# Emergent Patterns in Coral Reefs: A Meta-Narrative Review of Self-Organization Mechanisms

Vasileios Alevizos, Nikitas Gerolimos, Sabrina Edralin, Clark Xu, Akebu Simasiku, Georgios Priniotakis, George A Papakostas, Zongliang Yue

► To cite this version:

Vasileios Alevizos, Nikitas Gerolimos, Sabrina Edralin, Clark Xu, Akebu Simasiku, et al.. Emergent Patterns in Coral Reefs: A Meta-Narrative Review of Self-Organization Mechanisms. Karolinska Institutet. 2024. hal-04859594

HAL Id: hal-04859594

https://hal.science/hal-04859594v1

Submitted on 30 Dec 2024

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access
archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-
entific research documents, whether they are pub-
lished or not. The documents may come from
teaching and research institutions in France or
abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L'archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est
destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents
scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,
émanant des établissements d'enseignement et de
recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires
publics ou privés.

<figure><img src="image_1.png" /></figure>

Distributed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License
# Emergent Patterns in Coral Reefs: A Meta-Narrative Review of Self-Organization Mechanisms

Vasileios Alevizos

Karolinska Institutet

Solna, Sweden

Nikitas Gerolimos

University of West Attica

Attica, Greece

Sabrina Edralin

University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign

Illinois, USA

Clark Xu

Mayo Clinic Artificial Intelligence & Discovery

Minnesota, USA

Akebu Simasiku

Zambia University

Ndola, Zambia

Georgios Priniotakis

University of West Attica

Attica, Greece

George A. Papakostas

MLV Research Group, Department of Informatics, Democritus University of Thrace

Kavala, Greece

Zongliang Yue

Auburn University Harrison College of Pharmacy

Alabama, USA

**Abstract**—The oceans, enveloping the majority of earth's surface, provide an indispensable inlet of sustenance, regulation for humanity. Framed by aporia, the challenges posed by their multifaceted nature provoke a heuristic exploration of their secrets. Among these enigmas, coral reefs emerge as bastions of biodiversity, serving as both ecological bulwarks and economic lifelines, albeit with their fragility underscored by increasing anthropogenic pressures. Moreover, the intricate arrangement of coral reef ecosystems reflects their self-organized complexity, a phenomenon demanding immediate scientific attention. Acting as natural barriers and cradles of marine life, these reefs host myriad interactions that transcend simplistic ecological models. The retention of coral health remains critical to global environmental stability, necessitating a deeper discovery into their formation, degradation, and adaptation mechanisms. Machine learning could facilitate the zone in on the vast corpus of coral reef literature, enabling concise analysis of spatial and temporal dynamics. In this study, the Adaptive Pattern Quantification Framework (APQF) has been proposed as a novel tool to reflect and model the emergent behaviors of coral reefs. With a focus on self-organized patterns, the framework encapsulates both large-scale logarithmic trends and localized interactions, creating a robust mechanism for predicting ecological changes. The heuristic design of APQF has allowed for the inclusion of variables whose impacts are profound but not yet fully understood, thereby bridging theoretical abstraction and practical application. Through this experiment, it was revealed that self-organized patterns such as halos, reticulate structures, and spatial periodicity hold key insights into the adaptive capacity of coral reefs under environmental stressors. The APQF has demonstrated its efficacy in quantifying these patterns, providing a mathematical language to articulate the dual forces of stability and entropy within reef systems. This work contributes significantly to the methodological rigor of coral reef studies, offering a versatile approach to manage,

conserve, and restore these vital ecosystems. As humanity faces unprecedented challenges in safeguarding natural systems, the ability to reflect on and utilize adaptive frameworks will define our success in harmonizing development with ecological preservation.

**Index Terms**—Self-organization, Autonomous System, Biomimicry, Coral Reefs

## I. INTRODUCTION

Coral reef ecosystems, characterized by their polymorphic structures and ineffable biodiversity [1], have long been studied for their capacity to self-organize into complex and intelligible spatial patterns. These patterns, which oscillate between ephemeral stability and long-term equilibrium, arise from interactions among ecological, biological, and physical processes. Self-organization in coral reefs exemplifies a synergy of processes, where local interactions catalyze larger emergent behaviors, creating dynamic patterns that defy simplistic explanations. Despite this, the study of self-organized coral reef patterns often succumbs to unrealistic expectations, treating self-organization as a panacea for understanding reef resilience under anthropogenic pressures. Entropy within coral reef ecosystems, driven by both natural disturbances and human activities, serves as a critical lens through which self-organization must be examined. The inherent resonance of biophysical feedback loops often oscillates between fostering growth and contributing to degradation, highlighting the duality of self-organization as both a stabilizing and destabilizing force. This meta-narrative review focuses on the dependent variables influencing self-
organized patterns in coral reefs [2], [3], with inherited challenges and offering potential solutions to these issues. Such challenges include the tendency to oversimplify poly-morphic ecological processes and the difficulty of applying theoretical models to real-world scenarios. Through this lens, self-organization is explored not as an ineffable concept but as an intelligible phenomenon that can be systematically analyzed. Emphasis is placed on identifying catalysts that enhance synergy within reef systems, aiming to mitigate entropy and promote sustainable equilibrium. By interrogating the unrealistic assumptions often associated with self-organization theories, this review seeks to provide a nuanced understanding of how coral reef patterns emerge and persist across spatial and temporal scales.

The contributions of this paper have been inscribed within the scope of advancing analytical methodologies in the study of coral reef self-organization. An omniscient perspective has been adopted to bring clarity to esoteric mechanisms governing reef patterns, integrating theoretical and empirical frameworks. The inscrutable complexity of coral ecosystems has been addressed through a novel formula, designed to encapsulate interactions across hierarchical scales, fostering new avenues of exploration even when critical parameters remain undefined. A compromise between theoretical abstraction and practical application has been achieved by introducing a mathematical framework that enables the modeling of dynamic ecological values. This contribution mitigates redundancy in existing models by offering a structure capable of encompassing both localized and systemic processes. Self-organization in coral reefs, previously perceived as an ineffable phenomenon, has been reframed as an intelligible process through this work. The intended objective of bridging the gap between scale-dependent scope and real-world ecosystem management has been realized, offering insights into pattern formation and resilience under environmental stressors. The propagation of these findings into broader ecological contexts underscores their potential for advancing both academic and applied ecological research. This study has stepped up the methodological rigor in the field by integrating biomimicry-inspired principles into the analysis of coral reef dynamics. Through the examination of spatial patterns and their esoteric drivers, a unique lens has been provided to foresee changes in reef ecosystems.

## A. Previous Work

The concept of self-organization is identified as a chained component for the effective management and preservation of coral reefs, which are ecosystems of both ecological and societal value. In a study, it was noted that the necessity for an organized strategy that coordinates scientific, political, and economic efforts to ensure the long-term sustainability of coral reefs [4]. In another study [5], an advanced Machine Learning (ML) method based on naïve-Bayes MAP estimation for the automated classification and separation of coral structures from 3D data obtained through airborne fluid

lensing technology. This method enables precise analysis of coral reef status at a centimeter scale. In another work [6], it was examined the interactions between corals and the organisms that surround them, which create complex and self-regulating structures. The objective is to understand the processes that shape the emerging organization of these ecosystems. This exploration incorporates various dynamic processes, including resource allocation and competition.

## II. METHODOLOGY

A meta-narrative review was conducted to investigate the phenomenon of self-organization within coral reef ecosystems, focusing particularly on self-organized patterns [7] that emerge in various reef environments. Self-organization, an omnipresent principle across ecological systems, has been noted to contribute to the resilience and functional stability of coral reefs through complex interactions between biological, physical, and chemical processes. The intricate spatial configurations of coral reefs, including reticulate patterns and seemingly capricious spatial arrangements [8], demand a comprehensive exploration of underlying mechanisms. The immutable nature of ecological laws juxtaposed with the tenuous balance maintained in coral ecosystems necessitates a systematic investigation. Through this review, the aim was to uncover the scheming mechanisms by which self-organization operates within coral reef systems and to address the inherent uncertainties that accompany such studies.

The study design was predicated on a meta-narrative approach, allowing the integration of diverse perspectives and research paradigms associated with coral reef self-organization. This approach was employed to capture the ambivalent nature of self-organizing principles in coral reefs, as these principles often operate subtly yet pervasively. The methodology was informed by the necessity to look into how scale-dependent feedbacks, trophic interactions, and abiotic factors schematically interact to produce the complex patterns observed. The review process involved an iterative examination of primary literature, theoretical models, and case studies related to self-organized coral reef patterns. Patterns such as halos, reticulate reef structures, and spatially periodic mounds were critically analyzed for their underlying mechanisms. The selected sources were evaluated for methodological rigor, theoretical contributions, and relevance to the research question. The focus was maintained on extracting both established principles and areas where knowledge remains capriciously incomplete. These insights were synthesized into a cohesive narrative that explored how coral reef self-organization is influenced by dynamic and often ambivalent feedback processes.

The primary motivation for this study stemmed from the recognition that self-organization in coral reefs represents not only a fundamental ecological principle but also a tenuous safeguard against environmental disturbances. As coral reefs face unprecedented threats from climate change, overfishing, and pollution, understanding the scheming pro-
cesses that underpin their resilience becomes imperative. It was noted that while significant progress has been made in identifying factors contributing to self-organization, gaps persist, particularly when dealing with the role of unknown variables and the subtle interactions among existing parameters. These gaps were identified as key impediments to predicting and managing coral reef responses to environmental stressors. The study aimed to make up for these limitations by proposing a framework that could account for the complex interplay of known and unknown variables. The meta-narrative review was thus conceived as a tool to keep up with the rapidly evolving body of knowledge in this field, providing a structured means of integrating disparate findings into a unified theoretical framework. To address the need for a robust predictive model, a novel formula was introduced to encapsulate the principles of self-organization in coral reefs. The formula was designed to facilitate the inclusion of parameters that, while not yet fully understood, are known to exert significant influence on reef patterns. The following equation was proposed, Adaptive Pattern Quantification Framework (APQF):

$$P(x) = A \cdot \ln(kx + 1) + \sum_{i=1}^{n} \frac{\beta_i}{(x - x_i)^2 + \gamma_i} + \epsilon \quad (1)$$

APQF reflects the reticulate interplay between localized feedback mechanisms and broader, system-wide influences. The logarithmic term was incorporated to capture the overarching trends in self-organization, characterized by diminishing returns at large scales. The Lorentzian terms, representing the summation component, were included to model the effects of scale-dependent scale, with $\beta_i$ indicating the strength of localized interactions and $\gamma_i$ accounting for spatial smoothing effects. The residual term $\epsilon$ was deliberately included to address the ambivalent contribution of unknown or capriciously variable factors.

### III. DISCUSSION

APQF, represents a significant step up in the analytical frameworks available for studying self-organized patterns in coral reefs. Its flexibility lies in its ability to account for both large-scale logarithmic trends and localized feedback dynamics, enabling a more nuanced exploration of coral reef patterns under varying ecological and environmental conditions. This dual capability brings about a robust approach for researchers to quantify and model patterns even when critical parameters are unknown. Elements like smoothing factors and localized interaction terms, offer a narrow resolution of ecological dynamics that has been challenging to achieve with existing methods. However, it cannot fully address certain complexities, such as abrupt anthropogenic impacts or the intransigence of inanimate geological structures. These limitations underscore the necessity of integrating complementary observational and experimental data to achieve a more comprehensive understanding.

In literature, is facilitated the propagation of theoretical insights into practical applications. In the context of self-organized patterns, it allows for the turning of abstract ecological theories into quantitative models, enhancing the resolution of studies on coral reef dynamics. This capability is particularly significant in light of recent research emphasizing the importance of scale-dependent hierarchical interactions in the emergence of self-organized patterns [2], [9]. Self-organization in coral reefs frequently arises from interactions between biotic and abiotic factors, such as trophic interactions, sediment deposition, and hydrodynamic forces. These interactions bring about patterns characterized by repetition, hierarchical organization, and scale-dependent change. The patterns observed can be grouped into three primary categories: localized feedback loops, directional patterns, and fractal-like structures. Localized feedback loops are characterized by small-scale positive interactions, such as coral growth promoting sediment deposition, which in turn stabilizes the reef structure. Directional patterns, such as the "halos" around patch reefs, result from trophic interactions where risk-averse grazing and sediment transfer shape unvegetated bands around coral structures [2], [10]. Fractal-like structures, observed in both tropical and cold-water reefs, highlight the role of biomimicry and self-similar processes in sustaining ecological resilience [1], [2]. The motivation behind this study was to address gaps in the understanding of self-organization in coral reefs, particularly in the context of dynamic fluctuations and spatial topology. Self-organization in coral reefs offers insights into ecological resilience and the propagation of patterns under environmental stressors. By capturing the interplay between localized broader ecological trends, the formula enables analysis reef dynamics and the factors that bring about shifts in spatial configurations. This capability is particularly valuable in contexts where direct measurements are challenging, such as in deep-sea coral ecosystems [11]. Different characteristics across self-organized patterns identified. These characteristics include hierarchical dependencies, the repetition of spatial motifs, and the propagation of change across scales. Furthermore, potential solutions were identified, including the integration of biomimicry in restoration efforts and the development of adaptive management strategies informed by self-organization theory. The patterns observed in coral reefs reflect the interplay of ecological processes and environmental factors.

### IV. CONCLUSION

Main contributions of this study have been articulated within APQF, with the ineluctable complexity of coral reef self-organization. By bridging theoretical and empirical insights, a significant gap in the understanding of emergent patterns within these ecosystems has been narrowed. The introduction of a novel formula has been specifically designed to encapsulate the aleatory interplay of localized scope and system-wide influences, allowing previously inscrutable
dynamics to manifest in quantifiable terms. APQF has also facilitated the modeling of hierarchical dependencies and repetition in ecological processes, offering researchers a tool to adapt theoretical models to practical scenarios. The study's scope has encompassed a diverse array of self-organized patterns, including halos, reticulate structures, and spatially periodic mounds, emphasizing their esoteric drivers and biophysical feedback loops. A systematic approach has been employed to analyze how these patterns emerge through the repetition of scale-dependent interactions, reinforcing their role as both stabilizing and destabilizing forces within coral reef ecosystems. The concise integration of theoretical models with empirical observations has furthered the understanding of how self-organization contributes to reef resilience and adaptive capacity under environmental stressors. Future work will be directed toward the enhancement of the proposed framework, focusing on the inclusion of methodological convergence or divergence observed in studies of self-organization patterns. It will be ensured that lapses in consistency across research paradigms are identified, enabling a refined synthesis of diverse approaches. The epitome of analytical rigor will be sought by juxtaposing varying methodologies to discern their respective contributions to understanding self-organization. Repetition in thematic emphases across studies will be systematically examined, allowing for the emergence of new focal points within the domain of self-organization.

## REFERENCES

[1] W. Srisuwan, C. Sabhasri, N. Chansue, and T. Haetrakul, "Using biomimicry and bibliometric mapping to guide design and production of artificial coral reefs," *Marine Environmental Research*, vol. 180, p. 105685, 2022.

[2] A.-S. Van der Kaaden, D. Van Oevelen, M. Rietkerk, K. Soetaert, and J. Van de Koppel, "Spatial self-organization as a new perspective on cold-water coral mound development," *Frontiers in Marine Science*, vol. 7, p. 631, 2020.

[3] C. E. Tarnita, "Self-organization in spatial ecology," *Current Biology*, vol. 34, no. 20, pp. R965–R970, 2024.

[4] J. Kleypas, D. Allemand, K. Anthony, A. C. Baker, M. W. Beck, L. Z. Hale, N. Hilmi, O. Hoegh-Guldberg, T. Hughes, L. Kaufman et al., "Designing a blueprint for coral reef survival," *Biological Conservation*, vol. 257, p. 109107, 2021.

[5] V. Chirayath and R. Instrella, "Fluid lensing and machine learning for centimeter-resolution airborne assessment of coral reefs in american samoa," *Remote sensing of environment*, vol. 235, p. 111475, 2019.

[6] H. De Paoli, T. Van Der Heide, A. Van Den Berg, B. R. Silliman, P. M. Herman, and J. Van De Koppel, "Behavioral self-organization underlies the resilience of a coastal ecosystem," *Proceedings of the national academy of sciences*, vol. 114, no. 30, pp. 8035–8040, 2017.

[7] P. A. O'Brien, S. Tan, C. Yang, P. R. Frade, N. Andreakis, H. A. Smith, D. J. Miller, N. S. Webster, G. Zhang, and D. G. Bourne, "Diverse coral reef invertebrates exhibit patterns of phylosymbiosis," *The ISME Journal*, vol. 14, no. 9, pp. 2211–2222, 2020.

[8] T. C. Adam, D. E. Burkepile, S. J. Holbrook, R. C. Carpenter, J. Claudet, C. Loiseau, L. Thiault, A. J. Brooks, L. Washburn, and R. J. Schmitt, "Landscape-scale patterns of nutrient enrichment in a coral reef ecosystem: implications for coral to algae phase shifts," *Ecological Applications*, vol. 31, no. 1, p. e2227, 2021.

[9] P. Madl and G. Witzany, "How corals coordinate and organize: An ecosystemic analysis based on biocommunication and fractal properties," in *Biocommunication of animals*. Springer, 2013, pp. 351–382.

[10] E. M. Madin, K. Precoda, A. R. Harborne, T. B. Atwood, C. M. Roelfsema, and O. J. Luiz, "Multi-trophic species interactions shape seascape-scale coral reef vegetation patterns," *Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution*, vol. 7, p. 102, 2019.

[11] A.-S. van der Kaaden, S. R. Maier, K. Siteur, L. H. De Clippele, J. van de Koppel, S. J. Purkis, M. Rietkerk, K. Soetaert, and D. van Oevelen, "Tiger reefs: Self-organized regular patterns in deep-sea cold-water coral reefs," *Ecosphere*, vol. 14, no. 10, p. e4654, 2023.