# Death, retirement or redeployment for unproductive farm animals? Dispositional tensions in organizational routines

François Charrier, Juliette Cognie, Geneviève Aubin-Houzelstein, Morgane

Costes-Thiré, Vanina Deneux-Le Barh, Valérie Fillon, Victoria

Fluckiger-Serra, Félix Jourdan, Aurore Kubica, Léa Lansade, et al.

► To cite this version:

François Charrier, Juliette Cognie, Geneviève Aubin-Houzelstein, Morgane Costes-Thiré, Vanina Deneux-Le Barh, et al. Death, retirement or redeployment for unproductive farm animals? Dispositional tensions in organizational routines. Séminaire du Métaprogramme SANBA, Métaprogramme SANBA, INRAE, Oct 2024, Paris, France. **hal-04713344**

HAL Id: hal-04713344

https://hal.inrae.fr/hal-04713344v1

Submitted on 29 Sep 2024

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access
archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-
entific research documents, whether they are pub-
lished or not. The documents may come from
teaching and research institutions in France or
abroad, or from public or private research centers.

L'archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est
destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents
scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,
émanant des établissements d'enseignement et de
recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires
publics ou privés.

Public Domain
**Intitulé de la communication et auteurs:** Death, retirement or redeployment for unproductive farm animals? Dispositional tensions in organizational routines

Charrier François, Cognie Juliette, Aubin-Houzelstein Geneviève, Costes-Thiré Morgane, Deneux – Le Barh Vanina, Fillon Valérie, Fluckiger-Serra Victoria, Jourdan Félix, Kubica Aurore, Lansade Léa, Mouret Sébastien, Nivelle Charline, Raspail Alice, Tapie Suzanne, Porcher Jocelyne.

**Acronyme et intitulé complet de l'action concernée** : EXIT - Sortie des animaux du travail et santé : abattage, reconversion, retraite

**Résumé de la communication** :

Human-animal relationships, including ethic of care relationships, are of growing interest to organisation studies, reflecting the substantial role of animals in organizing processes. While some scholars approach these as working relationships, almost no studies examine the organizational routines established to manage animals in the period after they have been retired (due to age, illness, or lack of productiveness). Through a multiple case study of four contrasting sectors in France (dairy ewes, horses, experimental animals, hens), we use dispositional analysis to examine variations in the performance of such routines. Our results show that death dispositives are the most common (animals other than horses are killed immediately on stopping work), but that operators often attempt to implement opportunistic dispositives to 'save' animals and guarantee them a decent retirement. The culling routine is highly conflictual and a source of mistrust and suffering, not least because the ethic of care relationships between operators (farmers, technical advisers, ranchers, animal carers, researchers, slaughterhouse employees, veterinarians etc.) is variable. The numerous conflicts between elements in the dispositive (actors, instruments, discourses, values, places, machines, etc.) allow us to discuss the stabilizing and/or dynamizing effects of the performance of the routine at multi-organizational level, revealing the lack of agency of the operators who directly work and live with animals. As the concretization of a technology that governs our relationship with animals, this routine must be collectively questioned so that we can exit the ethical blindness associated with it and move instead towards a form of ethical foresight.