# Acute effect of tendon vibration applied during isometric contraction at two knee angles on maximal knee extension force production

Jonathan Harnie, Thomas Cattagni, Christophe Cornu, Peter Mcnair, Marc Jubeau

► To cite this version:

Jonathan Harnie, Thomas Cattagni, Christophe Cornu, Peter Mcnair, Marc Jubeau. Acute effect of tendon vibration applied during isometric contraction at two knee angles on maximal knee extension force production. PLoS ONE, 2020, 15 (11), pp.e0242324. 10.1371/journal.pone.0242324. hal-03289154

HAL Id: hal-03289154

https://nantes-universite.hal.science/hal-03289154v1

Submitted on 7 Jul 2025

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access
archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-
entific research documents, whether they are pub-
lished or not. The documents may come from
teaching and research institutions in France or
abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L'archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est
destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents
scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,
émanant des établissements d'enseignement et de
recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires
publics ou privés.

<figure><img src="image_1.png" /></figure>

Distributed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License
RESEARCH ARTICLE

# Acute effect of tendon vibration applied during isometric contraction at two knee angles on maximal knee extension force production

Jonathan Harnie¹‡, Thomas Cattagni 1,†, Christophe Cornu¹, Peter McNair², Marc Jubeau¹*

1 Laboratoire Motricité, Interactions, Performance EA 4334, Faculty of Sport Sciences, University of Nantes, Nantes, France, 2 Health and Rehabilitation Research Institute, Faculty of Health and Environmental Sciences, Auckland University of Technology, Auckland, New Zealand

‡ JH and TC contributed equally to this work as co-first authors.

* marc.jubeau@univ-nantes.fr

<figure><img src="image_2.png" /></figure>

## Abstract

The aim of the current study was to investigate the effect of a single session of prolonged tendon vibration combined with low submaximal isometric contraction on maximal motor performance. Thirty-two young sedentary adults were assigned into two groups that differed based on the knee angle tested: 90° or 150° (180° = full knee extension). Participants performed two fatigue-inducing exercise protocols: one with three 10 min submaximal (10% of maximal voluntary contraction) knee extensor contractions and patellar tendon vibration (80 Hz) another with submaximal knee extensor contractions only. Before and after each fatigue protocol, maximal voluntary isometric contractions (MVC), voluntary activation level (assessed by the twitch interpolation technique), peak-to-peak amplitude of maximum compound action potentials of vastus medialis and vastus lateralis (assessed by electromyography with the use of electrical nerve stimulation), peak twitch amplitude and peak doublet force were measured. The knee extensor fatigue was significantly (P<0.05) greater in the 90° knee angle group (-20.6% MVC force, P<0.05) than the 150° knee angle group (-8.3% MVC force, P = 0.062). Both peripheral and central alterations could explain the reduction in MVC force at 90° knee angle. However, tendon vibration added to isometric contraction did not exacerbate the reduction in MVC force. These results clearly demonstrate that acute infrapatellar tendon vibration using a commercial apparatus operating at optimal conditions (i.e. contracted and stretched muscle) does not appear to induce knee extensor neuromuscular fatigue in young sedentary subjects.

<figure><img src="image_3.png" /></figure>

OPEN ACCESS

**Citation:** Harnie J, Cattagni T, Cornu C, McNair P, Jubeau M (2020) Acute effect of tendon vibration applied during isometric contraction at two knee angles on maximal knee extension force production. PLoS ONE 15(11): e0242324. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0242324

**Editor:** Riccardo Di Giminiani, University of L'Aquila, ITALY

**Received:** November 29, 2019

**Accepted:** November 2, 2020

**Published:** November 13, 2020

**Copyright:** © 2020 Harnie et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.

**Data Availability Statement:** All relevant data are within the manuscript.

**Funding:** The research was supported by a grant (n°2013-12915) from the Region des Pays de la Loire, France, for the project "Longévité, Mobilité, Autonomie" (LMA), http://www.paysdelaloire.fr.

**Competing interests:** The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.

## Introduction

Over the past two decades, the effects of prolonged tendon vibration on maximal motor performance have been widely investigated. However, the results reported in the literature are
contradictory. Some findings showed a decrease in maximal force production for knee exten-
sor (KE) [1–6], plantar flexor [7–9] and dorsiflexor [10] muscles following at least 20 min of
tendon/muscle vibration. Prolonged vibration may therefore induce neuromuscular fatigue,
defined by a reduction in maximal voluntary contraction (MVC) force [11]. Neuromuscular
fatigue is associated with alterations at different levels of the motor pathway from the brain to
the skeletal muscle [11,12]. It is classically defined as being proximal (central fatigue) or distal
(peripheral fatigue) to the neuromuscular junction, even if neuromuscular fatigue results from
a complex interaction between both central and peripheral fatigue [11]. After prolonged vibra-
tion, it has been reported that peripheral mechanisms are rarely altered [3,6–8,13–16], suggest-
ing that the decrease in MVC force is mainly explained by neural alterations. In this context,
previous studies showed an attenuation of Ia afferent function [1, 2, 5, 7, 8], supported by reduc-
tions in spinal loop excitability, as evidence by H-reflex measurement [13,14]. However, this
reduction in H-reflex excitability is not always associated with a reduction in maximal force
production [14,15]. Indeed, recent investigations did not reveal a significant effect of tendon
vibration on maximal motor performance for muscle groups crossing the ankle or the knee
joints [13–16]. Although experimental parameters such as the vibration frequency used [1,16]
have been examined in the literature to maximize fatigue effect following prolonged tendon/
muscle vibration, other factors need to be explored such as muscle activity (i.e. contraction) or
joint angle (i.e. muscle length) during vibration.

Indeed, it is worth noting that participants in the aforementioned studies were asked to
remain relaxed during prolonged tendon vibration. However, muscle contraction implies an
increased activity of γ-motor neurons that control the sensitivity of muscle spindle primary
endings [17]. In other words, increased levels of γ-motor neuron activation result in more sen-
sitive muscle spindle primary endings. Consequently, a higher discharge rate of spindle muscle
endings is observed when tendon vibration is applied during submaximal isometric muscle
contraction compared to muscle discharge at rest [18]. Therefore, submaximal muscle con-
traction performed during prolonged tendon vibration may strengthen the attenuation of Ia
afferent function and cause a higher alteration in maximal muscle force production. Whereas
some authors used prolonged tendon vibration during submaximal KE muscles contraction
for optimizing chronic neuromuscular adaptations [19–22], the acute effects of a single session
combining KE muscles contraction and vibration has never been investigated.

Furthermore, the question of the effect of joint angle on neuromuscular fatigue while pro-
longed tendon vibration is applied remains to be considered. Considering the knee joint
model, a change in knee angle from extended to flexed leg causes an elongation of KE muscles
[23,24]. It is well known that increasing muscle length implies an enhanced Ia, Ib and second-
ary afferent sensitivity [25–27]. Furthermore, it has been found that the Ia afferent discharge
rate associated with vibration is higher at long muscle lengths than at short muscle lengths
[18]. Prolonged KE contraction with tendon vibration at a long muscle length (i.e. flexed knee)
should therefore induce more neuromuscular fatigue than at a short muscle length (i.e.
extended leg).

The purpose of this study was therefore to assess the effect of a fatiguing exercise including
the application of tendon vibration during submaximal isometric KE contraction at two knee
angles (i.e. 90° and 150°; 180° = full leg extension) on the maximal motor performance of KE
muscles. Knee angles of 90° and 150° were chosen because they correspond to long (stretched)
KE muscle length and short (slacked) KE muscle length, respectively [28]. We hypothesized
that prolonged weak muscle contraction induced a greater neuromuscular fatigue with con-
comitant tendon vibration than without vibration. Since tendon vibration especially alters Ia
afferent function, we also hypothesized that the neuromuscular fatigue induced by tendon
vibration during the submaximal contraction may primarily result from central fatigue. In
addition, since the effects of vibration are more effective at long muscle lengths rather than at short muscle lengths, we assumed that the neuromuscular fatigue should be greater at a 90° knee angle compared to a 150° knee angle.

# Methods

## Participants

Thirty-two young adults (25 males, 7 females, 22.1 ± 3.2 years, 174.7 ± 8.2 cm, 67.5 ± 10.3 kg, mean ± standard deviation) with no history of neurological and/or musculoskeletal disorders participated in the experiment. Only sedentary individuals were included, i.e. individual who had less than 2 hours of moderate-to-intensive physical activity per week within the 6 months preceding the experimental session. Selected individuals were volunteers and gave their written consent prior to participation in the investigation after being informed about the nature, aims, possible risks and discomfort associated with the study. They were asked not to engage in any strenuous locomotor activity for at least 48 h before the experimental sessions. The protocol of the current investigation was approved by the ethics committee of Nantes and was in conformity with the Declaration of Helsinki (last modification, 2013).

## Design and procedures

Participants were randomly assigned into two different groups, based on the knee angle tested: i) group 90° (performing neuromuscular assessment and fatiguing exercise at 90° knee angle); ii) group 150° (performing neuromuscular assessment and fatiguing exercise at 150° knee angle). All tests were carried out on the right leg. Each participant completed two experimental sessions: one in which fatiguing exercise included tendon vibration and submaximal KE contraction (10% MVC); and another in which fatiguing exercise only included submaximal KE contraction at 10% MVC (control session, i.e without vibration). These two experimental sessions were randomly administered to the participants at the same time of day and were interspaced by an interval of 4 weeks.

Before each experimental session, the optimal intensity of stimulation evoking maximal compound action potentials (Mmax) and maximal twitch force was determined. Then, participants performed a standardized warm-up consisting of nine submaximal KE contractions (3 at 25%, 3 at 50% and 3 at 90% of their estimated maximum force), each lasting 5 s. Each experimental session included in the following order: 1) two or three 5 s maximal voluntary contractions (MVC) of the KE muscles; 2) a fatiguing exercise; 3) one MVC of the KE muscles, 4–5 s after the fatiguing exercise (Fig 1).

Each subject performed two MVCs of the KE muscles before the fatiguing exercise. A third MVC trial was performed if the difference in the peak force between the two MVC was greater than 5%. Each MVC effort lasted 5 s and a 4 min rest period was given between each MVC to

<figure><img src="image_4.png" /><figcaption>**Fig 1.** Illustration of the experimental protocol. MVC: maximal voluntary contraction; 1 arrow: single electrical stimulus; 2 arrows: doublet stimulation (10 ms between 2 electrical stimuli); condition: with vibration or without vibration; dotted line: rest period.</figcaption></figure>

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0242324.g001
avoid potential fatigue effects. Another MVC was performed 4–5 s after the fatiguing exercise.
Standardized verbal encouragement was given during attempts to produce the maximal effort.

The fatiguing protocol consisted of three bouts of 10 min sustained KE contractions at an intensity corresponding to 10% MVC force. The force signal and a target line corresponding to 10% MVC force were displayed on a monitor in front of the subject to provide a visual feedback. Individuals were asked to maintain the force signal on the target line. A minute rest period was given between each bout. For the experimental session including vibration, low-amplitude mechanical vibrations (amplitude: 1 mm) were applied perpendicularly to the midportion of the right infrapatellar tendon using a commercial vibrator apparatus (Techno Concept, VB 115, Maine, France) during each of the three sustained contractions (Fig 2). The vibrator apparatus was strapped to the knee using elastic Velcro fasteners for the two protocols (i.e. vibration protocol and no-vibration protocol). To optimize the activation of Ia afferents, the vibration frequency was set at 80 Hz [29,30]. For the control session, the vibrator apparatus

<figure><img src="image_5.png" /><figcaption>**Fig 2.** Illustration of experimental setup used during neuromuscular assessment and fatiguing exercise for the experimental session in which the individuals were tested at 150° knee angle. VL: Vastus Lateralis; VM: Vastus Medialis.</figcaption></figure>

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0242324.g002
was placed over the infrapatellar tendon, but no vibration was applied, while participants performed the three submaximal KE contractions.

## Data collection

Mechanical responses associated with MVC and electrical stimulations of the KE muscles were collected using a home-made ergometer with a strain gauge (model CSSPE01345, Garos capteur, Bouguenais, France; calibration: 0 mV = 0 N; 3.5mV = -981 N France) (Fig 2). Participants were firmly attached to the ergometer by non-elastic belts, with a 90° hip joint angle (0° = full hip extension) and the right anatomical knee flexion-extension axis being aligned with the center of the ergometer's rotation. The right leg was firmly attached with noncompliant straps to the ergometer's accessory. In all of the experimental sessions, individuals were instructed to keep their head straight against the back of the chair while their arms crossed and grasped the two crossover shoulder belts, to avoid any movement (Fig 2).

Regarding electromyographic (EMG) recordings, the subject's skin was carefully prepared by shaving, abrading and cleaning with alcohol. With respect to the SENIAM recommendation [31] and the underlying muscle fiber arrangement, two circular surface electrodes (Kendall Medi-Trace™, Canada) with a 1 mm diameter and an inter-electrode distance (center to center) of 2 cm were placed on the target muscles. For the vastus medialis (VM), a pair of electrodes was placed at 80% on the line between the anterior spina iliaca superior and the joint space in front of the anterior border of the medial ligament. For the vastus lateralis (VL), a second pair of electrodes was positioned at 2/3 on the line from the anterior spina iliaca superior to the lateral side of the patella. The reference electrodes were positioned on the patella of the left leg. The placement of the electrodes was marked on the skin with an indelible pen in order to ensure that the same recording site was used between the two experimental sessions (i.e. over 4 weeks). The EMG signal was collected using a BIOPAC MP35 system, sampled at 2 kHz, amplified (x500) and filtered with a band-pass filter 5 Hz–500 Hz. The EMG signals were stored with commercially available software (BIOPAC Student Lab Pro®, BIOPAC System Inc., Goleta, USA).

A high-voltage constant-current stimulator (maximal voltage 400 V, model DS7A, Digitiemer, Hertfordshire, UK) was used to perform transcutaneous electrically-evoked contractions of the KE muscles. The stimulator was set to deliver rectangular pulses (1 ms) with a high voltage (400 V). The femoral nerve was stimulated using a surface electrode (Kendall Medi-Trace™, Canada) positioned over the nerve, in the femoral triangle. The anode was a rectangular electrode (50×90 mm; Stimex, Rouffach, France) located in the gluteal fold opposite to the cathode. The optimal intensity of stimulation required to evoke a $M_{max}$ for VL and VM and maximal twitch force was determined at rest by progressively increasing stimulation intensity by 10 mA from 40 mA until the $M_{max}$. The optimal intensity of stimulation was set to 120% of that required to elicit VL and VM $M_{max}$ and maximal twitch force. Stimulation intensity was kept constant throughout the protocol (mean current, 84.4 ± 15.7 mA). A single electrical femoral nerve stimulation was delivered at rest 4 s before each MVC. A doublet (10 ms between 2 stimuli) was delivered over the isometric plateau (superimposed doublet) and 4 s after each MVC (potentiated doublet) to estimate the voluntary activation level (VAL) according to the interpolated twitch technique [32–34] (Fig 1).

## Data analysis

The MVC force was considered as the highest peak force value measured over two (or three) trials. Peak twitch force and peak doublet force were measured to assess peripheral fatigue [32,35]. The VAL was quantified by measurement of the superimposed force response to nerve
stimulation during the MVC effort [36,37] to assess central fatigue. Because the superimposed stimulation is not consistently applied at the MVC peak force, the VAL was estimated according to the following formula, including the Strojnik and Komi [38] correction:

$$VAL = \left[ 1 - \frac{\text{superimposed doublet amplitude} \times (T_{\text{stim}}/\text{MVC force})}{\text{potentiated doublet amplitude}} \times 100 \right]$$

VAL: maximal voluntary activation level; T<sub>stim</sub>: force value recorded at the time of the superimposed double stimulation; MVC force: maximal voluntary contraction peak force

Peak-to-peak amplitude of VL and VM M<sub>max</sub> was measured from each single stimulus preceding the MVCs before and after the fatiguing exercises.

## Statistical analysis

The statistical analyses were performed using Statistica software 7.0 (StatSoft Inc., Tulsa, Oklahoma, USA). Data are presented as means ± standard deviation. A significance level of *P*<0.05 was used to identify statistical significance. All data being normally distributed (Shapiro-Wilk test), three-factor repeated measures ANOVAs [angle (90° and 150°) x condition (vibration and no-vibration) x time (before and immediately after fatiguing exercise)] were performed to compare each of the dependent variables (MVC force, VAL, peak twitch force, peak doublet force, and M<sub>max</sub> for VL and VM muscles). When a main effect or a significant interaction was found, a post-hoc analysis was made using Tukey's test. Partial eta squared (η<sub>p</sub><sup>2</sup>) values have been reported as measures of the effect size, with η<sub>p</sub><sup>2</sup> > 0.14 considered to be a very large effect and 0.07 < η<sub>p</sub><sup>2</sup> < 0.14 considered to be a moderate effect [39].

## Results

All the mechanical and electrophysiological measurements are presented in Table 1.

### Maximal knee extensor force production

Statistical analysis performed for KE MVC force revealed a significant time effect (*P*<0.001; η<sub>p</sub><sup>2</sup> = 0.68) with an interaction angle × time (*P*<0.001; η<sub>p</sub><sup>2</sup> = 0.39) but no effect of the vibration condition was observed (*P* = 0.21; η<sub>p</sub><sup>2</sup> = 0.05). The post-hoc analysis showed that the KE MVC force was higher for the group<sup>90°</sup> than the group<sup>150°</sup> (*P*<0.05; η<sub>p</sub><sup>2</sup> = 0.18) before the fatiguing exercise (Fig 3A). The MVC force was significantly reduced (*P*<0.001) after the fatiguing

<table><caption>Table 1. Mechanical and electrophysiological measurements according to angle, vibration condition and time.</caption><thead><tr><th rowspan="3"></th><th colspan="4">90°</th><th colspan="4">150°</th><th colspan="2">STATISTICS</th></tr><tr><th colspan="2">WITH VIBRATION</th><th colspan="2">WITHOUT VIBRATION</th><th colspan="2">WITH VIBRATION</th><th colspan="2">WITHOUT VIBRATION</th><th rowspan="2">Main effects</th><th rowspan="2">Interaction</th></tr><tr><th>MVC Pre</th><th>MVC Post</th><th>MVC Pre</th><th>MVC Post</th><th>MVC Pre</th><th>MVC Post</th><th>MVC Pre</th><th>MVC Post</th></tr></thead><tbody><tr><td>MVC force (N)</td><td>1563±490</td><td>1228±338</td><td>1594±496</td><td>1274±384</td><td>1099±333</td><td>1006±344</td><td>1099±374</td><td>1008±407</td><td>Angle-Fatigue</td><td>Fatigue* Angle</td></tr><tr><td>Single twitch force (N)</td><td>315±80</td><td>269±103</td><td>310±145</td><td>252±112</td><td>147±52</td><td>140±59</td><td>145±69</td><td>120±60</td><td>Angle-Fatigue</td><td>/</td></tr><tr><td>PD force (N)</td><td>673±193</td><td>578±169</td><td>623±221</td><td>564±204</td><td>469±144</td><td>473±149</td><td>468±159</td><td>463±177</td><td>Angle-Fatigue</td><td>Fatigue* Angle</td></tr><tr><td>VAL (%)</td><td>93.6±4.1</td><td>87.5±5.6</td><td>95.8±3.0</td><td>91.6±6.7</td><td>90.9±10.4</td><td>90.2±12.0</td><td>91.8±9.7</td><td>89.9±10.6</td><td>Fatigue</td><td>Fatigue* Angle</td></tr><tr><td>VL M<sub>max</sub> (mV)</td><td>6.4±4.6</td><td>5.9±3.8</td><td>6.3±4.2</td><td>6.0±4.2</td><td>7.0±2.9</td><td>6.6±3.0</td><td>6.5±2.7</td><td>6.2±3.0</td><td>Fatigue</td><td>/</td></tr><tr><td>VM M<sub>max</sub> (mV)</td><td>9.8±4.0</td><td>9.2±3.9</td><td>8.2±3.5</td><td>7.3±3.2</td><td>8.9±3.2</td><td>8.9±3</td><td>9.0±3.6</td><td>8.8±3.7</td><td>Fatigue</td><td>Fatigue* Angle</td></tr></tbody></table>

Values are means ± SD; MVC: Maximal voluntary contraction; VAL: Voluntary activation level; PD: Potentiated doublet; Pre: before fatiguing exercise; Post: immediately after fatiguing exercise; VL: Vastus Lateralis; VM: Vastus Medialis; M<sub>max</sub>: maximal compound action potential.
<figure><img src="image_6.png" /></figure>

<figure><img src="image_7.png" /></figure>

A

<figure><img src="image_8.png" /></figure>

B

<figure><img src="image_9.png" /></figure>

C

<figure><img src="image_10.png" /></figure>
**Fig 3.** Effect of knee angle and fatiguing exercise on neuromuscular characteristics. A represents the effect of knee angle and fatiguing exercise on MVC force. B represents the effect of knee angle and fatiguing exercise on voluntary activation level, C represents the effect of knee angle and fatiguing exercise on potentiated doublet force. Note that this figure represents the significant interaction between angle and time, i.e. the conditions with vibration and without vibration are pooled. *MVC: Maximal voluntary contraction; VAL: Voluntary activation level.* \* P < 0.05, \*\* P < 0.01, \*\*\* P < 0.001.

https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0242324.g003

exercise for the group⁹⁰°. For the group¹⁵⁰°, the MVC force was not significantly reduced but a strong tendency towards statistical significance was found (P<0.06).

## Twitch force and evoked potentials

Statistical analysis performed for peak twitch force revealed a significant angle (P<0.001; $\eta_p^2$ = 0.45) and time effect (P<0.01; $\eta_p^2$ = 0.28) but no effect of the vibration condition was observed (P = 0.21; $\eta_p^2$ = 0.04).

The ANOVA analysis performed for peak doublet force revealed a significant time effect (P<0.001; $\eta_p^2$ = 0.45) and an interaction angle × time (P<0.001; $\eta_p^2$ = 0.44) but no effect of the vibration condition (P = 0.22; $\eta_p^2$ = 0.04). The post hoc analysis showed that the peak doublet force was greater for the group⁹⁰° than that for the group¹⁵⁰° before the fatiguing exercise (648.3 ± 207.7 vs. 468.8 ± 152.1 N, respectively; P<0.001). Only the potentiated doublet force of the group⁹⁰° was significantly reduced after the fatiguing exercise (P<0.001).

Statistical analysis performed for Mmax amplitude revealed a significant time effect of VL (P<0.05; $\eta_p^2$ = 0.13) and VM muscle (P<0.001; $\eta_p^2$ = 0.22) and an interaction angle × time of VM muscle (P<0.05; $\eta_p^2$ = 0.13). The post hoc analysis showed that the Mmax was significantly reduced after the fatiguing exercise only for the group⁹⁰° (P<0.01).

## Voluntary activation level

The ANOVA analysis revealed a significant time effect (P<0.001; $\eta_p^2$ = 0.31) and an interaction between angle × time (P<0.05; $\eta_p^2$ = 0.13) for VAL but no effect of the vibration condition was observed (P>0.05; $\eta_p^2$ = 0.08). The post hoc analysis showed that the VAL was not different for the two knee angles (P = 0.61) before the fatiguing exercise but it was reduced after the fatiguing exercise only for the group⁹⁰° (P<0.001).

## Discussion

The aim of this study was to investigate the acute effects of an exercise, combining prolonged tendon vibration and weak submaximal isometric contraction, on maximal force production at two different knee angles. Significant neuromuscular fatigue of KE was observed for 90° knee angle but not for 150° knee angle. In contrast to our hypothesis, the neuromuscular fatigue, as revealed by the reduction in KE MVC force, observed at 90° knee angle was only the result of prolonged submaximal contraction. The tendon vibration did not therefore exacerbate the reduction in KE MVC force.

## Effect of tendon vibration

In our study, we investigated the effects of a single session of an exercise combining tendon vibration and submaximal fatiguing contractions on the maximal force produced by the quadriceps muscle. Because muscle length influences the effect of tendon vibration on neuromuscular function [40], we also investigated whether knee angle may change the acute effect of the
combined exercise. No significant change in MVC force was found at the 150° knee angle dur-
ing the fatigue-inducing protocols, with and without tendon vibration. In contrast, a signifi-
cant neuromuscular fatigue was observed when the experimental protocol was performed at a
90° knee angle, without any differences between the vibration and control condition. This
indicates that the fatigue-related combined exercise at a 90° knee angle was only the result of
submaximal contractions but not of the tendon vibration. The lack of effect of muscle/tendon
vibration on neuromuscular performance is in agreement with some reports for ankle plantar
flexor [14,16], ankle dorsiflexor [15] and KE muscles [13]. However, this remains in contrast
with other works in which it was observed that prolonged muscle/tendon vibration altered the
maximal motor performance of several muscle groups, such as KE muscles [1,2,4,5,7-10].
These conflicting results might be also explained by the variability of experimental conditions
among these studies such as subject's morphological characteristics, vibration duration, fre-
quency and amplitude, and the site of vibration application, i.e., muscle vs. tendon. In addi-
tion, it should be acknowledged that the present study did not assess the effects of tendon
vibration on the Ia afferent activity, which according to our hypothesis could alter central
fatigue. We also did not assess H-reflex excitability, which is known to decrease as a function
of Ia afferent activity enhancement. Previous studies reported a decrease in H-reflex excitabil-
ity without changes in MVC force after prolonged vibration at rest [14,15]. Therefore, it is pos-
sible that the vibration we applied in our participants altered the spinal loop, but this alteration
was not sufficient to result in a greater decrement in MVC (or evoked) force and/or voluntary
activation level compared to the control condition.

Effect of submaximal contraction

Neuromuscular fatigue is defined as the decline in muscle performance associated with
repeated muscle activity [41,42]. Sustained submaximal isometric contraction, even for low
levels of intensity, can induce substantial neuromuscular fatigue [43–46]. For instance, it has
been reported a decrease in KE muscle performances of ~27% [45] and ~28% [46] after pro-
longed submaximal contraction at 20% MVC until exhaustion. In accordance with these stud-
ies, our results revealed a large fatigue-related decrease in KE MVC force at 90° knee angles
(-20.6%) but no significant fatigue for 150° knee angle, even if a strong decreasing trend was
observed (-8.3%). Neuromuscular fatigue has been shown to be task dependent [41,45,47,48]
and can be related to joint angle or muscle length [49]. This difference in muscle length may
explain, therefore, the greater neuromuscular fatigue observed after submaximal isometric
knee extensions performed at long muscle length (90° knee angle) compared to short muscle
length (150° knee angle) [45,50–52]. It has been reported that an increase in actin-myosin
crossbridges [52], a greater metabolic cost [51], a disruption of blood circulation [50] and an
improved sensitivity of the myofilament to Ca²⁺ [53] for long muscle length compared to short
muscle length, could explain the greater reduction in force production in the former
condition.

In the present study, the greater reduction in MVC force at the 90° knee angle is partly
explained by a greater alteration of the muscular contractility for the long muscle length com-
pared to the short one. Indeed, we observed a peak twitch and doublet force reduction after
the fatiguing exercise at the 90° knee angle but not at the 150° knee angle. This indicates that
decreased excitation-contraction coupling only occurred after the fatiguing contractions per-
formed at the 90° knee angle. This observation was corroborated by the VM Mmax, which was
also significantly reduced at the 90° knee angle but not for the 150° knee angle. However, VL
Mmax is similarly reduced, for both the 90° knee angle and 150° knee angle, after the fatiguing
exercises. It is worth noting that the decrease in Mmax amplitude after the fatiguing exercise
may also be explained by an alteration of the neuromuscular propagation [45,47,54]. This
weak presence of peripheral fatigue at 150° could be explained by exercise that is not long
enough and/or intensive enough to be able to generate an accumulation of metabolites [35,55].

The level of activation can also explain this observed force reduction. Before the fatiguing exercise, the activation level was lower at a short length compared to a long length, as previously shown [56–58]. A lower activation level corresponds to a reduced number and/or firing frequency of activated motor units. After the fatiguing exercise, the maximal VAL loss was greater for the group⁹⁰, suggesting a greater development of central fatigue during the sustained contraction at long compared to short KE length. This difference in fatigue could then be explained by a greater turnover of the motor units at 150°, allowing certain motor units to rest temporarily. Conversely, higher activation at longer lengths would reduce the possibility of motor unit rotation during fatiguing contraction, leading to a higher incidence of central fatigue for the same working time.

To conclude, this study demonstrated that a single session of infrapatellar tendon vibration and submaximal isometric contractions of KE induced a greater neuromuscular fatigue at the 90° knee angle compared to the 150° knee angle. However, this neuromuscular fatigue only resulted from voluntary submaximal contraction and is not exacerbated by tendon vibration.

Author Contributions

**Conceptualization:** Thomas Cattagni, Christophe Cornu, Peter McNair, Marc Jubeau.

**Data curation:** Jonathan Harnie, Thomas Cattagni.

**Formal analysis:** Jonathan Harnie.

**Funding acquisition:** Christophe Cornu.

**Investigation:** Jonathan Harnie, Thomas Cattagni, Christophe Cornu, Marc Jubeau.

**Methodology:** Jonathan Harnie, Thomas Cattagni, Marc Jubeau.

**Project administration:** Thomas Cattagni, Christophe Cornu.

**Resources:** Jonathan Harnie, Thomas Cattagni.

**Software:** Jonathan Harnie.

**Supervision:** Jonathan Harnie, Thomas Cattagni, Christophe Cornu, Peter McNair, Marc Jubeau.

**Validation:** Jonathan Harnie, Thomas Cattagni, Christophe Cornu, Peter McNair, Marc Jubeau.

**Visualization:** Jonathan Harnie, Thomas Cattagni, Christophe Cornu, Peter McNair, Marc Jubeau.

**Writing – original draft:** Jonathan Harnie, Thomas Cattagni.

**Writing – review & editing:** Jonathan Harnie, Thomas Cattagni, Christophe Cornu, Peter McNair, Marc Jubeau.

References

1. Jackson SW, Turner DL. Prolonged muscle vibration reduces maximal voluntary knee extension performance in both the ipsilateral and the contralateral limb in man. European Journal of Applied Physiology. 2003; 88: 380–386. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00421-002-0701-6 PMID: 12527966
2. Kouzaki M, Shinohara M, Fukunaga T. Decrease in maximal voluntary contraction by tonic vibration applied to a single synergist muscle in humans. Journal of Applied Physiology. 2000; 89: 1420-1424.
https://doi.org/10.1152/jappl.2000.89.4.1420 PMID: 11007577

3. Saito A, Ando R, Akima H. Effects of prolonged patellar tendon vibration on force steadiness in quadriceps femoris during force-matching task. Experimental Brain Research. 2015. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00221-015-4447-x PMID: 26419664

4. Rice DA, McNair PJ, Lewis GN. Mechanisms of quadriceps muscle weakness in knee joint osteoarthritis: the effects of prolonged vibration on torque and muscle activation in osteoarthritic and healthy control subjects. Arthritis Research & Therapy. 2011; 13: R151. https://doi.org/10.1186/ar3467 PMID: 21933392

5. Konishi Y, Kubo J, Fukudome A. Effects of prolonged tendon vibration stimulation on eccentric and concentric maximal torque and emgs of the knee extensors. Journal of Sports Science & Medicine. 2009; 8: 548-52.

6. Souron R, Besson T, McNeil CJ, Lapole T, Millet GY. An Acute Exposure to Muscle Vibration Decreases Knee Extensors Force Production and Modulates Associated Central Nervous System Excitability. Frontiers in Human Neuroscience. 2017; 11: 519. https://doi.org/10.3389/fnhum.2017.00519 PMID: 29118698

7. Herda TJ, Ryan ED, Smith AE, Walter AA, Bemben MG, Stout JR, et al. Acute effects of passive stretching vs vibration on the neuromuscular function of the plantar flexors. Scandinavian Journal of Medicine & Science in Sports. 2009; 19: 703-13.

8. Ushiyama J, Masani K, Kouzaki M, Kanehisa H, Fukunaga T. Difference in aftereffects following prolonged Achilles tendon vibration on muscle activity during maximal voluntary contraction among plantar flexor synergists. Journal of Applied Physiology. 2005; 98: 1427-33. https://doi.org/10.1152/japplphysiol.00613.2004 PMID: 15579581

9. Yoshitake Y, Shinohara M, Kouzaki M, Fukunaga T. Fluctuations in plantar flexion force are reduced after prolonged tendon vibration. Journal of Applied Physiology. 2004; 97: 2090-7. https://doi.org/10.1152/japplphysiol.00560.2004 PMID: 15286048

10. Shinohara M, Moritz CT, Pascoe MA, Enoka RM. Prolonged muscle vibration increases stretch reflex amplitude, motor unit discharge rate, and force fluctuations in a hand muscle. Journal of Applied Physiology. 2005;99.

11. Gandevia SC. Spinal and Supraspinal Factors in Human Muscle Fatigue. Physiol Rev. 2001; 81: 1725-1789. https://doi.org/10.1152/physrev.2001.81.4.1725 PMID: 11581501

12. Boyas S, Guével A. Neuromuscular fatigue in healthy muscle: Underlying factors and adaptation mechanisms. Annals of Physical and Rehabilitation Medicine. 2011; 54: 88-108. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rehab.2011.01.001 PMID: 21376692

13. Fry A, Folland JP. Prolonged infrapatellar tendon vibration does not influence quadriceps maximal or explosive isometric force production in man. European Journal of Applied Physiology. 2014; 114: 1757-66. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00421-014-2904-z PMID: 24846679

14. Ekblom MMN, Thorstensson A. Effects of prolonged vibration on H-reflexes, muscle activation, and dynamic strength. Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise. 2011; 43: 1933-9.

15. Farabet A, Souron R, Millet GY, Lapole T. Changes in tibialis anterior corticospinal properties after acute prolonged muscle vibration. European Journal of Applied Physiology. 2016; 116: 1197-1205. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00421-016-3378-y PMID: 27113961

16. Cattagni T, Billet C, Cornu C, Jubeau M. No Alteration of the Neuromuscular Performance of Plantar-Flexor Muscles After Achilles Tendon Vibration. Journal of Sport Rehabilitation. 2017; 26: jsr.2016-0013. https://doi.org/10.1123/jsr.2016-0013 PMID: 27632884

17. Vallbo AB. Human Muscle Spindle Discharge during Isometric Voluntary Contractions. Amplitude Relations between Spindle Frequency and Torque. Acta Physiologica Scandinavica. 1974; 90: 319-336. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1748-1716.1974.tb05594.x PMID: 4274638

18. Burke D, Hagbarth KE, Löfstedt L, Wallin BG. The responses of human muscle spindle endings to vibration of non-contracting muscles. The Journal of Physiology. 1976; 261: 673-93. https://doi.org/10.1113/jphysiol.1976.sp011580 PMID: 135840

19. Fattorini L, Ferraresi A, Rodio A, Azzena GB, Filippi GM. Motor performance changes induced by muscle vibration. European Journal of Applied Physiology. 2006; 98: 79-87. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00421-006-0250-5 PMID: 16896736

20. Brunetti O, Filippi GM, Lorenzini M, Liti A, Panichi R, Roscini M, et al. Improvement of posture stability by vibratory stimulation following anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Knee Surgery, Sports Traumatology, Arthroscopy. 2006; 14: 1180-1187. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00167-006-0101-2 PMID: 16763853
21. Filippi GM, Brunetti O, Botti FM, Panichi R, Roscini M, Camerota F, et al. Improvement of Stance Control and Muscle Performance Induced by Focal Muscle Vibration in Young-Elderly Women: A Randomized Controlled Trial. Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation. 2009; 90: 2019-2025. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apmr.2009.08.139 PMID: 19969163

22. Brunetti O, Botti FM, Brunetti A, Biscarini A, Scarponi AM, Filippi GM, et al. Effects of focal vibration on bone mineral density and motor performance of postmenopausal osteoporotic women. The Journal of Sports Medicine and Physical Fitness. 2015; 55: 118-27. PMID: 25642687

23. Visser JJ, Hoogkamer JE, Bobbert MF, Huijing PA. Length and moment arm of human leg muscles as a function of knee and hip-joint angles. European Journal of Applied Physiology and Occupational Physiology. 1990; 61: 453-460. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00236067 PMID: 2079066

24. Chen X, Sanchez GN, Schnitzer MJ, Delp SL. Changes in sarcomere lengths of the human vastus lateralis muscle with knee flexion measured using in vivo microendoscopy. Journal of Biomechanics. 2016; 49: 2989-2994. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jbiomech.2016.07.013 PMID: 27481293

25. Matthews PBC. Muscle Spindles and Their Motor Control. Physiological Reviews. 1964; 44: 219-288. https://doi.org/10.1152/physrev.1964.44.2.219 PMID: 14152906

26. Matthews PBC. The differentiation of two types of fusimotor fibre by their effects on the dynamic response of muscle spindle primary endings. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Physiology and Cognitive Medical Sciences. 1962; 47: 324-33. https://doi.org/10.1113/expphysiol.1962.sp001616 PMID: 13933877

27. Jami L. Golgi tendon organs in mammalian skeletal muscle: functional properties and central actions. Physiological Reviews. 1992; 72: 623-66. https://doi.org/10.1152/physrev.1992.72.3.623 PMID: 1626033

28. Xu J, Hug F, Fu SN. Stiffness of individual quadriceps muscle assessed using ultrasound shear wave elastography during passive stretching. Journal of Sport and Health Science. 2018; 7: 245-249. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jshs.2016.07.001 PMID: 30356470

29. Roll JP, Vedel JP, Ribot E. Alteration of proprioceptive messages induced by tendon vibration in man: a microneurographic study. Experimental Brain Research. 1989; 76: 213-22. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00253639 PMID: 2753103

30. Fallon JB, Macefield VG. Vibration sensitivity of human muscle spindles and golgi tendon organs. Muscle & Nerve. 2007; 36: 21-29.

31. Hermens HJ, Freriks B, Disselhorst-Klug C, Rau G. Development of recommendations for SEMG sensors and sensor placement procedures. Journal of Electromyography Kinesiology. 2000; 10: 361-374. https://doi.org/10.1016/s1050-6411(00)00027-4 PMID: 11018445

32. Place N, Maffiuletti NA, Martin A, Lepers R. Assessment of the reliability of central and peripheral fatigue after sustained maximal voluntary contraction of the quadriceps muscle. Muscle & Nerve. 2007; 35: 486-495. https://doi.org/10.1002/mus.20714 PMID: 17221875

33. Hucteau E, Jubeau M, Cornu C, Cattagni T. Is there an intermuscular relationship in voluntary activation capacities and contractile kinetics? European Journal of Applied Physiology. 2020; 120: 513-526. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00421-019-04299-z PMID: 31925519

34. Cattagni T, Lepers R, Maffiuletti NA. Effects of neuromuscular electrical stimulation on contralateral quadriceps function. Journal of Electromyography and Kinesiology. 2018; 38: 111-118. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jelekin.2017.11.013 PMID: 29202270

35. Bigland-Ritchie B, Furbush F, Woods JJ. Fatigue of intermittent submaximal voluntary contractions: central and peripheral factors. Journal of Applied Physiology. 1986; 61: 421-9. https://doi.org/10.1152/jappl.1986.61.2.421 PMID: 3745035

36. Allen GM, Gandevia SC, McKenzie DK. Reliability of measurements of muscle strength and voluntary activation using twitch interpolation. Muscle & Nerve. 1995; 18: 593-600. https://doi.org/10.1002/mus.880180605 PMID: 7753121

37. Gandevia SC, Allen GM, Butler JE, Taylor JL. Supraspinal factors in human muscle fatigue: evidence for suboptimal output from the motor cortex. The Journal of Physiology. 1996; 490 (Pt 2): 529-36. https://doi.org/10.1113/jphysiol.1996.sp021164 PMID: 8821149

38. Strojnik V, Komi P V. Neuromuscular fatigue after maximal stretch-shortening cycle exercise. Journal of Applied Physiology. 1998; 84: 344-350. https://doi.org/10.1152/jappl.1998.84.1.344 PMID: 9451655

39. Cohen J. Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences. 2nd ed. Hillsdale N.J.: L. Erlbaum Associates; 1988.

40. Nakajima T, Izumizaki M, Sekihara C, Atsumi T, Homma I. Combined effects of preceding muscle vibration and contraction on the tonic vibration reflex. Experimental Brain Research. 2009; 192: 211-219. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00221-008-1571-x PMID: 18818909
41. Enoka RM, Duchateau J. Muscle fatigue: what, why and how it influences muscle function. The Journal of Physiology. 2008; 586: 11–23. https://doi.org/10.1113/jphysiol.2007.139477 PMID: 17702815

42. Allen DG, Trajanovska S. The multiple roles of phosphate in muscle fatigue. Frontiers in Physiology. 2012; 3: 463. https://doi.org/10.3389/fphys.2012.00463 PMID: 23248600

43. Rozand V, Cattagni T, Theurel J, Martin A, Lepers R. Neuromuscular fatigue following isometric contractions with similar torque time integral. International Journal of Sports Medicine. 2015; 36: 35–40. https://doi.org/10.1055/s-0034-1375614 PMID: 25285471

44. Bojsen-Møller J, Schwartz S, Magnusson SP. Limited difference in time to failure between sustained force and position control contractions with the knee extensors. Scandinavian Journal of Medicine & Science in Sports. 2011; 21: e48–e55.

45. Place N, Maffiuletti NA, Ballay Y, Lepers R. Twitch potentiation is greater after a fatiguing submaximal isometric contraction performed at short vs. long quadriceps muscle length. Journal of Applied Physiology. 2005; 98: 429–36. https://doi.org/10.1152/japplphysiol.00664.2004 PMID: 15475602

46. Pageaux B, Marcora SM, Lepers R. Prolonged Mental Exertion Does Not Alter Neuromuscular Function of the Knee Extensors. Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise. 2013; 45: 2254–2264.

47. Fuglevand AJ, Zackowski KM, Huey KA, Enoka RM. Impairment of neuromuscular propagation during human fatiguing contractions at submaximal forces. The Journal of Physiology. 1993; 460: 549–72. https://doi.org/10.1113/jphysiol.1993.sp019486 PMID: 8387589

48. Gondin J, Duclay J, Martin A. Soleus- and gastrocnemii-evoked V-wave responses increase after neuromuscular electrical stimulation training. Journal of Neurophysiology. 2006; 95: 3328–3335. https://doi.org/10.1152/jn.01002.2005 PMID: 16481458

49. Fitch S, McComas A. Influence of human muscle length on fatigue. The Journal of Physiology. 1985; 362: 205–213. https://doi.org/10.1113/jphysiol.1985.sp015671 PMID: 4020687

50. Hisaeda H, Shinohara M, Kouzaki M, Fukunaga T. Effect of local blood circulation and absolute torque on muscle endurance at two different knee-joint angles in humans. European Journal of Applied Physiology. 2001; 86: 17–23. https://doi.org/10.1007/s004210100497 PMID: 11820316

51. Kooistra RD, de Ruiter CJ, de Haan A. Muscle activation and blood flow do not explain the muscle length-dependent variation in quadriceps isometric endurance. Journal of Applied Physiology. 2005; 98: 810–816. https://doi.org/10.1152/japplphysiol.00712.2004 PMID: 15489262

52. Ng A V, Agre JC, Hanson P, Harrington MS, Nagle FJ. Influence of muscle length and force on endurance and pressor responses to isometric exercise. Journal of Applied Physiology. 1994; 76: 2561–9. https://doi.org/10.1152/jappl.1994.76.6.2561 PMID: 7928884

53. Balnave CD, Allen DG. The effect of muscle length on intracellular calcium and force in single fibres from mouse skeletal muscle. The Journal of Physiology. 1996; 492 (Pt 3): 705–13. https://doi.org/10.1113/jphysiol.1996.sp021339 PMID: 8734983

54. Duchateau J, Balestra C, Carpentier A, Hainaut K. Reflex regulation during sustained and intermittent submaximal contractions in humans. The Journal of Physiology. 2002; 541: 959–67. https://doi.org/10.1113/jphysiol.2002.016790 PMID: 12068054

55. Kent-Braun JA. Central and peripheral contributions to muscle fatigue in humans during sustained maximal effort. European Journal of Applied Physiology and Occupational Physiology. 1999; 80: 57–63.

56. Bampouras TM, Reeves ND, Baltzopoulos V, Maganaris CN. Muscle activation assessment: Effects of method, stimulus number, and joint angle. Muscle & Nerve. 2006; 34: 740–746.

57. Becker R, Awiszus F. Physiological alterations of maximal voluntary quadriceps activation by changes of knee joint angle. Muscle & Nerve. 2001; 24: 667–72. https://doi.org/10.1002/mus.1053 PMID: 11317277

58. Kluka V, Martin V, Vicencio SG, Jegu A-G, Cardenoux C, Morio C, et al. Effect of muscle length on voluntary activation level in children and adults. Medicine & Science in Sports and Exercise. 2015; 47: 718–24. https://doi.org/10.1249/MSS.0000000000000463 PMID: 25083726