# In situ transformations during SLM of an ultra-strong TiC reinforced Ti composite

Sasan Dadbakhsh, Raya Mertens, Kim Vanmeensel, Gang Ji, Jean-Pierre Kruth

► To cite this version:

Sasan Dadbakhsh, Raya Mertens, Kim Vanmeensel, Gang Ji, Jean-Pierre Kruth. In situ transformations during SLM of an ultra-strong TiC reinforced Ti composite. Scientific Reports, 2020, Scientific Reports, 10 (1), pp.1-12. 10.1038/s41598-020-67434-3. hal-02922333

HAL Id: hal-02922333

https://hal.univ-lille.fr/hal-02922333

Submitted on 26 Aug 2020

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access
archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-
entific research documents, whether they are pub-
lished or not. The documents may come from
teaching and research institutions in France or
abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L'archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est
destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents
scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,
émanant des établissements d'enseignement et de
recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires
publics ou privés.

<figure><img src="image_1.png" /></figure>

Distributed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License
<figure><img src="image_2.png" /></figure>

# In situ transformations during SLM of an ultra-strong TiC reinforced Ti composite

Sasan Dadbakhsh<sup>1,2✉</sup>, Raya Mertens<sup>1</sup>, Kim Vanmeensel<sup>3</sup>, Gang Ji<sup>4</sup> & Jean-Pierre Kruth<sup>1</sup>

This work demonstrates a successful in situ method capable of producing an ultra-strong novel Ti composite without aluminium and vanadium. In this method, selective laser melting is used to conduct in situ alloying and reinforcing of a Ti/10.5 wt% Mo<sub>2</sub>C powder mixture. It is shown that this leads to a metastable β-Ti matrix homogeneously reinforced by high aspect ratio, 50–200 nm wide and up to several micrometre long TiC whiskers. The transformations of the phases are controlled by decomposition, dissolution, diffusion, and reformation of constituents. The whisker morphology of in situ formed TiC particles is associated with directional crystal growth along the TiC<sub>≤110</sub> direction. The developed TiC reinforced β-Ti alloy combines a hardness over 500 HV, a Young's modulus of 126 GPa, and an ultimate compressive strength of 1642 MPa. Improving the ductility of this composite is the subject of another work.

Metal matrix composites (MMCs) are intended to ideally combine the tough, ductile and conductive properties of a metal matrix with rigidity, stiffness and wear resistance of a ceramic (or in many cases intermetallics). However, this ideal combination cannot be obtained for a vast majority of the cases. This is due to several difficulties such as a weak interfacial reinforcement-matrix bonding, imperfect morphology of reinforcements, cracks at the interfaces, inhomogeneous reinforcement distributions, residual stresses, dislocations and work hardening induced by thermal mismatches between the composing phases<fnref n="1" />. To mitigate such issues, more research is now being directed to investigate the production of MMCs based on in situ approaches which involve chemical reactions to form reinforcements within the metal matrix. Selective laser melting (SLM) is a particularly suitable method to generate these types of MMCs. SLM is a powder based additive manufacturing (AM) method in which a complex three-dimensional part is built through laser scanning (and hence melting and solidifying) of the required geometry, layer-by-layer on top of each other. The free-form fabrication offered by SLM is an excellent opportunity for manufacturing in situ based MMCs. This enables complex geometry MMC parts with well-designed, very fine and homogeneously dispersed reinforcements²,³, which can mitigate the common issues for this category of materials.

In contrast to previous work on in situ SLM manufacturing of MMCs from aluminium<sup>2–6</sup> or steels<sup>7,8</sup>, here the focus is on Ti-based MMCs. Ti is one of the main metals that has been attempted to be reinforced using in situ SLM techniques. For example, the in situ reaction technique has been applied to produce bulk ceramic TiC reinforced Ti<sub>5</sub>Si<sub>3</sub> components from a mixture of Ti and SiC with an equivalent molar ratio (according to 8Ti + 3SiC → Ti<sub>5</sub>Si<sub>3</sub> + 3TiC)<sup>9</sup>. In another work, Gu et al.<sup>10,11</sup> explored the reaction of 9Ti + Si<sub>3</sub>N<sub>4</sub> → 4TiN + Ti<sub>5</sub>Si<sub>3</sub> by SLM to obtain a composite with TiN secondary phases in an intermetallic Ti<sub>5</sub>Si<sub>3</sub> matrix. Under optimised SLM conditions, a relative density of 97.7% is reached and the hardness drastically increased to 1358HV.

In addition to the above-mentioned powder mixtures leading to an intermetallic matrix and ceramic reinforcements by in situ reaction, there are several studies<sup>12–14</sup> on SLM of ball-milled Ti-TiB<sub>2</sub> powder mixtures. These investigations reported a phase change from TiB<sub>2</sub> to TiB (through an in situ chemical reaction between Ti and TiB<sub>2</sub><sup>13</sup>, i.e., Ti + TiB<sub>2</sub> → 2TiB<sup>15</sup>). The in situ formed TiB showed a very fine needle-shape morphology and increased the hardness (~402 HV) and compressive strength (~1,103 MPa) through grain refinement and hard reinforcements in comparison with pure titanium<sup>12–14</sup>, but lowered the ductility.

<footnote n="1">¹PMA, Department of Mechanical Engineering, KU Leuven and Member of Flanders Make, 3001 Leuven, Belgium. ²Department of Production Engineering, KTH Royal Institute of Technology, 10044 Stockholm, Sweden. ³Department of Materials Engineering, KU Leuven, 3001 Leuven, Belgium. ⁴CNRS, INRAE, Centrale Lille, UMR 8207 - UMET - Unité Matériaux et Transformations, Univ. Lille, 59000 Lille, France. ✉email: sdad@kth.se</footnote>
<figure><img src="image_3.png" /><figcaption>Figure 1. Relatively dense cross-sections of optimally dense and crack-free parts from (a) Ti and (b) Ti/ Mo₂C. The samples are cut along building direction (BD).</figcaption></figure>

Besides in situ reinforcing of Ti, several authors looked into in situ alloying of titanium with Mo. For example, Collins et al.¹⁶ were the first to mix Ti and Mo powder via laser cladding for creating compositionally graded structures. This resulted in β-Ti grains containing α-Ti precipitates. Almeida et al.¹⁷ also used laser cladding to synthesise Ti and 4–19 wt% Mo. After reaching a fully β-Ti alloy at about 10 wt% Mo, they reported a low Young’s modulus of 75 GPa and an adequate hardness of 240 HV at about 13 wt% Mo. More recently, Vrancken et al.¹⁸ looked into SLM of Ti6Al4V/10 wt% Mo powders. They found that in contrast to the fully α’ microstructure of Ti6Al4V after SLM, the Ti6Al4V/Mo microstructure consists of a β titanium matrix with residual Mo particles. The new microstructural characteristic led to a combination of a high tensile strength (σ₀.₂ = 858 MPa) and an excellent tensile elongation (εₜₐc = 20.1%).

Looking at the biomedical applications of titanium-based materials, it is worth mentioning that Ti6Al4V is the most common titanium alloy to manufacture orthopaedic and dental implants (because of its combination of high strength, toughness, and corrosion resistance)¹⁹. Despite this popularity, there are still some long-term concerns about the potential release of harmful ions of Al and V²⁰,²¹. In comparison, although pure Ti imposes no bio-concern over the long term biocompatibility, its lower strength and hardness makes it unsuitable for highly stressed bone implants or wear-prone prostheses²². Therefore, to replace Ti6Al4V and Cp-Ti for orthopaedic and dental implant applications, it is ideal to develop a hard and strong titanium alloy composite with a high hardness and strength but without any biomedical concern. To this end, future applications are looking to take advantage of solid solution strengthening elements without any toxicity concern (such as Mo²³) or secondary strengthening phases preferably with even some bioactivity influences (such as TiC²⁴,²⁵). This can be done by using both in situ alloying and reinforcing phenomena with the assistance of the SLM process. Accordingly, this work investigates a system consists of pure Ti and molybdenum carbide (Mo₂C). In this system, Mo₂C is supposed to be decomposed during the SLM process and react with Ti. This occurs due to higher thermodynamic stability of the products, changing the microstructural features. This can be via formation of in situ titanium carbides while Mo dissolves into Ti as an alloying element (see Eq. 1). For a better understanding, this system is compared to pure Ti. According to the microstructural characteristics and the mechanical properties of the manufactured components, the formation and growth mechanisms of in situ products are investigated and discussed.

$$Ti + Mo_2C \rightarrow TiC + Ti(2Mo) \quad (1)$$

## Results

**Cross-sectional analysis.** Pure Ti theoretical density is about 4.51 g/cm³²⁶. This was much less than the density of the current material, as measured to be 4.75 ± 0.05 g/cm³ from the Archimedes principle. This was since pure Ti is α-phase at room temperature without any additional combination, while the in situ material developed here was no longer an α-Ti and contained Mo and in situ secondary particles. Therefore, since no straightforward theoretical density was available for this new material, no accurate relative density could be calculated by measuring the density. Therefore, analysing the cross section were found to be the best method to estimate density, as shown in Fig. 1. This demonstrates that crack free parts were produced from both material systems (Ti and Ti/Mo₂C) using optimal SLM parameters, where the remaining porosity (< 1%) appeared to be spherical in both cases. However, Ti SLM parts were denser (~ 99.8% vs. 99.3%), which is logical considering the simpler system and the better powder flow of pure Ti. Moreover, the visually larger pore sizes in the composite system in the range of 5–70 µm (typically ~ 30–40 µm) may impose a stronger effect to reduce ductility compared to small pores below 5 µm in Cp–Ti. Nevertheless, from the cross sectional analysis, the theoretical density of the current material seem to be around 4.80 ± 0.03 g/cm³.

**XRD.** The XRD patterns of the Ti and Ti/10.5 wt% Mo₂C powders and the corresponding SLM parts are shown in Fig. 2. As seen, the α-Ti peaks representative for the hexagonal Ti powder are maintained after SLM. In contrast, when comparing the diffraction spectra of the Ti/10.5 wt% Mo₂C powder and part after SLM, it can be observed that the intensity of the hexagonal α-Ti peaks was significantly reduced in favour of the formation of a
<figure><img src="image_4.png" /><figcaption>**Figure 2.** XRD spectra of Ti powder, Ti/10.5 wt% Mo₂C powder mixture, and the corresponding SLM parts.</figcaption></figure>

<figure><img src="image_5.png" /><figcaption>**Figure 3.** High resolution SEM and EBSD pictures of Ti/Mo₂C SLM parts using optimal parameters. (a) EBSD image of the grain structure, largely elongated in the building direction (vertical and upwards), (b) dominant granular microstructure containing (c–e) homogenous distribution of nano whisker-shape carbides (as observed with the black contrast).</figcaption></figure>

β-Ti phase with cubic crystal structure. Additionally, no Mo₂C peaks were detected and instead a small fraction of TiC was observed after SLM. This can indicate that the initial Mo₂C had completely decomposed in the melt pool during SLM. After Mo₂C decomposition, the resulting Mo incorporated into the Ti lattice, stabilising the BCC β-Ti crystal structure, while carbon was preferentially reacting with Ti, forming TiC. A small fraction of α-Ti phase is still detected after SLM since the Mo content in the powder mixture (9.88 wt%) is slightly below the critical content required to fully stabilise the β-Ti phase (10 wt%¹⁷).

**Microstructural analysis.** *Microstructural appearance after SLM.* It is well reported that pure Ti after SLM has an acicular and lath-like α' (martensitic α-Ti) microstructure²⁷,²⁸. The addition of Mo₂C, however, completely changes the microstructural characteristics, as shown in Fig. 3. As Mo stabilises the high tempera-
<figure><img src="image_6.png" /><figcaption>**Figure 4.** SEM pictures (with BSE contrast) of residual Mo/Mo₂C particles in SLM parts made from Ti/Mo₂C using different laser parameters, illustrating the in situ transformations. (a, b) The initial interaction of a Mo₂C particle with the molten Ti matrix during SLM at a low laser energy, where a Mo₂C polycrystalline particle is partitioning to the original crystals and decomposing to Mo and C. (c, d) Accumulation of nano-sized C inside Mo while Mo and C are gradually migrating into the Ti matrix. (e, f) a small residual Mo particle dissolving into Ti matrix and releasing the accumulated carbon particles. The red arrows indicate the direction of diffusion and migration. The orange arrows are for identifying the different phases.</figcaption></figure>

ture β-Ti phase, the EBSD map, shown in Fig. 3a, indicates that the material mainly consist of the cubic β-Ti phase after SLM. Additionally, as the EBSD map was collected within a plane parallel to the building direction, a predominant <100> texture is observed, corresponding to the preferential growth direction of BCC metals during solidification. No martensitic α' phase with hexagonal crystal symmetry and acicular shape was detected in contrast to SLM processed pure Ti<sup>27,28</sup>. Figure 3b–e indicate that a secondary phase is homogeneously dispersed within the Ti matrix after SLM. The secondary phase particles content add up to 6 vol%, based on image analysis. Morphologically, they have a whisker shape with a width of typically less than 200 nm and a length that can reach several micrometres (Fig. 3c–e). Occasionally, a small amount of unreacted Mo₂C–Mo may remain after SLM, as observed in Fig. 3b.

*In situ reaction footmarks.* In order to elucidate the in-situ reaction mechanism, the residual Mo₂C/Mo particles (see Fig. 3b) and their immediate surroundings were investigated in detail, representing the actual freeze frames of the dissolved particles. Figure 4 shows the transformation evolution through an increase in laser power. As shown in Fig. 4a, b, taken from an as-built sample processed at low laser energy, a residual Mo₂C particle consisting of several grains is still present within the Ti matrix. In these pictures, Mo appears with the brightest colour, attempting to penetrate into the Ti matrix. Next to Mo, Mo₂C particles (more greyish in contrast to white Mo) may exist, as a source of carbon, releasing black carbon into the crystalline borders. At higher laser power (Fig. 4c, d), carbon accumulates and coalesces in residual Mo pieces until it finds the chance to be released while Mo is being dissolved into the Ti matrix. After releasing of carbon into Ti, they diffuse within the melt and form whisker-shaped carbides. This continues until almost all the Mo dissolves, leaving only few carbon particles to migrate into Ti matrix (as it can be seen from higher powers in Fig. 4d, f). It should be reminded that the black particles are from carbon and not pores, since they have a clear diffusion tendency and they change their form when they diffuse into the Ti matrix from Mo.

**Mechanical properties.** Micro Vickers tests on SLM Ti/Mo₂C parts showed a hardness of 513 ± 38 HV (equal to 50 ± 3 HRC). This is significantly higher than the hardness of SLM Cp-Ti (220 ± 19 HV), SLM Ti-6Al-4 V (399 ± 5 HV¹⁸) as well as β-alloy SLM Ti-24Nb-4Zr-8Sn (227 ± 8 HV²⁹) and Ti-6Al-4 V + 10Mo (338 ± 5 HV¹⁸), as summarised in Fig. 5. The Young's moduli of SLM Ti and Ti/Mo₂C, as measured using IET at room
<figure><img src="image_7.png" /><figcaption>**Figure 5.** Hardness and Young's modulus of the composite made in this work compared to other SLM processed Ti alloys.</figcaption></figure>

<figure><img src="image_8.png" /><figcaption>**Figure 6.** Compressive stress-strain curves of pure Ti and Ti/Mo₂C SLM parts. Note that the compressive displacements of the compression plates are also included in the reported compressive strains.</figcaption></figure>

temperature, were determined to be 107 ± 2 GPa and 126 ± 7 GPa, respectively. Therefore, SLM of Ti/Mo₂C powder resulted in the hardest and the stiffest Ti alloy amongst the most common Ti alloys (Fig. 5).

Figure 6 shows the compression curves of the SLM parts made from Ti/Mo₂C alloy. The SLM parts can reach a very high compression strength of 1642 ± 77 MPa, but they fail without any plastic deformation. This is very different from the curves of pure Ti showing a much lower compressive yield and ultimate strength, but much higher ductility. The recorded compressive strains included all the compressive displacements from samples and compression plates and therefore they can be used only for comparison.

Figure 7 shows the fracture surfaces after the compression tests of pure Ti and Ti/Mo₂C parts. As seen, compressive fracture in Ti has developed relatively smoothly, even from a close view (Fig. 7a). In contrast, the rougher fracture surface of the Ti/Mo₂C sample hints at a more brittle behaviour. Additionally, the presence of fine cavities, which are observed on the fracture surface, especially near the ends of the solidified grains (Fig. 7b), can be due to whisker particles pull-out. It can be argued that the presence of carbide whiskers hinders material shear and hence plastic flow.

## Discussion

**In situ formation mechanisms.** For successful SLM of an in situ reacting powder mixture, it is very important to understand the transformation mechanisms of the constituents. This is particularly interesting since the melting point of Mo₂C is very high (~ 2,687 °C) which cannot normally be reached during SLM with the employed
<figure><img src="image_9.png" /><figcaption>**Figure 7.** Compressive fracture surfaces of (a) Ti and (b) Ti/Mo₂C SLM parts.</figcaption></figure>

<figure><img src="image_10.png" /><figcaption>**Figure 8.** Decomposition and diffusion mechanisms diminishing the parent Mo₂C particles and reinforcing Ti.</figcaption></figure>

parameters. Therefore, in accordance to the changes of the residual Mo/Mo₂C particles in Fig. 4, Fig. 8 schematically explains how the in situ transformation occurs. As seen, with raising temperature in Ti solid/melt, a typical Mo₂C particle (Fig. 8a) decomposes due to more stability of dissolved Mo in liquid Ti and Ti carbide at high temperatures. More specifically, for the corresponding composition of 0.0265 mol Mo₂C and 0.9735 mol liquid Ti at 2000 °C, the Gibbs free energy of Mo dissolution in liquid Ti is –17.9 kJ (calculated using Thermo-Calc Software, TCTI2 database, 2019) and TiC formation is –4.1 kJ against only –1.6 kJ stability of Mo₂C (calculated from the Gibbs free energy graphs in ³⁰). The resulting Mo₂C decomposition occurs by splitting Mo₂C into several crystalline Mo-rich regions while accumulating the C within crystalline borders (Fig. 8b). At the same time with the migration and accumulation of carbon nano-particles at the intercrystalline Mo₂C borders, Mo regions coalesce until the borders between them diminish. This is followed by accumulation and coalescence of carbon inside Mo regions. Now after these decomposition phenomena, logically solid Mo (T_m ~ 2,623 °C) and C (T_m ~ 3,550 °C) can both diffuse to the Ti melt (Fig. 8c). While C is being combined with Ti to form titanium carbides, Mo dissolves in Ti melt (Fig. 8d). After solidification, Mo saturated Ti lead to a β-Ti matrix (due to rapid solidification of Ti-10Mo) reinforced by numerous, fine, and homogeneously dispersed TiC particles (see Figs. 2, 3).

It worth mentioning that this theory more looks into the possibility of TiC formation through a hypereutectic reaction (Fig. 9). This is also in confirmation with the previous studies on melting of Ti–15Mo–0.2C, reporting the formation of coarse TiCx from the melt due to the role of Mo to reduce the carbon dissolubility in Ti³¹. In addition to this for the current case, it seems that after a rapid release of carbon, TiC forms due to a local high carbon content around the carbon particles. This is in agreement with the kinetic studies on Ti–C systems, concluding that instead of dissolving C in Ti, TiC primarily forms below the combustion temperatures of 2,438 °C³². This is also the main temperature range in a Ti melt in which a successful SLM occurs³³. Above this temperature, which could be reached perhaps using excessively high laser energies, carbon dissolution becomes easier into the titanium melt (instead of TiC formation)³², forming TiC from the eutectic reaction. However, these high temperatures (e.g., above 2,500 °C) could not be dominantly reached using the employed optimal parameters for SLM at this work, since excessive over melting has been avoided here.

According to the above-mentioned theory, the fast solidification at high laser scanning speeds has a determining effect to suppress dissolution of TiC particles after formation. As a result, when the scanning speed is decreased, TiC particles become thinner and shorter (since the formed TiC thermodynamically tends to dissolve in the Ti melt, as seen in the binary diagram in Fig. 9, utilising the longer-lasting melt). This is while eutectic TiC increases (compare Fig. 10a and b showing the effects of the scanning speed reduction). This significantly refines and changes the microstructure, as the eutectic TiC can be finer or may even precipitate in a cellular format (Fig. 10b). It should be noted that this is contradictory to the well-known refining influence of the higher solidification rates. This is since the formation mechanisms are completely changed here (from hypereutectic to eutectic) with the use of much lower laser speeds.
<figure><img src="image_11.png" /><figcaption>**Figure 9.** Schematic of the possibility of hypereutectic TiC formation after sudden release of carbon prior to the rapid solidification. The equilibrium Ti-C diagram is adapted with permission from ³⁴.</figcaption></figure>

<figure><img src="image_12.png" /><figcaption>**Figure 10.** Microstructural refinement and precipitations in cellular format with decreasing the laser scanning speed from (a) 1,000 mm/s (and P = 300 W) to (b) 100 mm/s (and P = 50 W). Notice that this is contradictory to the microstructural coarsening at a lower scanning speed.</figcaption></figure>

**In situ growth and crystal orientations.** TiC ideally develops with an octahedron shape under equilibrium condition due to its NaCl-type face centred cubic structure (with a unit cell of a $TiC_6$ octahedron)³⁵⁻³⁷. However, in a non-equilibrium state, thermal and mass transportation in the melt also play an important role, enabling different growth kinetics and mechanisms and hence a variety of growth morphologies³⁶. As a result, according to the laser parameters used in SLM, TiC can form with different shapes, such as laminated, octahedron, semi-spherical³⁸, or even whisker³⁹. In the current case, whisker-shaped⁴⁰ TiC nano constituents has been formed, as clearly shown in Fig. 11a. This peculiar whisker-shape originates from the rapid growth mechanisms activated in the <110> direction, as shown in Fig. 11b, c. Therefore, in this case, it seems that carbon has dif-fused in TiC to pass through {110} planes which provides the lowest packing density and hence the easiest route compared to {111} and {100} TiC planes⁴¹.

It should be noted that no certain orientation relationship was found between the TiC whiskers and the main planes in the cubic Ti matrix (Fig. 12). No orientation relationship between the whiskers and the Ti matrix can be an indication for formation of these whiskers dominantly in the Ti melt. Accordingly, it seems that the TiC whiskers follow the Marangoni forces and the melt stream after the formation. The melt streams in irregular cycles towards the back of the laser melt pool where it solidifies. Within such streams there are strong velocities and temperature changes³³. TiC whiskers, circulating with this stream, can logically leave the high velocity streams to lower velocity streams from several preferential locations in which the melt stream does a sharp turn. Some TiC whiskers can also be impeded at the solidified regions, orienting them into the liquid-solid borders according to their remaining momentum. After solidification, these lead to a Ti matrix homogeneously reinforced by numerous TiC whiskers with several preferential orientations across different grains and also congregated in
<figure><img src="image_13.png" /><figcaption>**Figure 11.** TEM observation of (a) TiC particle, growing in <110> direction determined from (b) diffraction pattern of TiC [111] and (c) the corresponding simulation of image (b), while the particle is composed of (d) Ti and C.</figcaption></figure>

<figure><img src="image_14.png" /><figcaption>**Figure 12.** TEM observation of (a) TiC whiskers oriented in Ti grains and (b) dark field diffraction pattern of Ti [100] (top Ti grain), showing no certain orientation between the whiskers and the cubic Ti-matrix. The possible orientations of the whiskers across the grains are shown with dotted lines in (a).</figcaption></figure>

grain boundaries (see Fig. 3). This is in agreement with the fact that particles can eject from the back of the laser melt track with some preferential orientations due to the melt pool dynamics⁴².

**Correlation of microstructure with mechanical properties.** The microstructure of the in situ formed MMC parts from Ti/10.5 wt% Mo₂C is a β-titanium matrix reinforced by homogenously distributed TiC whiskers with 50–200 nm width and a high aspect ratio, with lengths up to several micrometres (see Figs. 2, 3). β-Ti alloys are typically known to show lower hardness, strength and stiffness but at the same time a higher ductility than Ti–6Al–4V¹⁷,¹⁸,⁴³. In this case, the ductile and low stiffness β-Ti matrix is reinforced with about 6 vol% of TiC whiskers. TiC is a high temperature ceramic with extremely high hardness (~3,200 HV) and elastic modulus (~448–451 GPa)⁴⁴. TiC whisker, compared to its particulate shape, can provide more bonding interfaces. This can more effectively suppress the deformation of titanium, drastically increasing the hardness of reinforced β-Ti to about 513 ± 38 HV, the stiffness to about 126 ± 7 GPa (even higher than fully martensitic α-Ti), and the compressive strength to about 1642 ± 77 MPa. In return, this allows no plasticity (Figs. 5, 6) without deformation or
displacement of ultra-strong TiC whiskers, owing to the excellent bonding between the TiC whiskers and the β-Ti matrix (see the well-bonded interfaces without any cracking, Fig. 11). As a result, the pressure under compressive deformation continues to grow until it reaches a value much greater than a common β-Ti matrix can sustain (~1642 MPa). At this stage, the β-Ti matrix catastrophically fails from the regions around the actual TiC whiskers where the deformation had been localised. As a result, compressive fracture appears as elongated and holed deformation cells which may have primary contained displaced TiC whiskers (Fig. 7b). This is of course very different with the smooth compressive fracture of pure Ti, as shown in Fig. 7a.

It is worth mentioning that the current Ti composite increases the strength of titanium without the use of any potentially harmful elements such as aluminium and vanadium. In contrary to Al and V, this work increases the hardness and strength of pure titanium through alloying with Mo (as a highly recommended element due to its high biocompatibility²³) and generating nano TiC whisker reinforcements (TiC is an excellent constituent to improve the bioactivity of titanium²⁴,²⁵). Despite these very high hardness (over 500 HV) and strength (~1642 MPa true ultimate compression strength) of the developed Ti alloy composite (see Fig. 5), the absence of plasticity is unfortunately a real issue. The possible strategies such as use of less Mo₂C content or application of heat treatment to improve this issue and to create a future bio-material are addressed in other works⁴⁵. From the bio-aspect, another issue with this new composite material is the fact that stiffness is even more than Ti and Ti-6Al-4V (Fig. 5). Therefore, the material itself does not reduce the issue of stress shielding of the bone implants, however this can be easily improved by implementing porosity and lattice structure in design and manufacture of implants using AM⁴³,⁴⁶.

## Conclusions

This work developed a strong and hard Ti alloy composite without potentially cytotoxic elements such as Al and V using the SLM process from an in situ reactive Ti/10.5 wt% Mo₂C powder mixture. It was found that:

* Despite the high cracking susceptibility, dense and crack free titanium alloy composites can be made via SLM from the Ti/10.5 wt% Mo₂C powder mixture.

* After SLM of the Ti/Mo₂C powder mixture, the in situ released Mo in conjunction with SLM rapid solidification stabilised the β-Ti phase (instead of martensitic α-phase). At the same time, this β-Ti matrix was homogenously reinforced with in situ formed and high aspect ratio TiC whiskers (50–200 nm wide and up to several micrometre long).

* During the SLM process, Mo₂C progressively decomposed to Mo and carbon in the Ti melt. Mo, on one hand, diffused and dissolved in the Ti melt, while carbon nano particles migrated until they formed in situ TiC whiskers. This means that the in situ formation and growth mechanisms were controlled by decomposition, dissolution, migration and reformation of constituents.

* The whisker shape of the in situ formed TiC constituents was associated with the directional crystal growth along <110> direction. The distribution and orientation of TiC whiskers was argued to be dictated by the melt flow streams.

* TiC whiskers (as an extremely hard and strong material) established an excellent interfacial bonding with β-Ti matrix. As a result, the developed in situ TiC whisker reinforced β-Ti had a high hardness of 513 HV and the compressive strength of about 1642 MPa. The obtained Young's modulus of 126 GPa was higher than that of fully martensitic α-Ti in as-SLM Ti or Ti-6Al-4V despite the low stiffness β-matrix.

* Despite the positive influence of TiC on the strength and the hardness, plastic deformation was hindered by the TiC whiskers in the β-Ti matrix, resulting in a catastrophic failure under very high stresses. Improving the extreme brittleness using appropriate heat treatments will be presented in other research works.

## Materials and methods

**Materials and SLM.** Gas atomised Cp-Ti powder (grade 1) was obtained from LPW Ltd (UK) with a particle size ranging from 15 to 45 µm. The Ti powder was mixed with 10.5 wt% molybdenum carbide powder (Mo₂C, supplied from Changsha Langfeng, China) with an average powder particle size ~ 3.5 µm, as seen in Fig. 13. Mo₂C powder can be decomposed (i.e., broken down into Mo and C as the original constituents) in intermediate steps at higher temperatures, where there is a chance for the dissolution of Mo in Ti and the formation of more stable carbides such as TiC (which is also a fully biocompatible material²⁴,²⁵). This amount of Mo₂C would theoretically generate around 9.88 wt% Mo and 0.62 wt% C after the decomposition. Since 10 wt% Mo was expected to be adequate to make a fully β-Ti matrix after rapid solidification¹⁸, this specific composition was chosen. This powder system was dry mechanically mixed in a Turbula mixer for at least 8 h. After mixing, although the Mo₂C powder particles could fill the spaces between spherical Ti powders, the agglomeration of Mo₂C particles (which is common for fine powders) remained to some extent after mixing (Fig. 13) and reduced the flowability, but it did not impede the SLM processing.

A commercial 3DS ProX 320 SLM machine with 400 W fibre laser and a beam diameter of about 60 µm was used to manufacture samples. The SLM was carried out under a protective argon atmosphere keeping the oxygen below 100 ppm during the process. The laser power, scan speed, and hatch spacing were varied while the layer thickness was kept constant at 30 µm. Each layer was scanned once. A bi-directional scanning was carried out and a 90° rotation was applied between the layers. Optimisations were based on reaching the highest density as well as the absence of macrocracks. This was since the Ti/10.5 wt% Mo₂C was extremely susceptible to cracking, as visually observed in Fig. 14a. Optimal parameters to produce dense and crack-free components were found (Fig. 14b) for both the Ti and Ti/Mo₂C material systems, as summarised in Table 1.
<figure><img src="image_15.png" /><figcaption>**Figure 13.** Powder mixture of Ti/10.5 wt% Mo₂C. Cp-Ti is the larger spherical particles and Mo₂C is the smaller and partially agglomerated particles.</figcaption></figure>

<figure><img src="image_16.png" /><figcaption>**Figure 14.** SLM part from powder mixture of Ti/10.5 wt% Mo₂C; (a) Visual cracks growing in the parts, and (b) possibility of crack free production of components. Note the coloured surfaces at the bottom of the parts in figure a is only due to cutting by wire electro discharge machining.</figcaption></figure>

<table><caption>**Table 1.** Optimum parameters resulting in crack free parts with over 99% density.</caption><thead><tr><td>Material system</td><td>Laser power (P) (W)</td><td>Scanning speed (v) (mm/s)</td><td>Hatch spacing (h) (mm/s)</td></tr></thead><tbody><tr><td>Ti/10.5 wt% Mo₂C</td><td>300</td><td>1,000</td><td>70</td></tr><tr><td>Cp-Ti</td><td>235</td><td>1,400</td><td>70</td></tr></tbody></table>

**Characterisation.** To investigate the degree of densification, the polished cross-sections were viewed using an Axiocam Leica optical microscope after polishing. All the cross-sections were cut and prepared along the SLM building direction (side view). To analyse the microstructure, a FEI-Nova Nanosem 450 equipped with EBSD detector was used to reveal the grain structures and the very fine secondary phases. To quantitatively analyse the features such as porosity or volume fraction of a phase, an average of at least 6 readings were recorded on up to 3 pictures using an image processing software (ImageJ). Moreover, transmission electron microscopy (TEM) was performed using a FEI Tecnai TEM at 200 kV, equipped with a Nanomegas ASTAR system and a Bruker XFlash 6T160 EDX unit. TEM samples were prepared using mechanical polishing and PIPS ion thinning. Phase identification was carried out by a Seifert 3,003 TT X-ray diffractometer (XRD) with coupled Theta/2Theta scan type and Cu-Kα1 radiation (wavelength: 0.15418 nm) operated at 40 kV and 40 mA.

Vickers microhardness tests were performed using a Future Tech FV-700 hardness tester with an indentation load of 1 kg. Compression tests were carried out to determine the strength of the material using a 250 kN INSTRON universal testing machine at room temperature and hardened tool steel as compressive plates. Tests were carried out parallel to the SLM building direction (vertical). The compression samples were cylindrical with 6 mm diameter and about 10 mm height. The top and bottom surfaces were cut by EDM beforehand and zinc stearate was used as lubricant. It should be noted that no extensometer could be used during compression and hence the deformation of the compression steel plates (present at the top and bottom of the samples) could also contribute to the measured strains. Therefore, the strains were not accurate (especially at elastic regions) and were only used for comparison purposes.

The impulse excitation technique (IET) was used to measure the Young's Modulus using a Resonance Frequency and Damping Analyser (RFDA, IMCE, Belgium) on machined bars with dimensions of about 2 mm × 6 mm × 60 mm, as described in ⁴⁷.
Data availability statement

Microstructural data generated or analysed during this study are included in this published article. Extra and
raw data are available on reasonable request from the corresponding author.

Received: 1 May 2020; Accepted: 8 June 2020

Published online: 29 June 2020

References

1. Dadbakhsh, S., Mertens, R., Hao, L., Van Humbeeck, J. & Kruth, J.-P. Selective laser melting to manufacture “in situ” metal matrix composites: a review. *Adv. Eng. Mater.* **21**, 1801244. https://doi.org/10.1002/adem.201801244 (2019).

2. Dadbakhsh, S. & Hao, L. In situ formation of particle reinforced Al matrix composite by selective laser melting of Al/Fe₂O₃ powder mixture. *Adv. Eng. Mater.* **14**, 45–48. https://doi.org/10.1002/adem.201100151 (2012).

3. Dadbakhsh, S. & Hao, L. Effect of Al alloys on selective laser melting behaviour and microstructure of in situ formed particle reinforced composites. *J. Alloys Compd.* **541**, 328–334. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jallcom.2012.06.097 (2012).

4. Dadbakhsh, S., Hao, L., Jerrard, P. G. E. & Zhang, D. Z. Experimental investigation on selective laser melting behaviour and processing windows of in situ reacted Al/Fe₂O₃ powder mixture. *Powder Technol.* **231**, 112–121. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.powtec.2012.07.061 (2012).

5. Chang, F., Gu, D., Dai, D. & Yuan, P. Selective laser melting of in-situ Al₄SiC₄+SiC hybrid reinforced Al matrix composites: influence of starting SiC particle size. *Surf. Coat. Technol.* **272**, 15–24. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.surfcoat.2015.04.029 (2015).

6. Dadbakhsh, S. et al. In situ alloying and reinforcing of Al6061 during selective laser melting. *Procedia CIRP* **74**, 39–43. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.procir.2018.08.009 (2018).

7. AlMangour, B., Grzesiak, D. & Yang, J.-M. In-situ TiC particle reinforced 316L stainless steel matrix nanocomposites: powder preparation by mechanical alloying and selective laser melting behavior. In *Solid Freeform Fabrication Symposium*. (Texas, 2016).

8. AlMangour, B., Grzesiak, D. & Yang, J.-M. In-situ formation of novel TiC-particle-reinforced 316L stainless steel bulk-form composites by selective laser melting. *J. Alloys Compd.* **706**, 409–418. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jallcom.2017.01.149 (2017).

9. Gu, D., Hagedorn, Y.-C., Meiners, W., Wissenbach, K. & Poprawe, R. Selective laser melting of in-situ TiC/Ti₅Si₃ composites with novel reinforcement architecture and elevated performance. *Surf. Coat. Technol.* **205**, 3285–3292. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.surfcov.2010.11.051 (2011).

10. Gu, D., Hong, C. & Meng, G. Densification, microstructure, and wear property of in situ titanium nitride-reinforced titanium silicide matrix composites prepared by a novel selective laser melting process. *Metall. Mater. Trans. A* **43**, 697–708. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11661-011-0876-8 (2012).

11. Gu, D., Shen, Y. & Lu, Z. Preparation of TiN–Ti₅Si₃ in-situ composites by selective laser melting. *Mater. Lett.* **63**, 1577–1579. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matlet.2009.04.010 (2009).

12. Attar, H. et al. Comparative study of microstructures and mechanical properties of in situ Ti–TiB composites produced by selective laser melting, powder metallurgy, and casting technologies. *J. Mater. Res.* **29**, 1941–1950. https://doi.org/10.1557/jmr.2014.122 (2014).

13. Attar, H. et al. Selective laser melting of in situ titanium–titanium boride composites: processing, microstructure and mechanical properties. *Acta Mater.* **76**, 13–22. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.actamat.2014.05.022 (2014).

14. Attar, H. et al. Effect of powder particle shape on the properties of in situ Ti–TiB composite materials produced by selective laser melting. *J. Mater. Sci. Technol.* **31**, 1001–1005. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmst.2015.08.007 (2015).

15. Wang, S. et al. Significantly enhanced creep resistance of low volume fraction in-situ TiBw/Ti6Al4V composites by architected network reinforcements. *Sci. Rep.* **7**, 40823. https://doi.org/10.1038/srep40823 (2017).

16. Collins, P. C., Banerjee, R., Banerjee, S. & Fraser, H. L. Laser deposition of compositionally graded titanium–vanadium and titanium–molybdenum alloys. *Mater. Sci. Eng.* **A** **352**, 118–128. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0921-5093(02)00909-7 (2003).

17. Almeida, A., Gupta, D., Loable, C. & Vilar, R. Laser-assisted synthesis of Ti–Mo alloys for biomedical applications. *Mater. Sci. Eng., C* **32**, 1190–1195. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.msec.2012.03.007 (2012).

18. Vrancken, B., Thijs, L., Kruth, J. P. & Van Humbeeck, J. Microstructure and mechanical properties of a novel β titanium metallic composite by selective laser melting. *Acta Mater.* **68**, 150–158. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.actamat.2014.01.018 (2014).

19. Vanmeensel, K. et al. 8 - Additively manufactured metals for medical applications. In *Additives Manufacturing* (eds Zhang, J. & Jung, Y.-G.) 261–309 (Butterworth-Heinemann, Oxford, 2018). https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-12-812155-9.00008-6

20. Gomes, C. C. et al. Assessment of the genetic risks of a metallic alloy used in medical implants. *Genet. Mol. Biol.* **34**, 116–121. https://doi.org/10.1590/S1415-47572010005000118 (2011).

21. Zaffe, D., Bertoldi, C. & Consolo, U. Accumulation of aluminium in lamellar bone after implantation of titanium plates, Ti–6Al–4V screws, hydroxyapatite granules. *Biomaterials* **25**, 3837–3844. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biomaterials.2003.10.020 (2004).

22. Iijima, D., Yoneyama, T., Doi, H., Hamanaka, H. & Kurosaki, N. Wear properties of Ti and Ti–6Al–7Nb castings for dental prostheses. *Biomaterials* **24**, 1519–1524. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0142-9612(02)00533-1 (2003).

23. Ribeiro, A. M., Flores-Sahagun, T. H. S. & Paredes, R. C. A perspective on molybdenum biocompatibility and antimicrobial activity for applications in implants. *J. Mater. Sci.* **51**, 2806–2816. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10853-015-9664-y (2016).

24. Brama, M. et al. Effect of titanium carbide coating on the osseointegration response in vitro and in vivo. *Biomaterials* **28**, 595–608. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biomaterials.2006.08.018 (2007).

25. Longo, G. et al. Improving osteoblast response in vitro by a nanostructured thin film with titanium carbide and titanium oxides clustered around graphitic carbon. *PLoS ONE* **11**, e0152566. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0152566 (2016).

26. Ahmad, Z. Chapter 9—Selection of materials for corrosive environment. In *Principles of Corrosion Engineering and Corrosion Control* (ed. Ahmad, Z.) 479–549 (Butterworth-Heinemann, Oxford, 2006). https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-075065924-6/50010-6

27. Attar, H., Ehtemam-Haghighi, S., Kent, D., Wu, X. & Dargusch, M. S. Comparative study of commercially pure titanium produced by laser engineered net shaping, selective laser melting and casting processes. *Mater. Sci. Eng. A* **705**, 385–393. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.mse.a.2017.08.103 (2017).

28. Wysocki, B. et al. Microstructure and mechanical properties investigation of CP titanium processed by selective laser melting (SLM). *J. Mater. Process. Technol.* **241**, 13–23. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmatprotec.2016.10.022 (2017).

29. Zhang, L. C., Klemm, D., Eckert, J., Hao, Y. L. & Sercombe, T. B. Manufacture by selective laser melting and mechanical behavior of a biomedical Ti–24Nb–4Zr–8Sn alloy. *Scripta Mater.* **65**, 21–24. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scriptamat.2011.03.024 (2011).

30. Shatynski, S. R. The thermochemistry of transition metal carbides. *Oxid. Met.* **13**, 105–118. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00611975 (1979).

31. Chen, Z. Q., Li, Y. G. & Loretto, M. H. Role of alloying elements in microstructures of beta titanium alloys with carbon additions. *Mater. Sci. Technol.* **19**, 1391–1398. https://doi.org/10.1179/026708303225005999 (2003).

32. Dunmead, S. D., Readey, D. W., Semler, C. E. & Hol, J. B. Kinetics of combustion synthesis in the Ti–C and Ti–C–Ni systems. *J. Am. Ceram. Soc.* **72**, 2318–2324. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1151-2916.1989.tb06083.x (1989).
33. Khairallah, S. A., Anderson, A. T., Rubenchik, A. & King, W. E. Laser powder-bed fusion additive manufacturing: physics of complex melt flow and formation mechanisms of pores, spatter, and denudation zones. *Acta Mater.* **108**, 36–45. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.actamat.2016.02.014 (2016).

34. Hamedi, M. J., Torkamany, M. J. & Sabbaghzadeh, J. Effect of pulsed laser parameters on in-situ TiC synthesis in laser surface treatment. *Opt. Lasers Eng.* **49**, 557–563. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.optlaseng.2010.12.002 (2011).

35. Li, S.-B., Xiang, W.-H., Zhai, H.-X. & Zhou, Y. Formation of TiC hexagonal platelets and their growth mechanism. *Powder Technol.* **185**, 49–53. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.powtec.2007.09.018 (2008).

36. Chen, Y. & Wang, H. M. Growth morphologies and mechanism of TiC in the laser surface alloyed coating on the substrate of TiAl intermetallics. *J. Alloys Compd.* **351**, 304–308. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0925-8388(02)01077-0 (2003).

37. Song, M. S. et al. Growth of TiC octahedron obtained by self-propagating reaction. *J. Cryst. Growth* **311**, 378–382. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jcrysgro.2008.10.065 (2009).

38. Gu, D., Shen, Y. & Meng, G. Growth morphologies and mechanisms of TiC grains during Selective Laser Melting of Ti–Al–C composite powder. *Mater. Lett.* **63**, 2536–2538. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matlet.2009.08.043 (2009).

39. Gu, D., Hagedorn, Y.-C., Meiners, W., Wissenbach, K. & Poprawe, R. Nanocrystalline TiC reinforced Ti matrix bulk-form nano-composites by selective laser melting (SLM): densification, growth mechanism and wear behavior. *Compos. Sci. Technol.* **71**, 1612–1620. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compscitech.2011.07.010 (2011).

40. Xiong, H., Li, Z. & Zhou, K. Synthesis and growth mechanism of TiC whiskers by carbothermal reduction of titania/microcrystal-line cellulose. *J. Am. Ceram. Soc.* **98**, 1951–1958. https://doi.org/10.1111/jace.13539 (2015).

41. Arya, A. & Carter, E. A. Structure, bonding, and adhesion at the TiC(100)/Fe(110) interface from first principles. *J. Chem. Phys.* **118**, 8982–8996. https://doi.org/10.1063/1.565323 (2003).

42. Zhao, C. et al. Real-time monitoring of laser powder bed fusion process using high-speed X-ray imaging and diffraction. *Sci. Rep.* **7**, 3602. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-017-03761-2 (2017).

43. Dadbakhsh, S. et al. Microstructural analysis and mechanical evaluation of Ti-45Nb produced by selective laser melting towards biomedical applications. In *TMS 2015 144th Annual Meeting & Exhibition*. 421–428 (Springer International Publishing). https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-48127-2_53.

44. Titanium Carbide, TiC. https://www.matweb.com (2019).

45. Vrancken, B. et al. Selective Laser Melting process optimization of Ti–Mo–TiC metal matrix composites. *CIRP Ann.* **68**, 221–224. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cirp.2019.04.120 (2019).

46. Dadbakhsh, S., Speirs, M., Kruth, J.-P. & Van Humbeeck, J. Influence of SLM on shape memory and compression behaviour of NiTi scaffolds. *CIRP Ann.* **64**, 209–212. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cirp.2015.04.039 (2015).

47. Roebben, G., Bollen, B., Brebels, A., Van Humbeeck, J. & Van der Biest, O. Impulse excitation apparatus to measure resonant frequencies, elastic moduli, and internal friction at room and high temperature. *Rev. Sci. Instrum.* **68**, 4511–4515. https://doi.org/10.1063/1.1148422 (1997).

## Acknowledgements

This work was supported by the Flanders Innovation & Entrepreneurship agency (Vlaio, No. 150010) under Strategic Basic Research (SBO) project “MultiMet”, Belgium. The financial support from the internal KU Leuven GOA project, entitled ‘Summa’ is appreciated. Gang JI thanks “Bourses de mobilité transfrontalière from I-site ULNE foundation. Open access funding provided by Royal Institute of Technology.

## Author contributions

In this work, S.D. was the main author, researcher and experimental designer; R.M. was the researcher, experimentalist and analyser; K.V. was the co-supervisor. G.J. carried out and analysed the TEM results; JP.K. was the main supervisor.

## Competing interests

The authors declare no competing interests.

## Additional information

Correspondence and requests for materials should be addressed to S.D.

Reprints and permissions information is available at www.nature.com/reprints.

Publisher's note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.

<figure><img src="image_17.png" /></figure>

**Open Access** This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons license, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons license and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.

© The Author(s) 2020