What happened? The day Flight 17 was downed

添付資料２

By: YURAS KARMANAU (AP), PETER LEONARD (AP)48.026138.7723
SNIZHNE, Ukraine (AP) — It was lunchtime when a tracked launcher with four SA-11
surface-to-air missiles rolled into town and parked on Karapetyan Street. Fifteen hundred miles(2,400 kilometers) to the west, passengers were checking in for Malaysia Airlines Flight 17.
It had been a noisy day in this eastern Ukrainian town, residents recounted. Plenty of militaryequipment was moving through. But still it was hard to miss the bulky missile system, also known
as a Buk M-1. It left deep tread marks in the asphalt as it rumbled by in a small convoy.
The vehicles stopped in front of journalists from The Associated Press. A man wearing unfamiliar
fatigues, speaking with a distinctive Russian accent, checked to make sure they weren't filming.
The convoy then moved on, destination unknown in the heart of eastern Ukraine's pro-Russia
rebellion.
Three hours later, people six miles (10 kilometers) west of Snizhne heard loud noises.
And then they saw pieces of twisted metal — and bodies— fall from the sky.
The rebel leadership in Donetsk has repeatedly and publicly denied any responsibility for thedowning of Flight 17.
Sergei Kavtaradze, a spokesman for rebel leader Alexander Borodai, repeated to the AP on
Friday that no rebel units had weapons capable of shooting that high, and said any suggestions
to the contrary are part of an information war aimed at undermining the insurgents' cause.
Nevertheless, the denials are increasingly challenged by accounts of residents, the observationsof journalists on the ground, and the statements of one rebel official. The Ukrainian government
has also provided purported communications intercepts that it says show rebel involvement in
the shoot-down.
A highly placed rebel, speaking to the AP this week, admitted that rebels were responsible. He
said a unit based in the hometown of ousted President Viktor Yanukovych, made up of both
Russians and Ukrainians, was involved in the firing of an SA-11 from near Snizhne. The rebel,
who has direct access to the inner circle of the insurgent leadership in Donetsk, said that hecould not be named because he was contradicting the rebels' official line.
The rebels believed they were targeting a Ukrainian military plane, this person said. Instead, they
hit the passenger jet flying from Amsterdam to Kuala Lumpur. All 298 people aboard were killed.
Intercepted phone conversations released by the Ukrainian government appear to back up thecontention they were unaware the aircraft was a passenger jet.
In those tapes, the first rebels to reach the scene can be heard swearing when they see thenumber of bodies and the insignia of Malaysia Airlines.
Ukraine immediately blamed the rebels for the shooting. In an interview in Kiev this week, theUkrainian counterterrorism chief, Vitaly Nayda, gave the AP the government's version of the1/3

events of July 17. He said the account was based on information from intercepts, spies andresident tips.
Nayda laid the blame fully on Russia: He said the missile launcher came from Russia and wasoperated by Russians. The Russian Foreign Ministry on Friday declined to comment on either
charge. Moscow has continually denied involvement in the downing of the plane.
The rebel official who spoke to AP did not address the question of any Russian government
involvement in the attack. U.S. officials have blamed Russia for creating the "conditions" for thedowning of the plane, but have offered no evidence that the missile came from Russia or that
Russia directly was involved.
According to Nayda, at 1 a.m. on July 17 the launcher rolled into Ukraine across the Russian
border aboard a flatbed truck. He cited communications intercepts that he would not share withthe AP. By 9 a.m., he said, the launcher had reached Donetsk, the main rebel stronghold 125
miles (200 kilometers) from the border. In Donetsk it is presumed to have been off-loaded fromthe flatbed and started to move in a convoy on its own.
Nayda said the Buk turned back east toward Snizhne. Townspeople who spoke to the AP said it
rolled into Snizhne around lunchtime.
"On that day there was a lot of military equipment moving about in town," recalled Tatyana
Germash, a 55-year-old accountant, interviewed Monday, four days after the attack.
Valery Sakharov, a 64-year-old retired miner, pointed out the spot where he saw the missilelauncher.
"The Buk was parked on Karapetyan Street at midday, but later it left; I don't know where," hesaid. "Look — it even left marks on the asphalt."
Even before the plane was downed, the AP had reported on the presence of the missile launcher
in the town July 17.
Here is what that dispatch said: "An Associated Press reporter on Thursday saw sevenrebel-owned tanks parked at a gas station outside the eastern Ukrainian town of Snizhne. In thetown, he also observed a Buk missile system, which can fire missiles up to an altitude of 22,000meters (72,000 feet)."AP journalists saw the Buk moving through town at 1:05 p.m. The vehicle, which carried four
18-foot (5.5-meter) missiles, was in a convoy with two civilian cars.
The convoy stopped. A man in sand-colored camouflage without identifying insignia — different
from the green camouflage the rebels normally wear — approached the journalists. The man
wanted to make sure they had not recorded any images of the missile launcher. Satisfied thatthey hadn't, the convoy moved on.
About three hours later, at 4:18 p.m., according to a recording from an intercepted phone callthat has been released by Ukraine's government, the Buk's crew snapped to attention when aspotter called in a report of an incoming airplane.

2/3

"A bird is flying to you," the spotter tells the rebel, identified by the Ukrainians as Igor Bezler, aninsurgent commander who the Ukrainian government asserts is also a Russian intelligence
officer.
The man identified as Bezler responds: "Reconnaissance plane or a big one?""I can't see behind the clouds. Too high," the spotter replies.
The rebel official who spoke to the AP about the incident said that Bezler commanded anotherfighter, code-named Sapper, who was the ranking rebel officer with the missile launcher at thetime.
According to the rebel official, Sapper led a rebel unit, about half of which was made up of men
from far eastern Russia, many from the island of Sakhalin off Russia's Pacific coast.
Sapper is from the nearby town of Yenakiieve, he said. The town also happens to be the home of
the former president, Yanukovych.
Sapper could not be reached for comment; his real identity is not known. Bezler, contacted on
Friday by the AP, denied any connection to the attack on the plane. "I did not shoot down theMalaysia Airlines plane. I did not have the physical capabilities to do so," he declared.
According to the account of the rebel official, however, Sapper had been sent that day to inspect
three checkpoints — in the towns of Debaltsevo, Chernukhino and Snizhne, all of which arewithin a 20-mile (30-kilometer) radius of where the plane went down. At some point in thesetravels, he joined up with the convoy accompanying the missile launch system.
At about 4:20 p.m., in the town of Torez, six miles (10 kilometers) west of Snizhne, residents
heard loud noises. Some reported hearing two blasts, while others recall only one.
"I heard two powerful blasts in a row. First there was one, but then after a minute, a minute and ahalf, there was another discharge," said Rostislav Grishin, a 21-year-old prison guard. "I raised
my head and within a minute I could see a plane falling through the clouds."
At 4:40 p.m., in another intercepted call released by Ukraine, the man identified as Bezler tells
his own superior that the unit had shot down a plane.
"Just shot down a plane. It was Sapper's group. It went down beyond Yenakiieve," the man says.
While the authenticity of the intercept cannot be verified independently, the U.S. Embassy inKiev said specialists in the intelligence community have deemed it authentic.
As for the Buk, Nayda said, intelligence suggests it went back on the move shortly after theattack.
That very night, he said, it crossed the border, back into Russia.
___
Leonard reported from Kiev. Other AP correspondents in eastern Ukraine assisted in this report.

3/3