Connectivity concepts in neuronal network modeling
Authors: Johanna Senk, Birgit Kriener, Mikael Djurfeldt, Nicole Voges, Han-Jia Jiang, Lisa Schüttler, Gabriele Gramelsberger, Markus Diesmann, Hans E Plesser, Sacha J van Albada
Journal: PLOS Computational Biology
Accepted: 2022-04-07T00:00:00Z


Sustainable research on computational models of neuronal networks requires published models to be understandable, reproducible, and extendable. Missing details or ambiguities about mathematical concepts and assumptions, algorithmic implementations, or parameterizations hinder progress. Such flaws are unfortunately frequent and one reason is a lack of readily applicable standards and tools for model description. Our work aims to advance complete and concise descriptions of network connectivity but also to guide the implementation of connection routines in simulation software and neuromorphic hardware systems. We first review models made available by the computational neuroscience community in the repositories ModelDB and Open Source Brain, and investigate the corresponding connectivity structures and their descriptions in both manuscript and code. The review comprises the connectivity of networks with diverse levels of neuroanatomical detail and exposes how connectivity is abstracted in existing description languages and simulator interfaces. We find that a substantial proportion of the published descriptions of connectivity is ambiguous. Based on this review, we derive a set of connectivity concepts for deterministically and probabilistically connected networks and also address networks embedded in metric space. Beside these mathematical and textual guidelines, we propose a unified graphical notation for network diagrams to facilitate an intuitive understanding of network properties. Examples of representative network models demonstrate the practical use of the ideas. We hope that the proposed standardizations will contribute to unambiguous descriptions and reproducible implementations of neuronal network connectivity in computational neuroscience.
Author summary: Neuronal network models are simplified and abstract representations of biological brains that allow researchers to study the influence of network connectivity on the dynamics in a controlled environment. Which neurons in a network are connected is determined by connectivity rules and even small differences between rules may lead to qualitatively different network dynamics. These rules either specify explicit pairs of source and target neurons or describe the connectivity on a statistical level abstracted from neuroanatomical data. We review articles describing models together with their implementations published in community repositories and find that incomplete and imprecise descriptions of connectivity are common. Our study proposes guidelines for the unambiguous description of network connectivity by formalizing the connectivity concepts already in use in the computational neuroscience community. Further we propose a graphical notation for network diagrams unifying existing diagram styles. These guidelines serve as a reference for future descriptions of connectivity and facilitate the reproduction of insights obtained with a model as well as its further use.