 0R¨3Q QRSTUV © &%¨ª « ¬ ­+ῌ ῏῍ῐ῎   
2 !"#$%&'() *+,- .+/ 0123456 0* 7 "(#,8%
<= >? @9:#;,/

AB5CD*EFGHIJ K *LMI NO +33* P QRSTUV TW4X YZ[\R 3Q(]^_`a 0)bI<c5* &%d e fgEFGhijIJ *^8 -&- k_)l )mno

01234(+,5ijp% Iqr TW4X*s8 - 0tbI5*uvmn<cijIJ*^8`0a)*ABRECOFTC g#wxI( ;  p ` FAO Oyb )mno 5ij zdecentralization/)&%uvmnh 5ij zdevolution/ *{s|}(~- J 0tῌ) ;*?. I#; > ? 0R ;*I<B a- * (; ,**. P +* p(  / Po RECOFTC *s01234 5ijbI*-` p` xO1R34

zCIFOR/ (bq6m(¡(  +,#0R ?¢£*¤4¥ -¦ p§0Hideyuki Kubo : Decentralization for Good Forest Governance¨Case Analysis
from Thailand and Indonesia¨O1R34 zCIFOR/ QR34R ®V¯V°± ²³´µ¶¤Z4Y·¸¹[4º1R34 zRECOFTC/» ¼   No. 0, ῍,**/῎29       !"#$ %&'()*+, -.
,ῌ ῒΐ῍ῐ῏ῑ῎ / )0 123456 78 9 :;  <=>?. @ARECOFTC

B' 3*CDEF>GHI J KL/M NO IPQR. STU @V

@/WX YZ M>I[R\ ]^_`a.
@Vb/ )cdef@gh&ijVk?
lm$&n. @V&opU/ `>q r`>q@s 't/r @V &uv=>125wxMyz )cdef VpU{|/} ~0yzI`?.
T @/@gh `z}&?k pU  k?. (>/ IW y}&na?  W IF>?  @gh&? `z @VpU/BfBTyty?. [z <ypUI@ghF?M&y*?

`?. q `?@ Vp
UIwx`a' 12/wx B
B#Kt¡¢£ ¤!/¥?rV¦§ ¨© ªpU/@<«jy¬­ ®¯y?"°&o­ +30@ ­ T ±wx&@VpUk?c¶³·$ : Hobley and Shilds, p -,, ,***-³ &¥¸%¹º»±­ + ¥²³. ( #@/ M> @ghk?<ypUI´µ& ¼  2 No. 0, ῌ,**/῍     !"# $% &' (- ῌ )*+,-.+,

/0/12 3456 789 :;<=>?% ( @:6)*+,$%K$ +33*

ABCDE +,FG@  HIJ

LMNO;=D <P$QRE

ῌS4?R ( 2)*+,6TUVWX?Y$YZR +,[\]6^_`[BCD$%

abG O;=D)*+,

65cd!efg6hGi j( Kk@:6l mUVnBC
D-.+,?2K45opkK$ 2 P>q r
B=s/ ;tu<> Cvwx$6  $45?y!4zR
( +33*LMN{  P>qOs/ |}~>$ QRE   ῌS4? Gi (@ ABCD)*+,6]$%!45p   ii i? -.+,6iS : G
E.45pkik!:(῍ E  +,E  6 <="4zRi z9$6 i( +33*LMNE  QO;=D <P P>qOs/ |}~>$K 
<=E  6245# E  ik5$SQRi ( G E  56 $ qῌw>ue $

¡%&$¢'£R ¤£.j <=%&UiKE.+,ik5, ¥'?¦( 8 ( z§ )iw>ueQ @:5/¨©=ªG 45E « ¬9 *(?­$% (M® E  ?ef¯4<P a)*+,° j UVP>qOs/ a-.+,° j U9 ±+²!"# E  ³¯?
w>u,' ´µ:i¶· (. :  M<P$6 +33.

 ¸<>¹>-WUV<>¹>+,º ? QR. »  ¼ No. 0, ῍,**/῎31
  !"!



# $%&'(  )&+,-./0123)3!"!

*$45 $) RECOFTC 789:;<ῌ=*<* C > M

/6!"!

?25) @ ABC!DEF GHI5J ῌM

$ 1 K&L M

MN$OPQR45/ST)OPU!BV$W&RXYZY[ +.
$) ]+] $)],) ?^\W& ,6   Q

ER_`a] .

+LX)

bR YZYcT53 de$ .,-** d) W&def$ERg /**h+,+** d \+**h-** i6   1 K&j / K&$klmnop ]P3bMN012) W& klmnop qr( s?klmnop qtuv453  T) j - K&$wPxyL) z{?|}~T53 O]ER_QD  $) klmnop   g25) O]$klmnop ]P] 3 X) M

EF OPῌQr$) 3Jb25@ v453  ῍ klmnop qEF!"!

 Gῌ &!'"#$) +33* $%&RXklmnop qr( MNX5EX) +33- $$ klmnop ]P'<V;S2 2L2) <V;S) klmnop¦§¨+* $¡¢£¤2¥1E35&!'($©ª«2F$) ¬R )*|( ­".+253 $®3,33<V;$klmnop tuq¯° - K&klmnop ]PR45±5²) ³ . K&$& -2­.$) r$<V;3 /MN0´µ¶.·§¸´53 <V;r$)!"!

3¹.r@ qº( R45klmnop q»1X) 2323 ¼ No. 0, ῍,**/῎ ῌ ῌ  !" #$%&() *+,-./0 !" 1234578"0'  +33. 569: ;<=>56578 ?@<A  3?@ ,**+  B%& =CD E%&) 56578!F GHI +,-./0 9ῌ#ῌ<(J&1' K) 78!LM  ;<=NOPU>%&Q ) +,-./0  RST!

" # VWX) "YZ ![!\" ] R#^_` $(3 QJ) a%bV56578!+,-./0<=>cNd&; 'ef<() +,-./0 V RST$(+,-./0 !g(%& h!) i)*j)43 ]k3 +,3lm-V) +,-./0 ?nop5qr
YZ ![.s</0tuv]k 34 k YZ ![wxy; 56578z{|1& }JkV) M 9 ;<G\"=c ~ ]kVWQ ) +,-./0?no) &VYZ ![wxy;M 9 ;<o43Q4 &+,-./0 ?no!73\"2VWX) "y-V ` $3%&!45

3Q4}h  'e ) \"6! 56578!M k_y;

7J&) ) \"2!YZ ![.s8<*V03PNOVWkῌ 789xH*]k ) M 78o]: GM 9 ;
NO \" ]4 i%&) <J ]4 %&QJ)

78= G\"= > q5 ¡a%¢£%3X? & M 78 >J¤M
NO¦AtVWk

G56578!¥@Q ) M 78]k M 9!78)  §X2&¨r ©ª«3 ¬­& RECOFTC ῌ®¯°±²V) ,**- ]XM  ;³NO
56578#"QJ / ´µ¶) AB*®¯·¸¹º¡»C D¼ No. 0, ῍,**/῎33    ! " # $ % &'(  )*+,-.!/ 012 3!45
 678 9:;< =>?@AῌB !C'2B D ?+<EF !  G;JK LM ! N 

<HI
0 "<OP# $" QRST UV  %W1  1X/ ῌ YZ[\ &']ῌ^$ ]_`a2b(c,**. ) 3 d YZ[\ef+333 )!K*gh&']i+,!-jk,.<l/ =,**. ),. -, mB k&',!  &'n0 o1 23p!?3qgh =4 ,. rB s56 e - ti^ῌu<v6F]_<wx =4 -2 rB 7%y*h>'
Dh*1 &']z{8(q/(c<E?+F|}~+333 )&',1  T-9]K:;!Lbh es^ =uB +ti  i<*gh^ῌus=i!' >;e?+@*</^ῌuTA!?Ibh "

41 3+ LM<BP ^!>Isq ti C ^!?
D"

E]

/KFG ^!FeHb¡ ; z{Uzgh ^ z{¢*]0£<¤FD' U¥ !ebIGz{<Uz1/?+! 1X &']!iFJ K¦L§¨M?+! ©ª.4NT.N;" ¡£O« J¬P&­ ^ "wQRS+0® {TU<¯VFD ^ " E]<JE°FD<BPW±X²7³b&'Y Z<[´ ^ \® 0£¤<T¨ 1X3B * ^ 67³!?W±X²67<v F]^<w   µ¶1 X²;·,X²¸jhD _`!# ^ 9!  0£¤  ·,!X²ghW±!2Y< ¹ºDhb W±<», !u¼
34a b

7 No. 0, ῍,**/῎ +* 

 !"#$%&' % ()*+ῌ, -./

0

ῌ123450 , 6.

7 8 9:;<12 =-> ?@AB  C'D , 6'51EFGH'IFJK>?

L  M6 N.-> O.

P A QRSTU:6V12W.-B  C. RXY5Z[2W\-]: 8^_`##:92EF0 aNQb:
cIF .-=>,d= -gS'hi e210RXfS

. jk -fST l!

m>\. 12 nRYo5"p'q#rsf$t6e:uZ.->

e6\%f 12B 5++

v.- .@. 12,RX&'p .

-jk0 O5():91EF*Tw+. x](yGHze345{6e-|,ze-.

ῌ}~@. -):@6 7. .- !"#$&ze=/: .@. SM ,0.-Qb,1cze2%3:+,  - 4 !

"#$' P  Q+):556e-b7ῌ =yR. W,89I:'0> 
=,; :M-,<PA=fῌ>=f? A,A Q
.-@'^ ¡¢0% aA QAWBC£¤ ¥U .-I:.3 ¦@e6D,89Eze@F@p§Ip¨© ª«G*¬H0% / +­QIQ+®¯J°  - K±²³:9LM´N .-OP0 .@. ):]  e/0b,m>µ .-> QR
².3D,S6ze@6 ¶#·¸¹º» :T¼6

=?

U V  S No. 0, ῍,**/῎35

ῌ ῌ ῌῌ      !

"#$ %&' ()*+,-./012#3#45 6789:;<=>?"3-$ @A;BC%1*D-&'EF- %G #HIJK*G&,LMN

O2 ῌ ῌ

#P!

QRST3UCV2W/12!&$ῌ ῌ "#XYT$*ZM% 3[&O5#4M! \]*D2'^(_*)' XY*+ῌ*`,
3UT,-5a*b-O(.O2#"#PF-$ %

% 3cdF/eO0-$ BfcdF +33* 12CB3Z4g53
hijk1lj5Fm+O2n IPFῌIFFῌUNFF

FG% 3*o*ZMTpq6&4*ZV2#-$ L 7cdnD-"#HI
JKr8W/TO2 s;%"QRSTῌ
ῌ

*tbFuvwx

2C#xP$ kO2yz{*|}O2#-~Vyz{ῌ{#P"#n#2 "#(T,-a;CA93*`,#P#"#HIJK| 012#-:G3"3#$ OO %CP3; O2-:{*<2 = 3MM- >

O2*ZMV2#3#$ῌcdFW/

cdnD-"# W/O2 ?q@V2#xDFGBῌA Kῌ

 K

Nῌ nC¡B  ῌ{{ 3U:-$ B ¢M#2C£ /0 ¤FDEFG¥¦§H¨012#-
F©ª01&#$ %1ῌ ῌ «B

QRST¬N­C-45 3"G®¯F5ab--O2#-$ OO 5a°|}#PI±3- «BQRSTJKT3OF)'12#-NyNF-:*?q²x@3#$ RECOFTC TO2#-A¢FG ³´ῌµL ¶PC & I· *+#2M²O#"#(T,-5ab-01&$ OO ¸N¯F¹º¬»#nD-O¼Pm*Z4Q(P%g5F-5aO2G
36

R S # 6 No. 0, ῍,**/῎|
ῌ
+33* 0!"#$%ῌ&'()*$+(ῌ,-.&1234 CIFOR 5678 9:;/<&'()*$+(=>0 ?@A343  B",-(%
CD4+-E F

#$%ῌ&'()*$+(ῌ,-.&DGHF5  I5JK ;
5CDDLM0 5 :NO PQRSTU R4 VWXYZ[\[ !]^"5 :O P
Q_` ab4>S #cQC de F5?@$fS%&D=5'g(h3R ij ?@klSAI51)m,-.&n*o&)
+S5C
#$%ῌ&'()*$+(ῌ,-.&

:59DpRqra5?@,st51j uv - cuwxyzN`5C{S |]};~$  D=5 :[>0.
 43 z5D/ 01 253455 q F65D >67?@ c B
 ,-.&3S835C0ῌ ῍ῐ῏῎9 1` !%7L:&m

N4 ;<N_ Fm=:&5C0%W!% >0C0 OF5$ >Q_SC 5>S ?};5L ¡¢^"5L @£ ^" ¤¥¦SABR W CD`E§¨};:FS©5 R '35=ª« F%  !"5>S |]};:5D
0 "=.)(5¬-¬G{ 9&'()*$+(=5­?@A®¯°±²ZQ_³ t´ µ§5{H IJ%&¶GQ
·5 u¸5W!]K¹º»LRm ¼7 =
M N : ´ No. 0, ῍,**/῎37 !

"#$%&' ()"%*#+,-./

& ' 01234/56789: ;<=>?/@AB /Cῌ῏῎῍D +E Manor, J. (+333) The Political Economy of democratic Decentralization. Washington DC. : The World Bank. ,E Agrawal, A. (,**+) The Regulatory
Community : Decentralization and the Environment in the Van Panchayats of
Kumaon, India. Mountain Research and Development. ,+ (-), ,*2ῌ,++. -E Hobley,
M. and Shields, D. (,***) The Reality of Trying to Transform Structures andProcesses : Forestry in Rural Livelihoods. Working Paper +-,. London : Overseas
Development Institute. .E FGHIJ K,**-E LMNOP#$%QR PSPTUVWXR /E YGZ[ K,**-E \]^_^`^ Ka_bcdEe &fR aLgg
hijVWklmnR gopqrstR 0E uv w K,**,E xyz{|}~R kR 1E Makarabhirom, P. (,**.) Decentralization and Devolution inForest Management in Thailand : A Case Study. A paper prepared for RECOFTC/
FAO workshop on decentralization and devolution. 2E u K,**,Ers)/R R 3E Resosudarmo, I.A.P.
(,**.) Closer to People and Trees : Will Decentralization Work for the People andthe Forests of Indonesia? European Journal of Development Research +0 (+). ++*ῌ+-,.
+*E Casson, A. and Obidzinski, K. (,**,) From New Order to Regional Autonomy :Shifting Dynamics of “Illegal” Logging in Kalimantan, Indonesia. World Development -* (+,). ,+--ῌ,+/+. ++E McCarthy, J. (,**.) Changing to Gray : Decentralization and the Emergence of Volatile Socio-Legal Conﬁgurations in Central
Kalimantan, Indonesia. World Development -, (1). ++33ῌ+,,-. +,E Ministry ofForestry. (,**.) Decentralization of the Forestry Sector : Indonesia’s Experience.
Paper prepared for Interlaken Workshop on Decentralization in Forestry. +-E
Edmunds, D. and Wollenberg, E. (,**+) A Strategic Approach to Multistakeholder
Negotiations. Development and Change -,. ,-+ῌ,/-.

38 s No. 0, ῌ,**/῍