Projection screen

An improved projection screen is provided having particular application for use in front projection composite photography. A substrate screen backing is provided onto which a plurality of tiles of screen material is attached. Each of the tiles of screen material is formed in the shape of a regular, concave hexagon whose connective line segment edges describe a concave arc from a first segment point "A" to a midpoint "M", wherein the concave arc has a radius of curvature R equal to the distance between segment point A and the midpoint M. A convex arc is described having a radius R from the midpoint M to a second segment point "B". Each of the tiles of screen material are attached to the substrate backing in a regular periodic fashion, such that the backing is tessellated with tiles of screen material. In the present embodiment, the edges of each tile of screen material are overlapped with adjacent tiles of material, in order to form a homogenous projection screen.

BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION 
1. Field of the Invention 
The present invention relates to the field of projection screens, and more 
particularly, to projection screens utilized in front projection composite 
photography. 
2. Art Background 
Composite photography is the art of combining two or more separately 
photographed subjects into one scene. In motion picture production, a 
classic example of this technique is the rendition of a scene comprising 
an automobile interior inhabited by actors with an exterior street scene 
visible through the automobile windows. Other examples of composite 
photography include the placement of fictional objects, such as futuristic 
spacecraft or extraterrestrial landscapes, in a scene with live actors or 
full scale props. 
Front projection is a method of composite photography which was originally 
developed through the work of Walter Thorner around 1932, as part of an 
effort to overcome the shortcomings inherent in rear projection processes. 
In a typical front projection system, a camera and projector are disposed 
at substantially 90.degree. with respect to one another, and a partially 
silvered mirror is located at an approximate B 45.degree. angle relative 
to both the camera and projector (see FIG. 1). The projector projects an 
image onto a background screen disposed in back of a foreground object. 
The camera then photographs both the projected background scene as well as 
the foreground object on one or more frames of film. 
It was soon realized that a major requirement of the front projection 
screen was to return the projected image back to the camera lens as 
efficiently and as uniformly as possible. The optical path of the 
projected image must be substantially coincident with the path of the 
return images seen and recorded by the camera. In early front projection 
systems, the background scene failed to equal the foreground scene in 
image quality. This degradation of the projected image threatened to 
destroy the illusion created by the front projection process. 
In 1951, the Motion Picture Research Council, Inc. issued Report No. 
58.334-D by Herbert Meyer, Chief chemist, entitled: "Front Projection 
Process Photography with Scotchlite". This report described the optical 
qualities of a material referred to as "Scotchlite" and its application to 
photographic front projection. This reflective material had been developed 
by Philip Palmquist and manufactured by the Minnesota Mining and 
Manufacturing Company ("3M"). Scotchlite material is the subject of two 
issued U.S. patents: U.S. Pat. No. 2,294,930, dated Sept. 8, 1942 and U.S. 
Pat. No. 2,379,741, dated July 3, 1945. Scotchlite was originally intended 
for traffic signs and the like and included minute glass beads, each of 
which acted like a concave mirror, reflecting back, not the whole 
projected image, but rather, a small portion of the image. 
The 1951 report by Herbert Meyer delineated in a very methodical fashion 
the various ways in which Scotchlite might be expected to have utility in 
motion picture production. Meyer examined the effects of camera movements 
by dollying, panning, tilting, etc., and concluded that, while movements 
that called for the camera to pivot about the nodal point of its lens, as 
in panning and tilting, were permissible, the system should otherwise be 
regarded as a stationary camera system. In his conclusion, Meyer stated 
that "[t]he fabricating of a large size screen from Scotchlite materials 
will introduce the problem of seams, which may require special attention". 
In the intervening years, it has been found that Scotchlite seams have 
presented a significant problem in sophisticated front projection 
composite photography. The manufacturer of Scotchlite, initially advised 
that it would be sufficient to lay the material out in strips 
horizontally, and as long as necessary, in a shingle fashion, with each 
succeeding layer overlapping the previous one. Another method described 
"butt joints" with a half inch wide Scotchlite strip covering the joint. 
However, it was soon apparent that the problem of seams in front 
projection systems utilizing a Scotchlite screen was much more complex 
than merely disguising the seam itself. As a result of the rather critical 
nature of the optics involved, and the vagaries of the mass production 
process, there were preceptible differences in the Scotchlite material, 
even within the same roll. The material had not only to be joined 
together, but first broken up into relatively small pieces and "shuffled" 
in order to reassemble it as a mosaic and thereby produce a homogenous 
whole onto which an image could be projected. 
Various methods were employed to accomplish the homogenizing of a 
Scotchlite screen. Cutting the material into squares, while economical, 
left a checkerboard pattern that was readily discerned by an audiences' 
eyes used to identifying straight lines and right angles. Tearing the 
Scotchlite material into irregular patches and placing it on a screen was 
found to be an improvement, but highly labor intensive and wasteful of 
material. Some improvement was obtained by cutting the Scotchlite material 
into hexagons, thus reducing the number of conjoint segments and limiting 
the length of a single edge. However, even through the use of hexagons, 
there were still straight lines evident, and a solution was required that 
would eliminate the straight line phenomena without incurring a waste of 
material. 
As will be described, the present invention overcomes the historic problems 
associated with utilizing Scotchlite or other high gain screen materials 
in a front projection system. The present invention provides a screen, 
having particular utility in front projection composite photographic 
systems, comprised of a plurality of uniquely formed complementary 
sections of high gain screen material. As will be appreciated from the 
discussion which follows, although the present invention is particularly 
suited for use with Scotchlite type materials, it may be used in numerous 
applications which require a homogenous projection screen. 
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION 
An improved projection screen is provided having particular application for 
use in front projection composite photography. A substrate screen backing 
is provided onto which a plurality of tiles of screen material is 
attached. Each of the tiles of screen material is formed in the shape of a 
regular, concave hexagon whose connective line segment edges describe a 
concave arc from a first segment point "A" to a midpoint "M", wherein the 
concave arc has a radius of curvature R equal to the distance between 
segment point A and the midpoint M. A convex arc is described having a 
radius R from the midpoint M to a second segment point "B". Each of the 
tiles of screen material are attached to the substrate backing in a 
regular periodic fashion, such that the backing is tessellated with tiles 
of screen material. In the present embodiment, the edges of each tile of 
screen material are overlapped with adjacent tiles of material, in order 
to form a homogenous projection screen. The projection screen of the 
present invention permits front projection composite photograhy such that 
the edges of each tile of screen material are not readily descernable by a 
viewer observing a scene on the projection screen. In the preferred 
embodiment, each tile of screen material is comprised of "Scotchlite" 
manufactured by the 3M Co.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION 
An improved projection screen is disclosed having particular application 
for use in front projection composite photography. In the following 
description for purposes of explanation, specific materials, shapes, 
optical structures, values and configurations are set forth in order to 
provide a thorough understanding of the present invention. However, it 
will be apparent to one skilled in the art that the present invention may 
be practiced without these specific details. In other instances, well 
known optical elements and systems are shown in diagrammatical form in 
order not to obscure the present invention unnecessarily. 
Referring now to FIG. 1, a traditional front projection system is 
illustrated. A camera 10 is disposed in optical alignment with a reflex 
screen 12. A projector 14 is positioned at substantially 90.degree. 
relative to camera 10. A partially silvered mirror ("beam splitter") 18 is 
disposed in optical alignment with, and at a 45.degree. angle relative to, 
camera 10 and projector 14, such that images projected by projector 14 are 
reflected onto reflex screen 12 and may be photographically recorded by 
camera 10. In practice, mirror 18 is partially silvered such that a 
desired percentage of the light from projector 14 is reflected onto the 
reflex screen 12. Light which is not reflected by mirror 18 is passed onto 
a black absorber screen 20 (commonly referred to as a "light trap"), so as 
not to interfere with the images recorded by camera 10. As illustrated, a 
foreground object 22 is disposed between camera 10 and reflex screen 12. 
The resulting image, as viewed by camera 10, is a composite of the 
projected image onto reflex screen 12 in conjunction with the image of the 
foreground object 22. As shown, light reflected from reflex screen 12 and 
foreground object 22 is passed through beam splitter 18 that the reflected 
light is recorded by camera 10. A composite scene is thereby generated in 
which the viewer observes the projected image from projector 14 and the 
foreground object 22 as being coincident in time and space. 
As previously discussed, typical reflex screens used for front projection 
composite photography are comprised of a "Scotchlite" material as 
described in U.S. Pat. Nos. 2,294,930 and 2,379,741. Scotchlite material 
includes numerous minute glass spheres embedded in a reflective binder 
which is disposed on a backing material (e.g., vinyl). In constructing 
reflex screen 12, a significant problem in the prior art has been in the 
elimination of perceived seams in the screen by a viewer. The visibility 
of seams or lines in the Scotchlite material comprising reflex screen 12 
may significantly degrade the believability of a subsequent composite 
image to a viewing audience. 
The improved projection screen of the present invention is comprised of a 
plurality of discrete tiles of high grain screen material formed and 
arranged in such a manner so as to significantly minimize the possibility 
of a viewer perceiving the edges of each tile, and thereby the reflex 
screen 12, in a composite picture. Although in the presently preferred 
embodiment, each tile is comprised of a Scotchlite material, it will be 
appreciated by one skilled in the art that the present invention may be 
used in conjunction with a variety of high gain sheeting or screen 
materials. For example, other screen materials which may be used by the 
present invention include those described in U.S. Pat. Nos. 3,702,213; 
3,810,804; 3,919,031; 3,935,359; 3,963,309; 4,068,922; and 4,354,738. 
The screen of the present invention is comprised of a plurality of tiles 
25, the shape of which is illustrated in FIG. 2. The shape of each tile 25 
may initially be approximated by a hexagon (as indicated by phantom lines 
in FIG. 2). The general hexagon shape is delineated by segment points, 
such as "A" and "B" illustrated in FIG. 2. As previously discussed, in 
order to minimize the possibility of a viewer observing the plurality of 
tiles comprising reflex screen 12, no straight edges may be utilized in 
defining the shape of each tile 25. Accordingly, it has been found that 
the use of tiles formed in the simple shape of a hexagon does not provide 
a satisfactory screen for composite front projection photography. 
As illustrated in FIG. 2 a point "M" may be defined as the midpoint of each 
line segment 23 between point A and point B. By deforming line segment 23 
in a generally sinusoidal shape through points A and B, a concave arc 
section 28 may be defined between point A and point M. Similarly, a convex 
section 29 may be defined between point B and point M, as illustrated in 
the drawings. By properly deforming line segments 23 between each segment 
point (e.g., points "C" and "D", etc.) of tile 25, tile 25 takes on the 
shape as illustrated in FIG. 2. Although line segment 23 is shown in FIG. 
2 as being deformed into one complete sin wave function between each 
segment point, it will be appreciated that each line segment 23 may be 
deformed into a plurality of sin waves passing through the segment and mid 
points. 
In assembling reflex screen 12, a plurality of tiles 25 are adhesively 
tessellated onto a substrate backing comprising screen 12 in a regular, 
periodic fashion. The substrate backing may be rigid or flexible, and may 
vary depending upon a particular application in which screen 12 is used. 
In the present embodiment, a substrate backing comprising a layered 
structure of cloth ("DACRON") and mylar has been found satisfactory. As 
best illustrated in FIG. 4, tiles 25 are applied to the substrate backing 
of screen 12 such that the edges of each of the tiles conjoin and overlap 
by approximately 1/4 to 1/2 of an inch. The overlapping of the tiles 25 
along the conjoined edges of adjacent tiles further minimizes the 
visibility of the edges, and results in a homogenous screen background 
onto which images may be projected for composite photography. 
In order to further geometrically define the shape of each tile 25, and 
specifically the shape of each segment between relative points A through 
F, shown in FIG. 2, the geometric construction illustrated in FIGS. 5 and 
6 may be completed. As best shown in FIG. 5, the central point of each 
tile 25 may be defined as an origin point "O". Segment points A and B lie 
at a distance 2R from point O, and are connected by line segment 34 which 
corresponds to line segment 23 in FIG. 2. As shown in FIG. 5(b), midpoint 
M may be located by circumscribing a circle 36 of radius R about point A, 
and a circle 38 with a radius R about point B. Point M is defined as that 
point wherein circles 36 and 38 contact one another, and is the midpoint 
of the line segment 34. As shown in FIG. 5(c), intermediate points 40 and 
42 may be defined by a circle 39 circumscribed about point M having a 
radius R. Points 40 and 42 are defined at the intersection of circle 39 
with circles 36 and 38, respectively. Finally, be defining two additional 
circles 45 and 48 about points 42 and 40, each circle having a radius R, 
arc sections 28 and 29 are completely defined as those segment passing 
through midpoint M, and points A and B, respectively. Although the Figures 
illustrate arc section 28 having a concave form and arc section 29 having 
a convex form, it will be appreciated by one skilled in the art that the 
present invention may also be realized by rendering section 28 convex and 
section 29 concave. As best shown in FIG. 6, the entire shape of each tile 
25 may be defined by carrying out the previously described geometric 
construction of FIG. 5 for each segment 23 defining the tile 25. 
It has been found that the present invention's projection screen comprising 
a plurality of conjoined and overlapped tiles 25 attached to substrate 
backing provides a homogenous and uniform retro-reflecting surface having 
particular utility in front projection composite photographic systems. The 
present invention's unique tile shape overcomes the disadvantages inherent 
in prior art projection screens, and minimizes the likelihood of a viewer 
perceiving the descrete tile elements comprising the screen and thereby 
destroying the illusion created using front projection techniques. 
While the present invention has been described with reference to FIGS. 1 
through 6, and with emphasis on front projection composite photography, it 
should be understood that the Figures are for illustration only, and 
should not be taken as limitations upon the invention. It is contemplated 
that many changes and modification may be made by one of ordinary skill in 
the art, to the materials and arrangements of elements disclosed without 
departing from the spirit and scope of the invention.