Pure control-plane approach for on-path connection admission control operations in multiprotocol label switching virtual private networks

The embodiments described herein present methods and apparatuses for on-path CAC operations in a MPLS-VPN environment. In an example embodiment, an ingress PE device receives a quality of service (QoS) resource reservation request; constructs an outgoing message that includes information allowing an egress PE device to identify the virtual private network routing and forwarding table (VRF) associated with a resource reservation resulting from the QoS resource reservation request; and transmits the outgoing message to the egress PE device, where the information allowing VRF identification is echoed back by the egress PE device and used by the ingress PE device to identify the VRF associated with the resource reservation resulting from the QoS resource reservation request. Other embodiments are described.

FIELD

The present disclosure relates generally to computer networks. In an example embodiment, the disclosure relates to a pure control-plane approach for on-path connection admission control (CAC) operations in multiprotocol label switching virtual private networks (MPLS VPN).

BACKGROUND

Resource ReSerVation Protocol (RSVP) and Next Steps in Signaling (NSIS) are network layer protocols designed to enable Internet applications to reserve resources across a network and obtain differing qualities of services (QoS). Such protocols are not routing protocols; however, both RSVP and NSIS work in conjunction with routing protocols, such as Open Short Path First (OSPF).

Multiprotocol Label Switching (MPLS) is a data-carrying mechanism that uses labels as a shorthand representation of an Internet Protocol (IP) packet's header. The use of the shorthand representation can increase the forwarding speed of routers. MPLS may also be used when implementing virtual private networks (VPN). MPLS is suited for such as task because of its ability to provide traffic isolation and differentiation with low overhead.

DESCRIPTION OF EXAMPLE EMBODIMENTS

Overview

In general, within a multiprotocol label switching virtual private network (MPLS-VPN), the virtual private network routing and forwarding table (VRF) is conveyed inside the MPLS header that encapsulates a packet. When an on-path signaling protocol includes the source and destination address information inside the protocol message itself and uses such information for routing, the on-path signaling protocol does not naturally have access to VRF information to easily provide VRF-aware routing because the packet is encapsulated within an MPLS header. This problem may exist with other protocols that include the source and destination addresses within the protocol message.

The embodiments described herein present methods and apparatuses for on-path connection admission control (CAC) operations in a MPLS-VPN environment. This disclosure describes the general concept of performing CAC operations in L3VPNs. One method of performing CAC in such an environment includes transmitting information that allows an egress provider edge (PE) to identify the virtual private network routing and forwarding table (VRF) associated with a resource reservation, where such information can be echoed back by the egress PE, thereby allowing an ingress PE to identify the VRF associated with the reservation. While examples are provided that illustrate such a process using RSVP and NSIS, it is understood that other network layer protocols may be used to obtain similar results. Various data structures and processes are described herein to achieve such messaging. While some data structures are provided as examples in the foregoing discussion, other data structures or processes to transmit the same or similar information are understood to be included in the scope of this disclosure.

In an example embodiment, a quality of service (QoS) resource reservation request is received at an ingress provider edge (PE) device from a customer edge (CE) device. An outgoing message that includes information allowing the ingress PE device to identify the virtual private network routing and forwarding table (VRF) associated with a resource reservation resulting from a QoS resource reservation request is constructed. The constructed outgoing message is transmitted to an egress PE device. The egress PE device may then echo back the VRF identification to be used by the ingress PE device to identify the VRF associated with the resource reservation that resulted from the QoS resource reservation request.

In an example embodiment, an incoming ReSerVation Protocol (RSVP) Path message is received. The Path message may be received by an ingress provider edge (PE). An outgoing RSVP Path message addressed to an egress provider edge (PE) device is then constructed, where the outgoing RSVP Path message includes: (i) a virtual private network routing and forwarding table (VRF) identification value and (ii) a VPN label. The VRF identification value may be echoed back by the egress PE in a RSVP Reservation (Resv) message, which may then allow the ingress PE to identify a corresponding relevant local VRF for Resv processing. In a similar manner, the VPN label may be used by the egress PE to identify a relevant local VRF for Path processing. The outgoing RSVP Path message to the egress PE device is then transmitted.

In another example embodiment, an incoming ReSerVation Protocol (RSVP) Path message is received. The Path message may be received at an egress PE. A VRF identification value and a virtual private network (VPN) label are extracted from the incoming RSVP Path message. The VRF identification value may be stored in the path state and the VPN label may be used to construct and forward an outgoing Path message to a customer edge (CE) device based on the VPN label.

In an example embodiment, the QoS resource reservation request includes an NSIS RESERVE message. In another example embodiment, the QoS resource reservation request includes an NSIS QUERY message.

Example Embodiments

In general, this document uses the following terminology. A customer edge (CE) includes a network device, such as a router, which is physically or logically positioned at the edge of a customer network. The CE may attach the customer network to a virtual private network (VPN) provider. A provider edge (PE) includes a network device, such as a router, which is physically or logically positioned at the edge of a provider's network. In some example configurations, one or more CE devices may be attached with a PE. A VPN label includes a multiprotocol label switching (MPLS) label associated with a route to a customer prefix in a VPN. The VPN label may also be referred to as a VPN route label. A VPN Routing and Forwarding (VRF) table is a lookup table managed by a PE enabling the PE to correctly manage traffic between CEs in a VPN.

FIG. 1is a diagram of a networked system100, in accordance with an example embodiment. The networked system100may include network devices, which may include a device at the edge of a particular network (e.g., a network edge). In the example illustrated, two customer edges (CE)102A,102B are connected to two provider edges (PE)104A,104B, respectively. The customer edges102A,102B and provider edges104A,104B may include devices such as routers or other network devices that analyze or direct network traffic. The provider edges104A,104B are connected via a backbone or core network106that includes one or more provider core (P) devices108. The provider core devices108may include routers or other network traffic-handling devices. In addition, one or more hosts110A,110B may be connected to the customer edges102A,102B, respectively. Other network configurations may be used without departing from the inventive subject matter described herein.

Examples of computer networks, such those illustrated inFIG. 1, include local area networks and wide area networks. A local area network connects the nodes over dedicated private communications links located in the same general physical location, such as a building or campus. A wide area network, on the other hand, connects geographically dispersed nodes over long-distance communications links, such as common carrier telephone lines, optical light paths, synchronous optical networks (SONET), or synchronous digital hierarchy (SDH) links. The Internet is an example of a wide area network that connects disparate networks throughout the world, providing global communication between nodes on various networks. The nodes communicate over computer network100by exchanging discrete frames or packets of data according to predefined protocols, such as Transmission Control Protocol/Internet Protocol (TCP/IP), User Datagram Protocol (UDP), Asynchronous Transfer Mode (ATM) protocol, Frame Relay protocol, Internet Packet Exchange (IPX) protocol, interior gateway protocol (IGP), and other protocols.

In the network configuration illustrated inFIG. 1, the provider edges104A,104B are configured to provide a virtual private network (VPN) using multiprotocol label switching (MPLS). During operation, HOST2110B may join a multicast group by using Internet Group Membership Protocol (IGMP). After HOST2110B joins an appropriate group, the content broadcaster, HOST1110A, may send one or more session initiation messages and the receiver, HOST2110B, may communicate one or more connection admission control (CAC) request messages. Similarly, HOST2110B and HOST1110A may participate in a unicast connection using unicast routing services, as an example.

In an example embodiment, the hosts (e.g., HOST1110A and HOST2110B) use the Resource ReSerVation Protocol (RSVP). RSVP may be used to perform admission control as part of an integrated services (int-serv) architecture. As provided by RSVP, reservation initiation messages include an RSVP Path message and the CAC request messages include an RSVP reservation (Resv) message. After the sender receives an RSVP Resv message, the sender begins sending data in accordance with the resource reservations requested by the RSVP Resv message.

As used herein, it should be noted that the terms “RSVP Path message” and “Path message” may be used interchangeably and refer to a Path message as constructed using the RSVP protocol. Also, other RSVP messages may be referred to by their name, such as, for example, referring to an “RSVP Resv message” as simply a “Resv message.”

In another example embodiment, the hosts (e.g., HOST1110A and HOST2110B) use the NSIS protocol. Similar to RSVP, NSIS may be used to perform admission control over the HOST1-HOST2link. Next Steps in Signaling (NSIS) provides a framework that concentrates on a two-layer signaling paradigm. The intention is to re-use, where appropriate, the protocol mechanisms of RSVP, while at the same time simplifying these mechanisms and implementing a more general signaling model. NSIS decomposes the overall signaling protocol suite into a generic (lower) layer and a separate upper layer that corresponds with each signaling application. In an example, for on-path QoS signaling, the lower layer is General Internet Signaling Transport (GIST) and the upper layer is NSIS Signaling Layer Protocol (NSLP) for Quality-of-Service Signaling. The upper layer of NSLP includes two messages: an NSIS QUERY message and an NSIS RESERVE message.

In an embodiment, an NSIS QUERY message may be used in an analogous manner to the RSVP Path message to transmit network environmental information associated with a QoS (Quality of Service) resource reservation, such as an MPLS VPN label. The MPLS VPN label may be used by an egress PE to identify a relevant local VRF for NSIS QUERY processing. In such an embodiment, an NSIS RESERVE message may then be used in an analogous manner to the RSVP Resv message, to echo back network environmental information that allows an ingress PE to identify a corresponding relevant local VRF.

FIG. 2is a block diagram, in accordance with an example embodiment, illustrating control and data flow between two hosts on a network using RSVP. As shown inFIG. 2, the system includes a first customer edge (CE1)102A, a first provider edge (PE1)104A, a second provider edge (PE2)104B, and a second customer edge (CE2)102B. The control and data flow illustrated is to establish a unidirectional reservation for a point-to-point flow. At200, CE1102A receives an RSVP Path message. The Path message may have originated from a host (e.g., HOST1110A) that CE1102A is servicing and is addressed to a receiver (e.g., HOST2110B). CE1102A processes the Path message (block202) using RSVP procedures and forwards the Path message toward the receiver (block204) along the link CE1-PE1. PE1104A receives the Path message (block206), processes the Path message (block208), and forwards the Path message toward a receiver across the provider core network to PE2104B (block210). In an example embodiment, PE1104A addresses the Path message directly to PE2104B, instead of to a final destination address (e.g., a host connected to CE2102B). In an example embodiment, PE1104A recognizes an RSVP Path message using the IP Router Alert option. PE2104B in turn receives the Path message (block212), processes the Path message (block214), and forwards the Path message toward the receiver (block216) along the link PE2-CE2. Then, CE2102B receives the Path message (block218), processes the Path message using RSVP procedures (block220), and forwards the Path message to the receiver (block222).

FIG. 3is a flow diagram, in accordance with an example embodiment, illustrating a method208of processing a Path message at an ingress PE. In general, when a Path message arrives at the ingress PE (e.g., PE1104A) the PE establishes a suitable path state and forward the Path message to the egress PE (e.g., PE2104B).

At300, when the ingress PE (e.g., PE1104A) receives a Path message from CE1that is addressed to the receiver (e.g., HOST2110B), the VRF that is associated with the incoming interface is identified, just as for other data path operations.

At302, the path state for the session is stored, and is associated with that VRF, so that potentially overlapping addresses among different VPNs do not appear to belong to the same session. According to RSVP operations, the path state includes at least the unicast IP address of the previous hop node, which may be used to route responsive RSVP messages hop-by-hop along the reverse path.

At304, the destination address of the receiver is looked up in the appropriate VRF, and the Border Gateway Protocol (BGP) Next-Hop for that destination is identified. The BGP Next-Hop is the address of the egress PE (PE2104B).

At306, a VRF_ID object is constructed and is used to carry a locally significant VRF identification value. In order to ensure that any responsive messages that will be sent to the ingress PE by the egress PE can be associated with the correct VPN context, the Path message may contain an identification value that can be echoed back inside responsive messages and thereby used to identify the corresponding VRF. Locally significant is meant to indicate that the VRF identification value is meaningful to the PE that created the object. As such, the identification value may be generated using a localized algorithm, such as a random number generator or an indexing algorithm, to maintain unique values at the PE. Other types of identification may be used, such as a globally-significant value, in example embodiments. In some embodiments, the VRF_ID object is not used, instead using other information to identify the VRF associated with the QoS resource reservation request.

At308, the VPN label for the destination address of the receiver is obtained and placed in a new RSVP object, VPN_LABEL. The VPN_LABEL object is discussed in further detail below (seeFIG. 4). The VPN label for the destination may be obtained from a lookup table or similar structure.

At310, a new (outgoing) Path message is constructed with a destination address equal to the address of the egress PE identified above. This outgoing Path message contains all the objects from the original Path message, plus the VRF_ID object and the VPN_LABEL object. It should be noted that the SESSION object contains the ultimate (e.g., customer) destination address of the flow, while the IP header for the message contains the address of the egress PE. By addressing the egress PE directly, the Router Alert IP option need not be relied on for interception of the Path message by the egress PE. This is useful in the context of MPLS-VPNs as usually an RSVP message would be MPLS encapsulated and thus the Router Alert option is not visible to the egress PE.

FIG. 4is a diagram of a VPN_LABEL data object400, in accordance with an example embodiment. The VPN_LABEL object includes a reserved portion402and a label portion404. In an example embodiment, the reserved portion402includes 12 bits and the label portion404includes 20 bits. In an example embodiment, the reserved portion402is set to zero on transmission and ignored on receipt. The VPN_LABEL object has an RSVP C-Type and a class identifier. In an example embodiment, the RSVP C-Type is defined to be 1. In an example embodiment, the VPN_LABEL object appears in all RSVP messages that contain a SESSION object and is sent from an ingress PE to an egress PE. In an example embodiment, the class number is assigned from the range 0x11bbbbbb so that messages containing the VPN_LABEL object will be ignored and forwarded by routers that do not understand this class number.

FIG. 5is a diagram of a VRF_ID data object500, in accordance with an example embodiment. The VRF_ID object includes an identifier portion502. In an example embodiment, the identifier portion502has a size of 32 bits. The VRF_ID object includes an identifier that is a locally significant opaque value. The VRF_ID object has an RSVP C-Type and a class identifier. In an example embodiment, the RSVP C-Type is defined to be 1. In an example embodiment, the class number is assigned from the range 0x11bbbbbb so that messages containing the VRF_ID object will be ignored and forwarded by routers that do not understand this class number.

FIG. 6is a flow diagram, in accordance with an example embodiment, illustrating a method214of processing a Path message at an egress PE. In general, the egress PE is configured to (1) determine the egress VRF for the specified flow in order to forward the Path message toward the correct CE, and ultimately to the final destination of the message and (2) store appropriate information to be able to construct one or more reply messages to the ingress PE.

At600, the egress PE VRF is determined. In an example embodiment, the MPLS label contained in the VPN_LABEL object and the destination IP address contained in the SESSION object are extracted and used to determine the forwarding path information for MPLS-encapsulated packets. The forwarding path information may include the outgoing interface information, including the egress VRF, that would have been used had a packet with that MPLS label and IP address been received. At602, the egress VRF is stored with the path state to facilitate the processing of reply messages for this session. At604, the VRF_ID object is accessed and the ingress PE's VRF identifier is stored. At606, a new Path message is constructed. The new Path message is addressed to the receiver's customer edge (e.g., CE2102B) using the destination IP address obtained from the SESSION object. Other portions of the Path message, such as the RSVP_HOP object, may be configured as per RSVP processing.

FIG. 7is a block diagram, in accordance with an example embodiment, illustrating control and data flow between two hosts on a network. The control and data flow illustrated inFIG. 7illustrate signaling in the reverse direction as that illustrated inFIG. 2. An RSVP responsive message is communicated back through the network in response to a corresponding Path message. Although the example embodiment illustrated inFIG. 7describes an RSVP reservation (Resv) message, it will be appreciated that other RSVP signaling messages may be communicated using similar processes.

At700, CE2102B receives an RSVP Resv message. The Resv message may have originated from a host (e.g., HOST2110B) that CE2102B is servicing and is addressed to a receiving device (e.g., CE2102B). RSVP Resv messages travel hop by hop, so they are addressed to the RSVP Previous Hop. CE2102B processes the Resv message (block702) using RSVP procedures and forwards the Resv message upstream toward the sender (block704) along the link CE2-PE2. PE2104B receives the Resv message (block706), processes the Resv message (block708), and forwards the Resv message again upstream toward the sender across the provider core network to the RSVP Previous Hop, PE104A (block710). PE1104A in turn receives the Resv message (block712), processes the Resv message (block714), and forwards the Resv message toward the RSVP Previous Hop (block716) along the link PE1-CE1. Then, CE1102A receives the Resv message (block718), processes the Resv message using RSVP procedures (block720), and forwards the Resv message to the RSVP Previous Hop (e.g., sender) (block722).

FIG. 8is a flow diagram, in accordance with an example embodiment, illustrating a method708of processing a Resv message at an egress PE. In general, when a Resv message arrives at the egress PE (e.g., PE2104B) the PE establishes a suitable Resv message and forwards the Resv message to the ingress PE (e.g., PE1104A).

When a host at the customer site (e.g., HOST2110B) originates a Resv message for the session, RSVP procedures apply until the Resv, making its way back towards the sender host (e.g., HOST1110A), arrives at the “egress” PE (it is “egress” with respect to the direction of data flow). At800, the corresponding path state is determined. In an example embodiment, on arriving at PE2104B, the SESSION and FILTER objects in the Resv, and the VRF in which the Resv was received, are used to find the matching path state stored previously. At802, admission control is performed on the CE2-PE2link. At804, if admission control is successful, a Resv message is constructed. The Resv message is addressed to the ingress PE (e.g., PE1104A) and includes the VRF_ID object that was obtained from the Path message as described above. The Resv message is addressed to the ingress PE and sent. At806, if admission control is not successful, a ResvError message is sent towards the receiver using RSVP processing.

FIG. 9is a flow diagram, in accordance with an example embodiment, illustrating a method714of processing a Resv message at an ingress PE. At900, the ingress PE (e.g., PE1104A) extracts the VRF_ID object and uses the VRF_ID object to determine which VRF the session is associated with. At902, a corresponding path state is determined. At904, a Resv message is constructed. In an example embodiment, the ingress PE does not perform admission control over the provider's backbone for this reservation.

Other types of RSVP messages are processed in a similar manner as that described above. For example, processing of RSVP messages PathError, PathTear, ResvTear, ResvErr, and ResvConfirm may include the ingress PE's VRF identification, the VPN label, and be directly addressed to the appropriate PE, removing the need for the Router Alert IP option.

In an example embodiment, admission control over the provider's backbone may be implemented in conjunction with other aspects described herein. For example, in an example embodiment, aggregate reservations may be used to achieve a form of admission control across provider routers. In another embodiment, an MPLS traffic engineering (TE) tunnel from an ingress PE to an egress PE may be constructed and used as a means to perform aggregate admission control in the backbone.

The example computer system1000includes a processor1002(e.g., a central processing unit (CPU), a graphics processing unit (GPU) or both), a main memory1004and a static memory1006, which communicate with each other via a bus1008. The computer system1000may further include a video display unit1010(e.g., a plasma display, a liquid crystal display (LCD) or a cathode ray tube (CRT)). The computer system1000also includes an alphanumeric input device1012(e.g., a keyboard), a user interface (UI) navigation device1014(e.g., a mouse), a disk drive unit1016, a signal generation device1018(e.g., a speaker) and a network interface device1020.

The disk drive unit1016may include machine-readable medium1022on which is stored one or more sets of instructions and data structures (e.g., software1024) embodying or utilized by any one or more of the methodologies or functions described herein. The software1024may also reside, completely or at least partially, within the main memory1004and/or within the processor1002during execution thereof by the computer system1000, where the main memory1004and the processor1002also constitute machine-readable, tangible media.

Software1024may further be transmitted or received over network1026via network interface device1020utilizing any one of a number of well-known transfer protocols (e.g., HTTP).

Although an embodiment has been described with reference to specific example embodiments, it will be evident that various modifications and changes may be made to these embodiments without departing from the broader spirit and scope of the invention. Accordingly, the specification and drawings are to be regarded in an illustrative rather than a restrictive sense. This disclosure is intended to cover any and all adaptations or variations of various embodiments. Combinations of the above embodiments, and other embodiments not specifically described herein, will be apparent to those of skill in the art upon reviewing the above description. For example, one functional, computational, or hardware module may be implemented as multiple logical modules, or several modules may be implemented as a single logical module. As another example, modules labeled as “first,” “second,” and “third,” etc., may be implemented in a single module, or in some combination of modules, as would be understood by one of ordinary skill in the art.

In the appended claims, the terms “including” and “in which” are used as the plain-English equivalents of the respective terms “comprising” and “wherein,” respectively. Also, in the following claims, the terms “including” and “comprising” are open-ended, that is, a system, device, article, or process that includes elements in addition to those listed after such a term in a claim are still deemed to fall within the scope of that claim. Moreover, in the following claims, the terms “first,” “second,” and “third,” etc. are used merely as labels, and are not intended to impose numerical requirements or a particular ordering on their objects.