# Human-Robot Interaction Enhancement Through Ergonomics and Human Factors: Future Directions

Okpala Charles Chikwendu, O C Ezeanyim, Nkemakonam Chidiebube Igbokwe

► To cite this version:

Okpala Charles Chikwendu, O C Ezeanyim, Nkemakonam Chidiebube Igbokwe. Human-Robot Interaction Enhancement Through Ergonomics and Human Factors: Future Directions. International Journal of Engineering Research and Development, 2023, 19 (6), pp.34-40. hal-04348897

HAL Id: hal-04348897

https://hal.science/hal-04348897v1

Submitted on 19 Dec 2023

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access
archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-
entific research documents, whether they are pub-
lished or not. The documents may come from
teaching and research institutions in France or
abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L'archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est
destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents
scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,
émanant des établissements d'enseignement et de
recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires
publics ou privés.

<figure><img src="image_1.png" /></figure>

Distributed under a Creative Commons CC BY 4.0 - Attribution - International License
# Human-Robot Interaction Enhancement Through Ergonomics and Human Factors: Future Directions

Okpala Charles Chikwendu, Ezeanyim Okechukwu Chiedu, and
Igbokwe Nkemakonam Chidiebube

Correspondence Address
Industrial/Production Engineering Department
NnamdiAzikiwe University, P.M.B. 5025 Awka
Anambra State - Nigeria.

**Abstract**

As the field of robotics continues to advance, the design of Human-Robot Interfaces (HRIs) becomes increasingly crucial for seamless and efficient collaboration. This article explores the pivotal role of ergonomics and human factors in shaping HRIs, emphasizing the significance of user-centered design for optimal Human-Robot Interaction (HRI). By examining key principles and emerging trends in this interdisciplinary domain, the research aims to provide insights that can guide the development of intuitive, safe, and effective HRIs. The work further explores the pivotal role of ergonomics and human factors in enhancing human-robot interaction. By delving into the collaborative efforts between these fields, the paper aims to unravel the complexities of designing robots that not only align with human physical capabilities, but also cater for the intricate nuances of human cognition and social dynamics. Through an inter-disciplinary approach, man can unlock the full potential of human-robot collaboration, paving the way for a future where robots seamlessly augment human capabilities across various domains.

**Keywords:** ergonomics, human factors, human-robot interaction, user-centered design, cognitive ergonomics, safety, trust, emerging trends

## I. Introduction

In the rapidly evolving landscape of robotics and artificial intelligence, the synergy between humans and robots has become increasingly integral to various industries, ranging from manufacturing and healthcare to service and entertainment. Human-Robot Interaction (HRI) stands at the forefront of this technological convergence, presenting both unprecedented opportunities and unique challenges. Colceriu et al. (2023), observed that mobile collaborative robots (cobots) enhances the potential for assembly works in industries. They pointed out that for human-friendly automation of cooperative assembly work, user-centered interfaces are quite necessary. To optimize this interaction, researchers and engineers are turning to the principles of ergonomics and human factors, recognizing their pivotal role in designing systems that seamlessly integrate with human capabilities, preferences, and comfort.

Defined as the science of designing tools and systems to fit the human body and its cognitive functions, ergonomics plays a crucial role in shaping the physical aspects of human-robot interfaces.

Okpala, Igbokwe, and Nwankwo (2023), explained that in an era characterized by rapid technological advancements, the integration of artificial intelligence into diverse industries has emerged as a transformative force that reshapes traditional paradigms and drive unprecedented innovation. They pointed out that one such sector at the forefront of AI revolution is manufacturing, where intelligent automation, predictive analytics, and machine learning algorithms are redefining the way products are designed, produced, and optimized. By tailoring robotic designs to align with human anatomy and movement patterns, ergonomics contributes to the creation of user-friendly and efficient interfaces. This ensures that human operators can interact with robots intuitively, minimizing physical strain and maximizing overall performance. According to Okpala and Ihueze (2017), the main objective of ergonomics is the optimization of man-machine integration, in order to enhance precision and rate of work.

Human factors, on the other hand, delve into the psychological and cognitive aspects of HRI. The International Ergonomics Association (2010), defined human factors as "the scientific discipline concerned with the understanding of interactions among humans and other elements of a system, and the profession that applies theory, principles, data, and other methods to design, in order to optimize human well-being and overall system
performance.” Understanding human behavior, perception, and decision-making processes allows engineers to design robots that seamlessly integrate into various social contexts, fostering trust and cooperation.

Improperly designed robots and machines which hamper seamless relationship between man and machine often lead to musculoskeletal disorders. Godwin and Okpala(2014), defined musculoskeletal disorders as cumulative degenerative disorders, which results from repetitive workactivities and work conditions over a long period of time, thereby leading to body pains, impairments, as well as subsequent decreasein production output. Human factors research provides valuable insights into how users perceive and respond to robots, enabling the development of emotionally intelligent machines that can adapt to diverse social environments.

Human-robot collaboration is becoming integral in various domains, ranging from manufacturing and healthcare to service and entertainment. The success of these collaborations hinges on the design of HRIs that prioritize user experience, safety, and efficiency. Ergonomics and human factors principles play a central role in achieving these objectives by tailoring interfaces to human capabilities, preferences, and limitations.

## II. Human-Centered Design in HRIs

Human-Centered Design (HCD) plays a crucial role in shaping positive and effective human-robot interactions (HRI). Dalberg (2023), defined HCD as a way of thinking that places the people one is trying to serve and other important stakeholders at the center of a design, innovation and implementation process. User-centered design principles form the foundation of effective HRIs, as it is based on understanding user needs, preferences, and cognitive abilities in designing interfaces that facilitate natural and intuitive interaction between humans and robots. As technology advances and robots become increasingly integrated into various aspects of human lives, it becomes imperative to prioritize the user experience and ensure that these interactions are intuitive, efficient, and, most importantly, human-centric.

Boschetti, Faccio, and Granata (2022), explained that the safety problem is still one of the biggest issues in collaborative robotics, as the operator works directly with the cobot, sharing the place and the time. They observed that this, of course, can lead to an improvement in the flexibility and in productivity of the system, as the operators have to be put at the center of the design techniques in order to maximize their wellness. Also, Villani et al. (2018), explained that safety, intuitive interfaces, which includes input modes, outputs, feedback, and programming approaches, together with innovative design and control methods, are the major ingredients and challenges for the upcoming development and implementation of collaborative production technologies.

HCD in human-robot interactions commences with a deep understanding of user needs and the context in which the interaction takes place. Designers must consider the environment, the tasks the robot is expected to perform, and the characteristics of the users involved. According to Huttenrauch (2006), HCD entails designing an interaction with a robot and its interfaces so that both are perceived as usable, as people that are expected to use a system should consequently be incorporated in the design process, because their inputs in the form of expressed need forms the baseline of features that will be considered for iterative development and evaluation cycles. He noted that users of future robotic system thus become active participants right from the design process.

The interface between humans and robots is a critical component of HRI. Designers should create interfaces that are user-friendly, visually intuitive, and require minimal cognitive effort. This includes the design of physical interfaces, such as buttons and touchscreens, as well as the design of virtual interfaces for communication and control. Also, human-robot interactions should mimic natural human communication patterns. This involves designing robots that can understand and respond to human gestures, facial expressions, and vocal cues. The goal is to make the interaction as seamless and natural as possible, thereby reducing the learning curve for users.

The need for adaptability and personalization is very in successful HCD in HRIs, as they should account for the diversity of users and their preferences. Robots should be adaptable to different users and customizable to individual needs. This adaptability enhances user satisfaction and ensures that the technology is inclusive and accessible to a wide range of people. The provision of clear and timely feedback is essential for effective communication between humans and robots. According to Scalise (2017), "one approach to improving understandability is to enable robots to directly explain their behaviors, either proactively, or in response to a query." Designers should therefore incorporate feedback mechanisms that inform users about the robot's status, actions, and intentions. This can include visual signals, sounds, or even haptic feedback, depending on the context.

Transparency in the functioning of robots is vital for building trust between humans and machines. Users should have a clear understanding of how the robot makes decisions and carries out tasks. This transparency fosters trust, which is crucial for the acceptance and successful integration of robots into human environments. On safety and ethical considerations, HCD must prioritize the safety of users in human-robot interactions. This involves designing robots with built-in safety features, as well as considering ethical
implications, such as privacy concerns. Designers should adhere to ethical guidelines and regulations to ensure that robots are deployed responsibly.

As HCD is an iterative process that involves continuous testing and refinement, designers should gather feedback from users through user testing, observe real-world interactions, and make iterative improvements based on this feedback. This will ensure that the design aligns with user expectations and evolves with changing needs.

### III. Ergonomic Considerations in HRI

Ergonomic considerations play a crucial role in designing effective and safe human-robot interactions, as it ensures that HRIs accommodate the physical and cognitive aspects of human users. As technology advances and robots become more integrated into various aspects of human life, it is essential to prioritize the well-being and comfort of individuals interacting with these machines. Busch, Toussaint, and Lopes (2023), observed that there is a need to form highly effective human-robot teams that combines strengths and competencies of both the robot and its human partner, while at the same time caring for the well-being of the people that are working with robots. They explained that compared to a fully automated assembly line, a robot and human worker team offers flexibility and adaptability to changing activities.

Some major ergonomic considerations in human-robot interactions are discussed below:

**Physical Ergonomics:** For optimal output, efforts should be made to ensure that robots are designed with human anthropometry in mind. This could be achieved by considering the size, reach, as well as the mobility of the robot to match human capabilities. Also, workspaces that accommodate both humans and robots should be created by allowing for comfortable movements, thereby minimizing the risk of physical strain or injury.

**Cognitive Ergonomics:** Design intuitive and user-friendly interfaces that facilitate easy communication between humans and robots that will incorporate touchscreen controls, voice commands, and other interaction methods should be part of the design from the onset. Designers should also implement effective feedback mechanisms to inform users about the robot's actions, status, and intentions. This will effectively reduce cognitive load and enhance situational awareness.

**Safety Considerations:** To forestall collision sensors and algorithms should be integrated to enable collision detection and avoidance, thereby ensuring the safety of both humans and robots in shared spaces. Experience has also revealed that easily accessible emergency stop buttons or gestures to halt robot operations in case of unexpected situations should be incorporated in the design.

**Task Design:** During task allocations, tasks should be assigned based on the strengths and capabilities of both humans and robots. Designers should endeavor to consider the ergonomic implications of repetitive or physically demanding tasks. To enhance collaborative workspace, work environments that promote collaboration between humans and robots, emphasizing shared responsibilities and mutual understanding should be integrated in the design.

**Adaptability and Customization:** To achieve user preferences, users should be allowed to customize robot behavior and settings based on individual preferences, taking into account differences in height, strength, and other personal factors. Also, the implementation of adaptive learning algorithms that enable robots to understand and adapt to the unique working styles of individual users over time should be improved upon.

**Training and Education:** Designers should provide comprehensive training for users to understand how to interact with robots safely and efficiently. This should include guidelines for posture, movement, and communication. To optimize feedback on performance, real-time feedback to users on their interactions with the robot should be offered, this will help them to improve their efficiency thereby avoiding ergonomic issues.

**Long-term Health Considerations:** For improved ergonomic assessments, regular ergonomic assessments to identify and address any issues that may arise over time should be conducted. This will include considering the impact of prolonged HRI on physical and mental well-being.

### IV. Cognitive Ergonomics and Decision Support

Cognitive ergonomics and decision support play crucial roles in enhancing human-robot interactions by optimizing the collaboration between humans and robots. These concepts are particularly significant as technology advances and robots become increasingly integrated into various aspects of man's daily lives, from manufacturing and healthcare to household assistance.

A human-robot interaction for the improvement of ergonomics in the shop floor is depicted in figure 1.
<figure><img src="image_2.png" /><figcaption>Figure 1: A Human-Robot integration for ergonomics improvement. Source: Kim et al. (2022)</figcaption></figure>

**Cognitive Ergonomics:**

Cognitive ergonomics focuses on designing systems that consider the mental processes and capabilities of humans. In the context of human-robot interactions, cognitive ergonomics aims to create interfaces and interactions that align with human cognitive abilities, making it easier for individuals to understand, control, and communicate with robots. It also promotes user-centered design principles, ensuring that robots are designed with the user's mental workload, attention span, and decision-making processes in mind. This approach enhances the overall user experience and reduces the cognitive burden associated with operating robots.

Kim (2022), explained that collaborative robots can automatize repetitive and high-effort tasks and reduce human task load by providing physical assistance, and therefore improve the working conditions of human workers. They noted that on the other hand, humans have better cognitive capability and can therefore supervise robots' operation or transfer new skills to the collaborative robot, thus adding a certain level of flexibility to the process and contributing to effective accomplishment of a broad range of manufacturing tasks.

Cognitive ergonomics also emphasizes the adaptability and flexibility of human-robot systems. Robots should be able to understand and adapt to the user's cognitive state, providing assistance or taking over tasks when the human is overloaded or fatigued. Effective communication is a key component of cognitive ergonomics. Robots need to provide clear and timely feedback to users, using intuitive interfaces and communication methods that align with human cognitive processes. This ensures that users can easily interpret information and make informed decisions.

**Decision Support in Human-Robot Interactions:**

Decision support systems assist humans in making better decisions by providing relevant information, analysis, and recommendations. In the context of HRI, these systems contribute to the collaborative efforts between humans and robots. This entails the integration and analysis of data from various sensors and sources. Robots can process large amounts of data quickly and provide valuable insights to users, thereby aiding in decision-making processes. Decision support systems for HRI should be context-aware, understanding the environment, the user's goals, and the overall situation. This allows robots to provide more relevant and timely information, improving the quality of decisions made by both humans and robots.

The collaboration between humans and robots is not only about the robot assisting the human but also about joint decision-making. Decision support systems should facilitate transparent communication between humans and robots, enabling a shared understanding of the situation and the rationale behind suggested actions. Decision support systems should also take into account ethical considerations in HRI. This includes ensuring that robots provide information in a transparent and unbiased manner, allowing users to make decisions aligned with their values and ethical standards.

The integration of cognitive ergonomics and decision support in human-robot interactions is essential for creating efficient, user-friendly, and ethically sound systems. As robots become more prevalent in various domains, these principles will continue to shape the design and implementation of human-robot collaborative systems.

**V. Emerging Trends in HRI Design**

HRI design is a dynamic field that continually evolves as technology advances and societal needs change. Several emerging trends are shaping the future of HRI, influencing the way humans and robots collaborate and communicate. These trends encompass various aspects of design, including interface development, social integration, and ethical considerations. Here are some key emerging trends in HRI design:
**Natural Language Processing and Understanding:** Advances in Natural Language Processing (NLP) enable robots to understand and respond to human language more effectively. Conversational interfaces, powered by sophisticated algorithms, enhance the ease of communication between humans and robots. This trend focuses on making interactions more intuitive and user-friendly, thereby enabling users to communicate with robots using natural language.

**Emotion Recognition and Expression:** The integration of emotion recognition technology allows robots to perceive and respond to human emotions. This trend involves designing robots that can recognize facial expressions, tone of voice, and other cues to adapt their behaviors accordingly. Emotional intelligence in robots enhances their ability to engage with users in a more empathetic and socially appropriate manner.

**Gesture and Body Language Recognition:** Improvements in computer vision and sensor technologies enable robots to interpret human gestures and body language. This trend emphasizes designing HRI systems that can understand non-verbal cues, making interactions more intuitive and responsive. Robots capable of interpreting gestures can be employed in various applications, such as healthcare, education, and industry.

**Collaborative Robotics (cobots):** Collaborative robots (cobots) are designed to work together with humans in shared shop floors. This trend focuses on creating robots that are safe, adaptable, and easy to work with. Cobots are employed in manufacturing, healthcare, and other industries to enhance productivity while ensuring the safety of human collaborators.

**Socially Assistive Robotics:** Socially assistive robots are designed to provide emotional and social support to users. This trend explores the use of robots in healthcare, therapy, and education to assist individuals with various needs. These robots aim to create positive and supportive interactions, addressing social and emotional aspects of human well-being.

**Ethical HRI Design:** As robots become more integrated into human environments, ethical considerations in HRI design are gaining prominence. This trend involves addressing issues such as privacy, transparency, bias, and accountability in robot behavior. Designers are exploring ways to ensure that robots adhere to ethical principles and respect human values throughout their interactions.

**Augmented Reality (AR) and Virtual Reality (VR) Integration:** Integrating AR and VR technologies into HRI design enhances the user experience by providing immersive environments for interaction. This trend explores how virtual elements can be seamlessly integrated with the physical world to create more engaging and realistic human-robot interactions.

**Personalization and Adaptability:** HRI systems are increasingly designed to be adaptable and personalized to individual users. This trend involves creating robots that can learn from user behavior, preferences, and feedback, allowing for a more tailored and user-centric experience.

**Safety:** HRI designers must ensure that interactions between humans and robots are quite safe. According to Gary (2021), the safety measures includes designing robots that can detect and evade obstacles, as well as designing robots that have in-built safety features like emergency stop buttons.

These emerging trends in HRI design collectively contribute to the development of robots that are not only technically advanced but also socially aware and ethically responsible. As technology continues to progress, the evolution of human-robot interactions will be shaped by a combination of these trends, offering new possibilities for collaboration and co-existence between humans and robots.

# VI. Challenges and Future Directions of HRI

Gary (2021), explained that the major challenge with HRI is designing robots that can comprehend and react to human emotions, as humans are social beings, who apply numerous non-verbal cues, like facial expressions and body language, to communicate with each other. He opined that robots, on the other hand, are programmed to respond to specific commands and may not understand the non-verbal expressions. Human-robot interactions (HRI) have witnessed significant advancements in recent years, leading to the integration of robots into various aspects of our lives. However, this burgeoning field faces numerous challenges, and as technology progresses, new directions and considerations emerge.

## Challenges:

Bigdeli (2023), explained that human-robot interaction represents a compelling frontier in the world of automation, as by addressing the challenges and embracing the opportunities it presents, man will be able to unlock the full potential of this collaboration. Some of these challenges include the following:

### a. Social Acceptance:

* **Challenge:** People may be hesitant to accept robots in social roles due to concerns about job displacement, privacy, and ethical considerations.

* **Future Direction:** Addressing public concerns through transparent communication, establishing ethical guidelines, and emphasizing the complementary nature of robots in enhancing human capabilities.

### b. Natural Language Processing:
* **Challenge:** Understanding and responding to natural language in various contexts remains a complex challenge for robots.

* **Future Direction:** Advancements in natural language processing, sentiment analysis, and context-aware communication to enable more intuitive and nuanced interactions.

c. **Human-Centric Design:**

* **Challenge:** Designing robots that are user-friendly and adaptable to diverse human preferences and cultural differences.

* **Future Direction:** Emphasizing user-centric design principles, involving end-users in the design process, and creating culturally sensitive robots.

d. **Safety and Trust:**

* **Challenge:** Ensuring the safety of human-robot interactions and building trust between humans and robots.

* **Future Direction:** Implementing robust safety features, integrating explainable AI to enhance transparency, and establishing standardized safety protocols.

e. **Long-Term Interaction:**

* **Challenge:** Sustaining engagement and meaningful interactions over extended periods.

* **Future Direction:** Developing adaptive and learning algorithms that enable robots to understand and respond to changes in human behavior over time.

f. **Ethical Considerations:**

* **Challenge:** Ethical dilemmas arising from decisions made by autonomous robots, especially in situations where human well-being is at stake.

* **Future Direction:** Establishing ethical frameworks, integrating value-based decision-making systems, and promoting responsible AI development.

**Future Directions:**

a. **Emotional Intelligence:**

* **Direction:** Enhancing robots' emotional intelligence to understand and respond appropriately to human emotions, fostering more empathetic interactions.

b. **Collaborative Robotics:**

* **Direction:** Developing robots that can seamlessly collaborate with humans in shared workspaces, enhancing productivity and efficiency.

c. **Augmented Intelligence:**

* **Direction:** Integrating robots as tools to augment human intelligence and capabilities rather than replacing human tasks entirely.

d. **Human-Robot Teams:**

* **Direction:** Promoting the integration of humans and robots as cohesive teams, leveraging the strengths of both to achieve common goals.

e. **Robotics in Healthcare:**

* **Direction:** Expanding the role of robots in healthcare, from assisting in surgeries to providing companionship for the elderly, thereby improving the overall quality of healthcare services.

f. **Neuro-Inclusive Interfaces:**

* **Direction:** Exploring interfaces that directly interpret neural signals, enabling more seamless and intuitive communication between humans and robots.

g. **Environmental Adaptability:**

* **Direction:** Developing robots capable of adapting to various environments, making them more versatile and applicable across a wide range of scenarios.

In conclusion, the challenges and future directions of human-robot interactions highlight the need for a multidisciplinary approach involving robotics, artificial intelligence, psychology, and ethics. As technology continues to advance, addressing these challenges and exploring new directions will be crucial in realizing the full potential of human-robot collaborations

## VII. Conclusion

While tremendous progress has been made, challenges remain in designing HRIs that seamlessly integrate with human capabilities. Human-centered design in human-robot interactions is about prioritizing the user experience, understanding user needs, and creating technology that enhances human capabilities while respecting human values and preferences. By placing humans at the center of the design process, HRI designers can create robots that seamlessly integrate into human lives and contribute positively to society. Prioritizing ergonomic considerations in human-robot interactions is essential for creating a seamless and safe collaborative
environment. By addressing physical, cognitive, and safety aspects, designers can contribute to the successful integration of robots into various domains while enhancing the overall well-being of users.

Ergonomics and human factors are pivotal in the design of HRIs, ensuring that these interfaces are not only technologically advanced but also user-friendly, safe, and efficient. By embracing user-centered design principles and addressing emerging challenges, researchers and designers can contribute to the realization of a future where humans and robots collaborate seamlessly across diverse applications.

## References

[1]. Bigdeli, R. (2023), "Human-Robot Interaction: Challenges and Opportunities" [Online]. Accessed on 18 October 2023, from https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/human-robot-interaction-challenges-opportunities-reza-bigdeli

[2]. Boschetti, G., Faccio, M. and Granata, I. (2022), "Human-Centered Design for Productivity and Safety in Collaborative Robots Cells: A New Methodological Approach" Electronics, vol. 12, iss.1

[3]. Busch, B. Tousaint, M. and Lopes, M. (2023), "Planning Ergonomic Sequences of Actions in Human-Robot Interaction" [Online]. Accessed on 8 November 2023, from http://web.tecnico.ulisboa.pt/manuel.lopes/myrefs/18-icra-comfopt.pdf

[4]. Colceriu, C., Theis, S., Brell-Cokcan, S. and Nitsch, V. (2023), "User-Centered Design in Mobile Human-Robot Cooperation: Consideration of Usability and Situation Awareness in GUI Design for Mobile Robots at Assembly Workplaces" [Online]. Accessed on 29 November, 2023 from file:///C:/Users/hp/Downloads/10.1515_icom-2023-0016.pdf

[5]. Dalberg (2023), "What is Human-Centered Design?" [Online]. Accessed on 5 August 2023, from https://dalberg.com/what-is-human-centered-design/

[6]. Gary, J. (2021), "Challenges in Robotics: Part VII - Human-Robot Interaction (HRI)" [Online]. Accessed on 4 December 2023, from https://www.unlimited-robotics.com/post/challenges-in-robotics-part-vii-human-robot-interaction-hri

[7]. Godwin, H. and Okpala, C. (2013), "Ergonomic Assessment of Musculoskeletal Disorders from Load-Lifting Activities in Building Construction" International Journal of Advanced Engineering Technology, vol. 4, iss. 4

[8]. Huttenraug, H. (2006), "From HCI to HRI: Designing Interaction for a Service Robot" [Online]. Accessed on 13 August 2023, from http://www.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:11491/FULLTEXT01.pdf

[9]. International Ergonomics Association (2010), "What is ergonomics?" [Online]. Accessed on 27 September 2023, from http://www.iea.cc/01_what/What%20is%20Ergonomics.html

[10]. Kim, W., Peternel, L., Lorenzini, M., Babic, J. and Ajoudani, A. (2022), "A Human-Robot Collaboration Framework for Improving Ergonomics During Dexterous Operation of Power Tools" Robotics and Computer-Integrated Manufacturing, vol. 68

[11]. Okpala, C. and Ihueze, C. (2017), "Ergonomics Improvements in a Paint Manufacturing Company" International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology, vol. 4, iss. 10

[12]. Okpala, C., Igbokwe, N. and Nwankwo, C. (2023), "Revolutionizing Manufacturing: Harnessing the Power of Artificial Intelligence for Enhanced Efficiency and Innovation" International Journal of Engineering Research and Development, vol. 19. Iss. 6

[13]. Scalise, R. (2017), "Human-Centered Design of Robot Explanations" [Online]. Accessed on 27 September 2023, from https://www.ri.cmu.edu/app/uploads/2017/05/Thesis_draft_v1.pdf

[14]. Villani, V., Pini, F., Leali, F. and Secchi, C. (2018), "Survey on Human-Robot Collaboration in Industrial Settings: Safety, Intuitive Interfaces and Applications" Mechatronics, vol. 55