Protection device for bolt seal and hasp

A plurality of walls form a housing cavity in which a latch hasp is received. An opening in the housing receives therethrough the latch hasp, the latch enclosing the cavity. The bolt seal has a shank with a head at one end or with a U-shaped bight in a second embodiment. The head engages a housing wall and a locking body engages and locks to the shank at a shank end distal the head. The shank between the head and lock body is fully enclosed by the housing and latch to preclude access to the shank by tampering tools. In a second embodiment, the shank bight engages the received hasp of a latch. The shank distal the bight is locked to the housing by a locking body. The latch depends into and encloses the housing cavity open at the top. The shank between the bight and the locking body is fully enclosed in the cavity. Different housings are disclosed wherein the head may be enclosed or exposed for access by a shank breaking tool. A reusable bolt and locking body is disclosed for use with several embodiments.

This invention relates to bolt seal protectors, and more particularly, to a 
protector for rail car door latch hasps and the like secured by bolt 
seals. 
Of interest are commonly owned U.S. Pat. Nos. 5,413,393 and 5,347,689, both 
in the name of Georgopoulos et al. and U.S. Pat. No. 5,732,989 in the name 
of David L. Stevenson et al., all incorporated by reference herein. 
Cargo shipping vehicles and containers, and in particular, rail cars, 
especially those shipping automobiles, are subject to widespread tampering 
due to the value of the cargo. Thieves break open conventional bolt seals 
which comprise a steel bolt shank to which a head is swaged at one end and 
to which a locking body containing a lock mechanism is locked at the other 
end. The shanks are subject to relatively easy tampering by way of bolt 
cutters or cutting torches. The problem is aggravated by the fact that 
different rail cars, for example, may employ different types of latches 
and hasps. 
U.S. Pat. No. 5,413,393 illustrates a bolt seal and a tool for breaking the 
shank at the head end of the shank. The tool engages the head and manually 
bends the shank which breaks due to serrations in the shank. In the 
aforementioned U.S. Pat. No. 5,732,989, a locking seal employs a steel 
bolt with a head at one end and grooves along the bolt shank for use with 
a locking body containing a releasable locking mechanism which engage the 
grooves. The mechanism is released by a disclosed mating specially 
designed tool and which locking body mechanism is otherwise difficult to 
release and is relatively tamper resistant. U.S. Pat. No. 5,347,689 shows 
a further bolt seal configuration using a bolt and locking body and which 
requires a tool similar to the tool of the '393 patent tool to break the 
seal shank. Other seals are known wherein tool cutters are required to cut 
the bolt shank. 
In U.S. Pat. No. 5,118,149, a container hasp protector is disclosed. A 
metal box-like body has a top plate, a bottom plate, right and left side 
plates, an open rear face and a front face. A shield plate is on the front 
face and extends between the side plates forming a top opening in the face 
between the shield plate and top plate and a bottom opening in the face 
between the shield plate and the bottom plate. The body is arranged to 
protect the hasp from intentional breakage. 
The shield plate has an aperture which cooperates with aligned apertures in 
a hasp to receive a breakaway security seal. The problem with this device 
as recognized by the present inventors is that while the hasp is 
protected, the shank of the seal is exposed via the openings in the front 
face. These openings are provide so that an authorized user can break the 
seal by cutting the shank. The problem is that the exposed shank permits 
tamperers to use bolt cutters or torches to readily cut the seal shank. 
The present inventors recognize that potential thieves do not like to 
tamper with locks that are difficult to open, especially locks on cargo 
doors which may be subject to periodic surveillance. If the locks can not 
be opened in a few minutes, thieves are likely to pass up such tampering. 
For this reason the device of the '149 patent is believed not desirable 
for valuable cargo containers and the like. 
U.S. Pat. No. 3,951,443 discloses a security lock that employs a locking 
pin. The lock employs interengaged keepers with aligned through apertures 
which receive the pin. One of the keepers has a through pilot hole in the 
face thereof so that the pin can be cut apart with a heavy duty power 
drill for use by an authorized person. The only way for the lock to be 
opened is by destroying the pin. This is not satisfactory because the 
locking pin is destroyed rather than capable of reuse. More importantly, 
it is disclosed that thieves would not like to use a noisy, inconvenient 
and conspicuous power drill. However, portable cutting torches may also be 
used to cut the pin via the pilot hole. This is believed unsatisfactory. 
Padlock protector devices are disclosed in U.S. Pat. Nos. 4,898,008, 
4,033,155, 5,146,771, and 5,477,710. These also are not satisfactory for 
cargo shipping containers or rail cars because the shackles are readily 
exposed for destruction by a tamperer. Further these devices are not 
disclosed as operative with bolt seals of the type described above. 
The present inventors recognize a need for a cost effective seal and latch 
protection device which uses cost effective reusable locking bodies or 
reusable bolts and locking bodies. They recognize a need for a protection 
device which precludes access to the bolt shank which is vulnerable to 
tampering. 
A device according to one aspect of the present invention protects a hasp 
and a bolt seal wherein the seal comprises a shank, a locking head means 
and a locking body, the hasp having an aperture for receiving the shank in 
a lock mode. The device comprises a housing defining a cavity, the housing 
having an opening for receiving the hasp in the cavity, the hasp for 
enclosing the opening to preclude access by tampering tools therethrough. 
At least one member is secured to the housing and has an aperture in 
communication with the cavity for receiving the shank, the locking head 
means and locking body for locking the shank to the at least one member 
and to the hasp, the cavity being sufficiently enclosed by the housing, at 
least one member and hasp to preclude access to the shank in the lock mode 
by tampering tools. 
A protection device according to a further aspect of the present invention 
is latch hasp and bolt seal wherein the hasp has at least one aperture and 
the seal comprises 1) a shank having opposing ends, the shank for passing 
through the at least one aperture, 2) locking means for precluding passage 
of one shank end in a locked state through the at least one aperture and 
3) a locking body selectively locked to the shank at an opposing shank end 
for locking the hasp therebetween. 
The device comprises a housing including a plurality of side walls defining 
a cavity having a bottom, a top and a plurality of sides, the housing 
having an opening for receiving the hasp in the cavity, the side walls for 
enclosing the cavity at the sides, the latch for enclosing the opening to 
preclude access to the cavity through the opening with tampering tools. 
At least one plate member is provided for enclosing at least the bottom 
such that the side walls, the at least one plate member and the latch 
cooperate to enclose the cavity to preclude tampering access to the cavity 
and received shank by the tampering tools, the at least one plate member 
having a first aperture cooperating with the received at least one hasp 
aperture for receiving the shank therethrough, the locking means and 
locking body for locking the received hasp to the at least one plate 
member whereby the shank and received hasp between the locking means and 
the locking body are enclosed to preclude access to the shank by the 
tampering tools. 
In a further aspect the opening is in one of the side walls, the housing 
having a further plate member for enclosing the top, the further plate 
member having a second aperture aligned with the first aperture and the 
received at least one hasp aperture for receiving the shank. 
In a still further aspect the locking means comprises a head secured to the 
shank, the device including a third plate member in the cavity 
intermediate the at least one and further plate members for further 
enclosing and dividing the cavity, the third plate member having a third 
aperture aligned with the first and second apertures and for alignment 
with the received at least one hasp aperture, the third aperture for 
receiving the shank therethrough, the second aperture being enlarged 
relative to the third aperture for receiving the head therethrough so that 
the received head is intermediate the third and further plate members. 
The shank in a further aspect is formed with a U-shaped portion having a 
bight between the one end and the opposing end, the hasp at least one 
aperture is for receiving the bight, the one bight and locking body for 
cooperating to lock the hasp to the at least one plate member.

In FIG. 1, latch 2 is a conventional existing assembly for securing two 
opposing doors of automobile carrying rail cars which may be bi-level or 
tri-level. Latch 2 comprises a sheet metal plate member 4 secured to one 
rail car door (not shown) and a staple 6 secured to the plate member 4. An 
elongated sheet metal latch member 8 has a hole through which is loosely 
attached staple 6 and has a slot 10 at the end distal the staple 6. A 
second sheet metal plate member 12 is secured to the other rail car door 
(not shown). 
A hasp assembly 14 comprises a first L-shaped hasp 16 having a leg 18 with 
an aperture 20. Hasp 16 pivots at pin 22 in directions 24. A second 
L-shaped hasp 26 is fixed to plate member 12. Hasp 26 leg 32 has an 
aperture 28 alignable with the aperture 20 of movable hasp 14. Legs 18, 30 
and 32 form a channel which receives the member 8 adjacent to the slot 10, 
hasp 26 passing through the slot 10. The member 8 is movable in directions 
34 and 36 to engage and disengage the hasp 26 after the hasp 16 is rotated 
in directions 24. 
Seal protection device 38, FIG. 2, comprises a box-like casing or housing 
40 preferably fabricated of 5/16 inch thick sheet steel plate members 
preferably welded together. While discrete plate members are shown, curved 
or rounded walls without discrete boundaries may also be used. The housing 
40 has a front plate member wall 42, a rear plate member wall 44, and two 
opposing lateral side plate member walls 46, 48. The walls may be formed 
of a single sheet bent as shown and then preferably butt welded medially 
side wall 46. The walls 40, 42, 44 and 46 define a cavity 50 having a 
plurality of sides, a top and a bottom. The cavity top is enclosed with a 
top plate member wall 52 and the cavity bottom is enclosed with a bottom 
plate member wall 54. An intermediate wall 56 is in the cavity 50 dividing 
the cavity 50 into two subchambers. 
The walls 52, 54 and 56 are preferably welded to the casing 40. The top 
wall 52 has a circular hole 58 next adjacent to wall 44. The bottom wall 
54 has a circular hole 60. Wall 56 has a circular hole 62 which has a 
beveled edge 64. The holes 58, 60 and 62 are preferably axially aligned. 
Wall 54 has a rear section 66 and a front section 68. The rear section 66 
is normal to all of the casing 40 walls. The front section 68 is normal to 
the side walls but inclined relative to the rear and front walls as best 
seen in FIG. 4. The rear wall 44 depends beyond the bottom wall 54 as do 
side walls 46 and 48. 
The depending portions are coextensive with and abut bottom wall rear 
section 66. The depending portions form a protective region about the bolt 
seal 70, and in particular, about the locking body 72 containing the 
locking mechanism (not shown). A depending side wall 48' has a hole 74 for 
receiving a tamper evidencing seal (not shown). 
The seal 70 is preferably releasable as more fully described in the 
aforementioned U.S. Pat. No. 5,732, 989 incorporated by reference herein. 
In the alternative, the seal may be of other configurations which may be 
commercially available or of the type described in the commonly owned 
patents described in the introductory portion. 
The seal 70 preferably comprises a circular steel shank 76 to which is 
swaged a locking head 78 having a frusto-conical portion tapering toward 
the shank 76. The frusto-conical portion mates with and nests within and 
against the beveled edge 64 of hole 62 in the intermediate wall 56. The 
head 78 has a diameter smaller than the top wall 52 hole 58 to pass 
therethrough. The head 78 is located in the chamber defined by walls 52 
and 56. The shank 76 adjacent the other end has an axial array of annular 
grooves 80 which mate with the locking mechanism (not shown) of locking 
body 72, which mechanism is fully described in the aforementioned U.S. 
Pat. No. 5,732,989. The shank 76 has an aperture 77 therethrough for 
receiving a tamper indicating seal (not shown) which is engaged also with 
hole 74. 
The locking body 72 maybe formed of a hardened steel casing to resist 
tampering and has a tapered outer surface. The smaller end of the casing 
is smaller than the hole 60 of bottom wall 54 so as to partially engage 
this hole to preclude tampering with the shank whose exposed portion 
between the head 78 and locking body 72 is entirely within cavity 50 
between the walls 56 and 54. 
The locking body mechanism has jaws (not shown) that are releasably engaged 
with any of the shank grooves 80. This permits the locking body 70 to 
enter into the hole 60 in the locked state. The locking jaws permit the 
body 70 to slide along the shank toward the head 78 while locked against 
displacement in the opposite direction unless released. 
Rear wall 44 has a substantially square opening 82 except for an enlarged 
transverse region 84. The opening 82 receives the hasp 26 (FIG. 2) and the 
enlarged region 84 receives the leg 18 of the hasp 16 as best seen in FIG. 
4. The received hasp apertures 20 and 28 are aligned with the holes 58, 60 
and 62 of the device 38. 
In operation, the bolt seal 70 shank is passed through all of the aligned 
apertures, with the head nested in hole 62. The locking body 72 is then 
attached to the shank until it seats in the hole 60 and against the bottom 
wall 54. The latch hasps enclose the opening 82 in the rear wall and 
support the device 38. As a result the shank 76 between the head 78 and 
seal locking body 72 is fully enclosed and inaccessible by tampering tools 
external the casing 40. 
To release the locking body 72, FIG. 5, a tool 86, as more fully described 
in the aforementioned U.S. Pat. No. 5,732,989, is employed. The tool 86 
has a pair of squeezable handles 88, 90. A jaw 92 is secured to handle 90. 
A second jaw 94 is pivotally secured to handle 88 via link 96. A 
compression spring 98 is between the jaws. A cylinder 100 is pivotally 
attached to jaw 92. The cylinder 100 engages the locking body 72 internal 
locking mechanism employing a spring. This spring (not shown) has a high 
spring constant, e.g., requiring several hundred pounds force to displace. 
This spring keeps the locking body jaw mechanism locked. The tool 86 by 
manually squeezing the handles together exerts a highly leveraged force 
against the jaw mechanism spring to displace and unlock these jaws. The 
locking mechanism spring is relatively tamper resistant due to its high 
spring load. 
The depending side wall portions such as portion 48' preclude bolt cutters 
from accessing the exposed locking body. The recessed head 78 is also not 
accessible to bolt cutters. Further, cutting torches will most likely melt 
and fuse the head or locking body to the casing and at best will take 
considerable time to free the latch of the device 38. Such increased 
tampering time serves as a deterrent to thieves who disdain lengthy 
tampering due to potential periodic surveillance. The inclination of 
bottom wall section 68 provides clearance access for the tool 86. The tool 
86 can access the locking body 72 through the open one side of the casing 
40 at the depending walls 48' which preclude easy access by more 
conventional tools. 
FIGS. 6, 7 and 8 illustrate a second embodiment comprising a protection 
device 102 having a housing 104 for use with a breakaway seal 106 of the 
type disclosed in the aforementioned U.S. Pat. Nos. 5,347,689 and 
5,413,393. Housing 104 is made of sheet steel plate members similar to the 
housing 40 of FIG. 3, and is used with the latch 2, FIG. 1. The housing 
104 has a front wall 107, a rear wall 108 and opposing lateral side walls 
110 and 112. The rear wall 108 has an opening 114 identical to the opening 
82 and a region 115 identical to region 84 of the housing 40, FIG. 2 for 
receiving the hasps 16 and 26. 
A top wall 116 encloses cavity 118 at the top thereof. Top wall 116 has a 
hole 119 with a beveled edge 120. The edge 120 mates with and engages the 
received frusto-conical portion of seal 106 head 124. The seal 106 shank 
126 is partially surrounded by top wall 116 with no portion exposed above 
the top wall 116. 
Bottom wall 128 is formed of a right angle iron. The apex 130 of the wall 
128 is interior the space between the front, rear and side walls closest 
to the top wall 116. The bottom wall 128 has two inclined sections 132 and 
134 each secured to and terminating distal the apex 130 at a different 
respective side wall 110, 112, A lock body 136 on the seal 106 is 
partially received in a hole 138 in the bottom wall through the apex 130 
and is adjacent to the rear wall 108. The walls are preferably joined by 
welds. 
The bolt seal lock body 136 includes a locking collet (not shown) that 
slides up the seal 106 shank 126 in a one way clutch action. The collect 
engages the grooves 140 in locking engagement as described in the 
aforementioned patents '689 and '393. This permits a portion of the lock 
body casing to enter into the cavity 118 so that the shank 126 is located 
fully within the cavity. 
To open the seal requires the head to be grasped by a breaking tool as 
described in patent '393. The shank is then bent and broken by the tool. 
The locking body, however is reusable, and the shank discarded. The shank 
has no externally exposed portions outside the housing 104, the shank 
being the most vulnerable component in the bolt seal. 
To protect the locking body 136, the bottom wall 128 forms a V-shaped 
recess with the front and rear walls which surround the locking body. This 
precludes accessing the body 136 from the sides with tampering tools. The 
access is only from the bottom direction which makes it more difficult to 
tamper with the locking body 136. 
The head 124 is protected and shielded on three sides by upwardly extending 
respective portions 107', 110' and 112' of the front wall 107, and side 
walls 110 and 112. The front wall portion 107' and side wall portion 110' 
extend for their entire transverse extent beyond the top wall 116, FIG. 6. 
The side wall portion 112' extends upwardly beyond the top wall slightly 
less than one half of the wall 112 width from the rear to front wall to 
form an open region 140 above top wall 116 at the housing side. The open 
region above top wall 116 and the opening 114 in the rear wall 108 is 
shielded by the latch 2 (FIG. 1) which precludes access to the head 124 
from the rear of device 102. The only side access to the head is via the 
open region 140 in to permit use of the seal breaking tool (not shown). 
Tampering tool access to the head is minimized by the upward extending 
portions 107', 110' and 112' and to the lock body 136 by the surrounding 
bottom and side walls. Torch access to the head and lock body requires 
undesirable excessive time to defeat the locked seal. 
A third embodiment of a bolt seal protective device 142 is shown in FIGS. 
12-14 for use with a rail box car latch 144, FIGS. 9-11. The latch 144 is 
used on sliding doors of box cars. The latch 144 comprises a yoke member 
146 which typically is cast iron as are all of the components of the latch 
144. The yoke member 146 comprises a pair of yokes 148, 150 secured by a 
common plate member 152. A handle 154 is pivoted to yoke 148 by pin 156. A 
stud 157 with an enlarged head 159 upstands from a side of the handle 154. 
A wedge hasp 158 locking member 160 is pivoted to yoke 150 by pin 162. 
In FIG. 10, locking member 160 comprises a body 164 pinned by pin 162 via 
hole 163, an upstanding L-shaped rib 166 and a tongue 168. A tamper 
indicating seal (not shown) receiving hole 170 is in rib 166. The rib 166 
and hole 170 are adjacent to the handle 154 when the wedge hasp 158 is in 
the locked state of FIG. 9. 
The wedge hasp 158 tapers somewhat to end 172, which end forms a hasp. The 
end 172 has a hole 174 for receiving a locking bolt 176 of the present 
invention, or as in the prior art, for receiving the shackle of a padlock 
(not shown) or a conventional bolt seal shank of the representative type 
shown in the '393 patent for example. The hasp 158 is passed through the 
yokes 148 and 150 in the locking state. In this locked state, the locking 
member 160 is pivoted to the position shown in FIG. 9 with the tongue 168 
engaged with a recess (not shown) in a side of the wedge hasp 158. 
In the unlocked state, the locking member 160 is pivoted in direction 161 
about pin 162 to disengage tongue 168 from the wedge hasp recess. The 
wedge hasp 158 is then free to be disengaged from the yokes 148 and 150 in 
direction 163. All of the above described structure of the latch 144 is 
secured to the side of a box car stationary wall. 
A sliding door securing bar 178, FIG. 11, is cast iron and elongated. The 
bar 178 has an aperture 180 at one end for receiving a staple 182 secured 
to the box car door (not shown), the staple movably locking the bar 178 to 
the door. The bar 178 has a somewhat centrally located enlarged portion 
183 with a rectangular opening 184 which receives therethrough the wedge 
hasp 158, FIG. 9, in the locked state. The end of the bar 178 distal 
staple 182 has an aperture 186 for receiving the stud 157. The handle 154 
has a seal receiving opening (not shown) to receive the tamper indicating 
seal which is engaged with the hole 170 of the locking member 160 in the 
locked state. Prior art bolt seals locked to the hasp hole 174 are easily 
defeated by thieves because the shanks are exposed for breakage. 
The handle 154 pivots about pin 156 to cam the door shut with the locking 
member 160 in the unlocked state. The locking member 160 is then pivoted 
to the locking state of FIG. 9. 
The protection device 142 according to this embodiment employs bolt 176, 
which has a 180.degree. bight 177, FIG. 14. The bight 177 sits within the 
hole 174 of the wedge hasp 158 (FIG. 9). The bolt 176 has a short shank 
portion 188 and a long shank portion 190. The long portion 190 has an 
axial array of circular grooves the same as grooves 80 in shank 76, FIG. 
4. These grooves are for releasable locking engagement with locking body 
72 described above and in U.S. Pat. No. '989. 
The protection device 142, FIGS. 12 and 13, comprises a housing 143 
including a front plate member wall 192, a rear plate member wall 194 and 
two opposing lateral side walls 196, 198. These walls form a cavity 197 
having four sides, a top and a bottom. The side wall 198 has a notch 200. 
The front wall 192 has a top portion 202 that extends toward the top of 
the device 142 higher than the side and rear walls. The cavity 197 bottom 
is enclosed by bottom wall 204. 
Bottom wall 204 is formed with a rear plate member section 206 normal to 
all of the walls and a front plate member section 208 normal to the side 
walls and inclined to the front and rear walls. The rear section 206 has 
an aperture 210 for receiving a portion of the locking body 72 and the 
bolt 176 long bolt portion 190. The front section 208 has an aperture 212 
for receiving the bolt 176 short portion 188. In similar fashion to the 
device 38, FIG. 3, the rear and side walls depend below the bottom wall 
204 to form a U-shaped protective region for the locking body 72. A 
portion of the locking body 72 enters and engages the aperture 210 in the 
locked state. 
In operation, the bolt 176 is first inserted in the wedge hasp hole 174 as 
shown in FIG. 9 after the latch 144 is placed in the locked state of FIG. 
9. The device 142 cavity 197 is open at the top for receiving the latch 
144 wedge hasp 158. The yoke 148 abuts the upper portion 202 of the front 
wall and overlies and encloses the open top of the cavity 197. The yoke 
148 has a leg 148' which engages and encloses the notch 200. 
A tamper indicating seal (not shown) is engaged with hole 216 in bolt 176, 
FIG. 14. The latch 144 fully encloses the bolt 176 in the region at the 
bight 186 to the locking body 72, precluding access to tampering to the 
bolt to break the bolt open. While the bolt shank portion 188 is exposed 
through the bottom wall 204, this portion is harmless with respect to 
breaking the bolt 176 by tampering. 
The bolt locking means in the claims corresponds to the bight 186 in this 
embodiment as compared to the bolt heads 78 and 124 in the other 
embodiments described hereinabove. As in the embodiment of FIG. 4, the 
bolt locking means is enclosed to preclude tampering. In the embodiment of 
FIG. 14, the bolt locking means, i.e., the bight, is fully enclosed. In 
the embodiment of FIG. 4, the bolt head locking means is partially 
enclosed due to the presence of hole 58. Tests on rail cars exhibiting 10% 
breaking and entering with prior art bolt seals exhibited no breakage of 
the seals on rail cars sealed with the device 142. 
The illustrated embodiments are for illustration and not limitation. It 
will occur to those of ordinary skill that various modifications may be 
made to the disclosed embodiments without departing from the scope of the 
invention defined by the appended claims. For example, steel plate members 
are illustrated but other high strength materials may be used. By way of 
further example, the device need not have defined separate sides as shown 
but may be curved which curves inherently include sides and walls as 
claimed.