Replaceable item authentication

A replaceable item for a host device includes a non-volatile memory and logic. The non-volatile memory stores passwords or authentication values, and/or a cryptographic key. The logic permits retrieval of a predetermined maximum number of the passwords from the non-volatile memory to authenticate the replaceable item within the host device. The predetermined maximum number of the passwords is less than the total number of the passwords.

BACKGROUND

Devices that use replaceable items include printing devices, including stand-alone printers, copy machines, and all-in-one (AIO) devices that can perform multiple functions, such as printing, copying, scanning, and/or faxing. Example replaceable items for such printing devices include ink, toner, and/or other types of colorant, including two-dimensional (2D) colorant. Other example replacement items, specifically for three-dimensional (3D) printing devices, include 3D printing agent and 3D printing build material.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION

As noted in the background, devices that use replaceable items include printing devices. A supply of print substance, such as colorant or another type of print substance, is stored in a cartridge that can be inserted into a printing device. When the supply becomes depleted, the cartridge can be replaced with a cartridge having a fresh supply of the print substance in question. Cartridges having different types of print substances can also be switched out as desired. As an example, a cartridge having general-purpose ink may be switched out for a cartridge having photo-quality ink within an inkjet-printing device as desired.

Manufacturers of printing devices also typically make or otherwise supply the print substance used in the printing devices. From the end user's perspective, using manufacturer-supplied or manufacturer-approved print substance cartridges can facilitate desired output by the printing devices and/or inhibit damage to the printing devices. For the original equipment manufacturer (OEM) it may be difficult to guarantee printing device output or printing device functioning if the printing device uses third party cartridges. A third party print substance is beyond the control of the OEM. For example, it could provide for different print output or entail a patenting risk of shortening the life of the print device. In some instances, such as 3D printers, there might even be a safety risk to a user when a print substance is a non-approved print substance. In certain instances, usage of non-approved print substance may affect a warranty associated with the printing device.

Manufacturers may therefore instill cartridges with authentication security. A printing device may interrogate the cartridge to determine if it is authentic. If the cartridge is not authentic (e.g., is not OEM approved), then the printing device may initiate a certain procedure, such as, for instance, informing the end user, such as immediately or soon after installation.

Techniques disclosed herein provide a novel, innovative authentication scheme for a print substance cartridge for a printing device, and more generally for a replaceable item for a (host) device in which the item can be installed (i.e., more generally, the device to which the item can be connected). The print substance cartridge stores a number of authentication values, or passwords. The cartridge includes logic (such as circuitry like a processor and memory storing code that the processor executes) to permit retrieval of just a subset of these authentication values. As different authentication values are requested from the cartridge, the cartridge can track the number of different values that have been returned. Once the cartridge has provided the maximum number of such unique authentication values, it will not provide any of the other authentication values that were originally stored in the cartridge. The cartridge continues to provide the previous authentication values that had been requested and returned, however.

As an example, a print substance cartridge may store sixty-four different passwords, or authentication values. Of these sixty-four, the cartridge may output no more than sixteen of the different passwords. Once the cartridge has provided sixteen different passwords, it will not provide any of the other forty-eight passwords that were stored in the cartridge. The cartridge can continue to respond to requests for the sixteen different passwords that it has already provided, however.

The print substance cartridge can also store hash values of the authentication values, or passwords. The hash values provide a way to determine whether a given authentication value that the cartridge has provided is correct. The cartridge may provide the hash values of the authentication values upon request, even for the values that the cartridge will not output. In the example of the previous paragraph, for instance, the cartridge can provide the hash values for all sixty-four passwords, even though the cartridge will provide no more than sixteen of the sixty-four passwords.

An authentication scheme using such a print substance cartridge may include a host printing device that might request four different passwords, or authentication values, stored in the cartridge. Different printing devices may and likely will request different passwords from a given cartridge. Similarly, a given printing device may and likely will request different passwords from different cartridges.

Having a print substance cartridge return a lesser number of authentication values than the total number of authentication values originally stored in the cartridge makes it much more difficult for a third party to frustrate such an authentication scheme. Even if a third party overcomes other security measures to obtain the sixteen authentication values that the cartridge will “give up,” or output or provide, the likelihood that a third party cartridge storing just these sixteen values will be authenticated by a printing device is low. In the example authentication scheme that has been presented above, the printing device may and will likely request at least one authentication value that is not one of the sixteen values that the third party cartridge shares, rendering it unlikely that any given printing device will successfully authenticate such a cartridge.

FIG. 1shows an example print substance cartridge100for a printing device. The cartridge100includes a print substance supply102. The cartridge100may contain any volume of print substance, such as from several milliliters to tens of liters. Different examples of print substance include ink for an inkjet-printing device, and liquid or powder toner for a laser-printing device. Such ink and toner are themselves examples of two-dimensional (2D) colorant, which is colorant used by a suitable printing device to form images on media like paper that minimally if at all extend in a third dimension perpendicular to the two dimensions defining the plane of the surface of the media on which the images have been formed. Other examples of print substance include three-dimensional (3D) printing agent and 3D printing build material, which are used by a suitable 3D printing device to form a 3D object that is typically removable from any substrate on which the object is constructed. Certain print substances, such as ink, may be used for both 2D and 3D printing.

The print substance cartridge100includes logic104. The logic104can be implemented as circuitry within the cartridge100. For example, the logic104can include a processor, and a non-volatile computer-readable data storage medium storing computer-executable code that the processor executes. In this respect, then, in one implementation, the logic104may include a microprocessor and embedded software stored on the microprocessor itself, where the non-volatile computer-readable data storage medium is integrated within the microprocessor. In another implementation, the logic104may include a microprocessor and software embedded within a non-volatile medium separate from the microprocessor.

As another example, the logic104can be or include an application-specific integrated circuit (ASIC) or a field-programmable gate array (FPGA). More generally in this respect, the logic104can be implemented using logic gates. As a third example, the logic104may be implemented as any combination of a processor, software stored within the processor or on a medium separate to the processor, and logic gates.

The print substance cartridge100includes non-volatile memory106. The memory106can be semiconductor memory, and is non-volatile in that when power is removed from the cartridge100, the memory106still retains its contents. The memory106stores passwords108, which are also referred to as authentication values herein. The memory106can store hash values110of, and which can individually correspond to, the passwords108. The memory106can store a cryptographic key112from which the passwords108are able to be generated.

The memory106stores a number of the passwords108, which is referred to as the total number of passwords108. The passwords108, or authentication values, are stored by the cartridge100so that the cartridge100can prove to a host printing device that it is authentic. Stated another way, the passwords108are used to authenticate the cartridge100within the printing device. The passwords108can be secured in an encrypted cryptographic manner, so that the passwords108are essentially irretrievable from the cartridge100outside of the approaches described herein. The passwords108can each be a series of bits, such as 256 bits.

The memory106can store one hash value110for each password108. The hash values110are stored by the cartridge100so that the cartridge100can prove to a host printing device that the passwords108are correct. Stated another way, the hash values110are used to verify the passwords108provided by the cartridge100within the printing device. The hash values110may not be cryptographically secured in that they are freely retrievable from the cartridge100, but may be cryptographically secured in that the hash values110cannot be modified. The hash values110may be one-way hash values110of the passwords108, which means that a password108cannot be determined just by knowing its corresponding hash value110, even if the one-way hash function used to generate the hash value110from the password108is known.

The hash values110can be provided by the cartridge100in one implementation in a way so that a host device is able to validate the hash values110as having been generated by an entity (i.e., the manufacturer or supplier of the cartridge100) that the host device trusts. As one example, the hash values110may be cryptographically signed with a private cryptographic key prior to storage in the cartridge100. The host device may use a corresponding public cryptographic key to validate the hash values110. The private key may not be stored on the cartridge100, and is unavailable publicly.

The logic104permits retrieval of a predetermined maximum number of the passwords108, less than the total number of the passwords108stored in the non-volatile memory106. The logic104can permit the retrieval of this smaller number of the passwords108(i.e., the predetermined maximum number of the passwords108), however, an unlimited number of times from the memory106. By comparison, the logic104prohibits retrieval of any password108other than the predetermined maximum number of passwords, even one time, from the memory106.

Which of the passwords108are selected as the predetermined maximum number of the passwords108of which the logic104permits retrieval can be unspecified a priori. For example, as any host printing device in which the cartridge100is currently installed or otherwise to which the cartridge100is connected requests particular passwords108, the logic104may return the requested passwords108until the predetermined maximum number has been reached. Thereafter, the logic104will just return passwords108that have already been requested, and not return any of the other passwords108, once the predetermined number of the passwords108has been selected. Stated another way, the logic104can select the particular predetermined maximum number of the passwords108as any host printing device requests them, until the maximum number has been reached.

As an example, the non-volatile memory106may store sixteen passwords108, numbered one through sixteen, and the logic104may return just four of these passwords108. The cartridge100may be inserted into a first host printing device, which may request and receive passwords having numbers one and thirteen. Therefore, the logic104has effectively selected two of the four passwords108that the cartridge100will reveal, those numbered one and thirteen. The cartridge may then be removed from this host printing device, and inserted into another host printing device that requests and receives passwords having numbers six and thirteen. Therefore, the logic104has now effectively selected three of the four passwords108that the cartridge100will reveal, those numbered one, six, and thirteen.

The cartridge may be removed from the host printing device in which it is currently installed and inserted into a third host printing device, which may request and receive passwords having numbers seven and thirteen. Therefore, the logic104has now effectively selected all four of the four passwords108that the cartridge100will reveal, those numbered one, six, seven, and thirteen. The logic104may continue to return these four passwords108, but will not return any other password108. That is, the logic104will not return any password108unless it has a number of one, six, seven, or thirteen.

The non-volatile memory106used for the storage of the passwords108can be a write-once, read-limited memory. The passwords108are written to the memory106just once, such as during a secure manufacturing process. A predetermined maximum number of the total number of the passwords108can be read an unlimited number of times. The passwords108other than this predetermined maximum number become unreadable once the predetermined maximum number of the passwords108has been specifically selected. Each password108thus may be retrievable an unlimited number of times or may be irretrievable, but the logic104does not determine ahead of time which passwords108are which.

Therefore, the passwords108other than the predetermined maximum number of the passwords108are at least functionally erased once the predetermined maximum number of the passwords108have been specifically selected. They may be completely and indelibly erased from the memory108by the logic104, for instance, in a manner so that “unerasing” or the recovery of the erased passwords108is considered impossible. The passwords108in question may be functionally erased in that these passwords108remain stored in the memory108, but are irretrievable. For example, fuse links to the physical parts of the memory108where the passwords108in question are stored may be severed, rendering the passwords108irretrievable and thus functionally erased even though in actuality the passwords108remain in memory.

The memory106can store the cryptographic key112in lieu of the passwords108when the cartridge100is manufactured. In this implementation, prior to first usage of the cartridge100, no passwords108may be stored in the cartridge108. Rather, when a password108is requested, the cartridge100generates the password108“on the fly,” if the predetermined maximum number of unique passwords108has not yet been generated and provided by the cartridge100. Once the predetermined maximum number of unique passwords108has been generated, the cryptographic key112may be at least functionally erased, in the manner described in the previous paragraph.

FIG. 2shows an example method200that a replaceable item for a device, such as the print substance cartridge100for a printing device, can perform. The method200can be implemented as computer-readable code stored on a non-transitory computer-readable data storage medium and that a processor executes. As such, the logic104of the cartridge100can perform the method200, for example. The replaceable item performs the method200once it has been installed in a host device.

The replaceable item receives a request from the host device for a particular authentication value of a number of authentication values that the item may store (202). The request may be signed with a digital cryptographic key, or may be secured in another manner. The replaceable item determines whether it has previously sent the authentication value in question to any host device (203), including the host device in which the item is currently installed, as well as any other host device. If the replaceable item has previously sent the requested authentication value (204), the item returns the requested value to the host device (206).

However, if the replaceable item has not previously sent the requested authentication value (206), the item determines whether it has already sent the maximum number of unique authentication values (208). For example, of sixty-four authentication values that the replaceable item may store, the item may send no more than sixteen of these values. If the replacement item has already sent the maximum number of unique authentication values (210), the item does not send the authentication value that the host device in which the item is installed has requested (212).

However, if the replaceable item has not yet sent the maximum number of unique authentication values, then the item sends the requested authentication value to the host device (214). The replaceable item then can again determine whether the maximum number of authentication values has now been sent (216), including the authentication value that the item just sent in part214. For example, if the item is permitted to send just sixteen of its sixty-four authentication values, if fifteen values were sent prior to performance of part214, then a different, sixteenth authentication value is sent in part214, such that the maximum number of sixteen different authentication values has now been sent.

If the maximum number of unique authentication values has now been sent (218), then the replaceable item can at least functionally erase the authentication values that it stores and that have not been sent (220). As such, in the ongoing example, once sixteen different authentication values have been sent, the other forty-eight authentication values are erased. Note that each time the method200ofFIG. 2is performed, then, the replaceable item can send any authentication value that it sent previously, and can send any authentication value that it has not sent previously so long as the maximum number of different authentication values that the item will send has not yet been reached.

From parts206,212, and220, and from part218when the maximum number of unique sent authentication values has not yet been reached, or as an entry point to the method200, the replaceable item can receive from the host device a request for one or more hash values corresponding to one or more authentication values (222). For example, the replaceable item may receive a request for all the hash values corresponding to all the authentication values, for just one of the hash values corresponding to just one of the authentication values, and so on. The replaceable item may receive a request for one or more hash values even after the authentication values that have never been sent are erased in part220, after the maximum number of unique authentication values that the item will send has been reached in part218. That is, the replaceable item may not erase the hash values for the authentication values that it erases, for instance. Part222can be considered as an entry point to the method200in that the request for the hash values can be received prior to receipt of a request for an authentication value.

FIG. 3shows an example method300that is an example of a particular implementation of parts202through part220of the method200. Identically numbered parts inFIGS. 2 and 3are performed in the method300at least substantially as described above in relation to the method200. Numbers in parentheses indicate that a given part of the method300is implementing a corresponding part of the method200. That is, Y(X) inFIG. 3means that part Y of the method300is implementing part X of the method200.

InFIG. 3, the authentication values can have identifiers, such as corresponding unique identifiers, which may also be referred to as addresses. For example, if the replaceable item stores sixty-four authentication values, the identifiers may be one, two, three, and so on, through sixty-four. The replaceable item receives a request from the host device in which it is installed for an authentication value by identifier (302). For example, the host device may request the authentication value having the identifier ABCD, may request the sixth authentication value, such that the identifier of the requested authentication value is six, and so on.

InFIG. 3, the replaceable item can have two tables. The first table has a number of entries equal to the maximum number of different authentication values that the replaceable item will return to any host device. When the replaceable item has not yet been used in any host device, the entries may all be empty. That is, the entries of the first table are initially empty. The first table stores at least the identifiers of the authentication values that the replaceable item has sent to any host device. The first table may also store the authentication values themselves. The replaceable item can store the first table in a cryptographically secure manner.

The second table has a number of entries equal to the number of authentication values that the replaceable item stores, such as before the replaceable item has yet to be used in any host device. Each entry includes at least an authentication value. Each entry may further store the identifier of the authentication value. If the identifiers are not stored in the second table, then they may be determinable by reference. For example, if there are sixty-four entries, the first entry can store the authentication value with the lowest identifier, the second entry can store the authentication value with the identifier equal to the lowest identifier plus an increment value, and the third entry can store the authentication value with the identifier equal to the lowest identifier plus two times the increment value, and so on. The sixty-fourth entry thus can store the authentication value having the identifier equal to the lowest identifier plus sixty three times the increment value. If the lowest identifier is BASE, and the increment value is INC, the identifier of the n-th authentication value, where n is a value from one (the first authentication value) to N (the last authentication value) is BASE+INC×(n−1).

The replaceable item thus looks up the requested identifier within the first table (303). That is, if the replaceable item received a request from the host device in part302for the authentication value having a given identifier, the replaceable item looks up the given identifier within the first table. If the replaceable item received a request in part302for the fifth authentication value, the identifier of this authentication value may be five, or may be determined as described above, which the item then looks up within the first table. If the requested identifier is within the first table, then this means that replaceable item previously sent the authentication value having this identifier. If the requested identifier is not within the first table, then this means that the item has not previously sent the authentication value having this identifier.

If the identifier is within the first table, then the replaceable item sends the authentication value having this identifier (206). For instance, if the first table stores authentication values as well as their identifiers, then the replaceable item can retrieve the authentication value in question from the first table. If the first table just stores identifiers and not the authentication values themselves, then the replaceable item can retrieve the authentication value having the identifier in question from the second table to return to the host device.

If the identifier is not within the first table, then the replaceable item determines whether there are any empty entries within the first table (306). If there are empty entries within the first table, then this means that the replaceable item has not yet sent the maximum number of different authentication values. If there are no empty entries within the first table, then this means that the replaceable item has already sent the maximum number of different authentication values. Therefore, if there are no empty entries (308), the replaceable item refuses to send the requested authentication value (212).

However, if there are empty entries within the first table (308), then the replaceable item retrieves the authentication value having the requested identifier from the second table (310). The item locates an empty identifier within the first table (312), and stores at least the identifier of the retrieved authentication value within this empty entry (314). For instance, the item can store the authentication value within the entry as well as this value's identifier. The replaceable item then sends the authentication value back to the host device that requested the value (214).

The replaceable item next determines whether the first table now has any empty entries (316). If there are no more empty entries after the empty entry located in part312was filled in part314, then this means that the maximum number of different authentication values that the replaceable item can provide has been reached. If there is still at least one empty entry in the first table after the empty entry located in part312was filled in part314, then this means that the maximum number of different authentication values that the replaceable item can provide has not yet been reached. Therefore, if there are any empty entries left in the first table (318), the method300is finished (320).

If there are not any empty entries left in the first table (318), then the replaceable item erases authentication values from the second table (220). The replaceable item may erase from the second table just the authentication values that it has not provided, which are those authentication values having identifiers that are not stored in the first table. If the first table stores both identifiers and authentication values, as opposed to just identifiers, then the replaceable item may erase all the authentication values from the second table. For instance, the replaceable item may delete the second table entirely. The replaceable item can erase the second table because the item stores the authentication values that it will still return responsive to proper requests from host devices in the first table. In another implementation, the replaceable item responds to requests for authentication values from the first table, and if an authentication value requested is not stored in the first table, is able to retrieve the value from the second table for storage in the first table just if there is an available empty entry in the first table in which to store the requested value.

FIG. 4shows an example method400that is another example of a particular implementation of parts202through220of the method200. Identically numbered parts inFIGS. 2 and 4are performed in the method400at least as has been described in relation to the method200. Numbers in parentheses indicate that a given part of the method400is implementing a corresponding part of the method200. That is, Y(X) inFIG. 4means that part Y of the method400is implementing part X of the method200.

The replaceable item receives a request for an authentication value from the host device in which it is installed (202). The replaceable item determines whether the authentication value was previously sent (203). If the authentication value was previously sent (204), then the replaceable item sends the authentication value that has been requested back to the host device (206).

The replaceable item maintains a counter of the number of unique authentication values that the item has provided to any host device in the implementation ofFIG. 4. The counter can be an increment-only counter, which can be increased and not decreased. The counter is stored in non-volatile memory, such as the non-volatile memory106, and can be cryptographically secured.

The replaceable item determines whether the counter is equal to the maximum number of unique authentication values that the item will provide to any host device if properly requested (402). If the counter is equal to this maximum number of unique authentication values, then this means that the replaceable item has already provided the maximum number of different authentication values that it will provide to any host device. Therefore, if the counter is equal to the maximum number of unique authentication values (404), then the replaceable item does not send the requested authentication value to the host device (212).

If the counter is not equal to the maximum number of unique authentication values (i.e., the counter is less than this number), then this means that the replaceable item has not yet provided the maximum number of different authentication values that it will provide to any host device. Therefore, the replaceable item sends the requested authentication value back to the host device (214). The replaceable item also increments the counter (406).

The replaceable item determines whether the counter is now equal to the maximum number of unique authentication values that it will provide to any host device (408). If the counter is not yet equal to the maximum number of unique authentication values (410), then the method400is finished (412). However, if the counter is now equal to this number (410), then this means that the replaceable item has now sent the maximum number of different authentication values that it will provide, and as such, can erase the authentication values that have not been provided or sent to any host device (220).

FIG. 5shows an example method500that is a third example of a particular implementation of parts202through220of the method200. Identically numbered parts inFIGS. 2 and 5are performed in the method500at least as has been described in relation to the method200. Numbers in parentheses indicate that a given part of the method500is implementing a corresponding part of the method200. That is, Y(X) inFIG. 5means that part Y of the method500is implementing part X of the method200.

The replaceable item receives a request for an authentication value from the host device in which it is installed (202). The replaceable item determines whether the authentication value was previously sent (203). If the authentication value was previously sent to any host device (204), then the replaceable item sends the authentication value back to the host device in which it is installed (206).

The replaceable item maintains a flag corresponding to whether the item has provided the maximum number of unique authentication values to any host device in the implementation ofFIG. 5. The flag can be a settable-only flag, which can be set but which cannot be cleared. The flag is stored in non-volatile memory, such as the non-volatile memory106, and can be cryptographically secured.

The replaceable item determines whether the flag has been set (502). If the flag has been set, this means that the replaceable item has already provided the maximum number of different authentication values that it will provide to any host device. Therefore, if the flag is set (504), then the replaceable item does not send the requested authentication value to the host device (212). If the flag is not set, then this means that the replaceable item has not yet provided the maximum number of different authentication values that it will provide to any host. Therefore, the replaceable item sends the requested authentication value back to the host device (214).

The replaceable item determines whether the maximum number of unique authentication values has now been sent (216). If the maximum number of different authentication values has still not been sent (218), then the method500is finished. However, if the maximum number of different authentication values has now been sent (218), then the replaceable item sets the flag (508), and can erase the authentication values that have not yet been provided or sent to any host device (220).

In a different implementation, the flag is set prior to sending the authentication value. That is, in this implementation, it is determined whether the maximum number of authentications will have now been sent with the sending of an authentication value, and if so, then the flag is set, and after the flag has been set, the authentication value is sent. The authentication values that will not have been sent can also be erased in this implementation prior to sending the authentication value in question. More generally, any action that is performed due to the sending of the last unique authentication value that will be provided by the replaceable item, such as incrementing a counter, setting a flag, storing a value in a table, and so on, can be performed prior to sending this last unique authentication value. It is noted in this respect that, more generally still, any such action that is performed in conjunction with sending an authentication value (and not the last authentication value) can be performed prior to the authentication value actually being sent.

FIG. 6shows an example method600that is a fourth example of a particular implementation of parts202through220of the method200. Identically numbered parts inFIGS. 2 and 6are performed in the method600at least as has been described in relation to the method200. Numbers in parentheses indicate that a given part of the method600is implementing a corresponding part of the method200. That is, Y(X) inFIG. 6means that part Y of the method600is implementing part X of the method200.

The replaceable item receives a request for an authentication value from a host device (202). The replaceable item determines whether the authentication value was previously sent (203). If the authentication value was previously sent to any host device (204), then the replaceable item sends the authentication value back to the requesting host device (206).

If the replaceable item has not previously sent the requested authentication value (206), then the item determines whether it has already sent the maximum number of unique authentication values (208). If the replacement item has already sent the maximum number of unique authentication values (210), then the item does not send the authentication value that the host device in question has requested (212). The method600is thus finished.

However, if the replaceable item has not yet sent the maximum number of unique authentication values (210), then the item generates the authentication value from a cryptographic key (602), such as the cryptographic key112of the print substance cartridge100ofFIG. 1. In the implementation ofFIG. 6, then, the passwords108may not be generated and a priori stored in the cartridge100at the time of manufacture of the cartridge100. A never-used print cartridge100may not have any passwords108stored therein, but rather just stores the cryptographic key112from which the passwords108are able to be generated. The replaceable item thus sends the authentication value that has been requested and that the item has just generated to the host device (214). In this respect, it is noted that the implementation ofFIG. 6can be employed in conjunction with at least a portion of the implementation ofFIG. 3, in which sent values are stored in a first table. As such, once the authentication value has been generated, it can be stored in the first table, so that the value does not have to be regenerated later, and if or when the cryptographic key is at least functionally erased, the authentication value can still be returned.

The replaceable item can again determine whether the maximum number of authentication values has now been sent (216), including the authentication value that the item just sent in part214. If the maximum number of authentication values has not yet been sent (218), then the method600is finished. However, if the maximum number of authentication values has now been sent (218), then the replaceable item can at least functionally erase the cryptographic key (606), so that additional authentication values cannot be generated. The cryptographic key may be at least functionally erased once the authentication value has been generated in part602, and prior to actually sending the authentication value in part214in one implementation.

The different implementations of parts of the method200that have been described in relation to the methods300,400,500, and600can be combined or modified in different ways. For example, just the first table of the method300may be employed. One or more tables of the method300can be employed in conjunction with the counter of the method400and/or the flag of the method500. The counter of the method400can be used in conjunction with the flag of the method500without either table of the method300as well. The first table of the method300, the counter of the method400, and/or the flag of the method500can be used in conjunction with the approach of the method600.

The techniques disclosed herein may improve, or provide for another scheme for, cryptographic security of a replaceable item for a device, such as a print supply cartridge for a printing device. A replaceable item provides a limited number of the authorization values, or passwords, it stores. Once the maximum number of different authorization values has been provided, requests for the other authorization values will not be honored, even if they remain stored in the replaceable item. Such an approach may decrease the likelihood that a third party attempting to retrieve all the authorization values from the replaceable item will succeed. Furthermore, the likelihood that possession of just the maximum number of unique authorization values will result in successful authentication is very low.