# Human Neural Cells Transiently Express Reelin during Olfactory Placode Development

Maria Antal, Brigitte Lacombe, Said Ghandour, Nelly Boehm

► To cite this version:

Maria Antal, Brigitte Lacombe, Said Ghandour, Nelly Boehm. Human Neural Cells Transiently Express Reelin during Olfactory Placode Development. PLoS ONE, 2015, 10 (8), pp.e0135710. 10.1371/journal.pone.0135710. [hal-05100148]

HAL Id: hal-05100148

https://hal.science/hal-05100148v1

Submitted on 5 Jun 2025

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access
archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-
entific research documents, whether they are pub-
lished or not. The documents may come from
teaching and research institutions in France or
abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L'archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est
destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents
scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,
émanant des établissements d'enseignement et de
recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires
publics ou privés.

<figure><img src="image_1.png" /></figure>

Distributed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License
RESEARCH ARTICLE

# Human Neural Cells Transiently Express Reelin during Olfactory Placode Development

M. Cristina Antal¹,²,³,⁵, Brigitte Samama¹,²,³*, M. Said Ghandour⁴,⁵, Nelly Boehm¹,²,³

¹ Institut d'Histologie, Faculté de Médecine, Université de Strasbourg, Strasbourg, France, ² Fédération de Médecine Translationnelle de Strasbourg, Strasbourg, France, ³ Hôpitaux Universitaires de Strasbourg, Strasbourg, France, ⁴ Laboratoire d'Imagerie et de Neurosciences Cognitives, CNRS, UMR 7237, Strasbourg, France, ⁵ CNRS UMR 7357, Strasbourg, France

* samama@unistra.fr

<figure><img src="image_2.png" /></figure>

CrossMark
click for updates

## Abstract

Reelin, an extracellular glycoprotein is essential for migration and correct positioning of neurons during development. Since the olfactory system is known as a source of various migrating neuronal cells, we studied Reelin expression in the two chemosensory olfactory systems, main and accessory, during early developmental stages of human foetuses/embryos from Carnegie Stage (CS) 15 to gestational week (GW) 14. From CS 15 to CS 18, but not at later stages, a transient expression of Reelin was detected first in the presumptive olfactory and then in the presumptive vomeronasal epithelium. During the same period, Reelin-positive cells detach from the olfactory/vomeronasal epithelium and migrate through the mesenchyme beneath the telencephalon. Dab 1, an adaptor protein of the Reelin pathway, was simultaneously expressed in the migratory mass from CS16 to CS17 and, at later stages, in the presumptive olfactory ensheathing cells. Possible involvements of Reelin and Dab 1 in the peripheral migrating stream are discussed.

<figure><img src="image_3.png" /></figure>

OPEN ACCESS

**Citation:** Antal MC, Samama B, Ghandour MS, Boehm N (2015) Human Neural Cells Transiently Express Reelin during Olfactory Placode Development. PLoS ONE 10(8): e0135710. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0135710

**Editor:** Hiroaki Matsunami, Duke University, UNITED STATES

**Received:** April 16, 2015

**Accepted:** July 26, 2015

**Published:** August 13, 2015

**Copyright:** © 2015 Antal et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.

**Data Availability Statement:** All relevant data are within the paper.

**Funding:** This study was supported in part by the Conseil Scientifique de la Faculté de Médecine de Strasbourg and by the Programme Hospitalier de Recherche Clinique, Hôpitaux Universitaires de Strasbourg. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.

**Competing Interests:** The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.

## Introduction

During development of the olfactory system, peripheral neurosensory axons arising from the invaginated placode reach the presumptive olfactory area of the telencephalon, thus mediating olfactory bulb (OB) development. In the main olfactory system, neurosensory cells in the olfactory epithelium (OE), sending axons to the main OB, make synapses with the dendrite of mitral/tufted cells, whereas in the accessory olfactory system, axons arising from the neurosensorial cells of the vomeronasal epithelium (VNE), lying in the vomeronasal organ (VNO), make synapses with mitral/tufted cells in the accessory olfactory bulb. However, in human, the VNO is present during embryonic/foetal development, contains neurosensory-like cells but is no more functional at birth [1].

The olfactory placode (OP), and later the VNO and OE are well known as sources of various migrating neurons toward the telencephalon; among them are GnRH neurons that migrate along the vomeronasal-terminal nerve (VN/TN) [2]. Several guidance molecules have been proposed for guiding olfactory axons and neurons through the mesenchyme toward the
presumptive OB area and the septal region, respectively. Molecules involved in cell adhesion (anosmin1, laminin, heparane sulphate proteoglycan), transcription factors and neurotransmitters have been described in the literature (review in [3]).

Reelin has emerged as an extracellular glycoprotein essential for migration and correct positioning of cortical neurons and for establishment of correct neuronal circuitry during nervous system development; Reelin is expressed during development by different classes of neurons and especially by Cajal-Retzius cells in cortical layer I [4, 5]. During development, Reelin acts mainly through its VLDL and Apo2E receptors, initiating a signalling cascade where an adapter protein Dab 1 is phosphorylated and binds to the intracellular part of the receptor [6-9]. Reelin expression has also been detected in many other regions of the developing central nervous system in addition to cortical layer I, as well as in peripheral organs such as liver, lymphatic endothelial cells, pituitary pars intermedia, adrenal chromaffin cells [10, 11] and in the peripheral part of the olfactory system in mouse embryos [12,13].

Most data about Reelin pathway during development were obtained in rodents and comparisons with human development showed similarities but also some differences [14]. Since, at our knowledge, no data were available about the expression of the Reelin pathway components in the human olfactory system during the period of cell migration, we studied the expression of Reelin and Dab 1 at some stages of the embryonic/early foetal period in human. Here we show that some early neural cells transiently express Reelin at the time they leave the presumptive OE/VNE and that Dab 1 is present in the migratory cell mass and in the presumptive ensheathing cells in the absence of Reelin expression.

# Materials and Methods

## Biological samples

Twelve human embryos/foetuses ranging from Carnegie stage (CS) 15 to gestational weeks (GW) 12 from legal abortions and one normal brain and nasal medial wall (14 GW) from a foetus without macroscopic malformations addressed to the Pathology Service of the University Hospital for examination following abortion were studied. These embryos/foetuses were collected following requirements and regulations approved by the Medical Ethics Committee of the Faculty of Medicine of Strasbourg. Written informed maternal consents were obtained from an independent physician according to the procedure approved by the ethics committee. 1 CS15, 1 CS16, 1 CS17, 1 CS18, 2 CS 20-21, 3 CS23-24, 2 GW8, 1 GW12 and 1 GW14 embryos/foetuses were used. For the CS18 embryo, only nasal cavities could be studied. Developmental stage of embryos/foetuses was ascertained based on external morphology, peripheral organs and brain development according to O'Rahilly and Müller [15], Wolff-Quenot and Sick [16] and Feess-Higgins and Larroche [17]. Tissues were fixed in Bouin-Holland fixative (13 embryos/foetuses) or buffered formalin (1 foetus) and 5 µm paraffin sections were cut. Microscopic examination following haematoxylin-eosin (H.E.) staining showed no abnormalities and adjacent sections were further processed for immunocytochemistry and *in situ* hybridization (one formalin fixed GW8 embryo).

## Immunohistochemistry

Antibodies used were mouse monoclonal antibodies against beta-III tubulin (1/1000, Chemicon, Abcys, Paris, France), ICBP90 (1/2000, Proteogenix, Illkirch, France), Reelin-142 (1/1000), a generous gift from Pr. A. Goffinet [18] and rabbit polyclonal antibodies against calretinin (1/10000, Swant, Bellinzona, Switzerland), NSE (1/1000, Dakocytomation, Trappes, France), GnRH (two antibodies: Sanbio, Tebu, Le Perray en Yvelines, France, 1/10000 and LR1, 1/10000, a generous gift from Pr. R. Benoit, Montreal), PGP 9.5 (1/2000, Affinity Reagents, Fisher Scientific, Illkirch,
France), Dab 1 and AC3 (1/1000, Santacruz Biotechnology, Tebu, Le Perray en Yvelines, France), S100 (1/1000 Dakocytomation, Trappes, France).

Microwave antigen retrieval (10 mM citrate buffer, pH 6.0) of paraffin sections was followed by incubation in blocking buffer; endogenous peroxydases were blocked (3% H2O2 for 10 min) and primary antibody incubated overnight at 4°C; a secondary biotinylated antibody incubation for 2 hours was followed by avidin-biotin complex incubation (Vectastain Elite kit, Vector Laboratories, Abcys, Paris, France). The peroxydase reaction product was revealed by VIP (Vector Laboratories, Abcys, Paris, France) as the chromogen. Sections were counterstained with methyl green, air-dried and cover slipped with Eukitt (Labonord, Templemars, France). Negative controls consisted in omission of the primary antibody, resulting in no staining.

For double immunostainings, sections were incubated simultaneously in anti-Reelin-142 (1/200) and anti-PGP9.5 (1/500), anti-calretinin (1/500), anti-GnRH (1/1000) or anti-Dab 1 (1/50) and the reaction was revealed by incubation in secondary either anti-mouse Alexa Fluor 568-labeled and anti-rabbit Alexa Fluor 488-labeled or anti-rabbit Alexa Fluor 568-labeled and anti-mouse Alexa Fluor 488-labeled antibodies (1/200, Molecular probes, Invitrogen, Cergy Pontoise, France). DAPI in mounting medium (Vectashield, Vector Laboratories, Abcys, Paris, France) was used for nuclei staining.

## Reelin *in situ* hybridization

**RNA isolation and probe preparation.** Total RNA and probe preparations by RT-PCR Dig labelling were performed as previously described [19]. Briefly, total RNA was isolated from C57BL/6 mouse brains using TRIzol reagent according to manufacturer instructions (GIBCO BRL, Cergy Pontoise, France). To eliminate contamination with genomic DNA, isolated RNAs were treated with DNaseI, RNase free (Amersham Pharmacia Biotech, Orsay, France). Before reverse transcribing the mRNA, we checked for genomic contamination by PCR using primers for genomic Reelin. cDNA was prepared from the total mouse brain RNA using Qiagen Omniscript kit (Qiagen, Hilden, Germany). Total RNA (1-2µg/reaction) in the presence of Oligo dT15 primers (Promega, Charbonnières-les Bains, France), and Omniscript Reverse Transcriptase was incubated at 37°C for 1 hour. Three µl of cDNA were subjected to PCR using Ready-to-Go PCR beads (Amersham Pharmacia Biotech, Orsay, France) in the presence of Digoxigenin-11-dUTP (Roche, Meylan, France) and 25 ng of Reelin-specific primers [forward primer (5'-AGTGCCTACCTTCCTCTTCCAAT); reverse primer (5'-ATGGGTATCGC CTAAGCGACCTT) (GIBCO BRL, Cergy Pontoise, France)]. Amplification was performed using Genius (Techné, Bibby Sterilin, Nemours, France) thermocycler. The cycling conditions for PCR were 1 cycle of initial denaturation at 95°C for 5 min followed by 40 cycles, each at 95°C for 0.5 min, 63°C for 1 min and then at 72°C for 0.5 min. The expected size of the PCR product (910 bp) was checked by electrophoresis in 1.5% agarose gel.

Digoxigenin labelled probes were tested by the dot-blot method using a nitrocellulose membrane (Millipore, Molsheim, France). The denatured probes were serially diluted and spotted onto nitrocellulose membrane. Spotted probes were then incubated with alkaline phosphatase tagged anti-Dig antibody and detected as described below.

**In situ hybridization.** The protocol described in Jalabi et al [19, 20] was adapted to formalin-fixed paraffin sections. Sections were rehydrated and washed twice in SSC2X for 10 min at RT, treated with HCl 0.2 M for 8 min and then rinsed twice in the same buffer for 10 min. They were treated with proteinase K (GIBCO BRL, Cergy Pontoise, France) 50 µg/ml in SSC2X for 30 min at 37°C. Sections were immersed in 0.1M triethanolamine for 5 min, in 0.25% acetic anhydride in 0.1M triethanolamine for 10 min and then washed twice in SSC2X for 5 min.
Two µl of diluted probe was added to 100 µl prehybridization solution (50% formamide, 2XSSC, 5% dextran sulfate, 1X Denhardt's and 0.1 mg/ml salmon testis DNA), boiled for 10 min, and snap-cooled on ice.

Sections were incubated in the above hybridization solution, overnight at 43°C. Next day the sections were washed in SSC2X for 30 min, followed by three sequential washes of 30 min in SSC1X, SSC1X and SSC0.5X. After rinsing for 10 min in 0.1M Tris buffered saline, pH 7.5 (TBS), tissue non-specific binding was blocked by incubation of sections in 3% DNA blocking solution (Roche, Meylan, France) for 30 min at RT. After non specific binding blocking, sections were incubated overnight in sheep anti-Dig antibody (Roche, Meylan, France) at 1:500 dilution in TBS followed by 2 hours incubation in biotinylated anti-sheep antibody (Roche, Meylan, France) at 1:200 dilution in TBS. Amplification was performed either with the streptavidin-biotin complex (Vectastain Elite kit, Vector Laboratories, Abcys, Paris, France) or using the catalysed signal amplification system CSA/Per from Dakocytomation according to the instructions of the manufacturer as tyramide amplification system is known to be able to detect very few copies of viral DNA in nuclei [21-23], where other amplification systems do not work. VIP (Vector Laboratories, Abcys, Paris, France) was used as the chromogen. The sections were counterstained with methyl green, air-dried and cover slipped with Eukitt.

Controls for *in situ* hybridization consisted of sections incubated in prehybridization solution without the probe. Other control experiments were performed using sense Dig-labelled probes. In these conditions, no staining was observed.

# Results

## Early development of the olfactory system

At CS15, the OP was invaginated as a thick epithelium (Fig 1A); at CS16-17, the primordium of the VNO first appeared (Fig 1B) and was well delineated at CS18 in the medial walls of the olfactory pits, protruding towards the mesenchyme. At later stages, VNOs appeared quite identical as small tubes (Fig 1C), communicating with the nasal cavities by a channel lined with a pseudostratified epithelium similar to that of the floor of the nasal cavity (Fig 1D). As previously described, calretinin-positive neurons were present in the VNE as well as in the OE (Fig 1E and 1F).

From CS15 to CS17, the basal telencephalon in front of the OP and OE consisted in a peripheral marginal zone (MZ) as defined by Meyer et al [24] and a ventricular proliferating zone (Fig 1G and 1H); OBs were present at CS 20-21 and easily identified by the strongly calretinin-labeled peripheral olfactory fibre layer (Fig 1I).

## Neuronal migrating cells in the peripheral olfactory system

At CS 15, beta-III tubulin-positive neurosensorial cells (Fig 2A and 2B) were present in the invaginated OP. This staining was enhanced at later stages (Fig 2C and 2D). Migrating neuronal markers-positive cells, as illustrated by beta-III tubulin and calretinin immunostaining were present in the mesenchyme between the nasal epithelium and the basal telencephalon at CS 15 (Fig 2A and 2B). At C16 enhanced calretinin staining in the mesenchyme shows neuronal cells leaving the epithelium (Fig 2D) and entering the basal telencephalon (Fig 2E). At that time, no olfactory fibres had yet entered the telencephalon. From CS 20-21 to GW14, neuronal cells still detached from the VNE but not from the OE (Fig 1E and 1F).

## Reelin expression in the telencephalon and the peripheral olfactory system

At CS15, the narrow external MZ of the telencephalon in front of the invaginated OP contained beta-III tubulin-positive (Figs 2A and 3A), calretinin-negative (Fig 2B) cells aligned
tangentially to the pial surface; these neural cells were Reelin-positive (Fig 3B); at CS 16–17, the MZ was thicker and well delineated from the proliferating ventricular zone (Fig 1H); cells in the MZ were beta-III tubulin-positive (Fig 2E), Reelin-positive (Fig 3C) but calretinin-negative (Fig 2C). At CS 20–21, when the OB had developed, the olfactory fibres layer was thick, beta-III tubulin- and calretinin-positive (Fig 1I); at GW8, a clear delineation was present between the weakly Reelin-positive developing mitral cells in the differentiating layer in the OB and the strongly Reelin-positive Cajal Retzius cells as detected by immunocytochemistry or *in situ* hybridization (Fig 3D–3I); at GW12, the mitral layer was well delineated, calretinin-negative and Reelin-positive (Fig 3J–3L).

A striking observation was the presence of Reelin-expressing cells in the presumptive OE and in the migratory stream between the OE and the basal telencephalon at early developmental stages. At CS15, Reelin-expressing cells were present in the epithelium of the invaginated

<figure><img src="image_4.png" /><figcaption>**Fig 1.** Development of the human olfactory system. (A-F) Development of the OE and VNE. (A) The arrow points to the invaginated OP in front of the telencephalon. (B) The nasal cavities have developed and the presumptive VNO is first delineated (arrows). (C) A transverse section of a VNO shows a small tube lined with a pseudostratified epithelium. (D, E) The entry of the VNO (arrow) is lined with a respiratory epithelium; calretinin-positive cells are present in the VNE and in the cell-stream leaving the VNO. (F) Many calretinin-positive cells are present in the OE. (G-I) Development of the OB. (G) Higher magnification of A shows the basal telencephalon consists of a thick proliferating ventricular zone and a narrow marginal zone. (H) ICBP immunostaining (purple nuclei) shows that the MZ has developed. (I) A low magnification of a coronal section at CS 20 shows that the olfactory fibres have reached the telencephalon and form a distinct layer at the surface of the developing OB; OBs are present with a peripheral fibre layer, a differentiating layer and a ventricular layer. Abbreviations: (cal) calretinin immunostaining, (CS) Carnegie stage, (HE) hematoxylin-eosin staining, (MZ) marginal zone, (OB) olfactory bulb, (OP) olfactory placode, (Tel) telencephalon.</figcaption></figure>

doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0135710.g001
<figure><img src="image_5.png" /><figcaption>**Fig 2.** Early neuronal migratory mass in the mesenchyme between the presumptive olfactory epithelium (OE) and the basal telecephalon. (A-B) Same case as in Fig 1A. (A) Beta-III tubulin-positive cells are present in the presumptive OE, the mesenchyme and in the marginal zone of the basal telencephalon. (B) Calretinin immunostaining in the migratory mass and the presumptive OE but not in the marginal zone. (C) Calretinin-positive neurons detach from the OE and form a compact migratory stream in front of the basal telencephalon; no calretinin-positive cells are present in the marginal zone. D: high magnification of the OE; beta-III tubulin-positive neurons are present in the OE and enter the mesenchyme. E: A single beta-III tubulin-positive cell sends a neurite to the telencephalon. Abbreviations: (cal) calretinin immunostaining, (CS) Carnegie stage, (MZ) marginal zone, (tub) beta-III tubuline immunostaining.</figcaption></figure>

doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0135710.g002

OP and in the migratory stream (Fig 4A and 4B). At CS 16 and 17, more Reelin-positive cells could be observed in the OE, leaving the OE and entering the migratory stream (Fig 4C). Double Reelin and calretinin immunostaining showed that Reelin-positive cells in the epithelium and mesenchyme from CS15 to CS17 exhibited neuronal identity (Fig 4D).

## Dab 1 expression in the olfactory system

Since Dab 1 plays a key role in the Reelin signalling pathway, we examined the relation between Reelin and Dab 1 expression. At CS15, when Reelin-positive cells were detected, we did not observe Dab 1 expression in the invaginated OP or in the migrating stream. From CS16 to CS17, both Dab 1 and Reelin were present in the migratory mass of cells in the mesenchyme and no Dab 1 expressing cells were observed in the OE (Figs 4C, 4D and 5A-5C). Double immunostaining of Reelin and Dab 1 did not allow concluding about their colocalisation. At CS 18 and at later stages, no Reelin-positive cells were present in the OE (Fig 5D and 5E). In
<figure><img src="image_6.png" /><figcaption>**Fig 3.** Reelin expression in the telencephalon and in the olfactory bulb (OB). (A, B) Same case as in Fig 1A. Beta-III tubulin- and Reelin-positive cells in the marginal zone of the telencephalon when the olfactory placode has invaginated in front of the telencephalon. (C) A thicker layer of Reelin-positive cells as during the preceding stage is present in the external part of the marginal zone. (D, E) The OB is well developed and shows a thick, beta-III tubulin-positive olfactory fibre layer. (F) The weakly Reelin-positive mitral cells in the OB contrast with the strongly Reelin-positive Cajal Retzius cells. (G) High magnification of the dorsal cortex showing Reelin mRNA in the single layer of Cajal-Retzius cells precursors. (H, I) Nearly adjacent sections comparing Reelin-positive cells by *in situ* hybridization (H) or immunocytochemistry (I). (J-L) At GW 12, the mitral cell layer is well delineated, including calretinin-negative but Reelin-positive cells. Abbreviations: (cal) calretinin immunostaining, (CR) Cajal-Retzius cells, (CS) Carnegie stage, (GW) gestational week, (HE) hematoxylin-eosin staining, (MC) mitral cell layer, (OB) olfactory bulb, (OF) olfactory fibre layer, (tub) beta-III tubuline immunostaining.</figcaption></figure>

doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0135710.g003

contrast, the presumptive VNE still contained Reelin-positive cells at CS 18 (Fig 5E), but not at CS 20 (Fig 5H). The migratory flow arising from VNE (Fig 5D and 5G) contained Reelin-
<figure><img src="image_7.png" /><figcaption>**Fig 4.** Early Reelin-expressing cells in the peripheral olfactory system. (A) At CS 15, few Reelin-expressing cells are present in the presumptive OE lining the invaginated placode and in the migratory stream in the mesenchyme in front of the telencephalon (arrows). (B) A higher magnification of the epithelium shows two Reelin-positive cells (arrows). (C) At CS 17, more Reeling-positive cells are present in the OE, leaving the OE and entering the migratory stream. (D) Double Reelin and calretinin immunostaining shows that Reelin-positive cells in the OE and the mesenchyme are neurons. Abbreviations: (cal) calretinin immunostaining, (CS) Carnegie stage, (OP) olfactory placode.</figcaption></figure>

doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0135710.g004

positive cells at CS 18 and 20 (Fig 5E and 5H). No Reelin-positive cells were observed in the VN/TN from 7 to 14 GW. From CS 18, Dab 1 was present in the VN/TN and olfactory fascicles, as slender cells around nerve fibres or neurons (Fig 5F and 5I) and in the olfactory fibres layer in the OB (Fig 6A–6C). Dab 1 expression in the olfactory fascicles overlapped that of S100 protein (Fig 6E).

## GnRH neurons were not Reelin-positive

We first detected GnRH at CS 20 in the migrating stream from the VNO and entering the telencephalon (Fig 7A and 7C); double staining showed that Reelin- and GnRH-expressing cells were distinct populations both in the telencephalon and in the VN/TN fascicles (Fig 7B and 7D).

## Discussion

We show that during early olfactory development in human, neuronal cells arising from the presumptive OE/VNE express Reelin; this is a temporally and spatially regulated phenomenon
<figure><img src="image_8.png" /><figcaption>**Fig 5. Reelin and Dab 1 expression in the olfactory system.** (A-C) Adjacent sections in a CS 17 embryo. (A) The migrating cells in the mesenchyme are well delineated (arrow) in front of the telencephalon which shows a thick proliferating ventricular zone and the developing marginal zone. (B) Reelin is present in the OE, the migrating cells in the mesenchyme and in the marginal zone of the basal telencephalon. (C) Dab 1-expressing cells are present in the migratory mass but not in the OE and the marginal zone. (D-F) Near adjacent sections in a CS 18 embryo. (D) Beta-III tubulin-positive cells are present in the OE, in the presumptive VNE (arrow) and in the cells leaving the presumptive VNE. (E) Reelin is only present in the presumptive VNE and in the cell stream leaving the VNE. (F) Higher magnification of the presumptive VNE: Dab 1 is present in the stream leaving the presumptive VNE but not in the epithelium. (G-I) Adjacent sections at CS 20. (G) Calretinin-positive cells are present in the VNE and in the migrating cell stream leaving the epithelium. (H) Only weakly Reelin-labeled cells are present in the migrating cell stream. (I) Dab 1 is present in the migrating cell stream but not in the VNE. Abbreviations: (cal) calretinine immunostaining, (CS) Carnegie stage.</figcaption></figure>

doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0135710.g005

since cells first arising from the presumptive OE and then from the presumptive VNE were Reelin-positive. This expression in the epithelium and migrating stream was a transient phenomenon since no neuronal Reelin-positive cells were present from GW7 to GW14.

Olfactory area development for each stage studied was in accordance with previous studies [25-27]. Bystron et al [28] observed beta-III tubulin-positive neurons in the OP and in the
<figure><img src="image_9.png" /><figcaption>**Fig 6.** Dab 1 expression in the olfactory nerve. (A-C): Near adjacent sections of the OB at CS 20. (A) Calretinin-positive fibres form a well delineated olfactory fibre layer around the protruding OB after the olfactory fibres have reached the ventricule (arrow). (B) Weak Reelin-staining of the developing mitral cells. (C) Dab 1 expression by cells in the olfactory fibre layer. (D, E) Adjacent sections of the olfactory lamina propria at GW12: Dab 1 and S100 protein expression show a similar pattern in the olfactory fascicles. Abbreviations: (cal) calretinin immunostaining, (CS) Carnegie stage, (GW) gestational week, (OF) olfactory fibre layer.</figcaption></figure>

doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0135710.g006

adjacent mesenchyme as soon as CS13. We showed at CS15, when the OP has invaginated, the presence of neurons both in the epithelium and the adjacent mesenchyme. The neurons arising from the OP, so called pioneer neurons [29] were seen penetrating the telencephalon at CS15, as we did at CS16. A common origin of these pioneer neurons with early cortical predecessor neurons in the anterior neural plate has been suggested [28]; the same authors concluded that these cells were not Cajal-Retzius cells as they did not detect Reelin at that time. However, we detected Reelin-expressing neurons in the basal telencephalon, as well as in the epithelium and in the mesenchyme at CS15. A point we could not elucidate was whether the neurons entering the telencephalon were Reelin-positive; if that was the case, we could hypothesize that the very early Reelin-positive cells at the surface of the presumptive cortex could be in part of peripheral origin. That point needs further explorations using both immunocytochemistry and *in situ* hybridization. Indeed, we successfully used for Reelin mRNA detection, an *in situ* hybridization method combining probe preparation by PCR, as previously described by Jalabi et al [19, 20] for oligodendrocytes PLP mRNA detection, and the powerfull signal amplification by tyramide, we previously used to detect single viral copies [21-23]. While classical streptavidin-
<figure><img src="image_10.png" /><figcaption>**Fig 7.** GnRH neurons in the cell stream arising from the vomeronasal organ and in the central nervous system are not Reelin-positive. (A, C) Some cells arising from the VNO are faintly Reelin-positive as in Fig 5H but are distinct from GnRH neurons. (B, D) GnRH cells which have entered the central nervous system are distinct from the Reelin-positive Cajal-Retzius cells present in the marginal zone. Abbreviations: (CS) Carnegie stage.</figcaption></figure>

doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0135710.g007

biotin complex method gave no signal, tyramide amplification showed strong Reelin signals. One constraint of *in situ* hybridization is the tissue fixation method since Bouin-Holland fixative preserves morphological details, but destroys nucleic acids, reason why we could not apply the method to the youngest embryos in the present study. This powerfull signal amplification method by tyramide will be useful when working on human embryonic and foetal tissue parafin-embedded sections, mainly in pathological conditions, where mRNA levels may be very weak because of the delay between *in utero* death and tissue fixation.

The most studied neuronal population in the migratory mass [30] are GnRH neurons that migrate in human as in other species from the OP to the hypothalamus [2, 31, 32]; they have been first detected at 42 but not at 28 or 32 days of embryogenesis [31]. Our observations highly suggest that the early neurons expressing Reelin were not GnRH neurons. The first Reelin-positive neurons in this study, present at CS 15 (approximately 35 days of pregnancy) were GnRH-negative. At CS20, when GnRH neurons very strongly expressed the peptide, the very few Reelin-positive cells still present in the VN/TN were not GnRH neurons.

What may be the role of the early Reelin-positive neurons? In the central nervous system, Reelin is an extracellular glycoprotein essential for migration and correct positioning of
cerebral cortical neurons as well as for other neurons such as midbrain or spinal cord neurons. For the peripheral olfactory system, it has been suggested in mice that olfactory and vomeronasal fibres pathfinding was dependent upon the presence of Reelin in the mesenchyme [13]; however, in *reeler* mice where Reelin is absent, normal VN development occurs [12] suggesting that Reelin is not the only guidance molecule for olfactory or vomeronasal fibres. However, it has been shown that Schwann cells in the developing peripheral nerve secrete Reelin, its level is downregulated in adult but upregulated following nerve injury and its absence in *reeler* mouse impairs axonal regeneration following injury [33, 34]. In the present study in human, we only observed Reelin-expressing neurons in a temporally determined window, first in the presumptive OE and then in the presumptive VNE; the expression is correlated with the early detachment of cells from the epithelium since soon after the beginning of epithelium differentiation, the intra-epithelial expression ceased. As Reelin is mainly considered as acting as a secreted extracellular molecule binding to receptors at the cell surface of other cells as those which secrete Reelin, we studied the expression of Dab 1, an adaptator intracellular protein activated following Reelin binding to its receptors (reviews in [35-38]). We did not detect Dab 1, neither in the epithelium nor in the mesenchyme at the earliest stage when epithelial and intra-mesenchymal neurons were Reelin-positive. The question arises whether the expression level of Dab 1 was too weak at that time to be detected by our immunocytochemistry method. Further studies are needed to explore the expression of the other members of the Reelin-pathway to elucidate that point. Conversely, Reelin may act independently from Dab 1; one possibility may be an autocrine action. Indeed, Reelin expressed by lymphatic endothelial cells during development in rodents and human [11] up-regulates an endothelial factor promoting smooth muscle development leading to lymphatics morphogenesis, in a way independent from the classical Reelin receptors [39]. Also Cariboni et al [40] showed that Reelin was a repellent for GnRH, guiding the neurons to the hypothalamus, in a manner independent from the classical Reelin cascade. Whether pioneer neurons promote their own migration through Reelin expression and action in an independent manner from the classical Reelin cascade will need further consideration.

At CS18, Dab 1 was present around and within olfactory fascicles, when olfactory Reelin expression had ceased; the cells shared the same pattern as S100 protein-positive cells, suggesting they are OECs. OECs are considered as a distinct glial type showing common properties of both Schwann cells and astrocytes. They promote the outgrowth of newly formed olfactory axons and direct them to their proper position in the OB (for review see [41, 42]). As Reelin was no more present, Dab 1 may function in a Reelin-independent pathway. Andrade et al [43] showed that postnatal neuronal migration in the rostral stream needs ApoER2/VLDL receptors and Dab 1, independently of Reelin. However, Howell et al [44] showed that VEGF regulated NMDA receptor via Dab 1. Dab 1 present in the human vomeronasal cell clusters or in the olfactory nerve fascicles may then mediate other signaling cascade as that initiated by Reelin.

**Acknowledgments**

We are grateful to Patricia Bos, Roland Bury, Josiane Meder and Anne-Laure Burry for their excellent technical assistance.

**Author Contributions**

Conceived and designed the experiments: NB. Performed the experiments: MCA BS MSG NB. Analyzed the data: NB. Contributed reagents/materials/analysis tools: MCA BS MSG NB. Wrote the paper: MCA BS MSG NB.
References

1. Boehm N, Gasser B. Sensory receptors-like cells in the human foetal vomeronasal organ. Neuroreport. 1993; 4: 867-870. PMID: 8369475

2. Schwanzel-Fukuda M, Pfaff DW. Origin of luteinising hormone-releasing hormone neurons. Nature. 1989; 338: 161-164. PMID: 2645530

3. Gonzalez-Martinez D, Hu Y, Bouloux P. Ontogeny of GnRH and olfactory neuronal systems in man: novel insights from the investigation of inherited forms of Kallmann's syndrome. Front Neuroendocrinol. 2004; 25: 108-130. PMID: 15571757

4. Tissir F, Goffinet AM. Reelin and brain development. Nat Rev Neurosci. 2003; 4: 496-505. PMID: 12778121

5. Soriano E, del Rio JA. The cells of Cajal-Retzius: still a mystery one century after. Neuron. 2005; 46: 389-394. PMID: 15882637

6. D'Arcangelo G, Homayouni R, Keshvara L, Rice DS, Sheldon M, Curran T. Reelin as a ligand for lipo-protein receptors. Neuron. 1999; 24: 411-420.

7. Hiesberger T, Trommsdorff M, Howell BW, Goffinet A, Mumby MC, Coper JA et al. Direct binding of reelin to VLDL receptor and ApoE receptor 2 induces tyrosine phosphorylation of disabled-1 and modulates tau phosphorylation. Neuron. 1999; 24: 481-489. PMID: 10571241

8. Howell BW, Herrick TM, Cooper JA. Reelin-induced tyrosine phosphorylation of disabled 1 during neuronal positioning. Genes Dev. 1999; 13: 643-648. PMID: 10090720

9. Trommsdorff M, Gotthardt M, Hiesberger T, Shelton J, Stockinger W, Nimpf J et al. Reeler/Disabled-like disruption of neuronal migration in knockout mice lacking the VLDL receptor and ApoE receptor 2. Cell. 1999; 97: 689-701. PMID: 10380922

10. Smalheiser NR, Costa E, Guidotti A, Impagnatiello F, Auta J, Lacor P et al. Expression of Reelin in adult mammalian blood, liver, pituitary pars intermedia, and adrenal chromaffin cells. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 2000; 97: 1281-1286. PMID: 10655522

11. Samama B, Boehm N. Reelin immunoreactivity in lymphatics and liver during development and adult life. Anat Rec A. 2005; 285: 595-599.

12. Teillon SM, Yiu G, Walsh CA. Reelin is expressed in the accessory olfactory system, but is not a guidance cue for vomeronasal axons. Brain Res Dev Brain Res. 2003; 140: 303-307. PMID: 12586436

13. Schnaufer C, Breer H, Fleischer J. Outgrowing olfactory axons contain the Reelin receptor VLDLR and navigate through the Reelin-rich cribriform mesenchyme. Cell Tissue Res. 2009; 337: 393-406. doi: 10.1007/s00441-009-0762-5 PMID: 19572151

14. Perez-Garcia CG, Tissir F, Goffinet AM, Meyer G. Reelin receptors in developing laminated brain structures of mouse and human. Eur J Neurosci. 2004; 20: 2827-2832. PMID: 15548227

15. O'Rahilly R, Muller F. Minireview: summary of the initial development of the human nervous system. Teratology. 1999; 60: 39-41. PMID: 10413339

16. Wolff-Quenot MJ, Sick H. Atlas d'embryologie clinique, De Boeck Université, Paris, Bruxelles; 1997.

17. Feess-Higgins A, Larroche JC. Le développement du cerveau foetal humain-Atlas anatomique. Editions INSERM, Masson, Paris; 1987.

18. De Bergeyck V, Naerhuyzen B, Goffinet AM, Lambert de Rouvroit C. A panel of monoclonal antibodies against reelin, the extracellular matrix protein defective in reeler mutant mice. J Neurosci Methods. 1998; 82: 17-24. PMID: 10223511

19. Jalabi W, Cerghet M, Skoff RP, Ghandour MS. Detection of oligodendrocytes in tissue sections using PCR synthesis of digoxigenin-labelled probes. J Histochem Cytochem. 2003; 51: 913-919. PMID: 12810841

20. Jalabi W, Boehm N, Grucker D, Ghandour MS. Recovery of myelin after induction of oligodendrocyte cell death in postnatal brain. J Neurosci. 2005; 25: 2885-2894. PMID: 15772348

21. Samama B, Plas-Roser S, Schaeffer C, Chateau D, Fabre M, Boehm N. HPV DNA detection by in situ hybridization with catalysed signal amplification on thin-layer cervical smears. J Histochem Cytochem. 2002; 50: 1417-1420. PMID: 12364574

22. Samama B, Lipsker D, Boehm N. P16 expression in relation to human papillomavirus in anogenital lesions. Hum Pathol. 2006; 37: 513-519. PMID: 16647947

23. Samama B, Schaeffer C, Boehm N. P16 expression in relation to human papillomavirus in liquid-based cervical smears. Gynecol Oncol. 2008; 109: 285-290. doi: 10.1016/j.ygyno.2008.01.043 PMID: 18387664

24. Meyer G, Schaaps JP, Moreau L, Goffinet AM. Embryonic and early fetal development of the human neocortex. J Neurosci. 2000; 20: 1858-1868. PMID: 10684887
25. O'Rahilly R. The early development of the nasal pit in staged human embryos. Anat Rec. 1967; 157: 380.

26. Bossy J. Development of olfactory and related structures in staged embryos. Anat Embryol. 1980; 161: 225-236. PMID: 7469043

27. Kim CH, Park HW, Kim K, Yoon JH. Early development of the nose in human embryos: a stereomicroscopic analysis. Laringoscope. 2004; 114: 1791-1800.

28. Bystron I, Rakic P, Molnar Z, Blakemore C. The first neurons of the human cerebral cortex. Nat Neurosci. 2006; 9: 880-886. PMID: 16783367

29. Whitlock KE, Westerfield M. A transient population of neurons pioneers the olfactory pathway in the zebrafish. J Neurosci. 1998; 18: 8919-8927. PMID: 9786997

30. Valverde F, Santacana M, Heredia M. Formation of an olfactory glomerulus: morphological aspects of development and organization. Neuroscience. 1992; 49: 255-275. PMID: 1436469

31. Schwanzel-Fukuda M, Crossin KL, Pfaff DW, Bouloux PM, Hardelin JP, Petit C. Migration of luteinizing-releasing hormone (LHRH) neurons in early human embryos. J Comp Neurol. 1996; 366: 256-270.

32. Boehm N, Roos J, Gasser B. Luteinizing hormone-releasing hormone (LHRH)-expressing cells in the nasal septum of human foetuses. Brain Res Dev Brain Res. 1994; 82: 175-180. PMID: 7842505

33. Panteri R, Mey J, Zhelyaznik N, D'Altocolle A, Del Fa A, Gangitano C. Reelin is transiently expressed in the peripheral nerve during development and is upregulated following nerve crush. Mol Cell Neurosci. 2006; 32: 133-142. PMID: 16697663

34. Lorenzetto E, Panteri R, Marino R, Keller F, Buffelli M. Impaired nerve regeneration in Reeler mice after peripheral nerve injury. Eur J Neurosci. 2008; 27: 12-19. PMID: 18093172

35. Rice DS, Curran T. Role of the reelin signalling pathway in the central nervous system development. Ann Rev Neurosci. 1999; 24: 1005-1039.

36. Bar I, Lambert de Rouvroit C, Goffinet AM. The Reelin signaling pathway in mouse cortical development. Eur J Morphol. 2000; 38: 321-325. PMID: 11151045

37. Förster E, Jossin Y, Zhao S, Chai X, Frotscher M, Goffinet AM. Recent progress in understanding the role of Reelin in radial neuronal migration, with specific emphasis on dentate gyrus. Eur J Neurosci. 2006; 23: 901-909. PMID: 16519655

38. Stolt PC, Bock HH. Modulation of lipoprotein receptor functions by intracellular adaptor proteins. Cell Signal. 2006; 18: 1560-1571. PMID: 16725309

39. Lutter S, Xie S, Tatin F, Makinen T. Smooth muscle-endothelial cell communication activates Reelin signalling and regulates lymphatic vessel formation. J Cell Biol. 2012; 197: 837-849. doi: 10.1083/jcb.201110132 PMID: 22665518

40. Cariboni A, Rakic S, Liappi A, Maggi R, Goffinet A, Parnavelas JG. Reelin provides an inhibitory signal in the migration of gonadotropin-releasing hormone neurons. Development. 2005; 132: 4709-4718. PMID: 16207762

41. Fairless R, Barnett SC. Olfactory ensheathing cells: their role in central nervous system repair. Int J Biochem Cell Biol. 2005; 37: 693-699. PMID: 15694828

42. Eckberg JAK, Amaya D, Mackay-Sim A, St. John JA. The migration of olfactory ensheathing cells during development and regeneration. 2012; 20: 147-158.

43. Andrade N, Komnenovic V, Blake SM, Jossin Y, Howell B, Goffinet A et al. ApoER2/VLDL receptor and Dab1 in the rostral migratory stream function in postnatal neuronal migration independently of reelin. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 2007; 104: 8508-8513. PMID: 17494763

44. Howell KR, Hoda MN, Pillai A. VEGF activates phosphorylation through Dab 1 pathway. Neurosci Lett. 2013; 552: 30-34 doi: 10.1016/j.neulet.2013.07.032 PMID: 23916658