WORLD TRADE
ORGANIZATIONTN/RL/4/Suppl.1
3 March 2003
(03-1237)
Negotiating Group on Rules
NEGOTIATING GROUP ON RULES
Report by the Chairman
to the Trade Negotiations Committee
Supplement
The following annex should be attached to document TN/RL/4.TN/RL/4/Suppl.1
Page 2
ANNEX
SUBMISSIONS BY PARTICIPANTS TO THE NEGOTIATING GROUP ON RULES1
Symbol Title of document Submitted by
TN/RL/W/1 IMPROVED DISCIPLINES UNDER THE
AGREEMENT ON SUBSIDIES AND
COUNTERVAILING MEASURES AND THE
ANTI-DUMPING AGREEMENTCanada
TN/RL/W/2 NEGOTIATIONS ON REGIONAL TRADE
AGREEMENTS:
KEY ISSUES FOR CONSIDERATIONAustralia
TN/RL/W/3 THE DOHA MANDATE TO ADDRESS
FISHERIES SUBSIDIES:  ISSUESAustralia, Chile,
Ecuador, Iceland,
New Zealand, Peru,
Philippines and the
United States
TN/RL/W/4 PROPOSALS ON IMPLEMENTATION RELATED
ISSUES AND CONCERNS
AGREEMENT ON SUBSIDIES AND
COUNTERVAILING MEASURES/
ANTI-DUMPING AGREEMENTIndia
TN/RL/W/5 EXPORT CREDITS IN THE WTO Brazil
TN/RL/W/6 ANTI-DUMPING:  ILLUSTRATIVE MAJOR
ISSUESBrazil; Chile; Colombia;
Costa Rica;
Hong Kong, China
Israel;  Japan;  Korea;
Mexico;  Norway;
Singapore;  Switzerland;
Thailand;  Turkey
TN/RL/W/7 IMPLEMENTATION ISSUES Brazil
                                                     
1 Until 27 February 2003.TN/RL/4/Suppl.1
Page 3
Symbol Title of document Submitted by
TN/RL/W/9 PROPOSAL FROM THE PEOPLE'S REPUBLIC
OF CHINA
ON FISHERIES SUBSIDIESThe People's Republic of
China
TN/RL/W/10 SECOND CONTRIBUTION TO DISCUSSION OF
THE NEGOTIATING
GROUP ON RULES ON ANTI-DUMPING
MEASURESBrazil;  Chile;
Colombia;  Costa Rica;
Hong Kong, China;
Israel; Japan;  Korea;
Norway;  Separate
Customs Territory of
Taiwan, Penghu, Kinmen
and Matsu;  Singapore;
Switzerland;  and
Thailand
TN/RL/W/11 JAPAN’S BASIC POSITION ON THE FISHERIES
SUBSIDIES ISSUEJapan
TN/RL/W/12 FISHERIES SUBSIDIES:  LIMITATIONS OF
EXISTING SUBSIDY DISCIPLINESNew-Zealand
TN/RL/W/13 SUBMISSION FROM THE EUROPEAN
COMMUNITIES CONCERNING THE
AGREEMENT ON IMPLEMENTATION OF
ARTICLE VI OF GATT 1994 (ANTI-DUMPING
AGREEMENT)European Communities
TN/RL/W/14 SUBMISSION ON REGIONAL TRADE
AGREEMENTS BY THE EUROPEAN
COMMUNITIES AND THEIR MEMBER STATESEuropean Communities
TN/RL/W/15 SUBMISSION ON REGIONAL TRADE
AGREEMENTS BY AUSTRALIAAustralia
TN/RL/W/16 SUBMISSION ON REGIONAL TRADE
AGREEMENTSChile
TN/RL/W/17 KOREA'S VIEWS ON THE DOHA
DEVELOPMENT AGENDA DISCUSSIONS ON
FISHERIES SUBSIDIESKorea
TN/RL/W/18 REPLIES TO THE QUESTIONS/COMMENTS
FROM AUSTRALIA ON TN/RL/W/10Brazil;  Chile;
Colombia;  Costa Rica;
Hong Kong, China;
Israel; Japan;  Korea;
Norway;  Separate
Customs Territory of
Taiwan, Penghu, Kinmen
and Matsu;  Singapore;
Switzerland;  and
ThailandTN/RL/4/Suppl.1
Page 4
Symbol Title of document Submitted by
TN/RL/W/19 COUNTERVAILING MEASURES:
ILLUSTRATIVE MAJOR ISSUESBrazil
TN/RL/W/20 QUESTIONS FROM THE EUROPEAN
COMMUNITIES ON DOCUMENTS
TN/RL/W/6 AND TN/RL/W/10European Communities
TN/RL/W/21 ADVERSE TRADE AND CONSERVATION
EFFECTS OF FISHERIES SUBSIDIESUnited States
TN/RL/W/22 COMMENTS ON DOCUMENT TN/RL/W/6 ON
ANTI-DUMPING MEASURESAustralia
TN/RL/W/23 COMMENTS ON DOCUMENT TN/RL/W/10
ON ANTI-DUMPING MEASURESAustralia
TN/RL/W/24 SUBMISSION BY THE UNITED STATES United States
TN/RL/W/25 QUESTIONS FROM THE UNITED STATES
ON PAPERS SUBMITTED TO THE RULES
NEGOTIATING GROUPUnited States
TN/RL/W/26 SECOND SUBMISSION OF INDIA (ANTI-
DUMPING AGREEMENT)India
TN/RL/W/27 COMMUNICATION FROM THE UNITED
STATES
BASIC CONCEPTS AND PRINCIPLES OF
THE TRADE REMEDY RULESUnited States
TN/RL/W/28/Rev.1 GENERAL CONTRIBUTION TO THE
DISCUSSION OF THE NEGOTIATING
GROUP ON RULES ON ANTI-DUMPING
MEASURESBrazil;  Chile;
Colombia;  Costa Rica;
Hong Kong, China;
Israel;  Japan;  Korea;
Mexico;  Norway;
Separate Customs
Territory of Taiwan,
Penghu, Kinmen and
Matsu;  Singapore;
Switzerland;  Thailand;
and Turkey
TN/RL/W/29 THIRD CONTRIBUTION TO DISCUSSION OF
THE NEGOTIATING GROUP ON RULES ON
ANTI-DUMPING MEASURESBrazil;  Chile;
Colombia;  Costa Rica;
Hong Kong, China;
Japan;  Korea;  Norway;
Separate Customs
Territory of Taiwan,
Penghu, Kinmen and
Matsu;  Singapore;
Switzerland;  Thailand;
and TurkeyTN/RL/4/Suppl.1
Page 5
Symbol Title of document Submitted by
TN/RL/W/30 WTO NEGOTIATIONS CONCERNING THE
WTO AGREEMENT ON SUBSIDIES AND
COUNTERVAILING MEASURESEuropean Communities
TN/RL/W/31 REPLIES TO ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS TO
OUR SECOND CONTRIBUTION
(TN/RL/W/10)Brazil;  Chile;
Colombia;  Costa Rica;
Hong Kong, China;
Israel;  Japan;  Korea;
Norway;  Separate
Customs Territory of
Taiwan, Penghu, Kinmen
and Matsu;  Singapore;
Switzerland;  Thailand
TN/RL/W/32 SUBMISSION ON REGIONAL TRADE
AGREEMENTSTurkey
TN/RL/W/33 SPECIAL AND DIFFERENTIAL TREATMENT
AND THE SUBSIDIES AGREEMENTUnited States
TN/RL/W/34 SECOND SET OF QUESTIONS FROM THE
UNITED STATES ON PAPERS SUBMITTED
TO THE RULES NEGOTIATING GROUPUnited States
TN/RL/W/35 INVESTIGATORY PROCEDURES UNDER
THE ANTI-DUMPING AND SUBSIDIES
AGREEMENTSUnited States
TN/RL/W/36 MOROCCO'S VIEWS REGARDING
NEGOTIATIONS ON RULES AND THE
DISCIPLINES OF THE AGREEMENT ON
IMPLEMENTATION OF ARTICLE VI OF
GATT 1994 AND THE AGREEMENT ON
SUBSIDIES AND COUNTERVAILING
MEASURESMorocco
TN/RL/W/37 COMMENTS FROM AUSTRALIA ON
BRAZIL'S PAPER ON COUNTERVAILING
MEASURES:  ILLUSTRATIVE MAJOR
ISSUES (DOCUMENT TN/RL/W/19)Australia
TN/RL/W/38 COMMENTS FROM AUSTRALIA ON THE US
PAPER ON BASIC CONCEPTS AND
PRINCIPLES OF THE TRADE REMEDY
RULES (DOCUMENT TN/RL/W/27)Australia
TN/RL/W/39 COMMENTS FROM AUSTRALIA ON THE
EUROPEAN COMMUNITIES' SUBSIDIES
PAPER (TN/RL/W/30)AustraliaTN/RL/4/Suppl.1
Page 6
Symbol
Title of documentSubmitted by
TN/RL/W/40 INTERVENTION BY INDIA ON THE
PROPOSAL BY THE EC
CAPTIONED WTO NEGOTIATIONS
CONCERNING THE WTO AGREEMENT
ON SUBSIDIES AND COUNTERVAILING
MEASURES (TN/RL/W/30)India
TN/RL/W/41&Corr.
1IMPROVED RULES UNDER THE
AGREEMENT ON SUBSIDIES AND
COUNTERVAILING MEASURES – NON-
ACTIONABLE SUBSIDIES
PARAGRAPH 10.2 OF THE DOCUMENT ON
IMPLEMENTATION-RELATED
ISSUES AND CONCERNSVenezuela
TN/RL/W/42 QUESTIONS TO THE UNITED STATES ON
TN/RL/W/24United States
TN/RL/W/43 COMMENTS FROM AUSTRALIA ON THE
UNITED STATES’ PAPER
ON INVESTIGATORY PROCEDURES UNDER
THE ANTI-DUMPING
AND SUBSIDIES AGREEMENTS
(TN/RL/W/35)Australia
TN/RL/W/44 TREATMENT OF CONFIDENTIAL AND
NON-CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION
UNDER ARTICLE 6.5 OF THE WTO ANTI-
DUMPING AGREEMENTAustralia
TN/RL/W/45 REPLIES TO QUESTIONS TO OUR FIRST
CONTRIBUTION (TN/RL/W/6)Brazil;  Chile;
Colombia;  Costa Rica;
Hong Kong, China;
Israel;  Japan;  Korea;
Norway;  Singapore;
Switzerland and
Thailand
TN/RL/W/46 FOURTH CONTRIBUTION TO THE
DISCUSSION OF THE
NEGOTIATING GROUP ON RULES ON ANTI-
DUMPING MEASURESBrazil;  Chile;
Colombia;  Costa Rica;
Hong Kong, China;
Israel;  Korea;  Japan;
Mexico;  Norway;
Separate Customs
Territory of Taiwan,
Penghu, Kinmen and
Matsu;TN/RL/4/Suppl.1
Page 7
SymbolTitle of  documentSingapore;  Switzerland;
Thailand and Turkey
Submitted by
TN/RL/W/47 SUBMISSION FROM CANADA RESPECTING
THE AGREEMENT ON IMPLEMENTATION
OF ARTICLE VI OF THE GATT 1994
(THE ANTI-DUMPING AGREEMENT)Canada
TN/RL/W/48/Rev.1 ANTI-DUMPING ACTIONS IN THE AREA OF
TEXTILES AND CLOTHING:  DEVELOPING
MEMBERS' EXPERIENCES AND CONCERNSBangladesh;  Brazil;  the
People's Republic of
China;  Colombia;  Costa
Rica;  Egypt;
Guatemala;  Hong Kong,
China;  India;  Indonesia;
Korea;  Macao, China;
Maldives;  Pakistan;
Paraguay;  Peru;
Thailand and Vietnam.
TN/RL/W/49 COMMUNICATION FROM THE UNITED
STATES ATTACHING A
COMMUNIQUÉ FROM THE ORGANIZATION
FOR ECONOMIC
COOPERATION AND DEVELOPMENT
(OECD)United States
TN/RL/W/50 CIRCUMVENTION United States
TN/RL/W/51 QUESTIONS PERTAINING TO THE UNITED
STATES' PAPER
ON BASIC CONCEPTS AND PRINCIPLES OF
THE
TRADE REMEDY RULESUnited States
TN/RL/W/52 JAPAN’S CONTRIBUTION TO DISCUSSION
ON FISHERIES SUBSIDIES ISSUEJapan
TN/RL/W/53 REPLIES TO QUESTIONS PRESENTED TO
THE UNITED STATES
ON SUBMISSION TN/RL/W/27United States
TN/RL/W/54 POSITION PAPER TO BE PRESENTED BY
THE ARAB REPUBLIC OF EGYPT
ON THE DOHA DECLARATION
CONCERNING THE NEGOTIATIONS
ON THE ANTI-DUMPING AGREEMENTEgypt
TN/RL/W/55 POSITION PAPER TO BE PRESENTED BY
THE ARAB REPUBLIC OF EGYPT
ON THE DOHA DECLARATION
CONCERNING THE NEGOTIATIONS
ON THE ANTI-DUMPING AGREEMENTEgypt
TN/RL/W/56 EGYPTIAN PAPER CONTAINING
COMMENTS ON THE CONTRIBUTIONSEgyptTN/RL/4/Suppl.1
Page 8
SymbolSUBMITTED IN THE FRAMEWORK OF THE
DOHA NEGOTIATIONS
ON THE ANTI-DUMPING AGREEMENT
Title of the documentSubmitted by
TN/RL/W/57 EGYPTIAN PAPER CONTAINING
QUESTIONS AND COMMENTS ON
THE CONTRIBUTIONS SUBMITTED IN THE
FRAMEWORK OF
THE DOHA NEGOTIATIONS ON THE
SUBSIDIES AND
COUNTERVAILING MEASURES
AGREEMENTEgypt
TN/RL/W/58 SUBSIDIES IN THE FISHERIES SECTOR:
POSSIBLE CATEGORIZATIONSArgentina, Chile,
Iceland, New Zealand,
Norway, and Peru
TN/RL/W/59 COMMENTS FROM AUSTRALIA ON THE
THIRD CONTRIBUTION
FROM A NUMBER OF COUNTRIES
(DOCUMENT TN/RL/W/29)Australia
TN/RL/W/60 COMMENTS FROM AUSTRALIA ON
MOROCCO’S PAPER ON
ANTI-DUMPING AND SUBSIDIES AND
COUNTERVAILING MEASURES
AGREEMENTS (DOCUMENT TN/RL/W/36)Australia
TN/RL/W/61 COMMENTS FROM AUSTRALIA ON
VENEZUELA’S SUBMISSION ON NON-
ACTIONABLE SUBSIDIES UNDER THE
AGREEMENT ON SUBSIDIES AND
COUNTERVAILING MEASURES
(DOCUMENT TN/RL/W/41)Australia
TN/RL/W/62 COMMENTS FROM AUSTRALIA ON
CANADA’S SUBMISSION ON THE
ANTI-DUMPING AGREEMENT (DOCUMENT
TN/RL/W/47)Australia
TN/RL/W/63 SENIOR OFFICIALS’ STATEMENT ON ANTI-
DUMPING NEGOTIATIONSBrazil;  Chile;
Colombia;  Costa Rica;
Hong Kong, China;
Israel;  Japan;  Korea;
Mexico;  Norway;
Singapore;  Switzerland;the Separate Customs
Territory of Taiwan,
Penghu, Kinmen andTN/RL/4/Suppl.1
Page 9
Matsu;  Thailand and
Turkey.
Symbol Title of document Submitted by
TN/RL/W/64 REPLIES TO THE QUESTIONS MADE BY
THE AUSTRALIAN DELEGATION
IN DOCUMENT TN/RL/W/37Brazil
TN/RL/W/65 KOREA’S COMMENTS ON CANADA’S
SUBMISSION ON THE
ANTI-DUMPING AGREEMENT (TN/RL/W/47)Korea
__________