WT/DS207/RW 
 Page I-1 
 
 
  ANNEX I 
 
LISTS OF EXHIBITS SUBMITTED BY THE PARTIES 
 
Contents Page 
Annex I-1  List of Exhibits submitted by Argentina I-2  
Annex I-2 List of Exhibits submitted by Chile I-5 
 WT/DS207/RW 
Page I-2  
 
  LIST OF EXHIBITS SUBMITTED BY ARGENTINA 
 
ARG-1 Law No.19.897 of the Ministry of Finance of the Republic of Chile 
ARG-2 Supreme Decree No.831 of the Ministry of Finance of the Republic of Chile 
ARG-3 Circular Letter No.292 of the National Customs Service of the Government of Chile
ARG-4 Daily bread wheat prices quoted for various Argentine ports. 
ARG-5 Exempt Decrees No. 691/2003, No. 77/200 4, No. 186/2004, No. 368/2004, No. 
485/2004;  No. 600/2004;  No. 762/2004;  No. 88/2005;  No. 278/05;  No. 466/2005;  No. 569/2005;  No. 706/2005;  No. 873/2005;  No.132/2006. 
ARG-6 History of application of the amended PBS, including No. of Exempt Decree, 
reference price, specific duties and rebates on ad valorem  tariff.  
ARG-7 Chart:  Relationship between the CIF price and the reference price during the period 
of application of the amended PBS 
ARG-8 Table:  Relationship between of the CIF price and the reference price during the 
period of application of the amended PBS 
ARG-9 Table:  Relationship between of the CIF price and the reference price from 1991 to 
2003 
ARG-10 Chart:  Relationship between the Chilean entry price under the amended PBS 
between March and May 2000 and the price that would have resulted if Chile had 
applied a minimum import price. 
ARG-11 Table:  The amended PBS does not ensure th at the price of wheat imports to Chile 
falls in tandem with world market prices. 
ARG-12 Chart:  The amended PBS does not ensure that the price of wheat imports to Chile 
falls in tandem with world market prices. 
ARG-13 Table:  The amended PBS does not ensure th at the price of wheat flour imports to 
Chile falls in tandem with world market prices. 
ARG-14 Chart:  The amended PBS does not ensure that the  price of wheat flour imports to 
Chile falls in tandem with world market prices. 
ARG-15 Chart:  Disconnection between the FOB price of Trigo Pan Argentino  and the 
reference price established by Chile duri ng the period of operation of the amended 
PBS. 
ARG-16 Table:  Disconnection between the FOB price of Trigo Pan Argentino  and the 
reference price established by Chile duri ng the period of operation of the amended 
PBS. 
ARG-17 Chart:  Disconnection between the FOB price of Soft Red Winter No. 2 wheat and 
the reference price established by Chile  during the period of operation of the 
amended PBS. 
ARG-18 Table:  Disconnection between the FOB price of Soft Red Winter No. 2 wheat and 
the reference price established by Chile  during the period of operation of the 
amended PBS. 
ARG-19 Chart:  Disconnection between the FOB pr ice of Argentine wheat flour and the 
reference price established by Chile duri ng the period of operation of the amended 
PBS.  WT/DS207/RW 
 Page I-3 
 
 
  ARG-20 Table:  Disconnection between the FOB pr ice of Argentine wheat flour and the 
reference price established by Chile duri ng the period of operation of the amended 
PBS. 
ARG-21 Table:  Amount of specific duties that would have resulted if the present amended 
PBS had operated with the average prices  recorded between 1986 and the present on 
the markets of concern for Chile.  
ARG-22 Chart:  Amount of specific duties that would have resulted if the present amended 
PBS had operated with the average prices  recorded between 1986 and the present on 
the markets of concern for Chile. 
ARG-23 Table:  The amended PBS contains a fo rmula that causes import duties to vary 
automatically. 
ARG-24 Chart:  The amended PBS contains a formula that causes import duties to vary 
automatically. 
ARG-25 Table:  Relationship between the FOB and CIF prices for bread wheat, Argentine 
port, transported by sea. 
ARG-26 Actual cases of wheat flour exports from Ar gentina to Chile, transported by land. 
ARG-27 Percentage variation of the FOB price for bread wheat and Soft Red Winter No. 2 
Wheat from July 1986 to March 2006 
ARG-28 Table:  Volumes and CIF prices of Chilean monthly wheat flour imports since 1991 
ARG-29 Table:  Relationship between the FOB price of Trigo Pan Argentino  and that of 
wheat flour during the period of application of the amended PBS 
  
EXHIBIT ARG-30 
 
Details of exhibits in which Argentina has made a time adjustment 
 
Exhibit Time adjustment (YES/NO) 
ARG-7 NO 
ARG-8 NO 
ARG-9 NO 
ARG-10 NO 
ARG-11 YES, on the basis of footnote 104 to Table I of the Argentine submission 
ARG-12 YES, on the basis of footnote 104 to Table I of the Argentine submission 
ARG-13 YES, on the basis of footnote 108 to Table III of the Argentine submission 
ARG-14 YES, on the basis of footnote 108 to Table III of the Argentine submission 
ARG-15 NO 
ARG-16 NO 
ARG-17 NO 
ARG-18 NO 
ARG-19 NO 
ARG-20 NO WT/DS207/RW 
Page I-4  
 
  ARG-21 NO 
ARG-22 NO 
ARG-23 YES, on the basis of footnote 104 to Table I of the Argentine submission 
ARG-24 YES, on the basis of footnote 104 to Table I of the Argentine submission 
ARG-25 NO 
ARG-26 NO 
ARG-27 NO 
ARG-28 NO 
ARG-29 NO 
 
 
ARG-31 Table:  ODEPA's record of wheat imports by origin (2004-2005) 
ARG-32 Table:  SAGPyA's official FOB prices (July 2006) 
ARG-33 Table:  ODEPA's price record of different wheat qualities since 1991 
ARG-34 Imports to Chile of differe nt qualities of wheat (2004-2005) 
ARG-35 Insulation from international price de velopments:  specific duties rise while 
international prices fall (graph) 
ARG-36 Insulation from international price de velopments:  specific duties rise while 
international prices fall (chart) 
ARG-37 Answer to question 22:  Extracts of the document "Historia de la Ley.  Compilación 
de textos oficiales del debate  parlamentario" to which Ar gentina refers in its first 
written submission 
ARG-38 Table:  Reference price variation since the amended PBS is in force 
(December 2003-August 2006) 
  WT/DS207/RW 
 Page I-5 
 
 
  LIST OF EXHIBITS SUBMITTED BY CHILE  
 
CHL-1 Law No. 19.897, published in the Official Journal on 25 September 2003 
CHL-2 Supreme Decree No. 831 of the Chilean Ministry of Finance approving the 
implementing regulations for Article 12 of Law No. 18.525, as replaced by 
Article 1 of Law No. 19.897 
CHL-3 Article 63.17 of the Constitution of the Republic of Chile 
CHL-4 Article 65 of the Constitution of the Republic of Chile 
CHL-5 Law No. 19.193, published in the Official Journal on 16 January 1993 
CHL-6 Law No. 19.446, published in the O fficial Journal on 8 February 1996 
CHL-7 Simulation of the operation of the PBS (by number of weeks) 
CHL-8 Law 19.589 providing for a rebate on the ta riff rate and introduc ing amendments to 
other fiscal and economic legislation.  Published in the Official Journal on 
14 November 1998 
CHL-9 Table of wholesale prices for wheat and wheat flour 
CHL-10 Graph of wholesale prices for wheat and wheat flour 
CHL-11 Graph showing the relation between the price of wheat flour and the price of wheat
CHL-12 Table:   "Monthly prices" of wheat from the website of Argentina's Agriculture, 
Livestock, Fish and Food Secretary. 
CHL-13 Table:  Wheat imports of Chile in 2002 and 2003 (ODEPA) 
CHL-14 Table of external prices " Trigo Pan " FOB Argentine ports; and 
Table of official prices " Trigo Pan " – monthly averages.  Both from the website of 
Argentina's Agriculture, Livestoc k, Fish and Food Secretary. 
CHL-15 Copy of "Historia de la Ley.  Comp ilación de textos of iciales del debate 
parliamenario" 
CHL-16 Chart and Table:  Wheat:  Chilean wholesale market, Argentine Trigo Pan  f.o.b., 
soft red winter No. 2 and entry prices.  16 December 2003 to 15 December 2005. 
CHL-17 Daily official prices of " Trigo Pan  f.o.b. Argentine ports", by SAGPyA 
(July 2006) 
CHL-18 Tables:  Imports to Chile of wheat and wheat flour (2004 and 2005) (ODEPA).  
Imports according to country of origin  (ODEPA).  Monthly imports (ODEPA) 
(2004 and 2005).  Quarterly imports (2004 and 2005). 
  
__________