This study explores the claim that Ali bin Al-Hussein directly heard from Safiyya bint Huyayy, focusing on the narrations attributed to him in the Sahihs of Al-Bukhari and Muslim, alongside determining the dates of Safiyya’s death and Ali bin Al-Hussein’s birth. It examines the views of scholars who affirm or deny this transmission to establish the most probable conclusion. Structured with an introduction, two sections, and results, the research first clarifies key concepts such as hearing, connection, and disconnection, before moving to a detailed verification of Ali bin Al-Hussein’s hearing from Safiyya using inductive and critical analytical methods. The findings highlight that hadith scholars preserved only one narration from Ali bin Al-Hussein on Safiyya’s authority, recorded by both Al-Bukhari and Muslim. Supporting this, Abd Al-Rahman bin Ishaq affirmed the hearing in his narration from Al-Zuhri, noting that Safiyya’s death occurred in the year fifty or fifty-two, a timeline consistent with the transmission found in the two Sahihs.