Appeal type: Experimental/Investigational
Decision: Overturned

Digestive System/Gastrointestinal - Other
Surgical Services
This  female patient has dysphagia due to type I achalasia documented endoscopically, on imaging as well as on esophageal manometry. Therefore, the attending gastroenterologist would like to refer the patient for peroral endoscopic myotomy (POEM) to treat her achalasia. The subject under review is whether POEM is likely to be more beneficial for this patient for her condition than any standard treatment.

The health plan's determination is upheld.

No, the proposed health service or treatment POEM is not likely to be more beneficial than any standard treatment or treatments for the insured's life threatening or disabling condition or disease.
Achalasia is a primary disorder of esophageal motility and typically presents with dysphagia to both solids and liquids but may be accompanied by regurgitation and chest pain. The gold standard for the diagnosis of achalasia is esophageal motility testing with manometry, which often reveals aperistalsis of the esophageal body and incomplete lower esophageal sphincter relaxation. The diagnosis is aided by complimentary tests, such as esophagogastroduodenoscopy and contrast radiography. Esophagogastroduodenoscopy is indicated to rule out mimickers of the disease known as "pseudoachalasia" (e.g., malignancy). Endoscopic appearance of a dilated esophagus with retained food or saliva and a puckered lower esophageal sphincter should raise suspicion for achalasia. Additionally, barium esophagography may reveal a dilated esophagus with a distal tapering giving it a "bird's beak" appearance. Several therapeutic modalities aid in the management of achalasia, the decision of which depends on operative risk factors. Conventional treatments include medical therapy, botulinum toxin injection, pneumatic dilation, and Heller myotomy. Dilation and myotomy are the most definitive treatment options. New emerging therapies include peroral endoscopic myotomy, placement of self-expanding metallic stents, and endoscopic sclerotherapy. Peroral endoscopic myotomy (POEM), a minimally invasive endoscopic technique, is one of the most recent advances in the treatment of achalasia. POEM is conceptually similar to a surgical myotomy without the inherent external incisions and post-operative care associated with surgery. Several studies have established the short term safety and efficacy of POEM. Serious adverse events are rare with POEM. They occur at a rate of less than (<) 0.1% with the most common serious event being perforation. Another, albeit less serious, complication following POEM is gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD). In carefully selected patients, some studies have shown short-term postoperative clinical symptoms of GERD following POEM is 10.9%, comparable to that of Laparoscopic Cardiomyotomy. A study by Li and colleagues which followed over 500 patients who had the POEM procedure over 49 months showed that POEM is a highly safe and effective treatment for esophageal achalasia with favorable long-term outcomes. However, there are no data regarding the long term efficacy of the procedure (beyond 5 or 10 years) as opposed to a conventional or laparoscopic Heller myotomy. According to current American Gastroenterological Association guidance, POEM to be the preferred treatment option in type III achalasia when a longer myotomy is indicated. For other achalasia syndromes, POEM should be considered as a treatment option of comparable efficacy to laparoscopic Heller myotomy, albeit with no long-term outcomes data and minimal controlled outcomes data currently available.