Phage Therapy—History from Twort and d'Herelle Through Soviet Experience to Current Approaches
Authors: Nina Chanishvili
Journal: Advances in virus research (2012)
Discipline: MICROBIOLOGY
Keywords: Felix d'Herelle; bacteriophages; phage therapy; Soviet Union; antibiotics
Affiliations: Laboratory for Genetics of Microorganisms and Bacteriophages, Eliava Institute of Bacteriophage, Microbiology & Virology, Tbilisi, GA, USA. 

Abstract:  Felix d'Herelle proposed the use of bacteriophages for the therapy of human and animal bacterial infections at the beginning of the 20th century. This approach, however, was not widely accepted in the West. After the emergence of antibiotics in 1940s, phage research was diverted to a more fundamental level. At the same time, phage therapy was widely practiced in the Soviet Union due to collaboration of Felix d'Herelle with his Georgian colleagues. The majority of the articles dedicated to this subject are from the 1930s and 1940s. The old Soviet literature indicates that phage therapy was used extensively to treat a wide range of bacterial infections in the areas of dermatology (Beridze, 1938), ophthalmology (Rodigina, 1938), urology (Tsulukidze, 1938), stomatology (Ruchko and Tretyak, 1936), pediatrics (Alexandrova et al., 1935; Lurie, 1938), otolaryngology (Ermolieva, 1939), and surgery (Tsulukidze, 1940, 1941). These articles were published in Russian and thus were not readily available to Western scientists. The Western skepticism toward phage therapy itself was again followed by renewed interest and reappraisal, mainly due to the emergence of drug-resistant bacteria. Often the experiments described in the old Soviet articles were not designed properly: the use of placebos and the coding of preparations were absent from most of the studies, number of patients in the experimental and control groups was unequal or missing, sometimes no control groups were used at all, or patients treated previously unsuccessfully with antibiotics were employed as an experimental group and as control. The results obtained and the efficiency of phage prophylaxis were estimated by comparing with results obtained in previous years. In most publications, phage titers and descriptions of methods used for evaluation of the results are not specified. Nevertheless, past experience indicates some effectiveness of phage therapy and prophylaxis. Therefore, these clinical results should not be neglected when designing any future studies. 

Retracted: No

PubPeer comments:
 Figure 3 appears to have some images which overlap. Some of the same coauthors have a paper with similar issues: https: pubpeer.com publications 76BEED31F0524241434852836F294D These types of errors are sometimes seen in paper mill papers. *** ![file] , 
 An Erratum has been published in the website https: www.frontiersin.org articles 10.3389 fonc.2021.685219 full? utm_source=Email_to_authors_ utm_medium=Email utm_content=T1_11.5e1_author utm_campaign=Email_publication field= journalName=Frontiers_in_Oncology id=685219. Thank you very muchuff01 , 
 **RETRACTED (finally)** https: www.frontiersin.org articles 10.3389 fonc.2021.744978 full The Journal retracts the 12 June 2019 article cited above for the following reasons: Following publication of the original article, concerns were raised regarding the integrity of the images in the published figures. During the investigation, the authors submitted a correction article which was published during our investigation and which, upon further scrutiny, did not resolve the fundamental issues of image integrity. In the end, the authors have failed to provide a satisfactory explanation during the investigation, which was conducted in accordance with Frontiersu2019 policies. This retraction was approved by the Chief Editors of Frontiers in Oncology and Chief Executive Editor. The authors did not agree to this retraction. The  correction has also been retracted: https: www.frontiersin.org articles 10.3389 fonc.2021.744980 full ,