1

Federal Register02/05/2014 !"# http://federalregister.gov/a/2014-02188$%&
FDsys.gov'#()*+),-./01
2
'#
4160-01-P

34567
89:;9<
21 CFR Part 1[Docket No. FDA-2013-N-0013]
RIN 0910-AG98

89=>?
89=>?@A=>?@ABCDE@ABCDEFG
BCDEFGHIJHHS89:;9<KLJMNOKLJ
FDASTU@AVWX89BFGYZ[\]^G_U`ab=>PQJ89:;9<R
PQJ?cdbeY>]fGghUij?Ykl_mUCDEFGMnVopqFG\]89
BrsV3t\]uvBPw[xVyv]z{V|O}qp]~zBKLTU89
sYu]89rs BV{}uFDAB>Mil89FGC
DBU200589FGCDR2005 SFTAS=>?2011FDA89
rsRFSMASBB]~JEYUuT
Y>UMNOY¡\]¢£¤V20145¥31¦Y
J
|§\]~
¨©J
¨©J¢£¤B|§TUª«¬¤­®No. FDA-2013-N-0013=>?¯uTM°±²­®RRINS0910-AG98B³´VkµU¶·Bp¸¹ºB»¼½z{m¾]mU
1995¿[ÀÁÂYÃÄÅ±²ÆÇ YÈ\]¢£¤YU¼ÉÊËÌ<
ROMBS±²ÍM° <Î|§}iµ¹ÏijipRÐÑBÒ1995¿gÀÁÂÓÔÕÖ×VØÙBz{S~|§     2¶·B»EY¢£¤V|§\]~• Federal eRulemaking Portal: http://www.regulations.gov¢£¤|§BuvB YZ½~
 Y>]|§¶·B»|OV|§\]~• FAXJ301-827-6870• 4G¯}¯R¿|§BSJDivision of Dockets Management (HFA-305),
Food and Drug Administration, 5630 Fishers Lane, rm. 1061, Rockville, MD 20852.

 Jkµlj¹]|§>T\qUHIUª«¬¤­®No. FDA-2013-N-0013U=>?zBMN Y pqBRIN 0910-AG98m ¹qpiµ¹Ïijip~kµlu¢£¤T\qU| ¹u_±²VWvUi}YU
http://www.regulations.govÎGj¹]~¢£¤|§YÈ\]±²Y pqTUÐÑ
B±²ÔÕÖ×B0§}Ò¢£¤ÓVØÙBz{~ª«¬¤JÑuTj¹u¢£¤VXuvYª«¬¤YÕÔ\]
YTUhttp://www.regulations.gov aV ¾UÐÑB0§}B!"#¬¢$Bª«¬¤­®VÒ%&Ó'¬ÕY()}U*+*¤YZ½U=>?¯uT¶·Y p
]JDivision of Dockets Management, 5630 Fishers Lane, rm. 1061, Rockville, MD 20852~
±²,-©JzBMNOYÈ}qJ Michael E. Kashtock, Center for Food Safety and Applied Nutrition,
Food and Drug Administration, 5100 Paint Branch Pkwy., College Park, MD 20740,
240-402-2022.

±²ÆÇYÈ}qJDomini Bean, Office of Operations, Food and Drug Administration, 1350
Picard Dr., PI50-400T, Rockville, MD 20850, domini.bean@fda.hhs.gov.

    



3

±²J

P0
MNOBE
89rsTU^G_U`abuTcdbeY>]fGghUkl_=>?8
9BFGYZ[\]B B_mUCDEFGMnVop]z{Y>U89V }]FG}ipz{VY\]Pw[xVyvuMNB$VFDAY*
Àµqp]~89=>?@AB8CDEiFG¼{z½}u89mFG Y ¹]z{Y>q z]¤Õ=>?B´B[ºjUY
89mFG Y ¹]Y pqmD#q¾qp]~MNOBETUF
G¼m89rs3ÕVD#ip>½Y\]z{]~B>½i3ÕVD#]¼YTU89V !i"%&'}ipz{U(^{(^BbeBÕ3)+m,-iz{UFG Y89V-Y3.}ipz{Ui/m]~MNOT1¼B
rs89FGMnYÃÄ¾UFG Y B3Õm245p89BFGYZ[\]hm !iCDEFGMnY6¸Z½z{V79}qp]~B BTUfGg:mU=>?B Brs;<ªV\]uvY6Pi=>?¢¤+=B·89mFG¹]z{V{\]uvYyvube=>?FG>LBÕ3)
+U%?U3@U^B(AB}U=>?fCYÈ\]2D¼VE¾F¾Go\]z{VHv]~MNOTUIJKL50Mª=NOB89FG[gYZ[\]^G_Ukl_uTfGghV¡P{}ip~uUMNOBPw[xTUQsR>¹
uS"T3U89UD¾u8oa>=>?VmFG\]DBVW>RRACSBFGYT o¹ip~jYUMNB o¡P{i]hTUB oXYm_{a>B4ZY{q[\iB·89mFG¹]]^V4ujipz{U=>?_`Ya}ipz{Vtb¾]UPw[xB oXYVPc\]z{m¾]~
MNOBdiMyBPQ    



4

YPw¹]>½YUMNOT89R89=>?@ASBCDEiFGV¡P{}qUCDE89FGMNY }qpipB·89FGYZ[}qp]^G_U`ab4}ÅTcdbeY>]fGghUuTkl_Y>qFG¹uUu
TFG\]uvY|¹uz{ºjU89m }qp]º/½º \]Yo\]Ã#=>?y*Vyv]~
MNOTUFGV`ab4}ÅTcdbeY>]gY=µ]89Ba{y*\]~uUMNOTU89FGgÀYZ[\]^G_U`abuTcdbeY>]f
GghU=>?kl_Y o¹]CDEFGMnY¡\]Pw[x4yv]~
EY½{UMNOT¶·Y¡\]Pw[xVyv]~• be=>?FG>L• FGgÀ• ¤)+• 0• oXY
MNOTUfGg:mU =>?B Brs;<ªV\]uvY6Pi
=>?¢¤+=B·89mFG¹]z{V{\]uvYyvube=>?FG>LBÕ3)+U%?U3@U^B(AB}U=>?fCYÈ\]2D¼VE¾F¾Go\]z{VHv]~
MNOTUFG Y B3Õm245p89BFGYZ[\]hm !iCDE
FGMnY6¸Z½z{VE{\]~3{}qUMNOTUQsY¹q
pipU3 ÏU'Bpu Y(uD 89i/B89VbeY( XYUb
emº/½ºU^G_m%?\]z{V*Àµ]~MNOTU3 Ï8U8
U*W9UDB4}UuT"}qpip¾i/BrsV3\]
uvYU]pTU3 Ï"}u^i/BY>]VuvU¯FSMA    



5"%¢¤+=V6P{\]89RTCS89SBFGgÀYZ[\]hY¡}U89
mbeY( ¹]YfGghmbeVv&}UFpq^G_m%t\]i/UFG¢=ªB3@V{\]KLVl]z{4*Àµ]~MNOTUzB|OB¡P{i]\qB89Yo¹]beuTFG>LY
pqBCDJBPw[x=>?"%¢¤+=Pw[xB¡P{i]89Y pq
B"%Pw[xVfGghY b \]z{V^G_Y*Àµ]~MNOTU^
G_mzB±²VfGghY|}uz{Vt\] 0V3Ê\]z{V*Àµ]~jYU"%¢¤+=Pw[xB¡P{i]89Y pqUMNOTUfGghmFGgÀ U89Y !i"%¢¤+=V }qpuz{V^G_YUuU
Pcm¹Ïkl_YUt\]z{V*Àµ]~uUMNOTU89BFGY|\]=Õbf}uB(^{BBz½}ubeBÕ3)+Y
pq^G_Y±²V|\]z{4UfGghY*Àµ]~MNOTU 0ÊË{¡
P{}UJ B0±²V^G_=>?kl_Y|\]»Y pqb}uV}U¼\]z{VfGghY*Àµ]~MNOTU 0ÊË{¡P{}UzBMN*Àµj¹]be=>?FG>LVÕ
3)+ÍÍ%?\]MnVb }uVfGghm }U¼\]Pw[xVyv]~MNOTUFGgÀYZ[\]fGghB¤)+Y pqBPw[xVyvU¹YTB¤)+VÑ}u 0Y pqBPw[xVWX~
jYUMNOTUB oXYm_uTa>B4ZY{q[\iB·
89mFG¹]]^V4uj¸U_`Ya}ip{FDAm }uYUFDAm
z½}uPw[xB oVXY\]{UB>½i oXYVl\YFDAm
Z½Vyv]~    

6

MNOTUIJKL50Mª=NOB89FG[gYZ[\]^G_Ukl_u
TfGghV¡P{}ip~
FDAmy}u2005 SFTA=>?FSMAV\]MNOTU FSMAYÃÄpq$\]B BMN{ Yfo¹U89rsÖV\]FDABREil
B{}qFG B89Brsm)^EY¹]z{V{\]~FSMAY
ÃÄ¾UFDATU89B1¼ #Mn{[P - =>?3ÕYÃÄÅÊ
ËR78 FR 3646U20131¥16¦SU=>?a>R78 FR 64736U201310¥29¦SU8
9R89{@AB¹ ¹YÈ}q|O¹]ÊËMNSUij?Y8oVW>B" ÍÆÍR>Í3ÊBÃ#R78 FR 3504U20131¥16¦SY pqBMNV
|O}u~
2o{`
zBMNOTU0(483,609&V¡P{\]~zBYTU89FG[gYZ[\]fGgh{UzBMNOB¡P{i]89V$G\]VÀ7RUSDASBVWX89mW¹]~%2oKLT0(414910Mª=R1&1,784ª=SU2oKLT0(43008Mª=R1&360ª=S]~MNOBE`Vy\]-iTip~, i89FGºj_{a>B4Z56ÎB ^,Tb ¾]mUyT¾ip~89mFG Y \]V#Yy\]QsiTU}ipuvU_uTa>Y=µ]Ei4ZÎB VÂ\]z{Y pqUMNOBPw[xB!)V0(4]z{m¾ip~jYU¼aY=µ]$iTR>rsiMn{p½%S
'¹]mUzBMNOBPw[xB]^{}qUMnY=µ]MiT(
¾ip~{Tp U #FGÖB*JY>U3¢=BVÂj}UB>½i ¹u89=>?@AYÈ,\]4ZÎB B3ÕVÂ}U ¹u89=>?@AB -=>?9B+,VÂj\z{TiT¸]~    



7

%
I. 
II. E
III. MNOBb
A. on(R|O§ 1.900S
B. o R|O§ 1.902S
C. y*R|O§ 1.904S
D. be=>?FG>LR|O§ 1.906S
E. FGgÀR|O§ 1.908S
F. ¤)+R|O§ 1.910S
G.
0R|O§ 1.912S
H. oXYR|O§§ 1.914 – 1.934S
IV.  EM°A. 
B. M°
C. 1995,ÉÃVipÉÎB
V. 1995¿[ÀÁÂVI. #VII. ,d*°%
VIII. |OB$)¦=>? ¦
IX. ¢£¤Pc
X. ØÙÑ    





8


FG Y ¹u89=>?@AmÈ]B¤ÕRRef. 1SRRef. 2S
ij?Y8CDEiFG¼B[=>?²8RRef. 3SRRef. 4SRRef. 5SRRef. 6S
RRef. 7SRRef. 8SY>UYuq$CDEi»FG
¹z{V{\]6PYÈ\]mD#qpuRRef. 9S~ > ºj{>Be»Y89Vf?U0V( > BÎ]¤ ¬ÕYÈ\]1980
 B£ B²dTU! ibBfCmUY>uTB B8
9¶BABfYG¹qpube B89B V}iºuYU89
m ¹U8oY iÅi]BTipº{BY imu~mz½}uY q}u199089FGCDR1990 SFTASTUfF7RDOTSYUyB¿B=ÕbFG¹]89uT89>mBbeYFG¹]UuTYFG¹u89¶B9Y>q ¹]z{VuvBMN
ByV }u~1990 SFTABBUFG B89BE T89¶B
9µTiºuz{mbjºYiu~Y\¾1994Y$D}u=" #B¤ÕTU$Õ3%¬ÕmUY&'BDVf}
qpuÕ+3FG Y ¹u~zB¤ÕT0(4sB
224,000_YV( uR Ref. 1S~
T2005Y1990 SFTAV)}U2005 SFTAV}u~z¹TUFG B89¶B Y>]89 B*BYV+qpip{p½U1990 SFTA
>4,-p89FGrs]~2005 SFTATFDAY¡}U^G_U`abuT
cdbeY>]fGghUklB._=>?89BFGYZ[\]B B_mZ½¾CDEFGMnVMy}uMNV\]z{V }u~
FDATU20104¥U 2005 SFTAB/¼ YUFG B89rs V*\]¢¤+=YºY o¾]|Vg:Y \1$2V$¼}uRRef. 10S~I.

    



9

uU2005 SFTAB{}qUFDAT2010Y|O¹]MN B[.
R2010 ANPRM; 75 FR 22713SV¼pU89FGg:{B¼U=>?FG¹]8
9B {È,\]¤ÕY pqU{±²VPc}u~2010 ANPRMTU1980¶ABrsi89FGYÈ\]BºU89FGg:
Y=µ]1¼Mn{89Y 3Õm] Y pq4u~1990 SFTAY¡\]DOTBKLY pqu~uU > BBm}u89FG*+Õ¤Y pq2007Y_¹u?]^Y4}uRRefs. 3SRRef. 4S~*+Õ¤BETU.FG B89{p½'Y=µ]89rs=>?89
7B1'V \]z{u~*+Õ¤TU89 BV5v]Uz
BMN YÈ,\]89FGY=µ]pÅ ºB my¹u~ 3 ÏU
, !i&'U#beFG¹] i Í^>B  V4uj}ºip»Y>]DB8Í8BFGR  {TU89Blpm, !iY]89ºj´B89Î!iÕ3ma\]z{]SU, !iR>U.BU8CDEi'R3JB\]º?jµBUBJBa>B/&SUrsi89"%YÈ\]fCB³BUfCB89rs¤)+,i/]~89FGB m0 ºu 3BÅT$B ¤ ¬ÕmÈ,}qpu~*+Õ¤B? Y%?¹uBRÔ%¤ Õ¤
S¤ ¬ÕY pqy¹uÒ T{/UuTuÅÓiºu~uU2009B²8$¹uUFDAYqEastern Research Groupm}u?RERG²8SB]^Y pq4U89FGYZ[\]ÔÕY=µ]1¼ÃÐ*#B¼Y pqVU89m B3ÕYj¹qp]1B Vy}uRRef. 9S~
ERG²8TUFG=>?' Y89m>ËEUEuTD>E
B3
ÕYj¹qp]B]UpÅ ºB Vy}u~    



10

89B, !i&'uT"%¢¤+=R, !i"%ÊËS~• VJ, !iFG3)¬¤uT'BÊËUz¹YT,!i)Ö×U!>4V ^{\]UÕ+3 0V
3Ê}qpipU, !i*B-Ucdbea B3=%)
.i/mW¹]~• FG3)¬¤uT'B , !i^Uz¹YTR>Bo94B2¬¤i/mW¹]~• , !i^(¼UuT>LUz¹YT( >LB, !i)
Ö×U6PY#qo3)¬¤VGo}ipz{U, !i( 2U B3ÕV5v] (^BFGi/mW¹]~• , !i^AB}¼UuT>LUz¹YT>LB, !i)Ö×UAV(ª¬ÕY4LpuY\]Ui/mW¹]~• FG3)¬¤uT'B,-i ¤¢¤+=• 89Brs=>?¯uTÔ8 3 YÈ\]fC¯ZgB¤)
+=>?¯uT ¯ÊËh¯!hB ³B,• FG3)¬¤B,-i=>?
• FG3)¬¤uT'B , !i3@U B]^U BUB\¾U]BuTB(VD#]~• ZgB,CD• rs=>?¯uTi89BFGuT'Y*µu,-i»• ¹u(^UÆÍÍ9¹u9uT-yB9B,!ilp=>?
• §^uT%?'B89B, !i3Ê¼Uz¹YTÊË¹qpip
9U9BT3ÊU B9B§^UC!{Ë)mpUi/m•    



11

W¹]~
2 È,B]V(}UERG²8 B±²V½uvUpÅ ºB
Ei YÈ,\]4 Y pqB=>?±²VWX23¬Õ¢£¤V
wvuR =>?4 Y pqT2010 ANPRMVØÙBz{S~i|§hºj=>45B¢£¤mj¹u~|§hYTU89=>?@ABgh{Bg:U89 .gh{Bg:U89$Igh{Bg:UFG>Lgh=>?* $U`abÍcdfGgh{Bg:U}u_¤ ¬Õf
GghV\]UÉHIU2h3.Uij?Y_2hu~¢£¤mzBMNOByBMyY±²V|\]4B]U½}u¢£¤
Y pqTÐÑÔÕÖ×IIIBÈ, - #]~ºB¢£¤T2005 SFTABÔÕÖ×416(c)(2)(A)=>?(c)(2)(B)Vq=U
z¹TFDAY¶·BCDE89FGMNVWXz{V }qp]~R1S=ÕbFG¹uU#beBFG¹]89V \]m]{34&56THRTHSm \]89¶B9B3¤U=>?R2S`abuTc
dbeRÕbuT=Õb¶SFG¹uU#beYUuT
BFG¹]89V \]m]{THm \]89¶B9B
3¤~zBVu¢£¤B YTU89{89¶B9V8YFG\]z{V#]3¤T,Ë{}§u4BmUBË{}qU¹Tg
89FGY¡}qU2hm_EY89Vf»U\iU89{89¶B9V8Y`Îfz{V% }ipPw[xVµ]z{Yi]{}u~]¢£¤TU89{!>4BFGV*\¾{d ¹qpu~
89¶B(^{89B(^BR UuT%B(^{}qSyBTy
BFGB·89B(^m \]Em]4BBUB>½i m z]TyB'Yj¹]~z¹TUp¸¹B4U89¶B    



129m89V ¾]º/½ºTUYUbeB3U89¶B9B4=>?
%{¹YW¹] >4U(^{%B(^BBÕ3)+Í gB»=>?n(U89(^B4UBB=>?GoEU89=>?89¶B(^mbe$'¹]»R=Õb¶BSUij?Y89=>?89¶B(^BR>%'R=Õb¶BS%ºj]~zBËºjUj]'
UB=Õbf¹]89V \]B] Ei89¶B
9Vy¾ipuvUzBMNOYB>½i9B3¤V|O¾ip{UyEY] µu~uUj]'UBuTY=Õb¶Bbef¹]89V \]B] Ei89¶B9Vy¾ipu
vUzBMNOYB>½i9B3¤V|O¾ipz{4U yE] {}u~u}U89¶B9m89V \]YFGgÀBm/B>½Y
\]ºY pqB1$2TFGg:Y{q!o{i]B½z{4 yE]{}UzB21MNV_}uYB>½i1$2Vy\]y]~¶JB yE] YÈ\]¢£¤Vwv]~
jYU89FGg:B=Õ=>?=Õ¶B0Ô+£¤$UfGghT¦EYUBuTYR=Õb¶BS89Vf\]beU89¶
B9VFG}qp]z{VH³}qp]~2010 ANPRMY¡}qj¹u¢£¤YÃÄ¾UÅBU^G_{fGghTU)}qU3 ÏU±² !i/V.}
qU=>? B89¶B(^Y pqU}]Y !Y¡}uFGgÀBV}qp]4B{% ]~B BUFGgÀT=>? B89¶B(^Y¡}ug:Bi2D¼BYZq¼¹]~89=>?@AY*µuzBMNO=>?ÊËMNOTU¹ ¹U^G_{fGghBB±² {UB[P - FG¼V% \]z{Y pqMy\]UzBMN
B¡P{i]^G_{|OÊËMNB¡P{i]mU=>? B89¶    



13

B(^m% [x]B=Õb=>?=Õb¶BFG>Y pqr
siFGMnV\]J-]{ yEY] \]U uiPw[xVyv]
z{Yi]~EzBMNOTU2005 SFTAYÃÄ¾UuUFSMAÔÕÖ×111(a)B Y>U$¼\]~
2005 SFTATUFD&CB uiÔÕÖ×416R21 U.S.C. 350eSVµ]z{Y>U,89Í:;9Í49RFD&CSV #}u~FD&CBÔÕÖ×416(b)TU^G_U`abuTcdbeY>]fGghUkl_=>?89BFGYZ[\]B B_mMy¹uCDEFGMnVop]z{Y>U89V }]FG\]z{m}qip>½Y\]Pw[xVyv]z{VFDAY }u~
FD&CBÔÕÖ×416(c)TUFDAmR 1S)Ö×UR2SR>U =>?
B B3.¡UR3SbeBGoYÈ\]°UR4SfGgh=>?ghY\¾±²Uij?YR5S 0ÊËYÈ}q !{ \]MnVMy}iµ¹Ï
ijip{b }qp]~FD&CBÔÕÖ×416(c)4UMNYTU=ÕbFG
¹uU#beBFG¹]89V \]m]89¶B
9B3¤{U`abuTcdbeRÕbuT=Õb¶SFG¹u
U#beYUuTBFG¹]89V \]m]89¶
B9B3¤V \]z{Vb }qp]~FSMABÔÕÖ×111(a)TUz¹
jBCDEFGMNV$\]z{VFDAY }u~
jYU2005 SFTATUFD&CY }pÔÕÖ×402(i)R21 U.S.C. 342(i)SVµU
ÔÕÖ×416YÃÄpq$¹uMNY }qpipB·^G_U`ab4}ÅTcdbeY>]fGghUkl_uT89BFGYZ[\]B B_YII.

    



14>qFG¹]UuTFG\]uvY|¹]89T }qp]{}U
FD&CB ÔÕÖ×301(hh)R21 U.S.C. 331(hh)STU^G_U`ab4}ÅTcd
beY>]fGghUkl_uT89BFGYZ[\]B B_mÔÕÖ×
416YÃÄpq$¹uMNÎB V]z{V#]~uU2005 SFTATUFD&CBÔÕÖ×703R21 U.S.C. 373S4#}qÔÕÖ×703(b)V}U^G_U`ab4}ÅTcdbeY>]fGghUkl_uTÔÕÖ×416B¡P{i]B
B_TUFDAmy}uuTZgBPcm¹ÏUBuTZg
Y¡}U iYUÔÕÖ×416YÃÄpq$¹uMNY>3Êm*Àµj¹]\qB 0V(}U¢\]z{V}iµ¹Ïijip{My}qp]~zBMNOY¡\]FDABTUFD&CB402(a)(1)U(a)(3)U(a)(4)U=>?701(a)R21 U.S.C. 371(a)SB0ÔÕÖ×ºj4j¹]~FD&CBÔÕÖ×402(a)(1)TU
B {}qU89V4ZY¡}q!i4B{\]B]!uT!i
>4V89mfUuTWXUB89T }qp]{My}qp]~
FD&CBÔÕÖ×402(a)(3)TU89BsuTB mU,iUÍ-
}u>4ºji]UuTB B%8oY ipUB89T }qp]{My}qp]~FD&CBÔÕÖ×402(a)(4)TU,i4BY ¹]m]>½iUuT4ZY¡}q!i4B{\]B]>½i8CDE
i·UR>uT3Ê¹qpuUB89T }qp]{My}qp]~FD&CBÔÕÖ×701(a)YÃÄ¾UFDATUFD&CB)!Ei¼Buv
YMNV$\]V( j¹qp]~MNOYTUFGgÀ B89BR/B>½
i ºjq4U,UÍ-UuTB B%8oY iÅi]U
]pT4ZY¡}q!{i]z{Y>]S V*\]uvY6PiPw[xmW¹]~z½}uPw[xY>UFD&CB¼m)!E{i]~    



15

MNOB
Bb
MNO
FDATÒ89=>?@ABCDEFGÓ{\] }p 21 CFR2¤1U2¤OByV|O}qp]~MNOTU89V }]FG\]z{m}qip>½Y\]uvU89BFGYZ[\]^G_U`abuTcdbeY>]f
Ggh=>?kl_mop]¾CDEFGMnVb \]~A. on(R|O§ 1.900S|O¹]§ 1.900TU2¤OBPw[xB¡PhV½~|OB§ 1.900(a)TU|OB§ 1.904Yy*¹]U¡PB[gRÐÑÔÕÖ×III.C]>½
YzBMNB¡P{ijiphSVY¾U2¤OBPw[xTU89m.
Y|¹]uT(]º/½ºYººj¸U89BFGgÀYZ[\]^G_Uk
l_=>?fGghY o¹]{My\]~|OB§ 1.900(b)TU^G_Ukl_
uTfGghmR1SV>}q´BÎG¹]89UuTR2S¦F§\]uvYF(¹U24 .4¹ip89BFGgÀYZ[\]YTU2¤OBPw[xm o¹ip{My\]~1. 89BFGYZ[\]B B_
FD&CBÔÕÖ×416(b)TUz½}uMN89BFGYZ[\]ÒB B_ÓV½¾]{bYqp]~FDATU^G_Ukl_uTfGgh¶U Y/B>½im89BFGYZ[\]ÒB B_Ó{i]ºU
uU89BFGYZ[\]ÒB B_ÓY*µuPw[xV|O\]z{mU89V }]FG\]z{m}qip>½Y\]J6PºU%}u~
B%B{}qUzBMNOB0MyVB>½i_Y o\]z{Y>q
4EYCDE89FGMnBGom ¹]m]z{V \>½i±²Y
pqU2010 ANPRMY¡\]¢£¤B m¼¹u~z¹jB¢£¤=>III.

    



16?B BFGg:YÈ}q(i±²B V¼pU^G_UfGgh=>?kl_Y pqFDAm|O}qp]y*V%}uU89FGY=µ] m89
BCD''Y\]{(¹UBuvYÐMNBPw[xB¡P{\]¾U8
9BFGYZ[\]ÒB B_ÓTpip{U yEY] µu~ZqU^G_Ukl_=>?fGgh¶B_VMNOB¡P{\]z{V|O}qpip~
FDA TUFD&CBÔÕÖ×416(b)mMy\]B·B B_VzBMNO
B¡P{\¾º/½ºY pqU¢£¤Vwvqp]~¢£¤TU89FGY=µ]BhB EVy}UB_m^G_UfGghuTkl_By*Y0}ipVb}UBhB¼m89BCD''Y/B>½Y}]ºY
pqUBhY o\¾M°JBMyB¿Y pq]¾]~
2. $aFDATUMNOB0MyV4J$BaY o{\¾]{ yEY]
µqp]~FD&CBÔÕÖ×416(a)(2)BiÑTUÒFGÓV`ab
uTcdbeY>].Y=µ]j]a¾Vy*}qp]~FD&CBÔÕÖ×416(b)TU^G_U`abuTcdbeY>]fGghUkl_=>?89BÒFGÓ
YZ[\]B B_YU89V }]FG\]z{m}qip>½
Y\]uvYTHmMy\]CDEFGMnBGoV*Àµ]MNVµ]z{VU
FDAY }qp]~ÔÕÖ×416YTU.Yy\]mW¹qpip~
FDATU0MyV4J$BaY o {\¾º/½ºU¢£¤Vwv]~
3. BazBMNOTU2uT .¹]89VFG\]^G_UfGgh=>?
kl_Y*µuCDEFGMnVyvqp]~}º}U YTUY(}q$FG¹q4U 2uT .¹ip89m]~3 ÏU B8
9TUºjV>}q´BÎG¹]R3J£8Ö¢ºjV>}q    



17#2ÎfÏ¹]89S~jYU89mÎF(¹UBÎFG¹U
B.2uT .¹¸Y´BÎF§¹]z{m]~
FDATUFD&CBÔÕÖ×416T24 .4¹ip89BFGYo\]z{m#¹qpip{U yEY] µu~ZqU|OB§ 1.900(b)TU^G_Ukl_=>?fGghmR1SV>}q´BÎG¹]89Uu
TR2S¦F§\]uvYF(¹U24 .4¹ip89BFGgÀY
Z[\]YTU2¤OBPw[xm o¹ip{My\]~u}U|Om o¹]BTU`abuTcdbeÎ+ FG¹]89BFGgÀ{i]~»UzB|OBPw[xTU21EYTB.*µ]º4}¹ipmU`abuTcdbeÎ+ FG¹ip89BFGYT o
¹ip~3 ÏUzBMNOBPw[xTU`abuTcdbeY>]ÎB+§^VWXFGgÀV¼½^G_=>?fGghY o¹]z{Yi]
R3J£8Ö¢ºj¤ ¬Õ§^¹UB¤ ¬ÕY(}U$j
YFG¹]89S~}º}UzBMNOBPw[xTU`abuTcdbeY>
Î+ §^¹]89VY¾U21EYT*µB89Y pqFGgÀV¼½^G_=>?fGghYT o¹ipR3J $§^UfGUkµlm¼¹]mU21EYTÎ/F¹]89S~jY3V]{UzBMNOBPw[xTU89m2uT .¹]U8Y>]J¢UuT8/>FGo¢89VY§^}U¢VB
`abuTcdbeY}qB.FG\]V\]F§ghi/UYp]hY4 o¹]z{Yi]~FDATUzBhmB.Y(]`abu
Tcdbe89B§^V \]z{ºjUB¼mY=µ]4Bu{}q4UzBhmzBMNOYÃÄÅ^G_{i\~B^G_mzBMNOBPw[xY }ipUFDATUB^G_Y>qY§^¹u89m]^{}    

18q }qp]m]z{ºjUB(^89TÎB(cY(B¡P{i]{ \]~4. 89FGY o¹]B BPw[x|OB§ 1.900TU2¤OBPw[xmU89FGY o¹]FDABB B
Pw[xY q o¹]z{4My\]~3 ÏUFDAmµuMNTU2¤225R21 CFR part 225SY=pq;o@AB1¼ #MnR CGMPSY pqU
z¹YW¹]ÔÕÖ×225.65BMyÒ>L{ YÓTU@Am;9Y
¹][\Vµ]uvU;o@AB .Yopj¹]>LBÕ3)+Y*µuP
w[xVqp]~YUFDATU2¤589R21 CFR part 589SY=pq@A
uTGom*¹qp]>V½MNVµq=Uz¹YT§ 589.2000Òa
,a>Y=pq*¹]a>2Õ4Ó=>?§ 589.2001Ò"'#R"$SB Vuv@AuT*¹]"#AÓBMymW¹Ua,a>B{a>B@AuTB¹ ¹ VuvUyB@A -B .Y
Go¹]>LYÈ\] }uYBPw[x{o>LBPw[xm¹qp]~
B. oR|O§ 1.902)
FD&CBÔÕÖ×402(i)R21 U.S.C. 342(i)SYÃÄ¾U89m 2005 SFTABÔÕÖ
×416YÃÄpq$¹uMNY }ip·U^G_U`ab4}ÅTc
dbeY>]fGghUkl_uT89BFGYZ[\]B B_YFG¹]UuTFGY|¹]UB89T }qp]{i¹iµ¹Ïijip~|OB§ 1.902(a)TU2¤OY }ip·U89BFGYZ[\]^G_U`ab4}ÅTcdbeY>]fGghUuTkl_Y89mFG¹uUu
TFGY|¹u{p½UFD&CBÔÕÖ×402(i)B Bn($89m
}qp]º/½º \]YU2¤OBÃ#=>?y*m o¹]z    



19{VMy\]~
FD&CBÔÕÖ×301(hh)YÃÄ¾U¶·B¼=>?B T#j¹]~\iU^G_U`abuTcdbeY>]fGghUkl_uT89BFGYZ[\]B B_mÔÕÖ×416YÃÄpqTHmyv]CDEFGMnY }
ipz{]~FD&CBÔÕÖ×416YÃÄpqµj¹uMNY }ipz{T*¼]z{VbY ]uvU|O§ 1.902(b)TU89FGgÀYZ
[\]^G_U`abuTcdbeY>]fGghUuTkl_m2¤OB
Pw[xY }ipz{TFD&CBÔÕÖ×301(hh)YÃÄÅT*¼]{My\]~
C. y*R|O§ 1.904S|OB§ 1.904TUÒ !ÓVU #_CDMnY qÐ#BEV^\uvY
6P]z{{y*\]~zBy*OTUUBCGMPMNR21 CFR 110.3(b)ØÙS
Y=µ]zBoBy*{]~FDATU89BÊËMNOBCGMPMy
B OYzBy*V3 }UuU@ABÊËMNOBCGMPMyY=pq4U
#y*V }qp]~89BCDEilpY,8iN=>?MnVb\]YzBm-Å o¾]z{ºjUzBVGo}qzBMNOYÈ,B]Pw[xV}U3 ÏUFG>LTÒ !ÓYÕ3)+}\p>½Y}iµ¹ÏijipUi/{\¹ÏUg:Ë¹U89V }]FG\]z{m}qip>½Y\]J)^EYi]{U yEY] µu~zBMNOBMyB YTFDA BCGMPMNBMy{¿0R1ØÙS}U gm89$u
T89FGgÀBp¸¹¹]4B¹U89Yºº]CD gB¹uNVa}qp]4Bm]~]^{}qUÅBgT\YzBMNBMyOY }qp]m5p~
    



20

0

§ 1.904§ 1.906(b)§ 1.906(c)§ 1.906(d)§ 1.906(e)§ 1.908(a)(2)§ 1.908(c)(1)1.-- FDABCGMPMNBMyY¿0\]ÐMNOB0My

0
8 CGMP
21 CFR 110.3(b)440
   !"#$$ 4 $'(40(  % &
!"#$ )* &
21 CFR 110.40(a)3+,-.(/125679:;!
abc\]1[Kd"<(3+ =>?@A(BCD
EF(G'HIJ!=K4L5 '(4 efghijRk Nl
M5("N'OPQRST$5 m$R(H125no1[pb#$ UV WXYZ1[ <!5qr5;s(G43+\] ^_ #$ %-`& tuLq5qr5;5N&
21 CFR 110.80(b)(6)3+.vwxiyzg{ R5qrST|}~5ST|}~5  
"=>3+,-KLqYZ  "=>(
1[3+\]'(ST|}~5  5<'(H=>?)  vw=> ^_ *! #$ U12lm(1[\ #$ !tR5qr5;5N&%-`&
21 CFR 110.40(e)3+.vwxiyzg{ R5qr|}
#$?!«
ST|}~5  
=>£¡DtKLq
"=>3+,-KLqYZ
G'3+\]1[  1[¢v£¡¤'(¤¡Lq¢v£¡¤(¤!¥ !¥vw ¦ 12l]Lq
vw ¦ 12l]Lq§¦vw §¦vwm(vw¨ \]G'm(vw¨ \]G'vw©ª\] vw©ª\] 5qr5;5
N¬#$ %-`&
21 CFR 110.35(e)YZ1[3+\]'(HYZG'efghij$´µ¶·¸3+\]?­®y ¯G°("N'¹\]!=>º»¼"<1
Hq;?±q!"=>?(3+,-./125679:;!" [Kd'(=>º»¼ 67:;t<(@A(BCDEF(G'HI ½ c¾1[!t a«
J!=K4L5M5(G'OP !"&
QRST$5125HIJ!
67Lq²$5#$ UV k³!t #$ %-`&
21 CFR 110.10(d)3+,-?¿ÀÁgyO ÂÃÄÂÃaÍÎ?Ágya4ÅRÆÇLq#$ tÈÉÊ S 5ËÌÍÎÏ³Ð# Ä a4Å #$ tÈ 
ÉÊ'(S 5ËÌÍÎÑ¥Ï$ %-`&³Ð5qr5;5N&
21 CFR 110.10(b)Ò+Ó1[ÔÕÓ(ÒÖ×1[Ò=>(=>º»¼1[=>í\ØÙRÚ,.ÛÜ!ÝÞß±qN
5N=> Õ³à2$áâLqYZã o$îºº»RïMð'ÞÎ?ñ
äå?æç!èé êë åìNÇl -.(=>67 U
çK!«12 #$ %-` 5!04ÅR5qr
5;5N&&
21 CFR 110.10(b)(3)    



21

4 5åìNÇl! RåìN:(ST|}167
U 5cÅ'´µ¬
21 CFR 110.37(e)åìNÇl'4 :æç!(4Ð5vwèé êëR5qr5;5N&|OB§ 1.904TÒ@AÓV_¶Ba>oB8>{y*}Uz¹YT ¬¤ªUUij?YA=>? -VWX~zBy*TU@AYÈ\]ÊËMNO
Y=µ]Ò@AÓBy*{]~|OB§ 1.904TÒ=ÕbÓVÕ+3U¬2¤ ¬ÕUÕbU
¬2bU>ÕU=ÕU>FGo¢U4}ÅT¬2
\]>½iB Bb
UuT89VÏj^FG}U89mBbe{+e{y*\]~zBy*OTFD&CBÔÕÖ×416(a)(1)R21 U.S.C. 350e(a)(1)Sºj+ %o¹qp]~zBy*TUÐMNOB¡P{i]`ab{cdbeBÔ¬¤U\iUÒ=ÕbÓ{UÐMNOB¡P{i]B B¿BbeU\iU¤ i/B=Õb¶{V´}qp]~ÔÕÖ×III.Eu>½YUFGgÀ B ºjB89B-i3.V{\]uvU=Õbmºº]FGgÀY o¹]pÅ ºB EiPw[xV\]z{V|O}u~|O¹uzBy*YTU89FGYGo¹]>L4W¹]mUBËTU`
abuTcdbeU3 Ï>Õi/Ylµj¹U ¹qp]ºj
]~FDATU=ÕbVJ |OB>½Yy*\]z{U=ÕbYÈ,\]ÐMN
B0MymUÕ+3ºj>ÕUB=ÕFG89mfG¹]U\qBB]FGgÀY o¹]z{m{i]{U yEY] µqp]~|OB§ 1.904TUÒfGghÓVU!U3UuTB B%89VFG    



22\]`abuTcdbeBGoY21Ei V ½h{y*\]~zBy*TU
jYU2¤OfGghY qj¹]\qBY pqU¤ ¬ÕfG
&mbeBfCBuvY ouTQ}qp]fCi/U hm¼\]
q4UfGghm V ½{y*\]~ uUfGghTUBhm2
¤OYy*¹]¹ ¹BhB4^\YTUkl_uT^G_{i]z{4]~
89BFGTU8i]UmÈ(\]i%¼¹]z{m]~3 ÏU`&oB¤ ¬Õ&UfCuTQfCV4uipTU¤ ¬ÕfG
&{FGQV]?U>ËEYT¤ ¬ÕfG&m`&BbeVGq89FG>VQy¹u´BÎFG\]m]~´B3{}qTU3ÊY89
V!\] .ghmU3BbeVfC}qÎ89V\]m]~z½}u3TUp¸¹B489VFG\]beBGoY pq21EY V ½
UU\iU2B3T¤ ¬ÕfG&U­B3T .ghmUÐMN
OYÃÄpqfGghY o¹]Pw[xB¡P{i]~­B3TU .gh
TU3ÊBfY>UÐMNOYÃÄpq^G_Y o¹]Pw[xB¡
PY4i]z{m]~zBy*OTUfGghm2¤OY=pqBhY qj¹]\qBY pqU¹mfGghB ouTQ}ufCi/B hm¼\]
q4U V ½{y*\]~ZqUfGghTU>ËEY89VFG\]beBGoY pq21EY V ½U]z{ºjUfGghmÐMNOYÃÄ
Å\qB Y ¾]>½Y\]»BbeVfC\]fCm-V^\z{V{\] V ½~3 ÏUFGgÀBUfGghTU|O§ 1.908(d)(2)YÃÄ¾UÔÕÖ×III.Eu>½YU"%y 0V^G_Y| }U|O§
1.908(b)(3)YZq^G_my}u{}u"%VFG Y}qpu    

23{t\]z{m¾]~YTUbeBfCm"% 0>LzB 0V µ]UuTÆ\]h{i]m5pmUfCmFGgÀ B-B{}q
Y 0V µUuTÆ}qU^G_Y|\]z{V{\]BTUfGghB{i]~ÒfGghÓ{p½By*TUbeBGoY V ½U]fGgh{beBfCh{BE´VH³}qp]~DOTY \],`abfFrs<TU,
`abfFrsMNR49 CFR part 390SY=pqB´V}q=UMNTÒf
C3ÓmgE`abVfC\]h{y*¹UfC3T`abfGghY o¹]{b ¹qp]R49 CFR 390.5S~z½}uMN4UYfC3B Y pqU`abfGghY V qp]~FDA TUÐMNOYÃÄpqfGghY qj¹] V_Y \]EfGgh{fC{V´\]VHvu~
jYUz½}u V_Y \]z{UÐMNOYyv]fGghV¡P{\]
Pw[xY¹m V ½BºYÈ\] 0Vµ]{i]{U yEY] µu~|OB§ 1.904TUÒ  ÓVUFD&CBÔÕÖ×201(qq)R21 U.S.C. 321(qq)SYy*¹]89=m@AVYÅ89Y#¸Yl ¹]z{V\]{y*\]~|O}qp]BTU89BÊËMNOY }uÒ  ÓB
By*{Ð4EY#y*B]R78 FR 3646 at 3693B %VØÙSmU|O\]y*YÒ@AVYÅÓBV >½{}qp]BTU@ABÊËMNOB
ÑYu>½YR78 FR 64736 at 64771, October 29, 2013SU89#=ma>YUuT@ABlpV.}q_Y7i4ZJB3ÕV4uj\z{V\t&VH³}qpipuv]~|OB§ 1.904TUÒVÓVU >B" =>?ÆUa>R*W>VWXSB@*UuTe»BuvBYGo¹]Us{}q B>ËEiY]V    



24

 \]{y*\]~jYUÒVÓBYTU89VR>uT3Ê\]VU
BaYopj¹]\qB89mBVuT#!hB´BV" U@*uT2¹]º/½ºYººj¸UWXz{V|O}qp]~FDAm|O\]ÒVÓBBy*TUFD&CBÔÕÖ×415YÃÄpq/Bm0V*Àµj¹]Bºb\]uvYopj¹]UÐ § 1.227(b)(3)Y=µ]VBy*{8i]~ÐMNOBEBuvY8i]VBy*V|O}qp]ËY pqTU¶·YzBÔÕÖ× ÒFGgÀÓY|O\]y*Y=pq]~|OB§ 1.904TÒ89ÓVUFD&CBÔÕÖ×201(f)Yy*¹]89V
\]{y*}Uz¹YTA=>? -mW¹]~zBy*TU89=>?@ABÊËMNOY=µ]Ò89ÓBy*{]~zBMNO½89Bn(VhmYË\]>½UzBy*BMyTUFD&CY=µ]Ò89ÓBy*{}qU89YTVÀ7B89rs%?<RFSISSmÊË\]@Aij?Y,8
%?U89%?=>?9%?B¡P{i]89mW¹]z{4 \] ~FSISTUgE 9aV}U[gaYFSISBM°¡P]9V½U
mUFSISB=>?M°JBPw[xY }qB>½i9VU'UFGU
2IU2IuTFGY*µq|UF(=>?F§\]z{V%t\]~FSISTU8U8=>?9BrsiFG=>? .Y*µu1$2RRef. 11SV_}qp]mUz½}u89BFGgÀV+ uPw[xTip~zBMN TU
FSISBM°¡P]8U8=>?9BCDE89FGMnB oV /\]uvBFSISBlV½z{Yi]~FDATFSIS{)}U¹ ¹BM°*++ V¼} UzB .B /Yv] 4]~1

FDA 
USDA   !"#$4%&'()* FSIS *+,-"./013567189:;<=>"?*@ABC"DRef. 12EF     1

25|OB§ 1.904TUÒQsY¹qpip89ÓVU m(#Y º¹u%Y(¹j¹u89V \]{y*\]~zBy*OTU#Y¡\]§Y> 3Õm5]z{ºjU89mEYFG Y }ip3tV
#}uzBMNOB EiMyB¡P{i]89#3Vy\]uvYopj¹]~zBy*BMyYTU B pu«¬¤uTU B pu'= Uu ¾'Bpu'= UuT'Bpu )=i/UB>½iB3mW¹]~y*TUzBYTUÐMNOy*¹]=ÕbF
G¹]89TW¹ipz{4My¹]~zB*+TU89=>?@ABÊËMNOY=µ]§}qpipR>
&'89Bp»{}qp]~3 ÏU89BÊËMNOTUBMNB
Pw[xB TU#Y§}qpipR>89B'BYºº]Yo¹ip{b }uR78 FR 3646 at 3713S»UTCS89]B>½i89Y*µu#Pw[xVµ]z{V|O}uR78 FR 3646 at 3773S~BMNOTU
Ò§}qpipR>89Ó{T#Y§}qpipR>89V \]{i}uz{Vb }uR78 FR 3646 at 3712S~
89BÊËMN§}qpipR>89V/B>½Y½¾º%\]YTU89BR>B3.4Y>U§}qpipR>89B >T
+Yj¹qp]Y puR78 FR 3646 at 3713S~#mU@AY*µuÊËMNOb ¹uR§0BYTFREoV| \]S~zBMNOTU
B 4 {H³}qp]~\iUQsY¹qpip89TFG B
3Õm5]{H³}UBuvUB>½i89BY o¹]yBPw[xV|O\]z{T !]{U yEY] µqp]~|OB§ 1.904TUÒ D>ÓVU Uº?UÕ3U$=UDa>U=>? $iDD>V \]{y*}Uz¹YT_CDJ7PiVWX~|O    



26

B§ 1.904TUÒ! D>ÓBoYT_CDJ7PiU89V]U89m,i4B ¹qp]z{V \UuTB B%89V \]
B] D>mW¹]z{4b \]~zBy*OTU89=>?@ABÊËMNOY=µ]zBoBy*{]~89V }]z{ºjUzBy*
Oy¹]¿B D>TU89=>?@ABrsCDEiDW{Y89B
CDEiFGY{q7P{i\~|OB§ 1.904TUÒ¡PB[gÓVUIJKL50Mª=NOBFGgÀYZ
[\]^G_Ukl_uTfGgh{y*\]~¡PB[gYÈ\]FDABy*OTU¢£¤Vwvu89*µÊËMNOY
=µ]gY pqBy*OB {¿0}qp]R78 FR 3646 at 3701S~BMNOYÃÄ¾UgTU[P - ÊËY pqBPw[xB oXYBMyVWXU#Pw[xB o¡P{i]~z½}u[gY pqTUÐMNYÃÄ
Å on(ºjY}UÐMNO{ÊËMNOBY0\]z¹jBgBp
VMy\]z{V|O}qp]~jYUfGgh{}qB-BV^}UZqÊËMNOB¡P{ijipgY pqTUIJKL50Mª=NOBfGghVÐMNOB on(ºjY\]z{UÐMNOB¡P{i]^G_=>?kl_Bp{}u»fGghV½z{Yi]~IJKL50Mª=NOBf
GghV o¡P{}ip{}q4U`abuTcdY>]\qB89FGB
972Ô¤TzBMNOB¡P{i]{0(4qp]~¡PB[gTUB[gmÐMNOB on($YW¹]º/½º{TººiÅU14Uu 4E¾F¾U YÈ\]MyUB B o¹]FD&CBMy=>? o¹]MNB¡P{i]z{V \]~IJKL50Mª=B V \89VU
jºB%ÐMNBUuTFSMAm21y¹uYTBp¸¹ºB¡P{i]4BY°\¾º/½ºY pqU¢£¤Vwvqp]~    



27|OB§ 1.904TUÒ!a>ÓVUU"%U; U.VWX}Åipj]a>uT.V \]{y*\]~zBy*OTU89BÊËMNOY
=µ]zBoBy*{]~zBMNOYTU|OYÈ,\]Ua>mÒ}ÅipÓ{i¹ippÅ ºB'Y pqB %4W¹]R78 FR 3646 at
3721S~FDATUzBy*Oy¹]¿B!a>mU89=>?@ABrs
CDEiDW{Y89BCDEiFGY{q7P{i}qp]~|OB§ 1.904TUÒkl_ÓY pqUFGY89Vkµl]j]hV
}UBhm89B21kl$¤]ººV ip{y*\]~zBy*
TUzBMNOYy*¹]fGghuT^G_B-4kl_m^\YTUk
l_mfGghuT^G_{4i]z{Y pq4b }qp]~|OB§ 1.904
TU_2huT_2hYq89Vkµl]UuT3Ê\]hUYlEB[hTiph=>?89V .\][gYqpiphU3 ÏU
=B 2¤Bki/UgE89V3Ê}qpiphTUkl_
YW¹ipz{4My}qp]~
FGg:$TUFG>m21Ei^k_Y+ Gj¹]3Ô+£¤FGU
uT'i/B EV>}qGj¹]Ô+£¤FG^G_m9Vkl_YG]z{m]~ZqUzBy*OTU21Ei^k_µiÅUFGY89Vkµl]\qBhmÐMNOkl_Y o¹]Pw[xB¡
P{i]{My\]~|OB§ 1.904TUÒS"T3U89ÓV("%=>?%B·'¾UR>BQsm ¹qp¹ÏUB3U U}ipUuTrs
iÅijip89V \]{y*\]~zBy*OBÃ{}uBTÑ RRef. 13S
RRef. 14SRRef. 15SRRef. 16SBÐ4EY¿0\]zBoBy*]~zBy*
BMyTU U UU'¤=(A*U 89i/VWX    



28

S"T3U89B34pÅ º \~|OB§ 1.904TUÒ^G_ÓVU`abuTcdY>89B§^V \]hV \]{y*\]~zBy*TUjYU^G_m2¤O ^G_Y
j¹]\qB-Y pqU¹V\]BmU89V3Ê}U¹V^G_m
}ubeY>ËEYa\]µBhi/B hu{}q4U V ½{My\]~3 ÏUVW> .ghR^G_SmU $= ¹uVW> .¤ ¬ÕFG\]uvY3ÊD VW>B^V( XfGghV\]z{89B$GV \]z{m]~ .ghY o¹qpip3ÊBZg
mUVW>V¤ ¬ÕY( Xº4}¹ip~zBMNOTU .ghmU3
ÏQJBlvi/V.}qU3ÊBZgmbeBV9%?}UÔÕÖ×III.E]|O§ 1.908(b)(2)Y*Àµj¹]U89BFGY !iCD''Y]>½Y0 UÐMNOBB BPw[xm\qOu¹qp]{ \]z{V{\] V ½z{Yi]~QJBÈByE { TU
+E#Eig:Mn]{% ]~zBy*TU2¤OYy*¹]fGghuTkl_B-4^G_m^\YTU^G_mfGghuTkl_{4i]m]z{Y pq4b }qp]~3 ÏU2«¬¤mD VW>B§^V}q .Ôkµl]>½Y\]]~Ò^G_ÓBY pqTzB>½YUÔÕÖ×III.E]^G_Y qj¹] VUFGgÀV \]_BhY ]>½Yy*}qp]mUzBhm
B89YÈ\]U3 ÏUR>=>?3Ê"%BPw[xi/UCDEiFGYÈ,
B]\qB Y pqU }qp]{'\]ºj]~^G_VzB>½
Yy*\¹ÏU }]·T89VFG}ipUuUz½}u V_
Y \¹ÏÐMNOYyv]^G_V¡P{\]Pw[xY¹m V ½BºY    

29

È\] 0Vµ]{i]U{ yEY] µu~|OB§ 1.904TUÒ$gÓVU|OB§ 1.900(a)RÔÕÖ×III.A%SB¡P{i]U o500_NOB[gV }Uu}U^G_4kl_4ip`abY>]fGghY pqTUzBoTU|OB§ 1.900(a)B¡P{i]U $gIm¤ ¬ÕfG&Y pqyvuÃ#YÃÄÅM{\]Uk52,550Mª=NOB[gV \]U{y*\]~|O¹]%BZg500_YTUyB
BZgYy¸UB[gBsZgmW¹]~FDATU`abY>]f
GghVYÅÐMNB¡P{i]\qBhY pqU $gIm{/B89ghY pq13 CFR2¤121YÃÄpq}uUMYÃÄÅ#RZg
\S{#$gBy*V\]z{V|O}qp]~`abY>]fGgh
Y pqTU $gIm¤ ¬ÕfG&Y pq13 CFR2¤121YÃÄpq
}uUMYÃÄÅ#R Mª=3&\S{Ð4EY#$gBy*V\]z{V|O}qp]~$gBy*T½}ugB mp Yi]ºY\]~|OB§ 1.904TUÒrs¯"%¢¤+=89RTCS89SÓVU$D>B# uT% V°\]UrsBuvB¯"%¢¤+=V6P{\]89{y*\]~zBy*OTUFDAB20090ª¢ªR89MyS
RRef. 17SY=µ]ÒE!89ÓRÒrs¯"%¢¤+=89ÓSBoBy*{UzBoTU# ]z{ºjU89=>?@ABÊËMNO4Go¹qp]R78 FR 3646 at 3712 and 78 FR 64736 at 64768S~|OB§ 1.904TUÒFGÓVUgEB`abuTcdbeY>]89Ba{y*\]~zBy*OTUbBuvÒ89BÓBV}uVY¾UFD&CBÔÕÖ×416(a)(2)Y=µ]zBoBy*{]~|OB§ 1.904TUÒFG>LÓVUbe¶BFGgÀYopj¹]>LU3 ÏU    



30

=Õ=>?=Õ¶B¢U U¤¤U2¬¤U*U 9U
U1«¬¤U^(=>?^AB}BÖi/V \]{y*}UuUF
G>LYTÈbY,]¹qpipcdbeuT¤ ÕY,]¹qpip¤ 4W¹]{b \]~zBy*TU89FGYopj¹]z{B]>LBÃÐEi¿V\qWUrsi89FGB3tYq]J6P]{UyEY] µqp]~zBy*BFG>LB3TREi4BTiÅUERG²8
=>?2010 ANPRMY¡\]¢£¤y¹uU89FGYopj¹]>LB¿VºY\]4B]~|OB§ 1.904TUÒFGgÀÓVU89BCD''Y}]U89FGY½\qBaV }Ube=>?FG>LBÕ3)+U%?U3@U^(=>?^AB}Uij?YfCVWX{y*\]~zBy*OTUjYUQsY
¹uS"T3U89U89o8 1UuTD¾u8oa>BBFGYºº]aTFGgÀYW¹ip{My\]~ÐÔÕÖ×©Yu>½YUFD&CBÔÕÖ×416(a)(2)TUÒFGÓV
gEB`abuTcdbeY>]a{y*}qp]~zBÒFGgÀÓBy*V\]JFDAm#}qp]BTU89V }]89FGYÈ,}q¼
¹]a{UzBEBipB Ba{V´\]z{UzBMNOByBPw[xB on(V>#Yy*\]z{]~zBMNOBPw[xTU
8CDEi»¹uY89V }]aBY o¹]~B>½iaB3V]{U=ÕÕ¤ ¬Õºjkl_B'ÕÎ^
V\z{]~zBMNOFGgÀ{i¹ipaB3TU89FG B
beB3AÕÎB)]~jYUFGgÀBy*OTUQsY¹uS"T3U89U89
o8 1U=>?D¾u8oa>BFGY½aVY\]~FDATUQs    



31

Y¹uS"T3U89YTFG B 3Õm{/ip{U yE
Y] µu~z½}u89T"%¢¤+=V6P{¸UBuv D>Y>]uT_CDJ7Pi D>B# B3ÕmiÅUuU3 ÏU BU
1 uT* ¬ÕB'¤=U ¹uuT i/BQsY¹qp]z{ºjFG#Y+ ¹]z{4ip~ZqUFDATUCDEFGMn
Y*µuPw[xVB>½i89Y o\]6PTip{U yEY] µu~
2010 ANPRMY¡\]¢£¤RRef. 18SR Ref. 19STUAY>1V(¹]uvYGo¹]>1i/B89o8 1TÖ32uT=ÕY(¹qUuT39BFGoB¤ cdbei/B=ÕbFG¹]{
qpu~z½}u¢£¤TU89o8 1T D>B# V ipz{U=miÅU=§( Vµ]µ]z{ºjE=>?>ËE V=>?be$B8FG¹]z{4qpu~BuvU
FDATU89o8 1TUFG¹]»ºjFG B 3Õm{/ip{ yEY] µUB>½i89Vz¹jBPw[xB on(ºjY\]z{V|O}qp]~zBMNOY]CDEFGMnV.}q¡¾]U3yBD¾u8oa>BFGYÈ,\]89BrsBY pqTUH³}qpip~2010 ANPRMY¡\]¢£¤TUB>½iT| ¹qpiºu~jYUFSISBB¡P{i]B3 gTUD¾u8oa>B  m ¹]z{Y>q
4uj¹] B3ÕV2$Y ]z{VE{\]Pw[xB¡P]~ZqUFDATUD¾u8oa>BFG B VCDEFGMnT6P
ip{ yEY] µUB>½i89Vz¹jBPw[xB on(ºjY\]z{V|O}qp]~
FDATYUQsY¹uS"T3U89U89o8 1U=>    



32?D¾u8oa>VzBMNOB on(ºjY\¾]{p½ yE] YÈ}qU¢£¤Vwvqp]~
jYUFGgÀBy*OTUVm¼½RACBFGaVY\]~FDATDBVW>{p½oVFD&CBÔÕÖ×201(r)Yy*¹]4B{}qGo\]~zBoB Y pqTU89BÊËMNOR78 FR 3646 at 3678SY=pqqp]~ÐÔÕÖ× U©YzBMNOBEUÒVÓBoTÒ >B" =>?ÆUa>R*W>VWXSB@*UuTe»BuvBYGo¹]Us{}q B>ËEiY]ÓV \]z{UBoYTÒ89VR>uT
3Ê\]VUBaYopj¹]\qB89mBVuT#!hB´
BV" U@*uT2¹]º/½ºYººj¸UWXÓz{V|O}u~zBMNOBEUVT >B" =>?Æij?Ya>B@*¶Va4¼½]~}º}UDBVW>BFGaBmUFGgÀBy*OºjY¹]~ÐÔÕÖ× U©YzBMNOY=µ]ÒVÓBoBy*TzB B§
1.227(b)(3)Y=µ]VBy*{8i]{u~ § 1.227(b)(3)Y=µ]VBy*TU
R>uT3ÊBaYopj¹]89mBVuT#!hB´BV"U@*uT2¹uY89VR>uT3Ê\]BY o¹]~§
1.227(b)(3)Y=µ]y*TUFD&CBÔÕÖ×415B0Pw[xV\]Ey¹u~}º}U¶·B2 + ].UzBMNO*Àµj¹]UVY>]FG BRACB VCDEFGMnTU#VuT8i]!
hB´BV" U@*uT2¹uRACBFGgÀVBVm¼qp]º/½ºV ¸U6Pip{ yEY] µUZqUzBMNOBEÒVÓ
BoB8i]y*m6P{] µu~zBMNOY]CDEFGMnV.}q¡¾]UVY>]RACBFGYÈ    



33,\]89BrsBY pqTUH³}qpip~2010 ANPRMY¡\]¢£¤TUB>½iT| ¹qpiºu~ EYTURACBFGV½UV
m¼½FGgÀYÈ}U8CDEi''uT¼R3J, !i"%¢¤+=U, !i>L U,-i>LBÕ3)+Sm8 B {iu3VH³}
qpip~#VuT8i]!hB´BV" U@*uT2¹uRAC
BFGgÀVBVm¼qp]º/½ºV ¸Uz¹mqT]z{Y\]~FDATUgÀBMUFG¹] >B¿R3J¤ Y( }u>uT i/B¾i^UD VW>uT¾i/B$i^SUUB
FG>LB¿R3J¤ Õ3¤ U$BV B¤ ¬ÕuTbS=>?>BER3J B&UV B uT¤ U ¹
uB SVWXUV=>?BFGgÀB{UzBÔÕsY}p,B6Pw[xVy\]YzBm\]Y pq}qp]~ZqUzBMNO*Àµj¹]CDEFGMnTUVY>]FG Y
RACm \]z{VuvY6PTip{ yEY] µUB>½i89
Vz½}uPw[xB on(ºjY\]z{V|O}qp]~|OBYTUVm^G_UfGghuTkl_B V^}qp]º/½ºV¸UVBaY o¹]y]~FDATUVºj BFGTU
VTip^G_uTkl_m\]U}ufGghm¼½z{mp{}qp]~YUVm+BfGghY>]FGV\]R\iU^G_
B V^\Sz{m]~}ufGghY>]FGTUVY>]{U
T6 Y?UGo\]beTYiUFG>LT+YVÔÕ¶Go
¹]>L{\]z{mÅi]m5p~jYUT6 FGgÀTU
B(^VAB}uU( \]uvYBV½z{m]~fG
ghU^G_Ukl_BB.{,TUB>½iFGV !Y¼\]J,    



348iP]~VW>BFGY2D¼V /\]uvUg:TUY}uf
GghY3 ¹]MnVu1$2Vy}qp]RRef. 20S~g:B>>YÃÄ¾UzBMNOBPw[xTUVºjFG¹]RACYÈ}qUB>½ifG
ghY o\¾]{ yEY] µu~
FDATYUVY>]FG BRACB VuvYzBMNO*Àµj¹]CDEFGMnT6PTip{p½ yE] YÈ}qU¢£¤Vwvqp]~jYUTCSBDBVW9R3J4}Ua>¿STU"%¢¤+=B
Pw[xYzBMNOB on({\]&m]z{ºjUz½}u9VÒFGg
ÀÓBy*YWX¾ºUuBT/B>½iPw[xm !ºY pqU¢£
¤Vwvqp]~|OB§ 1.904TUÒbeÓVU3 Ï`abi/B V uUuTcd
bei/B=JVa\]7JFGÈUFGgÀYopj¹]4BV \]{y*\]~FDATU89BFGYopj¹]B]Uj]¿B`ab=>?cdBFGÈVRW}UB>½iFGÈm\qzBMNOBMyB¡P{i]z{V{\]uvUºiy*V|O}qp]~¤ T V
qpipmU¤ ÕY,]¹q89BFGYopj¹]YTUB¤ mFGÈB {}q\]uvU¤ Vbe{i\~YUc
dbeTÈb{,]¹qp]Ybe{i\~zBy*Y=µ]beB3TR
Ei4BTiÅU2010 ANPRMY¡\]¢£¤y¹uU89FGYopj¹]7JFGÈB¿VºY\]4B]~
D. be=>?FG>LR|O§ 1.906S|OB§ 1.906(a)TUFGgÀYopj¹]be=>?FG>LBUBY
opj¹]A=>?Bm !i4B]z{{UFG\]89mUFGgÀ
YU/B>½i ºjq4U,UÍ-UuTB B%8o    



35

Y iÅi]U]pT4ZY¡}q!{i]z{VuvUBGoEY#qÕ3)+m}\pz{VPw\]~
2010 ANPRMY¡}qj¹u¢£¤TUbe=>?FG>Lm+YUCD
Ei U=>?3Bg:=>?$hBÃ#VOu\>½Y j¹qp]{
¹qpu~3 ÏU]¢£¤TU¢ +BÃ#TUGoEB·8V \]z{{U + U¬ +U8+U¬+UÅ
¹=>?mmipz{mPw¹]{u~}º}Um ibe=>?F
G>LTUFG B89 B {i]~3 ÏUbeuTFG>LB89
B¢ +m8ipU]pT3 Ï8+uT¬+mD#qp]>½iUE Y>UuT89V8oY ip4B{\]z{
Y>U=ÕFG¹qp]89V \]mUBbeuTFG>LVBGoEY ip4B{\]z{Yi]~YU-YÕ3)+¾ipbe=>?FG>LTUFG B89 B
{i]~3 ÏUFGBYDB8uT8V(¹]uvYopj¹]
TUmB3B Y! D>i/B >4V3 \]Y>
U }qFGBYB2¾]VW>V(¹j¹]CD''Y\]z{m¾ipRRef. 21S~ZqUDB8uT8V(¹qopuYB2
¾]VW>V(¹]uvYop]TUBVW>B {i]mU
FDATUB>½iVUDB8uT8BFGYVW>BFG\]uvY
-YÕ3)+¾]{iip~|OB§ 1.906(a)TUB %{2010 ANPRMY¡\]¢£¤YÃÄ¾Ube=>?FG>LBYÈ}q89FGg:$¹qp]2D¼{}qp]{U yEY] µu~|OB§ 1.906(b)TUbe=>?FG>LY pqUFG\]89mUFGgÀ    



36

YU/B>½i ºjq4U,UÍ-UuTB B%8oYiÅi]U]pT4ZY¡}q!{i]z{V>½iCD''Y \]z{VPw\]~CD''m ¹ipbe=>?FG>LT89B B U
uTFG B  Y>q=m89Yl ¹] {i]RRef.
1S~3 ÏUFDATU>LmD/BlpBGoYÕ3)+¹iºuUzBm  Y>q/RdP89=SmB>L%Y¹]89Yl ¹]z{Y im]m]uvU=Õ89FGgÀYGo¹]>LU3 Ï*mU !iCD''Y ¹qp]{iip~|OB§ 1.906(b)TU  Y>q=m^Yl ¹]z{Vµ]uvY^g:0Å .Y¹qp]»{\]z{Y\]RRef. 22S~
YUFDATU2¬¤mU3 ÏUBm<<Yiqp]i/UËB¼¾#pqpip''YU89BR>V+}qBQsm,¹]
{iU89m+
¹]V5v]z{Yi]U !iCD''Y
¹qp]{iip~|OB§ 1.906(b)TU89 .Ô$Go¹]
2¬¤TyEYÕ3)+¹q­YGo¹]UuT-¹]{u2010 ANPRMY¡\]¢£¤BbB.U89FGg:$¹qp]2¬¤B¢¤+=£{4\]z{Y\]~jYU|OB§ 1.906(b)TU2¤110Y=µ]FDABCGMPMNR21 CFR part 110SR§ 110.40(a)=>?1ØÙSU89B>L=>?o B #ÊËV*Àµ]U89=>?@ABÊËMNOBCGMPMy{}qp]~BuvU|OB§
1.906(b)TU#>½YCD
BPw[xV89FGbe=>?>LY o\]~
B>½iPw[xT89VDW\]uvYGo¹]>L=>?o Yz¹ o¹q¾q=UuUz¹ºj4E¾F¾ o¹]ºj]~|OB§ 1.906(c)TUFG Y"%¢¤+=V}iµ¹Ï! D>B3i#    

37V ]B]89RrsV3\]UuT D>Y>]VuvY
¯"%¢¤+=V6P{\]j]89U3 ÏU8U8U*W9U
DB4}U"Ë¹qpip¾UuT"^SBFGgÀY
Go¹]be=>?>LY pqUB>½i D>B# V ip"%·Y
89V ¾]>½YUÊËU> \]z{V*Àµ]~©Yu>½YU
FDAT§ 1.904Y=pqUÒ! D>ÓBoYU_CDJ7PiU89V]U89m,i4B ¹qp]z{V \UuTB B%89V \]B] D>VWXz{V|O}qp]~!i"%·Y89V ¾]>½YUÊËUuTB B%> ¹qpipbe=>?FG>LBGoTUTCS89BFGYGo¹]U_BVE¾ z\z{m¾] D>B=VJ ]]^{iUB>½i89
B V4uj\m]~3 ÏU"%¢¤+=TU"Ë¹qpip¾ B+RSESUB BTCS89 B33Í $¤"U= " U=>?B B$i/UTCS89 B$B# V2$
Y ]uvYopj¹]RRef. 17SRRef.23SRRef. 24SRRef. 25SRRef. 26S~
zBV% }UFG YTCS89m \]z{VuvUyB"%¢¤+
=m6P]{ yEY] µ]~jYU !i"%·Y89V ¾]>½YUÊËUuTB B%
> ¹qpipbe=>?FG>LBGoTU D>Y>}\p89BF
GYGo¹]U89BV3¾UuUB>½i89B V4uj\m]~3 ÏUrsV3\]uvY"¹]89B YTUS"B
T3Umip4Bm]~z½}u"89TU$ip D>
B# Y>]89BVuvYFG TT&'\]6Pm]~3 ÏU"Ë}uÖ¤ ^RzB|Oop]zBoTUS"T3U^V    



38

WipSTU /i/B" ¹ip D>B#V¢¤+=\]uvU . B&'V6P{\]RRef. 27SRRef. 28S~zBV% }U D>Y>}\p89mFG Y \]z{VuvUyB"%¢¤+=m6P]{ yEY] µ]~FDA TU8 B*W9i/UrsV3\]uvY¯"%¢¤+=V6P{\]89Uij?Y"%ÊËm, !{ D>Y>}\p8
9mU&'BipbeU3 Ï&{$2¬Õi/U89V !i"%·Y \]uvBB B%B> 4iÅFG¹qp]z{Y pqU3
F}q²8Vkµ]UuTB B% j¹qp]RRef. 5SRRef. 6SRRef. 7S
RRef. 8S~! D>B# Vuv"%¢¤+=V6P{\]89BFGY
Go¹]&'BipbeuT>Lm|OB§ 1.906(c)Y \]{i¹]
BTU89V&''Y \]i/BVl(¹qp]ºU]pTU
3 Ï&{$2¬Õi/UB B%89V !i"%·Y \]> mi¹qp]Yj¹]~|OB§ 1.906(c)B0TU2¤110Y=µ]FDABCGMPMNR§ 110.80(b)(6)=>?1ØÙSU¹ ¹BMNB¡P{i]U! D>B3i# V ]
B]89VUMy¹]gÀ YB89B V"%Y3 z{V*Àµ]U89=>?@ABÊËMNO{}qp]~|OB§ 1.906(c)TU !i3
Ê"%BPw[xm89VDW\]Y=pqz¹ o¹q¾q=UuU
z¹ºj4E¾F¾ o¹]z{ºjUz½}uPw[xV89FGbe=>?>LY o\]~|OB§ 1.906(d)TUFG Y"%¢¤+=V}iµ¹Ï! D>B3i# V ]B]89BFGgÀYGo¹]beuTFG>LB0&
=>?EY&'¹]"'SYUS$#Y"%V \>½YL¹u    



39

 "%U"%y>LuT"% 0>LV ]z{V*Àµ]~zBPw[
xOTU^G_Ukl_uTfGghmUgÀ YS"V¬Õ\]z{Y>U|OB§ 1.908(a)(3)(iii)RÔÕÖ×III.E%SY*Àµj¹].UFGgÀ B"%VUBgÀm|OB§ 1.908(a)(3)BPw[xVOu}UFG Y89m }ipz{V3t\]J !]>½Y\]z{V{\]z{m¾]
V|\]~jYUzBPw[xOTU^G_m89V( XYUfGghBo}u0&=>?EY&'¹]"'SuTm|OB§
1.908(b)(4)RÔÕÖ×III.E%SY*Àµj¹]>½Y^G_m|§}u±²YZq&¹qp]z{VH¾]V|\]~uUzBPw[xOTUF
Grs%?V\]mU B%?YÈ\]0{ YUFGgÀm|OB§
1.908(a)(3)RÔÕÖ×III.E%SV q¹qp]º/½ºV \]
4|\]~|OB§ 1.906(d)B0TU2¤110Y=µ]FDABCGMPMNR§ 110.40(e)=>?
1ØÙSU! D>B# V ]z{m¾]89B'Í3ÊYopj¹]0&=>?EY&'¹]"'SYUS$#Y"%V \>½YL¹u "%U"%y>LuT"% 0>LV ]z{V*Àµ]U89=>?@ABÊËMNO{}qp]~BuvU|OB§ 1.906(d)TU89FG
be=>?>LB89"% >LY¡\]Pw[xVµ]~B>½iPw[xm89VDW\]Y=pqz¹ o¹q¾q=UuUz¹ºj4E¾F¾
o¹]ºj]~|OB§ 1.906(e)TUbe=>?FG>Lm!a>V]UuTB B%
 ¹UFGgÀ YU/B>½i ºjq4U,UÍ-U
uTB B%8oY iÅi]U]pT4ZY¡}q!{i]z{V»be=>?FG>LV3Ê\]z{V*Àµ]~3Ê Y!a>V]U    



40

uTB B% ¹ube=>?FG>LTU89BFGYGo\]YYÕ3)+¾ipUFG Y89V \]m]~3 ÏUFDA
TU893Ê -Y ¸"%BÇV$D]>½i»3Ê¹u¤ ¬ÕUcdbeUuT¢VU|OB§ 1.906(e)BPw[xVOu}qp]{iip~|OB§ 1.906(e)BPw[xTUCDEFGMnVbY}q=UFDATUz¹
jBPw[xmU }]·89mFG¹ipz{V3t\]uvY6P
]U{ yEY] µu~jYUzBMyB0TUÕ3)+Í
V ºj3.\]
Ba&>L89
B]4B=>?o TU89
=>?»3Ê\]z{V3 \]U2¤110Y=µ]FDABCGMPMNR§
110.35(e)=>?1ØÙS{}qp]~
E. FGgÀR|O§ 1.908S
1. +EPw[x|OB§ 1.908(a)TUFGgÀY o¹]+EiMy=>?Pw[xV \]~|OB§ 1.908(a)(1)TUY´BymipU|OB§ 1.908BPw[xmFG
gÀYZ[\]\qB^G_UfGgh=>?kl_Y o¹]{My\]~zB
MyV uBTU|OB§ 1.908BPw[xmY^G_Ukl_uTfGghBY o¹]VY¾UPw[xmz¹jB_\qY o¹]z{VbY\]uv]~|OB§ 1.908(a)(2)TUFGgÀm2¤OBPw[xB\qY }q
¹]z{V3t\] V!i Y q]z{V*Àµ]~|OB§1.908(a)(2)#¹]BTUFGgÀmz¹jBPw[xY }UFG B89B
V»¹]z{V3t\]uvU89FGgÀYZ[\]^G_U
kl_=>?fGghYUYzBMNOYÃÄpqOuiµ¹ÏijipPw[    

41xVy}U_=b*ÀV]z{]~zBMyTU89BU
UR>uT3ÊYÈ\]1BCGMPMNTÅFpq¾uMyR§ 110.10(d)=>?1ØÙS{U89=>?@Ae»BÊËOY=µ]Ð4EY}pMyV
1}q=Uz¹TMNBPw[x{B VÒ3t\]ÓR BMNOTÒ{\]ÓS V!i Y q]z{V*Àµqp]~|OB§ 1.908(a)(3)TU\qBFGgÀVUFG}qp]89mFGgÀ YU/B>½i ºjq4U,UÍ-UuTB B%8oY iÅi]U]pT4ZY¡}q!{i]z{VuvY6Pi=>?¢¤+=B·¼½z{V*Àµ]~zBMyOTUFGgÀ Y$D}] uT8CDEiB]^{}q8
9m }]{(¹]'Vqp]~3 ÏUÕ3)+m,-i=ÕbFG Y@Am1  ¹uUFDATU89ma>B4ZY¡}q!{i]z{VuvY6Pi=>?¢¤+=B·BFGgÀ
m¼¹iºu{i\~YUrsV3\]uvYFG Y&'V6P{\]¾i/B9mU ºi¦Y$GÔL¹uUFDATU
B89m_B4ZY¡}q!{i]z{VuvY6Pi=>?¢¤+=B·BFGgÀBkµlm¼¹iºu{i\~jYU9B&'m,-uuvY"Ë}uÖ¤ ^m}uUFDATU
B89m8oY iÅi]z{VuvY6Pi=>?¢¤+=B·
BFGgÀm¼¹iºu{i\~|OB§ 1.908(a)(3)(i)U(a)(3)(ii)=>?(a)(3)(iii)TUgÀm|OB§ 1.908(a)(3)BPw[x{ \]z{V{\]uvYFGgÀYZ[\]hm{jiµ¹ÏijipyBKLVy\]~|OB§ 1.908(a)(3)(i)TUFGgÀ Y89V#(^ BDB89=>?89¶
    



42

B9Y>] ºj@]uvY uT- i/B)^Ei¡Vl]z{V*Àµ]~FGgÀ Y89V#(^ BDB89=>?89¶B9Y>]ºj@]uvY)^Ei¡U3 ÏUDB89=>?B2¾]89B!i( i/V]{UDB8ºj B pu$BD 89Î]i/B'Y im]mU3.¹qpip89m,i4BU>4uT
D>i/B >4Y>q \]]^{4iºipRRef. 3SRRef. 5S~
89FGghTU#(^89=>?89¶B9VMy.rsYFG}qp]{d }uU2010 ANPRMY¡\]¢£¤mj¹u~#(^ B89¶
B9Y>] ºj89V !Y3.\]z{V{\]uvYg:m$q¾u>½i !iMnYYZqp]Uz¹TrsY ¹]{\]z½}u¢£¤YT\]~z½}uMnT2010 ANPRMY¡\]¢£¤Yj¹].Ug:$4]~3 ÏU BgÀTU89{#(^FG¹]89¶B9TU Y3Bip ¹u$Y(¹j¹qp]~z½}u89¶B9TUBU89¶B9oB2¬¤YLº¹]~´BgÀTU
89¶B9V$( Y(¹U89¶B9oB2¬¤JY+ (J]z{m]~89{89¶B9V#2¬¤Y(JU2¬¤JT89¶
B9V89B9B·YL¾U89¶B9Bm+VkµuU]pT
m,-iYB m89Y¹§ip>½Y\]gÀ4]~FDATU89¶B9mBR>Y>q ¹UbeuT§^¢$(^m !Yy¹qp]B¹ÏUz½}uMnmU|OB§ 1.908(a)(3)(i)Y*Àµj¹]>½YU ºj89V3.\]J)^E]{i\~u}U89¶B9m
89V \]]^{iºipU3.\]>½YR>¹qpipUuTy¹ip»be4}ÅT§^¢Î( ¹qp]89¶B9{89VFG\]z{TU|OB§ 1.908(a)(3)(i)m*Àµ]U89V ºj3.\]uvB    



43)^Ei¡Vl]z{Vqp]{i\~jYUÔÕÖ×III.D|OB§ 1.906(c)B %u>½YUDBa>89{
RTE89VFG\]¤ ¬ÕB, !i^(mUFG YU3 ÏDB8BmD
VW>Y]i/UY0 ]  VRTE89Y4uj\]^{i]z{Y pqU3F}q²8Vkµ]UuTB B% j¹qp]RRef. 4SRRef. 5SRRef.
7S~ 3 ÏUFDATUDBa>89Y>]RTE89Bm{i]»beuTa&¢Y( Xz{TU|OB§ 1.908(a)(3)(i)Y*Àµ]D89Y>] ºj89V3.\]uvY)^EiKLVlqpip{i\~|OB§ 1.908(a)(3)(ii)TUFGgÀYZ[\]hYU U- UuTpi/BB B*¡VlU=ÕbFG¹]89uTQsY¹q
pip89VFGgÀ B =>?  ºj3.\]z{V*Àµ]~
#Yj¹qp]89U(^Vl½hm \]B]89UuT
beY+\]89VFGgÀ B uT  ºj3.\]uvY)^EiKLVljip{U3.¹qpip89m,i4BU>44}ÅT D>
i/B >4UuT=Y>q \]]^{4iºip~FDA
TU89FGghm=ÕbB89=>?QsY¹qpip89VMy.
rsYFG}qp]{H³}qp]~zB[TU2010 ANPRMY¡\]¢£¤b¹]>½YUB>½i89BFGYopj¹]be=>?mÕ3)+
¹U89FGY|¹]{¾Y !iCD''Y]z{V{}U^B(AB} g UCDmopj¹]z{V{\]uvYg:m$$q¾u¼Y
 \]4B{% ]~}º}U§}uUuT=ÕFG¹]89mFG Y}ipz{VQsY{\]uvYTUFGgÀYZ[\]hmFGgÀYÈ
,\] BP 4% }iµ¹Ïijip{ yEY] µu~
3 ÏUFGBYQsY¹ipUB2¾]D VW>B^G    



44_TUB(^V3.\]uvYUQJBlvY>UFGgÀ YBÇ^V¼½yBfGghY¡}U^G_B^m(¹ubeY( XBT BD VW>uT YR>¹u9B{\]z{VPw\]º4}¹ip~|OB§1.908(a)(3)(ii)Y \]YTU^G_{fGghTUFG YDBVW>BVµ]uvUB>½i3.¡mY¹]>½Y}iµ¹Ïijip~
jYUQsY¹qpipD VW>VFG\]beBfCTU^AB}BYVl½z{m(¹]º4}¹ip~FG YUBfCmU2
Õ}u$B i/UbeB Y¡\]6PY j¹uUfCBT ¹uU ¹u}uº4}¹ip~B>½i'Y=pqUzBMyTU
lp Y89m ¹]VÂ\]uvUfCmVW>BVl
½YV½z{V*Àµ]~uU=ÕÕ+3¢Ö+¬*VFG\]&TUB(^Y8i]
fGghVG½z{mUB YTU/4FG\]4B{U¢Ö+¬*BV
FG\]4Bm]º4}¹ip~89=]/mFG Y  Y>
q¢Ö+¬*Yl ¹ip>½Y\]uvU^G_TU¹ ¹BfGghm
FG\](^0{Y8i]gÀVy}qp]m]~/4FG\]fGgh
VG½FGgÀY pqU^G_TU(qÅ]0Õ+3BfChY¬Ö«¬¤V| UYUbBfChYUÕ3)+BÕ+3
YÕÔ$¤Ö=Vj]z{m% j¹]~¢Ö+¬*BVFG\]fGghY pqTU¢Ö+¬*BFGoU0¹u%Õ3
)+V¼½Õ+3Bm|¹]{BfGghBQJB3tV\]z{V^G_Tº4}¹ip~^G_TUB>½iUFG B uT
 Y>q¢Ö+¬*m }ipz{V{\]uvB¡Vlu
YU|OB§ 1.908(a)(3)(ii)Y \]z{Yi]~FDATUCDEi»=Õ    



45FGgÀV¼½z{V \uvUÔÕÖ×III.E.4Y=pq}Åu|OB§1.908(d)(4)=>?(d)(5)U=Õb89VFG\]fGghmB(^{BBbeBÕ3)+Y pqB±²V^G_Y \]z{YÈ\]MyVµ]z{Y\]~|OB§ 1.908(a)(3)(iii)TUFG Y"%¢¤+=V}iµ¹Ï! D>B3
i# V ]B]89R|OB§ 1.906(c)B %Y=µ]3VØÙBz{SmU"%VWvU/B>½i ºjq4U89m,UÍ-U
uTB B%8oY iÅi]U]pT4ZY¡}q!{i]z{V»FG¹]z{V{\]z{V*Àµ]~89=>?@ABÐMNO=>?ÊËMNOBMyB#TUB {i] D>B# V¢¤+=\]¯"%¢¤+=V6P{\]89BF
GY¡\]UQEi»\]z{]~TCS89=>?, !i"%¢¤+=B·YLº¹]{ D>Y>]mz\p89BFG Y"%¢¤+=V \]7PY pqTUÔÕÖ×
III.D|OB § 1.906(c)B %Y=pqu~ÊËMNOBp¸¹ºB¡P{i]TCS89Y pqTUFG Y !i"%¢¤+=BV]{89rs;<ªV4uj}ºipB¹ÏU{/BUB89VUUR>U
uT3Ê\]B!hU>hUuTË_mU89BuvYB;<ª
B$DVÊËVy\] V ½R78 FR 3646 at 3737, 3744, and 3773; 78 FR
64736 at 64784S~ZqUÊËMNOBp¸¹ºB¡P{i]hTRz¹jBM
Nm21y¹u{¾SU|OB§ 1.908(a)(3)(iii){ \]uvYBhY6P{¹]KLVy}U¼\]z{V*Àµj¹]{U yEY] µu~
©Yu>½YU"Ë}uÖ¤ ^TU^BY" 
¹ipz{m]U$ip D>B# V¢¤+=\]uvY    



46. Y"%¢¤+=V6P{\]8TCS89B3]~B>½i89mU D>Y>]V z}U8oY iÅi]z{V"%B·Y3u¹ipU
B>½i89TFG Y \]m]~}º}U89m D>Y>]
V z\z{VuvY6Pi Ei"%TU89{B3ÊYÈ\]
BP B0 oY ¹U¹T-Y]z{ºjU D>Y>]89
VuvYFG YB>½i89V3uiµ¹ÏijipUºY o¾]"%Vyv]z{T,]~ZqU|OB§ 1.908(a)(3)(iii)B o¡P{i]8TCS89Y pqU Ei"%BPw[xByV|O}qpip~u}U|OB§ 1.908(a)(3)(iii)YÃÄ¾UÐMNOB o¡P{i]hTU! D>B# VuvU6PY#qUFGgÀ Y !i"%¢¤+=V}iµ¹Ïijip~ D>Y>]m z\pU3 Ï"Ë}u^i/
B8TCS89VU, !i"%¢¤+=B·FG\]z{Yi]FGgÀYZ[\]hTU|OB§ 1.908(a)(3)(iii)BPw[xVOu\z{Yij¸UFDATUFD&CBÔÕÖ×402(i)YÃÄ¾UCDE89FGMNY }ip·89mFG
¹qpu{p½Y=pqUB89m }qp]{i\m]~&89YÈ}qTU89Y*µuÊËMNOBÑR78 FR 3646 at 3774SY=
pqUFDATU&''Y ¹ipY&89mrsiÅi]"%=>?
TUB89Y7i94 V4uj\z{Yi]~&89m'? . Y q}½"%Yj¹]{p½ mu{Tp U89mrs
iÅi]z{Y&89mÈ,}u{p½'T*pqpipz{Y}u~Z
qUFDATU&89mTCS89]z{T{/ip{% ]{u~}º}U"Ë}u^BFGYÈ}q©Yu#% mU&89B
FGY4qT]~, !i"%¢¤+=UuT89m D>Y>}
], !i"%B·B&89BFGT|OB§ 1.908(a)(3)(iii)Y ¸UFDATU    



47BÔÕÖ×402(i)YÃÄ¾UCDE89FGMNY }ip·89
mFG¹qpu{p½Y=pqUB89m }qp]{i\m]~
2YU+Y"%¢¤+=·FG¹]89B YTU"%¢¤+=m¼¹ip4 \]3Õmip4Bm]~B>½i89B3TU
i/B^>U BE V j]uvY"%¢¤+=·FG
¹]~FDATUzBU BEµ+Y"%¢¤+=·FG¹]B B89VU"%¢¤+=V}iµ¹Ï! D>
B3i# V ]B]89{i¸UZqUz¹jB89T|OB§
1.908(a)(3)(iii)B o¡P{ijip~
2. ^G_Y o¹]Pw[x|OB§ 1.908(b)TUFGgÀYZ[\]^G_Y o¹]Pw[xV]~|OB§ 1.908(b)(1)TU^G_mfGghY¡}UfGghBbe=>?FG>LY pqU^G_m6P{i\ EiPw[x=>?Õ3)+VWvU\qB6PiCDPw[xV b }Ube=>?FG>LmU3 ÏU89m
FG Y/B>½i ºjq4U,UÍ-UuTB B%8oY iÅi]U]pT4ZY¡}q!{i]z{V>½iU89BFGY!iCD''Y]z{V{\]z{V*Àµ]~|OB§ 1.908(b)(1)TU^G_mfGghY|§\]±²m|OB§ 1.912(a)Y=µ] 0Pw[xB o¡P{i]z{4My\]~|OB§ 1.908(b)(1){ÐMNO B¿0\]Pw[xR\iU|OB§ 1.908(b)(3)U(d)(2)U(d)(4)=>?(d)(5)STUFGgÀYZ[\]»B[hºj »B[hÎB±²B|V½~FD&CBÔÕÖ×416(c)(1)(D)R21 U.S.C. 350e(c)(1)(D)STU
z¹jBMNV$\]YUTHR=>? Y>FDASTUYUfGghY¡}q89BFGV\]hmUuUghUfGghY>]89BFGVU
FD&C    



48

uT89BFGoYÕb4}ÅT=ÕbV|\]B BhY¡}q\¾±²YÈ}qTHm !{ \]MnVyviµ¹Ïijip{My}qp]~|OB§ 1.908(b)(1)TU89V \]89BFGV¼ipz{V{\]uvY6P{FDAmi\U^G_mfGghY \¾±²Y pqBPw[xVyvqp]~^G_{fGghY¡\]±² !Pw[xY pqTU¶·
BÔÕÖ×]~89FGg:BfGghT+YU89VFG\]be=>?FG>LB {#Y#EVopqp]~3 ÏU2010 ANPRMY¡\]¢£¤TU"%¢¤+=V6P{\]89BFGYÕ+3mGo¹]z{Y}qp]~z½}uÕ+3T.UyB89B"%m/B %J \]º¢¤+=\]gMY }qÍ¹qp]~jYU2010 ANPRM
Y¡\]¢£¤TU&'¹ipQsR>89BFGYGo¹] }u¤T½¾uTYY}uYU^(Y|¹]{qpu~u}UbeuTFG>LmyB89BFGY !iCD''Y]z{V{\]u
vB# Y6Pi EV^G_my\]'m]~3 ÏU ¹ipY(¹uD VW>B^G_TU(^V \]B]UB^Y>]'
VlY¾UË\]uvY&'¤ B#Ei2¬Ö {m6P{ \]º4}¹ip~@AB^G_TUY;o@AVf=ÕbV@ABFGYop]Y´i *&m6P{ \]º4}¹ip~
FDATU^G_mbe=>?FG>LY6PiCDPw[xVy\]z{TUYUyB¿B89U3 ÏUÏj^UuTQsY¹¸YFG¹]89
mbeuTFG>LYyB# V6P{\]m]z{V% \]{UfGghm|\]z{Yi]beuTFG>Lmy¹]FGgÀY !]z{V3t\]uvY,8]{U yEY] µu~|OB§ 1.908(b)(1)TU    



49

zB V^G_Y q]mU¹TUbeuTFG>LmFGgÀY !iC
D''Y]z{V{\]uvU3 ÏUÕVY\]i/UyBV]z{V6P{\]B]UuTUfGghY>]U3 ÏUyBb
i/UyB# KLV6P{\]B]UFGyB89BV ]J^G_m2 iY]{U yEY] µuºj]~jYU^G_m
Ybe=>?FG>LY6PiCDPw[xVy}UfGghmgÀoBbeu
TFG>LB ?# Y6PiKLV¾]>½Y\]uvYUzB±²Vf
GghY  ]z{V^G_Y*Àµ]z{m6P]{U yEY] µu~2010 ANPRMY qj¹u¢£¤YÃÄ¾U^G_=>?fGghTUg:
B2D¼YZpUYbeUFG>LU=>?Õ3)+BPw[xY p
q±² V}qp]{3¹]~ZqU|OB§ 1.908(b)(1)mU89FGg:$
\Y+E]z{¶JB¾i)VP\]{T% j¹ip~
be=>?FG>Lm89BFGY|¹]{¾Y !iCD''Y]z{V
{\]7PV% }U|OB§ 1.908(b)(1)TU^G_m y\]be=>?FG>LBCD''BPw[xm|OB§ 1.912(a)BRÔÕÖ×III.GuS
0Pw[xB o¡P{i]z{4My\]~|OB§ 1.908(b)(2)TUQsY¹qpip89VUfGghm|\]beuT§^¢i/BFG>LY( XYUBfGghm|}ube
uTFG>LV^G_mY pq9%?}UBbeuTFG>Lm89
BFGY !iCD''Y]º/½º }iµ¹Ïijip{yv]~|O ¹]UÒ89BFGY !iCD''Ó{i¹]3TUbeuTFG>LYU89V \] {i]U!a>B(U UB(^UuTi/
BY0 ]t&mipz{]~    



50ÐÔÕÖ×Y=µ]|OB§ 1.908(a)(3)(ii)YÈ\]©B %TUQsY
¹¸UBuv#ºjBE Yj¹]89V ºj3.\]uvYFGgÀ Y)^EiKLV\]6PY pqu~B>½i3.TU]%U89mFG¹]be=>?FG>Lm !iCD''U§}u89B
{ijipz{V{¾]º/½ºY ¹]~|OB§ 1.908(b)(2)Y*Àµj¹]>½YUfGghm|}ubeuTFG>LVU( Y^G_
mY pq9%?}U89BFGY !iCD''Y]º/½º \]z
{TUFGgÀmCDEFGMnYZq¼¹]z{V{\]uvY6P]{ yEY] µ]~2010 ANPRMY qj¹uB¢£¤U( B9%?m+EYFGgÀ¼¹qp]{¹qpu~89$IghºjB¢£¤TUB>½i%?Y=pqU3 ÏUº?Uº?Ua>B U-i*UU!a>Y>] BjºB}]}UuT'U ¹4}ÅT89m ¹]B]{i]¤ `BB B8V }u¤ TU+YU89BFG
Y !iCD''Y]{Ti¹ip{¹qpu~|OB§ 1.908(b)(3)TUFG Y"%¢¤+=V}iµ¹Ï! D>B3
i# V ]B]89B^G_YU¹mTCS89¹U8TCS89
¹UÕ89VFG\]fGghVYÅfGghY¡}UBgÀ"%
m ¹U|OB§ 1.908(a)(3)BPw[xmOu¹]z{V{\]uvU&VWvuFGgÀ Y6Pi"%V b \]z{V*Àµ]~|OB§ 1.908(a)(3)(iii)Y pqB %©Yu.U!i D>B# Y>
q89mrsiÅi]z{VUuT!Tip D>B# VuvU
i¿B89mFG Y"%¢¤+=V6P{\]~B>½i89B^G_
TU+YUFG Bz½}u89B"%¢¤+=B6PY pq }qp]z    



51{m'¹]~3 ÏU§ 118.4(e)Y=µ]DWU'=>?FG B¾BSE
*Y*µuMNU=>?§ 115.50(b)(2)Y=µ]$I .oY3Ê¹]¾B&'Y*µuMNTUV45ºFR7ºCS¶·B"%3Ê>TFG\]z{V*Àµqp]~^G_mfGghYU&VWvuFGgÀ Y6Pi"%Y pqb \]z{TU89Y !i"%V \]{p½gÀm|OB§ 1.908(a)(3)BPw[xVOu\z{V{\]uvY6PU^G_YTFGY|¹]89Y
pq24ÅB ³{±²m]z{ºjU6Pi"%Vy\] ]J^G_m2 iY]{ yEY] µ]~u}UÕY>]89B§^TUyB89B"%m/B %J \]º°\]>½YÕmÍ¹qp]uvU^G_mB>½Yb \]z{T6PiÅU^G_T|O
B§ 1.908(b)(1)BPw[xYÃÄpqUB>½ibeB6PVb \]z{4U 
q yEY] }u~uU^G_mfGghY z¹V ]>½*Àµ]z{U^G_m89Y¡\]z½}u"%Pw[xV% }UfGghY¹VbY UfGghTFGgÀY=pqy¹u"%V\]z{m¾]{4U
yEY] µu~^G_mfGghY|\]±²Y>qU|OB§ 1.906(c)=>?§ 1.908((a)(3)(iii)YÈ}qÔÕÖ×III.D=>?ÐÔÕÖ×Y=pqq¾u89Y pqB%
{\]UFG\]89B !i3Ê"%my¹]z{V'\]~89u
TAY pqBÊËMNOB o¡P{i]^G_TUFG Y"%V !Y¢¤+=}iµ¹Ï89mrsiÅi]U/B>½i89Y pq4U !i3Ê"%V ]z{Yi]~#}Å"%V¢¤+=}iµ¹Ï D>Y>q}\p8TCS89Y
pqTU|OB§ 1.908(a)(3)(iii)Y pqB %Y=pqÐÔÕÖ×©Yu.U    



52

D>Y>]89Y\]P Bi0 oBuvU|OB§ 1.908(a)(3)(iii)=>?(b)(3)B o¡P{i]8TCS89Y pqU Ei"%Pw[xByV|O}qpip~|OB§ 1.908(b)(3)TUB>½i89B^G_TU D>B#
Y>9m }ipz{V{\]uvY6Pi"%B YÃÄÅU
B89B"%¢¤+=Pw[xVfGghY. \]z{Yi]~2010 ANPRMY qj¹u¢£¤YÃÄ¾Ug:B2D¼YZpU^G_
TUYFGgÀY=pq6Pi"%Y pqfGghY. \]{Ë\]~ZqU|OB§ 1.908(b)(3)TU89FGg:$\Y+EY¹qp]){\]¾]~
89m !i"%¢¤+=·Y ¹qp]z{V{\]7PV%}U^G_TU 0V.}qUfGghY¡}U3 ÏUFGQY=pq89Y6P
i"%V y}qp]z{Vt¾]¾]U{ yEY] µ]~0TU^G_{fGghBÈBn($U89m }ipz{V{\]uvUFGgÀ Y6Pi"%¢¤+=B Y !im¹qp]z{Vt\]~|OB§ 1.908(b)(3)TU^G_mfGghYFGgÀ Y89Y6Pi"%
Y pq y\]z{m|OB§ 1.912(a)RÔÕÖ×III.G%SB 0P
w[xB o¡P{i]z{4My\]~|OB§ 1.908(b)(4)TU89V( X
YUFG Y"%¢¤+=V}iµ¹Ï! D>B3i# V ]B
]89B^G_TU0&=>?EY&'¹]"'SuT¢mU|OB§ 1.908(b)(3)Y>qwvj¹].Y^G_m|§}u±²YZq&¹qp]z{V%t}iµ¹Ïijip{Pw\]~
ÔÕÖ×III.DY=µ]|OB§ 1.906(c)=>?§ 1.908(a)(3)(iii)B%UTCS8
9=>? D>Y>q}\pB B89Y pqUz½}u¿B89mrsiÅi]UuTB B% \]z{m}qip>½UFG Y"%¢    

53¤+=V\]7PY pqu~ !i"%¢¤+=BTU]%U89V( Xbe=>?¢B !i&Y ¹]z{m]~&'¤ Y89V( X !Y&¹qpipU89B"%mJ }U&'>LmB89VY ½"%Y&\TUB89BrsCDEiFG
V{\]uvY6Pi=¶J{i]m]~ZqU|OB§ 1.908(b)(4)
TU^G_Y¡}U( YbeuT§^¢B&V%t}qU89V
}ºip}q89VFG}ipz{V*Àµ]~2010 ANPRMY qj¹u¢£¤YÃÄ¾Ug:B2D¼YZqU^G_Y>]&'be=>?¢B&B%tTUFGgÀY=pq+EY¼¹qp]{3¹]Ru}UB>½i%t¬ÕBUªm pqp]{¾U3ÏUU*-+\]B]$'ªR>i/B B*- VuvU&'>Lm Yiqp]º4}¹ipU{3¹]S~Z
qU|OB§ 1.908(b)(4)Y>^G_Y¹]Pw[xmU89FGg:$\Y+E]z{¶JB¾i)VP\]{T% ip~|OB§ 1.908(b)(5)TU|OB§ 1.908(d)(2)(ii)RÐÔÕÖ×\]SYZqUFGgÀ Y89mYY ½"%Y3u¹]z{Y pq^G_m V½z{Y^G_{fGghm }qp]Ukl_Yt\]z{YÈ}q|OB§ 1.908(d)(2)(i)RÐÔÕÖ×\]SY=pqfGghY o¹]Pw[xV^G_m½{My\]~|OB§ 1.908(b)(5)TU|OB§ 1.908(d)(6)(ii)=>?
|OB§ 1.912(c)R#ÅÐÔÕÖ×\]SYÃÄpqfGghY o¹]U¡\] 0Pw[xV^G_m½z{4My\]~hTUfGghm^G_YUuUPcm¹Ïkl_Y¡}q4U^G_my}u{}u"%VfGghmFGgÀ Y }uz{Vt\]U|OB§ 1.908(d)(2)(i)Y=µ]Pw[xY pqBÐÔÕÖ×B %VØÙ\]z{~|O    



54

B§ 1.908(d)(2)(ii)TU^G_m"%B )3+Y V ½UuTB
B%FGgÀ Y89mÃ#VOu\"%B·Y ¹uz{V3t\]z{YUfGgh{^G_m FGgÀBY}qp]UfGghYzBP
w[xB oVXY\]~|OB§ 1.908(d)(2)(ii)¡¹]'Y=pqU3 ÏU^G_m3}ucd
be$B&'>LBfCV¢¤+=\]&'bB§^UÐMNOYÃÄpqÐ
#TfGghY qj¹] V^G_m½U|OB§ 1.908(b)(5)TU^G_mUPcm¹Ïkl_Y¡}UÐ#TfGghm|\]T¸By¹utV¼½z{4*Àµj¹]{b \]~|OB§ 1.908(b)(5)TU|OB§ 1.908(d)(6)(ii)=>?|OB§ 1.912(b)YÃÄpqÐ#TfGghY o¹]T¸BU¡\] 0
Pw[xV^G_m½z{4b \]~zB>½YU|OB§ 1.908(b)(5)TU^G_mUÐ#TfGghm ½T¸B V^G_mqp]'Y=pqUÐ#TfGghmÐ#qpuT¸BPw[x{#Ukl_Y±²V|\]Pw[x=>?¡\] 0Pw[xB o¡P{i]z{V{\]~3. ^G_=>?kl_Y o¹]Pw[x|OB§ 1.908(c)TUFGgÀYZ[\]^G_{kl_»Y o¹]Pw[xVyv]~|OB§ 1.908(c)(1)TU(AB} g UQsY¹qpip89Vl
½{(¹]befChm  *V upV o¾]>½Y\]z{V^G_=>?kl_Y*Àµ]~z¹TU  *V upV|\]z{Y>UfChBm89B Yijipz{V{\]~ÐÔÕÖ×Y=pqU©Y|OB§ 1.908(a)(3)(ii)B %u>½YUQsY
¹qpip89VFG\]beBfCT^AB} YVl½{(¹]z{m]~3 ÏUFG YfCm$V }iµ¹ÏijiºuU    



55

fCBT ¹UuT ¹qUlp Y89m ¹]V
Â\]uvYfCmVW>BVl½YV½z{m6P{i]~|OB§ 1.908(c)(1)TUfChBm89B Yijipz{V{\]uvU
fCmFG¹qp]89Vl½{(¹]YT !ipV|
\]z{V^G_uTkl_Y*Àµ]~|OB§ 1.908(c)(1)TFDAB1BCGMPMN{}Uz¹YW¹]YÈ\]MyTU89Y+}qÅhmCDMnR§ 110.10(b)U(b)(3)=>?110.37(e)ij?Y1ØÙSY }iµ¹Ïijip{}qp]~z¹jBCDMnYTU
}qVpU6PY#q}qU! D>Y>] Vz{R§110.10(b)(3)SmW¹]~zBMNYTUm o¾iµ¹Ïijipp
VuMy4W¹]R3 ÏU§ 110.37(e)ØÙS~jYU89{@ABp¸¹BÊËMNOY4UpY pqBCDMymW¹]~3 ÏUeÊËMNOBCGMPMyU !º  U !i"%B *V uV|\]z{Y>UZgBm89RuT@ASU89
UuT89R>AB
{ijipz{V{\]>½Y¹upV|\]z{V0Y*Àµ]Ã#Vyv]R78 FR 3646 at 3723; 78 FR 64736 at 64774S~|OB§ 1.908(c)(2)TUFG Y"%¢¤+=V}iµ¹Ï! D>B3
i# V ]B]89B^G_=>?kl_YU89mB>½i D>B# V ip>½Y\]B·(AB} gV¼½z{V*Àµ]~"%Ê
Ëm, !iU! D>B3i# V ]B]89TU89BV
E¾ z\z{m¾] D>B=VJ ]UuTU\]z{_4}
ÅTa>BVE¾ z\ D>V# ]B]V ]z{m]~2010 ANPRMY¡\]¢£¤B YTU B§^=>?klBª¬8+ 3
T"% )3+m¼¹]{u4Bmu»U]¢£¤TU    



56

B>½i"% )3+m&'?&89B(AB} g UY¹q
Tpip{}qpu~}º}imjU"%¢¤+=m¹qpip(AB} 3
V.\]z½}u89BaTU89B"%Y V}ºipB·
89mTYuq3Ê¹iµ¹ÏUB89Y B3ÕV4ujip{UFDAT yEY] µu~u}UFDATU"%¢¤+=V}iµ¹Ï!
D>B3i# V ]z{m¾]89VUÇ^my¹]U"%¢¤+=m¹qpip^(ª¬Õ# Í3Ê\]z{VU|OB § 1.908(c)(2)YÃ
ÄÅUB>½i89Y¹]lp¼{iip~J BTU89V[\>TB B% \] {i]ºj]~
4. fGghY o¹]Pw[x|OB§ 1.908(d) TUFGgÀYZ[\]fGghY o¹]Pw[xVyv]~|OB§ 1.908(d)(1)TU|OB§ 1.908(b)(1)YZq^G_my}uPw[xVOu}UFGgÀ YU/B>½i ºjq4U89m,UÍ-U
uTB B%8oY iÅi]U]pT4ZY¡}q!{i]z{VuvYB B !iUbe=>?FG>LV|\]z{VfGghY*Àµ]~ÐÔÕÖ×Y=pqU©Y|OB§ 1.908(b)(1)B %U^G_mfGghY¡}U
fGghm|\]z{Yi]beuTFG>Lmy¹]FGgÀY !
]z{V3t\]uvYbe=>?FG>LY6PiCDPw[xVy\]7P
Y pqu~^G_TUFGyB89BUbeuTFG>LmFGgÀ
Y !iCD''Y]z{V3t\]uvU=>?FG Y89m }ipz{
V3t\]uvYfGghml]¾ EiKLV24>Å qp]uvUz½}
uPw[xVy\]J2 ]{ yEY] µu{u~89BFGY|¹u{¾Y !iCD''YipbeTFG Y {i]uvU^G_my}uCDPw[xVOu}UB B89BCDEiFG    



57

Y !ibe=>?FG>LVfGghm|\]FG Y89m }ipz{
V3t\]J z{4}Å7P]{U yEY] µ]~ZqU|O
B§ 1.908(d)(1)TU|OB§ 1.908(b)(1)YZq^G_my}uPw[xVOu}UFGgÀ YU/B>½i ºjq4UFG¹qp]89m,UÍ-UuTB B%8oY iÅi]U]pT4ZY¡}q!{ijipz{V3t\]z{VWvU89BFGY !i''Y]beV|\] VfG
ghY ]~
3 ÏUfGghm@ABFGoB=ÕbV^(Y|\]YUbem
Y;o@ABFGYopj¹UBbeºj;o@AB'VlYÅuvY^G_myvu YVfGghm}qpiºuUfGghTzBMyOY}qp]{i¹ip~|OB§ 1.908(d)(2)TUÐÔÕÖ×©Yu|OB§ 1.908(b)(3)B o¡P{i]89B"%¢¤+=B YÈ,\]fGghÎBPw[xVyv]~|OB§ 1.908(d)(2)(i)TUFGgÀmQ}uU^G_YUuUPcm¹Ï
kl_Y¡}q4U|OB§ 1.908(b)(3)YZq^G_my}u{}u"%
VFGgÀ Y }u{t\]z{VUfGghY*Àµ]~|OB§1.908(d)(2)(i)TjYUzBtTfGgh{^G_m¾] !iY>
q ¾]{My\]~3 ÏUfGghTU¯"% 0>LB*3¤¤
uTFG Biu"%yB 0V| \]z{m¾]~|OB§ 1.908(b)(3)B %u>½YU&VWvuFGgÀ Y6Pi"%V^G_mfGghYy\]z{TUgÀ Y89B !i"%B V
{\]uvY7P]~ZqU|OB§ 1.908(b)(3)TUfGghYzByV¼½z{V^G_Y*Àµ]~2010 ANPRMY qj¹u¢£¤YÃÄ¾U^G_{fGghT|OB§ 1.908(b)(3)m*Àµ]¿B±²V¦EY }q=    



58

UjYU¢=ªB BuvYg:B2D¼m3¹q¾u{3¹]~}º}imjU !i"%¢¤+=B84TUERG²8Eo¹u89B,!i"%¢¤+=Y pqBU#}p"%¢¤+=i}FG¹]
89Y pqkµlFµq¾u²8mb \].U89FGY=µ]E ]RRef. 3SRRef. 4SRRef. 5SRRef. 6SRRef. 7SRRef. 8SRRef. 9S~z½}uYÙj}UFGgÀ Y"%m#}Å¢¤+=¹iµ¹Ï \]º4}¹ip89mÃ#VOu\"%B·FG¹uz{Y pqUfGghm^G_Yt}iµ¹Ïijip£#)VWXz{V|O\]~|OB§ 1.908(d)(2)(i)
TUFGgÀmQ}uU^G_my}u{}u"%VfGghmFG
gÀ Y }u{UfGghm^G_Yt\]z{V*Àµ]~|OB§ 1.908(d)(2)(i)TUjYUfGghm¼½¾tTfGgh{^G_m¾] !i ¾]{My\]~zBMyTUfGghmUBg:
¼YZq8i]»zBtV¼½z{mHvj¹]~3 ÏUTCS89B^G_{BY>UfGghTUFGgÀ BbeB¢2¤£¤"%V )
\]uvYlµu 0>LVGo}qU )3+±²V^G_Y|\]z{m¾]~]pTU^G_{BY>UfGghTU¢2¤£¤"%V
¾++Y 0}UB++V^G_Y|}q4>p~
FG Y"%¢¤+=V}iµ¹Ï! D>m3Y# }\p89B!i"%¢¤+=TUfGghm6Pi"%¢¤+=V}ip{Ukl_m }u89VkµlUBU2huTB BY¹V|\]]^{iºipz{ºjUkl_Y{q47P]~ZqU|OB§
1.908(d)(2)(i)TUfGghmUkl_ºjPcm¹ÏUkl_Y¡}U^G_my}u{}u"%VfGghmFGgÀ Y }uz{Vt}iµ¹
    



59Ïijip{b \]~FDATUyB'Y=pqUFGgÀ Y89mÃ#VOu\"%B·Y
¹]z{V3t\] V^G_m½m]RRef. 20S{H³}qp]~
B>½iU|OB§ 1.908(d)(2)(ii)TUFGgÀY©UFGgÀ B"%
)3+uTB B%FGgÀ YB89mÃ#VOu\"%B·
Y ¹qpuz{V3t\] V^G_m½z{YfGgh{^G_m
}qp]UfGghT|OB§1.908(d)(2)(i)BPw[xB o¡P{ijip{My\]~3 ÏUfGgh{BY>U^G_m`&B"% )3+>L
VbeYlµU89V}uB>LVÆ\]lvV\]>½im]~´B3TU%6 FG¹]yB"}u^B^G_mUR1Sbem!Y&¹qpuz{VH\]( B%?{UR2S}ukl_
m¼½89B%?Yqp]º4}¹ip~zBlvTUzB89mÃ#VOu\"%B·FG¹uz{m3t¹]{^G_m }uUfGg
hm^G_YtV¼½z{B,O{i]~zB>½YU|OB§ 1.908(d)(2)TU^G_m"%B )3+Y V ½U
uTB B%FGgÀ Y89mÃ#VOu\"%B·Y ¹uz{
V3t\]z{YUfGgh{^G_m }qp]VY¾UfGghm^
G_By}u"%VOu}uz{VfGghm^G_Yt\] V ½U
UBg:¼{¿0\]i£#)Vyv]~|OB§ 1.908(d)(2)(ii)TUjYUPcm¹Ïkl_YÑ¹uV|
\]z{VfGghY*Àµ]~zBMyTU|OB§ 1.908(d)(2)(i)Y*Àµj¹]tVfGghm¼½z{Vkl_mPc\]YUFGgÀ Y89mÃ#VOu\"%B·Y ¹qpuz{V3t\] V^G_mqpuz{V    



60

fGghmkl_Y. \]oEiVyv]~|OB§ 1.908(b)(5)YÈ}qÐÔ
ÕÖ×©Yu>½YUB>½i'TU|OB§ 1.908(d)(2)(i)Y=pqÐ#TfGghY o¹]Pw[xV^G_m½~fGgh{^G_{BY>UÐMNOYÃÄpqÐ#TfGghY qj¹] m^G_ÎC¹]z{ºjUzBT {\¾UV
{\]z{V*Àµ¹Ï BCm !YÑ¹]{ yEY] µUB>½Y|OB§ 1.908(d)(2)(ii)Yyvu~|OB§ 1.908(d)(2)(ii)TUjYUÑ¹uTÐ2¤B§ 1.912(b)B 0Pw[xB o¡P{i]{yvqp]~|OB§ 1.908(d)(3)TU"%¢¤+=V}iµ¹Ï! D>B3i# V
 ]B]89BFGY&'>L¾BbeuTFG>LV|\]YUfGghT|OB§ 1.908(b)(3)YZq^G_my}u>½YEY&'¹]0&=>?"'SV&}iµ¹Ïijip{Pw\]~ÐÔÕÖ×Y=µ]|OB§ 1.908(b)(3)B©B %U&VWvuFGgÀ
Y6Pi"%VfGghYy\]z{V^G_Y*Àµ]z{TBgÀ
m89Y !i"%B YÈ}q|OB§ 1.908(a)(3)VYOu\uvY6P
u{\] yE] Y pqu~^G_TU!i D>B# Y>q89m }ipz{V3t\]uvYFGyB89B"%¢¤+=Pw[xV]J2 iY]z{ºjUz½}uPw[xVy¾]~ZqU|OB
V^G_Y § 1.908(b)(3)TUz½}u"%V fGghYy\]]~beuTFG>Lm !Y&¹qpip{U( Y D>B# V¢¤+=\]uvY6Pi"%V ]/89B"%mJ ]]^{i]~ZqU|OB§ 1.908(d)(3)TUfGghY¡}U"%¢¤+=V}iµ¹Ï!
 D>B3i# V ]B]89BFGY&'>L¾Bbe    



61

uTFG>LV|\]YU|OB§ 1.908(b)(3)YZq^G_my}u>½Y
EY&'¹]0&=>?"'SV&\]z{V*Àµ]~zBMyO
TUEY&'¹]0&=>?"'SY>q89B"%¢¤+=V\]beuTFG>LBY o¹]mUBËTUEi&'¶B
89B"%¢¤+=V \]beuTFG>LU3 ÏU=Õ
Õ+3i/BU( Y89B"%¢¤+=V{\]uvY&V6P{}ipºj]~
2010 ANPRMY qj¹u¢£¤YÃÄ¾Ug:BfGghTUg:B2D
¼YZpU U"%¢¤+=¹]89BFGY|\]yBbeV&\]{3¹]~ZqU|OB§ 1.908(d)(3)Y>qfGghY¹]Pw[xmU
89FGg:$\Y+E]z{¶JB¾i)VP\]{T% j¹ip~|OB§ 1.908(d)(4)TU89FGY=ÕbV|\]fGghYUBbeFG}u3B>Vy\]±²V^G_Y|\]z{V*Àµ]~z¹TU^
G_{fGghmFGgÀY©UfGghm3NOB>Vy\]±²V|
\]z{UuTU|¹]=Õbmy¹]FGgÀY !]{3t\]myvj¹qp]U3 ÏQY>qfGghm1¿B9BFGo
B=ÕbBV|\]YTUfGghmB>½i±²V|\]6PTipz{Y ¾]z{VY¾UFDAmË\]1¼Bg:¼{\]~zB
MyY pqTU|OB§ 1.908(d)(5)BbBY]~|OB§ 1.908(d)(4)TUÑ}um|OB§ 1.912(b)B 0Pw[xB o¡P]z{4yv]~|OB§ 1.908(d)(5)TU89FGY=ÕbV|\]fGghY¡}U=Õb
B+BÕ3)+Y pqu±²V^G_Y|\]z{V*Àµ]~u}U|¹]=Õbmy¹]FGgÀY !]z{V3t\]m    



62

¹qp]U3 ÏUy¹uy¹uÕ3)+Vop]z{
YfGghmQ}qp]UuTU89V=ÕbY( XY^G_
m`&beBÕ3)+V¼½YTU^G_{fGghmFGgÀY©
UfGghmB>½i±²V|\]6PTipz{Y ¾]U{}qp]~|OB§ 1.908(d)(5)TUÑ}um|OB§ 1.912(b)B 0Pw[xBo¡P]z{4yv]~
2010 ANPRMY¡\]¢£¤TU89=>?@AB=ÕFGV½FGgÀY
=pqU^G_{fGghT+YU=Õbm|¹]{¾YBgÀY }qp]z{V{\]uvU±² \]{¹qpu~Y>qTU>V \] {i]UuTBgEY V\>½i%`&B>YV( ]B]4B4Bº/½º \]uvU^G_T=ÕbFG¹uB>Y pq ]6Pm]º4}¹ip~uU^G_TUopj¹uÕ3)+m`&9BFGoY=ÕbV# \]J !uº/½º\]uvU=ÕbBÕ3)+m/B>½Y¼¹uºY pq4 ]6Pm
]º4}¹ip~ÐÔÕÖ×|OB§ 1.908(b)(1)B %Y=pq}u.U@AB=ÕFGTUY;o@AVFG}u=ÕbYUy¹u Ym¹qp]3tV]6Pm^G_YT]º4}¹ip~&B/9¶B89B=ÕFGD#]B]^G_{fGgh{B¢% )«Ö×VP\]'TUY/VFG}ubem  V.}
q/9¶B89Y=Vl ipz{V3t\]6Pm]~ÐÔÕÖ×Y=µ]|OB§ 1.908(a)(3)(ii)B %u>½YU=ÕfGghm/VF
G\]uvYbeVGqp]º/½ºY>qU^G_T=Õbm`&9BFG
Y }qp]º/½ºVH\]uvY8i]Vop]z{m¾]~3 ÏUfGghm39U3 Ï^BFGoBbeBV|\]U^B^G_TU    



63

B9VbeY( XY=ÕbBB>muBºU ]6PTip~}º}UBfGghm2U#^G_Y|¹]=Õb/VFG}uUB=ÕbY'qp]º4}¹ip/B'm=ÕbBBB>V \]m]~^G_TUfGghºjU/mFG¹uz{V ]6Pm]º4}¹ip}UuUBÕ++Y¼u+BÕ3)+Y pq±²
V6P{\]º4}¹ip~
YTU=ÕfGgh{^G_T+YUB>{Õ3)+YÈ}U.
TQJBlvV.}q0Ykµ(¹j¹]V}U=Õbm|
¹]FGgÀY }qp]z{V3t}qp]~B>½ilvTUyB9B
FGB2DMnVyvuU=ÕFGY*µug:BYÃÄpqp]z{m]RRef. 22SRRef. 29S~z½}uTUyB9BFGYobeBGomwv]U
]pTUobeBGom6PipYB>{}qi4BVy\]z{m]~z½}uTUÃ#VOu\U=ÕbBÕ3)+V½z{4]~^G_{fGghm+YUBFGgÀY©U0Ykµ(¹j¹]=Õ
FGBV}qp]»UB>½im¹¸UFG Y89m }ipz{V3t\]J=ÕbB''m !]{t\]uvYU=Õbm|¹]^G_mfGghºj=ÕbBB>{Õ3)+YÈ
\]±²Viµ¹Ïijip[34]º4}¹ip~
B>½i'Y¡\]uvUCDE89FGMNTU^G_Y|\]=ÕbY pqUB>Vy}UÕ3)+Vb\]±²V^G_Y|\]z{VfGghY*Àµ]¾]{ yEY] \]~uUUB¼{}uV4u]uvUzBMNOTU=Õbmy¹]FGgÀY !
]{3t\]6PmipTzB±²B uT\qB Vi}\    64]z{Y^G_{fGghm 0Y¾]>½Y\]¾]{4U
yEY] \]~
3 ÏU^B^G_{fGghTUfGghm^FGoB=ÕbBV|\]z{Y}qp]T=ÕbBB>Y pq^G_Y±²V|\]6Pmipz{Y 0Y¾]~YU^G_m !{i\=ÕbBÕ3)+Vop]z{YfGghmQY>q\]Ue[hTU|OB§ 1.908(d)(5)YÃÄ¾UbeBÕ3)+Y pq^G_Y±²V|\]6
Pmipz{Y \]z{m¾]~|OB§ 1.908(d)(4)YÃÄ¾UfGghm|\]±²TU=ÕbFG¹u3
B>Vy\]~FG Y89m }ipz{V3t\]J=ÕbB''m !]z{V^G_Yt\]YT3B>Y pqB±²-{U yEY] }u~zB yE] m] %&{}u2Bg:1$2ÑTU^
g:{,-p89g:B4BUzYT^G_mfGghºj=ÕbB
3B>Vy\]±²V(\]|OmW¹qp]RRef. 22SRRef. 29S~
uUFDAmFSIS{§0}u1996 ANPRMR61 FR 59372 at 59379SY=pqU=ÕFG¹]EY[\i89RTCS89Yopj¹qpuSBfGghY¡}U89BFGYGo\]uvY89B^G_Y|¹]pºi]FGÈY p
q4U3B>Vy\] 0V^G_Y|\]z{V*Àµ]º/½ºU%}qpu{uY4\]~}º}U2010 ANPRMY¡\]¢£¤TU
89FGg:B BÔÕU3 ÏU@AFGÔÕi/Y=pqTU.U|¹]=ÕbB+B>Y pqB±²BV \]{¹qpu~FDATU|
OB§ 1.908(d)(4)=>?(d)(5)mU89=>?@AB=ÕFGWgBBÔÕY=µ] oV{}Ui=º UFG Y89m }ipz{V3t\]J=ÕbB''m !]{t\]uvY6PY#q¼½fGgh{^G_B    



65

B±² Y pqMy\]Ð#BEV \]UV4qº¹qp]º/½ºY pqU¢£¤Vwv]~uUPcm¹Ïkl_Y4UFG Y89m
}ipz{V3t\]uvYU=ÕbB''Y pqU=ÕfGghmzB±²V|\]6Pm]'m]º/½ºY pq4U¢£¤Vwv]~
89=>?@AB=ÕFGYÈ,\]Pw[xTU89VUUR>UuT3Ê\]B!hU>hUuTË_Y o¹]z{mU89=>?@ABÊËMNOB o¡P]z{Y4\]~3 ÏU89B
ÊËMNOYÃÄ¾UB>½iB!hU>hUuTË_TUFG
¼m D#]B]4BVWvU BUuTËEYi89
B;<ªV }iµ¹Ïijip~|OB§ 1.908(d)(4)=>?(d)(5)Y=pqUz¹jBMyYÃÄpq oi´BVop]z{YfGgh{^G_m}uz{V !YÑ\]uvUz¹jB
ÔÕÖ×Pw¹]VÑ{\]z{V*Àµqp]~|OB§ 1.908(d)(6)TUfGghY¡}U|OB§ 1.912(b)B 0Pw[xB o¡
P{i]U EiV }qÑ}U\]z{V*Àµ]~|OB§ 1.908(d)(6)(i)TUÑ¹uY=pqU89BFGoYfGghm|\]be=>?FG>LV|OB§ 1.906(b)Y*Àµj¹] !iCD''Y\]uvUbe=>?FG>LBÕ3)+U6PY#qU=>?%?BMnVb \]z{V*Àµ]~beuTFG>LBÕ3)+=>?%?TCDEi89FGBÃÐEP
U89V }ºip89VFG}ipz{V{\]uvY6P
]~ÐÔÕÖ×Y=pqU|OB§ 1.908(b)(1)B %}u>½YU89FG
g:BfGghT+YU89FGobe=>?FG>LV !Y# \]uvY#EVopqp]~B %TU^G_mU'Y>qTUbe=>?FG>L    



66

B# Y=pqfGghmop]¾yBVy\]z{m]Y4}u~z½}u¿BÕ3)+TUfGghmyB'opqUÑ¹uY|O¹]Pw[xVOu\z{m¾]~VÑ\]Pw[xOTU
z¹m}q o¹]z{VY}Uz½}uYÈ\]¤)+V /}UFDA=>?B B<Y>]%tVY\]J T¸]~|OB§ 1.908(d)(6)(ii)TUÑ¹uY=pqUÐÔÕÖ×}u|OB§ 1.908(d)(2)B"%¢¤+=Y pqBMyYfGghm/½\¹Ï \]ºU]z{m*Àµj¹]~3 ÏUfGghBÑ¹uTUfGghm¯"% 0>LBV^G_uTRPcm¹ÏSkl_Y|\]U]pTUBV \Ukl_m }uktV^G_Y| \]{]z{m% j¹]~BTU§^B§$R^G_m }qp]S=>?^G_Y>]beB&B%t{ U^G_By}u"%YZq89mFG¹
uz{V^G_m ]J-iT¸]~YTUfGghTUBFGY
pq2BVop]º4}¹ip~"% 0>LBU^G_mfGghYy}u.Y89B"%m ¹uz{m^G_uTkl_Yt¹]ºj]~>m`&V§$}uUf¹]BT%Yip{ }qp]z{ºjU89B"%¢¤+=my.Y¹uz{V^G_uTk
l_m¾]UE%6 BFGY pqTUfGghThBVop]º4}¹ip~ !i»ByT^G_m¼½~"%¢¤+=B7PY pqTUÐÔÕÖ×Y=pqU|OB§ 1.908(d)(2)
B %}u~VÑ\]Pw[xOTUz¹m}q o¹]z{VY}Uz½}uYÈ\]¤)+V /}UFDA=>?B B<Y>]%tVY\]J T¸]~|OB§ 1.908(d)(6)(iii)TUÑ¹uY=pqUÐÔÕÖ×}u|    



67

OB§ 1.908(d)(4)=>?(d)(5)B=ÕbBGoY pqBMyYfGghm/½\¹
Ï \]ºU]z{m*Àµj¹]~B>±²{=ÕbBÕ3)
+B7PY pqTUÐÔÕÖ×Y=pqU|OB§ 1.908(d)(4)=>?(d)(5)B %}u~VÑ\]Pw[xOTUz¹m}q o¹]z{VY}Uz½}uYÈ\]¤)+V /}Uij?YFDA=>?B B<Y>]%tVY\]J T¸]~F. ¤)+R|O§ 1.910S|OB§ 1.910TUfGghY¡\]¤)+Pw[xVyv]~|OB§1.910(a)TUFGgÀYZ[\]YU89BFG YD#]B]E
i89rs Y pqB³V5vUz½}uE Y¡\]ÃÐEiCDF
GMn=>?ÐMNOYÃÄÅfGghB VH³]¤)+V\]z{VfGghY*Àµ]~|OB§ 1.910TUzB¤)+V o=>?BT6PY#q\]z{4*Àµ]~©Y}u>½YUERG²8UFG=>?' Y89m>ËEUEuTD>E B3ÕYj¹qp]B]  {}qU89Brs=>?¯uTÔ8 3 YÈ\]fC¯ZgB¤)+=>?¯uT¯ÊËh¯!hB ³B,my¹uRRef. 9S~2007Y%Ö1Vg<m_}u?]^RRef. 3STUrsi89"%Y pqBfCB³B{fCB89rs¤)+B,m89FGY=µ]B {}qy¹u~uUÔÕÖ×III.D=>?III.EY=µ]|OB§ 1.906(c)=>?§ 1.908(a)(3)(i)
B %u.U8=>?*W9m, !i"%B·FG¹qp]z{Y pqU3F}q²8Vkµ]UuTB B% j¹RRef. 5SRRef. 6S
RRef. 7SRRef. 8SUuUbeB,CDi''Y>qFG Y@Am ¹]z
{Y pqUP8890B(ºj3U²8Vkµlq¾uRRef. 2S~    



68Y¡\]¢£¤YÃÄ¾U89FGhT+YU89V¡P{}qC
DEi89BlpYlX¤)+*++ V}qp]{UFDAT
H³}qp]~}º}UJ By¹u 2B mUÐMNOB·f
GghB {i]¼YÈ\]4B]Y4\]~z¹TU89FGg:B
fGghBUCDEi89BlpMnY=µ]¤)+m}q¹qpipz{V \{¹]~zBËºjUÐMNOfGghY¡\]¤)+Pw[xV|O}qp]~zB¤)+TUDOT HM 181 ÃÐE[\>4
Zg¤)+{Ï¹]¤)+{B ¦B  $%&¾U ÔÕY|¾]{(y\]~|O¹]¤)+MyTU¤)+V o=>?BT6PY#q\]z{V*Àµ]~z¹TU
fGghmFGgÀYZ[\]Y89rs {`jB Y pq ³V8v]z{V{\]~uU6PY#qU3 ÏUfGghBgÀm,YYiu{¾UuTUZgB[m¤)+B6PV \i/YU¤)+m¹]z{4{\]~^G_=>?kl_B¤)+)TUFDABCGMPMNi/B BMN89=>?@ABÊËMNOYU^G_=>?fGgh{}q[gaV¼½B
Zg¤)+YÈ\]MymW¹]z{ºjUz¹jBMN=>?MNOY>q24 !Y¹]{U yEY] µu~
89Y*µuFDABCGMPMNBÔÕÖ×110.10(c)TU)Ö×B, u
T89 ByY V ½TUrsi89BDWY6Pi)=V]YTU *4}ÅT>>U>TBe»Bm]¾{p½1$2V}qp]~ÔÕÖ×110.10(c)TUjYU89Vl½h=>? hmU#}
p89lp=>?893.NY pq !i¤)+VkµU_B,
CD=>?8CDEi¼B[\Y pq±²V]¾z{V|}qp]~
2010 ANPRM    



69

B89=>?@ABÊËMNOYTU3 ÏU89rs0B i/UyB V^\UuT \]_V¡P{\]¤)+Pw[xmW¹]
R78 FR 3646 at 3761 and 78 FR 64736 at 64750S~|OB§ 1.910(b)TUfGghYU6B¤)+VÑ\] 0B=>? V*Àµ]~B>½i 0YTU¤)+B¦U¤)+B¿U=>?¤)+V½µuhRuSV \]z{mwvj¹]~J
0TU|OB§ 1.912RÔÕÖ×III.G%SB 0Pw[xB o¡P{i]~fG
ghmCDEiFGgÀV¼½JB !i¤)+B7PV% }UzBMNOTUfGghY¡}U`&BY6B¤)+V}uz{VÑ\] 0V µUFDAm%?=>? 0?V.}q¤)+Pw[x{B V%t¾]>½Y\]z{4*Àµ]¾]{U yEY] µ]~G. 0R|O§ 1.912S|OB§ 1.912TUFGgÀYZ[\]^G_=>?fGghY o¹]U 0B
3U=>? oY pqBPw[xVyv]~^G_=>?fGghY*Àµ] 0{UB>½i 0V \]6PY pqB %TUÔÕÖ×III.EY=µ]|OB§1.908(b)(1)U(b)(3)=>?(d)(6)B0 %Y \~|OB§ 1.912(a)TU^G_Y¡}U#MBFGgÀB{}q|OB§1.908(b)(1)=>?(b)(3)*Àµj¹]>½Y±²V|}qp]z{Vt\] 0VU^G_mB>½i±²V|\]Pw[xB o¡P]{¾Vqºj12º¥U3U\]z{V*Àµ]~|OB§ 1.912(b)TUfGghY¡}U|OB§ 1.908(d)(2)(ii)*Àµj¹]Ñ¹uB 0{U|OB§ 1.908(d)(6)*Àµj¹]Ube=>?FG>LBÕ3)+UU=>?%?BY pquUÑ¹uB 0VU
B>½i=>?mFGgÀopj¹qp]{¾Vqºj12º¥U3
FDA    



70

U\]z{V*Àµ]~|OB§ 1.912(c)TUfGghY¡}U|OB§1.910(b)*Àµj¹]¤)+ 0VUB>½i 0y¹uhmB¤)+V}uE]-V^u}Fµqp]{¾Vqºj12º¥U3U\]z{V*Àµ]~|OB§ 1.912(a)ºj(c)B0Pw[xY>U¼EB%? Y^G_=>?
fGghBFGgÀ 0V }UÐMNOB0Pw[x{B V \]z{mYi]~|OB§ 1.912(a)=>?(b)*Àµj¹] 0Y pqTU3 ÏU
2B8 ¤ÕB?i/U6PiYU^G_uTfGghB2
BgÀV ¾]>½U12º¥B3UV*Àµ]z{V|O}qp]~|OB§ 1.912(d)TU^G_=>?fGghY¡}U >T Pcm¹Ï+YUÐMNO*Àµj¹]\qB 0V#&YV( j¹u_Y|\]z{V*Àµ]~|OB§ 1.912(e)TUÐMNOPw¹]\qB 0VÐ 0U#ÐR3
ÏU¢U U8¢U$Õ+ =U$Õ+ ¬Ö UuT
B BÐ 0B#iSUuT 0{}q3Ê\]z{V*Àµ]~ 0T21 CFR2¤11YZq3Ê}iµ¹Ïijip~|OB§ 1.912(f)TU|OB§ 1.908(d)(6)*Àµj¹]Ñ¹uVY¾U_& BPcºj24¶$Y1B 0VÆÍ|¾]TU 0m ¹u¦ºj6º¥Y 0V1ºj ¹q3Ê¾]>½Yi]U{My\]~|OB§ 1.912(f)TU|OB§ 1.908(d)(6)*Àµj¹]Ñ¹umFGgÀY=pqGo¹qp]UBV1Y=ºiµ¹Ïijipz{4yv]~6º¥Y B 0V1ºj ¹q3Ê\]z{Y pqBMyY>UY
TU 03UY¡\]Pw[xY } U 0mY|¹]z{ºj 03
    

71

UBEV]z{iÅ 0B13ÊY6Pi VÂj\m4uj
¹]~|OB§ 1.912(f)TU1Y]ºjÕÔ¹ÏU 0m1Y]{i¹]z{4UMy\]~&$B¢ ÖT"¬¤Õ
¾UB&B: B8i]\q{±²BlVrsi»¼½z{m]~zBBÖVGo}qUBUBuTºjB 0YÕÔV|¾]~|OB§ 1.912(f)TU*W9?^V¡P{\]FDAB;<ª- =>?6ÊËRHACCPSMN{}qp]~*W9V¡P{\]FDABHACCPMNTU
JUuT+ÅB1U 03Ê)mj¹qp]YUPcVkµq_& BuvY 0V+Y\z{m¾]B 0aY pqMy}qp]R21 CFR 123.9(b)(3)S~^V¡P{\]FDABHACCPMNTU_& 
BPcºj24¶$Y1B 0VÆÍ|¾]TU )3+m¼
¹u¦ºj6º¥Y 0V1ºj }q3Ê¾]{}U 0m1Y]ºjÕÔ¹ÏUz¹V1Y]{i\R21 CFR
120.12(d)(2)S~|OB§ 1.912(g)TUÐMNOPw¹]\qB 0V2¤20R21 CFR part20SYÃÄÅ
Pw[xB o¡P{My\]~2¤20BFDABMNU±²_ 
RFOIASR5 U.S.C. 552SU,#> *R18 U.S.C. 1905S=>?FD&CmUg&±²RCCISg&±²BpVWXUFDAB±² Y o¹]~
H. oXYR|O§§ 1.914 - 1.934S
1. EFD&CBÔÕÖ×416(d)TUTHYFD&CBÔÕÖ×416YÃÄÅPw[xB
oVXY\]V( q=Uz¹YTU oXYm_{a>B4ZY{q[\    



72

iB·89mFG¹]]^V4uj¸U_`Ya}ip{THm \]Uj]¿B_UbeU89uT89¶B9YÈ}qUÐMNOBPw[
xmW¹]~FD&CBÔÕÖ×416(d)(2)TUjYUTHT/B>½i oXY
Y pq4UB oXYBË{ YFederal RegisterY_}iµ¹Ïijip{My}qp]~ÔÕÖ×416(d)(2)VY¾UÔÕÖ×416TUÔÕÖ×416(d)YÃÄp
q oXYVHv]UuTÔÕÖ×416(d)YÃÄpq\YHvj¹u oX
YVl\U4}ÅT#\]VUbYMy}qpip~
2. Pw[xO
BBMy{YUFDAm2¤OBPw[xB ¶JY pqU`
$EYUuT ÈB]hBc1Y¡}qU oXYVHv]*+ÔVUB>½ic1Y iµ¹Ïijip±²UFDAmB>½ic1VuT}U\YHvj¹u oXYV#\]UuTl\?'VWvU|O}qp]~FDAmHv] oXYTUFDAm oXYV_\]Federal RegisterB.8Y=
pqy}uU2¤OBPw[xYj¹UFD&CuTFDAMNB BMy
B oYVip~|OB§ 1.914TUj]¿B_UbeU89uT89¶B9YÈ}qU
oXYY>q_uTa>B4ZY{q[\iB·89mFG¹]]^{ij¸U oXYT_`Ya}ip{FDAm \]UFDAm2¤OB
Pw[xY pq oVXY¾]z{VMy\]~zBMyOTUFD&CBÔÕÖ×416(d)(1)Y]Mn{]~zBMnYÃÄ¾U oXYT2¤O
B EiPw[xuTPw[xBÔ¬¤YÈ}U]pT2¤OY
]\qBPw[xYÈ}qU¹]m]~YUzBMnYÃÄ¾U
oXYTj]¿B_UbeU89=>?¯uT89¶B9Uij?YZ[\]FGgÀYÈ}qU¹]m]~    



73|OB§ 1.916TUFDAm`$EYUuT§ 10.30R21 CFR 10.30SYÃÄpqUj]¿B_UbeU89uT89¶B9YÈ}q2¤OBPw[xBo¡P]hm|§}uc1Y¡}U2¤OBPw[xB oVXY\]º/½ºU%\]{My\]~FDATU oXYm_uTa>B4ZY{q[\iB·89mFG¹]]^V4uj¸U_`Ya}ipz{Vt\]uvY
6Pi?±²VWvU2¤OBPw[xB uT\qY pqU
oXYVwv]c1B/$V \uvU Èh{B% +VWXc1B
0%BPcV \]~|OB§ 1.918TU§ 10.30Y]Pw[xY U oXYVwv]c1B
R§ 10.30(b)¹]SY=pqUPc\] oXYY pqUB oXYB¡P]_UbeU89uT89¶B9Uij?YB oXYB¡P]
2¤OBPw[xVWvU{ Yb}iµ¹Ïijip{My\]R|OB§
1.918(a)S~jYUTU oXYm_uTa>B4ZY{q[\i
B·89mFG¹]]^V4uj¸U_`Ya}ipz{Vt\]±²B|
V*Àµj¹]R|OB§ 1.918(b)S~z½}u0MyYÃÄ¾U ÈhTU
oXYm_uTa>B4ZY{q[\iB·89mFG¹]]^V4uj¸U_`Ya}ipz{Vt\]uvUPc\] oXYY!BUÈ,m
UEYºi±²uTAV|§\]z{m*Àµj¹]~z¹YTU89
B4UFG¹]»U89rs VÂ\]uvY¹]¢¤+=UÉ
=>?¯uTÉ¶Y>]89BFGB 9Y pqB±²mW¹]~|OB§ 1.920TU oXYVPc\]c1Y=pq|§¹]±²=>?B>½i
c1Y pq|§¹]¢£¤TUÐ 2¤20YÃÄpq_ VXY¹]±²VW¸UzBPcYÈ,\]ª«¬¤B {}q_ ¹]{B3yVH}qp]~Ð B2¤20YÃÄpq_ VXY¹]±²TUB>½ic1Y=pqFDAm|    



74§V*Àµ]U]pTB>½ic1Y pq|§¹]¢£¤Y=pqÈ,m]¿pB±²ip{% ]~zB±²Y¡\]+ºjBÕÔVs EYHv]z{TUbV3\]JUuU B Èhmc1Y pq¢£¤V]BuvYU7P]{4% ]~ZqUJ B|§>V_ \]z{V
FDAT'\]~|OB§ 1.922TUCFSANSuTa>o:;9ÔRCVMS B Õ4}ÅT  ÕUCFSAN¢* $SB ÕUuTCVM
9Í¢* $SB ÕVU2¤OB1x¶JBPw[xY
pqB oXYBPcY¡\] h{yv]~|OB§ 1.924TU2¤OB1x¶JBPw[xY pqB oXYVPc\]c1Y o¹]+Vyv]~|OB§ 1.924(a)TU oXYVPc\]c
1YFDAm¡\]B*+ÔYU§ 10.30Y]m o¹]{My\]~ÔÕÖ×10.30TU]hRB ipc1hVWXSmFDAÎ|§}u c
1BPw[xVb }qp]~|OB§ 1.924(b)TU§ 10.30(h)(3)YÃÄ¾UFDAm
Federal RegisterY.8V }U|§¹uc1YÈ\]±²=>?0VUc1m
¹]z{YiuY oXYY>qVkµ]B] ÈhºjB±²=>?0R3 ÏUB oXYmU]hm\]yuT\qBFGgÀY40\]uvSVWvqUPc\]z{Vyv]~B>½ihYTU
c1B¡P{¿0}u'Y=pqU¿0}uU*+ÔUuT¼FGgÀV¼½hmW¹UuUBc1B¡PB E89{¿0uTB89BFG
gÀYZ[\]^G_UfGghuTkl_mW¹]~|OB§ 1.924(c)TU§ 10.30(e)(3)YÃÄ¾UFDAm c1hY\]{yv]~|OB§ 1.924(c)(1)TUFDAmc1V}uYUFederal RegisterY.8V
}U oXY{B>½i oXYBËVsÑuTB V \]{yv]~    75

zBKLTUFD&CBÔÕÖ×416(d)(2)Y>q*Àµj¹qp]~|OB§1.924(c)(2)TUFDAmc1V}uR 4WXSU FDATc1hY¡\] Y=pqËVb\]{yv]~|OB§ 1.924(d)YÃÄ¾U oX
YVPc}q|§¹uc1B3¤VU0c1B''R3 ÏUc UUuTSVWvU+_mY o¾]>½Y}UyEY \]z{V|O\]~|OB§ 1.924Y=µ]MyTUFDABa?yY=µ]bV3\]~z¹Y>UFDAByY pqB BËm8vj¹Um5Ubm /¹]~|OB§ 1.926TU|OB§ 1.918YÃÄpq*Àµj¹]±²R§ 10.30BPw[xVWXSm|¹qpipUuTUB oXYY>q_uTa>B4Z
Y{q[\iB·89mFG¹]]^{i]U]pTB oXYT_`Ya\]{FDAm \]UFDAT oXYVPc\]c1V¾]{My\]~3 ÏUPc¹] oXYY>q_uTa>B4ZY{q[\iB·
89mFG¹]]^{ijipz{Vt\]U±²>TB BAVU
c1hm|§}iºuUFDATc1V\]{(\]~|OB§ 1.928TU oXYm !]{FDAm`$EY \]UFDAT
Federal RegisterY.8V }U oXY{B>½i oXYBËV]{My\]~yB'Y=pqUFDATU|O¹] oXYY pqU oXYV\]º/½ºYÈ}q21EYy\]YRÐÔÕÖ×\].UÐMNOY
=pq¼u>½YSU23¬Õ¢£¤Vwv]z{m]~}º}UB B'
TUFD&CBÔÕÖ×416(d)(1)=>?|OB§ 1.914Y ¹]Ã#YZqoXYm !]{FDAm }uUFDAT©¸23¬Õ¢£¤Vwv¸
Y oXYV\]z{m]~zB*+ÔTUFD&CBÔÕÖ×416(d)(2) Y
¹]*+Ô]z{ºjUFDAm`$EY oXYV\]J-    



76]{U yEY] }u~|OB§ 1.930TUFDAm}u oXYTUFederal RegisterYB oXYB.
m ¹]¦Y!){i]z{Vyv]~|OB§ 1.932YÃÄ¾U oXYY>q_uTa>B4ZY{q[\iB·89mFG¹]]^{i]m]U]pTU oXYm_`Ya\]
m]{ \]UFDAT oXYV#\]UuTl\z{m¾]>½Yi]~3 ÏU oXYB¡Pn($BFGgÀop]U*+ÔUuT¼YÈ\]2 BEuT[±²B YÃÄ¾U oXYB
V#\]6Pm]{i\º4}¹ip~|OB§ 1.934TU oXYV#\]UuTl\¾]{FDAm \]Y o¹]Vyv]~|OB§ 1.934(a)YÃÄ¾UFDATB>½i Y
pqU%B>½Y.8V¼½~R1Sc1Y¡}q¹u oXYV#\]UuTl\¾]{FDAm \]U2Y oXYVPc}uYU
c1Y=pqy¹u1¨B . \]~R2S oXYV#\]UuTl\¾]{B Y pqUFederal RegisterY.8V \]~zB.8
23¬Õª«¬¤mµj¹U¹Y>U ÈhTFDA B YÈ\]|OV |§¾]~FDATU23¬Õª«¬¤Y¡\]i|§Y*µuPw[
xVy\¾ºU\¾]T21MN¼½¾ºU]pTzBY p
qT1$2Ñ½½m !ºY pqU¢£¤Vwv]~|OB§ 1.934(b)YÃÄ¾UFDATU Èhm23¬Õª«¬¤Y |§}u|OV%\]~|OB§ 1.934(c)YÃÄ¾UFDATFederal RegisterY21yB.8V \]~zB
yB$)¦T.8B_¦{i]~
J B0MyTUFDABa?yY=µ]b{b V{\]
    



77µiÅUÈ[hY #F¾BV|\]uvY4U6Pº !]{yEY] \]~
3. E oXYÔÕÖ× 416(d)(1)=>?|OB§ 1.914Y ¹]Ã#YÃÄ¾UuU¹Y
FÅ02 + jYu>½YU|O.Y21y¹uU¶·B¿
B_YÈ}q2¤OB oiPw[xVXY\]z{T !]{yEY] }qp]~• /BFGYÈ\],RNCIMSSB>A/rs*++ YÃÄ¾U!)
itV!}U%?Vkµqp]^G_UfGgh=>?kl_Uu}U>
AB/=>?/9Yºº]FGgÀYZ[}qp]B~• !)itV!\]89Uu}U89mºjFGY2hÎ3
¹][gY=pqUkl_{}qUuT^G_=>?fGgh{}qUFGgÀY
Z[}qp]B~FDATUzB21MNB_YUJ B¿B_Y o¹]2¤OB
Pw[xB oXY{B oXYBËVUFederal Register´_\] 4
]~FDA TUz½}u oXYY>q_uTa>B4ZY{q[\iB·89mFG¹]]^{i]U]pTU oXYm_`Ya\]m
]º/½ºYÈ}qU¢£¤Vwv]~
a. NCIMSB>A/rs*++ YÃÄÅ!)itV!\]^G_UfGg
h=>?kl_Uu}U>AB/=>?/9Yºº]FGgÀYZ[}qp]B~NCIMSB>A/rs*++ TUs50U¢+ ´=>?*=¤3¢mØ}UÃÐEiM{}qUn{i]/MN]Ò>AB"
/Yºº]MNÓR>A PMOSRRef. 30SVopqp]~z¹YTU%=Õ=>?%=Õ9U/=>?/9Uij?Y0/=>? /9VWXU    



78

>AB/=>?/9BU'UlpUUR>UFG=>?2IY o
¹]Mym ¹qp]~>A PMO=>?>A/rs*++ B0MyTU
.Y=pq>AB/=>?/9BFGYGo¹]UVB=Õ/Ç^Õ+3/FGÕVWX/Õ¤ ¬Õ{¹V½gÀVqp]~
>A PMO=>?PMOVn{}uBMNTUj]/DWhU/IghU
=Õ/FGgh¯0Ð%?_U/Õ¤ ¬ÕU/FG&Uij?Y0/U
klUGU=>?/Õ¤ ¬ÕBÕ3)+>hTUV!
\]M°HIU\iUÉHIm$¼\]!)itV!}iµ¹Ïijip{yvqp]~jYU>A/rs*++ BPw[xY amuUt!hTBV*¹]~>A PMOTU/uT/9mBBn($2¹]yB90 VU/UklUGU=>?/Õ¤ ¬ÕBÕ3)+Uij?Y"U D>Í>4Í"%BÃ#Y
pq0ÐVÆÇ}U Vºj/UkluTGÎFG\]0=Õ/FGgh¯0Ð%?_Uij?Y0/Õ¤ ¬Õ{B 9mUtB$¼U=>?t$¼TyBUM°HIY>]%?¯ ?Vkµiµ¹Ï
ijipz{4yvqp]~
2¤OPw[xB oXYTU|O.Y21y¹uUNCIMSB>
A/rs*++ YÃÄ¾U!)itV!}U%?Vkµqp]^G_UfG
gh=>?kl_YÈ}U>AB/=>?/9Yºº]FGgÀYZ[}qp]{¾YU_uTa>B4ZY{q[\iB·89mFG¹]]^V4
uj¸UuU_`Ya}ip{U yEY] }u~ EY½{UNCIMSB
>A/rs*++ YÃÄ¾U!)itV!}U%?Vkµqp]^G_U
fGgh=>?kl_TU>A PMOY ¹]4B{BPw[xY \]z
{Y>U>AB/=>?/9mB>½i9B V3¾ºipB·    



79

FG¹ipz{V{\]CDEFGMnVopqp]{ }qp]~3 ÏU
B>½iPw[xYÃÄ¾U]/ºj´B/Î/VFG\]¤ ¬ÕT ¹iµ¹Ïij¸UuU\qB/=>?/9B"%TUz¹jB
kµl]/=>?/9BÕ¤ ¬ÕB(^0{Y%t¹iµ¹Ïijip~
jYU>ABºj§^¹]\qB/uT/9BÕ¤ ¬ÕB(^Y
TUY§^}uÖ=BÖ=­®{( B9B"%VWXU§^bV iµ¹Ïijip~J =>?B B¿0\]Pw[xB- Uij?
NCIMSB>/rs*++ Bn($1¹qp]%?=>?*+ÔYÃÄ¾UFDATU|OB2¤OBPw[xTU|O.Y21y¹uU>A/=>?/9mB>½i9B V3¾ºipB·FG¹ipz{V{\]uvY6PTip{U yEY] }u~ZqU2
¤OPw[xm|O.Y21y¹uUNCIMSB>A/rs*++ YÃÄ¾U!)itV!}U%?Vkµqp]^G_UfGgh=>?kl_YÈ}U
>AB/=>?/9Yºº]FGgÀYZ[}qp]{¾YUB oXY
V|O\]~b. !)itV!\]89Uu}U89mºjFGY2hÎ3
¹][gY=pqUkl_{}qUuT^G_4}ÅTfGgh{}qUFGg
ÀYZ[}qp]B~zBE oXYBn(Vyv]EUÒ89Ó
By*Yª¢ª2 0RRef. 17SY ¹]¶·By*Vop] 4]~89{T%B>½i[gVp½~• 89V'UUR>U4U2hÎ+ 2IUuTB B%U_m2\]89V|\]~3 ÏU¤ UC uT§})8V¼½U§}gÀR2hÎ+ UuT_BFGYopj    



80¹]FGÈÎ89V|\]gÀBSU U2IU_BFG
Yopj¹]FGÈU_ UuTª+~• 8A9BÑ4}ÅT¤ B  ÑUuT+BfG
ghm|\] i/B V.}q+ EuT EY2hÎ89B!V3\]~ª¢ªTU89V>\]hTM°<U\iUÉHIm$¼\]!)itV!\¾]{yvqp]RRef. 31S~B>½it
V!\]89>hBmUzBE oXYBn(Y0\]z{Yi]~89TU_BFGYopj¹]FGÈÎ89V|\]21 CFR 2¤1240=>?1250BPw[xB¡P{i]V3{}qU+YUVWX¼É B¡
PU$B$I89=>?89 g:BM°YdP V ½3,000V
 ]U»U=>? BHImz¹V¼½~z¹jBHITU89V2hÎ+|\]100MV ]B%?{ Yd{}q V qp]~FDATU$
I=>?89 B#E&B]89rsNB oV /}U8 
B$D!V2$Y ]z{Y>Uz½}uHI{BM°¡P]g:V \]~FDATUª¢ªV_}Ug:B$I=>?89 BÔ+£
¤R¤ =>?8A9 Uij?Y8.i/B_ SVM°\]UEY¾]? =V|\]z{Y>qÉBj]=89¢¤+=ÊV \]~»UU =>?,M°<TUª¢ªV ={}qopqU¹ ¹B89rsMNVyuT }UB
89M°É{B0V#]~ª¢ªB2 0uT0Vn{}u
BMyTUs50%o¹qp]~uUFDATUz¹jBHIV \]uvU
E&B]1$2U¤)+U*++  U? 4|\]~
FDATU89Y
uT, !i"%ÊËTbjºYiºuz{VH\]u    



81

vBkµlB%?{lpV½ª¢ªB0MyV.}qU$I89=>?89 BgÀYÈ,\]CDE89FGB Vd{}q½~3 ÏU
1993¶AUª¢ªYT89mkµluBTCS89B"%VuMymW¹Uz¹TUz½}u89mkµlj¹]YB89mrsiÅi]B]"%FG¹qpipz{VH\]4B]RRef. 32S~jYU
89 B*=>?TCS89B3Ê"%UuT"%¢¤+=mipY
V_ CD¢¤+={}qop]z{V½ª¢ªB0MyTU89
ºj89m2hÎ3¹]B89BFGY o¹]RRef. 32S~
FDATUª¢ªV ={}u?»HIBM°*++ VU$I
89=>?89 BgÀYÈ,\]89rs V½JEUREº)^E]{i}UE¾F¾U,{B)E£#)V.}qa\]y]~
FDATU!)itV!\]89YÈ}U2¤OBPw[xB oX
YTU|O.Y21y¹uU89mBºjFG¹uY2hÎ3
¹][gY pqkl_{}qUuT^G_=>?fGgh{}qFGgÀYZ
[}qp]{¾YU_uTa>B4ZY{q[\iB·89mFG¹]]^V4uj¸UuU_`Ya}ip{U yEY] }u~ EY½{UB>½i89TUª¢ªV ={}uBPw[xY \]z{
Y>UB>½i9m \]B]B·89mFG¹ipz{
V{\]CDEFGMnVopqp]{ }u~zB oXYTU89YÈ}qU89mBºjFG¹uY2hÎ3¹][gY pqkl_{}qU=>?^G_uTfGgh{}qFGgÀYZ[}qp]YBU|O}qp]z{V \]~89mU3 ÏU .ºjBÎFG\]i/U|
OB§ 1.904YÃÄpq^G_=>?¯uTfGghBy*VOu\z{Yi]B    



82

BV^\YTU^G_=>?¯uTfGgh{}qB>½iY o
¹]|OB2¤OYÃÄÅPw[xTUj¸ o¹UXY¹ip~ÐÔÕÖ×Y=pq}u.U§ 1.934FDAm !i. {¢£¤{ Y
oXYVl\z{m¾]Vµ]z{V|O}qp]~
 EM°A. 
FDATU12866U13563UM°R5 U.S.C. 601-612S=>?1995
,ÉÃVipÉÎB RPublic Law 104-4SYÃÄ¾UÐ
MNOBV?}u~12866=>?13563TU!)iM°JB,OBj]2o{`V }UM°m6PiYTU`REi>U#U_
CD{rsU=>?B B U %EUij?YWLVWXSV2{\]M°B*+V \]z{VU0HIY }qp]~FDA TUÐMNO
B`{2oV \ EM°- RPRIASV$ }uRRef. 33S~MNOTU
12866Yy*¹]7PiM°KLYi]{% qp]~zBPRIAYÈ\]¢£¤Vwv]~ÐÑYW¹]`{2oB - VE¾§}uiPRIARRef. 33SB(Thttp://www.regulations.govRDocket No. FDA- 2013-N-0013SUuU¶·
BFDA$¤ºj4(¾]~IV.

http://www.fda.gov/AboutFDA/ReportsManualsForms/Reports/EconomicAnalyses/default.htm.

M°
M°TUMNm$MBY( ]7iV2$Y ]M°JB
B- V0HIY*Àµqp]~ÐMNOTUKÆ(m50Mª=NOB^
G_Ukl_uTfGghV¡P{}ip~}º}imjUFDAm|O\]Ò$gÓB.

    

83

By*YqT]UÐMNOB¡P{i]ºiBB$MBYU21MNm
7i>EV\m]{U yEY] µqp]~C. 1995,ÉÃVipÉÎB
1995,ÉÃVipÉÎBBÔÕÖ×202(a)TUÑ}uÌV }U(¹]2oÍ`B VWXz{V0HIY*ÀµuUÒ1Y1ª=¶JR$0SBU»U=>? ÉY>]§KLuT ÔÕY>]§V3ÅB],VWXMNÓ{|O}qp]~$0B1¼%LTU2 R2012SB$*3Ö¬¤GDPVopq14100Mª=]~FDATUÐMNOmUzBLVO
u\UuTJ]1B§V4uj\{(\]~12866U13563UM°=>?1995,ÉÃVip
ÉÎB YÃÄpqÐMNOBV]uvY¼u- TUÐMN
OBª«¬¤RRef. 33S_ ¹qp]~¿[ÀÁÂÐMNOYTU1995¿[ÀÁÂR44 U.S.C. 3501-3520SYÃÄ¾U¼ÉÊËÌ<ROMBSY>] B¡P{i]±²ÆÇMymW¹]~ÆÇ}u±²TU
1995¿[ÀÁÂBÔÕÖ×3507(d)YÃÄpqBuvUOMBÎ|§¹qp]~FDATU%B>½iY pqU¢£¤Vwv]~R1S|O¹]±²ÆÇmFDABV#}Å^\uvY6Pº/½ºU±²Yom]º/½ºU
VWX~R2S|O¹]±²ÆÇB Y pqBFDAB0(4B#UGo
¹]»=>?yB!)VWX~R3SÆÇ\]±²B94U!o=>?b
V*J]»~R4ShB±²ÆÇB V2$Y ]»U6P
Y#q`aÆÇ=>?B B%'B±²BGoVWX~
V. 1995    



84±²ÆÇYÈ\]¢£¤BklV{\]uvUOMBTÑ}u¢£¤
VOMB±²ÍM° SBFDAÕ  ¨¬ÕFAX: 202-395-7285U
uT£=oira_submission@omb.eop.govÎG\]z{V3 }qp]~\
qB¢£¤YUÒ89=>?@ABCDEFGÓBVµ]¾]~
1995¿[ÀÁÂR44 U.S.C. 3407(d)SY }U FDATÐMNOB±²ÆÇM
yV BuvYOMBÎ|§}qp]~z¹jBPw[xTUFDAmOMBBH
V]U))V4uip~FDATUz¹jBPw[xBOMBY>]HYÈ\]. VFederal Register_\]~B01995¿[ÀÁÂYÃÄ¾U%²8U 0ÊËU=>?$hB(4{ YÐMNOBV]uvYFDAm¼u- TUÐMNOBª«¬¤RRef. 33S_ ¹qp]~
#FDA TU21 CFR 25.30(j)YÃÄ¾UzBKLm3UuT(EY_#Y7
iVip¿pB4B]{ }u~ZqU#Ô£¤4U
# ²846P{¹ip~
VI.

,d*°%
FDAT13132Yb ¹]NYZqUÐMNOV- }u~BÔÕÖ×4(a)TU0HIY¡}UÒ,mY\]BTU,Yb
ExmW¹]UuTºYjºBUmY¡\]V#}ub
it&m]U]pTUBB¼Gm,YÃÄÅ,BB¼G{% \]Yj¹]{0\]Óz{Vwvqp]~,TUFD&CBÔÕÖ×416(e)Yb ExmW¹U89BFGYºº]uTB¼É$
VII.

    



85

BPw[xTUR1SuTB¼É$ BPw[x{FD&CBÔÕÖ×416
BPw[x4}ÅTFD&CBÔÕÖ×416YÃÄpq$¹]MNY \]z{TipUuTR2S ouT¼¹]uT¼É$ BPw[xmU
FD&CBÔÕÖ×4164}ÅTFD&CBÔÕÖ×416YÃÄpq$¹]MN
V¼=>?¼\] {i]Y¹]{My}qp]~ÔÕÖ×416(e)TUjYUb ExTFD&CBÔÕÖ×416YÃÄpq$¹]MN
B$)¦¶AY¼¹]FGY o¹]{My}qp]~zBb ExTUÐ
MNOBPw[xm21y¹uUz¹Y o¹]z{Yi]~|OB$)¦=>? ¦ÅBgB1¼MnT|O¹] BPw[xVO]Y-T]4BBUÐMNOm21y¹uU BgTiÅ{4jºBV¼½
6PmD#]~FDATU21MNB_U0m ''Yi]uvY-iT
BVµ]z{m !]{ yEY] \]~2005 SFTAYÃÄÅ/B>½i
21MN4UFederal RegisterY=µ]_ºj60¦Y$)\]z{{}U ¦T¸
j\z{V|O}u~FDATU$g¶Bgm }pPw[x{ ''Yi]
uvYU21MNB_¦ºj1V( ]z{m {% ]~uUFDATU$gm }pPw[x{ ''Yi]uvYU21MNB_¦ºj2V(]z{m ]{4% ]~FDATU89FGg:U *Í *U=>?
B2¤{Y)}qUÐMNBV \ 4]~FDATU ¦
Y¡}q|O\]*+Y pqU¢£¤VPc\]~
VIII.

¢£¤PcFDATUÐÑy}u BºUÈB]U89=>?@ABCDEFGM
IX.

    



86

NOYÈ\]B B/B>½i Y pq4U23¬Õ¢£¤Vwv]~ÈB]hTUÐÑYÈ\]¢£¤Vhttp://www.regulations.govÎG\]ºUÑ}u¢£¤Vª«¬¤ÊËRADDRESSESØÙSÎ|§\]z{m¾]~6
PiBT¢£¤V{vqG]z{µ]~¢£¤TUÐÑB!"ºz$Y ¹uª«¬¤­®Vµ]z{~j¹u¢£¤TUª«¬¤ÊËU¥ºjB 9ºj 4BU0]z{m¾]~
X.

ØÙÑ

¶·BØÙÑTª«¬¤ÊËRADDRESSESØÙSY ¹q=UÈB
]hTU¥ºjB 9ºj 4U0]z{m¾]~EYT
http://www.regulations.gov¾]~R$¤BªY pqT%t
]mUÐÑmFederal Register_¹uB$¤BY pqT
V ip~S
1. Hennessy T.W., Hedberg, C.W., Slutsker, L. et al., 1996, "A National Outbreak of
Salmonella Enteriditis Infections From Ice Cream," New England Journal of Medicine, Vol. 334,
No. 20, pp. 1281–1286, available at
http://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJM199605163342001#t=articleTop, accessed andprinted on September 10, 2013.
2. FDA Memorandum, "Feed RFRs Related to Transportation Problems," 2012.
3. Wojtala, G., 2007, Interstate Food Transportation Assessment Project, presented at
the June 16 through 20, 2007, Conference of the Association of Food and Drug Officials,
available at http://www.michigan.gov/documents/mda/truckproj_224450_7.pdf, accessed andprinted on September 9, 2013.
4. Michigan Department of Agriculture, "Food Truck Assessment Project, April 18/19,

    



872006."
5. The Indy Channel, "200 Pounds of Contaminated Food Headed to Central Indiana
Restaurants in Semi Destroyed, Police: Raw Chicken, Veggies Found Together,"(http://www.theindychannel.com/news/local-news/200-pounds-of-contaminated-food-headed-to
central-indiana-restaurants-in-semi-destroyed ), 2013, accessed and printed on September 9,
2013.
6. Caledonia Record, "DMV Stops Truck, Finds Spoiled Food," August 18, 2012.
7. Courier Journal, "Overheated Transport Trucks Spark Concerns About Spoilage,"
August 10, 2012.
8. Motor Carrier Division, Michigan State Police, "Commercial Motor Vehicle
Enforcement Quarterly,"(http://www.michigan.gov/documents/msp/CMV_Quarterly_January_2007_205099_7.pdf),
2007, accessed and printed on September 9, 2013.
9. Eastern Research Group, Inc., 2009, Characteristics of Current Food Transportationand Holding Practices for Food Commodities, GSA MOBIS SIN 874-1, Contract No.
GS-10F-0125P, Order No.HHSF223200730236G, ERG Task No. 0193.16.001.001)
10. FDA, “Guidance for Industry: Sanitary Transportation of Food,”(http://www.fda.gov/food/guidanceregulation/guidancedocumentsregulatoryinformation/sanitati
ontransportation/ucm208199.htm), accessed and printed on January 28, 2014.
11. FSIS, "FSIS Safety and Security Guidelines for the Transportation andDistribution of Meat, Poultry, and Egg Products,"(http://www.fsis.usda.gov/shared/PDF/Transportation_Security_Guidelines.pdf ), 2005,
accessed and printed on September 9, 2013.
12. FDA, "Compliance Policy Guide Sec. 565.100 FDA Jurisdiction Over Meat and    



88

Poultry Products," 2005.
13. FSIS, "HACCP for Shelf Stable Processes,"(http://www.fsis.usda.gov/shared/PDF/FSRE_SS_HACCP_Student.pdf), 2009, accessed andprinted on September 9, 2013.
14. Greater Pittsburgh Community Food Bank, "Shelf Life of Food Bank Products,"(http://www.pittsburghfoodbank.org/pdf/shelflifeguide.pdf), 2012, accessed and printed on
September 9, 2013.
15. NSW Food Authority, "Shelf Stable Acid Preserved Foods,"(http://www.foodauthority.nsw.gov.au/_Documents/science/shelf-stable-acid-preservedfoods.pdf ), 2011, accessed and printed on September 10, 2013.
16. FSIS, "Shelf Stable Food Safety,"(http://www.fsis.usda.gov/wps/portal/fsis/topics/food-safety-education/get-answers/food-safetyf
act-sheets/safe-food-handling/shelf-stable-food-safety), 2013, accessed and printed on
September 9, 2013.
17. FDA, "Food Code 2009: Chapter 1 - Purpose and Definitions," 2009.
18. Compressed Gas Association, letter, "Docket No. FDA–2010–N–0013," 2010.
19. Airgas, Inc., letter, "Docket No. FDA–2010–N–0013," 2010.
20. North American Produce Transportation Working Group, "Produce Transportation
Best Practices,"(http://www.hortcouncil.ca/uploads/file/naptwg_produce_trans_best_practices.pdf), 2012,
accessed and printed on September 9, 2013.
21. University of Florida IFAS Extension, "Sanitary Design and Construction of Food
Equipment," (http://edis.ifas.ufl.edu/fs119), 2011, accessed and printed on September 9, 2013.
22. Juice Products Association, "Model Tanker Wash Guidelines for the Fruit Juice    



89

Industry,"(http://www.tankerwash.org/data/archive/JPA%20Model%20Tanker%20Wash%20Guidelines%
20November%202010(1).pdf), 2010, accessed and printed on September 9, 2013.
23. FSIS, "Kitchen Companion: Your Safe Food Handbook,"(http://www.fsis.usda.gov/wps/wcm/connect/2bc7ada9-12a4-4b36-960c-3230904edcc2/Kitchen_Companion.pdf?MOD=AJPERES&amp;CACHEID=8bf06fa4-b0e7-488a-afff-22018c3bb075),
2008, accessed and printed on September 9, 2013.
24. FDA, "Food Code 2009: Annex 3 - Public Health Reasons / Administrative
Guidelines - Chapter 3, Food," 2009.
25. FDA, "Food Code 2009: Annex 3 - Public Health Reasons / Administrative
Guidelines - Chapter 1, Purpose and Definitions," 2009.
26. Institute of Food Technologists, "Evaluation and Definition of PotentiallyHazardous Foods – Chapter 2,"(http://www.fda.gov/Food/FoodScienceResearch/SafePracticesforFoodProcesses/ucm094143.htm), 2001, accessed and printed on September 9, 2013.
27. Cornell University College of Agriculture and Life Sciences, "Paenibacillus andBacillus Are the Shelf-Life Limiting Microbes for Fluid Milk Products," 103(http://impact.cals.cornell.edu/project/paenibacillus-and-bacillus-are-shelf-life-limitingmicrobes-fluid-milk-products), accessed and printed on September 9, 2013.
28. University of Guelph, "Microorganisms in Milk,"(http://www.uoguelph.ca/foodscience/dairy-science-and-technology/dairymicrobiology/microor
ganisms-milk), 2010, accessed and printed on September 9, 2013.
29. National Food Processors Association, letter, "Safeguarding Food FromContamination During Transportation," 1991.

    



90

30. FDA, "Grade 'A' Pasteurized Milk Ordinance (2011 Revision)," 2012.
31. FDA, "Food Code 2009: Chapter 8 – Compliance and Enforcement," 2009.
32. FDA, "Food Code 2009: Chapter 3 – Food," 2009.
33. FDA, "Preliminary Regulatory Impact Analysis," 2014.

2¤1Bd3¤49U:;9UF§9U89 UF(9U U²8=>? 0ÊËB0Pw[
x~
BuvYU,89Í:;9Í49YÃÄ¾UuU89:;9<THY
¹uYÃÄ¾U21 CFR2¤1V%B>½Y#\]z{V|O\]~2¤1--+¼MN
1. 21 CFR2¤1B &EoT%B>½Y v]~&J15 U.S.C. 1453, 1454, 1455; 19 U.S.C. 1490, 1491; 21 U.S.C. 321, 331, 333, 334, 335a,
21 CFR

343, 350c, 350d, 350e, 352, 355, 360b, 362, 371, 374, 381, 382, 387, 387a, 393; 42 U.S.C. 216,
241, 243, 262, 264%B>½i§§ 1.900ºj1.934B2¤OV2¤1Y\]~2¤O--89=>?@ABCDEFG
2.

Sec.

+My
1.900 Ð2¤B¡P{i]BT¹º~1.902 Ð2¤BÃ#=>?y*T,89Í:;9Í49B·/B>½Yo¹]Bº~1.904 Ð2¤YT/B>½iy*mqT]Bº~be=>?FG>L
1.906 be=>?FG>LYT/B>½iPw[xm o¹]Bº~FGgÀ    



91FGgÀYT/B>½iPw[xm o¹]Bº~¤)+
1.910 FGgÀYZ[\]fGghYT/B>½i¤)+Pw[xm o¹]Bº~0
1.912 FGgÀYZ[\]^G_=>?fGghYT/B>½i 03Ê?B
B 0Pw[xm o¹]Bº~oXY
1.914 FDAT/B>½i'Ð2¤BPw[xV oXY\]Bº~
1.916 FDAT/B>½iYÐ2¤BPw[xV oXY\]º/½ºU%
\]Bº~1.918 oXYVwv]c1BTUV}iµ¹Ïijipº~1.920 oXYVwv]c1|§¹]UuTB>½ic1YÈ\]¢£¤|§¹]U/B>½i±²m_ ¹]Bº~
1.922 oXYVwv]c1YTU¹m¡\]Bº~
1.924 oXYVwv]c1YT/B>½i*+Ôm o¹]Bº~
1.926 FDAT/B>½i' oXYVwv]c1V}]Bº~
1.928 FDAm`$EYÐ2¤BPw[xV oXY\]UFDAT/B>½i*+ÔYZ½Bº~
1.930 FDAm}u oXYTp !){i]Bº~
1.932 FDAT/B>½i' oXYV#UuTl }]Bº~
1.934 FDAm oXYV#\]UuTl\¾]{ }uU/B>½im o¹]Bº~
1.908

2¤O--89=>?@ABCDEFG
+My§ 1.900 Ð2¤B¡P{i]BT¹º~(a) § 1.904Yy*¹]¡PB[gVY¾UÐ2¤BPw[xTFG
gÀYZ[\]^G_Ukl_=>?fGghY o¹U89m.Y|¹]uT(]º/½ºT ip~jYUÐ2¤BPw[xTU89BFGYo¹]U3 ÏU21 CFR 2¤1U110U118U225=>?589BUÐ BB BP
w[xY o¹]~    



92Ð2¤BPw[xTU^G_Ukl_uTfGghm¶·BFG
gÀYZ[\]U o¹ip~(1) $V.q´BÎ*µU(, j¹]89UuT(2) #F§\]uvYF(¹U24 .4¹ip89~§ 1.902 Ð2¤BÃ#=>?y*T,89Í:;9Í49B·/B>½
Y o¹]Bº~(a) Ð2¤BÃ#=>?y*TUÐ2¤Y }qpipB·FGgÀYZ[}qp]^G_U`ab4}ÅTcdbeY>]fGghUuTkl_
Y>q89mFG¹uUuTFG\]uvY|¹u{p½U,89Í
:;9Í49BÔÕÖ×402(i)R21 U.S.C. 342(i)SB Bn($89m }qp]º/½º \]Y o¹]~(b) FGgÀYZ[}qp]^G_U`ab4}ÅTcdbeY>]fGghUu
Tkl_mÐ2¤BPw[xY }ipz{TU,89Í:;9Í49
BÔÕÖ×301(hh)R21 U.S.C. 331(hh)SYÃÄÅ*¼]~§ 1.904 Ð2¤YT/B>½iy*mqT]Bº~,89Í:;9Í49BÔÕÖ×201R21 U.S.C. 321SBy*?0TU
B>½iomÐ2¤opj¹]Y o¹]~¶·By*4 o¹]~!{TU #_CDMnY qÐ#BEV^\uvY6P]z{V\]~@A{TU_¶Ba>oB8>V }Uz¹YT ¬¤ªUUij?YA=>? -VWX~
=Õb{TUÕ+3U¬2¤ ¬ÕUÕbU¬2bU>ÕU=ÕU>FGo¢U4}ÅT¬2 UuT89
VÏj^FG}U89mBbe{+\]>½iB BbeV \]~(b)    



93fGgh{TU!U3UuTB B%89VFG\]`abuTcd
beBGoY21Ei V ½hV \]~fGghTUÐ2¤fGgh
Y qj¹]\qBY pqU¤ ¬ÕfG&m ouTQ}qp]
fCi/U hm¼\]q4U V ½~ uUfGghTUBhmÐ2¤Yy*¹]¹ ¹BhB4^\YTUkl_uT^G_{i]z{4]~ {TU,89Í:;9Í49BÔÕÖ×201(qq)Yy*¹]89
=m@AVYÅ89Y#¸Yl ¹]z{V \]~V{TU >B" =>?ÆUa>R*W>VWXSB@*UuTe»Buv
BYGo¹]Us{}q B>ËEiY]V \]~ÒVÓB
YTU89VR>uT3Ê\]mW¹UBaYopj¹]\qB89
mBVuT#!hB´BV" U@*uT2¹]º/½ºT 
ip~
89{TU,89Í:;9Í49BÔÕÖ×201(f)Yy*¹]89V
}Uz¹YTA=>? -mW¹]~89YT@Aij?Y,8%?U8
9%?=>?9%?B¡P{4i]89mW¹]~
QsY¹qpip89{TU m(#Y º¹u%Y(¹j¹u89V \]~B>½iB3{}qTU B pu«¬¤uT
U B pu'= Uu ¾'Bpu'= UuT'Bpu)=i/m]~zBoYTUÐ2¤Yy*¹]=ÕbFG¹]
89TW¹ip~
D>{TU Uº?UÕ3U$=UDa>U=>? $iDD>
V }Uz¹YT_CDJ7PiVWX~Ò! D>ÓBoYT_CDJ
7PiU89V]U89m,i4B ¹qp]z{V \UuT    



94

B B%89V \]B] D>mW¹]~¡PB[g{TUIJKL50Mª=NOBFGgÀYZ[\]^G_Ukl_
uTfGghV \]~!a>{TUU"%U; U.VWX}Åipj]a>uT.
V \]~
kl_{TUFGY89Vkµl]j]hV }UBhm89B21kl
$¤]ººV ip~kl_mÐ2¤Yy*¹]fGghuT^G_B-4^\YTUBhmfGghuT^G_{4i]z{m]~_2huT_2hYq89Vkµl]UuT3Ê\]hUYlE
B[hTiphU=>?89V .\][gYqpiphTUkl_YW
¹ip~
S"T3U89{TU("%=>?%B·'¾UR>BQs
m ¹qp¹ÏUB3U U}ipUuTrsiÅijip89V
 \]~S"T3U89B3{}qTU U UU'¤=(A*BºUU2U$ U U Ai/B 89m]~^G_{TU`abuTcdY>89B§^V \]hV \]~^G_TÐ2¤^G_Yj¹]\qB-Y pqU¹V\]BmU89
V3Ê}U¹V^G_m}ubeY>ËEYa\]µBhi/B hu{}q4U V ½~Ð2¤Yy*¹]-4^G_m^\YTU^
G_mfGghuTkl_{4i]~$g{TU§ 1.900(a)B¡P{i]U o500_NOB[gV \]~u}U^
G_4kl_4ipU`abY>]fGghY pqTUzBoTU§ 1.900(a)B¡P{i]Uk52,550Mª=NOB[gV \]~rs¯"%¢¤+=RTCSS89{TU$ D>B# uT%    

95V°\]UrsBuvB¯"%¢¤+=V6P{\]89V \]~FG{TUgEB`abuTcdbeY>]89BaV \]~FG>L{TUbe¶B89FGgÀYopj¹]>LU3 ÏU=Õ=>?
=Õ¶B¢U U¤¤U2¬¤U*U 9UU1«¬¤U^(=>?^AB}BÖi/V \]~uUFG>LYTÈbY,]
¹qpipcdbeuT¤ ÕY,]¹qpip¤ 4W¹]~
FGgÀ{TU89BCD''Y}]U89FGY½\qBaV }U
z¹YTbe=>?FG>LBÕ3)+U%?U3@U^(=>?^AB}Ui
j?YfCmW¹]~QsY¹uS"T3U89U89o8 1UuTD¾u8oa>BBFGYºº]aTFGgÀYW¹ip~jYUV
m¼½DBVW>BFGaTFGgÀYW¹ip~
be{TU3 Ï`abi/B V uUuTcdbei/B=JV
a\]7JFGÈUFGgÀYopj¹]4BV \]~be=>?FG>L§ 1.906 be=>?FG>LYT/B>½iPw[xm o¹]Bº~(a) FGgÀYopj¹]be=>?FG>LBUBA=>?TU !
BGoEY#qÕ3)+m}\ÅUFG\]89mUFGgÀ YU/B>½i ºjq4U,UÍ-UuTB B%8oY iÅ
i]U]pT4ZY¡}q!{i]z{V4B{}iµ¹Ïijip~(b) be=>?FG>LTUFGgÀ Y/B>½i
ºjq4UFG\]
89m,UÍ-UuTB B%8oY iÅi]U]pT4ZY¡}q!{i]z{V*\]CD''Y }iµ¹Ïijip~(c) FG Y"%¢¤+=V}iµ¹Ï! D>B3i# V ]B
]89BFGgÀYGo¹]be=>?FG>LTU! D>B3i# V    



96°\]"%Y89V \]>½YUÊË=>?> }iµ¹Ïijip~(d) FG Y"%¢¤+=V}iµ¹Ï! D>B3i# V ]B]89BFGgÀYGo¹]beuTFG>LB0&=>?EY&'¹]"'SYTUS$#Y"%V \>½YL¹u "%U"%
y>LuT"% 0>LV iµ¹Ïijip~(e) be=>?FG>LTUBbeuTFG>Lm ¤V]U]pT ¹jmG¹]E]89mUFGgÀ Y/B>½i ºjq4U,
UÍ-UuTB B%8oY iÅi]UuT4ZY¡}q!{i]>½iB B% ¹]]^{i]z{V*\]»3Ê}iµ¹Ïijip~TFGgÀ
§ 1.908 FGgÀYT/B>½iPw[xm o¹]Bº~(a) +Pw[x~(1) ÐÔÕÖ×YyB$UÐÔÕÖ×BPw[xTFGgÀYZ[\]\qB^G_UfGgh=>?kl_Y o¹]~(2) FGgÀmÐ2¤BPw[xB\qY }q¹]z{V3t\] TU!i Y qiµ¹Ïijip~(3) \qBFGgÀTU89mUFGgÀ Y/B>½i
ºjq4U,
UÍ-UuTB B%8oY iÅi]UuT4ZY¡}q!{i]z{V*\]uvY6Pi=>?¢¤+=·}iµ¹Ïiji
p~z¹YTU¶·mW¹]~(i)  uT- i/B)^Ei¡VlU89V#(^ BDB89=>?8
9¶B9Y>] ºj@]z{~(ii)  U- UuTpi/BB B)^Ei¡VlU=ÕbFG    



97¹]89uTQsY¹qpip89VFGgÀ B =>? ºj3.\]z{~(iii) FG Y"%¢¤+=V}iµ¹Ï! D>B3i# V ]B]89Y pqU"%VWvUFGgÀmÐÔÕÖ×B2 + (a)(3)B
Pw[xVOu\»89mFG¹]z{V{\]z{~(b) FGgÀYZ[\]^G_Y o¹]Pw[x~(1) ^G_TUfGghY¡}U
fGghBbe=>?FG>LY pqU EiPw[x=>?Õ3)+VWvU\qB6PiCDPw[xV b }Ube=>?FG>LmU3
ÏU89mFG Y/B>½i ºjq4U,UÍ-UuTB
B%8oY iÅi]U]pT4ZY¡}q!{i]z{V>½iU8
9BFGY !iCD''Y]z{V{}iµ¹Ïijip~^G_mfGgh
Y|§\]±²TU§ 1.912(a)Y=µ] 0Pw[xB o¡P{i]~(2) QsY¹qpip89VUfGghm|\]beuTfGghm|
\]FG>LY( XYU^G_TBfGghm|}ubeuTFG>LVY pq9%?}iµ¹Ïijip~^G_TUBbeuTFG>Lm
89BFGY !iCD''Y]ºU3 ÏU89V \] {i]U!
a>B(U UB(^UuTi/BY0 ]t&mipz{VUH}iµ¹Ïijip~(3) FG Y"%¢¤+=V}iµ¹Ï! D>B3i# V ]B]89B^G_TU¹mTCS89¹U8TCS89¹UÕ89
VFG\]fGghVYÅfGghY¡}U&VWvuFGgÀ Y6Pi"%
V b }UBgÀ"%m ¹UÐÔÕÖ×B2 + (a)(3)BPw[xmOu¹]z{V{}iµ¹Ïijip~^G_mfGghÎ|§\]±²TU§ 1.912(a)B 0Pw[xB o¡P]~    



98

FG Y"%¢¤+=V}iµ¹Ï! D>B3i# V ]B]89B^G_TU89V( XYU0&=>?EY&'¹]"'SuT¢mUÐÔÕÖ×B2 + (b)(3)Y>qwvj¹].Y^G_m|§}u±²YZq&¹qp]z{V%t}iµ¹Ïijip~(5) ^G_TUFGgÀ Y89mYY ½"%Y3u¹]z{Y pq^G_m V ½z{Y§ 1.908(d)(2)(ii)YÃÄpq^G_{fGghm }qp]Ukl_YtV¼½z{YÈ}qU§ 1.908(d)(2)(i)fGghY o¹]Pw[xV½~^G_{fGghmB>½iV}qp]U^G_T§
1.908(d)(6)(ii)=>?§ 1.912(b)B¡\] 0Pw[x4½~(c) FGgÀYZ[\]^G_=>?kl_Y o¹]Pw[x~(1) ^G_=>?
kl_TU^(=>?^AB} g YQsY¹qpip89Vl½{(¹]befCmpV o¾]>½Y}iµ¹Ïijip~pT  *V)}UbefCmVq89B V¾]>½Y}
iµ¹Ïijip~(2) FG Y"%¢¤+=V}iµ¹Ï! D>B3i# V ]B]89B^G_=>?kl_TU89mB>½i D>B# V ip>½Y\]B·^B(AB} gV¼iµ¹Ïijip~(d) FGgÀYZ[\]fGghY o¹]Pw[x~(1) fGghTUÐÔÕÖ×
B2 + (b)(1)YZq^G_my}uPw[xVOu}UFGgÀ YU/
B>½i ºjq4U89m,UÍ-UuTB B%8oYiÅi]U]pT4ZY¡}q!{i]z{VuvYB B !iU
be=>?FG>LV|}iµ¹Ïijip~(2) fGghTU(i) FGgÀmQ}uU^G_YUuUPcm¹Ïkl_Y¡}q4U§(4)    



99

YZq^G_my}u{}u"%VFGgÀ Y }u{
t}iµ¹Ïijip~B>½itTU3 ÏUfGghm¯"% 0>L
B*3¤¤uTFG Biu"%yB 0V| \]i/UfGgh{^G_m¾] !iY>q ¾]~(ii) FGgÀY©UFGgÀ B"% )3+uTB B%FGg
À YB89mÃ#VOu\"%B·Y ¹qpuz{V3t\] V^G_m½z{YfGgh{^G_m }qp]UÐÔÕÖ×B2+ (d)(2)(i)BPw[xB o¡P{ijip~fGghTUPcm¹Ïkl_Y¡}qÑ¹uV|}iµ¹Ïijip~Ñ¹uT§ 1.912(b)B
0Pw[xB o¡P]~(3) "%¢¤+=V}iµ¹Ï! D>B3i# V ]B]89BFGYGo\]&'>L¾BbeuTFG>LV|\]YUfGghTÐÔÕÖ×B2 + (b)(3)YZq^G_my}u>½YEY&'¹]0&=>?"'SV&}iµ¹Ïijip~(4) 89FGY=ÕbV|\]fGghTUBbeFG}u 3B>Vy\]±²V^G_Y|}iµ¹Ïijip~^G_{fGghTUfGghm3
NOB>Vy\]±²V|\]z{UuTU|¹]=Õbmy¹]FGgÀY !]{3t\]myvj¹qp]U3 ÏQY>qf
Gghm1¿B9BFGoBbeBV|\]YTUfGghmB>½
i±²V|\]6PTipz{Y ¾]~Ñ¹uT§ 1.912(b)B 0Pw[xB o¡P]~(5) 89FGY=ÕbV|\]fGghTU=ÕbB+BÕ3)+Y p
qu±²V^G_Y|}iµ¹Ïijip~u}U|¹]=Õbmy¹]FGgÀY !]z{V3t\]YfGghmZ½U3 ÏUy1.908(b)(3)    

100

¹uy¹uÕ3)+Vop]z{YfGghmQ}qp]UuTU^G_m`&beBÕ3)+V¼½YTUfGghmB>½i±²V|\]6PTipz{Y^G_{fGghm ¾]~
Ñ¹uT§ 1.912(b)B 0Pw[xB o¡P]~}(6) fGghTU§ 1.912(b)B 0Pw[xB o¡P{i]U%B>½iVqÑ}U}iµ¹Ïijip~(i) 89BFGoYfGghm|\]be=>?FG>LV§ 1.906(b)Y*Àµj¹] !iCD''Y \]uvUbe=>?FG>LBÕ3)+U6PY#qU=>?%?BMnVb \]~(ii) ÐÔÕÖ×B2 + (2)B"%¢¤+=Y pqBMyY \]»
V]~(iii) ÐÔÕÖ×B2 + (d)(4)=>?(d)(5)B=ÕbBGoY pqBMyY
\]»V]~¤)+§ 1.910 FGgÀYZ[\]fGghYT/B>½i¤)+Pw[xm o¹]Bº~(a) fGghTUFGgÀYZ[\]YU89BFG YD#]B]
Ei89rs Y pqB³V5vUz½}uE Y¡\]ÃÐEiCD
FGMn=>?Ð2¤YÃÄÅfGghB VH³]¤)+V}iµ¹Ïijip~¤)+TU o=>?BT6PY#q}iµ¹Ïijip~(b) fGghTUÐÔÕÖ×B2 + (a)Y]¤)+VÑ\] 0
V =>? }iµ¹Ïijip~B>½i 0YTU¤)+B¦U¤)+B¿U=>?¤)+V½µuhRuSV }iµ¹Ïijip~    

101z½}u 0TU§ 1.912(c)B 0Pw[xB o¡P]~0§ 1.912 FGgÀYZ[\]^G_=>?fGghYT/B>½i 03Ê?B
B 0Pw[xm o¹]Bº~(a) ^G_TU#MBFGgÀB{}q§ 1.908(b)(1)=>?(3)*Àµj¹]>½
YfGghÎ±²V|}qp]z{Vt\] 0VU^G_mB>½i±²V|
\]Pw[xB o¡P]{¾Vqºj12º¥U3U}iµ¹Ïijip~(b) fGghTUÐ2¤B § 1.908(d)(2)(ii)*Àµj¹]Ñ¹uB
0{U§ 1.908(d)(6)*Àµj¹]Ñ¹uB 0VU=>?mFGgÀopj¹qp]{¾Vqºj12º¥U3U}iµ¹Ïijip~(c) fGghTU§ 1.910(b)*Àµj¹]¤)+ 0VUB>½i 0y¹uhmB¤)+V}uE]-V^u}Fµqp]{¾V
qºj12º¥U3U}iµ¹Ïijip~(d) ^G_=>?fGghTU>T Pcm¹Ï+YUÐ2¤*Àµj¹]\qB 0V#&YV( j¹u_Y| }iµ¹Ïijip~(e) Ð2¤Pw¹]\qB 0TUÐ 0U#ÐR3 ÏU¢U U8¢U$Õ+ =U$Õ+ ¬Ö UuTB BÐ
0B#iSUuT 0{}q3Ê}U 0TÐ 2¤11YZq
3Ê}iµ¹Ïijip~(f) § 1.908(d)(6)*Àµj¹]Ñ¹uVY¾U_&BPcºj24
¶$Y1B 0VÆÍ|¾]TU 0m ¹u¦ºj6º¥Y 0V1ºj ¹q3Ê¾]>½Yi]~§ 1.908(d)(6)*Àµj¹]Ñ
¹uTUBmFGgÀY=pqGo¹qp]U1Y=ºiµ¹Ïijip~ 0TU1Y]ºjÕÔ¹ÏU1Y]{    

102

i¹]~(g) Ð2¤Pw¹]\qB 0TUÐ B2¤20YÃÄÅPw[xB o¡P]~oXY§ 1.914 FDAT/B>½i'Ð2¤BPw[xV oXY\]Bº~
FDATUFDAm¶·B>½Y \]Uj]¿B_UbeU89uT8
9¶B9YÈ}qUÐ2¤B/BPw[x4U oVXY\]~(a) oXYY>q_uTa>B4ZY{q[\iB·89mFG¹]]^{ijip~(b) oXYT_`Ya}ip~§ 1.916 FDAT/B>½iYÐ2¤BPw[xV oXY\]º/½ºU%\]Bº~FDATU`$EYUuTÐ B § 10.30YÃÄpqUj]¿B_UbeU89
uT89¶B9YÈ}qÐ2¤BPw[xB o¡P]hm|§}
uc1Y¡}UÐ2¤BPw[xB oVXY\]º/½ºU%\]~§ 1.918 oXYVwv]c1BTUV}iµ¹Ïijipº~Ð B§ 10.30Y]Pw[xY U oXYVwv]c1BTU%B.
iµ¹Ïijip~(a) Pc\] oXYY pqUB oXYB¡P]_UbeU89uT89¶B9Uij?YB oXYB¡P]Ð2¤BPw[xVWvU{ Yb\]~(b) oXYm_uTa>B4ZY{q[\iB·89mFG¹]]^
V4uj¸U_`Ya}ipz{Vt\]±²V| \]~§ 1.920 oXYVwv]c1|§¹]UuTB>½ic1YÈ\]¢£¤    



103|§¹]U/B>½i±²m_ ¹]Bº~oXYVPc\]c1Y=pq|§¹]±²=>?B>½ic1Y pq|§¹]¢£¤TUÐ 2¤20YÃÄpq_ VXY¹]±²VW¸UzBPcYÈ,\]ª«¬¤B {}q_ ¹]{3y\]~§ 1.922 oXYVwv]c1YTU¹m¡\]Bº~89rsÍo88ÔRCFSANSuTa>o:;9ÔRCVMSBÕ4}ÅT  ÕUCFSAN¢* $SB ÕU
uTCVM 9Í¢* $SB ÕmU oXYBPcY¡\]~§ 1.924 oXYVwv]c1YT/B>½i*+Ôm o¹]Bº~(a) +YUÐ B § 10.30Y]mU oXYVPc\]c1ÎB¡Y o¹]~(b) Ð B§ 10.30(h)(3)YÃÄ¾U FDATFederal RegisterY.8V }U|§¹uc
1YÈ\]±²=>?0VUc1m¹]z{YiuY oXYY>q
Vkµ]B]hºjB±²=>?0VWvqUPc\]~(c) Ð B§ 10.30(e)(3)YÃÄ¾U FDAT c1hY\]~(1) FDAmc1V}uTUFederal RegisterY.8V }U oXY{B>½
i oXYBËBsÑuTB V \]~(2) FDAmc1V}uR 4WXSU FDATc1hY¡\] Y=pqËVb\]~(d) oXYVPc}q|§¹uc1B 3¤TU0c1B''R 3 ÏUc U
UuTSVWvU+_mY o¾]>½Y}UyEY \]~§ 1.926 FDAT/B>½i' oXYVwv]c1V}]Bº~§ 1.918YÃÄpq*Àµj¹]±²RÐ B § 10.30 BPw[xVWXSmc1
|¹qpipUuTUB oXYY>q_uTa>B4ZY{q[    



104\iB·89mFG¹]]^{i]U]pTB oXYT_`Ya\]{
FDAm \]U FDAT oXYVPc\]c1V¾]~§ 1.928 FDAm`$EYÐ2¤BPw[xV oXY\]U FDAT/B>½i*+ÔYZ½Bº~oXYm !]{FDAm`$EY \]UFDATFederal RegisterY.8
V }U oXY{B>½i oXYBËV]~§ 1.930 FDAm}u oXYTp !){i]Bº~
FDAm}u oXYTU Federal RegisterYB oXYB. m ¹]¦Y!){i]~§ 1.932 FDAT/B>½i' oXYV#UuTl} ]Bº~oXYY>q_uTa>B4ZY{q[\iB·89mFG¹]]^{i]m]U]pTU oXYm_`Ya\]m]{FDAm\]UFDAT oXYV#\]UuTl\z{m¾]~§ 1.934 FDAm oXYV#\]UuTl\¾]{ }uU/B>½im o¹]Bº~(a) FDA T%B>½Y. V¼½~(1) c1Y¡}q¹u oXYV#\]UuTl\¾]{FDAm\]U2Y oXYVPc}uYUc1Y=pqy¹u1¨B
. \]~(2) oXYV#\]UuTl\¾]{B Y pqUFDATFederal
RegisterY.8V \]~zB.823¬Õª«¬¤mµj¹U¹Y>UÈhTFDAB YÈ\]|OV |§¾]~(b) FDATU Èhm Y23¬Õª«¬¤Î |§}u|OV%\]~(c) FDATUFederal RegisterYyB.8V \]~zByB$)¦T.8B_¦    



105

{i]~
¦J20141¥29¦
Leslie Kux,
Assistant Commissioner for Policy[FR Doc. 2014-02188 Filed 01/31/2014 at 11:15 am; Publication Date: 02/05/2014]    

