Modeling the daily rhythm of human pain processing in the dorsal horn
Authors: Jennifer Crodelle, Sofia H Piltz, Megan Hastings Hagenauer, Victoria Booth
Journal: PLOS Computational Biology
Accepted: 2019-05-14T00:00:00Z


Experimental studies show that human pain sensitivity varies across the 24-hour day, with the lowest sensitivity usually occurring during the afternoon. Patients suffering from neuropathic pain, or nerve damage, experience an inversion in the daily modulation of pain sensitivity, with the highest sensitivity usually occurring during the early afternoon. Processing of painful stimulation occurs in the dorsal horn (DH), an area of the spinal cord that receives input from peripheral tissues via several types of primary afferent nerve fibers. The DH circuit is composed of different populations of neurons, including excitatory and inhibitory interneurons, and projection neurons, which constitute the majority of the output from the DH to the brain. In this work, we develop a mathematical model of the dorsal horn neural circuit to investigate mechanisms for the daily modulation of pain sensitivity. The model describes average firing rates of excitatory and inhibitory interneuron populations and projection neurons, whose activity is directly correlated with experienced pain. Response in afferent fibers to peripheral stimulation is simulated by a Poisson process generating nerve fiber spike trains at variable firing rates. Model parameters for fiber response to stimulation and the excitability properties of neuronal populations are constrained by experimental results found in the literature, leading to qualitative agreement between modeled responses to pain and experimental observations. We validate our model by reproducing the wind-up of pain response to repeated stimulation. We apply the model to investigate daily modulatory effects on pain inhibition, in which response to painful stimuli is reduced by subsequent non-painful stimuli. Finally, we use the model to propose a mechanism for the observed inversion of the daily rhythmicity of pain sensation under neuropathic pain conditions. Underlying mechanisms for the shift in rhythmicity have not been identified experimentally, but our model results predict that experimentally-observed dysregulation of inhibition within the DH neural circuit may be responsible. The model provides an accessible, biophysical framework that will be valuable for experimental and clinical investigations of diverse physiological processes modulating pain processing in humans.
Author summary: Human pain sensitivity follows a daily (∼24 hour) rhythm. In particular, humans experience the highest sensitivity to pain in the middle of night and lowest in the afternoon. Patients suffering from neuropathy, a disease resulting from nerve damage leading to an increase in pain sensitivity, experience an approximately 12-hour shift in their rhythmicity such that the highest sensitivity occurs in the afternoon. Neuropathy is a difficult condition to treat since it is often unfeasible to locate the damaged nerve and it is also unclear how this damage causes a shift in rhythmicity and an increase in pain. Understanding the mechanism underlying the shift in rhythmicity may lead to improvements in the knowledge of the transmission of pain from the damaged nerve to the pain-processing center in the spinal cord, and thus better treatment protocols. We have built a population-based model to describe this transmission with a particular focus on daily rhythms. We show that our model reproduces experimentally-observed rhythmicity of both normal pain responses, as well as neuropathic pain. Our model predicts that a potential mechanism underlying the shift in rhythmicity for neuropathic pain is a change in the interaction of the nerve fibers from inhibition to excitation.