N,N'-alkylated Imidazolium-derivatives act as quorum-sensing inhibitors targeting the Pectobacterium atrosepticum-induced symptoms on potato tubers.

Yannick Raoul Des Essarts, Mohamad Sabbah, Arnaud Comte, Laurent

Soulère, Yves Queneau, Yves Dessaux, Valérie Hélias, Denis Faure

► To cite this version:

Yannick Raoul Des Essarts, Mohamad Sabbah, Arnaud Comte, Laurent Soulère, Yves Queneau, et al. N,N'-alkylated Imidazolium-derivatives act as quorum-sensing inhibitors targeting the Pectobacterium atrosepticum-induced symptoms on potato tubers. International Journal of Molecular Sciences, 2013, 14 (10), pp.19976-19986. 10.3390/ijms141019976 . hal-00919246

HAL Id: hal-00919246

https://hal.science/hal-00919246

Submitted on 22 Jun 2019

**HAL** is a multi-disciplinary open access
archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-
entific research documents, whether they are pub-
lished or not. The documents may come from
teaching and research institutions in France or
abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L'archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est
destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents
scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,
émanant des établissements d'enseignement et de
recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires
publics ou privés.

<figure><img src="image_1.png" /></figure>
Article

*N*,*N'*-alkylated Imidazolium-Derivatives Act as
Quorum-Sensing Inhibitors Targeting the
*Pectobacterium atrosepticum*-Induced Symptoms on
Potato Tubers

Yannick Raoul des Essarts <fnref n="1" />,<fnref n="2" />, Mohamad Sabbah <fnref n="3" />, Arnaud Comte <fnref n="4" />, Laurent Soulère <fnref n="3" />, Yves Queneau <fnref n="3" />, Yves Dessaux <fnref n="1" />, Valérie Hélias <fnref n="2" />,<fnref n="5" /> and Denis Faure <fnref n="1" />,*

**Abstract:** Bacteria belonging to the *Pectobacterium* genus are the causative agents of the blackleg and soft-rot diseases that affect potato plants and tubers worldwide. In *Pectobacterium*, the expression of the virulence genes is controlled by quorum-sensing (QS) and *N*-acylhomoserine lactones (AHLs). In this work, we screened a chemical library of QS-inhibitors (QSIs) and AHL-analogs to find novel QSIs targeting the virulence of *Pectobacterium*. Four *N*,*N'*-bisalkylated imidazolium salts were identified as QSIs; they were active at the µM range. In potato tuber assays, two of them were able to decrease the

<footnote n="1">¹ Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique, Institut des Sciences du Végétal, UPR 2355, Gif-sur-Yvette 91198, France; E-Mails: yannick.desessarts@isv.cnrs.gif.fr (Y.R.E.); Yves.Dessaux@isv.cnrs.gif.fr (Y.D.)</footnote>

<footnote n="2">² FN3PT/RD3PT, Fédération Nationale des Producteurs de Plants de Pomme de terre, 43-45 Rue de Naples, Paris F-75008, France; E-Mail: valerie.helias@fnpppt.fr</footnote>

<footnote n="3">³ INSA Lyon, ICBMS, UMR 5246, CNRS, Université Lyon 1, INSA-Lyon, CPE-Lyon, Bât J. Verne, 20 av A. Einstein, 69621 Villeurbanne Cedex, France; E-Mails: mohamadsabbah7@hotmail.com (M.S.); laurent.soulere@insa-lyon.fr (L.S.); yves.queneau@insa-lyon.fr (Y.Q.)</footnote>

<footnote n="4">⁴ Service de Chimiothèque, ICBMS, UMR 5246, CNRS, Université Lyon 1, INSA-Lyon, CPE-Lyon, Bât Curien, 43 bd du 11 Novembre 1918, 69622 Villeurbanne Cedex, France; E-Mail: arnaud.comte@univ-lyon1.fr</footnote>

<footnote n="5">5 Institut National de la Recherche Agronomique, UMR 1349IGEPP, Le Rheu F-35653, France</footnote>

<footnote>* Author to whom correspondence should be addressed; E-Mail: faure@isv.cnrs.gif.fr; Tel.: +33-1-69-82-35-77; Fax: +33-1-69-82-36-95.</footnote>
severity of the symptoms provoked by *P. atrosepticum*. This work extends the range of the QSIs acting on the *Pectobacterium*-induced soft-rot disease.

**Keywords:** *N*-acylhomoserine lactone; quorum-sensing; quorum-sensing inhibitor; *Pectobacterium*; soft-rot; potato tuber

**Abbreviations:** 3-OC8-HSL, 3-oxo-octanoyl-L-homoserine lactone; 4-NPO, 4-nitropyridine-*N*-oxide; AC₅₀, half maximal activity concentration; AHL, *N*-acyl homoserine lactone; DMSO, dimethylsulfoxide; GIₐC₅₀, growth index at the AC₅₀ concentration; MBC, minimal bactericidal concentration; MIC, minimal inhibitory concentration; OD₆₀₀, optical density at a wavelength of 600 nm; Pa6276, *P. atrosepticum* CFBP6276; QS, quorum-sensing; QSI, quorum sensing-inhibitor.

# 1. Introduction

Causative agents of the blackleg and soft-rot diseases of potato belong to the *Pectobacterium* and *Dickeya* genera [1]. These soft-rot enterobacteria produce *N*-acyl homoserine lactones (AHLs), mainly 3-oxo-octanoyl-L-homoserine lactone (3-OC8-HSL) [2,3]. In *P. carotovorum* subsp. *carotovorum* and *P. atrosepticum* populations, AHLs are involved in the expression of virulence factors, including plant cell-wall degrading enzymes, such as cellulases and pectinases [4,5]. This cell-to-cell communication that involves the production, exchange and perception of AHL signals is termed quorum sensing (QS) [6].

Several quorum-quenching strategies have been proposed to interfere with the QS-regulated expression of the virulence factors in *Pectobacterium*. They encompass the construction of transgenic plants that express bacterial AHL-degrading enzymes, such as lactonases [7], the identification and biostimulation of soil AHL-degrading bacteria that could act as biocontrol agents, such as *Bacillus thuringiensis* and *Rhodococcus erythropolis* [8–10], and the identification and synthesis of natural and synthetic compounds acting as quorum-sensing inhibitors (QSIs) [11–13]. In contrast with the abundant literature on QSIs targeting the human pathogen *Pseudomonas aeruginosa* [14–16], only a few QSIs that efficiently reduce the *Pectobacterium*-induced symptoms have been described. Noticeably, some archetypical QSIs active on *Pseudomonas* or other pathogens do not diminish the severity of the *Pectobacterium*-induced symptoms [17], a feature that stresses the importance of the identification of dedicated QSIs targeting this plant pathogen.

In this work, we constructed and used a *Pectobacterium* AHL-biosensor to screen a collection of synthetic AHL and QSI derivatives and identifying QSIs of which the protective activity against the *Pectobacterium*-induced symptoms was evaluated in potato-tuber maceration assays.

# 2. Results and Discussion

## 2.1. *Construction of the Pectobacterium AHL-Biosensor*

We constructed a *Pectobacterium* AHL-biosensor that exhibited the two typical characteristics of the current QS signals biosensor, i.e., (i) it was defective for the synthesis of its own AHL signal;
(ii) it was able to produce a measurable reporting activity that correlated with the concentrations of the added AHLs in the culture medium. In *P. atrosepticum* CFBP6276, the genome sequence of which has been published [18], the *expI* gene encodes the synthase responsible for the biosynthesis of the AHL-signals that are required for the expression of the virulence factors and induction of the plant symptoms on potato tubers [5]. In the *expI* mutant CFBP6276-EI [19], we introduced the plasmid pME6031-*rsmA::uidA* that was generated by cloning the *rsmA::uidA* reporting fusion in the broad range vector pME6031. In *P. atrosepticum*, the *rsmA*-promoter is down-regulated in the presence of AHLs [20]. Hence, in the resulting *Pectobacterium* AHL-biosensor, the *uidA*-encoded glucuronidase activity was expressed at a high level in the absence of AHLs, and decreased after addition of AHLs in the culture medium. QSI molecules should therefore increase the expression of glucuronidase in the presence of AHLs.

<figure><img src="image_2.png" /><figcaption>**Figure 1.** Structure of the used quorum sensing (QS)-molecule and identified quorum sensing-inhibitors (QSIs). (a) The 3-OC8-HSL is the *N*-acyl homoserine lactone (AHL) used as the QS-signal. (b) Structure of the identified QSIs. (c) 4-NPO, used as a QSI reference.</figcaption></figure>

## 2.2. QSIs Identification

A chemical library of 240 molecules was generated based on AHLs and known QSI structures; it consisted in carboxamides, sulfonamides, sulfonylurea, reverse amides, triazoles, tetrazoles, bromoenamines, bromofuranones and imidazolium derivatives (see experimental section). This library was screened with the above described QS signal-biosensor *P. atrosepticum* CFBP6276-EI (pME6031-*rsmA::uidA*) in the presence of 3-OC8-HSL at 1.5 µM. Using the compounds of the library at 100 µM, 67 putative QSIs were found to restore glucuronidase activity in the *Pectobacterium* QS-biosensor in the presence of AHLs. In the course of this screening, 4-nitropyridine-*N*-oxide
(4-NPO) was used as a control QSI (Figure 1) [17]. The identified compounds were thereafter tested at lower concentrations (50, 10, 2.5, and 0.1 µM). At 10, 2.5, and 0.1 µM, none variations of the reporting activity were observed. At 50 µM, the higher glucuronidase activities were measured in the presence of the compounds 29-L-A06, 29-L-A11, 29-L-B02 and 29-L-C03. All of these compounds were imidazolium-derivatives which exhibit bis-N-substitution with a polyaromatic group and an aliphatic chain (Figure 1). These compounds were designed by analogy to calmidazolium previously identified as QSI by virtual screening [21]. Their synthesis involved two successive N-alkylation of imidazole, with variations in the aromatic moiety (halogenations, fluorenyl) on one nitrogen atom, and variations in the alkyl chain length on the other nitrogen atom. Both substitutions were found to influence the QSI activity when tested in a modified *E. coli* strain which expresses the *Vibrio fisheri* QS-system. Indeed, a stronger QSI-activity was found for shorter chains when the aromatic residue was larger (highly halogenated), or for longer chains when the aromatic residue was smaller (unsubstituted or sterically constrained) [22].

### 2.3. Biological Effects of the Identified QSIs on Pectobacterium Cells

For the calculation of the half maximal activity concentration (AC₅₀), the activity of the reporter gene *uidA* was measured in the presence of different concentrations of QSIs (0.1 to 100 µM). In addition, cell density (OD₆₀₀) of the cultures was measured in the absence and presence of the QSIs at the AC₅₀ concentrations. These values were used to calculate a growth index (GIₐ₅₀) and evaluate growth inhibition of the QSIs; a ratio value of 1 indicates that the growth of the bacteria is not affected by the presence of the QSI added at the AC₅₀ concentration. The AC₅₀ values of the four imidazolium-compounds ranged between 14 and 20 µM (Table1). The GIₐ₅₀ values (from 0.93 to 0.99) were not statistically different (Kruskal Wallis test α = 5%) from those of the control cultures without QSIs (GIcontrol = 1.00), suggesting that the cell growth was not affected near the AC₅₀ concentrations. As a reminder, the AHL concentration in this assay was strictly controlled by the addition of pure 3-OC8-HSL at 1.5 µM in the culture medium, hence the reporting activity of the *Pectobacterium* AHL-biosensor could not be altered by a variation of the AHL level. Moreover, an antibacterial activity should decrease glucuronidase activity by killing the cells; by contrast, imidazolium derivatives increase this reporting activity which is the opposite effect of potential antibacterial activity. All these observations allow us to suggest that the identified molecules could act as QSIs under our experimental conditions. We also observed that the already known QSI 4-NPO that was active in *P. aeruginosa* [23] was less efficient than were the identified imidazolium-derivatives against the QS-regulated gene *rsmA::uidA* of *Pectobacterium*.

The minimal inhibitory concentration (MIC) and minimal bactericidal concentration (MBC) were measured for all QSIs in *P. atrocepticum*. The QSI 29-L-B02 exhibited MIC and MBC values lower than the AC₅₀ value, while the other QSIs exhibited MIC and MBC values higher than AC₅₀ values, or comparable in the case of the MIC of 29-L-A11 (Table 1). It should be noticed that the MIC and MBC values were measured after 40-h of culture in the presence of QSIs, hence at the end of the growth cycle of the bacteria when nutrients became limiting. In contrast, GIₐ₅₀ and AC₅₀ values were measured during exponential growth of the bacteria. The apparent higher sensitivity of the *Pectobacterium*
cells when grown under MIC and MBC conditions as compared to $GI_{AC50}$ and $AC_{50}$ conditions could be explained by the physiological status of the cells.

<table><caption>**Table 1.** Biological characteristics of the four identified QSIs.</caption><thead><tr><th rowspan="2">Name</th><th colspan="4">Pectobacterium cells</th></tr><tr><th>AC<sub>50</sub><sup>a</sup></th><th>GI<sub>AC50</sub><sup>b</sup></th><th>MIC<sup>a</sup></th><th>MBC<sup>a</sup></th></tr></thead><tbody><tr><td>4-NPO</td><td>&gt;100 (12%)<sup>c</sup></td><td>1.00</td><td>50</td><td>&gt;100</td></tr><tr><td>29-L-A06</td><td>18</td><td>0.94</td><td>25</td><td>25</td></tr><tr><td>29-L-A11</td><td>14</td><td>0.93</td><td>10</td><td>25</td></tr><tr><td>29-L-B02</td><td>16</td><td>0.99</td><td>&lt;2.5</td><td>2.5</td></tr><tr><td>29-L-C03</td><td>20</td><td>0.93</td><td>25</td><td>25</td></tr></tbody></table>

<sup>a</sup> Values are expressed in µM; <sup>b</sup> Growth index ($GI_{AC50}$) is the ratio of cell densities of bacterial cultures performed in the presence of QSIs at the $AC_{50}$ concentrations to those obtained without QSI; <sup>c</sup> In brackets, inhibition (%) at 100 µM, which is the maximal concentration tested in this study.

## 2.4. QSIs Could Moderate the P. atrosepticum-Induced Symptoms in Potato Tubers

The four QSIs were tested for their capacity to limit the QS-associated symptoms induced by the plant pathogen *P. atrosepticum* CFBP6276 on potato tubers (Figure 2). The QSI 29-L-B02 that exhibited MIC and MBC values lower than $AC_{50}$, did not protect the tubers against the plant pathogen, as the severity of the symptoms was similar to that observed in the absence of QSI (Figure 2). This observation suggested that under the tested conditions the introduced bacterial cells ($10^7$ cells at the infection site) were still able to multiply and express the QS-regulated virulence factors in the tuber assay, even in the presence of a potential bacteriostatic and bactericidal delivery of the inhibitory molecule at 20 µM. By contrast, two other QSIs, 29-L-A11 and 29-L-C03 that exhibited a lower bacteriostatic and bactericidal activity than 29-L-B02, reduced (but did not abolish) the severity of the symptoms (Figure 2). The limitation of QS-dependent symptoms was therefore not correlated with the potential bacteriostatic and bactericidal activity of the identified compounds, and could reflect their QSI-activity.

These imidazolium-derivatives were also efficient at the µM range to disrupt QS-signaling in the marine bacterium *Vibrio fisheri* that uses 3-oxo-hexanoyl-L-homoserine lactone as a QS-signal [19]. This feature suggests that they may be used as a structural backbone for the generation of broad range QSIs. Polyaromatic compounds have been frequently described as QSIs. As natural compounds, they have been identified in many organisms, especially plants [14]. As synthetic compounds, they have been revealed by chemical library and virtual (in silico) screenings [14,21].

This work extends the spectrum of QSIs targeting the QS-controlled virulence of the plant pathogen *Pectobacterium* [11–13]. Aside the *P. atrosepticum* and *P. carotovorum* species in which QS plays a key-role in virulence, QS has been also involved in a partial regulation of virulence in *D. dianthicola* and the emerging pathogen *Dickeya solani*, which are other causative agents of the soft-rot and blackleg diseases in potato cultures [3]. The QSI-treatment may be proposed as a complement of other QS-targeting approaches such as the use of biocontrol agents and transgenic plants which are able to degrade the QS-signals [7–10]. All the proposed anti-QS strategies remain to be evaluated under green house and field conditions.
**Figure 2.** QSIs and soft-rot tuber assay. Each tuber of *S.tuberosum* was inoculated with 10⁷ cells of *P. atrosepticum* CFBP6276 (Pa6276) in the absence and presence of the QSIs at 20 µM. The uninfected tubers were used a negative control. The virulence symptoms are categorized according a four-category scale. The different letters indicate the symptoms of QSI-treated conditions which were statistically different to those obtained in the presence of Pa6276 alone (Kruskal and Wallis test, α = 5% or 10%).

<figure><img src="image_3.png" /></figure>

**3. Experimental Section**

**3.1. Bacterial Strains and Growth Conditions**

*P. atrosepticum* CFBP6276 and its derivative CFBP6276-EI in which the *expI* gene was disrupted [19] were cultivated in TY medium (tryptone 5 g/L, yeast extract 3 g/L). The *Pectobacterium* QS-biosensor was obtained by electroporating the constructed plasmid pME6031-*rsmA*::*uidA* in the *expI* mutant CFBP6276-EI. Antibiotics were used at the following concentrations: kanamycin, 50 µg/mL; tetracycline, 10 µg/mL.

**3.2. Chemical Library**

The chemical library of the ICBMS (Université de Lyon, INSA, Villeurbanne, France) contained 240 synthetic derivatives of AHLs or known QSIs. These chemicals were kept in DMSO stock solutions (10 mM) at -20 °C. The library includes various types of QS agonists or antagonists, either structurally related to AHL (carboxamides, sulfonamides, urea, sulfonylurea, reverse amides, triazoles
or tetrazoles), or bromoenamines and bromofuranones designed by analogy to natural compounds known as QSI [24–31]. This latter category includes the imidazolium derivatives found to be active in this study and designed as analogues of calmidazolium which were identified as QSIs by virtual (in silico) screening [21,22].

### 3.3. Screening for QSIs

Compounds of the chemical library were individually assayed for QSI-activity at two concentrations (100 µM and 0.1 µM) in 96-microwell plates in the presence of the AHL 3-OC8-HSL at 1.5 µM and the *Pectobacterium* QS-biosensor. After 4 h of incubation at 30 °C, β-glucuronidase activities were measured using the appropriate substrate 4-nitrophenyl-β-D-glucuronide, as previously described [32]. The 4-nitropyridine-*N*-oxide (4-NPO) was used as a QSI reference [23]. The added DMSO did not exceed 5% of the total volume of culture medium and did not alter the bacterial growth.

### 3.4. Measurement of AC₅₀, GIₐC₅₀, MIC and MBC Values of the QSIs

In the case of the *Pectobacterium* QS-biosensor, half maximal activity concentrations (AC₅₀) were calculated using QSI concentrations ranging from 0.1 to 100 µM. At the AC₅₀ concentrations, the growth index (GIₐC₅₀) was calculated as the ratio of the OD₆₀₀nm mean-values measured for bacterial cultures performed with and without QSI. Toxicity of these compounds was also evaluated by measuring the minimal inhibitory concentration (MIC) and minimal bactericidal concentration (MBC). MICs, which are the lowest concentrations of QSI inhibiting any visible growth after 40 h of incubation at 30 °C, were estimated by culturing 10⁵ CFU/mL of the *Pectobacterium* cells in the presence of different concentrations of QSI. MBCs, which are the lowest concentrations of QSI (µM) that result in a 99.9% reduction of the initial bacterial population (10⁵ CFU/mL) after 40 h of incubation at 30 °C in the presence of different concentrations of QSI, were estimated by plating 100 µL of the *Pectobacterium* cultures onto agar TY plates. After an incubation of 24 or 48 h at 30 °C, CFU were enumerated and the MBC values calculated.

### 3.5. Virulence Assays on Potato Tubers

Potato tubers of *S. tuberosum* var. Bintje (length 35 to 45 mm, CNPPT/SIPRE, Achicourt, France) were surface sterilized by washing in a diluted commercial bleach solution for 10 min. Next, the potatoes were rinsed once with sterile water and allowed to dry at room temperature overnight. An overnight culture (25 °C; 200 rpm) of the *P. atrosepticum* wild-type strain CFBP6276 in TY medium was collected by centrifugation (room temperature, 4000 rpm, 15 min) and washed twice using 0.8% NaCl. The bacterial pellet was resuspended in 0.8% NaCl (room temperature, 4000 rpm, 15 min). Each tuber (n = 10 per conditions) was inoculated with 10⁷ CFU of *P. atrosepticum* in presence of the QSIs at 20 µM. The infected tubers were incubated at 25 °C in a water saturated atmosphere. Five days post-infection, the tubers were cut in the middle, photographed and the soft-rot symptoms were categorized using a virulence scale that contained four categories, depending on the diameter (D) of the maceration zone around the infection site: 1, no maceration; 2, low maceration (D < 2 mm);
3, moderate maceration (D < 5 mm) and 4, strong maceration (D ≥ 5 mm). The Kruskal and Wallis
statistical test with α = 5 or 10% allowed the statistical analysis of symptoms on potato tubers.

**4. Conclusions**

Our work highlighted a novel family of QSI that limit *Pectobacterium*-induced symptoms in the potato tubers. The identified QSIs are *N*,*N*'-bisalkylated imidazolium salts which exhibited QSI-activity when used under sub-lethal concentrations. Future works should evaluate the QSI strategy under greenhouse and field conditions, especially in combination with biocontrol-strategies [33–36] to limit the symptoms caused by the pathogens *Pectobacterium* and *Dickeya*.

**Acknowledgments**

The authors thank *Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique* (CNRS-France), *Agence nationale de la recherche* (ANR – project ECORUM - ANR 11-BSV7-019), Fédération Nationale des Producteurs de Plants de Pomme de Terre (FN3PT/RD3PT) and *Association Nationale de la Recherche et de la Technologie* (ANRT-CIFRE n°1282/2011) for financial supports. Potato tubers were kindly supplied by CNPPT/SIPRE.

**Conflicts of Interest**

The authors declare no conflict of interest.

**References**

1. Pérombelon, M.C.M. Potato diseases caused by soft rot erwinias: An overview of pathogenesis. *Plant Pathol. 2002*, *51*, 1–12.

2. Põllumaa, L.; Alamäe, T.; Mäe, A. Quorum sensing and expression of virulence in pectobacteria. *Sensors* **2012**, *12*, 3327–3349.

3. Crépin, A.; Beury-Cirou, A.; Barbey, C.; Farmer, C.; Hélias, V.; Burini, J.F.; Faure, D.; Latour, X. *N*-Acyl homoserine lactones in diverse *Pectobacterium* and *Dickeya* plant pathogens: Diversity, abundance, and involvement in virulence. *Sensors* **2012**, *12*, 3484–3497.

4. Liu, H.; Coulthurst, S.J.; Pritchard, L.; Hedley, P.E.; Ravensdale, M.; Humphris, S.; Burr, T.; Takle, G.; Brurberg, M.B.; Birch, P.R.J.; et al. Quorum sensing coordinates brute force and stealth modes of infection in the plant pathogen *Pectobacterium atrosepticum*. *PLoS Pathog.* **2008**, *4*, e1000093.

5. Smadja, B.; Latour, X.; Faure, D.; Chevalier, S.; Dessaux, Y.; Orange, N. Involvement of *N*-acylhomoserine lactones throughout the plant infection by *Erwinia carotovora* subsp. *atroseptica* (*Pectobacterium atrosepticum*). *Mol. Plant-Microbe Interact.* **2004**, *17*, 1269–1278.

6. Fuqua, W.C.; Winans, S.C.; Greenberg, E.P. Quorum sensing in bacteria: The LuxR-LuxI family of cell density-responsive transcriptional regulators. *J. Bacteriol.* **1994**, *176*, 269–275.

7. Dong, Y.H.; Wang, L.H.; Xu, J.L.; Zhang, H.B.; Zhang, X.F.; Zhang, L.H. Quenching quorum-sensing-dependent bacterial infection by an *N*-acyl homoserinelactonase. *Nature* **2001**, *411*, 813–817.
8. Uroz, S.; D'Angelo-Picard, C.; Carlier, A.; Elasri, M.; Sicot, C.; Petit, A.; Oger, P.; Faure, D.; Dessaux, Y. Novel bacteria degrading *N*-acylhomoserine lactones and their use as quenchers of quorum-sensing-regulated functions of plant-pathogenic bacteria. *Microbiology* **2003**, *149*, 1981–1989.

9. Dong, Y.H.; Zhang, X.F.; Xu, J.L.; Zhang, L.H. Insecticidal *Bacillus thuringiensis* silences *Erwinia carotovora* virulence by a new form of microbial antagonism, signal interference. *Appl. Environ. Microbiol.* **2004**, *70*, 954–960.

10. Cirou, A.; Diallo, S.; Kurt, C.; Latour, X.; Faure, D. Growth promotion of quorum-quenching bacteria in the rhizosphere of *Solanum tuberosum*. *Environ. Microbiol.* **2007**, *9*, 1511–1522.

11. Manefield, M.; Welch, M.; Givskov, M.; Salmond, G.P.; Kjelleberg, S. Halogenated furanones from the red alga, *Delisea pulchra*, inhibit carbapenem antibiotic synthesis and exoenzyme virulence factor production in the phytopathogen *Erwinia carotovora*. *FEMS Microbiol. Lett.* **2001**, *205*, 131–138.

12. Palmer, A.G.; Streng, E.; Jewell, K.A.; Blackwell, H.E. Quorum sensing in bacterial species that use degenerate autoinducers can be tuned by using structurally identical non-native ligands. *Chembiochem* **2011**, *12*, 138–147.

13. Palmer, A.G.; Streng, E.; Blackwell, H.E. Attenuation of virulence in pathogenic bacteria using synthetic quorum-sensing modulators under native conditions on plant hosts. *ACS Chem. Biol.* **2011**, *6*, 1348–1356.

14. Kalia, V.C. Quorum sensing inhibitors: An overview. *Biotechnol. Adv.* **2013**, *31*, 224–245.

15. Stevens, A.M.; Queneau, Y.; Soulère, L.; von Bodman, S.; Doutheau, A. Mechanisms and synthetic modulators of AHL-dependent gene regulation. *Chem. Rev.* **2011**, *111*, 4–27.

16. Galloway, W.R.; Hodgkinson, J.T.; Bowden, S.D.; Welch, M.; Spring, D.R. Quorum sensing in gram-negative bacteria: Small-molecule modulation of AHL and AI-2 Quorum sensing pathways. *Chem. Rev.* **2011**, *111*, 28–67.

17. Rasch, M.; Rasmussen, T.B.; Andersen, J.B.; Persson, T.; Nielsen, J.; Givskov, M.; Gram, L. Well-known quorum sensing inhibitors do not affect bacterial quorum sensing-regulated bean sprout spoilage. *J. Appl. Microbiol.* **2007**, *102*, 826–837.

18. Kwasiborski, A.; Mondy, S.; Beury-Cirou, A.; Faure, D. Genome sequence of the *Pectobacterium atrosepticum* strain CFBP6276, causing blackleg and soft rot diseases on potato plants and tubers. *Genome Announc.* **2013**, *1*, doi:10.1128/genomeA.00374-13.

19. Latour, X.; Diallo, S.; Chevalier, S.; Morin, D.; Smadja, B.; Burini, J.F.; Haras, D.; Orange, N. Thermoregulation of *N*-acyl homoserine lactones-based quorum sensing in the soft rot bacterium *Pectobacterium atrosepticum*. *Appl. Environ. Microbiol.* **2007**, *73*, 4078–4081.

20. Cui, Y.; Chatterjee, A.; Hasegawa, H.; Chatterjee, A.K. *Erwinia carotovora* subspecies produce duplicate variants of ExpR, LuxR homologs that activate *rsmA* transcription but differ in their interactions with *N*-acylhomoserine lactone signals. *J. Bacteriol.* **2006**, *188*, 4715–4726.

21. Soulère, L.; Sabbah, M.; Fontaine, F.; Queneau, Y.; Doutheau, A. LuxR-dependent quorum sensing: Computer aided discovery of new inhibitors structurally unrelated to *N*-acylhomoserine lactones. *Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett.* **2010**, *20*, 4355–4358.

22. Sabbah, M.; Soulère, L.; Reverchon, S.; Queneau, Y.; Doutheau, A. LuxR dependent quorum sensing inhibition by *N,N'*-disubstituted imidazolium salts. *Bioorg. Med. Chem.* **2011**, *19*, 4868–4875.
23. Rasmussen, T.B.; Bjarnsholt, T.; Skindersoe, M.E.; Hentzer, M.; Kristoffersen, P.; Ko, M.; Nielsen, J.; Eberl, L.; Givskov, M. Screening for Quorum-sensing snhibitors (QSI) by use of a novel genetic system, the QSI selector. *J. Bacteriol.* **2005**, *187*, 1799–1814.

24. Reverchon, S.; Chantegrel, B.; Deshayes, C.; Doutheau, A.; Cotte-Pattat, N. New synthetic analogues of *N*-acyl homoserine lactones as agonists or antagonists of transcriptional regulators involved in bacterial quorum sensing. *Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett.* **2002**, *12*, 1153–1157.

25. Castang, S.; Chantegrel, B.; Deshayes, C.; Dolmazon, R.; Gouet, P.; Haser, R.; Reverchon, S.; Nasser, W.; Hugouvieux-Cotte-Pattat, N.; Doutheau, A. *N*-sulfonylhomoserine lactones as antagonists of bacterial quorum sensing. *Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett.* **2004**, *14*, 5145–5149.

26. Frezza, M.; Castang, S.; Estephane, J.; Soulère, L.; Deshayes, C.; Chantegrel, B.; Nasser, W.; Queneau, Y.; Reverchon, S.; Doutheau, A. Synthesis and biological evaluation of homoserine lactone derived ureas as antagonists of bacterial quorum sensing. *Bioorg. Med. Chem.* **2006**, *14*, 4781–4791.

27. Frezza, M.; Soulère, L.; Reverchon, S.; Guiliani, N.; Jerez, C.; Queneau, Y.; Doutheau, A. Synthetichomoserine lactone-derived sulfonylureas as inhibitors of *Vibrio fischeri* quorum sensing regulator. *Bioorg. Med. Chem.* **2008**, *16*, 3550–3556.

28. Boukraa, M.; Sabbah, M.; Soulère, L.; El Efrit, M.L.; Queneau, Y.; Doutheau, A. AHL-dependent quorum sensing inhibition: Synthesis and biological evaluation of α-(*N*-alkyl-carboxamide)-γ-butyrolactones and α-(*N*-alkyl-sulfonamide)-γ-butyrolactones. *Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett.* **2011**, *21*, 6876–6879.

29. Sabbah, M.; Fontaine, F.; Grand, L.; Boukraa, M.; Efrit, M.L.; Doutheau, A.; Soulère, L.; Queneau, Y. Synthesis and biological evaluation as LuxR-dependent Quorum-Sensing modulators of new *N*-acyl-homoserine-lactone analogues based on triazole and tetrazole scaffolds. *Bioorg. Med. Chem.* **2012**, *20*, 4727–4736.

30. Estephane, J.; Dauvergne, J.; Soulere, L.; Reverchon, S.; Queneau, Y.; Doutheau, A. *N*-Acyl-3-amino-5*H*-furanone derivatives as new inhibitors of LuxR-dependent quorum sensing: Synthesis, biological evaluation and binding mode study. *Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett.* **2008**, *18*, 4321–4324.

31. Sabbah, M.; Bernollin, M.; Doutheau, A.; Soulère, L.; Queneau, Y. A new route towards fimbrolide analogues: Importance of the exomethylene motif in LuxR dependent quorum sensing inhibition. *Med. Chem. Comm.* **2013**, *4*, 363–366.

32. Tannières, M.; Beury-Cirou, A.; Vigouroux, A.; Mondy, S.; Pellissier, F.; Dessaux, Y.; Faure, D. A metagenomic study highlights phylogenetic proximity of quorum-quenching and xenobiotic-degrading amidases of the AS-family. *PLoS One* **2013**, *8*, e65473.

33. Wood, E.M.; Miles, T.D.; Wharton, P.S. The use of natural plant volatile compounds for the control of the potato postharvest diseases, black dot, silver scurf and soft rot. *Biol. Control* **2013**, *64*, 152–159.

34. Cirou, A.; Mondy, S.; An, S.; Charrier, A.; Sarrazin, A.; Thoison, O.; DuBow, M.; Faure, D. Efficient biostimulation of the native and introduced quorum-quenching *Rhodococcus erythropolis* revealed by a combination of analytical chemistry, microbiology and pyrosequencing. *Appl. Environ. Microbiol.* **2012**, *78*, 481–492.
35. Cirou, A.; Raffoux, A.; Diallo, S.; Latour, X.; Dessaux, Y.; Faure, D. Gamma-caprolactone stimulates the growth of quorum-quenching *Rhodococcus* populations in a large-scale hydroponic system for culturing *Solanum tuberosum*. *Res. Microbiol.* **2011**, *162*, 945–950.

36. Jafra, S.; Przysowa, J.; Czajkowski, R.; Michta, A.; Garbeva, P.; van Der Wolf, J.M. Detection and characterization of *N*-acyl homoserinelactone-degrading bacteria from the potato rhizosphere. *Can. J. Microbiol.* **2006**, *52*, 1006–1015.

© 2013 by the authors; licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/).