƤĵèmǓnN¦©u©XZ03£©£dƤĵmƧĆXďƉDIiXZV8Gj[f7TEe8;ǹ4U78ǇümƯƍDIM1ƧĆ
YüǨŶU\cR?ǇüUǒPS0ÖSõŢYǇüUGiU0­ƫŹWŌXWPSE`8Mb0Ư 6 XƍGǇüŌmÆĶEM1
Ư 6. oqoX\cR?Ǉü人工知能学会
経営課題にAIを！ビジネスインフォマティクス研究会 (第7回)
JSAI Special Interest Group on Business Informatics (SIG-BI #7)

 ħgjM 150 ¶ÜYƧĆYüǨŶUoqoY
Z0¡§ X~£EM89TÔǌEM
¥w¡r¦©u©XǍ»E0oqoYƾÉmÈǧEM1E[E[Ƴgj0ƧĆYüǨŶdoqoYƻǊY
ÓĐXQW<PMcYUƥ9gji1fhoqoYǇmǭbS7?MbX0åŚYǭ7ǇümVYf8XǓĻGi;<0¸ĦYǃǨUESƥ9gji1 )" ħgjMoqoXZ0ŽƫĭYƾÉ< ¼/ ŗƋƔYoqoƾÉŏŮZ0¦©u©1 ¶YƾÉXÈČES:h0BY¦©u©Y°ƵĭmŁǞG
icYTZW71ŗƋƔYđƵĭmǭbiMbX0
ÔƮƋƔ[8]míƥX 20 öƑĝY¦©u©YƾÉmïŒDIMƾÉŮmƌƕDIiĨƲ<6i1ǇYǭ
7¹³mGi¦©u©mǓĻGiŏŮd0¦©u©
YįĳƇWƾÉmǕ@iŏŮ<7?Q;ƊgjS:h0¸ĦYƾÉŮYƌƕX÷@SYíƥXEM71
 ǇüŌYÆĶZ05W1H Y¤©¦©wmƃ7M~§£WķŮUZ790ŗǄŌYķŮTZoq
oãÛY©XôlIS0Ǉüm³áXÆĶG
iĨƲ<6i1BjTZǇüŌÆĶƦYÆşǅĽ<ċ=?0¸ĦYľġĭZÄ71¸ĦZ¦©u©YżŭXĩFM0oqoYƆĲmËGMbXŕåWǇ
üŌYƂĶmGi~YšƚmƈŀEM71¦©u©CUXÏÞXVYf8WǇü<ŕåWY;0w¡r©~§xmƃ7SĺƏģğT©mǠ
bS7?BU<ƥ9gji1ǇüƂĶ~ǜǏYƋƔXZ©¡£[9]WV0ŤŝčƤY
ķŮYĕÕ<ǐbgjS7i1ŗƋƔYoqoĺƓ|q^YĐưòƪĭXQ7Sc¸ĦŞƹmƮ8BUUEM71«0ŕåĭYƾÉ< YcYZagjW;PMƯ1ëÿUES0¦©u©X®9iq§§p<Ä7Ŷ0ƧĆYüǨŶUƶūYMbYoqoU78©<ŽƫĭdŕåĭmƆŇGiXZ6`hXcªƬƇW©T6PMBUWV<ƥ9gji1Ư óoqoĺƓ|qYžħEMƾÉYŋ ŗƋƔTZ0½ǂ  ZňĿDjW;PM<0½ǂ
ZňĿDjiƟŚUWPMƯ 1Ư ĐǬƟŚ

*&
[ǯ]

Howe, J, The rise of crowdsourcing. Wired Magazine, 14.
Availableat:

http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/14.06/crowds_pr.html (accessed 20 August 2017).

  . gYÔƮƋƔ !XfiU0œƸY}q§TZ0ÒjMoqoYƞaôlIXfPSoqoYǇ<ǭ`iU78ƟŚ<ÛS7i<0ŗƋƔTZ0vmŅƍESƞaôlImËES7iŶTƅWi1ºƦY}q§YÒjMƲƝmƫgY}q§XðhÕjiBUZũǉƇĒőUīlji<0vY¯YÒjMƲƝmðhÕjiBUZ0ǡE7Uīlj0ĐǟXoqoYƞaôlImƮPMUīljiy©Z_UnVagjW;PM1 ªŏ0ǇüXĔĩEMƻǊmGiBUZũǉƇĒ
őT6iUƥ9gj0ĐǟXǇüXĔĩEMƻǊ<[ǰ]A. Majchrzak and A. Malhotra, Towards an information
systems

perspectiveandresearch

agendaoncrowdsourcing for innovation, J. Strateg. Inf. Syst., vol.
22, no. 4, 257–268, (2013).
[Ǳ]

L. Yu and J. V Nickerson, Cooks or Cobblers? Crowd
Creativity through Combination, Proc. 29th Annu. ACM
SIGCHI Conf. Hum. Factors Comput. Syst., 1393–1402,(2011).

[ǲ]

K.

Wang,J.

VNickerson,andY.

Sakamoto,

Crowdsourced Idea Generation : The Effect of Exposure
to an Original Idea, Howe Sch. Technol. Manag. - Res.
Pap. Ser., vol. 16, no. 1, 1–9, (2013).
[ǳ]

S. Dow, A. Kulkarni, K. Scott, and H. Bjorn, Shepherding
the crowd yields better work, Proc. CSCW ’12, 1013–人工知能学会
経営課題にAIを！ビジネスインフォマティクス研究会 (第7回)
JSAI Special Interest Group on Business Informatics (SIG-BI #7)

1022, (2012).
[Ǵ]s© W. §x0oqoYQ?h;M0
CCC por(1988)[ǵ]

P. Gray, Engaging students intellects : The immersion
approach to critical thinking in psychology instruction,
Teaching of Psychology, 20, 68-74, (1993).

[Ƕ]

C. Riedl, I. Blohm, J. M. Leimeister, and H. Krcmar, The
Effect of Rating Scales on Decision Quality and User
Attitudes in Online Innovation Communities, Int. J.
Electron. Commer., vol. 17, no. 3, 7–36, (2013).

[Ƿ]ƀĬǢ0ǮŜ0ā´ÌĠ0ǤŵŘ0ĎűøŨ·0©¡£XĄR? ǇüŌƂĶ£Yw¥q§ƾÉ0ƷǁÚƁčÀ Ɩ 23 þěŦċÀ ƆƯǄŌǠ00 