Office Action 4: Final Rejection (2024-11-27)
Rejection types: 103 - Obviousness, 112 - Written Description/Enablement

CLAIMS:
Listing of Claims:

This listing of claims will replace all prior versions, and listings, of claims in the application.

1\. (Currently Amended) An assembly for delivering an output current Is, comprising:N electrical energy storage or production cells B1 of rank i, where N>2, each cell comprising an elementary cell or an elementary assembly of elementary cells CE arranged in series and/or in parallel, each electrical energy storage or production cell being able to supply a maximum current Imax,1 continuously during a time period T;
a management circuit for managing said electrical energy storage or production cells B1, wherein said electrical energy storage or production cells are ordered according to their rank i in decreasing priority order of use,
wherein a production cell Biis able to provide a maximum current Imax. at any time t,said management circuit comprises means, in discharge mode, for discharging at least the electrical energy storage or production cell of rank 1 or the electrical energy storage or production cells according to their rank i and according to the following criteria:
the discharge of the electrical energy storage or production cell B1 of rank 1 is , smaxiactivated:\[\[;\]\] if the electrical energy storage or production cell Bi of rank 1 is able to supply an output current Is, wherein Imax.1 > Is, only the electrical energy storage or production cell Bi of rank 1 is discharged;otherwise, if Imax,1 < Is, the electrical energy storage or production cell Bi of rank 1 is discharged with additionally a number k of electrical energy storage or production cells B1 that are discharged successively according to their rank i, so as to supply the current Is continuously during said time period T in discharge mode, the number k being such that 2 < k < N, the number K meeting the following conditions:SVG {EMBED HERE} 0.190.33Imax,i < IsandSVG {EMBED HERE} 0.190.30Imax,i Is;

said management circuit for managing said electrical energy storage or production cells B1 comprising:
blocks M1 of rank i for controlling the electrical energy storage or production cells B1, each electrical energy storage or production cell B1 being coupled to a block M1, each cell B1 coupled to a block Mi being capable of delivering an output current L, ; SVG {EMBED HERE} 0.2572.54
the set of said blocks M1 generating \[\[an\]\] said output current Is which is equal to the sum of the output currents L, said blocks Mibeing configured to selectively address \[\[an\]\] the associated electrical energy storage or production cells B1, \* wherein the assembly operates with an output voltage Vs, each block (M) comprising a switched-mode converter having a setpoint voltage and able to supply:
a current at output when the output voltage Vs is lower than said setpoint voltage, in order to keep the output voltage Vs at the setpoint voltage, and
a zero current when the output voltage Vs is greater than this setpoint.

2-5. Canceled.34

6\. (Original) The assembly according to Claim 1, comprising electrical energy storage or production cells having different electrical capacity values.
7\. (Original) The assembly according to Claim \[\[3\]\] 1, wherein the electrical energy storage or production cells have electrical capacity values that decrease according to the rank i.

8\. (Previously Presented) The assembly according to Claim 1, wherein the management circuit comprises means for placing all of the cells in parallel in recharge mode, corresponding to a negative output current -Is.
9\. (Previously Presented) The assembly according to Claim 1, wherein the management circuit comprises means, in recharge mode, corresponding to a negative output current -Is, for discharging the cells of high rank as a priority, from rank N to rank 1.

10\. (Original) The assembly according to Claim 1, wherein the elementary electrical energy storage or production cells are batteries.

11\. (Original) The assembly according to Claim 1, wherein the elementary electrical energy storage or production cells are microbatteries.

12\. (Original) The assembly according to Claim 1, wherein the elementary electrical energy storage or production cells are hydrogen fuel cells.

13\. (Original) The assembly according to Claim 11, wherein the microbatteries and the management circuit are contained in a 3D stack.

14 (New) The assembly according to claim 1, further comprising an estimator configured to estimate said maximal current Imaxi per instant time.

15\. (New) An assembly for delivering an output current Is, comprising:N electrical energy storage or production cells B1 of rank i, where N>2, each cell comprising an elementary cell or an elementary assembly of elementary cells CE arranged in series and/or in parallel, each electrical energy storage or production cell being able to supply a maximum current Imax,i continuously during a time period T;

a management circuit for managing said electrical energy storage or production cells B1, wherein said electrical energy storage or production cells are ordered according to their rank i in decreasing priority order of use,
wherein a production cell B1 is able to provide a maximum current Imax,i at any time t,
said management circuit comprises means, in discharge mode, for discharging at least the electrical energy storage or production cell of rank 1 or the electrical energy storage or production cells according to their rank i and according to the following criteria:
the discharge of the electrical energy storage or production cell Bi of rank 1 is activated:
if the electrical energy storage or production cell Bi of rank 1 is able to supply an output current Is, where Imax,1>Is, ,only the electrical energy storage or production cell Bi of rank 1 is discharged;otherwise, if Imax,1 said management circuit for managing said electrical energy storage or production cells B1 comprising:
blocks Mi of rank i for controlling the electrical energy storage or production cells B1, each electrical energy storage or production cell B1 being coupled to a block M1, each cell B1 coupled to a block Mi being capable of delivering an output current L,
the set of said blocks Mi generating said output current Is which is equal to the sum of the output currents L, the blocks Mi being configured to selectively address the associated electrical energy storage or production cells B1,
wherein each block M1 comprises a regulator with a reference output voltage Uthi, wherein the assembly operates with an output voltage Vs, the regulator of each block M operating with a voltage threshold Uthi, and the voltage thresholds of the regulators of the blocks Mi being such that Uth2 >Uth3 >... > UthN, and
wherein in discharge mode:

the cell of rank 1, B1, is first activated by the management circuit if Vs> Uth2;
and for each index i different from 1:a next cell B1+1 is activated in addition to the cells of lower rank B1+B2+ . . . B1, when Vs wherein when the voltage Vs > Uthi-1, the cell of highest rank is disconnected, and only B1, ..., B1-1 are connected.

16\. (New) An assembly for delivering an output current Is, comprising:N electrical energy storage or production cells B1 of rank i, where N>2, each cell comprising an elementary cell or an elementary assembly of elementary cells CE arranged in series and/or in parallel, each electrical energy storage or production cell being able to supply a maximum current Imax,i continuously during a time period T;
a management circuit for managing said electrical energy storage or production cells B1, wherein said electrical energy storage or production cells are ordered according to their rank i in decreasing priority order of use,
wherein a production cell B1 is able to provide a maximum current Imax,i at any time t,
said management circuit comprises means, in discharge mode, for discharging at least the electrical energy storage or production cell of rank 1 or the electrical energy storage or production cells according to their rank i and according to the following criteria:
the discharge of the electrical energy storage or production cell Bi of rank 1 is activated:
if the electrical energy storage or production cell Bi of rank 1 is able to supply an output current Is, where Imax,1>Is, ,only the electrical energy storage or production cell Bi of rank 1 is discharged;otherwise, if Imax,1

said management circuit for managing said electrical energy storage or production cells B1 comprising:
blocks Mi of rank i for controlling the electrical energy storage or production cells B1, each electrical energy storage or production cell B1 being coupled to a block M1, each cell B1 coupled to a block Mi being capable of delivering an output current L,
the set of said blocks Mi generating said output current Is which is equal to the sum of the output currents L, the blocks Mi being configured to selectively address the associated electrical energy storage or production cells B1,
wherein each electrical energy storage or production cells B1 is coupled to a switch K1, wherein the assembly operates with an output voltage Vs, the output voltage Vs being comprised between a lower voltage Uow and an upper voltage Uhigh,
wherein a next cell (B1+1) is activated in discharge mode each time the output voltage Vs drops below Uiom; and
wherein if the output voltage Vs is strictly higher than UHigh, the connected cell having the highest index is disconnected.

17\. (New) The assembly of claim 16, wherein following the incrementing or decrementing of the number of connected cells, a waiting period is applied to stabilize the output voltage Vs.

OFFICE ACTION:
DETAILED ACTION
Notice of Pre-AIA  or AIA  Status
The present application, filed on or after March 16, 2013, is being examined under the first inventor to file provisions of the AIA .
Status of Claims
This Office Action is in response to the application filed on 8/19/2024.  Claims 1, and 6-17 are presently pending and are presented for examination.
Response to arguments
Applicant amended claims 1, cancelled claims 2-5 and added claims 14-17 which changes the scope of the claims and as such a new ground of rejection is issued.
In regards to the 103 rejection of Claim(s) 1 and similarly claim 16 Applicant asserts (pg. 9-10):
The cited combination of references does not teach or suggest at least these features of amended.
And further asserts (pg. 11):
Although Jhunjhunwala relates to the same general field (battery management), Jhunjhunwala describes a battery management approach that is different from the battery management approach as claimed in amended claim 1.
In response:
Examiner respectfully disagrees. As seen in the rejection of claim 1, Examiner does not rely on Jhunjhunwala but the combined teachings of Jhunjhunwala, Okui, and Martin to teach claim language of claims 1 and 16 as specified below.
In regards to the 103 rejection of Claim(s) 1 and similarly claim 16 Applicant further asserts (claim 12):
However, although Jhunjhunwala relates to management of battery usage, Jhunjhunwala fails to disclose or suggest the features of amended claim 1 according to which: the discharge of the electrical energy storage or production cell B1 of rank 1 is activated: if the electrical energy storage or production cell B1 of rank 1 is able to supply an output current Is, where lmax,1 >Is , only the electrical energy storage or production cell B1 of rank 1 is discharged;…”
In response:
Jhunjhunwala, Okui, and Martin to teach claim language of claims 1 and 16 as specified below
Specifically, The Examiner uses Jhunjhunwala to disclose the discharge of the electrical energy storage or production cell B1 of rank 1 is activated ([0046] - [0049] Fig. 8 At step 804):
if the electrical energy storage or production cell Bi of rank 1 is able to supply an output current Is, wherein Imax,1 > Is (load current, IL identified as Is), only the electrical energy storage or production cell Bi of rank 1 is discharged ([0046] - [0049] Fig. 8 At step 804, if the current requirement of the load (IL) is less than the lower threshold (It1), then battery bank B1 is selected for use at step 806. It1 can be the maximum current that can be drawn from B1 alone).
In regards to the 103 rejection of Claim(s) 1 and similarly claim 16 Applicant further asserts (pg.12-13):
Also notably missing from Jhunjhunwala is the exploitation of a priority order of use of the electrical energy storage or production cells and the features of claim 1 as amended according to which the management circuit for managing the electrical energy storage or production cells Bi comprises: blocks Mi of rank i for controlling the electrical energy storage or production cells Bi, each electrical energy storage or production cell Bi being coupled to a block Mi, each cell Bi coupled to a block Mi being capable of delivering an output current L, the set of said blocks Mi generating said output current Is which is equal to the sum of the output currents L, the blocks Mi being configured to selectively address the associated electrical energy storage or production cells Bi, wherein the assembly operates with an output voltage Vs, each block (Mi) comprising a switched-mode converter having a setpoint voltage and able to supply: a current at output when the output voltage Vs is lower than said setpoint voltage, in order to keep the output voltage Vs at the setpoint voltage, and a zero current when the output voltage Vs is greater than this setpoint.
In response:
Examiner respectfully disagree in regards to Applicants remark “Also notably missing from Jhunjhunwala is the exploitation of a priority order of use of the electrical energy storage or production cells”, as seen below, the Examiner use Jhunjhunwala to teach claim language “wherein said electrical energy storage or production cells are ordered according to their rank in decreasing priority order of use ([0026] Fig. 3A-3B,5 Battery Banks 1021-102N, are configured to be used/discharged in a sequence based on pre-defined priorities for the usage of the battery banks, where a bank is drained as per set limit before a subsequent bank is used)”.
Additionally, the Examiner uses the combined teachings of Jhunjhunwala, Okui, Martin to teach claim language of claim 1 as specified below.
Specifically, Jhunjhunwala further discloses a block Mi of rank i for controlling the electrical energy storage or production cells Bi ([0046] the battery bank selector 704 is a logic unit as shown in FIG. 5 with the additional functionality to select multiple battery banks. i.e. logic control unit 504 and a switching mechanism shown in 502), each electrical energy storage or production cell Bi being coupled to the block Mi, each cell Bi coupled to the block Mi being capable of delivering an output current Ii (Fig. 5 Each battery bank coupled to power conditioning element. [0026] FIG. 3A, 3B and Fig. 8),
Block Mi generating said output current Is which is equal to the sum of the output currents Ii ([0048]-[0049]  Fig. 8), block Mi being configured to selectively address the associated electrical energy storage or production cells Bi (Fig. 7 battery bank selector 704 is a logic unit as shown in FIG. 5 (element 400 and Control 504) with the additional functionality to select multiple battery banks based on pre-configured power harnessing modes, and individual parameter specific thresholds. The logic control and splitting of battery (i.e Fig. 5) can be pre-configured based on anticipated usage patterns/priorities. [0038] [0046] [0042]).
Jhunjhunwala further discloses wherein the assembly operates with an output voltage Vs (output voltage of across the load 506/706).
Okui teaches a management circuit for managing said electrical energy storage or production cells Bi comprising multiple blocks Mi of rank i, each electrical energy storage or production cell Bi being coupled to a block Mi,  wherein each cell Bi coupled to a block Mi being capable of delivering an output current Ii (Fig. 2 battery banks 210 with corresponding converters 220. A priority order between the battery banks is determined and at least some of the battery banks to be discharged based on the priority order. The distribution controller 230 controls the DC/DC converters 220 so that some of the battery banks 210 perform the discharging according to the target charging/discharging amount. ([0046] [0050]) As such, since the converters facilitate the discharging of their corresponding battery bank, the converters 22 have the same priority rank order (rank i) as the prioritized battery banks they are connected to), and that set of said blocks Mi generating an the output current (Is) equal to the sum of the output currents Ii ([0050] battery banks 210 are connected to a common node. The battery banks 210 may be connected to one another in parallel via the DC/DC converters 220. Based on scientific principle, the sum of currents in parallel add at a single node).
Martin teaches a block (M,  Fig.12 1245) comprising a switched-mode converter (Fig. 12 power supply circuit 1245. [0120] … the transient controller 1210 portion of controller circuit 1206 can … initiate successive, rapid opening and closing of element 1272) having a setpoint voltage ([0019]…threshold value) and able to supply: a current at output when the output voltage Vs (Fig. 12 voltage 1220) is lower than said setpoint voltage, in order to keep the output voltage Vs at the setpoint voltage ([0119]- [0120] In response to a more drastic drooping of voltage 1220 as a result of increased power consumption (i.e. Vs < setpoint voltage) , the controller circuit 1206 enables transient controller 1210 to generate respective control signals to activate dynamic power supply circuit 1245 at a same time the voltage regulator circuit 1255 is enabled to supply power to the load. Accordingly, when load 1218 suddenly requires a substantial increase in power, the controller circuit 1206 deploys transient controller 1210 to prevent drooping of voltage 1220 by supplementing an amount of load voltage power (e.g., current) conveyed to load 1218).
Jhunjhunwala in view of Okui in view of Martin does not specifically teach a zero current when the output voltage Vs (voltage across the load) is greater than this setpoint (i.e. greater than the output voltage of the converter).
However it would be obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art to provide zero current when the load/battery has charged to a higher voltage than the setpoint voltage (i.e. greater than the output voltage of the converter) indicating a fully charged battery, thereby preventing overcharging.
And further asserts (pg.13):
“Jhunjhunwala is clearly silent about the use of the blocks Mi as claimed to optimally manage usage of the electrical energy storage or production cells Bi.”
In response:
Claims 1, 15 and 16 does not claim the blocks Mi “optimally manag[ing] usage of the electrical energy storage or production cells Bi.”
In regards to the 103 rejection of Claim(s) 1 and similarly claim 16 Applicant further asserts (pg. 13):
Okui relates to an energy storage system using a battery system, which does not disclose either the above features of amended claim 1.
And further asserts (pg. 13):
However, Okui is silent about the above noted features of amended claim 1. Accordingly, amended claim 1 is not anticipated by Okui.
Applicant further asserts (pg. 13):
Assuming that the skilled person had tried to combine Jhunjhunwala and Okui references to solve the above problem, he would not have arrived to the features of amended claim 1, none Jhunjhunwala and Okui teach or suggest the above noted features of amended claim 1.
In response:
Examiner respectfully disagree and points to the rejection of claim 1 where the Examiner does not use Okui alone but the combined teachings of Jhunjhunwala, Okui and Martin to teach the claim language of claims 1 and 16 as specified below.
In regards to applicants remaining remarks:
Applicant remarks have been considered but are moot base on new grounds of rejection.
Claim Objection
Claim 15 and 16 are objected to due to the following informalities:
Claim 15-16 recites “Is, ,only” wherein two (2) commas are placed. Examiner will interpret as “Is,only”
Correction is required.
Claim Rejections - 35 USC § 112
The following is a quotation of the first paragraph of 35 U.S.C. 112(a):
(a) IN GENERAL.—The specification shall contain a written description of the invention, and of the manner and process of making and using it, in such full, clear, concise, and exact terms as to enable any person skilled in the art to which it pertains, or with which it is most nearly connected, to make and use the same, and shall set forth the best mode contemplated by the inventor or joint inventor of carrying out the invention.
The following is a quotation of the first paragraph of pre-AIA  35 U.S.C. 112:
The specification shall contain a written description of the invention, and of the manner and process of making and using it, in such full, clear, concise, and exact terms as to enable any person skilled in the art to which it pertains, or with which it is most nearly connected, to make and use the same, and shall set forth the best mode contemplated by the inventor of carrying out his invention.
Claim 17 is rejected under 35 U.S.C. 112(a) or 35 U.S.C. 112 (pre-AIA ), first paragraph, as failing to comply with the written description requirement. The claim(s) contains subject matter which was not described in the specification in such a way as to reasonably convey to one skilled in the relevant art that the inventor or a joint inventor, or for applications subject to pre-AIA  35 U.S.C. 112, the inventor(s), at the time the application was filed, had possession of the claimed invention.
The following is a quotation of 35 U.S.C. 112 (b), second paragraph:
The specification shall conclude with one or more claims particularly pointing out and distinctly claiming the subject matter which the applicant regards as his invention.
Claims 17 is/are rejected under 35 U.S.C. 112(b) or 35 U.S.C. 112 (pre-AIA ), second paragraph, as being indefinite for failing to particularly point out and distinctly claim the subject matter which the inventor or a joint inventor, or for pre-AIA  the applicant regards as the invention.
Claim 17 recites “wherein following the incrementing or decrementing of the number of connected cells” which lacks antecedent basis and is unclear. An incrementing or decrementing of the number of connected cells is not claimed in claim 16 from which it depends.
Examiner will interpret as “following an incrementing or decrementing of the number of connected cells”.
Claim Rejections - 35 USC § 103
The following is a quotation of 35 U.S.C. 103 which forms the basis for all obviousness rejections set forth in this Office action:
A patent for a claimed invention may not be obtained, notwithstanding that the claimed invention is not identically disclosed as set forth in section 102, if the differences between the claimed invention and the prior art are such that the claimed invention as a whole would have been obvious before the effective filing date of the claimed invention to a person having ordinary skill in the art to which the claimed invention pertains. Patentability shall not be negated by the manner in which the invention was made.
Claims 1, 6-10,14  and 16 is/are rejected under 35 U.S.C. 103 as being unpatentable over Jhunjhunwala (US 20170229880) in view of Okui (US 20160226268) in view of Martin (US 20080157743).
As to claim 1, Jhunjhunwala discloses an assembly (Fig. 7) for delivering an output current Is ([0047] IL refers to the current demanded by the load), comprising:
N electrical energy storage or production cells Bi of rank i ([0026] Fig. 3A-3B,5,7 Battery Banks 1021-102N, The battery banks 1021-N are configured to be used/discharged in a sequence based on pre-defined priorities for the usage of the battery banks, where a bank is drained as per set limit before a subsequent bank is used), where N>2, each cell comprising an elementary cell or an elementary assembly of elementary cells CEij arranged in series and/or in parallel (Fig. 5 and 7 and [0021] … multiple banks of individual batteries. Banks are placed in parallel), each electrical energy storage or production cell being able to supply a maximum current lmaxi continuously during a time period T ([0026] Fig. 3A-3B Battery Banks 1021-102N, the battery banks 1021-N are configured to be used/discharged in a sequence … where a bank is drained as per set limit before a subsequent bank is used. As such each battery supplies it’s Imaxi).
Jhunjhunwala further discloses a management circuit (Fig. 7 battery bank selector 704) for managing said electrical energy storage or production cells Bi (Fig. 7 battery bank selector 704 is a logic unit as shown in FIG. 5 (element 400 and Control 504) with the additional functionality to select multiple battery banks based on pre-configured power harnessing modes and individual parameter specific thresholds. The logic control and splitting of battery (i.e Fig. 5) can be pre-configured based on anticipated usage patterns/priorities. [0038] [0046] [0042]), wherein said electrical energy storage or production cells are ordered according to their rank in decreasing priority order of use ([0026] Fig. 3A-3B,5 Battery Banks 1021-102N, are configured to be used/discharged in a sequence based on pre-defined priorities for the usage of the battery banks, where a bank is drained as per set limit before a subsequent bank is used),
wherein a production cell Bi is able to provide a maximum current Imax,i at any time t ([0048]-[0049]  Fig. 8 at step 812, if current required by load (IL) is greater than the upper current threshold (It2) then at step 814, B1, B2, and B3 are selected. It1 is the maximum current that can be drawn from B1 alone, and It2 can be the maximum current that can be drawn from B1 and B2 combined. As such all cells are configured to supply its individual maximum current “Imax,i”), said management circuit comprises means, in discharge mode, for (Fig. 7 battery bank selector 704 and Control 504 of Fig. 5),  discharging at least the electrical energy storage or production cell of rank 1 or the electrical energy storage or production cells according to their rank i ([0026] Fig. 3A-3B,5,7-8 where selector 704 selects a single or multiple Battery Banks 1021-102N, to discharge to a load) and according to the following criteria:
the discharge of the electrical energy storage or production cell B1 of rank 1 is activated ([0046] - [0049] Fig. 8 At step 804):
if the electrical energy storage or production cell Bi of rank 1 is able to supply an output current Is, wherein Imax,1 > Is (load current, IL identified as Is), only the electrical energy storage or production cell Bi of rank 1 is discharged ([0046] - [0049] Fig. 8 At step 804, if the current requirement of the load (IL) is less than the lower threshold (It1), then battery bank B1 is selected for use at step 806. It1 can be the maximum current that can be drawn from B1 alone).
Jhunjhunwala further discloses said management circuit for managing said electrical energy storage or production cells Bi comprising:
A block Mi of rank i for controlling the electrical energy storage or production cells Bi ([0046] the battery bank selector 704 is a logic unit as shown in FIG. 5 with the additional functionality to select multiple battery banks. i.e. logic control unit 504 and a switching mechanism shown in 502), each electrical energy storage or production cell Bi being coupled to the block Mi, each cell Bi coupled to the block Mi being capable of delivering an output current Ii (Fig. 5 Each battery bank coupled to power conditioning element. [0026] FIG. 3A, 3B and Fig. 8),
Block Mi generating said output current Is which is equal to the sum of the output currents Ii ([0048]-[0049]  Fig. 8), block Mi being configured to selectively address the associated electrical energy storage or production cells Bi (Fig. 7 battery bank selector 704 is a logic unit as shown in FIG. 5 (element 400 and Control 504) with the additional functionality to select multiple battery banks based on pre-configured power harnessing modes, and individual parameter specific thresholds. The logic control and splitting of battery (i.e Fig. 5) can be pre-configured based on anticipated usage patterns/priorities. [0038] [0046] [0042]).
Jhunjhunwala further discloses wherein the assembly operates with an output voltage Vs (output voltage of across the load 506/706).
Jhunjhunwala does not specifically state that the block Mi ([0046] the battery bank selector 704 is a logic unit as shown in FIG. 5) is multiple blocks (Mi) of rank i, each electrical energy storage or production cell Bi being coupled to a block Mi, wherein each cell Bi coupled to a block Mi being capable of delivering an output current Ii and that set of said blocks Mi generating an the output current (Is) equal to the sum of the output currents Ii.
Okui teaches a management circuit for managing said electrical energy storage or production cells Bi comprising multiple blocks Mi of rank i, each electrical energy storage or production cell Bi being coupled to a block Mi,  wherein each cell Bi coupled to a block Mi being capable of delivering an output current Ii (Fig. 2 battery banks 210 with corresponding converters 220. A priority order between the battery banks is determined and at least some of the battery banks to be discharged based on the priority order. The distribution controller 230 controls the DC/DC converters 220 so that some of the battery banks 210 perform the discharging according to the target charging/discharging amount ([0046] [0050]).  As such, since the converters facilitate the discharging of their corresponding battery bank, the converters 22 have the same priority rank order (rank i) as the prioritized battery banks they are connected to), and that set of said blocks Mi generating an the output current (Is) equal to the sum of the output currents Ii ([0050] battery banks 210 are connected to a common node. The battery banks 210 may be connected to one another in parallel via the DC/DC converters 220. Based on scientific principle, the sum of currents in parallel add at a single node).
It would have been obvious to a person of ordinary skill in the art to modify the management circuit of Jhunjhunwala to comprise multiple blocks (Mi) of rank i, each electrical energy storage or production cell Bi being coupled to a block Mi, wherein each cell Bi coupled to a block Mi being capable of delivering an output current Ii and that set of said blocks Mi generating an the output current (Is) equal to the sum of the output currents Ii in order to provide a voltage level that is suitable for the load while allowing some of the battery banks to perform the discharging while pausing others ([0050] of Okui).
Jhunjhunwala in view of Okui does not disclose/teach each block (M) comprising a switched-mode converter having a setpoint voltage and able to supply: a current at output when the output voltage Vs is lower than said setpoint voltage, in order to keep the output voltage Vs at the setpoint voltage, and a zero current when the output voltage Vs is greater than this setpoint.
Martin teaches a block (M,  Fig.12 1245) comprising a switched-mode converter (Fig. 12 power supply circuit 1245. [0120] … the transient controller 1210 portion of controller circuit 1206 can … initiate successive, rapid opening and closing of element 1272) having a setpoint voltage ([0019]…threshold value) and able to supply: a current at output when the output voltage Vs (Fig. 12 voltage 1220) is lower than said setpoint voltage, in order to keep the output voltage Vs at the setpoint voltage ([0119]- [0120] In response to a more drastic drooping of voltage 1220 as a result of increased power consumption (i.e. Vs < setpoint voltage) , the controller circuit 1206 enables transient controller 1210 to generate respective control signals to activate dynamic power supply circuit 1245 at a same time the voltage regulator circuit 1255 is enabled to supply power to the load. Accordingly, when load 1218 suddenly requires a substantial increase in power, the controller circuit 1206 deploys transient controller 1210 to prevent drooping of voltage 1220 by supplementing an amount of load voltage power (e.g., current) conveyed to load 1218).
It would have been obvious to a person of ordinary skill in the art to modify each block (Mi) of Jhunjhunwala in view of Okui to comprise a switched-mode converter having a setpoint voltage and able to supply: a current at output when the output voltage Vs is lower than said setpoint voltage, in order to keep the output voltage at a substantially constant value in the event of a load transient ([0123] of Martin).
Jhunjhunwala in view of Okui in view of Martin does not specifically teach a zero current when the output voltage Vs (voltage across the load) is greater than this setpoint (i.e. greater than the output voltage of the converter).
However it would be obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art to provide zero current when the load/battery has charged to a higher voltage than the setpoint voltage (i.e. greater than the output voltage of the converter) indicating a fully charged battery, thereby preventing overcharging.
As to claim 6, Jhunjhunwala in view of Okui in view of Martin teaches the assembly according to Claim 1, comprising electrical energy storage or production cells having different electrical capacity values (Abstract …each of which may have different characteristics).
As to claim 7, Jhunjhunwala in view of Okui in view of Martin teaches the assembly according to Claim 1.
Jhunjhunwala does not disclose/teach wherein the electrical energy storage or production cells have electrical capacity values that decrease according to the rank i.
Okui teaches wherein the electrical energy storage or production cells have electrical capacity values that decrease according to the rank i. ([0086] In the case of the discharging mode, the distribution controller may determine the priority order between the battery banks so that the battery bank having higher SOC and higher SOH may have higher priority (operation S66). The battery bank having a higher SOC may be more likely to be discharged than the battery bank having a lower SOC. The battery bank having a higher SOH may be more likely to be discharged than the battery bank having a lower SOH.
It would have been obvious to a person of ordinary skill in the art to modify the assembly of Jhunjhunwala to include wherein the electrical energy storage or production cells have electrical capacity values that decrease according to the rank I, as taught by Okui in order to preserve the state of health for each battery by maintaining the SOC of each battery at a level that reduces deterioration.
As to claim 8,  Jhunjhunwala in view of Okui in view of Martin teaches the assembly according to Claim 1, wherein the management circuit comprises means, for placing all of the cells in parallel in recharge mode, corresponding to a negative output current -Is (Fig. 5 of Jhunjhunwala all battery modules are in parallel and are charged and discharged in said configuration [0026]).
As to claim 9,  Jhunjhunwala in view of Okui in view of Martin teaches the assembly according to Claim 1, wherein the management circuit comprises means, in recharge mode, corresponding to a negative output current -Is, for discharging the cells of high rank as a priority, from rank N to rank 1 ([0026] and Fig. 3A of Jhunjhunwala battery banks are configured to be used/discharged in a sequence based on pre-defined priorities for the usage of the battery banks, where a bank is drained as per set limit before a subsequent bank is used. First battery bank 102 that is discharged first is charged first) .
As to claim 10, Jhunjhunwala in view of Okui in view of Martin teaches the assembly according to Claim 1, wherein the elementary electrical energy storage or production cells are batteries (Fig. 1 of Jhunjhunwala battery banks 102).
As to claim 14, Jhunjhunwala in view of Okui in view of Martin teaches the assembly according to claim 1.
Jhunjhunwala in view of Okui in view of Martin does not explicitly teach an estimator configured to estimate said maximal current Imax,i per instant time.
However, Jhunjhunwala teaches the battery banks are selected based on whether the load requirement (Il is less than or greater than the maximum current of the battery ([0048]-[0049]). Therefore, it would be obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art for Jhunjhunwala to include an estimator configured to estimate said maximal current Imax,i per instant time in order to determine how to select the batteries to meet the load requirement.
As to claim 16, Jhunjhunwala discloses an assembly (Fig. 7) for delivering an output current Is ([0047] IL refers to the current demanded by the load), comprising:
N electrical energy storage or production cells Bi of rank i ([0026] Fig. 3A-3B,5,7 Battery Banks 1021-102N, The battery banks 1021-N are configured to be used/discharged in a sequence based on pre-defined priorities for the usage of the battery banks, where a bank is drained as per set limit before a subsequent bank is used), where N>2, each cell comprising an elementary cell or an elementary assembly of elementary cells CEij arranged in series and/or in parallel (Fig. 5 and 7 and [0021] … multiple banks of individual batteries. Banks are placed in parallel), each electrical energy storage or production cell being able to supply a maximum current lmaxi continuously during a time period T ([0026] Fig. 3A-3B Battery Banks 1021-102N, the battery banks 1021-N are configured to be used/discharged in a sequence … where a bank is drained as per set limit before a subsequent bank is used. As such each battery supplies it’s Imaxi).
Jhunjhunwala further discloses a management circuit (Fig. 7 battery bank selector 704) for managing said electrical energy storage or production cells Bi (Fig. 7 battery bank selector 704 is a logic unit as shown in FIG. 5 (element 400 and Control 504) with the additional functionality to select multiple battery banks based on pre-configured power harnessing modes, and individual parameter specific thresholds. The logic control and splitting of battery (i.e Fig. 5) can be pre-configured based on anticipated usage patterns/priorities. [0038] [0046] [0042]), wherein said electrical energy storage or production cells are ordered according to their rank in decreasing priority order of use ([0026] Fig. 3A-3B,5 Battery Banks 1021-102N, are configured to be used/discharged in a sequence based on pre-defined priorities for the usage of the battery banks, where a bank is drained as per set limit before a subsequent bank is used),
wherein a production cell Bi is able to provide a maximum current Imax,i at any time t ([0048]-[0049]  Fig. 8 at step 812, if current required by load (IL) is greater than the upper current threshold (It2) then at step 814, B1, B2, and B3 are selected. It1 is the maximum current that can be drawn from B1 alone, and It2 can be the maximum current that can be drawn from B1 and B2 combined. As such all cells are configured to supply its individual maximum current “Imax,i”), said management circuit comprises means, in discharge mode, for (Fig. 7 battery bank selector 704 and Control 504 of Fig. 5),  discharging at least the electrical energy storage or production cell of rank 1 or the electrical energy storage or production cells according to their rank i ([0026] Fig. 3A-3B,5,7-8 where selector 704 selects a single or multiple Battery Banks 1021-102N, to discharge to a load) and according to the following criteria:
the discharge of the electrical energy storage or production cell B1 of rank 1 is activated ([0046] - [0049] Fig. 8 At step 804):
if the electrical energy storage or production cell Bi of rank 1 is able to supply an output current Is, wherein Imax,1 > Is (load current, IL identified as Is), only the electrical energy storage or production cell Bi of rank 1 is discharged ([0046] - [0049] Fig. 8 At step 804, if the current requirement of the load (IL) is less than the lower threshold (It1), then battery bank B1 is selected for use at step 806. It1 can be the maximum current that can be drawn from B1 alone).
Jhunjhunwala further discloses said management circuit for managing said electrical energy storage or production cells Bi comprising:
A block Mi of rank i for controlling the electrical energy storage or production cells Bi ([0046] the battery bank selector 704 is a logic unit as shown in FIG. 5 with the additional functionality to select multiple battery banks. i.e. logic control unit 504 and a switching mechanism shown in 502), each electrical energy storage or production cell Bi being coupled to the block Mi, each cell Bi coupled to the block Mi being capable of delivering an output current Ii (Fig. 5 Each battery bank coupled to power conditioning element. [0026] FIG. 3A, 3B and Fig. 8),
Block Mi generating said output current Is which is equal to the sum of the output currents Ii ([0048]-[0049]  Fig. 8), block Mi being configured to selectively address the associated electrical energy storage or production cells Bi (Fig. 7 battery bank selector 704 is a logic unit as shown in FIG. 5 (element 400 and Control 504) with the additional functionality to select multiple battery banks based on pre-configured power harnessing modes, and individual parameter specific thresholds. The logic control and splitting of battery (i.e Fig. 5) can be pre-configured based on anticipated usage patterns/priorities. [0038] [0046] [0042]).
Jhunjhunwala further discloses wherein the assembly operates with an output voltage Vs (output voltage of across the load 506/706).
Jhunjhunwala does not specifically state that the block Mi ([0046] the battery bank selector 704 is a logic unit as shown in FIG. 5) is multiple blocks (Mi) of rank i, each electrical energy storage or production cell Bi being coupled to a block Mi, wherein each cell Bi coupled to a block Mi being capable of delivering an output current Ii and that set of said blocks Mi generating an the output current (Is) equal to the sum of the output currents Ii.
Okui teaches a management circuit for managing said electrical energy storage or production cells Bi comprising multiple blocks Mi of rank i, each electrical energy storage or production cell Bi being coupled to a block Mi,  wherein each cell Bi coupled to a block Mi being capable of delivering an output current Ii (Fig. 2 battery banks 210 with corresponding converters 220. A priority order between the battery banks is determined and at least some of the battery banks to be discharged based on the priority order. The distribution controller 230 controls the DC/DC converters 220 so that some of the battery banks 210 perform the discharging according to the target charging/discharging amount. ([0046] [0050]) As such, since the converters facilitate the discharging of their corresponding battery bank, the converters 22 have the same priority rank order (rank i) as the prioritized battery banks they are connected to), and that set of said blocks Mi generating an the output current (Is) equal to the sum of the output currents Ii ([0050] battery banks 210 are connected to a common node. The battery banks 210 may be connected to one another in parallel via the DC/DC converters 220. Based on scientific principle, the sum of currents in parallel add at a single node).
It would have been obvious to a person of ordinary skill in the art to modify the management circuit of Jhunjhunwala to comprise multiple blocks (Mi) of rank i, each electrical energy storage or production cell Bi being coupled to a block Mi, wherein each cell Bi coupled to a block Mi being capable of delivering an output current Ii and that set of said blocks Mi generating an the output current (Is) equal to the sum of the output currents Ii in order to provide a voltage level that is suitable for the load while allowing some of the battery banks to perform the discharging while pausing others ([0050] of Okui).
Jhunjhunwala in view of Okui does not disclose/teach wherein each electrical energy storage or production cells B1 is coupled to a switch K1, the output voltage Vs being comprised between a lower voltage Ulow and an upper voltage Uhigh, wherein a next cell (B1+1) is activated in discharge mode each time the output voltage Vs drops below Ulow; and wherein if the output voltage Vs is strictly higher than Uhigh, the connected cell having the highest index is disconnected.
Martin teaches wherein a voltage source is coupled to a switch K1 (switches 1272 and 1282), the output voltage Vs (load 1218 and corresponding load voltage) being comprised between a lower voltage Ulow ([0019]…threshold value) and an upper voltage Uhigh (Vs) wherein a next cell (B1+1) is activated in discharge mode each time the output voltage Vs drops below Ulow  ([0119]- [0120] In response to a more drastic drooping of voltage 1220 as a result of increased power consumption (i.e. Vs < setpoint voltage) , the controller circuit 1206 enables transient controller 1210 to generate respective control signals to activate dynamic power supply circuit 1245 at a same time the voltage regulator circuit 1255 is enabled to supply power to the load. Accordingly, when load 1218 suddenly requires a substantial increase in power, the controller circuit 1206 deploys transient controller 1210 to prevent drooping of voltage 1220 by supplementing an amount of power (e.g., current) conveyed to load 1218).
It would have been obvious to a person of ordinary skill in the art to modify the assembly for delivering an output current to include wherein each electrical energy storage or production cells B1 is coupled to a switch K1, the output voltage Vs being comprised between a lower voltage Ulow and an upper voltage Uhigh, wherein a next cell (B1+1) is activated in discharge mode each time the output voltage Vs drops below Ulow in order to keep the output voltage at a substantially constant value in the event of a load transient ([0123] of Martin).
Jhunjhunwala in view of Okui in view of Martin does not specifically teach wherein if the output voltage Vs (voltage across the load)  is strictly higher than Uhigh, the connected cell having the highest index is disconnected (i.e. greater than the output voltage of the converter).
However it would be obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art to disconnect all connected cells (including the connected cell having the highest index) when the load/battery has charged to a higher voltage than Uhigh indicating a fully charged battery, thereby preventing overcharging
Claims 11 and 13 is/are rejected under 35 U.S.C. 103 as being unpatentable over Jhunjhunwala (US 20170229880) in view of Okui (US 20160226268) in view of  Martin (US 20080157743) in view of Rothschild (US 20190027943).
As to claim 11,  Jhunjhunwala in view of Okui in view of Martin teaches the assembly according to Claim 1.
Jhunjhunwala in view of Okui in view of Martin teaches each battery bank is multiple banks of individual batteries ([0021]), Jhunjhunwala in view of Okui in view of Martin does not specifically teach the elementary electrical energy storage or production cells (each battery bank) are micro batteries.
Rothschild teaches elementary electrical energy storage or production cells are micro batteries ([0017] The rectifier 102 may be connected to the battery unit 104. The battery unit 104 may comprise a plurality of micro-batteries (B1, B2, B3 . . . Bn).
It would have been obvious to a person of ordinary skill in the art to modify the elementary electrical energy storage or production cells of Jhunjhunwala  in view of Okui to be micro batteries, in order to reduce the physical size of Jhunjhunwala battery pack.
As to claim 13,  Jhunjhunwala in view of Okui in view of Martin teaches the assembly according to Claim 11.
Jhunjhunwala in view of Okui in view of Martin in view of Rothschild does not specifically teach wherein the micro batteries and the management circuit are contained in a 3D stack.
However it would be obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art to contain the micro batteries and the management circuit taught by Jhunjhunwala in view of Okui in view of Rothschild in a 3D stack in order to reduce the space of the assembly.
Claim 12 is/are rejected under 35 U.S.C. 103 as being unpatentable over Jhunjhunwala (US 20170229880) in view of Okui (US 20160226268) in view of  Martin (US 20080157743) in view of Despesse (US 20140287278)
As to claim 12, Jhunjhunwala in view of Okui in view of Martin teaches the assembly according to Claim 1.
Jhunjhunwala in view of Okui in view of Martin does not specifically teach wherein the elementary electrical energy storage or production cells are hydrogen fuel cells.
Despesse teaches elementary electrical energy storage or production cells are hydrogen fuel c]ells ([0239] hydrogen fuel cell).
It would have been obvious to a person of ordinary skill in the art to modify the assembly of Jhunjhunwala  in view of Okui to include elementary electrical energy storage or production cells to be hydrogen fuel cell, as taught by Despesse in order to apply Jhunjhunwala  method to applications using hydrogen fuel cells in order to optimizes at least one of cost, weight or size of the overall system (Abstract of Jhunjhunwala).
Claim 17 is/are rejected under 35 U.S.C. 103 as being unpatentable over Jhunjhunwala (US 20170229880) in view of Okui (US 20160226268) in view of Martin (US 20080157743) in view of Rush (US 20160043580).
As to claim 17, Jhunjhunwala in view of Okui in view of Martin teaches the assembly of claim 16.
Jhunjhunwala in view of Okui in view of Martin does not specifically teach wherein following the incrementing or decrementing (interpreted as “wherein following an incrementing or decrementing) of the number of connected cells, a waiting period is applied to stabilize the output voltage Vs.
Rush teaches wherein following the incrementing or decrementing of the number of connected cells, a waiting period is applied to stabilize the output voltage Vs ([0008] OCV values may be measured, by disconnecting one battery at a time from the load, waiting for the voltage to stabilize, and measuring the voltage with no load).
In the case were Jhunjhunwala load 506/706 is a battery, it would be obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art to modify the assembly of Jhunjhunwala in view of Okui to include wherein following the incrementing or decrementing  of the number of connected cells, a waiting period is applied to stabilize the output voltage Vs in order to measure the OCV value of the load ([0008]).
Allowable Subject Matter
Claim 15 would be allowable if rewritten to overcome the claim objection above.
The following is a statement of reasons for reasons for allowance:
Regarding independent claim(s) 15, although the prior art discloses an assembly for delivering an output current Is, comprising: N electrical energy storage or production cells Bi of rank i, where N2:2, each cell comprising an elementary cell or an elementary assembly of elementary cells CEij arranged in series and/or in parallel, each electrical energy storage or production cell being able to supply a maximum current lmax,i continuously during a time period T;  a management circuit for managing said electrical energy storage or production cells B1, wherein said electrical energy storage or production cells are ordered according to their rank i in decreasing priority order of use, wherein a production cell B1 is able to provide a maximum current Imax,i at any time t, said management circuit comprises means, in discharge mode, for discharging at least the electrical energy storage or production cell of rank 1 or the electrical energy storage or production cells according to their rank i and according to the following criteria: the discharge of the electrical energy storage or production cell Bi of rank 1 is activated: if the electrical energy storage or production cell Bi of rank 1 is able to supply an output current Is, where Imax,1>Is, ,only the electrical energy storage or production cell Bi of rank 1 is discharged; otherwise, if Imax,1
PNG
media_image1.png
50
313
media_image1.png
Greyscale
said management circuit for managing said electrical energy storage or production cells B1 comprising:  blocks Mi of rank i for controlling the electrical energy storage or production cells B1, each electrical energy storage or production cell B1 being coupled to a block M1, each cell B1 coupled to a block Mi being capable of delivering an output current L,  the set of said blocks Mi generating said output current Is which is equal to the sum of the output currents L, the blocks Mi being configured to selectively address the associated electrical energy storage or production cells B1, wherein each block M1 comprises a regulator with a reference output voltage Uthi, wherein the assembly operates with an output voltage Vs, the regulator of each block M operating with a voltage threshold Uthi, and the voltage thresholds of the regulators of the blocks Mi being such that Uth2>Uth3 >...> UthN, the prior art of record does not disclose or teach the combination of:
“wherein in discharge mode: the cell of rank 1, B1, is first activated by the management circuit if Vs> Uth2; and for each index i different from 1: a next cell B1+1 is activated in addition to the cells of lower rank B1+B2+ . . . B1, when VsUthi-1, the cell of highest rank is disconnected, and only B1, ..., Bi-1 are connected”.
Any comments considered necessary by applicant must be submitted no later than the payment of the issue fee and, to avoid processing delays, should preferably accompany the issue fee.  Such submissions should be clearly labeled “Comments on Statement of Reasons for Allowance.”
Conclusion
Applicant's amendment necessitated the new ground(s) of rejection presented in this Office action.  Accordingly, THIS ACTION IS MADE FINAL.  See MPEP § 706.07(a).  Applicant is reminded of the extension of time policy as set forth in 37 CFR 1.136(a).
A shortened statutory period for reply to this final action is set to expire THREE MONTHS from the mailing date of this action.  In the event a first reply is filed within TWO MONTHS of the mailing date of this final action and the advisory action is not mailed until after the end of the THREE-MONTH shortened statutory period, then the shortened statutory period will expire on the date the advisory action is mailed, and any extension fee pursuant to 37 CFR 1.136(a) will be calculated from the mailing date of the advisory action.  In no event, however, will the statutory period for reply expire later than SIX MONTHS from the date of this final action.

APPLICANT REBUTTAL: REMARKSClaims 1 and 6-17 are pending, with claims 1 and 15 being independent.Claims 1, 6-14 and 16-17 stand rejected. Claims 15 and 16 stand objected.Claim 15 is amended. Claims 1, 6-14, and 16-17 are canceled. Claims 18-24 are new. No new subject matter has been added.Allowable Subject Matter Claim 15 is allowable if rewritten to overcome the claim objection. Office Action, at 26.Applicant thanks the Office for indicating allowable subject matter and submits that all claims are in condition for allowance in view of Applicant's remarks and amendments submitted herein.Claim Objections Claims 15 and 16 stand objected to for reciting "Is, ,only" wherein two (2) commas are placed. Office Action, at 8. Claim 15 has been amended to address the claim objection. As such, Applicant submits that claim 15 is in condition for allowance. Claim 16 is canceled.Reconsideration and withdrawal of the claim objections are respectfully requested.Claim Rejections - 35 U.S.C. § 112 Claim 17 stands rejected under 35 U.S.C. § 112(a), first paragraph, as failing to comply with the written description requirement and under 35 U.S.C. § 112(b), second paragraph, as being indefinite for failing to particularly point out and distinctly claim the subject matter. Office Action, at 9. Claim 17 is canceled, rendering the 35 U.S.C. § 112 rejections of claim 17 moot.Claim Rejections - 35 U.S.C. § 103 Claims 1, 6-10, 14 and 16 stand rejected under 35 U.S.C. § 103 as being unpatentable over U.S. Publication No. 2017/0229880 (hereinafter "Jhunjhunwala") in view of U.S.Publication No. 2016/0226268 (hereinafter "Okui") and further in view of U.S. Publication No.2008/0157743 (hereinafter "Martin"). Office Action, at 10. Claims 1, 6-10, 14 and 16 are canceled, rendering the 35 U.S.C. § 103 of claims 1, 6-10, 14 and 16 moot.Claims 11 and 13 stand rejected under 35 U.S.C. § 103 as being unpatentable over Jhunjhunwala in view of Okui in view of Martin and further in view of U.S. Publication No.2019/0027943 (hereinafter "Rothschild"). Office Action, at 23. Claims 11 and 13 are canceled, rendering the 35 U.S.C. § 103 of claims 11 and 13 moot.Claim 12 stands rejected under 35 U.S.C. § 103 as being unpatentable over Jhunjhunwala in view of Okui in view of Martin and further in view of U.S. Publication No. 2014/0287278 (hereinafter "Despesse"). Office Action, at 24. Claim 12 is canceled, rendering the 35 U.S.C. § 103 of claim 12 moot.Claim 17 stands rejected under 35 U.S.C. § 103 as being unpatentable over Jhunjhunwala in view of Okui in view of Martin and further in view of U.S. Publication No. 2016/0043580 (hereinafter "Rush"). Office Action, at 25. Claim 17 is canceled, rendering the 35 U.S.C. § 103 of claim 17 moot.New Claims New claims 18-24, which correspond to now-canceled claims 6, 7, 10-14, depend from amended independent claim 15. The Office has indicated that claim 15, as amended, is allowable. As such, new claims 18-24 are also in condition for allowance based at least on their dependency from amended claim 15.CONCLUSIONApplicant respectfully submits that the present application is in condition for allowance.Reconsideration of the application and an early Notice of Allowance are respectfully requested.In the event that the Examiner cannot allow the application for any reason, the Examiner is encouraged to contact Applicant's representative.Date: March 3, 2025

NEXT OFFICE ACTION: DETAILED ACTION
Notice of Pre-AIA  or AIA  Status
The present application, filed on or after March 16, 2013, is being examined under the first inventor to file provisions of the AIA .
Status of Claims
This Office Action is in response to the application filed on 3/3/2025.  Claims 15, and 18-24 are presently pending and are presented for examination.
Information Disclosure Statement
The information disclosure statement (IDS) submitted on 1/27/2025 is in compliance with the provisions of 37 CFR 1.97.  Accordingly, the information disclosure statement is being considered by the examiner.
Allowable Subject Matter
Claims 15, and 18-24 are allowed.
The following is a statement of reasons for reasons for allowance:
Regarding independent claim(s) 15, although the prior art discloses an assembly for delivering an output current Is, comprising: N electrical energy storage or production cells Bi of rank i, where N2:2, each cell comprising an elementary cell or an elementary assembly of elementary cells CEij arranged in series and/or in parallel, each electrical energy storage or production cell being able to supply a maximum current lmax,i continuously during a time period T;  a management circuit for managing said electrical energy storage or production cells B1, wherein said electrical energy storage or production cells are ordered according to their rank i in decreasing priority order of use, wherein a production cell B1 is able to provide a maximum current Imax,i at any time t, said management circuit comprises means, in discharge mode, for discharging at least the electrical energy storage or production cell of rank 1 or the electrical energy storage or production cells according to their rank i and according to the following criteria: the discharge of the electrical energy storage or production cell Bi of rank 1 is activated: if the electrical energy storage or production cell Bi of rank 1 is able to supply an output current Is, where Imax,1>Is, only the electrical energy storage or production cell Bi of rank 1 is discharged; otherwise, if Imax,1
PNG
media_image1.png
50
313
media_image1.png
Greyscale
said management circuit for managing said electrical energy storage or production cells B1 comprising:  blocks Mi of rank i for controlling the electrical energy storage or production cells B1, each electrical energy storage or production cell B1 being coupled to a block M1, each cell B1 coupled to a block Mi being capable of delivering an output current L,  the set of said blocks Mi generating said output current Is which is equal to the sum of the output currents L, the blocks Mi being configured to selectively address the associated electrical energy storage or production cells B1, wherein each block M1 comprises a regulator with a reference output voltage Uthi, wherein the assembly operates with an output voltage Vs, the regulator of each block M operating with a voltage threshold Uthi, and the voltage thresholds of the regulators of the blocks Mi being such that Uth2>Uth3 >...> UthN, the prior art of record does not disclose or teach the combination of:
“wherein in discharge mode: the cell of rank 1, B1, is first activated by the management circuit if Vs> Uth2; and for each index i different from 1: a next cell Bi+1 is activated in addition to the cells of lower rank B1+B2+ . . . B1, when VsUthi-1, the cell of highest rank is disconnected, and only B1, ..., Bi-1 are connected”.
Any comments considered necessary by applicant must be submitted no later than the payment of the issue fee and, to avoid processing delays, should preferably accompany the issue fee.  Such submissions should be clearly labeled “Comments on Statement of Reasons for Allowance.”
Conclusion and Related art
Chen (US 20240213786) is cited for based on the voltage difference, that the first regulator is to be invoked comprises: when the voltage difference is greater than a first voltage threshold and less than a second voltage threshold, determining that the first regulator is to be invoked, wherein the first voltage threshold is determined based on a maximum allowable voltage difference between the multiple battery clusters, and the second voltage threshold is determined based on a maximum regulating voltage of the first regulator.
However Chen is filed after the effective filing date.

CITED REFERENCE SUMMARIES: Ref US20160043580A1: [content unavailable]
Ref US20170229880: Claims:
1. An energy storage system comprising:
a plurality of battery banks of individual batteries based on split configuration derived by a splitter, wherein split battery configuration of the plurality of banks varies based on a probability distribution function (pdf) of expected usage pattern, optimization goal, and battery characteristics of a corresponding single battery system; and a logic unit, pre-configured with the pdf and connected to the plurality of battery banks, configured to:
obtain performance of each of the battery banks;
select at least one battery bank, from the plurality of battery banks, to provide power to a load based on current performance data of each said battery banks and at least one selection criterion; and
rotate use of battery banks from the plurality of battery banks until next charging opportunity;
wherein the split from a single battery bank is to optimize at least one among cost, weight or size of the system; and
wherein the selection of at least one battery bank is based on the pdf; and
wherein the selection of battery banks is to optimize at least one among weight, cost, size, and life of the system for the usage pattern without compromising on the range of the system.
2. The system of claim 1, wherein characteristic of each battery bank is different based on at least one among chemistry, variability in chemistry, energy density, size, weight, and cost.
3. The system of claim 1, wherein the required storage capacity is obtained by using plurality of battery banks aiding the performance, and reducing the total cost of the system by using the required battery bank or battery banks according to the selection criterion.
4. The system of claim 1, wherein said criteria is configured to select a battery bank out of the plurality of battery banks in a sequential order according to usage requirements based on pre-defined priorities for the plurality of battery banks or in an adaptive manner based on the matrices chosen for a given application.
5. The system of claim 1, wherein the logic unit is further configured to dynamically switch from a first energy harnessing mode to a second energy harnessing mode, wherein said harnessing modes are based on usage parameters.
6. The system of claim 1, wherein the selection criteria comprises at least one threshold dynamically defined based on the plurality of usage parameters.
7. The system of claim 4, wherein the selection criteria depends upon the said battery usage parameters comprising at least one among Depth of Discharge (DoD), rate of charging, rate of discharging, and operation temperature which vary based on the application usage of the system.
8. The system of claim 5, wherein the selection criteria depends upon the said battery usage parameters comprising at least one among Depth of Discharge (DoD), rate of charging, rate of discharging, and operation temperature which vary based on the application usage of the system.
9. The system of claim 6, wherein the selection criteria depends upon the said battery usage parameters comprising at least one among Depth of Discharge (DoD), rate of charging, rate of discharging, and operation temperature which vary based on the application usage of the system.
10. The system of claim 1, wherein performance data comprises at least one of a state of charge, generated current, generated voltage, state of health and lifetime of the battery bank(s).
11. The system of claim 1, said logic unit further configured to update its logic based on said pre-configured pdf with an updated pdf based on actual usage patterns observed.
12. The system of claim 1, wherein frequency of use of different battery banks and life of the batteries from said plurality of battery banks varies based on usage probability distribution function in use.
13. An energy management method for an energy storage system configured with a plurality of battery banks, the method comprising:
deriving a split battery configuration with a plurality of battery banks by a splitter, wherein the split battery configuration of the plurality of banks varies based on a probability distribution function (pdf) of expected usage pattern, optimization goal, and battery characteristics of a corresponding single battery system; obtaining, by the energy storage system, performance information of said plurality of battery banks; selecting, by the energy storage system, at least one battery bank to provide power to a load based on desired performance and at least one selection criterion; and rotating use of battery banks from the plurality of battery banks until next charging opportunity, wherein the split from a single battery bank is to optimize at least one among cost, weight or size of the system, and wherein the selection of at least one battery bank is based on the pdf, and wherein the selection of battery banks is to optimize at least one among weight, cost, size, and life of the system for the usage pattern without compromising on the range of the system.
14. The method of claim 13, wherein characteristic of each battery bank is different based on at least one among chemistry, variability in chemistry, energy density, size, weight, and cost.
15. The method of claim 13, wherein the required storage capacity is obtained by using plurality of battery banks aiding the performance, and reducing the total cost of the system by using the required battery bank or battery banks according to the selection criterion.
16. The method of claim 13, wherein said criteria is configured to select a battery bank out of the plurality of battery banks in a sequential order according to usage requirements based on pre-defined priorities for the plurality of battery banks or in an adaptive manner based on the matrices chosen for a given application.
17. The method of claim 13, wherein the logic unit is further configured to dynamically switch from a first energy harnessing mode to a second energy harnessing mode, wherein said harnessing modes are based on usage parameters.
18. The method of claim 13, wherein the selection criteria comprises at least one threshold dynamically defined based on the plurality of usage parameters.
19. The method of claim 14, wherein the selection criteria depends upon the said battery usage parameters comprising at least one among Depth of Discharge (DoD), rate of charging, rate of discharging, and operation temperature which vary based on the application usage of the system.
20. The method of claim 15, wherein the selection criteria depends upon the said battery usage parameters comprising at least one among Depth of Discharge (DoD), rate of charging, rate of discharging, and operation temperature which vary based on the application usage of the system.
21. The method of claim 16, wherein the selection criteria depends upon the said battery usage parameters comprising at least one among Depth of Discharge (DoD), rate of charging, rate of discharging, and operation temperature which vary based on the application usage of the system.
22. The method of claim 13, wherein performance data comprises at least one of a state of charge, generated current, generated voltage, state of health and lifetime of the battery bank(s).
23. The method of claim 13, said logic unit further configured to update its logic based on said pre-configured pdf with an updated pdf based on actual usage patterns observed.
24. The method of claim 13, wherein frequency of use of different battery banks and life of the batteries from said plurality of battery banks varies based on usage probability distribution function in use.
Ref US20160226268: Claims:
1. A battery system comprising:
a plurality of battery banks connected in parallel with each other; and a distribution controller coupled to the battery banks and configured to:
receive a command comprising a target charging/discharging amount;
determine a priority order between the battery banks based on a state of charge (SOC) and a state of health (SOH) of each of the battery banks;
select at least some of the battery banks to be charged or discharged according to the target charging/discharging amount based on the priority order; and
perform a charging or discharging on the at least some of the battery banks according to the target charging/discharging amount so that others of the battery banks are paused.
2. The battery system of claim 1, further comprising a plurality of direct current (DC)/DC converters that are connected respectively to the plurality of battery banks in series,
wherein the battery banks are connected in parallel with each other via the plurality of DC/DC converters, and the distribution controller is configured to control the plurality of DC/DC converters so that the at least some of the battery banks are charged or discharged while the others of the battery banks are paused.
3. The battery system of claim 2, wherein the battery banks comprise at least one first battery bank comprising battery cells of a first number, and at least one second battery bank comprising battery cells of a second number that is different from the first number, and
the plurality of DC/DC converters comprise at least one first DC/DC converter connected to the at least one first battery bank, and at least one second DC/DC converter connected to the at least one second battery bank.
4. The battery system of claim 1, wherein the battery banks comprise at least one first battery bank comprising battery cells of a first number, and at least one second battery bank comprising battery cells of a second number that is different from the first number,
the battery system further comprises at least one DC/DC converter connected to the at least one first battery bank, and at least one switch connected to the at least one second battery bank, and the distribution controller is configured to control the at least one DC/DC converter and the at least one switch so that the at least some battery banks are charged and discharged while the other battery banks are paused.
5. The battery system of claim 1, wherein the plurality of battery banks are connected to an electrical grid via a power converter.
6. The battery system of claim 1, wherein the distribution controller is configured to update the priority order between the plurality of battery banks at every update period.
7. The battery system of claim 6, wherein the distribution controller is configured to set the update period based on temperatures of the plurality of battery banks, and the update period is increased when the temperatures lower.
8. The battery system of claim 1, wherein the distribution controller is configured to update the priority order between the plurality of battery banks whenever a sign of the target charging/discharging amount is inversed.
9. The battery system of claim 1, wherein the distribution controller is configured to:
set a charging limitation amount of a first battery bank among the battery banks having an SOC that is greater than a first critical value as 0 from among the battery banks so that the first battery bank is paused when the distribution controller receives a charging command; and set a discharging limitation amount of a second battery bank among the battery banks having an SOC that is less than a second critical value as 0 from among the battery banks so that the second battery bank is paused when the distribution controller receives a discharging command.
10. The battery system of claim 1, wherein the distribution controller is configured to grant a higher priority to a first battery bank having lower SOC and higher SOH from among the battery banks when receiving the charging command, and the distribution controller is configured to grant the higher priority to a second battery bank having higher SOC and higher SOH from among the plurality of battery banks when receiving the discharging command.
11. The battery system of claim 10, wherein the first or second battery bank having higher SOH has a shorter paused time.
12. The battery system of claim 1, wherein the at least some of the battery banks have charging/discharging rates (C-rate) that are equal to each other.
13. The battery system of claim 1, wherein the distribution controller is configured to:
compare a total remaining capacity of the plurality of battery banks with a target remaining capacity; generate a corrected target charging/discharging amount by correcting the target charging/discharging amount based on a difference between the total remaining capacity and the target remaining capacity; and the at least some battery banks are charged or discharged according to the corrected target charging/discharging amount.
14. The battery system of claim 13, wherein,
in response to the total remaining capacity being greater than the target remaining capacity, the distribution controller is configured to determine the corrected target charging amount to be less than the target charging amount and to determine the corrected target discharging amount to be greater than the target discharging amount, and in response to the total remaining capacity being less than the target remaining capacity, the distribution controller is configured to determine the corrected target charging amount to be greater than the target charging amount and to determine the corrected target discharging amount to be less than the target discharging amount.
15. An energy storage system comprising:
a plurality of power converters; a plurality of battery units connected to an electrical grid respectively via the power converters; and a combined controller configured to control the plurality of power converters and the plurality of battery units, wherein each of the plurality of battery units comprises:
a plurality of battery banks connected in parallel with each other; and
a distribution controller configured to:
receive a command including a target charging/discharging amount;
determine a priority order between the plurality of battery banks based on a state of charge (SOC) and a state of health (SOH) of each of the plurality of battery banks;
select at least some battery banks among the battery banks to be charged or discharged according to the target charging/discharging amount based on the priority order; and
perform a charging or discharging on the at least some battery banks according to the target charging/discharging amount so that others of the battery banks are paused.
Ref US20080157743: Claims:
1. A power supply system, for delivering a current to a load at a load voltage, comprising:
two or more switching power conversion phases, each power conversion phase comprising a phase switch and a phase inductor; and a controller configured to:
monitor a change in the current delivered to the load; and
 based on a detected magnitude of the change in the current delivered to the load, predict a modification to a relative timing of initiation and duration of on-times of the phase switches in order to alter a rate-of-change of the current delivered by the power supply system.
2. The power supply system of claim 1, wherein the controller is configured to monitor a variation in the load voltage to determine the magnitude of the change in the load current.
3. The power supply system of claim 2 further comprising:
a monitor circuit configured to produce an error signal indicative of a difference between the value of the load voltage and a pre-determined setpoint value.
4. The power supply system of claim 3, wherein the controller is configured to monitor the error signal to detect a rate-of-change of the error voltage.
5. The power supply system of claim 1, wherein a current in a phase inductor in a given power converter phase increases during a time that a respective phase switch in the given power converter phase is ON.
6. The power supply system of claim 1, wherein the controller is configured to predict a time duration, T I, that is an estimate of the amount of time required for the current delivered by the two or more switching power conversion phases to increase in an amount equal to the detected magnitude of the change in current.
7. The power supply system of claim 6 in which the controller is configured to turn the phase switches ON in the two or more switching power conversion phases for the time duration T1.
8. The power supply system of claim 1 in which one of the two or more switching power conversion phases is configured as a transient phase, the transient phase comprising a transient switch and transient inductor, the transient switch and transient inductor corresponding, respectively, to the phase switch and the phase inductor in the remainder of the switching power conversion phases, the transient inductor having a smaller inductance value than each of the inductance values associated with corresponding phase inductors of the two or more switching power conversion phases.
9. The power supply system of claim 8, wherein the controller is configured to predict a time duration, T1, that is an estimate of the amount of time required for the current delivered by the two or more switching power conversion phases to increase in an amount equal to the detected magnitude of the change in current;
wherein the controller is configured to turn the phase switches and the transient switch ON for duration T1 and thereafter turn the transient switch OFF; and wherein the controller is configured to predict a time duration, T2, that is an estimate of the additional time that will be required to allow the current delivered by the remainder of the switching power conversion phases to increase in value in an amount equal to the change in load current.
10. The power supply system of claim 9 in which duration T2 is a multiple of duration T1.
11. The power supply system of claim 10 in which the multiple is a function of the relative values of the corresponding phase inductors and the transient inductor.
12. The power supply system of claim 9 in which the controller is configured to turn the phase switches OFF after time duration T2.
13. The power supply system of claim 8 in which:
the controller is configured to monitor an error signal indicative of the difference between the load voltage and a pre-determined setpoint value, and the controller is configured to predict a time duration, T3, that is an estimate of the time required for the current delivered by the two or more switching power conversion phases to increase in an amount equal to the detected magnitude of the change in current, and wherein the controller is configured to turn the phase switches ON for duration T3 and turn the transient switch ON during a transient time period that begins at the beginning of the time duration T3 and that ends when the magnitude of the error signal becomes less than a pre-determined threshold value.
14. The power supply system of claim 9, wherein the controller is configured to cycle the transient switch ON and OFF during the transient time period.
15. The power supply system of claim 4 in which the controller is further configured to:
compare the rate-of-change of error voltage to a slope threshold, and turn ON the phase switches in the power converter phases essentially immediately upon determining that the rate-of-change of load voltage exceeds the slope threshold.
16. A method comprising:
monitoring a current delivered by a power supply system to a load, the power supply system comprising at least two switching power conversion phases, each of the at least two switching power conversion phases having a corresponding phase switch and phase inductor; detecting a change in the current delivered to the load; and based on a magnitude of the change in the current through the load, predicting a modification to a relative timing of initiation and duration of on-times of the phase switches of the multiphase switching power converter to alter a magnitude of the current delivered by the power sup
[Truncated to input limit]