Exploring optimal granularity for extractive summarization of unstructured health records: Analysis of the largest multi-institutional archive of health records in Japan
Authors: Kenichiro Ando, Takashi Okumura, Mamoru Komachi, Hiromasa Horiguchi, Yuji Matsumoto
Journal: PLOS Digital Health
Accepted: 2022-07-28T00:00:00Z


Automated summarization of clinical texts can reduce the burden of medical professionals. “Discharge summaries” are one promising application of the summarization, because they can be generated from daily inpatient records. Our preliminary experiment suggests that 20–31% of the descriptions in discharge summaries overlap with the content of the inpatient records. However, it remains unclear how the summaries should be generated from the unstructured source. To decompose the physician’s summarization process, this study aimed to identify the optimal granularity in summarization. We first defined three types of summarization units with different granularities to compare the performance of the discharge summary generation: whole sentences, clinical segments, and clauses. We defined clinical segments in this study, aiming to express the smallest medically meaningful concepts. To obtain the clinical segments, it was necessary to automatically split the texts in the first stage of the pipeline. Accordingly, we compared rule-based methods and a machine learning method, and the latter outperformed the formers with an F1 score of 0.846 in the splitting task. Next, we experimentally measured the accuracy of extractive summarization using the three types of units, based on the ROUGE-1 metric, on a multi-institutional national archive of health records in Japan. The measured accuracies of extractive summarization using whole sentences, clinical segments, and clauses were 31.91, 36.15, and 25.18, respectively. We found that the clinical segments yielded higher accuracy than sentences and clauses. This result indicates that summarization of inpatient records demands finer granularity than sentence-oriented processing. Although we used only Japanese health records, it can be interpreted as follows: physicians extract “concepts of medical significance” from patient records and recombine them in new contexts when summarizing chronological clinical records, rather than simply copying and pasting topic sentences. This observation suggests that a discharge summary is created by higher-order information processing over concepts on sub-sentence level, which may guide future research in this field.
Author summary: Medical practice includes significant paperwork, and therefore, automated processing of clinical texts can reduce medical professionals’ burden. Accordingly, we focused on hospitals’ discharge summaries from daily inpatient records stored in Electric Health Records. By applying summarization technologies, which are well-studied in Natural Language Processing, discharge summaries could be generated automatically from the source texts. However, automated summarization of daily inpatient records involves various technical topics and challenges, and the generation of discharge summaries is a complex process of mixing extractive and abstractive summarization. Thus, in this study, we explored optimal granularity for extractive summarization, attempting to decompose actual physicians’ processing. In the experiments, we used three types of summarization units with different granularities to compare performances of discharge summary generation: whole sentences, clinical segments, and clauses. We originally defined clinical segments, aiming to express the smallest medically meaningful concepts. The result indicated that sub-sentence processing, larger than clauses, improves the quality of the summaries. This finding can guide future development of medical documents’ automated summarization.