Discussion paper .)/@N(5=@1'!

%}C#Ee\¶D~%­¥·

Discussion paper2008 œ 5 ƪ 24 ƜǱ.)/@N(5=@1'!

%}C#Ee\¶D~%­¥·ƲæħıƲæL`Lșȥce ƟƜ˕Ģŉ
http://www.cir.tohoku.ac.jp/~asuka/
asuka@cneas.tohoku.ac.jp»p¼
 ƜƯ2-5 cXe×Lwg /ɭɛ2 4 +4Ůā.ǟ-¸IG
-EùÐĹ/%G&G2Ľ!FĔ˅Ȝ®4ôŦ5ħ=2©4C2=/@DGF
1¹«A\`.)/@kMP¸iO¹*8239>3'¥lx\¶GXf˝źɟȟʜBÉʩĔ4\~hllƟȚ1ǸǴ2-ʥĔÂ
ôȈ!F45ǭǺA1)K/ĳɏ!F/1ɧƇÓĔ/Ƙ'1Tj]J1E¸4AȆĊkeƕÃʙ/ƹƯȊĊˑE
2¹L¬\"«A\"\N®{jFy3;>-4+:4<¸Iº\¶°±UG¹ Y\Y.)/@BP{'%#\¶w 'z
lx¸2008 c 1 s06-G¦\¶D~ %ovmd7,+:>¹\¶GXfº+4Sw_ /ɭ1A1Ęǹ4ʫăJ­ƾ4ɈĔ˅êÝ
ȾɌ2ɰ!C1/21F4.ĊˑĥkeAƕÃG-D"ȾɌȊ1ǧÃ³ÙAƕ*-1'@2009 œ=.4Ĕ˅¡ǡ2-5Ï³Ȋ1ʊʅ4Ľʌ21E2
3¹L¬\³P{'%¶bT^%S g¸IºVH[®$ CO2 kM®¹'#$­ lx\¶GXfºƜƯ2/*-ƫØ(ȳĔB_LƲǋ2/*-5Ø='àǷ©Ĥ2A\al10§4ŌȅåĜǧ5įė!FkeƕÃʙ/ƹƯȊĊˑAE
%A%AɘȊ+Ĕ˅Ȋ2ǿDGF Sectoral approach /ɭɛ254C1Ůā5ÿ=G-D"ɭɛ4¸ƙ/-ǌȚŪ2ǉ
4¹\N®{'`!%_ZY.)/@P®'  ¢ lx\¶GXfºĔ×ɆʹȏǄ4ħ/%GJʭŲ!F'@4ùcXe2FĽȮ\al%-ÚǢʹJƟD2!Fɮȯƙǘ4ʰžĊˑ/5ÌǊÈʮɺƜƯ4Ĕ×ɆʹȏǄ4ƽɯ4˅2ɐŰ'/4.G6%G5ƜƯ4ĔÐĊˑ.E%
A%A04ĔA´D4ƙǘ.Ȥ>'ƔÁJòɐ2-Ĕ×ɆʹȏǄJƽɯ-F!1I)×2ƘƎƻ.51Ŝ'EÛ4/Jɭ*-F2ʬ1AȤ>ƙ104ƙǘʅ2ˀ-àǷŪ/ĜǧJĔ˅Ȋ2ʷɪ!:/Ï³Ȋ1Ǝƻ
14.G6%G5ÛÓ4 3˚21F"G2H4ĞúA Sectoral approach /ɭɛ4ɘȊ1¸ƙ/5ȅ1F ¤š4ƜƯĔÐ2FʊʅC8Ĕ˅¡ǡJàǷȊ2ʩ@F'@25ǭǿ1ǟBƂʧ
Jʱ-źɟȟʜB˂ȃÚǢ\alƧɇ104Ĕ˅úŮŝŲwca2Fʷɧʃˑ2ˀ-ĔÐĤ.Ɲũ2ʊʅJǞ@-ŤɧF

1

Discussion paper .)/@N(5=@1'!

%}C#Ee\¶D~

%­¥·

!
 ǸėƜƯ.ǜŎ-F

cXe×Lwg

cXeLwg

cXlLwg ˙ɚɿ.5Sectoral approach ɘȊ1ɭƙ.Sector-based approach ¸IGFĞúAĥŃF˚104ʨ4ɭɛ5ɱ4 4 +4Ůāǟû-¸IG-EĔ˅Ȋ1Îʦɾʉ/4ˇʀɬ%-ǟF
1˚ʥĔ4ǳĳcXe2ƇÓÚǢ˙ŻÙ˚4\~hllJʃ!Ǝƻ
2˚ÉʩĔAʥĔAĔ×ɆʹȏǄ5ƅ'"2Ĕ˅ʻʼê®4C1lan_n1­ƾ4Ĕ˅Ȋ1ʨúȾɌùĔ4ùcXe4ÚǢȏǄJ=/@-ĴƚJɏâ¨-ȰǺ!
FĔ˅Ȋ1ƵȾ>Jǂȱ!:/Ǝƻ˙2008 œ 1 ƪ4f{a®ʊ=.4Ĕ˅¡ǡ2FƜƯƒŕ4ǌŘ1|`_˚

3˚ÉʩĔʿ4ÚǢȏǄJŌȅå!F˅4Ĝǧ47/+.FàǷŪ˙¹˝ì±ɥąǽǾʹ'E4 CO2 ƇÓʹ˚JCEʷɪ!:/Ǝƻ
4˚Ĕ×ɆʹȏǄJĳ@FĞú2ùcXe4ÚǢʹJȤ>-ɮȯ!:/Ǝƻ ƜƯƒŕˀ¼ɑ5ǟF5ƜƯƒŕƻŸÖG-FǺȁ/-66
Â4ʀɬ

ɓ

JƆFĥ4Ğú5ʀɬ.51¹62008 œ 3 ƪ2éɛ.ʾÄ

G' G20 ®ú.A4 ƪ2eN4r\X.ʾÄG' UNFCCC 4ʽƭȊêÝɞá2ˀ

!FLmzhXVYYw ˙AWGLCA˚.AƜƯƒŕ5Sectoral approach 4ȫɏ/FʥĔ4ǳĳcXe2ƇÓɆʹ˂˙Vhw˚JFƎƻ˙ɱ4 1˚˚JƟȚ2ɞ*'4.E%G2Ľ-ʥĔÂ5ŮāJǌȚ2Ǻɬ-ƟȚ2ôȈ'(.
F1=''/ʀɬ(/-AʀɬJFC1wdJ!Fƙ2˙A˚ʑ¬5
F1$1D6ɘȊ25șȥɑBĔ˅¡ǡ2Ó-FùĔƒŕˀ¼ɑ2/*-ɱ4 1˚/ 2˚4Ůā. Sectoral approach /ɭɛ¸IGF/2ſŽ51A443˚4Ůā.5ʦŐ5¸IG14.ʮĄůJƅ+D.F='4˚2ˀ-AȏǄ4ħBÏ³Ȋ
1Ȥ>ƙǘ2ˀ!Fɭó1˂EŜ'EÛ4/Jɭ*-FC2ɓ1 Ưȣ.5Sectoral approach 2ˀ!FĔ˅Ȋ1ÎʦɾʉC8ƜƯ.4ʊʅ/4"GJȼ¥!
F/ûƣ2¤š4|al 2013 œ4Ĕ˅¡ǡ2Fʷɧʃˑ2+-Ï³Ȋ1ʅǬJʢ:FG2C*-CEàǷȊ1ʊʅĔÐĤ2-ɞIGF/2ʏǶ'

1. Sectoral approach ¨ ȃ.ƩÕ2 Sectoral approach /ɭɛJ¸%4ǁŧJ³ȴȊ2Ŷ)Ó'45ȳĔ
4_XeX Center for Clean Air Policy˙CCAP˚.F˙ƩÕ2ɭĪ@'45 2004 œˎƩƘ4Ɇʁ5 Schmidt et al. 2007˚%4šĔ˅QpWǈˀ˙IEA˚BmNi4_Xe
X Ecofys 10AɆʁȊ1ysJƨ'EÙŖɲɮ2ˀ!FÏ³Ȋ1șȥJʩ@'EF˙Baron et al. 2007, Ecofys 2007˚"GAĜƯȊ1ɐƙ/45 CCAP 4A

1Ĵ˅25ƜƯƒŕ5AWGLCA 2-ʥĔJÿ? ɧƇÓĔ 2Ľ-cXe(.51-Ĕ×ɆʹȏǄJʃ!/JƎƻ'˙Government of Japan 2008˚1ǌŘ1ƖƨF5ÍŘ1
Ğ. ɧƇÓĔ˙major emitting countries˚ /ɭɛJ¸*-F45Ȭɑ4ȖF˂EƜƯƒŕ4>.E%4ĳɏ5=(ƟD2G-1

2

Discussion paper .)/@N(5=@1'!

42ǖ*-F'@4%}C#Ee\¶D~

Sectoral approach 4ĶƓŏ%­¥·/AĂ:F CCAP 4ɐƙBĳɏ;<ȃȊ1Îʦɾʉ/1*-F ȳĔ_l4ƒȮ_XeX.F CCAP  Sectoral approach JƎƻ'1Ǻȁ5
1˚ʥĔJòÞ#F'@4i2˚ÉʩĔ­ƾ4Ĕ˅ȪÝČĨĊˑ4ɬǔi4
+2Ǚȏ'D.F!1I)Sectoral approach 5ƟD2ÉʩĔ˙­ƾ˚4ØȌJʷɪ'ɐ.E%G5vh_ƒǆ4A/ȳĔƒŕJ
-AʥĔJòÞòÞ

#F'@250

#FŤɧFŃ1/A%4*/1FC1Ï³Ȋ1

ƎƻJ!FŤɧF/ȳĔF5ȳĔ_XeX4ǳǍŬ2î'A4.
*' 4C1 CCAP Ĉ!F Sectoral approach 4Ï³Ȋ1ÙŖɲɮ2F|Nl5ȗƭȊ25ĔÌ³.4ɆʹȏǄJöËGF÷ɕŪˋŐ2łʥĔ2Ľ-ǳĳǾƾcX
eF5^vcXe4>2ǳĳ4źɟBǈĎ4ØǿJÛƎ/'ïì±àǷȏǄ˙xg}X˝¹/-5ì±ɥąǽǾʹ'E4 CO2 ƇÓʹ2˚Jɲĳ!F/2C*-'/ĔÌ³4ƇÓʹ4ʲ.*-AĴʕȊ1ƇÓɆʹ˂˙Vhw˚JƔÁȏǄ/-ʃ!
@2 .ƕǺ' 1˚4ŮāɘȊ2¸IG-FA˛˛˛˛
4.ESectoral approach 5=.AʥĔ4ǳĳ4ǾƾcXe(.A òÞ #
/.F!1I)Ưȣ4 5

F'@4i/-Ĕ˅Ȋ25ɾʉG-F ÉʩĔF5ÉʩĔ­ƾ2/*-4hl5ɭ=.A1'/ǳĳǾƾcXe
(.AʥĔ´D4ƔÁȏǄJƅ+/.F%G5ĴʕȊ25˙àǷə˚ÉʩĔ­ƾ5ħ1ƇÓÚǢJ#"2Ǡ>˙àǷū˚ʥĔ­ƾ5ħ1ƇÓÚǢJ1
G61D1C1Ĕ˅ƵȾ>4ǂȱJŮā!FƙʥĔ2/*-4hl5ÉʩĔǊȫ.5FA44źɟʔʺȟʜƃħ!F÷ɕŪF/.F˙=.A÷ɕŪ.F/2ǙŮ˚ƙʥĔ4khl5FcXeʲÔ(.5FA44
VhwJƅ+/.EG2C*-ŜɻcXe.4 CDM 5÷ɕ21F˙GHG S
uchlw`PXl5 JI /1F˚4'@Ĕ2C*-5źɟ˙ʔʺ˚ȟʜǢF/AɐDGF!1I)4 Sectoral approach 5ÉʩĔʥĔ9ż' L / g4ƙȾúI*'Ǝƻ.E g
L4ÐĹAÏ³Ȋ25ƟD21*-1A44

4ÐĹ5A*/ƟD21*-1/4ǸǴ.F ĘǹÌ³.4ǻğàƴ/-5ʥĔ2FƇÓÚǢ˙ŻÙ˚ʩ?/2C*-ĘǹÌ³.4ƇÓʹÚǢ˙ŻÙ˚ʩ?÷ɕŪFƙǼïì±ȏǄVhwJF
/2C*-´D4ŝ.ƇÓʹõřÙŖË*'ĞúĘǹÌ³.4ƇÓʹÚǢ˙ŻÙ˚
ʩ=1÷ɕŪAF!1I)xg}X4ɲĳ4¦ƙ2C*-wa2A}Nn
a2A1F
 Ʃħ4ʃˑ5xg}Xɲĳ4ˈ.F1$1Dxg}X4ƔÁɖ³B
%G2ɗFȿʚJùĔēƫ4ǴǗ˙ǸėC8ĿƱ2FQpW~hXaƒȮȿǠŲʽǛáʹ10˚JɐŰ-Ō×å'A4JùĔɖD¶Ų-%GJĔ˅Ȝ®Ź
ɾ!FŤɧFD.F Ĵ5ǸėÉʩĔJÿ@'ùĔùǾƾcXe2FǸƣǬ.4àǷJǌȚ2Ĕ˅ǐʞ%GD2Ľ-ùĔúŮ'ke5įė1/ɭ*-Aʬɭ.51¹6ƩAƘke/-52005 œ4YNYa.4 G8 ^~hl.ăJö' IEA 2

G©Ĥ2Aì±ɥąǽǾʹŜ'E4QpW¸ǿʹBȓQpǈĎ4ƤóǷ10xg}X/
-ɐDGF

3

Discussion paper .)/@N(5=@1'!

%}C#Ee\¶D~%­¥·ɧĔ4Ĕ˅ǐʞJɸ>'A4F˙IEA 2007˚Ĵ˅2ǐʞFƔÁÓ'45c
lÔʸ4>.§4cXe2-5keʙBğȃ˙rOf˚4ĳɏ2ˀ!
FʮDƩȽȊ2ùĔúŮ.FƔĮJ¶F/5.1*'D2xg}
X4ƔÁ5ĿƱ4ĔÐƚȮC8Ĕ˅ȿǠǻğ2ŞˍJöF'@CEħ1ȚĴŪJ°/21F!1I)ʥĔ5ɭI"A1ÉʩĔ.!DcXeǏ4ȻĵɫȊ
1keJ¶F/5ĒˈJƿ@F )1>22007 œ 6 ƪ2ȬɑĔƒŕˀ¼ɑƔ£2 Sectoral approach 4hl/khl2ˀ-ˆȊ2Net'/H1˚ʥĔǳ2Ĕ2-5+4Ǿƾc
Xe2Aĥǃ1ɩǅBȢ˒4­ƾįė!F4.û

cXe.AɦƔ4xg}XŤ

ɧ/1F2˚cXe4>(/-AVhwF/5öËGDG13˚ïì±
ȏǄ14.ƇÓʹĠF0˙ÉʩĔÂ5˚%G.AC4˞101ôŦ.*''(!.2Ĕ2-5Ĕ4ȓQpĔĸw4ȻĴƚųȄȮĳ4'@2c
XeB¿×4­ƾ2vXfO'keJǿ-Ĵ˅2ȓQpȏǄĴǸ4ųȄ_nSƨG++F'*-Ń1/Aʲ4cXe2ˀ-5ke104Ċˑ5§4ʥĔCE5ł/ɐDGF
 "G2HʥĔ2/*-5'/ǳĳǾƾcXe4>(/-A£Ŝ'EƇÓʹ4ɃĽȊ1ƺŌFǸǴ2-ɨʡE12CDM Jʆ@-ƔÁ\~hllJöËGF/5ɐDG1'*-Ûʢ4C2 L/-Ń1D3ɤÆʥĔ2Ľ-Ťɧ÷ǉ/4Ĕ˅Ȋ1ɾʉ/1*-E%4C1Ǻȁ.Ǹėšʢ!FC2źɟʔʺȟʜĔ˅¡ǡ2-ħ1j}/1*-F˙“no lose”/Ă6
GFynjM41ȏǄɲĳAʥĔ2Ľ-5ƎƻG-F˚

2. ov´K¡.)/@N(5=@1

j¤ 4C1 Sectoral approach 2ˀ-ƜƯ˙ƒŕˀ¼ɑNGO­ƾ}a\~˚2F
cXe×Lwg/ɭɛ4¸ƙ25"G/ǟF ȫ2ƜƯ.5 Ĕ×ɆʹȏǄJĳ@FĞú2ùcXe4ÚǢʹJȤ>-ɮȯ!
:/Ǝƻ ˙Ưȣ4 5@2 .ƕǺ' 4˚˚/Ůā.}a\~102-ȼ¥GFĞúĥG=.ʢ:'C2ɘȊ+Ĕ˅Ȋ2ǿDGF Sectoral
approach /ɭɛ254C1Ůā5ÿ=G-D"ɭɛ4¸ƙ/-ǌȚŪ2ǉ-F ȫ2 EU 4ȏǄƔÁɲĳ5lhwfO.cXe×Lwg2CFƜƯ4ȏǄƔÁɲĳ5{lLhw/ɭƙǣƥåĽȮ4ȏǄɲĳBĽȮJʊʅ!FĞ

úɘȊ2lhwfO/45ɘęɠkJǿ'ɮȯJŮā{lLhw/45¿×4źɟJƟțȊ2ŷk˙¹˝ƜƯ4ĔȧǻğșȥŴ4 AIM3˚Jǿ'ɮ
ȯJŮā!F!1I)="ȏǄ*-%GJʭŲ!F'@4ĽȮ\alȿǠÌ³
94Şˍ10JÏ³Ȋ2ƟD2!Fƙǘ/-lhwfO2CFɮȯƙǘ/{lLhw2CFɮȯƙǘFȏǄƔÁ4ɲĳƙǘBħ/lhwfOF5{lLhw/45xȅ1Fǁŧ14.F ȫ2 {lLhw4cXe×Lwg.5ȏǄÁł1F'@˙ȞıȊ2Ť

3 AIM k5{lLhwĚ4Qmak˙QpWƩȽǝʒ2+-4k˚/-ƫü(ǫȺȡ4ɮȯ.5lhwfOkAá-F2050 œ 70˘ÚǢ5Ĵ˅25ƙ4
ɧȺJȾ>úI#'A4.ˉɧ4ǢŃJÛƎ/-F/A*- 70˘ÚǢ/ǐʞȊħ1ÚǢ
ő21*-F

4

Discussion paper .)/@N(5=@1'!

%}C#Ee\¶D~%­¥·

ɧ14˚ÚǢʹ2Ň1 /ʊʅA¹6ƜƯ4ĔȧǻğșȥŴ4 AIM k
2CF{lLhw.Ȥ>'ɮȯ.A2050 œ 70˘ÚǢ/ǐʞȊħ1ÚǢƔÁȏǄ2Ľ!FÏ³ȊĽȮƟD21*-E%GDJĴƚ!F˅4\alAɮȯG-F
 ȫď2 ĔÌ³4ƇÓÚǢʹJcXeǏ2Ȥ>-ɮȯ!F/45ƜƯǵɖ4LN
kL

4C1ɭƙBʊʅAĔ×ɆʹȏǄJǔ@F/2cXeǏ2Ȥ>

F/45(G.AɐFŜ'EÛ4/.Ĵ˅2 EU ÞȍĔ4¢ʳʊĳƨȏǄ4ʍƀÔƀƙǘ˙1998 œˎ2Ȯĳ˚5cXeǏ2àǷJĜǧ2-1EɊĺ2{lLhw.Ȥ>-ɮȯ-FŜǮEU 4|al 2012 œ2F 1990 œǐ 20˘-30˘ÚǢ/ȏǄ4ĞúAEU 4v/1*-FSfĔȧǻğșȥŴ˙RIVM˚cXe
Ǐ2{lLhw.Ȥ>-ƛ2ɮȯ-F˙Elzen et al. 2007˚D2Ĵ5 EU ÞȍĔ
4Ô4>1D"˙ƜƯAÿ@'˚ȃùĔ 450ppmCO2eq B 550ppmCO2eq /ǪŖĲĳå
ȏǄJƅ*'Ğú20G(4ÚǢŤɧ/1FA˙1990 œD.A 2010 œD.A BAUD.A˚!.2ɼȻ2{lLhw.ɮȯ-F˙EU 4 20˘/4AŜǮ4 RIVM
4ɮȯJòɐ2-Ŷ)ÓG-F˚
 !1I)AƜƯƒŕÓ-FcXe×Lwg.4ƔĮ˙ȞıȊ2Ťɧ1˚ÚǢɆʹBȏǄ2Ň14.G6%G5²˂ȃÚǢ\al4ĽȮĴƚ1/ÛƎ.ùcXe4ÚǢʹ˙|j_˚Jɮȯ-%GDJȤ>'(.FɭƏG6Ȥ>ƙŘūDĽȮBźɟ1D{lLhw.ɮȯ'
D/Ċˑ.Ì1ʍƀC/!F\alJł'˙ƒŕF5ĔǑÌ³/-ħ1\alJ'1˚/ƒǕȊŮŨ4Ċˑ.F ȫ2ʥĔ4ǳĳcXe2\~hllJʃ!Ǝƻ˙ 5

Ůā.¸Ğú2 cXe×Lwg5źɟȟʜJ½!ƙǘ

@2 .ƕǺ' 1˚˚4/Ś!F4AˋŐ2~akMY.F1$1D6!.2ʥĔ2Ľ-ÇÉȊ2źɟȟʜ!:Ï³Ȋ1
cXeAźɟA\alA;<ƟD21*-FD.F%A%AʥĔÂ4ʐ'Ś5 ǒÀģáƵȾ>ưȶȫ 4 ưȫ 5 ˏ.źɟȟʜ5ÉʩĔ4ɏâ/5*EƨF5%G142ÉʩĔźɟȟʜJʥĔ4ƇÓÚǢ˙ŻÙ˚/
#F/ɖ³

g/A4.F!1I)Ʃħ4Ċˑ5ʂ\alJʍƀ!

F.EGAƙǘʅBƵȾ>4Ċˑ.51Ûʢ4C2Ĵ˅25
g

/Ⱦ>úI

L

/



4raF5¡ǡ4Ċˑ.*-ÉʩĔ/ʥĔƙ4ƒǕȊ1ŮŨ4Ċˑ.

F 166ċ¯GFʥĔ2ƜƯ4źɟŁËG'Ğú4ÚǢ|j_5ħ/ɭʁ5ʥĔÂDɨG6ʑ¬ʜĬ4ʊʅ/ơD1/5ɾʉ!:(/Ũ1$1D6|j_F/A%4ħAĽȮźɟ4ŁËŤɧ.
F/A!:-ɖƟ(D.F˙ʬñèœ2´ȉ/ÉɞșȥBƎɭF˚!1I)
So what? /4ʥĔ4ôŦ.EĊˑ5Ûʢ'C2 ʂ\alJʍƀ!F
4

.F4C1ɭʁ5¹G6|j_Jƅ+ĭº5ħ£21G6A*/ƝʗGFħ1/Ŝ'EÛ4/Jɭ*-F2ʬ1ƯʕȊ1Ċˑ5ĭºJħ£2#F'@4Ɠɔǈ®4ƎºBƸ˓4ºɂ10J0!F14.F

4ƜƯ4kML10.C4C1 ȞıȊ /ɭɛ¸IG-Fĥ4ĞúCOP13
4 AWG 4ƩȽúŮƖƨ2ɱʟG' IPCC 4ÚǢ_nS4+.F 2020 œ2ÉʩĔ. 25-40˘ÚǢ
˙1990 œǐ˚ 4C1ÚǢʹJŮā-F/ŨIGF5
ưƖ.5 ɏâ /-ɾʉGF shall /ɭɛ¸IG-F5Discussion paper .)/@N(5=@1'!

%}C#Ee\¶D~%­¥·

3. 3;>-4+:4<y.)/@#%\¶U`˛˛˛˛˛˛˛˛˛ ƜƯƒŕ52008 œ 1 ƪ4ȃȿǠuR˙f{a®ʊ˚=.5 ÉʩĔAʥĔAĔ˛˛˛˛˛˛˛˛˛˛×ɆʹȏǄ5ƅ'"2 Ĕ˅ʻʼê®4C1lan_ n1ȾɌùĔùcXe4ÚǢȏǄJ=/@-ĴƚJɏâ¨-ȰǺ!FC1Ĕ˅ȊƵȾ> ˙Ưȣ4

5

@2

.ƕ

Ǻ' 2˚˚J 2013 œ©ˁ4Ĕ˅ȊƵȾ>4ɧ1ƶ/-'/GF
 4C1Ĕ˅ƵȾ>5Sw_/-5įė!FA44ȩȊ2ɭ6

J­ƾ2CFɖȊ1\~hllBɈĔ˅êÝȾɌ2¬#-C4˞

Ęǹ4ʫă
/ɖ

Ǯ1ȆĊDÙŖɲɮ4ɧ1ƶ2!F45ˈ/4Ĕ˅Ȋ1ɾʉ(/ŨIGF˙CCAP 2007, IEA 2007, Colombier and Neuhoff 2007˚ǳ2IPCC țć!FĔ˅Ȝ®Ì³4ʽƭȏǄ/4ˀ¼keʙTrǷcXeʿ4ÍŒŪ­ƾʿ4ÍŒŪàǷŪ
oeY4ĒˈǘȊʑ¬4ƙǾƾȃ4Ĕ˅êÝȾɌɖ³4ǧÃ³Ù4èÔ
10Ċˑ/-ƆDGF'*-Ɣœ4Ĕ˅¡ǡ2-5ǁŧȊ1ʊʅ5
÷ɕ.5FA44ʊʅ4ɀƴÏ³Ȋ1ƔÁȏǄɲĳ2!2+1F/5ɐ2
%GCEAÇÉː±4˗L`Pf2¡ǡ4ħʲÔ4ƣʿ5ʒBGF/ŭGF
 %A%AǩȪ--ƇÓʹ4ÍɡƁþ-'˙F˚­ƾɖD4Ǜá
ʹ2ÙȶJFC1õEǔ@JɖȊ+Ȫú­ƾ/êÝ-Ùĳ.F5ħ2ȆĊ
.EɦƔ4Ĕ2ǽǾɲÃJƅ+ĥĔȲ­ƾ4ųȄ5§4­ƾ/5ȅ1F/AŭG
F!1I)­ƾʿ4¡ǡȹȵ-ƩȽȊ25!:-4­ƾ2/*-ǼƔÁȏǄ21*-=÷ɕŪ5˗C2ŨIGF6 '*-4C1Sw_

4ƫàŪJŚ!F//2009 œ4 COP15 .4úŮŝ

ŲJľȠ2ËG-ǻğÔʸ.4Ĕ˅Ȋ1f_hwJ/F//5ȧ-D"ʤ2ƜƯ4XkMtjMJ'C2ŨIGF 14Sw_

ÉʩĔĔ×ɆʹȏǄJƅ+/ư«4ʊʅ.G6ÉʩĔ4Ĕ×ɆʹȏǄ2Ľ-ʣÞȊ2ʥĔ4ǳĳcXe2\~hllJʃ!C1ƵȾ>4Ǝƻ/=*'ûʊʅ'ʥĔJ.EƯȣ4 5

òÞ

@2 4 1˚/-ƕǺƯȣ4 1 .I#F'@4ʃˑûC2Ŝ-5=Fʤ2AÉʩĔʿ(

4ƵȾ>.G6ʥĔ2/*-5ˀ¼41ɺ21F˙A)HKÉʩĔ4Ưˌ4/
H.4e[hl5ʥĔ4ʻʼclL~104ǾƾcXe14.ÉʩĔʿ(
.ɺJʩ@F/5ɐ2˚ Ȭɑ2008 œ 1 ƪ4f{a®ʊš4 2 ƪ2 EU BʥĔ4¡ǡƀŜɑƔ£2Net
'/H ƜƯ5Ĕ×ɆʹȏǄJŤɧ/ɭ*-F4ɧ/*-FƮ(2C
ID1
4|`_/\lŃ11*'G52f{a®ʊ©Û4ƜƯƒŕÉʩĔ4Ĕ×ȏǄ2ˀ-ƟȚ.1*'/ŅJř-F/ŨIGF='==1Ĕ˅®ʊ.4wd4¦ƙBwdje4Ōȅ˙ȓŔʿ4Ōȅ˚2
AŞˍJö-F÷ɕŪAF "G2HAʪA442008 œ 3 ƪéɛ.4 G20 ®ú.ƜƯƒŕŸÖG-ʶƟ
2ʣIG'C1ǴǗJʱF'@25ʽƭȏǄɲĳBcXe×Lwg2ˀ-="ĔÐ2-èÔ2ʊʅJń-ÎʦɾʉJʵŲ%4š2Ĕ˅Ȝ®2Ľ-XL
1hc`JÓ!/wcaŤɧ.*'C2ŨIGF6ȃƒŕįė1ǸǴ2-5ùĔƒŕF5 UNFCCC ´D4¥ËJ!FŤɧŪ5F%4ƙǘ5ĥ4Sw_ EàƴJÏ³Ȋ2ɷ»!F4AĹƠ.51

6

Discussion paper .)/@N(5=@1'!

%}C#Ee\¶D~%­¥·

4. L¬\³RQ|ª¸Comparable effort¹^.)/@N(5=@1
£J
 !.2ʢ:'C2ĜƯȊ25ǸėĔ˅Ȝ®.ʊʅG-F Sectoral approach 5ʥĔ2FǳĳǾƾcXe4òÞ2ˀ!FƎƻ.EÉʩĔʿ4ȏǄ4Ōȅå2ˀ!

FŮāú5ÿ=G-1'*-CCAP 5ƜƯˀ¼ɑ¸ cXe×Lwg4.4

ùǾƾ4àǷJʷɪ!F/ʲÔ˙Ưȣ45@2

4 3˚4Ůā˚J

ɱ4C1ÉʩĔ4Ĕ×ƇÓÚǢȏǄ4ɲĳ2-ùĔ4Ťɧ1ßÝ˙Úɧʹ˚Jǐʞ˙Comparable effort˚-ǔĳ!FĞú4+4ɐƙ4)4+/ťŖ-ƕǺ-F
˙Schmidt 2008˚ ȫ5źɟLwg˙àǷLwg˚/ɭFA4.ì±ǽǾʹ'E4ƇÓʹBǈĎ4ŁËǷ104xg}XJǔ@-%2ʭŲ!F=.4ÚǢʹJùÉʩĔ4ÚǢŤɧʹ/-ʃ!ƜƯƒŕŚ-F45=2G.F ȫ5\alLwg/AɭFA4.ǣķàƴUaƇÓÚǢźɟBĽȮJĴƚ!FĞú4˂ȃÚǢ\al˙MAC: Marginal Abatement Cost˚F5ɆÚǢ\alJùÉʩĔ.
û

2!F˂ȃÚǢ\al4Ğú5¹6ùĔ 30 m˜t-CO2 =.4źɟJŁË'E

ĽȮƋɎJĴƚ'E!F/Jɏâ/%4˅4ÚǢʹJÚǢŤɧʹ/-ʃ!ɆÚǢ\al4Ğú5¹6 GDP 'E 1˘/ĽȮ2FɆ\al4˂Jǔ@-ùĔ%=.\alJ-ÚǢ'Ğú4ÚǢʹJÚǢŤɧʹ/-ʃ!7 .ǙŮ!:145"GAȏǄÁ4ħ4ʄƕ÷ɕ1/.F!1I)
CEðxg}XJɲĳ'E˂ȃÚǢ\al4CE˗ĽȮJĴƚ'E!G6
ïǺȊ25ȏǄÁ5D.A˗!F/.F ùÉʩĔ4öĹŪ5©4C2ŭGF ȳĔB_LƲǋʇĔ52QpW»ƺĲǺȁ.ĥ4cXe2-àǷ5ū˙ȓQpǈĎ4ŁËǷ10²˚'*-źɟLwg5Ø1Sw_/1F˙ʤ2˂ȃÚǢ\alJǿ'\alLwg4Ğú5ȓQp104pUjMv\al21FĽȮźɟŃ1ȳĔ5ƫØ21F˚='G=.ȳĔ5ĔÐ.4Ï³Ȋ1
ÚǢƙǘ4ʰž5ÐƒĊˑ.F/ǺȁDƒȮƋɎ4Ĕ˅Îʦå25śôĽ-'ȿɉFD2źɟLwg4ĞúùĔĔÐ.4ùcXeʿ4ʍƀÔʴ4ÍŒŪBàǷŪ/ĊˑAF EU 5¢ʳȏǄ4 EU ěÐ.4ʍƀÔƀ4ƣ5źɟLwgJƈǿ--|al 2012
.ARIVM 5ûC1ƵȾ>JƊɜ-F˙Elzen et al. 2007˚2008 œ 2 ƪ2ɞ*'Ȭɑ4 EU ƒȮƀŜɑ94NetC8ŠD4 COP ǧÃ®ú.4Ȉɭ102CF/
EU īĆ®5˙RIVM 4ƎɭJǭɪ-˚\alLwg%GA GDP 'E4Ɇ\alJû

2!FLwgJCEʷɪ!FC21*-F%4Ǻȁ5|al 2012 4 EU Þȍ

27 TĔ4.4ʍƀÔƀ¡ǡ.ƲǋʇĔȑŵ2źɟLwgJŚɄF45ˈ*'D.F!1I)Yr4Ğú.AȳĔBTnfB_LJòÞ#F'@25\alLwg4ƙǸĴȊ25÷ɕŪ˗/ EU 5ɐ-F '*-˙ƜƯ2/*-ƫØ1ƻ.F/5ƟȚ(D/Ůā.˚ƜƯƒŕ4Ś
5ǺɬG++FA44źɟLwg4>.ÉʩĔʿ2-Ĕ˅úŮJŢF45ǸĴȊ25ĒˈŭGF

7

CCAP 5źɟLwg5 equal endpoint\alLwg5 equal effort /ɭɛJ%G&G¸*-ƕǺ-F˙Schmidt et al. 2008˚

7

Discussion paper .)/@N(5=@1'!

%}C#Ee\¶D~%­¥·

 '(ĔȌB­ƾȌJCEʷɪ!F/ȏȊ4A/.5ʥĔ94wd4¦ƙƂʧ(*'/J˃6ƜƯ4ʲ4ǾƾcXe.4àǷ4əJ/2ĔÐĤ2śɵF/ƜƯƒŕB­ƾ4BEƙųȄȊ2ʿʮ*-F/ɺ.A11$1D6
\alLwg2-A´D4Ōȅå5Ťɧ.E%4˅25àǷ4əūʷ
ɧ1ŌȅåĜǧ4+21EFD.F˙Ĵ˅25\al/àǷ/4qNvhmĚ2
1F/ŭGF˚=' ɖȜ4àǷ5ˋŐ2C

/ƜƯ­ƾ2CFhc`5ĔÐƇÓʹõřÙŖƜƯ2ŁËG'Ğú4ĔÐcXeʿ4ʍƀÔƀJŮʉ'hc`2A1*-F/ƊĻGF

5. h?§¯©­g Ƣœ 12 ƪ2Nmp_L4r.ɞIG' COP13 4ƩȽƜ˙15 ƜĕƦƜ˚ȹȵ-ǔɢ
ļÛ=.*'Ʃħ4ïĐ5źɟʔʺȟʜĊˑɁK(ʥĔ4ǣķàƴUaƇÓɈĄɏ
â2ˀ!FƖȨ4ʛJ@*-4Ľȧ.*'ȳĔ/ƜƯ5ƩȽƜÛĦ4ǎ˄.5
ɱ4C1ƖȨ˙ƩȽƜ4ĕƦƜƬ2ƎÓG'ʊʽƻ4ƖȨ/û˚2!F/JśŚ-ʥĔ5%42FC1ƖȨ˙ʥĔƻ4ƖȨ˚2!F/JśŚ'ɀ
ƴȊ25ȳĔ/ƜƯ4ƻJƈǿ'ŝ.ʊʽƻ/E"ƎțG''@ʥĔÂʊ
ʽ2Ľ-śôȈ'1$1DÛĦ4ʊʅ.5ɀʅÓ1*'4.ʊʽƻ.5ʅ
·ɱ21F/ʥĔÂ5Ũ*-'D.F
 <\#ovx¸15 o]qulM&¦²x¹n¼
measurable, reportable and verifiable nationally appropriate mitigation actions by developing countries
in the context of sustainable development, supported and enabled by technology, financing and capacity
building.

˙"Proposal by the President"˝FCCC/CP/2007/L.7˚˙Ąɴ˝ƅɄ÷ɕ1Ȉň2ǖźɟBʔʺɕÝý102ɣŶ)G'ɮǤĝĀƽɶ÷ɕ1ŜɻĔ2/*-ʯŜ1ƇÓÚǢŻÙɞá˚ »«A\xn¼
nationally appropriate mitigation actions by developing countries in the context of sustainable
development, supported and enabled by technology, financing and capacity building, in a measurable,
reportable and verifiable manner.  ˙Advance unedited version, Decision -/CP.13˝Bali Action Plan˚˙Ąɴ˝ɮǤĝĀƽɶ÷ɕ1źɟBʔʺɕÝý102ɣŶ)G'ƅɄ÷ɕ1Ȉň
2ǖɮǤĝĀƽɶ÷ɕ1ŜɻĔ2/*-ʯŜ1ƇÓÚǢŻÙɞá˚
 |Nl5NehXŝ.ț' measurable, reportable and verifiable8˙ɮǤĝĀƽɶ÷
ɕ1˚/ɭɛʥĔ4ɈĄ2ˀ!Fɞá(2F4%G/A˙ʥĔ.4ɈĄJ½!'@4˚ÉʩĔ4źɟȟʜBVs_jMtkMY104ɞá2AF40
.F!1I)šɑ(/ʥĔ5ÉʩĔDʥĔ94źɟȟʜèÔ.51
*'DɈĄɞáJĴƚ1-AC/ɬʶ÷ɕ21EĴ˅2ʥĔ5%4C
2ɬʶ-F˙¹6Su et al. 2008˚%-ƩȽȊ25ȳĔ/ƜƯİȧ''@2Ĕ5ĩêJµÅ1Gʊʽƻ¾ǌGF/21*'!1I)ʥĔɧǓ'ƖȨrɞáɮȂ4ǌŘ1ƖȨ/-ƈžG'

8

4 3 +4ɭɛ4.5
˙ɘȊ2ȫɑƽɶŤɧ/1F˚
verifiable /4ƩAśŮāJƅ+

8

Discussion paper .)/@N(5=@1'!

%}C#Ee\¶D~%­¥· ®ʊȽȎ4 12 ƪ 14 ƜǞĦD 15 ƜƝƬ2-4ǴǗǌȚ2uR.1*'44C1ĴJõE'ƜƯ4}a\~5ȋǭ2ʠÉʩĔÂ2CFźɟȟʜ
C8ʔʺȟʜ4ɏâ¤š4Ĕ˅¡ǡ2-ʥĔƅ+ˋŐ2ħ1Tm21

F/5Ťɗ.EĴ˅2 UNFCCC âņB EU 4¡ǡƀŜɑA%4C1\lJɍE
ʡ-F˙Reuters 2008˚1$1DʥĔ2FƇÓÚǢ˙ŻÙ˚2Ľ!FĖÝś=F
.ǣķàƴUaƇÓÚǢźɟ4źɟȟʜ5WvLmjNX4jNX/-ʥ
Ĕ2/*-ɃĽ2ʋG1D.F %-ˋŐ2ʷɧ1|Nl5ʥĔǓ@-Fźɟȟʜ5ĉƾxa.4ʦŐ4ʓƠǛá©4źɟȟʜ//.FCEÏ³Ȋ2ɭ6Ēˈ5ŭGFA44ʥĔÂĴʕȊ2ãØ++FQNbǕȇɝ4ȖȊʎǾǆ˙IPR˚4Ċˑ4C2ȃʓƠǈˀ˙WTO˚ɾ@FśÙǳɳĴƚǆ˙CL: Compulsory Licensing˚102C*-ÉʩĔ­ƾƅ+ȖȊʎǾǆJÙ˂!FF5Ĳ».ȓQpźɟÉʩĔDʖË.FC1ÙŖ4ǂȱ.F9ǸƣǬ.4ʊʅ5=(Ï³Ū2ǉ-5FA442008 œ 4 ƪr\X.
4 AWGLCA 2-A+4ʥĔȖȊʎǾĊˑJõE-F˙ENB 2008˚ A)HKQNbǕȇɝ4Ğú;0ìȸ.51/ʥĔÂAèÔ2ɾʉ-F='źɟȟʜ25ȖȊʎǾǆ©Ĥ4rLÉʩĔÂ2AʥĔÂ2Aįė!F4AȚ.FÉʩĔŐɭC2ǣƥåĊˑ5Ĕ˅Ȋ2Ʌũ1ĽŦJɧ!FħĊˑ/

4.G6Ĕ˅Ȝ®5QNb4Ğú/ûȭ4ĽŦJƽɯ!F:/4ʥĔÂ4śŨ.H%4Ůā.5ȖȊʎǾǆĊˑ5ëæĽȧ2FʌţȊ1ŮāúJƅ*-F'*-r\X.4 AWGLCA 2ƜƯƒŕÛ2ƎÓ'Ɩƨ˙Government ofJapan 2008˚42F ȖȊʎǾǆJŀʷ!:źɟȟʜ5ĉƾxa. /Ɩɭ5

ʥĔ4ɧǓ/5Ȕ*ýDĽȧ!FA4.EɀƴȊ25

ƜƯ5źɟȟʜ2ǝƿȊ

/íʌJś@-=*'C2ŨIGF

6. µP*-3r­g Ï³Ȋ1ǣƥåĽȮ˙źɟ˚ÚǢʹ˙ÚǢ|j_˚\al10J
Ȥ>-{lLhw.

ɐFĞú2ɃĽȊ2ʷɧ1şÜJƅ+4ùĔùcXe2FƇÓÚǢƋɎ˙źɟ˚J»ƺĲː2ŋD:'˂ȃÚǢ\alƧɇ.F˙MACC: Marginal
Abatement Cost Curve. ɋʝÚǢ\al.ǇʝÚǢʹ˚4Ƨɇ4ŝǴ2C*-ùƒȮ4\alÚǢʹ˙ÚǢ|j_˚%-ÇÉː±ħģå!F'*-șȥɑ24ƧɇJǌȚ2ƍ/.FƒȮȧƻɑB¡ǡƀŜɑ2/*-ˋŐ2ħ1ŮāJƅ+ Ǹė4Ĕ×C8cXe×4˂ȃÚǢ\alƧɇ2ˀ-5Ûʢ4Sf4 RIVM
SalL4Ĕ˅Ŧǿ_ajɬƳșȥŴ˙IIASA˚ƜƯ4ĔȧǻğșȥŴ\^jM
Y®Ȝ4}hVdȜ10%G&Gǵɖ2kexa/-ǂȱ++F¹
6}hVdȜ5ƜƯJÿ?ùĔ˙mNiSalLȳĔ5!.2Íɡ˚4˂
ȃÚǢ\alƧɇJ¶Ų-E˙Mckinsey & Company 2008˚Ȭɑ4ȿ˖F5íʌ.5ǸėˋŐ2ĥ4șȥɑʅƖBʈǨȈɡ10.řǿ-F7 ƪ4ǚǰǥ^~hl4˅25ȃÌ³4ǴǗJ=/@'ɼȻ1|lJȈɡ!Fĳ.E%4ÐĹħ2Ǚȏ

9

QNb4Ğú5 Ĕğ1çŏđ 10ʥĔÂJƑƐ'ǸėeN10.5QNbǕȇɝ(
.51§4çɝą2ˀ-AśÙǳɳĴƚǆ4ʯǿJƃħC/áFA)HKȖȊʎǾǆ4Ù˂­ƾ4șȥʾȈ102FŞˍBƒŕ4ˀIEƙ102ˀ-ĥ4ʊʅEìȸ1Ċˑ.51/5Ț.F

9

Discussion paper .)/@N(5=@1'!

%}C#Ee\¶D~

%­¥·

GF
 Ċˑ5ûĔ4û

cXe2-A˂ȃÚǢ\alƧɇ4ŝǴùșȥǈˀ

2C*-ħȅ1F/.F!1I)û

ǴǗ.4û

źɟBĽȮ.AÚǢ\alBÚǢʹ4ƊĳÁʮ*-F4.F%1*-=Ǻȁ5˂ȃÚǢ\alƧɇJ¶
Ų!FĞú4ǃ1ÛƎBªĳ˙źɟ4ayhX\alɒǿœƔǛáʹǤˉɂǤåȘǯƗ»ƺǤƤóǷǤÜřǷ10˚2ħŞˍJöFD.F '*-ùĔȷŢ!FúǺȊ1ÚǢȏǄJ¶F'@25="ùșȥǈˀ˙șȥɑ˚
4ʿ.ɮȯ4ÛƎ102ˀ!FÎʦɾʉJƝũ2ŝŲ!FŤɧF%4š2șȥǈˀ˙șȥɑ˚ʿ.ŝŲG'ÎʦɾʉJùĔ4ƒȮƀŜɑ2Ǻɬ-AD×4¶ƾŤɧ/1
F%GD4wcaJȿ-B*/ùĔ4¡ǡƀŜɑ2CFäƄȊ1shZ`.4Ĕ˅¡ǡ
 COP 4Ğ.÷ɕ/1FGúǺȊ1ÚǢȏǄJúŮŝŲ!F'@4ǺŭȊ+Ťɧ1w
ca.EǸėʲ4ƒŕBșȥɑ%4C1áJʩ@C/-F
ɭ=.A1Ʃħ4Ċˑ5 ƣʿ/4ų .E2009 œ4 COP15 =.ʿ2úI#F/Ůā.5Ń1/AǀɫȊ1ǴǗ.51/5Ț.F

7. Eeat ƩÕ2 Sector approach JĈ' CCAP%4šuR-F IEA B Ecofys%-Ĕ˅¡ǡ2+AÓ-FùĔƒŕ¡ǡƀŜɑ5Ƣœ'EDƜƯƒŕɭĪ@'e×Lwg2Ľ-5 CID1

cX/4ƩÕ4ôŦ(*'/ŨIGF %4š51K/1Ůā5Ǻɬ++A ƜƯ4Ĕ×ɆʹȏǄJɐF˅2ƜƯcX
e×.Ȥ>-ɮȯ'/Ś.G6ãŵ2BG6CĴ˅204ĔAc
Xe×2B*-F'(%4/ƜƯÌ³.4²Ĕ×ɆʹȏǄƔÁ4ȐƉȊ1Ǻȁ25ʅǺȊ21D1

AÉʩĔʿ4ȏǄŌȅå2-ùǾƾcXe4ǸƣǬ.4àǷ4əūJɐŰ!:/AŃÏ³Ȋ1Ś.F41DȳĔB_LƲǋ5
ôĽ!F(HʥĔ2VhwJʃ'/Ś.G6źɟȟʜBÉʩĔ4\~hll5*E1ǴǗ.1EÓ-AʥĔôȈ!F45ȏ2ɨ-F

%A%Aźɟȟʜ5t`paxa./Ś5źɟȟʜ½ʩ/ħăˑ/ȕȒ-FĔ×ɆʹȏǄ1.ùĔ4ùǾƾcXeȏǄƔÁJA+:/Ś.G

6Ęǹ4ʫăJĔ˅ʻʼʨȍ102¬#F/21F4.Ċˑĥ

cXecXe/ɓGɄF/ƜƯ5=( 2008 ƪ 1 ƪ4f{a®ʊ©Û4|`_˙ÉʩĔAĔ×ɆʹȏǄ5ɧ˚DģI*-1C2Ũ*-=f{a.4ȝȀ˔ȑ4\l5
³Ì³´(*'4˞/íʌF5ůŭJƅ*-FC2ŨIGF ǣƥå¡ǡJŊFĽȧ4;/K05Ȧɹ@-ɭ6­ƾ4Ĕ˅ȪÝČĨĊˑJƒŕC8­ƾűŧ-F/2ʘĐ!F/ɭ*-Aʬɭ.51%-ƜƯ4>1D"
ÉʩĔÌ³4Ưˌ/-Ĕ˅ȪÝĊˑ5Ĕ˅¡ǡ2-AĔÐ4ÙŖɲɮ2A=!=!ʷɧ1ʃˑ/1*-F Ĵ˅2EU 2-5 Sectoral approach Ĕ˅ȪÝĊˑ2ĽŦ!F 3 +4Sw_

4)4+/-ʊʅG-E˙/4+5ƇÓʹ4ǭÆÜŜ/Ĕğȡʄƕ104ʓƠƋɎ˚EU ­ƾƅ+Ǧ5ǔ-ł1'(ûƣ2!.2ƚɞG-F EU ěÐƇÓʹõřÙŖ102C*-ŞˍJöF­ƾ5Ì³DɨG6ŃƔ.EŞˍJöF­ƾAƇÓʹ4ÜŜƙǘBǽǾ\alƞÔ4»ƺʜĬ4ÜúǊȫ.5ġ˗čƾØȌǷħƞ!F/Aǃ1șȥ2C*-ĳʹȊ2țG++F˙Carbon Trust 2008˚ "G2HƜƯ­ƾF5ĔÌ³4ȿǠȊŞˍJúǺȊ2ƽɯ1DACEħņ

10

Discussion paper .)/@N(5=@1'!

%}C#Ee\¶D~%­¥·

Ȋ1ɨĘD4ƒǕȊŮŨJț1G6Ĕ˅Ȝ®5ƜƯJǻğĊˑ2FĔ˅Ȋ1
f/-ɾ@1(HÊJʣ/5ĹƠ.51Ĕ/-4ÇÉː±JĔǑÌ³.ǔĳ!FŤɧF%4'@2AƜƯ˗ÚǢȏǄJƅ*'Ğú4ƜƯȿǠB­ƾȿ
č2Ľ!FŞˍBÍŒŪ104ĜƯȊ1ɐƙ2+-ĳʹȊ1ke2Ĝ,'Ñˊ1ʊʅǓ@DGF˙Ưȣ5 ʳōĊˑ ˙Ʋ¢ōƒʄƷ®˚ œ  ƪø ȿǠc~n ˙ƜƯɷʅȜ˚œ  ƪø ǽǛȿǠƒȮ ˙ǽǛȿǠƒȮșȥŴ˚ œ  ƪø ǻğźɟ®ɽ ˙ƜƯŗƼǲÒǺƚɲźɟȰǺɑêʊ®˚ œ  ƪø102ƌʟF5ƌʟĳ4ƖȨ4ʲJ=/@-+ħő2¾ǌÞȬ'A4.F˚11Discussion paper .)/@N(5=@1'!

%}C#Ee\¶D~

%­¥·

Wn
Baron Richard; Reinaud Julia; Genaschi Matt; Philibert Cedric˙2007˚"Sectoral Approach to Greenhouse
Gas Mitigation: Exploring Issues for Heavy Industry".
http://www.iea.org/Textbase/publications/free_new_Desc.asp?PUBS_ID=2000
Carbon Trust˙2008˚"EU ETS impacts on profitability and trade: a sector by sector analysis".
http://www.carbontrust.co.uk/publications/publicationdetail?productid=CTC728
Colombier Michael and Neuhoff Karseten˙2007˚"Can Sectoral Agreement and output based allocation
address leakage? ", WORKING PAPER June 6th, 2007.
http://www.climate-strategies.org/item_list.php?item=document&id=97#97
Ecofys˙2007˚"Sectoral Proposal Templates".

http://www.sectoral.org/

Earth Negotiation Bulletin˙2008˚Vol. 12 No. 362 - AWGLCA 1 & AWG 5 (Climate Change) - Summary
and Analysis.
Elzen MGJ den; Hohne N; Lucas PL; Moltmann S; Kuramochi T˙2007˚"The Triptych approachrevisited: A staged sectoral approach for climate mitigation", RIVM Report no. 500114008.
http://www.mnp.nl/en/publications/2007/TheTriptychapproachrevisited_Astagedsectoralapproachfor
climatemitigation.html
Government of Japan˙2008˚"Submission for UNITED NATIONS FRAMEWORK CONVENTION ON
CLIMATE CHANGE AD HOC WORKING GROUP ON LONG-TERM COOPERATIVE ACTION
UNDER THE CONVENTION", First session, Bangkok, 31 March to 4 April 2008, Item 3 of theprovisional agenda Development of a work programme, Views regarding the work programme of
the Ad Hoc Working Group on Long-term Cooperative Action under the Convention.
http://unfccc.int/resource/docs/2008/awglca1/eng/misc01a01.pdf
IEA˙2007˚"Tracking Industrial Energy Efficiency and CO2 Emissions"
Mckinsey & Company˙2008˚"Reducing U.S. Greenhouse Gas Emissions: How Much at What Cost?"
http://www.mckinsey.com/clientservice/ccsi/
Schmidt Jake; den Elzen Michel; Jasper van Vliet; Hoehne Niklas; Ellerman Christian ˙ 2008˚"Developed Country Further Emissions Reductions: What is “Comparable Effort”? ", presentation at
Future Actions Dialogue, Tokyo, Japan11-13 February 2008.
http://www.ccap.org/international/Feb%202008%20FAD/Schmidt%7EDeveloped%20Country%20C
omparable%20Efforts%7EFINAL.pdf
Schmidt Jake˙2008˚"Sectoral Approaches to the Post-2012 Climate Change Policy Architecture",
UNFCCC In-Session Workshop, Bangkok, Thailand, 1-3 April 2008.
http://unfccc.int/files/meetings/intersessional/awg-lca_1_and_awg-kp_5/presentations/application/v
nd.ms-powerpoint/bkk_ccap_sectoral.pps
Schmidt Jake; Helme Ned; Lee Jin; Houdashelt Mark˙2007˚"Sector-based Approach to the Post-2012:
Climate Change Policy Architecture".
http://www.ccap.org/international/future.htm
Su Wei; Lu Xuedu; Sun Guoshun˙2008˚"The Core Elements of Future UN Negotiation on Climate
Change and Its Perspective – The interpretation and analysis on Bali Roadmap", Advances in
Climate Change Research, vol.4, no.1, January 2008, p.57-60.
http://www.climatechange.cn/
Reuters 2008 œ 4 ƪ 12 Ɯ "Financing crucial to next climate change pact: U.N." Sat Apr 12, 2008
7:04pm EDT.

12

Discussion paper .)/@N(5=@1'!

%}C#Ee\¶D~%­¥·

http://www.reuters.com/article/newsOne/idUSN1228263320080412

13