<figure><img src="image_1.png" /></figure>

HAL
open science

# Exploration, explanation and exploitation of hydroxyls in zeolites

Eddy Dib, Edwin Clatworthy, Hugo Cruchade, Izabel Medeiros-Costa, Nikolai

Nesterenko, Jean-Pierre Gilson, Svetlana Mintova

► To cite this version:

Eddy Dib, Edwin Clatworthy, Hugo Cruchade, Izabel Medeiros-Costa, Nikolai Nesterenko, et al. Exploration, explanation and exploitation of hydroxyls in zeolites. National Science Review, 2022, 10.1093/nsr/nwac081. hal-03752218

HAL Id: hal-03752218

https://hal.science/hal-03752218

Submitted on 31 May 2024

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access
archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-
entific research documents, whether they are pub-
lished or not. The documents may come from
teaching and research institutions in France or
abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L'archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est
destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents
scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,
émanant des établissements d'enseignement et de
recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires
publics ou privés.

<figure><img src="image_2.png" /></figure>

Distributed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License
MATERIALS SCIENCE

Special Topic: New Era of Zeolite Science

# Exploration, explanation and exploitation of hydroxyls in zeolites

Eddy Dib ID¹,*, Edwin B. Clatworthy¹, Hugo Cruchade¹, Izabel C. Medeiros-Costa², Nikolai Nesterenko², Jean-Pierre Gilson¹ and Svetlana Mintova¹,*,

The ideal crystalline framework of zeolites is perturbed by hydroxyl groups. In pure silica zeolites the framework is neutral, however, the introduction of Al³⁺ into the Si⁴⁺ oxide framework creates negative charges, giving rise to Brønsted acid sites (BASs). Often referred to as bridged hydroxyls [Si–O(H)–Al], they are formed when a proton is bound to one of the oxygens adjacent to an aluminum. This hydroxyl group is at the heart of the remarkable properties of zeolites in acid-catalyzed reactions, as these sites and the reactants are confined in a well-defined molecule-sized environment. Other hydroxyl groups called silanols [Si–O(H)] are also present in the zeolite structure and their role is still not fully understood. Both the BAS and silanols are considered as defects of zeolite framework structures yet they hold the key to transforming inert perfect pure-silica frameworks such as quartz into chemically active materials.

BAS and silanols have been investigated for decades, during which time different characterization methods were employed in order to optimize the properties of zeolite-based catalysts, and will continue to intricate researchers for years [1].

Various direct and post-synthesis approaches have been developed either to create or heal BAS or silanol groups in zeolites. Synthetic control of the distribution of Al in high-silica zeolites is critical due to the enormous number of Al arrangements and their effect on

the catalytic performance of zeolites [2]. The distribution of both isolated and pairs of Al can be tuned by changing the polarization of the structure directing agent (SDA) or by varying the type of Al source. However, the combined use of inorganic and organic SDAs to achieve high-Al-containing zeolites creates a new challenge due to the apparent detrimental effect of other cations on the formation of Al pairs. Optimizing the combination of alkali metal cations and organic cationic SDAs for obtaining new zeolites will be crucial for controlling the Al site distribution and performance of new zeolite catalysts by controlling the bridged hydroxyls.

The main techniques used to characterize hydroxyls in zeolites are X-ray diffraction and infrared (IR) and nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy [3]. Theoretical calculations have also provided a new tool for precise assignments [4]. Their combination provides a complete vision of the distribution of these sites, as each technique highlights a specific feature. However, each technique has the intrinsic weaknesses of low resolution and sensitivity. Various classifications of the hydrogen bonds have been suggested based on their strength, assessed in terms of binding energy, hydrogen bonding distance, elongation of the bond, etc. Emerging and powerful new electron diffraction methodologies are now available to locate hydrogen atoms, and their devel-

opment will likely bring rich structural information on hydroxyl groups [5].

Silanols present a different but equally important type of hydroxyl group because they can act as sites for further functionalization, i.e. introducing metals into the zeolite framework [6]. Post-synthetic strategies typically involve the initial formation of silanol groups by acidic dea-lumination treatments followed by metal incorporation, however, this can lead to incomplete removal of isolated silanols. Recent efforts have shown that metals can be incorporated into zeolite frameworks using direct synthesis strategies resulting in the complete healing of the hydroxyl sites. Different factors, including the presence of alkali metal cations, and the type of silanols, are key in determining whether metals are incorporated into the framework [7]. The great challenge is the incorporation of a higher number of metals, understanding the mechanism of catalyst deactivation, and catalyst stabilization. Single-metal-site catalysts with high stability, accessibility and controlled distribution of hydroxyls (BAS and silanols) are of critical importance.

The properties of BAS are one of the major concerns when it comes to designing zeolitic catalysts [7]. Regarding the local environment, the interaction of an acidic proton and an extra-framework aluminum may enhance the alkane cracking activity. Furthermore, the zeolite local environment plays a crucial role in activity and selectivity by stabilizing
MATERIALS SCIENCE

Special Topic: New Era of Zeolite Science

# Exploration, explanation and exploitation of hydroxyls in zeolites

Eddy Dib ID¹,*, Edwin B. Clatworthy¹, Hugo Cruchade¹, Izabel C. Medeiros-Costa², Nikolai Nesterenko², Jean-Pierre Gilson¹ and Svetlana Mintova¹,*,

The ideal crystalline framework of zeolites is perturbed by hydroxyl groups. In pure silica zeolites the framework is neutral, however, the introduction of Al³⁺ into the Si⁴⁺ oxide framework creates negative charges, giving rise to Brønsted acid sites (BASs). Often referred to as bridged hydroxyls [Si–O(H)–Al], they are formed when a proton is bound to one of the oxygens adjacent to an aluminum. This hydroxyl group is at the heart of the remarkable properties of zeolites in acid-catalyzed reactions, as these sites and the reactants are confined in a well-defined molecule-sized environment. Other hydroxyl groups called silanols [Si–O(H)] are also present in the zeolite structure and their role is still not fully understood. Both the BAS and silanols are considered as defects of zeolite framework structures yet they hold the key to transforming inert perfect pure-silica frameworks such as quartz into chemically active materials.

BAS and silanols have been investigated for decades, during which time different characterization methods were employed in order to optimize the properties of zeolite-based catalysts, and will continue to intricate researchers for years [1].

Various direct and post-synthesis approaches have been developed either to create or heal BAS or silanol groups in zeolites. Synthetic control of the distribution of Al in high-silica zeolites is critical due to the enormous number of Al arrangements and their effect on

the catalytic performance of zeolites [2]. The distribution of both isolated and pairs of Al can be tuned by changing the polarization of the structure directing agent (SDA) or by varying the type of Al source. However, the combined use of inorganic and organic SDAs to achieve high-Al-containing zeolites creates a new challenge due to the apparent detrimental effect of other cations on the formation of Al pairs. Optimizing the combination of alkali metal cations and organic cationic SDAs for obtaining new zeolites will be crucial for controlling the Al site distribution and performance of new zeolite catalysts by controlling the bridged hydroxyls.

The main techniques used to characterize hydroxyls in zeolites are X-ray diffraction and infrared (IR) and nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy [3]. Theoretical calculations have also provided a new tool for precise assignments [4]. Their combination provides a complete vision of the distribution of these sites, as each technique highlights a specific feature. However, each technique has the intrinsic weaknesses of low resolution and sensitivity. Various classifications of the hydrogen bonds have been suggested based on their strength, assessed in terms of binding energy, hydrogen bonding distance, elongation of the bond, etc. Emerging and powerful new electron diffraction methodologies are now available to locate hydrogen atoms, and their devel-

opment will likely bring rich structural information on hydroxyl groups [5].

Silanols present a different but equally important type of hydroxyl group because they can act as sites for further functionalization, i.e. introducing metals into the zeolite framework [6]. Post-synthetic strategies typically involve the initial formation of silanol groups by acidic dea-lumination treatments followed by metal incorporation, however, this can lead to incomplete removal of isolated silanols. Recent efforts have shown that metals can be incorporated into zeolite frameworks using direct synthesis strategies resulting in the complete healing of the hydroxyl sites. Different factors, including the presence of alkali metal cations, and the type of silanols, are key in determining whether metals are incorporated into the framework [7]. The great challenge is the incorporation of a higher number of metals, understanding the mechanism of catalyst deactivation, and catalyst stabilization. Single-metal-site catalysts with high stability, accessibility and controlled distribution of hydroxyls (BAS and silanols) are of critical importance.

The properties of BAS are one of the major concerns when it comes to designing zeolitic catalysts [7]. Regarding the local environment, the interaction of an acidic proton and an extra-framework aluminum may enhance the alkane cracking activity. Furthermore, the zeolite local environment plays a crucial role in activity and selectivity by stabilizing
<figure><img src="image_1.png" /><figcaption>**Figure 1.** Exploration, explanation and exploitation of hydroxyls with the aim of creating zeolites with novel properties.</figcaption></figure>

transitional states of reactive intermediates in the confined void; this is described as the solvation effect [8]. At relatively longer range the aluminum distribution and the size of the crystal affect the acidity of the zeolite. Hydrogen mobility over the zeolitic crystal or neighboring active sites is another important consideration for reactions such as hydrogenation or for other applications including gas storage, purification and separation. Thus, the BAS activity must be considered a combination of interactions established at different length scales; deciphering the relationship between BAS properties and the catalytic behavior of zeolites is an ongoing challenge [9].

Besides acidic activity, hydroxyl groups play a key role in bifunctional catalysts by providing anchor points to disperse metals [1].

The understanding of hydroxyls in acidic catalysts is continuously progressing; the constant evolution of synthesis and characterization methods will undoubtedly reveal more about the role of silanols in catalysis and allow tuning of new active sites. For example, Lewis Acidic sites possessing hydroxyl groups may arise from the formation of extra-framework Al species that can

exist in different oxide and hydroxide forms [10]. Still, the challenging questions are how to control hydroxyls in zeolites using different synthesis methodologies and how to identify them and relate them to the reactivity of zeolites. A specific challenge is the characterization of hydroxyls in zeolites with atomic resolutions via *in situ* and operando techniques. Considering the above statements, several additional questions need to be answered: how do silanols impact the local and extended environments of BAS? Is there a synergetic effect between silanols and neighboring BAS upon activity or hydrogen mobility?

From this, we can clearly see that hydroxyls in zeolites demand further understanding. They belong to the 'Zeolite Crystal Engineering' toolbox for designing new materials for catalysis and adsorbents. Advances in the understanding of hydroxyls in zeolites will provide endless opportunities for discovering zeolites with original properties not previously known (Fig. 1). In the long term, zeolites with controlled hydroxyls (BAS and silanols) will contribute to society by addressing the challenges of energy transition and climate change, and provide solutions to reduce CO₂ emissions.

## FUNDING

This work was supported by the Label of Excellence for the Centre for Zeolites and Nanoporous Materials by the Region of Normandy (CLEAR) and Industrial Chair ANR-TOTAL 'Nanoclean Energy'.

*Conflict of interest statement.* None declared.

Eddy Dib ID 1,*, Edwin B. Clatworthy¹, Hugo Cruchade¹, Izabel C. Medeiros-Costa², Nikolai Nesterenko², Jean-Pierre Gilson¹ and Svetlana Mintova¹,*,

¹Laboratory of Catalysis and Spectrochemistry (LCS), Normandy University, National Graduate School of Engineering of Caen (ENSICAEN), French National Center for Scientific Research (CNRS), France and

²Total Energies Research and Technology, Belgium

*Corresponding authors.

E-mails: eddy.dib@ensicaen.fr;

svetlana.mintova@ensicaen.fr

## REFERENCES

1. Medeiros-Costa IC, Dib E and Nesterenko N *et al.* *Chem Soc Rev* 2021; **50**: 11156–79.

2. Dedecek J, Tabor E and Sklenak S. *ChemSusChem* 2019; **12**: 556–76.

3. Karge HG, Hunger M and Beyer HK. Characterization of zeolites — infrared and nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy and X-ray diffraction. In: Weitkamp J and Puppe L (eds). *Catalysis and Zeolites*. Berlin and Heidelberg: Springer, 1999, 198–326.

4. Dib E, Mineva T and Veron E *et al.* *J Phys Chem Lett* 2018; **9**: 19–24.

5. Palatinus L, Brawda P and Boullay P *et al.* *Science* 2017; **335**: 166–9.

6. Clatworthy EB, Konnov SV and Dubray F *et al.* *Angew Chem Int Ed* 2020; **59**: 19414–32.

7. Guisnet M and Pinard L. *Catal Rev* 2018; **60**: 337–436.

8. Gounder R and Iglesia E. *Chem Commun* 2013; **49**: 3491–509.

9. Derouane EG, Védrine JC and Pinto RR *et al.* *Catal Rev* 2013; **55**: 454–515.

10. Ravi M, Sushkevich VL and van Bokhoven JA. *Nat Mater* 2020; **19**: 1047–56.
<figure><img src="image_3.png" /><figcaption>**Figure 1.** Exploration, explanation and exploitation of hydroxyls with the aim of creating zeolites with novel properties.</figcaption></figure>

transitional states of reactive intermediates in the confined void; this is described as the solvation effect [8]. At relatively longer range the aluminum distribution and the size of the crystal affect the acidity of the zeolite. Hydrogen mobility over the zeolitic crystal or neighboring active sites is another important consideration for reactions such as hydrogenation or for other applications including gas storage, purification and separation. Thus, the BAS activity must be considered a combination of interactions established at different length scales; deciphering the relationship between BAS properties and the catalytic behavior of zeolites is an ongoing challenge [9].

Besides acidic activity, hydroxyl groups play a key role in bifunctional catalysts by providing anchor points to disperse metals [1].

The understanding of hydroxyls in acidic catalysts is continuously progressing; the constant evolution of synthesis and characterization methods will undoubtedly reveal more about the role of silanols in catalysis and allow tuning of new active sites. For example, Lewis Acidic sites possessing hydroxyl groups may arise from the formation of extra-framework Al species that can

exist in different oxide and hydroxide forms [10]. Still, the challenging questions are how to control hydroxyls in zeolites using different synthesis methodologies and how to identify them and relate them to the reactivity of zeolites. A specific challenge is the characterization of hydroxyls in zeolites with atomic resolutions via *in situ* and operando techniques. Considering the above statements, several additional questions need to be answered: how do silanols impact the local and extended environments of BAS? Is there a synergetic effect between silanols and neighboring BAS upon activity or hydrogen mobility?

From this, we can clearly see that hydroxyls in zeolites demand further understanding. They belong to the 'Zeolite Crystal Engineering' toolbox for designing new materials for catalysis and adsorbents. Advances in the understanding of hydroxyls in zeolites will provide endless opportunities for discovering zeolites with original properties not previously known (Fig. 1). In the long term, zeolites with controlled hydroxyls (BAS and silanols) will contribute to society by addressing the challenges of energy transition and climate change, and provide solutions to reduce CO₂ emissions.

## FUNDING

This work was supported by the Label of Excellence for the Centre for Zeolites and Nanoporous Materials by the Region of Normandy (CLEAR) and Industrial Chair ANR-TOTAL 'Nanoclean Energy'.

*Conflict of interest statement.* None declared.

Eddy Dib ID 1,*, Edwin B. Clatworthy¹, Hugo Cruchade¹, Izabel C. Medeiros-Costa², Nikolai Nesterenko², Jean-Pierre Gilson¹ and Svetlana Mintova¹,.*

¹Laboratory of Catalysis and Spectrochemistry (LCS), Normandy University, National Graduate School of Engineering of Caen (ENSICAEN), French National Center for Scientific Research (CNRS), France and

²Total Energies Research and Technology, Belgium

*Corresponding authors.

E-mails: eddy.dib@ensicaen.fr;

svetlana.mintova@ensicaen.fr

## REFERENCES

1. Medeiros-Costa IC, Dib E and Nesterenko N *et al.* *Chem Soc Rev* 2021; **50**: 11156–79.

2. Dedecek J, Tabor E and Sklenak S. *ChemSusChem* 2019; **12**: 556–76.

3. Karge HG, Hunger M and Beyer HK. Characterization of zeolites — infrared and nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy and X-ray diffraction. In: Weitkamp J and Puppe L (eds). *Catalysis and Zeolites*. Berlin and Heidelberg: Springer, 1999, 198–326.

4. Dib E, Mineva T and Veron E *et al.* *J Phys Chem Lett* 2018; **9**: 19–24.

5. Palatinus L, Brawda P and Boullay P *et al.* *Science* 2017; **335**: 166–9.

6. Clatworthy EB, Konnov SV and Dubray F *et al.* *Angew Chem Int Ed* 2020; **59**: 19414–32.

7. Guisnet M and Pinard L. *Catal Rev* 2018; **60**: 337–436.

8. Gounder R and Iglesia E. *Chem Commun* 2013; **49**: 3491–509.

9. Derouane EG, Védrine JC and Pinto RR *et al.* *Catal Rev* 2013; **55**: 454–515.

10. Ravi M, Sushkevich VL and van Bokhoven JA. *Nat Mater* 2020; **19**: 1047–56.