WT/DSB/W/609/Rev.14  
 
20 September  2019 
(19-6074) Page: 1/2 
Dispute Settlement Body  
30 September 2019  Original: English  
 
APPELLATE BODY APPOI NTMENTS  
PROPOSAL BY ANGOLA ; ARGENTINA ; AUSTRALIA ; BENIN; PLURINATIONAL STATE OF BOLIVIA ; 
BOTSWANA ;  BRAZIL ; BURKINA FASO; BURUNDI ; CABO VERDE ; CAMEROON ; CANADA ; CENTRAL 
AFRICAN REPUBLIC ; CHAD; CHILE; CHINA; COLOMBIA ; CONGO ; COSTA RICA; CÔTE D'IVOIRE; 
CUBA; DEMOCRATIC REPUBLIC OF CONGO ; DJIBOUTI ; DOMINICAN REPUBLIC ; ECUADOR ; EGYPT; 
EL SALVADOR ; ESWATINI ; THE EUROPEAN UNION ; GABON ; THE GAMBIA ; GHANA ; GUATEMALA ; 
GUINEA ; GUINEA -BISSAU ; HONDURAS ; HONG KONG, CHINA; ICELAND ; INDIA; INDONESIA ; 
ISRAEL ; KAZAKHSTAN ; KENYA ; REPUBLIC OF KOREA ; LESOTHO ; LIECHTENSTEIN ; MADAGASCAR ; 
MALAWI ; MALAYSIA; MALI; MAURITANIA ; MAURITIUS ; MEXICO ; MOROCCO ; MOZAMBIQUE ; 
NAMIBIA; NEW ZEALAND ; NICARAGUA ; NIGER; NIGERIA ; NORTH MACEDONIA ; NORWAY ; 
PAKISTAN ; PANAMA ; PARAGUAY ; PERU; QATAR ; RUSSIAN FEDERATION ; RWANDA ; SENEGAL ; 
SEYCHELLES ; SIERRA LEONE ; SINGAPORE ; SOUTH AFRICA ; SWITZERLAND ; THE SEPARATE 
CUSTOMS TERRITORY OF TAIWAN , PENGHU , KINMEN AND MATSU; TANZANIA ; THAILAND;  TOGO; 
TUNISIA ; TURKEY ; UGANDA ; UKRAINE ; URUGUAY ; THE BOLIVARIAN REPUBLIC OF VENEZUELA ; 
VIET NAM; ZAMBIA AND  ZIMBABWE  
Revision  
The following communication, dated 18 September  2019, is being circulated at the request of the 
Delegations of proposal by Angola ; Argentina ; Australia ; Benin; Plurinational State of Bolivia ; 
Botswana ;  Brazil; Burkina Faso; Burundi ; Cabo Verde; Cameroon ; Canada ; Central African 
Republic ; Chad; Chile; China; Colombia ; Congo; Costa Rica; Côte D'Ivoire; Cuba; Democratic 
Republic of Congo; Djibouti ; Dominican Republic ; Ecuador ; Egypt; El Salvador ; Eswatini ; the 
European Union; Gabon; The Gambia ; Ghana; Guatemala ; Guinea ; Guinea -Bissau; Honduras ; 
Hong Kong, China; Iceland ; India; Indonesia ; Israel; Kazakhstan ; Kenya; Republic of Korea; 
Lesotho ; Liechtenstein ; Madagascar ; Malawi; Malaysia; Mali; Mauritania ; Mauritius ; Mexico; 
Morocco ; Mozambique ; Namibia; New Zealand ; Nicaragua ; Niger; Nigeria ; North Macedonia ; 
Norway ; Pakistan ; Panama ; Paraguay ; Peru; Qatar; Russian Federation ; Rwanda ; Senegal ; 
Seychelles ; Sierra Leone; Singapore ; South Africa; Switzerland ; the Separate Customs Territory of 
Taiwan , Penghu , Kinmen and Matsu; Tanzania ; Thailand; Togo; Tunisia ; Turkey ; Uganda ; Ukraine ; 
Uruguay ; the Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela ; Viet Nam; Zambia and Zimbabwe . 
 
_______________  
 
 
Given the urgency and importance of filling the vacancies in the Appellate Body, in compliance with 
the DSU and so that it can carry on its functions properly, the delegations referred to above, propose 
that, at its meeting, the DSB takes a decision with r egard to the following:  
 
(1)  to launch: (i) one selection process to replace Mr. Ricardo Ramírez Hernández, whose 
second  four-year term of office expired on 30 June 2017 ; (ii) a second selection process to replace 
Mr. Hyun Chong Kim, who resigned from th e Appellate Body as of 1 August 2017 ; (iii) a third 
selection process to replace Mr. Peter Van den Bossche, whose second four -year term of office 
expired on 11 December 2017 ; (iv) a fourth selection process to replace Mr. Shree Baboo Chekitan 
Servansing, w hose four -year term of office expired on 30 September 2018 ; (v) a fifth selection 
process to replace Mr.  Ujal Singh Bhatia whose second four -year term of  office will expire on 
10 December 2019 ; and (vi) a sixth selection process to replace  Mr. Thomas R. Gr aham whose 
second four -year term of office will expire on 10  December 2019;  
 WT/DSB/W/609/Rev.14  
 
- 2 - 
 
  (2) to establish a Selection Committee, consistent with the procedures set out in document 
WT/DSB/1 and with previous selection processes, composed of the Director -General and th e 
Chairpersons of the General Council, the Goods Council, the Services Council, the TRIPS Council and 
the DSB, to be Chaired by the DSB Chair;  
 
(3) to set a deadline of a 30 -day period after the date of its decision, for Members to submit 
nominations of c andidates; and  
 
(4) to request the Selection Committee to carry out its work in order to make recommendations 
to the DSB within 60 days after the deadline for submitting nominations of candidates, so that the 
DSB can take a decision to appoint six new Appellate Body members as soon as  possible.  
 
 
__________