Optical filter assembly for enhancement of image contrast and glare reduction of cathode ray display tube

An optical interference filter structure incorporates antireflectance and light absorbing elements disposed on a substrate. The filter structure is shaped to conform substantially to the face of a cathode ray tube or other luminous display, such as a cathode ray tube for example. The materials of the elements are selected for their characteristics including indices of refraction, light absorption and chromatic filtering so that in combination they provide optimum antireflectance, antiglare and image contrast features.

TECHNICAL FIELD 
This invention relates to an optical filter assembly and in particular to a 
filter assembly for improving the image of a cathode ray tube or other 
luminous display. 
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION 
Various self-luminous displays are used today for displaying data and 
images, such as employed for computers and television screens. The 
displays may be generated with cathode ray tubes, electroluminescent 
devices and plasma panels, among other things. 
It is known that the average television viewer and computer operators spend 
many hours daily looking at display screens which present images and data, 
including graphics and alphanumeric symbols, among other things. There are 
significant problems that may occur when watching a display screen over a 
long period of time. One problem is reflection of objects external to the 
display tube that appear to be superimposed on the display image and also 
produce undesirable glare. This can occur during daylight hours when a 
window facing the display face appears as a reflection, by way of example, 
or at other times when light bulb radiation impinges on the display screen 
face. Another problem is evidenced when image contrast is low and the 
image does not appear to be sufficiently sharp to the viewer. As a result, 
the viewer's eyes are deleteriously affected and tend to become tired, 
which may lead to poor work performance or other undesirable effects. 
CROSS-REFERENCE TO RELATED PATENT 
U.S. Pat. No. 4,333,983, which issued June 8, 1982 in behalf of T. A. Allen 
and is assigned to the same assignee, discloses an optical coating 
assembly incorporating a flexible polymer substrate that is coated with an 
aluminum oxide thin film to a defined thickness, and an optical coating 
formed on the aluminum oxide film. The optical coating is made of at least 
one layer of magnesium fluoride formed to a predetermined optical 
thickness. The aluminum oxide thin film serves as an adhesive layer to 
ensure that the optical coating adheres to the polymer substrate, and is 
relatively hard to afford durability to the assembly. The optical coating 
enhances the antireflectance of the assembly. 
The present invention discloses an improvement of the patented optical 
coating assembly, and substantially enhances the antireflectance 
characteristic of an optical filter to reduce glare which is generally 
experienced with self-luminous displays, and significantly improves the 
contrast of the images and data which are displayed. 
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION 
An object of this invention is to provide an optical filter assembly for 
use with cathode ray tubes and other self-luminous displays whereby 
reduced glare and improved image contrast are realized. 
Another object of this invention is to provide an optical filter assembly 
that is easily positioned in juxtaposition with a face of a display device 
to achieve optical filtering and enhanced light image transmission. 
Another object is to provide an optical filter assembly that resists 
humidity and is highly durable. 
For purpose of explanation, the description hereinafter will be directed to 
a cathode ray tube display, although the invention is not limited thereto, 
but is applicable to self-luminous displays in general. 
In accordance with this invention, an optical filter assembly comprises a 
transparent plastic substrate having front and rear surfaces. The filter 
assembly is configured to match substantially the configuration of the 
face of the display tube with which it is to be associated for improving 
image contrast and for minimizing glare resulting from reflection of 
externally illuminated objects. A multilayer optical coating, which is 
formed of layers of substantially transparent thin metal films interleaved 
with films of material having a low index of refraction, such as magnesium 
fluoride, is deposited on the front surface of the plastic substrate. The 
multilayer coating has optical characteristics that reduce reflectance and 
glare and enhance the contrast of the display image. 
In an alternative embodiment, in addition to the optical coating deposited 
on the front surface of the substrate, an optical coating formed of a 
material having a low index of refraction, such as magnesium fluoride, is 
deposited on the rear surface of the substrate to enhance antireflectance. 
In each embodiment, a hard coat of alumina is utilized preferably to 
provide adherence between the plastic substrate and the optical coating, 
as well as to improve the durability of the optical filter structure.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION 
With reference to FIG. 1 an optical filter comprises a substrate 10 formed 
from a flexible transparent plastic or polymer, such as polyethylene 
terephthalate (PET) or polycarbonate. The substrate layer is about 
0.003-0.007 inches in physical thickness depending upon the rigidity 
required, and the plastic material forming the substrate has an index of 
refraction in the range of about 1.5-1.8. 
A thin film 12 of aluminum oxide is vacuum deposited on the front surface 
of the substrate to a thickness of at least 170 nanometers approximately, 
which is about 3/8 wave of optical thickness at a design wavelength of 
approximately 500 nanometers. This design wavelength is within the visible 
spectrum that extends from about 400-750 nanometers. Aluminum oxide has an 
index of refraction of about 1.65. The aluminum oxide thin film serves to 
enable a multilayer optical coating to be joined securely to the plastic 
substrate. The relatively inexpensive alumina hard coat 12 also improves 
the durability of the optical filter assembly so that the optical filter 
is made to be commercially feasible. 
In one embodiment of this invention, a multilayer optical coating is 
deposited over the aluminum oxide film 12 to provide a light filter having 
antireflectance and antiglare features. The optical coating is formed, in 
this implementation, with two periods of dark mirrors, each period 
comprising two layers of different materials. The first layer 14 that is 
deposited on the aluminum oxide is a very thin film of a metal, such as 
nickel, having a thickness of about 13 to 80 Angstroms. The nickel film is 
light absorbing and acts to reduce reflectance and glare significantly. 
The second layer 16 of the first period consists essentially of magnesium 
flouride, which is deposited to a thickness equivalent to a quarter wave 
optical thickness at a design wavelength in the range of 500-650 
nanometers that is substantially within the center of the visible 
spectrum. Magnesium fluoride has an index of refraction of about 1.38 and 
is a material that is nonabsorbing or antireflectance to light. The 
optical filter includes a second like pair of a thin film nickel layer 18 
with a thickness on the order of 75 Angstroms and thin film of magnesium 
fluoride 20 deposited successively on the first pair of thin film layers. 
The second magnesium fluoride layer 20 has a quarter wave optical 
thickness at a design wavelength in the range of about 400-500 nanometers. 
It has been established by test measurements that when using an optical 
filter coating on PET as disclosed above with a cathode ray tube display, 
only 0.5-0.8% of the integrated reflected light reaches the eyes of a 
viewer of the display, and that the integrated light transmittance of the 
image display is about 84%. Without the optical filter coating, 10-12% of 
reflected light reaches the viewer's eyes. 
To use the optical filter, the layered structure is housed in a frame (not 
shown) and the completed filter assembly is either attached, by its frame 
with adhesive or other fastener for example, to the housing of the display 
tube. An alternative approach is to attach the optical filter directly to 
the glass surface with a two-sided adhesive element having an index of 
refraction similar to glass which is about 1.52. In such case, there is 
approximately an 0.2% reflectance from the display tube. 
To enhance the antireflectance of the optical filter, the rear surface of 
the filter assembly, i.e., the surface which faces the display tube when 
in use, is coated with a single layer 22 of magnesium fluoride. An 
aluminum oxide layer 24 is deposited between the rear surface of the 
plastic substrate 10 and the magnesium fluoride thin film layer 22 to 
provide adherence of the coating 22 to the plastic. With this additional 
antireflectance coating, the two surface coated optical filter has a 
reflectance of only 0.1-0.2%. 
With reference to FIG. 8, a series of curves A-E depict the percent 
reflectance plotted against the wavelengths of the visible spectrum 
between 400-700 nanometers for alternative optical filter configurations. 
Curve A represents an optical coating formed of a single layer of 
magnesium fluoride 26 deposited on a PET substrate 30, with an alumina 
layer 28 therebetween, as depicted in FIG. 3. The quarterwave optical 
thickness of the MgF.sub.2 layer is about 550 nanometers. The integrated 
reflectance of this structure was calculated to be about 0.8% and the 
integrated transmittance was about 99% for this single antireflectance 
layer on the front surface of a plastic substrate. 
Curve B of FIG. 8 represents a two-layer nonabsorbing optical coating 
having a layer 32 of achromatizing material designated as M deposited over 
an aluminum oxide film formed on a plastic substrate, as illustrated in 
FIG. 4. The material M has an index of refraction of about 1.85, and may 
be cerium stannate, zirconium oxide or indium tin oxide, by way of 
example. The material M is formed to have a quarterwave optical thickness 
of about 850 nanometers. A MgF.sub.2 layer 34 having a quarterwave optical 
thickness of about 500 nanometers is deposited on top. The integrated 
reflectance for this design was calculated to be about 0.25% and the 
integrated transmittance about 99%. 
With reference to FIG. 5, an absorbing two-layer structure formed with a 
nickel thin film 36 having a physical thickness of about 2.0 nanometers 
and a thin film 36 of MgF.sub.2 on top provides the characteristic of 
Curve C of FIG. 8. The MgF.sub.2 layer is fabricated to have a quarterwave 
optical thickness of about 620 nanometers. The layers are deposited on an 
alumina film over a PET substrate 30 as described heretofore. The single 
period dark mirror optical filter of this design has an integrated 
reflectance of about 0.18% and an integrated transmittance of about 87%. 
Curve D of FIG. 8 relates to the performance of a one period dark mirror 
optical filter having an achromatizing layer. The three layer structure 
which is illustrated in FIG. 6 includes a layer 40 of material M, such as 
cerium stannate or indium tin oxide, deposited on a PET substrate 30. The 
material has a quarter wave optical thickness at about 1060 nanometers and 
its index of refraction for this design is 2.05. A metallic thin film 42 
of nickel having a thickness of about 1.3 nanometers is next deposited, 
followed by a layer 44 of MgF.sub.2 having a quarter-wave optical 
thickness of about 510 nanometers. The layers 42 and 44 form a single 
period dark mirror and the M material serves as an achromatizing layer. 
The optical filter provides an integrated reflectance of about 0.09% and 
an integrated transmittance of about 91%. 
The curve E of FIG. 3 depicts the performance of an optical filter 
incorporating a single period dark mirror and two one-half wave 
achromatizing layers, as shown in FIG. 7. The achromatizing structure is 
formed with a first layer of MgF.sub.2 46 on an Al.sub.2 O.sub.3 layer 28 
deposited on a PET substrate 30. A second achromatizing layer 48 of 
material M having an index of refraction of 2.05 is next deposited. A 
single period dark mirror consisting of a thin film 50 of nickel and a 
layer 52 of MgF.sub.2 is formed on the M layer. The first MgF.sub.2 layer 
46 has a quarter-wave optical thickness at about 1060 nanometers, whereas 
the second MgF.sub.2 or top layer 52 has a quarter wave optical thickness 
at a design wavelength of about 515 nanometers. The nickel film 50 has a 
physical thickness of about 2.3 nanometers, and the M material 48 has a 
quarter wave optical thickness at 1066 nanometers. This optical coating 
structure provides an integrated reflectance of about 0.05% and an 
integrated transmittance of 84%, and is effective over a wide range of the 
visible spectrum. 
It should be understood that the scope of the invention is not limited to 
the particular materials or configurations described above. For example, 
the thin film metal layers may consist essentially of nickel, molybdenum, 
chromium, tantalum, nichrome or inconel alloy, inter alia. If molybdenum 
is utilized for the metal layer, then the antireflectance layers are 
preferably formed from fused silica, which has an index of refraction of 
about 1.46. Also, the configuration of the optical filter can be flat or 
planar, or arcuate or curred in two dimensions to conform to or match the 
face of the display tube. To attain the desired shape, the PET substrate 
is thermoformed before or after deposition of the optical filter coatings. 
When operating and viewing a cathode ray tube or other luminous display, it 
is highly desirable to have high contrast between the illuminated display 
elements and the dark background. This is particularly significant to 
computer operators who are looking at a multiplicity of alphanumeric 
characters over long periods of time, as well as television viewers. The 
optical coating filter of this invention enhances contrast as a result of 
the balance of light absorption and transmission effectuated by the 
selected materials acting in combination. To further enhance contrast of 
the display, the substrate is made of a dyed polyester, which may have a 
neutral gray hue. The dyed substrate provides a uniform attenuation across 
the light frequency band. 
In an alternative approach to achieving enhanced contrast, the absorbing 
thin film metal layers are made to be thicker, which adds to the 
absorption realized with the metal layers.