# Isotropically coercive free layer integration in a magnetic tunnel junction for neuromorphic applications

Marco Mansueto, Antoine Chavent, Ricardo C. Sousa, Liliana D.

Buda-Prejbeanu, Ioan Prejbeanu, Bernard Diény

► To cite this version:

Marco Mansueto, Antoine Chavent, Ricardo C. Sousa, Liliana D. Buda-Prejbeanu, Ioan Prejbeanu, et al.. Isotropically coercive free layer integration in a magnetic tunnel junction for neuromorphic applications. 2020 IEEE International Memory Workshop (IMW), May 2020, Dresden, Germany. pp.1-4, 10.1109/IMW48823.2020.9108129. hal-03111548

HAL Id: hal-03111548

https://hal.science/hal-03111548

Submitted on 1 Sep 2021

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access
archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-
entific research documents, whether they are pub-
lished or not. The documents may come from
teaching and research institutions in France or
abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L'archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est
destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents
scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,
émanant des établissements d'enseignement et de
recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires
publics ou privés.

<figure><img src="image_1.png" /></figure>

Distributed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License
Isotropically coercive free layer integration in a
magnetic tunnel junction for neuromorphic
applications

Marco Mansueto

Univ. Grenoble Alpes, CEA, CNRS,
Grenoble INP
SPINTEC

Grenoble, France

marco.mansueto@cea.fr

Antoine Chavent

Univ. Grenoble Alpes, CEA, CNRS,
Grenoble INP
SPINTEC

Grenoble, France

antoine.chavent@cea.fr

Ricardo Sousa

Univ. Grenoble Alpes, CEA, CNRS,
Grenoble INP
SPINTEC

Grenoble, France

ricardo.sousa@cea.fr

Liliana D. Buda-Prejbeanu

Univ. Grenoble Alpes, CEA, CNRS,
Grenoble INP
SPINTEC

Grenoble, France

liliana.buda@cea.fr

Ioan L. Prejbeanu

Univ. Grenoble Alpes, CEA, CNRS,
Grenoble INP
SPINTEC

Grenoble, France

ioan.prejbeanu@cea.fr

Bernard Dieny

Univ. Grenoble Alpes, CEA, CNRS,
Grenoble INP
SPINTEC

Grenoble, France

bernard.dieny@cea.fr

Abstract—The concept of a spintronic memristor based on angular variation of Tunnel Magnetoresistance relies on the development of an isotropically coercive free layer able to stabilize the magnetization in any in-plane direction. In this work, we first demonstrate those properties in a composite ferromagnet/antiferromagnet/ferromagnet trilayer by performing hysteresis loops at different in-plane angles and rotating field experiments. In the second part, we describe the material composition of the total stack and the fabrication process to create the final device. In the last part, the hysteresis loops at different in-plane angles and the rotating field experiments are performed at device level and compared with the ones performed at full sheet film, confirming the magnetically isotropic nature of the free layer.

Keywords—spintronics, memristor, MTJ, TMR

I. INTRODUCTION

The exponentially increasing amount of data in the
information and communication technology (ICT) world in
the last decade results in a corresponding increase of electrical
power consumption associated to it. In 2018, it was estimated
that the ICT's amount of data generated worldwide reached 20
Zettabytes (20 bilion Terabytes). The power consumption
associated to ICT is estimated to represent about 10% of the
worldwide total electrical consumption [1]. The main causes
in ICT power consumption are associated with the wireless
transmission of data, displays, and inefficient computer
architectures. To address this issue of ICT power
consumption, the scientific community is looking to the most
efficient and lowest power consuming system known, the
human brain. The concept of AI is born to try to emulate the
complex functionalities of the brain. Between those, the
development of an architecture with massive parallelization of
processing units (neurons) and memory units (synapses)
seems to be a promising solution. In the last few years, several
devices were proposed to mimic both neuron and synapse
working principles. For the specific case of synapses, the
concept of memristor, a device with a resistance value
dependent on the history of the electrical charges passed
through it, developed in the 70's [2], has been exploited for
the realization of devices using different technologies. An

example is a device that is able to change resistance value
thanks to the voltage dependent ion migration (as for example
oxygen ions) in materials like TiₓO₁₋ₓ or HfₓO₁₋ₓ [3], [4]. In
this particular case, problems of endurance represent the main
limitation since learning processes usually involve a large
number of write cycles. In contrast, spintronic memristors do
not present this problem, since the information relies on the
magnetization state and no atomic motion takes place during
the writing process. An example of this is a magnetic tunnel
junction (MTJ) with a domain wall in the free layer that can
be moved through current pulses, thus varying the proportion
of MTJ area in parallel and anti-parallel configuration and
correlatively reaching different resistance states [5]. Another
example exploits spin-orbit torque (SOT) in an
antiferromagnetic material exchange biased with an out-of-
plane magnetized ferromagnet that is gradually switched [6],
[7]. A third example uses a chain of MTJs in serial
configuration, in which the MTJ can be switched one by one,
thus achieving a gradual change in the total resistance [8].
However, a drawback of these above mentioned spintronic
devices is their relatively large size (micronic dimension)
required to get several intermediate resistance states.

The device we propose in this work is based on a single nano-
sized pillar very similar to a usual MRAM cell. The idea to
achieve several resistance states is to exploit the dependence
of the tunnel magnetoresistance (TMR) on the angle between
the magnetization of the two ferromagnetic electrodes in an
in-plane MTJ (the analyzer layer AL and the free layer FL in
Fig. 1a) [9]. The lowest resistance value is obtained in the case
of parallel configuration of the two magnetization while the
antiparallel case gives the highest resistance. In between the
two, the TMR is varying with the cosine of the angle as shown
in Fig. 1b. The writing mechanism relies on the spin-transfer
torque (STT) created by an out-of-plane spin polarized current
injected in the FL layer. This polarized current is obtained
thanks to an additional out-of-plane magnetized polarizer
(POL) placed underneath the FL. This current generates an
out-of-plane precession of the FL magnetization (shown as
dashed line in Fig. 1a). The application of current pulses rather
than a DC current enables clockwise or anticlockwise step by
step discrete rotations of the FL magnetization achieving
intermediate resistance states. The use of an additional in-plane field perpendicular to the AL magnetization direction allows limiting the angular excursion of the FL magnetization to ±90° around this transverse field thus insuring the monotonicity of the resistance variation with the polarity of the applied voltage as required for a memristive behavior. A more accurate description of the functionalities of the device is given in [10].

In this work, we present how to realize a FL able to stabilize the magnetization along different in-plane directions with isotropic thermal stability by creating an isotropically coercive free layer and how to integrate it in a complex structure as in Fig. 1a. After a nano-fabrication process, magnetic characterizations were performed to confirm the magnetically isotropic nature of the free layer.

<figure><img src="image_2.png" /><figcaption>Fig. 1a) Schematics of the device. b) TMR variation with the in-plane angle between analyzer and free layer as in the inset and schematics of the relative resistance loops.</figcaption></figure>

## II. ISOTROPICALLY COERCIVE FREE LAYER

### A. Realization

Isotropic magnetic properties were already observed in amorphous in-plane magnetized ferromagnetic systems in which the disordered crystalline structure creates a distribution of anisotropy directions all over the plane [11]. In this work, instead, we exploit a structure based on the coupling between ferromagnet FM and thin antiferromagnet AF. It is well-known that, above a certain thickness of the AF layer, its anisotropic energy is strong enough to pin the FM magnetization along an in-plane direction thanks to the exchange bias phenomenon. However, for lower thicknesses, this AF pinning becomes too weak and the AF spin lattice gets entirely dragged due to the interfacial F/AF coupling when the F magnetization rotates or switches. This results in an increase in F coercive field while the exchange bias field is still negligible. In such system, similarly to the random anisotropy materials, the dissipation is not associated to the presence of a well-defined anisotropy axis but to numerous magnetization rearrangements at the nanometer scale occurring during the magnetization evolution. As a result, this dissipative mechanism is isotropic. From conceptual point of view, it can be described by a dry friction-like term which can be introduced in the Landau Lifshitz Gilbert equation (for more details [10]).

### B. Vibrating Sample Magnetometer Characterization

To determine the right AF thickness yielding this isotropically coercive behavior, a study of exchange bias and coercive field dependence on AF thickness was performed on a trilayer sample made of unpatterned Py(1nm)/IrMn(x)/Py(1nm). The sample was deposited by magnetron sputtering and annealed

at 300°C for 1h30 under an in-plane field of 230mT. In Fig. 2a, it is shown that, for IrMn thicknesses around 2.1nm, while the exchange bias is still negligible, a steep increase of coercive field is observed as expected. This particular IrMn thickness was chosen for the following experiments.

<figure><img src="image_3.png" /><figcaption>Fig. 2a) Coercive field $H_C$ and exchange bias $H_{EB}$ dependence on IrMn thickness. b) Hysteresis loops at different in-plane angles with respect to the annealing field direction (red arrow in the inset). c) Coercive field $H_C$ and exchange bias $H_{EB}$ dependence on the in-plane angle $\phi_H$ [10]</figcaption></figure>

Measurements at different in-plane angles (Fig. 2b) show that the magnetic properties such as coercive field and remanence are almost independent on this angle as in Fig. 2c, confirming the isotropic nature of the free layer. Note that the rounded shape of the loop is expected as a result of dry friction torque due to the F/AF coupling (see [10]).

### C. Rotating Field Characterization

The same sample was used for a rotating field experiment using a planar Hall (PHR) measurement setup [12].

<figure><img src="image_4.png" /><figcaption>Fig. 3a) Planar Hall resistance (PHR) under rotating field of frequency of 10Hz and different amplitudes. b) Angular shift dependence on field amplitude with dry friction model (blue line) and experimentally obtained (green stars). [10]</figcaption></figure>

As expected, for large rotating field amplitude $H_{rot}$, the resistance varies as $\sin(2\phi_H)$ (black curve in Fig. 3a). For smaller amplitudes of the field, the curve gradually shifts creating a dragg angle between the rotating field and the magnetization. For fields smaller than the coercive field, the magnetization no more follows the rotating field (as in the 13mT curve of Fig. 3a). The observed gradual increase of the amplitude PHR signal versus $H_{rot}$ amplitude is also expected since the amount of spins following the field increases as $H_{rot}$ amplitude increases. Fig. 3b shows the phase shifts between magnetization and field (i.e the dragg angle) versus field amplitude. This variation can be well fitted by the analytical solution obtained with the dry friction model. This is a further confirmation of the isotropic properties of the unpatterned free layer.
### III. INTEGRATION IN THE FULL STACK AND FABRICATION

Here we briefly describe the material stack used for the device as in Fig. 1a and the fabrication process to pattern such device. All the thicknesses in parenthesis are in nm.

#### A. Full Stack

The F/AF/F trilayer constituting the device FL was inserted in the full structure as represented in Fig. 4a. The samples were deposited by magnetron sputtering at Spintec. After a seed layer of Pt, an out-of-plane synthetic antiferromagnet (SAF) was deposited by exploiting the perpendicular anisotropy of a multilayer structure of [Co (0.5)/Pt(0.25)]<sub>6</sub> and [Co (0.5)/Pt(0.25)]<sub>3</sub> separated by a thin layer of Ru(0.9) to exploit the peak of the antiferromagnetic RKKY coupling. The SAF is coupled to a polarizer layer of FeCoB(1.2) in contact with the first MgO barrier with a relatively low resistance*area product of 2Ωµm². The F/AF/F trilayer structure was then inserted between two FeCoB(1.6) layers in contact with the top and bottom MgO barrier. The second MgO barrier with a resistance*area product of 10Ωµm² was optimized to give a TMR as large as possible between the free layer and an in-plane magnetized synthetic antiferromagnet placed above the top tunnel barrier. This pinned top analyzer layer has the composition: FeCoB(1.2)/Ta(0.2)/Co(1)/Ru(0.9)/Co(2.5)/IrMn(7). A capping layer of Cu and Pt protects the stack from oxidation and constitutes the top electrical contact to the stack.

<figure><img src="image_5.png" /></figure>

#### B. Nano-Fabrication Process

The samples were annealed at 300°C for 1h30 under an in-plane magnetic field of 230mT. The field is intended to set the orientation of the in-plane analyzer magnetization. After deposition of a hard mask of Ta, e-beam lithography was used to create circular resist patterns with diameters between 20nm and 150nm. A Reactive Ion Etching machine was then used to etch the Ta layer and creates the hard mask Ta pillars (as in Fig. 4b). The magnetic stack was then etched by Ion Beam Etching at different incident angles. The etched stacks are then embedded in a planarizing resist which is subsequently partially etched to open the top electrical contacts. The contacts are then patterned as in Fig. 4c.

### IV. CHARACTERIZATION RESULTS

Magnetic characterizations were performed on these samples to test the success of the fabrication process and to assess the isotropic properties of the FL at device level. An

example of resistance-field loop is presented in Fig. 5a. The device has a diameter of 80nm and a total resistance consistent with the expected resistance*area product (2+10Ωµm²). The TMR value is around 30% and the rounded shape of the loop is similar to the full sheet film one of Fig. 2b confirming the dry friction like reversal with field.

<figure><img src="image_6.png" /></figure>

#### A. In-plane Field Loops

A series of hysteresis loops measurement was performed at different in-plane angles with respect to the AL layer magnetization direction. This was realized with two orthogonal couples of coils with the sample placed at their center. The two components of the field (along x-axis and y-axis) were then adjusted to obtain different in-plane angles of the field. As shown in Fig. 5b, the coercive field of the different loops do not vary while the high and low resistance states at zero field are gradually shifting towards the center. This demonstrates that the magnetic properties are again independent on the in-plane angle even at device level. The obtained variation of TMR was directly compared to the cosine variation expected in the ideal case in Fig. 5c showing good agreement.

#### B. Rotating Field Experiment

Rotating field experiments were performed on a similar setup as the previous one. The two couples of coils along x and y directions are supplied by 90° out-of-phase current creating a rotating field on the device of constant amplitude. The rotating frequency could be varied up to 5Hz. The results shown in Fig. 6a correspond to an applied field of 40mT and frequency of 2Hz. The resistance (Fig. 6b) is oscillating between its maximum and its minimum value with the same frequency as the rotating field one. Note that the resistance smoothly varies in quasi-sine form, passing through all the intermediate values. In contrast to this, if the same experiment is performed on a standard binary MTJ, the result of Fig. 6c is observed. The resistance values are then distributed non uniformly with two main regions in the high resistance region and in the low resistance region. The magnetization does not follow smoothly the rotating field. Due to its uniaxial anisotropy, during its rotation, the FL magnetization undergoes irreversible jumps while it crosses its hard axis direction. Also in this case, the isotropic properties of the device can be confirmed.
<figure><img src="image_7.png" /><figcaption>Fig. 6 a) Rotating field applied to the experiment. b) Resistance variation of a device as in Fig. 4a. c) Resistance variation of a standard MTJ.</figcaption></figure>

V. CONCLUSION AND PERSPECTIVES

In conclusion, a memristive device based on the angular variation of TMR requires the development of an isotropically coercive free layer able to stabilize the magnetization along different in-plane angles with equal thermal stability. In this study, we demonstrated the realization of such layer by exploiting the coupling at the FM/AF interface of a trilayer FM/AF/FM. The full sheet film measurements of coercivity and exchange bias at different in-plane angles and the rotating field experiments confirmed the isotropic properties of the free layer. After the development of the total stack, and fabrication process, devices with diameter between 20nm and 150nm were measured with the same techniques. The hysteresis loops at different angles showed that the angular variation of TMR is, as expected, cosine-like while the coercive field is kept constant. The rotating field experiments demonstrated that the resistance can take all the intermediate values between its maximum and its minimum without any preference. This does not occur in a standard MTJ where the magnetization is stable along two opposite directions giving rise to a bimodal distribution of resistance values.

These promising results bring us to the next step where the
use of Spin Transfer Torque through the application of pulses

will allow the discrete rotation of the magnetization. The
realization of this device would represent a good option for a
scalable, easily integrable and low power consumption
device for neuromorphic computing.

ACKNOWLEDGMENT

The authors want to acknowledge the Plateforme de
Technologie Amont PTA for technical help in the fabrication
process. Funding from ERC Advanced grant MAGICAL
669204 is acknowledged.

REFERENCES

[1] D. Reinsel et al., IDC White Paper Data Age 2025, (2017)

[2] L. O. Chua, Memristors-the missing circuit element, IEEE Trans. Circuit Theory CT-18, 507 (1971)

[3] D. B. Strukov, G. S. Snider, D. R. Stewart & R. S. Williams, The missing memristor found, Nature, Vol 453, (2008)

[4] Y. Li, Z. Wang, R. Midya, Q. Xia, and J. J. Yang, Review of memristor devices in neuromorphic computing: Materials sciences and device challenges, J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys. 51, 503002 (2018)

[5] S. Lequeux, J. Sampaio, V. Cros, K. Yakushiji, A. Fukushima, R. Matsumoto, H. Kubota, S. Yuasa, and J. Grollier, A magnetic synapse: Multilevel spin-torque memristor with perpendicular anisotropy, Sci. Rep. 6, 31510 (2016).

[6] S. Fukami, C. Zhang, S. DuttaGupta, and H. Ohno, Magnetization switching by spin-orbit torque in an antiferromagnet-ferromagnet bilayer system, Nat. Mater. 15, 535 (2016).

[7] A. Kurenkov, S. D. Gupta, C. Zhang, S. Fukami, Y. Horio, and H. Ohno, Artificial Neuron and Synapse Realized in an Antiferromagnet/Ferromagnet Heterostructure Using Dynamics of Spin-Orbit Torque Switching, Adv. Mater., 31, 1900636 (2019)

[8] E. Raymenants, A. Vaysset, D. Wan, M. Manfrini, O. Zografos, O. Bultynck, J. Doevenspeck, M. Heyns, I. P. Radu, and T. Devolder, Chain of magnetic tunnel junctions as a spintronic memristor, J. Appl. Phys. 124, 152116 (2018).

[9] J. C. Slonczewski, Conductance and exchange coupling of two ferromagnets separated by a tunneling barrier, Phys. Rev. B 39, 6995 (1989).

[10] M. Mansueto, A. Chavent, S. Auffret, I. Joumard, J. Nath, I.M. Miron, U. Ebels, R.C. Sousa, L.D. Buda-Prejbeanu, I.L. Prejbeanu, and B. Dieny, Realizing an Isotropically Coercive Magnetic Layer for Memristive Applications by Analogy to Dry Friction, Phys. Rev. Applied 12, 044029 (2019)

[11] B. Dieny, B. Barbara, G. Fillion, M. Maeder, and B. Michelutti, Hysteresis loop and torque experiments on a random anisotropy system, J. Phys. 48, 1741 (1987)

[12] F. Nguyen Van Dau, A. Schuh, J. R. Childress, and M. Sussiau, Magnetic sensors for nanotesla detection using planar Hall effect, Sens. Actuators A 53, 256 (1996)