1 
 EN 
 
ANNEX I  
Feed additives to be withdrawn from the market, as referred to in Article 1  
 
CHAPTER I.A.  
Feed additives which were authorised  without a time limit  
 
Part 1 – Feed Additives to be withdrawn from the market for all species and categories of 
animals  
Identific
ation 
Number  Additive  Species or 
category of 
animals  
Preservatives  
E 331  Sodium citrates  All species  
E 332  Potassium citrates  All species  
E 325  Sodium lactate  All species  
E 326  Potassium lactate  All species  
Emulsifying and stabilising agents, thickeners and gelling agents  
E 420  Sorbitol  All species  
 
 
E 421  Mannitol  All species  
 
Binders, anti -caking agents and coagulants  
E 558  Bentonite -montmorillonite  All species  
Vitamins, provitamins and chemically well -defined substances having similar effect  
 Riboflavin or Vitamin B 2. All forms with the exception of : 
- Riboflavin solid form produced by Ashbya gossypii  
DSM 230961; 
- Riboflavin solid form produced by Bacillus subtilis  
DSM 17339 and/or DSM 239841; 
- Riboflavin 5’ -phosphate ester monosodium salt solid 
form produced after phosphorylation of riboflavin 98 
% produced by Bacillus subtilis  DSM 17339 and/or 
DSM 239841; 
- Riboflavin (80 %) produced by Bacillus subtilis 
KCCM -104452. All species  
 
                                                 
1 Those forms of riboflavin have been authorised by Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2019/901 of 
29 May 2019 concerning the authorisation of riboflavin produced by Ashbya gossypii  (DSM 23096), 
riboflavin produced by Bacillus subtilis  (DSM 17339 and/or DSM 23984) and riboflavin 5′ -phosphate sodium 
salt produced by Bacillus subtilis  (DSM 17339 and/or D SM 23984) (sources of vitamin B2) as feed additives 
for all animal species  (OJ L 144, 3.6.2019, p. 41).   
2 
 Identific
ation 
Number  Additive  Species or 
category of 
animals  
E 160 (a)  Beta-carotene. All forms with the exception of  beta-
carotene authorised by Commission Implementing 
Regulation (EU) 2015/11033 All species  
 
Silage additives  
Microorganisms  
 Enterococcus faecium  CNCM I -3236 / ATCC 19434  All species  
 Bacillus subtilis MBS -BS-01 All species  
 Lactobacillus plantarum  DSM 11520  All species  
Colourants, including pigments  
Other colourants  
E 153  Carbon black as a colouring agent authorised for colouring 
foodstuffs by Community rules  All species  
 
Flavouring and appetising  substances  
Natural products - botanically defined  
 Allium cepa  L.: Onion concentrate CoE 24  All species  
 Allium sativum L.: Garlic extract (water -based)  All species  
 Amyris balsamifera  L.: Amyris oil CoE 33  All species  
 Anacardium occidentale  L.: Cashew oil CoE 34  All species  
 Anethum graveolens  L.: Dill seed extract CAS 8006 -75-5 
CoE 42 EINECS 289 -790-8 All species  
 Apium graveolens  L.: Celery seed extract CAS 89997 -35-3 
FEMA 2270 CoE 52 EINECS 289 -668-4 All species  
 Artemisia absinthium  L.: Wormwood oil CAS 8008 -93-3 
FEMA 3116 CoE 61 EINECS 284 -503-2 All species  
 Artemisia annua L.: Annual mugwort extract (water -based) / 
Annual mugwort oil  All species  
 Artemisia pallens Wall.: Davana oil CAS 8016 -03-3 FEMA 
2359 CoE 69 EINECS 295 -155-6 All species  
 Bacopa monnieri  (L.) Pennell: Thyme leaved gratiola 
tincture  All species  
 Carum carvi  L. = Apium carvi  L.: Caraway seed extract/ 
oleoresin CAS 8000 -42-8 CoE 112 EINECS 288 -921-6 All species  
 Cimicifuga simplex  (Wormsk. ex DC.) Ledeb.  
= C. racemosa (L.) Nutt.: Sarashina shoma extract  All species  
                                                                                                                                                        
2 This form of riboflavin has been the subject of a denial of authorisation by Commission Implementing 
Regulation (EU) 2018/1254 of 19 September 2018 co ncerning the denial of authorisation of riboflavin (80 %) 
produced by Bacillus subtilis  KCCM -10445 as a feed additive belonging to the functional group of vitamins, 
pro-vitamins and chemically well -defined substances having similar effect (OJ L 237, 20.9.2 018, p. 5).  
3 Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2015/1103 of 8 July 2015 concerning the aut horisation of beta -
carotene as a feed additive for all animal species  (OJ L 181, 9.7.2015, p. 57).   
3 
 Identific
ation 
Number  Additive  Species or 
category of 
animals  
 Cinnamomum aromaticum  Nees, C. cassia Nees ex Blume: 
Cassia bark extract CAS 84961 -46-6 FEMA 2257 CoE 131 
EINECS 284 -635-0 All species  
 Cinnamomum zeylanicum  Bl., C. verum  J.S. Presl: 
Cinnamon bark oleoresin CAS 84961 -46-6 FEMA 2290 
CoE 133 EINECS 283 -479-0 All species  
 Citrus aurantium  L.: Neroli bigarade oil CAS 8016 -38-4 
FEMA 2771 CoE 136 EINECS 277 -143-2 / Petitgrain 
bigarade absolute CAS 8014 -17-3 CoE 136 EINECS 283 -
881-6 All species  
 Citrus reticulata  Blanco: Mandarin, Tangerine terpenes CoE 
142 All species  
 Citrus x paradisi  Macfad.: Grapefruit oil expressed CAS 
8016 -20-4 FEMA 2530 CoE 140 EINECS 289 -904-6 / 
Grapefruit extract CoE 140  All species  
 Glycyrrhiza glabra  L.: Licorice extract (solvent -based) CAS 
97676 -23-8 FEMA 2628 CoE 218 EINECS 272 -837-1 All species  
 Juniperus communis  L.: Juniper berry extract CAS 84603 -
69-0 CoE 249 EINECS 283 -268-3 All species  
 Laurus nobilis  L.: Laurel leaves extract / oleoresin CAS 
84603 -73-6 FEMA 2613 CoE 255 EINECS 283 -272-5 All species  
 Lavandula latifolia  Medik.: Spike lavender oil CoE 256  All species  
 Lepidium meyenii  Walp.: Maca extract  All species  
 Leptospermum scoparium  J. R. et G. Forst.: Broom teatree 
oil All species  
 Macleaya cordata (Willd.) R. Br.: Plume poppy absolute / 
Plume poppy extract / Plume poppy oil / Plume poppy 
tincture  All species  
 Mallotus philippinensis  (Lam.) Muell. Arg.: Kamala extract 
CoE 535  All species  
 Malpighia glabra  L.: Acerola extract  All species  
 Malus sylvestris  Mill.: Apple concentrate CoE 386  All species  
 Medicago sativa  L.: Alfalfa tincture CoE 274  All species  
 Melissa officinalis  L.: Melissa oil CoE 280  All species  
 Mentha pulegium  L.: Pennyroyal oil CAS 8013 -99-8 FEMA 
2839 CoE 283 EINECS 290 -061-1  All species  
 Myristica fragrans  Houtt.: Mace oil CAS 8007 -12-3 FEMA 
2653 CoE 296 EINECS 282 -013-3 / Nutmeg oleoresin CAS 
8408268 -8 CoE 296 EINECS 282 -013-3 All species   
4 
 Identific
ation 
Number  Additive  Species or 
category of 
animals  
 Myroxylon balsamum  (L.) Harms: Tolu balsam extract 
(solvent -based) CAS 9000 -64-0 FEMA 3069 CoE 297 
EINECS 232 -550-4 All species  
 Myroxylon balsamum  (L.) Harms var. Pereirae : Balsam 
peru extract (solvent -based) CAS 8007 -00-9 FEMA 2117, 
2116 CoE 298 EINECS 232-352-8 All species  
 Ocimum basilicum  L.: Basil oil CAS 801573 -4 FEMA 2119 
CoE 308 EINECS 283 -900-8 All species  
 Opopanax chironium  (L.) Koch, Commiphora erythrea  
Engler: Opoponax oil CAS 8021 - 36-1 CoE 313 EINECS 
232-558-8 All species  
 Passiflora edulis  Sims. = P. incarnata L.: Passionfruit 
extract (water -based) CoE 321  All species  
 Pelargonium asperum  Her. ex Spreng.: Geranium oil  All species  
 Peumus boldus  Mol.: Boldo extract CoE 328 / Boldo 
tincture CoE 328  All species  
 Pinus pinaster  Soland.: Pine oil  All species  
 Pimenta racemosa  (Mill.) J.W.Moore: Bay oil CAS 8006 -
78-8 CoE 334  All species  
 Piper methysticum  G. Forst.: Kawa -kawa tincture  All species  
 Quillaja saponaria  Molina: Quillaia extract (solvent -based) 
CoE 391 / Quillaia co ncentrate  All species  
 Ribes nigrum  L.: Black currant extract CoE 399  All species  
 Satureja hortensis  L.: Savory summer oil CAS 8016 -68-0 
FEMA 3013 CoE 425 EINECS 283 -922-8 All species  
 Sophora japonica  L.: Pagoda tree oil  All species  
 Styrax benzoin  Dryand., S. tonkinensis  (Pierre) Craib ex 
Hartwich: Benzoin resinoid CAS 9000 -05-9 FEMA 2133 
CoE 439 EINECS 232 -523-7 All species  
 Tagetes erecta  L., T. glandulifera  Schrank., T. minuta L. 
e.a.: Tagetes oil CAS 8016 - 84-0 FEMA 3040 CoE 443/494 
EINECS 294-862-7 All species  
 Thea sinensis  L. = Camellia thea  Link. = Camellia sinensis  
(L.) O. Kuntze: Tea tincture CoE 451  All species  
 Uncaria tomentosa  L. = Ourouparia guianensis  Aubl.: Cat's 
claw extract  All species  
 Valeriana officinalis L.: Valerian root tincture CoE 473  All species  
 Vetiveria zizanoides  (L.) Nash.: Vetiver oil CAS 8016 -96-4 
CoE 479 EINECS 282 -490-8 All species   
5 
 Identific
ation 
Number  Additive  Species or 
category of 
animals  
 Vitis vinifera  L.: Cognac oil green CAS 8016 -21-5 FEMA 
2331 CoE 485 EINECS 232 -403-4 / Cognac oil white CAS 
801621 -5 FEMA 2332 CoE 485 EINECS 232 -403-4 All species  
 Vitis vinifera  L.: Grape seed extract CoE 485  All species  
 Yucca mohavensis  Sarg. = Y. schidigera  Roezl ex Ortgies: 
Mojave yucca extract (solvent -based) CAS 90147 -57-2 
FEMA 3121 EINECS 290 -449-0 / Yucca concentrate / 
Yucca residuals  All species  
 Zingiber officinale  Rosc.: Ginger extract CAS 84696 -15-1 
FEMA 2521 CoE 489 EINECS 283 -634-2 
 All species  
Natural products and corresponding synthetic products  
 CAS No. 1128 -08-1 / 3-Methyl -2-pentylcyclopent -2-en-1-
one / Flavis No. 07.140  All species  
 CAS No. 352195 -40-5 / Disodium Inosine -5-Mono -
phosphate (IMP)  All species  
 
Part 2 – Feed additives to be withdrawn from the market for certain species or categories 
of animals  
Identifica
tion 
Number  Additive  Species and 
category of 
animals  
Trace elements  
E 7 Molybdenum – Mo, Sodium molybdate  All animal 
species and 
categories with 
the exception 
of sheep  
Acidity regulators  
E 503 (i)  Ammonium carbonate  Cats; Dogs  
E 503 (ii)  Ammonium hydrogen carbonate  Cats; Dogs  
E 525  Potassium hydroxide  Cats; Dogs  
E 526  Calcium hydroxide  Cats; Dogs   
6 
 Identifica
tion 
Number  Additive  Species and 
category of 
animals  
Colourants, including pigments  
Other colourants  
E 141  Chlorophyllin copper complex as a colouring agent 
authorised for colouring foodstuffs by Community rules  All animal 
species and 
categories with 
the exception 
of dogs and 
cats 
E 141  Chlorophyll copper complex as a colouring agent  
[functional group 2 a (iii)]  Grain -eating 
ornamental 
birds; Small 
rodents; 
Ornamental 
fish 
E 153  Carbon black as a colouring agent  
[functional group 2 a (iii)]  Ornamental 
fish 
E 172  Iron Oxide Red, Black &  Yellow as colouring agent 
authorised for colouring foodstuffs by Community rules  Horses  
Flavouring and appetising substances  
Natural products – botanically defined  
 Helianthus annuus  L.: Sunflower extract  Cats; Dogs  
 Hyssopus officinalis  L. = H. decumbens  Jord. & Fourr.: 
Hyssop. Oil CAS 8006 -83-5 FEMA 2591 CoE 235 EINECS 
283-266-3  Cats; Dogs  
 Sus scrofa (extract from defatted porcine pancreatic glands)  Cats and dogs 
and other 
carnivorous 
and 
omnivorous 
companion 
animals such 
as ferrets  
Amino ac ids, their salts and analogues  
3.2.7.  Mixtures of:  
(a) L-lysine -monohydrochloride, technically pure and,  
(b) DL-methionine, technically pure  
protected with copolymer vinyl -pyridine/styrene  Dairy cows  
 
 
  
7 
 CHAPTER I.B.  
Feed additives which were authorised for a limited  period  
Identific
ation 
Number  Additive  Species or 
category of 
animals  
Coccidiostats and other medicinal substances  
E 758  Robenidine hydrochloride 66 g/kg (holder of the 
authorisation Zoetis Belgium SA)  Turkeys  
E 770  Maduramicin ammonium alfa 1 g/100 g (holder of the 
authorisation Zoetis Belgium SA)  Turkeys  
 
 
CHAPTER I.C.  
Feed additives for which a notification referred to in Article 10(1)(a) of Regulation (EC) 
No 1831/2003 was not submitted  
Identifica
tion 
Number  Additive  Species or 
category of 
animals  
Amino acids, their salts and analogues  
3.2.6.  L-lysine phosphate and its by -products produced by 
fermentation with Brevibacterium lactofermentum  NRRL B -
11470  Poultry; Pigs  
  
8 
 ANNEX II  
Products which are not feed additives within the scope of Regulation (EC) No 
1831/2003 , as referred to in Article 5 (1) 
 
1. Tamarind seed flour  
2. Potassium dihydrogen orthophosphate  
3. Dipotassium hydrogen orthophosphate  
4. Tripotassium orthophosphate  
5. Ammonium dihydrogen orthophosphate  
6. Diammonium hydrogen orthophosphate  
7. Diso dium dihydrogen diphosphate  
8. Tetrapotassium diphosphate  
9. Pentapotassium triphosphate  
10. Sodium sesquicarbonate  
11. Potassium hydrogen carbonate  
12. Calcium oxide  
13. Sucrose esters of fatty acids (esters of saccharose and edible fatty acids)  
14. Sucroglycerides (mixture of est ers of saccharose and mono - and di -glycerides of 
edible fatty acids)  
15. Polyglycerol esters of non -polymerised edible fatty acids  
16. Mono -esters of propane -1,2-diol (propyleneglycol) and edible fatty acids, alone or in 
mixtures with diesters  
17. Merluccius capensis , Galeorhinus australis  e.a., / Cartilage  
   
9 
 ANNEX III  
 
Products which are feed additives within the scope of Regulation (EC) No 1831/2003, as 
referred to in Article 6(1) 
 
1. Xylitol  
2. Ammonium lactate  
3. Ammonium acetate