EN   EN 
 
 
 EUROPEAN  
COMMISSION   
Brussels, XXX   
SANTE/11027906/2023 ANNEX CIS 
(POOL/G5/2023/11027906/11027906 -
EN ANNEX CIS.docx)  
[…](2024) XXX  draft  
ANNEX  
 
ANNEX  
to the  
Commission Implementing Regulation (EU)  
withdrawing from the market certain feed additives    
EN 1  EN ANNEX  
Feed additives to be withdrawn from the market, as referred to in Article 1  
 
PART 1  
Feed additives to be withdrawn from the market for all animal species and categories  
 
Identification 
number  Additive  Animal species 
or category  
Flavouring and appetising substances  
Natural products – botanically defined  
 Citrus sinensis  (L.) Osbeck = Citrus sinensis  (L.) Pers.  = 
Citrus aurantium  L. var. dulcis : Folded orange oil CAS 
8028 -48-6 FEMA 2822, other than  the following forms1: 
- characterised by a non -volatile fraction of 10.5%, a 
d-Limonene content of 89 -96% in the volatile 
fraction a nd a perillaldehyde content < 0.3% in the 
volatile fraction [2b143 -f]; 
- characterised by a non -volatile fraction of 20.9%, a 
d-Limonene content of 79 -89% in the volatile 
fraction and a perillaldehyde content < 0.6% in the 
volatile fraction [2b143 -f-i]; 
- characterised by a non -volatile fraction of 18%, a 
d-Limonene content of 85 -95% in the volatile 
fraction and absence of perillaldehyde in the 
volatile fraction [2b143 -f-ii]. All species  
 Echinacea angustifolia  DC.: Blacksamson  echinacea 
tincture  All species  
 Hypericum perforatum  L.: St. John’s wort tincture CoE 
234 All species  
 Linum usitatissimum  L.: Linseed tincture CoE 263  All species  
 Thymus mastichina L.: Spanish marjoram oil CAS 8016 -
33-9 EINECS 284 -294-8 All species  
 
 
1 Three forms of folded orange oil [2b143 -f, 2b143 -f-i and 2b143 -f-ii] have been authorised by Commission 
Implementing Regulation (EU) 2022/1421 of 22 August 2022 concerning the authorisation of expressed orange 
essential oil, distilled orange essential oil and folded orange oils from Citrus sinensis  (L.) Osbeck as feed 
additives for certain animal species (OJ L 218, 23.8.2022, p. 27), ELI: 
http://data.europa.eu/eli/reg_impl/2022/1421/oj . 
  
EN 2  EN  
PART 2  
Feed additives to be withdrawn from the market for certain animal species and 
categories  
 
Identification 
number  Additive  Animal species 
or category  
Preservatives  
E 270  Lactic acid  Ruminants with 
a non -
functional 
rumen  
E 295  Ammonium formate  Laying hens, 
sows, dairy 
ruminants, pet 
and non -food 
producing 
animals  
E 327  Calcium lactate  Ruminants with 
a non -
functional 
rumen  
Colourants, including pigments  
Other colourants  
E 127  Erythrosine  
[functional group 2 a (i)]  Ornamental 
fish and reptiles  
Flavouring and appetising substances  
Natural products – botanically defined  
 Anethum graveolens L.: Dill herb essential oil CAS 8006 -
75-5 FEMA 2383 CoE 42 EINECS 289 -790-8 All animal 
species with the 
exception of  
dogs and cats  
 Angelica sinensis  (Oliv.) Diels: Dong quai tincture  All animal 
species with the 
exception of 
horses, dogs 
and cats   
EN 3  EN  Boswellia serrata Roxb. ex Colebr.: Olibanum extract  
 All animal 
species with the 
exception of 
horses and dogs  
 Citrus aurantiifolia  (Christm.) Swingle: Distilled lime 
essential oil  Dogs, cats, 
ornamental fish 
and ornamental 
birds  
 
 Citrus aurantium L.: Petitgrain bigarade essential oil CAS 
8014 - 17-3 EINECS 283 -881-6 FEMA 2855 CoE 136  All animal 
species with the 
exception of 
chickens for 
fattening, 
laying hens, 
turkeys for 
fattening, pigs 
for fattening, 
piglets, 
lactating sows, 
calves, dairy 
cows, c attle for 
fattening, 
sheep/goats, 
horses, rabbits, 
salmonids, 
dogs, cats and 
ornamental fish  
 Citrus x aurantium  L.: Bitter orange extract  Dogs, cats, 
ornamental fish 
and ornamental 
birds  
 Citrus limon  (L.) Osbeck: Expressed lemon essential oil  Dogs, cats, 
ornamental fish 
and ornamental 
birds  
 Citrus limon  (L.) Osbeck: Residual fraction of expressed 
lemon oil distilled  Dogs, cats, 
ornamental fish 
and ornamental 
birds  
 Citrus reticulata  Blanco.: Expressed mandarin essential 
oil Dogs, cats, 
ornamental fish 
and ornamental 
birds   
EN 4  EN  Citrus sinensis  (L.) Osbeck  = Citrus sinensis  (L.) Pers.  = 
Citrus aurantium  L. var. dulcis : Distilled orange essential 
oil Dogs, cats, 
ornamental fish 
and ornamental 
birds  
 Citrus sinensis  (L.) Osbeck  = Citrus sinensis  (L.) Pers.  = 
Citrus aurantium  L. var. dulcis : Expressed orange 
essential oil  Dogs, cats, 
ornamental fish 
and ornamental 
birds  
 Citrus sinensis  (L.) Osbeck  = Citrus sinensis  (L.) Pers. = 
Citrus aurantium  L. var. dulcis : Folded orange oil  CAS 
8028 -48-6 FEMA 2822, in the following forms which 
have been authorised for certain animal species2: 
- characterised by a non -volatile fraction of 10.5%, a 
d-Limonene content of 89 -96% in the volatile 
fraction and a perillaldehyde content < 0.3% in the 
volatile fraction ; 
- characterised by a non -volatile fraction of 20.9%, a 
d-Limonene content of 79 -89% in th e volatile 
fraction and a perillaldehyde content < 0.6% in the 
volatile fraction;  
- characterised by a non -volatile fraction of 18%, a 
d-Limonene content of 85 -95% in the volatile 
fraction and absence of perillaldehyde in the 
volatile fraction.   
 
 
- Dogs, ca ts, 
ornamental fish 
and ornamental 
birds  
- Dogs, cats, 
ornamental fish 
and ornamental 
birds  
- Horses, 
rabbits, dogs, 
cats, 
ornamental fish 
and ornamental 
birds  
 Curcuma longa L.: Turmeric tincture  All animal 
species with the 
exception of 
horses and dogs  
 Eleutherococcus senticosus (Rupr. et Maxim.) Maxim.: 
Taiga root tincture  All animal 
species with the 
exception of 
horses, dogs 
and cats  
 Ferula assa -foetida L.: Asafoetida oil essential oil CAS 
9000 -04-8 FEMA 2108 CoE 196  All animal 
species with the 
exception of 
 
2 Three forms of folded orange oil [2b143 -f, 2b143 -f-i and 2b143 -f-ii] have been authorised by Commission 
Implementing Regulation (EU) 2022/1421 of 22 August 2022 concerning the authorisation of expressed orange 
essential oil, distilled orange essential oil and folded orange oils from Citrus sinensis  (L.) Osbeck as feed 
additives for certain animal species (OJ L 218, 23.8.2022, p. 27), ELI: 
http://data.europa.eu/eli/reg_impl/2022/1421/oj . 
  
EN 5  EN dogs and cats  
 Litsea cubeba (Lour.) Pers.: Litsea berry essential oil CAS 
68855 -99-2 EINECS 290 -018-7 FEMA 3846 CoE 491  
 All animal 
species with the 
exception of 
chickens for 
fattening, 
laying hens, 
turkeys for 
fattening, pigs 
for fattening, 
piglets, 
lactating sows, 
calves, dairy 
cows, cattle for 
fattening, 
sheep/goats, 
horses, rabbits, 
salmonids, 
dogs, cats and 
ornamental fish  
 Panax ginseng  C. A. Mey.: Ginseng tincture CoE 318  All animal 
species with the 
exception of 
horses, dogs 
and cats  
 Piper nigrum  L.: Black pepper supercritical extract  All animal 
species with the 
exception of 
dogs and cats  
 Schisandra  chinensis (Turcz.) Baill:  Omicha tincture  All animal 
species with the 
except ion of  
horses, dogs, 
cats, poultry 
and game birds  
 Zingiber officinale Roscoe: Ginger oleoresin CoE 489  All animal 
species with the 
exception of  
chickens for 
fattening, 
laying hens, 
turkeys for 
fattening, 
piglets, pigs for 
fattening, sows, 
dairy cows,  
EN 6  EN veal calves 
(milk 
replacers), 
cattle for 
fattening, sheep 
and goats, 
horses, rabbits, 
fish and pets  
 Zingiber officinale Roscoe: Ginger tincture  
 All animal 
species with the 
exception of 
horses and dogs  
Natural products and corresponding synthetic products  
 CAS No. 106 -24-1 / Geraniol / Flavis No. 02.012  
 Marine animals  
 CAS No. 104 -54-1 / Cinnamyl alcohol / Flavis No. 02.017  Marine animals  
 CAS No. 4602 -84-0 / 3,7,11 -Trimethyldodeca -2,6,10 -trien-1-ol 
/ Flavis No. 02.029  Marine animals  
 CAS No. 122 -97-4 / 3-Phenylpropan -1-ol / Flavis No. 02.031  Marine animals  
 CAS No.  106-25-2 / (Z) -Nerol / Flavis No. 02.058  Marine animals  
 CAS No. 5392 -40-5 / Citral / Flavis No. 05.020  Marine animals  
 CAS No. 93 -53-8 / 2-Penylpropanal / Flavis No. 05.038  Marine animals  
 CAS No. 103 -95-7 / 3-(p-Cumenyl )-2-methylpropionaldehyde / 
Flavis No. 05.045  Marine animals  
 CAS No. 101 -39-3 / Alpha -Methylcinnamaldehyde / Flavis No. 
05.050  Marine animals  
 CAS No. 104 -53-0 / 3-Phenylpropanal / Flavis No. 05.080  Marine animals  
 CAS No. 621 -82-9 / Cinnamic acid / Flavis No. 08.022  Marine animals  
 CAS No. 105 -87-3 / Geranyl acetate / Flavis No. 09.011  Marine animals  
 CAS No. 103 -54-8 / Cinnamyl acetate / Flavis No. 09.018  
 Marine animals  
 CAS No. 106 -29-6 / Geranyl butyrate / Flavis No. 09.048  Marine animals  
 CAS No. 103 -61-7 / Cinnamyl butyrate / Flavis No. 09.053  Marine animals  
 CAS No. 105 -86-2 / Geranyl formate / Flavis No. 09.076  Marine animals   
EN 7  EN  CAS No. 105 -90-8 / Geranyl propionate / Flavis No. 09.128  Marine animals  
 CAS No. 105 -91-9 / Neryl propionate / Flavis No. 09.169  Marine animals  
 CAS No. 2142 -94-1 / Neryl formate / Flavis No. 09.212  Marine animals  
 CAS No. 141 -12-8 / Neryl acetate / Flavis No. 09.213  Marine animals  
 CAS No. 2345 -24-6 / Neryl isobutyrate / Flavis No. 09.424  Marine animals  
 CAS No. 103 -58-2 / 3-Phenylpropyl isobutyrate / Flavis No. 
09.428  Marine animals  
 CAS No. 2345 -26-8 / Geranyl isobutyrate / Flavis No. 09.431  Marine animals  
 CAS No. 140 -27-2 / Cinnamyl isovalerate / Flavis No. 09.459  Marine animals  
 CAS No. 103 -59-3 / Cinnamyl isobutyrate / Flavis No. 09.470  Marine animals  
 CAS No. 1191 -16-9 / Prenyl acetate / Flavis No. 09.692  Marine animals  
 CAS No. 103 -36-6 / Ethyl cinnamate / Flavis No. 09.730  Marine animals  
 CAS No. 103 -26-4 / Methyl cinnamate / Flavis No. 09.740  Marine animals  
 CAS No. 7779 -65-9 / Isopentyl cinnamate / Flavis No. 09.742  Marine animals  
Artificial substances  
E 954(iii)  Sodium saccharin  Piglets