Office Action 1: Non-Final Rejection (2024-12-19)
Rejection types: 103 - Obviousness, 112 - Written Description/Enablement, Double Patenting

CLAIMS:
CLAIMS What is claimed is:
1\. A vessel rinsing apparatus configured to be installed on a mounting deck adjacent a sink basin, the vessel rinsing apparatus comprising: an externally threaded mounting shank extending along a longitudinal axis, the mounting shank configured to extend though a mounting aperture formed within a mounting deck; a fluid discharge control including a central body supporting a sprayface having a plurality of nozzles, and a trigger, the central body being movable relative to the mounting shank along the longitudinal axis; a valve operably coupled to the fluid discharge control for movement between a normally closed position and an open position, the valve including a valve seal configured to cooperate with a valve seat supported by the mounting shank; wherein in the open position of the valve, the mounting shank is in fluid communication with the plurality of nozzles of the fluid discharge control via the valve; a drain bowl operably coupled to the mounting shank, the drain bowl including a base and an upwardly extending wall; a drain channel extending through the upwardly extending wall; and wherein in an installed condition of the vessel rinsing apparatus, the drain channel extends above the sink basin supported by the mounting deck, and the drain channel is inclined downwardly toward the sink basin such that fluid from the drain bowl is discharged from above and into the sink basin.
2\. The rinsing apparatus of claim 1, wherein the valve includes a valve pin coupled to the central body of the fluid discharge control and supporting the valve seal, the valve seal biased against the valve seat of the mounting shank in the normally closed position.
3\. The rinsing apparatus of claim 2, wherein: the trigger is moveable between a lowered position and a raised position; the trigger is biased in the raised position; and wherein depressing the trigger to the lowered position is configured to move the valve pin such that the valve seal moves away from the valve seat causing the valve to be in the open position.
4\. The rinsing apparatus of claim 3, further comprising a spring operable to bias the trigger toward the raised position.
5\. The rinsing apparatus of claim 1, wherein the plurality of nozzles of the sprayface includes a first nozzle configured to discharge fluid at a first angle relative to the longitudinal axis, and a second nozzle configured to discharge fluid at a second angle relative to the longitudinal axis.
6\. The rinsing apparatus of claim 1, wherein the central body of the fluid discharge control is positioned intermediate the sprayface and the valve seat.
7\. The rinsing apparatus of claim 1, wherein the sprayface of the fluid discharge control is located substantially within the drain bowl.
8\. The rinsing apparatus of claim 1, wherein the base of the drain bowl includes an opening through which at least a portion of the mounting shank extends.
9\. The rinsing apparatus of claim 1, wherein the fluid discharge control is in selective fluid communication with an outlet of a faucet mixing valve.
10\. The rinsing apparatus of claim 1, wherein the trigger of the fluid discharge control includes a plurality of arms extending radially outwardly from the central body.
11\. A drinkware rinsing apparatus configured to be installed on a mounting deck adjacent a sink basin, the rinsing apparatus comprising: a hollow, cylindrical mounting shank extending along a longitudinal axis, the mounting shank defining a first fluid passageway and including a valve seat; a valve at least partially disposed within the mounting shank, the valve having an open position and a closed position, the valve including a valve pin and a valve seal supported by the valve pin, the valve seal biased against the valve seat in the closed position; a fluid discharge control including: a central body extending along the longitudinal axis and at least partially disposed within the mounting shank, wherein the central body includes a second fluid passageway, a sprayface supported by a first end of the central body and including at least one outlet in fluid communication with the second fluid passageway, a depressible trigger operably coupled to the central body, the trigger moveable between a rest position and a depressed position, and a spring operable to bias the trigger toward the rest position; a drain bowl operably coupled to the mounting shank, the drain bowl defined by a base and an upwardly extending wall; a drain channel extending through the upwardly extending wall radially outwardly relative to the longitudinal axis; and wherein in the installed condition of the rinsing apparatus, the drain bowl is positioned above the mounting deck, at least a portion of the drain channel is positioned above the sink basin, and the drain channel is configured to receive fluid from the drain bowl and discharge fluid above and into the sink basin.
12\. The rinsing apparatus of claim 11, wherein: the trigger is biased toward the rest position; depressing the trigger is configured to move the valve pin such that the valve seal moves away from the valve seat causing the valve to be in the open position; and in the open position, the first fluid passageway of the mounting shank is in fluid communication with the second fluid passageway of the central body and the at least one outlet of the sprayface.
13\. The rinsing apparatus of claim 11, wherein: the valve pin defines a third fluid passageway; and fluid is configured to flow from the first fluid passageway of the mounting shank to the second fluid passageway of the central body through the third fluid passageway of the valve pin when the valve is in the open position.
14\. The rinsing apparatus of claim 11, wherein the central body of the fluid discharge control is positioned intermediate the sprayface and the valve seat.
15\. The rinsing apparatus of claim 11, wherein the at least one outlet of the sprayface includes a first outlet configured to discharge fluid at a first angle relative to the longitudinal axis, and a second outlet configured to discharge fluid at a second angle relative to the longitudinal axis.
16\. The rinsing apparatus of claim 15, wherein the at least one outlet of the sprayface further includes a third outlet configured to discharge fluid at a third angle relative to the longitudinal axis.
17\. The rinsing apparatus of claim 11, wherein the sprayface of the fluid discharge control is located substantially within the drain bowl.
18\. The rinsing apparatus of claim 11, wherein the base of the drain bowl includes an opening through which at least a portion of the mounting shank extends.
19\. The rinsing apparatus of claim 11, wherein the fluid discharge control is in selective fluid communication with an outlet of a faucet mixing valve.
20\. The rinsing apparatus of claim 11, wherein the trigger of the fluid discharge control includes a plurality of arms extending radially outwardly from the central body.

OFFICE ACTION:
DETAILED ACTION
Notice of Pre-AIA  or AIA  Status
The present application, filed on or after March 16, 2013, is being examined under the first inventor to file provisions of the AIA .
Double Patenting
The nonstatutory double patenting rejection is based on a judicially created doctrine grounded in public policy (a policy reflected in the statute) so as to prevent the unjustified or improper timewise extension of the “right to exclude” granted by a patent and to prevent possible harassment by multiple assignees. A nonstatutory double patenting rejection is appropriate where the conflicting claims are not identical, but at least one examined application claim is not patentably distinct from the reference claim(s) because the examined application claim is either anticipated by, or would have been obvious over, the reference claim(s). See, e.g., In re Berg, 140 F.3d 1428, 46 USPQ2d 1226 (Fed. Cir. 1998); In re Goodman, 11 F.3d 1046, 29 USPQ2d 2010 (Fed. Cir. 1993); In re Longi, 759 F.2d 887, 225 USPQ 645 (Fed. Cir. 1985); In re Van Ornum, 686 F.2d 937, 214 USPQ 761 (CCPA 1982); In re Vogel, 422 F.2d 438, 164 USPQ 619 (CCPA 1970); In re Thorington, 418 F.2d 528, 163 USPQ 644 (CCPA 1969).
A timely filed terminal disclaimer in compliance with 37 CFR 1.321(c) or 1.321(d) may be used to overcome an actual or provisional rejection based on nonstatutory double patenting provided the reference application or patent either is shown to be commonly owned with the examined application, or claims an invention made as a result of activities undertaken within the scope of a joint research agreement. See MPEP § 717.02 for applications subject to examination under the first inventor to file provisions of the AIA  as explained in MPEP § 2159. See MPEP § 2146 et seq. for applications not subject to examination under the first inventor to file provisions of the AIA . A terminal disclaimer must be signed in compliance with 37 CFR 1.321(b).
The filing of a terminal disclaimer by itself is not a complete reply to a nonstatutory double patenting (NSDP) rejection. A complete reply requires that the terminal disclaimer be accompanied by a reply requesting reconsideration of the prior Office action. Even where the NSDP rejection is provisional the reply must be complete. See MPEP § 804, subsection I.B.1. For a reply to a non-final Office action, see 37 CFR 1.111(a). For a reply to final Office action, see 37 CFR 1.113(c). A request for reconsideration while not provided for in 37 CFR 1.113(c) may be filed after final for consideration. See MPEP §§ 706.07(e) and 714.13.
The USPTO Internet website contains terminal disclaimer forms which may be used. Please visit www.uspto.gov/patent/patents-forms. The actual filing date of the application in which the form is filed determines what form (e.g., PTO/SB/25, PTO/SB/26, PTO/AIA /25, or PTO/AIA /26) should be used. A web-based eTerminal Disclaimer may be filled out completely online using web-screens. An eTerminal Disclaimer that meets all requirements is auto-processed and approved immediately upon submission. For more information about eTerminal Disclaimers, refer to www.uspto.gov/patents/apply/applying-online/eterminal-disclaimer.
Claims 1-20 are rejected on the ground of nonstatutory double patenting as being unpatentable over claims 1-26 and 31-34 of U.S. Patent No. 12,006,670. Although the claims at issue are not identical, they are not patentably distinct from each other because the claims of the instant application, although broader in scope, are anticipated in the limitations of US 12,006,670 claims 1-20. For example claim 1 of the instant application limitations (a mounting shank, fluid discharge control, central body, drain bow…) are claimed in US 12,006,670 claim 31. The difference being that claim 1 of the instant application does not require the limitation of a channel lower wall extending outwardly relative to the longitudinal axis.
Claim Rejections - 35 USC § 112
The following is a quotation of 35 U.S.C. 112(b):
(b)  CONCLUSION.—The specification shall conclude with one or more claims particularly pointing out and distinctly claiming the subject matter which the inventor or a joint inventor regards as the invention.
The following is a quotation of 35 U.S.C. 112 (pre-AIA ), second paragraph:
The specification shall conclude with one or more claims particularly pointing out and distinctly claiming the subject matter which the applicant regards as his invention.
Claims 1-10 are rejected under 35 U.S.C. 112(b) or 35 U.S.C. 112 (pre-AIA ), second paragraph, as being indefinite for failing to particularly point out and distinctly claim the subject matter which the inventor or a joint inventor (or for applications subject to pre-AIA  35 U.S.C. 112, the applicant), regards as the invention.
Regarding claim 1, it is unclear as to whether “a mounting deck” in the preamble is the same or different from “a mounting deck” in line 4.
Claims 2-10 are dependent upon claim 1.
Claim Rejections - 35 USC § 103
The following is a quotation of 35 U.S.C. 103 which forms the basis for all obviousness rejections set forth in this Office action:
A patent for a claimed invention may not be obtained, notwithstanding that the claimed invention is not identically disclosed as set forth in section 102, if the differences between the claimed invention and the prior art are such that the claimed invention as a whole would have been obvious before the effective filing date of the claimed invention to a person having ordinary skill in the art to which the claimed invention pertains. Patentability shall not be negated by the manner in which the invention was made.
The factual inquiries for establishing a background for determining obviousness under 35 U.S.C. 103 are summarized as follows:
1. Determining the scope and contents of the prior art.
2. Ascertaining the differences between the prior art and the claims at issue.
3. Resolving the level of ordinary skill in the pertinent art.
4. Considering objective evidence present in the application indicating obviousness or nonobviousness.
Claim(s) 1-3 and 5-10 is/are rejected under 35 U.S.C. 103 as being unpatentable over Van Der Linden (US 2008/0142095 cited in IDS), and in further view of Thomas (US 2011/0061754 cited in IDS).
Regarding claim 1, Van Der Linden figures 1-2 teach a vessel rinsing apparatus configured to be installed on a mounting deck (assembly of 2 column 4 worktop) adjacent a sink basin (35 recess), the rinsing apparatus comprising:
a mounting shank (28 supply line) extending along a longitudinal axis, the mounting shank configured to extend through a mounting aperture (recess 29 in the wall of the column 2) formed within a mounting deck (assembly of 2 column and 4 worktop);
a fluid discharge control including a central body (27 cylindrical end) supporting a sprayface (23 nozzle body) having a nozzle (24 spray channel), and a trigger (22 abutment member), the central body being movable relative to the mounting shank along the longitudinal axis;
a valve (26) operably coupled to the fluid discharge control for movement between a normally closed position and an open position;
a drain bowl  (31 cup shaped container) operably coupled to the mounting shank, the drain bowl including a base (32 bottom) and an upwardly extending wall (33 upright wall);
a drain channel (34 outflow opening) extending through the upwardly extending wall; and
wherein in an installed condition of the vessel rinsing apparatus, the drain channel (34 outflow opening) extends above the sink basin (35 recess) supported by the mounting deck, and the drain channel is inclined downwardly toward the sink basin such that fluid from the drain bowl is discharged from above and into the sink basin.[0030-35]
Van Der Linden teaches when a pressure is exerted on the abutment member 22 in the pressure direction 25 by pressing the open end of a glass against said abutment member, the valve 26 (only shown schematically) will open, so that washing liquid will be sprayed into the glass in question from the spray channel 24 thereby reading on in the open position of the valve, the mounting shank is in fluid communication with the plurality of nozzles of the fluid discharge control via the valve. [0031]
Although, Van Der Linder teaches washing water will be supplied to the spray channel 24 from the supply line 29 and be sprayed into the glass in question in order to thus wash said glass. Van Der Linden is silent to a plurality of nozzles.
It would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filing date of the present invention to provide a plurality of spray channels as a duplication of parts has no patentable significance unless a new and unexpected result is produced.(MPEP 2144.04)
Van Der Linden is silent to an externally threaded mounting shank.  Van Der Linder is also silent to the valve including a valve seal configured to cooperate with a valve seat supported by the mounting shank.
Thomas is directed towards a rinsing apparatus wherein figures 1-5 and 8A-8C teach a nut 56 threadably engages the mounting post 52 and secures the mounting base 50 to the mounting deck 4. Thomas further teaches a valve seat (82 diverter housing, 104 first seat), the valve (78 diverter valve) including a valve seal (106 second seal). [0033, 0041-42]
It would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filing date of the present invention to provide the valve assembly of Thomas in the rinsing apparatus of Van Der Linder to  control water flow from the inlet port to the first and second outlet ports.[0006]
Regarding claim 2, Thomas 1-5 and 8A-8C teach the valve ( 787 diverter valve) includes a valve pin (90 valve member, 98 valve stem) coupled to the central body of the fluid discharge control and supporting the valve seal (106 second seal), the valve seal biased against the valve seat (82 diverter housing, 104 first seat) of the mounting shank in the normally closed position.[0033, 0041-42]
Regarding claim 3, Van Der Linden teaches the trigger (22 abutment member). Van Der Linden teaches when a pressure is exerted on the abutment member 22 in the pressure direction 25 by pressing the open end of a glass against said abutment member, the valve 26 (only shown schematically) will open, so that washing liquid will be sprayed into the glass in question from the spray channel 24 thereby suggesting the trigger is moveable between a lowered position and a raised position; the trigger is biased in the raised position; and wherein depressing the trigger to the lowered position is configured to move the valve pin such that the valve seal moves away from the valve seat causing the valve to be in the open position.[0031]
Regarding claim 5, Van Der Linden figure 2 teaches at least one outlet of the sprayface includes a first outlet configured to discharge fluid at a first angle relative to the longitudinal axis.  Thomas teaches the spray  has (multiple water outlets).[0043] Therefore, it would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filing date of the present invention to provide a second outlet configured to discharge fluid at a second angle relative to the longitudinal axis to provide more effective cleaning of the glassware.
Regarding claim 6, Van Der Linder in view of Thomas suggests the central body (27 cylindrical end ) of the fluid discharge control is positioned intermediate the sprayface (23 nozzle body)and the valve seat (104 valve seat Thomas).
Regarding claim 7, Van Der Linden figure 1 teaches the sprayface (23 nozzle body) of the fluid discharge control is located substantially within the drain bowl (31 cup shaped container).
Regarding claim 8, Van Der Linder figure 2 teaches the base (32 bottom) of the drain bowl includes an opening through which at least a portion of the mounting shank (28 supply line) extends.
Regarding claim 9, Thomas figure 2 teaches the fluid discharge control is in selective fluid communication with an outlet of a faucet mixing valve (20).[0031]
Regarding claim 10,  Van Der Linden figures 1 and 2 teach the trigger (22 abutment) of the fluid discharge control includes a plurality of arms extending radially outwardly from the central body.
Claim(s) 4 and 11-20 is/are rejected under 35 U.S.C. 103 as being unpatentable over Van Der Linden (US 2008/0142095 cited in IDS) and Thomas (US 2011/0061754 cited in IDS), and in further view of Pein (US 784,755 cited in IDS).
Regarding claim 4, Van Der Linden in view of Thomas is silent to a spring operable to bias the trigger toward the raised position.[page 1 lines 60-65]
Pein is directed towards a rinsing apparatus wherein a spring 14 is interposed between the wall 7 and collar 9a, which serves to force the valve 9 upwardly, thus normally closing the ports of the valve.
It would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filing date of the present invention to provide a spring as taught in Pein so that the ports of the valve is closed.
Regarding claim 11, Van Der Linden figures 1-2 teach a drinkware rinsing apparatus configured to be installed on a mounting deck (4 work top)adjacent a sink basin(35 recess), the rinsing apparatus comprising:
a hollow, cylindrical mounting shank (28 supply line) extending along a longitudinal axis, the mounting shank defining a first fluid passageway;
a valve (26) at least partially disposed within the mounting shank, the valve having an open position and a closed position;
a fluid discharge control including:
a central body (27 cylindrical end) extending along the longitudinal axis and at least partially disposed within the mounting shank, wherein the central body includes a second fluid passageway (24 spray channel),
a sprayface (23 nozzle body) supported by a first end of the central body (27 cylindrical end) and including at least one outlet in fluid communication with the second fluid passageway (24 spray channel),
a depressible trigger (22 abutment member) operably coupled to the central body, the trigger moveable between a rest position and a depressed position, and
a drain bowl (31 cup shaped container) operably coupled to the mounting shank (28 supply line), the drain bowl defined by a base (32 bottom) and an upwardly extending wall (22 upright wall);
a drain channel (34 outflow opening) extending through the upwardly extending wall radially outwardly relative to the longitudinal axis; and
wherein in the installed condition of the rinsing apparatus, the drain bowl (31 cup shaped container) is positioned above the mounting deck (4 worktop), at least a portion of the drain channel (34 outflow opening) is positioned above the sink basin (35 recess), and the drain channel (34) is configured to receive fluid from the drain bowl (31) and discharge fluid above and into the sink basin (35)[0030-35].
Van Der Linden is silent to the hollow, cylindrical mounting shank (28 supply line) having a valve seat, the valve including a valve pin and a valve seal supported by the valve pin, the valve seal biased against the valve seat in the closed position.
Thomas is directed towards a rinsing apparatus wherein figures 1-5 and 8A-8C teach a hollow, cylindrical mounting shank (52 mounting shank) having a valve seat (82 diverter housing, 104 first seat), the valve (78 diverter valve) including a valve pin (90 valve member, 98 valve stem) and a valve seal (106 second seal) supported by the valve pin, the valve seal biased against the valve seat in the closed position, and wherein the valve pin (90 valve member, 98 valve stem) is coupled to the central body.[0033, 0041-42]
It would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filing date of the present invention to provide the valve assembly of Thomas in the rinsing apparatus of Van Der Linder to  control water flow from the inlet port to the first and second outlet ports.[0006]
Van Der Linden in view of Thomas is silent to a spring operable to bias the trigger toward the raised position.[page 1 lines 60-65]
Pein is directed towards a rinsing apparatus wherein a spring 14 is interposed between the wall 7 and collar 9a, which serves to force the valve 9 upwardly, thus normally closing the ports of the valve.
It would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filing date of the present invention to provide a spring as taught in Pein so that the ports of the valve is closed.
Regarding claim 12, Van Der Linden figure 1 teaches the trigger is biased toward the rest position. Van Der Linden teaches when a pressure is exerted on the abutment member 22 in the pressure direction 25 by pressing the open end of a glass against said abutment member, the valve 26 (only shown schematically) will open, so that washing liquid will be sprayed into the glass in question from the spray channel 24 thereby reading on in the open position, the first fluid passageway of the mounting shank is in fluid communication with the second fluid passageway of the central body and the at least one outlet of the sprayface.[0031] Therefore, Van Der Linden in view of Thomas teaches depressing the trigger is configured to move the valve pin such that the valve seal moves away from the valve seat causing the valve to be in the open position; and in the open position, the first fluid passageway of the mounting shank is in fluid communication with the second fluid passageway of the central body and the at least one outlet of the sprayface.
Regarding claim 13, Thomas teaches water 146 flows in from the valve 20 into the center portion of the diverter stem 98 and either exits out the spout outlet tube 30 (FIG. 15B) or out the sprayer tube 46 (FIG. 15C), depending on whether the sprayer trigger 47 has been actuated thereby reading on the valve pin (98 stem) defines a third fluid passageway; and fluid is configured to flow from the first fluid passageway of the mounting shank to the second fluid passageway of the central body through the third fluid passageway of the valve pin when the valve is in the open position.[0045]
Regarding claim 14, Van Der Linder in view of Thomas suggests the central body (27 cylindrical end ) of the fluid discharge control is positioned intermediate the sprayface (23 nozzle body)and the valve seat (104 valve seat Thomas).
Regarding claim 15, Van Der Linden figure 2 teaches at least one outlet of the sprayface includes a first outlet configured to discharge fluid at a first angle relative to the longitudinal axis.  Thomas teaches the spray  has (multiple water outlet).[0043] Therefore, it would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filing date of the present invention to provide a second outlet configured to discharge fluid at a second angle relative to the longitudinal axis to provide more effective cleaning of the glassware.
Regarding claim 16, it would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filing date of the present invention to provide the at least one outlet of the sprayface further includes a third outlet configured to discharge fluid at a third angle relative to the longitudinal axis as a duplication of parts has no patentable significance unless a new and unexpected result is produced.(MPEP 2144.04)
Regarding claim 17, Van Der Linden figure 1 teaches the sprayface (23 nozzle body) of the fluid discharge control is located substantially within the drain bowl (31 cup shaped container).
Regarding claim 18, Van Der Linder figure 2 teaches the base (32 bottom) of the drain bowl includes an opening through which at least a portion of the mounting shank (28 supply line) extends.
Regarding claim 19, Thomas figure 2 teaches the fluid discharge control is in selective fluid communication with an outlet of a faucet mixing valve (20).[0031]
Regarding claim 20, Van Der Linden figures 1 and 2 teach the trigger (22 abutment) of the fluid discharge control includes a plurality of arms extending radially outwardly from the central body.
Conclusion

APPLICANT REBUTTAL: REMARKS/ARGUMENTSIntroduction Reconsideration and reversal of the rejections presented in the Office Action dated December 19, 2024 are respectfully requested in view of the foregoing amendments and the following remarks.Following entry of this Amendment, claims 1-25 are pending, wherein claims 1, 11 and 21 are presented in independent form. Claims 1 and 11 have been amended, and new claims 21- 25 have been added.Summary of Examiner Interview Examiner Tate-Sims is thanked for the courtesies extended to the undersigned during the telephonic interview of April 3, 2025. The foregoing amendments and the following remarks are intended to serve as Applicant's written statement under M.P.E.P. § 713.04, covering substance of the interview. During the interview, proposed amendments to claims 1 and 11 and new claim 21 were discussed in view of the relied-upon art.Claim Reiections - Double Patenting Claims 1-20 have been rejected on the ground of non-statutory double patenting as being unpatentable over claims 1-26 and 31-34 of U.S. Patent No. 12,006,670.Not in acquiescence of the Examiner's position, but in order to advance the application toward allowance, submitted herewith is a Terminal Disclaimer over U.S. Patent No. 12,006,670.In support of this Terminal Disclaimer, also find concurrently herewith are a Statement under 37 C.F.R. § 3.73 and a Power of Attorney.In view of the foregoing, it is respectfully submitted that the double patenting rejections have been obviated.Claim Reiections - 35 U.S.C. § 112 Claims 1-10 have been rejected under 35 U.S.C. §112(b) as being indefinite for failing to particularly point out and distinctly claim the subject matter which the inventor or a joint inventor, regards as the invention More particularly, claim 1 was alleged to be unclear as to whether "a mounting deck" in the preamble is the same or different from "a mounting deck" in line 4. In response, claim 1 at line 4 has been amended to recite "the mounting deck".Claim Reiections - 35 U.S.C. § 103 Claims 1-3 and 5-10 have been rejected under 35 U.S.C. §103 as being unpatentable over Van Der Linden (U.S. Patent Application Publication No. 2008/0142095) in view of Thomas (U.S. Patent Application Publication No. 2011/0061754).Van Der Linden discloses a draft tower 1 including a column 2 and two tapping devices 3. The draft tower 1 includes a washing device 21 having a cross-shaped abutment member 22 and a spray nozzle body 23. The washing device 21 further includes a cup-shaped container 31 including a concave bottom 32 and an upright wall 33 having an outflow opening 34. FIG. 5 discloses a water faucet 71 provided with a washing device 78 mounted to a fixed base 73. An outflow opening 79 of the washing device 78 opens above a sink 77.Thomas discloses a faucet assembly 10 including a side sprayer assembly 42. A diverter assembly 12 includes a diverter valve 78 secured to an inlet end 80 of the sprayer tube 46 of the sprayer assembly 42. The diverter assembly 12 illustratively includes a coupler or connector 62 having a connector housing 64 secured to an inlet end 66 of a spout outlet tube 30. The diverter valve 78 is configured to be slidably received within the connector housing 64.Independent Claim 1 As discussed in the aforementioned telephonic interview, it is respectfully submitted that one of ordinary skill in the art would not be motivated to combine Van Der Linden with Thomas.More particularly, Van Der Linden discloses a glass rinser attached to a faucet, while Thomas discloses a kitchen side sprayer. There is no suggestion or teaching in Thomas of modifying Van Der Linden to arrive at the present invention.Moreover, there is no reasonable expectation of success by modifying Van Der Linden in view of Thomas. In fact, modifying Van Der Linden with the teachings of Thomas would frustrate its intended purpose. Van Der Liden teaches a glass rinser supported by a faucet, while Thomas teaches a side sprayer mounted to a sink deck and having a different function, such that the proposed modification of Van Der Linden would render it unsatisfactory for its intended purpose.Furthermore, Applicant fails to see how one of ordinary skill in the art would modify Van Der Linden based on the teachings of Thomas and arrive at the present invention.For at least these reasons, it is respectfully submitted that the solicited claims are in condition for allowance over Van Der Linden and Thomas.Even assuming, arguendo, that one would combine Van Der Linden and Thomas, she would not arrive at the claimed invention. Independent claim 1 recites, and the relied upon art fails to disclose or suggest, a mounting shank supporting a valve seat, and a valve seal biased against the valve seat. (FIG. 5, para. [0035], mounting shank (66), valve seat (109), valve seal (108)).As acknowledged in the aforementioned interview, amended claim 1 distinguishes over the relied-upon art. In view of the foregoing, it is respectfully submitted that claim 1, and the claims dependent therefrom, are properly allowable.Claims 4 and 11-20 have been rejected under 35 U.S.C. §103 as being unpatentable over Van Der Linden (U.S. Patent Application Publication No. 2008/0142095) in view of Thomas (U.S. Patent Application Publication No. 2011/0061754) and further in view of Pein (U.S. Patent No. 784,755).Pein discloses a rinser apparatus including a spring (14) interposed between a wall (7) and a collar (9a), which serves to force a valve (9) upwardly (FIG. 2).Independent Claim 11 As discussed in the aforementioned telephonic interview, it is respectfully submitted that one of ordinary skill in the art would not be motivated to combine Pein with Van Der Linden.More particularly, Van Der Linden discloses that "pressure in the supply line 29 will keep the valve 26 in the closed position as long as no pressure is exerted on the abutment member 22, so that the supply of washing liquid from the supply line 29 to the spray channel 24 is blocked." (para. [0031]). Since there is no need for a different biasing means in Van Der Linden, one of ordinary skill in the art would not be motivated to insert the spring of Pein therein.In other words, one would not be motivated to modify Van Der Linden to include a spring, which would be an unnecessary modification. Van Der Linden clearly utilizes water pressure to bias a valve toward a closed position. There is simply no need for a spring in Van Der Linden, such that one skilled in the art would not be motivated to include a spring therein.Even assuming, arguendo, that one would combine Van Der Linden, Thomas and Pein, she would not arrive at the claimed invention. Independent claim 11 recites, and the relied upon art fails to disclose or suggest, a mounting shank including a valve seat, and a valve seal biased against the valve seat, much less the valve seal being supported by a valve pin. (FIG. 5, para.[0035], mounting shank (66), valve seat (109), valve seal (108), valve pin (96)).As acknowledged in the aforementioned interview, amended claim 11 distinguishes over the relied-upon art. In view of the foregoing, it is respectfully submitted that claim 11, and the claims dependent therefrom, are properly allowable.New Claims New independent claim 21 recites, and the relied-upon art fails to disclose or suggest, a drain channel fluidly coupled to the drain bowl and including a channel lower wall extending outwardly from the drain bowl relative to the longitudinal axis defined by a mounting shank alone, or in combination with the other elements recited therein. As such, it is respectfully submitted that claim 21 is properly allowable.New claims 22-25 are respectfully submitted to be in condition for allowance as depending, either directly or indirectly, from properly allowable claim 21.Conclusion For at least the foregoing reasons, it is respectfully submitted that all of the solicited claims are in condition for allowance. Such action is respectfully requested.If necessary, Applicant requests that this response be considered a request for an extension of time appropriate for the response to be timely filed. Applicant requests that any required fees needed beyond those submitted with this amendment be charged to the account of Bose McKinney & Evans LLP, Deposit Account No. 02-3223.If any questions or comments should arise during consideration of this matter, the Examiner is invited to call the undersigned at the number provided below.Respectfully submitted, /Douglas A. Yerkeson/ Douglas A. Yerkeson Registration No. 39,882 Attorney for Applicant BOSE MCKINNEY & EVANS LLP111 Monument Circle, Suite 2700 Indianapolis, Indiana 46204 Telephone: 317-684-5110 Date: April 17, 2025

NEXT OFFICE ACTION: DETAILED ACTION
Reasons for Allowance
The following is an examiner’s statement of reasons for allowance: the closest prior art of record Van Der Linden (US 2008/0142095 cited in IDS) in further view of Thomas (US 2011/0061754 cited in IDS) fails to teach or suggest the claimed invention.
Van Der Linden figures 1-2 teach a vessel rinsing apparatus configured to be installed on a mounting deck (assembly of 2 column 4 worktop) adjacent a sink basin (35 recess), the rinsing apparatus comprising:
a mounting shank (28 supply line) extending along a longitudinal axis, the mounting shank configured to extend through a mounting aperture (recess 29 in the wall of the column 2) formed within a mounting deck (assembly of 2 column and 4 worktop);
a fluid discharge control including a central body (27 cylindrical end) supporting a sprayface (23 nozzle body) having a nozzle (24 spray channel), and a trigger (22 abutment member), the central body being movable relative to the mounting shank along the longitudinal axis;
a valve (26) operably coupled to the fluid discharge control for movement between a normally closed position and an open position;
a drain bowl  (31 cup shaped container) operably coupled to the mounting shank, the drain bowl including a base (32 bottom) and an upwardly extending wall (33 upright wall);
a drain channel (34 outflow opening) extending through the upwardly extending wall; and
wherein in an installed condition of the vessel rinsing apparatus, the drain channel (34 outflow opening) extends above the sink basin (35 recess) supported by the mounting deck, and the drain channel is inclined downwardly toward the sink basin such that fluid from the drain bowl is discharged from above and into the sink basin.[0030-35]
Van Der Linden teaches when a pressure is exerted on the abutment member 22 in the pressure direction 25 by pressing the open end of a glass against said abutment member, the valve 26 (only shown schematically) will open, so that washing liquid will be sprayed into the glass in question from the spray channel 24 thereby reading on in the open position of the valve, the mounting shank is in fluid communication with the plurality of nozzles of the fluid discharge control via the valve. [0031]
Although, Van Der Linden teaches washing water will be supplied to the spray channel 24 from the supply line 29 and be sprayed into the glass in question in order to thus wash said glass. Van Der Linden is silent to a plurality of nozzles.
It would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filing date of the present invention to provide a plurality of spray channels as a duplication of parts has no patentable significance unless a new and unexpected result is produced.(MPEP 2144.04)
Van Der Linden is silent to an externally threaded mounting shank.  Van Der Linden is also silent to the valve including a valve seal configured to cooperate with a valve seat supported by the mounting shank.
Thomas is directed towards a rinsing apparatus wherein figures 1-5 and 8A-8C teach a nut 56 threadably engages the mounting post 52 and secures the mounting base 50 to the mounting deck 4. Thomas further teaches a valve seat (82 diverter housing, 104 first seat), the valve (78 diverter valve) including a valve seal (106 second seal). [0033, 0041-42]
However, modifying the faucet of Van Der Linden with the components of the sprayer of Thomas renders the faucet of Van Der Linden in operable.
Furthermore, the vessel rinsing apparatus of Van Der Linden fails to teach or suggest a mounting shank support a valve seat, and a valve seal biased against the valve seat.
Conclusion
Any comments considered necessary by applicant must be submitted no later than the payment of the issue fee and, to avoid processing delays, should preferably accompany the issue fee.  Such submissions should be clearly labeled “Comments on Statement of Reasons for Allowance.”

CITED REFERENCE SUMMARIES: Ref US20080142095A1: Claims:
A faucet characterised by washing means for washing the insides of glasses and the like, comprising an abutment surface for abutment thereagainst of an open end of a glass, a supply line for supplying washing liquid, a spray nozzle at one end of said supply line for spraying washing liquid being supplied via the supply line into the glass from the spray nozzle during abutment of said open end against said abutment surface, and a valve in the supply line to be actuated by actuating means for supplying washing liquid to the spray nozzle as desired.
A faucet according to claim 1 , characterised in that the washing means comprise a container on the side of the abutment surface that is remote from the glass when the glass is being washed, which container functions to receive washing liquid that was previously sprayed into the glass, as well as an outlet opening formed in said container for discharging washing liquid from the container.
A faucet according to claim 2 , characterised in that the container forms part of a base of the faucet.
A faucet according to claim 2 , characterised in that the outlet opening is provided in a bottom of the container.
A faucet according to claim 2 , characterised in that the outlet opening is provided in a wall of the container.
A faucet according to claim 2 , characterised in that at least a part of an upright wall that forms part of the container is spaced from the circumference of the abutment surface by a distance of maximally 25 mm.
A faucet according to claim 2 , characterised in that at least a part of a bottom that forms part of the container is spaced from the abutment surface by a distance of maximally 40 mm while a glass is being washed.
A faucet according to claim 2 , characterised in that at least a part of an upright wall forming part of the container is circular in shape.
A faucet according to claim 8 , characterised in that the radius of said circular shape ranges between 40 mm and 100 mm.
A faucet according to claim 1 , characterised in that the abutment surface is oriented at an inclined angle.
A faucet according to claim 1 , characterised in that the abutment surface extends within the height of an at least partially circumferential wall of the container while the glass is being washed.
A faucet according to claim 2 , characterised by a discharge line which is connected to the outlet opening.
A faucet according to claim 12 , characterised in that said discharge line extends through the base.
A faucet according to claim 13 , characterised by a common lead-through channel for leading through a tap line to an outflow opening of the faucet and for leading through the supply line.
A faucet according to claim 1 , characterised by a coolant line which extends around the supply line and a tap line for the faucet.
A faucet according to claim 1 , characterised in that the supply line and further preferably a tap line extends though a cooling unit.
A faucet construction comprising a worktop and a faucet, the faucet comprising washing means for washing the insides of items, comprising an abutment surface for abutment thereagainst of an open end of the item, a supply line for supplying washing liquid, a spray nozzle at one end of said supply line for spraying washing liquid being supplied via the supply line into the item from the spray nozzle during abutment of said open end against said abutment surface, and a valve in the supply line to be actuated by actuating means for supplying washing liquid to the spray nozzle as desired; wherein the washing means comprise a container on the side of the abutment surface that is remote from the item when the item is being washed, which container functions to receive washing liquid that was previously sprayed into the item, as well as an outlet opening formed in said container for discharging washing liquid from the container; wherein the outlet opening opens above a recessed part of the work top, and the recessed part is provided with a further outlet opening extending through the work top for discharging liquid from the upper side of the work top to the bottom side of the work top.
wherein the washing means comprise a container on the side of the abutment surface that is remote from the item when the item is being washed, which container functions to receive washing liquid that was previously sprayed into the item, as well as an outlet opening formed in said container for discharging washing liquid from the container;
wherein the outlet opening opens above a recessed part of the work top, and the recessed part is provided with a further outlet opening extending through the work top for discharging liquid from the upper side of the work top to the bottom side of the work top.
A construction according to claim 17 , characterised in that said recessed part is a sink in the work top.
Ref US20110061754A1: [content unavailable]
Ref US0784755A: [content unavailable]
Ref US12006670B2: Claims:
A drinkware rinsing apparatus configured to be installed on a mounting deck adjacent a sink basin, the rinsing apparatus comprising: a hollow, cylindrical mounting shank extending along a longitudinal axis, the mounting shank defining a first fluid passageway and including a valve seat; a valve at least partially disposed within the mounting shank, the valve having an open position and a closed position, the valve including a valve pin and a valve seal supported by the valve pin, the valve seal biased against the valve seat in the closed position; a fluid discharge control including: a central body extending along the longitudinal axis and at least partially disposed within the mounting shank, wherein the central body includes a second fluid passageway, and wherein the valve pin is coupled to the central body, a sprayface supported by a first end of the central body and including at least one outlet in fluid communication with the second fluid passageway, a trigger operably coupled to the central body, the trigger moveable between a lowered position and a raised position, wherein the trigger is biased toward the raised position, wherein moving the trigger to the lowered position is configured to move the valve pin such that the valve seal moves away from the valve seat causing the valve to be in the open position, and wherein in the open position, the first fluid passageway of the mounting shank is in fluid communication with the second fluid passageway of the central body and the at least one outlet of the sprayface; a drain bowl operably coupled to the mounting shank, the drain bowl defined by a base and an upwardly extending wall; a drain channel extending through the upwardly extending wall; and wherein in an installed condition of the rinsing apparatus, the drain bowl is positioned above the mounting deck, at least a portion of the drain channel is positioned above the sink basin, and the drain channel is configured to receive fluid from the drain bowl and discharge the fluid above and into the sink basin.
a hollow, cylindrical mounting shank extending along a longitudinal axis, the mounting shank defining a first fluid passageway and including a valve seat;
a valve at least partially disposed within the mounting shank, the valve having an open position and a closed position, the valve including a valve pin and a valve seal supported by the valve pin, the valve seal biased against the valve seat in the closed position;
a fluid discharge control including: a central body extending along the longitudinal axis and at least partially disposed within the mounting shank, wherein the central body includes a second fluid passageway, and wherein the valve pin is coupled to the central body, a sprayface supported by a first end of the central body and including at least one outlet in fluid communication with the second fluid passageway, a trigger operably coupled to the central body, the trigger moveable between a lowered position and a raised position, wherein the trigger is biased toward the raised position, wherein moving the trigger to the lowered position is configured to move the valve pin such that the valve seal moves away from the valve seat causing the valve to be in the open position, and wherein in the open position, the first fluid passageway of the mounting shank is in fluid communication with the second fluid passageway of the central body and the at least one outlet of the sprayface;
a central body extending along the longitudinal axis and at least partially disposed within the mounting shank, wherein the central body includes a second fluid passageway, and wherein the valve pin is coupled to the central body,
a sprayface supported by a first end of the central body and including at least one outlet in fluid communication with the second fluid passageway,
a trigger operably coupled to the central body, the trigger moveable between a lowered position and a raised position,
wherein the trigger is biased toward the raised position,
wherein moving the trigger to the lowered position is configured to move the valve pin such that the valve seal moves away from the valve seat causing the valve to be in the open position, and
wherein in the open position, the first fluid passageway of the mounting shank is in fluid communication with the second fluid passageway of the central body and the at least one outlet of the sprayface;
a drain bowl operably coupled to the mounting shank, the drain bowl defined by a base and an upwardly extending wall;
a drain channel extending through the upwardly extending wall; and
wherein in an installed condition of the rinsing apparatus, the drain bowl is positioned above the mounting deck, at least a portion of the drain channel is positioned above the sink basin, and the drain channel is configured to receive fluid from the drain bowl and discharge the fluid above and into the sink basin.
The rinsing apparatus of claim 1 , wherein: the valve pin defines a third fluid passageway; and fluid is configured to flow from the first fluid passageway of the mounting shank to the second fluid passageway of the central body through the third fluid passageway of the valve pin when the valve is in the open position.
the valve pin defines a third fluid passageway; and
fluid is configured to flow from the first fluid passageway of the mounting shank to the second fluid passageway of the central body through the third fluid passageway of the valve pin when the valve is in the open position.
The rinsing apparatus of claim 1 , wherein the central body of the fluid discharge control is positioned intermediate the sprayface and the valve seat.
The rinsing apparatus of claim 1 , wherein in the installed condition of the rinsing apparatus, the drain channel is inclined downwardly toward the sink basin.
The rinsing apparatus of claim 1 , wherein the sprayface of the fluid discharge control is located substantially within the drain bowl.
The rinsing apparatus of claim 1 , wherein the at least one outlet of the sprayface includes a first outlet configured to discharge fluid at a first angle relative to the longitudinal axis, and a second outlet configured to discharge fluid at a second angle relative to the longitudinal axis.
The rinsing apparatus of claim 1 , wherein the base of the drain bowl includes an opening through which at least a portion of the mounting shank extends.
The rinsing apparatus of claim 1 , wherein the fluid discharge control is in selective fluid communication with an outlet of a faucet mixing valve.
The rinsing apparatus of claim 8 , further comprising a diverter valve fluidly coupled intermediate the outlet of the faucet mixing valve and the fluid discharge control.
The rinsing apparatus of claim 1 , wherein the trigger of the fluid discharge control includes a plurality of arms extending radially outwardly from the central body.
The rinsing apparatus of claim 1 , further comprising a spring operable to bias the trigger toward the raised position.
A drinkware rinsing apparatus configured to be installed on a mounting deck adjacent a sink basin, the rinsing apparatus comprising: a hollow, cylindrical mounting shank extending along a longitudinal axis, the mounting shank defining a first fluid passageway and including a valve seat; a valve at least partially disposed within the mounting shank, the valve having an open position and a closed position, the valve including a valve pin and a valve seal supported by the valve pin, the valve seal biased against the valve seat in the closed position; a fluid discharge control including: a central body extending along the longitudinal axis and at least partially disposed within the mounting shank, wherein the central body includes a second fluid passageway, a sprayface supported by a first end of the central body and including at least one outlet in fluid communication with the second fluid passageway, and a depressible trigger operably coupled to the central body, the trigger moveable between a rest position and a depressed position; a drain bowl operably coupled to the mounting shank, the drain bowl defined by a base and an upwardly extending wall; a drain channel extending through the upwardly extending wall; and wherein in the installed condition of the rinsing apparatus, the drain bowl is positioned above the mounting deck, at least a portion of the drain channel is positioned above, and inclined downwardly toward, the sink basin, and the drain channel is configured to receive fluid from the drain bowl and discharge fluid above and into the sink basin.
a fluid discharge control including: a central body extending along the longitudinal axis and at least partially disposed within the mounting shank, wherein the central body includes a second fluid passageway, a sprayface supported by a first end of the central body and including at least one outlet in fluid communication with the second fluid passageway, and a depressible trigger operably coupled to the central body, the trigger moveable between a rest position and a depressed position;
a central body extending along the longitudinal axis and at least partially disposed within the mounting shank, wherein the central body includes a second fluid passageway,
a sprayface supported by a first end of the central body and including at least one outlet in fluid communication with the second fluid passageway, and
a depressible trigger operably coupled to the central body, the trigger moveable between a rest position and a depressed position;
wherein in the installed condition of the rinsing apparatus, the drain bowl is positioned above the mounting deck, at least a portion of the drain channel is positioned above, and inclined downwardly toward, the sink basin, and the drain channel is configured to receive fluid from the drain bowl and discharge fluid above and into the sink basin.
The rinsing apparatus of claim 12 , wherein: the trigger is biased toward the rest position; depressing the trigger is configured to move the valve pin such that the valve seal moves away from the valve seat causing the valve to be in the open position; and in the open position, the first fluid passageway of the mounting shank is in fluid communication with the second fluid passageway of the central body and the at least one outlet of the sprayface.
the trigger is biased toward the rest position;
depressing the trigger is configured to move the valve pin such that the valve seal moves away from the valve seat causing the valve to be in the open position; and
in the open position, the first fluid passageway of the mounting shank is in fluid communication with the second fluid passageway of the central body and the at least one outlet of the sprayface.
The rinsing apparatus of claim 12 , wherein: the valve pin defines a third fluid passageway; and fluid is configured to flow from the first fluid passageway of the mounting shank to the second fluid passageway of the central body through the third fluid passageway of the valve pin when the valve is in the open position.
The rinsing apparatus of claim 12 , wherein the central body of the fluid discharge control is positioned intermediate the sprayface and the valve seat.
The rinsing apparatus of claim 12 , wherein the at least one outlet of the sprayface includes a first outlet configured to discharge fluid at a first angle relative to the longitudinal axis, and a second outlet configured to discharge fluid at a second angle relative to the longitudinal axis.
The rinsing apparatus of claim 16 , wherein the at least one outlet of the sprayface further includes a third outlet configured to discharge fluid at a third angle relative to the longitudinal axis.
The rinsing apparatus of claim 12 , wherein the sprayface of the fluid discharge control is located substantially within the drain bowl.
The rinsing apparatus of claim 12 , wherein the base of the drain bowl includes an opening through which at least a portion of the mounting shank extends.
The rinsing apparatus of claim 12 , wherein the fluid discharge control is in selective fluid communication with an outlet of a faucet mixing valve.
The rinsing apparatus of claim 20 , further comprising a diverter valve fluidly coupled intermediate the outlet of the faucet mixing valve and the fluid discharge member.
The rinsing apparatus of claim 12 , wherein the trigger of the fluid discharge control includes a plurality of arms extending radially outwardly from the central body.
The rinsing apparatus of claim 12 , further comprising a spring operable to bias the trigger toward the rest position.
A drinkware rinsing apparatus configured to be installed on a mounting deck adjacent a sink basin, the rinsing apparatus comprising: a hollow, cylindrical mounting shank extending along a longitudinal axis, the mounting shank defining a first fluid passageway and including a valve seat; a valve at least partially disposed within the mounting shank, the valve having an open position and a closed position, the valve including a valve pin and a valve seal supported by the valve pin, the valve seal biased against the valve seat in the closed position; a fluid discharge control including: a central body extending along the longitudinal axis and at least partially disposed within the mounting shank, wherein the central body includes a second fluid passageway, a sprayface supported by a first end of the central body and including a plurality of outlets in fluid communication with the second fluid passageway, wherein the plurality of outlets include a first outlet configured to discharge fluid at a first angle relative to the longitudinal axis, a second outlet configured to discharge fluid at a second angle relative to the longitudinal axis, and a third outlet configured to discharge fluid at a third angle relative to the longitudinal axis, a depressible trigger operably coupled to the central body, the trigger moveable between a lowered position and a raised position, wherein the trigger is biased toward the raised position, wherein depressing the trigger to the lowered position is configured to move the valve pin such that the valve seal moves away from the valve seat causing the valve to be in the open position; and wherein in the open position, the first fluid passageway of the mounting shank is in fluid communication with the second fluid passageway of the central body and the outlets of the sprayface; a drain bowl operably coupled to the mounting shank, the drain bowl defined by a base and an upwardly extending wall; a drain channel extending through the upwardly extending wall; and wherein in an installed condition of the rinsing apparatus, the drain bowl is positioned above the mounting deck, at least a portion of the drain channel is positioned above the sink basin, and the drain channel is configured to receive fluid from the drain bowl and discharge the fluid above and into the sink basin.
a fluid discharge control including: a central body extending alo
[Truncated to input limit]