Obsessive-compulsive disorder is characterized by decreased Pavlovian influence on instrumental behavior
Authors: Ziwen Peng, Luning He, Rongzhen Wen, Tom Verguts, Carol A Seger, Qi Chen
Journal: PLOS Computational Biology
Accepted: 2022-09-28T00:00:00Z


Obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) is characterized by uncontrollable repetitive actions thought to rely on abnormalities within fundamental instrumental learning systems. We investigated cognitive and computational mechanisms underlying Pavlovian biases on instrumental behavior in both clinical OCD patients and healthy controls using a Pavlovian-Instrumental Transfer (PIT) task. PIT is typically evidenced by increased responding in the presence of a positive (previously rewarded) Pavlovian cue, and reduced responding in the presence of a negative cue. Thirty OCD patients and thirty-one healthy controls completed the Pavlovian Instrumental Transfer test, which included instrumental training, Pavlovian training for positive, negative and neutral cues, and a PIT phase in which participants performed the instrumental task in the presence of the Pavlovian cues. Modified Rescorla-Wagner models were fitted to trial-by-trial data of participants to estimate underlying computational mechanism and quantify individual differences during training and transfer stages. Bayesian hierarchical methods were used to estimate free parameters and compare the models. Behavioral and computational results indicated a weaker Pavlovian influence on instrumental behavior in OCD patients than in HC, especially for negative Pavlovian cues. Our results contrast with the increased PIT effects reported for another set of disorders characterized by compulsivity, substance use disorders, in which PIT is enhanced. A possible reason for the reduced PIT in OCD may be impairment in using the contextual information provided by the cues to appropriately adjust behavior, especially when inhibiting responding when a negative cue is present. This study provides deeper insight into our understanding of deficits in OCD from the perspective of Pavlovian influences on instrumental behavior and may have implications for OCD treatment modalities focused on reducing compulsive behaviors.
Author summary: One of the salient symptoms of OCD is compulsive behavior that is difficult to control or suppress. Neuropsychological studies indicate that people with OCD tend to engage in habitual behaviors rather than flexibly adjusting behaviors according to their goals. Behavior can also be affected by cues learned via a separate Pavlovian system that are associated with reward or punishment. Positive Pavlovian cues previously associated with reward typically increase vigorous active engagement whereas negative Pavlovian cues previously associated with punishment typically decrease engagement. In this study, behavioral experiments and computational modeling were used to investigate the effect of Pavlovian cues on instrumental behavior in both clinical OCD patients and healthy controls. People with OCD were less affected by the Pavlovian cues than healthy controls when performing a previously learned instrumental task, especially when negative cues associated with punishment were present.