WORLD TRADE  
ORGANIZATION  WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1 
10 November 2006 
 (06-5409) 
  
 
 
 
DISPUTE SETTLEMENT BODY 
 
Draft Annual Report (2006 ) 
 
Overview of the State of Play of WTO Disputes 
 
Addendum  
   
 The attached overview, which reflects the state of play of WTO disputes during the period 
from 1 January 1995  to 31 October 2006 , has been prepared by the Secretariat on its own 
responsibility.  Section I summarizes the developmen ts from the initial requests for consultations until 
the establishment of panels, including the cases wh ere mutually agreed solutions were found.  
Section II deals with the stages covering the estab lishment of panels, circ ulation of panels and 
Appellate Body reports, appeals and finally adoption of reports.  Section III covers the stage dealing 
with the monitoring of the implementation of the DS B's recommendations.  Finally, Section IV covers 
recourse to Articles 21.5 and 22 of the DSU.   
  WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1 
Page 2  
 
SECTION I  
 
Requests for Consultations;  Establishment of Panels;  Mutually Agreed Solutions  
 
(1 January 1995 – 31 October 2006) 
 
 
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
1. Malaysia – Prohibition of Imports of 
Polyethylene and Polypropylene Singapore 
WT/DS1/1 10.01.95  
 17.03.95 
Singapore 
WT/DS1/2  
  19.07.95 
WT/DSB/M/6  
(withdrawal of 
request) 
2. United States – Standards for Reformulated 
and Conventional Gasoline Venezuela 
WT/DS2/1 24.01.95  27.03.95 
Venezuela 
WT/DS2/2 10.04.95 
WT/DSB/M/3  
3. Korea – Measures Concerning the Testing and 
Inspection of Agricultural Products US 
WT/DS3/1 04.04.95 Japan 
WT/DS3/2    
4. United States – Standards for Reformulated 
and Conventional Gasoline Brazil 
WT/DS4/1 10.04.95  22.05.95 
Brazil 
WT/DS4/2 31.05.95 
WT/DSB/M/5  
5. Korea – Measures Concerning the Shelf–Life 
of Products US 
WT/DS5/1 03.05.95 Canada 
WT/DS5/2  
Japan 
WT/DS5/4  
   31.07.95 
WT/DS5/5 and 
Corr.1  
24.11.95 
Add.1  
22.04.96 
Add.1/Rev.1  
22.04.96 
Add.2  
22.04.96 
Add.3  
19.07.96 
Add.4  
20.09.96 
Add.5 
6. United States – Imposition of Import Duties on 
Automobiles from Japan under Sections 301 
and 304 of the Trade Act of 1974 Japan 
WT/DS6/1 17.05.95 EC 
WT/DS6/2  
Australia 
WT/DS6/3   19.07.95 
WT/DSB/M/6  
   WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1
 Page 3 
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
7. European Communities – Trade Description of 
Scallops Canada 
WT/DS7/1 19.05.95 Chile 
WT/DS7/2  
Iceland 
WT/DS7/3  
Japan 
WT/DS7/4  
Peru 
WT/DS7/5 10.07.95 
Canada 
WT/DS7/7 and 
Corr.1 19.07.95 
WT/DSB/M/6  
 19.07.96 
WT/DS7/12 
8. Japan – Taxes on Alcoholic Beverages EC 
WT/DS8/1 21.06.95 US 
WT/DS8/2  
Canada 
WT/DS8/3 15.09.95 
EC 
WT/DS8/5 27.09.95 
WT/DSB/M/7  
9. European Communities – Duties on Imports of 
Cereals Canada 
WT/DS9/1 30.06.95  15.09.95 
Canada 
WT/DS9/2 
 11.10.95 
WT/DSB/M/8  
10. Japan – Taxes on Alcoholic Beverages Canada 
WT/DS10/1 07.07.95 US 
WT/DS10/2  
EC 
WT/DS10/3 15.09.95 
Canada 
WT/DS10/5 27.09.95 
WT/DSB/M/7  
11. Japan – Taxes on Alcoholic Beverages US 
WT/DS11/1 07.07.95  15.09.95 
USA 
WT/DS11/2 and 
Corr.1 27.09.95 
WT/DSB/M/7  
12. European Communities – Trade Description of 
Scallops Peru 
WT/DS12/1 18.07.95 Canada 
WT/DS12/3  
Chile 
WT/DS12/2 and  
Rev.1  
Japan 
WT/DS12/5 15.09.95 
Peru 
WT/DS12/6  
Annex 
22.09.95 
Peru 
WT/DS12/7 11.10.95 
WT/DSB/M/8  
 19.07.96 
WT/DS12/12  
 
13. European Communities – Duties on Imports of 
Grains US 
WT/DS13/1 19.07.95  29.09.95 
US 
WT/DS13/2  
22.11.96 
WT/DS13/2/  
Add.1  
13.02.97 
WT/DS13/5  
27.03.97 
WT/DS13/6  
 02.05.97 
WTDS13/8  
(withdrawal of 
request)  
  WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1 
Page 4  
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
14. EC – Trade Description of Scallops Chile 
WT/DS14/1 24.07.95 Canada 
WT/DS14/2  
Peru 
WT/DS14/3  
Japan 
WT/DS14/4 15.09.95 
Chile 
WT/DS14/5  
Annex 
27.09.95 
Chile 
WT/DS14/6  
Annex 11.10.95 
WT/DSB/M/8  
 19.07.96 
WT/DS14/11 
15. Japan – Measures Affecting the Purchase of 
Telecommunications Equipment EC 
WT/DS15/1 18.08.95 US 
WT/DS15/2    
16. European Communities – Regime for the 
Importation, Sale and Distribution of Bananas Guatemala 
Honduras 
Mexico 
US 
WT/DS16/1  
 28.09.95 St. Lucia 
WT/DS16/2  
Colombia 
WT/DS16/3  
Dominican 
Republic 
WT/DS16/4  
Venezuela 
WT/DS16/5  
Nicaragua 
WT/DS16/6  
Costa Rica 
WT/DS16/7    
17. European Communities – Duties on Imports of 
Rice Thailand 
WT/DS17/1 05.10.95     
18. Australia – Measures Affecting Importation of 
Salmon Canada 
WT/DS18/1 05.10.95  10.03.97 
WT/DS18/2 10.04.97 
WT/DSB/M/31  
19. Poland – Import Regime for Automobiles India 
WT/DS19/1 28.09.95    11.09.96 
WT/DS19/2 
20. Korea – Measures Concerning  Bottled Water Canada 
WT/DS20/1 08.11.95 US 
WT/DS20/2   
EC 
WT/DS20/4   24.04.96 
WT/DS20/6  
 
21. Australia – Measures Affecting the 
Importation of Salmonids US 
WT/DS21/1 20.11.95 Canada 
WT/DS21/2 11.05.99 
US 
WT/DS21/4 16.06.99 
WT/DSB/M/64 27.08.00 
WT/DS21/10 
22. Brazil – Measures Affecting Desiccated 
Coconut Philippines 
WT/DS22/1 30.11.95  08.02.96 
Philippines 
WT/DS22/5 05.03.96 
WT/DSB/M/12   
   WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1
 Page 5 
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
23. Venezuela – Anti–Dumping Investigation in 
Respect of Imports of Certain Oil Country 
Tubular Goods OCTG  Mexico 
WT/DS23/1 05.12.95    26.05.97 
WT/DS23/3  
(termination of 
investigation) 
24. United States – Restriction on Imports of 
Cotton and Man–Made Fibre Underwear Costa Rica 
WT/DS24/1 22.12.95  27.02.96 
Costa Rica 
WT/DS24/2 05.03.96 
WT/DSB/M/12  
25. European Communities – Implementation of 
the Uruguay Round Commitments Concerning Rice Uruguay 
WT/DS25/1 14.12.95     
26. European Communities – Measures 
Concerning Meat and Meat Products 
(Hormones) US 
WT/DS26/1  
 26.01.96 New Zealand 
WT/DS26/2  
Australia 
WT/DS26/3  
Canada 
WT/DS26/4 25.04.96 
US 
WT/DS26/6 20.05.96 
WT/DSB/M/17  
27. European Communities – Regime for the 
Importation, Sale and Distribution of Bananas 
(I)  Ecuador 
Guatemala 
Honduras 
Mexico 
US 
WT/DS27/1  
 05.02.96 Dominican 
Republic 
WT/DS27/2  
St. Lucia 
WT/DS27/3  
Nicaragua 
WT/DS27/4  
Jamaica 
WT/DS/27/5 12.04.96 
Ecuador, Guatemala, 
Honduras,  
Mexico,  
US 
WT/DS27/6 08.05.96 
WT/DSB/M/16   
  WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1 
Page 6  
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
27. European Communities – Regime for the 
Importation, Sale and Distribution of Bananas 
(II) Ecuador 
Guatemala 
Honduras 
Mexico 
US 
WT/DS27/18   Panama 
WT/DS27/19 
Dominican 
Republic 
WT/DS27/20  
Jamaica 
WT/DS27/22  
Costa Rica 
WT/DS27/23  
Colombia 
WT/DS27/24  
Brazil 
WT/DS27/25  
Saint Lucia 
WT/DS27/26  
Dominica 
WT/DS27/27  
Côte d'Ivoire 
WT/DS27/28  
Cameroon 
WT/DS27/29    
28. Japan – Measures Concerning Sound 
Recordings 
 US 
WT/DS28/1 09.02.96 EC 
WT/DS28/2   24.01.97 
WT/DS28/4 
29. Turkey – Restrictions on Imports of Textile 
and Clothing Products Hong Kong 
WT/DS29/1 12.02.96 EC 
WT/DS29/2 
Malaysia 
Philippines 
Thailand 
WT/DS29/3 
Peru 
WT/DS29/4 
India 
WT/DS29/5 
Brazil 
WT/DS29/7 
Canada 
WT/DS29/8    
30. Brazil – Countervailing Duties on Imports of 
Desiccated Coconut and Coconut Milk Powder 
from Sri Lanka Sri Lanka 
WT/DS30/1 23.02.96      
   WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1
 Page 7 
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
31. Canada – Certain Measures Concerning 
Periodicals 
 US 
WT/DS31/1 11.03.96  24.05.96 
US 
WT/DS31/2 19.06.96 
WT/DSB/M/19  
32. United States – Measures Affecting Imports of 
Women's and Girls' Wool Coats    15.03.96 
India 
WT/DS32/1 
 17.04.96 
WT/DSB/M/14 30.04.96 
WT/DS32/2 
(termination of 
further action in 
pursuance of the DSB decision of 
17.04.96) 
33. United States – Measures Affecting Imports of 
Woven Wool Shirts and Blouses    15.03.96 
India 
WT/DS33/1  
and Corr.1 17.04.96 
WT/DSB/M/14  
34. Turkey – Restrictions on Imports of Textile 
and Clothing Products 
 India 
WT/DS34/1 21.03.96  02.02.98 
WT/DS34/2 13.03.98 
WT/DSB/M/43 06.07.01 
WT/DS34/14 
35. Hungary – Export Subsidies in Respect of 
Agricultural Products 
 Argentina 
Australia 
Canada 
New Zealand 
Thailand 
US 
WT/DS35/1 27.03.96 Japan 
WT/DS35/2 10.01.97 
Australia 
WT/DS35/4  
10.01.97 
New Zealand 
WT/DS/35/5  
10.01.97 
US 
WT/DS35/6  
10.01.97 
Argentina 
WT/DS35/7 25.02.97 
WT/DSB/M/29  
 30.07.97 
WT/DSB/M/36 
36. Pakistan – Patent Protection for 
Pharmaceutical and Agricultural Chemical 
Products US 
WT/DS36/1 30.04.96 EC 
WT/DS36/2 04.07.96 
US 
WT/DS36/3  07.03.97 
WT/DS36/4 
37. Portugal – Patent Protection under the 
Industrial Property Act US 
WT/DS37/1 30.04.96    15.10.96 
WT/DS37/2 and 
Corr.1  
  WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1 
Page 8  
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
38. United States – The Cuban Liberty and 
Democratic Solidarity Act EC 
WT/DS38/1 03.05.96  08.10.96 
EC 
WT/DS38/2  
14.10.96 
 Corr.1 20.11.96 
WT/DSB/M/26 
Panel lapsed on 
22.04.98 pursuant 
to Article 12.12 of 
the DSU  
39. United States – Tariff Increases on Products 
from the European Communities EC 
WT/DS39/1 18.04.96  24.06.96 
EC 
WT/DS39/2   
40. Korea – Laws, Regulations and Practices in 
the Telecommunications Procurement Sector EC 
WT/DS40/1 
 09.05.96    29.10.97 
WT/DS40/2 
41. Korea – Measures Concerning Inspection of 
Agricultural Products US 
WT/DS41/1 24.05.96     
42. Japan – Measures Concerning Sound 
Recordings EC 
WT/DS42/1 28.05.96 US 
WT/DS42/2   7.11.97 
WT/DS42/4 
43. Turkey – Taxation of Foreign Film Revenues US 
WT/DS43/1 12.06.96  10.01.97 
US 
WT/DS43/2 25.02.97 
WT/DSB/M/29 24.07.97 
WT/DS43/3 
44. Japan – Measures Affecting Consumer 
Photographic Film and Paper US 
WT/DS44/1 13.06.96  20.09.96 
US 
WT/DS44/2 16.10.96 
WT/DSB/M/24  
45. Japan – Measures Affecting Distribution 
Services US 
WT/DS45/1 
and Add.1 13.06.96     
46. Brazil – Export Financing Programme for 
Aircraft 
 Canada 
WT/DS46/1  
 19.06.96  17.09.96 
Canada 
WT/DS46/2  
04.10.96 
WT/DS46/4 
13.07.98 
WT/DS46/5 23.07.98 
WT/DSB/M/47  
47. Turkey – Restrictions on Imports of Textile 
and Clothing Products 
 Thailand 
WT/DS47/1 20.06.96      
   WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1
 Page 9 
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
48. European Communities – Measures Affecting 
Livestock and Meat (Hormones) Canada 
WT/DS48/1 28.06.96 Australia 
WT/DS48/2  
US 
WT/DS48/3  
New Zealand 
WT/DS48/4 17.09.96 
Canada 
WT/DS48/5  
 16.10.96 
WT/DSB/M/24  
49. United States – Anti–Dumping Investigation 
Regarding Imports of Fresh or Chilled Tomatoes from Mexico Mexico 
WT/DS49/1 01.07.96     
50. India – Patent Protection for Pharmaceutical 
and Agricultural Chemical Products US 
WT/DS50/1 
US 
WT/DS50/11  02.07.96 EC 
WT/DS50/2 
EC 
WT/DS50/12 08.11.96 
US 
WT/DS50/4 20.11.96 
WT/DSB/M/26  
51. Brazil – Certain Automotive Investment 
Measures Japan 
WT/DS51/1 30.07.96 Korea 
WT/DS51/2  
EC 
WT/DS51/3  
US 
WT/DS51/4  
Canada 
WT/DS51/6    
52. Brazil – Certain Measures Affecting Trade and 
Investment in the Automotive Sector US 
WT/DS52/1 09.08.96 Canada 
WT/DS52/2  
Japan 
WT/DS52/3  
Korea 
WT/DS52/4  
EC 
WT/DS52/5    
53. Mexico – Customs Valuation of Imports EC 
WT/DS53/1 27.08.96 Norway 
WT/DS53/2  
Switzerland 
WT/DS53/3    
54. Indonesia – Certain M easures Affecting the 
Automobile Industry EC 
WT/DS54/1 03.10.96 US 
WT/DS54/2  
Japan 
WT/DS54/3  
Korea 
WT/DS54/4  
Canada 
WT/DS54/5 12.05.97 
EC 
WT/DS54/6 12.06.97 
EC 
WT/DSB/M/34   
  WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1 
Page 10  
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
55. Indonesia – Certain M easures Affecting the 
Automobile Industry Japan 
WT/DS55/1 04.10.96 US 
WT/DS55/2  
EC 
WT/DS55/3  
Korea 
WT/DS55/4  
Canada 
WT/DS55/5 18.04.97 
Japan 
WT/DS55/6  
WT/DS64/4  12.06.97 
WT/DSB/M/34  
56. Argentina – Measures Affecting Imports of 
Footwear, Textiles, Apparel and Other Items US 
WT/DS56/1 04.10.96 Hungary 
WT/DS56/2  
EC 
WT/DS56/3 10.01.97 
US 
WT/DS56/5 25.02.97 
WT/DSB/M/29  
57. Australia – Textile, Clothing and Footwear 
Import Credit Scheme US 
WT/DS57/1 
 07.10.96     
58. United States – Import Prohibition of Certain 
Shrimp and Shrimp Products India, Malaysia, 
Pakistan, Thailand 
WT/DS58/1 08.10.96 Hong Kong 
WT/DS58/2  
EC 
WT/DS58/3  
Japan 
WT/DS58/4  
Australia 
WT/DS58/5 10.01.97 
Malaysia 
Thailand 
WT/DS58/6  
07.02.97 
Pakistan 
WT/DS58/7  
04.03.97 
India 
WT/DS58/8 25.02.97 
WT/DSB/M/29  
(Malaysia, 
Thailand, 
Pakistan) 
10.04.97 
WT/DSB/M/31  
India  
59. Indonesia – Certain M easures Affecting the 
Automobile Industry US 
WT/DS59/1 08.10.96 Japan 
WT/DS59/2  
EC 
WT/DS59/3  
Korea 
WT/DS59/4  
Canada 
WT/DS59/5 13.06.97 
US 
WT/DS59/6 30.07.97 
WT/DSB/M/36  
60. Guatemala – Anti–Dumping Investigation 
Regarding Portland Cement from Mexico Mexico 
WT/DS60/1 17.10.96  13.02.97 
Mexico 
WT/DS60/2 20.03.97 
WT/DSB/M/30  
61. United States – Import Prohibition of Certain 
Shrimp and Shrimp Products Philippines 
WT/DS61/1 25.10.96 Australia 
WT/DS61/2  
Japan 
WT/DS61/3     
   WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1
 Page 11 
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
62. European Communities – Customs 
Classification of Some Computer Equipment US 
WT/DS62/1 08.11.96 Korea 
WT/DS62/2  
Canada 
WT/DS62/3 13.02.97 
US 
WT/DS62/4 25.02.97 
WT/DSB/M/29  
63. United States – Anti–Du mping Measures on 
Imports of Solid Urea from the Former 
German Democratic Republic EC 
WT/DS63/1 28.11.96     
64. Indonesia – Certain M easures Affecting the 
Automobile Industry Japan 
WT/DS64/1 29.11.96 US 
WT/DS64/2  
EC 
WT/DS64/3 18.04.97 
Japan 
WT/DS55/6  
WT/DS64/4   12.06.97 
WT/DSB/M/34  
65. Brazil – Certain Measures Affecting Trade and 
Investment in the Automotive Sector US 
WT/DS65/1 10.01.97     
66. Japan – Measures Affecting Imports of Pork EC 
WT/DS66/1 15.01.97 Canada 
WT/DS66/2    
67. United Kingdom – Customs Classification of 
Certain Computer Equipment US 
WT/DS67/1 14.02.97 Korea 
WT/DS67/2 10.03.97 
US 
WT/DS67/3 20.03.97 
 DSB decided  that 
this matter be 
examined by the 
panel established 
on 
25 February 1997 
WT/DSB/M/30  
68. Ireland – Customs Classification of Certain 
Computer Equipment US 
WT/DS68/1 14.02.97  10.03.97 
US 
WT/DS68/2 20.03.97 
 DSB decided that 
this matter be 
examined by the 
panel established 
on 
25 February 1997 
WT/DSB/M/30  
69. European Communities – Measures Affecting 
Importation of Certain Poultry Products Brazil 
WT/DS69/1 24.02.97  12.06.97 
Brazil 
WT/DS69/2 
 30.07.97 
WT/DSB/M/36  
70. Canada – Measures Affecting the Export of 
Civilian Aircraft Brazil 
WT/DS70/1 10.03.97  13.07.98 
Brazil 
WT/DS70/2 23.07.98 
WT/DSB/M/47  
71. Canada – Measures Affecting the Export of 
Civilian Aircraft Brazil 
WT/DS71/1 10.03.97      
  WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1 
Page 12  
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
72. European Communities – Measures Affecting 
Butter Products New Zealand 
WT/DS72/1 24.03.97  7.11.97 
New Zealand 
WT/DS72/2 18.11.97 
WT/DSB/M/39 11.11.99 
WT/DS72/7  
73. Japan – Procurement of a Navigation Satellite EC 
WT/DS73/1 26.03.97 US 
WT/DS73/2   19.02.98 
WT/DS73/5  
74. Philippines – Measures Affecting Pork and 
Poultry US 
WT/DS74/1 01.04.97 EC 
WT/DS74/2  
Canada 
WT/DS74/3   13.03.98 
WT/DS74/5 
WT/DS102/6 
75. Korea – Taxes on Alcoholic Beverages EC 
WT/DS75/1 02.04.97 US 
WT/DS75/2  
Canada 
WT/DS75/3 15.09.97 
EC 
WT/DS75/6 16.10.97 
WT/DSB/M/38  
76. Japan – Measures Affecting Agricultural 
Products US 
WT/DS76/1 07.04.97  06.10.97 
US 
WT/DS76/2 18.11.97 
WT/DSB/M/39 23.08.01 
WT/DS76/12 
77. Argentina – Measures Affecting Textiles and 
Clothing EC 
WT/DS77/1 21.04.97 US 
WT/DS77/2 15.09.97 
EC 
WT/DS77/3  
06.10.97 
Rev.1  
16.10.97 
Rev.1/Corr.1 16.10.97 
WT/DSB/M/38  
29.07.98 
WT/DS77/5  
Panel suspended 
its proceedings  
78. United States – Safeguard Measure Against 
Imports of Broom Corn Brooms Colombia 
WT/DS78/1 28.04.97     
79. India – Patent Protection for Pharmaceutical 
and Agricultural Chemical Products EC 
WT/DS79/1 28.04.97  15.09.97 
EC 
WT/DS79/2 16.10.97 
WT/DSB/M/38  
80. Belgium – Measures Affecting Commercial 
Telephone Directory Services US 
WT/DS80/1 02.05.97     
81. Brazil – Certain Measures Affecting Trade and 
Investment in the Automotive Sector EC 
WT/DS81/1 07.05.97     
82. Ireland – Measures Affecting the Grant of 
Copyright and Neighbouring Rights US 
WT/DS82/1 14.05.97  12.01.98 
US 
WT/DS82/2  06.11.00 
WT/DS82/3 
83. Denmark – Measures Affecting the 
Enforcement of Intellectual Property Rights US 
WT/DS83/1 14.05.97    07.06.01 
WT/DS83/2  
   WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1
 Page 13 
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
84. Korea – Taxes on Alcoholic Beverages US 
WT/DS84/1 23.05.97 Canada 
WT/DS/84/2  
EC 
WT/DS84/3 15.09.97 
US 
WT/DS84/4 16.10.97 
WT/DSB/M/38  
85. United States – Measures Affecting Textiles 
and Apparel Products EC 
WT/DS85/1 22.05.97 Switzerland 
WT/DS85/2  
Honduras 
WT/DS85/3  
Hong Kong 
WT/DS85/4  
Pakistan 
WT/DS85/5  
India 
WT/DS85/6  
Japan 
WT/DS85/7  
Dominican 
Republic 
WT/DS85/8   11.02.98 
WT/DS85/9 
86. Sweden – Measures Affecting the 
Enforcement of Intellectual Property Rights US 
WT/DS86/1 28.05.97    02.12.98 
WT/DS86/2 
87. Chile – Taxes on Alcoholic Beverages EC 
WT/DS87/1 04.06.97 Peru 
WT/DS87/2  
US 
WT/DS87/3  
Mexico 
WT/DS87/4 06.10.97 
EC 
WT/DS87/5 18.11.97 
WT/DSB/M/39  
88. United States – Measure Affecting 
Government Procurement EC 
WT/DS88/1 20.06.97 Japan 
WT/DS88/2 
 09.09.98 
EC 
WT/DS88/3 21.10.98 
WT/DSB/M/49 
14.02.00 
WT/DS88/6  
Lapse of authority 
for establishment 
of the Panel   
  WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1 
Page 14  
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
89. United States – Imposition of Anti–Dumping 
Duties on Imports of Colour Television 
Receivers from Korea Korea 
WT/DS89/1   
and Corr.1 10.07.97 Mexico 
WT/DS89/2  
Thailand 
WT/DS89/3  
Japan 
WT/DS89/4  
Hong Kong, 
China 
WT/DS89/5  
EC 
WT/DS89/6 07.11.97 
Korea 
WT/DS89/7  
28.11.97 
WT/DS89/7/  
Corr.1  
  05.01.98 
WT/DS89/8  
18.09.98 
WT/DS89/9 
(withdrawal of 
request) 
90. India – Quantitative Restrictions on Imports of 
Agricultural, Textile and Industrial Products US 
WT/DS90/1 15.07.97 Japan 
WT/DS90/2  
EC 
WT/DS90/3  
Canada 
WT/DS90/4  
Australia 
WT/DS90/5  
Switzerland 
WT/DS90/6  
New Zealand 
WT/DS90/7 06.10.97 
US 
WT/DS90/8  
07.11.97 
WT/DS90/8/  
Corr.1 18.11.97 
WT/DSB/M/39  
91. India – Quantitative Restrictions on Imports of 
Agricultural, Textile and Industrial Products Australia 
WT/DS91/1 16.07.97 Japan 
WT/DS91/2  
US 
WT/DS91/3  
EC 
WT/DS91/4  
Canada 
WT/DS91/5  
Switzerland 
WT/DS91/6  
New Zealand 
WT/DS91/7   17.03.98 
WT/DS91/8 
17.08.98 
WT/DS91/8  
Corr.1  
   WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1
 Page 15 
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
92. India – Quantitative Restrictions on Imports of 
Agricultural, Textile and Industrial Products Canada 
WT/DS92/1 16.07.97 Japan 
WT/DS92/2  
US 
WT/DS92/3  
EC 
WT/DS92/4  
Australia 
WT/DS92/5  
Switzerland 
WT/DS92/6  
New Zealand 
WT/DS92/7   18.03.98 
WT/DS92/8 
25.09.98 
WT/DS92/8/ 
Corr. 1  
93. India – Quantitative Restrictions on Imports of 
Agricultural, Textile and Industrial Products New Zealand 
WT/DS93/1 16.07.97 Japan 
WT/DS93/2  
US 
WT/DS93/3  
EC 
WT/DS93/4  
Canada 
WT/DS93/5  
Australia 
WT/DS93/6  
Switzerland 
WT/DS93/7   01.12.98 
WT/DS93/8 
94. India – Quantitative Restrictions on Imports of 
Agricultural, Textile and Industrial Products Switzerland 
WT/DS94/1  
and Corr.1 17.07.97 Japan 
WT/DS94/2  
US 
WT/DS94/3  
EC 
WT/DS94/4  
Canada 
WT/DS94/5  
Australia 
WT/DS94/6  
New Zealand 
WT/DS94/7   23.02.98 
WT/DS94/9 
18.09.98 
WT/DS94/9/ 
Corr. 1  
  WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1 
Page 16  
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
95. United States – Measure Affecting 
Government Procurement Japan 
WT/DS95/1 18.07.97 EC 
WT/DS95/2 
 09.09.98 
Japan  
WT/DS95/3 21.10.98 
WT/DSB/M/49 
14.02.00 
WT/DS95/6  
Lapse of authority 
for establishment 
of the Panel  
96. India – Quantitative Restrictions on Imports of 
Agricultural, Textiles and Industrial Products EC 
WT/DS96/1 18.07.97 Japan 
WT/DS96/2  
US 
WT/DS96/3  
Canada 
WT/DS96/4  
Australia 
WT/DS96/5  
Switzerland 
WT/DS96/6  
New Zealand 
WT/DS96/7   07.04.98 
WT/DS96/8 
28.09.98 
WT/DS96/8/ 
Corr. 1 
97. United States – Countervailing Duty 
Investigation of Imports of Salmon from Chile Chile 
WT/DS97/1 
 05.08.97     
98. Korea – Definitive Safeguard Measure on 
Imports of Certain Dairy Products EC 
WT/DS/98/1 12.08.97 Australia 
WT/DS98/2 12.01.98 
EC 
WT/DS98/4 23.07.98 
WT/DSB/M/47  
 
99. United States – Anti–Dumping Duty on 
Dynamic Random Access Memory 
Semiconductors (DRAMS) of One Megabit or Above from Korea Korea 
WT/DS99/1  
and Corr.1 to 
Corr.2 14.08.97  07.11.97 
Korea 
WT/DS99/2 16.01.98 
WT/DSB/M/40 25.10.00 
WT/DS99/12 
100. United States – Measures Affecting Imports of 
Poultry Products EC 
WT/DS100/1 18.08.97     
101. Mexico – Anti–Dumping Investigation of 
High–Fructose Corn Syrup (HFCS) from the United States US 
WT/DS101/1 04.09.97     
102. Philippines – Measures Affecting Pork and 
Poultry US 
WT/DS102/1 07.10.97 Canada 
WT/DS102/3  
EC 
WT/DS102/4   
 13.03.98 
WT/DS74/5  
WT/DS102/6  
   WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1
 Page 17 
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
103. Canada – Measures Affecting the Importation 
of Milk and the Exportation of Dairy Products US 
WT/DS103/1 08.10.97 Japan 
WT/DS103/2  
Australia 
WT/DS103/3 03.02.98 
WT/DS103/4 25.03.98 
WT/DSB/M/44 09.05.03 
WT/DS103/33 
104. European Communities – Measures Affecting 
the Exportation of Processed Cheese US 
WT/DS104/1 08.10.97 Japan 
WT/DS104/2  
Australia 
WT/DS104/3  
Canada 
WT/DS104/4    
105. European Communities – Regime for the 
Importation, Sale and Distribution of Bananas Panama 
WT/DS105/1  
and Add.1 to 
Add.2 24.10.97 Colombia 
WT/DS105/2  
and Add.1 
Guatemala 
WT/DS105/3  
Dominican 
Republic 
WT/DS105/4  
Mexico 
WT/DS105/5  
Costa Rica 
WT/DS105/6  
Honduras 
WT/DS105/7  
and Add.1 
Ecuador 
WT/DS105/8  
US 
WT/DS105/9  
Côte d'Ivoire 
WT/DS105/10     
106. Australia – Subsidies Provided to Producers 
and Exporters of Automotive Leather US 
WT/DS106/1 10.11.97  12.01.98 
US 
WT/DS106/2 
 22.01.98 
WT/DSB/M/41 11.06.98 
WT/DS126/2 
(panel request 
withdrawn) 
107. Pakistan – Export Measures Affecting Hides 
and Skins EC 
WT/DS107/1 07.11.97     
108. United States – Tax Treatment for "Foreign 
Sales Corporations" EC 
WT/DS108/1 
and Add.1 18.11.97  09.07.98 
EC 
WT/DS108/2 22.09.98 
WT/DSB/M/48   
  WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1 
Page 18  
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
109. Chile – Taxes on Alcoholic Beverages US 
WT/DS109/1  
and Corr.1 11.12.97 Peru 
WT/DS109/2  
Mexico 
WT/DS/109/3    
110. Chile – Taxes on Alcoholic Beverages EC 
WT/DS110/1 15.12.97 US 
WT/DS110/2  
Mexico 
WT/DS110/3 13.03.98 
WT/DS110/4 25.03.98 
WT/DSB/M/44  
111. United States – Tariff Rate Quota for Imports 
of Groundnuts Argentina 
WT/DS111/1 19.12.97 Canada 
WT/DS111/2  
Japan 
WT/DS111/3    
112. Peru – Countervailing Duty Investigation 
Against Imports of Buses from Brazil Brazil 
WT/DS112/1 23.12.97     
113. Canada – Measures Affecting Dairy Exports New Zealand 
WT/DS113/1 29.12.97 US 
WT/DS113/2  
Japan 
WT/DS113/3 12.03.98 
WT/DS113/4 25.03.98 
WT/DSB/M/44 09.05.03 
WT/DS113/33 
114. Canada – Patent Protection of Pharmaceutical 
Products EC 
WT/DS114/1 19.12.97 US 
WT/DS114/2  
Australia 
WT/DS114/3  
Switzerland 
WT/DS114/4 12.11.98 
WT/DS114/5 01.02.99 
WT/DSB/M/54  
115. European Communities – Measures Affecting 
the Grant of Copyright and Neighbouring 
Rights US 
WT/DS115/1 06.01.98  12.01.98 
US 
WT/DS115/2  06.11.00 
WT/DS115/3 
116. Brazil – Measures Affecting Payment Terms 
for Imports EC 
WT/DS116/1 08.01.98 Switzerland 
WT/DS116/2  
Japan 
WT/DS116/3  
Australia 
WT/DS116/4  
US 
WT/DS116/5  
Korea 
WT/DS116/6    
117. Canada – Measures Affecting Film 
Distribution Services EC 
WT/DS117/1 20.01.98      
   WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1
 Page 19 
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
118. United States – Harbour Maintenance Tax EC 
WT/DS118/1 06.02.98 Canada 
WT/DS118/2  
Japan 
WT/DS118/3  
Norway 
WT/DS118/4    
119. Australia – Anti–Dumping Measures of 
Coated Wood Free Paper Sheets Switzerland 
WT/DS119/1 20.02.98 Japan 
WT/DS119/2  
EC 
WT/DS119/3   
 13.05.98 
WT/DS119/4 
120. India – Measures Affec ting Export of Certain 
Commodities 
 EC 
WT/DS120/1 11.03.98  13.10.00 
EC 
WT/DS120/2   
121. Argentina – Safeguard Measures on Imports of 
Footwear EC 
WT/DS121/1 06.04.98 US 
WT/DS121/2  11.06.98 
EC 
WT/DS121/3 23.07.98 
WT/DSB/M/47  
122. Thailand – Anti–Dumping Duties on Angles, 
Shapes and Sections of Iron and Iron–Alloy 
Steel and H–Beams from Poland Poland 
WT/DS122/1 06.04.98  15.10.99 
Poland 
WT/DS122/2 19.11.99 
WT/DSB/M/71  
123. Argentina – Safeguard Measures on Imports of 
Footwear Indonesia 
WT/DS123/1 22.04.98 US 
WT/DS123/2  16.04.99 
WT/DS123/3  
On 10.05.99, 
Indonesia requested 
the withdrawal of the 
panel request from the 
DSB agenda and 
reserved its rights to 
include that request at 
a future DSB meeting 
(WT/DS123/4)   
124. European Communities – Enforcement of 
Intellectual Property Rights for Motion 
Pictures and Television Programmes US 
WT/DS124/1 30.04.98    20.03.01 
WT/DS124/2 
125. Greece – Enforcement of Intellectual Property 
Rights for Motion Pictures and Television 
Programmes US 
WT/DS125/1 04.05.98    20.03.01 
WT/DS125/2 
126. Australia – Subsidies Provided to Producers 
and Exporters of Automotive Leather US 
WT/DS126/1 04.05.98  11.04.98 
US 
WT/DS126/2 22.06.98 
WT/DSB/M/46 24.07.00 
WT/DS126/11  
  WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1 
Page 20  
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
127. Belgium – Certain Income Tax Measures 
Constituting Subsidies US 
WT/DS127/1 05.05.98     
128. Netherlands – Certain Income Tax Measures 
Constituting Subsidies US 
WT/DS128/1 05.05.98     
129. Greece – Certain Income Tax Measures 
Constituting Subsidies US 
WT/DS129/1 05.05.98     
130. Ireland – Certain Income Tax Measures 
Constituting Subsidies US 
WT/DS130/1 05.05.98     
131. France – Certain Income Tax Measures 
Constituting Subsidies US 
WT/DS131/1 05.05.98     
132. Mexico – Anti–Dumping Investigation of 
High–Fructose Corn Syrup (HFCS) from the United States US 
WT/DS132/1 08.05.98  14.10.98 
US 
WT/DS132/2 25.11.98 
WT/DSB/M/51  
133. Slovak Republic – Measures Concerning the 
Importation of Dairy Pr oducts and the Transit 
of Cattle Switzerland 
WT/DS133/1 07.05.98 US 
WT/DS133/2    
134. European Communities – Restrictions on 
Certain Import Duties on Rice India 
WT/DS134/1 
and Corr.1 27.05.98     
135. European Communities – Measures Affecting 
Asbestos and Products Containing Asbestos Canada 
WT/DS135/1 28.05.98 Brazil 
WT/DS135/2 09.10.98 
Canada 
WT/DS135/3 25.11.98 
WT/DSB/M/51  
136. United States – Anti–Dumping Act of 1916 EC 
WT/DS136/1 04.06.98  12.11.98 
EC 
WT/DS136/2 01.02.99 
WT/DSB/M/54  
137. European Communities – Measures Affecting 
Imports of Wood of Conifers from Canada Canada 
WT/DS137/1 17.06.98     
138. United States – Imposition of Countervailing 
Duties on Certain Hot–Rolled Lead and Bismuth Carbon Steel Products Originating in 
the United Kingdom EC 
WT/DS138/1 12.06.98 Canada 
WT/DS138/2 14.01.99 
WT/DS138/3  
25.01.99 
WT/DS138/3 and 
Corr.1 17.02.99 
WT/DSB/M/55 
and Corr.1  
139. Canada – Certain Automotive Industry 
Measures Japan 
WT/DS139/1 03.07.98  13.11.98 
WT/DS139/2 01.02.99 
WT/DSB/M/54  
140. European Communities – Anti–Dumping 
Investigations Regarding Unbleached Cotton 
Fabrics from India India 
WT/DS140/1 03.08.98 Pakistan 
WT/DS140/2    
141. European Communities – Anti–Dumping 
Duties on Imports of Cotton–Type Bed–Linen 
from India India 
WT/DS141/1 03.08.98 Pakistan 
WT/DS141/2 08.09.99 
India 
WT/DS141/3 27.10.99 
WT/DSB/M/70   
   WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1
 Page 21 
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
142. Canada – Certain Measures Affecting the 
Automotive Industry EC 
WT/DS142/1 17.08.98  14.01.99 
WT/DS142/2 01.02.99 
WT/DSB/M/54  
143. Slovak Republic – Measure Affecting Import 
Duty on Wheat from Hungary Hungary 
WT/DS143/1 18.09.98 
(20 days)  09.10.98 
Hungary 
WT/DS143/2   
144. United States – Certain Measures Affecting 
the Import of Cattle, Swine and Grain from 
Canada Canada 
WT/DS144/1 25.09.98     
145. Argentina – Countervailing Duties on Imports 
of Wheat Gluten from the European Communities EC 
WT/DS145/1 
and Rev.1 23.09.98     
146. India – Measures Affecting the Automotive 
Sector EC 
WT/DS146/1  and 
Corr.1  06.10.98 Japan 
WT/DS146/2 
US 
WT/DS146/3 13.10.00 
EC 
WT/DS146/4  17.11.00 
WT/DSB/M/92  
147. Japan – Tariff Quotas and Subsidies Affecting 
Leather EC 
WT/DS147/1 08.10.98     
148. Czech Republic – Measure Affecting Import 
Duty on Wheat from Hungary 
 Hungary 
WT/DS148/1 12.10.98 
(20 days)     
149. India – Import Restrictions EC 
WT/DS149/1 
 28.10.98 US 
WT/DS149/2 
Japan 
WT/DS149/3 
Switzerland 
WT/DS149/4 
Australia 
WT/DS149/5    
150. India – Measures Affecting Customs Duties  EC 
WT/DS150/1 
 31.10.98 US 
WT/DS150/2  
Canada 
WT/DS150/3  
Japan 
WT/DS150/4  
Switzerland 
WT/DS150/5  
Australia 
WT/DS150/6     
  WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1 
Page 22  
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
151. United States – Measures Affecting Textiles 
and Apparel Products (II) 
 EC 
WT/DS151/1 19.11.98 Dominican 
Republic 
WT/DS151/2 
Hong Kong, 
China 
WT/DS151/3  
Pakistan 
WT/DS151/4  
Honduras 
WT/DS151/5  
Japan 
WT/DS151/6  
Switzerland 
WT/DS151/7 
El Salvador 
WT/DS151/8  
India 
WT/DS151/9   24.07.00 
WT/DS151/10 
152. United States – Sections 301–310 of the Trade 
Act of 1974 
 EC 
WT/DS152/1 25.11.98 Dominican 
Republic 
WT/DS152/2 
Panama 
WT/DS152/3  
Guatemala 
WT/DS152/4  
Mexico 
WT/DS152/5  
Jamaica 
WT/DS152/6  
Honduras 
WT/DS152/7  
Japan 
WT/DS152/8  
Colombia 
WT/DS152/9  
Ecuador 
WT/DS152/10  02.02.99 
EC 
WT/DS152/11  02.03.99 
WT/DSB/M/56   
   WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1
 Page 23 
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
153. European Communities – Patent Protection for 
Pharmaceutical and Agricultural Chemical 
Products 
 Canada 
WT/DS153/1 02.12.98 US 
WT/DS153/2  
Australia 
WT/DS153/3  
Switzerland 
WT/DS153/4    
154. European Communities – Measures Affecting 
Differential and Favourable Treatment of Coffee 
 Brazil 
WT/DS154/1 07.12.98 Colombia 
WT/DS154/2  
Peru 
WT/DS154/3  
Costa Rica 
WT/DS154/4  
Bolivia 
WT/DS154/5    
155. Argentina – Measures Af fecting the Export of 
Bovine Hides and the Import of Finished 
Leather 
 EC 
WT/DS155/1 23.12.98  04.06.99 
EC 
WT/DS155/2 26.07.99 
WT/DSB/M/65  
156. Guatemala – Definitive Anti–Dumping 
Measure on Grey Portland Cement from 
Mexico  Mexico 
WT/DS156/1  
and Corr.1  
to Corr.2 05.01.99  
 15.07.99 
Mexico 
WT/DS156/2  
05.08.99 
WT/DS156/2 and 
Corr.1 22.09.99 
WT/DSB/M/68  
157. Argentina – Definitive Anti–Dumping 
Measures on Imports of Drill Bits from Italy EC 
WT/DS157/1  14.01.99  
    
158. European Communities – Regime for the 
Importation, Sale and Distribution of Bananas Guatemala, 
Honduras, Mexico, 
Panama and the 
United States 
WT/DS158/1 20.01.99 Ecuador 
WT/DS158/2  
Belize 
WT/DS158/3    
159. Hungary – Safeguard Measure on Imports of 
Steel Products from the Czech Republic Czech Republic 
WT/DS159/1  21.01.99     
160. United States – Section 110(5) of US 
Copyright Act EC 
WT/DS160/1 26.01.99 Australia 
WT/DS160/2 
Canada 
WT/DS160/3  
Switzerland 
WT/DS160/4  16.04.99 
EC 
WT/DS160/5 26.05.99 
WT/DSB/M/62   
  WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1 
Page 24  
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
161. Korea – Measures Affec ting Imports of Fresh, 
Chilled and Frozen Beef US 
WT/DS161/1 01.02.99  New Zealand 
WT/DS161/2  
Australia 
WT/DS161/3  
Canada 
WT/DS161/4 16.04.99 
US 
WT/DS161/5  26.05.99 
WT/DSB/M/62  
162. United States – Anti–Dumping Act of 1916 Japan 
WT/DS162/1 10.02.99 EC 
WT/DS162/2 04.06.99 
Japan 
WT/DS162/3 26.07.99 
WT/DSB/M/65  
163. Korea – Measures Affecting Government 
Procurement US 
WT/DS163/1 16.02.99 EC 
WT/DS163/2  
Japan 
WT/DS163/3  11.05.99 
US 
WT/DS163/4 16.06.99 
WT/DSB/M/64  
164. Argentina – Measures Affecting Imports of 
Footwear US 
WT/DS164/1  01.03.99 EC 
WT/DS164/2  20.05.99 
US 
WT/DS164/3 
15.07.99 
WT/DS164/4 26.07.99 
WT/DSB/M/65  
165. United States – Import Measures on Certain 
Products from the European Communities EC 
WT/DS165/1  04.03.99 Dominican 
Republic 
WT/DS165/2  
Japan 
WT/DS165/3 
Honduras 
WT/DS165/4  
Guatemala 
WT/DS165/5  
Ecuador 
WT/DS165/6  
Panama 
WT/DS165/7 
and Corr.1 11.05.99 
EC 
WT/DS165/8  16.06.99 
WT/DSB/M/64  
166. United States – Definitive Safeguard Measures 
on Imports of Wheat Gluten from the 
European Communities EC 
WT/DS166/1 17.03.99 Australia 
WT/DS166/2  04.06.99 
EC 
WT/DS166/3 26.07.99 
WT/DSB/M/65  
167. United States – Countervailing Duty 
Investigation with respect to Live Cattle from 
Canada Canada 
WT/DS167/1 19.03.99 Mexico 
WT/DS167/2    
168. South Africa – Anti–Dumping Duties on 
Certain Pharmaceutical Products from India India 
WT/DS168/1 01.04.99      
   WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1
 Page 25 
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
169. Korea – Measures Affec ting Imports of Fresh, 
Chilled and Frozen Beef Australia 
WT/DS169/1 13.04.99 New Zealand 
WT/DS169/2  
US 
WT/DS169/3  
Canada 
WT/DS169/4 
and Corr.1 15.07.99 
Australia 
WT/DS169/5 26.07.99 
WT/DSB/M/65  
  
170. Canada – Term of Patent Protection US 
WT/DS170/1  06.05.99  15.07.99 
US 
WT/DS170/2 22.09.99 
WT/DSB/M/68  
171. Argentina – Patent Protection for 
Pharmaceuticals and Test Data Protection for Agricultural Chemicals US 
WT/DS171/1 06.05.99 Switzerland 
WT/DS171/2   31.05.02 
WT/DS171/3 
172. European Communities – Measures Relating 
to the Development of a Flight Management 
System US 
WT/DS172/1 21.05.99     
173. France – Measures Relating to the 
Development of a Flight Management System US 
WT/DS173/1  21.05.99      
  WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1 
Page 26  
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
174. European Communities – Protection of 
Trademarks and Geographical Indications for 
Agricultural Products and Foodstuffs US 
WT/DS174/1 
and Add.1  01.06.99 
 
04.04.03 Canada 
WT/DS174/3 
Australia 
WT/DS174/4 
Mexico 
WT/DS174/5 
New Zealand 
WT/DS174/6 
Sri Lanka 
WT/DS174/7  
India 
WT/DS174/8  
Argentina 
WT/DS174/9  
Hungary 
WT/DS174/10  
Malta 
WT/DS174/11  
Bulgaria 
WT/DS174/12  
Czech Republic 
WT/DS174/13  
Cyprus 
WT/DS174/14  
Slovenia 
WT/DS174/15  
Turkey 
WT/DS174/16 
Romania 
WT/DS174/17  
Slovak Republic 
WT/DS174/18 18.08.03 
US 
WT/DS174/20  02.10.03 
WT/DSB/M/156  
175. India – Measures Affecting Trade and 
Investment in the Motor Vehicle Sector US 
WT/DS175/1 02.06.99 Japan 
WT/DS175/2  
EC 
WT/DS175/3 18.05.00 
US 
WT/DS175/4 27.07.00 
WT/DSB/M/86  
176. United States – Section 211 Omnibus 
Appropriations Act of 1998 EC 
WT/DS176/1  08.07.99  07.07.00 
EC 
WT/DS176/2 26.09.00 
WT/DSB/M/89   
   WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1
 Page 27 
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
177. United States – Safeguard Measure on Imports 
of Fresh, Chilled or Frozen Lamb from New 
Zealand New Zealand 
WT/DS177/1  
 16.07.99 Australia 
WT/DS177/2 
Canada 
WT/DS177/3 15.10.99 
New Zealand 
WT/DS177/4 19.11.99 
WT/DSB/M/71  
178. United States – Safeguard Measure on Imports 
of Lamb Meat from Australia 
 Australia 
WT/DS178/1  
and Corr.1 
 23.07.99 New Zealand 
WT/DS178/2 
and Corr.1 
EC 
WT/DS178/3 
Canada 
WT/DS178/4 15.10.99 
Australia 
WT/DS178/5 and 
Corr.1 19.11.99 
WT/DSB/M/71  
179. United States – Anti–Du mping Measures on 
Stainless Steel Plate in Coils and Stainless 
Steel Sheet and Strip from Korea Korea 
WT/DS179/1  30.07.99  15.10.99 
Korea 
WT/DS179/2 19.11.99 
WT/DSB/M/71  
180. United States – Reclassification of Certain 
Sugar Syrups  Canada 
WT/DS180/1 06.09.99     
181. Colombia – Safeguard Measure on Import of 
Plain Polyester Filaments from Thailand    08.09.99 
Thailand 
WT/DS181/1  
Request withdrawn 
27.10.99 
WT/DSB/M/70   
182. Ecuador – Definitive Anti–Dumping Measures 
on Grey Cement from Mexico Mexico 
WT/DS182/1 and 
Corr.1 05.10.99     
183. Brazil – Measures on Import Licensing and 
Minimum Import Prices EC 
WT/DS183/1 14.10.99 US 
WT/DS183/2    
184. United States – Anti–Du mping Measures on 
Certain Hot–Rolled Steel Products from Japan Japan 
WT/DS184/1 18.11.99  11.02.00 
Japan 
WT/DS184/2 20.03.00 
WT/DSB/M/77  
185. Trinidad and Tobago – Certain Measures 
Affecting Imports of Pasta from Costa Rica Costa Rica 
WT/DS185/1 18.11.99     
186. United States – Section 337 of the Tariff Act 
of 1930 and Amendments thereto EC 
WT/DS186/1 12.01.00 Canada 
WT/DS186/2 
Japan 
WT/DS186/3    
187. Trinidad and Tobago – Provisional Anti–
Dumping Measure on Imports of Macaroni 
and Spaghetti from Costa Rica Costa Rica 
WT/DS187/1 17.01.00      
  WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1 
Page 28  
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
188. Nicaragua – Measures Affecting Imports from 
Honduras and Colombia Colombia 
WT/DS188/1 17.01.00  28.03.00 
Colombia 
WT/DS188/1 and 
Corr.1 18.05.00 
WT/DSB/M/80  
189. Argentina – Definitive Anti–Dumping 
Measures on Carton–Board Imports from 
Germany and Definitive Anti–Dumping 
Measures on Imports of Ceramic Floor Tiles from Italy EC 
WT/DS189/1 
 26.01.00  15.09.00 
EC 
WT/DS189/2 
07.11.00 
WT/DS189/3 17.11.00 
WT/DSB/M/92  
190. Argentina – Transitional Safeguard Measures 
on Certain Imports of Woven Fabrics of 
Cotton and Cotton Mixtures Originating in Brazil    11.02.00 
Brazil 
WT/DS190/1 
 20.03.00 
WT/DSB/M/77 27.06.00 
WT/DS190/2 
191. Ecuador – Definitive Anti–Dumping Measure 
on Cement from Mexico Mexico 
WT/DS191/1 15.03.00     
192. United States – Transitional Safeguard 
Measure on Combed Cotton Yarn from 
Pakistan N.A. N.A. N.A. 03.04.00 
Pakistan 
WT/DS192/1 19.06.00 
WT/DSB/M/84  
193. Chile – Measures Affecting the Transit and 
Importation of Sword Fish EC 
WT/DS193/1 19.04.00  06.11.00 
EC 
WT/DS193/2 12.12.00 
WT/DSB/M/94  
23.03.01 
WT/DS193/3  
Suspension of the 
constitution of the 
Panel  
194. United States – Measures Treating Export 
Restraints of Subsidies Canada 
WT/DS194/1 19.05.00  24.07.00 
Canada 
WT/DS194/2  11.09.00 
WT/DSB/M/88   
195. Philippines – Measures Affecting Trade and 
Investment in the Motor Vehicle Sector United States 
WT/DS195/1 23.05.00  13.10.00 
United States 
WT/DS195/3 17.11.00 
WT/DSB/M/92  
196. Argentina – Certain Measures on the 
Protection of Patents and Test Data United States 
WT/DS196/1 30.05.00 EC 
WT/DS196/2  
Switzerland 
WT/DS196/3   31.05.02 
WT/DS196/4 
197. Brazil – Measures on Minimum Import Prices United States 
WT/DS197/1 30.05.00 EC 
WT/DS197/2    
198. Romania – Measures on Minimum Import 
Prices United States 
WT/DS198/1 30.05.00    26.09.01 
WT/DS198/2  
   WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1
 Page 29 
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
199. Brazil – Measures Affecting Patent Protection United States 
WT/DS199/1 30.05.00 EC 
WT/DS/199/2 08.01.01 
United States 
WT/DS199/3 01.02.01 
WT/DSB/M/98 05.07.01 
WT/DS199/4 
200. United States – Section 306 of the Trade Act 
of 1974 and Amendments Thereto EC 
WT/DS200/1 05.06.00 Ecuador 
W/DS200/2  
Jamaica 
WT/DS200/3 
Japan 
WT/DS200/4  
Dominican 
Republic 
WT/DS200/5  
Honduras 
WT/DS200/6  
Guatemala 
WT/DS200/7 
Canada 
WT/DS200/8  
Panama 
WT/DS200/9  
Australia 
WT/DS200/10 
St. Lucia 
WT/DS200/11     
201. Nicaragua – Measures Affecting Import from 
Honduras and Colombia Honduras 
WT/DS201/1 06.06.00 EC 
WT/DS201/2    
202. United States – Definitive Safeguard Measures 
on Imports of Circular Welded Carbon Quality 
Line Pipe from Korea Korea 
WT/DS202/1 13.06.00 EC 
WT/DS202/2  
Japan 
WT/DS202/3  15.09.00 
Korea  
WT/DS202/4  
 23.10.00 
WT/DSB/M/91  
203. Mexico – Measures Affecting Trade in Live 
Swine United States 
WT/DS203/1 10.07.00     
204. Mexico – Measures Affecting 
Telecommunications Services United States 
WT/DS204/1 
and Add.1  17.08.00  10.11.00 
United States 
WT/DS204/2 
18.02.02 
WT/DS204/3 17.04.02 
WT/DSB/M/123  
205. Egypt – Import Prohibition on Canned Tuna 
with Soybean Oil Thailand 
WT/DS205/1  22.09.00      
  WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1 
Page 30  
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
206. United States – Anti–Dumping and 
Countervailing Measures on Steel Plate from 
India India 
WT/DS206/1  04.10.00  07.06.01 
India 
WT/DS206/2 24.07.01 
WT/DSB/M/107  
207. Chile – Price Band System and Safeguard 
Measures Relating to Certain Agricultural Products Argentina 
WT/DS207/1 05.10.00  19.01.01 
Argentina 
WT/DS207/2 12.03.01 
WT/DSB/M/101  
208. Turkey – Anti–Dumping Duty on Steel and 
Iron Pipe Fittings Brazil 
WT/DS208/1 09.10.00     
209. European Communities – Measures Affecting 
Soluble Coffee Brazil 
WT/DS209/1 12.10.00 Ecuador 
WT/DS209/2    
210. Belgium – Administration of Measures 
Establishing Customs Duties for Rice United States 
WT/DS210/1 12.10.00  19.01.01 
United States 
WT/DS210/2  
01.03.01 
WT/DS201/2/ 
Rev.1 12.03.01 
WT/DSB/M/101 18.12.01 
WT/DS210/6 
211. Egypt – Definitive Anti–Dumping Measures 
on Steel Rebar from Turkey 
 Turkey 
WT/DS211/1 06.11.00  04.05.01 
Turkey 
WT/DS211/2 
11.05.01 
WT/DS/211/2/Corr. 120.06.01 
WT/DSB/M/106  
  
212. United States– Countervailing Measures 
Concerning Certain Products from the 
European Communities EC 
WT/DS212/1 
and Add.1  10.11.00 Brazil 
WT/DS212/2 
and Add.1 
Israel 
WT/DS212/3  10.08.01 
EC 
WT/DS212/4 10.09.01 
WT/DSB/M/109  
213. United States – Countervailing Duties on 
Certain Corrosion–Resist ant Carbon Steel Flat 
Products from Germany EC 
WT/DS213/1 
and Add.1 10.11.00 India 
WT/DS213/2 10.08.01 
EC 
WT/DS213/3 10.09.01 
WT/DSB/M/109  
214. United States– Definitive Safeguard Measures 
on Imports of Steel Wire Rod and Circular 
Welded Quality Line Pipe EC 
WT/DS214/1 01.12.00 Canada 
WT/DS214/2 
India 
WT/DS214/3 10.08.01 
WT/DS214/4 10.09.01 
WT/DSB/M/109  
215. Philippines – Anti–Dumping Measures 
Regarding Polypropylene Resins from Korea Korea 
WT/DS215/1 15.12.00     
216. Mexico–Provisional Anti–Dumping Measure 
on Electric Transformers 
 Brazil 
WT/DS216/1 20.12.00 EC 
WT/DS216/2 
United States 
WT/DS216/3     
   WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1
 Page 31 
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
217. United States – Continued Dumping and 
Subsidy Offset Act of 2000 Australia, Brazil, 
Chile, 
the EC, India, 
Indonesia, Japan, 
Korea and 
Thailand 
WT/DS217/1 21.12.00 Argentina 
WT/DS217/2 
Canada 
WT/DS217/3 
Mexico 
WT/DS217/4 
and Add.1  13.07.01 
Australia, Brazil, 
Chile, 
the EC, India, 
Indonesia, Japan, 
Korea and Thailand 
WT/DS217/5 23.08.01 
WT/DSB/M/108  
218. United States – Countervailing Duties on 
Certain Carbon Steel Products from Brazil Brazil 
WT/DS218/1 21.12.00 EC 
WT/DS218/2    
219. European Communities – Anti–Dumping 
Duties on Malleable Cast Iron Tube or Pipe Fittings from Brazil Brazil 
WT/DS219/1 21.12.00  08.06.01 
Brazil 
WT/DS219/2 24.07.01 
WT/DSB/M/107  
220. Chile – Price Band System and Safeguard 
Measures Relating to Certain Agricultural 
Products Guatemala 
WT/DS220/1 05.01.01     
221. United States – Section 129(C)(1) of the 
Uruguay Round Agreements Act Canada 
WT/DS221/1 
 17.01.01 India 
WT/DS221/2 
EC 
WT/DS221/3  13.07.01 
Canada 
WT/DS221/4 23.08.01 
WT/DSB/M/108  
222. Canada – Export Credits and Loan Guarantees 
for Regional Aircraft Brazil 
WT/DS222/1 22.01.01  01.03.01 
Brazil 
WT/DS222/2 12.03.01 
WT/DSB/M/101  
223. European Communities– Tariff–Rate Quota on 
Corn Gluten Feed from the United States United States 
WT/DS223/1 25.01.01 
     
224. United States – US Patents Code Brazil 
WT/DS224/1 31.01.01 India 
WT/DS224/2    
225. United States – Anti–Dumping Duties on 
Seamless Pipe from Italy EC 
WT/DS225/1 05.02.01 Japan 
WT/DS225/2    
226. Chile – Provisional Safeguard Measure on 
Mixtures of Edible Oils  
 Argentina 
WT/DS226/1 19.02.02      
  WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1 
Page 32  
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
227. Peru – Taxes on Cigarettes Chile 
WT/DS227/1 
and Corr.1 
to Corr.2  01.03.01  03.05.01 
Chile 
WT/DS227/2 
The complaint was 
formally withdrawn 
on 12 July 2001 
WT/DS227/3 20.06.01 
WT/DSB/M/106  
228. Chile– Safeguards on Sugar  Colombia 
WT/DS228/1 15. 03.01 Cuba 
WT/DS228/2 
Guatemala 
WT/DS228/3 
Nicaragua 
WT/DS228/4 
Costa Rica 
WT/DS228/5 
El Salvador 
WT/DS228/6     
229. Brazil– Anti–dumping Duties on Jute Bags 
from India India 
WT/DS229/1 09.04.01     
230. Chile – Safeguard Measures and Modification 
of Schedules Regarding Sugar 
 Colombia 
WT/DS230/1 17.04.01 Guatemala 
WT/DS230/2 
Costa Rica 
WT/DS230/3 
Cuba 
WT/DS230/4 
Nicaragua 
WT/DS230/5     
231. European Communities – Trade Description of 
Sardines Peru 
WT/DS231/1 20.03.01 Venezuela 
WT/DS231/2 
Chile 
WT/DS231/3 
United States 
WT/DS231/4 
Ecuador 
WT/DS231/5  07.06.01 
Peru 
WT/DS231/6 24.07.01 
WT/DSB/M/107 25.07.03 
WT/DS231/18  
   WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1
 Page 33 
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
232. Mexico– Measures Affecting the Import of 
Matches Chile 
WT/DS232/1 
Withdrawal of the 
request for 
consultations 
WT/DS232/3  
(02.02.04) 17.05.01 EC 
WT/DS232/2    
233. Argentina – Measures Affecting the Import of 
Pharmaceutical Products India 
WT/DS233/1 25.05.01     
234. United States – Continued Dumping and 
Subsidy Offset Act of 2000 Canada and 
Mexico 
WT/DS234/1 21.05.01 Japan 
WT/DS234/2 
EC 
WT/DS234/3 
Brazil 
WT/DS234/4 
Indonesia 
WT/DS234/5 
Korea 
WT/DS234/6 
India 
WT/DS234/7 
Guatemala 
WT/DS234/8 
Thailand 
WT/DS234/9 
Australia 
WT/DS234/10 
Chile 
WT/DS234/11 10.08.01 
Canada 
WT/DS234/12  
10.08.01 
Mexico 
WT/DS234/13 10.09.01 
DSB decided that 
the Panel 
established on 
23.08.01 at the 
request of 
Australia, Brazil, 
Chile, EC, India, 
Indonesia, Japan, 
Korea and 
Thailand in 
relation to the 
same matter would 
also examine the 
complaints by 
Canada and 
Mexico 
WT/DSB/M/109  
235. Slovakia – Safeguard Measure on Imports of 
Sugar   Poland 
WT/DS235/1  11.07.01    11.01.02 
WT/DS235/2 
236. United States – Preliminary Determinations 
with respect to certain Softwood Lumber from 
Canada Canada 
WT/DS236/1 21.08.01  26.10.01 
Canada 
WT/DS236/2 05.12.01 
WT/DSB/M/114 12.10.06 
WT/DS236/5 
237. Turkey – Certain Import Procedures for Fresh 
Fruit Ecuador 
WT/DS237/1 31.08.01 EC 
WT/DS237/2 14.06.02 
Ecuador 
WT/DS237/3 29.07.02 
WT/DSB/M/130 22.11.02 
WT/DS237/4  
  WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1 
Page 34  
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
238. Argentina – Definitive Safeguard Measure on 
Imports of Preserved Peaches Chile 
WT/DS238/1 14.09.01  06.12.02 
Chile 
WT/DS238/2 18.01.02 
WT/DSB/M/117  
239. United States – Anti–Dumping Duties on 
Silicon Metal from Brazil Brazil 
WT/DS239/1  
and Rev.1  18.09.01 
 
01.11.01 Thailand 
WT/DS239/2  
 
EC 
WT/DS239/3    
240. Romania – Import Prohibition on Wheat and 
Wheat Flour Hungary 
WT/DS240/1  
and 
WT/DS240/1  
Add.1  18.10.01 
 
 
30.10.01  28.11.01 
Hungary 
WT/DS240/2  
20.12.01 
Withdrawal of the 
panel request 
WT/DS240/3   
241. Argentina – Definitive Anti–Dumping Duties 
on Poultry from Brazil Brazil 
WT/DS241/1 07.11.01 EC 
WT/DS241/2 26.02.02 
Brazil 
WT/DS241/3 17.04.02 
WT/DSB/M/123  
242. European Communities – Generalized System 
of Preferences Thailand 
WT/DS242/1 07.12.01 Costa Rica 
WT/DS242/2  
Guatemala 
WT/DS242/3  
Nicaragua 
WT/DS242/4  
Honduras 
WT/DS242/5  
Colombia 
WT/DS242/6    
243. United States – Rules of Origin for Textiles 
and Apparel Products India 
WT/DS243/1 11.01.02 Bangladesh 
WT/DS243/2  
EC 
WT/DS243/3 08.05.02 
India 
WT/DS243/5  
07.06.02 
WT/DS243/5/ 
Rev.1 24.06.02 
WT/DSB/M/128  
244. United States – Sunset Review of Anti–
Dumping Duties on Corrosion–Resistant Carbon Steel Flat Products from Japan Japan 
WT/DS244/1 30.01.02 EC 
WT/DS244/2  
India 
WT/DS244/3 05.04.02 
Japan 
WT/DS244/4 22.05.02 
WT/DSB/M/124 
and Corr.1   
   WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1
 Page 35 
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
245. Japan – Measures Affecting the Importation of 
Apples US 
WT/DS245/1 01.03.02  08.05.02 
US 
WT/DS245/2 03.06.02 
WT/DSB/M/125 30.08.05 
WT/DS245/21 
246. European Communities – Conditions for the 
Granting of Tariff Preferences to Developing Countries India 
WT/DS246/1 05.03.02 Venezuela 
WT/DS246/2  
Colombia 
WT/DS246/3 06.12.02 
India 
WT/DS246/4 27.01.03 
WT/DSB/M/142  
247. United States – Provisional Anti–Dumping 
Measure on Imports of Certain Softwood Lumber from Canada Canada 
WT/DS247/1 06.03.02    12.10.06 
WT/DS247/2 
248. United States – Definitive Safeguard Measures 
on Imports of Certain Steel Products EC 
WT/DS248/1 07.03.02 Japan 
WT/DS248/2  
Switzerland 
WT/DS248/3  
Korea 
WT/DS248/4  
Norway 
WT/DS248/5  
Venezuela 
WT/DS248/6  
Canada 
WT/DS248/7  
Mexico 
WT/DS248/8  
China 
WT/DS248/9  
New Zealand 
WT/DS248/10 08.05.02 
EC 
WT/DS248/12 03.06.02 
WT/DSB/M/125   
  WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1 
Page 36  
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
249. United States – Definitive Safeguard Measures 
on Imports of Certain Steel Products Japan 
WT/DS249/1 20.03.02 Norway 
WT/DS249/2  
New Zealand 
WT/DS249/3  
Mexico 
WT/DS249/4 24.05.02 
Japan 
WT/DS249/6 14.06.02 
The DSB agreed 
that the Panel 
established on 
3 June 2002 to 
examine the 
complaint by 
the EC would also 
examine the 
complaint by 
Japan pertaining to 
the same matter. 
WT/DSB/M/127   
250. United States – Equalizing Excise Tax 
Imposed by Florida on Processed Orange and 
Grapefruit Products Brazil 
WT/DS250/1 20.03.02  19.08.02 
Brazil 
WT/DS250/2 01.10.02 
WT/DSB/M/133 28.05.04 
WT/DS250/3 
251. United States – Definitive Safeguard Measures 
on Imports of Certain Steel Products Korea 
WT/DS251/1 20.03.02 Norway 
WT/DS251/2  
Japan 
WT/DS251/3  
New Zealand 
WT/DS251/4  
Mexico 
WT/DS251/5 24.05.02 
Korea 
WT/DS251/7 14.06.02 
The DSB agreed 
that the Panel 
established on 
3 June 2002 to 
examine the 
complaint by 
the EC would also 
examine the 
complaint by 
Korea pertaining 
to the same matter.
WT/DSB/M/127   
   WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1
 Page 37 
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
252. United States – Definitive Safeguard Measures 
on Imports of Certain Steel Products China 
WT/DS252/1 26.03.02 Japan 
WT/DS252/2  
New Zealand 
WT/DS252/3 27.05.02 
China 
WT/DS252/5 24.06.02 
The DSB agreed 
that the Panel 
established on 
3 June 2002 to 
examine the 
complaint by 
the EC would also 
examine the 
complaint by 
China pertaining 
to the same matter.
WT/DSB/M/128   
253. United States – Definitive Safeguard Measures 
on Imports of Certain Steel Products Switzerland 
WT/DS253/1 03.04.02 New Zealand 
WT/DS253/2  
Japan 
WT/DS253/3 04.06.02 
Switzerland 
WT/DS253/5 24.06.02 
The DSB agreed 
that the Panel 
established on 
3 June 2002 to 
examine the 
complaint by the 
EC would also 
examine the 
complaint by 
Switzerland 
pertaining to the 
same matter. 
WT/DSB/M/128   
254. United States – Definitive Safeguard Measures 
on Imports of Certain Steel Products Norway 
WT/DS254/1 04.04.02 New Zealand 
WT/DS254/2  
Japan 
WT/DS254/3 04.06.02 
Norway 
WT/DS254/5 24.06.02 
The DSB agreed 
that the Panel 
established on 
3 June 2002 to 
examine the 
complaint by 
the EC would also 
examine the 
complaint by 
Norway pertaining 
to the same matter.
WT/DSB/M/128    
  WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1 
Page 38  
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
255. Peru – Tax Treatment on Certain Imported 
Products Chile 
WT/DS255/1 22.04.02 US 
WT/DS255/2 14.06.02 
Chile 
WT/DS255/3 
25.09.02 
WT/DS255/5  
(withdrawal of the 
matter)   
256. Turkey – Import Ban on Pet Food from 
Hungary Hungary 
WT/DS256/1 03.05.02     
257. Final Countervailing Duty Determination with 
Respect to Certain Softwood Lumber from Canada Canada 
WT/DS257/1 03.05.02  19.07.02 
Canada 
WT/DS257/2 
19.08.02 
WT/DS257/3 01.10.02 
WT/DSB/M/133 12.10.06 
WT/DS257/26 
258. United States – Definitive Safeguard Measures 
on Imports of Certain Steel Products New Zealand 
WT/DS258/1 14.05.02 EC 
WT/DS258/2  
Japan 
WT/DS258/3  
Korea 
WT/DS258/4  
Norway 
WT/DS258/5  
China 
WT/DS258/6 
Mexico  
WT/DS258/7 28.06.02 
New Zealand 
WT/DS258/9 08.07.02 
The DSB agreed 
that the Panel 
established on 
3 June 2002 to 
examine the 
complaint by 
the EC would also 
examine the 
complaint by 
New Zealand 
pertaining to the 
same matter. 
WT/DSB/M/129    
   WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1
 Page 39 
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
259. United States – Definitive Safeguard Measures 
on Imports of Certain Steel Products Brazil 
WT/DS259/1 21.05.02 EC 
WT/DS259/2  
Japan 
WT/DS259/3  
Korea 
WT/DS259/4  
Norway 
WT/DS259/5  
China 
WT/DS259/6  
Mexico 
WT/DS259/7 22.07.02 
Brazil 
WT/DS259/10 29.07.02 
The DSB agreed 
that the Panel 
established on 
3 June 2002 to 
examine the 
complaint by 
the EC would also 
examine the 
complaint by 
Brazil pertaining 
to the same matter.
WT/DSB/M/130   
260. European Communities – Provisional 
Safeguard Measures on Imports of Certain 
Steel Products US 
WT/DS260/1 30.05.02 Japan 
WT/DS260/2 19.08.02 
US 
WT/DS260/4 16.09.02 
WT/DSB/M/132  
261. Uruguay – Tax Treatment on Certain Products Chile 
WT/DS261/1 18.06.02 EC 
WT/DS261/2 
Mexico 
WT/DS261/3 03.04.03 
Chile 
WT/DS261/4  19.05.03 
WT/DSB/M/150 08.01.04 
WT/DS261/7 
262. United States – Sunset Review of Anti–
Dumping and Countervailing Duties on 
Certain Steel Products from France and 
Germany EC 
WT/DS262/1 25.07.02 Canada 
WT/DS262/2  
Japan 
WT/DS262/3    
263. European Communities – Measures Affecting 
Imports of Wine Argentina 
WT/DS263/1 04.09.02     
264. United States – Final Dumping Determination 
on Softwood Lumber from Canada Canada 
WT/DS264/1 13.09.02  06.12.02 
Canada 
WT/DS264/2 08.01.03 
WT/DSB/M/140 12.10.06 
WT/DS264/29  
  WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1 
Page 40  
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
265. European Communities – Export Subsidies on 
Sugar Australia 
WT/DS265/1 27.09.02 Mauritius 
WT/DS265/2 
Brazil 
WT/DS265/3 
Swaziland 
WT/DS265/4  
Fiji 
WT/DS265/5 
Guyana 
WT/DS265/6  
Belize 
WT/DS265/7 
Jamaica 
WT/DS265/8 
India 
WT/DS265/9  
Zimbabwe  
WT/DS265/10  09.07.03 
Australia 
WT/DS265/21 29.08.03 
WT/DSB/M/155  
   Malawi 
WT/DS265/11  
Canada 
WT/DS265/12  
Kenya 
WT/DS265/13  
Barbados 
WT/DS265/14  
Côte d'Ivoire 
WT/DS265/15  
Congo 
WT/DS265/16  
Madagascar 
WT/DS265/17  
Colombia 
WT/DS265/18 
Saint Kitts and 
Nevis 
WT/DS265/19     
   WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1
 Page 41 
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
266. European Communities – Export Subsidies on 
Sugar Brazil 
WT/DS266/1 27.09.02 Australia 
WT/DS266/2  
Mauritius 
WT/DS266/3  
India 
WT/DS266/4  
Swaziland 
WT/DS266/5  
Fiji 
WT/DS266/6  
Guyana 
WT/DS266/7  
Belize 
WT/DS266/8  
Jamaica 
WT/DS266/9  
Zimbabwe 
WT/DS266/10  
Malawi 
WT/DS266/11  
Canada 
WT/DS266/12  
Kenya 
WT/DS266/13  
Barbados 
WT/DS266/14 
Côte d'Ivoire 
WT/DS266/15  
Congo 
WT/DS266/16  
Madagascar 
WT/DS266/17  
Colombia 
WT/DS266/18 
Saint Kitts and 
Nevis 
WT/DS266/19  09.07.03 
Brazil 
WT/DS266/21 29.08.03 
WT/DSB/M/155   
  WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1 
Page 42  
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
267. United States – Subsidies on Upland Cotton Brazil 
WT/DS267/1 27.09.02 Zimbabwe 
WT/DS267/2  
India 
WT/DS267/3 
Argentina 
WT/DS267/4 
Canada 
WT/DS267/5 06.02.03 
Brazil 
WT/DS267/7 18.03.03 
WT/DSB/M/145   
268. United States – Sunset Reviews of Anti–
Dumping Measures on Oil Country Tubular 
Goods from Argentina Argentina 
WT/DS268/1 07.10.02  03.04.03 
Argentina 
WT/DS268/2 19.05.03 
WT/DSB/M/150  
269. European Communities – Customs 
Classification of Frozen Boneless Chicken 
Cuts Brazil 
WT/DS269/1 11.10.02 US 
WT/DS269/2 19.09.03 
Brazil 
WT/DS269/3 07.11.03 
WT/DSB/M/157  
270. Australia – Certain Measures Affecting the 
Importation of Fresh Fruit and Vegetables Philippines 
WT/DS270/1 18.10.02 EC 
WT/DS270/2  
Thailand 
WT/DS270/3 07.07.03 
Philippines 
WT/DS270/5/ 
Rev.1 29.08.03 
WT/DSB/M/155  
271. Australia – Certain Measures Affecting the 
Importation of Fresh Pineapple Philippines 
WT/DS271/1 18.10.02 EC 
WT/DS271/2  
Thailand 
WT/DS271/3    
272. Peru – Provisional Anti–Dumping Duties on 
Vegetable Oils from Argentina Argentina 
WT/DS272/1 21.10.02     
273. Korea – Measures Affecting Trade in 
Commercial Vessels EC 
WT/DS273/1 21.10.02  11.06.03 
EC 
WT/DS273/2 21.07.03 
WT/DSB/M/153  
274. United States – Definitive Safeguard Measures 
on Imports of Certain Steel Products The Separate 
Customs Territory 
of Taiwan, Penghu, 
Kinmen and Matsu
WT/DS274/1 01.11.02 Japan 
WT/DS274/2     
   WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1
 Page 43 
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
275. Venezuela – Import Licensing Measures on 
Certain Agricultural Products US 
WT/DS275/1 07.11.02 EC 
WT/DS275/2 
Canada 
WT/DS275/3  
New Zealand 
WT/DS275/4 
Argentina 
WT/DS275/5  
Colombia 
WT/DS275/6  
Chile 
WT/DS275/7    
276. Canada – Measures Relating to Exports of 
Wheat and Treatment of Imported Grain US 
WT/DS276/1 17.12.02 Japan 
WT/DS276/2  
Mexico 
WT/DS276/3  
EC 
WT/DS276/4  
Australia 
WT/DS276/5  06.03.03 
US 
WT/DS276/6 
 
30.06.03 
US 
WT/DS276/9 31.03.03 
WT/DSB/M/146  
 
 
11.07.03 
WT/DSB/M/152  
277. United States – Investigation of the 
International Trade Commission in Softwood 
Lumber from Canada Canada 
WT/DS277/1 20.12.02  03.04.03 
Canada 
WT/DS277/2 07.05.03 
WT/DSB/M/149 12.10.06 
WT/DS277/20 
278. Chile –Definitive Safeguard Measure on 
Imports of Fructose Argentina 
WT/DS278/1 20.12.02     
279. India – Import Restrictions Maintained under 
the Export and Import Policy 2002–2007 EC 
WT/DS279/1 23.12.02 US 
WT/DS279/2    
280. United States – Countervailing Duties on Steel 
Plate from Mexico Mexico 
WT/DS280/1 21.01.03  04.08.03 
Mexico 
WT/DS280/2 29.08.03 
WT/DSB/M/155  
281. United States – Anti–Du mping Measures on 
Cement from Mexico Mexico 
WT/DS281/1 31.01.03  29.07.03 
Mexico 
WT/DS281/2 29.08.03 
WT/DSB/M/155  
282. United States – Anti–Du mping Measures on 
Oil Country Tubular Goods (OCTG) from Mexico Mexico 
WT/DS282/1 18.02.03  29.07.03 
Mexico 
WT/DS282/2 29.08.03 
WT/DSB/M/155   
  WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1 
Page 44  
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
283. European Communities – Export Subsidies on 
Sugar Thailand 
WT/DS283/1 14.03.03  09.07.03 
Thailand 
WT/DS283/2 29.08.03 
WT/DSB/M/155  
284. Mexico – Certain Measures Preventing the 
Importation of Black Beans from Nicaragua Nicaragua 
WT/DS284/1 17.03.03 US 
WT/DS284/2 
Canada 
WT/DS284/3    
285. United States – Measures Affecting the Cross–
Border Supply of Gambling and Betting Services Antigua and 
Barbuda 
WT/DS285/1 
and 
WT/DS285/1/ 
Add.1 13.03.03 
  
 
01.04.03  12.06.03 
Antigua and Barbuda 
WT/DS285/2 21.07.03 
WT/DSB/M/153  
286. European Communities – Customs 
Classification of Frozen Boneless Chicken 
Cuts Thailand 
WT/DS286/1 25.03.03 Brazil 
WT/DS286/2  
US 
WT/DS286/3 27.10.03 
Thailand 
WT/DS286/5 21.11.03 
The DSB agreed 
that the Panel 
established on 
7 November 2003 
to examine the 
complaint by 
Brazil 
(WT/DS269/3) 
would also 
examine the 
complaint by 
Thailand 
pertaining to the 
same matter. 
WT/DSB/M/158   
287. Australia – Quarantine Regime for Imports EC 
WT/DS287/1 03.04.03 Chile 
WT/DS287/2  
Canada 
WT/DS287/3  
India 
WT/DS287/4  
Philippines 
WT/DS287/5 29.08.03 
EC 
WT/DS287/7 
and 
14.10.03 
WT/DS287/7/ 
Rev.1   
288. South Africa – Definitive Anti–Dumping 
Measures on Blanketing from Turkey Turkey 
WT/DS288/1 09.04.03      
   WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1
 Page 45 
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
289. Czech Republic – Additional Duty on Imports 
of Pig–Meat from Poland Poland 
WT/DS289/1 16.04.03     
290. European Communities – Protection of 
Trademarks and Geographical Indications for Agricultural Products and Foodstuffs Australia 
WT/DS290/1 17.04.03 Malta 
WT/DS290/2  
Bulgaria 
WT/DS290/3  
Czech Republic 
WT/DS290/4  
Cyprus 
WT/DS290/5  
US 
WT/DS290/6  
Slovenia 
WT/DS290/7  
New Zealand 
WT/DS290/8  
Turkey 
WT/DS290/9 
Mexico 
WT/DS290/10  
Argentina 
WT/DS290/11 
Hungary 
WT/DS290/12  
Colombia 
WT/DS290/13  
Romania 
WT/DS290/14  
Slovak Republic 
WT/DS290/15  
The Separate 
Customs 
Territory of 
Taiwan, Penghu, 
Kinmen and 
Matsu 
WT/DS290/16 18.08.03 
Australia 
WT/DS290/18 02.10.03 
WT/DSB/M/156   
  WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1 
Page 46  
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
291. European Communities – Measures Affecting 
the Approval and Marketing of Biotech 
Products US 
WT/DS291/1 13.05.03 Peru 
WT/DS291/2  
Colombia 
WT/DS291/3  
Mexico 
WT/DS291/4  
Australia 
WT/DS291/5 
New Zealand 
WT/DS291/6  
Argentina 
WT/DS291/7  
Brazil 
WT/DS291/8  
Canada 
WT/DS291/9 
India 
WT/DS291/10  
Chile 
WT/DS291/11  07.08.03 
WT/DS291/23 29.08.03 
WT/DSB/M/155  
292. European Communities – Measures Affecting 
the Approval and Marketing of Biotech Products Canada 
WT/DS292/1 13.05.03 Mexico 
WT/DS292/2  
US 
WT/DS292/3  
Australia 
WT/DS292/4 
Argentina 
WT/DS292/5  
Brazil 
WT/DS292/6  
India 
WT/DS292/7  
New Zealand 
WT/DS292/8 07.08.03 
WT/DS292/17 29.08.03 
WT/DSB/M/155   
   WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1
 Page 47 
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
293. European Communities – Measures Affecting 
the Approval and Marketing of Biotech 
Products Argentina 
WT/DS293/1 14.05.03 Mexico 
WT/DS293/2  
US 
WT/DS293/3  
Australia 
WT/DS293/4  
Brazil 
WT/DS293/5  
Canada 
WT/DS293/6  
India 
WT/DS293/7  
New Zealand 
WT/DS293/8  07.08.03 
Argentina 
WT/DS293/17 29.08.03 
WT/DSB/M/155   
294. United States – Laws, Regulations and 
Methodology for Calculating Dumping 
Margins ("Zeroing") EC 
WT/DS294/1 
and 
WT/DS294/1/ 
Add.1 12.06.03 
 
 
08.09.03 India 
WT/DS294/2  
Korea 
WT/DS294/3  
Japan 
WT/DS294/4  
Mexico 
WT/DS294/5  
and 
WT/DS294/6  05.02.04 
EC 
WT/DS294/7 19.03.04 
WT/DSB/M/166  
295. Mexico – Definitive Anti–Dumping Measures 
on Beef and Rice US 
WT/DS295/1 16.06.03  19.09.03 
US 
WT/DS295/2   
296. United States – Countervailing Duty 
Investigation on Dynamic Random Access 
Memory Semiconductors (DRAMS) from Korea Korea 
WT/DS296/1 
and 
WT/DS296/1/ 
Add.1 30.06.03 
 
 
18.08.03  19.11.03 
Korea 
WT/DS296/2 23.01.04 
WT/DSB/M/163  
297. Croatia – Measure Affecting Imports of Live 
Animals and Meat Products Hungary 
WT/DS297/1 09.07.03      
  WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1 
Page 48  
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
298. Mexico – Certain Pricing Measures for 
Customs Valuation and Other Purposes Guatemala 
WT/DS298/1 
Withdrawal of the 
request for 
consultations  
WT/DS298/2  
(29.08.05) 22.07.03     
299. European Communities – Countervailing 
Measures on Dynamic Random Access 
Memory Chips from Korea Korea 
WT/DS299/1 
and 
WT/DS299/1/ 
Rev.1/Add.1 25.07.03 
 
 
25.08.03  19.11.03 
Korea 
WT/DS299/2 23.01.04 
WT/DSB/M/163  
300. Dominican Republic – Measures Affecting the 
Importation of Cigarettes Honduras 
WT/DS300/1 28.08.03     
301. European Communities – Measures Affecting 
Trade in Commercial Vessels Korea 
WT/DS301/1 03.09.03 China 
WT/DS301/2 05.02.04 
Korea 
WT/DS301/3 19.03.04 
WT/DSB/M/163  
302. Dominican Republic – Measures Affecting the 
Importation and Internal Sale of Cigarettes Honduras 
WT/DS302/1 08.10.03 Guatemala 
WT/DS302/2 
Nicaragua 
WT/DS302/3 08.12.03 
Honduras 
WT/DS302/5 09.01.04 
WT/DSB/M/162  
303. Ecuador – Definitive Safeguard Measure on 
Imports of Medium Density Fibreboard Chile 
WT/DS303/1 24.11.03     
304. India – Anti–Dumping Measures on Imports 
of Certain Products from the European 
Communities EC 
WT/DS304/1 
and 
Corr.1 08.12.03 Turkey 
WT/DS304/2  
The Separate 
Customs 
Territory of 
Taiwan, Penghu, 
Kinmen and 
Matsu 
WT/DS304/3    
305. Egypt – Measures Affecting Imports of Textile 
and Apparel Products US 
WT/DS305/1 23.12.03 EC 
WT/DS305/2   20.05.05 
WT/DS305/4  
   WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1
 Page 49 
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
306. India – Anti–Dumping Measure on Batteries 
from Bangladesh Bangladesh 
WT/DS306/1 28.01.04 EC 
WT/DS306/2   20.02.06 
WT/DS306/3 
307. European Communities – Aid for Commercial 
Vessels Korea 
WT/DS307/1 13.02.04     
308. Mexico – Tax Measures on Soft Drinks and 
Other Beverages US 
WT/DS308/1 16.03.04 Canada 
WT/DS308/2 10.06.04 
US 
WT/DS308/4 06.07.04 
WT/DSB/M/172  
309. China – Value–Added Tax on Integrated 
Circuits US 
WT/DS309/1 18.03.04 EC 
WT/DS309/2  
Japan 
WT/DS309/3  
Mexico 
WT/DS309/4  
The Separate 
Customs 
Territory of 
Taiwan, Penghu, 
Kinmen and 
Matsu 
WT/DS309/5    05.10.05 
WT/DS309/8 
310. United States – Determination of the 
International Trade Commission in Hard Red 
Spring Wheat from Canada Canada 
WT/DS310/1 08.04.04  10.06.04 
Canada 
WT/DS310/2 
On 20.07.04 Canada 
requested the 
withdrawal of the 
panel request from the 
DSB agenda and 
reserved its rights to 
include that request at 
a future meeting 
(WT/DSB/M/173)   
311. United States – Reviews of Countervailing 
Duty on Softwood Lumber from Canada Canada 
WT/DS311/1 14.04.04    12.10.06 
WT/DS311/2  
  WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1 
Page 50  
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
312. Korea – Anti–Dumping Duties on Imports of 
Certain Paper from Indonesia Indonesia 
WT/DS312/1 04.06.04  16.08.04 
Indonesia 
WT/DS312/2 27.09.04 
WT/DSB/M/176  
313. European Communities – Anti–Dumping 
Duties on Certain Flat Rolled Iron or Non–Alloy Steel Products from India India 
WT/DS313/1 05.07.04    22.10.04 
WT/DS313/2 
314. Mexico – Provisional Countervailing 
Measures on Olive O il from the European 
Communities EC 
WT/DS314/1 18.08.04     
315. European Communities – Selected Customs 
Matters US 
WT/DS315/1 21.09.04 Australia 
WT/DS315/2  
Japan 
WT/DS315/3  
Brazil 
WT/DS315/4  
Argentina 
WT/DS315/5  
The Separate 
Customs 
Territory of 
Taiwan, Penghu, 
Kinmen and 
Matsu 
WT/DS315/6  
India 
WT/DS315/7 13.01.05 
US 
WT/DS315/8 21.03.05 
WT/DSB/M/186  
316. European Communities and Certain Member 
States – Measures Affecting Trade in Large Civil Aircraft US 
WT/DS316/1 
and 
WT/DS316/1/ 
Add.1 
 06.10.04 
  
31.01.06  31.05.05 
US 
WT/DS316/2 
11.04.06 
US 
WT/DS316/6 20.07.05 
WT/DSB/M/194 
 
09.05.06 
WT/DSB/M/211 
and Corr.1  
317. United States – Measures Affecting Trade in 
Large Civil Aircraft EC 
WT/DS317/1 
and 
WT/DS317/1/ 
Add.1 06.10.04 
 
 
27.06.05  31.05.05 
EC 
WT/DS317/2 
20.01.06 
EC 
WT/DS317/5 20.07.05 
WT/DSB/M/194 
 
17.02.06 
WT/DSB/M/205 
   
   WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1
 Page 51 
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
318. India – Anti-Dumping Measures on Certain 
Products from the Separate Customs Territory 
of Taiwan, Penghu, Kinmen and Matsu The Separate 
Customs Territory 
of Taiwan, Penghu, 
Kinmen and Matsu
WT/DS318/1 28.10.04     
319. United States – Section 776 of the Tariff Act 
of 1930 EC 
WT/DS319/1 05.11.04     
320. United States – Continued Suspension of 
Obligations in the EC – Hormones Dispute EC 
WT/DS320/1 08.11.04 Canada 
WT/DS320/2 
Australia 
WT/DS320/3 
Mexico 
WT/DS320/4 13.01.05 
EC 
WT/DS320/6 17.02.05 
WT/DSB/M/183  
321. Canada – Continued Suspension of 
Obligations in the EC – Hormones Dispute EC 
WT/DS321/1 08.11.04 Australia 
WT/DS321/2 
Mexico 
WT/DS321/3 
US 
WT/DS321/4 13.01.05 
EC 
WT/DS321/6 17.02.05 
WT/DSB/M/183  
322. United States – Measures Relating to Zeroing 
and Sunset Reviews Japan 
WT/DS322/1 24.11.04 India 
WT/DS322/2 
Norway 
WT/DS322/3 
Argentina 
WT/DS322/4 
The Separate 
Customs 
Territory of 
Taiwan, Penghu, 
Kinmen and 
Matsu 
WT/DS322/5 
EC 
WT/DS322/6 
Mexico 
WT/DS322/7 
 04.02.05 
Japan 
WT/DS322/8 28.02.05 
WT/DSB/M/185   
  WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1 
Page 52  
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
323. Japan – Import Quotas on Dried Laver and 
Seasoned Laver  Korea 
WT/DS323/1 01.12.04  04.02.05 
Korea 
WT/DS323/2 21.03.05 
WT/DSB/M/186 23.01.06 
WT/DS323/5 
324. United States – Provisional Anti-Dumping 
Measures on Shrimp from Thailand Thailand 
WT/DS324/1 09.12.04 Japan 
WT/DS324/2 
Brazil 
WT/DS324/3 
EC 
WT/DS324/4 
China 
WT/DS324/5 
India 
WT/DS324/6 
Ecuador 
WT/DS324/7     
325. United States – Anti-Dumping Determination 
Regarding Stainless Steel from Mexico Mexico 
WT/DS325/1 05.01.05 Japan 
WT/DS325/2 
EC 
WT/DS325/3    
326. European Communities – Definitive Safeguard 
Measures on Salmon Chile 
WT/DS326/1 
Withdrawal of the 
request for 
consultations 
WT/DS326/4  
(12.05.05) 08.02.05 Norway 
WT/DS326/2    
327. Egypt – Anti-Dumping Duties on Matches 
from Pakistan  Pakistan 
WT/DS327/1 21.02.05  09.06.05 
Pakistan 
WT/DS327/2 20.07.05 
WT/DSB/M/194  27.03.06 
WT/DS327/3 
328. European Communities – Definitive Safeguard 
Measure on Salmon Norway 
WT/DS328/1 01.03.05 Chile 
WT/DS328/2    
329. Panama – Tariff Classification of Certain Milk 
Products  Mexico 
WT/DS329/1 16.03.05    20.09.05 
WT/DS329/2 
330. Argentina – Countervailing Duties on Olive 
Oil, Wheat Gluten and Peaches EC 
WT/DS330/1 29.04.05      
   WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1
 Page 53 
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
331. Mexico – Anti-Dumping Duties on Steel Pipes 
and Tubes from Guatemala Guatemala 
WT/DS331/1 17.06.05  06.02.06 
Guatemala 
WT/DS331/2 17.03.06 
WT/DSB/M/207 
  
332. Brazil – Measures Affecting Imports of 
Retreaded Tyres EC 
WT/DS332/1 20.06.05 Argentina 
WT/DS332/2 17.11.05 
EC 
WT/DS332/4 20.01.06 
WT/DSB/M/203  
333. Dominican Republic – Foreign Exchange Fee 
Affecting Imports from Costa Rica  Costa Rica 
WT/DS333/1 12.09.05 Guatemala 
WT/DS333/2  
El Salvador 
WT/DS333/3     
334. Turkey – Measures Affecting the Importation 
of Rice  US 
WT/DS334/1 02.11.05 Australia 
WT/DS334/2 
Thailand 
WT/DS334/3 06.02.06 
US 
WT/DS334/4 17.03.06 
WT/DSB/M/207 
  
335. United States – Anti- Dumping Measure on 
Shrimp from Ecuador Ecuador 
WT/DS335/1 17.11.05 EC 
WT/DS335/2 
India 
WT/DS335/3 
Brazil 
WT/DS335/4 
Thailand 
WT/DS335/5 08.06.06 
Ecuador 
WT/DS335/6 19.07.06 
WT/DSB/M/217  
336. Japan – Countervailing Duties on Dynamic 
Random Access Memories from Korea Korea 
WT/DS336/1 14.03.06 US 
WT/DS336/2 
EC 
WT/DS336/3  18.05.06 
Korea 
WT/DS336/5  19.06.06 
WT/DSB/M/215  
337. European Communities – Anti-Dumping 
Measure on Farmed Salmon from Norway Norway 
WT/DS337/1 
and 
WT/DS337/1/ 
Add.1 
  
17.03.06 
 
27.03.06  29.05.06 
Norway 
WT/DS337/2 22.06.06 
WT/DSB/M/216  
338. Canada – Provisional Anti-Dumping and 
Countervailing Duties on Grain Corn from the United States US 
WT/DS338/1 17.03.06      
  WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1 
Page 54  
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
339. China – Measures Af fecting Imports of 
Automobile Parts EC 
WT/DS339/1 30.03.06 US 
WT/DS339/2 
Japan 
WT/DS339/3 
Australia 
WT/DS339/4 
Mexico 
WT/DS339/5 
Canada 
WT/DS339/6 15.09.06 
EC 
WT/DS339/8 
 26.10.06 
WT/DSB/M/221  
340. China – Measures Af fecting Imports of 
Automobile Parts US 
WT/DS340/1 30.03.06 Japan 
WT/DS340/2 
EC 
WT/DS340/3 
Australia 
WT/DS340/4 
Mexico 
WT/DS340/5 
Canada 
WT/DS340/6  15.09.06 
US 
WT/DS340/8 26.10.06 
WT/DSB/M/221   
341. Mexico – Definitive Countervailing Measures 
on Olive Oil from the European Communities EC 
WT/DS341/1 31.03.06     
342. China – Measures Af fecting Imports of 
Automobile Parts Canada 
WT/DS342/1 13.04.06 US 
WT/DS342/2 
Australia 
WT/DS342/3 
Japan 
WT/DS342/4 
EC 
WT/DS342/5 
Mexico 
WT/DS342/6  15.09.06 
Canada 
WT/DS342/8 26.10.06 
WT/DSB/M/221    
   WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1
 Page 55 
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
343. United States – Measures Relating to Shrimp 
from Thailand Thailand 
WT/DS343/1 
and Corr.2 24.04.06 India 
WT/DS343/2 
Japan 
WT/DS343/3 
Brazil 
WT/DS343/4 
China 
WT/DS343/5  15.09.06 
Thailand 
WT/DS343/7 
 
   
344. United States – Final Anti-Dumping Measures 
on Stainless Steel from Mexico Mexico 
WT/DS344/1 26.05.06 Japan 
WT/DS344/2  12.10.06 
Mexico 
WT/DS344/4 26.10.06 
WT/DSB/M/221   
345. United States – Custom s Bond Directive for 
Merchandise Subject to Anti-Dumping/ 
Countervailing Duties  India 
WT/DS345/1 06.06.06 Thailand 
WT/DS345/2 
China 
WT/DS345/3 
Brazil 
WT/DS345/4 13.10.06 
India 
WT/DS345/6   
346. United States – Anti-Dumping Administrative 
Review on Oil Country Tubular Goods from Argentina Argentina 
WT/DS346/1 20.06.06     
347. European Communities and Certain Member 
States – Measures Affecting Trade in Large 
Civil Aircraft (Second Complaint) US 
WT/DS347/1 31.01.06  11.04.06 
US 
WT/DS347/3 09.05.06 
WT/DSB/M/211  
and Corr. 1   
  WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1 
Page 56  
Dispute Request for  
Consultations Date of Receipt of 
the Request for 
Consultations Request to Join 
Consultations Request for 
Establishment of a 
Panel Panel Established Mutually Agreed 
Solution 
348. Colombia – Customs Measures on Importation 
of Certain Goods from Panama Panama  
WT/DS348/1 20.07.06 Guatemala 
WT/DS348/2 
China 
WT/DS348/3 
the Philippines  
WT/DS348/4  
Hong Kong, 
China  
WT/DS348/5 
Pakistan  
WT/DS348/6 
The Separate 
Customs 
Territory of 
Taiwan, Penghu, 
Kinmen and 
Matsu 
WT/DS348/7 
Thailand 
WT/DS348/8     
349. European Communities – Measures Affecting 
the Tariff Quota for Fresh or Chilled Garlic Argentina 
WT/DS349/1 06.09.06     
350. United States – Continued Existence and 
Application of Zeroing Methodology  EC  
WT/DS350/1 
and  
WT/DS350/1/ 
Add.1 02.10.06 
 
 
09.10.06 Japan 
WT/DS350/2 
Thailand 
WT/DS350/3 
Brazil 
WT/DS350/4 
India 
WT/DS350/5 
  
    
351. Chile – Provisional Safeguard Measure on 
Certain Milk Products Argentina 
WT/DS351/1 25.10.06     
  
   WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1
 Page 57 
SECTION II 
 
Panel and Appellate Body Reports  
Circulation and Adoption  
 
(1 January 1995 – 31 October 2006) 
 
Dispute Panel Established  
 Panel Report 
Circulated Notice of Appeal Panel Report 
Adopted Appellate Body 
Report Circulated Appellate Body 
Report Adopted 
1. United States – Standards for 
Reformulated and Conventional 
Gasoline 10.04.95 
Venezuela 
WT/DS2  
31.05.95 
Brazil 
WT/DS4 29.01.96 
WT/DS2/R  
 21.02.96 
US 
WT/DS2/6  
 20.05.96 
WT/DS2/9  
 
 29.04.96 
WT/DS2/AB/R  
 20.05.96 
WT/DS2/9  
 
2. Japan – Taxes on Alcoholic 
Beverages 
 
 27.09.95 
EC 
WT/DS8  
Canada 
WT/DS10  
US 
WT/DS11 11.07.96 
WT/DS8/R  
WT/DS10/R  
WT/DS11/R 08.08.96 
Japan 
WT/DS8/9  
WT/DS10/9  
WT/DS11/6 01.11.96  
WT/DS8/11  
WT/DS10/11  
WT/DS11/8 04.10.96 
WT/DS8/AB/R  
WT/DS10/AB/R  
WT/DS11/AB/R  
 01.11.96 
WT/DS8/11  
WT/DS10/11  
WT/DS11/8 
3. European Communities – Trade 
Description of Scallops 19.07.95 
Canada 
WT/DS7 05.08.96 
WT/DS7/R N.A. N.A. N.A. N.A. 
4. European Communities – Trade 
Description of Scallops 11.10.95 
Peru 
WT/DS12  
Chile 
WT/DS14 05.08.96 
WT/DS12/R  
WT/DS14/R N.A. N.A. N.A. N.A. 
5. Brazil – Measures Affecting 
Desiccated Coconut 05.03.96 
Philippines 
WT/DS22 17.10.96 
WT/DS22/R 16.12.96 
Philippines 
WT/DS22/8 20.03.97 
WT/DS22/11/ 
Rev.2 21.02.97 
WT/DS22/AB/R 20.03.97 
WT/DS22/11/  
Rev.2 
6. United States – Restrictions on 
Imports of Cotton and Man–
Made Fibre Underwear 05.03.96 
Costa Rica 
WT/DS24 08.11.96 
WT/DS24/R 11.11.96 
Costa Rica 
WT/DS24/5 25.02.97 
WT/DS24/8 10.02.97 
WT/DS24/AB/R 25.02.97 
WT/DS24/8 
7. United States – Measure 
Affecting Imports of Woven Wool Shirts and Blouses from 
India 17.04.96 
India 
WT/DS33 06.01.97 
WT/DS33/R 24.02.97 
India 
WT/DS33/3 23.05.97 
WT/DS33/5 25.04.97 
WT/DS33/AB/R  
and Corr.1 23.05.97 
WT/DS33/5  
  WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1 
Page 58 Dispute Panel Established  
 Panel Report 
Circulated Notice of Appeal Panel Report 
Adopted Appellate Body 
Report Circulated Appellate Body 
Report Adopted 
8. Canada – Certain Measures 
Concerning Periodicals 19.06.96 
US 
WT/DS31 14.03.97 
WT/DS31/R and 
Corr.1 29.04.97 
Canada 
WT/DS31/5 30.07.97 
WT/DS31/7 30.06.97 
WT/DS31/AB/R 30.07.97 
WT/DS31/7 
9. European Communities – 
Regime for the Importation, 
Sale and Distribution of Bananas 08.05.96 
Ecuador, Guatemala, 
Honduras, 
Mexico, 
US 
WT/DS27 22.05.97 
WT/DS27/R/ECU  
WT/DS27/R/GTM  
WT/DS27/R/HND  
WT/DS27/R/MEX  
WT/DS27/R/USA  
 11.06.97 
EC 
WT/DS27/9 25.09.97 
WT/DS27/12 09.09.97 
WT/DS27/AB/R 25.09.97 
WT/DS27/12 
10. European Communities – 
Measures  Concerning Meat and 
Meat Products (Hormones) 20.05.96 
US 
WT/DS26  
16.10.96 
Canada 
WT/DS48 18.08.97 
WT/DS26/R/USA  
WT/DS48/R/CAN 24.09.97 
EC 
WT/DS26/9 
WT/DS48/7 13.02.98 
WT/DS26/13  
WT/DS48/11 16.01.98 
WT/DS26/AB/R  
WT/DS48/AB/R 13.02.98 
WT/DS26/13  
WT/DS48/11 
11. India – Patent Protection for 
Pharmaceutical and Agricultural 
Chemical Products 20.11.96 
US 
WT/DS50 05.09.97 
WT/DS50/R 15.10.97 
India 
WT/DS50/6 16.01.98 
WT/DS50/9 19.12.97 
WT/DS50/AB/R 16.01.98 
WT/DS50/9 
12. Argentina – Measures Affecting 
Imports of Footwear, Textiles, 
Apparel and other Items 25.02.97 
US 
WT/DS56 25.11.97 
WT/DS56/R  
 21.01.98 
Argentina 
WT/DS56/8 22.04.98 
WT/DS56/11 27.03.98 
WT/DS56/AB/R 
20.04.98 
WT/DS56/AB/R/ 
Corr.1 22.04.98 
WT/DS56/11 
13. European Communities – 
Customs Classification of 
Certain Computer Equipment 25.02.97 
US 
WT/DS62  
30.03.97 
WT/DS67  
WT/DS68 05.02.98 
WT/DS62/R  
WT/DS67/R  
WT/DS68/R 24.03.98 
EC 
WT/DS62/8  
WT/DS67/6  
WT/DS68/5 22.06.98 
WT/DS62/11 
WT/DS64/9 WT/DS68/8 05.06.98 
WT/DS62/AB/R 
WT/DS67/AB/R WT/DS68/AB/R 22.06.98 
WT/DS62/11 
WT/DS67/9 
WT/DS68/10 
14. European Communities – 
Measures Affecting the 
Importation of Certain Poultry 
Products 30.07.97 
Brazil 
WT/DS69 12.03.98 
WT/DS69/R 29.04.98 
Brazil 
WT/DS69/4 23.07.98 
WT/DS69/7 13.07.98 
WT/DS69/AB/R 23.07.98 
WT/DS69/7 
15. Japan – Measures Affecting 
Consumer Photographic Film 
and Paper 16.10.96 
US 
WT/DS44 31.03.98 
WT/DS44/R N.A. 22.04.98 
WT/DS44/5 N.A. N.A.  
   WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1
 Page 59Dispute Panel Established  
 Panel Report 
Circulated Notice of Appeal Panel Report 
Adopted Appellate Body 
Report Circulated Appellate Body 
Report Adopted 
16. United States – Import 
Prohibition of Certain Shrimp and Shrimp Products 25.02.97 
Malaysia, Thailand, 
Pakistan 
10.04.97 
India 
WT/DS58 15.05.98 
WT/DS58/R 
09.11.98 
WT/DS58/R/ 
Corr. 1 13.07.98 
US 
WT/DS58/11 06.11.98 
WT/DS58/14 12.10.98 
WT/DS58/AB/R 06.11.98 
WT/DS58/14 
17. Australia – Measures Affecting 
Importation of Salmon 
 10.04.97 
Canada 
WT/DS18 12.06.98 
WT/DS18/R 
13.07.98 
WT/DS18/R/ 
Corr. 1 22.07.98 
Australia 
WT/DS18/5 06.11.98 
WT/DS18/11 20.10.98 
WT/DS18/AB/R 06.11.98 
WT/DS18/11 
18. Guatemala – Anti–Dumping 
Investigation Regarding Portland Cement from Mexico 20.09.97 
Mexico 
WT/DS60 19.06.98 
WT/DS60/R 04.08.98 
Guatemala 
WT/DS60/9 25.11.98 
WT/DS60/12 02.11.98 
WT/DS60/AB/R 25.11.98 
WT/DS60/12 
19. Indonesia – Certain Measures 
Affecting the Automotive 
Industry 12.06.98 
Japan 
WT/DS55 
WT/DS64 
EC 
WT/DS54 
30.06.97 
US 
WT/DS59 02.07.98 
WT/DS54/R 
WT/DS55/R WT/DS59/R 
WT/DS64/R 
and Corr.2 
 N.A. 23.07.98 
WT/DS54/10 
WT/DS55/10 
WT/DS59/9 
WT/DS64/8 N.A. N.A. 
20. India – Patent Protection for 
Pharmaceutical and Agricultural 
Chemical Products 16.10.97 
EC 
WT/DS79 24.08.98 
WT/DS79/R N.A. 22.09.98 
WT/DS79/5 
andCorr.1  N.A. N.A. 
21. Korea – Taxes on Alcoholic 
Beverages  16.10.97 
EC 
WT/DS75 
US 
WT/DS84 17.09.98 
WT/DS75/R 
WT/DS84/R 20.10.98 
Korea 
WT/DS75/9 
WT/DS84/7 17.02.99 
WT/DS75/12 
WT/DS84/10 18.01.99 
WT/DS75/AB/R 
WT/DS84/AB/R 17.02.99 
WT/DS75/12 
WT/DS84/10 
22. Japan – Measures Affecting 
Agricultural Products 18.11.97 
US 
WT/DS76 27.10.98 
WT/DS76/R 24.11.98 
Japan 
WT/DS76/5 19.03.99 
WT/DS76/8 22.02.99 
WT/DS76/AB/R 19.03.99 
WT/DS76/8 
23. United States – Anti–Dumping 
Duty on Dynamic Random 
Access Memory Semi–
Conductors (DRAMS) of one 
Megabit or above from Korea 16.01.98 
Korea 
WT/DS99 29.01.99 
WT/DS99/R N.A. 19.03.99 
WT/DS99/5 N.A. N.A.  
  WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1 
Page 60 Dispute Panel Established  
 Panel Report 
Circulated Notice of Appeal Panel Report 
Adopted Appellate Body 
Report Circulated Appellate Body 
Report Adopted 
24. India – Quantitative Restrictions 
on Imports of Agricultural, Textile and Industrial Products 18.11.97 
US 
WT/DS90 06.04.99 
WT/DS90/R 25.05.99 
India 
WT/DS90/11 22.09.99 
WT/DS90/14 23.08.99 
WT/DS90/AB/R 22.09.99 
WT/DS90/14 
25. Brazil – Export Financing 
Programme for Aircraft 23.07.98 
Canada 
WT/DS46 14.04.99 
WT/DS46/R 03.05.99 
Brazil 
WT/DS46/8 20.08.99 
WT/DS46/10 02.08.99 
WT/DS46/AB/R  20.08.99 
WT/DS46/10 
26. Canada – Measures Affecting 
the Export of Civilian Aircraft 23.07.98 
Brazil 
WT/DS70 14.04.99 
WT/DS70/R 03.05.99 
Canada 
WT/DS70/4 20.08.99 
WT/DS70/6 02.08.99 
WT/DS70/AB/R  20.08.99 
WT/DS70/6 
27. Canada – Measures Affecting 
the Importation of Milk and the Exportation of Dairy Products 25.03.98 
US 
WT/DS103 
New Zealand 
WT/DS113 17.05.99 
WT/DS103/R 
WT/DS113/R 15.07.99 
Canada 
WT/DS103/6 
WT/DS113/6 27.10.99 
WT/DS103/11 
WT/DS113/11  13.10.99 
WT/DS103/AB/R 
WT/DS113/AB/R 27.10.99 
WT/DS103/11 
WT/DS113/11  
28. Australia – Subsidies Provided 
to Producers and Exporters of 
Automotive Leather 22.06.98 
US 
WT/DS126 25.05.99 
WT/DS126/R N.A. 16.06.99 
WT/DS126/5 N.A. N.A. 
29. Turkey – Restrictions on 
Imports of Textile and Clothing 
Products 13.03.98 
India 
WT/DS34 31.05.99 
WT/DS34/R 26.07.99 
Turkey 
WT/DS34/6  19.11.99 
WT/DS34/11 22.10.99 
WT/DS34/AB/R 19.11.99 
WT/DS34/11 
30. Chile – Taxes on Alcoholic 
Beverages 
 18.11.97 
EC 
WT/DS87 
25.03.98 
EC 
WT/DS110 15.06.99 
WT/DS87/R 
WT/DS110/R 13.09.99 
Chile 
WT/DS87/8 
WT/DS110/7 12.01.00 
WT/DS87/12 
WT/DS110/11 13.12.99 
WT/DS87/AB/R 
WT/DS110/AB/R 12.01.00 
WT/DS87/12 
WT/DS110/11 
31. Korea – Definitive Safeguard 
Measure on Imports of Certain 
Dairy Products 22.07.98 
EC 
WT/DS98 21.06.99 
WT/DS98/R 15.09.99 
Korea 
WT/DS98/7 12.01.00 
WT/DS98/10 14.12.99 
WT/DS98/AB/R 12.01.00 
WT/DS98/10 
32. Argentina – Safeguard 
Measures on Imports of 
Footwear 23.07.98 
EC 
WT/DS121 25.06.99 
WT/DS121/R 15.09.99 
Argentina 
WT/DS121/6 and 
Corr.1 12.01.00 
WT/DS121/9 14.12.99 
WT/DS121/AB/R 12.01.00 
WT/DS121/9 
33. European Communities – 
Measures Affecting Butter 
Products 18.11.97 
New Zealand 
WT/DS72 24.11.99 
WT/DS72/R N.A. N.A. N.A. N.A. 
34. United States – Tax Treatment 
for "Foreign Sales 
Corporations" 22.09.98 
EC 
WT/DS108 08.10.99 
WT/DS108/R 26.11.99 
US 
WT/DS108/7 20.03.00 
WT/DS108/10 24.02.00 
WT/DS108/AB/R 20.03.00 
WT/DS108/10  
   WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1
 Page 61Dispute Panel Established  
 Panel Report 
Circulated Notice of Appeal Panel Report 
Adopted Appellate Body 
Report Circulated Appellate Body 
Report Adopted 
35. United States – Sections 301–
310 of the Trade Act of 1974 02.03.99 
EC 
WT/DS152 22.12.99 
WT/DS152/R N.A. 27.01.00 
WT/DS152/14 N.A. N.A. 
36. United States – Imposition of 
Countervailing Duties on 
Certain Hot–Rolled Lead and Bismuth Carbon Steel Products 
Originating in the UK 17.02.99 
EC 
WT/DS138 23.12.99 
WT/DS138/R 27.01.00 
US 
WT/DS138/5 07.06.00 
WT/DS138/9 
and Corr.1 10.05.00 
WT/DS138/AB/R 07.06.00 
WT/DS138/9 
and Corr.1 
37. Mexico – Anti–Dumping 
Investigation of High Fructose Corn Syrup (HFCS) from the 
US 25.11.98 
US 
WT/DS132 
and Corr.1 28.01.00 
WT/DS132/R N.A. 24.02.00 
WT/DS132/4 
and Corr.1 N.A. N.A. 
38. Canada – Certain Measures 
Affecting the Automotive Industry 01.02.99 
Japan 
WT/DS139  
01.02.99 
EC 
WT/DS142 11.02.00 
WT/DS139/R 
WT/DS142/R 02.03.00 
Canada 
WT/DS139/5 
WT/DS142/5 19.06.00 
WT/DS139/8 
WT/DS142/8  31.05.00 
WT/DS139/R 
WT/DS142/R 19.06.00 
WT/DS139/8 
WT/DS142/8  
39. Canada – Patent Protection of 
Pharmaceutical Products 04.02.99 
EC 
WT/DS114 17.03.00 
WT/DS114/R N.A. 07.04.00 
WT/DS114/9 N.A. N.A. 
40. United States – Anti–Dumping 
Act of 1916 01.02.99 
EC 
WT/DS136 31.03.00 
WT/DS136/R 
and Corr.1 29.05.00 
US 
WT/DS136/5 26.09.00 
WT/DS136/8  28.08.00 
WT/DS136/AB/R  26.09.00 
WT/DS136/8  
41. Korea – Measures Affecting 
Government Procurement 16.06.99 
US 
WT/DS163 01.05.00 
WT/DS163/R N.A. 19.06.00 
WT/DS163/7  N.A. N.A. 
42. Canada – Term of Patent 
Protection 22.09.99 
US 
WT/DS170 05.05.00 
WT/DS170/R 19.06.00 
Canada 
WT/DS170/4 12.10.00 
WT/DS170/7 18.09.00 
WT/DS170/AB/R  12.10.00 
WT/DS170/7 
43. United States – Anti–Dumping 
Act of 1916 26.07.99 
Japan 
WT/DS162 29.05.00 
WT/DS162/R 
and 
25.09.00 
Add.1 29.05.00 
US 
WT/DS162/6 26.09.00 
WT/DS162/11  28.08.00 
WT/DS162/AB/R  26.09.00 
WT/DS162/11  
44. United States – Section 110(5) 
of the US Copyright Act 26.05.99 
EC 
WT/DS160 15.06.00 
WT/DS160/R N.A. 27.07.00 
WT/DS160/8  N.A. N.A.  
  WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1 
Page 62 Dispute Panel Established  
 Panel Report 
Circulated Notice of Appeal Panel Report 
Adopted Appellate Body 
Report Circulated Appellate Body 
Report Adopted 
45. United States – Import 
Measures on Certain Products from the European 
Communities 16.06.99 
EC 
WT/DS165  17.07.00 
WT/DS165/R 
and  
Add.1 12.09.00 
EC 
WT/DS165/10  10.01.01 
WT/DS165/13 11.12.00 
WT/DS165/AB/R 10.01.01 
WT/DS165/13 
46. Korea – Measures Affecting 
Imports of Fresh, Chilled and Frozen Beef 26.05.99 
US 
WT/DS161 
26.07.99 
Australia 
WT/DS169  31.07.00 
WT/DS161/R 
WT/DS169/R  11.09.00 
Korea 
WT/DS161/8 
WT/DS169/8  10.01.01 
WT/DS161/11 
WT/DS169/11 11.12.00 
WT/DS161/AB/R 
WT/DS169/AB/R 10.01.01 
WT/DS161/11 
WT/DS169/11 
47. United States – Definitive 
Safeguard Measures on Imports 
of Wheat Gluten from the European Communities 26.07.99 
EC 
WT/DS166  
 31.07.00 
WT/DS166/R  26.09.00 
US 
WT/DS166/7 
 19.01.01 
WT/DS166/10 22.12.00 
WT/DS166/AB/R 19.01.01 
WT/DS166/10 
48. European Communities – 
Measures Affecting Asbestos 
and Asbestos–Containing Products 25.11.98 
Canada 
WT/DS135  18.09.00 
WT/DS135/R 
and  
Add.1  23.10.00 
Canada 
WT/DS135/8 05.04.01 
WT/DS135/12 12.03.01 
WT/DS135/AB/R 05.04.01 
WT/DS135/12 
49. Guatemala – Definitive Anti–
Dumping Measures on Grey Portland Cement from Mexico 22.09.99 
Mexico 
WT/DS156 24.10.00 
WT/DS156/R N.A. 17.11.00 
WT/DS156/4 N.A. N.A. 
50. United States – Anti–Dumping 
Measures on Stainless Steel 
Plate in Coils and Stainless Steel Sheet and Strip from 
Korea  19.11.99 
Korea 
WT/DS179 22.12.00 
WT/DS179/R N.A. 01.02.01 
WT/DS179/4 N.A. N.A. 
51. Argentina – Measures Affecting 
the Export of Bovine Hides and the Import of Finished Leather 26.07.99 
EC 
WT/DS155 19.12.00 
WT/DS155/R 
and Corr.1 N.A. 16.02.01 
WT/DS155/5 N.A. N.A. 
52. European Communities – Anti–
Dumping Duties on Imports of 
Cotton–Type Bed Linen from India 27.10.99 
India 
WT/DS141 30.10.00 
WT/DS141/R 01.12.00 
EC 
WT/DS141/6 12.03.01 
WT/DS141/9 01.03.01 
WT/DS141/AB/R 12.03.01 
WT/DS141/9 
53. Thailand – Anti–Dumping 
Duties on Angels, Shapes and 
Sections of Iron or Non–Alloy Steel and H–beams from Poland19.11.99 
Poland 
WT/DS122 28.09.00 
WT/DS122/R 23.10.00 
Thailand 
WT/DS122/4 05.04.01 
WT/DS122/7 12.03.01 
WT/DS122/AB/R 05.04.01 
WT/DS122/7  
   WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1
 Page 63Dispute Panel Established  
 Panel Report 
Circulated Notice of Appeal Panel Report 
Adopted Appellate Body 
Report Circulated Appellate Body 
Report Adopted 
54. United States – Safeguard 
Measures on Imports of Fresh Chilled or Frozen Lamb Meat 
from New Zealand and 
Australia 19.11.99 
New Zealand 
WT/DS177  
Australia 
WT/DS178 21.12.00 
WT/DS177/R 
WT/DS178/R 31.01.01 
US 
WT/DS177/7 
WT/DS178/8  16.05.01 
WT/DS177/10 
WT/DS178/11  01.05.01 
WT/DS177/AB/R 
WT/DS178/AB/R  16.05.01 
WT/DS177/10 
WT/DS178/11  
55. United States – Anti–Dumping 
Measures on Certain Hot–
Rolled Steel Products from 
Japan 
 20.03.00 
Japan 
WT/DS184 28.02.01 
WT/DS184/R 25.04.01 
US 
WT/DS184/5 23.08.01 
WT/DS184/8 24.07.01 
WT/DS184/AB/R 23.08.01 
WT/DS184/8 
56. United States – Transitional 
Safeguard Measure on Combed 
Cotton Yarn from Pakistan 19.06.00 
Pakistan 
WT/DS192 31.05.01 
WT/DS192/R 09.07.01 
US 
WT/DS192/4 05.11.01 
WT/DS192/7 08.10.01 
WT/DS192/AB/R 05.11.01 
WT/DS192/7 
57. United States – Measures 
Treating Exports Restraints as 
Subsidies 11.09.00 
Canada 
WT/DS194 29.06.01 
WT/DS194/R N.A. 23.08.01 
WT/DS194/4 N.A. N.A. 
58. United States – Section 211 
Omnibus Appropriations Act of 
1998 26.09.00 
EC 
WT/DS176 06.08.01 
WT/DS176/R 04.10.01 
EC 
WT/DS176/5 01.02.02 
WT/DS176/9 02.01.02 
WT/DS176/AB/R 01.02.02 
WT/DS176/9 
59. Argentina – Definitive 
Measures on Imports of Ceramic Floor Tiles from Italy 17.11.00 
EC 
WT/DS189 28.09.01 
WT/DS189/R N.A. 05.11.01 
WT/DS189/6 N.A. N.A. 
60. United States – Definitive 
Safeguard Measures on Imports 
of Circular Welded Carbon Quality Line Pipe from Korea 23.10.00 
Korea 
WT/DS202 29.10.01 
WT/DS202/R 19.11.01 
US 
WT/DS202/9 08.03.02 
WT/DS202/13 15.02.02 
WT/DS202/AB/R 08.03.02 
WT/DS202/13 
61. India – Measures Affecting the 
Automotive Sector 27.07.00 
US 
WT/DS175  
17.11.00 
EC 
WT/DS146 21.12.01 
WT/DS146/R and 
Corr.1 
WT/DS175/R and 
Corr.1  31.01.02 
India 
WT/DS146/8 
WT/DS175/8 05.04.02 
WT/DS146/11 
WT/DS175/11 19.03.02 
WT/DS146/AB/R 
WT/DS175/AB/R 05.04.02 
WT/DS146/11 
WT/DS175/11 
62. Canada – Export Credits and 
Loan Guarantees for Regional 
Aircraft 12.03.01 
Brazil 
WT/DS222 28.01.02 
WT/DS222/R and 
Corr.1 N.A. 19.02.02 
WT/DS222/6 N.A. N.A. 
63. Chile – Price Band System and 
Safeguard Measures Relating to Certain Agricultural Products 12.03.01 
Argentina 
WT/DS207 03.05.02 
WT/DS207/R 24.06.02 
Chile 
WT/DS207/5 23.10.02 
WT/DS207/8 23.09.02 
WT/DS207/AB/R 23.10.02 
WT/DS207/8 
64. European Communities – Trade 
Description of Sardines 24.07.01 
Peru 
WT/DS231 29.05.02 
WT/DS231/R and 
Corr.1 28.06.02 
EC 
WT/DS231/11 23.10.02 
WT/DS231/15 26.09.02 23.10.02 
WT/DS231/15  
  WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1 
Page 64 Dispute Panel Established  
 Panel Report 
Circulated Notice of Appeal Panel Report 
Adopted Appellate Body 
Report Circulated Appellate Body 
Report Adopted 
65. United States – Anti–Dumping 
and Countervailing Measures on Steel Plate from India 24.07.01 
WT/DS206 28.06.02 
WT/DS206/R and 
Corr.1 N.A. 29.07.02 
WT/DS206/5 N.A. N.A. 
66. United States – Countervailing 
Duties on Certain Corrosion–
Resistant Carbon Steel Flat Products from Germany 10.09.01 
EC 
WT/DS213 03.07.02 
WT/DS213/R and 
Corr.1 30.08.02 
US 
WT/DS213/6 19.12.02 
WT/DS213/9 28.11.02 
WT/DS213/AB/R 
and Corr.1 19.12.02 
WT/DS213/9 
67. United States – 
Section 129(C)(1) of the 
Uruguay Round Agreements Act 23.08.01 
Canada 
WT/DS221 15.07.02 
WT/DS221/R 
and Corr.1 N.A. 30.08.02 
WT/DS221/7 N.A. N.A. 
68. United States – Countervailing 
Measures Concerning Products 
from the European Communities 10.09.01 
EC 
WT/DS212 31.07.02 
WT/DS212/R 09.09.02 
US 
WT/DS212/7 08.01.03 
WT/DS212/11 09.12.02 
WT/DS212/AB/R 08.01.03 
WT/DS212/11 
69. Egypt – Definitive Anti–
Dumping Measures on Steel 
Rebar from Turkey 20.06.01 
Turkey 
WT/DS211 08.08.02 
WT/DS211/R N.A. 01.10.02 
WT/DS211/5 N.A. N.A. 
70. United States – Continued 
Dumping and Subsidy Offset 
Act of 2000 23.08.01 
Australia 
Brazil 
Chile 
EC 
India 
Indonesia 
Japan 
Korea 
Thailand 
WT/DS217  
10.09.01 
Canada 
Mexico 
WT/DS234 16.09.02 
WT/DS217/R 
WT/DS234/R 18.10.02 
US 
WT/DS217/8 
WT/DS234/16  27.01.03 
WT/DS217/11 
WT/DS234/19 
 16.01.03 27.01.03 
WT/DS217/11 
WT/DS234/19 
71. United States – Preliminary 
Determinations with Respect to 
Certain Softwood Lumber from 
Canada 05.12.01 
Canada 
WT/DS236 27.09.02 
WT/DS236/R N.A. 01.11.02 
WT/DS236/4 N.A. N.A. 
72. Argentina – Definitive 
Safeguard Measure on Imports 
of Preserved Peaches 18.01.02 
Chile 
WT/DS238 14.02.03 
WT/DS238/R N.A. 15.04.03 
WT/DS238/5  N.A. N.A.  
   WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1
 Page 65Dispute Panel Established  
 Panel Report 
Circulated Notice of Appeal Panel Report 
Adopted Appellate Body 
Report Circulated Appellate Body 
Report Adopted 
73. European Communities – Anti–
Dumping Duties on Malleable Cast Iron Tube or Pipe Fittings 
from Brazil 24.07.01 
Brazil 
WT/DS219 07.03.03 
WT/DS219/R 23.04.03 
Brazil 
WT/DS219/7 18.08.03 
WT/DS219/10 22.07.03 
WT/DS219/AB/R 18.08.03 
WT/DS219/10 
74. Argentina – Definitive Anti–
Dumping Duties on Poultry from Brazil 17.04.02 
Brazil 
WT/DS241 22.04.03 
WT/DS241/R N.A.  19.05.03 
WT/DS241/6  N.A. N.A. 
75. United States – Rules of Origin 
for Textiles and Apparel 
Products 24.06.02 
India 
WT/DS243 20.06.03 
WT/DS243/R 
and Corr.1 N.A. 21.07.03 
WT/DS243/8  N.A. N.A. 
76. United States – Definitive 
Safeguard Measures on Imports 
of Certain Steel Products 03.06.02 
EC 
WT/DS248  
14.06.02 
Japan 
WT/DS249  
14.06.02 
Korea 
WT/DS251  
24.06.02 
China 
WT/DS252  
24.06.02 
Switzerland 
WT/DS253  
24.06.02 
Norway 
WT/DS254  
08.07.02 
New Zealand 
WT/DS258  
29.07.02 
Brazil 
WT/DS259 11.07.03 
WT/DS248/R 
and Corr.1 
WT/DS249/R 
and Corr.1 
WT/DS251 
and Corr.1 WT/DS252 
and Corr.1 
WT/DS253 
and Corr.1 
WT/DS254 and Corr.1 
WT/DS254 
and Corr.1 WT/DS258 
and Corr.1 
WT/DS259 and Corr.1 11.08.03 
US 
WT/DS248/17 
WT/DS249/11 WT/DS251/12 
WT/DS252/10 
WT/DS253/10 WT/DS254/10 
WT/DS258/14 
WT/DS259/13  10.12.03 
WT/DS248/20 
WT/DS249/14 
WT/DS251/15 WT/DS252/13 
WT/DS253/13 
WT/DS254/13 WT/DS258/17 
WT/DS259/16  10.11.03 
WT/DS248/AB/R 
WT/DS249/AB/R 
WT/DS251/AB/R WT/DS252/AB/R 
WT/DS253/AB/R 
WT/DS254/AB/R WT/DS258/AB/R 
WT/DS259/AB/R 10.12.03 
WT/DS248/20 
WT/DS249/14 
WT/DS251/15 WT/DS252/13 
WT/DS253/13 
WT/DS254/13 WT/DS258/17 
WT/DS259/16  
77. Japan – Measures Affecting the 
Importation of Apples 03.06.02 
US 
WT/DS245 15.07.03 
WT/DS245/R 28.08.03 
Japan 
WT/DS245/5  10.12.03 
WT/DS245/8 26.11.03 
WT/DS245/AB/R 10.12.03 
WT/DS245/8  
78. United States – Sunset Review 
of Anti–Dumping Duties on 
Corrosion–Resistant Carbon 
Steel Flat Products from Japan 22.05.02 
Japan 
WT/DS244 14.08.03 
WT/DS244/R 15.09.03 
Japan 
WT/DS244/7  09.01.04 
WT/DS244/10 15.12.03 
WT/DS244/AB/R 09.01.04 
WT/DS244/10  
  WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1 
Page 66 Dispute Panel Established  
 Panel Report 
Circulated Notice of Appeal Panel Report 
Adopted Appellate Body 
Report Circulated Appellate Body 
Report Adopted 
79. United States – Final 
Countervailing Duty Determination with Respect to 
Certain Softwood Lumber from 
Canada 01.10.02 
Canada 
WT/DS257 29.08.03 
WT/DS257/R 
and Corr.1 21.10.03 
US 
WT/DS257/8  17.02.04 
WT/DS257/11  19.01.04 
WT/DS257/AB/R  17.02.04 
WT/DS257/11  
80. European Communities – 
Conditions for the Granting of 
Tariff Preferences to 
Developing Countries 27.01.03 
India 
WT/DS246 01.12.03 
WT/DS246/R  08.01.04 
EC 
WT/DS246/7 20.04.04 
WT/DS246/10 07.04.04 
WT/DS246/AB/R 20.04.04 
WT/DS246/10 
81. United States – Investigation of 
the International Trade 
Commission in Softwood 
Lumber from Canada 07.05.03 
Canada 
WT/DS277 22.03.04 
WT/DS277/R N.A. 26.04.04 
WT/DS277/5 N.A. N.A. 
82. Mexico – Measures Affecting 
Telecommunications Services 17.04.02 
United States 
WT/DS204 02.04.04 
WT/DS204/R N.A. 01.06.04 
WT/DS204/8 N.A. N.A. 
83. United States – Final Dumping 
Determination on Softwood 
Lumber from Canada 08.01.03 
Canada 
WT/DS264 13.04.04 
WT/DS264/R 13.05.04 
US 
WT/DS264/6 31.08.04 
WT/DS264/9 11.08.04 
WT/DS264/AB/R 31.08.04 
WT/DS264/9 
84. Canada – Measures Relating to 
Exports of Wheat and Treatment of Imported Grain 31.03.03 
United States 
WT/DS276 06.04.04 
WT/DS276/R 01.06.04 
US 
WT/DS276/15 27.09.04 
WT/DS276/18 30.08.04 
WT/DS276/AB/R 27.09.04 
WT/DS276/18 
85. United States – Sunset Reviews 
of Anti-Dumping Measures on 
Oil Country Tubular Goods from Argentina 19.05.03 
Argentina 
WT/DS268 16.07.04 
WT/DS268/R 31.08.04 
US 
WT/DS268/5 17.12.04 
WT/DS268/8 29.11.04 
WT/DS268/AB/R 17.12.04 
WT/DS268/8 
86. United States – Subsidies on 
Upland Cotton 18.03.03 
Brazil 
WT/DS267 08.09.04 
WT/DS267/R 
and Corr.1 18.10.04 
US 
WT/DS267/17 21.03.05 
WT/DS267/20 03.03.05 
WT/DS267/AB/R 21.03.05 
WT/DS267/20 
87. Korea – Measures Affecting 
Trade in Commercial Vessels 21.07.03 
EC 
WT/DS273 07.03.05 
WT/DS273/R N.A. 11.04.05 
WT/DS273/8 N.A. N.A. 
88. European Communities – 
Protection of Trademarks and Geographical Indications for 
Agricultural Products and 
Foodstuffs 02.10.03 
US 
WT/DS174  
Australia 
WT/DS290 15.03.05 
WT/DS174/R 
and Add.1, 2 & 3 
WT/DS290/R  
and Add.1, 2 & 3 N.A. 20.04.05 
WT/DS174/23 
WT/DS290/21 N.A. N.A. 
89. United States – Measures 
Affecting the Cross-Border 
Supply of Gambling and Betting Services 21.07.03 
Antigua & Barbuda 
WT/DS285 10.11.04 
WT/DS285/R 07.01.05 
US 
WT/DS285/6 20.04.05 
WT/DS285/10 07.04.05 
WT/DS285/AB/R 20.04.05 
WT/DS285/10  
   WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1
 Page 67Dispute Panel Established  
 Panel Report 
Circulated Notice of Appeal Panel Report 
Adopted Appellate Body 
Report Circulated Appellate Body 
Report Adopted 
90. European Communities – 
Export Subsidies on Sugar 29.08.03 
Australia 
WT/DS265 
Brazil 
WT/DS266 
Thailand 
WT/DS283 15.10.04 
WT/DS265/R 
WT/DS266/R 
WT/DS283/R 13.01.05 
EC 
WT/DS265/25 
WT/DS266/25 
WT/DS283/6  19.05.05 
WT/DS265/29 
WT/DS266/29 
WT/DS283/10  28.04.05 
WT/DS265/AB/R 
WT/DS266/AB/R 
WT/DS283/AB/R  19.05.05 
WT/DS265/29 
WT/DS266/29 
WT/DS283/10  
91. Dominican Republic – 
Measures Affecting the Importation and Internal Sale of 
Cigarettes 09.01.04 
Honduras 
WT/DS302 26.11.04 
WT/DS302/R 24.01.04 
Dominican Republic 
WT/DS302/8 19.05.05 
WT/DS302/12 25.04.05 
WT/DS302/AB/R 19.05.05 
WT/DS302/12 
92. European Communities – 
Measures Affecting Trade in Commercial Vessels 19.03.04 
Korea 
WT/DS301 22.04.05 
WT/DS301/R N.A. 20.06.05 
WT/DS301/6 N.A. N.A. 
93. United States – Countervailing 
Duty Investigation on Dynamic 
Random Access Memory Semiconductors (DRAMS) 
from Korea 19.11.03 
Korea 
WT/DS296 21.02.05 
WT/DS296/R 29.03.05 
US 
WT/DS296/5 20.07.05 
WT/DS296/10 27.06.05 
WT/DS296/AB/R 20.07.05 
WT/DS296/10  
94. European Communities – 
Countervailing Measures on 
Dynamic Random Access 
Memory Chips from Korea 23.01.04 
Korea 
WT/DS299  17.06.05 
WT/DS299/R N.A. 03.08.05 
WT/DS299/6 N.A. N.A. 
95. European Communities – 
Customs Classification of 
Frozen Boneless Chicken Cuts  07.11.03 
Brazil 
WT/DS269 
21.11.03 
Thailand 
WT/DS286 30.05.05 
WT/DS269/R  
WT/DS286/R 13.06.05 
EC 
WT/DS269/6 
WT/DS286/8 27.09.05 
WT/DS269/10  
WT/DS286/12  12.09.05 
WT/DS269/AB/R  
WT/DS286/AB/R  27.09.05 
WT/DS269/10  
WT/DS286/12  
96. Mexico – Definitive Anti-
Dumping Measures on Beef and Rice:  Complaint with respect to 
Rice  07.11.03 
United States 
WT/DS295 06.06.05 
WT/DS295/R 20.07.05 
Mexico 
WT/DS295/6 20.12.05 
WT/DS295/9  29.11.05 
WT/DS295/AB/R 20.12.05 
WT/DS295/9 
97. United States – Anti-Dumping 
Measures on Oil Country Tubular Goods (OCTG) from 
Mexico 29.08.03 
Mexico 
WT/DS282 20.06.05 
WT/DS282/R 04.08.05 
Mexico 
WT/DS282/6 28.11.05 
WT/DS282/10  02.11.05 
WT/DS282/AB/R  28.11.05 
WT/DS282/10  
98. Korea – Anti-Dumping Duties 
on Imports of Certain Paper 
from Indonesia 27.09.04 
Indonesia 
WT/DS312 28.10.05 
WT/DS312/R  N.A. 28.11.05 
WT/DS312/5  N.A. N.A.  
  WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1 
Page 68 Dispute Panel Established  
 Panel Report 
Circulated Notice of Appeal Panel Report 
Adopted Appellate Body 
Report Circulated Appellate Body 
Report Adopted 
99. Mexico – Tax Measures on Soft 
Drinks and other Beverages  06.07.04 
US 
WT/DS308 07.10.05 
WT/DS308/R  06.12.05 
Mexico 
WT/DS308/10 
 24.03.06 
WT/DS308/13  06.03.06 
WT/DS308/AB/R  24.03.06 
WT/DS308/13  
100. United States – Laws, 
Regulations and Methodology for Calculating Dumping 
Margins ("Zeroing") 
 19.03.04 
EC 
WT/DS294 31.10.05 
WT/DS294/R  17.01.06 
EC 
WT/DS294/12  09.05.06 
WT/DS294/17  18.04.06 
WT/DS294/AB/R  09.05.06 
WT/DS294/17  
101. Japan – Import Quotas on Dried  
Laver and Seasoned Laver 
 21.03.05 
Korea 
WT/DS323 
 01.02.06 
WT/DS323/R  N.A. N.A. N.A. N.A. 
102. European Communities – 
Selected Customs Matters 
 21.03.05 
US 
WT/DS315 
 16.06.06 
WT/DS315/R  14.08.06 
US 
WT/DS315/11     
103. United States – Measures 
Relating to Zeroing and Sunset 
Reviews 
 28.02.05 
Japan 
WT/DS322 20.09.06 
WT/DS322/R 11.10.06 
Japan 
WT/DS322/12     
104. European Communities – 
Measures Affecting the 
Approval and Marketing of Biotech Products 29.08.03 
US 
WT/DS291 
Canada 
WT/DS292 
Argentina 
WT/DS293 
 29/09.06 
WT/DS291/R 
WT/DS292/R WT/DS293/R 
 
 
      
   WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1
 Page 69SECTION III 
 
Implementation of DSB Recommendations  
 
(1 January 1995 – 31 October 2006) 
 
 
 
 
Dispute  
 
Adoption of 
Panel/Appellate Bod y 
Reports  
Notification of Intentions in respect 
of Implementation of DSB 
Recommendations  
(Within 30 days after the date of 
adoption of the panel/Appellate Body 
report )  
 
Date of Determination 
of Reasonable Period 
of Time   
Reasonable Period 
of Time pursuant to 
Article 21.3 of the 
DSU  
Surveillance of 
implementation by the  
DSB pursuant to 
Article 21.6 of the DSU 
1. United States – Standards 
for Reformulated and 
Conventional Gasoline 20.05.96 
WT/DS2/9 19.06.96 
WT/DSB/M/19 03.12.96 
WT/DSB/M/27 20.05.96 – 20.08.97 
(15 months) WT/DS2/10 and Add.1 to 
Add.7  
 
2. Japan – Taxes on Alcoholic 
Beverages 
 01.11.96 
WT/DS8/11  
WT/DS10/11  
WT/DS11/8 20.11.96 
WT/DSB/M/26 14.02.97 
WT/DS8/15  
WT/DS10/15  
WT/DS11/13 
(arbitration) 14.02.97 – 14.05.98 
(15 months) WT/DS8/18 
WT/DS10/18 
WT/DS11/16 
and Add.1 to Add.2  
3. United States – Restrictions 
on Imports of Cotton and Man–made Fibre 
Underwear 25.02.97 
WT/DS24/8 20.03.97 
WT/DSB/M/30 N.A. N.A. The measure expired on 
28.03.97 
WT/DSB/M/31 
4. Brazil – Measures Affecting 
Desiccated Coconut 20.03.97 
WT/DS22/11/Rev.2 N.A. N.A. N.A. N.A. 
5. United States – Measure 
Affecting Imports of Woven 
Wool Shirts and Blouses 
from India 23.05.97 
WT/DS33/5 N.A. N.A. N.A. The restraint rescinded on 
03.12.96 
WT/DSB/M/33 
6. Canada – Certain Measures 
Concerning Periodicals 30.07.97 
WT/DS31/7 29.08.97 
WT/DS31/8 15.09.97 
 30.07.97 – 30.10.98 
(15 months) WT/DS31/9 and Add.1 to 
Add.5 
7. European Communities – 
Regime for the Importation, 
Sale and Distribution of Bananas 
 25.09.97 
WT/DS27/12 16.10.97 
WT/DSB/M/38 07.01.98 
WT/DS27/15 
(arbitration) 25.09.97 – 01.01.99 
(15 months and 
1 week) WT/DS27/17 and Add.1 to 
Add.3 
 
WT/DS27/51 and Add.1 to 
Add.25 
8. India – Patent Protection for 
Pharmaceutical and 
Agricultural Chemical 
Products 16.01.98 
WT/DS50/9 13.02.98 
WT/DSB/M/42 21.04.98 
WT/DSB/M/45 16.01.98 – 19.04.99 
(15 months) WT/DS50/10 and Add.1 to 
Add.4  
  WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1 
Page 70  
 
 
Dispute  
 
Adoption of 
Panel/Appellate Bod y 
Reports  
Notification of Intentions in respect 
of Implementation of DSB 
Recommendations  
(Within 30 days after the date of 
adoption of the panel/Appellate Body 
report )  
 
Date of Determination 
of Reasonable Period 
of Time   
Reasonable Period 
of Time pursuant to 
Article 21.3 of the 
DSU  
Surveillance of 
implementation by the  
DSB pursuant to 
Article 21.6 of the DSU 
9. European Communities – 
Measures Concerning Meat 
and Meat Products (Hormones) 
 13.02.98 
WT/DS26/13 
WT/DS48/11 13.03.98 
WT/DSB/M/43 29.05.98 
WT/DS26/15 
WT/DS48/13 
(arbitration) 13.02.98 – 13.05.99 
(15 months) WT/DS26/17 
WT/DS48/15 
and Add.1 to Add.4 
10. Argentina – Measures 
Affecting Imports of Footwear, Textiles, Apparel 
and Other Items 22.04.98 
WT/DS56/11 08.05.98 
WT/DS56/12 15.06.98 
WT/DSB/M/46 22.04.98 – 19.10.98 
(180 days to conform specific duties on 
textiles and apparel to 
the findings) 
 
22.04.98 – 01.01.99 
(242 days to conform 
statistical tax to the 
findings)  WT/DS56/15 and Add.1 to 
Add.4 
11. Japan – Measures Affecting 
Consumer Photographic 
Film and Paper 22.04.98 
WT/DS44/5 
 N.A. N.A. N.A. N.A. 
12. European Communities – 
Customs Classification of Certain Computer 
Equipment 22.06.98 
WT/DS62/11 
WT/DS67/9 
WT/DS68/8 N.A.  N.A. N.A. N.A. 
13. European Communities – 
Measures Affecting Importation of Certain 
Poultry Products 23.07.98 
WT/DS69/7 27.08.98 
WT/DS69/8 20.10.98 
WT/DS69/9 Until 31.03.99 
  
14. Indonesia – Certain 
Measures Affecting the Automobile Industry 23.07.98 
WT/DS54/10 
WT/DS55/10 
WT/DS59/9 
WT/DS64/8 21.08.98 
WT/DS54/12 
WT/DS55/11 
WT/DS59/10 
WT/DS64/9 
 07.12.98 
WT/DS54/15 
WT/DS55/14 
WT/DS59/13 
WT/DS64/12 
(arbitration)  23.07.98 – 23.07.99 
(12 months)  WT/DS54/17 
WT/DS55/16 WT/DS59/15 
WT/DS64/14 
and Add.1 
 
15. India – Patent Protection for 
Pharmaceutical and 
Agricultural Chemical 
Products 22.09.98 
WT/DS79/5 and 
Corr.1 21.10.98 
WT/DSB/M/49 24.11.98 
WT/DSB/M/51 until 19.04.99 WT/DS79/6  
   WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1
 Page 71 
 
 
Dispute  
 
Adoption of 
Panel/Appellate Bod y 
Reports  
Notification of Intentions in respect 
of Implementation of DSB 
Recommendations  
(Within 30 days after the date of 
adoption of the panel/Appellate Body 
report )  
 
Date of Determination 
of Reasonable Period 
of Time   
Reasonable Period 
of Time pursuant to 
Article 21.3 of the 
DSU  
Surveillance of 
implementation by the  
DSB pursuant to 
Article 21.6 of the DSU 
16. United States – Import 
Prohibition of Certain 
Shrimp and Shrimp Products 06.11.98 
WT/DS58/14 
 
 25.11.98 
WT/DSB/M/51 21.01.99 
WT/DSB/M/54 06.11.98 – 06.12.99 
(13 months) WT/DS58/15 
17. Australia – Measures 
Affecting Importation of 
Salmon 06.11.98 
WT/DS18/11 25.11.98 
WT/DSB/M/51 23.02.99 
WT/DS18/9 
(arbitration) 06.11.98 – 06.07.99 
(8 months) (See Section IV) 
18. Guatemala – Anti–Dumping 
Investigation regarding 
Portland Cement from 
Mexico 25.11.98 
WT/DS60/12 N.A N.A N.A 
 N.A. 
19. Korea – Taxes on Alcoholic 
Beverages 17.02.99 
WT/DS75/12 
WT/DS84/10 
 19.03.99 
WT/DSB/M/57 04.06.99 
WT/DS75/16 
WT/DS84/14 
(arbitration) 17.02.99 – 
31.01.2000 
(11 months and  
2 weeks) 
 WT/DS75/18 
WT/DS84/16 
20. Japan – Measures Affecting 
Agricultural Products 19.03.99 
WT/DS76/8 15.04.99 
WT/DSB/M/58 15.06.99 
WT/DS76/9 19.03.99 – 31.12.99 
(9 months and  
12 days) WT/DS76/11 and Add.1 to 
Add.16 
Japan and the US notified the 
DSB that they reached a 
mutually satisfactory solution 
WT/DS76/12 
21. United States – Anti–
Dumping Duty on Dynamic 
Random Access Memory Semiconductors (DRAMS) 
of one Megabit or Above 
from Korea 19.03.99 
WT/DS99/5 15.04.99 
WT/DSB/M/58 19.05.99 
WT/DSB/M/65  19.03.99 – 19.11.99 
(8 months) WT/DS99/6 
22. Australia – Subsidies 
Provided to Producers and 
Exporters of Automotive 
Leather 16.06.99 
WT/DS126/5 06.07.99 
WT/DS126/6  In accordance with 
Article 4.7 of the 
SCM Agreement, the 
Panel recommended 
that the measures be 
withdrawn within a 
90–day period from 
the date of adoption 
of the report. WT/DS126/7 
 
(See Section IV)  
  WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1 
Page 72  
 
 
Dispute  
 
Adoption of 
Panel/Appellate Bod y 
Reports  
Notification of Intentions in respect 
of Implementation of DSB 
Recommendations  
(Within 30 days after the date of 
adoption of the panel/Appellate Body 
report )  
 
Date of Determination 
of Reasonable Period 
of Time   
Reasonable Period 
of Time pursuant to 
Article 21.3 of the 
DSU  
Surveillance of 
implementation by the  
DSB pursuant to 
Article 21.6 of the DSU 
23. Brazil – Export Financing 
Programme for Aircraft 20.08.99 
WT/DS46/10 13.09.99 
WT/DS46/11  In accordance with 
Article 4.7 of the 
SCM Agreement, the 
Panel recommended 
that the measures be 
withdrawn within a 
90–day period from 
the date of adoption 
of the report. WT/DS46/12 
 
(See Section IV) 
24. Canada – Measures 
Affecting the Export of 
Civilian Aircraft 20.08.99 
WT/DS70/6 06.09.99 
WT/DS70/1  In accordance with 
Article 4.7 of the 
SCM Agreement, the 
Panel recommended 
that the measures be 
withdrawn within a 
90–day period from 
the date of adoption 
of the report. WT/DS70/8 
 
(See Section IV) 
25. India – Quantitative 
Restrictions on Imports of 
Agricultural, Textile and 
Industrial Products 22.09.99 
WT/DS90/14 14.10.99 
WT/DSB/M/69 28.12.99 
WT/DS90/15 Until 01.04.00 and 
01.04.01 WT/DS90/16 and Add.1 to 
Add.7  
26. Canada – Measures 
Affecting the Importation of 
Milk and the Exportation of 
Dairy Products 27.10.99 
WT/DS103/11 
WT/DS113/11 19.11.99 
WT/DSB/M/71 22.12.99 
WT/DS103/10 
WT/DS113/10 The last stage of 
implementation no 
later than 31.12.00 WT/DS103/12 – WT/DS113/12 
and Add.1 to Add.6 
 
(See Section IV)  
27. Turkey – Restrictions on 
Imports of Textile and 
Clothing Products 19.11.99 
WT/DS34/11 15.12.99 
WT/DS34/9 07.01.00 
WT/DS34/10 19.02.01 WT/DS34/12 and Add.1 to 
Add.8 
Notification of mutually 
acceptable solution regarding 
implementation by Turkey 
WT/DS34/14 
28. Chile – Taxes on Alcoholic 
Beverages 12.01.00 
WT/DS87/12 
WT/DS110/11 11.02.00 
WT/DSB/M/75 23.05.00 
WT/DS87/15 
WT/DS110/4  
(arbitration) 12.01.00 – 21.03.01 
(14 months and 
9 days) WT/DS87/17 and Add.1 to 
Add.2  
   WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1
 Page 73 
 
 
Dispute  
 
Adoption of 
Panel/Appellate Bod y 
Reports  
Notification of Intentions in respect 
of Implementation of DSB 
Recommendations  
(Within 30 days after the date of 
adoption of the panel/Appellate Body 
report )  
 
Date of Determination 
of Reasonable Period 
of Time   
Reasonable Period 
of Time pursuant to 
Article 21.3 of the 
DSU  
Surveillance of 
implementation by the  
DSB pursuant to 
Article 21.6 of the DSU 
29. Korea – Definitive 
Safeguard Measure on 
Imports of Certain Dairy Products 12.01.00 
WT/DS98/10 11.02.00 
WT/DSB/M/75 21.03.00 
WT/DS98/11 Until 20.05.00 WT/DS98/12  
30. Argentina – Safeguard 
Measures on Imports of 
Footwear 12.01.00 
WT/DS121/9 11.02.00 
WT/DSB/M/75 N.A. N.A. N.A. 
31. United States – 
Sections 301–310 of the 
Trade Act of 1974 27.01.00 
WT/DS152/14 N.A. N.A. N.A. N.A. 
32. Mexico – Anti–Dumping 
Investigation of High Fructose Corn Syrup 
(HFCS) from the United 
States 24.02.00 
WT/DS132/4  
and Corr.1 20.03.00 
WT/DSB/M/77 10.04.00 
WT/DS132/5 24.02.00 – 22.09.00 
(6 months and 
29 days) (See Section IV) 
33. United States – Tax 
Treatment for "Foreign 
Sales Corporations" 20.03.00 
WT/DS108/10 07.04.00 
WT/DSB/M/78 20.03.00 
(adoption of the report)Until 01.10.00 
Subsequently the 
time–period was 
extended until  
1.11.00 (See Section IV) 
34. Canada – Patent Protection 
of Pharmaceutical Products 07.04.00 
WT/DS114/9 25.04.00 
WT/DSB/M/79  18.08.00 
WT/DS114/13  
(arbitration) Until 07.10.00 The relevant regulations were 
repealed on 07.10.00 
35. United States – Imposition 
of Countervailing Duties on 
Certain Hot–Rolled Lead and Bismuth Carbon Steel 
Products Originating in the 
United Kingdom 07.06.00 
WT/DS138/9 
and Corr.1 05.07.00 
WT/DSB/M/85 N.A. N.A. N.A. 
36. Canada – Certain Measures 
Affecting the Automotive 
Industry 19.06.00 
WT/DS139/8 
WT/DS142/8 27.07.00 
WT/DSB/M/86  04.10.00 
WT/DS139/12 
WT/DS142/12 
(arbitration) Until 19.02.01 The measures were repealed on 
18.02.01 
WT/DSB/M/101 
37. Korea – Measures Affecting 
Government Procurement 19.06.00 
WT/DS163/7 N.A. N.A. N.A. N.A.  
  WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1 
Page 74  
 
 
Dispute  
 
Adoption of 
Panel/Appellate Bod y 
Reports  
Notification of Intentions in respect 
of Implementation of DSB 
Recommendations  
(Within 30 days after the date of 
adoption of the panel/Appellate Body 
report )  
 
Date of Determination 
of Reasonable Period 
of Time   
Reasonable Period 
of Time pursuant to 
Article 21.3 of the 
DSU  
Surveillance of 
implementation by the  
DSB pursuant to 
Article 21.6 of the DSU 
38. United States – 
Section 110(5) of the US 
Copyright Act 27.07.00 
WT/DS160/8  24.08.00 
WT/DS160/9  15.01.01 
WT/DS160/12  
(arbitration) Until 27.07.01 
Subsequently the 
time–period was 
extended until  the 
end of the session of 
the US Congress or 
31.12.01 
(WT/DS160/14 ) WT/DS160/18 and Add.1 to 
Add.16 
 
(See Section IV) 
 
On 23.06.03 the parties 
concluded a mutually 
satisfactory temporary 
arrangement 
(WT/DS160/23) 
Subsequently status reports were 
resumed:  WT/DS160/24 and 
Add.1 to Add.22   
39. United States – Anti–
Dumping Act of 1916 26.09.00 
WT/DS136/8 
WT/DS162/11  23.10.00 
WT/DSB/M/91 28.02.01 
WT/DS136/11 
WT/DS162/14  
(arbitration) Until 26.07.01 
Subsequently the 
time–period was 
extended until the end 
of the session of the 
US Congress or 
31.12.01 
(WT/DS136/13 
WT/DS162/16 ) WT/DS136/14 
WT/DS162/17 
and Add.1 to Add.31 
 
(See Section IV) 
40. Canada – Term of Patent 
Protection 12.10.00 
WT/DS170/7  23.10.00 
WT/DSB/M/91  28.02.01 
WT/DS170/10  
(arbitration) Until 12.08.01 
 Canada announced that the 
implementation process was 
completed on 12.08.01 
WT/DSB/M/107  
41. Guatemala – Definitive 
Anti–Dumping Measures on 
Grey Portland Cement from Mexico 17.11.00 
WT/DS156/4 12.12.00 
WT/DSB/M/94 N.A. N.A. The definitive anti–dumping 
duties were repealed on 02.10.00 
WT/DSB/M/94 
42. Korea – Measures Affecting 
Imports of Fresh, Chilled 
and Frozen Beef 10.01.01 
WT/DS161/11 
WT/DS169/11 01.02.01 
WT/DSB/M/98 19.04.01 
WT/DS161/12 
WT/DS169/12 Until 10.09.01 Korea announced that the 
implementation process was 
completed on 10.09.01 
WT/DSB/M/110  
   WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1
 Page 75 
 
 
Dispute  
 
Adoption of 
Panel/Appellate Bod y 
Reports  
Notification of Intentions in respect 
of Implementation of DSB 
Recommendations  
(Within 30 days after the date of 
adoption of the panel/Appellate Body 
report )  
 
Date of Determination 
of Reasonable Period 
of Time   
Reasonable Period 
of Time pursuant to 
Article 21.3 of the 
DSU  
Surveillance of 
implementation by the  
DSB pursuant to 
Article 21.6 of the DSU 
43. United States – Definitive 
Safeguard Measures on 
Imports of Wheat Gluten from the EC 19.01.01 
WT/DS166/10 03.04.01 
WT/DSB/M/99 04.04.01 
WT/DS166/12 Until 02.06.01  
44. United States – Anti–
Dumping Measures on 
Stainless Steel Plate in Coils and Stainless Steel and Strip 
from Korea 01.02.01 
WT/DS179/4 01.03.01 
WT/DSB/M/100 26.04.01 
WT/DS179/5 Until 01.09.01 The United States announced 
that the implementation process 
was completed on 01.09.01 
WT/DSB/M/109 
45. Argentina – Measures 
Affecting the Export of Bovine Hides and the 
Import of Finished Leather 16.02.01 
WT/DS155/5 12.03.01 
WT/DSB/M/101 31.08.01 
WT/DS155/10  
(arbitration) Until 28.02.02 WT/DS155/12  
The DSB took note of the 
Agreement between the EC and 
Argentina concerning 
procedures under Articles 21 and 
22 of the DSU 
WT/DSB/M/121 
46. European Communities – 
Anti–Dumping Duties on 
Imports of Cotton Type–
Bed Linen from India 12.03.01 
WT/DS141/9 05.04.01 
WT/DSB/M/103 26.04.01 
WT/DS141/10 Until 14.08.01 See Section IV 
47. Thailand – Anti–Dumping 
Duties on Angels, Shapes 
and Sections of Iron or 
Non–Alloy Steel and H–Beams from Poland 05.04.01 
WT/DS122/7 26.04.01 
WT/DSB/M/104 25.05.01 
WT/DS122/8 Until 20.10.01 WT/DS122/9 
WT/DS122/11  
(The parties reached agreement 
that the item should no longer 
appear on the DSB's agenda) 
48. European Communities– 
Measures Affecting 
Asbestos and Asbestos–Containing Products 05.04.01 
WT/DS135/12 N.A. N.A. N.A. N.A. 
49. United States – Safeguard 
Measures on Imports of 
Fresh, Chilled or Frozen Lamb Meat from New 
Zealand and Australia 16.05.01 
WT/DS177/10 
WT/DS178/11 20.06.01 
WT/DS177/11 
WT/DS178/12 31.08.01 
Decision to end the 
measure by 15.11.01 
WT/DS177/12 
WT/DS178/13 Until 15.11.01 On 14.11.01 the United States 
announced that it completed the 
necessary legal steps to 
implement the 31 August 
decision 
WT/DSB/M/113  
  WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1 
Page 76  
 
 
Dispute  
 
Adoption of 
Panel/Appellate Bod y 
Reports  
Notification of Intentions in respect 
of Implementation of DSB 
Recommendations  
(Within 30 days after the date of 
adoption of the panel/Appellate Body 
report )  
 
Date of Determination 
of Reasonable Period 
of Time   
Reasonable Period 
of Time pursuant to 
Article 21.3 of the 
DSU  
Surveillance of 
implementation by the  
DSB pursuant to 
Article 21.6 of the DSU 
50. United States – Anti–
Dumping Measures on 
Certain Hot–Rolled Steel Products from Japan 23.08.01 
WT/DS184/8 10.09.01 
WT/DSB/M/109 19.02.02 
WT/DS184/13  
(arbitration) 23.08.01 – 23.11.02 
(15 months) 
Subsequently, the 
time–period was 
extended until 
31.12.03 
or on the date on 
which the session of 
the US Congress 
adjourns, whichever 
is earlier 
(WT/DS184/16 ) 
Subsequently, the 
time–period was 
modified so as to 
expire on 31.07.04 
(WT/DS184/17 ) 
Subsequently, the 
time–period was 
modified so as to 
expire on 31.07.05 
(WT/DS184/18 ) WT/DS184/15 and Add.1 to 
Add.47 
51. United States – Measures 
Treating Exports Restraints as Subsidies 23.08.01 
WT/DS194/4 N.A. N.A. N.A. N.A. 
52. United States – Transitional 
Safeguard Measure on 
Combed Cotton Yarn from Pakistan 05.11.01 
WT/DS192/7 21.11.01 
WT/DSB/M/113 N.A. N.A. The United States announced 
that the measure was removed 
on 9 November 2001 
WT/DSB/M/113 
53. Argentina – Definitive 
Anti–Dumping Measures on 
Imports of Ceramic Floor Tiles from Italy 05.11.01 
WT/DS189/6 05.12.01 
WT/DSB/M/114 18.12.01 
WT/DS189/7 05.11.01 – 05.04.02 
WT/DS189/7 WT/DS189/8  
   WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1
 Page 77 
 
 
Dispute  
 
Adoption of 
Panel/Appellate Bod y 
Reports  
Notification of Intentions in respect 
of Implementation of DSB 
Recommendations  
(Within 30 days after the date of 
adoption of the panel/Appellate Body 
report )  
 
Date of Determination 
of Reasonable Period 
of Time   
Reasonable Period 
of Time pursuant to 
Article 21.3 of the 
DSU  
Surveillance of 
implementation by the  
DSB pursuant to 
Article 21.6 of the DSU 
54. United States – Section 211 
Omnibus Appropriations 
Act of 1998 01.02.02 
WT/DS176/9 19.02.02 
WT/DSB/M/120 28.03.02 
WT/DS176/10 Until 31.12.02 or on 
the date on which the 
session of the US 
Congress adjourns, 
whichever is later, but 
no later than 
03.01.03. 
Subsequently the 
time–period was 
modified so as to 
expire on 30.06.03 
(WT/DS176/12 ) and 
again the time–period 
was modified so as to 
expire on 31.12.03 
(WT/DS176/13 ) 
Subsequently, the 
time–period was 
modified so as to 
expire on 31.12.04 
(WT/DS176/14 ) 
Subsequently the 
time-period was 
modified so as to 
expire on 30.06.05 
(WT/DS176/15) WT/DS176/11 and Add.1 to 
Add.47 
55. Canada – Export Credits 
and Loan Guarantees for 
Regional Aircraft 19.02.02 
WT/DS222/6 08.03.02 
WT/DSB/M/121  The Panel 
recommended that 
the measure be 
withdrawn within 
90 days from the date 
of the adoption of the 
Report (by 20.05.02)(See Section IV)  
  WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1 
Page 78  
 
 
Dispute  
 
Adoption of 
Panel/Appellate Bod y 
Reports  
Notification of Intentions in respect 
of Implementation of DSB 
Recommendations  
(Within 30 days after the date of 
adoption of the panel/Appellate Body 
report )  
 
Date of Determination 
of Reasonable Period 
of Time   
Reasonable Period 
of Time pursuant to 
Article 21.3 of the 
DSU  
Surveillance of 
implementation by the  
DSB pursuant to 
Article 21.6 of the DSU 
56. United States – Definitive 
Safeguard Measures on 
Imports of Circular Welded Carbon Quality Line Pipe 
from Korea 08.03.02 
WT/DS202/13 05.04.02 
WT/DSB/M/122 29.07.02 
WT/DS202/18 Until 01.09.02 At the DSB meeting on 
18.03.03, the US announced that 
the measure had been terminated 
on 01.03.03 
WT/DSB/M/145 
57. India – Measures Affecting 
the Automotive Sector 05.04.02 
WT/DS146/11  
WT/DS175/11 02.05.02 
WT/DS146/12 
WT/DS175/12 18.07.02 
WT/DS146/13 
WT/DS175/13 05.04.02 – 05.09.02 
(5 months) At the DSB meeting on 11.11.02 
India announced that it had 
complied with the DSB's 
recommendations 
WT/DSB/M/136 
58. United States – Anti–
Dumping and 
Countervailing Measures on 
Steel Plate from India 29.07.02 
WT/DS206/5 27.08.02 
WT/DS206/6 01.10.02 
WT/DS206/7 20.07.02 – 29.12.02 
(5 months) 
Subsequently, the 
time–period was 
modified so as to 
expire on 31.01.03 
(WT/DS206/8 ) At the DSB meeting on 19.02.03 
the United States announced that 
it had complied with the DSB's 
recommendations 
WT/DSB/M/143  
59. United States – 
Section 129(c)(1) of the 
Uruguay Round Agreements Act 30.08.02 
WT/DS221/7 N.A. N.A. N.A. N.A. 
60. Egypt – Definitive Anti–
Dumping Measures on Steel 
Rebar from Turkey 01.10.02 
WT/DS211/5 23.10.02 
WT/DSB/M/134 14.11.02 
WT/DS211/6 01.10.02 – 31.07.03 
(9 months) WT/DS211/7 and Add.1 to 
Add.3 
(At the DSB meeting on 
29.08.03, Egypt announced that 
it had complied with the DSB's 
recommendations)  
61. Chile – Price Band System 
and Safeguard Measures 
Relating to Certain 
Agricultural Products 23.10.02 
WT/DS207/8 11.11.02 
WT/DSB/M/136 17.03.03 
WT/DS207/13  
(arbitration) 23.10.02 – 23.12.03 
(14 months) WT/DS207/15 
and Add.7 
 
(See Section IV) 
62. European Communities – 
Trade Description of 
Sardines 23.10.02 
WT/DS231/15 11.11.02 
WT/DSB/M/136 19.12.02 
WT/DS231/16 23.10.02 – 23.04.03 
Subsequently the 
time–period was 
modified so as to 
expire on 01.07.03 
(WT/DS231/17 ) WT/DS231/18  
(mutually agreed solution)  
   WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1
 Page 79 
 
 
Dispute  
 
Adoption of 
Panel/Appellate Bod y 
Reports  
Notification of Intentions in respect 
of Implementation of DSB 
Recommendations  
(Within 30 days after the date of 
adoption of the panel/Appellate Body 
report )  
 
Date of Determination 
of Reasonable Period 
of Time   
Reasonable Period 
of Time pursuant to 
Article 21.3 of the 
DSU  
Surveillance of 
implementation by the  
DSB pursuant to 
Article 21.6 of the DSU 
63. United States – Preliminary 
Determinations with 
Respect to Certain Softwood Lumber from Canada 01.11.02 
WT/DS236/4 28.11.02 
WT/DSB/M/137 N.A. N.A. N.A. 
64. United States – 
Countervailing Duties on 
Certain Corrosion Resistant Carbon Steel Flat Products 
from Germany 19.12.02 
WT/DS213/9 17.01.03 
WT/DSB/M/141 N.A. N.A. At the DSB meeting on 
20.04.04, the United States 
announced that it had 
implemented the DSB's 
recommendations 
(WT/DSB/M/167) 
65. United States – 
Countervailing Measures 
Concerning Certain 
Products from the European 
Communities 08.01.03 
WT/DS212/11 27.01.03 
WT/DSB/M/142 10.04.03 
WT/DS212/12 08.01.03 – 08.11.03 
(10 months) WT/DS212/13 
WT/DS212/19 
(See Section IV)  
  WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1 
Page 80  
 
 
Dispute  
 
Adoption of 
Panel/Appellate Bod y 
Reports  
Notification of Intentions in respect 
of Implementation of DSB 
Recommendations  
(Within 30 days after the date of 
adoption of the panel/Appellate Body 
report )  
 
Date of Determination 
of Reasonable Period 
of Time   
Reasonable Period 
of Time pursuant to 
Article 21.3 of the 
DSU  
Surveillance of 
implementation by the  
DSB pursuant to 
Article 21.6 of the DSU 
66. United States – Continued 
Dumping and Subsidy 
Offset Act of 2000 27.01.03 
WT/DS217/11 
WT/DS234/19 27.01.03 
WT/DSB/M/142  
19.02.03 
WT/DSB/M/143 
26.02.03 
WT/DSB/M/144 13.06.03 
WT/DS217/14 
WT/DS234/22 
(arbitration) 27.01.03 – 27.12.03 
(11 months) 
 
In relation to the 
disputes with 
Australia, Indonesia 
and Thailand, the 
time–period for 
implementation was 
modified so as to 
expire on 27.12.04 
(WT/DS217/17, 18, 
19) 
Subsequently, the US 
reached separate 
procedural 
understandings on 
these matters with 
Australia 
(WT/DS217/44) , 
Thailand 
(WT/DS217/45)  
and Indonesia 
(WT/DS217/46)   WT/DS217/16 
WT/DS234/24 
and Add.1 to Add.24 
 
(See Section IV)  
67. Argentina – Definitive 
Safeguard Measure on 
Imports of Preserved Peaches 15.04.03 
WT/DS238/5 14.05.03 
WT/DS238/6 
19.05.03 
WT/DSB/M/150 30.05.03 
WT/DS238/7 Until 31.12.03 At the DSB meeting on 
23.01.04, Argentina announced 
that it had complied with the 
DSB's recommendations 
(WT/DSB/M/163) 
68. Argentina – Definitive 
Anti–Dumping Duties on Poultry from Brazil 19.05.03 
WT/DS241/6 N.A. N.A. N.A. N.A. 
69. United States – Rules of 
Origin for Textiles and 
Apparel Products 21.07.03 
WT/DS243/8 N.A. N.A. N.A. N.A.  
   WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1
 Page 81 
 
 
Dispute  
 
Adoption of 
Panel/Appellate Bod y 
Reports  
Notification of Intentions in respect 
of Implementation of DSB 
Recommendations  
(Within 30 days after the date of 
adoption of the panel/Appellate Body 
report )  
 
Date of Determination 
of Reasonable Period 
of Time   
Reasonable Period 
of Time pursuant to 
Article 21.3 of the 
DSU  
Surveillance of 
implementation by the  
DSB pursuant to 
Article 21.6 of the DSU 
70. European Communities – 
Anti–Dumping Duties on 
Malleable Cast Iron Tube or Pipe Fittings from Brazil 18.08.03 
WT/DS219/10 15.09.03 
WT/DS219/11 
02.10.03 
WT/DSB/M/156 01.10.03 
WT/DS219/12 18.08.03 – 19.03.04 
(7 months) On 17.03.04, the EC provided 
information regarding its 
compliance with the DSB's 
recommendations 
(WT/DS219/13) 
71. Japan – Measures Affecting 
the Importation of Apples 10.12.03 
WT/DS245/8 09.01.04 
WT/DSB/M/162 30.01.04 
WT/DS245/9 10.12.03 – 30.06.04 
(6 months and 
20 days) (See Section IV) 
72. United States – Definitive 
Safeguard Measures on 
Imports of Certain Steel Products 10.12.03 
WT/DS248/20 
WT/DS249/14 WT/DS251/15 
WT/DS252/13 
WT/DS253/13 
WT/DS254/13 
WT/DS258/17 WT/DS259/16 N.A. N.A. N.A. At the DSB meeting on 
10.12.03, the United States 
stated that on 04.12.03 the 
US President had issued a 
proclamation terminating all 
10 safeguard measures subject to 
these disputes 
(WT/DSB/M/160) 
73. United States – Sunset 
Review of Anti–Dumping 
Duties on Corrosion–Resistant Carbon Steel Flat 
Products from Japan 09.01.04 
WT/DS244/10 N.A. N.A. N.A. N.A. 
74. United States – Final 
Countervailing Duty Determination with Respect 
to Certain Softwood Lumber 
from Canada 17.02.04 
WT/DS257/11 05.03.04 
WT/DS257/12 28.04.04 
WT/DS257/13 17.02.04 – 17.12.04 
(10 months) WT/DS257/14 and Add.1 
 
(See Section IV) 
75. European Communities – 
Conditions for the Granting 
of Tariff Preferences to 
Developing Countries 20.04.04 
WT/DS246/10 19.05.04 
WT/DSB/M/169 20.09.04 
WT/DS246/14 
(arbitration) 20.04.04 – 01.07.05 
(14 months and 
11 days) WT/DS246/16 and Add.1 to 
Add.3 
76. United States – 
Investigation of the 
International Trade 
Commission in Softwood 
Lumber from Canada 26.04.04 
WT/DS277/R 19.05.04 
WT/DSB/M/169 01.10.04 
WT/DS277/7 26.04.04 – 26.01.05 
(9 months) At the DSB meeting on 
25.01.05,  the United States 
stated that it had implemented 
the DSB's recommendations in 
this dispute 
 (See Section IV)   
  WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1 
Page 82  
 
 
Dispute  
 
Adoption of 
Panel/Appellate Bod y 
Reports  
Notification of Intentions in respect 
of Implementation of DSB 
Recommendations  
(Within 30 days after the date of 
adoption of the panel/Appellate Body 
report )  
 
Date of Determination 
of Reasonable Period 
of Time   
Reasonable Period 
of Time pursuant to 
Article 21.3 of the 
DSU  
Surveillance of 
implementation by the  
DSB pursuant to 
Article 21.6 of the DSU 
77. Mexico – Measures 
Affecting 
Telecommunications Services 01.06.04 
WT/DS204/8 01.06.04 
WT/DS204/7 01.06.04 
WT/DS204/7 13 months from the 
date of adoption of 
Reports;  i.e. by end 
of July 2005 WT/DS204/9 and Add.1 to 
Add.8 
78. United States – Final 
Dumping Determination on 
Softwood Lumber from Canada 31.08.04 
WT/DS264/9 27.09.04 
WT/DSB/M/176 06.12.04 
WT/DS264/12 31.08.04 – 15.04.05 
Subsequently, the 
time-period was 
modified so as to 
expire on 02.05.05 
(WT/DS264/15) 
 At the DSB meeting on 
19.05.05, the United States 
stated that it had implemented 
the DSB's recommendations and 
rulings. 
WT/DSB/M/189) 
(See Section IV) 
79. Canada – Measures Relating 
to Exports of Wheat and 
Treatment of Imported 
Grain 27.09.04 
WT/DS276/18 18.10.04 
WT/DSB/M/177 15.11.04 
WT/DS276/19 27.09.04 – 01.08.05 
(10 months and 
5 days) WT/DS276/20 and  
Add.1 to Add.3 
80. United States – Sunset 
Reviews of Anti-Dumping Measures on Oil Country 
Tubular Goods from 
Argentina 17.12.04 
WT/DS268/8 14.01.05 
WT/DSB/M/181 07.06.05 
WT/DS268/12  
(arbitration) 17.12.04 – 17.12.05 
(12 months) 
 At the DSB meeting on 
20.12.05, the United States 
stated that it had implemented 
the DSB's recommendations and 
rulings. 
(See Section IV) 
81. United States – Subsidies on 
Upland Cotton 21.03.05 
WT/DS/267/20 20.04.05 
WT/DSB/M/188  In accordance with 
Article 4.7 of the 
SCM Agreement, the 
Panel recommended 
that the measure be 
withdrawn at the 
latest within six 
months of the date of 
adoption of the Panel 
Report by the DSB or 
1 July 2005 
(whichever is earlier)(See Section IV)  
   WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1
 Page 83 
 
 
Dispute  
 
Adoption of 
Panel/Appellate Bod y 
Reports  
Notification of Intentions in respect 
of Implementation of DSB 
Recommendations  
(Within 30 days after the date of 
adoption of the panel/Appellate Body 
report )  
 
Date of Determination 
of Reasonable Period 
of Time   
Reasonable Period 
of Time pursuant to 
Article 21.3 of the 
DSU  
Surveillance of 
implementation by the  
DSB pursuant to 
Article 21.6 of the DSU 
82. Korea – Measures Affecting 
Trade in Commercial 
Vessels 11.04.05 
WT/DS273/8   In accordance with 
Article 4.7 of the 
SCM Agreement, the 
Panel recommended 
that the measure be 
withdrawn within 90 
days from the date of 
adoption of the report 
83. European Communities – 
Protection of Trademarks and Geographical 
Indications for Agricultural 
Products and Foodstuffs  20.04.05 
WT/DS174/23 
WT/DS290/21 19.05.05 
WT/DSB/M/189 09.06.05 
WT/DS174/24 
WT/DS290/22  Time-period for 
implementation to 
expire on 03.04.06 
(11 months and 
2 weeks) WT/DS174/25 – WT/DS290/23 
and Add.1 to Add.3 
84. United States – Measures 
Affecting the Cross-Border 
Supply of Gambling and Betting Services 20.04.05 
WT/DS285/10 19.05.05 
WT/DSB/M/189 19.08.05 
WT/DS285/13  
(arbitration) 20.04.05 – 03.04.06 
(11 months and 
2 weeks) WT/DS285/15 and Add.1  
(See Section IV) 
85. European Communities – 
Export Subsidies on Sugar 19.05.05 
WT/DS265/29 
WT/DS266/29 WT/DS283/10 13.06.05 
WT/DSB/M/191 28.10.05 
WT/DS265/33 – 
WT/DS266/33 – 
WT/DS283/14 
(arbitration) 19.05.05 – 22.05.06 
(12 months and 
3 days) WT/DS265/35 –  
WT/DS266/35 – WT/DS283/16 
and Add.1 
86. Dominican Republic – 
Measures Affecting the Importation and Internal 
Sale of Cigarettes 19.05.05 
WT/DS302/12 13.06.05 
WT/DSB/M/191 16.08.05 
WT/DS302/17 24 months from 
19.05.05:  i.e. by 
19.05.07  
87. European Communities – 
Measures Affecting Trade in Commercial Vessels 20.06.05 
WT/DS301/6 20.07.05 
WT/DSB/M/194     
88. United States – 
Countervailing Duty 
Investigation on Dynamic Random Access Memory 
Semiconductors (DRAMS) 
from Korea 20.07.05 
WT/DS296/10 03.08.05 
WT/DSB/M/195  07.11.05 
WT/DS296/11 20.07.05 – 08.03.06 
(7 months and 
16 days) At the DSB meeting on 
14.03.06,  the United States 
stated that it had complied with 
the DSB's recommendations and 
rulings. 
(WT/DSB/M/206)  
  WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1 
Page 84  
 
 
Dispute  
 
Adoption of 
Panel/Appellate Bod y 
Reports  
Notification of Intentions in respect 
of Implementation of DSB 
Recommendations  
(Within 30 days after the date of 
adoption of the panel/Appellate Body 
report )  
 
Date of Determination 
of Reasonable Period 
of Time   
Reasonable Period 
of Time pursuant to 
Article 21.3 of the 
DSU  
Surveillance of 
implementation by the  
DSB pursuant to 
Article 21.6 of the DSU 
89. European Communities – 
Countervailing Measures on 
Dynamic Random Access Memory Chips from Korea  03.08.05 
WT/DS299/6 31.08.05 
WT/DSB/M/196 12.10.05 
WT/DS299/7 03.08.05 – 03.04.06 
(8 months) WT/DS299/8 
WT/DS299/9 
90. European Communities – 
Customs Classification of 
Frozen Boneless Chicken Cuts 27.09.05 
WT/DS269/10 
WT/DS286/12 18.10.05 
WT/DSB/M/199 20.02.06 
WT/DS269/13 –
WT/DS286/15 
(arbitration)  27.09.05 – 27.06.06 
(9 months) WT/DS269/15 – WT/DS286/17 
and Add.1 
91. United States – Anti-
Dumping Measures on Oil 
Country Tubular Goods (OCTG) from Mexico 28.11.05 
WT/DS282/10 20.12.05 
WT/DSB/M/202 15.02.06 
WT/DS282/11 28.11.05 – 28.05.06 
(6 months) (See Section IV) 
92. Korea – Anti-Dumping 
Duties on Imports of Certain 
Paper from Indonesia 28.11.05 
WT/DS312/5 20.12.05 
WT/DSB/M/202  10.02.06 
WT/DS312/6  28.11.05 – 28.07.06 
(8 months) (See Section IV) 
93. Mexico – Definitive Anti-
Dumping Measures on Beef 
and Rice:  Complaint with respect to Rice 20.12.05 
WT/DS295/9 19.01.06 
WT/DS295/10 18.05.06 
WT/DS295/12 20.12.05 – 20.08.06 
[8 months with 
respect to the 
recommendations in 
paras. 8.1 and 8.3 of 
the Panel Report and 
paras 350(b) and (c) 
of the AB Report] 
 
20.12.05 – 20.12.06 
[12 months with 
respect to the 
recommendations in 
para. 8.5 of the Panel 
Report & para. 350(d) 
of the AB Report]   
   WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1
 Page 85 
 
 
Dispute  
 
Adoption of 
Panel/Appellate Bod y 
Reports  
Notification of Intentions in respect 
of Implementation of DSB 
Recommendations  
(Within 30 days after the date of 
adoption of the panel/Appellate Body 
report )  
 
Date of Determination 
of Reasonable Period 
of Time   
Reasonable Period 
of Time pursuant to 
Article 21.3 of the 
DSU  
Surveillance of 
implementation by the  
DSB pursuant to 
Article 21.6 of the DSU 
94. Mexico – Tax Measures on 
Soft Drinks and Other 
Beverages 24.03.06 
WT/DS308/13  21.04.06 
WT/DSB/M/210 03.07.06 
WT/DS308/15 24.03.06 – 01.01.07 
(9 months & 8 days) 
 or 
If the Mexican 
Congress enacts 
legislation between 
1-31 December 2006 
repealing the 
measures 
24.03.06 – 31.01.07 
(10 months & 7 days) 
95. United States – Laws, 
Regulations and 
Methodology for 
Calculating Dumping Margins "Zeroing" 09.05.06 
WT/DS294/17 30.05.06 
WT/DSB/M/213 28.07.06 
WT/DS294/19 09.05.06 – 09.04.07 
(11 months)  
 
  
  WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1 
Page 86  
SECTION IV 
 
(i)  Recourse to Article 21.5 of the DSU  
 
(1 January 1995 – 31 October 2006) 
 
 
Dispute  
Recourse to  
Article 21.5 Referral to 
Original Panel 
by the DSB  
Panel Report  
Circulated  
Notice of Appeal  
Appellate Body 
Report Circulated Panel and/or  
Appellate Body 
Reports 
Adopted 
1. European Communities – Regime for 
the Importation, Sale and Distribution of Bananas 15.12.98 
EC 
WT/DS27/40 
18.12.98 
Ecuador 
WT/DS27/41 12.01.99 
WT/DSB/M/53 
EC, Ecuador 12.04.99 
WT/DS27/RW/ECU 
WT/DS27/RW/EEC 
and Corr.1  N.A. N.A. 06.05.99 
WT/DSB/M/61 
(WT/DS27/RW/ECU) 
2. Australia – Measures Affecting 
Importation of Salmon 
 28.07.99 
Canada 
WT/DS18/14 28.07.99 
WT/DSB/M/66  18.02.00 
WT/DS18/RW N.A.  N.A. 20.03.00 
WT/DSB/M/77 
3. Australia – Subsidies Provided to 
Producers and Exporters of 
Automotive Leather 04.10.99 
US 
WT/DS126/8 14.10.99 
WT/DSB/M/69 21.01.00 
WT/DS126/RW and 
Corr.1 N.A. N.A. 11.02.00 
WT/DSB/M/75 
4. Brazil – Export Financing Programme 
for Aircraft 26.11.99 
Canada 
WT/DS46/13 09.12.99 
WT/DSB/M/72 09.05.00 
WT/DS46/RW 22.05.00 
Brazil 
WT/DS46/17  21.07.00 
WT/DS46/AB/RW  04.08.00 
WT/DSB/M/87  
5. Canada – Measures Affecting the 
Export of Civilian Aircraft  23.11.99 
Brazil 
WT/DS70/9 09.12.99 
WT/DSB/M/72 09.05.00 
WT/DS70/RW 22.05.00 
Brazil 
WT/DS70/12  21.07.00 
WT/DS70/AB/RW  04.08.00 
WT/DSB/M/87  
6. United States – Anti–Dumping Duty 
on Dynamic Random Access Memory 
Semiconductors (DRAMS) of one megabit or above from Korea  07.04.00 
Korea 
WT/DS99/8 25.04.00 
WT/DSB/M/79 07.11.00 
WT/DS99/RW  
(mutually agreed 
solution) N.A. N.A. N.A. 
7. United States – Import Prohibition of 
Certain Shrimp and Shrimp Products  13.10.00 
Malaysia 
WT/DS58/17 23.10.00 
WT/DSB/M/91 15.06.01 
WT/DS58/RW 23.07.01 
Malaysia 
WT/DS58/20 22.10.01 
WT/DS58/AB/RW 21.11.01 
WT/DSB/M/113 
8. Mexico – Anti–dumping Investigation 
of High–Fructose Corn Syrup (HFCS) 
from the United States  13.10.00 
US 
WT/DS132/6 23.10.00 
WT/DSB/M/91 22.06.01 
WT/DS132/RW 24.07.01 
Mexico 
WT/DS132/10 22.10.01 
WT/DS132/AB/RW 21.11.01 
WT/DSB/M/113  
   WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1
 Page 87 
Dispute  
Recourse to  
Article 21.5 Referral to 
Original Panel 
by the DSB  
Panel Report  
Circulated  
Notice of Appeal  
Appellate Body 
Report Circulated Panel and/or  
Appellate Body 
Reports 
Adopted 
9. United States – Tax Treatment for 
"Foreign Sales Corporations"  07.12.00 
EC 
WT/DS108/16 20.12.00 
WT/DSB/M/95 20.08.01 
WT/DS108/RW 15.10.01 
US 
WT/DS108/21 14.01.02 
WT/DS108/AB/RW 29.01.02 
WT/DSB/M/118 
10. Brazil – Export Financing Programme 
for Aircraft:  Second Recourse by 
Canada to Article 21.5 of the DSU  19.01.01 
Canada 
WT/DS46/26 16.02.01 
WT/DSB/M/99 26.07.01 
WT/DS46/RW/2 N.A. N.A. 23.08.01 
WT/DSB/M/108 
11. Canada – Measures Affecting the 
Importation of Milk and the Exportation of Dairy Products  16.02.01 
US 
WT/DS103/16  
16.02.01 
New Zealand 
WT/DS113/16 01.03.01 
WT/DSB/M/100 11.07.01 
WT/DS103/RW 
WT/DS113/RW 04.09.01 
Canada 
WT/DS103/20 
WT/DS113/20 03.12.01 
WT/DS103/AB/RW 
WT/DS113/AB/RW 18.12.01 
WT/DSB/M/116 
12. Canada – Measures Affecting the 
Importation of Milk and the 
Exportation of Dairy Products:  Second Recourse to Article 21.5 of 
the DSU by New Zealand and the 
United States  06.12.01 
US 
WT/DS103/23  
06.12.01 
New Zealand 
WT/DS113/23 18.12.01 
WT/DSB/M/116 26.07.02 
WT/DS103/RW/2 
WT/DS113/RW/2 23.09.02 
Canada 
WT/DS103/28 
WT/DS113/28 20.12.02 
WT/DS103/AB/RW2 
WT/DS113/AB/RW2 17.01.03 
WT/DSB/M/141 
13. European Communities – Anti–
Dumping Duties on Imports of 
Cotton–Type Bed Linen from India  07.05.02 
India 
WT/DS141/13/ 
Rev.1 22.05.02 
WT/DSB/M/124 
and Corr.1 29.11.02 
WT/DS141/RW 08.01.03 
India 
WT/DS141/16 08.04.03 
WT/DS141/AB/RW 24.04.03 
WT/DSB/M/148 
14. United States – Countervailing 
Measures Concerning Certain 
Products form the European Communities 17.03.04 
EC 
WT/DS212/14 27.09.04 
WT/DS212/15 
WT/DSB/M/176 17.08.05 
WT/DS212/RW N.A. N.A. 27.09.05 
WT/DSB/M/198 
15. Chile – Price Band System and 
Safeguard Measures Relating to 
Certain Agricultural Products 19.05.04 
Argentina 
WT/DS207/17 20.01.06 
WT/DS207/18 
WT/DSB/M/203     
16. Japan – Measures Affecting the 
Importation of Apples 19.07.04 
US 
WT/DS245/11 30.07.04 
WT/DSB/M/174 23.06.05 
WT/DS245/RW N.A. N.A. 20.07.05 
WT/DSB/M/194 
17. United States – Final Countervailing 
Duty Determination with Respect to Certain Softwood Lumber from 
Canada 04.01.05 
Canada 
WT/DS257/15 14.01.05 
WT/DSB/M/181 01.08.05 
WT/DS257/RW 06.09.05 
US 
WT/DS257/22 05.12.05 
WT/DS257/AB/RW  20.12.05 
WT/DSB/M/202  
  WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1 
Page 88  
Dispute  
Recourse to  
Article 21.5 Referral to 
Original Panel 
by the DSB  
Panel Report  
Circulated  
Notice of Appeal  
Appellate Body 
Report Circulated Panel and/or  
Appellate Body 
Reports 
Adopted 
18. United States – Tax Treatment for 
"Foreign Sales Corporations":  
Second Recourse to Article 21.5 by the EC 14.01.05 
EC 
WT/DS108/29 
 
 17.02.05 
WT/DSB/M/183 30.09.05 
WT/DS108/RW2 14.11.05 
US 
WT/DS108/32 
 13.02.06 
WT/DS108/AB/RW2 
 14.03.06 
WT/DS108/36 
 
19. United States – Investigation of the 
International Trade Commission in Softwood Lumber from Canada 15.02.05 
Canada 
WT/DS277/8 
 25.02.05 
WT/DSB/M/184 15.11.05 
WT/DS277/RW  13.01.06 
Canada 
WT/DS277/16  13.04.06 
WT/DS277/AB/RW  09.05.06 
WT/DS277/19 
20. United States – Final Dumping 
Determination on Softwood Lumber from Canada 19.05.05 
Canada 
WT/DS264/16 
 01.06.05 
WT/DSB/M/190 03.04.06 
WT/DS264/RW  17.05.06 
Canada 
WT/DS264/25  15.08.06 
WT/DS264/AB/RW  01.09.06 
WT/DS264/28  
21. European Communities – Banana 
Import Regime and ACP-EC Partnership Agreement 30.11.05 
Honduras 
WT/DS27/62 
30.11.05 
Panama 
WT/DS27/63 
30.11.05 
Nicaragua 
WT/DS27/64 
      
22. United States – Sunset Reviews of 
Anti-Dumping Measures on Oil 
Country Tubular Goods from 
Argentina  26.01.06 
Argentina  
WT/DS268/15 
  17.03.06 
WT/DS268/16 
WT/DSB/M/207      
23. United States – Measures Affecting 
the Cross Border Supply of Gambling 
and Betting Services 08.06.06 
Antigua & 
Barbuda 
WT/DS285/17 
 19.07.06 
WT/DS285/18 
WT/DSB/M/217     
24. United States – Subsidies on Upland 
Cotton 18.08.06 
Brazil 
WT/DS267/30 
 28.09.06 
WT/DSB/M/220      
   WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1
 Page 89 
Dispute  
Recourse to  
Article 21.5 Referral to 
Original Panel 
by the DSB  
Panel Report  
Circulated  
Notice of Appeal  
Appellate Body 
Report Circulated Panel and/or  
Appellate Body 
Reports 
Adopted 
25. United States – Anti-Dumping 
Measures on Oil Country Tubular 
Goods (OCTG) from Mexico 21.08.06 
Mexico 
WT/DS282/13      
26. Korea – Anti-Dumping Duties on 
Imports of Certain Paper from 
Indonesia 26.10.06 
Indonesia 
WT/DS312/8      
  
  WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1 
Page 90 SECTION IV 
 
(ii)  Recourse to Article 22 of the DSU  
 
(1 January 1995 – 31 October  2006) 
 
 
 
 
Dispute 
  
Recourse to 
Article 22.2  
Request for Arbitration 
under 
Article 22.6  
Report 
of the 
Arbitrator Authorization 
by the DSB 
to Suspend 
Concessions 
1(a). European Communities – Regime for the 
Importation, Sale and Distribution of Bananas  14.01.99 
US 
WT/DS27/43 
 
 29.01.99 
EC 
WT/DS27/46 
 
 09.04.99 
WT/DS27/ARB Pursuant to the US request 
(WT/DS27/49)  
authorization was granted at 
the DSB meeting on 
19.04.99  
(WT/DSB/M/59)  
1(b). European Communities – Regime for the 
Importation, Sale and Distribution of Bananas  08.11.99 
Ecuador 
WT/DS27/52 
 19.11.99 
EC 
WT/DS27/53  24.03.00 
WT/DS27/ARB/ECU Pursuant to Ecuador's 
request  
(WT/DS27/54)  
authorization was granted at 
the DSB meeting on 
18.05.00  
(WT/DSB/M/80) 
2. European Communities – Measures Concerning Meat 
and Meat Products (Hormones)  17.05.99 
US 
WT/DS26/19 
20.05.99 
Canada 
WT/DS48/17 02.06.99 
EC 
WT/DS26/20 
WT/DS48/18 12.07.99 
WT/DS26/ARB 
WT/DS48/ARB  Pursuant to the US request 
(WT/DS26/21)  
and Canada's request 
(WT/DS48/19)  
authorization was granted at 
the DSB meeting on 
26.07.99  
(WT/DSB/M/65)  
3. Australia – Measures Affecting Importation of 
Salmon  15.07.99 
Canada 
WT/DS18/12 27.07.99 
Australia 
WT/DS18/13 
 N.A. N.A. 
4. Brazil – Export Financing Programme for Aircraft  
 10.05.00 
Canada 
WT/DS46/16 22.05.00 
Brazil 
WT/DS46/18 
 28.08.00 
WT/DS46/ARB  Pursuant to Canada's request 
(WT/DS46/25)  
authorization was granted at 
the DSB meeting on 
12.12.00 
(WT/DSB/M/94)  
   WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1
 Page 91 
 
Dispute 
  
Recourse to 
Article 22.2  
Request for Arbitration 
under 
Article 22.6  
Report 
of the 
Arbitrator Authorization 
by the DSB 
to Suspend 
Concessions 
5. United States – Tax Treatment for "Foreign Sales 
Corporations"  17.11.00 
EC 
WT/DS108/13 28.11.00 
US 
WT/DS108/17 30.08.02 
WT/DS108/ARB Pursuant to the EC's request 
(WT/DS108/26 ) 
authorization was granted at 
the DSB meeting on 
07.05.03 
(WT/DSB/M/149 ) 
6. Canada – Measures Affecting the Importation of Milk 
and the Exportation of Dairy Products  16.02.01 
US 
WT/DS103/17  
16.02.01 
New Zealand 
WT/DS113/17 28.02.01 
Canada 
WT/DS103/18 
WT/DS113/18   
7. United States – Anti–Dumping Act of 1916 07.01.02 
EC 
WT/DS136/15  
07.01.02 
Japan 
WT/DS162/18 17.01.02 
United States 
WT/DS136/16 
WT/DS162/19 24.02.04 
WT/DS136/ARB  
8. United States – Section 110(5) of the US Copyright 
Act  07.01.02 
EC 
WT/DS160/19 17.01.02 
United States 
WT/DS160/20   
9. Canada – Export Credits and Loan Guarantees for 
Regional Aircraft  23.05.02 
Brazil 
WT/DS222/7 and 
Corr.1 21.06.02 
Canada 
WT/DS222/8 17.02.03 
WT/DS222/ARB Pursuant to Brazil's request 
(WT/DS222/10 ) 
authorization was granted at 
the DSB meeting on 
18.03.03 
(WT/DSB/M/145)   
  WT/DSB/W/334/Add.1 
Page 92  
 
Dispute 
  
Recourse to 
Article 22.2  
Request for Arbitration 
under 
Article 22.6  
Report 
of the 
Arbitrator Authorization 
by the DSB 
to Suspend 
Concessions 
10. United States – Continued Dumping and Subsidy 
Offset Act of 2000  15.01.04 
Brazil 
WT/DS217/20  
Chile 
WT/DS217/21  
EC 
WT/DS217/22  
India 
WT/DS217/23  
Japan 
WT/DS217/24  
Korea 
WT/DS217/25  
Canada 
WT/DS234/25  
Mexico 
WT/DS234/26 
and Corr.1 23.01.04 
US 
WT/DS217/26 
WT/DS217/27 
WT/DS217/28 
WT/DS217/29 WT/DS217/30 
WT/DS217/31 
WT/DS234/27 WT/DS234/28 31.08.04 
WT/DS217/ARB/BRA 
WT/DS217/ARB/CHL 
WT/DS217/ARB/EEC 
WT/DS217/ARB/IND 
WT/DS217/ARB/JPN 
WT/DS217/ARB/KOR 
WT/DS234/ARB/CAN 
WT/DS234/ARB/MEX Pursuant to the requests by 
Brazil (WT/DS217/38) ; 
 the EC (WT/DS217/39) ; 
 India (WT/DS217/40) ; 
 Japan (WT/DS217/41) ; 
 Korea (WT/DS217/42) ; 
 Canada (WT/DS234/31) ; 
 Mexico (WT/DS234/32) , 
 authorization was granted at 
the DSB meeting on 
26.11.04 
(WT/DSB/M/178)  
 
Pursuant to the request by 
Chile (WT/DS217/43)  
authorization was granted at 
the DSB meeting on 
17.12.04 
(WT/DSB/M/180) 
11. Japan – Measures Affecting the Importation of 
Apples 19.07.04 
US 
WT/DS245/12 29.07.04 
Japan 
WT/DS245/13   
12. United States – Final Countervailing Duty 
Determination with Respect to Certain Softwood 
Lumber from Canada 04.01.05 
Canada 
WT/DS257/16 13.01.05 
US 
WT/DS257/17   
13. United States – Investigation of the International 
Trade Commission in Softwood Lumber from Canada 15.02.05 
Canada 
WT/DS277/9 23.02.05 
US 
WT/DS277/10   
14. United States – Final Dumping Determination on 
Softwood Lumber from Canada 19.05.05 
Canada 
WT/DS264/17 31.05.05 
US 
WT/DS264/19   
15. United States – Subsidies on Upland Cotton (I) 05.07.05 
Brazil 
WT/DS267/21 14.07.05 
US 
WT/DS267/23   
16. United States – Subsidies on Upland Cotton (II) 06.10.05 
Brazil 
WT/DS267/26  17.10.05 
US 
WT/DS267/27   
 
__________