Benefit of stereoscopic volume rendering for the identification of pediatric pulmonary vein stenosis from CT angiography
Authors: Michelle Noga, Jiali Luan, Deepa Krishnaswamy, Brendan Morgan, Ross Cockburn, Kumaradevan Punithakumar
Journal: PLOS Digital Health
Accepted: 2023-02-10T00:00:00Z


The use of three-dimensional (3D) technologies in medical practice is increasing; however, its use is largely untested. One 3D technology, stereoscopic volume-rendered 3D display, can improve depth perception. Pulmonary vein stenosis (PVS) is a rare cardiovascular pathology, often diagnosed by computed tomography (CT), where volume rendering may be useful. Depth cues may be lost when volume rendered CT is displayed on regular screens instead of 3D displays. The objective of this study was to determine whether the 3D stereoscopic display of volume-rendered CT improved perception compared to standard monoscopic display, as measured by PVS diagnosis. CT angiograms (CTAs) from 18 pediatric patients aged 3 weeks to 2 years were volume rendered and displayed with and without stereoscopic display. Patients had 0 to 4 pulmonary vein stenoses. Participants viewed the CTAs in 2 groups with half on monoscopic and half on stereoscopic display and the converse a minimum of 2 weeks later, and their diagnoses were recorded. A total of 24 study participants, comprised of experienced staff cardiologists, cardiovascular surgeons and radiologists, and their trainees viewed the CTAs and assessed the presence and location of PVS. Cases were classified as simple (2 or fewer lesions) or complex (3 or more lesions). Overall, there were fewer type 2 errors in diagnosis for stereoscopic display than standard display, an insignificant difference (p = 0.095). There was a significant decrease in type 2 errors for complex multiple lesion cases (≥3) vs simpler cases (p = 0.027) and improvement in localization of pulmonary veins (p = 0.011). Subjectively, 70% of participants stated that stereoscopy was helpful in the identification of PVS. The stereoscopic display did not result in significantly decreased errors in PVS diagnosis but was helpful for more complex cases.
Author summary: There has been a tremendous increase in three-dimensional (3D) technology in the non-medical and more recently, medical communities. Computed tomography (CT) imaging is widely used and easy to translate into 3D technology such as printing and virtual reality. Although there are numerous publications about the use of 3D printing and its applications, there is still relatively little information about virtual reality displays and their usefulness in medical practice. Pulmonary vein stenosis (PVS) is an uncommon condition with significant morbidity in children that is frequently diagnosed with CT. Using our homegrown stereoscopic display system for 3D imaging data, we displayed the 3D CT images for PVS. We tested 24 physicians and compared their diagnostic accuracy for PVS for 3D stereoscopic display vs. conventional monoscopic flat screen display. Our study found that overall, there was no significant difference between the two forms of display for diagnostic accuracy when viewing the entire group of cases, however, for complex cases, there was an improvement when using 3D stereoscopic display.